Malachi 3:14
Ye have said, It is vain to serve God: and what profit is it that we have kept his ordinance, and that we have walked mournfully before the LORD of hosts?
Translations
You have said, It is vain to serve God: and what profit is it that we have kept his ordinance, and that we have walked mournfully before the LORD of hosts?
King James Version, Webster Bible
Ye have said, It is vain to serve God: and what profit is it that we have kept his ordinance, and that we have walked mournfully before the LORD of hosts?
Ye have said, It is vain to serve God:
And what profit is it that we have kept his ordinance,
And that we have walked mournfully before the Lord of hosts?Ye have said, It is vain to serve God: and what profit is it that we have kept his charge, and that we have walked mournfully before the LORD of hosts?
Ye have said, It is vain to serve God; and what profit is it that we have kept his charge, and that we have walked mournfully before Jehovah of hosts?
Ye have said, 'A vain thing to serve God! And what gain when we kept His charge? And when we have gone in black, Because of Jehovah of Hosts?
Ye say, It is vain to serve God; and what profit is it that we keep his charge, and that we walk mournfully before Jehovah of hosts?
Ye have said, Vain is it to serve God,—and, What profit when we have kept his charge, or when we have walked gloomily before Yahweh of hosts?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
You have said, ‘ It is futile to serve God. What have we gained by keeping His requirements and walking mournfully before the LORD of Hosts?
You have said, ‘ It is vain to serve God,’ and ‘ What profit is it that we have followed his instructions and that we have walked mournfully before the LORD of Armies?
You have said, It is no use worshipping God: what profit have we had from keeping his orders, and going in clothing of sorrow before the Lord of armies?
Ye haue saide, It is in vaine to serue God: and what profite is it that we haue kept his commandement, and that we walked humbly before the Lord of hostes?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And you have said: What have we spoken against thee? You have said: He laboureth in vain that serveth God, and what profit is it that we have kept his ordinances, and that we have walked sorrowful before the Lord of hosts?
Cross-references
- Malachi 3:10
Bring ye all the tithes into the storehouse, that there may be meat in mine house, and prove me now herewith, saith the LORD of hosts, if I will not open you the windows of heaven, and pour you out a blessing, that there shall not be room enough to receive it.
God’s promised blessing is a reason to trust him rather than call service vain.
- Malachi 3:18
Then shall ye return, and discern between the righteous and the wicked, between him that serveth God and him that serveth him not.
It promises a final distinction between those who serve God and those who do not.
- Malachi 3:8
Will a man rob God? Yet ye have robbed me. But ye say, Wherein have we robbed thee? In tithes and offerings.
Withheld tithes and offerings are identified as the charge against God’s people.
- Malachi 4:1-3
For, behold, the day cometh, that shall burn as an oven; and all the proud, yea, and all that do wickedly, shall be stubble: and the day that cometh shall burn them up, saith the LORD of hosts, that it shall leave them neither root nor branch.
The wicked are destroyed, while those who fear God are delivered.
- Revelation 22:12
And, behold, I come quickly; and my reward is with me, to give every man according as his work shall be.
Christ brings each person a reward according to their works.
- Galatians 6:7-9
Be not deceived; God is not mocked: for whatsoever a man soweth, that shall he also reap.
Those who sow will reap, so believers should not grow weary while waiting.
- Malachi 2:17
Ye have wearied the LORD with your words. Yet ye say, Wherein have we wearied him? When ye say, Every one that doeth evil is good in the sight of the LORD, and he delighteth in them; or, Where is the God of judgment?
Both question whether God judges or rewards people justly.
- Luke 11:42
But woe unto you, Pharisees! for ye tithe mint and rue and all manner of herbs, and pass over judgment and the love of God: these ought ye to have done, and not to leave the other undone.
Jesus affirmed tithing alongside judgment and the love of God.
- Psalms 119:126-127
It is time for thee, LORD, to work: for they have made void thy law.
The faithful love God’s law when others treat obedience as profitless.
- Matthew 5:45
That ye may be the children of your Father which is in heaven: for he maketh his sun to rise on the evil and on the good, and sendeth rain on the just and on the unjust.
Rain falls on both the just and the unjust.
- Ecclesiastes 8:12-13
Though a sinner do evil an hundred times, and his days be prolonged, yet surely I know that it shall be well with them that fear God, which fear before him:
It contrasts the final good of those who fear God with the outcome for the wicked.
- Psalms 73:2-17
But as for me, my feet were almost gone; my steps had well nigh slipped.
The psalmist envies the wicked until he sees their end in God's sanctuary.
- Zephaniah 1:12
And it shall come to pass at that time, that I will search Jerusalem with candles, and punish the men that are settled on their lees: that say in their heart, The LORD will not do good, neither will he do evil.
