God actually sent Adam out of the garden of Eden to work the ground from which he had been formed and earn his bread by labor outside it.RH Nov 22, 1906ST May 12, 1890 This was literal history of the first disobedience, when Adam and Eve broke God's law and were sentenced to leave their innocent home under curse and death.ST Sep 9, 1930ST Apr 7, 1914RH Jul 1, 1909 He cut them off from the tree of life lest, after eating the forbidden fruit and knowing good and evil, they should eat of it also and live forever as sinners, perpetuating sin and misery forever.ST Nov 16, 1876ST Jul 16, 1912RH Aug 29, 1854 Man had no life forever in himself, for life was conditional on obedience and access to the tree, so exclusion began mortality and made death certain.ST Nov 16, 1876RH Mar 22, 1860RH Dec 8, 1868 Eternal life lost by this sending is found only in God's Son, and Christ as second Adam restores what was forfeited, opening the way back to the tree and Paradise regained.ST Feb 3, 1914RH Mar 24, 1904RH Aug 7, 1916RH Jul 3, 1900RH Oct 3, 1912
Literal History Affirmed
The verse belongs to the creation-and-fall account in Genesis 1-3, to Genesis 1-11 recording God's dealings with the race, and to Genesis 3-5 telling of temptation, fall and promise.ST Jan 3, 1911ST Aug 9, 1905ST Mar 17, 1914 It is part of the first ten chapters which give an epitome of 1,656 years of history before the universal Deluge, and the whole Bible stands upon that record of creation and fall. That early history grounds doctrines, redemption, and the biblical message that follows, so to reject it is to reject the foundation for the teachings joined to it and to undermine the authority of what follows.ST Jan 3, 1911ST Feb 22, 1883 It belongs to the history of humanity's first sin and fall as the starting point of the events leading to redemption and restoration.ST Dec 24, 1885
It is literal factual history received by Moses through revelation from God and given by inspiration, to be received on divine authority as reliable Scripture for doctrine, reproof, correction and instruction.ST Jul 28, 1881ST Aug 25, 1881ST Nov 1, 1905 It records the real sending of fallen man out of Eden to work the ground, and is not allegory, symbols of inner nature, spiritualized legend, tradition, fiction, fable, myth, poem, forgery or error.ST Sep 20, 1899ST Jul 28, 1881ST Nov 13, 1893ST Nov 25, 1889 Because the fall truly happened redemption was truly needed, and the gospel is built on fact and not imagination; to call the fall imaginary makes the whole gospel a fable.ST Nov 13, 1893 The truthfulness of the entire Bible and the whole fabric of Christianity depends on its truthfulness, so the whole Bible must be accepted together or rejected together, and to diminish confidence in it endangers the whole, most of all when religious teachers slight it while professing reverence.ST Nov 13, 1893ST Aug 25, 1881
The early history is plain and clear so that a child may be enlightened by reading it, and it concerns the true Adam meaning man, made in God's image and likeness in Genesis 1:26-27 as part of the creation pronounced very good, given inheritance and dominion.ST Jan 28, 1903 Adam was a real man with real history, not a figure who disappears, and the account keeps absolute authority and historical character as the foundation for every religious belief.ST Apr 2, 1902 Mankind does not come into the world with a brute and savage inheritance to be subdued, and that claim has no place if the Bible account is true, nor is the account a product of evolution working throughout the universe.ST Apr 2, 1902
The New Testament treats the fall as real history and part of the foundation of redemption, explaining the introduction of death among humanity.ST Mar 9, 1888ST May 8, 1879 Christ and His apostles held the record of man's origin and fall in Creation and Eden as fact, Paul referring to Adam and Eve as first parents, so rejecting it rejects their teaching.ST Mar 9, 1888ST Nov 1, 1905 Faith in the Bible story of man's fall and his helpless sinful condition as the word of God is fundamental.ST Mar 20, 1907
The inspired record of Eden and the fall explains traditions of an original age of purity and hope of restoration, and substantially agrees with Assyrian tablet legends of creation and the fall.ST Feb 10, 1887ST Aug 12, 1880 It agrees in all essentials with Karen traditions about creation, the sinless pair in the garden, and the fall.ST Jul 25, 1911 That true account of creation, fall and flood was known in remote time by the Karens, and its traditions are still retained even while wandering far from God in demon worship, showing they once knew Jehovah, whom God regards with compassion as a despised mistreated people.RH Aug 10, 1905
The first few chapters telling how sin began stand opposite the last chapters of Revelation carrying the mind to when sin shall be no more.ST Aug 17, 1915 The fall belongs to the study of Satan's work and redemption through Christ.RH May 11, 1911 The driving out begins the course of divine history running until God was manifested in the flesh, and that whole course is revelation and prophecy of Christ's coming in the flesh, not merely general history leading to that time.RH Dec 31, 1901
Those who held otherwise described the story of the Fall as literature for ethical instruction rather than a literal account.ST Mar 20, 1907
The weight of testimony holds the fall was downward from moral rectitude, innocence and a comparatively high level, not upward evolution from savagery through barbarism to civilization.ST Nov 22, 1910AUST Jun 14, 1920 The Bible teaches the Fall and denies evolution, so the two cannot both be held, and Christians must pin faith to God's Word.AUST Jun 14, 1920 The evolutionary major premise of successive geological ages is directly antagonistic to the most fundamental facts of the first chapters, and that premise is the weakest point and tender spot of the whole theory which its friends never want touched. Since man sinned he has been degenerating rather than evolving upward, with proof in that no men today equal the giants in strength before Christ; to claim an upward fall from ape and animals destroys atonement, what Christ came to accomplish, and the Bible's authority.RH Apr 1, 1909ST Jun 3, 1913 Allowing geological hypothesis to set aside Moses, putting evolution for creation and preferring Darwin's Origin of Species to Moses, rejects the Word on which Christ's faith rested.ST Feb 13, 1901
Denying the historicity of the fall and of being sent out to till the ground repudiates God's Word and with it the Spirit, life and power revealed in Christ.ST Oct 20, 1909 It removes the basis for understanding incarnation, atonement, redemption and Christianity, and for humanity's need of redemption and salvation from the fall.ST Nov 15, 1883ST Apr 26, 1905ST Sep 13, 1905 It logically leads from questioning Moses to sifting all prophets and apostles, and to denying miracles, Christ's superhuman birth, vicarious death, physical resurrection, bodily ascension and divinity, as well as the flood, Sabbath, regeneration and restoration.ST Oct 20, 1909 If humanity arose by evolution with no fall, there was no fall and atonement is undermined.ST Nov 15, 1883
Rejecting creation-and-fall wrongly makes salvation a matter of good works and human service. Belief in the record of the fall is bound up with faith in God's Son and connected with the plan of salvation.ST Feb 17, 1888 Redemption is the means bringing people back to God's favor and to immortality.ST Feb 19, 1880
The account of the fall in Eden is identified as the basis of the old theology's teaching of original sin as guilt handed on from the fall, in contrast to explaining inheritance as inherited appetites and passions.RH Oct 15, 1901
God knew beforehand what Adam and Eve would think and do.ST Nov 22, 1910 He foresaw the human fall when creating the world, with redemption already included in His purpose in creation.ST Feb 11, 1913 The charge that He was unfair and laid a trap and then condemned man for falling into it, leading men to reject revelation, presumes by human reason to balance God's dealings and pass judgment on the Almighty, ignoring that He reads hearts, knows motives and sees the end from the beginning.RH Feb 18, 1902
Setting and Wording
The events belong in the Garden of Eden immediately after the six days' work of creation, where Satan stood as tempter.ST Jul 7, 1898 He was once Lucifer, the Day Star or Light-bringer, one of the morning stars that sang together and shouted for joy when the foundations of the earth were laid, yet he had already fallen when Adam was placed in Eden.ST Jul 7, 1898
The sending out occurred within the first 130 years of Adam's life, before Seth was born, belonging to the early history in which God gave the first gospel promise and a divinely directed system of worship after the fall.RH Dec 25, 1913 It is the loss of Paradise and access to the tree of life, and because the first man lived 930 years the generations after him could hear firsthand from him about the garden where he had lived and the events by which it was lost.RH Dec 10, 1861
God actually sent Adam forth from Eden to till the ground from which he had been formed and made, to work it outside the garden and earn bread in the sweat of his face as the literal consequence of disobedience.RH Nov 22, 1906ST May 12, 1890ST Jul 26, 1910RH Nov 11, 1858 After humanity fell into sin the expulsion brought loss of Eden and life under the curse of sin and death, with return to dust following sin, and the first Adam who fell in a garden was driven into the wilderness.ST May 12, 1890RH Jul 27, 1876 His former place of pleasure had offered no security against falling, and this sending belongs to the biblical account of the fall and the plan of salvation from it.ST Jul 26, 1910RH Nov 11, 1858
The verb for tilling means labor, and it can refer to hired or compulsory labor, but its use for Adam sent to work the ground does not imply chattel slavery.RH Oct 1, 1861
After taking what God had reserved for Himself, Adam was sent outside the garden to till the ground, to work less fertile ground from which he had been taken.RH Jan 21, 1909RH Mar 31, 1903RH Feb 9, 1905 Outside meant tilling under burden, toil and anxiety rather than the happy labor known before, with labor in place of spontaneous provision along with hardship and the effects of the curse.ST Jan 23, 1879RH May 5, 1863 This contrasts with his first employment in his sinless state cultivating the trees and flowers God had planted.RH Feb 9, 1905
The garden was a distinct place and not the whole earth, a real place and locality where the tree stood.ST Jan 31, 1911RH Nov 20, 1860ST Nov 3, 1881 It was Eden, the Paradise of God and humanity's home and first schoolroom, the paradise from which humanity was shut out by transgression.RH Jun 23, 1910ST Nov 3, 1881 The Tree of Life there was a literal tree, removed to heaven and destined to return as the center of a sinless earth, to be restored to man when Paradise itself is restored and the whole man is redeemed.ST Jan 31, 1911ST Nov 3, 1881
The garden remained on earth until the Flood, specially blessed and kept free from the curse that sin brought upon the earth, when God withdrew it.ST Feb 20, 1879ST Sep 25, 1907 It will return more gloriously adorned than before as the renewed home of redeemed people.ST Feb 20, 1879ST Sep 25, 1907 Eden was where the first week and the first day began and where the true date line was, and after sin entered God removed Eden from the earth, so that with the Flood changing the surface of the earth and causing the world that then was to perish its location cannot be identified on the world that now is.RH Aug 19, 1915
