John 18:36
Jesus answered, My kingdom is not of this world: if my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight, that I should not be delivered to the Jews: but now is my kingdom not from hence.
Jesus answered, My kingdom is not of this world: if my kingdom were of this world, then would my servants fight, that I should not be delivered to the Jews: but now is my kingdom not from hence.
Commentary part 3 of 3
Pioneers and periodicals (continued)
Demands for Sunday legislation and making and enforcing Sabbath laws and other observances attempt to make the kingdom of this world and subvert good government and genuine experience; civil law should leave men free to accept or reject religion and protect each in choice or refusal as far as others' equal rights are regarded.RH Dec 12, 1907 The state has no duty to enforce Sunday observance; control of conscience, faith and religion belongs to God alone, civil government has no right to control conscience, and when in face of light it sets itself against God or acts in God's place by compelling conscience it departs from law of its life, its fall is certain and days numbered as with Babylon, Medo-Persia, Greece and Rome, with yielding to Sunday laws leading to yielding again unto death of government.ST Feb 22, 1910 When religion and government are united, religious work outside the dominant religion can be punished as disturbance of religious peace, as seen when Sunday observers object to people quietly keeping the seventh day.RH Sep 7, 1911
The kingdom contrasts with human authority being elevated through Sunday laws while divine law is treated as less important.ST Oct 28, 1889 The religion of Jesus is meek and humble, never aspiring to earthly dominion nor seeking aid from civil power; temporal sovereignty is brittle reed and crown of thorns, true religion relies on its own excellencies and spurns human legislation, so laws such as prohibiting mail transport on the first day because God set it apart corrupt religion into intolerant superstition and endanger citizens' rights, with bigotry armed with temporal power as liberty's deadliest foe.RH May 11, 1911 Apostolic Christianity sought civil protection for rights but did not appeal to civil law to enforce Christian duties; when denied rights Christians accepted persecution rather than compel faith, so Sunday legislation and union of church and state do not arise from the Christianity he described.ST Nov 25, 1886
It was acted on by framers of the Constitution in creating civil government without religious tests that guaranteed equal rights regardless of religious profession; giving religion state favor or making profession condition of office turns faith into political advantage and threatens individual rights.RH Sep 23, 1909 Opposing religious laws allying religion with government can guard pure religion rather than show hostility to it. The kingdom does not depend on civil or state power; its weapons are spiritual, working on human judgment and heart, and Christianity can prevail by its own excellence under God's providence where religious liberty remains.ST Jun 18, 1912
Christians must rely on Christ for protection and support, not use government influence to make people believe, because earthly power hinders rather than supports Christianity, and true Christianity does not persecute but relies on the Lord alone, who is sufficient, and is not upheld by civil power.ST Sep 19, 1900ST Feb 28, 1906 Its religion relies on power of truth, not force imposed by religious majority, and its truths and principles change the heart, and where received people do not seek laws binding others' consciences; when churches lose Christ's Spirit they may turn to political power to enforce beliefs and restrict religious liberty.ST Feb 12, 1885ST Dec 1, 1881 Preaching Christ does not mean regulating or reforming civil governments; ministers are to preach Christ crucified and invite individuals to be reconciled to God, not compel civil or religious duties.ST Jun 13, 1906ST Feb 27, 1896
The kingdom is not expanded through civil laws, political agitation, or appeals to rulers; its messengers preach the gospel and heal the sick, calling people to enter.ST Oct 4, 1899 At trial he was not convicted of interfering with Rome, and he allowed that government to put him to death though he had power in heaven and on earth.ST Oct 4, 1899 The kingdom and its laws are carried forward through gospel and love, not by civil law or compelled outward observance; enforcing Christian institutions by law is counterfeit, and even efforts called for Christ using political means are not his method for he had no connection with politics.ST Mar 20, 1893ST Nov 29, 1910 Christianity cannot be made into government or enforced by human law without losing living power; it is individual life and relationship with Jesus Christ concerning the individual soul, not gaining earthly control for the church.ST Jun 17, 1897ST Mar 27, 1901
