John 20:23
Whose soever sins ye remit, they are remitted unto them; and whose soever sins ye retain, they are retained.
Translations
Whose soever sins you remit, they are remitted to them; and whose soever sins you retain, they are retained.
Whose soever sins ye remit, they are remitted unto them; and whose soever sins ye retain, they are retained.
whose soever sins ye remit, they are remitted unto them; and whose soever sins ye retain, they are retained.
Whose soever sins ye remit, they are remitted to them; and whose soever sins ye retain, they are retained.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
whose soever sins ye forgive, they are forgiven unto them; whose soever sins ye retain, they are retained.
if of any ye may loose the sins, they are loosed to them; if of any ye may retain, they have been retained.'
whose soever sins ye remit, they are remitted to them; whose soever [ sins] ye retain, they are retained.
Whosesoever sins ye shall remit, they are remitted unto them, whosesoever ye shall retain, they are retained.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
If you forgive anyone his sins, they are forgiven; if you withhold forgiveness from anyone, it is withheld.”
If you forgive anyone’s sins, they have been forgiven them. If you retain anyone’s sins, they have been retained.”
Any to whom you give forgiveness, will be made free from their sins; and any from whom you keep back forgiveness, will still be in their sins.
Whosoeuers sinnes ye remit, they are remitted vnto them: and whosoeuers sinnes ye reteine, they are reteined.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Whose sins you shall forgive, they are forgiven them; and whose sins you shall retain, they are retained.
Cross-references
- Matthew 16:19
And I will give unto thee the keys of the kingdom of heaven: and whatsoever thou shalt bind on earth shall be bound in heaven: and whatsoever thou shalt loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven.
Both texts give authority to bind and loose, including authority concerning forgiveness.
- Matthew 18:18
Verily I say unto you, Whatsoever ye shall bind on earth shall be bound in heaven: and whatsoever ye shall loose on earth shall be loosed in heaven.
Christ gives the church authority to bind and loose, with its decisions ratified in heaven.
- Luke 24:47
And that repentance and remission of sins should be preached in his name among all nations, beginning at Jerusalem.
Repentance and remission of sins are preached in Christ’s name.
- Acts 5:1-10
But a certain man named Ananias, with Sapphira his wife, sold a possession,
Peter confronts concealed sin and declares its severe consequences.
- John 20:19
Then the same day at evening, being the first day of the week, when the doors were shut where the disciples were assembled for fear of the Jews, came Jesus and stood in the midst, and saith unto them, Peace be unto you.
Jesus appears to the gathered disciples and breathes on them at this meeting.
- Mark 2:7
Why doth this man thus speak blasphemies? who can forgive sins but God only?
Both texts connect forgiveness of sins with God’s authority.
- Matthew 28:18
And Jesus came and spake unto them, saying, All power is given unto me in heaven and in earth.
Christ’s authority frames the apostles’ authority to proclaim the gospel.
- Acts 2:38
Then Peter said unto them, Repent, and be baptized every one of you in the name of Jesus Christ for the remission of sins, and ye shall receive the gift of the Holy Ghost.
Peter’s preaching calls for repentance and baptism for remission of sins.
- Matthew 9:6
But that ye may know that the Son of man hath power on earth to forgive sins, ( then saith he to the sick of the palsy,) Arise, take up thy bed, and go unto thine house.
Christ’s authority to forgive sins demonstrates His divinity.
- 2 Corinthians 2:10
To whom ye forgive any thing, I forgive also: for if I forgave any thing, to whom I forgave it, for your sakes forgave I it in the person of Christ;
Forgiveness is exercised in Christ’s name.
- Acts 13:38
Be it known unto you therefore, men and brethren, that through this man is preached unto you the forgiveness of sins:
Forgiveness is preached through Christ.
- Mark 16:16
He that believeth and is baptized shall be saved; but he that believeth not shall be damned.
Belief in the preached gospel brings salvation, while rejection brings condemnation.
- 1 Corinthians 5
It is reported commonly that there is fornication among you, and such fornication as is not so much as named among the Gentiles, that one should have his father’s wife.
Cited as guidance for church discipline.
- Acts 2:1-4
And when the day of Pentecost was fully come, they were all with one accord in one place.
Jesus’ breathing on the disciples connects with the later outpouring of the Holy Spirit.
- Acts 5:31
Him hath God exalted with his right hand to be a Prince and a Saviour, for to give repentance to Israel, and forgiveness of sins.
God gives repentance and forgiveness through Christ.
- Micah 7:19
He will turn again, he will have compassion upon us; he will subdue our iniquities; and thou wilt cast all their sins into the depths of the sea.