Just before the Flood God transplanted the Garden of Eden itself to heaven, with its tree of life and the vines Adam and Eve had trained into their bower home.ST Jan 11, 1916 Adam's Eden home had been left just as it was when he was driven out, while angels guarded the tree of life so fallen man could not eat and become an immortal sinner.ST Jan 11, 1916 That preserved Eden with its trees is now within the city God has built for the saved, which is to become the capital of the earthly home.ST Jan 11, 1916
Adam crossed the threshold of his Eden home for the last time, leaving it behind.RH Nov 6, 1916ST Sep 22, 1898 That departure marks the point since which great events have taken place on earth, beginning the history of sin on earth whose last days will be the most warlike and revolutionary time since Adam and Eve left.RH Nov 6, 1916ST Sep 22, 1898
The sending marks the first expulsion from Eden after sin had defiled the earth, God sending Adam away from the garden to work the ground from which he had been formed.ST This began the long history of human sin on earth, which the Flood later cleansed in part but did not end.ST It places humanity's long experience of sin and death in the millennia since Eden was lost.RH Dec 17, 1914
When Adam ate of the tree of knowledge the Garden disappeared in the sense that man was sent out to till the ground from which he was taken.ST Dec 16, 1903 Being gifted with knowledge, that is with a brain, man learned he was not like the beast of the field going up and down devouring what came in its path but must live by the sweat of his brow.ST Dec 16, 1903 The decree to obtain a living through work was made to compel him to use and develop his intelligence, the one faculty distinguishing him from the rest of creation, since any function atrophies from disuse and man would have no intellect if he were not required to use it.ST Dec 16, 1903
God designed men to till the soil for a living, making agriculture the honorable pursuit and His plan devised by the Creator for the maintenance of the race.ST Mar 25, 1903 Departing from that plan for the uncertain, dependent occupations of the cities bears terrible fruit in unemployment, helplessness, discouragement, dependence, oppression, debauchery and crime.ST Mar 25, 1903 The ground from which Adam was taken became the place he had to cultivate, and recovery from the fall is connected with practical education and manual training promoting industry and discipline.RH Jun 6, 1907
Adam obeyed God's command to leave Eden and till the land from which he was made, laboring through his long life in exile, which illustrates that work is good for humanity.ST Mar 24, 1881 Outside the garden his labor meant struggling with stubborn soil for daily bread, unlike the pleasant work he had done in Eden, yet it protected him from temptation and gave him happiness.ST Oct 9, 1884 Carrying on his sinless work of cultivating the trees and flowers God had planted was not a curse but a blessing, for working among beautiful trees and plants, especially fruit trees, has a refining and uplifting moral influence that restrains what is rough and cruel in man and encourages kindness and gentleness.RH Mar 21, 1912
After the fall God sent man out of Eden to cultivate the soil, and with scarcity of fruits and grains man was told to eat the plants of the field, food originally given to the lower creatures.ST Aug 31, 1915 Sin drove Adam from Eden to work the ground from which he had been formed, and people were permitted to eat the plants of the field in addition to the original foods of seed-bearing plants and fruit, namely fruits, nuts, grains and vegetables as the Creator's original diet.ST Sep 14, 1915 After the Fall pain and death entered through transgression though God did not design creatures to suffer or die, and the biblical record gives no permission to eat flesh until after the Flood, until then food coming from the ground.ST Apr 8, 1875
After sin Adam was sent out of Eden to live and work on the ground from which he had been taken, and the earth where he had to abide was under sin's curse.ST Sep 23, 1908ST Aug 24, 1904 Cut off from the Tree of Life and from Eden's perfection, humanity became imperfect and the ground no longer yielded as before, with toil and the earth's curse marking the changed condition brought by sin.ST Sep 23, 1908 Human life was thus placed outside Eden on ground blighted by sin, where weeds and thorns grow as consequences of the Fall and hardship in working the ground adds toil and sorrow to earning daily bread.ST Dec 8, 1887
The expulsion followed open violation of the moral law, specifically the first commandment.ST Sep 21, 1876RH Aug 10, 1876ST Aug 3, 1882ST Nov 12, 1912 Satan set before Eve the motive of becoming as gods, Eve was tempted by that prospect in the forbidden fruit, and Adam, who was not deceived, knowingly chose to follow his wife rather than obey the Lord.ST Sep 21, 1876ST Aug 3, 1882 Before that fall man was upright, innocent and free from guilt, needing no redemption through Christ's death and under no obligation of sacrifices for sin, types and shadows of future redemption, or carnal ordinances looking forward to reformation.ST Sep 21, 1876 The whole system of rites and ceremonies, the shadow of good things to come, gained existence only because of this transgression, arose after the Fall to point forward to Christ, and lasted until His sacrifice.ST Sep 21, 1876ST Aug 3, 1882 That punishment in Genesis 3:14-24, including Genesis 3:16-24 with the gospel foreshadowed and the plan of salvation indicated in Genesis 3:15, positively proves the moral law was already present and known, because death with its long train of previous disabilities was pronounced as the wages of sin, and sin is transgression of the law; without law there could be no transgression or imputed sin.RH Aug 10, 1876ST Nov 12, 1912
After Adam and Eve sinned they refused to accept responsibility, believed and obeyed Satan instead of God, and Adam's accusation against Eve did not save him from the result.ST May 29, 1901ST Apr 7, 1914ST Feb 15, 1883RH Sep 12, 1865 God sent them out of Eden back to the ground from which man had been made, to work the soil and not remain in the garden, sentencing them to death with the earth placed under a curse and driving them to suffer and die as part of sin's penalty extending to the race.ST Apr 7, 1914ST Jan 13, 1888RH Aug 3, 1876 An angel with a flaming sword guarded the way to the tree of life so the disloyal pair could not gain access and immortalize transgression.ST May 29, 1901 Their sincerity did not remove consequences, for sincere belief that the serpent told the truth did not excuse disbelief of God's word in face of the declared consequence.ST Feb 15, 1883RH Sep 12, 1865
God's word must be treated as sacred and His commands obeyed, for the expulsion after Adam sinned, with barring from the tree lest he eat and live forever and with the curse on the ground, shows breaking even one requirement brings serious consequences and reveals the sacred character of His law.ST Apr 15, 1875RH Jun 22, 1911 God is very particular about obedience: one single act by one man and one woman cost Eden, an act so serious it required God to give His only Son to die, for God is in earnest and sin is exceeding sinful transgression of His law.RH Jun 22, 1911ST Mar 5, 1912 God's law condemned sin and its sentence banished the first parents from Paradise.ST Sep 30, 1886
Disobedience shut humanity from the tree and cost Eden, Paradise, the beautiful home, dominion, innocency and joys.RH Jan 4, 1912ST Nov 19, 1894RH Jul 13, 1916ST Mar 30, 1904 Rebellion brought death upon them and their descendants with the earth cursed, and the pair went forth in shame, sorrow, sighs and bitter regrets to reap transgression's reward, marking the beginning of separation from the tree of life under conditions of sin, pain and death in contrast with the second Adam's victory and reign.RH Jan 4, 1912ST Nov 19, 1894ST Aug 11, 1914 Through Satan's deception humanity lost dominion and was driven in shame from Eden.ST Aug 11, 1914ST
Adam and Eve lost their Eden home through seeking forbidden knowledge, and that loss illustrates the grave cost of unholy desires and aims in bringing an experience God never intended.RH Aug 4, 1910 The mother of all living expected greater exaltation by transgression in believing and acting a lie but found instead humiliation, degradation and death in removal to work the ground, the first disappointment whose end is not yet reached and which laid the foundation for every other disappointment, since disappointments come from false hopes and are mortals' common experience largely on account of sin.ST Aug 13, 1902
Their moral powers were weakened by indulgence of perverted appetite, and their being sent forth to till the ground was recorded for all who should live on earth to deter recklessly departing from God's requirements and following the same steps.ST Jul 8, 1880 Their expulsion stands as an object lesson warning against intemperance, for intemperate desire led to Eden's loss and temperance in all things is connected with restoration to Eden.ST May 6, 1889
They had to leave their beautiful home where the Tree of Life stood because they chose death instead of life.ST Jul 7, 1909 God had told them His laws of life and His purpose that they represent Him, had shown them the happiness, peace and everlasting life of obedience with their children and the great suffering disobedience would bring on themselves and children, and had warned them of the enemy and the one place he would be allowed to entice them at the tree of knowledge of good and evil, yet they were deceived because knowing both good and evil seemed pleasant and profitable.ST Jul 7, 1909
Placed with permission to eat of every tree but one, they ate the forbidden fruit and opened the floodgates of woe, after which sin grew worse until God destroyed the world by the Flood saving only Noah and his sons, and has steadily increased since.ST May 26, 1898 If humanity's falls had ended with Adam driven out, people would now be physically, mentally and morally better, but instead people repeat Adam's violation instead of learning from his example, and since that fall human history has been a succession of falls with greater crime, disease and loss of health, beauty and moral power, men becoming more and more disobedient.ST Feb 11, 1875RH Mar 4, 1875RH Jul 9, 1901ST Feb 11, 1897
Man apostatized and fell under the power of the enemy, giving Satan subjects and sympathizers on earth which had been a paradise and establishing a precedent for his rebellion there.ST Jun 6, 1878RH Jan 29, 1867 This makes this world the place where Satan sought to establish his kingdom and display rebellion's results, and the sending forth planted Satan's principles of rule in man with man, containing the social volcano of world war in seed as the oak is in the acorn, so that world war is the final result of the conquest begun in Eden.RH Jan 9, 1900RH Jun 24, 1915
Transgression left them unfit to dwell in perfect Paradise, yet the fall did not remove obligation to obey God's moral law.ST Mar 17, 1914 Expulsion and assignment to work the ground from which man was made did not make Adam unable to obey later commands, for he understood and carried out the new command to leave.RH May 12, 1859 Lamenting the expulsion while overlooking the fruit-taking is like condemning enforcement while excusing the offense, and the verse does not mean God compelled Adam to sin, for his disobedience was not necessary in order to obey God's command.RH Dec 10, 1908RH Jun 18, 1861