People are brought into the kingdom through faith and God's Spirit in individual hearts and the gospel transforming lives, not by making government or its laws religious; Christianity's power is God's power and can progress even under tyrannical rulers, while governments cannot produce righteousness and constitutional changes or religious laws cannot gradually absorb nations into the kingdom.ST Jan 20, 1904ST Aug 15, 1916 God's kingdom is present in the earth but does not originate in the world; the world is to be changed through people renewed by the gospel, not through laws and ordinances.ST Mar 11, 1913 Worldly agencies may serve civil government but have no place in advancing Christianity; loyalty to heaven can therefore bring persecution from those enforcing observance by civil law.RH Jun 29, 1905
Those made new creation do not try to force men to be religious and do not enforce a spurious sabbath by civil law.ST Aug 8, 1906ST Aug 8, 1906 Political action can produce only professed loyalty to Christ, not genuine allegiance, and even loud profession may be hypocritical.ST Dec 11, 1893 The kingdom does not depend on worldly favor, wealth or support; the church's pursuit of patronage and alliances with worldly interests conflicts with its character, and worldly approval signals it has lowered standard and lost the Saviour's image.RH Sep 22, 1859ST Mar 19, 1885
The kingdom is not advanced by worldly fundraising methods such as church fairs, gambling-like attractions, appetite, and entertainment; its resources belong to ecclesiastical economy for which Christians should organize means rather than depend on occasional appeals.RH Apr 14, 1859RH Oct 10, 1871 The religious system of Christ is not ruled by internal and external politics, factional strife, vetoes of monarchies, or balancing alliances to choose a leader, in contrast to such political procedures.RH Jul 14, 1903 Armed priests engaging in political conflict contradict the character of his representatives and reveal harmful results of uniting church and state.RH May 9, 1907
The verse does not require Christians to abstain from all voting when good and evil measures are mixed; voting straight prohibition is permitted, but voting for Sabbath or Sunday legislation is wholly evil. Christians cannot bring the kingdom by voting, seeking political rule, capturing rulers or government, campaigning for candidates, or binding themselves to political party; they may express judgment at the polls when duty calls without party belonging, but work is to save people one by one through the gospel, not to seek influence over kings and courts.ST Sep 28, 1882ST Jan 30, 1912ST Nov 12, 1894RH Nov 5, 1908RH Jan 7, 1902 The kingdom does not rise and fall with parties, cannot be voted from the throne and back, and cannot be established by amending the constitution to acknowledge Christ as governor; to do so puts man on the throne as vicegerent, makes the Bible a state-enforced civil code, creates an American papacy, and raises whose interpretation becomes law and what is done with dissenters.RH Nov 16, 1911
The kingdom is not established by violent struggles of governments or by acknowledging God in constitutions; such turmoil cannot mean nations are being prepared to enthrone Christ.ST Dec 17, 1902 His kingdom will not be established as kingship over nations by human action or by national confession of him as King in the Constitution; when pressed to establish such rule he refused and rebuked expectation, and that rebuke applies now to the program to enthrone him in national affairs.RH Sep 30, 1909 That human enthronement is what he denies; true enthronement will be done by God the Father himself, who announced the end of theocratic rule by declaring he himself would give rulership of this world to his chosen One.RH Sep 30, 1909
Earthly nations do not follow Christ's principles and are not accepted as his kingdom; Christians may live under them but they are not Christian, and God saves people out of nations to make them subjects of the everlasting kingdom where only Christians dwell.ST Jun 5, 1901 Christ has allied himself with no earthly government and no nation is Christian in any sense; so-called Christian nations are tried by his teaching and life like heathen nations, and the unregenerate in them need regeneration as truly as any heathen.ST Sep 18, 1901 True Christianity never enters politics to gain control; any religion seeking political power is not Christ's, those entering politics on that basis add to corruption, no human government will ever be made righteous, and no world kingdom can become Christ's except to be destroyed by him.ST Oct 19, 1904
A nation whose servants fight belongs to this world and cannot be a Christian nation, for Jesus would not fight and did not allow servants to fight even to defend him.ST Nov 19, 1894 A nation cannot become Christ's nation by making Christianity its official political identity; his kingdom will come when he breaks earthly kingdoms with a rod of iron, scatters them, and brings last-day judgment by fire.RH Dec 10, 1908 The kingdom's nature is honored by keeping church and state separate and protecting worship according to conscience; seeking civil power to enforce religion turns from Christ and encourages religious tyranny.ST Oct 8, 1896
