Matthew 18:8
Wherefore if thy hand or thy foot offend thee, cut them off, and cast them from thee: it is better for thee to enter into life halt or maimed, rather than having two hands or two feet to be cast into everlasting fire.
Translations
Why if your hand or your foot offend you, cut them off, and cast them from you: it is better for you to enter into life halt or maimed, rather than having two hands or two feet to be cast into everlasting fire.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
Wherefore if thy hand or thy foot offend thee, cut them off, and cast them from thee: it is better for thee to enter into life halt or maimed, rather than having two hands or two feet to be cast into everlasting fire.
Wherefore, if thy hand or thy foot causeth thee to sin, cut them off, and cast them from thee: it is better for thee to enter into life halt or maimed, rather than having two hands or two feet, to be cast into everlasting fire.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
And if thy hand or thy foot causeth thee to stumble, cut it off, and cast it from thee: it is good for thee to enter into life maimed or halt, rather than having two hands or two feet to be cast into the eternal fire.
'And if thy hand or thy foot doth cause thee to stumble, cut them off and cast from thee; it is good for thee to enter into the life lame or maimed, rather than having two hands or two feet, to be cast to the fire the age-during.
And if thy hand or thy foot offend thee, cut it off and cast [ it] from thee; it is good for thee to enter into life lame or maimed, [ rather] than having two hands or two feet to be cast into eternal fire.
But, if, thy hand or thy foot, be causing thee to stumble, cut it off, and cast it from thee: It is, seemly for thee, to enter into life, maimed or lame, rather than, having two hands or two feet, to be cast into the age-abiding fire.
If your hand or your foot causes you to sin, cut it off and throw it away. It is better for you to enter life crippled or lame than to have two hands and two feet and be thrown into the eternal fire.
If your hand or your foot causes you to sin, cut it off and throw it away. It is better for you to enter life lame or crippled than to have two hands and two feet and be thrown into the eternal fire.
If your hand or your foot causes you to stumble, cut it off and cast it from you. It is better for you to enter into life maimed or crippled, rather than having two hands or two feet to be cast into the eternal fire.
And if your hand or your foot is a cause of trouble, let it be cut off and put it away from you: it is better for you to go into life with the loss of a hand or a foot than, having two hands or two feet, to go into the eternal fire.
Wherefore, if thy hand or thy foote cause thee to offend, cut them off, and cast them from thee: it is better for thee to enter into life, halt, or maimed, then hauing two hands, or two feete, to be cast into euerlasting fire.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And if thy hand, or thy foot scandalize thee, cut it off, and cast it from thee. It is better for thee to go into life maimed or lame, than having two hands or two feet, to be cast into everlasting fire.
Cross-references 20 of 24
- Mark 9:43-48
And if thy hand offend thee, cut it off: it is better for thee to enter into life maimed, than having two hands to go into hell, into the fire that never shall be quenched:
Jesus warns that it is better to lose a member than face unquenchable fire.
- Matthew 5:29-30
And if thy right eye offend thee, pluck it out, and cast it from thee: for it is profitable for thee that one of thy members should perish, and not that thy whole body should be cast into hell.
Both teach removing what leads to sin to avoid judgment.
- Matthew 25:41
Then shall he say also unto them on the left hand, Depart from me, ye cursed, into everlasting fire, prepared for the devil and his angels:
Both describe the wicked being sent into everlasting fire.
- Isaiah 66:24
And they shall go forth, and look upon the carcases of the men that have transgressed against me: for their worm shall not die, neither shall their fire be quenched; and they shall be an abhorring unto all flesh.
Its unquenched fire and undying worm describe Gehenna’s punishment.
- Revelation 20:9-10
And they went up on the breadth of the earth, and compassed the camp of the saints about, and the beloved city: and fire came down from God out of heaven, and devoured them.
Fire falls on the wicked, and the lake of fire is the place of final punishment.
- Isaiah 33:14
The sinners in Zion are afraid; fearfulness hath surprised the hypocrites. Who among us shall dwell with the devouring fire? who among us shall dwell with everlasting burnings?
Describes the devouring fire as everlasting burnings.
- Luke 12:5
But I will forewarn you whom ye shall fear: Fear him, which after he hath killed hath power to cast into hell; yea, I say unto you, Fear him.
Both speak of being cast into Gehenna.
- Luke 17:1-2
Then said he unto the disciples, It is impossible but that offences will come: but woe unto him, through whom they come!
Both warn against causing others, especially little ones, to stumble.
- 2 Thessalonians 1:9
Who shall be punished with everlasting destruction from the presence of the Lord, and from the glory of his power;
Both describe everlasting punishment for the wicked.
- Matthew 25:46
And these shall go away into everlasting punishment: but the righteous into life eternal.
Both describe punishment as everlasting.
- Revelation 21:8
But the fearful, and unbelieving, and the abominable, and murderers, and whoremongers, and sorcerers, and idolaters, and all liars, shall have their part in the lake which burneth with fire and brimstone: which is the second death.
It names the lake of fire as the wicked’s portion.
- Galatians 5:24
And they that are Christ’s have crucified the flesh with the affections and lusts.
Cutting off sin connects with crucifying the flesh and its desires.
- Matthew 10:28
And fear not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul: but rather fear him which is able to destroy both soul and body in hell.
It says God can cast both soul and body into Gehenna.
