Hebrews 12:17
For ye know how that afterward, when he would have inherited the blessing, he was rejected: for he found no place of repentance, though he sought it carefully with tears.
Translations
For you know how that afterward, when he would have inherited the blessing, he was rejected: for he found no place of repentance, though he sought it carefully with tears.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
For ye know how that afterward, when he would have inherited the blessing, he was rejected: for he found no place of repentance, though he sought it carefully with tears.
For ye know that afterward, when he would have inherited the blessing, he was rejected: for he found no place of repentance, though he sought it carefully with tears.
For ye know that even when he afterward desired to inherit the blessing, he was rejected ( for he found no place of repentance), though he sought it diligently with tears.
For ye know that even when he afterward desired to inherit the blessing, he was rejected; for he found no place for a change of mind in his father, though he sought it diligently with tears.
for ye know that also afterwards, wishing to inherit the blessing, he was disapproved of, for a place of reformation he found not, though with tears having sought it.
for ye know that also afterwards, desiring to inherit the blessing, he was rejected, ( for he found no place for repentance) although he sought it earnestly with tears.
For ye know that, afterwards—when he even wished to inherit the blessing, he was rejected; for, place of repentance, found he none, even though, with tears, he diligently sought it.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
For you know that afterward, when he wanted to inherit the blessing, he was rejected. He could find no ground for repentance, though he sought the blessing with tears.
For you know that even when he afterward desired to inherit the blessing, he was rejected, for he found no place for a change of mind though he sought it diligently with tears.
For you have knowledge that even long after, when he was desiring the blessing for his heritage, he was turned away, though he made his request frequently and with weeping; because the past might not be changed.
For ye knowe howe that afterwarde also when he woulde haue inherited the blessing, he was reiected: for he founde no place to repentance, though he sought that blessing with teares.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
For know ye that afterwards, when he desired to inherit the benediction, he was rejected; for he found no place of repentance, although with tears he had sought it.
Cross-references
- Genesis 25:29-34
And Jacob sod pottage: and Esau came from the field, and he was faint:
Esau traded his birthright for food and later sought the blessing with tears.
- Genesis 27:34-38
And when Esau heard the words of his father, he cried with a great and exceeding bitter cry, and said unto his father, Bless me, even me also, O my father.
Esau weeps and pleads for the blessing after discovering Jacob received it.
- 2 Corinthians 7:10
For godly sorrow worketh repentance to salvation not to be repented of: but the sorrow of the world worketh death.
Godly sorrow leads to repentance, unlike Esau’s sorrow that came too late.
- Matthew 27:3-5
Then Judas, which had betrayed him, when he saw that he was condemned, repented himself, and brought again the thirty pieces of silver to the chief priests and elders,
Judas regrets his betrayal but cannot undo it or turn in true repentance.
- Hebrews 6:4-8
For it is impossible for those who were once enlightened, and have tasted of the heavenly gift, and were made partakers of the Holy Ghost,
Both warn that rejecting God brings rejection and a fatal limit.
- Hebrews 11
Now faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen.
Its examples of faithful people contrast with unbelief.
- Romans 2:4-5
Or despisest thou the riches of his goodness and forbearance and longsuffering; not knowing that the goodness of God leadeth thee to repentance?
God’s goodness leads to repentance, while an impenitent heart stores up wrath.
- Proverbs 1:28
Then shall they call upon me, but I will not answer; they shall seek me early, but they shall not find me:
Those who refuse God’s call later seek him in vain.
- Genesis 27:38
And Esau said unto his father, Hast thou but one blessing, my father? bless me, even me also, O my father. And Esau lifted up his voice, and wept.
Esau weeps as he pleads for a blessing.
- 1 Peter 2:4
To whom coming, as unto a living stone, disallowed indeed of men, but chosen of God, and precious,
Uses the same Greek word translated “rejected” in Hebrews 12:17.
- 1 Peter 2:7
Unto you therefore which believe he is precious: but unto them which be disobedient, the stone which the builders disallowed, the same is made the head of the corner,
Uses the same Greek word translated “rejected” in Hebrews 12:17.
- Isaiah 55:6-7
Seek ye the LORD while he may be found, call ye upon him while he is near:
Calls people to seek God and receive his mercy.
- Luke 16:24
And he cried and said, Father Abraham, have mercy on me, and send Lazarus, that he may dip the tip of his finger in water, and cool my tongue; for I am tormented in this flame.
Both describe a desperate plea for relief after it is too late.
- Exodus 8:8
Then Pharaoh called for Moses and Aaron, and said, Intreat the LORD, that he may take away the frogs from me, and from my people; and I will let the people go, that they may do sacrifice unto the LORD.
Pharaoh’s plea to remove the frogs exemplifies grief without genuine repentance.