Christ did not appeal to secular authority to enforce reforming work but provided the Holy Spirit as higher power for carrying it forward until return.ST Jun 13, 1906 The keynote of Christ's ministry is adjusting relations with God not readjusting material conditions; seeking legislation to compel men by civil law to adjust relations with God forces rendering to Caesar things belonging to God, and seeking to secure philanthropic and church work through civil laws and gathering religious and political forces under one dominion is opposed to its principles.RH Jan 1, 1914 When the church takes up political aims and makes civic righteousness and national civilization central, it makes God's kingdom appear wholly worldly, leaving only trace of religious sentiment and displacing true gospel.ST Feb 22, 1905ST Dec 11, 1901
Its citizens do not advance it through political power or coercion, and its heavenly character must not be set aside for union of religion and politics.ST Sep 2, 1897 True Israel is never reckoned among nations and never identifies or unites as body with worldly kingdoms except as individual citizens living under them; whatever unites with earthly kingdoms is not Israel even under the name, while true people are delivered from darkness into the kingdom of God's Son as a kingdom of priests standing by obedience between God and rebels to persuade return.ST Dec 8, 1914 Its subjects are never confined to one human government and no human government will ever consist entirely of them; they are taken from every nation, kindred, tongue and people by the everlasting gospel not government decrees, as spiritual seed who are Christ's to be heirs of the world with Abraham, marked by keeping God's commandments and Jesus' faith in deed and truth, and like Christ not of the world.ST Mar 11, 1903
His mission was to free men in this world's kingdoms and save them out of them to enter the eternal world's kingdom, incidentally teaching conduct toward fellows by doing unto others as we would have them do, the principle of gospel liberty at work.ST Jul 6, 1904 Christ turned his back forever on worldly kingdoms, so the Chinese revolution was not giving China's politics to Christ, but it was victory for the coming King of kings in removing difficulties and opening doors for the gospel.RH Jul 11, 1912
Heavenly Citizenship and Mission
His disciples are chosen out of the world and are not of the world even as he is not of the world, so the world remains ever the world and hates them, and God has never promised to convert the world. Christians are kings whose kingdom is heavenly and not of this world, with incorruptible eternal crowns and an undefiled inheritance that never fades away.RH Aug 18, 1863 In this world they pass onward toward that glorious possession through ruin, dangers, temptations, injuries, losses and great tribulations, while powerful, subtle, unceasingly vigilant enemies throng the path to beat them back, spoil them of heavenly honors, hinder full attainment and compass complete perdition.RH Aug 18, 1863
Christian citizenship is heavenly, belonging to heaven and sharing nothing with this world's sins, crimes, vanities and follies.RH Mar 7, 1912ST Sep 1, 1898 Believers dwelling here are only sojourners in a foreign land who must renounce allegiance to this world, since as no man can be citizen of two earthly countries at once, no one can hold citizenship in this world and in Christ's kingdom at once, with allegiance and affection centered in one government to the exclusion of the other.ST Sep 1, 1898 Christianity is a matter of conscience and heart shaped by the Holy Spirit, not produced by civil laws, penalties or coercion, though its call to love neighbors can benefit earthly citizenship without its promised outcome depending on civil government or belonging to its administration.RH Mar 7, 1912
The lack of fighting explains why he was delivered up without an outbreak or resistance by servants, for if his kingdom were worldly his servants would have fought to keep him from being handed over to the Jews.ST May 6, 1897 These same words should express the outlook of his followers today.ST Jul 29, 1897 As pilgrims and strangers they look toward the heavenly home he prepares and await the time when kingdom and dominion under heaven are given to the saints, and therefore need not take part in the nation's political contests.RH Jul 10, 1856
As pilgrims and strangers followers belong to a heavenly government rather than making worldly politics their defining work, and they can help communities by living the Christ life, since political involvement does not strengthen the church and can undermine Christian character.ST May 10, 1905 God's people may be citizens of earthly nations but also belong to heaven's kingdom with duty to serve it, and its work is a spiritual campaign to win people from Satan to Christ in which every believer is called to take part.RH Aug 20, 1914 The affairs of government that Christians have to do with belong to God's kingdom, not to the kingdoms of this world.RH Feb 20, 1900
Followers therefore do not strive primarily to build an earthly kingdom, though they may influence earthly life for good, and they obey civil laws unless those laws conflict with obedience to God, for the salvation he brings is for people not governments. His kingdom is distinct from earthly political rule, not established or maintained by force, contention, oppression or the sword, but characterized by love with witness to truth, unlike Caesar's kingdom maintained by force, so his subjects can live within civil governments and be a blessing to them without seeking Caesar's throne.ST Jun 18, 1912 Fidelity to him instead separates disciples from the world and brings its scorn and rejection, rather than winning the world by pleasing it or adapting the church to its tastes, and disciples chosen out of the world are not to share its aims and motives because its spirit is opposed to God.ST Nov 4, 1889ST Oct 20, 1909
