Matthew 18:9
And if thine eye offend thee, pluck it out, and cast it from thee: it is better for thee to enter into life with one eye, rather than having two eyes to be cast into hell fire.
Translations
And if your eye offend you, pluck it out, and cast it from you: it is better for you to enter into life with one eye, rather than having two eyes to be cast into hell fire.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
And if thine eye offend thee, pluck it out, and cast it from thee: it is better for thee to enter into life with one eye, rather than having two eyes to be cast into hell fire.
And if thy eye causeth thee to sin, pluck it out, and cast it from thee: it is better for thee to enter into life with one eye, rather than having two eyes, to be cast into hell-fire.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
And if thine eye causeth thee to stumble, pluck it out, and cast it from thee: it is good for thee to enter into life with one eye, rather than having two eyes to be cast into the hell of fire.
'And if thine eye doth cause thee to stumble, pluck it out and cast from thee; it is good for thee one-eyed to enter into the life, rather than having two eyes to be cast to the gehenna of the fire.
And if thine eye offend thee, pluck it out and cast [ it] from thee; it is good for thee to enter into life one-eyed, [ rather] than having two eyes to be cast into the hell of fire.
And, if, thine eye, causeth thee to stumble, pluck it out, and cast it from thee: It is, seemly, for thee, one-eyed, into life, to enter, rather than, having two eyes, to be cast into the fiery gehenna.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
And if your eye causes you to sin, gouge it out and throw it away. It is better for you to enter life with one eye than to have two eyes and be thrown into the fire of hell.
If your eye causes you to stumble, pluck it out and cast it from you. It is better for you to enter into life with one eye, rather than having two eyes to be cast into the Gehenna of fire.
And if your eye is a cause of trouble to you, take it out, and put it away from you: it is better for you to go into life with one eye than, having two eyes, to go into the hell of fire.
And if thine eye cause thee to offende, plucke it out, and cast it from thee: it is better for thee to enter into life with one eye, then hauing two eyes to be cast into hell fire.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And if thy eye scandalize thee, pluck it out, and cast it from thee. It is better for thee having one eye to enter into life, than having two eyes to be cast into hell fire.
Cross-references 20 of 25
- Mark 9:47-48
And if thine eye offend thee, pluck it out: it is better for thee to enter into the kingdom of God with one eye, than having two eyes to be cast into hell fire:
Both warn that removing what causes sin is better than entering Gehenna’s unquenched fire.
- Matthew 5:29
And if thy right eye offend thee, pluck it out, and cast it from thee: for it is profitable for thee that one of thy members should perish, and not that thy whole body should be cast into hell.
Gives the parallel warning about removing an eye that causes sin and being cast into Gehenna.
- Luke 12:5
But I will forewarn you whom ye shall fear: Fear him, which after he hath killed hath power to cast into hell; yea, I say unto you, Fear him.
Both warn of Gehenna as the place into which God has power to cast.
- Matthew 10:28
And fear not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul: but rather fear him which is able to destroy both soul and body in hell.
Both warn of the wicked’s destruction of soul and body in Gehenna.
- Matthew 5:22
But I say unto you, That whosoever is angry with his brother without a cause shall be in danger of the judgment: and whosoever shall say to his brother, Raca, shall be in danger of the council: but whosoever shall say, Thou fool, shall be in danger of hell fire.
Both warn of hell fire, using Gehenna for punishment.
- Matthew 23:33
Ye serpents, ye generation of vipers, how can ye escape the damnation of hell?
Both verses name Gehenna as the fate of the wicked.
- Matthew 25:41
Then shall he say also unto them on the left hand, Depart from me, ye cursed, into everlasting fire, prepared for the devil and his angels:
Gehenna is identified with the everlasting fire prepared for the devil and his angels.
- Mark 9:47
And if thine eye offend thee, pluck it out: it is better for thee to enter into the kingdom of God with one eye, than having two eyes to be cast into hell fire:
Both warn against sin and teach that Gehenna is the final punishment.
- Isaiah 66:24
And they shall go forth, and look upon the carcases of the men that have transgressed against me: for their worm shall not die, neither shall their fire be quenched; and they shall be an abhorring unto all flesh.
Its unquenched fire describes the punishment of Gehenna.
- Mark 9:45
And if thy foot offend thee, cut it off: it is better for thee to enter halt into life, than having two feet to be cast into hell, into the fire that never shall be quenched:
Both use Gehenna for the final place of punishment.
- 2 Kings 23:10
And he defiled Topheth, which is in the valley of the children of Hinnom, that no man might make his son or his daughter to pass through the fire to Molech.
Names the Valley of Hinnom, associated with Gehenna’s perpetually burning fires.