- 1 Samuel 15:26
And Samuel said unto Saul, I will not return with thee: for thou hast rejected the word of the LORD, and the LORD hath rejected thee from being king over Israel.
Saul’s disobedience brings rejection, as Esau’s did.
- Proverbs 29:1
He, that being often reproved hardeneth his neck, shall suddenly be destroyed, and that without remedy.
Both describe a point of rejection and destruction beyond remedy.
- Acts 5:31
Him hath God exalted with his right hand to be a Prince and a Saviour, for to give repentance to Israel, and forgiveness of sins.
Christ gives repentance and forgiveness.
- Hebrews 10:26
For if we sin wilfully after that we have received the knowledge of the truth, there remaineth no more sacrifice for sins,
Explains persistent, defiant sin and its danger.
- Hebrews 10:29
Of how much sorer punishment, suppose ye, shall he be thought worthy, who hath trodden under foot the Son of God, and hath counted the blood of the covenant, where with he was sanctified, an unholy thing, and hath done despite unto the Spirit of grace?
Both describe rejecting what God offers and treating sacred things with contempt.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
37 sources
Esau despised a sacred inheritance and sold his birthright for a single meal, and the same is done whenever what God has given is traded away for present gratification.Ms 4, 1885, par. 1Lt 35, 1898, par. 20–21Lt 179c, 1905, par. 9–11 Afterward when he would have inherited the blessing he was rejected and could not recover what he had forfeited, though he sought it earnestly with tears.Lt 21, 1867, par. 16–19Lt 47, 1894, par. 41–42SG3 116.1–117.1 His rejection did not mean he was barred from seeking God's favor through repentance, for what could not be restored was the birthright and blessing he had carelessly lost.PP 181.2PP 181.3–182.1 His tears did not undo his choice because his sorrow was for the loss and painful consequences rather than godly sorrow for the guilt of sin itself, without a changed heart turned from sin to God.PP 181.2PP 181.3–182.12SP 205.2–206.14RED 57.2–58.1 The verse therefore warns that a person may forfeit blessing through profane choice and afterward find no way to regain it, even when seeking it with tears, once the day of privilege and opportunity has passed.Lt 97, 1896, par. 12–15Ms 27, 1885, par. 19–20SG3 116.1–117.1Lt 87, 1896, par. 15Lt 5, 1877, par. 4–5
Esau's Sale and Rejection
The verse describes Esau as a profane person and fornicator who despised and treated lightly a sacred inheritance and sold his birthright for a single meal, for one morsel of meat, for a mess of pottage.Ms 4, 1885, par. 1Lt 35, 1898, par. 20–21Lt 179c, 1905, par. 9–112T 37.3–38.2Lt 83, 1897, par. 17–20 The same is done whenever a God-given inheritance is squandered and sacred responsibilities are betrayed for present gratification.2T 37.3–38.2Lt 83, 1897, par. 17–20 It is done when young men gain ever so much knowledge in the sciences and yet fail to put it to practical use, when obtaining an education absorbs the mind so that prayer and religious privileges are neglected and the welfare of the soul becomes a matter of carelessness and indifference and learning in the school of Christ ceases.3T 223.1–2 Knowledge is only of value when sought from principle to do good to others and promote God's glory, to develop and direct the faculties so as to be more useful and bless others, and if obtaining knowledge increases love of self and inclination to excuse self from bearing responsibilities, it is better to be without it.3T 223.1–2 If books are loved and idolized and allowed to come between duty and the soul, so that there is reluctance to leave study and reading to do essential labor that someone must do, desire for study must be restrained and love for neglected practical duties must be cultivated.3T 223.1–2
Esau did not see the sale as momentous at the time and passed the crisis of his life without knowing it.Lt 4, 1898, par. 14Lt 5, 1877, par. 16 What he regarded as scarcely worth a thought revealed the prevailing traits of his character, showed his choices, and showed his true estimate of that which was sacred and should have been sacredly cherished, and to him a morsel of meat was more than the service of his Master.Lt 5, 1877, par. 16 Long indulgence had let appetite overpower every other consideration, for he had long gratified himself for a particular dish until he felt he must have it, letting his imagination dwell on it until he feared great inconvenience and even death without it.CTBH 43.1–44.2 His desire grew until the birthright lost its value and sacredness and he bartered it away for a small indulgence to meet his present wants, and this determined the aftercourse of his life.CTBH 43.1–44.2Lt 5, 1877, par. 16 He flattered himself that he could give it up at will and buy it back when he pleased, treating his birthright as something he could surrender and later recover.CH 110.2CTBH 43.1–44.2
