AdventAI

Malachi 3:13

Your words have been stout against me, saith the LORD. Yet ye say, What have we spoken so much against thee?

King James Version

Translations

  • American King James Version

    Your words have been stout against me, says the LORD. Yet you say, What have we spoken so much against you?

  • King James Version, Webster Bible

    Your words have been stout against me, saith the LORD. Yet ye say, What have we spoken so much against thee?

  • KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible

    Your words have been stout against me, saith the Lord.
    Yet ye say, What have we spoken so much against thee?

  • Revised Version

    Your words have been stout against me, saith the LORD. Yet ye say, Wherein have we spoken against thee?

  • American Standard Version

    Your words have been stout against me, saith Jehovah. Yet ye say, What have we spoken against thee?

  • Young's Literal Translation

    Hard against Me have been your words, Said Jehovah, and ye have said: 'What have we spoken against Thee?'

  • Darby Translation

    Your words have been stout against me, saith Jehovah; but ye say, What have we been speaking against thee?

  • Rotherham's Emphasised Bible

    Stout against me, have been your words, saith Yahweh,—and yet ye say, What have we spoken, one to another, against thee?

  • Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible

    “ Your words against Me have been harsh,” says the LORD. “ Yet you ask, ‘ What have we spoken against You?’

  • World English Bible

    “ Your words have been harsh against me,” says the LORD. “ Yet you say, ‘ What have we spoken against you?’

  • Bible in Basic English

    Your words have been strong against me, says the Lord. And still you say, What have we said against you?

  • Geneva Bible

    Your wordes haue bene stout against me, sayeth the Lord: yet ye say, What haue we spoken against thee?

  • Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)

    Your words have been unsufferable to me, saith the Lord.

Commentary

Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.

Ellen G. White

44 sources

Your words have been strong and defiant against God in arrogant opposition, yet those charged refuse to see it and answer back by asking what wrong they have done.STMW6 14.16T 389.1–2Ms 87, 1899, par. 20–21Ms 15, 1899, par. 4–5Ms 53, 1894, par. 50–52
Their complaint is that serving Him and keeping His requirements brings no profit, that their mournful walk before Him was useless while the proud and wicked are called happy, prosper and escape.STMW6 14.1Ms 39, 1891, par. 26STMW9 73.1–2Lt 310, 1908, par. 9–14Ms 24, 1901, par. 24–26
The charge belongs with withholding the tithe and offerings He reserved for His work and using His entrusted goods selfishly, though His plan is that all bring tithe into His storehouse so His cause is supplied and the gospel is spread through the world.6T 389.1–2STMW9 73.1–2GW 227.1Ms 24, 1901, par. 24–26Lt 38, 1902, par. 19–21
In contrast those who fear Him speak sincerely to one another with thoughts on His name, without complaint and murmuring, and He hears them, records them for remembrance, and claims them as His own.STMW6 14.1Lt 30, 1900, par. 2–3
The record of ingratitude therefore calls not for blaming His work but for honest self-examination, repentance, prayer and return to Him, with ceasing from robbery and serving Him in sincerity and self-denial.Ms 3, 1895, par. 12–15Lt 38, 1902, par. 25–27Ms 147, 1901, par. 44–45Lt 72, 1890, par. 7

Charge and Denial

The charge is that words spoken against the Lord are stout, that is strong, firmly set in opposition to Him, defiant and arrogant in spirit.Ms 87, 1899, par. 20–21Ms 15, 1899, par. 4–5Ms 15, 1899Ms 38a, 1905, par. 21–23Ms 142, 1903, par. 123–125 Such speech is an offense against Him, whether uttered openly or cherished as unspoken thoughts by those who prize worldly advantage.Ms 87, 1899, par. 20–21Ms 53, 1894, par. 50–52 It weighs His actions by human standards, seeks to justify self, dishonors Him, and fosters an evil influence in the life.Ms 87, 1899, par. 20–21Ms 15, 1899, par. 4–5

Those charged answer with denial, asking what they have spoken against Him.STMW6 14.16T 389.1–2Ms 32, 1894, par. 8Ms 144, 1897, par. 7–8Ms 15, 1899 The question is itself defiant and self-justifying, asking what wrong was done instead of examining duties neglected.STMW6 14.16T 389.1–2Lt 310, 1908, par. 9–14Ms 183, 1897, par. 7–9Ms 144, 1897, par. 7–8 Even while denying opposition, they speak against Him in disobedience, doubt, and blindness to His ways and works.STMW6 14.16T 389.1–2Lt 310, 1908, par. 9–14Ms 183, 1897, par. 7–9Ms 144, 1897, par. 7–8