- Matthew 13:41-42
The Son of man shall send forth his angels, and they shall gather out of his kingdom all things that offend, and them which do iniquity;
Both describe the wicked being cast into fire for judgment.
- Isaiah 30:33
For Tophet is ordained of old; yea, for the king it is prepared; he hath made it deep and large: the pile thereof is fire and much wood; the breath of the LORD, like a stream of brimstone, doth kindle it.
Tophet’s prepared fire corresponds to the fire of Gehenna.
- Matthew 13:49-50
So shall it be at the end of the world: the angels shall come forth, and sever the wicked from among the just,
The wicked are separated and cast into the furnace of fire.
- Matthew 26:31
Then saith Jesus unto them, All ye shall be offended because of me this night: for it is written, I will smite the shepherd, and the sheep of the flock shall be scattered abroad.
“Offended” likewise means caused to stumble.
- Matthew 11:6
And blessed is he, who soever shall not be offended in me.
“Offended” has the same sense of being caused to stumble.
- Luke 3:17
Whose fan is in his hand, and he will throughly purge his floor, and will gather the wheat into his garner; but the chaff he will burn with fire unquenchable.
Both texts speak of punishment by unquenchable fire.
- Malachi 4:1
For, behold, the day cometh, that shall burn as an oven; and all the proud, yea, and all that do wickedly, shall be stubble: and the day that cometh shall burn them up, saith the LORD of hosts, that it shall leave them neither root nor branch.
The wicked are burned up in unquenchable fire.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
52 sources
To offend is to be led into sin, and to cut off the offending hand or foot is to separate decisively from whatever causes that sin, not to injure the body.Lt 208a, 1902, par. 31–33Ms 47, 1908, par. 10–11Ms 33, 1885, par. 27–29ST May 20, 18976MR 208.3–209.1 The hand or foot stands for anything as close, precious, and useful as one's own limb that hinders full surrender to Christ, including cherished faults, hereditary and cultivated tendencies, ideas, plans, and self-will.Ms 115, 1902, par. 19–209MR 59.2–4Lt 93, 1901, par. 1–3Ms 47, 1908, par. 10–11Ms 33, 1885, par. 27–29 Whatever leads into sin must be renounced and cast away, however dear or costly the loss, for it is better to enter life without it than to keep it and be cast into everlasting fire.Ms 70, 1895, par. 13–16Lt 140, 1910, par. 3–7Lt 117, 1897, par. 6–7 This requires painful cutting away of selfishness, covetousness, harshness, pride, and striving for supremacy, and of any influence that causes Christ's weak and humble believing ones to stumble.STMW9 7.1Ms 115, 1902, par. 19–20Ms 107, 1903, par. 8–10ST May 20, 1897ST May 20, 1897 To refuse that separation is to choose death, since sin separates from God and his presence consumes what clings to it, while putting it away opens the way to communion with him and life.Ms 33, 1885, par. 27–29
Language and Imagery
In this verse “offend” means to lead oneself into sin, and the offending hand or foot is whatever stands in the way of surrender to Christ and hinders faithfulness to Him.Ms 47, 1908, par. 10–11Ms 33, 1885, par. 27–29 Sin must be decisively removed even when it is as dear as a hand or foot, and anything blocking that surrender must be given up however dear it may be.Ms 47, 1908, par. 10–11Ms 33, 1885, par. 27–29 It is better to suffer that loss and enter into life than to keep what is cherished and be lost, because sin separates a person from God and leads to everlasting fire, while putting away darling sins makes a right relation to God possible.Ms 47, 1908, par. 10–11Ms 33, 1885, par. 27–29
The command to cut off the hand or foot is a forceful picture of decisive separation from what causes sin, not an instruction to injure or maim the body.Lt 208a, 1902, par. 31–33ST May 20, 18976MR 208.3–209.1 Anything leading a person into sin must be given up however precious or useful it may seem, for entering life maimed is better than keeping both hands or both feet and being cast into everlasting fire.Lt 208a, 1902, par. 31–336MR 208.3–209.1 The offending members represent evil traits to be removed from the character, and that character work requires close attention and may be painful.Lt 208a, 1902, par. 31–33ST May 20, 1897 Hereditary and cultivated wrong tendencies — selfishness, covetousness, harshness, unkindness, and hard-heartedness — must be cut away, for if they remain they corrupt the whole person, wound and destroy others, and lead to neglect of those needing help.ST May 20, 1897 The cutting off is figurative in the same way when cherished ideas and opinions that a person insists others must share are to be given up once they lead to offense and spiritual harm.Ms 60, 1904, par. 3–6Ms 102, 1904, par. 15–176MR 208.3–209.1
The hand or foot stands for what is as close, familiar, precious, dear, or useful as one’s own limb.Ms 115, 1902, par. 19–20Lt 93, 1901, par. 1–3Ms 102, 1904, par. 15–17 It includes any fault or defective attribute and any hereditary and cultivated wrong tendency to sin, which must be removed rather than allowed to destroy the whole person, since entering life with that loss is better than keeping them and perishing in everlasting destruction.Ms 115, 1902, par. 19–20Lt 93, 1901, par. 1–3 It includes a cherished spirit, idea, plan, or use of authority that conflicts with God’s ways, and unsanctified ideas and sentiments held so stubbornly that others are expected to agree and think and speak the same way and have them pressed upon them; these must be surrendered and abandoned rather than allowed to offend, harm, or lead astray.9MR 59.2–4Ms 60, 1904, par. 3–6Ms 102, 1904, par. 15–17 It includes an evil disposition of self-exalting sharpness with harsh, unfeeling, cruel words that hurt, wound, or discourage others, and whatever in a person leads them to injure or hinder others; such conduct must be put away however dear or valued it is, for it is better to give it up and enter into life than to keep it and face everlasting fire and judgment.9MR 59.2–4Ms 116, 1904, par. 8–11