Hypocrisy, deception and fraud are the chief ways by which Satan and the fallen angels ruined mankind.ST May 27, 1880 Eve's desire to know evil as well as good parallels attempting to experience folly while retaining wisdom.RH Jan 12, 1869 The serpent who caused dominion's loss is the devil and Satan, and the misery and death that came on Eden's happy dwellers through believing his false promise, ending in expulsion, finds its last and highest fulfillment in antichrist's characteristic lie in opposing God and declaring himself to be God.RH Sep 29, 1859ST Mar 12, 1885
Satan planned to beguile Adam and Eve so God would make some provision to pardon them, in which he and all fallen angels would then share God's mercy.ST Jan 16, 1879 If pardon failed, their transgression would place them in rebellion with the fallen angels so all could unite to take and hold Eden as home, and if they gained the tree of life their strength would equal holy angels so that even God Himself could not expel them.ST Jan 16, 1879 The fall of man came in swift succession after the angels' fall as dissension by foes in God's household, rooted in pride with the creature judging the Creator's words and works, exalting self and calling in question God's righteousness and truth, and the sending from Eden launches God's plan for redemption; pride is identified as the cause of paradise's loss.ST Jan 30, 1901RH Feb 25, 1873
Every man has a Paradise around him till he sins, when the angel of accusing conscience drives him from his Eden, for eating like the serpent leads to being driven out.ST Mar 10, 1914ST Sep 4, 1901 The fall ending in expulsion was witnessed by angels, the same who fought for God when Satan sought supremacy, who shouted for joy over creation of the world and its sinless inhabitants, and who desire to look into redemption.RH Mar 19, 1901ST Dec 1, 1909ST Apr 27, 1904 Those messengers are now intensely interested in the fallen redeemed race, working in union with human agencies, invisible with visible, to bind up sin's wounds and bruises and restore God's moral image in man for the salvation of perishing sinners.RH Mar 19, 1901ST Dec 1, 1909 The primal fall described in the verse is presented as the event after which God's wrath rested on humanity.ST May 7, 1894
Tree of Life Barred
God sent fallen man out of Eden to cut him off from the tree of life, lest after knowing good and evil and eating the forbidden fruit he should also take of life and live forever as a sinner, perpetuating sin and sorrow and misery forever.ST Nov 16, 1876ST Jul 16, 1912RH Aug 29, 1854RH Mar 22, 1860RH Dec 8, 1868 The expulsion carried out the threatened sentence of death by cutting off the means of keeping life going, for had man been allowed to keep eating he would have lived forever, and being shut out he could not continue to live.ST Nov 16, 1876RH Aug 29, 1854RH Mar 22, 1860RH Dec 8, 1868ST The loss covered every life man had, so no part of him was naturally immortal and unaffected by removal, and human beings do not have life forever in themselves apart from eating of that tree.ST Nov 16, 1876RH Dec 8, 1868ST Everlasting life belongs with character in harmony with God, not with sinful existence or self-salvation, for sin persisted in brings eternal death.ST Jul 16, 1912
The tree was a life-giving arrangement designed as a source of vitality to perpetuate man's days through continued eating of its fruit, so being shut out brings loss of available life.ST Feb 27, 1879RH Mar 22, 1860ST Jan 14, 1875 Endless life required continued access, and deprived of it human life gradually wears out, the body degenerating and at last returning to dust.ST Feb 27, 1879ST Jan 11, 1877ST Jun 1, 1915 Life was God's gift continued only on condition of obedience, so disobedience required giving up life, which is what dying thou shalt die means.ST Jan 11, 1877 The connection of the tree with immortality stands at the center of the account.RH Mar 17, 1874
Its fruit had supernatural virtue as the antidote of death, so that to eat was to live forever, and its leaves sustained life and immortality.ST Mar 31, 1909 Before sin Adam had access to the river flowing out of Eden, which was the River of Life, and as long as he drank of that river and ate of the tree he lived, being fed by the very life of God, until after sin he was cut off from both.ST Apr 7, 1909 Through redemption purchased by blood fallen people may still eat its life-giving fruit, for its branches hang over the wall to the lower world, and Christ is the fountain and bread of life whose words are Spirit and life to the overcomer who receives the tree in the midst of the paradise of God.ST Mar 31, 1909
While Adam obeyed, life was assured through free access to its source, and no power could take it from him.ST Sep 17, 1912 Had he continued to obey that access would not have been taken away, for the promise of eternal life was conditional, and obedience and loyalty would have kept the way open to continue eating and living forever.ST Sep 17, 1912ST Feb 23, 1915
The account gives no indication that they ever ate from the tree of life.RH May 26, 1874 It was provided as the means by which Adam could receive immortality if obedient, but he had not eaten from it before he sinned, and after sin God barred him, thereby preventing a sinner from becoming immortal.RH Aug 29, 1854 The word also in the warning shows he had eaten of knowledge but not of life, and with access guarded his death was certain.RH Sep 26, 1854
Those who held the other view teach that they had partaken of its life-giving fruit, even repeatedly, in innocency before being sent forth to till the ground.ST Aug 27, 1902ST Aug 27, 1902 They did not live forever because immortality depended not on tasting once but on eating continually, yet their eating before banishment contributed to the much longer lives of Adam and his immediate posterity compared with men now.ST Aug 27, 1902 That tree is but one literal tree throughout the Bible, the same tree now in the city of God transplanted from Eden, standing on both sides of the river by completely overarching it, faintly illustrated by the banyan of India whose branches take root and become new trunks so one tree becomes connected throughout.ST Aug 27, 1902
Being sent from Eden to till the ground was the immediate execution of the death sentence by exclusion from the tree.RH Dec 22, 1863ST May 29, 1884ST Apr 16, 1885ST Oct 2, 1879 Free access and eating would have caused living forever, so taking it away took life in effect and made death certain, and that shutting away alone was enough to leave him to decay and return to earth.RH Dec 22, 1863ST Apr 16, 1885 Return to the ground from which man was taken explains what God meant by death, with no immortal intelligent soul escaping that sentence.ST Oct 2, 1879 The guarded way back also points to access to eternal life through Jesus the Door rather than by any other way.ST May 29, 1884
The words live forever mean literal life and mere eternal existence, not merely happiness.RH Dec 22, 1863ST Jan 11, 1877 Adam could have lived forever in sin, and God still wills the sinner to turn and become happy, as shown by the promise concerning the woman's seed given before the sentence.RH Dec 22, 1863ST Jan 11, 1877 The guarded tree here is not Christ, since all are invited to come to Christ for pardon and life and happiness with no cherubim and flaming sword barring the way, rather than guarding the way to Christ.RH Dec 22, 1863ST Aug 28, 1879
God shut the entire man away lest he eat and live forever, and so keeps there from being eternal sin and eternal sinners.ST Jan 1, 1894 The entire man sinned and the entire man died, not an immortal soul that lives on more alive after death, for man was taken from dust and at death returns to dust.ST Jan 1, 1894
After transgression God cut off access to the means of continuing life so the penalty of the law could be carried out and Adam return to dust.RH Jun 25, 1867 The tree had been given so lives could be perpetuated, and expulsion followed condemnation to die. Paradise and the tree, once in Eden, were later removed to the city of God, and Paradise lost through transgression can be regained through obedience.RH Jun 25, 1867
The tree remained on earth behind a guarded way of access for a time, and the garden remained for a time guarded from human access by the cherubim's flaming sword.RH Sep 21, 1869 The tree itself could not die, and to continue its life-giving function without dying it was removed from earth to heaven, to God's Paradise in the third heaven.RH Sep 21, 1869ST Jan 18, 1916 The garden was probably removed at the time of the Flood.RH Sep 21, 1869
Mankind remains in a present state of exclusion, and eating its fruit is the sure pledge of immortal life, so those excluded cannot live as long as those who have access.RH Dec 8, 1868RH Feb 10, 1874 The wicked are likewise excluded, so their punishment in the fire does not mean they live eternally, while the righteous in paradise with free access receive eternal life.RH Dec 8, 1868RH Jul 14, 1874 Return comes only by overcoming the sinful nature, so living forever while continuing in sin is impossible.RH Feb 10, 1874
God sent fallen humanity out to prevent eating and living forever as sinners, exactly as the words state at the beginning of the Bible.RH Jul 7, 1874ST Sep 13, 1905RH Dec 22, 1863 Removal limited life in sin with the purpose of bringing sin and death to an end, and outside Adam had to till the ground from which he had been made.ST Sep 13, 1905 The life given the race in Adam was thereby forfeited by disobedience and utterly lost, and approach was made impossible.RH Dec 22, 1863 This exclusion is terrible yet merciful, because to become immortal in sin would be the greatest curse and a great calamity, and endless life in sin would be miserable.RH Dec 22, 1863ST Sep 5, 1911 In mercy God cut man off so sin and its curse would not be perpetuated forever and become more intolerable, for man could not make himself and his descendants immortal in sinful condition.RH Aug 7, 1866 The forfeited life cannot be regained by man and should not be desired apart from the gospel, but life and immortality are brought to light in Christ the resurrection and the life, in whom all die in Adam and are made alive in order, they that are Christ's at His coming, to whom alone the promises belong, the sinner feeding on Christ by faith in prospect of eternal life until as final overcomer the tree is restored to him.RH Dec 22, 1863
Expulsion to toil on the sin-cursed earth thwarted Satan, who through disobedience had brought sin and wanted man also to take of life and live forever, which would make his work coexistent with God's and bring eternal misery.ST Jul 2, 1894RH Jul 9, 1872 God removed man from where everything grew spontaneously and he had only to dress and keep it, and set him to till the ground under labor and sorrow.RH Jul 9, 1872 This hardship was better than luxury and idleness, for labor kept men honestly occupied and restrained deeper sin, while thorns and poor soil reminded them of sin and urged them to seek what was lost, without God abandoning the earth or His purpose for it.ST Jul 2, 1894 After sentence Adam was sent from beauty and plenty to face labor for food and return to the ground from which he was taken.
