John 20:19
Then the same day at evening, being the first day of the week, when the doors were shut where the disciples were assembled for fear of the Jews, came Jesus and stood in the midst, and saith unto them, Peace be unto you.
Then the same day at evening, being the first day of the week, when the doors were shut where the disciples were assembled for fear of the Jews, came Jesus and stood in the midst, and saith unto them, Peace be unto you.
Commentary part 2 of 2
Pioneers and periodicals (continued)
No Sacred Title Given
The day is called only the first day of the week, with no sacred title such as Christian Sabbath, Sabbath, holy day, or Lord's day and no indication that it is superior to other days, while the seventh day immediately before it is called the Sabbath.ST Mar 16, 1882RH May 12, 1863ST Nov 8, 1905RH Nov 19, 1872ST Apr 22, 1897 The gathering and the presence of Jesus do not show a meeting to honor the day as a Sabbath or to recognize special sacredness in it, for fear of the Jews is given as the reason for assembling, and the disciples did not yet believe he had risen but were frightened supposing him a ghost.ST Mar 16, 1882ST Apr 22, 1897ST Jul 12, 1905 The timing itself is questioned by those who hold the meeting may have fallen on the second day of the week according to how after eight days is understood.RH May 12, 1863
It is not called sacred, holy, blessed, sanctified, commanded to be kept holy, a rest day, or a Sabbath, it is not said to have been made holy, and no holy time is appointed.RH Apr 1, 1873RH Nov 28, 1871ST Sep 16, 1913ST Feb 27, 1893RH Jun 19, 1856 It is named only by its place in the week as an ordinary weekday, the day after the Sabbath, and its naming gives no hint of a replacement Sabbath or a change of the Sabbath.RH Apr 1, 1873RH Nov 28, 1871ST Feb 27, 1893 It does not call the day the Lord's day, does not identify it as the Lord's day or Sabbath, and gives no authority for calling the first day the Lord's day.RH Mar 22, 1864RH Aug 1, 1912ST Oct 14, 1913 Sixty-six years after the resurrection the day was still called the first day of the week, not the Lord's day, for John wrote in A.D. 97 keeping the same name used by Matthew, Mark, Luke and Paul, which proves the first day had not been renamed the Lord's day.ST Jan 8, 1885
Calling the resurrection day the first day of the week rather than the Lord's day shows it was an ordinary workday, not a Sabbath.ST Jun 18, 1894 The resurrection appearance day is called by no other name than the plain first day of the week, never given a sacred title or called a holy day or day of worship, the first day is distinguished from the Sabbath, no event peculiar to the Sabbath is recorded, the disciples met in anxiety and unrest, and the day is a day of secular activity, not a holy day.ST Sep 10, 1896RH Sep 2, 1851 It simply calls the day the first day of the week and never calls it the Christian Sabbath, the Sabbath, the Lord's day, or a rest-day.RH Jun 16, 1874ST Aug 1, 1916RH Mar 11, 1862
It forbids no work, gives no penalty for violation, promises no blessing for observance, records no change of the Sabbath from seventh to first, gives no regulation for observance, and Jesus says nothing about the day itself.RH Jun 16, 1874ST Aug 1, 1916 It is one of only eight New Testament mentions of the first day, six of which refer to this same resurrection day, and it gives no command to keep that day, no appointment of it as a Sabbath, no blessing placed upon it, no making of it holy, no sacredness attached to it, no promise for observing it and no threat for not observing it, never calls it the Sabbath nor gives it any sacred title, and records neither the apostles keeping it nor commanding it to be kept nor the early churches observing it, leaving not even a hint of a Sunday institution and no Bible authority for Sunday observance.RH Jun 16, 1874ST Aug 1, 1916 The appearance and greeting are not an example of resting on or sanctifying the first day, and meeting the disciples that day is not proof of designating it as a Sabbath.RH Sep 18, 1866 The gathering is not evidence that the day was a Sabbath or a day of rest, but the first day is treated as an ordinary working day in contrast to the divinely appointed seventh-day Sabbath.ST Jul 30, 1912
It only mentions the first day when Jesus came, stood among disciples assembled behind shut doors for fear of the Jews, and said Peace be unto you.RH Nov 12, 1872RH May 12, 1874 It makes no declaration and implies nothing that the Sabbath is changed, does not call the first day the Sabbath, holy, or sacred, does not require abstinence from labor, and does not appoint it as the Christian Sabbath to commemorate the resurrection.RH May 12, 1874 It names only the first day when the empty tomb was found, says nothing about the Sabbath, nothing about ending Sabbath obligation, and nothing about beginning any new obligation or institution.RH Nov 12, 1872 It does not say they had assembled to honor that day, gives the first day no sacred title, does not say Christ rested on it, and does not describe God transferring the seventh day's blessing to it or setting it apart as holy, and therefore does not establish a change of the Sabbath.RH May 5, 1863
