After Cain had killed Abel his brother in the field, the Lord spoke to him to confront him with his deed before pronouncing his doom.ST Apr 8, 1913 Cain lied that he did not know where Abel was, though he knew what he had done, and then in defiance disowned any responsibility to guard his brother.RH Apr 6, 1911ST Jul 14, 1898ST May 6, 1897RH Jul 3, 1856RH Aug 17, 1876 The question sought no information God lacked, but exposed Cain's evasion, held him accountable for his brother, and gave him opportunity to confess before judgment.RH Dec 6, 1864 To his question the answer is yes, for every man, woman and child is his brother's and neighbor's keeper as children of a common Father who cannot live in isolation.ST Sep 27, 1899RH Jan 22, 1857RH Jul 24, 1913 Cain was dealt with as a murderer and transgressor of a known law against killing, proving that murder was sin from the beginning and the principle of the sixth commandment was binding before it was spoken at Sinai.RH Oct 18, 1853ST May 4, 1882
Setting and Wording
The Lord speaks audibly to Cain after Cain has killed Abel his brother in the field, asking where Abel his brother is and confronting him with his deed before pronouncing his doom.ST Apr 8, 1913ST Dec 22, 1898RH Jun 27, 1878 The killing followed anger because the disobedient offering was rejected while Abel's was accepted, and because Abel maintained that God is just, and it was done as they talked together, the younger brother slain by the elder.ST Dec 25, 1901RH Jun 27, 1878 Cain answers, I know not, lying about Abel's whereabouts though he knows where Abel is and what he has done, using falsehood to conceal murder and hide guilt.RH Apr 6, 1911ST Jul 14, 1898ST May 6, 1897ST Jul 14, 1898RH Jun 27, 1878 Sin had dulled his sense of God's presence and knowledge, so he followed Satan's example as liar and murderer in trying deception before God.ST Dec 16, 1886
He adds, Am I my brother's keeper, in cool audacity, defiance and selfishness, combining falsehood, awareness of guilt and an attempt to evade responsibility for his brother.RH Jul 3, 1856RH Aug 17, 1876ST Dec 11, 1884ST Jan 31, 1911ST Jun 9, 1898 The denial claims no rightful duty to protect or help another, and becomes a motto for neglecting one in need and a pattern of self-justification for oppression and other wrongs, especially sins of commission.RH Jul 3, 1856ST Dec 11, 1884ST Jun 9, 1898 He had not been appointed to control his brother, but when he assumed the role of guiding and compelling Abel in worship he became answerable for the consequences, and the question exposes his attempt to escape that responsibility.ST Jan 31, 1911ST Jan 31, 1911 God's question does not seek information He lacks but exposes Cain's evasion, holds him accountable for his brother, and gives him opportunity to confess before judgment.ST Dec 16, 1886RH Dec 6, 1864 He already knew of the murder through its witness, yet He called Cain to account for what had happened to his brother, and Cain remained rebellious instead of confessing.ST Dec 16, 1886RH Dec 6, 1864 The evasion is answered by the fact that Abel's blood cries to God from the ground, meaning God holds a person accountable for a brother's suffering and death.ST Apr 24, 1893
The exchange shows God knows every act and thought of the heart despite denial, that time, place, speech or apparel cannot hide from Him, that He continued to make His will known even to the wicked, and that His dealing with Cain shows His long-suffering.ST Feb 6, 1879ST Feb 6, 1879ST Dec 20, 1910PGGC 5.1–2 Cain's answer reveals sin had dulled his awareness of God's presence, greatness and knowledge, while God revealed the hidden guilt and the crying blood.ST Feb 6, 1879ST Dec 16, 1886ST Feb 6, 1879 The verse belongs to the world's history before the Deluge in the first ten chapters of Genesis, to the account of Cain's life and posterity to the sixth generation reaching nearly to the time of the flood.RH Dec 23, 1915RH Dec 25, 1913ST Sep 5, 1895 It distinguishes Cain's line, which began with Enoch in Nod and later included Lamech, another murderer, and went out from the Lord's presence, from Seth's line, which continued as Seth was born to take Abel's place with other sons and daughters recorded afterward out of chronological order.RH Dec 23, 1915RH Dec 25, 1913ST Oct 16, 1879ST Sep 5, 1895 Those early generations were not primitive savages but lived with farming, herding, metalworking, music and city-building, and Cain's descendants grew up wholly irreligious in wickedness as a distinct family from Seth's until all perished in the flood.RH Dec 6, 1870ST Oct 16, 1879
Cain and Abel
Abel meekly submitted to God's requirements while Cain rebelled and resented, and their different offerings showed the test of obedience upon them.ST Dec 16, 1886 Abel brought of the firstlings of his flock and of the fat thereof by faith and obtained witness that he was righteous, while Cain brought fruit of the ground without blood and without faith, did not do well, and was rejected with sin lying at the door.ST Jul 1, 1889ST Mar 9, 1888 Abel's sacrifice was more excellent than Cain's, and the blood Cain shed was righteous blood.ST Mar 9, 1888
Cain became angry because his disobedient offering was rejected while Abel's was accepted, accused God, and refused to see that his own disobedience made his offering unacceptable.ST Dec 25, 1901RH Jun 27, 1878 He slew Abel because his own works were evil and Abel's were righteous, moved by envy because God had respect to Abel and to his offering, and after contention and talk together in the field he killed his younger brother without cause.ST May 6, 1897ST Mar 9, 1888RH Jun 27, 1878ST Mar 25, 1889 Instead of ruling over sin through faith in the promised Savior he yielded to it, and instead of repenting he murmured at punishment and went out from the presence of God manifested at the gate of Paradise to dwell at a distance in separation from God.ST May 6, 1897ST Oct 16, 1879
Murder begins in allowed angry feelings, envy and hatred in the heart and ends in taking a life that none but God can give, lifting a puny arm against man made in the image of God.ST Mar 25, 1889RH Jan 18, 1870 Covetousness, envy, and desire for power and influence yielded to brought sin's criminal element into human society with the first murder.ST Apr 22, 1903 One sin led to another in Cain from disobedience and accusation against God to deception and murder, reflecting Satan who was a murderer from the beginning and both liar and murderer.ST Dec 16, 1886ST Mar 25, 1889 Sin dulled his sense of God's presence, greatness and knowledge, so though he knew where Abel was and God already knew of the murder through its witness, he used falsehood to hide guilt and evade responsibility, yet remained rebellious when given opportunity to confess before judgment.ST Dec 25, 1901ST Dec 16, 1886
The murder brought a curse on Cain and on the ground, which would no longer yield its strength to him, making him a branded murderer, a fugitive and vagabond and wanderer from the face of the Lord.ST Feb 6, 1879ST Mar 25, 1889 Abel's death was the first death Adam witnessed in his family and deepened his grief and remorse over his own transgression.ST Feb 6, 1879 Though Abel's death was the strongest case ever for avenging a death and Cain the strongest case ever for being slain, both for killing his brother and for bringing added curse upon the ground, God would not permit men to avenge Abel but let Cain live to reap the fruit of his own sowing, gave him opportunity to repent while reserving punishment, and declared sevenfold vengeance on anyone who assumed God's place as Judge and Avenger by killing Cain.ST Nov 8, 1899 Christians must therefore leave judgment and execution of judgment to God and must not demand that their nation chastise other nations to avenge oppressed peoples.ST Nov 8, 1899
God's sparing of Cain's life demonstrated to the universe what happens when sin is permitted to go unpunished, for Cain's life and teaching influenced his descendants toward growing corruption until the whole world had to be destroyed by the Flood. This proves long life is no blessing to the sinner and that great forbearance does not repress wickedness, for the longer men lived the more corrupt they became, and God as guardian as well as sovereign cuts off those determined upon rebellion so they will not lead others to ruin. Sparing the rebels at Sinai would have produced evils even greater than resulted from sparing Cain and would have made the earth as corrupt as in the days of Noah, so it was mercy to punish the few to save the many. Cain's descendants grew up wholly irreligious like him as a distinct family from Seth's and all perished in the Flood, so Eve had no hope in Cain's family and her hope centered in Seth born to take Abel's place.ST Oct 16, 1879 Cain's portion as fratricide is to be accursed at home and abroad, in city and field, to have the malediction of the law laid on the sons of iniquity come upon him, to have his name blotted out from the book of the living and not written with the righteous, and to perish in the day of Judgment devoured by everlasting fire with the devil and his angels unless there is restitution or amendment.RH Sep 29, 1874 His sin is presented as unpardonable because he brought a substitute offering without blood and rebelled against God's ordinance, for which God pronounced a curse on him with no remedy.ST Nov 9, 1915
