John 8:41
Ye do the deeds of your father. Then said they to him, We be not born of fornication; we have one Father, even God.
Translations
You do the deeds of your father. Then said they to him, We be not born of fornication; we have one Father, even God.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
Ye do the deeds of your father. Then said they to him, We be not born of fornication; we have one Father, even God.
Ye do the deeds of your father. Then said they to him, We are not born of fornication; we have one Father, even God.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
Ye do the works of your father. They said unto him, We were not born of fornication; we have one Father, even God.
ye do the works of your father.' They said, therefore, to him, 'We of whoredom have not been born; one Father we have — God;'
Ye do the works of your father. They said [therefore] to him, We are not born of fornication; we have one father, God.
Ye, are doing the works of your father. They said unto him—We, of fornication, were not born: One father, have we—God.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
You are doing the works of your father.”“ We are not illegitimate children,” they declared. “ Our only Father is God Himself.”
You do the works of your father.”They said to him, “ We were not born of sexual immorality. We have one Father, God.”
You are doing the works of your father. They said to him, We are true sons of Abraham; we have one Father, who is God.
Ye do the workes of your father. Then said they to him, We are not borne of fornication: we haue one Father, which is God.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
You do the works of your father. They said therefore to him: We are not born of fornication: we have one Father, even God.
Cross-references 20 of 29
- Matthew 3:7-9
But when he saw many of the Pharisees and Sadducees come to his baptism, he said unto them, O generation of vipers, who hath warned you to flee from the wrath to come?
Both reject ancestry as proof of belonging to God and call for conduct befitting repentance.
- John 8:33
They answered him, We be Abraham’s seed, and were never in bondage to any man: how sayest thou, Ye shall be made free?
The Jews claim freedom because they are Abraham’s descendants.
- John 8:56-58
Your father Abraham rejoiced to see my day: and he saw it, and was glad.
Abraham rejoiced in Christ’s day, while Jesus declares his existence before Abraham.
- Galatians 3:7
Know ye therefore that they which are of faith, the same are the children of Abraham.
Those who have faith are identified as Abraham’s children.
- Galatians 3:29
And if ye be Christ’s, then are ye Abraham’s seed, and heirs according to the promise.
Belonging to Christ makes believers Abraham’s seed and heirs of the promise.
- Romans 9:6-8
Not as though the word of God hath taken none effect. For they are not all Israel, which are of Israel:
Physical descent from Abraham does not by itself make someone God’s child.
- John 8:34
Jesus answered them, Verily, verily, I say unto you, Whosoever committeth sin is the servant of sin.
Those who commit sin are servants of sin.
- John 1:12
But as many as received him, to them gave he power to become the sons of God, even to them that believe on his name:
Receiving Christ gives believers power to become God’s children.
- Romans 8:14-17
For as many as are led by the Spirit of God, they are the sons of God.
Those led by God’s Spirit are his children and heirs.
- John 3:6
That which is born of the flesh is flesh; and that which is born of the Spirit is spirit.
Children bear the character and deeds of the nature from which they are born.
- Galatians 3:26
For ye are all the children of God by faith in Christ Jesus.
Those who believe in Christ are children of God.
- 1 John 3:10
In this the children of God are manifest, and the children of the devil: whosoever doeth not righteousness is not of God, neither he that loveth not his brother.
Righteous conduct distinguishes God’s children from the devil’s.
- 1 John 3:8
He that committeth sin is of the devil; for the devil sinneth from the beginning. For this purpose the Son of God was manifested, that he might destroy the works of the devil.
Sinful deeds identify a person as belonging to the devil.
- Luke 3:8
Bring forth therefore fruits worthy of repentance, and begin not to say within yourselves, We have Abraham to our father: for I say unto you, That God is able of these stones to raise up children unto Abraham.
Ancestry alone does not make people children of Abraham.
- John 8:58
Jesus said unto them, Verily, verily, I say unto you, Before Abraham was, I am.
climax of same dispute over Abraham
- Acts 13:10
And said, O full of all subtilty and all mischief, thou child of the devil, thou enemy of all righteousness, wilt thou not cease to pervert the right ways of the Lord?
Paul calls Elymas a child of the devil.
- 1 John 2:23
Whosoever denieth the Son, the same hath not the Father: [but] he that acknowledgeth the Son hath the Father also.
Acknowledging the Son is necessary to have the Father.
- Luke 1:34-35
Then said Mary unto the angel, How shall this be, seeing I know not a man?