- Isaiah 33:14
The sinners in Zion are afraid; fearfulness hath surprised the hypocrites. Who among us shall dwell with the devouring fire? who among us shall dwell with everlasting burnings?
Its everlasting burnings are identified with Gehenna fire.
- Matthew 18:3-4
And said, Verily I say unto you, Except ye be converted, and become as little children, ye shall not enter into the kingdom of heaven.
The call to become humble like a child frames the warning about sin and stumbling.
- Luke 17:1-2
Then said he unto the disciples, It is impossible but that offences will come: but woe unto him, through whom they come!
Jesus warns of the consequences of causing others to stumble.
- Matthew 5:30
And if thy right hand offend thee, cut it off, and cast it from thee: for it is profitable for thee that one of thy members should perish, and not that thy whole body should be cast into hell.
same Greek word Gehenna for hell
- Mark 9:42
And whosoever shall offend one of these little ones that believe in me, it is better for him that a millstone were hanged about his neck, and he were cast into the sea.
Both warn against causing offense, with severe consequences.
- Isaiah 30:33
For Tophet is ordained of old; yea, for the king it is prepared; he hath made it deep and large: the pile thereof is fire and much wood; the breath of the LORD, like a stream of brimstone, doth kindle it.
Tophet’s prepared fire connects with Gehenna’s judgment.
- Matthew 13:49-50
So shall it be at the end of the world: the angels shall come forth, and sever the wicked from among the just,
The wicked are separated from the just and cast into a fiery furnace.
- Matthew 11:6
And blessed is he, who soever shall not be offended in me.
Uses “offended” in the sense of stumbling.
- Matthew 13:42
And shall cast them into a furnace of fire: there shall be wailing and gnashing of teeth.
Both texts describe the wicked being cast into fiery punishment.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
44 sources
To pluck out the offending eye is not a call to harm the body, but a figure for cutting away something as dear and close as an eye when it causes sin.Ms 115, 1902, par. 19–20Ms 47, 1908, par. 10–11DA 432 Whatever leads into sin, whether inherited or cultivated tendency, cherished habit, idea, or selfish scheme, must be decisively surrendered however painful the loss, for it is better to enter life with loss than to keep it and be cast into hell fire.Lt 140, 1910, par. 3–7Ms 70, 1895, par. 13–16Ms 115, 1902, par. 19–20Ms 47, 1908, par. 10–11 It belongs to Christ's warning that offenses will come but woe to the one through whom they come, joined to the duty not to despise or harm those who believe in Him.STMW9 7.1Ms 11, 1888, par. 48–51 The little ones who must not be caused to stumble are not children in years but weak and trembling believers in Christ, the special charge of angels who always behold the Father, so that injustice to them is the same as to Jesus Himself.Ms 11, 1888, par. 48–51Ms 191, 1903, par. 2–3 The offending eye is thus an evil, self-exalting disposition of selfishness, harshness, unkindness and criticism that wounds others and corrupts the whole person, and causing such little ones to stumble by harshness, contempt or neglect brings grave judgment.Ms 11, 1888, par. 48–51Ms 116, 1904, par. 8–1115MR 189.2–191.3ST May 20, 1897DA 438.2–439.1
Setting in Matthew Eighteen
Matthew 18:9 belongs to Christ's warning that offenses will come, but woe rests upon the person through whom the offense comes, and in that setting the warning is joined to the duty not to despise or harm those who believe in Christ.STMW9 7.1Ms 11, 1888, par. 48–51 It was spoken amid the disciples' dispute over rank and authority, and it forbids striving for supremacy, because greatness in Christ's spiritual kingdom consists in inward excellence and spiritual excellence manifested in true conversion rather than position, outward splendor, or authority.ST Sep 19, 1900Ms 107, 1903, par. 11–18Lt 64, 1900, par. 1–3 The instruction shows the principles His followers are to act on in every circumstance and in all cases and under all circumstances, and doing the wrongs pointed out in the chapter dishonors God and mars His cause.ST Sep 19, 1900Lt 64, 1900, par. 1–3
The little ones who must not be despised or caused to stumble are not children in years but little children in Christ, weak and trembling souls with many defects of character.Ms 11, 1888, par. 48–51 They are the special charge of angels who always behold the Father in heaven, so that injustice done to them is the same as done to Jesus Himself.Ms 11, 1888, par. 48–51Ms 191, 1903, par. 2–3 The surrounding teaching stresses humility and the grave seriousness of causing a believer to stumble.Lt 48a, 1900, par. 5–6