Afterward, when he would have inherited the blessing, he was rejected and could not recover what he had forfeited, though he sought it carefully with tears and even at great sacrifice.Lt 21, 1867, par. 16–19Lt 47, 1894, par. 41–42CH 110.2CTBH 43.1–44.2Lt 98a, 1897, par. 1–6 His regret came only after he learned Jacob had received the blessing, when his rash choice could no longer be undone.SG3 116.1–117.1 His bitter repentance of his rash folly and madness was in vain, because he had despised the blessing and the Lord had removed it from him permanently.2T 37.3–38.2CH 110.2CTBH 43.1–44.2 It warns that sinners may realize too late that they have traded away their birthright, and that the crown and inheritance they might have received are lost, for gratifying selfish desires can bring consequences that later regret cannot reverse.Lt 21, 1867, par. 16–19Lt 47, 1894, par. 41–42 Those who trade their inheritance of heaven for selfish pleasure and hurtful lusts, for appetite, hurtful indulgences, or selfish pleasures, will find in the day of God and when God's judgment comes that their repentance comes too late to remedy what they have bartered away.SG3 116.1–117.11SP 108.1–2
Tears Without True Repentance
The finding of no place of repentance did not shut Esau out from seeking divine favor, for repentance toward God still remained open to him.PP 181.2PP 181.3–182.1 What could never be recovered was the birthright and blessing he had carelessly exchanged for momentary gratification, even though he afterward sought it with tears.PP 181.2PP 181.3–182.1 His tears and earnest seeking could not reverse the forfeiture because his sorrow was over the loss and its painful consequences and fear of punishment, not godly sorrow for the guilt of the sin itself.PP 181.2PP 181.3–182.12SP 205.2–206.1ST Apr 19, 1877SC 23.3–24.1 He did not seek reconciliation with God, did not turn from sin with a changed heart, and his apparent repentance was insincere, the grief of one whose heart remained set on wickedness.PP 181.2PP 181.3–182.12SP 205.2–206.1Lt 3, 1872, par. 5–9SC 23.3–24.1 Regret over loss or punishment does not itself change the heart, and tears over trouble or the unexpected results of wrongdoing do not undo what was done nor work the godly sorrow that leads to repentance unto eternal life.2SP 205.2–206.1ST Apr 19, 1877SC 23.3–24.1
Selfish sorrow that comes only when guilt is discovered and wrongdoing has brought disagreeable circumstances with unexpected consequences has no merit to remove even a single stain of sin.4RED 57.2–58.1 There is no virtue in living under a perpetual cloud and repining, and such mourning, like Pharaoh crying for the plagues to be removed while his heart was unchanged and ready to repeat his crime, is not unto repentance.4RED 57.2–58.1 True mourning feels the whole life to have been ingratitude, robbing the best Friend of time and strength bought at infinite price and slighting and grieving the compassionate Saviour.4RED 57.2–58.1 It binds the penitent to the Infinite One, brings back lost graces, and yields the peaceable fruits of righteousness, leading to comfort, holiness, and joy.4RED 57.2–58.1
The same false sorrow appeared in Satan, who regretted his loss and pleaded for restoration from suffering and lost privileges rather than from love for God and willing obedience, while rebellion still remained in him.1SP 29.2–30.2 His case shows that law can condemn sin but cannot pardon it.1SP 29.2–30.2 So also the anguish of Esau and the desperate confession of Judas, arising from grief over results rather than hatred of evil, cannot prepare a person for the day of God.GC 620.2–3GC88 620.1–3 In the final conflict and time of trouble, when those who have concealed or delayed confessing sin at last confess as punishment draws near, such fearful confessions made from fear of punishment cannot bring deliverance.GC 620.2–3GC88 620.1–3
Warning Against Forfeiting Inheritance
A blessing can be forfeited by profane choice and then never regained, even when sought earnestly with tears.Lt 97, 1896, par. 12–15Lt 87, 1896, par. 15Lt 5, 1877, par. 4–5Lt 23, 1890, par. 6–7Ms 40, 1895, par. 6 The day of privilege and opportunity passes as surely for one who keeps choosing pleasure and harmful company over God's claims as it did for Esau.Lt 97, 1896, par. 12–15Lt 87, 1896, par. 15Lt 5, 1877, par. 4–5 The same end comes to those who persist in resisting God's appointed work, who continue in sin after refusing Christ's words because confession seems to lower dignity and who grow ever more vulnerable to deception, who keep a divided heart with idols where God does not reign supreme and take on entangling obligations such as a marriage that draws away from God's work, or who delay with murmuring, faultfinding, and a perverted religious life that leads others away until repentance is forever too late.Lt 87, 1896, par. 15Lt 5, 1877, par. 4–5Lt 87, 1905, par. 9–10Lt 23, 1890, par. 6–7Ms 40, 1895, par. 6
