Genesis 3:11
And he said, Who told thee that thou wast naked? Hast thou eaten of the tree, whereof I commanded thee that thou shouldest not eat?
Translations
And he said, Who told you that you were naked? Have you eaten of the tree, whereof I commanded you that you should not eat?
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Revised Version, American Standard Version
And he said, Who told thee that thou wast naked? Hast thou eaten of the tree, whereof I commanded thee that thou shouldest not eat?
And he said, Who told thee that thou wast naked? Hast thou eaten of the tree of which I commanded thee, that thou shouldest not eat?
And He saith, 'Who hath declared to thee that thou [art] naked? of the tree of which I have commanded thee not to eat, hast thou eaten?'
And he said, Who told thee that thou art naked? Hast thou eaten of the tree of which I commanded thee not to eat?
And he said, Who told thee that, naked, thou wast? Of the tree whereof I commanded thee not to eat, hast thou eaten?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
“ Who told you that you were naked?” asked the LORD God. “ Have you eaten from the tree of which I commanded you not to eat?”
God said, “ Who told you that you were naked? Have you eaten from the tree that I commanded you not to eat from?”
And he said, Who gave you the knowledge that you were without clothing? Have you taken of the fruit of the tree which I said you were not to take?
And he saide, Who tolde thee, that thou wast naked? Hast thou eaten of the tree, whereof I commanded thee that thou shouldest not eate?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And he said to him: And who hath told thee that thou wast naked, but that thou hast eaten of the tree whereof I commanded thee that thou shouldst not eat?
Cross-references 20 of 26
- Romans 5:12
Wherefore, as by one man sin entered into the world, and death by sin; and so death passed upon all men, for that all have sinned:
Adam’s disobedience brought sin and death into the world and to all people.
- Genesis 2:16-17
And the LORD God commanded the man, saying, Of every tree of the garden thou mayest freely eat:
gives the Eden command and penalty confronted
- Genesis 3:22-24
And the LORD God said, Behold, the man is become as one of us, to know good and evil: and now, lest he put forth his hand, and take also of the tree of life, and eat, and live for ever:
Humanity is expelled from Eden and barred from the tree of life.
- Genesis 3:4-6
And the serpent said unto the woman, Ye shall not surely die:
The serpent deceives Eve, and Adam and Eve yield to temptation and disobey God.
- Genesis 3:15
And I will put enmity between thee and the woman, and between thy seed and her seed; it shall bruise thy head, and thou shalt bruise his heel.
The promise of the woman’s Seed follows the exposure of sin and offers hope of deliverance.
- 1 Corinthians 15:21-22
For since by man came death, by man came also the resurrection of the dead.
Contrasts death through Adam with life through Christ.
- Genesis 3:7
And the eyes of them both were opened, and they knew that they were naked; and they sewed fig leaves together, and made themselves aprons.
Eating the forbidden fruit is followed by awareness of nakedness.
- 1 Timothy 2:14
And Adam was not deceived, but the woman being deceived was in the transgression.
Eve was deceived, while Adam knowingly transgressed.
- Genesis 3:17-19
And unto Adam he said, Because thou hast hearkened unto the voice of thy wife, and hast eaten of the tree, of which I commanded thee, saying, Thou shalt not eat of it: cursed is the ground for thy sake; in sorrow shalt thou eat of it all the days of thy life;
God declares the curse, toil, and death resulting from Adam’s disobedience.
- Revelation 22:14
Blessed are they that do his commandments, that they may have right to the tree of life, and may enter in through the gates into the city.
The right to the tree of life lost through Adam’s disobedience is restored to the obedient.
- Revelation 12:9
And the great dragon was cast out, that old serpent, called the Devil, and Satan, which deceiveth the whole world: he was cast out into the earth, and his angels were cast out with him.
Identifies the serpent in Eden as Satan, who deceives the world.
- Genesis 2:8-9
And the LORD God planted a garden eastward in Eden; and there he put the man whom he had formed.
Eden is prepared for humanity, with the forbidden tree identified.
- 2 Corinthians 11:3
But I fear, lest by any means, as the serpent beguiled Eve through his subtilty, so your minds should be corrupted from the simplicity that is in Christ.
The serpent’s deception of Eve warns against minds being led astray.
- Genesis 3:6
And when the woman saw that the tree was good for food, and that it was pleasant to the eyes, and a tree to be desired to make one wise, she took of the fruit thereof, and did eat, and gave also unto her husband with her; and he did eat.