Describes God removing the sins of the repentant.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
24 sources
Christ gives His church on earth in its organized capacity authority to declare on His behalf the terms on which sins are forgiven or retained.RCOC 8.34T 17.2ST May 24, 1883Ms 21, 1889, par. 65–66 This does not give any apostle, minister, or successor personal power to remove guilt, grant absolution, or pronounce God's final judgment, for forgiveness belongs to God and Christ alone.Ms 149, 1897, par. 8–113SP 244.2–245.16RED 82.1–83.1 It means His chosen ministers are to set forth from Scripture the obedience of faith that brings forgiveness and the impenitent disobedience that leaves sins retained, and God remits or retains according to those terms.Ms 21, 1889, par. 65–66Ms 149, 1897, par. 8–11DA 805.2–3 When the church acts together under the Holy Spirit's guidance according to God's word, whether in warning and censuring the persistent sinner or in assuring and restoring the repentant, its judgment is ratified in heaven.GW 502.1–23SP 244.2–245.1DA 805.2–3 That work requires prayer, spiritual discernment, and united decision by consecrated representatives showing Christ's character, and its authority is to be respected in submission and unity rather than set aside by individual judgment.RCOC 8.34T 17.2Ms 21, 1889, par. 65–66Ms 149, 1897, par. 8–11DA 805.2–3
Setting and Commission
On the evening of the first day of the week Jesus came and stood in the midst of the disciples assembled behind shut doors for fear of the Jews.18MR 96.4–97.2Ms 72, 1902, par. 23–24 He said Peace be unto you, showed them His hands and His side, and the disciples were glad when they saw the Lord.18MR 96.4–97.2Ms 72, 1902, par. 23–24 He said Peace be unto you again, commissioned them as the Father had sent Him, breathed on them and said Receive ye the Holy Ghost, and then spoke the word about remitting and retaining sins.18MR 96.4–97.2Ms 72, 1902, par. 23–24 That word is His legacy of peace to His church and comfort in a trying hour that His followers would be under the guidance of the Holy Spirit.18MR 96.4–97.2Ms 72, 1902, par. 23–24 Those who accept Him by living faith receive power to become sons of God, enter His school as His students, and need not be troubled or anxious, for He will ratify His promise to them and fulfill all His promises without restricting His word.18MR 96.4–97.2
The appearance took place in the upper chamber where the disciples had gathered in grief and despair.AA 26.1 They had fastened the doors because they feared they would share their Teacher's fate.AA 26.1 It was the same room where He had met with them for the last supper and where He appeared to them after His resurrection.Ms 55, 1911, par. 29
The authority over sins remitted or retained belongs within the commission in which they were sent as the Father sent Christ.Ms 149, 1897, par. 4–7Ms 113, 1897, par. 20–21 They were sent to preach and teach the gospel in His name, and they received the Holy Spirit as the spiritual life and qualification for that work.Ms 149, 1897, par. 4–7 Their service was to reflect His character and example, so that His followers could work as He did.Ms 149, 1897, par. 4–7Ms 113, 1897, par. 20–21 No one is to undertake God's work presumptuously, but only under the Spirit's evident supervision.Ms 113, 1897, par. 20–21
The authority concerning sins they remit or retain was given in connection with receiving the Holy Spirit.Ms 155, 1904, par. 12–13Ms 144, 1897, par. 31–32Ms 155, 1904, par. 11 The surrounding account of Thomas shows the importance of believing the disciples' testimony about Jesus' death and resurrection rather than demanding physical proof.Ms 155, 1904, par. 12–13
Meaning and Limits
After His resurrection Christ delegated power to His church on earth in its organized capacity concerning the remission and retention of sins.RCOC 8.34T 17.2ST May 24, 1883Ms 135, 1901, par. 29ST Apr 1, 1913 That delegation places upon those who hold responsible positions an authority that cannot be lightly esteemed or lightly dismissed.RCOC 8.34T 17.2ST May 24, 1883Ms 135, 1901, par. 29ST Apr 1, 1913 The disciples, filled with the Holy Spirit, were commissioned to preach forgiveness through the merits of the sin-pardoning Saviour, with heaven ratifying work done in Christ's spirit and power.3SP 244.2–245.1 The united church thus has rightful restraint and discipline over its members, and connection to it is not to be easily canceled.RCOC 8.3ST Apr 1, 1913
The verse does not give individuals permission or authority to pass judgment on others, for that judgment belongs to God.GW 502.1–2DA 805.2–3DA 805.4–806.2 It gives the organized church responsibility to address members who fall into sin, not a license for private judging.GW 502.1–2DA 805.2–3DA 805.4–806.2 It does not give apostles or their successors personal power to remove guilt, erase sin's stain, or pronounce God's final judgment.Ms 149, 1897, par. 8–113SP 244.2–245.16RED 82.1–83.1ST Oct 10, 18783SP 246.1–247.1 Remission of sins belongs to God alone and to Christ alone, who only can save and forgive, while the Holy Spirit convicts of sin, righteousness, and judgment.Ms 149, 1897, par. 8–113SP 244.2–245.16RED 82.1–83.1ST Oct 10, 18783SP 246.1–247.1
What is committed is that Christ's chosen ministers are to prescribe and publish the terms on which salvation rests, setting forth the obedience that brings forgiveness and the disobedience that keeps sins retained.Ms 21, 1889, par. 65–66 This amazing power is delegated to them as they act in the place of Christ in church discipline, and God remits or retains according to the terms they prescribe as the proper foundation.Ms 21, 1889, par. 65–66 They are not left to exercise this power merely according to their own human judgment and strength of memory.Ms 21, 1889, par. 65–66
The church, acting in its organized capacity and according to inspired rules, may censure or remove censure and may assure a repentant sinner of the Saviour's forgiveness, but it cannot erase sin or wield arbitrary power over conscience.Ms 149, 1897, par. 8–113SP 244.2–245.16RED 82.1–83.1ST Oct 10, 18783SP 246.1–247.1 The verse allows no arbitrary power over another's conscience, no granting of absolution, no selling of indulgences, no accepting a bribe to conceal sin, and no personally executing God's judgment against the guilty.6RED 82.1–83.1ST Oct 10, 1878 Christ alone forgives, and He will judge the impenitent and execute judgment against them.6RED 82.1–83.1ST Oct 10, 1878