Setting in Matthew 18
The saying belongs to Jesus' instruction to the disciples at Capernaum on how his followers are to act and how his work is to be done.ST Sep 19, 1900Ms 34, 1900, par. 1–2DA 432.1–2 In that instruction self is to be kept under the control of the great Teacher, and his teachings are to be practiced.ST Sep 19, 1900Ms 34, 1900, par. 1–2 The chapter teaches humility, thorough conversion, and singleness of purpose, with no striving for supremacy.ST Sep 19, 1900Lt 64, 1900, par. 1–3RH May 18, 1876 Greatness in Christ's spiritual kingdom is inward and spiritual excellence manifested in true conversion, not position, outward splendor, or authority.ST Sep 19, 1900Lt 64, 1900, par. 1–3 Following Christ there requires humbling oneself and turning from self toward love and service to others, with pure motives and single purpose.RH May 18, 1876Lt 48a, 1900, par. 5–6 Its lessons are to be taken personally and practiced through self-discipline rather than through criticism of others.Lt 64, 1900, par. 1–3Lt 48a, 1900, par. 5–6
The warning stands with the condemnation of causing one of Christ's believing little ones to stumble, and to harm or mislead them brings severe judgment.STMW9 7.1Ms 107, 1903, par. 8–10RH Feb 17, 1903 Those little ones are not children in years but little children in Christ, weak and trembling souls with many defects and objectionable traits.Ms 11, 1888, par. 48–51 The same warning guards even a humble servant of Christ against being harmed or hindered.Ms 107, 1903, par. 8–10RH Feb 17, 1903 None of these little ones is to be despised or left to perish, but the erring are to be cared for.STMW9 7.1Ms 11, 1888, par. 48–51 Christ's followers must use their God-given talents to save that which is lost, giving compassion, earnest labor, and persevering effort not to the saint but to the sinner who needs it.Ms 11, 1888, par. 48–51
The chapter gives principles for acting in all cases and under all circumstances for all who claim to be disciples of the meek and lowly Jesus.Lt 64, 1900, par. 1–3 That instruction brings relief and courage and hope, directing to go forward in faith and to take the case to the Lord Jesus in prayer, believing that he hears.Lt 159, 1905, par. 4–5Lt 64, 1900, par. 1–3 Faults that endanger people and corrupt the church must be corrected, and the one in the wrong is to be told of the danger with the aim of saving from ruin.Ms 112, 1904, par. 12–14 Confession of sin with repentance and a humble walk with God finds pardon, for the Lord corrects to purify and save.Lt 159, 1905, par. 4–5 The instruction shows the church's duty to deal with sin and error and to be organized to carry out that duty, with serious offenses and wrong attitudes dealt with decisively, since criticism and disrespect are an offense to God and contrary to Christ's way.Ms 112, 1904, par. 12–14Lt 32, 1892, par. 29–30Lt 1, 1899, par. 6–7
Call to Decisive Renunciation
Anything that leads a person into sin must be decisively removed, renounced, rejected, surrendered and cast away, however precious, dear, useful, painful or costly the sacrifice may feel.Ms 70, 1895, par. 13–16Lt 140, 1910, par. 3–7Lt 117, 1897, par. 6–7Ms 115, 1902, par. 19–20Ms 1, 1880, par. 60–61 It is better to enter into life halt or maimed through that loss than to keep both hands or both feet and be cast into everlasting fire and destruction.Ms 70, 1895, par. 13–16Lt 140, 1910, par. 3–7Lt 117, 1897, par. 6–7Ms 40, 1896, par. 12–13Ms 1, 1880, par. 60–61 Even a fault or tendency as close and familiar as a hand or foot must be cut away rather than allowed to destroy the whole person.Ms 115, 1902, par. 19–20Ms 40, 1896, par. 12–13ST May 20, 1897 This cutting off applies to harmful attitudes and practices, including an unsympathetic spirit and a misuse of authority that harms believers, and to influences that threaten spiritual purity and healthy thoughts, for yielding to them leaves the heart unclean and turned toward idols.Ms 70, 1895, par. 13–16Lt 117, 1897, par. 6–7 Personal responsibility requires uprooting sin and guarding thought and conduct so as not to become a stumbling block to others, since sin is offensive to God and harming or misleading others is a grave offense.Ms 40, 1896, par. 12–13Ms 1, 1880, par. 60–61
Hereditary and cultivated wrong tendencies must be removed from the life through close character work that requires close attention and is sometimes painful.Ms 115, 1902, par. 19–20ST May 20, 1897ST May 20, 1897 Selfishness, covetousness, harshness, unkindness and hard-heartedness must be cut away, with selfishness, covetousness and harshness named with special urgency.ST May 20, 1897ST May 20, 1897ST Mar 5, 1912 If such offending traits of character, pictured as hand, foot and eye, remain they will corrupt and destroy the whole person and keep the person from entering life.Ms 115, 1902, par. 19–20ST May 20, 1897ST May 20, 1897ST Mar 5, 1912 Left in place they can also wound and destroy others and lead to neglect of those who need help.ST May 20, 1897
To offend in this sense is to lead oneself into sin, and what is as dear as a hand or foot must be given up rather than kept to be lost.Ms 33, 1885, par. 27–29 Removing cherished and darling sins makes a right relation to God possible, for sin separates a person from God.Ms 33, 1885, par. 27–29 Life comes through communion with God and surrender to his will, and the hand or foot stands for the self and the will that must yield to him. Hidden sins cannot be concealed from him, and to refuse to separate from sin is to choose death, for his presence consumes sin and those who cling to it and refuse to leave it will be consumed.