Content of the Complaint

The stout words are the charge that serving God is vain and useless and that keeping His ordinances, commands and requirements brings no profit or gain.Ms 39, 1891, par. 26STMW9 73.1–2Ms 24, 1901, par. 24–26Ms 60, 1896, par. 16–17Ms 16, 1902, par. 13–15 Those who speak so have turned from God and, blinded by the enemy, cannot discern His ways and works, envying the apparent success of the proud and wicked.STMW6 14.1Ms 39, 1891, par. 26Ms 87, 1899, par. 20–21 Their complaint grows out of withholding what belongs to God and using His entrusted goods selfishly, hindering His work, then blaming Him for hardship they brought upon themselves through disloyalty.STMW9 73.1–2Ms 24, 1901, par. 24–26Ms 60, 1896, par. 16–17Ms 25, 1894, par. 9–11 They use adversity and poor crops as excuses despite having withheld the resources meant for His work, and their failure to serve as His helping hand in good works, self-denial, love for others and care for the needy exposes the selfishness behind their words.STMW9 73.1–2Ms 24, 1901, par. 24–26Ms 60, 1896, par. 16–17 God permits the spoiler to damage their crops and calamities to come upon them, and such claims contradict the duty owed to Him and reveal a poor spiritual condition whatever is professed.Ms 60, 1896, par. 16–17Ms 25, 1894, par. 9–11 The same complaint means bringing worldly plans and business methods into the church, unholy trading in sacred things which He hates, selfishness and greed turning souls purchased by blood into merchandise, the church selling itself to the world by taking up worldly principles, and the triumph of ungodliness, whereas those accepted as His subjects must cherish high holy uplifting sanctifying principles and hold them before the world without changing the church to fit worldly policy.Ms 16, 1902, par. 13–15

They add that they have walked mournfully before Him in vain, while the proud and wicked are called happy, prosper, are built up, and those who tempt God escape punishment and are delivered.STMW6 14.1Lt 310, 1908, par. 9–14Ms 53, 1894, par. 50–52Ms 16, 1902, par. 13–15Lt 223, 1904, par. 29–30 Though separated from God they deny that their words have been against Him, yet those complaints accuse Him of failing to reward faithfulness and to judge evil.STMW6 14.1Lt 310, 1908, par. 9–14Lt 223, 1904, par. 29–30 Their words weigh His actions by human standards, attempt to justify themselves, dishonor Him, and foster an evil influence within.Ms 87, 1899, par. 20–21 Even unspoken thoughts that prize worldly advantage are an offense against Him.Ms 53, 1894, par. 50–52Ms 100, 1899, par. 22–23 In contrast to those who fear Him and speak sincerely to one another without deceit, guile, complaint against God or evil-speaking against fellow believers, whom He hears, records for remembrance, claims as His own, spares, and at last distinguishes from the wicked, these speakers resent the apparent success of evil and call it happiness.STMW6 14.1

Their mournfulness was not required but arose from their own will and chosen course, expressing opposition and revealing an unsanctified spirit.Ms 15, 1899, par. 4–5Ms 38a, 1905, par. 21–23 No one is told to walk gloomily or mournfully before God.Ms 100, 1899, par. 22–23Ms 38a, 1905, par. 21–23 He wants His people to walk in the light of the Sun of Righteousness, reflect heaven's light, and rejoice because redemption draws near.Ms 100, 1899, par. 22–23 Those joined to Him in obedience find gladness and cheerfulness and eat of the leaves of the tree of life.Ms 38a, 1905, par. 21–23 The speakers instead work out their own plans and follow their own chosen course, complain because He does not bless them yet will not place themselves where He can bless them, find fault with Him and with their brethren, and keep lamenting over their own wretched condition.Ms 38a, 1905, par. 21–23

Tithe Context and Claims

Malachi 3:13 stands within the plain requirement of the whole third chapter that all pay tithe because the Lord Himself requires it as heaven's plan for teaching that His people are subjects of Christ's kingdom.GW 227.1Lt 38, 1902, par. 19–217MR 137.4 It belongs to the call to stand upon the Lord's word and be faithful in paying the tithe into His treasury and storehouse, with systematic contributions and gifts and offerings, with all whose names are on the church books giving a tenth of increase as prospered, and with even the poorest giving small gifts in acknowledgment of mercy in supplying necessities.GW 227.1Ms 156, 1898, par. 187MR 137.4Ms 70, 1896, par. 20–24 That faithfulness is honesty in relation to the Lord and His work, using His entrusted means and property and talents in His service for the reckoning and judgment of how gifts are used, and for spreading the gospel throughout the world.9T 53.3Ms 70, 1896, par. 20–24 Faithfulness gives abundant supply in the treasury so that more laborers are encouraged to take up ministerial work and give themselves to the ministry instead of being held back by a depleted treasury, while selfish hearts and hands withholding the tithes or using them to support other lines of work leave the treasury empty.GW 227.17MR 137.4

