Translations
And he said to them, What would you that I should do for you?
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Revised Version, American Standard Version
And he said unto them, What would ye that I should do for you?
Webster Bible, Darby Translation
And he said to them, What would ye that I should do for you?
and he said to them, 'What do ye wish me to do for you?'
But, he, said unto them—What desire ye, I should do for you?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
“ What do you want Me to do for you?” He inquired.
He said to them, “ What do you want me to do for you?”
And he said to them, What would you have me do for you?
And he sayd vnto them, What would ye I should doe for you?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
But he said to them: What would you that I should do for you?
Cross-references
- Matthew 20:20-28
Then came to him the mother of Zebedee’s children with her sons, worshipping him, and desiring a certain thing of him.
Parallel request for places of honor and Jesus’ teaching that greatness comes through service.
- Mark 10:42-45
But Jesus called them to him, and saith unto them, Ye know that they which are accounted to rule over the Gentiles exercise lordship over them; and their great ones exercise authority upon them.
Jesus answers their ambition by contrasting worldly rule with service and self-giving.
- Mark 10:40
But to sit on my right hand and on my left hand is not mine to give; but it shall be given to them for whom it is prepared.
Places of honor are prepared, not granted by ambition.
- Matthew 20:25-28
But Jesus called them unto him, and said, Ye know that the princes of the Gentiles exercise dominion over them, and they that are great exercise authority upon them.
Contrasts worldly rule with greatness through serving and giving one’s life.
- Luke 22:24
And there was also a strife among them, which of them should be accounted the greatest.
The disciples dispute who should be greatest.
- Matthew 20:23
And he saith unto them, Ye shall drink indeed of my cup, and be baptized with the baptism that I am baptized with: but to sit on my right hand, and on my left, is not mine to give, but it shall be given to them for whom it is prepared of my Father.
Places of honor are prepared by the Father for those who will receive them.
- Matthew 20:22
But Jesus answered and said, Ye know not what ye ask. Are ye able to drink of the cup that I shall drink of, and to be baptized with the baptism that I am baptized with? They say unto him, We are able.
Jesus asks whether they can share his cup and baptism.
- Luke 18:31-34
Then he took unto him the twelve, and said unto them, Behold, we go up to Jerusalem, and all things that are written by the prophets concerning the Son of man shall be accomplished.
A parallel account of the events surrounding Jesus’ journey to Jerusalem.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
12 sources
In the verse Jesus draws out James and John, inviting them to state plainly the favor they had already asked Him to grant and giving them opportunity to voice their petition.BS 48.2–49.1Ms 43, 1897, par. 10–12Ms 54, 1897, par. 22–24DA 548.1–5 What they voice is a request brought through their mother for the chief and highest places at His right and left in His kingdom and glory.BS 48.2–49.1Ms 43, 1897, par. 10–12Ms 54, 1897, par. 22–24DA 548.1–5 They still expect Him soon to reign as a temporal prince in Jerusalem, and in their confidence that the kingdom will soon be established they fail to grasp His prediction of betrayal, suffering, death and resurrection, which seems vague to them.Ms 54, 1897, par. 22–24DA 547.2–3 Following Him was to mean sharing His cup and baptism of suffering, not merely claiming honor for themselves, yet they sought places of honor in the coming kingdom while failing to understand that cost.DA 547.2–32T 32.1
The request comes from pride and ambition for status and from desire for worldly honor and distinction, which is contrary to following Christ.BS 48.2–49.1Ms 43, 1897, par. 10–12GC88 91.1–92.1 Such seeking of distinction can arise alongside envy and a wish for worldly advancement, especially when people are tempted to make the cross less prominent.RH Aug 4, 1910 They do not know what they ask or the true import and cost of their prayer, and fall far short of understanding the situation.BS 48.2–49.1Ms 54, 1897, par. 22–242T 32.12MR 43.1 They think the highest place can be gained simply by asking, and when asked if they can drink His cup and share His baptism they answer that they can, yet they little comprehend what that baptism signifies.BS 48.2–49.14MR 333.42MR 43.1