Faithful Church Discipline
The organized church bears responsibility to deal with members who fall into sin, by warning, instructing, and laboring to restore them.GW 502.1–2DA 805.2–3DA 805.4–806.2 When wrongdoing persists, it must faithfully name the sin and declare God's judgment upon it from Scripture.GW 502.1–2DA 805.2–3DA 805.4–806.2 It must not sanction persistent sin nor by silence or action appear to approve the deeds of the impenitent.GW 502.1–2DA 805.2–3DA 805.4–806.2
Alongside faithful reproof the church is to proclaim Christ's forgiving mercy and urge sinners to repent and believe in the sin-pardoning Saviour.3SP 244.2–245.1DA 805.2–3DA 805.4–806.2ST Oct 10, 18783SP 246.1–247.1 On the authority of God's word it may assure the repentant sinner of the Saviour's forgiveness, accept that repentance, and declare forgiveness.3SP 244.2–245.1DA 805.2–3DA 805.4–806.2ST Oct 10, 18783SP 246.1–247.1 Censure laid according to inspired directions is to be removed when the offender confesses and repents, and the restored one is to be received back into fellowship with grateful hearts.Ms 149, 1897, par. 8–113SP 244.2–245.1DA 805.2–3ST Oct 10, 18783SP 246.1–247.1
When the church acts in its organized capacity according to God's directions, word, and Spirit, its judgment is ratified in heaven.GW 502.1–23SP 244.2–245.1DA 805.2–36RED 82.1–83.1DA 805.4–806.2 This holds both for retaining sins through censure of the offender and for remitting sins through acquittal, removal of censure, and restoration.3SP 244.2–245.1DA 805.2–36RED 82.1–83.1DA 805.4–806.2ST Oct 10, 1878 Work done in Christ's spirit and power and according to inspired rules carries heaven's endorsement, whether it condemns persistent wrong or affirms forgiveness to the penitent.3SP 244.2–245.1DA 805.2–36RED 82.1–83.1ST Oct 10, 18783SP 246.1–247.1
Such work cannot be done without the Holy Spirit, given for these special duties of the church.3SP 244.2–245.1DA 805.2–3ST Oct 10, 1878 It calls for prayer, faith, and spiritual discernment, and for decision together by responsible, consecrated, Spirit-taught representatives rather than by one person's judgment.Ms 149, 1897, par. 8–11DA 805.2–3ST Oct 10, 18783SP 246.1–247.1 Decisions must not rest on prejudice nor be arbitrary or bought, and those who act must show Christ's character in a way the head of the church can endorse.Ms 21, 1889, par. 65–66Ms 149, 1897, par. 8–11ST Oct 10, 1878 Mere human judgment and strength of memory are insufficient, since they may condemn those who should be commended or uphold those doing evil, whereas God remits or retains according to the terms of obedience and disobedience set forth from His word.Ms 21, 1889, par. 65–66Ms 149, 1897, par. 8–11ST Oct 10, 1878
The authority thus placed upon those holding responsible positions cannot be lightly esteemed or dismissed.RCOC 8.34T 17.2ST May 24, 1883Ms 135, 1901, par. 29ST Apr 1, 1913 This remains true even though leaders share the common faults of others and may err in their decisions.RCOC 8.34T 17.2ST May 24, 1883Ms 135, 1901, par. 29ST Mar 9, 1876 Individual judgment must submit to the verdict and voice of the united church rather than exalting private opinion above it.RCOC 8.3ST Apr 1, 1913 Members are to realize the sacredness of church relations, submit to its restraint and discipline, and not easily cancel their connection with it.RCOC 8.3ST Apr 1, 1913 Unity and Christian fellowship are necessary, for in union only is strength, while refusal to submit and encouragement of independence and opposition bring anarchy and confusion, and these directions remain valid until the end of time.RCOC 8.3ST Apr 1, 19133SP 246.1–247.1
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
89 sources
Christ's words give no man power in himself to pardon sin against God, for that belongs to God alone through Christ.ST Dec 10, 1894ST Aug 9, 1899ST May 30, 1906 They entrust a declarative authority to be exercised by proclaiming the gospel and its conditions, so that those who believe, receive and truly confess are declared forgiven and saved, and those who reject and refuse to confess are declared bound and lost.ST Nov 22, 1910ST Mar 8, 1905ST Apr 23, 1896ST Jul 18, 1911 That authority lives in God's message and Word itself, not in office, ordination or personal judgment, and it holds only as long as those who speak act in Christ's Spirit and under the Spirit's direction through the Word, when heaven ratifies their work.ST Jul 17, 1907ST Nov 22, 1910ST Mar 4, 1897ST Apr 11, 1900 What was spoken to Peter was spoken to all the apostles and is given to the church as a body in its organized capacity for all time, belonging to every true minister and follower who faithfully bears God's message, and giving Peter no supremacy or headship.ST May 24, 1905ST Jul 7, 1898ST Mar 4, 1897ST Aug 9, 1899ST Sep 29, 1881 In practice the church is thus to restore the repentant by assuring them of Christ's forgiving mercy and to withdraw fellowship from the impenitent by declaring God's judgment from His Word, an act pronounced on earth and ratified in heaven.ST May 24, 1905ST May 24, 1883RH May 13, 1909RH Jun 30, 1874RH Sep 14, 1916 It does not make confession to priests the means of assurance nor give priests in penance power truly to forgive or retain at their own sentence and control salvation, a claim condemned as a blasphemous assumption of divine power belonging to God the Father alone.ST May 4, 1876RH Jun 30, 1874RH Feb 8, 1912ST Jan 3, 1884RH May 24, 1870
Resurrection Evening Setting
John 20:23 belongs to Jesus' only recorded meeting with his disciples on the resurrection day, held in the evening as the first day was closing into the second, with Thomas absent.ST Apr 22, 1897ST Nov 24, 1898RH Jul 6, 1911 It records Jesus breathing the Holy Spirit upon the disciples and speaking to them at the close of that evening meeting, giving them the commission to preach, which was repeatedly kept before them as they prepared to carry the gospel to the world.RH Nov 14, 1871ST Jan 9, 1893 It was Christ's first meeting with the apostles after his resurrection, when he showed them that he was risen, and it was not a religious gathering to celebrate Sunday.RH Jul 6, 1911