The stout complaints belong with withholding what God reserved and specified for His work and with selfish use of His entrusted goods that hinders His cause.6T 389.1–2STMW9 73.1–2Ms 24, 1901, par. 24–26Ms 60, 1896, par. 16–17Ms 25, 1894, par. 9–11 Those who kept back what belonged to Him blamed God for their adversity and hardship, though their disloyalty brought the loss upon themselves, and they used adversity and poor crops as excuses despite having withheld the resources meant for His work.6T 389.1–2STMW9 73.1–2Ms 60, 1896, par. 16–17 Their words claim that serving Him and keeping His ordinances and commands bring no benefit or profit, especially while the wicked are seen to prosper, and they resent His not recognizing them as they expect.6T 389.1–2STMW9 73.1–2Ms 24, 1901, par. 24–26Ms 60, 1896, par. 16–17Ms 25, 1894, par. 9–11 Their failure to serve as His helping hand in good works, self-denial, love for others and care for the needy exposes the selfishness behind the words and reveals a poor spiritual condition whatever is professed.Ms 24, 1901, par. 24–26Ms 25, 1894, par. 9–11 God still tests whether they will prove faithful servants by considering His goodness, responding to His mercy, and giving proof of loyalty by bringing all the tithes into His storehouse, but disloyalty that appropriates the reserved portion proves unfaithful stewardship, and He permits the spoiler to damage crops and calamities to come, with curse and loss of both what was withheld from God and what was committed as one's own.Ms 60, 1896, par. 16–17

The chapter is warning and instruction in righteousness for every soul that must be carefully read and its instruction followed for one's own good and for the help of others by example, and must be studied and practiced through love and fear of God by following out every specification in His Word.Lt 38, 1902, par. 19–21Lt 70, 1893, par. 11 It states God's claims on His people, states duties the church was failing to see because spiritual perceptions were clouded, warns that He will judge false dealing with Him and with others, and calls the people to do the work essential for His approval because withholding brings a curse.Ms 144, 1897, par. 29–30Ms 24, 1901, par. 11–12Ms 192, 1898, par. 2Ms 24, 1901, par. 34–36 It lifts a danger signal cautioning against every species of self-indulgence, for yielding to selfishness by withholding from the Lord the portion He claims as His own leaves undone what He requires and makes a record unwelcome to meet, while neglecting the chapter brings sure visitation leaving the neglectful found committing robbery toward God.Lt 70, 1893, par. 11Lt 38, 1902, par. 25–27 Those whose attention has been called to this subject and still refuse to comply and disregard it as non-essential will be dealt with in the manner described in the chapter, with spiritual failure and the church left without His blessing.Lt 38, 1902, par. 19–21Ms 144, 1897, par. 29–30 Strict obedience to return to God His own is to be impressed by parents upon children, teaching them to deny self, to pay tithe, to bring even small offerings, to deny worldly pleasures in order to help advance His work, and thus to become fruitful in good works bearing fruit to the glory of God and unto eternal life.Lt 38, 1902, par. 25–27

Obedience in bringing all the tithes and proving Him carries the fulfilled promise that He will act for them when they do their part, open the windows of heaven, and give blessing without room to receive it.Lt 14, 1899, par. 17–19 Funds so given in systematic liberality will be abundantly blessed and will swell the revenues of the church.Ms 156, 1898, par. 18

The third chapter was set forth on the Sabbath to meet determined apostasy when laborers gave up their position on truth, went in for holiness altogether, came out against the testimonies of the Spirit of the Lord, accepted some other light than the third angel's message, and claimed they would have nothing to say against Adventists.Lt 152, 1897, par. 1–4

Contrast with the Faithful

Set against those separated from God who deny speaking against Him, are those who fear the Lord and speak sincerely to one another with their thoughts upon His name.STMW6 14.1Lt 30, 1900, par. 2–3 Their speech is without deceit and guile, without complaint and murmuring and lamentation against God, and without evil-speaking against fellow believers.STMW6 14.1Lt 30, 1900, par. 2–3 God hears them and records them in a book of remembrance, claims them as His own, and spares them.STMW6 14.1Lt 30, 1900, par. 2–3 While the disaffected complain that serving God is useless, the faithful value His commandments all the more.STMW6 14.1Ms 183, 1897, par. 7–9 Because the Lord is soon to come there must be a refining, winnowing process in every church and a transformation of character, in which the church arises to put on her beautiful garments, the righteousness of Christ.Lt 15, 1892, par. 10–12 Then it will be seen who are vessels unto honor, for they will receive the latter rain, and there will be a return and a discerning between the righteous and the wicked, between him that serves God and him that serves Him not, revealing the difference between them.STMW6 14.1Lt 15, 1892, par. 10–12