It calls the day simply the first day of the week, not the Sabbath, not a Sabbath, not holy, not the Lord's day and not a worship day.ST Sep 23, 1897ST Oct 10, 1878ST Jul 11, 1878ST Aug 17, 1876RH Feb 27, 1872 The plain secular name shows it is treated as a common day, and John's continued use of that plain name even after Revelation shows Sunday had not been given the name Lord's day, which is the seventh-day Sabbath.ST Oct 24, 1895 John calls the day the first day of the week in both of his Gospel references to the first day, does not identify it as the Christian Sabbath, does not prove it was the special day for Christian worship, and the early church did not call the first day the Lord's day until a century after John's time when apostasy was well under way.ST Sep 23, 1897ST Aug 17, 1876RH Feb 27, 1872ST Oct 24, 1895 It means the first day of the week, not one of the sabbaths or a first-day sabbath, pointing to the particular day on which Jesus rose.ST Sep 23, 1897
It is listed among New Testament references to the first day as evidence the day is mentioned, not as a command to observe it as a Sabbath or sacred day.ST Jun 4, 1874 The day's earlier events including the conversation with Mary gave opportunity to teach that Sunday was sacred, but there is no evidence he did so, and Mary is presumed to have remained unaware of any such teaching.RH Nov 19, 1872 The words Peace be unto you and the gift of the Holy Spirit, with spiritual instruction and authority, were directed to the disciples to comfort grieving witnesses and give opportunity to see him alive, not to the day.ST Feb 3, 1887ST Aug 24, 1888ST Aug 24, 1888RH Apr 1, 1873RH Jun 19, 1860
They did not bless the day, make the day sacred, approve the gathering as a religious service, refer to the first day, or give a command or blessing setting it apart, and the blessing was on the apostles, not the day.ST Feb 3, 1887ST Aug 24, 1888ST Aug 24, 1888RH Jun 19, 1860ST Sep 12, 1916 They were gathered around the supper table at home eating supper, not holding a religious meeting or celebrating the resurrection, still not believing he had risen, and the meeting was an appearance confirming his resurrection.ST Feb 3, 1887ST Aug 24, 1888ST Aug 24, 1888 The verse does not contain the word change or alter, does not call the day the Sabbath or rest, does not say Jesus blessed the day, and does not appoint the day to be kept and observed for any purpose.RH Jun 19, 1860 This blessed the disciples, but it does not say that Jesus blessed or sanctified Sunday.ST Sep 12, 1916
Those who treat the two first-day appearances as choosing and honoring the first day hold that repeated expectation gave special regard for its return, calling it the resurrection day and the Lord's day in contrast to the seventh day on which no meeting with the risen Lord is recorded.RH Apr 1, 1873 Christ's meeting that evening puts no claim on the first day as his and gives no direction or instruction for keeping it holy, and John's plain naming proves Revelation 1:10 is not the first day of the week. The resurrection day remains simply the first day of the week, named exactly as at creation, proving it is still one of the six working days and not a new Sabbath, and the seventh day therefore remains the Sabbath and the Lord's day.RH Mar 22, 1864ST Jun 6, 1900 The evening gathering was not a religious service in honor of the resurrection, but disciples at home eating a common meal behind shut doors for fear, who did not yet believe Jesus had risen.ST Jun 6, 1900
John does not use the verse to declare Sunday sacred, does not establish a new first-day Sabbath, and does not even hint at a change of the Sabbath from the seventh day to the first day.ST Jan 13, 1914 He affirms he writes no new commandment but the old commandment heard from the beginning, showing the commandments remain as God first spoke them.ST Jan 13, 1914
No Sabbath Change Shown
John 20:19 records Jesus appearing to the disciples in the evening on the first day of the week while assembled behind shut doors for fear of the Jews, calling the day only the first day of the week with no sacred title or indication of superiority, and the gathering and presence give no command, example, blessing, hallowing, or instruction establishing the first day as sacred, as a Sabbath, as a new weekly rest day or Christian Sabbath, changing the Sabbath, abrogating the seventh-day law, or releasing anyone from keeping the seventh day holy.ST Mar 16, 1882ST Nov 8, 1905RH Nov 19, 1872ST Apr 22, 1897ST Jul 12, 1905 The meeting itself does not prove any day sacred simply because Jesus met with the disciples, and its timing is questioned as possibly on the second day depending on how after eight days is understood.RH May 12, 1863 The disciples were not assembled expecting him or to honor the day, because that first day they did not yet know he must rise and did not believe he was risen, and when he stood among them they were frightened supposing him a ghost and he reproved unbelief, so the meeting gives no example of keeping the first day as the Christian Sabbath and no support for first-day observance.ST Apr 22, 1897ST Jul 12, 1905
