Mark 4:10
And when he was alone, they that were about him with the twelve asked of him the parable.
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
And when he was alone, they that were about him with the twelve asked of him the parable.
And when he was alone, they that were about him, with the twelve, asked of him the parable.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
And when he was alone, they that were about him with the twelve asked of him the parables.
And when he was alone, those about him, with the twelve, did ask him of the simile,
And when he was alone, those about him with the twelve asked him [ as to] the parables.
And when he was alone they who were about him with the twelve questioned him as to the parables;
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
As soon as Jesus was alone with the Twelve and those around Him, they asked Him about the parable.
When he was alone, those who were around him with the twelve asked him about the parables.
And when he was by himself, those who were round him with the twelve put questions to him about the purpose of the stories.
And whe he was alone, they that were about him with the twelue, asked him of ye parable.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And when he was alone, the twelve that were with him asked him the parable.
Cross-references
- Luke 8:9-10
And his disciples asked him, saying, What might this parable be?
The disciples ask Jesus about the parable, and he explains its meaning.
- Mark 4:14-20
The sower soweth the word.
Explains the seed as the word and how it is received, hindered, or made fruitful.
- Matthew 13:10-23
And the disciples came, and said unto him, Why speakest thou unto them in parables?
The disciples ask about the parable, and Jesus explains the different responses to the word.
- Matthew 13:10-11
And the disciples came, and said unto him, Why speakest thou unto them in parables?
The disciples ask Jesus about the parables and receive his explanation.
- Matthew 13:1-9
The same day went Jesus out of the house, and sat by the sea side.
Parallel account of the sower and its explanation.
- Luke 8:11
Now the parable is this: The seed is the word of God.
Defines the seed in the parable as the word of God.
- Mark 4:21-25
And he said unto them, Is a candle brought to be put under a bushel, or under a bed? and not to be set on a candlestick?
Jesus continues teaching about hearing and receiving his words.
- Mark 4:15
And these are they by the way side, where the word is sown; but when they have heard, Satan cometh immediately, and taketh away the word that was sown in their hearts.
The path soil represents hearts where the word is sown.
- Mark 4:20
And these are they which are sown on good ground; such as hear the word, and receive it, and bring forth fruit, some thirtyfold, some sixty, and some an hundred.
The good soil represents fruitful reception of the seed.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
21 sources
After He had taught the parable of the sower from a boat to a large, eager crowd beside the Sea of Galilee, Jesus was left alone in private with the twelve and other followers gathered around Him, and they asked Him for its explanation.COL 33.2–34.1COL 30.1COL 57.1–22SP 235.1–22SP 234.1–2 His parables were meant to awaken inquiry, so that honest seekers who desired divine things would ask for clearer understanding and receive it.ST May 3, 18772SP 235.1–2ST Jan 19, 1915 The story reveals God's work to bring His people back to loyalty, with the seed as the word of God and gospel of Christ's grace, sown alike by the same sower but bearing according to the condition of the heart-soil.COL 33.1COL 30.1COL 56.1–24T 499.2 Its limited immediate results came because hearers were left free, with some losing the word at once, some falling away under trial, and some letting cares, riches, and pleasures choke it, since Christ would not force belief by miracles.2SP 241.1–24RED 86.2–3TCBMP 140.1–142.1 Hard hearts can still be softened by Christlike care and by repentance and earnest effort united with divine power to uproot evil, and truth long dormant can awaken to conversion and fruit, especially when Christ as Saviour and His redeeming love are set forth.COL 57.1–2COL 56.1–2GW 185.1TBC1872 111.1Lt 202, 1897, par. 6
Setting and Inquiry
This moment belongs to the parable of the sower, taught beside the Sea of Galilee where a large crowd had gathered and Jesus spoke to them from a boat.COL 33.2–34.1COL 30.1 It was a large, eager company gathered to hear Him, curious about God's kingdom which they could not see with physical eyes.COL 30.1ST May 10, 1877
