Malachi 3:8
Will a man rob God? Yet ye have robbed me. But ye say, Wherein have we robbed thee? In tithes and offerings.
Translations
Will a man rob God? Yet you have robbed me. But you say, Wherein have we robbed you? In tithes and offerings.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
Will a man rob God? Yet ye have robbed me. But ye say, Wherein have we robbed thee? In tithes and offerings.
Will a man rob God? yet ye have robbed me. But ye say, In what have we robbed thee? In tithes and offerings.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
Will a man rob God? yet ye rob me. But ye say, Wherein have we robbed thee? In tithes and offerings.
Doth man deceive God? but ye are deceiving Me, And ye have said: 'In what have we deceived Thee?' The tithe and the heave-offering!
Will a man rob God? But ye rob me. And ye say, Wherein do we rob thee? [ In] tithes and heave-offerings.
Will, a son of earth, defraud, God? Nevertheless, ye, have been defrauding me, and yet ye say, Wherein have we defrauded thee? In the tithe and the offering.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Will a man rob God? Yet you are robbing Me!But you ask, ‘ How do we rob You?’In tithes and offerings.
Will a man rob God? Yet you rob me! But you say, ‘ How have we robbed you?’ In tithes and offerings.
Will a man keep back from God what is right? But you have kept back what is mine. But you say, What have we kept back from you? Tenths and offerings.
Will a man spoyle his gods? yet haue ye spoyled me: but ye say, Wherein haue we spoyled thee? In tithes, and offerings.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Shall a man afflict God? for you afflict me. And you have said: Wherein do we afflict thee? in tithes and in firstfruits.
Cross-references 20 of 70
- Leviticus 27:30
And all the tithe of the land, whether of the seed of the land, or of the fruit of the tree, is the LORD’s: it is holy unto the LORD.
Declares the tithe holy and belonging to the Lord.
- Matthew 23:23
Woe unto you, scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites! for ye pay tithe of mint and anise and cummin, and have omitted the weightier matters of the law, judgment, mercy, and faith: these ought ye to have done, and not to leave the other undone.
Jesus affirms tithing while stressing justice, mercy, and faith.
- Genesis 14:20
And blessed be the most high God, which hath delivered thine enemies into thy hand. And he gave him tithes of all.
Abraham gave Melchizedek a tenth, acknowledging God’s ownership.
- Proverbs 3:9-10
Honour the LORD with thy substance, and with the firstfruits of all thine increase:
Honoring God with substance and firstfruits is tied to promised provision.
- Genesis 28:22
And this stone, which I have set for a pillar, shall be God’s house: and of all that thou shalt give me I will surely give the tenth unto thee.
Jacob vows to give God a tenth of all he receives.
- 1 Corinthians 16:2
Upon the first day of the week let every one of you lay by him in store, as God hath prospered him, that there be no gatherings when I come.
Instructs believers to set aside gifts regularly in proportion to their prosperity.
- 2 Corinthians 9:7
Every man according as he purposeth in his heart, so let him give; not grudgingly, or of necessity: for God loveth a cheerful giver.
Both texts connect giving offerings with giving willingly and cheerfully.
- Acts 5:1-4
But a certain man named Ananias, with Sapphira his wife, sold a possession,
Ananias kept back part of the proceeds while pretending to give the full amount.
- Numbers 18:21
And, behold, I have given the children of Levi all the tenth in Israel for an inheritance, for their service which they serve, even the service of the tabernacle of the congregation.
Israel’s tithe is assigned to the Levites for their sanctuary service.
- 1 Corinthians 9:13-14
Do ye not know that they which minister about holy things live of the things of the temple? and they which wait at the altar are partakers with the altar?
Temple provision for priests is applied to support for gospel ministers.
- Exodus 20:15
Thou shalt not steal.
Withholding God’s tithes and offerings is called stealing.
- Luke 11:42
But woe unto you, Pharisees! for ye tithe mint and rue and all manner of herbs, and pass over judgment and the love of God: these ought ye to have done, and not to leave the other undone.
Jesus affirms tithing while warning against neglecting justice and love for God.
- Deuteronomy 14:22
Thou shalt truly tithe all the increase of thy seed, that the field bringeth forth year by year.
Both texts command the faithful giving of a tithe from one’s increase.
- 1 Chronicles 29:14
But who am I, and what is my people, that we should be able to offer so willingly after this sort? for all things come of thee, and of thine own have we given thee.
Giving to God returns what already belongs to him.
- 2 Chronicles 31:5-6
And as soon as the commandment came abroad, the children of Israel brought in abundance the firstfruits of corn, wine, and oil, and honey, and of all the increase of the field; and the tithe of all things brought they in abundantly.
The people bring abundant tithes and firstfruits, supplying the priests and accompanying God’s blessing.
- Hebrews 7:1-10
For this Melchisedec, king of Salem, priest of the most high God, who met Abraham returning from the slaughter of the kings, and blessed him;
Abraham paid tithes to Melchizedek, and Levi paid tithes through Abraham.
- Nehemiah 13:10-12
And I perceived that the portions of the Levites had not been given them: for the Levites and the singers, that did the work, were fled every one to his field.
Neglected tithes left the Levites without support, and Nehemiah restored their provision.
- Deuteronomy 16:16-17
Three times in a year shall all thy males appear before the LORD thy God in the place which he shall choose; in the feast of unleavened bread, and in the feast of weeks, and in the feast of tabernacles: and they shall not appear before the LORD empty:
Worshipers must give according to God’s blessing and not appear before him empty-handed.