His silent, unresisting conduct at trial displayed the kingdom's character, and his invitation never compelled anyone, for the kingdom remains a kingdom of love in which subjects can live within and bless even oppressive civil governments.ST Jun 18, 1912 His kingdom exists in the world but does not derive authority from earthly rule, for he alone is King and no earthly ruler governs its subjects in its matters.ST May 22, 1901 Its citizens obey civil laws and customs when they do not conflict with God's higher law or conscience, but may judge those laws and refuse obedience when conscience requires even under persecution, serving civil authority from conscience toward God not from fear of rulers.ST May 22, 1901
Its principles are planted in hearts of subjects rather than established through earthly political power, and subjects remain loyal even when they conflict with perverted principles of earthly governments, so that when civil governments stay within proper authority there need be no conflict, but the two must remain distinct and separate.ST Jul 29, 1897 Servants remain separate from worldly political power, and duties owed to God are distinct from those owed to Caesar and are not rendered to God through civil government.ST Sep 12, 1895 Followers belong to the heavenly kingdom and give highest allegiance to their absent King, and though they obey righteous earthly laws and use things of the world in his service, they do not seek worldly power or position or take part in political parties and corrupt practices.ST Jul 15, 1889
Christians and the church belong to a different kingdom from this world's kingdoms and should represent him to the world rather than stand on the world's plane. His followers are likewise not of the world and do not establish God's kingdom through human government or coercive law, since his kingdom does not originate in or operate like earthly kingdoms.ST Aug 29, 1895 The church is in the world but not to be of it, called not to seek dominion or authority over people but to serve, lift the fallen and give, and when it took imperial power through union with the state it departed from his servant spirit.ST Jul 18, 1900 Any claim to lordship over earthly kingdoms in both spiritual and temporal affairs is contrary to him and marks antichrist.RH Nov 29, 1870
Greatness in the kingdom comes through humbleness and service not ruling as the world rules, and leadership is service and example, for servants are called to serve not seek political rule, with the kingdom advanced through spiritual power and means not political schemes or force.ST Jan 14, 1889ST Jul 3, 1907 Officers are forbidden to condemn or discipline those outside and to lord over faith of those inside, being called instead to be helpers of joy and examples to the flock.ST Jul 3, 1907ST He came not to judge the world or destroy lives but to save them, leaving judgment to his spoken word in the last day, so disciples must not execute judgment on those who reject him.ST Jul 3, 1907ST
Men are to be besought and persuaded not compelled or coerced, for weapons are not carnal but mighty through God to cast down imaginations and every high thing against knowledge of God and bring every thought into captivity to obedience of Christ, with armor forged by God to rule inward thought.ST Jul 3, 1907ST May 26, 1898ST Followers follow his steps by doing no sin, reviling not when reviled, threatening not when suffering, but committing themselves to him who judges righteously, and they do not avenge themselves because vengeance belongs to God who will recompense.ST May 26, 1898 Using carnal weapons can gain only temporary deliverance, while leaving the cause with God brings eternal life and victory even out of the grave.ST Jan 30, 1907
Servants do not advance the kingdom by serving earthly nations or compromising with sin, but carry forward his principles to turn sinners toward his character, and though this work may disturb people by confronting sin, this is the gospel's purpose not political agitation.RH Jan 11, 1912 The church's work is to preach the gospel and make individual disciples in every nation as the organized means of gospel work guided by the Holy Spirit, not to prescribe national policies or establish universal political rule, and individuals can receive the gospel without disloyalty to civil authority so long as civil and divine authority are not confused.ST Jul 29, 1897 Its establishment is the final act in the drama of nations, not by earthly nations or sword, and Christians serve as heaven's citizens carrying the message through missionary work rather than political power or force.ST Jan 20, 1909