Hearts Behind the Words

The speakers are those separated and turned away from God, found even among His professed people, blinded by the enemy and by continuing in sin while light is shining, so that they cannot discern His ways and works.STMW6 14.1Ms 39, 1891, par. 26Lt 15, 1892, par. 10–12 Their condition is one of spiritual darkness, disobedience, doubt, and poor spiritual state whatever they profess, refusing instruction while denying that they speak against Him.Ms 144, 1897, par. 7–8Ms 25, 1894, par. 9–11Ms 26, 1896, par. 22–23 They do not love the truth or honor Him, and every soul who continues in sin under present light becomes blinded and accepts delusions from Satan, making a refining, winnowing process and transformation of character necessary in every church.Lt 15, 1892, par. 10–12 When the church arises to put on her beautiful garments, the righteousness of Christ, it will be seen who are vessels unto honor receiving the latter rain, with a return and discerning between the righteous and the wicked, between him that serves God and him that serves Him not.Lt 15, 1892, par. 10–12

They weigh God's actions by human standards, attempt to justify themselves, dishonor Him, and foster an evil influence within their own lives.Ms 87, 1899, par. 20–21RH Jul 31, 1900 The mouth speaks from the abundance of the heart, so such speech reveals the heart.5T 287.2 Words can justify or condemn, and in the final reckoning each receives according to deeds.5T 287.2

Their words expose selfishness in withholding what God specified and reserved for His work, contradicting the duty owed to Him.Ms 24, 1901, par. 24–26Ms 25, 1894, par. 9–11Ms 26, 1896, par. 22–23 They fail to serve as His helping hand in good works, self-denial, love for others, and care for the needy, and this failure lays bare the selfishness behind the complaint that serving Him brings no profit.Ms 24, 1901, par. 24–26 They work out their own plans and follow their own chosen course, complain because God does not bless them yet will not place themselves where He can bless them, find fault with God and with their brethren, and keep lamenting over their own wretched condition.Ms 38a, 1905, par. 21–23 Neglect of His mercies and turning away from His love are added to the record of words and actions set against Him.Lt 72, 1890, par. 7

Their chief business becomes murmuring and complaining, accusing God by accusing the children of God, seeing nothing defective in themselves but very much to displease in others.Lt 123, 1897, par. 29–31Ms 183, 1897, par. 7–9 This occurs in the crisis when wicked men and the church harmonize in hatred of God's law, through a company of disaffected professed Christians.Lt 123, 1897, par. 29–31 Though they should have represented the truth well and been examples to new believers, they give a testimony that misrepresents His gracious paternal character.Ms 32, 1894, par. 8 Their complaint is a dark picture presented by Satan, and it may exist even as unspoken thoughts prizing worldly advantage, yet it remains an offense against God.Ms 53, 1894, par. 50–52Ms 32, 1894, par. 8

The complaint means bringing worldly plans and business methods into the church, unholy trading in sacred things which He hates.Ms 16, 1902, par. 13–15 It is selfishness and greed turning souls purchased by blood into merchandise, the church selling itself to the world by taking up worldly principles, and the triumph of ungodliness.Ms 16, 1902, par. 13–15 It dwells on the great advantages to be gained by worldly association while calling the proud happy and holding that workers of wickedness are built up and those who tempt God are delivered.RH Apr 20, 1916 Those accepted as His subjects must instead cherish high and holy, uplifting and sanctifying principles of truth and hold them up before the world, and the church must not be changed to fit worldly policy.Ms 16, 1902, par. 13–15

Warning and Call to Return

The charge exposes a defiant self-justifying response that asks what wrong has been done instead of examining what duties have been neglected, and it calls for honest self-examination rather than blaming His work or judging others.Ms 3, 1895, par. 12–15 Neglecting His mercies and turning from His love adds to the record of words and actions set against Him, and that record of ingratitude and disregard for His claims calls for repentance, prayer, and return to the heavenly Father.Lt 72, 1890, par. 7

The third chapter plainly points out the need and importance of paying tithe as the Lord's own requirement and heaven's plan to teach that His people are subjects of Christ's kingdom, and it must be carefully read and its instruction followed for one's own good and for the help of others by example.Lt 38, 1902, par. 19–21 It must be studied and practiced through love and fear of God by following out every specification in His Word, for neglecting it brings the sure visitation of God, leaving the neglectful found committing robbery toward Him, a result that cannot be afforded.Lt 70, 1893, par. 11 Church members who refuse to give tithes and offerings are urged to read the chapter as a warning that disregarding God's requirements brings spiritual failure and leaves the church without His blessing.Ms 144, 1897, par. 29–30 Those whose attention has been called to this subject and still refuse to comply and disregard it as non-essential will be dealt with in the manner described in the chapter.Lt 38, 1902, par. 19–21 Speaking as though serving God is vain and obedience brings no profit is speaking stoutly against Him, such words reveal the heart since the mouth speaks from its abundance, and they will be judged, for words can justify or condemn and in the final reckoning each receives according to deeds.5T 287.2