Evils to Be Cut Away
The hand, foot, and eye that offend are not limbs to be maimed but evil traits of character that lead into sin and harm others and must be cut away rather than allowed to bring ruin.ST May 20, 1897ST May 20, 1897 That cutting off means putting away passion, anger, loss of self-control, sternness, harshness, unkindness, hard-heartedness, selfishness, and covetousness.Ms 8a, 1891, par. 13–16ST May 20, 1897ST May 20, 1897ST Mar 5, 1912 The work demands close attention to character-building and is painful, yet hereditary and cultivated tendencies to evil must be removed however dear and cherished they are and whatever the cost.Ms 8a, 1891, par. 13–16ST May 20, 1897ST Mar 5, 1912 If they remain they corrupt and destroy the whole person, keep the person from entering life, wound and destroy others, and lead to neglect of those who need help.ST May 20, 1897ST May 20, 1897ST Mar 5, 1912
The same severing applies to cherished dispositions, plans, and uses of authority represented by hand, foot, and eye.Ms 70, 1895, par. 13–16Ms 70, 1895, par. 17–18 A hard, unsympathetic spirit, distrust that refuses to act in faith, and personal schemes that distort judgment must be given up rather than allowed to harm fellow believers.Ms 70, 1895, par. 13–16Ms 70, 1895, par. 17–18 Authority is meant to uplift, not to break down, and it is better to relinquish it than to abuse it and cause a brother to stumble.Ms 70, 1895, par. 13–16Ms 70, 1895, par. 17–18 The iron in the soul with its satanic attributes must be put away, including forcing one's own will, ideas, and plans, and that spirit must be let to die out of the heart and out of the church.Ms 8a, 1891, par. 13–16
Self and every unsanctified element must be removed from the soul temple, with plain and decided words against self-sufficiency, wounded dignity, trust in superior discernment and judgment, perversity of spirit and disposition, self-esteem, self-exaltation, dissension, and inward and open strife for supremacy and to be first and to be highly esteemed.Ms 26, 1889, par. 15–17Lt 107a, 1900, par. 2–3 Such self-life interposes self between the soul and God, grieves the Saviour's Spirit, and turns those who ought to be a blessing into a hindrance and curse that retards the work by words that tear down instead of building up the Redeemer's kingdom.Ms 26, 1889, par. 15–17 Divine power and grace cannot be manifested until this is cleansed away.Ms 26, 1889, par. 15–17
Criticism and faultfinding is expressly the devil's work.Lt 107a, 1900, par. 2–3 Satan began it in the heavenly courts by suggesting that a change in God's government would bring advantage, gaining sympathy and assent from angels, planting his own thoughts in their minds, then reporting their disaffection as if it came from themselves, while covering his tracks so that suspicion and distrust of God and of one another spread without its source being detected.Lt 107a, 1900, par. 2–3
Cherished ideas, opinions, sentiments, and unsanctified ideas must be surrendered when they are held so stubbornly that others are expected to agree and to think and speak the same way.Ms 60, 1904, par. 3–6Ms 102, 1904, par. 15–176MR 208.3–209.1 The cutting off is figurative: what is as precious or useful as a hand or foot must be abandoned rather than pressed upon others, for it is better to give it up than to let it cause offense and spiritual harm and face everlasting fire.Ms 60, 1904, par. 3–6Ms 102, 1904, par. 15–176MR 208.3–209.1 Influences that threaten spiritual purity and healthy thoughts must likewise be decisively removed even at great personal cost, since yielding to them leaves the heart unclean and turned toward idols.Lt 117, 1897, par. 6–7 Anything standing in the way of surrender to Christ and faithfulness to Him must be given up however dear it is, including self-indulgent sin or habit that obstructs the heart's openness to Jesus, for losing it is better than losing eternal life.Lt 117, 1897, par. 6–7Ms 47, 1908, par. 10–11Ms 4, 1888, par. 21
Care Not to Cause Stumbling
Anything within a person that causes others to stumble, injures or hinders Christ's humble servants, or leads another in a wrong direction must be decisively put away and cast away, however much it is valued and even at great cost.Ms 107, 1903, par. 11–18Ms 116, 1904, par. 8–11Ms 107, 1903, par. 8–10Ms 70, 1895, par. 17–182MR 286.3–287.2 The hand or foot is an evil disposition, including self-exalting sharpness and harsh, unfeeling words that hurt or discourage others, and cherished dispositions, plans, or uses of authority such as a hard, unsympathetic spirit, distrust that refuses to act in faith, or personal schemes that distort judgment.Ms 116, 1904, par. 8–11Ms 70, 1895, par. 17–18 Authority is meant to uplift and not to break down, and it is better to relinquish it than to abuse it and cause a brother to stumble.Ms 70, 1895, par. 17–18 It is better to suffer loss and enter into life, even maimed, than to keep what leads to sin and bring such offense and face judgment and everlasting fire and destruction.Ms 107, 1903, par. 11–18Ms 116, 1904, par. 8–11Ms 107, 1903, par. 8–102MR 286.3–287.2 This warning follows the words about offending believers and applies with special force where young people of different backgrounds and temperaments influence one another in a school, calling for resisting harmful influence and choosing what prepares people for eternal life.Ms 107, 1903, par. 8–102MR 286.3–287.2