Law Before Sinai
Cain was cursed for murdering Abel, and his being dealt with as a murderer and transgressor proves that murder was sin from the beginning and that the law forbidding it already existed then.RH Oct 18, 1853ST May 4, 1882 The killing violated a known law against taking life before that law was spoken at Sinai, and God treated him as a lawbreaker for it.RH Oct 18, 1853ST May 4, 1882ST Jun 3, 1875 The principle specified is that of the sixth commandment, known and binding from the beginning before it was given at Sinai.RH Mar 19, 1857RH Dec 25, 1860
He had no excuse of ignorance, for God held him guilty for his brother's blood and punished him accordingly.RH Jan 15, 1875RH Nov 13, 1856ST Feb 11, 1886 That guilt before Moses demonstrates that God's law and knowledge of it existed from Adam onward and that people before Moses had a revealed law to transgress, even though Genesis records no formal giving of the law and no express command against murder before the act.RH Jan 15, 1875ST Sep 2, 1875RH Nov 13, 1856ST Feb 11, 1886 God's speaking with Cain after the murder shows He continued to make His will known even to the wicked.RH Oct 18, 1853
The account belongs among the early Genesis passages reflecting the moral law, the Ten Commandments, with the killing read together with the surrounding verses as an early reference to that law.ST May 6, 1875ST Mar 20, 1879 God's moral law condemned Cain for killing his innocent brother, applying from the beginning of human history and making obedience to God obligatory.RH Dec 28, 1869RH Dec 15, 1868 Envy of Abel led to murder, followed by falsehood to conceal the crime in denying knowledge of his brother and rejecting responsibility for him, so Cain violated the law against murder and the duty of honesty and did not keep the law by killing his brother.RH Jan 18, 1870ST Jul 9, 1874RH Dec 28, 1869
That killing broke the sixth commandment long before God's voice was heard from Sinai, proving sin was in the world and the ten precepts were already known and binding before they were proclaimed from the mount.ST Mar 30, 1915 The law was later spoken at Sinai so that the offense might abound and sin by the commandment might become exceeding sinful.ST Mar 30, 1915 The Lord's words to Cain about Abel his brother made the sixth commandment against murder known in the beginning, showing killing was treated as sin and moral obligation in that age even though Genesis is history and records no formal law code.RH Mar 17, 1874 Its presence proves that lack of a recorded commandment in Genesis does not prove lack of obligation.RH Mar 17, 1874
The cry represents justice seeking redress for death, with blood itself not conscious and not literally speaking.RH Apr 25, 1865ST Mar 15, 1877ST Mar 27, 1879 An inanimate thing is made to speak and act in reference to the facts of its case as though alive, with the language of a rational being.ST Mar 15, 1877ST Mar 27, 1879 The example therefore proves that the dead speaking and acting as though alive does not mean they are conscious.ST Mar 15, 1877ST Mar 27, 1879
The same personification explains the blood of those slain for the word of God crying to God for vengeance from beneath the altar without being conscious.RH Sep 22, 1859RH Jul 8, 1862RH Apr 25, 1865 Those are unconscious martyred dead whose cry, like Abel's, is justice seeking redress and not conscious souls speaking after death.RH Jul 8, 1862RH Apr 25, 1865 It likewise explains the conversation of the rich man and Lazarus in hades as personified dead men with bodily organs speaking as though alive, not disembodied conscious spirits.ST Mar 15, 1877ST Mar 27, 1879 This proves the dead in hades are unconscious in darkness and silence without knowledge, wisdom, memory, or speech.ST Mar 15, 1877ST Mar 27, 1879
Types of Two Classes
Cain and Abel stand as opposing characters and continuing types, Abel for faith, love and obedience and Cain for unbelief, hatred and disobedience, with the fruit of each blessing or cursing the earth ever since and the two classes of the righteous and the wicked continuing until the end.ST Nov 18, 1897ST Mar 18, 1903ST Sep 1, 1909RH Jan 23, 1900 Righteousness in the account is life and enlightens, while sin is death and blinds and deceives, showing the reward of obedience and the fearful result of disobedience.ST Aug 13, 1896 The two brothers are the first representatives of the children of the kingdom and the children of the wicked one pictured in the parable of the wheat and tares, which applies from the time of Adam's sons through the close of the day of grace.RH Feb 10, 1874ST Jun 25, 1874 Cain as elder son became head of the ungodly line, whose beginnings and history show the development of its character and its distinction from the godly line.ST Jul 27, 1915
Righteous Abel belongs with the first parents who turned from sin to God among God's first called-out ones, showing that the church as those who heed God's call, come out from the world and join with Him began then and that God has had His called-out ones in all ages since.ST Apr 29, 1908 Abel also marks the beginning of the history of martyrs recorded in the Bible through the time of John on Patmos.ST Mar 5, 1912 In worship Abel obeyed God's direction while Cain followed his own ideas and then persecuted Abel for worshiping as required, so that Cain exemplifies religious tyranny and Abel exemplifies religious liberty and loyalty to God even at the cost of life.ST Mar 12, 1894 Cain had not been appointed to control his brother, but when he assumed the role of guiding and compelling him in worship he became answerable for the consequences, and his evasion exposes his attempt to escape that responsibility.ST Jan 31, 1911ST Jan 31, 1911
Those who coerce another's conscience and worship by civil power will likewise answer to God for the harm they cause, including for persecuted Sabbath keepers, and cannot escape responsibility.ST Jan 31, 1911ST Jan 31, 1911 By religious bigotry Cain denied Abel the right to worship according to his faith and took his life, violating both freedom of worship and the right to live, so that Abel's blood stands as a protest against denying to others rights one claims for oneself.ST Dec 7, 1915 The brothers present an early conflict between true religion and fraudulent man-made religious institutions, Cain representing wicked persecutors and Abel the righteous persecuted.ST Mar 12, 1894 The shedding of Abel's blood began an unbroken history in which the usurped unhallowed union of secular and ecclesiastical power drenches the earth with blood in no country or age without fail, warning against joining church and state to enforce religion by law.RH Feb 4, 1873
Cain's rejection of God's light was the first step of apostasy, beginning a pattern of turning from God's word to one's own way that later generations repeat when they reject light already given.ST Jul 21, 1898 His example marks the beginning of humanity's effort to gain standing before God through works of its own devising instead of acknowledging helplessness.ST Dec 26, 1906 He refused the required blood offering of a spotless lamb shadowing the great sacrifice and brought fruit of the ground instead, revealing lack of faith and fidelity, while Abel believed God meant what He said and by faith obeyed and was counted righteous, proving God requires exact obedience and will not accept substituted service such as keeping Sunday instead of the commanded seventh-day holy day.RH Sep 22, 1874 Through Abel's murder Satan sought to destroy the promised Seed.ST
Cain's creed was blood, murdering his brother to mend human misery on the plea that evil done will bring good, with sin and righteousness changing places under Satan's control, and the gospel of peace cannot be carried by the hand of Cain, for drowning misery in men's blood only rushes men to eternal ruin.ST Aug 22, 1900ST Aug 22, 1900 In the last days those who follow him, refusing glad submission to God's will and the love of the truth, repeat his violent hand in movements like anarchy that would drown human woe in blood.ST Aug 22, 1900 The only safety is to take the lesson to heart by cultivating love of the truth and sharing in the triumph of the truth, otherwise his followers will fill the earth with violence and go down to destruction with those who had pleasure in unrighteousness.ST Aug 22, 1900
Universal Brotherly Responsibility