The chapter lifts a danger signal cautioning against every species of self-indulgence, for yielding to selfishness by withholding from the Lord the portion He claims as His own leaves undone what He requires and makes a record unwelcome to meet.Lt 38, 1902, par. 25–27 The warning therefore calls for ceasing robbery in tithes and offerings and instead serving Him in sincerity, cooperating with Him in the saving of souls, practicing self-denial, and laying out no money unnecessarily.Ms 147, 1901, par. 44–45 Strict obedience to the command to return to God His own is to be impressed by parents upon children, teaching them to deny self, to pay tithe, to bring even small offerings, and to deny themselves worldly pleasures in order to help advance His work, and thus to become fruitful in good works bearing fruit to the glory of God and unto eternal life.Lt 38, 1902, par. 25–27 That return is made in gratitude for the life He gave by helping plant His standard in places that have never heard the truth and by forwarding the work in foreign fields.Ms 147, 1901, par. 44–45

Sources

  1. STMW6 14.1 Special Testimonies for Ministers and Workers—No. 6 — MINGLING OF BELIEVERS WITH UNBELIEVERS. Ellen G. White, 1896
  2. 6T 389.1–2 Testimonies for the Church Volume Six — GIVING TO GOD HIS OWN. Ellen G. White, 1901
  3. Ms 87, 1899, par. 20–21 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 14 (1899) — Ms 87, 1899 Ellen G. White, written June 13, 1899
  4. Ms 15, 1899, par. 4–5 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 14 (1899) — Ms 15, 1899 Ellen G. White, written February 23, 1899
  5. Ms 53, 1894, par. 50–52 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 9 (1894) — Ms 53, 1894 Ellen G. White, written 1894
  6. Ms 39, 1891, par. 26 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 7 (1891-1892) — Ms 39, 1891 Ellen G. White, written November 17, 1891
  7. STMW9 73.1–2 Special Testimonies for Ministers and Workers - No. 9 — GOD’S CLAIMS ON HIS STEWARDS. Ellen G. White, 1897
  8. Lt 310, 1908, par. 9–14 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 23 (1908) — Lt 310, 1908 Ellen G. White, written October 1, 1908
  9. Ms 24, 1901, par. 24–26 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 16 (1901) — Ms 24, 1901 Ellen G. White, written March 4, 1901
  10. GW 227.1 Gospel Workers — TEACHING THE PEOPLE TO BE LIBERAL Ellen G. White, 1915
  11. Lt 38, 1902, par. 19–21 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 17 (1902) — Lt 38, 1902 Ellen G. White, written March 2, 1902
  12. Lt 30, 1900, par. 2–3 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 15 (1900) — Lt 30, 1900 Ellen G. White, written February 25, 1900
  13. Ms 3, 1895, par. 12–15 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 10 (1895) — Ms 3, 1895 Ellen G. White, written February 1, 1895
  14. Lt 38, 1902, par. 25–27 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 17 (1902) — Lt 38, 1902 Ellen G. White, written March 2, 1902
  15. Ms 147, 1901, par. 44–45 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 16 (1901) — Ms 147, 1901 Ellen G. White, written April 6, 1901
  16. Lt 72, 1890, par. 7 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 6 (1889-1890) — Lt 72, 1890 Ellen G. White, written November 10, 1890
  17. Ms 15, 1899 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 14 (1899) — Ms 15, 1899 Ellen G. White Estate, written February 23, 1899
  18. Ms 38a, 1905, par. 21–23 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 20 (1905) — Ms 38a, 1905 Ellen G. White, written April 1, 1905
  19. Ms 142, 1903, par. 123–125 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 18 (1903) — Ms 142, 1903 Ellen G. White, written 1903
  20. Ms 32, 1894, par. 8 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 9 (1894) — Ms 32, 1894 Ellen G. White, written July 29, 1894
  21. Ms 144, 1897, par. 7–8 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 12 (1897) — Ms 144, 1897 Ellen G. White, written December 30, 1897
  22. Ms 183, 1897, par. 7–9 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 12 (1897) — Ms 183, 1897 Ellen G. White, written March 9, 1897
  23. Ms 60, 1896, par. 16–17 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 11 (1896) — Ms 60, 1896 Ellen G. White, written October 1896
  24. Ms 16, 1902, par. 13–15 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 17 (1902) — Ms 16, 1902 Ellen G. White, written February 11, 1902
  25. Ms 25, 1894, par. 9–11 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 9 (1894) — Ms 25, 1894 Ellen G. White, written April 23, 1894
  26. Lt 223, 1904, par. 29–30 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 19 (1904) — Lt 223, 1904 Ellen G. White, written June 15, 1904
  27. Ms 100, 1899, par. 22–23 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 14 (1899) — Ms 100, 1899 Ellen G. White, written July 24, 1899
  28. 7MR 137.4 Manuscript Releases, vol. 7 [Nos. 419-525] — MR No. 451—The Tithe Ellen G. White, written 1904; published 1990
  29. Ms 156, 1898, par. 18 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 13 (1898) — Ms 156, 1898 Ellen G. White, written December 5, 1898
  30. Ms 70, 1896, par. 20–24 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 11 (1896) — Ms 70, 1896 Ellen G. White, written September 27, 1896
  31. 9T 53.3 Testimonies for the Church Volume Nine — “FREELY YE HAVE RECEIVED, FREELY GIVE.” Ellen G. White, 1909
  32. Lt 70, 1893, par. 11 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 8 (1893) — Lt 70, 1893 Ellen G. White, written December 1893
  33. Ms 144, 1897, par. 29–30 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 12 (1897) — Ms 144, 1897 Ellen G. White, written December 30, 1897
  34. Ms 24, 1901, par. 11–12 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 16 (1901) — Ms 24, 1901 Ellen G. White, written March 4, 1901
  35. Ms 192, 1898, par. 2 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 13 (1898) — Ms 192, 1898 Ellen G. White, written 1898
  36. Ms 24, 1901, par. 34–36 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 16 (1901) — Ms 24, 1901 Ellen G. White, written March 4, 1901
  37. Lt 14, 1899, par. 17–19 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 14 (1899) — Lt 14, 1899 Ellen G. White, written January 1899
  38. Lt 152, 1897, par. 1–4 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 12 (1897) — Lt 152, 1897 Ellen G. White, written April 6, 1897
  39. Lt 15, 1892, par. 10–12 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 7 (1891-1892) — Lt 15, 1892 Ellen G. White, written June 25, 1892
  40. Ms 26, 1896, par. 22–23 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 11 (1896) — Ms 26, 1896 Ellen G. White, written September 25, 1896
  41. RH Jul 31, 1900 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 77, No. 31 — GOD'S ESTIMATE OF SERVICE Ellen G. White, July 31, 1900
  42. 5T 287.2 Testimonies for the Church Volume Five — INFLUENCE OF UNBELIEF. Ellen G. White, 1889
  43. Lt 123, 1897, par. 29–31 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 12 (1897) — Lt 123, 1897 Ellen G. White, written March 8, 1897
  44. RH Apr 20, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 20 — Secret Societies Ellen G. White, April 20, 1916