The expulsion came after the first test of loyalty over knowledge, debarring sinful man from life's fruit.ST Aug 6, 1896 The tree was given to perpetuate an endless existence of worthy character, but sinful man was sent forth lest he perpetuate a sinful and miserable existence.ST Aug 6, 1896 This sending belongs to man's fall, history, and salvation, with which trees are intimately connected.ST Aug 6, 1896
Being kept from life prefigured the gospel and was necessary to check sin.RH Jul 26, 1906RH Mar 19, 1914 God's purpose was not merely to cut off sinners but to conquer sin so completely that it would never arise again.RH Jul 26, 1906 With the way barred, eternal life could not come from humanity itself but only from outside through God's plan, foreshadowed in the promise that the woman's seed would bruise the serpent's head, through which every person can be saved, showing no other route.RH Jul 26, 1906RH Mar 19, 1914
The driving out did not mean God purposed to shut the family away from life forever, for man was created to live forever and it remained the purpose that he enjoy unending life, but life must be forever divorced from sin.RH Sep 9, 1902 Hence God provided another tree of life of which mankind may freely partake, which is Jesus Christ eaten by faith, since sin and faith cannot exist together, so that by coming to Him the sinner turns from sins and by partaking of His flesh and blood the life of righteousness is maintained within, and there remains a real spiritual paradise where those who will may live in touch with heaven.RH Sep 9, 1902 In this sense being sent forth did not remove all access, because Christ as the tree of life has been accessible to Adam's descendants ever since.RH Sep 10, 1901
In depriving fallen man of the tree God also withheld the secret of what life is, for wise reasons.ST Dec 11, 1901 Magnetism and electricity are great forces closely related and analogous to life, and their true nature belongs to the same withheld secret.ST Dec 11, 1901
Death and Mortality
Human beings do not have life forever in themselves and are not naturally inherently immortal, for the life given at creation was conditional, depending on access to the tree of life and on obedience, and exclusion from it begins mortality and death.ST Nov 16, 1876RH Mar 22, 1860RH Dec 8, 1868STST Feb 3, 1914 The tree was a life-giving arrangement designed as a source of vitality to perpetuate days through continued eating of its fruit, and to be shut out from it is to lose available life, proving no tenure of life independent of it.RH Mar 22, 1860ST Apr 4, 1900ST Jun 1, 1904 Living forever requires eating of that tree, and God drove man out and set cherubim with a flaming sword to guard the way, leaving mankind in a present state of exclusion so the sentence of death would be carried out.ST Nov 16, 1876RH Dec 8, 1868RH Dec 22, 1863 If man had been allowed to keep eating he would have lived forever, but because he was shut out he could not continue to live.ST Nov 16, 1876RH Mar 22, 1860ST Oct 3, 1906 The loss covered every life man had, so no part of him was naturally immortal and unaffected by removal from the tree.ST Nov 16, 1876
Sin persisted in brings eternal death, so everlasting life belongs with character in harmony with God, not with sinful existence or self-salvation.ST Jul 16, 1912RH Nov 28, 1912 God will not suffer sin to be perpetuated but will end sin and perpetuate righteousness, and when redemption is complete the exclusion is reversed and the righteous are restored to partake that they may live forever when corruptible puts on incorruption and mortal puts on immortality.ST Jul 16, 1912RH Nov 28, 1912 Man did not possess life in himself even while sinless, for continued life depended on access to the tree rather than on an immortal soul that could not die, and expulsion with the guarded way meant return to dust.ST Feb 20, 1893ST Sep 17, 1912ST Jun 1, 1904ST Nov 21, 1900 Human life was not self-sustaining but borrowed, retained only through faith and obedience to what God provided, with hope resting in Jesus Christ who can re-create.ST Apr 2, 1912ST Dec 26, 1906ST Nov 21, 1900
Before choice Adam was neither naturally mortal nor naturally immortal but capable of either destiny, receiving immortality through obedience or losing life through disobedience, life through the tree or a mortal dying nature returning to dust.RH Sep 26, 1854RH May 1, 1879ST Dec 26, 1906ST Dec 25, 1893 He was a perfect physical being possessing eternal life by faith connecting him with the Source of all life, and had he believed God he would have continued to live eternally until character became fixed and his whole being was made immortal not subject to death, but by sinning he broke that connection and became a dying creature.ST Dec 26, 1906ST Dec 25, 1893 In this sense he was neither immortal nor created mortal but a candidate for immortality, for immortal means deathless incorruptible which he did not attain, and mortal means subject to death which God did not create.ST Sep 29, 1898 He had pure healthy holy uncorrupted flesh with God's eternal life flowing through unhindered, and had he lived always in harmony with the law of God's life so as to develop incorruptible character no temptation could corrupt, God would have placed upon it the stamp of immortality by making flesh incorruptible deathless.ST Sep 29, 1898
God placed Adam on probation with reference to continuance of life, not granting immortality at creation but making him capable of inheriting it after forming by obedience a character entitled to that gift.RH Apr 7, 1874ST Mar 4, 1880RH Mar 3, 1874 If he sinned he must be shut out from the tree and die, while continued obedience would have kept access to live forever, for life was given with conditions annexed.RH Apr 7, 1874ST Mar 4, 1880RH Jul 14, 1874 Adam held life on condition of obedience and immortality could not be his until probation was complete, and rebellion brought sentence of death rather than a higher or happier existence.RH Apr 7, 1874 The original condition and the provision after the fall both center on choosing God's way of obedience, with life secured through Christ's righteousness and obedience for those who accept Him as substitute. Before transgression he could have continued forever through obedience and partaking and was not inherently immortal, but shut away he became absolutely mortal.RH Jan 24, 1865RH Dec 22, 1863 Being sent shut the whole race away lest sinners eat and live forever, and only those who believe and overcome will have the tree restored by the Saviour to live forever, proving every soul is not by nature destined to live as long as God exists.RH Dec 22, 1863
Adam's immortality was not natural inherent or part of nature but depended on God's provision, favor, and the tree in Eden that could have sustained life.RH Mar 31, 1863RH Mar 22, 1860ST Jan 10, 1878 Before the fall he was mortal and dependent, not naturally immortal, the tree having real design to sustain life which would have no purpose if natural immortality were possessed.RH Nov 29, 1870RH Aug 29, 1854 Disobedience brought mortality and eventual death as threatened, death was made sure from that day, and the expulsion exposes the error of assuming pre-fall immortality and of hereditary total depravity.RH Nov 29, 1870RH Aug 29, 1854 Being cut off from the tree of God's power and energy whose life-giving properties had perpetuated the endowed gift made man at once subject to corruption, mortality and decay.ST Apr 9, 1912 His connection with God that had let him know the power and pleasure of everlasting life was broken, and isolation left him to know only weakness and pains of everlasting death, passing from life to death, made from dust and sent to till the ground to return to dust.ST Apr 9, 1912
After sin God cut Adam off from his source of life and immortality, yet he did not die at once but like a tree severed from nourishment weakened over time and returned to dust, fulfilling dying thou shalt die, the sentence of literal death not immediately carried out.RH Apr 11, 1865 Continued access was necessary, so separation meant separation from life's source and eventual death.ST Apr 2, 1912 The verse puts the physical death penalty for breaking the original law into effect, cutting off the means of keeping alive so man would live by toil, suffer mortal ills, and return to dust.RH Jan 5, 1864 Adam lived 930 years and died under a sentence never revoked, with nature set against him to wear him down until sleep in dust, and that dying nature was passed to all posterity, which without salvation through Jesus Christ would be an eternal unconscious night.ST Jun 17, 1897RH Jan 5, 1864 Barred from the tree that would have continued God-given life, Adam and the family came under the death penalty, and those continuing in sin face eternal death rather than eternal life.ST Jun 17, 1897
Being sent back to the ground means God took back the life-breath by which Adam became a living soul, for that life was not an immortal heavenly being inside the body but the principle by which God made him alive and kept by God.ST Dec 9, 1880ST Jun 12, 1879RH Dec 29, 1868 When Adam died God took that life again into His keeping, leaving him with just as much life thought and knowledge as before it was given, which was none at all.RH Dec 29, 1868ST Jun 12, 1879 Death does not return to paradise or bring conscious life with God and does not open the door back to the paradise from which sin expelled him, but hope of endless life is in resurrection when the second Adam who has life in himself gives life a second time that shall never end.ST Jun 12, 1879ST Jun 12, 1879 God deprived access to the means by which life could have been prolonged forever, and the death imposed was cessation of life, God not changing Adam's nature.RH Nov 24, 1863 Return to the ground explains what God meant by death, and no immortal intelligent soul escaped that sentence.RH Nov 24, 1863ST Oct 2, 1879
After disobedience God sent man out cutting off access through which life would have been sustained, so man became mortal wearing out and dying, the result of sin being death of the whole person.RH Mar 22, 1860ST Oct 3, 1906ST May 11, 1915 Expelled humanity lost access to the life represented by the tree and became mortal unable to live forever without provision from the Creator, proving no undying principle living without the tree.RH Mar 22, 1860ST May 11, 1915 God sent sinful man out to cut him off so he would not live forever but would die, and approach was made impossible.RH Dec 22, 1863 The life given the race in Adam was thereby forfeited by disobedience and utterly lost in execution of death sentence, yet terrible as exclusion is it is merciful because immortality in sin would be greatest curse.RH Dec 22, 1863 Forfeited life cannot be regained by man and should not be desired as sinner, but life and immortality are brought to light through the gospel in Christ who is resurrection and life, for in Adam all die and in Christ all shall be made alive each in order, they that are Christ's at His coming, to whom alone promises of eternal life belong.RH Dec 22, 1863 The sinner is invited to Christ for removal of sin, and when forgiven has eternal life in prospect by faith feeding on Christ without yet being restored to the tree, needing to fight the good fight and overcome before Christ restores it.RH Dec 22, 1863
Expulsion as part of the sentence with loss of the tree and subjection to physical death means redemption must include recovery of physical life lost, for driving made death sure and entailed death upon posterity, so redemption is salvation from death and resurrection of the dead has been the gospel hope from the beginning.ST Oct 4, 1905ST Apr 3, 1884 The mortality settled upon Adam is natural temporal first death distinct from eternal second death, inflicted as penalty upon Adam for his sin only since he alone was transgressor.ST Mar 3, 1881 His children received from him a nature no higher than his own, were with him shut out, became subject to death and return to dust, to them not as penalty but as consequence of relation to Adam unremitted by repentance faith and pardon.ST May 15, 1884 Saints justified and pardoned still die in Adam, and infants with no sins still die not as condemned sinners but as mortal creatures cut off by Adam's action, while second death is the separate penalty for personal sins answered at judgment.ST Mar 3, 1881RH Apr 29, 1873 From expulsion onward history proceeds under Adam's fallen mortal nature, while Christ provides new probation where final destiny depends on each one's own course.RH Apr 29, 1873ST May 31, 1877