Both describe people claiming that God does nothing.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
55 sources
The verse records defiant words against God claiming there is no use in serving Him and no gain in keeping His requirements and going about in sorrowful display before Him.STMW6 14.1STMW9 73.1–2Lt 223, 1904, par. 31 Walking mournfully is an outward gloomy show put on by human will from an unsanctified heart, which God never commanded.6T 389.1–2Ms 15, 1899, par. 4–5Ms 38a, 1905, par. 21–23 The complaint belongs to withholding the tithe that is the Lord's own, refusing to bring it faithfully into His storehouse to sustain His work while still expecting His favor.6T 389.1–29T 249.3–4STMW9 73.1–2GW 227.1Lt 38, 1902, par. 19–21 Serving God is not empty but brings profit and priceless reward, and He pledges Himself to bless spiritually and temporally all who deal honestly with Him and prove Him.4T 106.1–2Ms 38a, 1905, par. 33Lt 14, 1899, par. 17–19ST Feb 3, 1887Ms 5, 1891, par. 4–5 At His soon coming He will discern between those who serve Him and those who serve Him not, burning the proud and wicked as stubble while those who fear His name rejoice in the light of the Sun of Righteousness.Ms 39, 1891, par. 26Lt 15, 1892, par. 10–12Ms 38a, 1905, par. 21–23Ms 147, 1901, par. 44–45ST Feb 3, 1887
Words and Chapter Setting
The verse records defiant speech directed against God, charging that serving Him is empty and useless and demanding what gain comes from keeping His ordinance and going about in mournful humiliation before the Lord of hosts.STMW6 14.1STMW9 73.1–2Lt 223, 1904, par. 31Lt 310, 1908, par. 9–14Ms 24, 1901, par. 24–26 It is the mistaken verdict that faithfulness brings no reward and no apparent profit, doubting the value of obedience and of keeping His requirements.STMW9 73.1–2Lt 223, 1904, par. 31Lt 310, 1908, par. 9–14Ms 24, 1901, par. 24–26Ms 87, 1899, par. 20–21 The complaint belongs to those who withhold what God has specified and reserved for Himself and who neglect works of mercy, yet expect Him to recognize and favor them, accusing Him of failing to reward them.STMW9 73.1–2Ms 24, 1901, par. 24–26Ms 147, 1901, par. 44–45 Their adversity follows their own disloyalty, for they have hindered His work by using for themselves what should have supported it, and then blame Him while comparing themselves with prosperous wicked people.6T 389.1–2STMW9 73.1–2Ms 87, 1899, par. 20–21 Such words are rebellion and disloyalty rather than a faithful judgment of God, measuring His actions by human standards, dishonoring Him, and fostering evil in the soul.STMW9 73.1–2Ms 87, 1899, par. 20–21RH Jul 31, 1900
Walking mournfully denotes an outward sorrowful religious display, pictured as going in black, arising from human will and an unsanctified spirit rather than from Christ.Ms 15, 1899, par. 4–5Ms 38a, 1905, par. 21–23Ms 26, 1896, par. 22–23 No one has ever been told to walk mournfully before the Lord of hosts, and God does not want such gloom from His people.6T 389.1–2Ms 38a, 1905, par. 21–23Ms 100, 1899, par. 22–23 Those joined to Christ in obedience walk in gladness and cheerfulness in the light of the Sun of Righteousness, eating of the leaves of the tree of life, reflecting heaven's light and rejoicing because redemption is near.Ms 38a, 1905, par. 21–23Ms 100, 1899, par. 22–23 The mournful profession instead comes from those working out their own plans and following a course of their own choosing, who grumble because God does not bless them while they refuse to place themselves where He can bless them.Ms 15, 1899, par. 4–5Ms 38a, 1905, par. 21–23 They find fault with God and with their brethren and keep lamenting as they see their own wretched condition, leaving others with the impression that being Christians does not pay, in spiritual darkness and failure to understand the duty to return to God the portion He has specified as His own.Ms 15, 1899, par. 4–5Ms 38a, 1905, par. 21–23Ms 26, 1896, par. 22–23
The verse belongs to what God says in Malachi 3 about the tithe, which is the Lord's and is required by the Lord Himself.9T 249.3–4GW 227.1Lt 38, 1902, par. 19–21Ms 82, 1904, par. 12–13 That word is to be carefully read and followed for one's own good and for the sake of others who will be helped by example, giving warning and instruction in righteousness by which God still tests whether people will prove faithful servants.Lt 38, 1902, par. 19–21 It calls churches to take their stand upon it by faithfully paying the tithe into His treasury and bringing all the tithes into the storehouse, without withholding or diverting to other lines of work.9T 249.3–4GW 227.1Ms 82, 1904, par. 12–13Ms 33, 1907, par. 17 The tithe in the treasury sustains ministerial work, provides abundant supply rather than depletion caused by selfish hearts and hands, encourages more men to give themselves to the ministry, and answers God's call to consider His goodness, respond to His mercy, and prove loyalty.GW 227.1Ms 33, 1907, par. 17 Appropriating to personal use the portion God has reserved proves an unfaithful steward, obstructs the work, discourages ministers, and causes loss not only of what was withheld from God but also of what was held as one's own, while those who refuse to comply after their attention has been called to the subject, disregarding the Lord's claims as non-essential, will be dealt with in the manner described in the chapter, under His promise to open the windows of heaven and pour out a blessing with no room to receive it.Lt 38, 1902, par. 19–21Ms 82, 1904, par. 12–13