Eve ate the forbidden fruit after being tempted by its appeal.
- Revelation 3:18
I counsel thee to buy of me gold tried in the fire, that thou mayest be rich; and white raiment, that thou mayest be clothed, and that the shame of thy nakedness do not appear; and anoint thine eyes with eyesalve, that thou mayest see.
Christ offers white raiment to cover the shame of nakedness.
- Revelation 2:7
He that hath an ear, let him hear what the Spirit saith unto the churches; To him that overcometh will I give to eat of the tree of life, which is in the midst of the paradise of God.
The tree of life is promised as the overcomer’s reward.
- Genesis 3:4
And the serpent said unto the woman, Ye shall not surely die:
The serpent denies God’s warning of death.
- 1 Corinthians 15:45-47
And so it is written, The first man Adam was made a living soul; the last Adam was made a quickening spirit.
Contrasts the first Adam’s fall with Christ, the second Adam.
- Genesis 1:26-27
And God said, Let us make man in our image, after our likeness: and let them have dominion over the fish of the sea, and over the fowl of the air, and over the cattle, and over all the earth, and over every creeping thing that creepeth upon the earth.
same Hebrew Adam made in God's image
- Genesis 3:1
Now the serpent was more subtil than any beast of the field which the LORD God had made. And he said unto the woman, Yea, hath God said, Ye shall not eat of every tree of the garden?
The serpent’s temptation leads to the forbidden eating.
Commentary part 1 of 2
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
85 sources
God comes to Adam and Eve in Eden after they hide in shame and fear, and confronts them not to gain information but to bring them to recognize their guilt by tracing their new knowledge of nakedness directly to eating from the tree He had forbidden.ST Jan 23, 18791SP 42.3Ms 97, 1901, par. 3–8Lt 106, 1896, par. 4–6ST Jan 23, 1879 Their nakedness means the covering of light and purity and glory God had given them had departed, and their shame and hiding and covering with fig leaves show the futility of trying to hide sin or become acceptable by human works.ST Jan 23, 1879Lt 106, 1896, par. 4–6ST Jan 23, 18792RED 33.1–34.2COL 310.4–311.2 The eating was transgression of God's express and fully binding law through indulgence of appetite, a failure in a slight test that looked small yet opened the floodgates of woe, sin and death upon the world and drove them from Eden and from the tree of life.Lt 35a, 1877, par. 3–6EW 103.22RED 74.34T 11.3LC1 178.3 Because God's law is unchangeable as His character and its penalty is death, mercy could not simply excuse the sin, so their guilt required Christ to leave heaven, take humanity and suffer to pay the penalty, while God gave hope in the first promise of redemption and delayed full execution to grant another trial determined by obedience.Lt 35a, 1877, par. 3–6Ms 17, 1893, par. 3–5Lt 110, 1896, par. 9–15Ms 143, 1898, par. 28Ms 196, 1903, par. 1 The full account stands as a warning example that violation of even one requirement surely brings punishment and ruin, and blessing is promised only to those who obey God rather than follow inclination.Ms 17, 1893, par. 3–52RED 74.3ST Apr 15, 1875ST May 31, 1910ST Jun 3, 1886
Question and Setting
God's questions to Adam are not asked to gain information but to bring the guilty pair to recognize their sin and to convict them of disobedience.ST Jan 23, 18791SP 42.3ST Jan 23, 1879ST Feb 11, 1875 The inquiry who revealed his nakedness and whether he had eaten from the forbidden tree exposes that Adam has eaten from the tree God commanded him not to eat.ST Jan 23, 18791SP 42.3Ms 97, 1901, par. 3–8ST Jan 23, 1879ST Feb 11, 1875 It traces his new knowledge that he was naked directly to that act of eating, confronting him with disobedience to the express command.Ms 97, 1901, par. 3–8Lt 106, 1896, par. 4–6Ms 31, 1901, par. 4–8PP 57.4Lt 188, 1903, par. 7–9
The setting is God's visit to Adam and Eve in the garden of Eden in divine presence as the great Lawgiver come to make known the consequences of transgression.Ms 17, 1893, par. 3–5PP 57.4 Where in innocence and holiness they had joyfully welcomed the approach of their Creator, they now flee in terror and seek to hide in the deepest recesses and among the trees of the garden in shame and fear.Ms 97, 1901, par. 3–8Lt 106, 1896, par. 4–6Ms 17, 1893, par. 3–5PP 57.4 Conscious of loss they are afraid to answer His call, and God calls, Adam where art thou.Lt 106, 1896, par. 4–6Ms 17, 1893, par. 3–5