Matthew 18 is among the most positive instructions in all Scripture, given to all who claim to be disciples of the meek and lowly Jesus, showing the principles to act on in all cases and under all circumstances.Lt 64, 1900, par. 1–3 It belongs to instruction that gives relief and courage and hope.Lt 159, 1905, par. 4–5 The chapter directs thorough organization and correction in the church, for faults that threaten to corrupt the church must be corrected with the aim of saving the person from ruin.Ms 112, 1904, par. 12–14Lt 32, 1892, par. 29–30 In this direction physicians who practice among the churches are to come fully under the supervision of the church as fully as the minister, and if they do not maintain strict integrity it is the duty of the church to labor with them according to the instruction of the law of God.Lt 32, 1892, par. 29–30
Matthew 18 condemns dissension, self-esteem, self-exaltation, and strife to be highly esteemed by men, with criticism and faultfinding shown to be expressly the work of the devil.Lt 107a, 1900, par. 2–3 That work is the same Satan began in the heavenly courts when he suggested a change in the government of God, gained sympathy and assent by deception, sowed suspicion and distrust of God and of one another, started strife, and caused rebellion that had to be met by God with the expulsion of Satan and the disloyal from heaven for the good of the loyal and true.Lt 107a, 1900, par. 2–3 The lesson must be studied and brought into practical life, for without practicing it no one will ever enter the kingdom of heaven.Ms 143, 1899, par. 6–7
The instruction is to be followed especially by those in positions of responsibility, who are to reject selfishness and set an example others can safely follow.Ms 165, 1902, par. 36–37 It forbids despising one of the little ones and forbids a masterly spirit that lords it over God's heritage, which closes the gates of heaven to men, and it requires meeting humanity to seek the one gone astray and to uplift the degraded and fallen and outcast.Ms 143, 1899, par. 6–7 Every individual must read the message from the lips of Christ to answer what he is doing while Christ and His angels are at work to bring men to repentance, requiring church members who have had light upon the truth to be converted and to cooperate with Christ in real ministerial service to win souls, enlighten the ignorant and relieve the oppressed, and not to remain disobedient to the truth and become workers for Satan to annoy and perplex those who are weak in the faith.Ms 29, 1900, par. 29–30
Meaning of Eye Imagery
The command to pluck out the eye is a figure for decisively cutting away anything in a person that leads into sin, even when it feels as much a part of them and as dear and precious as an eye, and entering life with that loss is better than keeping it and being cast into hell fire and everlasting destruction.Ms 115, 1902, par. 19–20Ms 47, 1908, par. 10–11DA 432RH Feb 17, 1903ST May 20, 1897 The eye is used to show how serious the removal of a cause of sin must be, and it stands for an offending trait of character and for inherited or cultivated tendencies to wrong that must be cut away however painful the change, lest they remain and the whole person perish and be lost from life unto judgment.Ms 115, 1902, par. 19–20RH Feb 17, 1903ST May 20, 1897 It is not a call to physical self-harm.ST May 20, 1897 Entering into life maimed rather than perishing whole represents surrendering the will and separating from sin, with hidden sin overcome through self-surrender to God, since clinging to sin and refusing God's will is choosing death because God's presence consumes sin and those who refuse to separate from it are consumed with it.Ms 4, 1888, par. 21
The eye can represent a critical, oppositional way of seeing that looks for things to criticize, which must be cast away at great personal cost rather than allowed to harm oneself or others, because entering into life is better than being cast into hell fire.Lt 93, 1901, par. 1–3 The offending eye represents an evil disposition, including self-exalting sharpness and harsh, unfeeling treatment that hurts or discourages others, which must be given up to enter into life rather than clung to unto everlasting destruction.Ms 116, 1904, par. 8–11 It also illustrates a cherished habit or practice that dishonors God and misleads others, which must be put away however great the sacrifice because sin brings death to the soul and keeping it means losing life.DA 438.2–439.1 The same warning reaches a disciple's harshness or coldness toward someone Christ is drawing, which can turn that person from Christ and cost a soul.DA 438.2–439.1
The offending eye represents traits such as selfishness, covetousness, harshness, and unkindness that must be removed from the character decisively however painful the loss, for it is better to enter into life with less than to keep what leads to everlasting destruction in hell fire.ST May 20, 1897ST Mar 5, 1912ST May 20, 1897ST Mar 5, 1912 These traits wound others and can lead a person to neglect those who need help, and if left in the life they corrupt the whole person and make a person offensive to God and lead away from life toward judgment.ST May 20, 1897ST May 20, 1897ST Mar 5, 1912 The eye and arm represent something precious that must be given up rather than retained at the cost of entering life, applied to a hard, unsympathetic, distrustful spirit that must be disconnected from a person and to cherished schemes and misuse of authority that must be renounced rather than allowed to injure others or cause a fellow believer to stumble.Ms 70, 1895, par. 13–16Ms 70, 1895, par. 17–18