In its context the warning calls professed children of God to come very close to Him and to carry Christ's spirit and teachings into everyday life.Ms 4, 1885, par. 119MR 177.1–2Lt 179c, 1905, par. 9–11 They are to look critically at themselves and compare character with the only standard of righteousness, to lift up drooping hands and feeble knees, and to make straight paths for the feet so the lame is healed rather than turned out of the way.Ms 4, 1885, par. 119MR 177.1–2Lt 35, 1898, par. 20–21Lt 179c, 1905, par. 9–11 They are to follow peace with all and holiness without which no one shall see the Lord, and to look diligently lest any fail of the grace of God and lest any root of bitterness spring up to trouble and defile many.Ms 4, 1885, par. 119MR 177.1–2Lt 35, 1898, par. 20–21Lt 179c, 1905, par. 9–11
The warning applies to every church member who claims to be a Sabbath-keeping Adventist and to believe the truth yet continues in sin and will not give up lustful practices.19MR 177.1–2Lt 35, 1898, par. 20–21 Continuing under Satan's deceiving sophistry until sin is no longer discerned as sinful leaves conscience defiled, heart corrupted, and thoughts continually corrupt.19MR 177.1–2Lt 35, 1898, par. 20–21 Such a course counterworks God's work and leads others into sin, making such ones decoys luring souls into unclean practices that defile the whole being.19MR 177.1–2Lt 35, 1898, par. 20–21 Bitterness and conduct contrary to Bible principles can thus turn people from God and leave them outside His family unless converted.Lt 97, 1896, par. 12–15
Trading the heavenly and eternal inheritance for temporary gain is done when truth is deliberately sacrificed for worldly advantage, for a treasure that will perish cannot compensate for the loss of eternal life.2T 37.3–38.2Lt 48, 1897, par. 27–30 It is done when self-indulgence and worldly pleasure seem more desirable, and when obtaining an education absorbs the mind so prayer and religious privileges are neglected and knowledge increases self-love and excuse from responsibility.2T 37.3–38.23T 223.1–2Lt 7, 1900, par. 13–22 Knowledge is of value only when sought from principle to do good, promote God's glory, and bless others by useful faculties, and when books are loved and idolized so as to come between duty and the soul and produce reluctance to leave study for essential labor, desire for study must be restrained and love for neglected practical duties cultivated.3T 223.1–2 A reckless spirit sells the soul for selfish indulgence when professing Christians join worldly demonstrations and zealously advocate opposing worldly policies with enthusiasm God's Spirit has not inspired, even publishing political preferences and speaking them when people assemble to hear the word of the Lord, leaving unbelievers unfavorably impressed toward the faith.Lt 4, 1898, par. 9–10
Those who trade their inheritance in heaven for selfish pleasure, appetite, and hurtful lusts will find in the day of God and the final conflict that repentance comes too late to remedy the choice.SG3 116.1–117.11SP 108.1–2ST Apr 24, 1879 The verse therefore sounds now as the clear ringing note of the third angel's message urging work for God and honoring His name.Lt 179c, 1905, par. 9–11 When heart-searchingly preached it gives freedom in preaching and by the Holy Spirit softens and subdues hearts, moves backsliders who are unhappy and troubled to wish to return, and moves hearers to stand for prayer and testify with gratitude for light and blessing.Ms 27, 1885, par. 19–20
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
79 sources
Esau sold his birthright for a single meal to gratify appetite and afterward could not get it back, for what he sought with tears was a change in his father’s decision and the blessing itself, not true repentance toward God.ST Jul 7, 1914RH Sep 17, 1857ST Feb 23, 1915ST Mar 30, 1888ST Feb 23, 1915 His bitter grief was sorrow over losing what he had despised and over its consequences, not godly sorrow for the sin, for he let decades pass without seeking reconciliation with God while still cherishing hatred.ST Apr 19, 1877ST Jun 14, 1910RH Jun 10, 1902ST Jun 14, 1910ST May 20, 1889 Once the opportunity had passed, even earnest and diligent tearful pleading could not undo the settled transfer or restore what was lost.RH May 15, 1866ST Jul 13, 1882ST Sep 22, 1898ST Feb 19, 1894RH May 15, 1866 God gives light and opportunity to repent and promises mercy to the penitent, but He does not promise another opportunity to the negligent, so the warning is not to delay turning to God lest the day of grace close.RH Apr 1, 1858RH Apr 1, 1858ST Jul 13, 1882RH Mar 19, 1901 Persisted-in sin and cherished bitterness can sear the conscience and harden the heart until sincere repentance becomes impossible, proving that those in the light must hold fast, grow, and follow peace and holiness.RH Mar 20, 1879ST Jan 24, 1900RH Sep 26, 1854ST Apr 17, 1907RH Aug 27, 1901
Esau's Story and Wording