Adam had no excuse, for all his wants were generously supplied and permission was given to eat of every tree in the beautiful Eden but one.Ms 97, 1901, par. 3–8ST May 26, 1898 Only one prohibition was laid upon him, yet he ate of the forbidden fruit.Ms 97, 1901, par. 3–8ST May 26, 1898 The eating it asks about came when Eve separated from her husband during daily labor in the garden despite angelic caution that with him she would be in less danger from temptation than alone.PP 53.5 Absorbed in her task she wandered unconsciously from his side, felt apprehension on perceiving she was alone but dismissed her fears, deciding she had sufficient wisdom and strength to discern evil and withstand it.PP 53.5 Unmindful of the caution she gazed with mingled curiosity and admiration on the forbidden tree, found its fruit very beautiful, questioned within herself why God had withheld it, and instead of fleeing lingered to hear the tempter address her through the serpent in a musical voice with subtle praise of her loveliness, having no thought that the serpent could become the medium of the fallen foe.PP 53.5
Eve was deceived and ate, and Adam followed despite God's command, accepting another's word instead of God's.CTBH 42.1–3ST Feb 27, 1912 This came after Satan, cast out of heaven for seeking a change in God's law, worked upon their minds and seduced them from loyalty into disobedience and fall, so cautiously that the sin was not detected until they ate.Lt 110, 1896, par. 9–15 Adam admitted eating but was not sorry for his disobedience and could not deny or excuse the act.1SP 42.3ST Nov 18, 1913 He threw blame on the woman and indirectly on God for giving her to him, saying the woman gave him the fruit, which is natural for all human beings to do.1SP 42.3Ms 31, 1901, par. 4–8ST Nov 18, 1913
Nakedness and Shame
To be naked means the garments of purity and brightness given by God had fallen away from Adam and Eve.Lt 106, 1896, par. 4–6ST Jan 23, 18792RED 33.1–34.2ST Jun 11, 1874COL 310.4–311.2 The covering of light and innocence that had clothed them departed, and the glory that had covered Adam was lost.Lt 106, 1896, par. 4–6ST Jan 23, 18792RED 33.1–34.2ST Jun 11, 1874COL 310.4–311.2 Sin could not remain covered by God's glory, so their nakedness laid bare what eating of the forbidden tree had done to them.Lt 106, 1896, par. 4–6ST Jan 23, 18792RED 33.1–34.2 Their nakedness reflected the loss of that light and a new sense of guilt and spiritual want.Lt 106, 1896, par. 4–6ST Jan 23, 1879 That fall brought humanity from its original purity into sin's curse, with poverty, sickness, and suffering.ST Jun 11, 1874
Awareness of nakedness followed disobedience, for shame and fear came only after they ate.ST Jan 23, 18791SP 42.3Ms 97, 1901, par. 3–8Ms 31, 1901, par. 4–8COL 310.4–311.2 Conscious of that loss they were ashamed and afraid to answer God's call when He asked who told them they were naked and whether they had eaten from the tree He had commanded them not to eat.ST Jan 23, 18791SP 42.3Ms 97, 1901, par. 3–8Lt 106, 1896, par. 4–6Ms 31, 1901, par. 4–8 The question traces their shameful knowledge directly to that act of eating and exposes their transgression.Ms 97, 1901, par. 3–8Lt 106, 1896, par. 4–6Ms 31, 1901, par. 4–8 They hid themselves in fear among the trees of the garden because they knew they were naked.Ms 97, 1901, par. 3–8Lt 106, 1896, par. 4–6Ms 31, 1901, par. 4–8 The same is true for all who yield to temptation and give themselves up to obey Satan: they are indeed naked, deprived of the divine covering, and afraid to meet their God.Lt 106, 1896, par. 4–6
Their sin severed their connection with God, leaving them ashamed and trying to cover themselves with fig leaves.COL 310.4–311.2 Those coverings picture the futile human effort to hide sin or become acceptable to God by one's own works.COL 310.4–311.2
Disobedience and Its Results
The eating was transgression of God's express command and law, violation of Jehovah's law that brought sin into the world.2RED 74.3LC1 178.3ST Oct 31, 1878 It was indulgence of appetite and passion against God's express injunction, indulgence of perverted appetite that weakened moral powers and led to reckless departure from God's requirements.LC1 178.3ST Oct 31, 1878ST Jul 8, 1880 Human life was meant to be lived in harmony with God's law and nature's laws, but Adam in eating became a law to himself, bringing discord and unhappiness and separation between him and God.ST9MR 37.1–2 Intemperance in desire caused the loss, and that disobedience with its result was traced for the benefit of all who should live on earth to deter them from following the same steps, yet men repeat it while mourning the transgression that brought sin.2RED 74.3LC1 178.3ST Jul 8, 1880