By sinning man forfeited given life and existence, and from expulsion is mortal perishing with nothing in nature saving from death, immortality and everlasting life beyond own reach apart from the tree that kept alive as long as he ate.RH Mar 22, 1860RH Aug 30, 1870 Excluded from that only source, humanity could not live forever and lost its only source of immortality, so any later immortality depends on further provision from the Creator.RH Mar 22, 1860 The expulsion left Adam able to give posterity no more than he possessed, having lost dominion, Eden home, and soul sold to Satan which none but Creator could buy back, so God gave His Son that believers should not perish but have everlasting life.ST Feb 13, 1912 Driven from the tree he lost hope of immortality, was condemned to hard labor and ultimately to dust and death, and without redemption his death would have been the end of the race.RH Sep 20, 1864RH Jul 19, 1870 Man thus forfeited original title to immortality so the dead have life in no sense, never recovered except by a Redeemer, and dead souls are not alive conscious capable of happiness or misery between death and resurrection, restoration coming only by resurrection.ST Aug 12, 1875
Belief in the serpent's falsehood that death would not come led to expulsion and loss of life, proving the assurance false and showing rejecting God's warning brings death contrary to inherent immortality.RH Jun 8, 1916RH Jan 28, 1858ST Oct 16, 1879ST Sep 13, 1905 God had warned eating would bring death while Satan proclaimed the first doctrine of soul immortality, and disobedience brought death as warned.RH Jun 8, 1916ST Sep 13, 1905 The verse belongs to Genesis 1 and 3 showing humans became mortal through choosing sin, is listed among texts showing humanity mortal, and shows man formed from ground and sent to labor on it.STRH Feb 20, 1872ST Oct 31, 1911ST Apr 26, 1905 Sin cut humanity off from life's source making a dying people whose dying leads to death.ST Loss of the only source meant earthly birth could no longer sustain forever leaving no hope without remedy, so eternal life requires being born again or re-created because God cannot give eternal existence to corrupt old sinful life.ST Apr 4, 1900ST Apr 4, 1900
After sin God sent Adam out bringing guilt distress, banishment from Paradise, and ultimately death, whereas access would have allowed continuing living.RH Sep 18, 1855RH Sep 21, 1869 Life outside involves toil ending in dust, kept from eating and living forever.RH Sep 18, 1855 Exclusion marked end of probation in innocence, and under death sentence he would live a dying life until returning to ground, deprived of the tree his life gradually wearing out.RH Jun 26, 1866ST Jan 19, 1882 This applies to Adam's Eden condition, not to endless life of redeemed saints in glory.RH Jun 26, 1866 The expulsion was love preventing forever fallen misery, removing access lest he live forever in fallen state and become immortal in misery.ST Feb 10, 1881ST Oct 28, 1875ST Aug 18, 1887 Adam remained mortal, living 930 years in toil and sorrow before dying.ST Feb 10, 1881ST Oct 28, 1875
Commentary part 2 of 3
Pioneers and periodicals
479 sources
God actually sent Adam out of the garden of Eden to work the ground from which he had been formed and earn his bread by labor outside it.RH Nov 22, 1906ST May 12, 1890 This was literal history of the first disobedience, when Adam and Eve broke God's law and were sentenced to leave their innocent home under curse and death.ST Sep 9, 1930ST Apr 7, 1914RH Jul 1, 1909 He cut them off from the tree of life lest, after eating the forbidden fruit and knowing good and evil, they should eat of it also and live forever as sinners, perpetuating sin and misery forever.ST Nov 16, 1876ST Jul 16, 1912RH Aug 29, 1854 Man had no life forever in himself, for life was conditional on obedience and access to the tree, so exclusion began mortality and made death certain.ST Nov 16, 1876RH Mar 22, 1860RH Dec 8, 1868 Eternal life lost by this sending is found only in God's Son, and Christ as second Adam restores what was forfeited, opening the way back to the tree and Paradise regained.ST Feb 3, 1914RH Mar 24, 1904RH Aug 7, 1916RH Jul 3, 1900RH Oct 3, 1912
Literal History Affirmed
The verse belongs to the creation-and-fall account in Genesis 1-3, to Genesis 1-11 recording God's dealings with the race, and to Genesis 3-5 telling of temptation, fall and promise.ST Jan 3, 1911ST Aug 9, 1905ST Mar 17, 1914 It is part of the first ten chapters which give an epitome of 1,656 years of history before the universal Deluge, and the whole Bible stands upon that record of creation and fall. That early history grounds doctrines, redemption, and the biblical message that follows, so to reject it is to reject the foundation for the teachings joined to it and to undermine the authority of what follows.ST Jan 3, 1911ST Feb 22, 1883 It belongs to the history of humanity's first sin and fall as the starting point of the events leading to redemption and restoration.ST Dec 24, 1885
It is literal factual history received by Moses through revelation from God and given by inspiration, to be received on divine authority as reliable Scripture for doctrine, reproof, correction and instruction.ST Jul 28, 1881ST Aug 25, 1881ST Nov 1, 1905 It records the real sending of fallen man out of Eden to work the ground, and is not allegory, symbols of inner nature, spiritualized legend, tradition, fiction, fable, myth, poem, forgery or error.ST Sep 20, 1899ST Jul 28, 1881ST Nov 13, 1893ST Nov 25, 1889 Because the fall truly happened redemption was truly needed, and the gospel is built on fact and not imagination; to call the fall imaginary makes the whole gospel a fable.ST Nov 13, 1893 The truthfulness of the entire Bible and the whole fabric of Christianity depends on its truthfulness, so the whole Bible must be accepted together or rejected together, and to diminish confidence in it endangers the whole, most of all when religious teachers slight it while professing reverence.ST Nov 13, 1893ST Aug 25, 1881
The early history is plain and clear so that a child may be enlightened by reading it, and it concerns the true Adam meaning man, made in God's image and likeness in Genesis 1:26-27 as part of the creation pronounced very good, given inheritance and dominion.ST Jan 28, 1903 Adam was a real man with real history, not a figure who disappears, and the account keeps absolute authority and historical character as the foundation for every religious belief.ST Apr 2, 1902 Mankind does not come into the world with a brute and savage inheritance to be subdued, and that claim has no place if the Bible account is true, nor is the account a product of evolution working throughout the universe.ST Apr 2, 1902
The New Testament treats the fall as real history and part of the foundation of redemption, explaining the introduction of death among humanity.ST Mar 9, 1888ST May 8, 1879 Christ and His apostles held the record of man's origin and fall in Creation and Eden as fact, Paul referring to Adam and Eve as first parents, so rejecting it rejects their teaching.ST Mar 9, 1888ST Nov 1, 1905 Faith in the Bible story of man's fall and his helpless sinful condition as the word of God is fundamental.ST Mar 20, 1907
The inspired record of Eden and the fall explains traditions of an original age of purity and hope of restoration, and substantially agrees with Assyrian tablet legends of creation and the fall.ST Feb 10, 1887ST Aug 12, 1880 It agrees in all essentials with Karen traditions about creation, the sinless pair in the garden, and the fall.ST Jul 25, 1911 That true account of creation, fall and flood was known in remote time by the Karens, and its traditions are still retained even while wandering far from God in demon worship, showing they once knew Jehovah, whom God regards with compassion as a despised mistreated people.RH Aug 10, 1905
The first few chapters telling how sin began stand opposite the last chapters of Revelation carrying the mind to when sin shall be no more.ST Aug 17, 1915 The fall belongs to the study of Satan's work and redemption through Christ.RH May 11, 1911 The driving out begins the course of divine history running until God was manifested in the flesh, and that whole course is revelation and prophecy of Christ's coming in the flesh, not merely general history leading to that time.RH Dec 31, 1901
Those who held otherwise described the story of the Fall as literature for ethical instruction rather than a literal account.ST Mar 20, 1907
The weight of testimony holds the fall was downward from moral rectitude, innocence and a comparatively high level, not upward evolution from savagery through barbarism to civilization.ST Nov 22, 1910AUST Jun 14, 1920 The Bible teaches the Fall and denies evolution, so the two cannot both be held, and Christians must pin faith to God's Word.AUST Jun 14, 1920 The evolutionary major premise of successive geological ages is directly antagonistic to the most fundamental facts of the first chapters, and that premise is the weakest point and tender spot of the whole theory which its friends never want touched. Since man sinned he has been degenerating rather than evolving upward, with proof in that no men today equal the giants in strength before Christ; to claim an upward fall from ape and animals destroys atonement, what Christ came to accomplish, and the Bible's authority.RH Apr 1, 1909ST Jun 3, 1913 Allowing geological hypothesis to set aside Moses, putting evolution for creation and preferring Darwin's Origin of Species to Moses, rejects the Word on which Christ's faith rested.ST Feb 13, 1901
Denying the historicity of the fall and of being sent out to till the ground repudiates God's Word and with it the Spirit, life and power revealed in Christ.ST Oct 20, 1909 It removes the basis for understanding incarnation, atonement, redemption and Christianity, and for humanity's need of redemption and salvation from the fall.ST Nov 15, 1883ST Apr 26, 1905ST Sep 13, 1905 It logically leads from questioning Moses to sifting all prophets and apostles, and to denying miracles, Christ's superhuman birth, vicarious death, physical resurrection, bodily ascension and divinity, as well as the flood, Sabbath, regeneration and restoration.ST Oct 20, 1909 If humanity arose by evolution with no fall, there was no fall and atonement is undermined.ST Nov 15, 1883
Rejecting creation-and-fall wrongly makes salvation a matter of good works and human service. Belief in the record of the fall is bound up with faith in God's Son and connected with the plan of salvation.ST Feb 17, 1888 Redemption is the means bringing people back to God's favor and to immortality.ST Feb 19, 1880
The account of the fall in Eden is identified as the basis of the old theology's teaching of original sin as guilt handed on from the fall, in contrast to explaining inheritance as inherited appetites and passions.RH Oct 15, 1901
God knew beforehand what Adam and Eve would think and do.ST Nov 22, 1910 He foresaw the human fall when creating the world, with redemption already included in His purpose in creation.ST Feb 11, 1913 The charge that He was unfair and laid a trap and then condemned man for falling into it, leading men to reject revelation, presumes by human reason to balance God's dealings and pass judgment on the Almighty, ignoring that He reads hearts, knows motives and sees the end from the beginning.RH Feb 18, 1902
Setting and Wording
The events belong in the Garden of Eden immediately after the six days' work of creation, where Satan stood as tempter.ST Jul 7, 1898 He was once Lucifer, the Day Star or Light-bringer, one of the morning stars that sang together and shouted for joy when the foundations of the earth were laid, yet he had already fallen when Adam was placed in Eden.ST Jul 7, 1898
The sending out occurred within the first 130 years of Adam's life, before Seth was born, belonging to the early history in which God gave the first gospel promise and a divinely directed system of worship after the fall.RH Dec 25, 1913 It is the loss of Paradise and access to the tree of life, and because the first man lived 930 years the generations after him could hear firsthand from him about the garden where he had lived and the events by which it was lost.RH Dec 10, 1861
God actually sent Adam forth from Eden to till the ground from which he had been formed and made, to work it outside the garden and earn bread in the sweat of his face as the literal consequence of disobedience.RH Nov 22, 1906ST May 12, 1890ST Jul 26, 1910RH Nov 11, 1858 After humanity fell into sin the expulsion brought loss of Eden and life under the curse of sin and death, with return to dust following sin, and the first Adam who fell in a garden was driven into the wilderness.ST May 12, 1890RH Jul 27, 1876 His former place of pleasure had offered no security against falling, and this sending belongs to the biblical account of the fall and the plan of salvation from it.ST Jul 26, 1910RH Nov 11, 1858
The verb for tilling means labor, and it can refer to hired or compulsory labor, but its use for Adam sent to work the ground does not imply chattel slavery.RH Oct 1, 1861