The glory they seek is the glory Christ was to receive through infinite sacrifice in humiliation, agony and shedding of blood, whose joy was to see souls saved.BS 48.2–49.1 Sharing that glory requires first bearing His yoke and burdens and daily learning His meekness and lowliness, so the cross comes before the crown and the way to the crown of eternal life runs through a race and a battle.BS 48.2–49.12T 32.1ST Mar 26, 19024MR 333.42MR 43.1 Jesus tells them they shall indeed drink His cup and share His baptism, but the places at His right and left are not His to give and shall be given to those for whom they are prepared.BS 48.2–49.1 Jesus reproves their pride by contrasting Gentile lordship and authority with greatness in His kingdom, where whoever would be great must be a minister and whoever would be chiefest must be servant of all, for even the Son of man came not to be ministered unto but to minister and to give His life a ransom for many.BS 48.2–49.1Ms 43, 1897, par. 10–12 Their request for the most honored places therefore leads to jealousy and a heated dispute among the disciples about who is greatest.Ms 19, 1897, par. 30–33
Their desire for worldly honor is an error not to be imitated.GC88 91.1–92.1 Great spiritual blessings such as the baptism of the Holy Spirit are not given without complying with the conditions God Himself has laid down, and God first tries those who ask to see if they can live without dishonoring Him.2MR 43.1
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
30 sources
Jesus asked James and John to name plainly what they wanted after they asked Him to grant whatever they would desire.ST May 11, 1904ST May 11, 1904 They sought the highest places of honor at His right hand and on His left in His glory, even as He was going up to Jerusalem to be betrayed and condemned and mocked and crucified and to rise the third day, because they still expected Him to set up an earthly kingdom.ST Feb 17, 1888RH Feb 18, 1915ST May 18, 1882ST Feb 17, 1888RH Nov 5, 1901 They did not understand what they were asking, for the glory they desired could be reached only through humiliation and suffering and the shedding of blood to save others.ST Oct 16, 1884ST Jan 15, 1885ST Nov 7, 1878RH Oct 29, 1861 He told them they would indeed drink of His cup and be baptized with His baptism, for no one wears the crown without first bearing the cross.RH Feb 18, 1915RH Oct 13, 1868RH Oct 29, 1861 He made their ambition a lesson in humility, that the Son of Man came not to be ministered unto but to minister, and that pride and striving for rank must be wholly banished from those who would share His kingdom.ST Feb 17, 1888ST Jun 15, 1904
Context of the Request
Jesus met James and John, the sons of Zebedee, with an invitation to state their specific request after they asked Him to do for them whatever they would ask.ST May 11, 1904ST May 11, 1904ST Sep 13, 1899 He encouraged them to make known what they wanted after they introduced that subject, asking what favor they desired after their mother had approached Him on their behalf for places of honor for them in His future kingdom.ST May 11, 1904ST May 18, 1882ST Sep 13, 1899 He asked what they wanted Him to do for them after they requested that He grant their desire and after they requested a place of honor in His kingdom.ST Sep 13, 1899 He put the question not because He was unaware of their thoughts, but because He knew what was in all people.ST May 11, 1904 The question stands within the first ten chapters of Mark, which present Him as a King whose power is joined with love and humility, who respects the least as well as the greatest and acts with pure, selfless benevolence.RH Oct 30, 1860
Their request, made through their mother, was for the places on the right hand and on the left beside Him in His glory and kingdom, the highest places of honor and reward.ST Oct 16, 1884ST Jan 15, 1885ST Feb 17, 1888RH Feb 18, 1915 They came asking to be honored in His glory by sitting one at His right hand and the other at His left hand, seeking the places of greatest honor when He sits upon His throne.ST Oct 16, 1884ST Jan 15, 1885RH Feb 18, 1915 Their asking for places of honor beside Him showed they sought positions of honor for themselves in His future kingdom.ST May 18, 1882RH Jun 2, 1904 Sitting in those seats signified lordship, dominion, and a place from which judgment is exercised.RH Jun 2, 1904
The request belongs to His last journey up to Jerusalem where He was to be offered as a sacrifice for sinners, parallel to Matthew 20:17-29.ST Feb 17, 1888 Mark's account includes the request for the two sons of Zebedee, which Luke's account in Luke 18:31-34 does not record.ST Feb 17, 1888 It came immediately after He foretold His betrayal to the chief priests and scribes, His condemnation to death, His delivery to the Gentiles to be mocked and scourged and spit upon and crucified, and His rising again the third day, exactly what had been written by the prophets.ST Feb 17, 1888 Yet even as He approached the crisis of His earthly ministry the disciples understood none of these things, because preconceived opinions gave way slowly to truth.ST Feb 17, 1888RH Nov 5, 1901 The request came immediately after He told them of His soon-coming sufferings.ST Feb 17, 1888
