Matthew 19:7
They say unto him, Why did Moses then command to give a writing of divorcement, and to put her away?
Translations
They say to him, Why did Moses then command to give a writing of divorce, and to put her away?
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
They say unto him, Why did Moses then command to give a writing of divorcement, and to put her away?
They say to him, Why did Moses then command to give a writing of divorcement, and to put her away?
Revised Version, American Standard Version
They say unto him, Why then did Moses command to give a bill of divorcement, and to put her away?
They say to him, 'Why then did Moses command to give a roll of divorce, and to put her away?'
They say to him, Why then did Moses command to give a letter of divorce and to send [ her] away?
They say unto him—Why then did, Moses, command, to give a writing of repudiation and to divorce?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
“ Why then,” they asked, “ did Moses order a man to give his wife a certificate of divorce and send her away?”
They asked him, “ Why then did Moses command us to give her a certificate of divorce and divorce her?”
They say to him, Why then did Moses give orders that a husband might give her a statement in writing and be free from her?
They said to him, Why did then Moses commaund to giue a bill of diuorcement, and to put her away?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
They say to him: Why then did Moses command to give a bill of divorce, and to put away?
Cross-references
- Genesis 2:24
Therefore shall a man leave his father and his mother, and shall cleave unto his wife: and they shall be one flesh.
Jesus grounds marriage and its one-flesh union in God’s original creation.
- Deuteronomy 24:1-4
When a man hath taken a wife, and married her, and it come to pass that she find no favour in his eyes, because he hath found some uncleanness in her: then let him write her a bill of divorcement, and give it in her hand, and send her out of his house.
The question refers to Moses’ instruction about a certificate of divorce.
- Matthew 5:31-32
It hath been said, Whosoever shall put away his wife, let him give her a writing of divorcement:
Jesus teaches the same limit on divorce.
- Malachi 2:14-16
Yet ye say, Wherefore? Because the LORD hath been witness between thee and the wife of thy youth, against whom thou hast dealt treacherously: yet is she thy companion, and the wife of thy covenant.
Marriage is a sacred covenant, and divorce is condemned as treachery against it.
- Mark 10:6-8
But from the beginning of the creation God made them male and female.
parallel account of same teaching
- Mark 10:10-12
And in the house his disciples asked him again of the same matter.
A parallel account gives Jesus’ general teaching on divorce and remarriage as adultery.
- Genesis 1:27
So God created man in his own image, in the image of God created he him; male and female created he them.
Jesus grounds marriage in God’s creation of humanity as male and female.
- Luke 16:18
Whosoever putteth away his wife, and marrieth another, committeth adultery: and whosoever marrieth her that is put away from her husband committeth adultery.
States Christ’s general rule linking divorce and remarriage with adultery.
- Genesis 2:18
And the LORD God said, It is not good that the man should be alone; I will make him an help meet for him.
Marriage was made for humanity before the fall.
- Mark 10:2
And the Pharisees came to him, and asked him, Is it lawful for a man to put away his wife? tempting him.
Records the parallel question about divorce.
- Mark 10:3-4
And he answered and said unto them, What did Moses command you?
parallel account attributing same law to Moses
- Genesis 2:21-23
And the LORD God caused a deep sleep to fall upon Adam, and he slept: and he took one of his ribs, and closed up the flesh instead thereof;
Jesus’ teaching on marriage and divorce points back to the creation of Eve and the first marriage.
- Ephesians 5:31
For this cause shall a man leave his father and mother, and shall be joined unto his wife, and they two shall be one flesh.
Both describe husband and wife becoming one flesh.
- 1 Corinthians 11:9
Neither was the man created for the woman; but the woman for the man.