Pioneers and periodicals

24 sources

God charges His people with speaking strongly and defiantly against Him while they deny having done so, complaining that serving Him and keeping His commands brings no profit and that the proud and wicked are built up and delivered.RH Jul 31, 1900ST Nov 22, 1899ST Mar 20, 1901RH Jun 12, 1900 The charge belongs to the closing work of the gospel in the last days, when He comes like a refiner's fire to purify the sons of Levi and comes near to judgment as a swift witness against every evildoer.ST Sep 9, 1889ST Sep 2, 1889RH Mar 23, 1905 In that setting He rebukes His professed people for departing from His requirements and withholding tithes and offerings, testing whether they will prove faithful stewards by bringing all the tithe into His storehouse and trusting His promise to open the windows of heaven.ST Sep 9, 1889RH May 1, 1879ST Sep 2, 1889RH Apr 8, 1909RH Oct 10, 1871 The difference between those who serve Him and those who do not is not seen in present prosperity, for both receive temporal blessings, but the faithful who fear Him and speak often to one another are heard and recorded, claimed and spared as a father spares his serving son, and the difference will be made plain at the final judgment.RH Dec 30, 1909ST Mar 6, 1893 True righteousness is done for its own sake even when circumstances look dark and suffering follows, and the rebuke is met in a present revival and reformation where hearts surrender, sins are confessed and forsaken, restitution is made for what was robbed from God, and fathers and children are turned to one another.RH May 4, 1905ST Dec 20, 1899RH Mar 23, 1905RH Aug 29, 1865ST Nov 22, 1899

Stout Words Against God

The charge is that words have been strong, open and defiant against God, yet those who spoke them deny having spoken against Him.ST Nov 22, 1899ST Mar 20, 1901ST Mar 20, 1901RH Aug 31, 1911 The denial itself is self-righteous, concealing murmuring and accusation beneath a claim of innocence.RH Jun 12, 1900ST Mar 20, 1901RH Jan 24, 1871 That failure to recognize fault is illustrated when a stingy heart grumbles as soon as what is due to God is demanded.RH Jan 24, 1871

The substance of the stout words is that serving God is vain and useless, that keeping His commands and ordinances yields no profit or benefit, and that walking mournfully and humbly before Him is worthless.RH Jul 31, 1900RH Apr 20, 1916ST Nov 22, 1899ST Mar 20, 1901 The complaint expresses weariness with His service, questions its value, and tempts those who utter it to abandon it.ST Mar 20, 1901RH Jun 12, 1900RH Aug 29, 1865 In one instance this discouragement echoed in a sister tempted to give up remaining with the church, until experiencing the Lord's Spirit renewed her resolve.RH Aug 29, 1865 The same spirit dwells in thought and talk upon the great advantages to be gained by worldly association.RH Apr 20, 1916

Along with despising God's service goes a misjudgment of the apparent success of evildoers.ST Mar 20, 1901RH Aug 31, 1911ST Nov 22, 1899 The proud are declared happy, those who work wickedness are said to be built up and regarded more favorably, and those who tempt God are claimed to prosper, escape punishment, and be delivered.RH Jul 31, 1900RH Apr 20, 1916ST Nov 22, 1899ST Mar 20, 1901ST Nov 22, 1899 Righteousness is thus treated as worthwhile only if it brings reward.ST Nov 22, 1899