The “it” sought carefully with tears was the father’s blessing and a change in the father’s purpose, not repentance itself. RH Sep 17, 1857ST Feb 23, 1915ST Feb 23, 1915 No place of repentance means no opportunity to bring about a change of mind in the father, not that Esau himself was barred from seeking God’s favor through repentance. RH Sep 17, 1857ST Feb 23, 1915ST Feb 23, 1915ST Jun 14, 1910 What could not be recovered was the birthright he had sold, while his tears were grief over the consequences of his sin rather than conviction of sin or desire to be reconciled to God. ST Feb 23, 1915ST Jun 14, 1910
The word rendered repentance denotes the inward change of mind or purpose meant by the Greek metanoia. RH Apr 28, 1874 To render it as outward penance, as if he found no place to do penance, is wrong. RH Apr 28, 1874
The birthright he disposed of was Heaven’s covenant favor, God’s covenant with Abraham and Isaac of the possession of the land of Canaan to them and their posterity and of the heavenly inheritance of which Canaan was the earnest and representation. ST Mar 31, 1881 This he understood and saw but despised with an infidel heart. ST Mar 31, 1881 He judged the valleys, Zion, Lebanon, and the possession of Canaan a worthless toy beside a mess of pottage, and renounced a benignant providence here and a heavenly paradise hereafter for the gratification of an hour. ST Mar 31, 1881
He was a passionate man with commendable traits who did not control himself and was determined to have what he wanted at any cost until he lost all reason and could see only the desire of a passionate heart. RH Aug 27, 1901 When faint and weary from hunting he begged for the red lentil pottage, reasoning that being at the point to die the birthright would profit him nothing. ST Mar 31, 1881RH Aug 27, 1901 Counting at that moment nothing of the worth of character, friends, or prospects, and feigning himself ready to die with hunger, he covenanted away all that was truly valuable on earth to gratify gluttony and appetite for one dinner, even if it meant starving in perdition forever as its penalty. ST Mar 31, 1881RH Aug 27, 1901
After deliberately selling his birthright for food and despising it, he afterward desired to inherit the blessing attached to it and still expected to inherit it when he came to claim it. ST Mar 30, 1888RH Apr 14, 1859ST Mar 31, 1881RH Jun 10, 1902 After Isaac’s words, when Jacob had received the blessing, he cried bitterly and pleaded for his father’s blessing. ST Jul 7, 1914ST Sep 22, 1898 He was rejected when he later sought the blessing he had forfeited, though he sought it earnestly and with tears and searched for it carefully. ST Jul 7, 1914ST Mar 30, 1888ST Feb 23, 1915RH Jun 10, 1902 He could not recover what he had deliberately sold or undo the settled transfer of the blessing and birthright to another, and found no opportunity to change or reverse that outcome and transaction. ST Jul 7, 1914ST Mar 30, 1888RH Apr 14, 1859ST Mar 31, 1881
His rejection concerned the consequence of his own voluntary sale of the birthright, not an arbitrary exclusion from salvation. ST Sep 22, 1898 Jacob’s fraud did not deprive him of the privilege of seeking God’s blessing. ST Sep 22, 1898 God’s grace through Christ is free to all, men turn from God and not God from them, and God hated Esau only in the sense that He hates sin. ST Sep 22, 1898
Tears Without True Repentance
Esau’s tears were grief over the consequences of his sin and over losing the blessing as a personal possession, not conviction of sin itself or desire to be reconciled to God.ST Apr 19, 1877ST Jun 14, 1910RH Jun 10, 1902 He had more than forty years in which he might have repented of despising his birthright and the spiritual blessings bound up with it, but he let the opportunity pass and did not turn in godly sorrow that leads to repentance and eternal life.ST Apr 19, 1877RH Jun 10, 1902 Even while weeping over the unexpected loss after the blessing had gone to another, he still cherished hatred for his brother.ST Jun 14, 1910ST Jun 14, 1910 That continued cherishing of hatred, with wilful sin occupying the heart, is why he found no place for true repentance.ST Jun 14, 1910ST Jun 14, 1910
Being deeply stirred in the affections, being much affected in prayer, and praying with feeling and even with tears is no true mark of Christianity and does not by itself secure God’s favor.RH Nov 4, 1858RH Mar 12, 1914 A person may be moved by his own performance in duty, by good thoughts passing through the mind and good words passing through the lips, and by good impulses stirring in the heart that vanish like sparks flying from a chimney, and may pray and even prevail in prayer, yet still be only almost a Christian.RH Nov 4, 1858 Tears shed for effect may deceive men, but they do not deceive God, who knows the thoughts and intents of the heart.RH Mar 12, 1914