The woman’s creation for the man echoes Jesus’ appeal to the beginning.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
3 sources
The verse preserves the Pharisees' question asking why Moses directed the giving of a writing of divorcement and the putting away of the wife.Ms 7, 1904, par. 53–6217MR 156.1–3Lt 57, 1888, par. 1–2 The permission to divorce was granted as a concession because of the hardness of people's hearts and human degeneracy, not as part of God's original plan.Ms 7, 1904, par. 53–62 A divorce granted under human law does not by itself end a marriage in God's sight, for only adultery releases a husband or wife from the marriage vow.17MR 156.1–3 When a legal divorce is granted on the ground of adultery, the innocent spouse is free to marry another.17MR 156.1–3
The marriage vow remains binding until death under God's law.Lt 57, 1888, par. 1–2 It is not set aside because love has faded and dislike has grown.Lt 57, 1888, par. 1–2 Where deception is alleged as the reason, there are still no grounds for divorce, and the vow remains as duty.Lt 57, 1888, par. 1–2
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
45 sources
The verse records the Pharisees testing Jesus over marriage by asking why Moses commanded giving a certificate and sending a wife away.ST Mar 17, 1914 They treated what Moses allowed as a command to divorce, but He answered that Moses only suffered it because of hardness of heart.ST Feb 6, 1901 He traced marriage back to Eden before the fall, where God made one man and one woman to become one flesh in a sacred lifelong union no man should break.ST Jan 28, 1875RH Feb 3, 1852RH Feb 4, 1875 The rules permitting divorce were a concession to a sinful condition, not the expression of God's will and ideal, which is revealed from the beginning.ST Aug 19, 1913ST Sep 27, 1899ST Feb 6, 1901 A man should not put away his wife except for fornication, and putting her away on other grounds and marrying another is adultery.ST Dec 11, 1928ST Jan 10, 1900ST Oct 31, 1916
Setting and Wording
The question is the Pharisees testing Jesus and challenging His teaching on marriage by appealing to Moses, asking why Moses commanded a certificate of divorce and sending a wife away.ST Mar 17, 1914ST Jan 28, 1875ST Jan 28, 1913 The challenge came over whether a man may put away his wife for every cause, after He had taught that husband and wife are no more twain but one flesh joined by God that no man should put asunder. That teaching set forth the marriage law given at creation as a moral precept of perpetual obligation, and their question held up Moses allowing divorce by a written bill as an objection to that perpetuity, prompting His exposition that the original law uniting two as one flesh remains binding.ST Mar 17, 1914ST Sep 27, 1899ST Jan 28, 1875 It concerned the nature of marriage as God made one man and one woman to become one flesh, intending their union to be sacred, permanent, and for human good.ST Jan 28, 1875
Moses allowed divorce on certain grounds, but the rabbis interpreted the stated cause so broadly that a trivial preference could be used as an excuse. The Pharisees used that dispute to try to trap Jesus and, if He condemned divorce in a way that implicated Herod Antipas's adultery, possibly turn Herod against Him. The questioners treated Moses' sufferance as a command to divorce, but He corrected them that Moses only suffered or permitted it because of hardness of heart.ST Feb 6, 1901RH Apr 21, 1904ST Feb 6, 1901 That permission was not God's original plan or an institution He established, for from the beginning it was not so, and breaking up God's ordained union subverts that institution.ST Feb 6, 1901
The writing of divorcement is the provision of Deuteronomy 24:1-3, cited by the Pharisees and attributed to Moses.ST Jan 24, 1900 In Greek it is biblion apostasion, the bill of apostasy, meaning rebellion, withdrawal, turning away, despising, and proving untrue as a false-hearted companion toward one with whom lifelong union was solemnly promised. That Jesus taught that Moses commanded and wrote the divorce law in Deuteronomy 24 proves Moses was the human author of the Pentateuch.ST Feb 15, 1883 In this He was teaching His Father's law, not revising that law or establishing a new one.RH Apr 16, 1861
Matthew 19:3-8 is one of the places where, during the last six months before His crucifixion as He entered the shadow of the cross, He answered opponents with the Old Testament, with His heart resting on its prophecies and promises.ST Feb 15, 1883 It proves His teaching concerning the Old Testament came from His heart and deepest convictions by His absolute reliance upon its words.ST Feb 15, 1883 He found in the Old Testament the vital air of His soul, its thoughts His thoughts, its principles His principles, its prophecies the motive and support and promise of His life, and dwelt with His Father in the holy sanctuary of His word.ST Feb 15, 1883
Creation Ideal of Marriage
When asked about divorce, Jesus traced marriage to its origin in Eden before the fall, to Genesis 2:21-24 where God made one man and one woman to become one flesh.ST Jan 28, 1875RH Feb 3, 1852RH Feb 4, 1875ST Jun 10, 1875RH Feb 4, 1862 That beginning was the original institution of marriage made for man, and the question about Moses' provision for divorce does not make its sacred character depend on that provision.RH Feb 3, 1852ST Jun 10, 1875ST May 18, 1882 Marriage was designed to unite two people in a sacred, permanent, lasting and enduring bond for their good, because God joined the first pair and provided for no separation.ST Aug 25, 1887ST Jan 28, 1875RH Feb 4, 1875RH Feb 4, 1862ST Jun 6, 1916 God's original intention was for one man and one woman to remain together throughout life, with separation coming only later, for in the beginning it was not so.ST Aug 25, 1887ST Jun 6, 1916