- Nehemiah 10:37-38
And that we should bring the firstfruits of our dough, and our offerings, and the fruit of all manner of trees, of wine and of oil, unto the priests, to the chambers of the house of our God; and the tithes of our ground unto the Levites, that the same Levites might have the tithes in all the cities of our tillage.
The people bring tithes and offerings to support the temple service.
- Haggai 2:8
The silver is mine, and the gold is mine, saith the LORD of hosts.
Declares that silver and gold belong to God.
Commentary part 1 of 4
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
367 sources
Withholding from God the tithes and offerings that belong to him is robbing him.3T 408.4–409.1ST May 6, 1875RH Apr 20, 1905 The tithe is a tenth of all increase set apart as sacred and reserved for him, not an amount to give or withhold by impulse.3T 408.4–409.1ST May 6, 1875STMW7 20.2 Offerings in addition to the tithe are also required, with no one to come before him empty-handed.3T 408.4–409.1ST May 6, 1875STMW7 20.2 Tithes and offerings are his own property reserved to sustain gospel laborers and advance his work, and withholding them empties the treasury and hinders the work.3T 408.4–409.1RH Dec 24, 190313MR 235.1–2Lt 354, 1906, par. 5–12STMW9 71.2–3 Withholding brings a curse while faithful returning brings blessing, and neglect must be confessed and repented of with restoration of what was withheld.RH Apr 20, 1905Lt 46, 1888, par. 13–15Lt 223, 1904, par. 26–28Ms 35, 1891, par. 34–36Ms 192, 1898, par. 2
Robbery Charge Stated
Withholding tithes and offerings that belong to God is robbing Him, including withholding or misusing what is due for His cause and work.3T 408.4–409.1ST May 6, 1875RH Apr 20, 1905RH Dec 24, 1903STMW7 20.2 Giving a faithful tenth of increase together with trespass and thank offerings supports His work, while neglecting this plan leaves the treasury impoverished and the church backslidden.3T 408.4–409.1ST May 6, 1875 The tenth is reserved for sacred purposes and offerings are also required, and returning a portion of what is entrusted shows dependence on Him and accountability to Him for carrying forward the gospel commission.ST May 6, 1875RH Dec 24, 1903 These resources are His and are reserved to support the work of publishing salvation and sharing the news of the Saviour with perishing souls, and using them for self-service and self-glorification obstructs the cause of truth.RH Apr 20, 1905RH Dec 24, 19036T 387.3–388.1 Failure to bring these gifts is the explicit answer to the question wherein He has been robbed, making faithfulness in tithes and offerings an explicit duty to God.ST May 6, 1875RH Apr 20, 1905STMW7 20.2
The charge is laid against the whole nation, which lies under a curse for this robbery while remaining unconvicted of sin and asking wherein it has robbed Him, and the answer given is in tithes and offerings.ST May 6, 1875RH Apr 20, 1905PK 707.2–3RH Aug 25, 1874Ms 24, 1901, par. 22–23 Going away from His ordinances includes this robbery, and this robbery of God is widespread.Ms 124, 1898, par. 22 The people deny knowing how they have robbed Him, but their failure is not returning what belongs to Him, and returning to Him requires restoring tithes and offerings to the storehouse to receive opened windows of heaven and protection of the fruits of the ground in a land other nations will call blessed.RH Aug 25, 1874Ms 24, 1901, par. 22–23Ms 124, 1898, par. 22
The question wherein have we robbed Thee reveals how selfishness can harden the conscience so that people fail to recognize the wrong they have done.6T 387.3–388.1Lt 38, 1902, par. 25–27STMW9 71.2–3 God with all-seeing eye sees every purpose of the heart and every transaction and cannot be deceived or cheated by human device.13MR 235.1–2Ms 2, 1900, par. 7–9 All must be tested in His balances whereby He weighs character, and the world's misuse of what He has lent will be answered for in the judgment when each receives sentence according to deeds.6T 387.3–388.113MR 235.1–2STMW9 71.2–3 Failure to fulfill the conditions of the agreement entered into with His people by returning what He calls for is treacherous dealing with the Creator, and those who deal treacherously with their Maker will certainly deal treacherously with fellow men.RH Jan 17, 1907 The portion He claims is tithes and offerings from annual increase of substance and business prosperity, to pass into the treasury for support of the gospel and missionary work in different parts of the land, and while some give conscientiously a large number deliberately withhold it, leaving undone what He requires and making a record they will not care to meet.13MR 235.1–2Lt 38, 1902, par. 25–27
The robbery is recorded in heaven's books as unfaithful dealing with God and will meet a person in the judgment when excuses disappear and destiny is fixed.STOM 40.2–41.13T 393.1–394.3STA 50.2–51.1Lt 23a, 1893, par. 57–59Ms 47, 1900, par. 5 The unpaid tithe is a debt owed to Him registered in the books of heaven, and being deficient causes withdrawal of His special blessing and requires careful self-examination, speedy repentance proved by works, and making up the deficiency without delay.Lt 23a, 1893, par. 57–59Ms 47, 1900, par. 5 Later correct giving alone does not erase the record, and repentance requires more than beginning to give correctly from then on.3T 393.1–394.3 Each person is responsible before Him for giving much or little under the system of regular weekly and monthly giving that tests the heart and develops character, and the gift is faithfully recorded, while continued covetousness brings separation from His people and loss of His prospering hand.1T 237.1–238.1
Robbing God is a real offense though the question suggests it unthinkable.Lt 8, 1890, par. 9–11 It applies to those who know His instructions about giving but fail to follow them, including by substituting their own plans for His arrangements.Lt 8, 1890, par. 9–11 It was presented as plain truth that could reach hearts of those who did not see the tithing system or their duty to pay, including an able church member taught the plain duty who had paid no tithe.Lt 8, 1890, par. 9–11Lt 112, 1896, par. 5–8