To the defiant question whether one is one's brother's keeper the answer is yes, for every man, woman and child is keeper of brother and neighbor under God, bound together as children of a common Father and fellow pilgrims who cannot live in isolation.RH May 13, 1909ST Sep 27, 1899RH Jan 22, 1857RH Jul 24, 1913ST Mar 10, 1881 All are one another's keepers, educators, helpers or hinderers, saviours or seducers, and life is filled with beautiful things by filling it with right things, for as society ripens and the standard of manhood rises the right things will become the beautiful things.ST Sep 27, 1899RH Jul 24, 1913ST Nov 24, 1881 The duty means watching over one another, so that seeing a brother heading into error and failing to warn him makes the silent one responsible for the resulting sin.RH Jan 22, 1857RH Jun 6, 1865 Churches bear this as a solemn duty to care for every member, and to neglect a member who repeatedly misses worship without asking why violates that duty and can bring discord and division.RH Jan 22, 1857RH Jan 15, 1867 Every professed Christian is responsible for his fellow man in the work of God and must not leave a brother unwarned, but cherish kindness and love toward the erring and not treat him as an enemy, since wrong is often done from spiritual blindness, deception and delusion.RH May 13, 1909RH Dec 9, 1862 The erring one has been bought with a price by the gift of the only begotten Son so that believers should not perish but have everlasting life, and the soul who accepts that sacrifice for himself is pledged to special care for his erring brother.RH May 13, 1909RH Jan 29, 1914 This lays sacred duties on the church through organization to recognize, protect and enforce the principles of the message, to care for brethren, sisters and children, and to labor for those with no interest in the truth, so that the church prospers instead of remaining a lifeless and powerless mere formal organization.RH Jan 22, 1857RH Jan 15, 1867
Denial does not remove keepership, for the denial did not change the fact, and the same plea today is evasion, excuse and shirking rather than release from duty.RH Jul 24, 1913ST Dec 11, 1884RH Mar 19, 1914ST Nov 24, 1881 To use the question as a motto for having nothing to do with one in need sets refusal to care against loving neighbor as self.ST Dec 11, 1884ST Nov 24, 1881 No one can excuse neglect by denying responsibility, for all are responsible before God for the welfare of others and for making their best efforts to help those within their influence, including finding what holds them back and giving practical help to become free.RH Mar 19, 1914RH Jun 6, 1865 Caring for those entrusted is duty not to be dismissed, and the call is to help the poor, degraded and lost rather than stand by, since a brother's blood cries to God.ST Nov 24, 1881RH Jun 6, 1865 One who fails to live by professed truth or spreads an unholy influence cannot rightly use the plea to avoid responsibility, but must warn against sin by spoken reproof and conscientious life and must not idle while others are in danger.RH Jan 22, 1857RH Jun 6, 1865
No one lives only for himself, for each life affects others for good or harm, and none can live and act among others without influencing them for help or harm.RH Apr 6, 1911RH Jul 24, 1913ST Nov 24, 1881 People are responsible not only for actions but for influence, example and the consequences borne in others' lives, and must answer to God at the judgment.RH Apr 6, 1911ST Nov 11, 1913RH Jul 24, 1913 Words and actions affect others for good or ill, and accountability includes sympathy and encouragement for those in distress, patient efforts to win back those who have left the way of truth, and prayerful attention to those at risk.RH Dec 9, 1862 All are brothers and sisters, and each should seek the neighbor's welfare, sympathize, do good, share the gospel and try to save from ruin whatever his condition or distance.RH Dec 9, 1862ST Jun 5, 1884RH Jan 29, 1914
Keepership means sharing pain and toil, weeping with those who weep and rejoicing with those who rejoice, acting a brother's part and feeling his sorrows in the heart, bearing his burden as one's own, doing to him as one would have done to oneself, proving faithful to his interests and loving neighbor as self.ST Mar 26, 1885RH Jul 16, 1857ST Nov 27, 1893 It is loving in deed and not in word only, entering into grief and ministering relief by clothing the naked and feeding the hungry, reproving sin, using what God has given even money and possessions for the good of those who call for rescue or aid.ST Mar 26, 1885RH Jul 16, 1857 This duty is learned from Jesus at His feet, for He came on a plan of mercy and His whole life was love to man, and His Spirit gives a kind and gentle heart that feels another's woe so as to be like Him as Head and walk in His footsteps.RH Jul 16, 1857RH Jan 7, 1915 To be keeper is to watch over a brother, take interest in his well-being, treat him with kindness and love, and show care and love wherein failure is failure of brotherly love.RH Nov 6, 1856ST Nov 27, 1893RH Apr 21, 1874 It makes neighbors keepers sharing in the honor and glory of God as shown in Christ who became poor that men might become rich, and it places all under trust as keepers for service and not for salvation alone, so that influence tells either for or against Christ and requires reverently careful conduct lest by indiscreet act, questionable amusement or single self-indulgence the trust be betrayed and an unsuspecting brother led into sin.RH Jan 7, 1915RH Apr 21, 1874
God holds each person accountable as keeper for seeking a brother's welfare, sympathizing, doing good, sharing the gospel and trying to save from ruin, and confronts neglect by asking where the brother is.RH Dec 9, 1862RH Jul 24, 1900RH Oct 15, 1901RH Jan 29, 1914 When an unequaled opportunity to sow the gospel seed is let pass, the need of unwarned souls cries from the ground and demands missionary work and warning.ST Oct 30, 1907RH Jul 24, 1900 The same answer is given by deeds when men pass by those needing help, and the question therefore calls each to show concern and act for others rather than abandon them.ST Jun 5, 1884RH Oct 15, 1901 Christians are responsible for helping and seeking to save the perishing in physical suffering, sin, misery and spiritual need by sharing received light and salvation, for living for self instead brings awful judgment.ST Nov 11, 1913ST Oct 30, 1907RH Jan 29, 1914 The compassionate example is one who offers to care for a distressed man's daughter as his own, showing help rather than abandonment.RH Dec 9, 1862ST Jun 5, 1884
Respectability, education, church membership and a record free from deeds of ill do not secure heaven when good deeds of care are wanting.ST Nov 11, 1913ST Apr 19, 1910ST Jun 18, 1912 To know a brother's inborn weakness and danger, such as toward drunkenness, and to have power to help him by a word, and instead to withdraw carelessly or send him on with a jest, makes one guilty of his ruin.ST Nov 11, 1913ST Apr 19, 1910 Neglecting to save another in this way causes loss of one's own eternity, for loving service to others without meddling belongs to working out one's own salvation and neglect is incompatible with salvation.ST Nov 11, 1913ST Jun 18, 1912 A wealthy man who knew suffering and wrongdoing around him and knew what was right yet cared more for money cannot escape blame by refusing the duty to care.ST Nov 11, 1913ST Apr 19, 1910
The selfish, self-indulgent spirit that refuses to care for others and asks the question in that spirit shows members not working together with God, and when it prevails in the church the Spirit is not poured out without measure.RH Aug 3, 1911
Practical Duties to Others
To be a brother's keeper means to watch over one another, and the answer to Cain's question is yes.RH May 13, 1909RH Jan 22, 1857ST Jun 9, 1898 If a brother is seen heading into error or danger and is not warned, the failure to warn leaves the silent one responsible for the resulting sin and harm.RH Jan 22, 1857ST Jun 9, 1898RH Jun 6, 1865 The duty therefore requires faithful direct admonition of the erring, patient effort to win back those who have strayed from truth, sympathy and encouragement for those in distress, and prayerful attention to those at risk.RH Jun 6, 1865 This reproof must be spoken with kindness, humility, patience and love, not as to an enemy and not by gossiping over faults with others, for wrongdoing often comes from spiritual blindness, deception and delusion, and harsh criticism or talking behind the back destroys confidence, fellowship and love.RH May 13, 1909RH Jun 6, 1865 The obligation rests on the price paid for the erring one by the gift of the only begotten Son, so that the one who accepts that sacrifice is pledged to special care for his brother, and words, actions, influence and conscientious life all affect others for good or ill and must be answered for to God.RH May 13, 1909RH Jun 6, 1865