Its immediate setting joins the complaint to envy of the wicked, calling the proud happy and saying that workers of wickedness who tempt God are built up, set up, and delivered.Ms 39, 1891, par. 26Lt 123, 1897, par. 29–31Ms 53, 1894, par. 50–52Ms 16, 1902, par. 13–15Ms 142, 1903, par. 123–125 It is the speech of the unconsecrated who have departed from God, blinded by the enemy so they cannot discern the ways and works of God.STMW6 14.1Ms 39, 1891, par. 26 It is the business of a company of disaffected professed Christians, especially in the crisis when wicked men and the church join together in hatred of the law of God, to murmur and complain and accuse God by accusing His children, seeing nothing defective in themselves while finding very much to displease in others.Ms 39, 1891, par. 26Lt 123, 1897, par. 29–31 These are the thoughts of many even when the words are not spoken, thinking and talking of the great advantages to be gained by worldly association and judging religion by its apparent rewards.Ms 53, 1894, par. 50–52Ms 142, 1903, par. 123–125RH Jul 31, 1900 It belongs to a church into which worldly policy and worldly dealing have been brought, with unholy trafficking in sacred things that the Lord hates, where selfishness and covetousness lead men to make merchandise of souls bought with the precious blood of Christ, where by adoption of worldly principles the church sells herself to the world and ungodliness triumphs, judging God's actions by human standards, complaining that the proud and wicked prosper, dishonoring God while trying to justify self, and creating an evil influence around them.Ms 16, 1902, par. 13–15RH Jul 31, 1900
Its immediate setting stands opposite those who fear the Lord and think upon His name, who speak often to one another from sincere hearts with no deceit, guile, underhanded working, evil speaking, or complaint against God.Ms 39, 1891, par. 26 The Lord hears them and writes them in a book of remembrance for those who fear Him and think upon His name, to claim as His jewels and to spare as a man spares his serving son, when it will be seen who serves God and who serves Him not.Ms 39, 1891, par. 26Ms 147, 1901, par. 44–45ST Feb 3, 1887 The question about the profit of serving God thus contrasts with the blessing and remembrance promised to those who fear and serve Him sincerely, and warns against murmuring when those who withhold from God fail to receive the favor they expect.Ms 147, 1901, par. 44–45ST Feb 3, 1887 Against the claim that devotion is profitless stands the priceless reward of a life devoted to His service, including making sacrifices to gather with those who fear Him, share testimonies, and encourage one another, whom God hears and remembers, regards as precious, and spares.Ms 39, 1891, par. 26ST Feb 3, 1887
Roots of the Complaint
The speakers are disaffected professed Christians separating from God, whose unconsecrated hearts have been blinded by the enemy so they cannot discern His ways and works.STMW6 14.1Ms 39, 1891, par. 26Lt 123, 1897, par. 29–31Ms 183, 1897, par. 7–9 They reject His claim and refuse instruction through His messengers, departing from Him while still professing belief.Ms 39, 1891, par. 26Ms 183, 1897, par. 7–9Ms 144, 1897, par. 7–8 Their chief business becomes murmuring and complaining and accusing God by accusing His children, seeing nothing defective in themselves while finding much to displease in others.Lt 123, 1897, par. 29–31 In contrast to those who fear the Lord and think upon His name, who speak often to one another from sincere hearts without deceit, guile, underhanded working, evil speaking or complaint, and whom the Lord hears and writes in a book of remembrance to claim as His jewels and spare as a man spares his serving son, these speakers utter stout words that it is useless to serve Him, that obedience brings no profit, and that keeping His ordinance and walking mournfully before the Lord of hosts is in vain.STMW6 14.1Ms 39, 1891, par. 26Lt 123, 1897, par. 29–31Ms 183, 1897, par. 7–9
The complaint is tied to withholding from God what He has specified and reserved for Himself, using His money selfishly and hindering His work while expecting Him to recognize and favor them.6T 389.1–2STMW9 73.1–2Ms 24, 1901, par. 24–26Ms 60, 1896, par. 16–17Ms 25, 1894, par. 9–11 They neglect works of mercy and deal falsely with Him and others, yet accuse Him of failing to reward them.Ms 24, 1901, par. 24–26Ms 24, 1901, par. 11–12 Their adversity follows their own disloyalty and wrongdoing, for God permits the spoiler to destroy crops and bring calamity when they fail to honor Him with entrusted goods.6T 389.1–2STMW9 73.1–2Ms 60, 1896, par. 16–17 Whatever they profess, their words reveal a poor spiritual condition, and the chapter leaves the disobedient without excuse by stating God's claims and the consequences of unfaithfulness plainly.Ms 25, 1894, par. 9–11Ms 24, 1901, par. 11–12
The speakers judge God's actions by human standards and apparent rewards, doubting the value of obedience because they see no profit in keeping His commands or living humbly before Him.Lt 223, 1904, par. 31Ms 87, 1899, par. 20–21Ms 142, 1903, par. 123–125RH Jul 31, 1900 They complain that they have received hardship while the proud are called happy and workers of wickedness who tempt God are built up, set up and delivered.Ms 60, 1896, par. 16–17Ms 142, 1903, par. 123–125RH Jul 31, 1900 Their mistaken judgment that faithfulness has no reward dishonors Him while they try to justify themselves.Lt 223, 1904, par. 31Ms 87, 1899, par. 20–21RH Jul 31, 1900
The thought is fostered by joining those who rejected truth and by weighing the great advantages to be gained by worldly association, even when the words are held in thought and not spoken.Ms 53, 1894, par. 50–524T 106.1–2RH Apr 20, 1916 It is brought into the church as worldly policy and worldly dealing, with unholy trafficking in sacred things, selfishness and covetousness leading men to make merchandise of souls, so that by adoption of worldly principles the church sells herself to the world and ungodliness triumphs.Ms 16, 1902, par. 13–15 It belongs to those striving for everlasting life who are tempted with earthly return, honor and riches, and it is met by refusing temptation in exclusive worship and service to God alone and by cherishing and presenting high and holy uplifting sanctifying principles.Ms 16, 1902, par. 13–15RH Apr 20, 1916
Such words are rebellion and disloyalty, not a faithful judgment of God.STMW9 73.1–2 They dishonor Him, foster evil in the soul, and create an evil influence around those who speak them.Ms 87, 1899, par. 20–21RH Jul 31, 1900 They are a false and harmful witness that misrepresents His goodness and can discourage others, especially new believers, whom God calls His followers to walk in the light rather than give voice to doubt and complaint.Ms 32, 1894, par. 8 They reveal the heart and will be brought to account at the final reckoning, when each person's words and work are judged and those who speak against God and discourage others face shame and condemnation.5T 287.2