In seeking knowledge God had withheld they gained no true profit, for by listening to the tempter they came only to know sin and its results.MH 427.2 They became estranged from God and brought separation between earth and heaven.MH 427.2 Had they not touched the tree, God would have imparted knowledge without sin's curse, bringing everlasting joy.MH 427.2
Taking the fruit looked like a simple thing unworthy of notice, apparently a very small sin from which recovery might seem possible.Lt 35a, 1877, par. 3–6Lt 116, 1893, par. 8–9Ms 94, 1899, par. 29–30 Yet it was failure to bear God's slight test and was followed by bitter experience and awful consequences, terrible retribution, and eternal ruin of thousands upon thousands, millions upon millions.Lt 35a, 1877, par. 3–6Lt 116, 1893, par. 8–9Ms 6, 1878, par. 36–37 It closed the gates of Paradise against them, proving God cannot approve any work having in it one thread of selfishness, and it stands as a beacon of warning to youth not to move on a so-called liberal plan careless in little matters and not particular about God's requirements.Ms 94, 1899, par. 29–30Ms 6, 1878, par. 36–37 Sinning against light and knowledge debases and corrupts the soul, so the worldly side of religion must be watched with constant vigilance giving no place to the devil, because small transgression strengthens the hands of sinners and multiplies evil, while ever since that transgression sin has increased in volume and prevalence and is still increasing, though divine benevolence has not been cut off and God's love and care still flow earthward.Lt 116, 1893, par. 8–9Ms 94, 1899, par. 29–30Ms 6, 1878, par. 36–37
Through transgression they fell from a perfect holy state and high estate into a helpless fallen condition under the power of the prince of darkness.LC1 118.2ST May 26, 1898 They broke His command and became sinners, lost beautiful Eden and their right to their Eden home, were driven out and expelled, and cost themselves access to Eden and the Tree of Life.EW 103.2ST Feb 27, 1912Lt 236, 1903, par. 21–22ST May 26, 1898 God guarded the way to the tree of life so they could not eat its fruit and live forever as sinners.EW 103.2 They had been placed in beautiful Eden with permission to eat of every tree but one, but they accepted another's word instead of God's, and their first sin of disobedience belongs to the history of sin and its consequences which brought woe upon the world.CT 427.3ST Feb 27, 1912ST May 26, 1898 Choosing that same disobedience now forfeits the right to Eden restored, so self-pleasing must cease, the side of the great rebel be left, time and talents given to the enemy be repented of, and the good be chosen and evil refused by giving the whole soul to God.Lt 236, 1903, par. 21–22
Their disobedience opened the floodgates of woe upon the world, bringing woe, disappointment, sorrow, suffering and misery, guilt and sorrow.Lt 35a, 1877, par. 3–65T 365.2ST May 26, 1898Lt 14, 1885, par. 1–3 That violation of the law of God is the greatest loss and deepest injury that can be conceived, laying an oppressive load upon humanity and leaving a fallen ruined race.Lt 14, 1885, par. 1–3 The first parents' sin with its terrible results shows the consequences of disregarding God's law and the need to obey every requirement He has given.ST Feb 26, 1894MYP 441.2–442.1 The example of Adam and Eve and the result of their transgression should lead every soul to avoid sin and abhor it as the hateful thing it is, and to feel in view of the sufferings sin is sure to inflict that it is better to suffer loss of all things than to depart from the least of God's commandments.Lt 14, 1885, par. 1–3
By that one sin, sin entered the world and death by sin, and humanity became subject to death.4T 11.3ST Feb 22, 1883Lt 22, 1900, par. 9–10 Disobedience to God's commands brings death and God's justice in punishing sin does not fail, requiring strict regard to His commandments.4T 11.3 Humanity fell from its perfect and holy state by transgressing God's law, forfeited its original likeness to God, and since the fall disease, suffering and death have rapidly increased.ST Sep 2, 1875ED 15.2 The glory that had covered Adam departed, his fall brought humanity from original purity into sin's curse with poverty, sickness and suffering, marring that likeness, weakening physical powers, lessening mental capacity, dimming spiritual vision.ST Jun 11, 1874ED 15.2 That fall is traced to indulgence of appetite and passion and transgression of the law of God and nature's laws, bringing weakened vital force, disease of every type, deformity, decrepitude, imbecility, feeble mental, moral and physical power, and decay spreading through successive generations.ST Oct 31, 1878
Creation, once full of knowledge of God, lost the brightness of God's presence and became marred and defiled, though it still bears lessons about its Creator.COL 18.1 Eden was beautiful and sin degraded it.20MR 151.2 After the fall people followed their carnal desires and changed God's order.1SP 68.1