Explains Jesus’ divine conception, which the hostile insinuation denies.
- John 8:47
He that is of God heareth God’s words: ye therefore hear them not, because ye are not of God.
Those who are of God hear God’s words, unlike the opposers.
- Romans 4:16-17
Therefore it is of faith, that it might be by grace; to the end the promise might be sure to all the seed; not to that only which is of the law, but to that also which is of the faith of Abraham; who is the father of us all,
Abraham is father of all who share the promise through faith.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
7 sources
The confrontation occurred in the court of the temple specially connected with the services of the Feast of Tabernacles, as part of the same temple teaching in which Jesus declared himself the light of the world.DA 463.2–4 Deeds reveal spiritual parentage, so that doing the devil's works shows opposition to God even while claiming God as Father.Ms 32a, 1896, par. 1 Merely claiming God as Father does not make a person God's child when deeds contradict the claim, exposing the boast as pretended piety.
The Pharisees and Jewish teachers claimed Abraham and God as Father and denied base birth, yet their works showed they were children of neither Abraham nor God but were acting as children of God's enemy.2SP 356.1–357.2Ms 136, 1899, par. 23–26 Their answer was given in bigotry and self-righteousness, prompted by the accusing spirit of Satan, whose advocates they had become.Ms 136, 1899, par. 23–26 Their denial of illegitimate birth partly showed they understood Jesus to be challenging their spiritual ancestry.LC1 102.2–103.2 Their remark about not being born of fornication also mocked Jesus by alluding to the circumstances of His birth.DA 467.2–3
Jesus gave love for himself as the test of the claim, since if God were truly their Father they would love him because he came from God and was sent by God.2SP 356.1–357.2DA 467.2–31RED 102.2–103.2LC1 102.2–103.2 Their claim was proved false because they had turned from God, refused to recognize His Son, rejected the truth, and sought to kill a man telling the truth heard from God, which Abraham never did.2SP 356.1–357.2Ms 136, 1899, par. 23–261RED 102.2–103.2LC1 102.2–103.2 That refusal to love and believe Him showed that their works aligned them with the devil, a liar and murderer, rather than with God.DA 467.2–3 The verse presents two classes, children of light who obey the truth and children of darkness who reject the truth, and claiming God as Father while hating the Word of truth with intense hatred repeats the same false claim today.Ms 136, 1899, par. 23–26
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
35 sources
After their claim to Abraham was answered by the proof of works, the Jews shifted to claim direct sonship to God, insisting their descent was legitimate and not born of fornication.ST Nov 26, 1896ST Dec 8, 1881RH Jan 16, 1872ST Nov 19, 1896RH Apr 28, 1868 Their denial also carried a malicious slur against Jesus himself, casting doubt on his birth and seeking to shame and discredit him.ST Sep 20, 1910ST Jan 3, 1911RH Dec 15, 1859 Deeds expose a person's true spiritual father, so claiming God as Father is empty when conduct contradicts it, and kinship is shown by character and obedience rather than ancestry or assertion.ST Nov 19, 1896ST Dec 8, 1881ST Sep 18, 1901ST Feb 24, 1887RH Oct 12, 1869 Their specific deeds proved another parentage, for in seeking to kill Jesus who told them the truth from God and in rejecting truth they manifested the spirit of murder belonging to Satan.ST Nov 19, 1896ST Sep 17, 1894ST Feb 20, 1907ST May 21, 1896 God is not the Father of all people but only of the righteous, while the rest have the devil as father; love for Jesus who came forth from God is the test of sonship, and a true child must be born from above by the inward work of the Spirit and bear the fruits of righteousness.RH Jun 14, 1867RH Mar 10, 1868ST Sep 24, 1896RH Nov 22, 1853RH Apr 28, 1868
Speech and Setting
When the claim to Abraham had been met by the proof of works, the Jews shifted their claim to direct sonship to God, saying they were not born of fornication and had one Father, even God.ST Nov 26, 1896ST Nov 19, 1896 The charge that they did the deeds of their father drew that answer from them, and Jesus met it by saying His Father glorifies Him, while those who said God was their God had not known Him, whereas He knows God and keeps His word.ST Nov 26, 1896ST Nov 19, 1896 The claim to have God as the one Father was joined to the claim to be Abraham's seed, yet it was put forth by those who were not God's children and not heirs of the promises, and Jesus as one qualified to settle the question authoritatively rejected it and declared their true position to be children of the devil.RH Apr 28, 1868