God's Correction and Promise
The claim that serving God and keeping His commands while living humbly before Him brings no profit is met by the declaration that serving God is not vain but brings a priceless reward.4T 106.1–2ST Feb 3, 1887 Those who complain that working for God brings no pay are reminded that such labor is the duty of those bought by Christ's blood and called to work for fallen humanity rather than spending life on self-glorification and amusement, with heavenly honor and immortal life as the greater reward.Ms 5, 1891, par. 4–5 Keeping His ordinance does bring profit, and the instruction on this is full of light for those who rejoice in the hope of the soon-coming morning with the reviving, healing beams of His sunshine.Lt 136, 1902, par. 17–18 The fashion of this world passes away but the fashion of the world to come endures forever, and the righteous will be rewarded with infinite bliss and boundless joy.Lt 136, 1902, par. 17–18 Christ has gone to prepare mansions for the faithful, those who love God and keep His commandments have a clear, unquestioned title to the immortal inheritance, those who by faith take God at His Word have everlasting life, and those who by faith enter the kingdom of God and hold fast their profession will possess the kingdom forever and ever.Lt 136, 1902, par. 17–18
The doubt taken into the heart through joining with those who rejected the truth is answered by God's promise to bless financially and spiritually those who deal faithfully with Him.4T 106.1–2Ms 38a, 1905, par. 33 The complaint is to be met by obeying God's Word, by teaching others how they may receive God's blessing, and by coming into harmonious action as educators, so that all may see the salvation of God.Ms 38a, 1905, par. 33 God stands behind all His promises and distinctly pledges Himself to answer prayer, inviting all to prove the Lord God of hosts by doing their part and seeing what He will do in their behalf.Lt 14, 1899, par. 17–19 His Word is an assurance so positive and ample that it leaves no room for mistake or limitation, Yea and Amen in Christ Jesus, and His resources cannot be exhausted.Lt 14, 1899, par. 17–19
The discouraged question of what profit there is in keeping God's ordinances arose after Adam's fall from perfect happiness to misery and sin, with a heavy curse resting on the human race and death the portion of all.1SP 64.1ST Feb 20, 1879 That darkness and gloom is cleared away by hope in the instructions given to Adam, repeated by Seth, and fully exemplified by Enoch, that as through Adam came death, through Jesus the promised Redeemer will come life and immortality.1SP 64.1ST Feb 20, 1879SG3 58.1–2 Enoch's case teaches faithful people living among rebellious sinners that obedience and faith in the Redeemer lead to acceptance by God, righteous living, and eventual exaltation to heaven.ST Feb 20, 1879SG3 58.1–2
No one is told to walk mournfully before the Lord of hosts, for the complaint comes from those working out their own plans and following a course of their own choosing, who grumble because God does not bless them while they refuse to place themselves where He can bless them, who find fault with God and with their brethren and keep lamenting as they see their own wretched condition.Ms 38a, 1905, par. 21–23 Those joined to Christ in obedience walk in gladness and cheerfulness and eat of the leaves of the tree of life, living in the light of the Sun of Righteousness, reflecting heaven's light, and rejoicing because redemption is near.Ms 38a, 1905, par. 21–23Ms 100, 1899, par. 22–23 True service is loving God supremely and neighbor as self, personally caring for the poor and suffering as Christ cared for them and taking fatherless children into homes instead of depending largely on institutions or doing the work by proxy.Ms 105, 1899, par. 14–16 Such self-denial and self-sacrifice gives Christlike evidence to the world and lets light shine from every Christian home.Ms 105, 1899, par. 14–16
The discouraged thought that religious service and sorrow have brought no benefit is echoed in the question about fasting and walking mournfully before the Lord.6T 266.1 Isaiah 58:6-7 gives the remedy by prescribing the fast God chooses through breaking oppression and helping people in need.6T 266.1 Those who feel faint-hearted and doubtful are to rise and help someone rather than remain in sorrow.6T 266.1
Judgment and Future Hope
The claim that serving God is empty and keeping His requirements brings no gain will be answered at the Lord's soon coming through a refining, winnowing work in every church that shows who are vessels unto honor.Lt 15, 1892, par. 10–12 Then all will return and discern between the righteous and the wicked, between the one who serves God and the one who serves Him not.Lt 15, 1892, par. 10–12 The coming day will burn as an oven, and all the proud and all who do wickedly will be as stubble burned up so as to leave neither root nor branch.Lt 15, 1892, par. 10–12 But to those who fear His name the Sun of Righteousness will arise with healing in His wings, and the vessels unto honor will receive the latter rain.Lt 15, 1892, par. 10–12
Words that accuse God by calling His service pointless reveal the heart, and every person's words and work will be brought to account at the final reckoning.5T 287.2 Those who speak against God and discourage others by such speech will face shame and condemnation.5T 287.2 Malachi 3 is God's plain warning that in the setting of entrusted gifts and coming judgment He will weigh character and reckon with each servant, rewarding work according to its character.Ms 70, 1896, par. 20–24Lt 354, 1906, par. 5–12 It teaches that serving God is not vain and keeping His ordinance brings profit, giving instruction full of light for those who rejoice in the hope of the soon-coming morning with its reviving, healing beams of sunshine.Lt 136, 1902, par. 17–18 The fashion of this world passes away but the fashion of the world to come endures forever, and the righteous will be rewarded with infinite bliss and boundless joy.Lt 136, 1902, par. 17–18 Christ has gone to prepare mansions for the faithful, and those who love God and keep His commandments have a clear, unquestioned title to the immortal inheritance.Lt 136, 1902, par. 17–18 Those who by faith take Him at His Word have everlasting life, and those who by faith enter the kingdom and hold fast their profession will possess the kingdom forever and ever.Lt 136, 1902, par. 17–18