That timing shows the blindness of the disciples and their slowness to believe that He did not intend to establish an earthly monarchy at that time.ST Feb 17, 1888 They asked for places of honor beside Him in His glory because they expected that He would soon establish an earthly kingdom. Their request for places of honor beside Him revealed that they misunderstood their calling, expecting a worldly kingdom.RH Jun 2, 1904 Their request for places of honor in the kingdom reflected an expectation of a kingdom still to come.RH Sep 22, 1863
Teaching on Humility and Service
The request for position was an exhibition of pride and ambition, the same spirit that caused the fall of Satan in heaven and, instilled by Satan into Eve with the promise that eating would make her like God, resulted in the fall of the first parents.ST Feb 17, 1888 Such a spirit must be entirely banished from the hearts of those who will share the kingdom of heaven, for if places there were distributed as in earthly kingdoms, confusion and ruin would ensue.ST Feb 17, 1888 The request was prompted by pride and natural human selfishness and showed they did not understand the true import of their prayer.ST Oct 16, 1884ST Nov 7, 1878 The glory they sought could only be purchased at infinite cost through Christ's humiliation, agony, shedding of blood, and enduring the cross to save souls from death by wholly unselfish joy.ST Oct 16, 1884
Their ambition shows they had failed to learn the lesson of humility Jesus had taught them, and reveals the self-seeking ambition that the lesson was meant to correct.ST Aug 8, 1906ST Aug 8, 1906 That lesson belonged especially to the sons of Zebedee, and it was still relevant at the Last Supper when the disciples disputed about greatness.ST Dec 30, 1889 Their request exposed ambition they had not abandoned.ST Jan 15, 1885 Jesus turned their request into teaching on humility, that the Son of Man came not to be ministered unto but to minister.ST Jun 15, 1904 He won His exalted position in heaven by first humbling Himself, and disciples succeed only by following in His footsteps, for he that humbles himself shall be exalted.ST Jun 15, 1904
He answered by showing that sharing His glory meant sharing suffering and service, not seeking power over others.ST Jan 15, 1885 Glory is reached through suffering, no one wears the crown without first bearing the cross, and Christ Himself was not glorified until He had been crucified.RH Oct 29, 1861 He told them they did not know what they asked, then asked whether they could share His cup and baptism and declared they would indeed drink of the cup He drinks of and be baptized with the baptism He is baptized with.RH Feb 18, 1915 That declaration is spoken at the same time to every follower, meaning it is justly given to suffer with Him in order to share with Him in His glory, which is the real meaning of every experience in the life of a true follower.RH Feb 18, 1915 Their answer, We are able, was borne out in their later lives.RH Oct 13, 1868
Following Christ means more than expressing a desire for honor or closeness to Him, it means accepting the crosses that obedience brings.RH Oct 13, 1868 Sharing Christ's glory required first bearing His yoke and burdens, for the way to the crown of eternal life runs through a race and a battle and the cross comes before the crown.ST Mar 26, 1902 Jesus turned their attention from temporal gain to the cost and purpose of discipleship: service may bring suffering and persecution, and the disciples' chief work is to serve for the good of others. Their reward is great in proportion as they set aside thoughts of temporal reward and serve unselfishly. Their request for places of honor beside Him revealed misunderstanding of their calling and of the nature of His kingdom, expecting a worldly kingdom and seeking self-exaltation rather than service.RH Jun 2, 1904ST May 18, 1882
The other disciples' anger at the selfish and ambitious request revealed their own jealousy, and Jesus called all twelve together to correct their misunderstanding.ST May 18, 1882 The passage shows an earlier outbreak of the same jealous strife over which should be greatest that appeared again at the Passover table, where the disciples wanted the post of honor by the side of the host.ST May 18, 1904 Jesus rebuked that ambitious spirit, and their anxiety to be seated in the honored place was the direct cause of His rising to wash their feet and permanently establish that ordinance.ST May 18, 1904 The verse reproves the desire for rank, political dignity and authority, and the ambition to administer power and govern fellow people even under the claim of serving Christ.ST Apr 13, 1915ST Jan 22, 1902ST Jan 22, 1902 This pursuit of supremacy, in which Christian service is confused with self-exaltation, is identified as the spirit of papal self-exaltation.RH Nov 5, 1901 Seeking distinction can arise alongside envy and a wish for worldly advancement, especially when people are tempted to make the cross less prominent.RH Aug 4, 1910
Their request for places of honor came from selfish ambition, like politicians seeking authority, and Jesus rebuked it.RH May 9, 1907 The church's later need for order and authority was met through the Holy Spirit and human instruments, not in the self-seeking manner they had imagined.RH May 9, 1907
Sources