After the crowd had departed, He was alone in a private setting with the twelve and other followers gathered around Him.COL 57.1–22SP 235.1–22SP 234.1–2GW 185.1CT 186.3–187.2 Those around Him with the twelve then asked Him about the parable, seeking its explanation.ST May 3, 18772SP 235.1–22SP 234.1–2ST May 10, 1877ST Jan 19, 1915
His parables were meant to awaken inquiry, gain attention, impress truth on the heart, and prompt listeners to seek a clearer understanding of the truth.ST May 3, 1877ST Jan 19, 1915 Honest inquirers who desired to know divine things and wanted to understand His teaching could ask Him for a fuller explanation and receive it.2SP 235.1–2ST Jan 19, 1915
Meaning of the Parable
The parable illustrates the kingdom of heaven and God's work for His people to bring them back to loyalty to Him.COL 33.1 The seed is the word of God, the gospel truth of Christ's grace, and the laws that govern the sowing of natural seed apply also to the sowing of truth.COL 33.1COL 30.1
It portrays the different tendencies of human hearts and the different kinds of people taught, with their differing ways of receiving the message.2SP 241.1–2ST May 3, 18774RED 86.2–3 It explains why the ministry had limited immediate results, for people were free to accept or reject, and miracles were not used to force belief or obedience.2SP 241.1–24RED 86.2–3 The difference in result does not lie with the sower or the seed, which are the same, but with the condition of the soil.COL 56.1–2 The soil represents the heart and mind, and hearers are responsible when they resist the Spirit and allow hardness or worldly concerns to hinder the word.COL 56.1–2 In early life the mind as soil is especially receptive, and good seed sown in good soil bears fruit unto eternal life.4T 499.2
People respond to the gospel seed in distinct unfruitful ways: some hear without retaining it, some receive it eagerly but fall away under trial, and some let worldly cares, riches, and pleasures choke the truth so it bears no lasting fruit.TCBMP 140.1–142.1 People must join their own efforts with divine power to overcome sin.2SP 241.1–2 The heart can be prepared as soil is prepared, with repentance breaking it up and with diligent, earnest effort in Jesus' strength uprooting evil tendencies that would choke the good seed.2SP 241.1–2COL 56.1–2ED 111.1–2
Sowing and Cultivating Truth
The gospel seed needs prepared soil to take root, and hard hearts pictured as the beaten path can be softened by personal, Christlike care and ministry so that the seed of truth finds a place in them.COL 57.1–2GW 185.1 Teaching believers the foundations of Christian life helps that truth take root and clears away what would choke it, and those foundations are living out Christ's character, bearing burdens, practicing self-denial, trusting Him, and working for the lost.COL 57.1–2 Truth sown in human hearts may lie dormant for a time, yet God's grace can awaken it to conviction and bring it to fruitfulness for God's glory.TBC1872 111.1Lt 202, 1897, par. 6 Truth heard can lodge in the heart, spring up, and bear fruit in conversion, especially when Christ as Saviour and His redeeming love are presented alongside the truth.Lt 202, 1897, par. 64T 393.3
The mind is like soil that is especially receptive in early life, and good seed sown in good soil bears fruit unto eternal life.4T 499.2 The heart is soil that must be prepared for the Sower to scatter the good seed, and parents are to do that preparing work for young children until eight or ten years of age by keeping them at home and being their best teachers.CTBH 67.3 They are to make the open air amid flowers and birds the schoolroom and the treasures of nature the textbook, opening before them God's great book of nature as fast as their minds can comprehend it.CTBH 67.3 They are to devote the time and labor now wasted on the fashions of the world to cultivating their minds and forming correct habits, and lessons given in this way will not soon be forgotten and will produce a marked change in families.CTBH 67.3
The seed imagery links teaching with what is planted in the heart and the harvest it produces, for truth sown in hearers can spring up and bear fruit.4T 393.3CT 186.3–187.2 Presenting Christ as the Saviour alongside the truth helps that seed take root, while leaving Christ and His redeeming love out may forfeit an opportunity that will not come again.4T 393.3 Harmful teaching can yield a harvest of unbelief.CT 186.3–187.2
