Translations
American King James Version, Webster Bible
Then said they to him, Where is he? He said, I know not.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
Then said they unto him, Where is he? He said, I know not.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
And they said unto him, Where is he? He saith, I know not.
they said, therefore, to him, 'Where is that one?' he saith, 'I have not known.'
They said therefore to him, Where is he? He says, I do not know.
And they said unto him—Where is, He? He saith—I know not.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
“ Where is He?” they asked.“ I do not know,” he answered.
Then they asked him, “ Where is he?”He said, “ I don’t know.”
And they said to him, Where is he? His answer was: I have no knowledge.
Then they sayd vnto him, Where is he? He sayd, I can not tell.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And they said to him: Where is he? He saith: I know not.
Cross-references
- John 9:6-7
When he had thus spoken, he spat on the ground, and made clay of the spittle, and he anointed the eyes of the blind man with the clay,
Jesus heals the blind man with clay and by sending him to wash.
- John 9:35-38
Jesus heard that they had cast him out; and when he had found him, he said unto him, Dost thou believe on the Son of God?
Jesus reveals himself to the healed man, who believes and worships him.
- John 9:25
He answered and said, Whether he be a sinner or no, I know not: one thing I know, that, whereas I was blind, now I see.
golden text for the blind-man account
- John 9:22
These words spake his parents, because they feared the Jews: for the Jews had agreed already, that if any man did confess that he was Christ, he should be put out of the synagogue.
The parents feared the expulsion decreed for anyone confessing Jesus as Christ.
- John 9:34
They answered and said unto him, Thou wast altogether born in sins, and dost thou teach us? And they cast him out.
The healed man is cast out after being healed.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
3 sources
The saying belongs to the questioning that followed Jesus' healing of the man born blind, after onlookers saw his transformation.Ms 97, 1901, par. 9–13 When asked how his eyes were opened, he explained that a man called Jesus made clay and anointed his eyes and sent him to wash in the pool of Siloam, and he washed and received sight.Ms 97, 1901, par. 9–13 When then asked where Jesus was, he answered that he did not know, for he did not yet know who had healed him.Ms 97, 1901, par. 9–13Lt 20, 1895, par. 1 The healing and the questioning around it were wonderful evidence of the truth and divine character of Jesus' mission.Ms 97, 1901, par. 9–13
The healing shows Jesus' compassionate and tender sympathy for human suffering, extended even to one who did not yet know Him in order to seek and save him.ST May 8, 1907Lt 20, 1895, par. 1 The restoration made the man an object of Pharisaic contempt.ST May 8, 1907 Later Jesus revealed Himself to the man as the Son of God, and the man worshiped Him.Lt 20, 1895, par. 1
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
18 sources
The question was asked of the man born blind after Jesus had healed his congenital blindness on the Sabbath by divine power, when friends and neighbors and then the Pharisees were questioning him about how he was healed.ST Oct 23, 1893ST Jun 24, 1886ST Feb 11, 1886RH Nov 13, 1860 His answer was simple and truthful ignorance, for he had never seen Jesus and had only heard His name, he could not see what was done when the clay was put on his eyes, and Jesus was no longer with him, so he plainly acknowledged what he knew without pretending to know more.ST Jun 24, 1886ST Dec 22, 1881RH Mar 30, 1876 The healing was a merciful act worthy of the Sabbath and its Lord, showing that works of necessity and mercy honor God and are more important than narrow human traditions about Sabbath-keeping.RH Feb 11, 1862RH May 5, 1874ST Jul 8, 1897ST Mar 4, 1889 Jesus purposely chose the Sabbath for this healing to exalt true Sabbath-keeping, correct false notions of what is lawful, and strip away rabbinical additions that had turned the Sabbath from a blessing into a curse.ST Aug 20, 1896ST Sep 15, 1909 His physical healing led to spiritual sight, for Jesus afterward sought him out when he was cast out for belief, opened his spiritual eyes, taught him His Messiahship, and led him to worship Him, showing that practical knowledge of Christ's work matters more than learning or theories.ST Sep 28, 1904ST May 16, 1911RH Nov 13, 1860ST Oct 18, 1905
Context and Answer
The verse belongs to the account of the Sabbath healing of a poor man blind from birth, whose congenital blindness was beyond the reach of human skill and for which no cure had been sought as possible, healed by a work of divine power.ST Jun 24, 1886ST Feb 11, 1886RH Nov 13, 1860 The healed man soon appeared before the Pharisees, presumably in the temple.ST Jun 24, 1886 Jesus was no longer with him after the healing, and afterward returned and sought him out with lowly, personal attention, finding him when he had been cast out and persecuted by men and teaching him privately the highest truths of his Messiahship.RH Nov 13, 1860
