Mark 9:10
And they kept that saying with themselves, questioning one with another what the rising from the dead should mean.
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
And they kept that saying with themselves, questioning one with another what the rising from the dead should mean.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
And they kept the saying, questioning among themselves what the rising again from the dead should mean.
and the thing they kept to themselves, questioning together what the rising out of the dead is.
And they kept that saying, questioning among themselves, what rising from among [ the] dead was.
And, the word, they held fast unto themselves, discussing what was, the rising from among the dead.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
So they kept this matter to themselves, discussing what it meant to rise from the dead.
They kept this saying to themselves, questioning what the “ rising from the dead” meant.
And they kept the saying, questioning among themselves what the coming back from the dead might be.
So they kept that matter to themselues, and demaunded one of another, what the rising from the dead againe should meane?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And they kept the word to themselves; questioning together what that should mean, when he shall be risen from the dead.
Cross-references
- Matthew 17:9-13
And as they came down from the mountain, Jesus charged them, saying, Tell the vision to no man, until the Son of man be risen again from the dead.
Both recount the disciples’ question about the resurrection and Jesus’ explanation about Elijah.
- Mark 8:31-32
And he began to teach them, that the Son of man must suffer many things, and be rejected of the elders, and of the chief priests, and scribes, and be killed, and after three days rise again.
Jesus had already foretold His death and resurrection
- 2 Peter 1:16-18
For we have not followed cunningly devised fables, when we made known unto you the power and coming of our Lord Jesus Christ, but were eyewitnesses of his majesty.
Both texts concern the transfiguration and Christ’s glory.
- Luke 9:28-36
And it came to pass about an eight days after these sayings, he took Peter and John and James, and went up into a mountain to pray.
Luke recounts the same transfiguration, including the disciples’ response afterward.
- Mark 9:31-32
For he taught his disciples, and said unto them, The Son of man is delivered into the hands of men, and they shall kill him; and after that he is killed, he shall rise the third day.
Jesus foretold his death and resurrection, which the disciples did not understand.
- Mark 10:34
And they shall mock him, and shall scourge him, and shall spit upon him, and shall kill him: and the third day he shall rise again.
Jesus predicts his death and rising on the third day.
- Luke 18:34
And they understood none of these things: and this saying was hid from them, neither knew they the things which were spoken.
The disciples did not understand Jesus’ prediction of rising from the dead.
- John 5:27-29
And hath given him authority to execute judgment also, because he is the Son of man.
Christ's voice raises the dead
- John 11:23-26
Jesus saith unto her, Thy brother shall rise again.
Jesus discusses Lazarus’s resurrection and himself as the resurrection and the life.
- Luke 9:44-45
Let these sayings sink down into your ears: for the Son of man shall be delivered into the hands of men.
Jesus predicts his coming death, but the disciples do not understand.
- Luke 20:35-38
But they which shall be accounted worthy to obtain that world, and the resurrection from the dead, neither marry, nor are given in marriage:
Moses’ words affirm that the dead are raised and live unto God.
- John 11:43-44
And when he thus had spoken, he cried with a loud voice, Lazarus, come forth.
Jesus calls Lazarus out of the tomb.
- Mark 9:1
And he said unto them, Verily I say unto you, That there be some of them that stand here, which shall not taste of death, till they have seen the kingdom of God come with power.
promise fulfilled by transfiguration
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
4 sources
This saying comes from the transfiguration, when the disciples had been with Christ on the mount while below them were people needing deliverance from Satan through faith and prayer.ST Jan 22, 1902 The events that follow the transfiguration are the same as those recorded in Matthew 17:9-21 and Luke 9:37-45.DA 426 Jesus had charged the disciples to keep the vision secret until the rising from the dead.Lt 354, 1907, par. 4–10
They kept that saying about rising from the dead among themselves, questioning one with another what it should mean, because they did not understand the resurrection.DA 426.1–2Lt 354, 1907, par. 4–10 Although Jesus had spoken plainly of what lay ahead, they were slow to understand and did not ask Him to explain it.DA 426.1–2 Sorrow led them to shrink from learning more about a future they hoped would never come.DA 426.1–2
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
17 sources
They kept to themselves the command to tell no one of the transfiguration until the Son of man had risen from the dead, questioning among themselves what the rising from the dead should mean because they did not yet understand the resurrection He had spoken of.RH Oct 30, 1860GSAM 68.2ST Aug 24, 1888 They questioned even though He had repeatedly told them He would rise on the third day, for they still expected a worldly kingdom and did not grasp His death and atoning sacrifice, and being heavy with sleep they had not fully heard Moses and Elijah speak of His decease to be accomplished at Jerusalem.GSAM 68.2ST Aug 24, 1888ST Jan 16, 1901 The transfiguration on the mountain was a real vision and a miniature representation of the kingdom of glory, given to show them the nature of the eternal kingdom and to sustain them with a glimpse of triumph beyond the tomb through the dark hours before them.ST Apr 9, 1902ST Jun 15, 1904ST Jan 16, 1901ST Apr 9, 1902 In that glory Christ appeared as the glorified King, with Moses present in a resurrected body as representative of those who sleep and will be raised at His coming, and Elijah present without having died as representative of those who will be translated alive and changed to immortality.STST Jun 15, 1904ST Jan 16, 1901RH Feb 4, 1875 Moses alive with Christ was brought from the grave when Michael contended with the devil for his body and raised him, a partial fulfillment of the promise of resurrection and a victory over death that demonstrates Christ's power to release all captives at His second coming, when alone the hope of His children will be consummated.STST Jun 15, 1904ST Sep 7, 1904ST Jan 16, 1901ST Apr 9, 1902