Sorrow caused only by fear of punishment is not the godly sorrow that leads to lasting repentance and salvation, and those who know only that kind of sorrow may afterward long for true repentance when it is too late.ST May 20, 1889 Repentance itself is a gift from God as spiritual sorrow for sin, which a willingly carnal heart opposed to God’s law cannot produce because it treats God’s gifts lightly.ST May 7, 1894 True sorrow for having sinned against God shows that a person has not passed beyond the reach of grace, whereas sorrow only over consequences or over being found out is not true repentance.ST Sep 8, 1909 A heart that repeatedly shuts God out and yields to sin can become hardened and lose the ability to hear the Spirit, so one who is unsure whether repentance is sincere should keep trusting God.ST Sep 8, 1909
Irreversible Loss and Urgency
After the opportunity had passed, bitter regret and diligent seeking with tears and earnest pleas could not undo the loss, change the settled outcome, or recover the blessing that had been despised for immediate appetite or other desire.RH May 15, 1866ST Feb 19, 1894RH May 15, 1866 Tears could not reverse the settled transfer or restore what had been forfeited by selling the birthright for food.RH May 15, 1866ST Feb 19, 1894RH May 15, 1866 Later regret and tears cannot change a past choice or undo its lasting record.ST Aug 30, 1877
God gives light and opportunity to repent and promises mercy to the penitent, but He does not promise the negligent another opportunity or the grace to repent.RH Apr 1, 1858RH Apr 1, 1858RH Jan 8, 1857 Esau sought the inheritance after the opportunity had passed and it could no longer avail, even when sought earnestly with tears.RH Apr 1, 1858RH Apr 1, 1858RH May 19, 1874 His case warns that a person in a downward course can reach a point where turning back is no longer possible, so the Lord must be sought while He may be found and sinners must not delay turning to God lest the day of grace close and repentance become too late.RH Apr 1, 1858RH Jan 8, 1857RH Apr 16, 1867 When the time for judgment arrives, those who have not sincerely repented may find no opportunity to repent and their tears will be in vain, so the present time must be used to repent and prepare for the day of the Lord.RH Apr 16, 1867
The example warns that there is a limit to forbearance with abuse of gifts and grace beyond which it is fatal to go, for Esau despised and foolishly bartered away the blessing and afterward even earnest tearful seeking could not recover it or inherit it.ST Jul 13, 1882
His suffering was not a special judgment like the Flood or the fire on Sodom, but the legitimate natural result of his own conduct, as certain as a law of nature.ST Mar 31, 1881 Whoever chooses present sensual gratification regardless of future good will find pain, remorse, wretchedness in life, bitterness in death, and inevitable ruin, and no regrets, cries, or tears can restore the heavenly peace of innocence and virtue.ST Mar 31, 1881 Habits of sin grow with growth and strengthen with strength until bound by chains of lust that drag downward to eternal death, so the transgressor seeks in vain for the penalty to be abated while still pursuing the lusts of the heart.ST Mar 31, 1881 Neither in the eternal world will such a one find any opportunity for repentance or change in God, even if sought with tears, piteous groans, or howlings, any more than the rich man in torment could obtain a drop of water.ST Mar 31, 1881
Repentance cannot always reverse consequences in this life.STRH Nov 7, 1865RH Sep 2, 1909 A misspent day can never be had again even if sought carefully with tears, for loss by neglect is final and without remedy, so the work given must be done now with no moment spared for idle thoughts or self-indulgent ease lest at set of sun one looks back too late to find the work undone.RH Sep 2, 1909 Wasted benefits such as sleep may later be regretted even with tears but cannot be recovered, since sleep is a valuable resource for present well-being and future strength.ST Mar 10, 1890 One who carelessly uses power to poison hearts cannot undo what he has done, for anger that stings, jealousy that harms in an hour, cruel pride, and wounding words chill and embitter a tender nature like frost killing flowers, and even when he relents he cannot restore freshness and fragrance to the blossom or sweeten the embittered heart in a lifetime, and his tears do not open a way to reverse the injury.RH Nov 7, 1865 Likewise wives’ and mothers’ tears cannot undo the effects of choosing to marry men given to drink.ST
Unlike that irreversible loss, grace now still offers forgiveness and restoration, for the blessing remains available and every repentant person can receive it through Christ, who shares His inheritance with them, though those who neglect salvation may likewise seek the blessing too late and find no place to repent.RH Apr 14, 1859 A crisis in which repentance is no longer possible is not an isolated event but culminates a course prepared by many earlier choices, since moral defeat follows prior habits and actions, while before a final crisis providence can use even humiliating failure to awaken a person and begin a new life of virtue and happiness.ST Oct 2, 1879