The warning applies to all generations against covetous withholding while pretending to fulfill duty, since God detects hidden sin and will not be mocked.AA 73.4–74.1 Keeping back what has been promised to Him while pretending to fulfill duty is fraud and hypocrisy warned against by the verse.AA 73.4–74.1 It applies to church members whose names remain on the books but who do not serve Him by withholding tithes and offerings that He requires as His portion.Lt 126, 1898, par. 2621MR 57.2 Their failure does not justify disparaging the church or those who remain faithful amid trial.21MR 57.2 Holding back is a crime with eternal danger because it comes from selfishness and worldliness.Ms 33, 1912, par. 14
Tithe Reserved Portion
The tithe is a tenth of all increase, possessions, income, substance and capital, large or small, set apart regularly as sacred and reserved by God for himself.3T 408.4–409.1ST May 6, 1875STMW7 20.2RH Aug 25, 1874Ms 65a, 1898, par. 11–16 The first and choicest appropriation belongs to him by definite arrangement, not an amount to give or withhold by impulse, and even small jots and tittles covetously retained are robbery that leaves the treasury impoverished.3T 408.4–409.1ST May 6, 1875RH Aug 25, 1874Ms 65a, 1898, par. 11–16Lt 46, 1888, par. 13–15 Withholding tithes and offerings that belong to him is robbing him, and the question wherein they have robbed him is answered plainly that it is in failing to bring these gifts, a charge laid against the whole nation.3T 408.4–409.1ST May 6, 1875STMW7 20.2RH Aug 25, 1874Lt 46, 1888, par. 13–15 His arrangement must be followed exactly, not offset by deeds of charity or gifts given when and how one chooses, nor averaged up by good impulses, and even those with small means must render it back without stopping to measure how they are coming out.Ms 65a, 1898, par. 11–16Lt 46, 1888, par. 13–15
A tenth is sacred and reserved for God just as the seventh day is set apart to him, with the remaining nine-tenths entrusted to people.RH Aug 25, 18743T 395.2–396.1Ms 34, 1887, par. 13 To employ that portion for one's own use is to rob him just as to employ his sacred Sabbath time for one's own use is to rob him.3T 395.2–396.1Ms 34, 1887, par. 13Ms 35, 1891, par. 37–38 God allows people to keep the rest while calling them to return what belongs to him, and failure to heed reflects a heart distracted by worldly concerns.3T 395.2–396.1Ms 34, 1887, par. 13Ms 35, 1891, par. 37–38 Limiting gifts limits blessings received, while honoring his claims with substance shares in promised prosperity, and tithing is no burden to willing hearts that love God.Ms 65a, 1898, par. 11–163T 395.2–396.1
The tithing system named is treated as already known and understood, reaching back to Abraham who gave a tenth to Melchizedek priest of the Most High.Ms 169, 1899, par. 45–46Ms 147, 1901, par. 1–7Lt 158, 1896, par. 2–3Ms 34, 1887, par. 13 It is the Bible plan ordained from the first and enjoined in all ages from Noah and Abraham onward as God's means to carry forward his work upon the earth and to impress that he is giver of all blessings.Ms 169, 1899, par. 45–46Ms 34, 1887, par. 13 The tithe is the Lord's portion of all possessed and received, owed with intellect and all capabilities by those connected with his appointed institutions, to be brought freely, willingly and gladly into the storehouse where there is blessing, for there is no safety in withholding.Ms 169, 1899, par. 45–46Ms 147, 1901, par. 1–7Ms 34, 1887, par. 13 Payment is not to be compelled by man any more than keeping the Sabbath is compelled, but both must be obeyed from a willing heart.Ms 34, 1887, par. 13
The obligation is even more binding now, with the first appropriation of every week's income belonging to God.ST Jan 29, 1880 Under the system enjoined on the Jews they were required to bring the first of flocks, herds, fields, orchards and vineyards or redeem it with an equivalent, while now his claims are left till last.ST Jan 29, 1880 Because the commission to preach the gospel throughout the world extends the work and increases responsibility, tenfold more means are needed and proportionate giving by rich and poor is doubly essential.ST Jan 29, 1880 Many part reluctantly, giving less than one-twentieth and robbing God of even the little tithe, or giving only the tithe with no offerings, yet if all tithes flowed into the treasury blessings would multiply gifts and offerings tenfold and keep open the channel between God and man.ST Jan 29, 1880 Those spiritually awake hear in every week's income the demand for tithes and offerings without waiting for thrilling missionary appeals.ST Jan 29, 1880
The tenth of increase is the least due to God, while offerings such as sin, peace, thank, trespass and gratitude offerings are additional.3T 393.1–394.3ST May 6, 1875 Ancient people devoted no less than one-third of income to sacred and religious purposes, and the urgent work in the last days calls for an even deeper spirit of sacrifice.3T 393.1–394.33T 395.2–396.1ST May 6, 1875 Giving is voluntary, but neglecting this trust is recorded in heaven as unfaithful dealing, and later correct giving alone does not erase the record.3T 393.1–394.3 Cheerful, willing, systematic giving brings prosperity in proportion to obedience in every age, while those who limit giving limit blessings received.3T 395.2–396.1ST May 6, 1875
The robbery has continued long because people do not realize the tithe is God's sacred reserved portion, have lost sense of his requirements, and think its sacred claim no longer exists.7MR 136.5–137.1 The tithe is to be brought into his treasury to sustain gospel laborers in their work.7MR 136.5–137.1 The verse is a plain direct command that must correct human ideas and practices rather than be blunted, mingled with prejudice, or evaded because other believers are imperfect.Lt 63a, 1893, par. 39–45 Disobeying brings his curse, especially in the last days when deceptive power leads men to corrupt the Word because their natures rise against its requirements.Lt 63a, 1893, par. 39–45 Faithfulness requires acknowledging all means belong to God, returning the portion he claims without flinching even when entrusted with large wealth, and using his capital to build up the Redeemer's kingdom.Lt 63a, 1893, par. 39–45