The disciples were not gathered to honor the day or in expectation of the risen Christ, because they did not yet know he must rise from the dead.ST Apr 22, 1897 They were frightened, doubting, discouraged and divided, supposing him to be a ghost, slow of heart to grasp his plain teaching, and he reproved their unbelief.ST Apr 22, 1897ST Jun 26, 1901RH Jul 8, 1909 He repeatedly gave them a message of peace, spoke peace to them, showed himself risen, approved them, commissioned them and imparted the Holy Spirit.ST Feb 27, 1896RH Oct 3, 1854RH Jul 8, 1909 His blessing of peace, as a pledge of his presence, changed hatred to love, strife to fellowship and doubt to assurance, revealed the living Christ to them, strengthened them to proclaim that he was risen, and prepared them for Pentecostal baptism and obedience to the great commission.RH Jul 8, 1909RH Jul 6, 1911
The gathering was intended to establish the fact of his resurrection and their belief in it, and to instruct them about their future work.RH Nov 24, 1868RH Apr 1, 1873 In that interview he resumed the teaching work he had carried on before his crucifixion, showing that his work did not cease on that day.RH Aug 1, 1871 The commission together with his appearances and the gift of the Holy Ghost marked the resurrection day as having special significance for the disciples' future guidance.RH Sep 26, 1854RH Oct 3, 1854
The risen Christ seen in this setting, risen from the dead, has become the first-fruits of them that slept, a fact of history better attested than any other, on which salvation depends and by which the truth of his word is tested and proved.ST Jun 14, 1905 He showed himself to his disciples as one born of the Spirit, a quickening spirit bearing the image of the heavenly.RH Sep 15, 1874 The new birth that begins with conversion is perfected at the resurrection when the just become immortal and become spirit, like the wind that blows where it wishes and cannot be traced, and every immortalized saint will be the same.RH Sep 15, 1874
That resurrection was farthest from their expectation when he appeared alive to the apostles, and the same surprise will happen at his second advent.ST Jun 26, 1901 Then masses of professed disciples will be as ill prepared for his sudden appearance as his disappointed followers were to see him alive, but those who love his appearing and believe his word will be looking for him.ST Jun 26, 1901 Blessed are they that have not seen, and yet have believed.ST Jun 26, 1901
His breathing on the disciples administered peace and the earnest of the abundant outpouring of the Spirit, with which he blessed them and gave them spiritual instruction.RH Aug 1, 1854RH Apr 1, 1873 That earnest was fulfilled in the outpouring at Pentecost, identified as the fiftieth day after Passover began, whose day of the week cannot be established from Scripture.RH Aug 1, 1854 The same greeting of peace was given at a later meeting on Monday evening.RH Aug 1, 1854
Spirit Given Commission
Jesus sent the disciples as the Father had sent him, then breathed on them, gave them the Holy Spirit, and entrusted them with remitting and retaining sins.ST May 24, 1905ST May 24, 1905ST Apr 24, 1901 This trust concerning whose sins are forgiven and whose are retained belongs to his evening meeting with them on resurrection day and to his commission to preach the gospel.RH Nov 14, 1871ST Jan 9, 1893RH Nov 14, 1871 That commission was repeatedly kept before them as they prepared to carry the gospel to the world.ST Jan 9, 1893
Receiving the Holy Spirit enabled them to carry out the work he sent them to do, including forgiving sins or retaining them.STST Apr 11, 1900 Without the Spirit they could not carry it out, for the gift at that time prepared them for their official work while the fuller outpouring needed to carry the gospel to the world came after Christ's ascension.ST The Spirit gives spiritual life, imparts Christ's life and character, and enables those who receive it to represent Christ in church ministry.ST Empowered by the Spirit they were commissioned to preach the merits of a Savior who pardons sin, and that sacred work carried tremendous results.ST Apr 11, 1900ST Apr 11, 1900
The Spirit given when he breathed on them was the same Spirit given at Pentecost, but then only in limited measure and as an earnest.STST Sep 10, 1902RH Apr 1, 1873 They could not receive it fully until Pentecost, with the abundant outpouring coming afterward.STST Sep 10, 1902RH Aug 1, 1854 His breathing on them administered peace, fulfilled in the outpouring on the fiftieth day after Passover began.RH Aug 1, 1854RH Apr 1, 1873
The delegated authority to remit and retain holds only as long as those exercising it are guided by the Spirit through the Word.ST Mar 4, 1897ST Jan 22, 1902 The Spirit's judgment does not err, and when Christ's followers speak under the Spirit's direction their words carry God's command rather than their own judgment.ST Mar 4, 1897ST Jan 22, 1902 When they act in Christ's spirit and power, heaven ratifies their work of declaring sins forgiven or retained.ST Apr 11, 1900CO 80.1ST Jun 3, 1897ST Apr 11, 1900 Imbued with the Spirit they go forth preaching the merits of a sin-pardoning Saviour with the assurance that all heaven is interested in their labors and what they do on earth in the Spirit and power of Christ is endorsed in heaven.ST Mar 4, 1897CO 80.1ST Jun 3, 1897
Meaning of Remitting Retaining
No man is given power in the fullest sense to forgive sins committed against God, for that belongs to God alone through Christ, the only name under heaven by which men are saved, although men can forgive trespasses committed against themselves.ST Oct 10, 1878ST Dec 10, 1894ST May 30, 1906ST Jun 3, 1897ST Apr 24, 1901 Even an apostle or an angel can impart nothing beyond the gospel, and ministers do not themselves grant forgiveness but proclaim it through the Spirit and the Word.ST Aug 9, 1899ST May 30, 1906ST Jun 3, 1897 Christ's ambassadors do not personally forgive sins or impose God's judgment by themselves; they declare God's word and the conditions on which forgiveness is given, so that those who receive that word in faith are forgiven and those who reject it are condemned.ST Oct 10, 1878ST Aug 9, 1899ST May 30, 1906 The authority is not power to pardon sin, which is against God, but authority to proclaim God's judgment, exercised when remission comes through preaching the Word so that people believe the gospel, as on the day of Pentecost.ST Oct 10, 1878ST May 30, 1906ST Jun 3, 1897 Remitting and retaining is done only through the Word: receiving the Word secures remission, rejecting the Word leaves sin retained, and if the church deals faithfully with fallen members, the forgiveness it declares toward the repentant is recognized in heaven and the judgment of the Word it pronounces upon those persisting in sin is endorsed by God as the great Judge of all.ST Oct 10, 1878ST Dec 10, 1894ST Apr 24, 1901