After taking what God had reserved for Himself, Adam was sent outside the garden to till the ground, to work less fertile ground from which he had been taken.RH Jan 21, 1909RH Mar 31, 1903RH Feb 9, 1905 Outside meant tilling under burden, toil and anxiety rather than the happy labor known before, with labor in place of spontaneous provision along with hardship and the effects of the curse.ST Jan 23, 1879RH May 5, 1863 This contrasts with his first employment in his sinless state cultivating the trees and flowers God had planted.RH Feb 9, 1905
The garden was a distinct place and not the whole earth, a real place and locality where the tree stood.ST Jan 31, 1911RH Nov 20, 1860ST Nov 3, 1881 It was Eden, the Paradise of God and humanity's home and first schoolroom, the paradise from which humanity was shut out by transgression.RH Jun 23, 1910ST Nov 3, 1881 The Tree of Life there was a literal tree, removed to heaven and destined to return as the center of a sinless earth, to be restored to man when Paradise itself is restored and the whole man is redeemed.ST Jan 31, 1911ST Nov 3, 1881
The garden remained on earth until the Flood, specially blessed and kept free from the curse that sin brought upon the earth, when God withdrew it.ST Feb 20, 1879ST Sep 25, 1907 It will return more gloriously adorned than before as the renewed home of redeemed people.ST Feb 20, 1879ST Sep 25, 1907 Eden was where the first week and the first day began and where the true date line was, and after sin entered God removed Eden from the earth, so that with the Flood changing the surface of the earth and causing the world that then was to perish its location cannot be identified on the world that now is.RH Aug 19, 1915
Just before the Flood God transplanted the Garden of Eden itself to heaven, with its tree of life and the vines Adam and Eve had trained into their bower home.ST Jan 11, 1916 Adam's Eden home had been left just as it was when he was driven out, while angels guarded the tree of life so fallen man could not eat and become an immortal sinner.ST Jan 11, 1916 That preserved Eden with its trees is now within the city God has built for the saved, which is to become the capital of the earthly home.ST Jan 11, 1916
Adam crossed the threshold of his Eden home for the last time, leaving it behind.RH Nov 6, 1916ST Sep 22, 1898 That departure marks the point since which great events have taken place on earth, beginning the history of sin on earth whose last days will be the most warlike and revolutionary time since Adam and Eve left.RH Nov 6, 1916ST Sep 22, 1898
The sending marks the first expulsion from Eden after sin had defiled the earth, God sending Adam away from the garden to work the ground from which he had been formed.ST This began the long history of human sin on earth, which the Flood later cleansed in part but did not end.ST It places humanity's long experience of sin and death in the millennia since Eden was lost.RH Dec 17, 1914
When Adam ate of the tree of knowledge the Garden disappeared in the sense that man was sent out to till the ground from which he was taken.ST Dec 16, 1903 Being gifted with knowledge, that is with a brain, man learned he was not like the beast of the field going up and down devouring what came in its path but must live by the sweat of his brow.ST Dec 16, 1903 The decree to obtain a living through work was made to compel him to use and develop his intelligence, the one faculty distinguishing him from the rest of creation, since any function atrophies from disuse and man would have no intellect if he were not required to use it.ST Dec 16, 1903
God designed men to till the soil for a living, making agriculture the honorable pursuit and His plan devised by the Creator for the maintenance of the race.ST Mar 25, 1903 Departing from that plan for the uncertain, dependent occupations of the cities bears terrible fruit in unemployment, helplessness, discouragement, dependence, oppression, debauchery and crime.ST Mar 25, 1903 The ground from which Adam was taken became the place he had to cultivate, and recovery from the fall is connected with practical education and manual training promoting industry and discipline.RH Jun 6, 1907
Adam obeyed God's command to leave Eden and till the land from which he was made, laboring through his long life in exile, which illustrates that work is good for humanity.ST Mar 24, 1881 Outside the garden his labor meant struggling with stubborn soil for daily bread, unlike the pleasant work he had done in Eden, yet it protected him from temptation and gave him happiness.ST Oct 9, 1884 Carrying on his sinless work of cultivating the trees and flowers God had planted was not a curse but a blessing, for working among beautiful trees and plants, especially fruit trees, has a refining and uplifting moral influence that restrains what is rough and cruel in man and encourages kindness and gentleness.RH Mar 21, 1912
After the fall God sent man out of Eden to cultivate the soil, and with scarcity of fruits and grains man was told to eat the plants of the field, food originally given to the lower creatures.ST Aug 31, 1915 Sin drove Adam from Eden to work the ground from which he had been formed, and people were permitted to eat the plants of the field in addition to the original foods of seed-bearing plants and fruit, namely fruits, nuts, grains and vegetables as the Creator's original diet.ST Sep 14, 1915 After the Fall pain and death entered through transgression though God did not design creatures to suffer or die, and the biblical record gives no permission to eat flesh until after the Flood, until then food coming from the ground.ST Apr 8, 1875
After sin Adam was sent out of Eden to live and work on the ground from which he had been taken, and the earth where he had to abide was under sin's curse.ST Sep 23, 1908ST Aug 24, 1904 Cut off from the Tree of Life and from Eden's perfection, humanity became imperfect and the ground no longer yielded as before, with toil and the earth's curse marking the changed condition brought by sin.ST Sep 23, 1908 Human life was thus placed outside Eden on ground blighted by sin, where weeds and thorns grow as consequences of the Fall and hardship in working the ground adds toil and sorrow to earning daily bread.ST Dec 8, 1887
Sin Causing Expulsion
The verse belongs to the entrance of sin into the world and to the history of humanity's first disobedience and rebellion against God, the real historical fall from innocence and uprightness to ruin.ST Sep 9, 1930RH Jul 1, 1909ST Nov 23, 1904ST Mar 24, 1881ST Apr 20, 1915 That fall explains the human condition, bringing separation from God, the penalty and wages of death, and making recovery and restoration necessary through Christ's atoning work.ST Sep 9, 1930RH Jul 1, 1909ST Nov 23, 1904ST Aug 25, 1914ST Apr 20, 1915 Disobedience brought death and cost Eden, and man placed on trial yielded to temptation so that sin and death came upon humanity.ST Aug 25, 1914ST Apr 20, 1915
The expulsion followed open violation of the moral law, specifically the first commandment.ST Sep 21, 1876RH Aug 10, 1876ST Aug 3, 1882ST Nov 12, 1912 Satan set before Eve the motive of becoming as gods, Eve was tempted by that prospect in the forbidden fruit, and Adam, who was not deceived, knowingly chose to follow his wife rather than obey the Lord.ST Sep 21, 1876ST Aug 3, 1882 Before that fall man was upright, innocent and free from guilt, needing no redemption through Christ's death and under no obligation of sacrifices for sin, types and shadows of future redemption, or carnal ordinances looking forward to reformation.ST Sep 21, 1876 The whole system of rites and ceremonies, the shadow of good things to come, gained existence only because of this transgression, arose after the Fall to point forward to Christ, and lasted until His sacrifice.ST Sep 21, 1876ST Aug 3, 1882 That punishment in Genesis 3:14-24, including Genesis 3:16-24 with the gospel foreshadowed and the plan of salvation indicated in Genesis 3:15, positively proves the moral law was already present and known, because death with its long train of previous disabilities was pronounced as the wages of sin, and sin is transgression of the law; without law there could be no transgression or imputed sin.RH Aug 10, 1876ST Nov 12, 1912
After Adam and Eve sinned they refused to accept responsibility, believed and obeyed Satan instead of God, and Adam's accusation against Eve did not save him from the result.ST May 29, 1901ST Apr 7, 1914ST Feb 15, 1883RH Sep 12, 1865 God sent them out of Eden back to the ground from which man had been made, to work the soil and not remain in the garden, sentencing them to death with the earth placed under a curse and driving them to suffer and die as part of sin's penalty extending to the race.ST Apr 7, 1914ST Jan 13, 1888RH Aug 3, 1876 An angel with a flaming sword guarded the way to the tree of life so the disloyal pair could not gain access and immortalize transgression.ST May 29, 1901 Their sincerity did not remove consequences, for sincere belief that the serpent told the truth did not excuse disbelief of God's word in face of the declared consequence.ST Feb 15, 1883RH Sep 12, 1865
God's word must be treated as sacred and His commands obeyed, for the expulsion after Adam sinned, with barring from the tree lest he eat and live forever and with the curse on the ground, shows breaking even one requirement brings serious consequences and reveals the sacred character of His law.ST Apr 15, 1875RH Jun 22, 1911 God is very particular about obedience: one single act by one man and one woman cost Eden, an act so serious it required God to give His only Son to die, for God is in earnest and sin is exceeding sinful transgression of His law.RH Jun 22, 1911ST Mar 5, 1912 God's law condemned sin and its sentence banished the first parents from Paradise.ST Sep 30, 1886
Disobedience shut humanity from the tree and cost Eden, Paradise, the beautiful home, dominion, innocency and joys.RH Jan 4, 1912ST Nov 19, 1894RH Jul 13, 1916ST Mar 30, 1904 Rebellion brought death upon them and their descendants with the earth cursed, and the pair went forth in shame, sorrow, sighs and bitter regrets to reap transgression's reward, marking the beginning of separation from the tree of life under conditions of sin, pain and death in contrast with the second Adam's victory and reign.RH Jan 4, 1912ST Nov 19, 1894ST Aug 11, 1914 Through Satan's deception humanity lost dominion and was driven in shame from Eden.ST Aug 11, 1914ST
Adam and Eve lost their Eden home through seeking forbidden knowledge, and that loss illustrates the grave cost of unholy desires and aims in bringing an experience God never intended.RH Aug 4, 1910 The mother of all living expected greater exaltation by transgression in believing and acting a lie but found instead humiliation, degradation and death in removal to work the ground, the first disappointment whose end is not yet reached and which laid the foundation for every other disappointment, since disappointments come from false hopes and are mortals' common experience largely on account of sin.ST Aug 13, 1902
Their moral powers were weakened by indulgence of perverted appetite, and their being sent forth to till the ground was recorded for all who should live on earth to deter recklessly departing from God's requirements and following the same steps.ST Jul 8, 1880 Their expulsion stands as an object lesson warning against intemperance, for intemperate desire led to Eden's loss and temperance in all things is connected with restoration to Eden.ST May 6, 1889
They had to leave their beautiful home where the Tree of Life stood because they chose death instead of life.ST Jul 7, 1909 God had told them His laws of life and His purpose that they represent Him, had shown them the happiness, peace and everlasting life of obedience with their children and the great suffering disobedience would bring on themselves and children, and had warned them of the enemy and the one place he would be allowed to entice them at the tree of knowledge of good and evil, yet they were deceived because knowing both good and evil seemed pleasant and profitable.ST Jul 7, 1909
Placed with permission to eat of every tree but one, they ate the forbidden fruit and opened the floodgates of woe, after which sin grew worse until God destroyed the world by the Flood saving only Noah and his sons, and has steadily increased since.ST May 26, 1898 If humanity's falls had ended with Adam driven out, people would now be physically, mentally and morally better, but instead people repeat Adam's violation instead of learning from his example, and since that fall human history has been a succession of falls with greater crime, disease and loss of health, beauty and moral power, men becoming more and more disobedient.ST Feb 11, 1875RH Mar 4, 1875RH Jul 9, 1901ST Feb 11, 1897