Sin grew steadily worse until God destroyed the world by a flood, men becoming more bold in disobedience.ST May 26, 1898 Adam's experience stands as a warning example not to violate God's law and to shun his example, yet men repeat his disobedience while mourning the transgression, adding a succession of falls instead of stopping with Adam, beginning a succession of falls in human history.LC1 178.3RH Jul 9, 1901RH Oct 13, 1874 People continue to disregard God's law despite Adam's example, and disobedience brings harm, for all men perpetuate that sure result of sin entering by one sin and fall under it one after another.LC1 179.1Lt 22, 1900, par. 9–10 Perpetuating that sin makes the moral atmosphere malarious, darkening the intellect so truth fades, is not valued, is not made precious by practice, and does not sanctify the soul.Lt 22, 1900, par. 9–10 Repetition takes away sensitiveness of conscience until the impression once made no longer arrests the diseased, depraved, dying transgressor, the voice no longer echoes God's voice, the heart where God should be enthroned brings forth abominations in accordance with satanic attributes, man has lost the reflection of God's character and degenerated, the serpent's track is seen and his venomous sting felt in every place, the whole earth is defiled under its inhabitants, the curse increasing as transgression increases toward purification by fire.Lt 22, 1900, par. 9–10
After that fall Satan claimed to be prince of the power of the air and to have control of everything in nature.Ms 154, 1903, par. 16–18 God permitted him to sow tares and to work out his principles of evil, while protecting from Satan's wrath those who desire to work out the principles of heaven.Ms 154, 1903, par. 16–18
Law and Divine Justice
God's law was fully binding in Eden as the rule of human conduct and the basis of all right conduct, with reward for obedience and penalty for disobedience.FE 504.1–3Lt 188, 1903, par. 7–9Lt 90, 1898, par. 14–16 His question exposes Adam's eating of the tree He had commanded him not to eat, calling Adam to account for breaking the command given in Eden and proving transgression of that law.Ms 17, 1893, par. 3–5FE 504.1–3Lt 188, 1903, par. 7–9Lt 90, 1898, par. 14–16 That accountability establishes that all people, especially rulers of nations and all in positions of responsibility, are under obligation to know and obey all of God's requirements, and the light of the law with its positive promises to the obedient is to be made so clearly known that all can understand it.Lt 188, 1903, par. 7–9Lt 90, 1898, par. 14–16 Disregarding that law brings guilt, and obedience to it is required to become members of the royal family, children of the heavenly King.Lt 90, 1898, par. 14–16ST May 11, 1876
Violation of even one requirement brought the Fall, demonstrating the sacred character of the law and that God means what He says.ST Apr 15, 1875ST May 31, 1910ST Jun 3, 1886 The full and explicit account records the law given in Eden together with the penalty for disobedience, then the temptation and fall, then the punishment inflicted, to teach that the wages of sin is death and that God's retributive justice never fails.ST May 31, 19101SP 59.1 Transgressors of God's commands will surely face punishment, for Adam's experience shows the consequences of disregarding God's law and the need to obey every requirement He has given.FE 504.1–31SP 59.1ST Feb 26, 1894 The example stands as sufficient warning requiring reverence for His commandments and strict regard for them without questioning the feasibility or convenience of obedience.ST May 31, 1910ST Jun 3, 1886ST Feb 26, 1894
God is severe and exacting toward transgression and will not pass over any transgression of His law now more lightly than in the day He judged Adam.Lt 35a, 1877, par. 3–6ST Sep 1, 1881 Mercy does not excuse the sinner or lessen guilt, but only covers guilt after sin is repented of and forsaken.Lt 35a, 1877, par. 3–6 To pardon without penalty would exalt the sinner in impenitence and sin and would encourage transgression instead of abating it, for the Father did not put benevolence above justice and set aside the principles of righteousness to give unconditional pardon.Ms 143, 1898, par. 28 The penalty required the Son of God to leave the royal courts of heaven, take a humble place on earth, and be subjected to insult, rejection, and crucifixion to save man from the penalty of his crime, and that costly sacrifice exalts the law and evidences its sacred character.Lt 35a, 1877, par. 3–6ST Sep 1, 1881Ms 143, 1898, par. 28