The appearance does not prove, establish, or show a change of the Sabbath, a transfer from seventh to first, a new first-day Sabbath, or sacred status for the first day, and gives no command or example making its observance a religious duty.RH Mar 31, 1874ST Dec 15, 1881RH Dec 19, 1871RH Apr 16, 1861RH Feb 25, 1862 They were not meeting to commemorate the resurrection, having not believed reports he had risen and being gathered to eat and keep out of danger, sitting at meat together in their common abode and terrified when he appeared, so it says nothing about a change and does not call the first day a holy Sabbath.RH Mar 31, 1874RH Apr 16, 1861RH Feb 25, 1862 Although recording the resurrection and its day, it gives no indication the Sabbath was changed or the first day appointed for worship, does not identify that day after the Sabbath as a Sabbath or show it made holy.RH Dec 19, 1871ST Feb 27, 1893 The meeting in verse 26 was after eight days, and comparing that expression with after six days in Mark 9:2 and Luke 9:28, which means about eight days, shows it could mean about ten days rather than the next Sunday.RH Feb 25, 1862
The verse makes no reference to the Sabbath commandment and does not say the Sabbath was changed or repealed.ST Apr 13, 1915 It reports no announcement that the Sabbath had been changed.ST Mar 12, 1912 Though this would have been an ideal time to announce a change from seventh to first, he did not do so, said nothing about the day becoming holy by his resurrection, and gave no command to hold future religious assemblies on that day.ST Jul 8, 1930ST Jul 19, 1883 The distance to Galilee made going there that day impossible so they were still in Jerusalem after the two returned from Emmaus, and this is counted first of three meetings followed by the meeting a week later and then at the Sea of Galilee, all before the appointed meeting on the mountain in Galilee whose weekday is not revealed.ST Jul 19, 1883
If the apostles had changed the Sabbath that day they would have acted in unbelief, since he appeared to convince them he had risen, a fact they had not yet believed, and they showed no awareness of such a change.ST Dec 15, 1881RH May 16, 1854RH Apr 14, 1874 Fear of the Jews was just as present after he rose as before, so the gathering for fear, not to celebrate the resurrection or keep the first day holy, gives no example or proof of first-day observance.RH Apr 9, 1861RH May 16, 1854 The mere fact he met with them does not prove any day sacred, establish successive first-day meetings, or show he never appeared on the seventh day during the forty days, for he could meet on any day without giving reason.RH May 12, 1863RH Nov 29, 1853RH Jan 17, 1856 Along with the later meeting in John 20:26 it does not establish a series of successive first-day meetings or evidence the Sabbath was changed.RH Jul 11, 1854 They had rested the day before according to the commandment, and two days in succession cannot both be kept according to the commandment, and even repeated meetings would prove nothing for a new Sabbath unless the time determined the meeting and Sabbath worship purpose was specified.RH Dec 11, 1860 They were together where they stayed, not necessarily for worship but at evening meal, and his greeting of peace does not establish the day a Sabbath, observed in honor of the resurrection, or to be observed in future, with unbelief weighing against treating it as celebration, nor does appearance that day show he was not seen during the forty days before ascension.RH Nov 29, 1853RH Jan 17, 1856
This was the only first day on which the record says he met with them, so it does not show repeated meetings on that day or intent to establish it as worship, while the account identifies the preceding seventh day as the Sabbath.ST Jun 18, 1894 It is the one occasion identified when he met them assembled, the only such first-day assembly positively described, and does not establish often meeting on the first day or that this was a worship service.RH Dec 21, 1869RH Aug 23, 1870 The verse is offered as a reason for keeping Sunday but only reports when he came to the assembled disciples on the first day, Sunday.ST May 29, 1884ST Jan 11, 1916 It describes a meeting on the first day offered as proof of a change with the question whether it established such change left unanswered.RH Jul 18, 1854 It is included among accounts showing what the disciples did on the first day, assembled that evening with shut doors for fear, presented as evidence about the character of the first day, not as keeping it as Sabbath.ST Jul 2, 1894
The meeting on resurrection evening greeting peace does not show they assembled for worship or that he instituted the first day as Sabbath, and his greeting to disciples who had traveled that day is not instruction to observe weekly rest. It shows him standing among them the same day he rose, one of only eight New Testament mentions of the first day and one of six in the Gospels, like the others only identifying resurrection day with no command, statement, or hint Sunday was made Sabbath or rest day.ST Jun 5, 1901 Accepting Sunday as the day he rose, that fact does not establish he intended to change Sabbath from seventh to first.RH Jun 20, 1871RH Oct 4, 1864 Cited as evidence the Sabbath was changed or Christ sanctioned the first day by meeting that evening or the resurrection day had special place in worship, and as proof they met after the resurrection, it is rejected as proving they immediately stopped keeping the seventh day or that he instructed change or established worship day, such reasons being unfounded excuses for not obeying the seventh-day Sabbath, and the verse is not instruction to change.RH Feb 28, 1856RH Apr 4, 1854RH Sep 26, 1854ST Jun 17, 1889