Offerings and Vows
Withholding offerings as well as the tenth is robbing God, for the tenth is reserved for sacred purposes and offerings are also required of all.3T 408.4–409.1ST May 6, 1875STMW7 20.2RH Aug 25, 1874Lt 46, 1888, par. 13–15 The faithful tenth of increase is to be given together with trespass and thank offerings to support his work, and neglecting this plan leaves the treasury impoverished.3T 408.4–409.1ST May 6, 1875STMW7 20.2 Even small withholdings kept back covetously drain the agreed proportion from the treasury, keep men under condemnation as unfaithful stewards, and forfeit the promised blessing and trust for larger responsibilities.STMW7 20.2Ms 65a, 1898, par. 11–16Lt 46, 1888, par. 13–15 Offerings beyond the tithe include willing, continual, first and best gifts, sin, trespass, thank, gratitude and peace offerings, with regular contributions, special freewill gifts and provision for the poor, and no one is to come before him empty-handed.ST Jan 29, 1880AA 74.2–75.2RH Feb 2, 1911ST Jan 29, 1880Lt 33a, 1888, par. 19–21 God's arrangement must be followed exactly and cannot be offset by deeds of charity or by gifts and offerings given when and how human agents see fit, nor improved by averaging up good impulses.Ms 65a, 1898, par. 11–16ST Jan 29, 1880
Treating offerings as deficient, stinted, grudging or small is robbery, for offerings reveal whether sacred things are valued above self-interest and whether hearts are reverent toward him.2T 256.3–258.3ST Sep 2, 18861T 221.1 Covetous withholding brings judgment in proportion withheld, with harvests and flocks suffering, families afflicted, and the withheld offering recorded in heaven.2T 256.3–258.3ST Sep 2, 1886SG4 210.2–31T 221.1 He rejects lame offerings and accepts only what is without blemish, the best of flock or field, given freely, with his blessing then resting on families and possessions.ST Sep 2, 1886SG4 210.2–31T 221.1
Promises made under the Holy Spirit's influence to support churches, schools, missionary work and other institutions are binding obligations to be honored, not set aside when payment becomes inconvenient.5T 153.25T 153.14T 468.1 Lives are to be examined for unpaid pledges and vows, with faithfulness shown in being exact in promises and in settling one's account with him while one has means.5T 153.24T 468.1Lt 33, 1888, par. 38–39Lt 33a, 1888, par. 19–21 Faithfulness to him in these transactions belongs alongside honesty in dealings with others, and guilt remains even when others do not know of the neglect.4T 468.1ST Jan 29, 1880Lt 33a, 1888, par. 19–21 A verbal or written pledge made in the presence of brethren to advance his sacred work is a vow and contract made not to man but to God, more binding than any legal bond for money.ST Jan 29, 1880 To withhold or turn to one's own use what has been pledged, including tithes and offerings, and to seek release from it, treats a promise to God as less binding than a promise to man and is sacrilege.ST Jan 29, 18804T 469.2–470.2ST Jan 29, 1880 The sin is just as heinous now as that of Ananias and Sapphira even though no visible mark of displeasure follows, with vows and actions weighed in the balance of justice in the heavenly courts, to be surely visited in the day of judgment, and many feel his curse even in this life.ST Jan 29, 1880
Robbery includes failing to fulfill pledges for churches, schools, institutions and missionary work when means are available, neglecting vows and unpaid pledges, withdrawing a pledge, or giving reluctantly.5T 153.14T 468.1ST Jan 29, 18804T 469.2–470.2 Only utter inability to pay can excuse neglect, and indifference in paying tithes and meeting pledges shows blindness and unworthiness of the Christian name.5T 153.14T 468.1ST Jan 29, 1880 Once a particular amount is vowed to him that portion is consecrated and is no longer one's own to withhold, while the tenth remains his claim and any gift beyond it is voluntary.AA 74.2–75.2RH Feb 2, 1911 Pretending to meet his requirements while keeping back what is due is fraud and hypocrisy, and dissembling and covetousness in dealing with him is among the greatest sins.ST Jan 29, 18804T 469.2–470.2RH Feb 2, 1911 Neglected vows and unpaid pledges should trouble the conscience as an unpaid honest debt to a neighbor would, for every person will answer to him in the last day.4T 468.14T 469.2–470.2ST Jan 29, 1880
Stewards of God's Goods
All things belong to God, and men and women are only stewards, hired servants and agents and not owners of money, possessions, produce, abilities and blessings, including life and strength and power to gain wealth and the produce of field, orchard and soil entrusted according to known ability through human representatives to be traded upon and required again, while money in the hands of worldly men is God's own money they have been robbing all their lives.13MR 235.1–2Ms 35, 1891, par. 34–36Lt 354, 1906, par. 5–12Ms 139, 1906, par. 47–48RH Jan 17, 1907 Withholding tithes and offerings that belong to him is robbing him, and it is dangerous business to do so, for with his all-seeing eye he sees every purpose of the heart and cannot be deceived or cheated by human device, and all must be tested in his balances whereby he weighs character so each must decide to be honest whatever the circumstances and let no temptation force dishonesty with fellow men or with God.13MR 235.1–2Ms 35, 1891, par. 34–36RH Jan 17, 1907 The portion he claims is tithes and offerings from annual increase of substance and business prosperity, to pass into his treasury for support of the gospel and for missionary work in different parts of the land and to help the poor and sustain that work, while the blessings and abilities used to produce food are entrusted by him and not given for one person to claim and exploit for private gain.13MR 235.1–2Lt 354, 1906, par. 5–12Ms 139, 1906, par. 47–48 While some conscientiously give this, a large number deliberately rob him by withholding it and treating everything as their own and refusing to return that portion in selfish robbery, which calls for repentance and giving him what is his, since persistent robbery is subject to judgment and the curse described in the following verse.13MR 235.1–2Ms 35, 1891, par. 34–36 The withholding exposes especially the temptation of those entrusted with large capital to indulge selfishness and avarice and keep back his own, yet one who loves and fears him will not find meeting the claims on an enlightened conscience a burden but will meet that temptation by answering with what is written, for all that people possess belongs to him who has given them life and their means.Ms 99, 1893, par. 21Ms 139, 1906, par. 47–48