God's law is a transcript of His character, as unchangeable as His character and throne, unaltered to meet Satan's request for a change in heaven and unaltered to meet man in his fallen condition.Lt 110, 1896, par. 9–15 Satan, cast out for seeking a change in that law, worked cautiously upon the minds of Adam and Eve and seduced them from loyalty into disobedience so that the sin was not detected until they ate.Lt 110, 1896, par. 9–15 If the law could have been changed, Adam would have been pardoned and would have retained his home in Eden, but the penalty of transgression was death, so Christ became man's substitute and surety and fallen man was granted another trial upon probation through Christ alone.Lt 110, 1896, par. 9–15Ms 143, 1898, par. 28Ms 196, 1903, par. 1 As Adam and Eve lost Eden by transgressing that law, those who transgress it will lose heaven, for sin is the transgression of the law and salvation is still determined by obedience or disobedience.Lt 110, 1896, par. 9–15Ms 196, 1903, par. 1Ms 8, 1888, par. 31–32
The same applies to the Sabbath law placed in the bosom of the decalogue, which cannot be broken with impunity by pleading a merciful God any more than stealing or murder or adultery can.Lt 35a, 1877, par. 3–6 Adam's sin is repeated when the Sabbath of the Lord is discarded and scorned for a spurious sabbath without sacredness.ST May 26, 1898 They had been placed in beautiful Eden with permission to eat of every tree but one, yet they ate of the forbidden fruit, lost Eden, opened the floodgates of woe upon the world, and afterward sin grew steadily worse until God destroyed the world by a flood, proving that God means what He says.Lt 35a, 1877, par. 3–6ST May 26, 1898
Promise and Redemption
The guilt incurred by eating from the forbidden tree was so great that it required God to give His Son from heaven to save the fallen race.Lt 35a, 1877, par. 3–6Ms 143, 1898, par. 28Ms 18, 1887, par. 4 The Son left the royal courts of heaven, laid aside His robes of royalty, clothed His divinity with humanity, and took a humble place on earth.Lt 35a, 1877, par. 3–6ST Sep 1, 1881Ms 18, 1887, par. 4 He lived as a man of sorrows acquainted with grief, and though He was the Majesty of heaven He suffered insult, reproach, mockery, rejection, and crucifixion by the very ones He came to bless, taking man's transgressions and their just penalty upon Himself.ST Sep 1, 1881Ms 143, 1898, par. 28Ms 18, 1887, par. 4 Through His merits and His blood it was made possible to keep the law, and that costly sacrifice exalts the law and evidences its sacred character.Lt 35a, 1877, par. 3–6Ms 143, 1898, par. 28 The provision did not abolish God's law to give unconditional pardon, for the Father did not put benevolence above justice and set aside the principles of righteousness, since to pardon without penalty would exalt the sinner in impenitence and sin and would encourage transgression instead of abating it.Lt 35a, 1877, par. 3–6Ms 143, 1898, par. 28 The same holds for the Sabbath law in the bosom of the decalogue, which cannot be broken with impunity by pleading a merciful God any more than stealing or murder or adultery can.Lt 35a, 1877, par. 3–6
God did not leave the fallen pair in their helpless fallen condition under the power of the prince of darkness, but gave them a star of hope to illuminate the dark future in the first gospel sermon.Ms 17, 1893, par. 3–5LC1 118.2 Although death was the sentence for sin, its full execution was delayed because Christ undertook to redeem humanity, opening a way of hope and safety through faith in Him.LC1 118.22RED 16.2–17.1 By taking humanity's place and obeying where Adam had failed, Christ provided another trial and a return to probation.LC1 118.22RED 16.2–17.1 Their history of happiness in obedience and ruin in disobedience, with God's readiness to give power to overcome, makes later people more responsible because the example is on record and repeated, and all are still on trial during probationary time with salvation determined by obedience or disobedience.Ms 17, 1893, par. 3–5SPBC 178.2–4
That talk in Eden commences the gradual unfolding of God's purposes in the plan of redemption.ST Jun 3, 1886Ms 69, 1897, par. 15 It is the beginning of the gospel shining forth with no uncertain light from Genesis to Revelation, a light that has continued to shine down through the ages.ST Jun 3, 1886Ms 69, 1897, par. 15 God's work is the same in all time, with different degrees of development and different manifestations of His power to meet the wants of man in different ages, from the fall through the patriarchal and Jewish ages even to the present time.ST Jun 3, 1886Ms 69, 1897, par. 15