Christ's ministers do not remit or retain sins by personal power, nor by office, denomination, ordination, or their own judgment.ST Jul 17, 1907ST Nov 22, 1910ST Dec 3, 1894 Their authority rests on living connection with God and the gospel message they bear, coming through the Holy Spirit and the message preached, and the same principle applies to every true minister who faithfully bears God's message.ST Jul 17, 1907ST Dec 3, 1894 That word, rather than a minister's own judgment, has power to save or condemn, so the message and not the messenger's own authority saves or condemns.ST Jul 17, 1907ST Jul 18, 1911 The power and authority are in God's message itself, not in the men themselves or their successors, and a claim of religious office without that true message does not carry it.ST Jul 18, 1911ST Dec 3, 1894ST Sep 10, 1902 Those who bear the message are accountable to God for how they present it, and those who hear it are accountable for their response.ST Jul 18, 1911
The authority is declarative and is exercised by proclaiming the gospel with its terms, conditions, and judgments, not by independently granting or withholding forgiveness.ST Nov 22, 1910ST Mar 8, 1905ST Apr 23, 1896 When sinners comply with His word their sins are forgiven, and when they refuse their sins are retained; those who believe, receive, and truly confess are declared forgiven, justified, released, and saved, while those who reject, refuse to confess, or slight it are declared retained, bound, condemned, and lost.ST Nov 22, 1910ST Mar 8, 1905 Ministers proclaim the Word of God which gives life and states the conditions for God's forgiveness and acceptance, teaching what sin is and the conditions for forgiveness, so they may assure a repentant person who confesses that those sins are forgiven and declare that sins remain with those who refuse to confess or do not truly confess.ST Nov 22, 1910ST Mar 8, 1905 God authorized the apostles to proclaim His word setting out the terms of salvation and offering salvation to those who receive it, and what was spoken to all the disciples and entrusted to apostles and ministers for all time is exercised by powerfully proclaiming the gospel and its conditions, so that those who accept it are saved and those who reject it are lost.ST Apr 23, 1896ST Jul 7, 1898 Christ's servants absolve from sin only through ministering the Word of God in Christ's Spirit.
As with Jeremiah's declarations to uproot, destroy, build and plant, the proclaimed word carries out God's purposes, bringing life to some and death to others.ST Apr 23, 1896 Human forgiveness may rest on words, but God weighs motives.ST Jul 18, 1911ST Nov 22, 1910 The verse expresses the same authority as the promise of the keys of the kingdom of heaven, which is the church of Christ, and the power to bind and loose.RH Jun 30, 1874ST Jul 24, 1907ST Nov 4, 1930ST Dec 3, 1894 To bind and to loose is to bid and forbid, to grant and refuse, to declare lawful or unlawful, to determine what is binding on conscience and what persons ought or ought not to be admitted to the church, and to decide on the character of those whose sins were or were not forgiven, with what is bound or loosed on earth in these things bound or loosed in heaven.RH Jun 30, 1874ST Dec 3, 1894 The keys are the Old and New Testaments and the authority to admit proper persons and exclude improper persons, exercised through the living word preached and through preaching the gospel and administering the sacraments, opening the kingdom to those who hear and believe and barring those who reject, as when Peter first preached to the Jews at Pentecost and later to the Gentiles, so that if the gospel word when declared truly is received it releases men from sins for salvation and they are loosed in heaven, and if rejected it leaves men bound by iniquity in condemnation and they are bound in heaven.RH Jun 30, 1874ST Jul 24, 1907ST Nov 4, 1930ST Dec 3, 1894ST Feb 21, 1906 Through this ministry people receive eternal gifts — righteousness, the Holy Spirit, and everlasting life — not bodily or civil power, and the verse does not authorize coercion, control of civil government, or wielding the sword.ST Feb 21, 1906 A person's forgiveness of someone who sinned against him does not determine whether God forgives that person, for the verse concerns gospel ministers declaring through their message the conditions on which sins are forgiven or retained.ST Nov 22, 1910
Recipients of the Authority
What was spoken to Peter was spoken also to all the apostles and disciples, so the power to bind and loose and to remit and retain sins belongs to them together and not to Peter alone.ST Jul 7, 1898ST Aug 9, 1899ST Sep 29, 1881ST Jul 24, 1907ST Dec 3, 1894 It gives Peter no supremacy, headship, or exclusive power over his fellow apostles and no warrant for a continuing line of successors with supreme power, for Jesus alone is head of the church with authority to forgive.ST Sep 29, 1881ST Nov 4, 1930ST Dec 3, 1894 They exercise it by powerfully proclaiming the gospel and its conditions through the Spirit and the Word, declaring sins remitted for those who believe, receive and truly confess, and retained for those who reject, refuse to confess or slight it.ST Jul 7, 1898ST Aug 9, 1899ST Dec 3, 1894 Forgiveness itself belongs to God and is given through Christ, so ministers do not themselves grant it by personal power, office, ordination or own judgment, and even an apostle or angel cannot impart anything beyond the gospel.ST Jul 17, 1907ST Aug 9, 1899ST Dec 3, 1894 This is the same authority as the promise of the keys of the kingdom, which is the church of Christ, to open the kingdom by the living word preached to those who hear and believe and to bar those who reject, with the keys being the Old and New Testaments.ST Jul 24, 1907ST Nov 4, 1930ST Dec 3, 1894 Thus Peter first preached to the Jews at Pentecost and later to the Gentiles, who heard the gospel through him, and if the word is received it releases men for salvation and they are loosed in heaven, while if rejected it leaves men bound by iniquity in condemnation and they are bound in heaven.ST Jul 24, 1907ST Dec 3, 1894