The church belongs to this spiritual kingdom and serves eternal welfare not civil government's sphere, bringing redemption and pointing toward a coming world free from sin, and it cannot use civil power to bestow righteousness that comes through faith.ST Jun 23, 1914 The kingdom is established within people's hearts where the church leads them to God, and civil government cannot establish it by imposing moral laws, nor after Israel's theocracy ended could any true theocracy be established until he returns and receives the kingdom rightfully his.RH Apr 3, 1913 Followers are not to cling to worldly aims or let material things take first place but give themselves to him putting spiritual things first and seeking honor from above, for love of the world conflicts with his claims and brings no rest, while separation brings open conflict with his enemy with assurance of victory and peace.RH Sep 17, 1903
Born from above as citizens of heaven and strangers sent to lead to salvation, followers cannot blend worldly politics with eternal truth and righteousness, and true Christian citizenship is governed by eternal righteousness not worldly politics or expediency, with Christian loyalty belonging to his kingdom not to any nation.ST Jul 15, 1897ST Jul 25, 1911ST Sep 2, 1897 The verse is reason the church must remain distinct from the world rather than win favor by accommodating worldly tastes.ST Apr 2, 1894 It also shows Christianity cannot be reconciled with religions denying him as only Saviour, since joining them in unity would require compromising faith and ceasing to be Christians.ST Nov 6, 1893
The kingdom belongs to the poor in spirit through meekness, not to pomp, high standing, political ambition, wealth, honors, or the righteousness and religious position of scribes and Pharisees, and true Christianity involves no political ambitions or pursuit of worldly honors.ST Jul 26, 1883ST May 1, 1901 His mission was to restore obedience to God's law and bring healing and relief, caring for distressed, hungry and burdened and giving comfort and joy to brokenhearted, not to live for display, wealth or aristocratic comfort.ST Jun 19, 1884 Followers should copy him, reject pomp and parade, and use lives and resources to bless and save others and lead them to happiness and heaven.RH May 26, 1859
Subjects are not promised ease, honor, riches or earthly possessions but are called to conflict with evil, and may endure hardship, imprisonment, torture, death, shame, reproach and the cross, yet his reign keeps them from power of the prince of evil.ST Jul 19, 1883 Because the world's ruler has the upper hand in this world, his people may be despised as fools and criminals without public support, with their advocate being him who came as servant and was crucified, so they must look to the future for consolation.RH Sep 18, 1856 His mission involved humiliation, suffering and death rather than armed resistance, aggressive warfare, avenging John's death or satisfying hopes of worldly power and high place, and followers also face trials and persecution after being taught that shame and the cross awaited him.ST Dec 24, 1894ST Feb 25, 1889
Persecution reminds Christians the kingdom is not worldly and turns them heavenward for consolation, holding fast as pilgrims and strangers and examining faith's foundations closely.RH Jul 8, 1858 The way to the eternal kingdom lies through tribulation and suffering.ST Feb 17, 1888 Turning to arms and battle is leaving the right path and forgetting warfare is not carnal, bringing punishment, for the church has no king but him and must not take direction from worldly politics or call for swords, prisons, treasures and wealth, conquering only through spiritual powers and his reign.ST Sep 30, 1908ST Nov 28, 1900 Like its King its march is from manger to cross and from cross to crown, through suffering before the crown.ST Sep 30, 1908ST Nov 28, 1900
His true people are a little flock whose kingdom is not established or defended by worldly nations and force.ST Nov 23, 1915 Its citizens may live among earthly kingdoms and seek peace with them, but allegiance belongs to a different kingdom whose life is not established by force, since servants do not fight to defend it or secure his rule.ST May 8, 1901 Christians as soldiers of the cross do not fight with earthly weapons in wars of nations, bear arms for civil government, carry swords for self-defense, or use physical warfare even to defend him or themselves, but advance the kingdom through suffering without retaliation, meeting opposition in faith and peace until he falls upon earth's proud nations as a stone cut without hands to break them and fill earth with universal peace on David's throne as King of kings and Lord of lords.ST Jun 23, 1898ST Dec 14, 1904ST Sep 20, 1910
The duty not to bear arms in civil government follows from the kingdom not being worldly and maintained by force.RH Nov 3, 1868 Training young men to be ready to fight a nation's battles prepares them to serve another kingdom not his, for carnal warfare is contrary to following the Prince of Peace even when the Master's life is at stake.ST Feb 27, 1893 Christian faith does not commission believers to destroy secret organizations by force, but to show social character through benevolence and helpfulness, having no part in the battle of Armageddon by wading through blood though war and oppression will bring judgment.ST Feb 26, 1902