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
29 sources
When he was alone those about him with the Twelve asked him about the parable, and he privately opened its meaning and taught them the mysteries of the kingdom.ST May 3, 1877RH Oct 30, 1860ST Nov 26, 1894 His parables were spoken to awaken inquiry and impress truth upon the heart, hiding their meaning from the careless while guiding honest seekers who love truth to ask for clearer understanding.ST May 3, 1877ST Jan 19, 1915ST Jan 28, 1889 The seed in the parable is the word of God, the gospel message of salvation sown in human hearts with spiritual life and power.RH Dec 21, 1905ST Oct 19, 1882ST Apr 11, 1900 The heart is the soil, and there are four kinds of hearers, where only the honest and good heart keeps the word with patience and perseverance and bears abundant fruit, while the rest lose it to Satan, wither under trial and persecution for lack of deep root, or are choked by worldly cares, riches and pleasures.RH May 11, 1869RH Aug 6, 1861 Unfruitfulness is therefore the hearer's fault and not the seed's, for the truth must rule the heart above every competing interest, and sowing it by preaching, publications and godly life must be persevered in with prayer and dependence on God's blessing.RH May 11, 1869ST Oct 19, 1882RH Aug 6, 1861ST Jun 16, 1887RH May 18, 1916
Private Inquiry and Parables
When he was alone, those about him with the Twelve asked him about the parable, and apart from the crowd he explained its meaning to them and instructed them concerning the mysteries of the kingdom.ST May 3, 1877RH Oct 30, 1860ST Nov 26, 1894ST Apr 11, 1900RH Oct 22, 1914 The asking came after the public teaching was finished, when Jesus was alone with his companions and followers, and the explanation belonged to that private circle.RH Oct 30, 1860ST Nov 26, 1894RH Oct 22, 1914ST Jan 28, 1889
The setting was teaching by parables to a crowd curious about the kingdom of God, which they could not see with physical eyes.ST May 10, 1877 His parables were meant to awaken inquiry, gain attention, and impress truth upon the heart, prompting listeners to seek a clearer understanding of the truth.ST May 3, 1877ST Jan 19, 1915 He was willing to explain them to honest inquirers who desired to know divine things.ST Jan 19, 1915
The parable instructs honest-hearted people who love truth and are ready to receive it, while its meaning is concealed from others.ST Jan 28, 1889 It explains the different kinds of people taught and why there were limited immediate results.ST May 3, 1877 In this same context he stands as a model of perfect character, powerful yet loving and humble, attentive to the rights and needs of all, compassionate toward sufferers, and wholly free from selfish ambition.RH Oct 30, 1860
Seed and Soils Explained
The seed in the parable is the word of God, Bible truth, the gospel, the message of salvation, and truth sown in human hearts.RH Dec 21, 1905ST Oct 19, 1882ST Dec 2, 1897RH Dec 24, 1908RH Feb 10, 1910 God's words carry spiritual life and power, and preaching the word is like sowing seed whose desired fruit and revival is people obeying the truth and bearing fruit unto eternal life.RH Dec 21, 1905ST Apr 11, 1900RH Dec 24, 1908RH Feb 10, 1910 Bible truth is the essential seed, needing suitable soil and thoughtful planting such as a stimulating question, suggestive remark, or helpful illustration, while criticism that turns hearers from a sermon can carry away the good seed before it takes root.ST Oct 19, 1882ST Dec 2, 1897
The human mind and heart are the soil, and faith supplies the conditions for the words to grow.ST Apr 11, 1900RH Oct 22, 1914 Life must be kept soft and receptive to God's influences, for merely receiving the words as words does not make them fruitful.ST Apr 11, 1900RH Oct 22, 1914 The fault for unfruitfulness is not in the seed.ST Apr 11, 1900
The heart is a soil in which every ill weed takes root and spreads, the thorns meaning worldly care and the thistles meaning worldly vanity.RH Jul 10, 1856 Christians should therefore watch their hearts as a husbandman watches his land, searching and examining the heart to cast out all unprofitable weeds and roots of bitterness that naturally take possession of it.RH Jul 10, 1856 When this work is rightly done the soil is ready for the good seed of the word of God, which springs up and prospers under the influence of divine grace as corn grows by rain and sunshine from heaven.RH Jul 10, 1856