The command is applied to abandoning wrong things however dear they may seem and to relinquishing cherished ideas, sentiments, and unsanctified personal ideas that a person insists everyone else must share, which should be given up rather than pressed on others to cause offense and lead oneself or others into sin and loss of eternal life.Ms 102, 1904, par. 15–176MR 208.3–209.1 It is better to suffer the loss of a bodily member than to lead another person into sin, showing the seriousness of protecting others, such as students who might lead one another away from God, from being led in a wrong direction.2MR 286.3–287.2
Requirement to Remove Sin
Anything that leads a person into sin must be decisively removed, even at great personal cost and however painful the loss may feel.Lt 140, 1910, par. 3–7Ms 70, 1895, par. 13–16Ms 115, 1902, par. 19–20Ms 107, 1903, par. 11–18Ms 47, 1908, par. 10–11 It is better to enter into life with that loss than to keep what leads to sin and be cast into hell fire and everlasting destruction.Lt 140, 1910, par. 3–7Ms 70, 1895, par. 13–16Ms 107, 1903, par. 11–18Ms 47, 1908, par. 10–11Lt 93, 1901, par. 1–3 What must be given up may feel as much a part of the person as an eye and as dear and precious as an eye, including cherished schemes, misuse of authority, a hard and unsympathetic spirit, and a critical, oppositional way of seeing that looks for things to criticize.Ms 70, 1895, par. 13–16Ms 115, 1902, par. 19–20Ms 47, 1908, par. 10–11Lt 93, 1901, par. 1–3 Anything that stands in the way of surrender must be let go for the same reason.Ms 115, 1902, par. 19–20Ms 107, 1903, par. 11–18Ms 47, 1908, par. 10–11
The command to pluck out the eye is a figure for cutting away inherited or cultivated tendencies to wrong, and if those faults remain the whole person will perish, while giving them up is better than losing life.Ms 115, 1902, par. 19–20 It is to a person's own interest to cast away whatever blocks surrender to Christ rather than lose eternal life.Ms 47, 1908, par. 10–11 Sin must be treated as a grave danger bringing death to the soul and must not be left to remain unchecked.Ms 112, 1904, par. 12–14DA 438.2–439.1 Clinging to sin and refusing God's will is choosing death, because God's presence consumes sin and those who refuse to separate from it are consumed with it.DA 438.2–439.1 Faults that threaten to corrupt must therefore be corrected with the aim of saving the person from ruin, and a cherished habit or practice that dishonors God and misleads others must be put away however great the sacrifice.Ms 112, 1904, par. 12–14DA 438.2–439.1
Each person must take responsibility for cleansing his own thoughts and character rather than concentrating on faults in others, and this self-purification helps prevent reckless words and conduct that can lead others astray.Ms 40, 1896, par. 12–13 All professed Christians must have the unsanctified element cleansed from the soul temple.Ms 26, 1889, par. 15–17 That includes self-sufficiency and self interposed between the soul and God, perversity of spirit and disposition, and inward concealed strife for supremacy with manifest striving to be first.Ms 26, 1889, par. 15–17 Such self and strife grieve the Saviour's Spirit and hinder the work, turning men who ought to be a blessing into a curse to retard instead of advance it, until they are cut away so the Lord can manifest His power and grace.Ms 26, 1889, par. 15–17
Offenses Against Fellow Believers
Causing another believer to stumble carries grave responsibility and brings judgment, so those who teach must live out Christ's instruction and be converted, for it is better to enter life with loss than to keep what leads to sin and be cast into hell fire.Lt 140, 1910, par. 3–7Ms 89, 1898, par. 1–3 The warning of verses 7-14 centers especially on believing little ones who must not be caused to stumble.Lt 140, 1910, par. 3–7Ms 89, 1898, par. 1–3 Offenses will come, but woe falls on the one through whom the offense comes, so whatever causes offense must be cut off and cast away.Ms 11, 1888, par. 48–51
The warning reaches those who selfishly neglect weak brethren or hold them in contempt, and those who are unforgiving and exacting, judging and condemning others until they are discouraged.Ms 11, 1888, par. 48–5115MR 189.2–191.3 Such harsh, unforgiving, judgmental and contemptuous conduct brings others into discouragement and places the offender himself under judgment.Ms 11, 1888, par. 48–5115MR 189.2–191.3 The little ones who must not be despised are not children in years but little children in Christ, weak and trembling souls with many defects of character who are the special charge of angels, so that injustice done to them is the same as done to Jesus Himself.Ms 11, 1888, par. 48–51