Apostasy Probation and Judgment
Joined to the command to follow peace with all and holiness without which no one will see the Lord and to the warning against falling from grace and being defiled, the verse proves that saints can fall away.RH Mar 20, 1879 Esau selling his birthright for one meal shows how easily the right to eternal glory is sold, and his rejection when he would have inherited the blessing though he sought it hard with tears shows that some go so far back that return becomes impossible despite hardest efforts.RH Mar 20, 1879 Those in the light must therefore walk in it, hold fast, keep growing, and not be deceived that there is no danger of falling.RH Mar 20, 1879
The verse warns that unbelief can cause people to fall short of the promised blessing and rest.RH Aug 5, 1873 Esau's unbelief led him to despise and surrender the blessing, and his tearful grief afterward could not undo that choice or restore what he had lost.RH Aug 5, 1873ST Jul 18, 1900
Tampering with sin can sear the conscience until it no longer feels revulsion toward sin, leading to presumption on mercy and rejection of salvation.ST Jan 24, 1900 One who repeatedly rejects God's appeals may become so hardened that sincere repentance is no longer possible, and like Esau may be terrified at death and cry for mercy without truly repenting.RH Sep 26, 1854 Selling the birthright for gratification of appetite is one of three ways of sinning against the Holy Ghost that many professing to love God will commit now, with the terrible result of being rejected and found unprepared when their cases come up in judgment, so every candidate for the kingdom should be aroused to prepare to meet God and watch with all faithfulness.RH Aug 27, 1901
That way begins with failing to look diligently lest anyone fall from grace and lest a root of bitterness springing up trouble and defile many.RH Aug 27, 1901 Bitterness kept in the heart brings entire separation from God, leading to hasty words, hasty conclusions and thoughtless speech.RH Aug 27, 1901 Esau is the example, a passionate man with commendable traits who did not control himself and was determined to have what he wanted at any cost until he lost all reason and saw only the desire of a passionate heart, begging when faint for the red pottage and covenanting away the birthright to gratify appetite on the reasoning that at the point to die it would profit him nothing.RH Aug 27, 1901 In the same way today people sell their birthright for gratification of appetite or other passionate lust, and this determination to have what pleases the fancy irrespective of what the Lord says seals doom.RH Aug 27, 1901
Repentance is necessary for forgiveness and salvation, and those who do not repent perish in their sins.RH Dec 10, 1867 Esau's example illustrates the final loss that follows rejecting God's work and grieving the Holy Spirit beyond recovery, where pardon cannot be obtained even when one later becomes alarmed and weeps.ST Jan 10, 1878 Those who despise mercy and choose present ease and guilty pleasures may later grieve and repent when it is too late, and then will have no hope and their sorrow will not restore what they rejected.RH Feb 9, 1869
Like Esau, those who trade their spiritual inheritance for what displeases God and choose what they want now will be let to have their choice, and afterward regret will not restore what was surrendered.RH Dec 2, 1862 The lukewarm must therefore be delivered lest they share his fate.RH Feb 25, 1858 The verse illustrates the two ways men fail to repent: because they will not now, and because they can no longer when mercy has ended and wrath is poured out.ST Oct 13, 1881 Under the darkness of the fifth plague the wicked have no disposition to repent, and seeking then finds no place of repentance.RH Mar 19, 1901 After probation closes the wicked likewise have no desire or heart for true repentance, having bartered the birthright for worldly desires and separated themselves from God and rejected His means of salvation.ST Apr 17, 1907
Those neglecting preparation now may find repentance unavailable in the time of trouble and latter rain and should not expect a special warning at the last moment.RH Jun 16, 1868 Saul's downfall beginning with disobedience led to too-late repentance with no space like Esau, though sought earnestly and with tears.ST Jul 13, 1904 In the day of God, sinners who trade their inheritance in heaven for selfish pleasure and harmful appetites will find no opportunity to repent and recover it.ST Apr 24, 1879 The Christless sinner whose voluntary rejection of Christ fixes his doom will likewise find the blessing cannot be regained and will be left excluded from the redeemed and their everlasting life.