The chapter gives warning and instruction in righteousness for every soul, and by it God still tests whether people will prove faithful servants. He calls His people to consider His goodness, respond to His mercy, and prove loyalty by bringing all the tithes into His storehouse, promising to open the windows of heaven and pour out a blessing with no room to receive it. Withholding tithes and offerings is disobedience to His plain requirement, dealing falsely with Him, and it brings His disapproval and curse rather than blessing.Ms 144, 1897, par. 29–30Ms 24, 1901, par. 11–12Ms 192, 1898, par. 2 Such unfaithfulness corresponds with weakened spiritual life, and its claims and consequences are so clearly stated as to leave the disobedient without excuse.Ms 144, 1897, par. 29–30Ms 24, 1901, par. 11–12 Appropriating to personal use the portion God has reserved proves an unfaithful stewardship and causes loss not only of what was withheld from God but also of what had been committed as one's own. The chapter exposes the false paths of those claiming to belong to God and calls them to examine themselves under His words and to account for failing to fulfill His requirements.Ms 37, 1896, par. 8–10Ms 3, 1895, par. 12–15 Its appeal to return to God applies especially to neglect of duty in tithes and offerings, where faithful obedience would have been a privilege and a source of happiness and blessing.Ms 3, 1895, par. 12–15
Call to Faithful Response
The complaint is to be studied and practiced as a binding warning, requiring that every specification in God's Word be followed out through love and fear of God.Lt 38, 1902, par. 19–21Lt 70, 1893, par. 11 The third chapter where it stands is to be carefully read for one's own good and for the sake of others who will be helped by example.Lt 38, 1902, par. 19–21Lt 70, 1893, par. 11 Neglect cannot be afforded, for it is robbery toward God and brings His sure visitation.Lt 38, 1902, par. 19–21Lt 70, 1893, par. 11
Churches are to take their stand upon that word by faithfully bringing all the tithes into the storehouse and into His treasury without withholding or diverting them to other lines of work.GW 227.1Ms 82, 1904, par. 12–13Ms 33, 1907, par. 177MR 137.4 Selfish hearts and hands must not deplete the treasury but practice self-denial and honest dealing with God, returning His own portion and using entrusted means to help others.9T 53.37MR 137.4Lt 38, 1902, par. 25–27 The tithe belongs to the Lord for ministerial work, to sustain His laborers and encourage more men to give themselves to the ministry instead of holding back.GW 227.1Ms 82, 1904, par. 12–13Ms 33, 1907, par. 177MR 137.4 Money entrusted for advancing the gospel must not be withheld but used to send the gospel throughout the world, while diverting it obstructs the work and discourages ministers.Ms 82, 1904, par. 12–139T 53.3Ms 33, 1907, par. 17 Parents and children alike are to obey the command, practice self-denial, and use their means to advance His work.9T 53.3Lt 38, 1902, par. 25–27
The vain-service claim is answered by God's promise to bless financially and spiritually those who deal faithfully with Him.Ms 38a, 1905, par. 33 It is to be met by obeying God's Word, by teaching others how they may receive His blessing, and by coming into harmonious action as educators.Ms 38a, 1905, par. 33 Then all may see the salvation of God.Ms 38a, 1905, par. 33
God's followers are to walk in the light and not give voice to doubt and complaint, for such testimony misrepresents His goodness and discourages others, especially new believers.Ms 16, 1902, par. 13–15Ms 32, 1894, par. 8 Those accepted as His subjects must cherish and present high and holy uplifting sanctifying principles rather than bringing worldly policy and worldly dealing, unholy trafficking, selfishness and covetousness making merchandise of souls into the church.Ms 16, 1902, par. 13–15Ms 32, 1894, par. 8 The church must not sell herself to the world by adoption of worldly principles nor be converted to worldly policy.Ms 16, 1902, par. 13–15RH Apr 20, 1916 Even when the thought of great advantage from worldly association is held in the mind without being spoken, with its weighing of earthly return, honor and riches and its envy calling the proud happy and workers of wickedness established and delivered, it is to be met by refusing temptation in exclusive worship and service to God alone.Ms 16, 1902, par. 13–15RH Apr 20, 1916
Serving God is not profitless but carries a priceless reward, and it includes making sacrifices to gather with those who fear Him, share testimonies and encourage one another.ST Feb 3, 1887 God hears and remembers such gatherings, regards them as precious, and spares them.ST Feb 3, 1887 The duties stated plainly in this chapter require clear spiritual perception to see.Ms 24, 1901, par. 34–36 Those whose perceptions are beclouded cannot see them, and God cannot work with them to renovate the mind, fill the heart with treasures of truth, and give sanctified memories to work to His honor and glory.Ms 24, 1901, par. 34–36
The message of this chapter is preached to meet determined apostasy.Lt 152, 1897, par. 1–4 That apostasy comes when those laboring in the truth give up their position on the truth, go in for holiness altogether, come out against the testimonies of the Spirit of the Lord, and unite to accept some other light than the third angel's message.Lt 152, 1897, par. 1–4
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
45 sources
The verse gives the complaint of professed believers who had turned from God's requirements yet claimed that obeying Him and humbling themselves before Him brought no benefit.RH Sep 8, 1863ST Nov 22, 1899ST Sep 9, 1889RH Dec 30, 1909 They judged faithfulness by immediate temporal reward, stumbling because God sends life and prosperity to both good and evil while the proud often prosper and the obedient suffer.RH Dec 30, 1909ST Mar 6, 1893ST Nov 22, 1899 Their charge centered on His ordinances, especially by withholding tithes and offerings and by profaning His Sabbath while asking what profit keeping them could give.ST Sep 9, 1889ST Aug 10, 1915ST Aug 10, 1915RH Sep 19, 1854RH Apr 7, 1904 That charge is false, for service done from love is never useless, and at His coming He will openly distinguish the righteous from the wicked, remembering those who fear Him as His precious jewels and sparing them as a father spares his obedient son.ST Nov 22, 1899RH Dec 30, 1909ST Mar 20, 1901RH Jun 12, 1900RH Nov 5, 1861 He still tests His people by this same word, calling them to prove Him by bringing the full tithe into His storehouse and to serve from principle rather than for worldly gain, trusting the slow harvest of obedience will surely come.RH May 26, 1910RH Dec 30, 1909RH Apr 5, 1864ST Jun 17, 1903