Selfish neglect, holding the weak in contempt, judging, condemning, and an unforgiving, exacting spirit that discourages weak brethren must be cut off and cast away rather than continued.Ms 11, 1888, par. 48–5115MR 189.2–191.3 The little ones who must not be offended are not children in years but little children in Christ, weak and trembling souls with many defects and objectionable traits.Ms 11, 1888, par. 48–51 An evil disposition of self-exalting sharpness and harsh, unfeeling, cruel words that hurt, wound, or discourage others must be given up to enter into life, and one whose harsh, cruel spirit wounds others needs a change of heart before handling sacred responsibilities, however painful the loss.Ms 116, 1904, par. 8–11Lt 58, 1901, par. 18–19 Trying to obstruct, hinder, and repress a fellow worker because that person does not follow one's plans, devising plans to separate brethren, drawing apart from brethren, lack of love, accusing one another, thinking and speaking evil, and wanting a fellow worker removed from position are the enemy's devices condemned by the verse and must be met and condemned, for God does not desire any to draw apart from brethren.Ms 107, 1903, par. 11–18Lt 31, 1903, par. 4–5
Such a stumbling block can cause the loss of a soul and misrepresent Christ, and the urgency rests on the infinite value of every soul and the work to save the lost.DA 438.2–439.1 Even one cherished sin degrades character and can mislead others, while remaining evils such as hereditary tendencies to evil, selfishness, covetousness, harshness, unkindness, and hard-heartedness can corrupt the whole person, wound and destroy others, and lead to neglect of those who need help.DA 438.2–439.1ST May 20, 1897 Cutting off the harmful influence does not mean abandoning the erring person to ruin or to Satan, but removing the hardness and barriers that obstruct help, prayer, and guidance.9MR 59.2–4 Christ's followers must use their God-given talents to save what is lost, giving compassion, earnest labor, and persevering effort not to the saint but to the sinner who needs it, and making loving efforts to bring the straying to Christ.Ms 11, 1888, par. 48–519MR 59.2–4
Daily and Pastoral Application
A man must take himself in hand and reprimand himself by the discipline of the Word.Lt 48a, 1900, par. 3–4 Daily humbling of self before God, overcoming entertained temptations, and receiving and practicing the lessons of Christ as a learner in His school is required.Lt 48a, 1900, par. 3–4 No one who retains a selfish, unholy spirit should enter upon work in ministration of the Word until this severe self-discipline has been done, stopping just where he is rather than going forward unfit.Lt 48a, 1900, par. 3–4
The instruction gives relief and courage and hope, directing to go forward in faith and to take the case to the Lord Jesus in prayer, believing that He hears.Lt 159, 1905, par. 4–5 Confession of sin with repentance and a humble walk with God finds pardon, for correction aims to purify and save.Lt 159, 1905, par. 4–5
Those in positions of responsibility should follow the instruction, reject selfishness, and set an example that others can safely follow.Ms 165, 1902, par. 36–37 Self must be kept under the control of the great Teacher, and His teachings must be practiced.Ms 34, 1900, par. 1–2 The lessons are to be taken personally and practiced through self-discipline rather than criticism of others.Lt 48a, 1900, par. 5–6 They are to be practiced in daily life, including in the care and training of young people, for losing what is precious is better than being lost to everlasting fire.Lt 37a, 1900, par. 18–20 Workers are urged to study them for present and eternal good, since entering life maimed is better than keeping what leads to being cast into everlasting fire.Lt 21, 1903, par. 14 The lesson is needed to turn from a wrong course and avoid conduct that causes offense and division, because anything leading into sin must be decisively put away.Lt 360, 1905, par. 15–16
Teachers and those caring for children and students must cut off completely whatever spirit prompts harshness and arbitrary action, however dear and cherished and whatever it costs, even as much as a right arm.Ms 8a, 1891, par. 13–16 The harsh, iron traits in character, the iron in the soul with passion, anger, loss of self-control, sternness, and forcing one's own will, ideas and plans, must die out of the heart and out of the church.Ms 8a, 1891, par. 13–16 It is better to sacrifice cherished ways and get along with half of the things thought essential to success in order to connect in meekness and humbleness with Christ, receive the baptism of the Holy Spirit through earnest secret prayer, and diffuse light.Ms 8a, 1891, par. 30–319MR 63.1–3 Conversion requires humbling self as hard as severing an arm, becoming as a little child in mind and spirit, putting self on the child's level, and coming to God's ideas, plans and ways.Ms 8a, 1891, par. 13–16 Human minds must be dealt with as tenderly as Christ deals, with love, tenderness and forbearance, making students feel loved in order to have good influence, never shaking or bruising a child, taking it alone to pray and talk with it, showing it the will of Christ, binding it to the heart, receiving one such little child, and seeking and saving that which is lost instead of offending little ones and remaining under condemnation.Ms 8a, 1891, par. 13–16 The harsh, angry spirit that bruises or mistreats children must be removed at any cost as urgently as cutting off hand or foot, for preserving it risks spiritual ruin.9MR 57.6–59.1