A disciple's harshness or coldness toward someone Christ is drawing can turn that person away from Christ and cost a soul, for cherished habits that dishonor God and mislead others bring death to the soul unless put away however great the sacrifice.DA 438.2–439.1 Avoiding harm to a little one's faith outweighs holding on to anything regarded as necessary for success, and teachers should give up even important things rather than offend or damage the young.DA 438.2–439.1Ms 8a, 1891, par. 30–31
Every person, and especially teachers, must cut away the harsh, angry, arbitrary spirit that shakes, bruises and forces children, though it feels as dear and natural as a right arm, hand, foot or eye and its removal feels like severing a limb.Ms 8a, 1891, par. 13–16 That spirit is satanic iron in the soul and must die and be put out of the heart and out of the church at whatever cost, replaced with love, tenderness and forbearance.Ms 8a, 1891, par. 13–16 Unless a person is converted to become as a little child and comes to God's ideas, plans and ways, bruising a child bruises his own soul more, destroys the child's manhood, offends believing little ones and leaves him under God's condemnation.Ms 8a, 1891, par. 13–16 Instead he is to receive children in Christ's name, place himself on the child's level, understand its trials, correct gently alone with prayer and talk, and seek and save that which is lost.Ms 8a, 1891, par. 13–16
As part of the instruction in Matthew 18 setting forth God's will about how to treat His children, harshness, lack of courtesy, and severe, dictatorial dealing with brethren in the sacred work must be put away.Lt 58, 1901, par. 18–19 This condemns exasperating brethren until they lose confidence, wounding and bruising souls, and acting with self-superiority and a hard, cruel spirit.Lt 58, 1901, par. 18–19 It requires transformation in spirit, loving one's neighbor as oneself, and showing mercy, kindness and courtesy in order to represent Jesus Christ and be fit to handle sacred things.Lt 58, 1901, par. 18–19
The instruction speaks directly to lack of love among believers, for God does not desire any man to draw apart from his brethren.Lt 31, 1903, par. 4–5 It condemns the strong desire to hinder and repress one who is doing a good work, accusing one another, wanting a worker in higher office removed from his position, thinking and speaking evil, and devising plans to separate brethren.Lt 31, 1903, par. 4–5
Changed Life and Service
The verse belongs to the instruction of the whole eighteenth chapter of Matthew that gives relief and courage and hope, and it directs the sinner to go forward in faith and take the case to the Lord Jesus in prayer.Lt 159, 1905, par. 4–5 The sinner is to believe that He hears, to confess sins and repent and walk humbly with God to find pardon.Lt 159, 1905, par. 4–5 The Lord's correction is to be received as purifying and saving.Lt 159, 1905, par. 4–5
Anything leading a person into sin must be decisively put away, for entering into life is better than keeping what leads to ruin.RH May 18, 1876 Following Jesus closely requires thorough conversion, humility before God, turning the mind away from self, singleness of purpose, and purity of motive.RH May 18, 1876 That following is shown in sympathy and love to others, especially through personal effort for those outside Christ.RH May 18, 1876
Christ's work is to save that which is lost, and His followers must do the same work with compassion, earnest labor, and persevering effort.Ms 11, 1888, par. 48–51 They are to use their God-given talents to save sinners rather than serving only saints, to meet humanity to seek the one gone astray and to uplift the degraded and fallen and outcast.Ms 11, 1888, par. 48–51Ms 143, 1899, par. 6–7 Offenses will come, but woe comes to the one by whom the offense comes, so whatever causes offense must be cut off and cast away, for it is better to enter into life maimed than to be cast into hell fire.Ms 11, 1888, par. 48–51 That warning falls on those who selfishly neglect or hold in contempt their weak brethren, and on those who are unforgiving and exacting, judging and condemning others and so discouraging them.Ms 11, 1888, par. 48–51 The little ones who must not be despised are not children in years but little children in Christ, weak and trembling souls with many defects of character who are the special charge of angels, and injustice done to them is the same as done to Jesus Himself.Ms 11, 1888, par. 48–51 The lesson forbids despising one of the little ones and forbids a masterly spirit that lords it over God's heritage, which closes the gates of heaven to men, and it must be studied and brought into practical life, for without practicing it no one will ever enter the kingdom of heaven.Ms 143, 1899, par. 6–7
The verse calls for self-reform first, for unity as branches under the one head Christ Jesus, and for sanctified ears and eyes and tongues that act as brethren.Lt 37a, 1900, par. 18–20 Those words are high and holy principles for daily practical life and must be put into daily practice.Lt 37a, 1900, par. 18–20 Applied, this requires perfect love and compassion, deeds of compassion, tenderness and love, deep interest in youth with earnest prayer, and educating and training youth as the property of Jesus Christ.Lt 37a, 1900, par. 18–20