Words and Historical Setting
The verse preserves the people's own charge that serving God is vain and useless, asking what profit there is in keeping His ordinance and walking mournfully before the Lord of hosts.RH Sep 8, 1863ST Nov 22, 1899RH Dec 30, 1909ST Mar 20, 1901RH Oct 7, 1902 It is the language of those who claimed to have obeyed His charge and kept His requirements and commands, yet concluded that obedience brought no profit and no reward.ST Nov 22, 1899RH Dec 30, 1909ST Mar 20, 1901RH Oct 7, 1902RH Aug 31, 1911 Their words set their complaint against the coming distinction between the righteous and the wicked and the harvest each will receive, when God gathers His people at the last day and makes the difference clear.ST Nov 22, 1899RH Dec 30, 1909RH Aug 31, 1911 For the present outward circumstances do not reliably distinguish the righteous from the ungodly, since God gives both life, health, rain and temporal prosperity, so that service is not to be driven by promise of worldly gain.RH Dec 30, 1909ST Mar 20, 1901 That worldly judgment of unbelief treats obedience as ending in defeat because the wicked prosper while the faithful suffer, but the appearance is false.RH Sep 8, 1863ST Mar 20, 1901
Walking mournfully means living humbly and in lowliness before Him, humbling themselves and walking humbly and sorrowfully while claiming to have obeyed.RH Jul 31, 1900RH Apr 20, 1916RH Aug 31, 1911RH Jun 12, 1900 It is joined with questioning what gain comes from keeping His ordinance, calling service vain and unprofitable and concluding that God has failed to keep His promises when no reward is seen.RH Apr 20, 1916RH Jun 12, 1900 Those who speak so judge God's actions by human standards, count the proud happy and the wicked as established and delivered, and dishonor God while trying to justify themselves.RH Jul 31, 1900RH Apr 20, 1916RH Jun 12, 1900 Their stout words may be held in thought even when not spoken, as the weighing of great advantages to be gained by worldly association, honor and riches, and their murmuring reveals hypocrisy and weakening faith that creates an evil influence and can turn others away from worship.RH Jul 31, 1900RH Apr 20, 1916RH Jun 12, 1900
The ordinance so questioned is God's Sabbath, and asking what profit there is in keeping it and serving God mournfully makes a sifting even among those proclaiming the last-day truth.ST Aug 10, 1915ST Aug 10, 1915 God recognizes the faithful in that sifting as His jewels just before the day that burns like an oven.ST Aug 10, 1915ST Aug 10, 1915 The complaint belongs to the professed people of God in their departure from His ordinances, especially by withholding tithes and offerings and by profaning the Lord's Sabbath, thereby robbing God.ST Sep 9, 1889RH Sep 19, 1854RH Apr 7, 1904 Disregard for His command in profaning the Sabbath brings a curse, and lack of blessing resulted from rebellion and withholding, so that to receive favor they had to return to Him and pay all that was due, not merely part.RH Sep 19, 1854RH Apr 7, 1904 God challenged them to prove Him by bringing the full tithe into the treasury, so His house would have food and the work of taking Christ to the world could be supported.RH Apr 7, 1904
It marks the period just before the Lord gathers His special treasure, when the proud are called happy and workers of wickedness are exalted.RH Apr 10, 1856 The prophecy applies throughout the Christian dispensation and especially to the last days, belonging to Malachi's message condemning the shortcomings of God's people.ST Sep 9, 1889ST Aug 29, 1911ST Sep 12, 1895 That message uses their state to point forward to the closing days, when the Lord will come and the great-day judgments and final judgment will separate the righteous from the wicked.ST Sep 9, 1889ST Aug 29, 1911
Why People Call Service Vain
The complaint arises when service to God and keeping His commands are judged by immediate temporal or financial results, judging righteousness by its reward and concluding that God favors the wicked.ST Mar 6, 1893ST Nov 22, 1899 Outward circumstances do not yet reliably distinguish the righteous from the ungodly, for both are given life, health, rain and temporal prosperity.RH Dec 30, 1909RH Feb 25, 1915 The wicked may prosper as readily as God's people while the faithful suffer, so that obedience can appear to end in defeat.ST Mar 6, 1893ST Mar 20, 1901RH Feb 25, 1915 That appearance is false, for the true difference will be revealed only in eternity at the last day when God gathers His people.RH Dec 30, 1909ST Mar 6, 1893
After self-denial and Sabbath-keeping, blessing and deliverance were expected, but instead came reproach, temptation, hard work, correction, humility and the watch-care of fellow believers, and that disappointment was treated as proof of futility.RH Sep 8, 1863 Doing right then seemed to leave a hard, cheerless life while the proud prospered and those who defied God escaped punishment.ST Jun 18, 1902 That discontent arises from their own wrongdoing and spiritual darkness, and reflects the mistaken conclusion that the prosperity, happiness and honor of the wicked make service pointless, a temptation that can come even to professed believers when they compare present circumstances.ST Jun 18, 1902
Some hold only a faint, vague faith that God acted long ago but does nothing now, explaining fulfilled prophecy by chance or natural causes and holding that miracles are past and all things continue as they were, so that serving God looks useless and keeping His requirements looks without profit.RH Jul 4, 1871 The pursuit of money can displace worship and leave no room for God, and success in acquiring wealth fosters independence and self-sufficiency that leads a once-pious person away from faith into sorrow.ST Jul 3, 1884 Some weigh the great advantages of worldly association, honor and riches, holding stout words against God in thought even when not spoken while tempted as seekers of everlasting life, calling service vain and unprofitable while counting the proud happy and the wicked established and delivered.RH Apr 20, 1916