Christ passed over the same ground where Adam fell, stood in Adam's place, and overcame the temptation Adam failed to endure.4T 293.2–3ST Feb 22, 1883Lt 148a, 1897, par. 3–4 His test of appetite in the wilderness, meeting temptation there and gaining the victory, redeemed the disgrace of Adam's failure and fall.4T 293.2–3ST Mar 7, 1878Lt 148a, 1897, par. 3–4 Thereby He placed the human family on vantage ground with God, so that all can overcome in their own behalf through the merits of the crucified and risen Saviour and perfect a character like His.SPBC 178.2–4LC1 118.2Lt 148a, 1897, par. 3–4
Adam treasured what God revealed to him, was commanded to instruct his posterity in the way of the Lord, and for nearly a thousand years to the ninth generation lived among men as a witness to the results of sin.PP 82.1 He faithfully sought to stem evil by describing man's holy and happy estate in Paradise, repeating the history of the fall, and explaining the merciful provisions for salvation, yet few gave heed to his words and he was often met with bitter reproaches for the sin that brought woe upon his posterity.PP 82.1 The gracious opportunity still open is to lay hold of the Saviour, receive His merits by faith, consent to receive the moral image of God, and perfect a character like Christ's, for refusing the character of Christ means heaven is lost.SPBC 178.2–4 Choosing that same disobedience now forfeits the right to the Eden restored, which was lost by the first disobedience that caused loss of the right to the Eden home, so self-pleasing must cease, the side of the great rebel must be left, time and talents given to the enemy must be repented of, and the good must be chosen and the evil refused by giving the whole soul to God and seeking the Lord while He may be found.SPBC 178.2–4Lt 236, 1903, par. 21–22
Their sin brought guilt and sorrow upon the world with grave consequences and made Christ's sacrifice necessary to save humanity from sin's penalty and rescue people from the ruin into which transgression brought the world.4T 248.1ST Sep 1, 1881Ms 18, 1887, par. 4
Warning and Obedience
God's confrontation over eating from the forbidden tree belongs to a full and explicit record that lays out the law given in Eden with its penalty, then the temptation and fall, then the punishment inflicted, and that record is given as a warning example to deter all from following the same steps.2RED 74.3ST May 31, 1910ST Jul 8, 1880HSFM 231.3RH Mar 4, 1875 The history traces the happiness of obedience and the ruin of disobedience, with the example and result of indulgence of perverted appetite traced for the benefit of all who should live on earth, and because it is on record and repeated it makes later people more responsible.Ms 17, 1893, par. 3–5ST Jul 8, 1880HSFM 231.3 It stands as a beacon against even one departure from right because of its reach to others, teaching that the wages of sin is death and that retributive justice never fails, and showing the danger of disobeying God so that people must choose between repeating transgression and walking in the light through humble obedience with blessings promised to those who love and obey.ST May 31, 1910ST Feb 27, 1912HSFM 231.3Ms 6, 1878, par. 36–37 Adam's transgression violated divine law and brought sin into the world, yet later people repeat that disobedience especially through indulgence of appetite and passion, even though his experience warns them against it.2RED 74.3RH Mar 4, 1875
The fall demonstrates the sure result of transgressing God's law and disproves the doctrine of once in grace always in grace, for the loss of the right to Eden and the condition of the fallen race today testify to its awful results.Ms 2, 1904, par. 38–41 Eating was indulgence of appetite and passion and transgression of the law of God and of nature's laws, and from that fall of man are traced all woe and suffering, with weakened vital force, disease of every type, deformity, decrepitude, imbecility, feeble mental, moral and physical power, and decay spreading through successive generations whenever fallen man persists in breaking God's law.ST Oct 31, 1878ST Human life was meant to be lived in harmony with God's moral law and nature's laws, and continued violation has greatly aggravated those evils.ST To be prepared for Paradise restored, perverted appetite must be brought under strict control, because indulgence of depraved appetite weakens power to resist evil and enables Satan to fasten evil habits upon man and ensnare him in his devices.Ms 126, 1903, par. 21–22