The trust is given to the church as a body in its organized capacity and for all time, not as personal power bestowed upon the disciples as individuals.ST May 24, 1905ST Mar 4, 1897ST May 24, 1905 No single man has liberty to pass judgment upon others, for judgment is the prerogative of God alone, and decisions are not to rest on one person's judgment, prejudice or arbitrary will, nor to be bought, but require prayer, faith, spiritual discernment and responsible consecrated members.ST May 24, 1905ST Oct 10, 1878RH May 13, 1909 The visible church has both authority and duty to maintain its unity and purity and bears responsibility for its individual members, warning, instructing and if possible restoring those who fall into sin by saying about sin what God says and dealing with it as God directs from his Word.ST May 24, 1905RH May 13, 1909RH Sep 14, 1916 Toward the repentant it preaches forgiveness through Christ the only Savior, assures the sinner of forgiving mercy through his merits, accepts the person and leads from unbelief and guilt into faith and righteousness.ST Oct 10, 1878ST Mar 4, 1897 If sinners persist in sin and disown Christ, the church must name the wrong, declare God's judgment from his Word, censure, refuse to sanction the conduct and receive, exclude or disfellowship, and its faithful action is pronounced on earth and ratified in heaven, while action contrary to Christ's instructions has no heavenly confirmation.ST May 24, 1905RH May 13, 1909RH Sep 14, 1916 Such church action does not itself remove guilt or sin's stain, for remission comes only through Christ's merits and the preaching of the Word that leads men to believe, as on the day of Pentecost, and he alone executes judgment against the impenitent; the church must show she does not sanction evil deeds or she herself dishonors her Lord, and he who despises the church's authority in this work despises Christ's.ST May 24, 1905ST Oct 10, 1878ST Mar 4, 1897RH May 13, 1909
The same commission applies for all time to every true minister and follower in whom God's Word is living who faithfully bears God's message in Christ's Spirit, for Christ's servants absolve from sin only through ministering the Word of God which gives life and states the conditions for forgiveness and acceptance.ST Jul 17, 1907ST Feb 16, 1915 The authority rests in the message borne, not in Peter or any other person or religious office, so accepting the gospel brings salvation and freedom while rejecting it brings bondage and destruction, and a claim of office without that true message carries nothing.ST Jul 17, 1907ST May 18, 1904ST Feb 16, 1915 It is entrusted to those holding responsible positions in the church, whose authority cannot be lightly esteemed even though those leaders have faults in common with others and may err in decisions.ST May 24, 1883ST Apr 1, 1913 Members must realize the sacredness of church relations and submit to its restraint and discipline rather than exalting private judgment above the united church or encouraging opposition to its voice, and connection to the church is not to be easily canceled.ST Apr 1, 1913
Those who held the gift to have been unique taught that on that special occasion when Christ breathed on them the apostles received a particular, specific endowment of power to remit or retain sins, distinct from the later power from on high for which they were to wait in Jerusalem as another operation of the Holy Spirit.RH Oct 8, 1901RH Jun 11, 1901RH Nov 19, 1901 In that teaching it was not intended to continue in the church, pass to successors, or be possessed later, nor could the apostles transfer it, and preaching forgiveness of sins in Christ's name is distinct from personally removing guilt, which God alone can do.RH Oct 8, 1901RH Jun 11, 1901RH Nov 19, 1901 Peter's dealings with Ananias and Sapphira illustrate the apostles' power to retain sins.RH Jun 11, 1901 The verse is cited as an example of apostolic supernatural authority to punish offenders, including through disease or death, supporting a literal destruction of the flesh in 1 Corinthians 5:5.RH Jun 11, 1901RH Sep 15, 1859
Church Discipline in Practice
After his resurrection Christ delegated to his church on earth power concerning the remission and retention of sins, giving an authority to those who hold responsible positions in it that cannot be lightly esteemed.ST May 24, 1883ST Apr 1, 1913ST Mar 9, 1876 Even though those leaders have faults in common with other people and may err in their decisions, members must realize the sacredness of church relations and submit to its restraint and discipline.ST May 24, 1883ST Apr 1, 1913ST Mar 9, 1876 They are not to exalt private judgment above the judgment of the united church nor encourage opposition to its voice, and connection to the church is not to be easily canceled.ST Apr 1, 1913
Ministers in this work are ambassadors of the government of God on earth who do not represent themselves but the principles and law at the foundation of his government in heaven and on earth.RH May 25, 1905 Behind such an ambassador stands all the power and influence of that government, so that when true to heaven all the authority of heaven is vested in them and their word carries the force of law as a consul's word carries his government's authority.RH May 25, 1905
The trust gives no single man liberty to pass judgment upon others, for judgment is the prerogative of God alone, but places responsibility and duty on the visible church in its organized capacity to maintain its unity and purity and to bear responsibility for its individual members.ST May 24, 1905RH May 13, 1909RH Sep 14, 1916 Toward those who fall into sin the church must warn, instruct, and if possible restore, saying about sin what God says about it and dealing with it as God directs from his Word by declaring what God has said.ST May 24, 1905ST May 24, 1905RH May 13, 1909RH Sep 14, 1916CO 82.1 It is to direct the erring to Christ, encourage repentance and faith, and lead from unbelief and guilt into faith and righteousness.ST May 24, 1905ST Oct 10, 1878CO 82.1 Toward the repentant it declares forgiveness, assures the sinner of the Saviour's forgiving mercy through his merits, and accepts the person, and this remission is ratified in heaven.ST May 24, 1905ST Oct 10, 1878CO 82.1