In the church this keepership takes organized form to recognize, protect and enforce the principles of truth, lest the church remain a lifeless, powerless mere form.RH Jan 15, 1867RH Apr 1, 1915RH Feb 26, 1867 It requires care for every member, brother, sister and child, visiting those repeatedly absent from worship instead of neglecting to ask why, instructing and supporting new converts rather than leaving membership as only a name on the record, laboring for those with no interest in truth, and bearing one another's burdens by precept and example unto perseverance.RH Jan 22, 1857RH Jan 15, 1867RH May 19, 1904RH Oct 30, 1856RH Feb 26, 1867 Part of guarding truth is refusing to suffer sin to rest upon a brother and separating from false brethren who hinder the cause, for neglect can bring discord and division while faithful care can keep a soul from sinking into despair beyond reach of mercy.RH Jan 22, 1857RH Oct 30, 1856RH Feb 26, 1867
Keepership begins at home over against one's own house, first by keeping one's own heart with diligence and abiding long in secret striving prayer until blessing is felt.ST Mar 8, 1905RH Feb 18, 1858 From that inward keeping flows a daily holy influence upon all around, shining as light and savoring as salt by bright example in probity, sincerity, cheerfulness, faithfulness, truth and blameless dealing, feeding the flock and laboring to save companions, children, brothers, sisters, fathers, mothers and associates so neighbors feel their good is sought.RH Feb 18, 1858ST Mar 8, 1905 A sister is thus her brothers' keeper, not leaving older brothers to their own sense or merely telling a father, but giving up clubs and pleasures, devoting evenings to making home pleasant, drawing brothers and their friends into the home, and with God's help taking a dead mother's place where needed.ST Nov 3, 1909ST Mar 8, 1905 The same law of example requires avoiding doubtful amusements, indiscreet acts and self-indulgence, for influence tells either for or against Christ and a single questionable indulgence can betray the trust and lead an unsuspecting brother into sin.ST Apr 30, 1902RH Apr 21, 1874
An employer is keeper of his workers and their families under God as children of a common Father and fellow pilgrims, and must not treat clerks and laborers as mere machines to be kept while they run well and cast off in disgrace when they fail.ST Mar 10, 1881ST Mar 10, 1881 Business and benevolence must not be kept apart nor help confined outside business, but the employer must take warm personal interest, knowing private struggles, whether wages suffice to live, educate children and care for families, and helping, guarding and guiding toward salvation.ST Mar 10, 1881ST Mar 10, 1881 Responsibility does not end with hiring and paying well for hours worked, but extends beyond hours to moral harm, especially drinking and money lost that leaves wives and children hungry, wretched, distressed and destitute. An employer who provides liquor through his own saloon and takes back wages while families suffer cannot excuse himself by regular pay, for he profits from ruin, is chargeable for suffering, sin and death, and will be called to account when the brother's blood cries from the ground.
That same accountability condemns the soul-destroying traffic in strong drink and requires temperance reform, local prohibition work to protect the weak unable to resist temptation, voting with prayer, and personal refusal to taste or allow alcohol on one's premises.RH Dec 6, 1864ST Jan 25, 1910RH Dec 30, 1915 Those who license or profit from drink while bringing blood upon their hands must answer to God for the ruined and dead, and calm indifference while others are destroyed is itself denial of keepership.RH Dec 6, 1864ST Jan 25, 1910 The scale of intemperance makes the duty urgent, causing yearly the death of 103,000 and worse than death to 160,000 more, a calamity more appalling than earthquake, fire or cyclone.ST Jan 25, 1910 The question asked in the primeval age thus remains written in living fire against all who do not shut the door to liquor and work only with those joined in that pledge.RH Dec 30, 1915
Keepership calls every believer, not ministers only, to missionary effort with wisdom, caution and love for the salvation of neighbors, friends, family members and the unwarned who do not know truth.RH Nov 19, 1914RH Apr 11, 1912RH Jan 5, 1905 Neglect of personal effort to warn and help family and neighbors in spiritual need echoes Cain's evasion, and withholding support from those who teach leaves souls uninstructed and unwarned.RH Nov 19, 1914RH Jan 5, 1905ST Mar 7, 1878 The work includes caring for physical suffering and spiritual need together, as in nursing the sick and dying who may have no other opportunity to know Christ, caring for neighbors struggling in spirit with sympathy and practical support, preaching the word, giving to the poor, and supporting workers and schools.RH Apr 11, 1912RH Oct 3, 1907ST Mar 7, 1878 Church members fulfill it also by instructing and upholding one another rather than treating fellowship as a mere name.RH Jan 5, 1905RH May 19, 1904
God still confronts mankind over war's bloodshed on sea and land, killing driven by glory and fame and merciless slaughter, for His patience is tested but He is not sleeping and no cover hides wasted hunger-stricken bodies.ST Jul 4, 1900ST Jan 9, 1901 The first killing without cause, from envy and jealousy when Cain slew Abel, was the birth of war on earth answering to the birth of war in heaven, and war ever remains Satan's contradiction of God's design, the science by which selfish ends are attained and insults fancied or real are avenged.ST Jul 4, 1900ST Jan 9, 1901 Every nation is brother to every other nation, so lifting the hand in war is lifting the hand against a brother and bears Cain's curse on the forehead forevermore, with the warrior's name abhorred.ST Aug 22, 1900RH Sep 22, 1874 Cain's creed that bloodshed will mend misery by doing evil that good may come only rushes men to eternal ruin, and the gospel of peace cannot be carried by Cain's bloody hand.ST Aug 22, 1900RH Sep 22, 1874
In economic and social life keepership means refusing to harm another's livelihood for personal gain and using work, wealth and resources for poorer people, for Christ's sake, as service done unto Christ.ST Nov 29, 1899ST Nov 29, 1899 Each person can thus become a redeemer of the weak and needy in sympathy and help, though no human can take the place of the divine Redeemer who saves from sin.RH Aug 17, 1905ST Nov 29, 1899 It places solemn responsibility on speech, for every man is measurably his keeper and expressed opinion affects others, requiring guarded words, refusal to trifle with speech, careful judgment of motives without condemnation lacking good reason, and to one asking opinion either refusal or a true, discriminating but kindly judgment after the pattern of Christ who is the truth.ST Nov 10, 1881ST Feb 10, 1881 The same care protects men and cattle from Sabbath labor and orders daily conduct, wealth, words and rest so as to live helpfully without meddling.ST Nov 29, 1899ST Nov 10, 1881ST Feb 10, 1881
Whoever assumes to guide and compel another's worship, though never appointed to control his brother, becomes answerable for the consequences and cannot escape by evasion.ST Jan 31, 1911ST Jan 31, 1911RH Mar 17, 1910 Cain's killing after assuming that mastery warns all who coerce conscience by civil power or religious intolerance, for like Cain they will face God's question about those they persecuted, including Sabbath keepers.ST Jan 31, 1911ST Jan 31, 1911 To use the keeper image for mere human policing of a neighbor's conduct perverts it, and the same true sense denies that a mother's friends were keepers of her sister in the sense of responsibility for her welfare in the poisoning case.RH Mar 17, 1910ST Aug 23, 1883
Under-shepherds who echo Cain's denial cannot excuse neglect of souls entrusted to them, for they are accountable to Christ the Chief Shepherd and at the judgment their failure to guard and warn the lost will stand against them.RH Jul 2, 1914RH Jun 14, 1906 Even when attacked, the keeper must not discourage others but must pray humbly for their conversion and pardon and live as a light and uplifting influence.RH Jul 2, 1914RH Jun 14, 1906 Yet each person must first learn to keep himself, for he is accountable for his own conduct on its own merits and cannot excuse his wrongdoing by pointing to a brother's faults, nor can another's wrongs atone for his.RH Jul 2, 1914RH Mar 22, 1870 The lack of love and care voiced in Cain's question had prevailed even among Sabbath-keepers, a serious failure of love calling for repentance.RH Mar 22, 1870RH Oct 30, 1856
Commentary part 2 of 2
Pioneers and periodicals
135 sources