People belong to him by creation and redemption, bought with Christ's blood and depending on him for life and being, and his rightful claim to persons, time, strength and money is grounded not only in right but also in love, belonging to covenant relation and confirmed through Christ who put his signature upon the contract, so required returns stand as covenant obligation.Ms 7, 1884, par. 12Ms 103, 1906, par. 15Lt 21, 1894, par. 17Ms 57, 1901, par. 4 Faithfulness in these gifts is part of that covenant relation and supports the work of warning the world and extending the work into new territories.Ms 103, 1906, par. 15 Withholding from him what is due is robbery, and the principle also applies to misusing God-given abilities and influence instead of putting them to their best use and to defrauding him by using his owned faculties and powers for sinful purposes, as in profane speech, evil thoughts, unhallowed passions and ungodly gain that turn body and powers into instruments of unrighteousness.5T 116.2EDFCP 12.3Ms 7, 1884, par. 12 These are entrusted talents that must be improved, and wasting them brings condemnation rather than the commendation given to a faithful servant, while honesty toward other people is no reason for self-congratulation if what belongs to him is withheld, and using these gifts for selfish pleasure violates his rightful claim.EDFCP 12.3Ms 7, 1884, par. 12Lt 21, 1894, par. 17 To rob him in this way is to trifle with him by selfishly withholding the returns he declared should be made to him, though he is tender and true toward his people and has given the richest blessings in Christ.Ms 57, 1901, par. 4
Returning tithes, gifts and offerings acknowledges that every mercy and entrusted possession comes from him and belongs to him, shows dependence, accountability, loyalty and gratitude, shows others that his children remember him as giver, and acknowledges that he makes people producers as well as consumers, with money devoted to saving souls laying up treasure in heaven.RH Dec 24, 1903Ms 65a, 1898, par. 11–16Ms 93, 1898, par. 16–20COL 144.3–5Ms 25, 1894, par. 9–11 Everything a man calls his own is entrusted to him, and a certain portion is to be given back in tithes and offerings as a return for his gifts and to sustain the preaching of the gospel and provide for the ministers he has appointed to give the message of mercy to a fallen world and for the watchmen upon the walls in no haphazard manner, turning men from unrighteousness to obedience.Ms 93, 1898, par. 16–20COL 144.3–5 Giving that portion shows appreciation for his gifts, while withholding it is unfaithful stewardship and covetously retaining even in small jots and tittles what should flow into the treasury, which may be a reason for unanswered prayer.RH Dec 24, 1903Ms 65a, 1898, par. 11–16COL 144.3–5 He owns all things but reserves a portion of what he entrusts so people can serve as stewards and support his work, and returning it is a response to his love and a token of loyalty and dependence, while those who withhold it are accountable and are recorded as misappropriating his property.Ms 25, 1894, par. 9–11 Choosing one's own way and transgressing his commandments and ordinances is spiritual blindness, for he gave his ordinances to keep men in harmony with his ways and will so he can cooperate with them in advancing his kingdom, and all receivers of his great treasure, mercies and stores must express appreciation by complying with his conditions and using entrusted gifts as faithful stewards, giving back of his own.Ms 93, 1898, par. 16–20
His arrangement must be followed exactly, not offset by deeds of charity, gifts or offerings given when and how human agents see fit nor improved by makeshifts averaging up good impulses, and even those with small means must render back the tenth of all increase because it belongs to him and is not their own, without stopping to measure how they are coming out.Ms 65a, 1898, par. 11–16Ms 42, 1898, par. 13–20 Unfaithfulness keeps men under condemnation as unfaithful stewards, deprives his treasury of its agreed proportion, deprives themselves of the promised blessing, forfeits trust for larger responsibilities and facilities for obtaining more, and if unfaithful with the least they cannot be entrusted with larger responsibilities.Ms 65a, 1898, par. 11–16Ms 42, 1898, par. 13–20 Those who strike true and faithful figures in tithing and bring all the tithes into the storehouse that there may be meat in his house and then trust him with goods to trade upon and teach others to do the same receive his pledged word to open the windows of heaven and pour out a blessing without room to receive it and to rebuke the devourer with fruits of the ground and vine preserved and all nations calling them blessed in a delightsome land, while his blessing is withdrawn from dishonest, covetous members who walk in their own wisdom and withhold their proportion.Ms 65a, 1898, par. 11–16Ms 42, 1898, par. 13–20 They will meet their delinquencies when the books are opened and every man is judged according to deeds done in the body.Ms 65a, 1898, par. 11–16Ms 42, 1898, par. 13–20