Man apostatized and fell under the power of the enemy, giving Satan subjects and sympathizers on earth which had been a paradise and establishing a precedent for his rebellion there.ST Jun 6, 1878RH Jan 29, 1867 This makes this world the place where Satan sought to establish his kingdom and display rebellion's results, and the sending forth planted Satan's principles of rule in man with man, containing the social volcano of world war in seed as the oak is in the acorn, so that world war is the final result of the conquest begun in Eden.RH Jan 9, 1900RH Jun 24, 1915
Transgression left them unfit to dwell in perfect Paradise, yet the fall did not remove obligation to obey God's moral law.ST Mar 17, 1914 Expulsion and assignment to work the ground from which man was made did not make Adam unable to obey later commands, for he understood and carried out the new command to leave.RH May 12, 1859 Lamenting the expulsion while overlooking the fruit-taking is like condemning enforcement while excusing the offense, and the verse does not mean God compelled Adam to sin, for his disobedience was not necessary in order to obey God's command.RH Dec 10, 1908RH Jun 18, 1861
Hypocrisy, deception and fraud are the chief ways by which Satan and the fallen angels ruined mankind.ST May 27, 1880 Eve's desire to know evil as well as good parallels attempting to experience folly while retaining wisdom.RH Jan 12, 1869 The serpent who caused dominion's loss is the devil and Satan, and the misery and death that came on Eden's happy dwellers through believing his false promise, ending in expulsion, finds its last and highest fulfillment in antichrist's characteristic lie in opposing God and declaring himself to be God.RH Sep 29, 1859ST Mar 12, 1885
Satan planned to beguile Adam and Eve so God would make some provision to pardon them, in which he and all fallen angels would then share God's mercy.ST Jan 16, 1879 If pardon failed, their transgression would place them in rebellion with the fallen angels so all could unite to take and hold Eden as home, and if they gained the tree of life their strength would equal holy angels so that even God Himself could not expel them.ST Jan 16, 1879 The fall of man came in swift succession after the angels' fall as dissension by foes in God's household, rooted in pride with the creature judging the Creator's words and works, exalting self and calling in question God's righteousness and truth, and the sending from Eden launches God's plan for redemption; pride is identified as the cause of paradise's loss.ST Jan 30, 1901RH Feb 25, 1873
Every man has a Paradise around him till he sins, when the angel of accusing conscience drives him from his Eden, for eating like the serpent leads to being driven out.ST Mar 10, 1914ST Sep 4, 1901 The fall ending in expulsion was witnessed by angels, the same who fought for God when Satan sought supremacy, who shouted for joy over creation of the world and its sinless inhabitants, and who desire to look into redemption.RH Mar 19, 1901ST Dec 1, 1909ST Apr 27, 1904 Those messengers are now intensely interested in the fallen redeemed race, working in union with human agencies, invisible with visible, to bind up sin's wounds and bruises and restore God's moral image in man for the salvation of perishing sinners.RH Mar 19, 1901ST Dec 1, 1909 The primal fall described in the verse is presented as the event after which God's wrath rested on humanity.ST May 7, 1894
Tree of Life Barred
God sent fallen man out of Eden to cut him off from the tree of life, lest after knowing good and evil and eating the forbidden fruit he should also take of life and live forever as a sinner, perpetuating sin and sorrow and misery forever.ST Nov 16, 1876ST Jul 16, 1912RH Aug 29, 1854RH Mar 22, 1860RH Dec 8, 1868 The expulsion carried out the threatened sentence of death by cutting off the means of keeping life going, for had man been allowed to keep eating he would have lived forever, and being shut out he could not continue to live.ST Nov 16, 1876RH Aug 29, 1854RH Mar 22, 1860RH Dec 8, 1868ST The loss covered every life man had, so no part of him was naturally immortal and unaffected by removal, and human beings do not have life forever in themselves apart from eating of that tree.ST Nov 16, 1876RH Dec 8, 1868ST Everlasting life belongs with character in harmony with God, not with sinful existence or self-salvation, for sin persisted in brings eternal death.ST Jul 16, 1912
The tree was a life-giving arrangement designed as a source of vitality to perpetuate man's days through continued eating of its fruit, so being shut out brings loss of available life.ST Feb 27, 1879RH Mar 22, 1860ST Jan 14, 1875 Endless life required continued access, and deprived of it human life gradually wears out, the body degenerating and at last returning to dust.ST Feb 27, 1879ST Jan 11, 1877ST Jun 1, 1915 Life was God's gift continued only on condition of obedience, so disobedience required giving up life, which is what dying thou shalt die means.ST Jan 11, 1877 The connection of the tree with immortality stands at the center of the account.RH Mar 17, 1874
Its fruit had supernatural virtue as the antidote of death, so that to eat was to live forever, and its leaves sustained life and immortality.ST Mar 31, 1909 Before sin Adam had access to the river flowing out of Eden, which was the River of Life, and as long as he drank of that river and ate of the tree he lived, being fed by the very life of God, until after sin he was cut off from both.ST Apr 7, 1909 Through redemption purchased by blood fallen people may still eat its life-giving fruit, for its branches hang over the wall to the lower world, and Christ is the fountain and bread of life whose words are Spirit and life to the overcomer who receives the tree in the midst of the paradise of God.ST Mar 31, 1909
While Adam obeyed, life was assured through free access to its source, and no power could take it from him.ST Sep 17, 1912 Had he continued to obey that access would not have been taken away, for the promise of eternal life was conditional, and obedience and loyalty would have kept the way open to continue eating and living forever.ST Sep 17, 1912ST Feb 23, 1915
The account gives no indication that they ever ate from the tree of life.RH May 26, 1874 It was provided as the means by which Adam could receive immortality if obedient, but he had not eaten from it before he sinned, and after sin God barred him, thereby preventing a sinner from becoming immortal.RH Aug 29, 1854 The word also in the warning shows he had eaten of knowledge but not of life, and with access guarded his death was certain.RH Sep 26, 1854
Those who held the other view teach that they had partaken of its life-giving fruit, even repeatedly, in innocency before being sent forth to till the ground.ST Aug 27, 1902ST Aug 27, 1902 They did not live forever because immortality depended not on tasting once but on eating continually, yet their eating before banishment contributed to the much longer lives of Adam and his immediate posterity compared with men now.ST Aug 27, 1902 That tree is but one literal tree throughout the Bible, the same tree now in the city of God transplanted from Eden, standing on both sides of the river by completely overarching it, faintly illustrated by the banyan of India whose branches take root and become new trunks so one tree becomes connected throughout.ST Aug 27, 1902
Being sent from Eden to till the ground was the immediate execution of the death sentence by exclusion from the tree.RH Dec 22, 1863ST May 29, 1884ST Apr 16, 1885ST Oct 2, 1879 Free access and eating would have caused living forever, so taking it away took life in effect and made death certain, and that shutting away alone was enough to leave him to decay and return to earth.RH Dec 22, 1863ST Apr 16, 1885 Return to the ground from which man was taken explains what God meant by death, with no immortal intelligent soul escaping that sentence.ST Oct 2, 1879 The guarded way back also points to access to eternal life through Jesus the Door rather than by any other way.ST May 29, 1884
The words live forever mean literal life and mere eternal existence, not merely happiness.RH Dec 22, 1863ST Jan 11, 1877 Adam could have lived forever in sin, and God still wills the sinner to turn and become happy, as shown by the promise concerning the woman's seed given before the sentence.RH Dec 22, 1863ST Jan 11, 1877 The guarded tree here is not Christ, since all are invited to come to Christ for pardon and life and happiness with no cherubim and flaming sword barring the way, rather than guarding the way to Christ.RH Dec 22, 1863ST Aug 28, 1879
By sin Adam forfeited his right to the tree, to eternal life, and to live, and exclusion kept him from continuing forever.ST Jan 12, 1882RH Feb 10, 1874RH Sep 25, 1913RH Dec 10, 1861 After humanity fell from its upright state he was driven from Paradise and excluded, his life to end in return to dust.RH Dec 10, 1861RH Dec 28, 1911 Human immortality was not inherent but depended on obedience and access, and endless life required that access.ST Jan 12, 1882RH Dec 28, 1911
God shut the entire man away lest he eat and live forever, and so keeps there from being eternal sin and eternal sinners.ST Jan 1, 1894 The entire man sinned and the entire man died, not an immortal soul that lives on more alive after death, for man was taken from dust and at death returns to dust.ST Jan 1, 1894
After transgression God cut off access to the means of continuing life so the penalty of the law could be carried out and Adam return to dust.RH Jun 25, 1867 The tree had been given so lives could be perpetuated, and expulsion followed condemnation to die. Paradise and the tree, once in Eden, were later removed to the city of God, and Paradise lost through transgression can be regained through obedience.RH Jun 25, 1867
The tree remained on earth behind a guarded way of access for a time, and the garden remained for a time guarded from human access by the cherubim's flaming sword.RH Sep 21, 1869 The tree itself could not die, and to continue its life-giving function without dying it was removed from earth to heaven, to God's Paradise in the third heaven.RH Sep 21, 1869ST Jan 18, 1916 The garden was probably removed at the time of the Flood.RH Sep 21, 1869
Mankind remains in a present state of exclusion, and eating its fruit is the sure pledge of immortal life, so those excluded cannot live as long as those who have access.RH Dec 8, 1868RH Feb 10, 1874 The wicked are likewise excluded, so their punishment in the fire does not mean they live eternally, while the righteous in paradise with free access receive eternal life.RH Dec 8, 1868RH Jul 14, 1874 Return comes only by overcoming the sinful nature, so living forever while continuing in sin is impossible.RH Feb 10, 1874
God sent fallen humanity out to prevent eating and living forever as sinners, exactly as the words state at the beginning of the Bible.RH Jul 7, 1874ST Sep 13, 1905RH Dec 22, 1863 Removal limited life in sin with the purpose of bringing sin and death to an end, and outside Adam had to till the ground from which he had been made.ST Sep 13, 1905 The life given the race in Adam was thereby forfeited by disobedience and utterly lost, and approach was made impossible.RH Dec 22, 1863 This exclusion is terrible yet merciful, because to become immortal in sin would be the greatest curse and a great calamity, and endless life in sin would be miserable.RH Dec 22, 1863ST Sep 5, 1911 In mercy God cut man off so sin and its curse would not be perpetuated forever and become more intolerable, for man could not make himself and his descendants immortal in sinful condition.RH Aug 7, 1866 The forfeited life cannot be regained by man and should not be desired apart from the gospel, but life and immortality are brought to light in Christ the resurrection and the life, in whom all die in Adam and are made alive in order, they that are Christ's at His coming, to whom alone the promises belong, the sinner feeding on Christ by faith in prospect of eternal life until as final overcomer the tree is restored to him.RH Dec 22, 1863
Expulsion to toil on the sin-cursed earth thwarted Satan, who through disobedience had brought sin and wanted man also to take of life and live forever, which would make his work coexistent with God's and bring eternal misery.ST Jul 2, 1894RH Jul 9, 1872 God removed man from where everything grew spontaneously and he had only to dress and keep it, and set him to till the ground under labor and sorrow.RH Jul 9, 1872 This hardship was better than luxury and idleness, for labor kept men honestly occupied and restrained deeper sin, while thorns and poor soil reminded them of sin and urged them to seek what was lost, without God abandoning the earth or His purpose for it.ST Jul 2, 1894 After sentence Adam was sent from beauty and plenty to face labor for food and return to the ground from which he was taken.