That disobedience opened the floodgates of disappointment, sorrow, suffering and woe upon the world as the result of disobeying God, and parents, especially mothers in the home, are to keep this fact before the tender minds of children to train them to lifelong obedience to all the statutes and commandments of the Lord.Ms 193, 1897, par. 4Lt 90, 1898, par. 14–16 The light of God's law, filled with positive promises to the obedient and required for becoming members of the royal family as children of the heavenly King, is to be made so clearly known that all can understand it, with parents making plain what it means to transgress it and urging obedience, since ignorance is no excuse because light is abundant.Lt 90, 1898, par. 14–16 Since the fall there has been a succession of falls because men keep doing just what God told them not to do, and pleading family inconvenience as an excuse for disobedience while setting a bad example perpetuates Adam's disobedience and leads children to follow the same transgression.Ms 20, 1894, par. 38–42
Refusing light after hearing truth repeats Eden's disobedience, for turning from truth because accepting it would retard success in business is turning from God and light, selling the soul cheaply, violating conscience which kept pure would be worth more than the whole world, and making a bargain with Satan that leads to disregard and disobedience of the expressed will of God, because obedience involves a cross and separation from the world in faith and practice.Ms 27, 1900, par. 26–28 The same intemperance in desire that caused the loss of Eden continues in indulged inclination and habit, in delicate unhealthful cooking and in unhealthful dress, weakening physical, mental and moral efficiency, making it impossible to overcome temptation, and leaving little sincere piety and religious fervor because the mind is occupied with unimportant things instead of meditation, searching the Scriptures and prayer.6MR 36.5–37.1 Adam's failure to bear God's slight test was followed by terrible retribution, and it stands as a beacon of warning to youth not to move on what they call a liberal plan, becoming careless in little matters and not particular about God's requirements, lest they deviate widely from Christ the only true Pattern, for Satan bewitches the mind so that even with this warning many talk of liberality, go on with defects of character instead of reforming, become more faulty and lose sight of the true Pattern.Ms 6, 1878, par. 36–37
The example of guilt and sorrow that would have plunged the race into hopeless despair without God's goodness and mercy stands as sufficient warning requiring reverence for the commandments and obedience without questioning feasibility or convenience.ST Jun 3, 1886 They accepted another's word instead of God's and their act brought woe into the world and cost them access to Eden and the Tree of Life, in contrast with the blessing promised to those who obey God rather than men despite opposition.ST Feb 27, 1912 Their disobedience must not be repeated but met with obedience to all requirements, overcoming as Christ overcame by perfect obedience in order to be brought back to the Eden home and to point others heavenward.Ms 84, 1886, par. 5–6 Keeping the commandments is the test of love, so the human family must obey the light about the binding claims of the law and lift the cross in view of the whole world.Ms 16, 1895, par. 19
The verse belongs to the inspired history of the race and the Bible's authentic history of the beginning of the world, giving true knowledge of the creation of man and his fall, the introduction of sin and its results upon the race after holy innocency in Eden in communion with God and sinless angels, and the origin of the earth, showing the disobedience and impenitence of man and the just retribution for sin.MYP 254.2–255.1Ms 42, 1904, par. 7 Without this history the mind is left to fables and conjectures and false theories, to superstition and falsehood, and to enfeebling of intellect that surely results from entertaining error, while with it there is no need to be hampered by human conjectures and unreliable theories.Ms 42, 1904, par. 7 With creation, the atonement and the perpetuity of the law it stands among the great facts and very pillars of faith, yet it is practically rejected by many professing Christianity who treat implicit confidence in the Bible as weakness and treat caviling and spiritualizing away its most important truths as proof of superior talent and learning.4SP 398.3 It is among the hidden treasures and jewels of truth, a grand subject whose dignified simplicity and sharp clear light develops mental powers and gives strength of intellect beyond philosophy with a boundless field far higher than unsanctified intellect, and that knowledge of the fall that opened the floodgates of woe is among the most important to receive as definite truth flashing divine light and glory.MYP 254.2–255.1Ms 8, 1896, par. 4–6
Sources