Their denial of being born of fornication asserted that their ancestry was legitimate and that their physical descent from Abraham was genuine.ST Dec 8, 1881RH Jan 16, 1872 They denied illegitimacy and claimed God as Father even though their deeds showed they did not follow God.ST Dec 8, 1881 Their literal descent from Abraham was real, but it did not make them Abraham's children in the true sense, since their actions showed whose character they followed.RH Jan 16, 1872
The words about not being born of fornication also carried a malicious slur that Jesus Himself was born out of wedlock.ST Sep 20, 1910ST Jan 3, 1911RH Dec 15, 1859ST Aug 16, 1910 Hostile tongues cast doubt on His parentage and treated the carpenter of Nazareth as His father, and the sneer that no one knew His father echoed the denial and was used to discredit Him.ST Jan 3, 1911RH Dec 15, 1859ST Aug 16, 1910 The accusation that He was born of fornication was an unrighteous attempt to shame Him and the house of Israel.ST Sep 20, 1910 In the same spirit they reviled Him for His birth together with His age, His manner of life, and His teaching otherwise than the Pharisees, who were held in as great opinion for holiness of life and deep learning as religious monks, and they beat upon Him the long continuance of Moses' law, which they said He came to destroy.RH Sep 16, 1873 Their scorn could not unsettle Him, though Mary treasured His words while grieving over the way people questioned His origin and destiny.RH Dec 15, 1859
The verse belongs to Christ's direct confrontation with the Jews, in which He exposed their false claims about their spiritual father and accused them of lying and murder.ST Dec 8, 1887 He spoke plainly and fearlessly to them, and did not withhold necessary truth from fear of their reaction.ST Dec 8, 1887
Jesus answered the claim to have God as Father by showing the conflict between the claim and their actions, for by rejecting Jesus whom God had sent they showed they were not living as God's children.ST Oct 23, 1879ST Dec 8, 1881 If God were truly their Father they would love Jesus, who proceeded forth and came from God and was sent by Him.ST Dec 8, 1881 Their refusal to recognize God's Son showed that they had turned their minds from God's love.ST Dec 8, 1881
Character Proves Parentage
Deeds expose a person's true spiritual father, so claiming God as Father does not make the claim true when conduct contradicts it, and true kinship is shown by character rather than ancestry or assertion.ST Nov 19, 1896ST Dec 8, 1881ST Sep 18, 1901ST Sep 17, 1894ST Feb 20, 1907 The claim to have God as Father was denied as illegitimate in effect because the claimants did not follow God, but cherished the spirit of Satan and entertained murder, and their desire to kill Christ who had told them the truth from God differed from Abraham's conduct and revealed a different spiritual kinship.ST Nov 19, 1896ST Dec 8, 1881ST Sep 17, 1894ST Feb 20, 1907 Reliance on outward religious observances and on descent from Abraham did not establish the relationship, for true descent is shown by doing Abraham's works.ST Feb 20, 1907RH Jan 3, 1856 Spiritual kinship is shown by character and actions, not merely by outward ancestry or a claim of religious identity.RH Jan 3, 1856
Sonship to Abraham is likewise shown by character and conduct like his, not merely by physical ancestry.RH Jan 16, 1872ST Feb 22, 1910RH Jan 3, 1856RH Jan 12, 1864 Literal descent from Abraham was genuine, yet it did not make the claimants Abraham's children in the true and scriptural sense, because their actions showed whose character they followed.RH Jan 16, 1872RH Jan 12, 1864 Their murderous intent and rejection of truth contradicted the claim and exposed their real spiritual father, and those who reject truth and seek to kill Christ do not follow Abraham's example but do the deeds of their father the devil and are not heirs of the promises merely because of ancestry.ST Feb 22, 1910RH Jan 12, 1864 Descendants of Jacob could not claim a place in God's kingdom on the basis of birth or national descent, for their deeds and the fruits they bore determined whether they belonged to it, and those counted as Abraham's seed are people of faith, including Christ and his followers.RH Sep 25, 1856RH May 5, 1851
Their specific deeds proved another parentage: seeking to kill Jesus who told them the truth from God, cherishing Satan's spirit and murder, and rejecting truth.ST Nov 19, 1896ST Sep 17, 1894ST Feb 20, 1907ST Feb 22, 1910RH Jan 12, 1864 Love for Jesus is the test of having God as Father, since he proceeded forth and came from God and was sent by him.RH Jun 14, 1867ST Dec 8, 1881 Whoever commits sin is the servant of sin and does what he has seen with his own father, so those who do not love Jesus are not the children of God, and hatred of truth and rejection of Christ contradict the claim to divine sonship and show that a person is not living as God's child.RH Jun 14, 1867ST Feb 24, 1887 Refusal to recognize God's Son shows minds turned from God's love, contrasting children of light who obey the truth with children of darkness who reject it.ST Dec 8, 1881