If sinners persist in sin they disown Christ, and the church must name the wrong, declare God's judgment from his Word, censure, refuse to sanction the conduct, and show she does not sanction their deeds lest she herself dishonor her Lord.ST May 24, 1905RH May 13, 1909RH Sep 14, 1916 In this discipline the church receives and dismisses members, admits proper persons and excludes improper persons, which is the power of the keys of the kingdom, which is the church of Christ, and the power to bind and loose, that is to bid and forbid, to grant and refuse, to declare lawful or unlawful.RH Jun 30, 1874ST Aug 26, 1880CO 21.1–2 When guided by the Holy Spirit and standing in the light of truth, its faithful action in receiving or disfellowshipping members is pronounced on earth and ratified in heaven by God's settled Word.ST May 24, 1905RH May 13, 1909RH Sep 14, 1916ST Aug 26, 1880CO 21.1–2 Action contrary to Christ's instructions has no heavenly confirmation, for the church's authority to remit or retain sins is not independent authority but holds only when it acts according to God's Word.CO 21.1–2 He who despises the authority of the church in this work despises the authority of Christ himself.RH May 13, 1909RH Sep 14, 1916
This power to censure and to remove censure according to the rules prescribed by inspiration and Scripture is to be exercised only by men of good repute consecrated by Christ as Head of the church who show by their lives that they earnestly seek to follow the guidance of the Spirit of God.ST Oct 10, 1878ST Mar 4, 1897ST Jun 3, 1897 Such decisions require prayer, faith and spiritual discernment, are not to rest on one person's judgment or prejudice, and are not to be arbitrary or bought.ST Oct 10, 1878ST Jun 3, 1897 The church's act does not itself remove guilt or sin's stain and men themselves do not pardon sin, for Jesus is the only name under heaven whereby men are saved.ST May 24, 1905ST Oct 10, 1878ST Jun 3, 1897 Remission comes only through Christ's merits and through the ministration of God's servants in proclaiming the Word of God and preaching the merits of a sin-pardoning Saviour so that people believe the gospel, as demonstrated on the day of Pentecost, with the assurance that all heaven is interested in their labors and that what they do on earth in the Spirit and power of Christ will be ratified in heaven.ST May 24, 1905ST Oct 10, 1878ST Mar 4, 1897ST Jun 3, 1897
The authority to retain sins is not rightly used when churches try and condemn members for disagreeing with their creeds rather than the Bible.RH Feb 25, 1862 Nor does it authorize church leaders to coerce people, control civil government, or wield the power of the sword.ST Feb 21, 1906 Exercised through preaching the gospel and administering the sacraments as the power of the keys, it ministers eternal gifts of righteousness, the Holy Spirit and everlasting life, not bodily or civil power.ST Feb 21, 1906
Against Priestly Absolution Claims
John 20:23 is one of the difficult texts that is used to argue for Peter's supremacy and for Catholic authority to remit or retain sins, and it requires explanation against interpretations that twist Scripture to support those claims.RH Nov 12, 1901
It does not give priests power to absolve sins committed after baptism in the sacrament of penance, nor does it refer to the sacrament of repentance.RH Jun 30, 1874
It does not make auricular confession to priests the divinely instituted means of assurance, though it is presented as granting apostolic priests power to forgive sins so that confession to priests is treated as the means by which people receive assurance of absolution.ST Jan 3, 1884
Its meaning is the same as the promise of the keys of the kingdom of heaven, which is the church of Christ, and the power to bind and loose.RH Jun 30, 1874
The keys are authority to admit proper persons to the church and to exclude improper persons from it, and to bind and to loose is to bid and forbid, to grant and refuse, to declare lawful or unlawful.RH Jun 30, 1874
The claim that priests can truly forgive or retain sins, rather than merely declare them forgiven, is condemned as a blasphemous assumption of divine power.RH Feb 8, 1912RH May 24, 1870
On that claim a priest can grant or refuse absolution with the sinner's pardon depending on the priest's sentence, so that God must follow the priest's judgment.RH May 24, 1870
That gives priests control over salvation and power to shut people out of heaven.RH Feb 8, 1912
To pardon or retain men's sins is to save or destroy their souls, and that power belongs to God the Father alone.ST Aug 20, 1894
To claim it for the pope sitting on the papal chair as divine vicegerent of the world and infallible ruler of conscience, sitting aloft above magistrates and kings with power to annul their laws, cast them down from their thrones, plant or pluck up nations, and abrogate even the precepts of the moral law, writing on the papal chair that it is the seat of God and the throne of the infallible and holy One, is to deny God the Father.ST Aug 20, 1894
The verse is invoked for the claim that Christ gave priests alone authority to forgive sins and to declare a sinner accepted by God or still bound by sin, as a human claim to power over forgiveness that belongs to God.RH Aug 4, 1910
It is connected with the claim that Christ gave the pope authority to forgive sins as his representative, so that the pope can forgive all sin.RH May 30, 1912
It concerns the power to retain or remit sins, a power belonging to God at the final judgment, yet it is invoked in connection with the claim that a priest exercises this power in the confessional and can condemn or absolve a person, even determining a soul's eternal reward or punishment.ST Aug 24, 1915
Whether such acts are Christ's or antichrist's depends on whether the one performing them has Christ's authority and stands for Christ.ST Mar 19, 1912
The papal application to priests who hear confessions and absolve penitents is therefore challenged by whether Christ truly appointed that church as his representative, since the verse is presented as a grant of authority that the papacy applies to its ministers to remit and retain sins.