Faults that endanger people and corrupt the church must be corrected, and the one in the wrong told of the danger to save from ruin.Ms 112, 1904, par. 12–14 The church has a duty to address those who fall into sin and error and must be organized to carry it out.Lt 32, 1892, par. 29–30 Serious offenses and wrong attitudes, including criticism and disrespect as offense to God and contrary to Christ's way, must be dealt with decisively.Lt 1, 1899, par. 6–7 Criticism and faultfinding is expressly the devil's work, begun in the heavenly courts by deceiving angels, suggesting a change in God's government would bring advantage, obtaining sympathy and assent, putting his own thoughts in their minds, then reporting their disaffection as if from them, while covering his tracks so suspicion and distrust of God and of one another spread without its source detected.Lt 107a, 1900, par. 2–3 Rebellion must be met with firm decision, and for the good of the loyal and true the disloyal must be separated and expelled with the instigator of evil, as God expelled Satan and the disloyal from heaven.Lt 107a, 1900, par. 2–3
Following Christ requires removing whatever leads into sin even at great personal cost, for entering life maimed is better than keeping what leads to everlasting destruction.RH May 18, 1876 Humble self and turn from self toward love and service to others with thorough conversion, single purpose, and pure motives.RH May 18, 1876 Church members who have had light on the truth must be converted, obey the truth in practice, and cooperate with Christ and His angels in helping needy souls to repentance, rather than remaining timid and inactive and becoming hinderers who annoy and perplex those weak in the faith.Ms 29, 1900, par. 29–30
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
46 sources
To offend here means to cause to stumble, and the command to cut off the hand or foot is not a call to injure the literal body but extreme language showing that even painful loss is better than keeping what causes stumbling.ST Jul 12, 1899ST Apr 23, 1912ST Aug 6, 1896ST Apr 1, 1897 The offending hand, foot and eye stand for sinful habits, pursuits, practices, associations, desires, motives and purposes that hinder obedience and must be surrendered, since outward injury cannot cure sin rooted in the soul.ST May 20, 1897RH Nov 27, 1860ST Apr 10, 1901 Anything that leads into sin must be decisively and promptly removed, however precious, useful or dear, including cherished traits, ambitions, relationships and indulgences, because entering eternal life maimed is better than keeping both hands or feet and being lost.RH Feb 17, 1903ST Jul 12, 1899ST Apr 23, 1912ST Jul 12, 1899ST Feb 19, 1902 The everlasting fire is God's consuming fire that will burn up the ungodly to ashes as it did Sodom and Gomorrah, so everlasting describes its lasting destructive effect and not endless preservation or conscious torment.ST Mar 4, 1880STST Mar 5, 1896RH Sep 29, 1859 This casting into Gehenna comes not in the present life but after the sentence at the last day, and the same cutting away applies to the church as Christ's body, which after efforts to correct and heal should remove a spiritually diseased member who causes others to stumble in order to save the body.ST Aug 6, 1896RH Feb 3, 1859ST Jul 15, 1880RH Jun 15, 1869
Wording and Imagery
The word rendered offend means to cause to stumble, not to make angry.ST Apr 1, 1897 An offence is anything that turns a person out of the ways of God or hinders him in them.RH Jun 20, 1854 The command to cut off the hand or foot is not a command to mutilate the literal body.ST Jul 12, 1899ST Apr 23, 1912ST Aug 6, 1896RH Nov 27, 1860 It uses extreme language to show that even painful loss is better than keeping what causes stumbling and being destroyed.ST Jul 12, 1899ST Apr 23, 1912 Anything that leads a person into sin must therefore be decisively removed, however precious, useful, valuable, or dear it may be, because to enter into eternal life maimed is better than to keep both hands or both feet and be cast into the fire.ST Jul 12, 1899ST Apr 23, 1912RH Nov 27, 1860
The cutting off applies to members that lead one to do wrong, individually to whatever leads a person to stumble, and also to the church as the body of Christ where a spiritually diseased member causes others to stumble.ST Jul 12, 1899ST Aug 6, 1896 Habits, professions, or pursuits that lead a person away from God and keep him from eternal life must be cut out, since entering into life with a loss is better than facing the eternal fire with everything intact.ST Apr 23, 1912RH Nov 27, 1860 The offending hand, foot, and eye are figures for what must be surrendered, not parts of the body to be injured.ST May 20, 1897RH Nov 27, 1860 Outward injury and bodily penance cannot cure sin rooted in the soul.RH Nov 27, 1860
They represent evil traits to be removed from the character, and that character work requires close attention and may be painful.ST May 20, 1897 The hand and foot stand for sinful habits, pursuits, practices, and associations, and for sinful acts, desires, motives, and purposes, anything that causes sin or hinders obedience to the gospel.RH Nov 27, 1860ST Apr 10, 1901 Sin must be rejected completely without compromise, even when doing so requires giving up something as precious as a hand or foot.ST Apr 10, 1901 Life means the eternal life the righteous enter, set against being cast whole into destructive fire.ST Mar 5, 1896RH Sep 29, 1859 Entering life halt or maimed is better than keeping both hands or both feet and being lost, and anything dear that causes stumbling should be given up rather than risk losing eternal life.ST Mar 5, 1896RH Sep 29, 1859ST Oct 31, 1900
The fire is fire that eternally consumes, an image of complete destruction and of the wicked being utterly consumed in the judgment, not of endless conscious torment.ST Mar 5, 1896RH Sep 29, 1859 Spiritual loss is worse than physical disfigurement, so the language about entering life halt, maimed, or blind shows it is better to lose something valuable than to be lost through sin.ST Oct 31, 1900 Yet merely removing outward temptations or disfiguring the body does not assure salvation, since a person may even become proud of humility.ST Oct 31, 1900