Fatherhood here describes whom people obey and which government they live under.RH Oct 12, 1869ST May 21, 1896 Those who obey the devil are his children, and those who obey God are his children, for the people of earth belong to only two spiritual families, one headed by the Father in heaven and one headed by the devil.RH Oct 12, 1869ST May 21, 1896 The deeds a person does reveal which father he belongs to, because each child manifests the plan of government of his family and bears the fruit of that from which he is born.ST May 21, 1896 People are not God's children by nature, but all have sinned and through disobedience are recipients of wrath rather than children of God.ST Feb 24, 1887
Doctrine and Application
God is not the Father of all people, for only the righteous are his children and the devil is the father of all the rest.RH Jun 14, 1867RH Mar 10, 1868 Wicked men may claim God as their Father while doing the deeds of their own father, but whoever commits sin is the servant of sin and does what he has seen with his own father, and the test of having God as Father is love for Jesus who proceeded forth and came from God, so those who do not love him are not God's children.RH Jun 14, 1867 God's tender compassion as a Father therefore does not apply to the wicked so as to save them from punishment.RH Jun 14, 1867 The claim to have God as Father does not establish universal divine sonship, since Jesus identified the Pharisees who made it as children of the devil, and the same distinction applies to wicked people generally.RH Mar 10, 1868 Unbelieving Jews who claimed God as their one Father and claimed to be Abraham's seed put forth a claim belonging to those who are not God's children and not heirs of the promises, and Jesus as one qualified to settle the question authoritatively rejected it and declared their true position to be children of the devil, a class wholly distinct from and opposite to the covenant people of God.RH Apr 28, 1868
Those counted as Abraham's seed are people of faith, including Christ and his followers, for claiming Abraham as father does not make people his true children in the spiritual sense but their deeds identify them.ST Sep 10, 1894RH May 5, 1851 Zacchaeus was a child of Abraham because he gladly received Jesus, and receiving Jesus brings salvation and makes a person a child of Abraham.ST Sep 10, 1894 The descendants of Jacob could not claim a place in God's kingdom on the basis of birth or national descent, for their deeds and the fruits they bore determined whether they belonged to it, and their claim to be Abraham's children was rejected with the charge that they were children of the devil.RH Sep 25, 1856 Descent from Abraham did not guarantee salvation because they were sinners like everyone else, a rebuke from Jesus like John the Baptist's rebuke.ST Jan 7, 1889
Claiming God as Father does not make a person God's child when deeds contradict the claim, for physical descent and claims of belonging to God do not establish sonship but deeds reveal true spiritual parentage.ST Sep 24, 1896RH Nov 22, 1853 A true child of Abraham does Abraham's works, and a true child of God must be born from above and bear the fruits of righteousness after ancestry is exposed by actions.ST Sep 24, 1896 It is the inward work of God's Spirit rather than outward circumcision or ancestry that marks those who are Jews inwardly.RH Nov 22, 1853 To profess God as Father and make boast in him while dishonoring him by transgressing his law is an empty profession contradicted by lawbreaking and causing many to stumble at the law.RH Nov 22, 1853RH Nov 22, 1853
The same truth applies to people who use human arguments against the Sabbath while claiming God as their Father, for they do the deeds of another father, the devil.ST Jul 16, 1894 Satan worked through Cain then and works through such reasoners now, so their arguments and the persecution that always goes with them are traced to their true origin, and because they are not of God they do not hear God's words.ST Jul 16, 1894 Their reasoning cannot overthrow the Sabbath but will overthrow themselves, for God cannot be mocked.ST Jul 16, 1894 Claiming God as Father does not prove a person belongs to God since deeds reveal whose child a person is, which warns against accepting anyone who invokes the Father while ignoring Jesus, since the Father is known through the Son.ST Dec 12, 1895 In this chapter Christ removes the law's condemnation by pardoning the sinner, not by abolishing the law, and his pardon comes with power to obey and the call to sin no more.ST Feb 15, 1899
Sources