Faithful people after Adam's fall could feel discouragement asking what obedience profits when humanity is under a curse and death comes to all.ST Feb 20, 1879 Discouragement can also come in isolation with no Sabbath-keepers nearby, even to saying and feeling it is no use to serve the Lord any longer and deciding to ask dismissal from the church.RH Aug 29, 1865 The complaint is an impatient demand for the rewards of righteousness before their time, especially when dishonest and careless people appear to prosper, whereas like a seed left to grow the harvest of obedience ripens slowly and what is sown will surely be reaped in its proper time.ST Jun 17, 1903 Some called service vain because they sought blessing by asking alone without meeting the conditions He had given, when faith in the promise had to lead to obedience including paying an honest tithe.RH Sep 22, 1904
God's Answer and Final Distinction
The charge that serving God is useless and brings no profit, even when His charge has been kept and life has been lived humbly and sorrowfully before Him, is false.ST Mar 20, 1901RH Jun 12, 1900 Righteousness is always gain, and the faithful will be vindicated in the end, for the appearance that obedience ends in defeat comes only from the worldly judgment of unbelief that sees the wicked prosper while the faithful suffer.ST Mar 20, 1901RH Jun 12, 1900 Sabbath-keeping is not in vain, because God sees and blesses those who honor His law, which was made for humanity, and keeping the whole day from its opening to its close in both letter and spirit brings benefits.RH Nov 5, 1861 Serving God is not vain, and obedience must match His commands rather than substitute human choices or small variations, for God rightly requires exact obedience, to depart from His requirements is to choose one's own will, and diligent obedience is the way to enter His everlasting kingdom abundantly.RH Jun 19, 1856
God allows both righteous and ungodly to share life, health, rain and temporal prosperity in this life, so that outward circumstances do not yet reliably distinguish them and service is not driven by promise of worldly gain.RH Dec 30, 1909RH Feb 25, 1915 He wants people to serve from love and principle and from faithful love and simple trust in His promises, not for temporal rewards nor for financial or commercial gain in tithes, Sabbath-keeping and service.RH Dec 30, 1909ST Jul 3, 1893RH Feb 25, 1915 The complaint that keeping His ordinances and walking mournfully before Him brings no profit judges righteousness by immediate temporal or financial reward, but its profit is ultimately revealed beyond this life and not measured by present circumstances.ST Mar 6, 1893ST Nov 22, 1899
The true difference between those who serve God and those who do not will be made clear when God gathers His faithful people at the last day.ST Nov 22, 1899RH Dec 30, 1909 Then God will distinguish the righteous from the wicked, saving the loyal and showing that sin ends in death, with destruction for the wicked and healing for those who fear Him.ST Mar 6, 1893RH Sep 5, 1912 That coming distinction and the harvest each will receive stands against the complaint, and it marks the period just before the Lord gathers His special treasure, when the proud are called happy and workers of wickedness are exalted.ST Nov 22, 1899RH Apr 10, 1856 The day of judgment will show that serving God is not in vain, for by words and actions the complainers refuse to serve Him and encourage others to do the same.RH Sep 5, 1912
In contrast to the complainers, those who fear God and speak together, even at sacrifice to gather, share testimonies and encourage one another, are heard by God, recorded in a book of remembrance, claimed as His own precious jewels, and spared as a father spares his serving son.ST Feb 3, 1887RH Oct 7, 1902RH Aug 31, 1911 Daniel's experience in the lions' den proves that sparing promise, showing that continual fellowship with God expressed in continual worship and continual service brings deliverance when service to God is placed above every other consideration even at apparent cost of death.RH Oct 7, 1902 After Adam's fall the faithful might feel discouragement asking what obedience profits when humanity is under a curse and death comes to all, but God's instructions to Adam and the example of Enoch remove that despair by giving hope that just as death came through Adam, life and immortality come through Jesus the promised Redeemer.ST Feb 20, 1879 Enoch's case teaches faithful people living among rebellious sinners that obedience and faith in the Redeemer lead to acceptance by God, righteous living and eventual exaltation.ST Feb 20, 1879
God's holy law is sufficient to justify and protect its obedient observer, and if it were not the righteous could rightly call service vain.RH Nov 22, 1853 True righteousness is therefore practiced for its own sake whatever happens, judging nothing by reward nor concluding that God favors the wicked.ST Nov 22, 1899 When circumstances look dark God's servants remain faithful, encourage one another and take comfort in God's faithfulness.ST Nov 22, 1899
Tithing and Stewardship Test
The whole chapter is instruction in faithfulness in tithing, and the complaint that keeping God's requirements brings no profit is answered by the blessing promised to those who return all the tithe and prove Him by earnest prayer and labor.RH May 26, 1910RH Apr 5, 1864 God is still testing every soul by this chapter to see whether they will prove faithful servants, calling them to consider His goodness, respond to His mercy, and prove loyalty by bringing all the tithes into His storehouse. His promise is to open the windows of heaven and pour out a blessing with no room to receive it. Appropriating to personal use the portion He has reserved proves an unfaithful steward, and causes loss not only of what was withheld from Him but also of what had been committed as one's own.