Armed with gospel spiritual weapons Christians put aside carnal weapons and remain separate from world governments, leaving the world to enforce laws with weapons and death penalty.RH Aug 14, 1856 They refuse to fight for earthly kingdoms or voluntarily give money to support warfare as conflicting with heavenly citizenship and the commandment not to kill, and they do not avenge themselves because vengeance belongs to God.RH Oct 2, 1900ST May 26, 1898 They have nothing to do with carnal instruments of war and must not fight, for they belong to that unworldly kingdom.RH Mar 7, 1865
Because he and his servants are not of the world they do not fight for kings of the world.RH Dec 16, 1862 Loyalty to him as supreme authority in faith and duty requires refusing carnal weapons in military service including volunteering as a Christian company, for true Christianity is pacific and the world's unity and conversion come only by spiritual weapons, mercy and renewing of the Holy Ghost, never by carnal warfare.ST Jun 9, 1898 He lived his whole life with none of the war spirit and stayed distinctly neutral toward world government, and followers must follow that non-fighting neutrality instead of blindly adhering to customs of time, guided by him alone.ST Jul 14, 1898
No Christian nation, Christian citizenship, Christian politics or Christian warfare with carnal weapons has ever existed or can exist till he comes and reigns over those loyal to his gospel of peace when not one soul will desire a carnal weapon.ST Jun 9, 1898 He would never arm himself, fight, cheer comrades or kill antagonists even in righteous war, so all professed Christians and ministers are tested by that example and must not fight, for war is the world's work for worldly sinners not Christians, and a truly Christian nation would not go to war while going to war proves a nation not Christian.ST Jul 7, 1898 Servants do not advance the kingdom by taking up arms but abstain from worldly strife and killing in war, since war is never justified unless God directly commands it and no such command applies.RH May 26, 1868
Followers must not fight nor justify war by a Christian people even in defense of right, for Old Testament wars cannot make Christian warfare lawful and his non-resistant teaching overrules them, drawing a line between civil and religious matters so that patriotism, political interest, loyalty to earthly institutions and using national strength and alliances to carry the gospel cannot be Christian endeavor. Christians are not to use the sword or presume to execute God's judgments, but their spiritual work is winning souls, resisting sin and building up God's people, since the kingdom is not material and worldly advanced by force.ST Feb 6, 1893 Giving up arms because of this teaching would reflect the spirit of Christianity.ST Apr 3, 1901
Those belonging to his kingdom are not called to mingle in political struggles, hold political offices and issues, join political factions, or depend on voting and elected members to secure reform, while respecting officers and obeying laws that do not conflict with heaven, and following his example of refraining from factions as the pattern.ST Mar 24, 1898ST Sep 1, 1898RH Dec 17, 1901RH Jul 16, 1901 His church must likewise remain separate from politics as his kingdom is separate from earthly political affairs.ST Oct 17, 1900 As soldiers of Christ with citizenship in heaven they cannot consistently unite as Christian citizens for aggressive political action, but following the Captain means enduring hardness and taking no part in enforcing fidelity of law officers by leagues, for no soldier entangles himself with this life's affairs to please him who chose him.ST Aug 25, 1898
He did not allow servants to fight to keep him from persecutors and murderers, and defense of immaculate innocence being the most worthy cause for arms yet forbidden shows Christians must not fight for lesser causes, while fighting to save nations would thwart God's purpose to break them with a rod of iron and dash them like a potter's vessel for sins.RH May 23, 1865 Peter's use of the sword denied his divinity, and Christianity is most powerful when unprotected and relying on God rather than armies, government or other worldly means.ST Jan 24, 1900 Choosing him over Barabbas is choosing righteousness, peace and joy in the Holy Ghost with power from on high over Barabbas's methods of force by taking matters into human hands, reforming government or the arm of flesh.ST Jun 3, 1908
The choice between Barabbas and him is between carnal and spiritual methods, with Barabbas representing an earthly kingdom pursued by taking matters into human hands to overthrow Rome by force rather than waiting for God's time and way, and his kingdom is not ushered in by force even for a worthy cause on reasoning that a little wrong brings a great right.ST Jun 3, 1908 His refusal to retaliate when a Samaritan village rejected him expresses the same principle, for his mission is to save not destroy, so those using compulsion in religion act contrary to his kingdom's spirit.ST Mar 19, 1896 He came to save people from sin not to champion a country, and followers obey governments and laws without becoming partisan supporters, so Christianity unjoined to state power can be a world-wide religion acceptable among all nations.