The verse means taking oneself in hand and reprimanding oneself by the discipline of the Word, as a learner in the school of Christ.Lt 48a, 1900, par. 3–4 It means daily humbling oneself before God and overcoming entertained temptations and a selfish, unholy spirit.Lt 48a, 1900, par. 3–4 Self is to be kept under the great Teacher's control and the Bible's teachings are to be practiced, for this is Christ's instruction for how His work is to be done.Lt 48a, 1900, par. 3–4Ms 34, 1900, par. 1–2 In this way a person becomes right and competent to handle sacred things and to enter upon work in ministering the Word.Lt 48a, 1900, par. 3–4
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
47 sources
To offend here means to cause to stumble, and the eye is an illustration of anything that causes stumbling, not a command to injure the literal body, since sin has its seat in the soul and harming the body cannot cure the heart.ST May 20, 1897ST Apr 23, 1912ST Aug 6, 1896ST Apr 1, 1897RH Nov 27, 1860
Whatever leads into sin, however dear, precious, useful, or seemingly necessary as an eye, must be dealt with decisively and put away completely, because it is better to enter into life with loss than to keep it and lose eternal life.ST Apr 16, 1885ST Apr 23, 1912ST Jul 12, 1899ST Jul 12, 1899ST Aug 6, 1896
The hell fire is Gehenna, not the grave or Hades, but the everlasting fire prepared for the devil and his angels, also called the lake of fire, where the wicked are cast alive after resurrection to final retribution and destroyed body and soul.ST Jul 15, 1880RH Jun 15, 1869RH Jun 15, 1869RH May 23, 1865RH Jul 2, 1872
Its fire is unquenchable in that it burns until its work is complete and consumes what is cast in, a symbol of inescapable punishment and complete destruction, coming after the judgment at the end of the thousand years, not during earthly life.RH Jun 15, 1869ST Mar 5, 1896RH Jan 17, 1856ST Nov 16, 1876ST Sep 30, 1930
In the church as Christ's body this means saving the straying by every effort to correct and heal, then withdrawing fellowship from one who remains a stumbling-block, and in daily life it means cutting away the offending part of character such as selfishness, covetousness, and harshness.ST May 20, 1897ST May 20, 1897ST Aug 6, 1896RH Mar 5, 1901ST Apr 16, 1885
Words and Context
In Matthew 18:9 the word rendered offend means to cause to stumble, not to make angry.ST Apr 1, 1897 The eye is an illustration of something that causes a person to stumble, not a command to injure the literal body.ST May 20, 1897ST Apr 23, 1912ST Aug 6, 1896RH Nov 27, 1860 Anything dear that turns a person from God's path must be given up rather than kept at the cost of eternal life, and anything as dear or useful as an eye must be given up if it causes stumbling, since its value or apparent necessity does not excuse its harmful effect.ST Apr 23, 1912ST Aug 6, 1896 The eye is a figure for an offending trait of character that leads to sin or harms others, and for a cherished source of temptation or hindrance to obedience that must be renounced promptly and decisively however painful the change.ST May 20, 1897RH Nov 27, 1860
Sin has its seat in the soul, so harming the body cannot cure the heart.RH Nov 27, 1860 The words hell fire translate the Greek Gehenna for the fate of being cast into punishment.RH Oct 24, 1854RH Jun 12, 1860RH Mar 7, 1865RH Jul 2, 1872 The warning speaks of being cast into Gehenna, alongside the parallel warning in verse 30, and says it is better to enter life with one eye than to be cast there with two.RH Oct 24, 1854RH Jun 12, 1860
Gehenna originally names the Valley of Hinnom south of Jerusalem, associated with idolatrous worship and later used for refuse, dead bodies, and the bodies of malefactors, where fires were kept burning and consumed what was cast in.RH Jun 12, 1860RH Jul 2, 1872ST Dec 17, 1902ST Nov 16, 1876 Named for the Valley of Hinnom outside Jerusalem, it became a type of the complete destruction of wickedness, a figure of the place where the wicked will finally be burned up, body and soul, after the resurrection.RH Jul 2, 1872ST Dec 17, 1902ST Nov 16, 1876 The verse belongs to Christ's instruction in Matthew 18 on how his followers are to act in every circumstance, including not striving for supremacy, since greatness in his spiritual kingdom is inward excellence rather than position, outward splendor, or authority, and how members should treat offenders with brotherly kindness.ST Sep 19, 1900ST May 18, 1882 In Matthew 18 forgiveness or pardon is used in a limited sense, which does not contradict the teaching that blood makes atonement for the soul.ST Oct 18, 1883
Renounce Every Stumbling Cause