All earthly blessings of food, health and clothing come daily from his hand through Jesus Christ, who left heaven and became poor that men might be rich in heavenly treasure, so it is only just to return the portion he claims as his own.Lt 30, 1893, par. 30–33 When he reserves a portion for himself it is not to enrich himself whose treasures of earth and heaven are already his but for human benefit and blessing, to give opportunity to become laborers together with him and to express gratitude by the ordained plan of tithes and offerings, which is the work he left stewards to do with entrusted means in watching for opportunities while they live to use their means themselves to help save fellow men and advance his cause in its various branches, which is only rendering to him the things that are his.2T 653.1–654.2ST Jun 11, 1894Lt 30, 1893, par. 30–33 That portion must be brought into the treasury that there may be meat in his house and that his work in saving souls may not be retarded by an empty treasury, and doing this expressed will is the only happiness and safety with no withholding to live to self.Lt 30, 1893, par. 30–33 Giving must be deliberate, regular and sustained rather than left to impulse or chance, for to rob him is also to rob self by giving up heavenly treasure for earthly gain and losing the eternal riches that could be laid up by using entrusted means to help save others, while honoring him with what one has brings his blessing on temporal affairs and his hand can defeat plans and scatter what people gather.5T 271.32T 653.1–654.2ST Jun 11, 1894 Freewill offerings do not enrich him but enrich the giver by laying up treasure in heaven, and to withhold tithes and gifts to increase earthly treasure through hearts fixed on earthly treasure, selfishness and covetousness profits nothing if the soul is lost.ST Jun 11, 1894Lt 30, 1893, par. 30–33
What people possess comes from him to be returned as consecrated gifts, a duty plainly stated and understandable even to a child.Ms 144, 1897, par. 1–4 Keeping his money weakens spiritual influence, turns people from his command, fosters selfishness and does not bring his blessing, while faithfully giving it back allows the entrusted means to increase through use in his work.Ms 144, 1897, par. 1–4 Tithes and offerings are specified goods to be consecrated as signs of loyalty and submission to his sovereignty because he is rightful owner of all possessions, and bringing them is accompanied by his promise to increase substance and provide abundance.9T 245.2
Wider Ways of Robbing
Robbing God reaches far beyond money to withholding unreserved consecration of heart, soul, mind and strength promised in professing to do his whole will, including time, capabilities, reason, thought, devotion, talents, influence and unselfish service, and refusing any obedience he enjoins while forgetting him and leaving eternity out of reckoning in seeking worldly gain at the cost of spiritual life, prayer and heart devotion.Ms 70, 1896, par. 20–24Ms 120a, 1901, par. 5Lt 72, 1893, par. 2STA 61.1STOM 48.1 Property and abilities are entrusted gifts to be used for his work and accounted for, not spent merely as one pleases, and those whose names remain on the church book yet live in business like avowed sinners break that solemn vow.Ms 70, 1896, par. 20–24Ms 120a, 1901, par. 5 Human beings are his by creation and redemption, under obligation for life, food and protecting care, so that to refuse required obedience is robbery bringing a curse, and he who bids men bring tithes and offerings to send the gospel, care for the poor, minister to widow and fatherless, and deal justly with hireling and stranger also claims the Sabbath for himself.Ms 106, 1893, par. 3–4Lt 72, 1893, par. 2 Unjust dealing with workers belongs to the same robbery, as when those controlling payments accept and defend large wages for themselves while limiting poorer workers' pay without considering need, thereby depriving his messengers and recording guilt in heaven.Lt 15, 1895, par. 14–16 The same charge meets treating his holy seventh day as common and using it for self-serving worldly work, and the whole world is guilty when it accepts a spurious sabbath and tramples the day he made holy.Ms 106, 1893, par. 3–4Lt 30, 1900, par. 10
Taking time he has reserved is robbing him, for as with means his portion of one seventh of time belongs wholly to him, and to infringe its borders each week, use even a little or one hour of the reserved seventh day for financial advantage, ordinary work and worldly talk, or set aside his sanctified seventh-day Sabbath for the first day, is to treat his commands lightly, dishonor him, breach his immutable law, and bring loss not blessing.19MR 265.2Ms 8, 1866, par. 2ExVEGW 53.1–24T 247.1 He set apart the Sabbath from toils and cares for holy communion, to lead men to contemplate his power and love in creation and redemption, and those who willfully disregard it rob themselves of rich blessing and are cursed with a curse by separating from him the source of good.Ms 106, 1893, par. 3–4 Sabbathkeepers who use his time for their own advantage fall under the charge of Malachi 3:8-9, and stewards who cling to earthly wealth also rob themselves of eternal riches by withholding time that should be devoted to his service.Ms 8, 1866, par. 22T 653.1–654.2 Time spent in needless visits and conversation that hinder laborers belongs to the Lord and should be devoted to the work, for frittering it diminishes the sacredness of the work.TBC1868 34.2–3
Robbery includes neglecting God through devotion to temporal gain, pursuing worldly interests first while forgetting him, scarcely praying, and leaving eternity and heart devotion out of work, thereby robbing one's own soul of spiritual care and one's family of godly teaching.STA 61.1STOM 48.1 Neglecting prayer and assembling for worship to have more time for farms or business shows which world is placed highest, sacrifices privileges essential to advancement, fails to gain knowledge of the divine will, and comes short of perfecting character to his measurement, marking such persons for curse rather than blessing.ST Jun 11, 1894 To profess to serve him while conducting business without devotion, piety and godliness, leaving him out of transactions and letting speculation and worldly cares displace religion, is robbery toward him, for godliness must shape every dealing and money and success cannot make work acceptable without heart piety.STOM 48.19MR 171.3–4Ms 6, 1890, par. 22–2321MR 455.3–456.1 Withholding property from spreading truth, even by placing means in children's hands to avoid responsibility to give, is likewise robbing him, for money handled is the Lord's money and to love in word but not in deed and truth fails the test of faith.ST Jun 11, 1894