After Cain had killed Abel his brother in the field, the Lord spoke to him to confront him with his deed before pronouncing his doom.ST Apr 8, 1913 Cain lied that he did not know where Abel was, though he knew what he had done, and then in defiance disowned any responsibility to guard his brother.RH Apr 6, 1911ST Jul 14, 1898ST May 6, 1897RH Jul 3, 1856RH Aug 17, 1876 The question sought no information God lacked, but exposed Cain's evasion, held him accountable for his brother, and gave him opportunity to confess before judgment.RH Dec 6, 1864 To his question the answer is yes, for every man, woman and child is his brother's and neighbor's keeper as children of a common Father who cannot live in isolation.ST Sep 27, 1899RH Jan 22, 1857RH Jul 24, 1913 Cain was dealt with as a murderer and transgressor of a known law against killing, proving that murder was sin from the beginning and the principle of the sixth commandment was binding before it was spoken at Sinai.RH Oct 18, 1853ST May 4, 1882
Setting and Wording
The Lord speaks audibly to Cain after Cain has killed Abel his brother in the field, asking where Abel his brother is and confronting him with his deed before pronouncing his doom.ST Apr 8, 1913ST Dec 22, 1898RH Jun 27, 1878 The killing followed anger because the disobedient offering was rejected while Abel's was accepted, and because Abel maintained that God is just, and it was done as they talked together, the younger brother slain by the elder.ST Dec 25, 1901RH Jun 27, 1878 Cain answers, I know not, lying about Abel's whereabouts though he knows where Abel is and what he has done, using falsehood to conceal murder and hide guilt.RH Apr 6, 1911ST Jul 14, 1898ST May 6, 1897ST Jul 14, 1898RH Jun 27, 1878 Sin had dulled his sense of God's presence and knowledge, so he followed Satan's example as liar and murderer in trying deception before God.ST Dec 16, 1886
He adds, Am I my brother's keeper, in cool audacity, defiance and selfishness, combining falsehood, awareness of guilt and an attempt to evade responsibility for his brother.RH Jul 3, 1856RH Aug 17, 1876ST Dec 11, 1884ST Jan 31, 1911ST Jun 9, 1898 The denial claims no rightful duty to protect or help another, and becomes a motto for neglecting one in need and a pattern of self-justification for oppression and other wrongs, especially sins of commission.RH Jul 3, 1856ST Dec 11, 1884ST Jun 9, 1898 He had not been appointed to control his brother, but when he assumed the role of guiding and compelling Abel in worship he became answerable for the consequences, and the question exposes his attempt to escape that responsibility.ST Jan 31, 1911ST Jan 31, 1911 God's question does not seek information He lacks but exposes Cain's evasion, holds him accountable for his brother, and gives him opportunity to confess before judgment.ST Dec 16, 1886RH Dec 6, 1864 He already knew of the murder through its witness, yet He called Cain to account for what had happened to his brother, and Cain remained rebellious instead of confessing.ST Dec 16, 1886RH Dec 6, 1864 The evasion is answered by the fact that Abel's blood cries to God from the ground, meaning God holds a person accountable for a brother's suffering and death.ST Apr 24, 1893
The exchange shows God knows every act and thought of the heart despite denial, that time, place, speech or apparel cannot hide from Him, that He continued to make His will known even to the wicked, and that His dealing with Cain shows His long-suffering.ST Feb 6, 1879ST Feb 6, 1879ST Dec 20, 1910PGGC 5.1–2 Cain's answer reveals sin had dulled his awareness of God's presence, greatness and knowledge, while God revealed the hidden guilt and the crying blood.ST Feb 6, 1879ST Dec 16, 1886ST Feb 6, 1879 The verse belongs to the world's history before the Deluge in the first ten chapters of Genesis, to the account of Cain's life and posterity to the sixth generation reaching nearly to the time of the flood.RH Dec 23, 1915RH Dec 25, 1913ST Sep 5, 1895 It distinguishes Cain's line, which began with Enoch in Nod and later included Lamech, another murderer, and went out from the Lord's presence, from Seth's line, which continued as Seth was born to take Abel's place with other sons and daughters recorded afterward out of chronological order.RH Dec 23, 1915RH Dec 25, 1913ST Oct 16, 1879ST Sep 5, 1895 Those early generations were not primitive savages but lived with farming, herding, metalworking, music and city-building, and Cain's descendants grew up wholly irreligious in wickedness as a distinct family from Seth's until all perished in the flood.RH Dec 6, 1870ST Oct 16, 1879
Cain and Abel
Abel meekly submitted to God's requirements while Cain rebelled and resented, and their different offerings showed the test of obedience upon them.ST Dec 16, 1886 Abel brought of the firstlings of his flock and of the fat thereof by faith and obtained witness that he was righteous, while Cain brought fruit of the ground without blood and without faith, did not do well, and was rejected with sin lying at the door.ST Jul 1, 1889ST Mar 9, 1888 Abel's sacrifice was more excellent than Cain's, and the blood Cain shed was righteous blood.ST Mar 9, 1888
Cain became angry because his disobedient offering was rejected while Abel's was accepted, accused God, and refused to see that his own disobedience made his offering unacceptable.ST Dec 25, 1901RH Jun 27, 1878 He slew Abel because his own works were evil and Abel's were righteous, moved by envy because God had respect to Abel and to his offering, and after contention and talk together in the field he killed his younger brother without cause.ST May 6, 1897ST Mar 9, 1888RH Jun 27, 1878ST Mar 25, 1889 Instead of ruling over sin through faith in the promised Savior he yielded to it, and instead of repenting he murmured at punishment and went out from the presence of God manifested at the gate of Paradise to dwell at a distance in separation from God.ST May 6, 1897ST Oct 16, 1879
Murder begins in allowed angry feelings, envy and hatred in the heart and ends in taking a life that none but God can give, lifting a puny arm against man made in the image of God.ST Mar 25, 1889RH Jan 18, 1870 Covetousness, envy, and desire for power and influence yielded to brought sin's criminal element into human society with the first murder.ST Apr 22, 1903 One sin led to another in Cain from disobedience and accusation against God to deception and murder, reflecting Satan who was a murderer from the beginning and both liar and murderer.ST Dec 16, 1886ST Mar 25, 1889 Sin dulled his sense of God's presence, greatness and knowledge, so though he knew where Abel was and God already knew of the murder through its witness, he used falsehood to hide guilt and evade responsibility, yet remained rebellious when given opportunity to confess before judgment.ST Dec 25, 1901ST Dec 16, 1886
The murder brought a curse on Cain and on the ground, which would no longer yield its strength to him, making him a branded murderer, a fugitive and vagabond and wanderer from the face of the Lord.ST Feb 6, 1879ST Mar 25, 1889 Abel's death was the first death Adam witnessed in his family and deepened his grief and remorse over his own transgression.ST Feb 6, 1879 Though Abel's death was the strongest case ever for avenging a death and Cain the strongest case ever for being slain, both for killing his brother and for bringing added curse upon the ground, God would not permit men to avenge Abel but let Cain live to reap the fruit of his own sowing, gave him opportunity to repent while reserving punishment, and declared sevenfold vengeance on anyone who assumed God's place as Judge and Avenger by killing Cain.ST Nov 8, 1899 Christians must therefore leave judgment and execution of judgment to God and must not demand that their nation chastise other nations to avenge oppressed peoples.ST Nov 8, 1899
God's sparing of Cain's life demonstrated to the universe what happens when sin is permitted to go unpunished, for Cain's life and teaching influenced his descendants toward growing corruption until the whole world had to be destroyed by the Flood. This proves long life is no blessing to the sinner and that great forbearance does not repress wickedness, for the longer men lived the more corrupt they became, and God as guardian as well as sovereign cuts off those determined upon rebellion so they will not lead others to ruin. Sparing the rebels at Sinai would have produced evils even greater than resulted from sparing Cain and would have made the earth as corrupt as in the days of Noah, so it was mercy to punish the few to save the many. Cain's descendants grew up wholly irreligious like him as a distinct family from Seth's and all perished in the Flood, so Eve had no hope in Cain's family and her hope centered in Seth born to take Abel's place.ST Oct 16, 1879 Cain's portion as fratricide is to be accursed at home and abroad, in city and field, to have the malediction of the law laid on the sons of iniquity come upon him, to have his name blotted out from the book of the living and not written with the righteous, and to perish in the day of Judgment devoured by everlasting fire with the devil and his angels unless there is restitution or amendment.RH Sep 29, 1874 His sin is presented as unpardonable because he brought a substitute offering without blood and rebelled against God's ordinance, for which God pronounced a curse on him with no remedy.ST Nov 9, 1915