Whatever turns a person aside into wrongdoing must be dealt with decisively and put away promptly, for entering into life is better than facing final destruction.RH May 18, 1876RH Feb 17, 1903ST Apr 16, 1885ST Jul 12, 1899ST Jul 12, 1899 Sin itself and whatever leads into it must be given up even at great personal cost rather than persisted in to ruin, and the eye shows how serious that removal must be.RH Feb 17, 1903ST Apr 16, 1885ST Feb 3, 1904 The parts of the person that lead to wrongdoing must be treated as things to surrender rather than allowed to lead on to sin and loss of life.ST Jul 12, 1899
Anything dear, precious, useful, or seemingly necessary, like an eye, must be given up if it turns one from God's path or causes stumbling, and its value or apparent necessity does not excuse its harmful effect.ST Apr 23, 1912ST Feb 19, 1902ST Aug 6, 1896ST Mar 5, 1896 What is cherished must be surrendered however precious or necessary it seems if it offends God or causes self or others to stumble.ST Feb 19, 1902 For the individual this means severing relationships, ambitions, and desires that lead to stumbling, and for the church it means separating those who become stumbling-blocks even when they seem as necessary as an eye.ST Feb 19, 1902 The eye and hand stand for costly ties or interests that may have to be given up for the truth, and willingness to make that sacrifice shows appreciation for Christ's sacrifice.ST Aug 14, 1879
It is better to enter into life with loss, with one eye, than to keep both eyes and be cast into hell fire and lose eternal life.RH Feb 17, 1903ST Jul 12, 1899ST Mar 5, 1896ST Aug 14, 1879 A cherished sin or idol must be surrendered even when doing so feels as painful as losing a right eye, since surrender is better than keeping it and being cast into hell fire. It is better to enter life with bodily loss than to be lost, so that even removing an outward feature to avoid temptation would be preferable to losing through neglect, just as entering God's kingdom maimed or blind is preferable to being lost, though removing outward temptation alone does not guarantee salvation since one may become proud even of humility.ST Oct 31, 1900
The eye, with the hand and foot in the surrounding teaching, represents a cherished source of temptation or hindrance that ensnares in sin or hinders obedience to the gospel.ST Feb 19, 1902RH Nov 27, 1860ST Aug 14, 1879RH Jun 20, 1854 Such hindrances include costly ties, interests, relationships, ambitions, and desires, and anything dear or useful that turns one away from God or hinders the way to Him must be cast aside however painful the loss.ST Feb 19, 1902ST Aug 14, 1879RH Jun 20, 1854 This rule is a sure way to prevent or cure evil speaking.RH Jun 20, 1854 Surrendering what is as precious as a right eye may be difficult and painful, and that very difficulty makes immediate obedience more necessary.RH Nov 27, 1860 Even the severance of the fondest ties should be accepted rather than entering the fire of Gehenna, whose punishment is terrible anguish and not merely loss of God's kingdom or a painless removal.RH Jun 22, 1869 Rejection of sin must be complete and without compromise, abandoning every sinful desire, motive, and purpose, and the image of plucking out an eye expresses how absolute that denial must be.ST Apr 10, 1901
Church Discipline and Brotherly Love
Matthew 18 lays out clearly marked steps for the administration of discipline within the fold.ST Apr 16, 1885RH Mar 5, 1901 Its instruction calls for humility before God, for turning the mind away from self, and for sympathy and love toward others.RH May 18, 1876 Whatever leads into sin must be given up even at great personal cost, because entering into life is better than facing final destruction.RH May 18, 1876ST Apr 16, 1885
The object of such discipline is to save and not to destroy, to bring back the straying.RH Mar 5, 1901ST Apr 16, 1885 Those who are spiritual are to restore such a one by immediate effort to correct every evil, before the enemy steals a march on the unwary.RH Mar 5, 1901 First every effort is to be made to correct the wrongdoer and heal him and reform him and save him.RH Mar 5, 1901ST Apr 16, 1885
If that correction fails, fellowship is to be withdrawn for the good of the wrongdoer and for the good of the cause.ST Apr 16, 1885 Individually this means severing cherished relationships, ambitions, and desires that cause stumbling for oneself or others, however precious or necessary they may seem.ST Feb 19, 1902 In the church it means separating those who become stumbling-blocks, even if they seem as necessary as an eye.ST Feb 19, 1902ST Apr 16, 1885 For the saying applies also to the church as Christ's body: a member who causes others to stumble and is spiritually diseased should, after proper effort to correct and heal, be removed, as a diseased bodily member may be cut off to save the body.ST Aug 6, 1896
Following Jesus closely in this setting requires thorough conversion, singleness of purpose, and purity of motive.RH May 18, 1876 It requires personal effort for those outside Christ.RH May 18, 1876 It requires stopping even in the middle of prayer to put a wrong right, since sin and whatever leads into sin must be dealt with decisively rather than persisted in to destruction.RH May 18, 1876ST Feb 3, 1904
Final Punishment in Gehenna Fire