Setting in Chapter
Matthew 18 belongs to instruction on how followers are to act, where greatness in the spiritual kingdom comes from inward excellence rather than position, splendor, or authority, with no striving for supremacy.ST Sep 19, 1900 It calls for humbling oneself and turning from self toward love and service to others, requiring thorough conversion, single purpose, and pure motives.RH May 18, 1876 Removing whatever leads into sin, even at great personal cost, belongs to that turning, since entering life maimed is better than keeping what leads to everlasting destruction.RH May 18, 1876
The verse stands together with teaching on rank among the disciples and on stumbling-blocks, with the parable of the lost sheep, with the lesson on how to treat brethren, and with the assurance that God hears the united prayers of His children.ST Jan 20, 1909 The teaching remains applicable to Christians and to church life, and its having been spoken before Pentecost does not make it irrelevant to Christian practice.ST Jun 4, 1885 Forgiveness or pardon in the chapter is used in a limited sense that does not contradict the teaching that atonement for sin is made by blood.ST Oct 18, 1883
Duty to Renounce Sin
Anything that leads a person into sin must be decisively and promptly removed, however precious, useful, valuable or dear it may be, because entering into eternal life maimed is better than keeping both hands or feet and being cast into everlasting fire.RH Feb 17, 1903ST Mar 5, 1912ST Jul 12, 1899ST Jul 12, 1899RH Nov 27, 1860 The cutting off applies to members that lead one to do wrong and uses extreme language to show painful loss is better than keeping what causes stumbling, not as literal mutilation, for outward injury cannot cure sin rooted in the soul.ST Jul 12, 1899ST Apr 23, 1912RH Nov 27, 1860 Anything cherished that offends God or causes oneself to stumble must be given up, including habits, professions, pursuits, relationships, ambitions and desires that turn a person from God's path and risk eternal life.ST Apr 23, 1912ST Feb 19, 1902RH Nov 27, 1860 The hand and foot are figures for sinful habits, pursuits, practices and associations that hinder obedience to the gospel, and the difficulty of surrendering an unlawful indulgence makes immediate obedience all the more necessary.ST Apr 23, 1912RH Nov 27, 1860
Any trait or passion that leads to sin must be decisively overcome at great cost rather than preserved as a cherished fault, otherwise it can defile and ruin the whole person.ST Dec 24, 1894ST Mar 5, 1912ST Dec 17, 1912ST May 20, 1897 Covetousness, called idolatry, is the mastering passion left unconquered in Judas as the example of such ruin, and anything in character that harms others must likewise be cut away however painful the change.ST Dec 24, 1894ST Dec 17, 1912ST May 20, 1897 The sacrifice must be complete, even as precious as a right hand or eye or as near and dear as a friend when it leads to sin or keeps a person from the truth, and sacrifice made for Christ shows appreciation for His sacrifice and is accepted and used in His cause.RH Nov 27, 1860ST Aug 14, 1879 It is better to enter into life bearing the cost of that loss than to keep what leads to ruin and everlasting fire.RH Feb 17, 1903ST Mar 5, 1912ST Aug 14, 1879
God requires whole consecration with no reservations kept back, with the grasping hand standing for covetously seeking wealth and honor, the foot for half-hearted attachment to the present evil world, and the eye for feasting upon the glitter and glory of forbidden things.ST Jan 7, 1886 Each must be cut off and cast away through separation from the world and death to sin, presenting every power and part of the body as a living sacrifice in living service for His glory until attaining the fullness of the measure of the stature of Christ.ST Jan 7, 1886 Entering life maimed is better than preserving strength at the cost of life, for surrender and humility make room for Christ's strength.RH May 27, 1902 Like Jacob stripped of self-reliance, a person may carry lasting weakness while depending on God's power, and such weakness can accompany victory.RH May 27, 1902
Meaning of Everlasting Fire
Everlasting does not mean the endless preservation of those consumed, but the lasting consequence and eternally abiding effect of the fire, just as the judgment called eternal in Hebrews 6:2 is not an endless process.ST Mar 4, 1880 It means age-lasting for a longer or shorter unknown time rather than burning without end, and like the Levitical priesthood called everlasting yet ended at the cross, this fire will cease because it is called everlasting since its effect lasts forever.ST The words translated eternal and everlasting, aion and aionios, occur 179 times in the New Testament and only nine times in connection with punishment, of which this verse is one.RH Apr 17, 1866 The eternal fire is fire that eternally consumes, God's consuming fire that will burn up the ungodly to ashes in the day of judgment, as with Sodom and Gomorrah which are called eternal though the cities were destroyed and the fire went out after turning them to ashes.ST Mar 4, 1880STST Mar 5, 1896RH May 13, 1858 Life is the life the righteous enter, while the fire is an image of complete destruction and not endless conscious torment, so the warning describes the wicked being utterly consumed in the judgment.RH Sep 29, 1859
Time and Place of Punishment
The everlasting fire into which the wicked are cast is the fire of Gehenna, called hell fire in the following verse, and it stands in contrast to entering into life.RH Jun 15, 1869RH Jun 15, 1869ST Jul 15, 1880 It is the same everlasting fire prepared for the Devil and his angels, the same lake of fire in which Satan is punished and which the wicked share with him.RH Jun 15, 1869ST Jul 15, 1880 This fire is part of the final punishment inflicted by fire upon the wicked.ST Jul 15, 1880ST Jul 15, 1880