The question about where Jesus was came during the questioning that followed the healing, which was evidence of his divine mission. The healed man had first told his friends and neighbors about Jesus and how he had been healed, and was then asked where Jesus was.ST Oct 23, 1893 The asking came after doubt about who he was, because when his eyes were opened his face was changed and brightened so he looked like another man, and after he settled the dispute by declaring that he was the same man who had sat and begged.ST Oct 23, 1893 This belongs to the second of three Sabbath miracles around which the controversy over proper Sabbath-keeping gathers.ST Aug 20, 1896
His answer was simple and truthful ignorance, for he had never seen Jesus and had only heard his name, and he could not see what was done when the clay was made and spread on his eyes, so he could only say he did not know.ST Dec 22, 1881 Though he knew Jesus had healed him, he could not tell where Jesus had gone.RH Mar 30, 1876RH Nov 13, 1860 His short answer was artless and unembarrassed truth, plain and decisive, with no mark of imposture or falsehood, acknowledging what he knew without pretending to know more.ST Dec 22, 1881RH Mar 30, 1876 The narrative itself does not explain the reply.ST Jun 24, 1886
Sabbath Mercy Vindicated
The healing of the man blind from birth was a merciful act worthy of the Sabbath and of its Lord, suited to deeds of mercy and relief for the suffering, honoring God and in no way a violation of the Sabbath.RH Feb 11, 1862RH May 5, 1874 After the healed man answered that he did not know where Jesus was, the Jews still wrongly treated the episode as unlawful work.ST Mar 4, 1889
Works of necessity and mercy are more important than narrow human traditions about Sabbath-keeping, which the Pharisees condemned him for not following, and the healing revealed God's purpose for the Sabbath.ST Jul 8, 1897 This does not lessen the holiness of the seventh day, since Jesus did not come to abolish any part of the law.
Jesus purposely and deliberately chose the Sabbath for this merciful healing to exalt true Sabbath-keeping, to correct false notions, and to teach what is lawful on the Sabbath.ST Aug 20, 1896ST Sep 15, 1909 He did so to expose Jewish additions and rabbinical traditions that had turned the Sabbath from a blessing into a curse, to rid it of encumbrances and leave it standing upon its own holy dignity, to denounce narrow prejudice and declare human traditions void.ST Aug 20, 1896ST Sep 15, 1909 He thereby showed that God's work never ceases but is even greater on the Sabbath, when His people leave usual employments for prayer, meditation and worship and ask special favors, and that Christ as Lord of the Sabbath kept the Sabbath by doing good and granting what is best.ST Aug 20, 1896
Christ's Sabbath work divided the people and led many to believe in him, while gathering the religious opposition that helped bring about his death. This plain setting forth of the simple Gospel truth of the Sabbath brought bitter opposition and was counted as the reason he should be put to death, so that the shadow of the cross fell across his path from the time he began this work.ST Sep 15, 1909 That conflict shows how vital the Sabbath blessing is to God's people and how relentless the opposition of the prince of evil is to overthrow it.ST Sep 15, 1909
Healing Power and Discipleship
Jesus healed the man born blind and forgave his sins, and afterward led him to worship him.ST Apr 10, 1893RH Apr 7, 1903ST Sep 28, 1904 This healing demonstrates his power to restore sight and to forgive sins.ST Apr 10, 1893RH Apr 7, 1903ST Sep 28, 1904 When the people asked the healed man where Jesus was, he answered that he did not know.ST Sep 28, 1904 His healing and his worship show that he alone is worthy of trust and worship rather than reliance on any other support.ST Apr 10, 1893RH Apr 7, 1903
The physical healing led to spiritual sight, for his bodily eyes were opened and his spiritual eyes were opened also, so that he saw Christ and worshiped him.ST May 16, 1911 Afterward Jesus returned and sought him out with lowly, personal attention, finding him when he had been cast out and persecuted by men and teaching him privately the highest truths of his Messiahship.RH Nov 13, 1860 He had been cast out of the synagogue for his belief in Christ.ST Oct 18, 1905 His restoration to sight by the compassionate Shepherd had made him an object of Pharisaic contempt, even while the Lord was seeking to save him.ST May 8, 1907
His answer was plain and decisive, acknowledging what he knew about Jesus and his healing without pretending to know more. Such simple, truthful testimony shows that practical knowledge of Christ's work matters more than learning or theories. The story holds a lesson for today because men will not come to Christ that they may have life.ST May 16, 1911 Every reader is therefore asked whether spiritual eyes have been opened to God's truths, whether he is willing to forsake all things that would keep him from the kingdom, and whether he would know his duty, for Christ is the Way, the Truth, and the Life, his Word is the Guide-Book that will not lead in the wrong way, and the whole duty of man is to fear God and keep his commandments.ST May 16, 1911
Sources