Mark 12:23
In the resurrection therefore, when they shall rise, whose wife shall she be of them? for the seven had her to wife.
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
In the resurrection therefore, when they shall rise, whose wife shall she be of them? for the seven had her to wife.
In the resurrection therefore, when they shall rise, whose wife shall she be of them? for the seven had her for a wife.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
In the resurrection whose wife shall she be of them? for the seven had her to wife.
in the rising again, then, whenever they may rise, of which of them shall she be wife — for the seven had her as wife?'
In the resurrection, when they shall rise again, of which of them shall she be wife, for the seven had her as wife?
In the resurrection,—of, which, of them shall she be, wife? For, the seven, had her to wife.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
In the resurrection, then, whose wife will she be? For all seven were married to her.”
In the resurrection, when they rise, whose wife will she be of them? For the seven had her as a wife.”
In the future life, when they come back from the dead, whose wife will she be? for the seven had her for a wife.
In the resurrection then, when they shall rise againe, whose wife shall she be of them? for seuen had her to wife.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
In the resurrection therefore, when they shall rise again, whose wife shall she be of them? for the seven had her to wife.
Cross-references
- Luke 20:35
But they which shall be accounted worthy to obtain that world, and the resurrection from the dead, neither marry, nor are given in marriage:
Jesus teaches that those raised to the future resurrection do not marry.
- Matthew 22:23-33
The same day came to him the Sadducees, which say that there is no resurrection, and asked him,
Parallel account of the Sadducees’ question about the seven brothers and Jesus’ answer.
- Deuteronomy 25:5-6
If brethren dwell together, and one of them die, and have no child, the wife of the dead shall not marry without unto a stranger: her husband’s brother shall go in unto her, and take her to him to wife, and perform the duty of an husband’s brother unto her.
The Sadducees’ seven-husbands puzzle rests on the law of a brother raising offspring for his deceased brother.
- Exodus 3:6
Moreover he said, I am the God of thy father, the God of Abraham, the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob. And Moses hid his face; for he was afraid to look upon God.
God’s words about Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob establish the resurrection.
- Matthew 22:30
For in the resurrection they neither marry, nor are given in marriage, but are as the angels of God in heaven.
Jesus says there is no marrying after the resurrection.
- Luke 20:36
Neither can they die any more: for they are equal unto the angels; and are the children of God, being the children of the resurrection.
The risen cannot die and are like angels.
- Luke 20:37
Now that the dead are raised, even Moses shewed at the bush, when he calleth the Lord the God of Abraham, and the God of Isaac, and the God of Jacob.
Same proof that the dead will be raised
- Acts 23:8
For the Sadducees say that there is no resurrection, neither angel, nor spirit: but the Pharisees confess both.
Both texts describe the Sadducees’ denial of the resurrection.
- 1 Corinthians 15:12-19
Now if Christ be preached that he rose from the dead, how say some among you that there is no resurrection of the dead?
Belief in the resurrection is essential to the truth of the gospel.
- Acts 26:8
Why should it be thought a thing incredible with you, that God should raise the dead?
The passage opens with this verse’s question about God raising the dead.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
3 sources
In this verse the Sadducees bring to a close their trap question to Christ about the woman who had been wife to seven brothers, asking whose wife she will be when they rise in the resurrection.Ms 28, 1904, par. 3–63SP 48.2–3 Those who ask say there is no resurrection and deny future rewards and punishments, their doctrines differing widely from those of the Pharisees.Ms 28, 1904, par. 3–6 They are skeptical and atheistical in belief, magnifying sophistries and speculative ideas of their own production.Ms 28, 1904, par. 3–6
The question rests on a false foundation from ignorance of the Scriptures and the power of God and of the true teachings of the Word of God.Ms 28, 1904, par. 3–6 It assumes that those raised will have the same bodies and earthly propensities, will resume their former relationships, and will continue marriage as before.3SP 48.2–3 Its purpose is to perplex Christ and entangle Him in His words and to confuse other minds.Ms 28, 1904, par. 3–6 By heaping ridicule upon the law of Moses about a brother taking his dead brother's wife to raise up seed, it seeks to bring all the Mosaic institutions into contempt and to make bodily resurrection appear absurd.Ms 28, 1904, par. 3–63SP 48.2–3 Though meant to entangle Christ, such questions from the Sadducees were answered by Him plainly and intelligently, bringing precious light to the people.Ms 71, 1897, par. 27
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
18 sources
The Sadducees, who denied that the dead will ever live again, put a hostile puzzle to Jesus about seven brothers who in turn married the same woman under the law of Moses and all died childless, asking whose wife she would be when the dead rise.ST Feb 6, 1901ST Oct 25, 1899RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 12, 1856RH Mar 18, 1902 Their wording looks to a future rising when the dead shall live again, still future for those who had died, not to anything that takes place at death.ST Aug 12, 1875RH Sep 8, 1859ST Jun 29, 1882 The question gives no proof of conscious life between death and resurrection and does not teach that the dead are already alive as immortal souls.ST Aug 12, 1875RH Sep 8, 1859ST Jun 29, 1882RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854 His answer corrects their denial and proves from the Scriptures and the power of God that those in their graves will be made alive again.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 12, 1856RH Mar 18, 1902 In that resurrection people neither marry nor are given in marriage but are like the angels, so the earthly marriage tie does not decide relations there.ST Aug 12, 1875ST Jun 29, 1882RH Aug 13, 1872