The reference to that evening behind closed doors for fear does not establish a new boundary for the day or repeal the fourth commandment and does not show Sabbath changed to first.RH May 17, 1870 The record does not make the first day holy, change Sabbath seventh to first, contain command to observe Sunday, or furnish authoritative basis for Sunday sacredness or worship.RH Jan 8, 1867ST Jan 1, 1894ST Jan 13, 1888ST Jun 12, 1901 Such meetings do not establish replacement of seventh-day Sabbath, that conclusion being human inference since Scripture gives no command or reason instituting a new Sabbath, nor regular rest and worship thereafter, nor transfer by resurrection and meeting without definite statement, nor command to keep holy by coming and breathing Receive the Holy Ghost, and the six mentions together only show he rose that day with nothing commanding observance, hinting sacredness, suggesting Sabbath observance, or showing he made a Sabbath.RH Jan 8, 1867ST Jan 1, 1894ST Jan 13, 1888ST Jun 12, 1901 The Sabbath command remained binding through the crucifixion with no New Testament command changing to Sunday.RH Aug 2, 1870
Greeting with peace that evening gives no authority for Sunday-keeping and does not make Sunday sacred for worship, and meeting that day to have peace and worship because he did so is human choice following others, not obedience to Scripture, lulling to sleep and leading to ruin instead of Scripture.ST Oct 25, 1883 The meeting does not make the day a Sabbath, for disciples and Jesus had been active throughout the day while the preceding day had been observed as Sabbath according to the commandment, with tomb visit and Emmaus journey showing no second weekly Sabbath observance and supplying no command to keep first day, since rest from labor is essential to Sabbath.RH Aug 19, 1851 On resurrection day he resumed teaching and instructing, meeting the eleven at close of day, his redemptive work not ceasing on the first day, part of a day filled with appearances and activity, not Sabbath rest.RH Aug 1, 1871
There is no command to remember the first day, and Jesus never mentioned or named it, never observed it holy, never taught its observance, nor did apostles, while inspired writers twenty-six to sixty-six years after crucifixion still called it only first day and the day before Sabbath.ST Nov 12, 1894 The claim he thereby made example for followers must be shown to establish intent as example, sacred status, and setting aside seventh, which the meeting itself does not establish.ST Mar 9, 1882 It does not say they had met each day preceding, that visit marked first day holy, or they understood lesson about sacredness, so it does not establish holiness or Sabbath disregard, and silence about Sabbath gatherings cannot prove none occurred.RH Apr 1, 1873 Even repeated meetings would not suffice against the fourth commandment to observe first day as Sabbath.RH Mar 21, 1865 Assembling from fear not Sunday worship, he gave there no sanction of first-day meeting, no change of convocation seventh to first, no teaching against Judaism or for Christian Sabbath, with nothing hidden for fear since he did not fear and apostles did not fear to speak and Paul fully taught yet left no Sunday record, the only fear barring preaching change being fear of disobeying commission and becoming false witnesses under curse.ST Jul 31, 1884
The greeting does not make the day holy, since he greeted again after eight days on the second or third day.RH Feb 11, 1858RH Sep 17, 1857 It is one appearance, not proof every special appearance was first day, for he was seen during forty days, and other appearances do not establish that weekday.RH Oct 21, 1858 Meeting on other days shows meeting or appearing does not make Sabbath, and the two meetings do not show change or holiness, the first not commemorating resurrection since unbelieving.RH Sep 17, 1857RH Feb 18, 1873 The time was incidental with nothing said or done to withdraw regard from the Father's rest day to resurrection day or consecrate hours for future use.RH Nov 5, 1872 Unlike the Lord's Supper inaugurated with command to do in remembrance, he gave no explanation of new institution and no command to repeat in remembrance.RH Nov 5, 1872 Even if exemplary first-day practice were established, the seventh commanded by the Father would still require observance alongside first for the Son unless seventh were shown secularized, and proof must authoritatively show practice claimed and exemplary design requiring imitation.RH Nov 5, 1872
Appearance and greeting are not example of resting or sanctifying first day.RH Sep 18, 1866 Meeting at evening same day he rose after Emmaus does not make fitting memorial, for baptism by burial and rising represents death and resurrection. Timing on that weekday does not make it sacred, for Pentecost's significance lay in feast and fulfillment not weekday, which varied yearly.ST Mar 11, 1886 Appearing Sunday evening and teaching was general Christian religion not Sunday observance and establishes no command.RH Mar 25, 1862 Concluding sacredness is human inference and tradition added to Bible, since no command or reason institutes new Sabbath.RH Jul 8, 1875 At most offered as reason for church festival not Sabbath replacement, and using it for sacredness lays aside God's commandment for men's tradition leaving Bible alone for Bible plus tradition.RH May 5, 1851RH Jul 8, 1875