The church must not turn from saving souls to seeking state power to enforce wishes or solve civic problems, but must carry out the commission he gave.RH Mar 17, 1910 The apostolic church had no living union with the state and used no compulsion or bodily punishment, for union with the world is not union with him.ST Dec 20, 1899 True Christianity lives by his teachings without using civil power to impose religion, and persecution is prevented only when Christian principles are in hearts.ST Feb 4, 1897 Christianity is a life implanting justice within receivers not compelling acceptance of law, promising eternal life in a people whose God is Jehovah their Righteousness with spiritual reign and law of love, and he departs from efforts to make him rule earthly kingdoms.ST Feb 27, 1896
Historical Departures and Counterfeits
When professed Christianity later relied on state power and the sword to advance and defend its cause, it departed from the principle that Christ's kingdom is not established or defended by worldly power, for if it were his servants would have fought to prevent his arrest.ST Mar 5, 1894 To ignore that teaching and make the church act as a political party or adjunct to one has led to persecution and bloodshed in the name of Christianity, since Christ does not rule the wicked world as its king.ST Jan 27, 1898
When the fallen church coveted earthly power it seized the civil sword, created tribunals like the Inquisition, called upon laws and crusades and religious wars, and shed blood through the secular arm, thereby abandoning the truth that worship is voluntary and free by persuasion and free choice rather than compulsion, torture or civil punishment, and fulfilling the wearing out of the saints.RH Jun 13, 1912 Misunderstanding the non-worldly nature of his kingdom led both to enforcing a religious creed by force and to Christ's crucifixion.ST Jul 6, 1915 The rise of the papacy as an ecclesiastical power controlling civil affairs and ruling over kingdoms, marked by worldly pomp, landed wealth, civil power and temporal sovereignty, stands as a counterfeit of the religion of the Prince of Peace, in contrast to a kingdom not maintained by force.RH Aug 23, 1906RH Jan 18, 1870ST Jun 5, 1884RH Mar 24, 1874
The union of church and state in the Roman Empire in the making of the papacy was claimed to be the coming of God's kingdom, but it was a kingdom of this world because it depended solely on worldly means, the only power known to kingdoms of this world, exerted through law enforced by pains and penalties, including Sunday laws and state power to render dwellers on earth fit subjects.RH Jun 12, 1900 The papal power in Rome, though claiming to be Christ's vicegerent, violated the rule that his servants do not fight with earthly weapons and that those who take the sword perish by the sword, by seeking to destroy differing religions by force and by uprooting the Heruli, the Vandals and the Ostrogoths to secure its own independence and power.ST Feb 17, 1909 The verse gives no warrant for earthly temporal rule and proves the pope's temporal dominion never came from Christ.RH Mar 17, 1874 The pope's claim to rule the world therefore exceeds the authority of Christ whose representative he claims to be.ST Jul 26, 1883 That conclusion is evaded by limiting the words to the moment when Christ was about to die and go to the Father, making not of this world mean no longer of this world but of the other everlasting world.RH Mar 17, 1874
One reading applies the heavenly origin of the kingdom to the church as God's kingdom on earth, a spiritual body ruled by Christ as king and priest, and then claims that this heavenly authority also gives the pope civil and political sovereignty in human society.ST Feb 7, 1900 Against such rule by worldly power, the character seen in Christ's example requires kindness, prayer for enemies, and blessing those who curse. The pope's claim to be its legal head, with his crown as a sign of present sovereignty, defies the declaration that Christ's kingdom is not worldly, a declaration Protestant churches also ignore.RH Aug 9, 1870 Any religious body that seeks worldly authority and compels support while claiming its kingdom is not of this world contradicts the truth that his kingdom is not a worldly political power maintained by force or secured through civil law.ST Jun 28, 1883