Setting and Wording of Question
The question is put by the Sadducees, who professed to hold the writings of Moses while denying the resurrection of the dead.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854RH Mar 18, 1902 They taught that when a person dies he remains dead for all time to come, with no future existence for good or bad, left unconscious, and therefore they denied any future life.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 12, 1856RH Apr 5, 1860 Their denial is the setting met by the answer that the dead will rise and live again.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 12, 1856RH Mar 18, 1902
The case they state is that seven brothers in turn successively married the same woman under Moses' law of levirate marriage, by which a brother marries his deceased brother's wife.ST Oct 25, 1899RH Mar 18, 1902RH Dec 12, 1854 Each died childless and the woman died last, whether the story is taken as actual or hypothetical.RH Mar 18, 1902ST Oct 25, 1910RH Dec 12, 1854 The inquiry is whose wife she will be in the resurrection, since all seven had her to wife.ST Feb 6, 1901RH Sep 8, 1859ST Oct 25, 1899
That inquiry is a hostile puzzle and challenge meant to overthrow the doctrine that the dead will be raised and to trap Jesus about His teaching.RH Mar 18, 1902ST Oct 25, 1910RH Apr 5, 1860 It treats continued marriage in the resurrection as the difficulty, supposing the same earthly relations must persist there.ST Oct 25, 1899RH Dec 12, 1854RH Mar 18, 1902 It ends in the questioners' defeat, and such reasoning is like arguments that make the resurrection seem incredible and weaken confidence in the gospel.RH Mar 18, 1902RH May 26, 1859
The wording looks to a future event when they shall rise and live again, with the case closed up till the next world.ST Aug 12, 1875RH Aug 13, 1872RH Mar 18, 1902 The seven brothers and the woman had died, and the resurrection addressed is still future for them, not something that occurred at their deaths.ST Aug 12, 1875RH Aug 13, 1872RH Sep 8, 1859 The phrase shall rise places the event in the future, not at death and not in an intermediate state after death.RH Sep 8, 1859ST Jun 29, 1882RH Aug 13, 1872
The discussion belongs to the encounter with the Sadducees recorded by Matthew, Mark, and Luke.RH Mar 10, 1868 Luke describes those who attain the resurrection as those accounted worthy, while Mark omits the word worthy.RH Mar 10, 1868 Mark's silence does not prove Luke's wording incorrect, since both are equally inspired.RH Mar 10, 1868
Resurrection, Not Immortal Souls
The question about whose wife the woman will be looks to the resurrection and to marriage in the resurrection, not to the state of the dead before that event, not to any intermediate state after death, and not to immortal souls claiming each other in the spirit world.ST Feb 6, 1901ST Jun 29, 1882RH Dec 12, 1854RH Mar 18, 1902 It asks about a future rising when the dead come to life and live again, with the seven brothers and the woman having died and the case closed until the next world, not about a resurrection that takes place at death.ST Aug 12, 1875RH Sep 8, 1859RH Mar 18, 1902 Jesus answers that those raised do not marry or enter marriage but are like the angels in heaven.ST Aug 12, 1875ST Jun 29, 1882RH Aug 13, 1872 The whole conversation gives no proof of life between death and resurrection in the form of immortal souls, and it does not establish that the dead are alive or that resurrection occurs at death.ST Aug 12, 1875RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854
It is a plain case for resurrection that meets men who professed belief in the writings of Moses yet denied the resurrection of the dead, holding that a person dies and remains dead with no future existence for good or bad and left unconscious.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 12, 1856 Christ's argument corrects, refutes, and reproves that denial of future life, proving that the dead will rise and will live again at an event still future to the seven brothers and the woman, not at their deaths.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 12, 1856RH Apr 5, 1860RH Sep 8, 1859 To treat the exchange as proof that people remain alive after death in conscious existence would make His reasoning defeat the resurrection He set out to establish and would make a resurrection unnecessary.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jun 12, 1856RH Sep 8, 1859 He does not tell them they are wrong that the dead are unconscious, and He does not teach that the dead are already alive in conscious existence with no need of a resurrection.RH Jun 12, 1856RH Sep 8, 1859
He answers that they err, not knowing the Scriptures which teach that the dead will live again, nor the power of God who is able to make alive again all who have gone into their graves, nor the nature and condition of that future state.RH Mar 18, 1902 The wording shall rise places the event in the future, when the seven who had died shall rise, not at death.ST Aug 12, 1875ST Jun 29, 1882RH Aug 13, 1872 In that resurrection they neither marry nor are given in marriage but are as the angels of God in heaven, while the Sadducees' challenge treats marriage as continuing there under the law of levirate marriage by which seven brothers successively married the same woman.ST Jun 29, 1882RH Aug 13, 1872ST Oct 25, 1899RH Mar 18, 1902 It therefore makes no difference how many husbands the woman had here, because relations there are not based on any such conventional arrangements.RH Mar 18, 1902
The verse is used to distinguish belief in resurrection and future life from the Sadducees' central denial, rather than to condemn views about the state of the dead.RH Apr 5, 1860
Sources