The resurrection-day appearance gives no intimation Sabbath changed seventh to first, the first intimation being identified instead with Acts 20:7, and Sunday was not kept as Sabbath until made so by Roman decrees.ST Oct 21, 1889ST Mar 24, 1881 Among six Gospel first-day occurrences its mention does not establish Sabbath or sacred rest.ST Oct 21, 1889 The later after eight days meeting was not next Sunday since after eight days reaches beyond full week, both meetings in shared dwelling where they lived, they not believing and eating ordinary meal and he saying nothing about change.RH May 12, 1863RH May 10, 1860 Whether evening meeting was same interview as Mark 16:14 is questioned, and how after eight days is understood affects timing.RH May 12, 1863RH May 5, 1863 Another meeting recorded after eight days is identified as next first day with a third on fishing day, yet fact of record does not itself establish Sabbath observance.RH Aug 10, 1869 The verse identifies previous meeting as first day, starting point for showing after eight days was not following first day, noting next recorded meeting after eight days not same first day.ST Feb 17, 1890ST Mar 11, 1886
Comparing after eight days with after six days in Mark 9:2 and Luke 9:28 meaning about eight days shows it could mean about ten days rather than next Sunday.RH Feb 25, 1862 The next recorded meeting after eight days reaches to Monday and possibly Tuesday not Sunday, and commemoration requiring past event impossible same day notable so weekly commemoration could begin only week later, with hardness rebuked for unbelief.RH Jan 27, 1874 Greeting peace and breathing are explained as giving peace, also given at next meeting placed Monday evening, and the meeting does not establish first day set apart or Sabbath blessing moved.RH Aug 1, 1854 Thomas absent and refusing others' testimony further weakens apostolic example claim, the gathering before belief in day's last moments providing none for holy day.ST Sep 15, 1887 Later after eight days meeting addressed doubts and taught blessing of faith, appearing then to witness resurrection not establish sacred day.ST Oct 4, 1899 Meeting resurrection evening did not make weekday holy or Sabbath, inconsistent to treat as proof since he met other occasions during forty days before ascension, including Monday evening, fishing workday, and Thursday farewell, so example gives no exclusive Sunday support.RH Oct 20, 1859ST Apr 12, 1883 He gave no honor to first day at this meeting.ST Jul 19, 1883
Claims Honoring First Day
John 20:19 begins the observance of the first day, with the first meeting of the disciples after the resurrection held on that evening and another meeting following the next Sunday.RH May 10, 1860 Christ himself was present to give his sanction and blessing, giving the highest possible approval of their meeting.ST Feb 3, 1887 He imparted the Holy Spirit to guide their own conduct and their teaching of others, and appointed them as ambassadors.ST Feb 3, 1887 This meeting is the last of four appearances on resurrection day and shows the disciples commencing religious observance of the first day immediately after the resurrection.ST Feb 3, 1887
The meeting is the principal scriptural basis for treating the first day as sacred.RH Nov 19, 1872 If the day became the Sabbath, the change began through events connected with the resurrection, with Christ impressing its Sabbath character on the disciples from the third day after the crucifixion.RH Nov 19, 1872 The verse is used to argue that the disciples met that day to commemorate the resurrection.ST Mar 11, 1880
Jesus appeared collectively late on resurrection evening while they were assembled behind shut doors for fear of the Jews, stood among them, blessed them with peace, gave spiritual instruction, and breathed on them the Holy Ghost.RH Apr 1, 1873 Their reason for meeting is not given, and it was not manifestly to commemorate the resurrection.RH Apr 1, 1873 His appearance on this day, followed by another appearance to the gathered disciples on the first day of the next week, shows his choosing and honoring the first day, and the disciples' repeated expectation of his presence gave them special regard for its return.RH Apr 1, 1873 The first day is thus the resurrection day and the Lord's day, in contrast to the seventh day on which no meeting with the risen Lord is recorded, and the meeting is counted among three meetings on that day supporting its observance.RH Apr 1, 1873RH Feb 25, 1862
The disciples were assembled together for religious purposes, and together with the visit a week later this shows repeated visits of Christ in first-day meetings for worship.RH Apr 2, 1861 This proves that under the Christian dispensation uniting Jews and Gentiles the Sabbath is altered back from seventh to first.RH Apr 2, 1861 The verse is included among New Testament texts claimed to call the first day a Sabbath and support its observance as the Christian Sabbath.ST Apr 10, 1879