The fire of Gehenna in this verse is the everlasting fire of verse 8, the fire prepared for the devil and his angels, also identified as the lake of fire where evildoers are punished with fire and brimstone.ST Jul 15, 1880RH Jun 15, 1869RH Jun 15, 1869RH Jun 15, 1869 It is one of the passages showing that the final punishment of the wicked will be by fire.ST Jul 15, 1880 Here Gehenna does not mean the grave or Hades, the place of the dead, but the place of final retribution for the wicked.ST May 22, 1879RH May 23, 1865ST Nov 16, 1876
The wicked are cast into Gehenna alive after being raised from the dead, with their bodily members restored and whole, and the contrast between entering life with one eye and being cast in with two eyes shows that bodily restoration.ST Jul 15, 1880RH May 23, 1865 The punishment there destroys the wicked, body and soul, rather than describing the suffering of a disembodied soul.RH May 23, 1865RH Jul 2, 1872ST Nov 16, 1876ST Nov 16, 1876 Gehenna, named for the Valley of Hinnom outside Jerusalem where fires consumed the bodies of malefactors and rubbish, became a type of the complete destruction of wickedness.RH Jul 2, 1872ST Dec 17, 1902
This punishment does not occur during earthly life, and no burning Gehenna exists now.RH Jun 15, 1869ST Nov 16, 1876 It comes after the Judge's sentence at the last day, after the judgment, at the end of the thousand years and close of the millennium, when Satan, sin, and all identified with sin are destroyed.RH Jun 15, 1869RH Jan 17, 1856ST Dec 17, 1902 Entering Gehenna is so terrible that even drowning in the sea is more tolerable, and the warning about losing an eye teaches its severity as terrible anguish, not merely loss of God's kingdom or painless removal.RH Jun 22, 1869RH Jun 22, 1869
Its fire is unquenchable in that it burns until its work is complete and consumes eternally what is cast into it.ST Mar 5, 1896ST Nov 16, 1876ST Sep 30, 1930 It is a symbol of inescapable punishment and complete destruction, not never-ending punishment.ST Sep 30, 1930 The verse therefore says nothing about the condition of the dead between death and resurrection.RH Jul 2, 1872ST Nov 16, 1876
Character Cleansing and Daily Life
The offending eye is a figure for an offending part of character that must be cut away rather than allowed to corrupt the whole person. Anything in character or life that leads to sin or harms others must be removed decisively, however painful the change and loss may be. The command is not a call to physical self-harm but to inward cleansing, since it is better to enter into life with less than to keep what leads away from life toward judgment and everlasting destruction in hell fire.ST May 20, 1897ST Mar 5, 1912ST May 20, 1897ST Mar 5, 1912
The traits to be cut away include selfishness, covetousness, harshness, and an unkind spirit. Such traits wound others and can lead to neglecting those who need help. Left in the life, they make a person offensive to God.ST May 20, 1897ST Mar 5, 1912
Consecration requires giving up every reservation with no part kept back. The right eye means the power to look and desire when kept back to feast upon the glitter and glory of forbidden things, the right hand means grasping covetously for wealth and honor, and the right foot means standing in half-hearted attachment to the present evil world. Baptized believers must not hold back eye or hand or foot but be utterly given up to God through separation from the world, presenting every power and part of the body as a living sacrifice in living service for the furtherance of His glory, and though deadness to the world is high and lofty it must remain the aim and desire, to be striven for by forgetting what is behind and reaching forth to what is before until attaining the fullness of the measure of the stature of Christ.ST Jan 7, 1886
Greed for riches, love of luxury and display, and sensuous pleasures such as feasting and drinking must be cut off through an abstemious life and plain dress that rebukes excess. Those excesses cause physical disease and degeneracy, benumb spiritual perception, and lessen sensibility to sin. Believers who are to prepare a people for Christ's second coming must set a good example to the young around them and not be to them a cause of stumbling, having to give account for the way they use this light.RH Jul 16, 1901
The same rule is a sure way to prevent or cure evil speaking by casting aside, however painful the loss, anything dear or useful that turns a person away from God or hinders the way to Him. It is better to give up something than to let it lead oneself or others toward ruin, and in this connection it supports refusing wine when one's example may cause another person to stumble.ST Jul 11, 1878RH Jun 20, 1854
The principle applies even to outward appearance such as children's curls and features kept for display. It would be better to enter God's kingdom maimed or blind with such a loss than to be lost through neglect. Yet removing outward temptation alone does not guarantee salvation, since a child may become proud even of humility.ST Oct 31, 1900
Sources