Robbing God includes withholding service and abilities he claims, such as spending hours on selfish pursuits instead of serving him and laboring for others' salvation when he continually works for humanity and gave his Son.ST Jul 3, 1884 It is withholding full consecration of body, soul and spirit with all energies throughout probation, burying talents and capital where they cannot be improved, failing to use talents in useful work, hiding gifts or using them for the world, diminishing powers through frivolous amusements and selfish ambition, refusing his requirements and failing to devote every ability with cooperation of every person.ST Aug 1, 1911MYP 210.1–2RH May 23, 190714MR 12.3 A young man robs him by withholding his heart's best and holiest affections, since he is not his own but bought with precious blood, and those redeemed remain accountable for buried trusts.Lt 72, 1890, par. 5ST Aug 1, 1911 His claim to every person's service remains binding, to be answered for in judgment in proportion to light received, and to use God-given strength and resources for self and treat entrusted wealth as one's own is covetousness and idolatry.RH May 23, 190714MR 12.3 Consuming benefits and fruits of the earth without gratitude offerings and without helping others through useful work withholds what is due, for men are entrusted with talents to use wisely as producers as well as consumers.MYP 210.1–2
Misuse of physical powers is also robbery, when harmful habits shorten life and weaken fitness for service, cutting short opportunity to bless others and do the work for which they were sent into the world, for which he holds men accountable and the world is deprived of good.RH Jun 20, 1912MYP 235.1–3 Such habits include neglecting exercise, overworking, keeping late hours, or gratifying appetite at expense of health, withholding body, mind and strength entrusted for consecrated service.CH 41.2 To rob him in education is to refuse him willing service of powers of spirit, soul and body by following methods that crowd out his word and keep men from doing what he asks.FE 352.1Lt 47, 1895, par. 51–53 Education's purpose is to take in light from knowledge of God in order to impart light in good works.FE 352.1 The worst kind of robbing is parents neglecting duty in the home, withholding whole-heart service plainly revealed in the Word when he demands whole heart service of parents and children.Ms 66, 1893, par. 2 Thereby they defraud their own souls of peace and happiness in children, bring his frown instead of blessing, leave high concerns of eternity and salvation out of reckoning, and neglect and misplace things belonging to eternal peace by putting them last instead of first.Ms 66, 1893, par. 2
Keeping back from him a part of the price is robbery, and every hour spent in careless inattention to his claims wastes opportunities and privileges that are his entrusted mercies and entreaties.Lt 12, 1893, par. 43–45 Those who so rob drop the future life out of reckoning and fail to increase his talents in usefulness and efficiency, a loss nothing can supply.Lt 12, 1893, par. 43–45 Even if saved they suffer terrible eternal loss with diminished crown, receiving according to works.Lt 12, 1893, par. 43–45
Selfish and Unjust Gain
Withholding tithes and offerings is robbery rooted in selfishness, covetousness, avarice, self-gratification and a heart fixed on earthly treasure, contrary to the liberality of Christ who gave Himself. AA 339.1PP 496.4–497.1ST Sep 1, 1909AA 339.2–33T 409.2–410.2 It includes professing faith while keeping unlawful gains and neglecting duty to give, which hinders the gospel and brings reproach on Christian faith. PP 496.4–497.1ST Sep 1, 1909 It includes making pleasure and selfish interest chief, seeking greatest profit in dollars and cents, loving money as ruling passion, laying up treasure on earth, and clinging to growing possessions from fear of want through lack of trust. RH Dec 15, 1874 It includes fastening money in property that must be sold before it can be used, used as excuse for doing little, which is as effectual a burial as the man in the parable, and in robbing God of the tenth robbers rob themselves of heavenly treasure. RH Dec 15, 1874
Means are robbed when withheld for personal gain and self-indulgence instead of sending the gospel to all parts of the world, and money so withheld becomes a curse bringing loss rather than increase. RH Apr 20, 19059T 53.32T 59.1 The robbery comes from self-indulgence, spending on unnecessary things, letting the world convert the church to its customs and fashions and gratifications, failing self-denial, and indolence, while faithful trading upon pence or pounds brings increase and divine commendation and the slothful burying of talent brings curse. Lt 15, 1887, par. 7–8 It includes spending on display, pride, amusement, extravagant dress, homes, land, embellishing houses and needless show instead of clothing the naked, feeding the hungry and advancing the cause. Ms 38a, 1905, par. 16–17Ms 100, 1899, par. 19–21 Money wasted on drink that destroys reason and on needless dress and fashion could support missions where people need the gospel, and using God-given means for costly massive structures instead of sending light to dark places must be answered for. Ms 38a, 1905, par. 16–17Ms 100, 1899, par. 19–21
Spending God's money on tobacco while souls perish for want of the word of life and the cause lacks means is robbing Him in tithes and offerings that should sustain the gospel. CH 84.1 Professed Christians rob Him when they spend more on tobacco than to relieve the poor or supply the wants of His cause, offering enormous yearly sums on the altar of destroying lust. CH 84.1ST Oct 5, 1882BS 28.1 Money entrusted to His people is also diverted when spent on selfish or useless purposes including photographs, calling for repentance, humbling, overcoming every hurtful lust, and redirecting needless expense into the treasury through self-denial, self-sacrifice and temperance. CH 84.1RH Nov 26, 1901