The gathering is presented as worship, and the verse is cited as evidence for keeping the first day as the Christian Sabbath and for the claim that the Lord changed the Sabbath to the first day.RH Mar 20, 1855ST Oct 21, 1889 Personal appearances on the first Sunday and the next Sunday especially honored the first day and taught that it had become holy time, showing the transfer of the Sabbath observed until Christ's death from the seventh to the first as the stated day for religious assemblies and services.ST Sep 6, 1883 This meeting begins Christians setting apart the first day for worship as the Lord's day, in contrast to the seventh-day Sabbath observed by Jews.RH Feb 11, 1858
The resurrection day began when the angel descended, the guard was stricken down, and the glorified Son came forth, and if the Sabbath was changed the change dated from that very moment.RH Nov 19, 1872 From that time forward every action imprinted the peculiar sacredness of the hours and gave no sanction to deliberate or unintentional disregard of their hallowed nature.RH Nov 19, 1872 The evening meeting was not accidental but a religious meeting in which the disciples instinctively acted in harmony with the spirit of the hour to recognize the heavenly character of the day, and Christ honored their effort by his personal presence.RH Nov 19, 1872 Along with his appearance, approval, commission, and gift of the Holy Ghost, this marked the first day as of special significance for future guidance and religious worship.RH Oct 3, 1854
Repeated appearances when gathered on the first day with blessing taught special sacredness and honored the day by his presence.RH Apr 15, 1873 The appearance is Christ's example supporting the introduction of first-day observance, with divine approval and sanction.RH May 8, 1856 It is one of the New Testament passages referring to the first day used to support Sunday observance.ST Feb 16, 1882
Christ honored the first day and passed by the seventh.RH May 27, 1873 His repeated meetings after rising honored the day hallowed by his resurrection, which became the day of weekly assemblies and of the Christian churches' weekly assemblies.RH Apr 29, 1873 The verse identifies the first day as the day of resurrection in connection with early Christians keeping that day, while distinguishing it from the Sabbath said to belong to Israel.ST Jul 12, 1899
Jesus appeared on six successive first days and set that day apart as the Lord's day, not as a Sabbath or day of rest.RH Oct 27, 1859 At most the assembling on the first day after the resurrection may support treating the first day as sacred, but it does not show the seventh-day Sabbath made less sacred or superseded, and at most the first day would be an additional sacred day.ST Nov 13, 1879
Resurrection Proof and Body
The evening appearance belongs to the historically well-attested resurrection, which was necessary because salvation depends on Christ risen and which tests the infallibility of his word that he would rise, forming part of the evidence that he rose as promised.ST Sep 9, 1880ST Jun 14, 1905 The resurrection provides the climax of physical proof that he is the Messiah and fulfills Scripture, leaving indubitable proof that he had risen.ST Jun 7, 1899 That appearance with the other appearances that day made the first day memorable and renewed the hope of those who had mourned that Israel's redemption had failed.RH Jun 24, 1873
It belongs to the Jerusalem appearances evidencing that the risen person was the same Jesus known before death, with greater weight given to the church and New Testament as living fruit of faith in him.RH May 11, 1916 The fearful gathering together in one place in an upper chamber shows close watching so no deception could be undertaken, and the seal could not have been broken, the Roman guard overcome, and the body stolen to invent the resurrection.RH Jan 18, 1912 The appearance was of Jesus himself alive as a living being, not the return of a dead person's spirit or a spiritual manifestation or phantom.ST Jun 12, 1884
The frightened disciples thinking him a phantom were convinced he was the same risen Jesus when he ate before them, and his greeting of peace soothed their troubled hearts.ST Apr 25, 1906 The risen Jesus was physically present in the room whose doors were shut, passing his physical body through the closed doors by his superior nature, as passing through an open door is natural to a human being.ST Apr 1, 1880 Bolts and bars could not keep out the risen Son of God, which made the priests and rulers fear meeting him face to face.ST Oct 3, 1878 His risen, glorious body could also walk on water and rise into the air, and the bodies of the resurrected will be like his.ST Mar 27, 1907 His entering without the door being opened raises the question whether his resurrected body was an ordinary material body.RH Nov 26, 1872
His entering and standing among them despite shut doors without visible opening illustrates that resurrected beings move imperceptibly like angels, and the saints as children of the resurrection will have movement like that of angels.RH Mar 13, 1856 His explanation that a spirit has not flesh and bones answered the disciples' fear of an apparition without affirming disembodied spirits. His appearing in a room without an opening is taken by those who hold it to show his post-resurrection appearances were generally recognized through spiritual perception rather than by his always being present in his natural body, though he may sometimes have assumed an earthly form.RH Nov 26, 1872 The same standing among the disciples despite shut doors illustrates that ideas cannot be confined by imprisoning the people who express them.ST Jan 21, 1903