Behind the words is an attitude that blames God for failing His promises, judges Him by human standards, and uses words for self-defense.RH Jul 31, 1900RH Jun 12, 1900 Such speech dishonors Him, fosters evil within the speaker, reveals the heart, and turns people away from worship.RH Jul 31, 1900RH Jun 12, 1900RH Apr 3, 1866 In contrast with those who fear the Lord and speak often with one another, the speech of the last days set against God shows the inner attitude toward Him, calling His people instead to encourage and comfort one another with kind, timely words, to seek wisdom from God to speak helpfully to the weary, and to avoid flattery.ST Nov 22, 1899RH Apr 3, 1866

Prophetic Setting and Warning

Though set down by Malachi, the charge is God's own forceful and practical message rather than merely human thought, and it belongs to his strong appeal for God's people to be ready for the Messenger of the Covenant, Christ Jesus, with the book standing around the time of Nehemiah's closing work.ST Dec 20, 1899

The prophecy reaches through the whole Christian dispensation down to the present time, and it stands as prophecy and warning and promise for that dispensation, with special force for the last days under the closing work of the gospel in connection with Malachi 4.ST Sep 9, 1889ST Sep 2, 1889ST Sep 12, 1895 In that closing setting the Sabbath and the tithe stand out in the work of reformation, and the tithing system tests souls by developing character and manifesting the true state of the heart, as was received by those who accepted the gospel in apostolic times.RH Mar 23, 1905 The verse stands in the setting of the day of His coming, when He is like a refiner's fire and like fullers' soap and sits as a refiner and purifier of silver to purify the sons of Levi and purge them as gold and silver that they may offer an offering in righteousness, and when He comes near to judgment to be a swift witness against sorcerers and adulterers and false swearers and against oppressors of the hireling in wages and against the widow and the fatherless and those who turn aside the stranger and those who do not fear God.ST Sep 12, 1895 In that setting the appointed way of supporting gospel ministers by the tithe, which belongs to God, remains binding, and receiving God's blessing requires doing this duty.ST Sep 2, 1889

There the chapter rebukes God's professed people for departing from His requirements, especially by withholding tithes and offerings, so that its rebuke addresses professed believers in this time as well.ST Sep 9, 1889 Malachi 3:7-17 is therefore to be read prayerfully so that the reader feels his own guilt, confronts measuring himself against others, has sin exposed, and is called to humble himself and confess and forsake his sins.RH Oct 10, 1871

Loyalty Tested and Rewarded

The chapter gives warning and instruction in righteousness for every soul, for the Lord is still testing whether people will prove faithful servants.RH Apr 5, 1864 He calls them to consider His goodness and respond to His mercy, to trust His promise to bless when they respond faithfully, and to believe and act rather than neglect His cause.RH Apr 5, 1864

The test centers on the tithe, which belongs to God as His appointed and still binding way of supporting gospel ministers and His service and work, including what He has set apart for His servants.RH May 1, 1879ST Sep 2, 1889RH Apr 8, 1909 Faithfully giving a tenth of income and bringing all the tithes into His storehouse brings His blessing, including the fulfilled promise of opened windows of heaven and blessing without room to receive it.RH May 1, 1879ST Sep 2, 1889 The tithing system develops character and manifests the true state of the heart, as received in apostolic times, and those who profess to keep God's law are in danger of stealing these holy things.RH Apr 8, 1909RH Mar 23, 1905 Disregarding God's plain claims and appropriating the portion He has reserved proves unfaithful stewardship and loses both what was withheld from God and what was committed as one's own. One who has robbed men or God, especially in tithes, must make restitution after the example of Zaccheus, with the assurance that salvation will come to him as it came to Zaccheus.RH Oct 10, 1871

The difference between those who serve God and those who do not may remain unseen in this life, when both receive temporal blessings so that present prosperity or hardship and outward success do not show standing before Him.RH Dec 30, 1909ST Mar 6, 1893 In contrast to the complainers, the faithful fear God and speak often with one another, and God hears and records their faithfulness.RH Aug 31, 1911RH Apr 3, 1866 He claims them as His own and spares them as a father spares a serving son, and He will make the difference plain at the final judgment and last day when He gathers His people to Himself.RH Dec 30, 1909ST Mar 6, 1893RH Aug 31, 1911

The rebuke concerns doing righteousness for profit and teaches that true and acceptable righteousness is practiced for its own sake whatever may come.ST Dec 20, 1899ST Nov 22, 1899 People are to do what is right even when they suffer for it, and when circumstances look dark remain faithful and trust that God is faithful and true.ST Dec 20, 1899ST Nov 22, 1899 They are to encourage and comfort one another with kind, timely words, seek wisdom from God to speak helpfully to the weary, and avoid flattery.ST Nov 22, 1899RH Apr 3, 1866 Discouragement that echoes the complaint, as in a sister tempted to give up remaining with the church, is renewed by experiencing the Lord's Spirit.RH Aug 29, 1865