Setting and Nature of Vision
Mark 9:1-10 records the transfiguration of Christ on the mountain before Peter, James and John, with Moses and Elijah talking with Him in glory, together with the events immediately following it.ST Jan 16, 1901ST Jun 15, 1904ST Mar 31, 1898 It is the same account as Matthew 17:1-9 and Luke 9:28-36, and parallel to Matthew 17:1-9 and Luke 9:28-42, varying only in additional details.ST Jan 16, 1901ST Mar 31, 1898 It occurred six days after the promise that some standing there would not taste death till they see the Son of man coming in His kingdom and the kingdom of God come with power, in fulfilment of that promise.ST Jun 15, 1904ST Mar 31, 1898ST Jan 16, 1901 The account faces those coming out of pagan falsehood about the immortality of the soul and consciousness in death.ST Jan 16, 1901
The transfiguration was a real supernatural scene that is also called a vision, where vision means a sight or spectacle, not necessarily an unreal event.ST Apr 9, 1902 The mountain, the heavenly glory, the voice, the prophets, and their conversation with Jesus were actually present and real, and its people and events were real.ST Apr 9, 1902ST Apr 9, 1902 After the transfiguration the disciples kept what they had seen to themselves and questioned what rising from the dead meant.ST Apr 9, 1902 Moses' presence alive on the mount therefore indicates that he had been raised from the dead.ST Apr 9, 1902
Disciples' Failure to Understand
They kept the saying with themselves and questioned one with another what rising from the dead should mean, for they did not yet understand the resurrection He had spoken of.RH Oct 30, 1860GSAM 68.2ST Aug 24, 1888ST Jan 1, 1894RH Aug 26, 1862
They questioned even though He had repeatedly told them He would rise on the third day and had commanded them not to speak of the transfiguration until the Son of man had risen from the dead.GSAM 68.2ST Aug 24, 1888ST Jan 1, 1894
They still did not understand that He would die and rise again, nor did they grasp the nature of His kingdom and atoning sacrifice, because they expected a worldly kingdom and held a wrong idea of the Messianic kingdom.ST Jan 16, 1901ST Jan 1, 1894
Being heavy with sleep, they did not fully hear Moses and Elijah speak of His decease to be accomplished at Jerusalem, and if they had kept awake they would have known the Master was to die and would not have been surprised when death came.ST Jan 16, 1901
Their lack of understanding left them unprepared for His death, and their hope failed when He was crucified.GSAM 68.2ST Jan 1, 1894
Their understanding became clear in God's time through the Spirit's teaching.RH Aug 26, 1862
Their confusion shows that people may need time and instruction before they can grasp or bear a truth, so that truth must be presented with wisdom and in a measure suited to their understanding.ST Aug 24, 1888
The verse is connected with the transfiguration and the claim that Moses had been resurrected and was present with Elijah.RH Nov 20, 1860
It does not itself explain the disciples' question, but provides context for discussing whether others had been raised before Christ's resurrection.RH Nov 20, 1860
Kingdom Prophecy and Application
The transfiguration was a miniature representation of the kingdom of glory in fulfilment of the promise Christ made six days before that some standing there would see the kingdom of God come with power and the Son of man coming in His kingdom.ST Jun 15, 1904ST Jan 16, 1901 It was given as encouragement to disciples who held a wrong idea of the Messianic kingdom and needed to learn the nature of the eternal kingdom.ST Jan 16, 1901 In the scene Christ appears as the glorified King with shining white garments and glorified countenance, and the voice out of the cloud declares, This is My beloved Son: hear Him.ST Jun 15, 1904ST Jan 16, 1901 Moses appears in glory as representative of those who sleep and will be raised from the dead at His coming, and Elijah appears as representative of those who will be translated alive without seeing death and changed to immortality when the Lord comes in glory.ST Jun 15, 1904ST Jan 16, 1901 It gives a glimpse of triumphant glory beyond the tomb to sustain them in the dark hours through which they were soon to pass, and shows the necessity of the resurrection and Christ's second coming, when alone the hope of His children will be consummated.ST Jan 16, 1901
Moses was present alive on the mount in a resurrected body, having come from heaven after Michael resurrected him.ST The devil disputed about the body of Moses to thwart God's purpose and to prevent its resurrection before the time, until Michael said, The Lord rebuke thee.ST The scene was real in its people and events, so Moses' presence on the mount therefore indicates that he had been raised from the dead.STST Apr 9, 1902 Moses alive with Christ is an illustrative, partial fulfilment of God's promise of resurrection given to maintain and strengthen faith.ST Sep 7, 1904 It marks the outcome of the crisis when Christ as Prince of Life disputed death's right to the body of Moses after death had reigned from Adam to Moses, bringing Moses from the enemy's land by a faith-inspiring victory over death and the grave that demonstrates His ability to release all captives.ST Sep 7, 1904
The appearance of Moses and Elijah faces pagan falsehood about the immortality of the soul and consciousness in death, and does not prove that the soul is immortal.ST Jan 16, 1901ST Their appearance does not show that both had died and been buried.RH Feb 4, 1875 Elijah went to heaven without dying, while God buried Moses and his grave's location was unknown.RH Feb 4, 1875
The transfiguration glory on the mountain was followed by giving the glory of His life to the needy, demon-haunted multitude in the valley below.ST May 8, 1901 The people below needed liberation from Satan through faith and prayer.ST Jan 22, 1902ST May 8, 1901 Just as beyond the resurrection and ascension of Christ lay the great field of the world where His body, the church, labors, ministers His life, witnesses to the power of His resurrection, and carries on the struggle begun by its self-sacrificing Head, so the mountain is followed by the broad needy field of sick bodies and dying souls, by labor, travail, pain, and the triumph of saving souls.ST May 8, 1901
Sources