His passing through closed doors is compared with his emergence from the sealed grave.ST Nov 25, 1889 The resurrection itself happened before the women arrived and was seen by no human observer though guards kept watch, the stone being rolled away only after he had risen so it did not enable the resurrection, the act being hidden from mortal eyes.ST Nov 25, 1889 His appearing suddenly despite closed doors illustrates the Spirit-born life as beyond ordinary human knowledge or limitation, like the wind whose coming and going cannot be known.RH Jan 22, 1857 In his resurrection state he is as one born of the Spirit and is spirit, and every immortalized saint will be the same at the resurrection of the just.RH Sep 15, 1874
His appearance displays the spirit-like condition of a resurrected, immortalized person, the perfected end of the new birth that begins with conversion and is completed at the resurrection of the just. The appearance occurred on the first day when he rose from the dead and rested from the work of redemption.RH Sep 13, 1853 The first day is also associated with the descent of the Holy Spirit on the apostles and the church.RH Sep 13, 1853
Commission Peace and Application
Together with verses 20-23 the evening of the day he rose records Jesus giving the commission to preach, a commission repeatedly kept before the disciples during the forty days before ascension with the promise of the Spirit's power for the work.ST Jan 9, 1893
On the evening of the resurrection day he breathed on the gathered disciples to receive the Holy Ghost, sent them as the Father sent him, gave the commission to the twelve in the upper chamber, and opened their understanding to understand the Scriptures.ST Feb 10, 1914ST Jan 16, 1893RH Sep 11, 1900ST Jul 31, 1884 These blessings and earlier experiences did not by themselves prepare them to carry the gospel to the world without power from on high.ST Jan 16, 1893 The assembling was from fear of the Jews, not for Sunday worship, and there he gave no sanction of first-day meeting, no change of convocation from seventh to first, and no teaching for a Christian Sabbath.ST Jul 31, 1884 Nothing said that night was hidden for fear of the Jews, for the only fear keeping from preaching a change was fear of disobeying the commission and becoming false witnesses under a curse.ST Jul 31, 1884
On that occasion the risen Christ breathed on them saying Receive the Holy Ghost.ST Jan 13, 1888 This event was given as one reason for observing Sunday, but it does not establish a command from Scripture to keep that day holy.ST Jan 13, 1888 The authority to bind and loose was given not to Peter alone but to the apostles and collectively the church.ST Sep 29, 1881 The appearance on the first day confirmed the priestly authority transferred to the disciples when he gave them the first fruits, as evidence that their new priesthood was confirmed on that day.RH Sep 30, 1858
The greeting of peace and resurrection appearance assures that hopes in him are secure after his sacrifice was accepted by the Father, that he conquered and is worthy to receive all power, giving reassurance he is alive.ST Apr 11, 1900ST Feb 27, 1893 His message continues to comfort and strengthen followers amid fear, care, and spiritual conflict, with resurrection giving assurance of victory while pardon, cleansing, grace, and keeping bring renewed peace.ST May 19, 1909 His greeting came after his offering had been accepted in heaven, making the way of peace sure for those who walk in it, repeating the angels' announcement of peace at his birth.ST May 24, 1899 This peace belongs to those who trust God and are justified by faith through Jesus, while the wicked have no peace.ST May 24, 1899
When he greeted them with peace he meant more than the customary Hebrew salutation often used as a mere form; his words conveyed a lasting truth and blessing.ST Jul 13, 1915 His greeting gave real peace, not mere formality: an honorable righteous peace with God purchased by his sacrifice and wounded hands, offered freely even to failing unbelieving disciples.ST Apr 24, 1901ST Feb 27, 1896 Received, it is inward calm amid outward trouble and hostility, expressing his continuing mission through the Gospel age.ST Mar 8, 1910ST Apr 24, 1901ST Feb 27, 1896 His words were not mere formality but gave a condition of mind the world could neither give nor take away.ST Mar 8, 1910 His words are the same assurance given to Gideon, the compassionate Savior coming to encourage those afraid.ST Jun 23, 1881
Peace be unto you with Behold my hands means look to him alone, for he alone took away sin and redeemed man and now gives peace from the Lord.ST Aug 16, 1883 Christ the Mediator overcame attempts from Herod's plot and Satan's temptations to the opposition that killed him, repeating the promise of peace announced at his birth and declaring that his mission of peace with God continued and triumphed.ST Apr 24, 1901 Men are saved by his work not their own and gain peace with God through Christ alone by believing the gospel word.ST Aug 16, 1883ST Apr 24, 1901