Ordination does not give even a wicked priest spiritual discernment or the power to save, for a carnal-minded person cannot know spiritual truth or discern who is a sinner, though the verse is invoked in connection with the claim that priests have authority to remit sins and to bind in heaven and on earth.ST Jan 16, 1896
The apostles received the Holy Ghost so they could infallibly declare the will of God to mankind, determine what is binding on conscience, show what persons ought or ought not to be admitted to the church, and decide on the character of those whose sins were or were not forgiven.ST May 4, 1876RH Jun 30, 1874
Whatever they bound or loosed on earth in these things would be bound or loosed in heaven.RH Jun 30, 1874
Remitting and retaining sins therefore does not give power to absolve individuals through a sacrament, but concerns faithful decisions about church membership and the standing of people's sins before God through declaring God's will and judging whether people should be admitted to or excluded from the church.ST May 4, 1876
No Proof for Sunday
John 20:23 contains no statement that the first day is sanctified and no instruction to change the Sabbath.RH Nov 14, 1871RH Nov 14, 1871 The record of the Lord meeting his disciples on the first day of the week gives no command for a Sunday sabbath and no divine example of one, but disproves any first-day sabbath.ST Oct 21, 1897 That appearance on the first day of the week does not prove that the first day became the Sabbath or that the seventh day ceased to be holy.RH Nov 29, 1853 The account of Christ appearing to the disciples on the day of his resurrection, breathing on them and sending them out, does not say that he changed the Sabbath or instituted Sunday observance, since the words spoken about such a change are not recorded and therefore the meeting cannot serve as evidence that Christ authorized a new Sabbath day.ST Jul 31, 1884 The verse belongs to Jesus' only recorded meeting with his disciples on the resurrection day, held in the evening as the first day was closing into the second, when the disciples were not gathered to honor the day or in expectation of the risen Christ because they did not yet know he must rise from the dead, but were frightened, supposing him to be a ghost, and he reproved them for unbelief, and the next meeting was after eight days, not on the next first day, so the verse gives no proof that Christ kept the first day or made it the Christian Sabbath.ST Apr 22, 1897 Merely meeting on a day does not change that day's character, and the verse gives no indication that Jesus appointed the first day of the week as a holy day.RH Nov 14, 1871
The gathering was intended to establish the fact of his resurrection, not to honor the first day of the week or make it sacred.RH Nov 24, 1868 It was not a religious gathering to celebrate Sunday, but Christ's first meeting with the apostles on the evening of the resurrection day when he showed them that he was risen, and the verse about remitting and retaining sins belongs to this appearance and does not establish a Sabbath transfer. It was not presented as a planned worship service or as evidence that the first day had become a Sabbath, since Jesus' greeting of peace to the disciples does not establish a new Sabbath, even though they were gathered in Jerusalem and Thomas was absent.RH May 5, 1851 The disciples' gathering on the day of Jesus' resurrection was when he appeared to them, approved them, commissioned them, and imparted the Holy Spirit, and these events marked the day as having special significance for the disciples' future guidance.RH Oct 3, 1854 The transactions are mentioned as possessing no peculiar characteristics affecting the mere time on which they occurred, with no inauguration of a new institution by Christ's own action, no explanation that his object was to consecrate those hours to religious use from that time forward, and no command to repeat them in remembrance of him as with the Lord's Supper.RH Nov 5, 1872
The next meeting was after eight days, not on the next first day.ST Apr 22, 1897 The later meeting took place more than eight days after the first and therefore could not have fallen before the second or third day of the week, so these two meetings offered as circumstantial evidence for changing the Sabbath do not prove that Christ transferred Sabbath observance to the first day of the week.RH Sep 17, 1857 They give no foundation for the conviction that Christ withdrew his regard from the day of his Father's rest and placed it upon the day of his own resurrection.RH Nov 5, 1872
John 20:23 is presented as giving the apostles supreme authority to legislate for the church, but it records no explicit command from them to abandon the seventh-day Sabbath and observe the first day instead.ST May 13, 1886 It is cited as saying that the apostles received from Christ the power of forgiving sins on the day they received their commission, and this is presented as one reason for changing the Sabbath to Sunday.ST Nov 11, 1913 It is cited as the occasion when Jesus gave the apostles power to forgive sins on the first day of the week, and this is presented as one reason for changing the weekly day of worship from the seventh day to Sunday.RH Oct 23, 1913
For the claim that these first-day meetings after his resurrection both introduce Sunday observance and make obligatory the distinguishing of the first day from the remaining days as sacred from profane to establish Sunday, three things must be proved: that the resurrection effected the change, that Christ's practice of meeting on that day was designed to be exemplary and to be imitated, and that he not only sanctified the first day but secularized the seventh day, which was commanded by God the Father and remains obligatory, so that keeping the first day for Christ the Son would otherwise stand alongside keeping the seventh day for God the Father rather than replacing it.RH Nov 5, 1872
The claim that the apostles received their commission and authority to forgive sins on Sunday as a reason to change the day of rest and worship provides no proof for changing the Sabbath.RH Nov 6, 1913 These events do not establish a transfer of the Sabbath blessing from the seventh day to the first, for Jesus' breathing on the disciples administering peace, connected with the claim that they would receive the Holy Ghost, was fulfilled in the outpouring at Pentecost on the fiftieth day after Passover began, whose day of the week cannot be established from Scripture, and the same greeting of peace was given at a later meeting on Monday evening.RH Aug 1, 1854
Sources