Law Before Sinai
Cain was cursed for murdering Abel, and his being dealt with as a murderer and transgressor proves that murder was sin from the beginning and that the law forbidding it already existed then.RH Oct 18, 1853ST May 4, 1882 The killing violated a known law against taking life before that law was spoken at Sinai, and God treated him as a lawbreaker for it.RH Oct 18, 1853ST May 4, 1882ST Jun 3, 1875 The principle specified is that of the sixth commandment, known and binding from the beginning before it was given at Sinai.RH Mar 19, 1857RH Dec 25, 1860
He had no excuse of ignorance, for God held him guilty for his brother's blood and punished him accordingly.RH Jan 15, 1875RH Nov 13, 1856ST Feb 11, 1886 That guilt before Moses demonstrates that God's law and knowledge of it existed from Adam onward and that people before Moses had a revealed law to transgress, even though Genesis records no formal giving of the law and no express command against murder before the act.RH Jan 15, 1875ST Sep 2, 1875RH Nov 13, 1856ST Feb 11, 1886 God's speaking with Cain after the murder shows He continued to make His will known even to the wicked.RH Oct 18, 1853
The account belongs among the early Genesis passages reflecting the moral law, the Ten Commandments, with the killing read together with the surrounding verses as an early reference to that law.ST May 6, 1875ST Mar 20, 1879 God's moral law condemned Cain for killing his innocent brother, applying from the beginning of human history and making obedience to God obligatory.RH Dec 28, 1869RH Dec 15, 1868 Envy of Abel led to murder, followed by falsehood to conceal the crime in denying knowledge of his brother and rejecting responsibility for him, so Cain violated the law against murder and the duty of honesty and did not keep the law by killing his brother.RH Jan 18, 1870ST Jul 9, 1874RH Dec 28, 1869
That killing broke the sixth commandment long before God's voice was heard from Sinai, proving sin was in the world and the ten precepts were already known and binding before they were proclaimed from the mount.ST Mar 30, 1915 The law was later spoken at Sinai so that the offense might abound and sin by the commandment might become exceeding sinful.ST Mar 30, 1915 The Lord's words to Cain about Abel his brother made the sixth commandment against murder known in the beginning, showing killing was treated as sin and moral obligation in that age even though Genesis is history and records no formal law code.RH Mar 17, 1874 Its presence proves that lack of a recorded commandment in Genesis does not prove lack of obligation.RH Mar 17, 1874
Death and Crying Blood
The voice of Abel's blood crying from the ground is not conscious blood living and speaking in heaven, but a figure in which an inanimate thing is given life, action, intelligence and personality.RH Sep 22, 1859RH Jul 8, 1862ST Apr 10, 1879RH Apr 25, 1865ST Mar 15, 1877 The cry revealed that a murder had been committed and a life had been taken, and so called for vengeance and judgment upon the murderer.RH Sep 22, 1859RH Jul 8, 1862RH Apr 25, 1865 It is a figurative representation in which injustice done on earth pleads to God for justice, showing how God regards wrongdoing and remembers the oppressed.RH Jul 8, 1862RH Apr 25, 1865 The facts of Abel's case are portrayed as though he could speak after death, not as proof that the dead are conscious.ST Jun 30, 1881RH Apr 25, 1865ST Mar 15, 1877ST Mar 27, 1879
The cry represents justice seeking redress for death, with blood itself not conscious and not literally speaking.RH Apr 25, 1865ST Mar 15, 1877ST Mar 27, 1879 An inanimate thing is made to speak and act in reference to the facts of its case as though alive, with the language of a rational being.ST Mar 15, 1877ST Mar 27, 1879 The example therefore proves that the dead speaking and acting as though alive does not mean they are conscious.ST Mar 15, 1877ST Mar 27, 1879
The same personification explains the blood of those slain for the word of God crying to God for vengeance from beneath the altar without being conscious.RH Sep 22, 1859RH Jul 8, 1862RH Apr 25, 1865 Those are unconscious martyred dead whose cry, like Abel's, is justice seeking redress and not conscious souls speaking after death.RH Jul 8, 1862RH Apr 25, 1865 It likewise explains the conversation of the rich man and Lazarus in hades as personified dead men with bodily organs speaking as though alive, not disembodied conscious spirits.ST Mar 15, 1877ST Mar 27, 1879 This proves the dead in hades are unconscious in darkness and silence without knowledge, wisdom, memory, or speech.ST Mar 15, 1877ST Mar 27, 1879
Types of Two Classes
Cain and Abel stand as opposing characters and continuing types, Abel for faith, love and obedience and Cain for unbelief, hatred and disobedience, with the fruit of each blessing or cursing the earth ever since and the two classes of the righteous and the wicked continuing until the end.ST Nov 18, 1897ST Mar 18, 1903ST Sep 1, 1909RH Jan 23, 1900 Righteousness in the account is life and enlightens, while sin is death and blinds and deceives, showing the reward of obedience and the fearful result of disobedience.ST Aug 13, 1896 The two brothers are the first representatives of the children of the kingdom and the children of the wicked one pictured in the parable of the wheat and tares, which applies from the time of Adam's sons through the close of the day of grace.RH Feb 10, 1874ST Jun 25, 1874 Cain as elder son became head of the ungodly line, whose beginnings and history show the development of its character and its distinction from the godly line.ST Jul 27, 1915
Righteous Abel belongs with the first parents who turned from sin to God among God's first called-out ones, showing that the church as those who heed God's call, come out from the world and join with Him began then and that God has had His called-out ones in all ages since.ST Apr 29, 1908 Abel also marks the beginning of the history of martyrs recorded in the Bible through the time of John on Patmos.ST Mar 5, 1912 In worship Abel obeyed God's direction while Cain followed his own ideas and then persecuted Abel for worshiping as required, so that Cain exemplifies religious tyranny and Abel exemplifies religious liberty and loyalty to God even at the cost of life.ST Mar 12, 1894 Cain had not been appointed to control his brother, but when he assumed the role of guiding and compelling him in worship he became answerable for the consequences, and his evasion exposes his attempt to escape that responsibility.ST Jan 31, 1911ST Jan 31, 1911
Those who coerce another's conscience and worship by civil power will likewise answer to God for the harm they cause, including for persecuted Sabbath keepers, and cannot escape responsibility.ST Jan 31, 1911ST Jan 31, 1911 By religious bigotry Cain denied Abel the right to worship according to his faith and took his life, violating both freedom of worship and the right to live, so that Abel's blood stands as a protest against denying to others rights one claims for oneself.ST Dec 7, 1915 The brothers present an early conflict between true religion and fraudulent man-made religious institutions, Cain representing wicked persecutors and Abel the righteous persecuted.ST Mar 12, 1894 The shedding of Abel's blood began an unbroken history in which the usurped unhallowed union of secular and ecclesiastical power drenches the earth with blood in no country or age without fail, warning against joining church and state to enforce religion by law.RH Feb 4, 1873
Cain's rejection of God's light was the first step of apostasy, beginning a pattern of turning from God's word to one's own way that later generations repeat when they reject light already given.ST Jul 21, 1898 His example marks the beginning of humanity's effort to gain standing before God through works of its own devising instead of acknowledging helplessness.ST Dec 26, 1906 He refused the required blood offering of a spotless lamb shadowing the great sacrifice and brought fruit of the ground instead, revealing lack of faith and fidelity, while Abel believed God meant what He said and by faith obeyed and was counted righteous, proving God requires exact obedience and will not accept substituted service such as keeping Sunday instead of the commanded seventh-day holy day.RH Sep 22, 1874 Through Abel's murder Satan sought to destroy the promised Seed.ST
Cain's creed was blood, murdering his brother to mend human misery on the plea that evil done will bring good, with sin and righteousness changing places under Satan's control, and the gospel of peace cannot be carried by the hand of Cain, for drowning misery in men's blood only rushes men to eternal ruin.ST Aug 22, 1900ST Aug 22, 1900 In the last days those who follow him, refusing glad submission to God's will and the love of the truth, repeat his violent hand in movements like anarchy that would drown human woe in blood.ST Aug 22, 1900 The only safety is to take the lesson to heart by cultivating love of the truth and sharing in the triumph of the truth, otherwise his followers will fill the earth with violence and go down to destruction with those who had pleasure in unrighteousness.ST Aug 22, 1900