Knowing their grief was joined by shame over unfaithfulness and denial, he made himself known, showed his hands and feet, ate before them, and greeted fearful, troubled, doubting disciples with peace to free them from distress, give encouragement and assurance of his presence, and make them peaceful and strong. Frightened and thinking they saw a spirit, they received joy, assurance, personal comfort and forgiveness, fitting the resurrection, as a message for all time and the whole household of faith.ST Apr 26, 1905 His care for the bereaved and for Peter burdened by shame shows his resurrection brings personal comfort and forgiveness, and his working, loving, forgiving life is an example for followers.RH May 4, 1911 His voice gives the fearful encouragement and assurance of his presence.RH Oct 20, 1863 His presence brought joy and assurance to those who had doubted, and strengthened them to announce that he had come to the sorrowful.ST Nov 27, 1893
The risen Jesus standing among disciples greeting peace raised in blessing the same hands pierced on the cross, joining the encounter with the risen Christ to his crucifixion.ST Oct 14, 1889 He appeared to gathered disciples on the evening of his resurrection in an upper room, revealing himself, refreshing mourning disciples, filling them with joy and the message that he had risen.ST Nov 11, 1908RH Jul 6, 1911 His appearance brought them a shower of blessing before the Pentecostal baptism, with hearts touched by the Holy Spirit.ST Sep 12, 1916ST Nov 11, 1908
The disciples were all assembled in an upper chamber on the evening of the first day for fear of the Jews, behind shut doors, divided and doubtful after three days apart.RH Jul 8, 1909 Jesus stood among them greeting peace twice to reassure and quiet fears, bringing assurance of peace with God, comfort, release from guilt and inner distress, a calm steady soul resting in God's power as inheritance, joy, and stability at the heart of the gospel bringing rest to troubled hearts.ST Apr 24, 1901ST Apr 21, 1914 At that meeting he began instructing future labors to take up gospel work and continue peace on earth goodwill to men, gave the Holy Spirit, changed hatred to love, strife to fellowship, and doubt to assurance preparing for Pentecostal baptism and obedience to the great commission.ST Apr 24, 1901RH Jul 8, 1909 His presence and peace are invited as a model for prayer and fellowship.RH Jun 6, 1912
The greeting expresses the peace and salvation they were to proclaim through repentance and the Saviour's power to forgive sins, strengthening those who doubted to announce him to the sorrowful.ST Nov 27, 1893 Greeting the disciples with peace applies to followers amid war and turmoil to trust God, remain calm, not be overcome by fear, confident God works for salvation.RH Oct 15, 1861 Appearing to doubting and despondent disciples he twice gave the message Peace be unto you as a message of peace to the troubled eleven.ST Feb 27, 1896
His presence among them when gathered behind shut doors and speaking about him illustrates his elevating and revealing influence when people earnestly discuss the kingdom.ST Jan 7, 1889 His words of peace still heard in the Christ-loving soul remove the dreariest darkness of sin and fill the heart with sunshine so joy depends on what a person is not where he is.RH Apr 21, 1868 His coming into the midst of believers gathered for prayer even when few brings peace, relief from sin and care, nourishment, and strength.ST May 17, 1899 Absent members who return to the gathered church may find the Saviour there, bringing peace.RH Aug 7, 1866 His nearness and blessing are likened to light coming through gates entered by the ascended Savior now interceding in heaven.ST Mar 16, 1882
The greeting of peace is applied to the time when Jesus comes, for which God's children look for peace rather than in a world of growing evil and deception.RH Jul 1, 1858 In the present, peace is in the heart of one who loves God's law, which reveals sin and leads the sinner to Christ as the only hope.RH Jul 1, 1858 His word of peace will sound again down future generations until war ceases.ST Dec 19, 1892 It ends war's blast, makes the warrior's name abhorred, lays Cain's curse on nations lifting hand against a brother, and replaces arsenals and forts with holy melodies of love.RH Sep 22, 1874
His sudden appearance to disappointed apostles slow to grasp his plain teaching foreshadows his second advent, when masses of professed disciples will be just as unprepared for his sudden appearance while those loving his appearing and believing his word will be looking for him.ST Jun 26, 1901 The gathering behind closed doors because they feared the Jews, even before the resurrection broke the power of the tomb, fulfilled his warnings that followers would face persecution beginning before he left the tomb.ST Jul 4, 1899 Their fear illustrates persecution against believers and its threat to freedom of worship.RH Oct 31, 1912
The gathering on the first day after the resurrection reflects danger of persecution and death from fear of the Jews, which also explains why they could not bear some of his teachings while he was with them.RH Jan 23, 1866 Their fear and hiding in hopeless grief made his cause appear to have failed. It reflects the threat of persecution for following Christ and worshiping according to belief.ST Jul 6, 1904 Unable to see triumph in his death, they fled and hid behind bolted doors in uncontrollable hopeless grief, having lost hope and fearing they had nowhere to go.RH Sep 9, 1915ST Jan 31, 1911
Sources