This punishment does not occur during the present life but after the Judge's sentence at the last day.RH Jun 15, 1869 It falls at the end of the thousand years, when the wicked after their resurrection gather with Satan against the holy city and are cast into it.ST Jul 15, 1880RH Jun 15, 1869 That everlasting destruction is the second death inflicted as the final punishment of the wicked.ST
Those cast into Gehenna are alive when cast into the fire, not merely dead bodies, and they undergo real suffering and anguish.RH Jun 22, 1869RH Jun 22, 1869 The punishment is more than loss of God's kingdom and is worse than drowning in the sea, so that even losing a hand, foot, or eye is preferable to entering it whole.RH Jun 22, 1869RH Jun 22, 1869 These losses picture the severing of the fondest ties, yet such loss is to be chosen rather than facing Gehenna's fire.RH Jun 22, 1869 The fire brings punishment by fire and brimstone, as at Sodom.ST Jul 15, 1880
Church Fellowship and Discipline
Matthew 18:8 belongs to the clearly marked gospel order and Bible principles for healing separation in the church and dealing with disorderly conduct.RH Feb 3, 1859RH Mar 5, 1901 That order gives steps to correct every evil at once, to bring back straying ones, to confess sin, and to have those who are spiritual restore them.RH Mar 5, 1901 Its object is to save and not to destroy those within the fold, before the enemy steals a march and the wicked one accomplishes their destruction.RH Mar 5, 1901 Failure to follow that rule brought reproach on the truth, while withdrawing fellowship from some whose conduct was disorderly helped restore brotherly love and unity.RH Feb 3, 1859
The command to cut off what causes stumbling applies individually to whatever leads a person to stumble, and also to the church as the body of Christ.ST Aug 6, 1896 A member who causes others to stumble and is spiritually diseased, disobeying Christ and poisoning others, should be removed after proper efforts to correct and heal.ST Aug 6, 1896 This is as a diseased limb may be removed to save the body.ST Aug 6, 1896 In the church this means separating from people who act as stumbling-blocks, even when they seem as necessary as an eye, just as individually it means severing cherished relationships, ambitions, and desires that lead to stumbling.ST Feb 19, 1902
Discipline is meant to reform and save the person if possible, and when correction fails separation from the disorderly person serves his good.ST Apr 16, 1885 Wrongdoing must be dealt with rather than left in place, so the verse supports stopping to undo a wrong.ST Feb 3, 1904
Practical Applications
Avoiding sin and its ruin matters more than keeping anything that leads to it, and applied to drinking this means refusing to let personal example draw vulnerable people into ruin, with Christians and especially ministers to give up drinking rather than contribute to another's fall.ST Jul 11, 1878ST Mar 16, 1904 It is better to suffer the loss of a hand or foot than to let it lead to sin and everlasting destruction, so grave is causing another's ruin by alcohol that severing one's own hand is preferable to placing that temptation before anyone by offering wine.ST Jul 11, 1878ST Mar 16, 1904 Cherished covetousness, called idolatry, is the example of a mastering passion left unconquered instead of decisively overcome at great cost, and as with Judas such a preserved fault can defile and ruin the whole person.ST Dec 24, 1894ST Dec 17, 1912 Hereditary tendencies to evil must be cut away through close and painful character work, for selfishness, covetousness, harshness, unkindness and hard-heartedness corrupt the whole person when retained.ST May 20, 1897ST May 20, 1897ST Mar 5, 1912 That inner surgery is required because those traits wound and destroy others and lead to neglect of those who need help, and anything in character that leads to sin or harms others must be removed however painful the change.ST May 20, 1897ST May 20, 1897ST Mar 5, 1912
Anything as precious as a hand, foot, right hand or eye must be given up if it turns a person from God's path, keeps them from the truth, or risks eternal life, whether it be habits, professions, pursuits, or even a near and dear friend.ST Apr 23, 1912ST Aug 14, 1879 Entering into life bearing the cost of that loss is better than keeping everything intact and facing eternal fire, and complete sacrifice made for Christ both shows appreciation for His sacrifice and is accepted and used in His cause.ST Apr 23, 1912ST Aug 14, 1879 Following Christ in this way may require painful sacrifice rather than yielding what conscience recognizes as truth, so that accepting unpopular Bible teaching despite opposition, grief and reproach belongs to staying on the narrow way toward life.RH Mar 26, 1872 The warning stands directly after the condemnation of causing one of Christ's little ones to stumble, and it is connected with the warning not to be a cause of stumbling to the young.RH Feb 17, 1903RH Jul 16, 1901 Anything dear, useful or enjoyable that turns a person out of or hinders them in the ways of God, such as evil speaking, must be decisively given up, since the loss is better than being led into sin and everlasting punishment.RH Jun 20, 1854 It is better to lose something valuable than to be lost through sin, for spiritual loss is worse than physical disfigurement, yet merely removing outward temptations or disfiguring the body, such as removing curls, does not assure salvation, since a person may even become proud of humility.ST Oct 31, 1900
Sources