Universal Brotherly Responsibility
To the defiant question whether one is one's brother's keeper the answer is yes, for every man, woman and child is keeper of brother and neighbor under God, bound together as children of a common Father and fellow pilgrims who cannot live in isolation.RH May 13, 1909ST Sep 27, 1899RH Jan 22, 1857RH Jul 24, 1913ST Mar 10, 1881 All are one another's keepers, educators, helpers or hinderers, saviours or seducers, and life is filled with beautiful things by filling it with right things, for as society ripens and the standard of manhood rises the right things will become the beautiful things.ST Sep 27, 1899RH Jul 24, 1913ST Nov 24, 1881 The duty means watching over one another, so that seeing a brother heading into error and failing to warn him makes the silent one responsible for the resulting sin.RH Jan 22, 1857RH Jun 6, 1865 Churches bear this as a solemn duty to care for every member, and to neglect a member who repeatedly misses worship without asking why violates that duty and can bring discord and division.RH Jan 22, 1857RH Jan 15, 1867 Every professed Christian is responsible for his fellow man in the work of God and must not leave a brother unwarned, but cherish kindness and love toward the erring and not treat him as an enemy, since wrong is often done from spiritual blindness, deception and delusion.RH May 13, 1909RH Dec 9, 1862 The erring one has been bought with a price by the gift of the only begotten Son so that believers should not perish but have everlasting life, and the soul who accepts that sacrifice for himself is pledged to special care for his erring brother.RH May 13, 1909RH Jan 29, 1914 This lays sacred duties on the church through organization to recognize, protect and enforce the principles of the message, to care for brethren, sisters and children, and to labor for those with no interest in the truth, so that the church prospers instead of remaining a lifeless and powerless mere formal organization.RH Jan 22, 1857RH Jan 15, 1867
Denial does not remove keepership, for the denial did not change the fact, and the same plea today is evasion, excuse and shirking rather than release from duty.RH Jul 24, 1913ST Dec 11, 1884RH Mar 19, 1914ST Nov 24, 1881 To use the question as a motto for having nothing to do with one in need sets refusal to care against loving neighbor as self.ST Dec 11, 1884ST Nov 24, 1881 No one can excuse neglect by denying responsibility, for all are responsible before God for the welfare of others and for making their best efforts to help those within their influence, including finding what holds them back and giving practical help to become free.RH Mar 19, 1914RH Jun 6, 1865 Caring for those entrusted is duty not to be dismissed, and the call is to help the poor, degraded and lost rather than stand by, since a brother's blood cries to God.ST Nov 24, 1881RH Jun 6, 1865 One who fails to live by professed truth or spreads an unholy influence cannot rightly use the plea to avoid responsibility, but must warn against sin by spoken reproof and conscientious life and must not idle while others are in danger.RH Jan 22, 1857RH Jun 6, 1865
No one lives only for himself, for each life affects others for good or harm, and none can live and act among others without influencing them for help or harm.RH Apr 6, 1911RH Jul 24, 1913ST Nov 24, 1881 People are responsible not only for actions but for influence, example and the consequences borne in others' lives, and must answer to God at the judgment.RH Apr 6, 1911ST Nov 11, 1913RH Jul 24, 1913 Words and actions affect others for good or ill, and accountability includes sympathy and encouragement for those in distress, patient efforts to win back those who have left the way of truth, and prayerful attention to those at risk.RH Dec 9, 1862 All are brothers and sisters, and each should seek the neighbor's welfare, sympathize, do good, share the gospel and try to save from ruin whatever his condition or distance.RH Dec 9, 1862ST Jun 5, 1884RH Jan 29, 1914
Keepership means sharing pain and toil, weeping with those who weep and rejoicing with those who rejoice, acting a brother's part and feeling his sorrows in the heart, bearing his burden as one's own, doing to him as one would have done to oneself, proving faithful to his interests and loving neighbor as self.ST Mar 26, 1885RH Jul 16, 1857ST Nov 27, 1893 It is loving in deed and not in word only, entering into grief and ministering relief by clothing the naked and feeding the hungry, reproving sin, using what God has given even money and possessions for the good of those who call for rescue or aid.ST Mar 26, 1885RH Jul 16, 1857 This duty is learned from Jesus at His feet, for He came on a plan of mercy and His whole life was love to man, and His Spirit gives a kind and gentle heart that feels another's woe so as to be like Him as Head and walk in His footsteps.RH Jul 16, 1857RH Jan 7, 1915 To be keeper is to watch over a brother, take interest in his well-being, treat him with kindness and love, and show care and love wherein failure is failure of brotherly love.RH Nov 6, 1856ST Nov 27, 1893RH Apr 21, 1874 It makes neighbors keepers sharing in the honor and glory of God as shown in Christ who became poor that men might become rich, and it places all under trust as keepers for service and not for salvation alone, so that influence tells either for or against Christ and requires reverently careful conduct lest by indiscreet act, questionable amusement or single self-indulgence the trust be betrayed and an unsuspecting brother led into sin.RH Jan 7, 1915RH Apr 21, 1874
God holds each person accountable as keeper for seeking a brother's welfare, sympathizing, doing good, sharing the gospel and trying to save from ruin, and confronts neglect by asking where the brother is.RH Dec 9, 1862RH Jul 24, 1900RH Oct 15, 1901RH Jan 29, 1914 When an unequaled opportunity to sow the gospel seed is let pass, the need of unwarned souls cries from the ground and demands missionary work and warning.ST Oct 30, 1907RH Jul 24, 1900 The same answer is given by deeds when men pass by those needing help, and the question therefore calls each to show concern and act for others rather than abandon them.ST Jun 5, 1884RH Oct 15, 1901 Christians are responsible for helping and seeking to save the perishing in physical suffering, sin, misery and spiritual need by sharing received light and salvation, for living for self instead brings awful judgment.ST Nov 11, 1913ST Oct 30, 1907RH Jan 29, 1914 The compassionate example is one who offers to care for a distressed man's daughter as his own, showing help rather than abandonment.RH Dec 9, 1862ST Jun 5, 1884
Respectability, education, church membership and a record free from deeds of ill do not secure heaven when good deeds of care are wanting.ST Nov 11, 1913ST Apr 19, 1910ST Jun 18, 1912 To know a brother's inborn weakness and danger, such as toward drunkenness, and to have power to help him by a word, and instead to withdraw carelessly or send him on with a jest, makes one guilty of his ruin.ST Nov 11, 1913ST Apr 19, 1910 Neglecting to save another in this way causes loss of one's own eternity, for loving service to others without meddling belongs to working out one's own salvation and neglect is incompatible with salvation.ST Nov 11, 1913ST Jun 18, 1912 A wealthy man who knew suffering and wrongdoing around him and knew what was right yet cared more for money cannot escape blame by refusing the duty to care.ST Nov 11, 1913ST Apr 19, 1910
The selfish, self-indulgent spirit that refuses to care for others and asks the question in that spirit shows members not working together with God, and when it prevails in the church the Spirit is not poured out without measure.RH Aug 3, 1911
Practical Duties to Others
To be a brother's keeper means to watch over one another, and the answer to Cain's question is yes.RH May 13, 1909RH Jan 22, 1857ST Jun 9, 1898 If a brother is seen heading into error or danger and is not warned, the failure to warn leaves the silent one responsible for the resulting sin and harm.RH Jan 22, 1857ST Jun 9, 1898RH Jun 6, 1865 The duty therefore requires faithful direct admonition of the erring, patient effort to win back those who have strayed from truth, sympathy and encouragement for those in distress, and prayerful attention to those at risk.RH Jun 6, 1865 This reproof must be spoken with kindness, humility, patience and love, not as to an enemy and not by gossiping over faults with others, for wrongdoing often comes from spiritual blindness, deception and delusion, and harsh criticism or talking behind the back destroys confidence, fellowship and love.RH May 13, 1909RH Jun 6, 1865 The obligation rests on the price paid for the erring one by the gift of the only begotten Son, so that the one who accepts that sacrifice is pledged to special care for his brother, and words, actions, influence and conscientious life all affect others for good or ill and must be answered for to God.RH May 13, 1909RH Jun 6, 1865