There are four classes of hearers: those represented by seed on the path, rocky ground, and thorny ground fail to bear mature fruit, while those represented by good soil hear and act with wisdom, perseverance, and patience, bearing fruit abundantly.RH May 11, 1869RH Aug 6, 1861RH May 11, 1869RH Jul 10, 1860 Some fail to understand God's Word, allowing the wicked one to take it from their hearts; others receive it joyfully but abandon it when trouble, persecution, temptation, or trial comes for lack of root and hardness; and others are choked by worldly cares, riches, and pleasures so they bear no lasting fruit.RH Aug 6, 1861RH Jul 10, 1860 Those with an honest and good heart keep the Word and patiently bear fruit, becoming sowers of the good seed themselves.RH May 11, 1869
Hearers are responsible for the unfruitfulness that results from their unprepared hearts, for God's truth produces different results because it meets different conditions of heart.RH May 11, 1869RH Aug 6, 1861 The truth must take deep root and rule the heart and take priority over worldly interests and duties that conflict with obedience.RH May 11, 1869RH Aug 6, 1861 If embraced for secondary motives or crowded by competing cares and desires, it will wither under persecution and trial or be choked out, and a divided heart is not safe ground for faith.RH Aug 6, 1861
The verse illustrates saving faith as taking God at his word and trusting him.ST Jun 28, 1883 Christ is freely and fully offered as God's gift, and faith receives that gift.ST Jun 28, 1883
Sowing Truth in Ministry
Sowing the seed is sharing truth through preaching and publications, including tracts and the quiet work of isolated believers whose speech and daily lives prepare the way for definite efforts by ministers.RH Nov 11, 1909ST Aug 12, 1880 It needs suitable soil and thoughtful planting, such as a stimulating question, suggestive remark, or helpful illustration, while scolding, needless repetition, and excessive explanation can bury good teaching and keep it from taking root.ST Oct 19, 1882 Its aim is to bring sin home specifically to the conscience, since the word can be taken from the conscience and become unfruitful, and even a passing word may have more effect than the rest of the sermon.ST Jun 16, 1887 It must seek out all kinds of people whether or not they seem ready to hear, and it must be persevered in as opportunity allows, with prayer and hope and dependence on God's blessing to make some of the seed grow.RH May 18, 1916ST Aug 12, 1880
A song telling of Jesus and his love can soften hardened hearts, so the good seed sown by the preacher takes root and springs up to everlasting life.RH Oct 23, 1913 The gospel sown in young minds is seed in good ground that can produce an abundant harvest.ST Mar 18, 1889 Seed sown by faithful workers takes root in some hearts, and with God's blessing it grows and spreads to others.RH Apr 2, 1867 Criticism that turns hearers from a sermon, by contrast, can carry away the good seed before it takes root.ST Dec 2, 1897
The seed of truth revives, and its desired fruit is people obeying the truth.RH Dec 21, 1905 It can take root and bring forth fruit unto eternal life even among people who are slow to understand, and truth planted in hearts may take root and grow later even if not believed while first heard.RH Dec 24, 1908RH Feb 10, 1910 It can be cherished in the heart for many years, even eleven years, until taking a decided stand when clear light comes.ST The good reception of the message among the German Russian families and the churches that grew among them illustrates this fruitful response, where receptive soil pictures people who receive the word of God and the word bears fruit in their lives.ST
Presenting the truths of the message and the plan of salvation to attentive hearers and appealing to them to give themselves to Christ sows that seed, even though some who respond may fall out by the way and not continue to baptism and church membership.RH Jan 9, 1913 The memory of seed sown may take root and ripen as its fruit is seen in loving action.RH Feb 10, 1910 The figure of a sower putting seed into the ground and afterwards reaping the same impresses the certainty that people will receive hereafter according to the deeds of this life.RH Sep 17, 1857 The present lifetime is the world's sowing time, when all are busily putting in seed for a future harvest either good or bad, whether tares or wheat, and no one can expect to reap differently from what was sown, and if one sows nothing there is no right to expect a harvest.RH Sep 17, 1857
Sources