Present-Day Warnings and Parallels
The history is a warning not to be a sexually immoral or profane person like Esau, who for one mess of meat sold his own birthright and despised it by treating the bargain lightly to satisfy present hunger.ST Feb 19, 1894 Afterward when he desired to inherit the blessing he was rejected and found no place of repentance though he sought it diligently with tears.ST Feb 19, 1894 Life is more than food and the body more than clothing, and no one is profited if he gains the whole world and forfeits his life, having nothing to give in exchange for it.ST Feb 19, 1894
The verse stands in the Father's admonition in Hebrews 12, where every son He receives is chastened and scourged because He loves him. That correction is to be gladly allowed to do its work to smooth the rough places and prepare the way of the Lord in the heart. Overcoming requires enduring that chastisement in which all legitimate children share.ST Apr 10, 1893 It is a refining and purifying process like holding metal over fire until the dross is burned out and the Saviour's likeness appears in character, and like pruning fruitful branches so they bring forth more fruit, however severe its operations may be.ST Apr 10, 1893
Sacrificing a splendid heritage of lofty ideals for temporary questionable enjoyment brings permanent loss that bitter tears afterward cannot avail to undo.ST Nov 19, 1902 Choosing present comfort over future good can leave no opportunity afterward to recover what was surrendered, and careless souls who expect everlasting life while refusing needed sacrifice may likewise find it too late.RH Nov 19, 1857 Because he left himself no opportunity to turn back and regain what he had sold, Esau illustrates that one who persistently rejects God's mercy can by that choice reach a point where salvation is no longer possible.RH Jun 5, 1900
After surrendering their birthright, a people driven to desperate action by terror may seek the blessing with tears and still find no place for repentance.RH Nov 24, 1859 That warns the church that awakening too late cannot undo the consequences of silence and support of slavery.RH Nov 24, 1859 Likewise fear of impending trouble can make people lose sight of the value of heavenly things and yield their ground as Esau did.RH Apr 21, 1903
The danger of surrendering the birthright for food applies to appetite now, and health reform helps in remaining faithful rather than yielding. The warning is linked with Israel's journey toward the promised land, with Caleb and Joshua as examples of those who entered it. Spending money on tobacco and persisting in its harmful use sells interest in the kingdom for even less than a meal, and religious professors who persist should not expect to enter God's kingdom.RH Aug 25, 1859 Like Esau trading a precious inheritance for immediate gratification, people today may surrender the kingdom of heaven along with health, hope, peace and goodness for wine, food, passion, pride or money.ST Dec 24, 1894
People may likewise treat the birthright and the heavenly inheritance it represents as worth less than a meal and trade eternal joy for temporary worldly security.ST Oct 21, 1886 Giving up Sabbath-keeping to protect a business treats the heavenly inheritance as less valuable than earthly concerns.ST Oct 21, 1886 Refusing a duty because obedience may threaten livelihood puts self-interest above God's service and risks completing that exchange and finding it too late to repent.ST Mar 30, 1888 A person can treat the birthright of God's children as worthless and forfeit it for any cherished earthly desire, and like Esau may later long for the blessing without undoing the choice.ST Dec 9, 1880
Esau's profaneness was violation of the third commandment which he knew, and by it he lost his life.ST May 9, 1906 Adam's disobedience which sold himself and his descendants into bondage is compared to Esau's sale for a meal.ST Sep 24, 1894 In every age worldliness and selfishness lead people to reject what is spiritually valuable, warnings do not reach hearts ruled by those desires, and the example is followed by those who count themselves wise in worldly matters.ST Feb 14, 1884 Selling the birthright for the things by which men are seduced from God is a fool's bargain, for Satan never fulfills his pledges while making men fulfill all of theirs, and the goods when delivered prove mean, cheap and vain, not worth taking even as a gift much less in exchange for the blessing, bringing sorrow and years of disobedience and ending with the sinner cheated and fooled.RH Jun 18, 1872
Esau's bargain is repeated wherever birthrights of eternal tracts and golden mansions in the Celestial City are sold for innumerable messes of pottage piping hot and momentary gratification at very disadvantageous rates.RH Jul 24, 1855 It trades lasting and permanent value for a few years' lease of small dismal inconvenient tenements, and whoever parts with the only thing of permanent value is sure to be a loser in the long run, like one who lays out a splendid fortune for diseases and spends all the rest for a heavy lot of repentance and a suit of rags.RH Jul 24, 1855 Youth repeat it little by little by grieving the Holy Spirit and bartering away conscience for the fashions and pleasures of this life till the world has so strong a hold that they never break away.RH Jul 22, 1873 The same is seen where one gives up a meeting expected to bring blessing in order to earn a fashionable hat and then grieves over the decision like Esau.ST Jul 4, 1878 The seller of a precious birthright for passing earthly reward who later grieves over lost heavenly hope may yet seek pardon and receive rest from Christ.ST Aug 26, 1889
The language of careful tearful seeking pictures the earnestness needed to find God's law written in the heart.RH Nov 1, 1853 The seventh-day Sabbath command is written there as part of the same moral law once written on stone and now written by the Spirit, and though hidden beneath spiritual rubbish it will be found when that is removed.RH Nov 1, 1853 A lost soul may seek repentance too late, and the devil who distracts believers from reverent worship will one day jeer over such belated repentance.ST May 6, 1875 Those not drawn by divine mercy into the gospel's faith and love, like Esau who though he sought the blessing with tears had no place of repentance afterward, are not restored to the covenant people, for the New Covenant belongs to those brought under God's law of love and confidence.RH May 29, 1855
Sources