In the church this keepership takes organized form to recognize, protect and enforce the principles of truth, lest the church remain a lifeless, powerless mere form.RH Jan 15, 1867RH Apr 1, 1915RH Feb 26, 1867 It requires care for every member, brother, sister and child, visiting those repeatedly absent from worship instead of neglecting to ask why, instructing and supporting new converts rather than leaving membership as only a name on the record, laboring for those with no interest in truth, and bearing one another's burdens by precept and example unto perseverance.RH Jan 22, 1857RH Jan 15, 1867RH May 19, 1904RH Oct 30, 1856RH Feb 26, 1867 Part of guarding truth is refusing to suffer sin to rest upon a brother and separating from false brethren who hinder the cause, for neglect can bring discord and division while faithful care can keep a soul from sinking into despair beyond reach of mercy.RH Jan 22, 1857RH Oct 30, 1856RH Feb 26, 1867
Keepership begins at home over against one's own house, first by keeping one's own heart with diligence and abiding long in secret striving prayer until blessing is felt.ST Mar 8, 1905RH Feb 18, 1858 From that inward keeping flows a daily holy influence upon all around, shining as light and savoring as salt by bright example in probity, sincerity, cheerfulness, faithfulness, truth and blameless dealing, feeding the flock and laboring to save companions, children, brothers, sisters, fathers, mothers and associates so neighbors feel their good is sought.RH Feb 18, 1858ST Mar 8, 1905 A sister is thus her brothers' keeper, not leaving older brothers to their own sense or merely telling a father, but giving up clubs and pleasures, devoting evenings to making home pleasant, drawing brothers and their friends into the home, and with God's help taking a dead mother's place where needed.ST Nov 3, 1909ST Mar 8, 1905 The same law of example requires avoiding doubtful amusements, indiscreet acts and self-indulgence, for influence tells either for or against Christ and a single questionable indulgence can betray the trust and lead an unsuspecting brother into sin.ST Apr 30, 1902RH Apr 21, 1874
An employer is keeper of his workers and their families under God as children of a common Father and fellow pilgrims, and must not treat clerks and laborers as mere machines to be kept while they run well and cast off in disgrace when they fail.ST Mar 10, 1881ST Mar 10, 1881 Business and benevolence must not be kept apart nor help confined outside business, but the employer must take warm personal interest, knowing private struggles, whether wages suffice to live, educate children and care for families, and helping, guarding and guiding toward salvation.ST Mar 10, 1881ST Mar 10, 1881 Responsibility does not end with hiring and paying well for hours worked, but extends beyond hours to moral harm, especially drinking and money lost that leaves wives and children hungry, wretched, distressed and destitute. An employer who provides liquor through his own saloon and takes back wages while families suffer cannot excuse himself by regular pay, for he profits from ruin, is chargeable for suffering, sin and death, and will be called to account when the brother's blood cries from the ground.
That same accountability condemns the soul-destroying traffic in strong drink and requires temperance reform, local prohibition work to protect the weak unable to resist temptation, voting with prayer, and personal refusal to taste or allow alcohol on one's premises.RH Dec 6, 1864ST Jan 25, 1910RH Dec 30, 1915 Those who license or profit from drink while bringing blood upon their hands must answer to God for the ruined and dead, and calm indifference while others are destroyed is itself denial of keepership.RH Dec 6, 1864ST Jan 25, 1910 The scale of intemperance makes the duty urgent, causing yearly the death of 103,000 and worse than death to 160,000 more, a calamity more appalling than earthquake, fire or cyclone.ST Jan 25, 1910 The question asked in the primeval age thus remains written in living fire against all who do not shut the door to liquor and work only with those joined in that pledge.RH Dec 30, 1915
Keepership calls every believer, not ministers only, to missionary effort with wisdom, caution and love for the salvation of neighbors, friends, family members and the unwarned who do not know truth.RH Nov 19, 1914RH Apr 11, 1912RH Jan 5, 1905 Neglect of personal effort to warn and help family and neighbors in spiritual need echoes Cain's evasion, and withholding support from those who teach leaves souls uninstructed and unwarned.RH Nov 19, 1914RH Jan 5, 1905ST Mar 7, 1878 The work includes caring for physical suffering and spiritual need together, as in nursing the sick and dying who may have no other opportunity to know Christ, caring for neighbors struggling in spirit with sympathy and practical support, preaching the word, giving to the poor, and supporting workers and schools.RH Apr 11, 1912RH Oct 3, 1907ST Mar 7, 1878 Church members fulfill it also by instructing and upholding one another rather than treating fellowship as a mere name.RH Jan 5, 1905RH May 19, 1904
God still confronts mankind over war's bloodshed on sea and land, killing driven by glory and fame and merciless slaughter, for His patience is tested but He is not sleeping and no cover hides wasted hunger-stricken bodies.ST Jul 4, 1900ST Jan 9, 1901 The first killing without cause, from envy and jealousy when Cain slew Abel, was the birth of war on earth answering to the birth of war in heaven, and war ever remains Satan's contradiction of God's design, the science by which selfish ends are attained and insults fancied or real are avenged.ST Jul 4, 1900ST Jan 9, 1901 Every nation is brother to every other nation, so lifting the hand in war is lifting the hand against a brother and bears Cain's curse on the forehead forevermore, with the warrior's name abhorred.ST Aug 22, 1900RH Sep 22, 1874 Cain's creed that bloodshed will mend misery by doing evil that good may come only rushes men to eternal ruin, and the gospel of peace cannot be carried by Cain's bloody hand.ST Aug 22, 1900RH Sep 22, 1874
In economic and social life keepership means refusing to harm another's livelihood for personal gain and using work, wealth and resources for poorer people, for Christ's sake, as service done unto Christ.ST Nov 29, 1899ST Nov 29, 1899 Each person can thus become a redeemer of the weak and needy in sympathy and help, though no human can take the place of the divine Redeemer who saves from sin.RH Aug 17, 1905ST Nov 29, 1899 It places solemn responsibility on speech, for every man is measurably his keeper and expressed opinion affects others, requiring guarded words, refusal to trifle with speech, careful judgment of motives without condemnation lacking good reason, and to one asking opinion either refusal or a true, discriminating but kindly judgment after the pattern of Christ who is the truth.ST Nov 10, 1881ST Feb 10, 1881 The same care protects men and cattle from Sabbath labor and orders daily conduct, wealth, words and rest so as to live helpfully without meddling.ST Nov 29, 1899ST Nov 10, 1881ST Feb 10, 1881
Whoever assumes to guide and compel another's worship, though never appointed to control his brother, becomes answerable for the consequences and cannot escape by evasion.ST Jan 31, 1911ST Jan 31, 1911RH Mar 17, 1910 Cain's killing after assuming that mastery warns all who coerce conscience by civil power or religious intolerance, for like Cain they will face God's question about those they persecuted, including Sabbath keepers.ST Jan 31, 1911ST Jan 31, 1911 To use the keeper image for mere human policing of a neighbor's conduct perverts it, and the same true sense denies that a mother's friends were keepers of her sister in the sense of responsibility for her welfare in the poisoning case.RH Mar 17, 1910ST Aug 23, 1883
Under-shepherds who echo Cain's denial cannot excuse neglect of souls entrusted to them, for they are accountable to Christ the Chief Shepherd and at the judgment their failure to guard and warn the lost will stand against them.RH Jul 2, 1914RH Jun 14, 1906 Even when attacked, the keeper must not discourage others but must pray humbly for their conversion and pardon and live as a light and uplifting influence.RH Jul 2, 1914RH Jun 14, 1906 Yet each person must first learn to keep himself, for he is accountable for his own conduct on its own merits and cannot excuse his wrongdoing by pointing to a brother's faults, nor can another's wrongs atone for his.RH Jul 2, 1914RH Mar 22, 1870 The lack of love and care voiced in Cain's question had prevailed even among Sabbath-keepers, a serious failure of love calling for repentance.RH Mar 22, 1870RH Oct 30, 1856
Sources