The verse meets its fulfilment in a present revival and reformation going forward in power, where people seek God for a new and living experience, surrender all to God, and confess and make restitution including paying tithe long withheld after robbing God.RH May 4, 1905 There children between ten and sixteen give their hearts to God, parents meet in earnest prayer, the hearts of the fathers are turned toward the children and the hearts of the children to their fathers, and God begins a definite work of deliverance.RH May 4, 1905 In that work of reformation the Sabbath and the tithe stand out, with the tithing system testing souls, developing character, and manifesting the true state of the heart.RH Mar 23, 1905

Sources

  1. ST Nov 22, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 47 — LESSON XII.—SUNDAY, DECEMBER 17, 1899 NOVEMBER 22, 1899
  2. ST Mar 20, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 12 — THE SABBATH SCHOOL March 20, 1901
  3. RH Jun 12, 1900 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 77, No. 24 — MINE Uriah Smith, June 12, 1900
  4. RH Jul 31, 1900 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 77, No. 31 — GOD'S ESTIMATE OF SERVICE Ellen G. White, July 31, 1900
  5. ST Sep 9, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 35 — ADDITIONAL NOTES September 9, 1889
  6. ST Sep 2, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 34 — RENDER UNTO GOD THE THINGS OF GOD M. C. W., September 2, 1889
  7. RH Mar 23, 1905 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 82, No. 12 — Apostasy and Reformation R. A. Underwood, Thursday, March 23, 1905
  8. RH May 1, 1879 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 53, No. 18 — MASSACHUSETTS D. A. Robinson, May 1, 1879
  9. RH Apr 8, 1909 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 86, No. 14 — Dost Thou Steal? C. B. STARR, April 8, 1909
  10. RH Oct 10, 1871 Review and Herald, Vol. 38, No. 17 — A Few Thoughts on the Pharisee of Luke 18: 9-14 James Ertzenberger, Third-day, October 10, 1871
  11. RH Dec 30, 1909 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 86, No. 52 — The Wheat and the Tares F. M. W., December 30, 1909
  12. ST Mar 6, 1893 Signs of the Times, Vol. 19, No. 18 — Christian Labor and God’s Guidance Editor, Monday, March 6, 1893
  13. RH May 4, 1905 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 82, No. 18 — College View R. D. Quinn, May 4, 1905
  14. ST Dec 20, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 51 — LESSON XIV.—SUNDAY, DECEMBER 31, 1899 December 20, 1899
  15. RH Aug 29, 1865 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 26, No. 13 — Meetings in Michigan Joseph Bates, Third-Day, August 29, 1865
  16. ST Nov 22, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 47 — LESSON XII.—SUNDAY, DECEMBER 17, 1899 NOVEMBER 22, 1899
  17. ST Mar 20, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 12 — THE SABBATH SCHOOL March 20, 1901
  18. RH Aug 31, 1911 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 88, No. 35 — The Privilege of Serving[^1] August 31, 1911
  19. RH Jan 24, 1871 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 37, No. 6 — Stingy Christians January 24, 1871
  20. RH Apr 20, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 20 — Secret Societies Ellen G. White, April 20, 1916
  21. RH Apr 3, 1866 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 27, No. 18 — Our Words Jesse Dorcas, April 3, 1866
  22. ST Dec 20, 1899 Signs of the Times, Vol. 25, No. 51 — Men or God Editor, December 20, 1899
  23. ST Sep 12, 1895 Signs of the Times, Vol. 21, No. 36 — Lesson XIII.—Sabbath, September 28, 1895 September 12, 1895
  24. RH Apr 5, 1864 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 23, No. 19 — To the Churches in Ohio J. H. Waggoner, Third-Day, April 5, 1864

Cross-references

  1. Malachi 3:8

    Will a man rob God? Yet ye have robbed me. But ye say, Wherein have we robbed thee? In tithes and offerings.

    Withholding God’s portion is portrayed as robbing God.

  2. Malachi 2:17

    Ye have wearied the LORD with your words. Yet ye say, Wherein have we wearied him? When ye say, Every one that doeth evil is good in the sight of the LORD, and he delighteth in them; or, Where is the God of judgment?

    Complaints about God’s justice weary him.

  3. Matthew 12:34-37

    O generation of vipers, how can ye, being evil, speak good things? for out of the abundance of the heart the mouth speaketh.

    The heart’s abundance shapes speech, and people answer for their words.

  4. Malachi 3:7

    Even from the days of your fathers ye are gone away from mine ordinances, and have not kept them. Return unto me, and I will return unto you, saith the LORD of hosts. But ye said, Wherein shall we return?

    The people’s question echoes their refusal to see why they must return to God.