God is robbed when people spend heavily on harmful indulgences while giving too little to support the gospel or relieve the poor, for means entrusted belong to the Lord for His service. GC 474.2–475.1GC88 474.3–475.1 Using money entrusted for wasteful or selfish purposes such as showy clothing for games robs His treasury, when it could take truth to new places. 2MR 219.1–2 Using time rightly belonging to God for elaborate entertainment for display is also robbery, wronging family members of needed attention and leading others to follow. 6T 343.1–3
Robbing God includes unjust treatment of His workers and institutions, as when those accepting large wages secure them for others while limiting poorer workers' pay without considering needs, pressing messengers into hardship recorded in heaven. 17MR 111.1–112.1 It includes leaders in publishing houses setting excessive wages and diverting funds that should support the work and laborers, reflecting covetousness and lack of self-denial and leaving the treasury short. Ms 2, 1900, par. 7–9 It includes failing to pay women laboring with husbands for their time, keeping back rightful wages of workers in His cause through lack of support, extorting money from believers and thereby robbing the treasury, and taking money belonging to His cause or extorted from His institutions, which harms and obstructs the work and must be put right. 7MR 391.2TEPD 79.25T 373.1–375.25MR 443.3–444.3 It includes taking consecrated money in a strait place, betraying His cause or allowing institutions and property to be harmed, and amassing wealth through iniquity and greed which robs both God and fellow beings. Ms 149, 1898, par. 12ST Apr 21, 1881
Taking money from God's treasury for one's own pay or benefit by taking higher or excessive wages than earned by honest effort is robbery and idolatry, especially when those taking receive more while others labor harder for less. 6MR 39.3Lt 26, 1897, par. 37–38Ms 142, 1903, par. 109–110 Plans to obtain advantage for self open the door to such dishonest practices, and withholding funds that should support fellow workers in needy fields is included. Lt 26, 1897, par. 37–38Ms 142, 1903, par. 109–110 Taking pay while neglecting duties for which it is given is robbery requiring thorough repentance, and selfishly seeking higher wages as full duty mingles the profane with the sacred and spreads like contagion, leavening witnesses with doubt until they hold back what belongs to God. RH Jan 4, 1906Ms 19a, 1891, par. 33T 559.3–560.2
The priests robbed God by taking the people's offerings for themselves for personal use, while public prayers, almsgiving and strict outward forms hid greed and lack of mercy including heavy taxes on widows. LC1 12.21RED 12.2 Priests and teachers were especially guilty because charged to teach faithfully and serve, yet greedily misused entrusted means, giving Gentiles reason to misjudge His character and kingdom. COL 292.1–3
Robbing God includes dishonest, selfish and unfair dealing in trade and business, such as seeking to buy land for less than known worth, trafficking for selfish gain with property bought by money given for His service, buying below real value and selling for gain and robbing a poor man in trades such as horse and cow, and misusing His goods for personal advantage, self-glory or wealth gained through injustice and deceit. Lt 110, 1897, par. 15–22Ms 149, 1898, par. 12 It includes taking advantage of small facilities of His work without fair payment, blind crooked devising and dickering woven with unfairness, grasping funds, denying fair compensation and retaining extra wages, and pursuing dishonest gain while connected with His work, which calls for removal unless there is sincere repentance and thorough conversion. Ms 149, 1898, par. 12ST Apr 21, 1881 Managers must therefore guard incomes and outgoes to keep dealing fair, clean and pure as they would be done by, under pain of punishment, for God keeps men alive every moment, bears long, marks wrongdoing, but after the day of test will not favor the unconverted robber whose character offends God and stumbles the church. Lt 110, 1897, par. 15–22Ms 149, 1898, par. 12
The principle applies to workers handling funds for His cause, where unfaithfulness can drain resources, burden it with debt and endanger the soul by weakening discernment of right principles. Ms 24, 1894, par. 6 Those entrusted with managing resources rob Him by failing to handle facilities and means with strict integrity and care, thereby preventing funds from reaching the treasury to build up the work in many places. Lt 19, 1905, par. 7 A selfish grasping spirit brought into His office work, failing to discern sacredness, bringing incorrect principles and working merely to secure higher wages while thinking duty done, mingles strange fire with the sacred and its plague spots spread as contagiously as leprosy, showing blindness in part happened to Israel. Ms 42, 1891, par. 14 Covetousness leading to dishonest gain violates Bible teaching. Ms 42, 1891, par. 14
Selfishly using entrusted means for self instead of God's glory in relieving suffering and saving souls is embezzlement bringing accountability and a record not to be met with joy, against which God lifts a danger signal. Lt 38, 1902, par. 25–27COL 371.2 It includes turning money resolved for the treasury aside to speculative investments such as patent rights or brilliant enterprises under bewitching enchantment in hope of fast increase for a larger future gift, then lost by deception, depriving the cause of sustenance for extending truth and passing means into Satan's ranks. ST Oct 1, 1894 Misusing entrusted talents is robbing God, as in Edson's persistent choice to follow his own inclinations and disregard given light, which disappointed the Saviour, and as in Asa whose fairness toward others did not make him just with God, for failure to serve showed ingratitude for abilities, self-righteousness and failure to recognize need of the Saviour and Christ's sacrifice. Ms 96, 1901, par. 9–14Ms 23, 1868, par. 2–4Lt 111, 1890, par. 7–8 Robbery happens daily when His people follow their own inclinations and withhold required service, sin even when not thought sin, dwarfing character and placing reason on the enemy's side. Ms 96, 1901, par. 9–14
Sources