Christ introduced a principle contrary to the pagan union of religion and state, that his kingdom is not worldly and his servants do not fight to establish or protect it, upon which the apostolic church was founded, so that restoring the pagan system led to apostasy and papal supremacy.ST Aug 30, 1905 Disregarding this led Constantine to bring Christianity under the state, unite civil and ecclesiastical authority in himself, and claim power over the church's councils and affairs.ST Sep 2, 1889 His effort to make the church powerful and affluent in the empire turned Christ's kingdom toward the worldly kingdom distinguished in the verse, entangling it with earthly power and interests contrary to Christ's spirit and sullying its heavenly influence.ST Mar 12, 1885ST Jul 15, 1875 Surrounding the church with wealth, honor and state privilege contradicted the kingdom's heavenly character, which does not depend on worldly favor, wealth or support, and pursuit of the world's patronage and alliances signals lowered standard and loss of the Saviour's image.RH Sep 22, 1859ST Mar 19, 1885
The church leaves its proper sphere when it enters political affairs for office and power, as when bishops gained political influence to secure civil sanction for doctrines and decrees including the first Christian Sunday law under Constantine, a union that also let pagan philosophy influence teaching and helped lead into corruption.ST Oct 17, 1916 When the church chains itself to vain profane earthly power for protection it is not protected but destroyed in spiritual entireness, ceasing to be the church and becoming an institution of the state, a kingdom of this world, since conscience and faith belong exclusively to the church and civil power must not assume jurisdiction over intellect and conscience.ST May 28, 1902 To seek wealth, unlimited power and supremacy in actual combination with civil and political forces, and to confuse church and state in an inextricable medley of aspirations for world-wide rule under guise of establishing his kingdom, supplants Christ as the central figure, because his kingdom is not from hence.ST Jan 22, 1902
Jesus did not seek the Roman sword to advance his religion, for his kingdom was not to be established or defended through state force but by spiritual weapons.ST Oct 24, 1895 The failure of the Caesars' arms and policy to defeat Christianity illustrates that its strength does not come from the state, and alliance with temporal power endangers it by corrupting it.ST Oct 24, 1895 Christianity is in far greater danger of being corrupted by alliance with temporal power than of being crushed by opposition, and to thrust temporal sovereignty upon her repeats what was done to her Author when men bowed the knee, spit, cried Hail, smote, gave a reed scepter, crowned with thorns, covered with purple and crucified. Attempts to make the state serve the church and enforce religious interests contradict his kingdom and lead to spiritual tyranny and loss of civil liberty.ST May 21, 1912 Attempts to make civil governments Christian bring division, strife, injustice, oppression and persecution rather than benefit through voluntary submission to truth in the heart.ST Feb 19, 1894 Civil religious laws can produce only counterfeit Christians or hypocrites, and choosing the world's power rejects Christ, since Christianity is established in each heart by God's Spirit and cannot be made genuine by legislation.ST Feb 26, 1894
Christ has a kingdom and dominion in this world, yet not of this world in the way civil government is, for civil government grew out of the necessity sin brought into the world, while the dominion given to man in the beginning was usurped by Satan and became his kingdom.RH May 27, 1909 The church is in the world to turn men from sin and translate them into God's kingdom, where one man has no right to rule over another.RH May 27, 1909
Further points
His kingdom is not of this sin-cursed world, and it is not human pacifism, although pacifism bears some resemblance to it. The Prince of Peace will not establish His kingdom of righteousness on earth through human plans for peace, through politicians and parliaments, because His kingdom is not from here and is not content with the world as it is. He brings peace by divine grace and conversion, asking of men only faith, and not by man's own goodness and righteousness.
Sources