Lack of blessing came from rebellion and withholding tithes and offerings, so to receive favor there must be a return to Him and payment of all that is due, not merely part.RH Apr 7, 1904 The challenge is to test His promise by bringing the full tithe into the treasury, so His house may have food and the work of taking Christ to the world may be supported.RH Apr 7, 1904 Asking alone cannot bring the blessing, for faith in the promise must lead to obedience including paying an honest tithe.RH Sep 22, 1904 Those who acted in faith by meeting the conditions given did not regard serving God as useless.RH Sep 22, 1904
The tithing system tests the soul, develops character, and reveals the true state of the heart.RH Mar 23, 1905 It remains binding in the Christian dispensation as in earlier times.ST Oct 29, 1912 The third chapter is distinctly a last-day scripture to the remnant church, in which Sabbath and tithe stand out in the work of reformation.RH Mar 23, 1905RH Oct 24, 1912 To complain that serving God brings no profit while neglecting the tithe yet professing to keep the Sabbath is to rob God in tithes and offerings.RH Oct 24, 1912 The closing chapters find fulfillment in a renewed experience of serving God associated with confession, restitution, and the return of withheld tithe.RH May 4, 1905
Some who suffer will complain that serving God is vain and keeping His ordinance brings no profit, but that murmuring is warned against.ST May 23, 1911ST Jul 3, 1893 His demands are still to be met without murmuring, including faithful stewardship of the remaining nine tenths.ST May 23, 1911 Serving God, giving tithes, and keeping the Sabbath are not to be done for financial or commercial gain but from faithful love and simple trust in His promises.ST Jul 3, 1893 Trust remains that He can bless what is left and share His blessings with His jewels.ST May 23, 1911ST Jul 3, 1893 The passage from Malachi 3:7-17 is a searching call to be read prayerfully and felt, exposing guilt for sin and for robbing God, urging self-examination, humbling before the Lord, confessing and forsaking sin, and making restitution where wrong has been done, so that salvation may come and the sinner may be ready for the final account.RH Oct 10, 1871
Sabbath Law and Obedience
Dismissing seventh-day Sabbath-keeping as a mere whim is saying that serving God is useless and questioning what benefit there is in keeping His requirements.ST Apr 15, 1886 That claim is false, for Sabbath-keeping is not in vain because God sees and blesses those who honor His law, which was made for humanity, and keeping it in both letter and spirit brings benefits.RH Nov 5, 1861 Faithful observance hallows the whole day from its opening to its close.RH Nov 5, 1861 Profaning the Lord's Sabbath and thereby robbing God is that same claim that serving God and keeping His ordinances are profitless, and such disregard for His command brings a curse.RH Sep 19, 1854
Serving God is not vain, but obedience must match His commands rather than substitute human choices or small variations.RH Jun 19, 1856 He rightly requires exact obedience, and to depart from His requirements is to choose one's own will, while diligent obedience is the way to enter His everlasting kingdom abundantly.RH Jun 19, 1856 The distrustful, self-serving complaint that serving God and keeping His commands bring no profit will be repeated in the last days by people facing severe trials, as Israel did when trapped at the Red Sea.ST Feb 11, 1889 The faithful, by contrast, are to obey God's command to go forward, trusting His providence despite apparent obstacles.ST Feb 11, 1889
The claim that serving God and keeping His ordinances are vain and bring no profit is made by those who deny that observing the law can justify and protect its observers.RH Apr 14, 1859 They hold that observing the law is supposed to justify and protect them.RH Apr 14, 1859 From that denial they conclude it is vain to serve God if the law cannot justify its observers.RH Apr 14, 1859
Warning and Faithful Response
Treating disappointment as proof that obedience is futile is dangerous murmuring that darkens the soul, spreads to others, and causes people to be sifted out and left behind.RH Sep 8, 1863RH Jun 12, 1900 The complaint arises when, after self-denial and Sabbath-keeping, blessing and deliverance are expected but instead there come reproach, temptation, hard work, correction, humility, and the watch-care of fellow believers.RH Sep 8, 1863 Judging God's dealings by human standards and complaining that the proud and wicked prosper dishonors God while attempting self-justification, creating an evil influence around the complainers.RH Jul 31, 1900 Claiming faithful performance of duty while concluding from lack of visible reward that promises have failed reveals hypocrisy and weakening faith that can turn people away from worship, for sincere service and humility before God are not vain.RH Jun 12, 1900
By word and action such complainers refuse to serve Him and encourage others to do the same.RH Jul 31, 1900RH Sep 5, 1912 The day of judgment will expose the error by distinguishing loyal servants from those who do not serve Him, saving the faithful and showing that sin ends in death.RH Sep 5, 1912 The faithful answer is to reject murmuring and praise the Lord.RH Sep 8, 1863 True righteousness is practiced for its own sake whatever happens, so when circumstances look dark God's servants remain faithful, encourage one another, and take comfort in God's faithfulness.ST Nov 22, 1899
Serving God includes making sacrifices to gather with those who fear Him, share testimonies, and encourage one another, in contrast to calling service profitless.ST Feb 3, 1887 Such a life devoted to His service has priceless reward, for God hears and remembers those who meet together, regards them as precious, and spares them.ST Feb 3, 1887 Faith should lead to earnest prayer and labor in trust that He will pour out a bountiful blessing, since serving God and keeping His requirements are not vain.RH Apr 5, 1864 Jesus is willing to fulfill His promises to those who seek Him with humility and submission to His will.RH Jul 13, 1869
Temptation comes to those striving for everlasting life as they weigh the great advantages to be gained by worldly association, holding stout words against God in thought even when not spoken.RH Apr 20, 1916 Counting the proud happy and the wicked as established and delivered while questioning what gain comes from keeping His ordinance and walking humbly before Him is met by refusing earthly return, honor, and riches in exclusive worship and service to God alone.RH Apr 20, 1916 Discouragement can deepen in isolation with no Sabbath-keepers nearby until one says and feels it is no use to serve the Lord any longer and even decides to ask dismissal from the church.RH Aug 29, 1865 Feeling and witnessing the Spirit of the Lord operating among God's people changes that feeling so one would not leave this people for any consideration whatever.RH Aug 29, 1865
Sources