The expulsion came after the first test of loyalty over knowledge, debarring sinful man from life's fruit.ST Aug 6, 1896 The tree was given to perpetuate an endless existence of worthy character, but sinful man was sent forth lest he perpetuate a sinful and miserable existence.ST Aug 6, 1896 This sending belongs to man's fall, history, and salvation, with which trees are intimately connected.ST Aug 6, 1896
Being kept from life prefigured the gospel and was necessary to check sin.RH Jul 26, 1906RH Mar 19, 1914 God's purpose was not merely to cut off sinners but to conquer sin so completely that it would never arise again.RH Jul 26, 1906 With the way barred, eternal life could not come from humanity itself but only from outside through God's plan, foreshadowed in the promise that the woman's seed would bruise the serpent's head, through which every person can be saved, showing no other route.RH Jul 26, 1906RH Mar 19, 1914
The driving out did not mean God purposed to shut the family away from life forever, for man was created to live forever and it remained the purpose that he enjoy unending life, but life must be forever divorced from sin.RH Sep 9, 1902 Hence God provided another tree of life of which mankind may freely partake, which is Jesus Christ eaten by faith, since sin and faith cannot exist together, so that by coming to Him the sinner turns from sins and by partaking of His flesh and blood the life of righteousness is maintained within, and there remains a real spiritual paradise where those who will may live in touch with heaven.RH Sep 9, 1902 In this sense being sent forth did not remove all access, because Christ as the tree of life has been accessible to Adam's descendants ever since.RH Sep 10, 1901
In depriving fallen man of the tree God also withheld the secret of what life is, for wise reasons.ST Dec 11, 1901 Magnetism and electricity are great forces closely related and analogous to life, and their true nature belongs to the same withheld secret.ST Dec 11, 1901
Death and Mortality
Human beings do not have life forever in themselves and are not naturally inherently immortal, for the life given at creation was conditional, depending on access to the tree of life and on obedience, and exclusion from it begins mortality and death.ST Nov 16, 1876RH Mar 22, 1860RH Dec 8, 1868STST Feb 3, 1914 The tree was a life-giving arrangement designed as a source of vitality to perpetuate days through continued eating of its fruit, and to be shut out from it is to lose available life, proving no tenure of life independent of it.RH Mar 22, 1860ST Apr 4, 1900ST Jun 1, 1904 Living forever requires eating of that tree, and God drove man out and set cherubim with a flaming sword to guard the way, leaving mankind in a present state of exclusion so the sentence of death would be carried out.ST Nov 16, 1876RH Dec 8, 1868RH Dec 22, 1863 If man had been allowed to keep eating he would have lived forever, but because he was shut out he could not continue to live.ST Nov 16, 1876RH Mar 22, 1860ST Oct 3, 1906 The loss covered every life man had, so no part of him was naturally immortal and unaffected by removal from the tree.ST Nov 16, 1876
Sin persisted in brings eternal death, so everlasting life belongs with character in harmony with God, not with sinful existence or self-salvation.ST Jul 16, 1912RH Nov 28, 1912 God will not suffer sin to be perpetuated but will end sin and perpetuate righteousness, and when redemption is complete the exclusion is reversed and the righteous are restored to partake that they may live forever when corruptible puts on incorruption and mortal puts on immortality.ST Jul 16, 1912RH Nov 28, 1912 Man did not possess life in himself even while sinless, for continued life depended on access to the tree rather than on an immortal soul that could not die, and expulsion with the guarded way meant return to dust.ST Feb 20, 1893ST Sep 17, 1912ST Jun 1, 1904ST Nov 21, 1900 Human life was not self-sustaining but borrowed, retained only through faith and obedience to what God provided, with hope resting in Jesus Christ who can re-create.ST Apr 2, 1912ST Dec 26, 1906ST Nov 21, 1900
Before choice Adam was neither naturally mortal nor naturally immortal but capable of either destiny, receiving immortality through obedience or losing life through disobedience, life through the tree or a mortal dying nature returning to dust.RH Sep 26, 1854RH May 1, 1879ST Dec 26, 1906ST Dec 25, 1893 He was a perfect physical being possessing eternal life by faith connecting him with the Source of all life, and had he believed God he would have continued to live eternally until character became fixed and his whole being was made immortal not subject to death, but by sinning he broke that connection and became a dying creature.ST Dec 26, 1906ST Dec 25, 1893 In this sense he was neither immortal nor created mortal but a candidate for immortality, for immortal means deathless incorruptible which he did not attain, and mortal means subject to death which God did not create.ST Sep 29, 1898 He had pure healthy holy uncorrupted flesh with God's eternal life flowing through unhindered, and had he lived always in harmony with the law of God's life so as to develop incorruptible character no temptation could corrupt, God would have placed upon it the stamp of immortality by making flesh incorruptible deathless.ST Sep 29, 1898
God placed Adam on probation with reference to continuance of life, not granting immortality at creation but making him capable of inheriting it after forming by obedience a character entitled to that gift.RH Apr 7, 1874ST Mar 4, 1880RH Mar 3, 1874 If he sinned he must be shut out from the tree and die, while continued obedience would have kept access to live forever, for life was given with conditions annexed.RH Apr 7, 1874ST Mar 4, 1880RH Jul 14, 1874 Adam held life on condition of obedience and immortality could not be his until probation was complete, and rebellion brought sentence of death rather than a higher or happier existence.RH Apr 7, 1874 The original condition and the provision after the fall both center on choosing God's way of obedience, with life secured through Christ's righteousness and obedience for those who accept Him as substitute. Before transgression he could have continued forever through obedience and partaking and was not inherently immortal, but shut away he became absolutely mortal.RH Jan 24, 1865RH Dec 22, 1863 Being sent shut the whole race away lest sinners eat and live forever, and only those who believe and overcome will have the tree restored by the Saviour to live forever, proving every soul is not by nature destined to live as long as God exists.RH Dec 22, 1863
Adam's immortality was not natural inherent or part of nature but depended on God's provision, favor, and the tree in Eden that could have sustained life.RH Mar 31, 1863RH Mar 22, 1860ST Jan 10, 1878 Before the fall he was mortal and dependent, not naturally immortal, the tree having real design to sustain life which would have no purpose if natural immortality were possessed.RH Nov 29, 1870RH Aug 29, 1854 Disobedience brought mortality and eventual death as threatened, death was made sure from that day, and the expulsion exposes the error of assuming pre-fall immortality and of hereditary total depravity.RH Nov 29, 1870RH Aug 29, 1854 Being cut off from the tree of God's power and energy whose life-giving properties had perpetuated the endowed gift made man at once subject to corruption, mortality and decay.ST Apr 9, 1912 His connection with God that had let him know the power and pleasure of everlasting life was broken, and isolation left him to know only weakness and pains of everlasting death, passing from life to death, made from dust and sent to till the ground to return to dust.ST Apr 9, 1912
After sin God cut Adam off from his source of life and immortality, yet he did not die at once but like a tree severed from nourishment weakened over time and returned to dust, fulfilling dying thou shalt die, the sentence of literal death not immediately carried out.RH Apr 11, 1865 Continued access was necessary, so separation meant separation from life's source and eventual death.ST Apr 2, 1912 The verse puts the physical death penalty for breaking the original law into effect, cutting off the means of keeping alive so man would live by toil, suffer mortal ills, and return to dust.RH Jan 5, 1864 Adam lived 930 years and died under a sentence never revoked, with nature set against him to wear him down until sleep in dust, and that dying nature was passed to all posterity, which without salvation through Jesus Christ would be an eternal unconscious night.ST Jun 17, 1897RH Jan 5, 1864 Barred from the tree that would have continued God-given life, Adam and the family came under the death penalty, and those continuing in sin face eternal death rather than eternal life.ST Jun 17, 1897
Being sent back to the ground means God took back the life-breath by which Adam became a living soul, for that life was not an immortal heavenly being inside the body but the principle by which God made him alive and kept by God.ST Dec 9, 1880ST Jun 12, 1879RH Dec 29, 1868 When Adam died God took that life again into His keeping, leaving him with just as much life thought and knowledge as before it was given, which was none at all.RH Dec 29, 1868ST Jun 12, 1879 Death does not return to paradise or bring conscious life with God and does not open the door back to the paradise from which sin expelled him, but hope of endless life is in resurrection when the second Adam who has life in himself gives life a second time that shall never end.ST Jun 12, 1879ST Jun 12, 1879 God deprived access to the means by which life could have been prolonged forever, and the death imposed was cessation of life, God not changing Adam's nature.RH Nov 24, 1863 Return to the ground explains what God meant by death, and no immortal intelligent soul escaped that sentence.RH Nov 24, 1863ST Oct 2, 1879
After disobedience God sent man out cutting off access through which life would have been sustained, so man became mortal wearing out and dying, the result of sin being death of the whole person.RH Mar 22, 1860ST Oct 3, 1906ST May 11, 1915 Expelled humanity lost access to the life represented by the tree and became mortal unable to live forever without provision from the Creator, proving no undying principle living without the tree.RH Mar 22, 1860ST May 11, 1915 God sent sinful man out to cut him off so he would not live forever but would die, and approach was made impossible.RH Dec 22, 1863 The life given the race in Adam was thereby forfeited by disobedience and utterly lost in execution of death sentence, yet terrible as exclusion is it is merciful because immortality in sin would be greatest curse.RH Dec 22, 1863 Forfeited life cannot be regained by man and should not be desired as sinner, but life and immortality are brought to light through the gospel in Christ who is resurrection and life, for in Adam all die and in Christ all shall be made alive each in order, they that are Christ's at His coming, to whom alone promises of eternal life belong.RH Dec 22, 1863 The sinner is invited to Christ for removal of sin, and when forgiven has eternal life in prospect by faith feeding on Christ without yet being restored to the tree, needing to fight the good fight and overcome before Christ restores it.RH Dec 22, 1863
Expulsion as part of the sentence with loss of the tree and subjection to physical death means redemption must include recovery of physical life lost, for driving made death sure and entailed death upon posterity, so redemption is salvation from death and resurrection of the dead has been the gospel hope from the beginning.ST Oct 4, 1905ST Apr 3, 1884 The mortality settled upon Adam is natural temporal first death distinct from eternal second death, inflicted as penalty upon Adam for his sin only since he alone was transgressor.ST Mar 3, 1881 His children received from him a nature no higher than his own, were with him shut out, became subject to death and return to dust, to them not as penalty but as consequence of relation to Adam unremitted by repentance faith and pardon.ST May 15, 1884 Saints justified and pardoned still die in Adam, and infants with no sins still die not as condemned sinners but as mortal creatures cut off by Adam's action, while second death is the separate penalty for personal sins answered at judgment.ST Mar 3, 1881RH Apr 29, 1873 From expulsion onward history proceeds under Adam's fallen mortal nature, while Christ provides new probation where final destiny depends on each one's own course.RH Apr 29, 1873ST May 31, 1877
By sinning man forfeited given life and existence, and from expulsion is mortal perishing with nothing in nature saving from death, immortality and everlasting life beyond own reach apart from the tree that kept alive as long as he ate.RH Mar 22, 1860RH Aug 30, 1870 Excluded from that only source, humanity could not live forever and lost its only source of immortality, so any later immortality depends on further provision from the Creator.RH Mar 22, 1860 The expulsion left Adam able to give posterity no more than he possessed, having lost dominion, Eden home, and soul sold to Satan which none but Creator could buy back, so God gave His Son that believers should not perish but have everlasting life.ST Feb 13, 1912 Driven from the tree he lost hope of immortality, was condemned to hard labor and ultimately to dust and death, and without redemption his death would have been the end of the race.RH Sep 20, 1864RH Jul 19, 1870 Man thus forfeited original title to immortality so the dead have life in no sense, never recovered except by a Redeemer, and dead souls are not alive conscious capable of happiness or misery between death and resurrection, restoration coming only by resurrection.ST Aug 12, 1875
Belief in the serpent's falsehood that death would not come led to expulsion and loss of life, proving the assurance false and showing rejecting God's warning brings death contrary to inherent immortality.RH Jun 8, 1916RH Jan 28, 1858ST Oct 16, 1879ST Sep 13, 1905 God had warned eating would bring death while Satan proclaimed the first doctrine of soul immortality, and disobedience brought death as warned.RH Jun 8, 1916ST Sep 13, 1905 The verse belongs to Genesis 1 and 3 showing humans became mortal through choosing sin, is listed among texts showing humanity mortal, and shows man formed from ground and sent to labor on it.STRH Feb 20, 1872ST Oct 31, 1911ST Apr 26, 1905 Sin cut humanity off from life's source making a dying people whose dying leads to death.ST Loss of the only source meant earthly birth could no longer sustain forever leaving no hope without remedy, so eternal life requires being born again or re-created because God cannot give eternal existence to corrupt old sinful life.ST Apr 4, 1900ST Apr 4, 1900
After sin God sent Adam out bringing guilt distress, banishment from Paradise, and ultimately death, whereas access would have allowed continuing living.RH Sep 18, 1855RH Sep 21, 1869 Life outside involves toil ending in dust, kept from eating and living forever.RH Sep 18, 1855 Exclusion marked end of probation in innocence, and under death sentence he would live a dying life until returning to ground, deprived of the tree his life gradually wearing out.RH Jun 26, 1866ST Jan 19, 1882 This applies to Adam's Eden condition, not to endless life of redeemed saints in glory.RH Jun 26, 1866 The expulsion was love preventing forever fallen misery, removing access lest he live forever in fallen state and become immortal in misery.ST Feb 10, 1881ST Oct 28, 1875ST Aug 18, 1887 Adam remained mortal, living 930 years in toil and sorrow before dying.ST Feb 10, 1881ST Oct 28, 1875
Sources