The marriage law uniting two as one flesh given at creation is a moral precept of perpetual obligation that remains binding, which no man should put asunder.ST Mar 17, 1914 The Pharisees held up Moses allowing divorce by a written bill as an objection to that perpetuity, treating Moses as commanding divorce, and this prompted Christ's exposition and correction that Moses only suffered it because of hardness of heart.ST Mar 17, 1914 Christ called attention to the original institution at creation to correct the light esteem in which marriage was held and its perversion, and from that beginning to show its real object and sacred character.RH Jun 10, 1852RH Feb 4, 1875RH Feb 4, 1862 The Jews had perverted the institution, and He opposed that perversion by placing the subject back on the Eden order.RH Feb 4, 1875RH Feb 4, 1862
Violations of that ideal by the patriarchs in polygamy and putting away do not destroy, undo, or lessen the sacred character and sanctity of the institution established before the fall.RH Feb 3, 1852ST Jun 10, 1875RH Nov 8, 1853ST May 18, 1882RH Jan 21, 1875 Moses' provision does not make marriage less sacred, just as those violations do not diminish its sanctity.RH Jan 21, 1875 The sacredness of marriage is not derived from the Decalogue; the seventh commandment guards it just as the fourth commandment guards the Sabbath.RH Feb 3, 1852RH Nov 8, 1853 Divorce was not part of God's original purpose, plan, or ordained institution for marriage, but a concession to hardness of heart and a human change to God's institution.ST Aug 19, 1913ST Feb 6, 1901RH Mar 1, 1870RH May 12, 1874 Its introduction was evidence of sin and its increase showed sin becoming more prevalent, and breaking up God's ordained union subverts that institution and does not make people happier.ST Feb 6, 1901ST Oct 15, 1902RH May 12, 1874
Moses Concession for Hardness
Moses permitted divorce as a concession and allowance suited to a sinful condition and hardness of heart, not as the final expression of God's will, approval, or ideal.ST Aug 19, 1913ST Sep 27, 1899ST Feb 6, 1901ST Oct 21, 1930ST Aug 25, 1887 Divorce was not part of God's original purpose, plan, or ordained institution for marriage, and breaking it up subverts that institution.ST Aug 19, 1913ST Feb 6, 1901ST Aug 25, 1887 God's original intention was for one man and one woman to remain together throughout life in a sacred union, and that ideal belongs to the restoration of human society to God's kingdom.ST Aug 25, 1887ST Jul 21, 1898 The same allowance for human wrongdoing explains why slavery and polygamy were tolerated for a time, until people became sufficiently morally and spiritually enlightened to abandon them.ST Oct 21, 1930
From the beginning it was not so, for the beginning reveals the higher standard.ST Sep 27, 1899ST Jun 6, 1916 God joined the first pair in Eden and provided for no separation, and Jesus placed the subject back on the Eden order from which people should never have departed.ST Sep 27, 1899RH Mar 1, 1870ST Jun 6, 1916 Separation came later, but in the beginning it was not so.ST Jun 6, 1916
The divorce provision was given because of the hardness of heart of the Hebrews, and it was not a permanent rule binding as the standard for life.RH Jul 22, 1852 Christ's teaching marks its discontinuance.RH Jul 22, 1852 As a civil ordinance protecting individual rights, that law of divorce expired with the Jewish state.ST May 14, 1896
Permission under the customs of the time did not mean God approved polygamy, for marriage was designed for one man and one woman to become one flesh.ST Jul 21, 1898 The provision for divorce did not make divorce itself right, but was an allowance and not God's ideal.ST Feb 27, 1893ST Jul 21, 1898 Just so, custom alone did not make morally right the claimed custom that a king inherited his predecessor's wives.ST Feb 27, 1893
The loose Jewish rules permitting divorce for many causes did not agree with God's law, since God instituted marriage.ST Sep 1, 1909 Divorce was not permitted for every cause, and fornication was the one true ground for it.ST Sep 1, 1909 Past practices and customs must not be treated as a guide to what is right, for God's original purpose in creation is the standard, and the appeal to Moses' provision as a command is answered by hardness of heart and the plan from the beginning.RH Apr 21, 1904 The introduction of divorce was evidence of sin, and its increase showed sin becoming more prevalent, since it was conceded because of hardness of heart and was not part of marriage's original design.ST Oct 15, 1902
Divorce Rule and Exception
In God's sight a man should not divorce his wife except for fornication, and violation of the seventh commandment is sufficient ground for divorce.ST Dec 11, 1928ST Jan 10, 1900ST Jan 10, 1900ST Sep 10, 1885ST Sep 1, 1909 The Mosaic allowance for a written dismissal does not justify divorce for every cause, for the loose Jewish rules permitting divorce for many causes did not agree with God's law by which God instituted marriage.ST Sep 10, 1885ST Sep 1, 1909 The general statements against divorce in Mark and Luke are understood in light of Matthew's fuller qualification with the exception for fornication.ST Aug 19, 1913
Putting away a wife except for fornication and marrying another is adultery. Divorce followed by remarriage on other than Scriptural grounds is iniquitous, unscriptural, and antibiblical.ST Oct 31, 1916 The faithful spouse separated from an unfaithful companion on that ground of fornication is entitled to marry again.
This rule applies to all Christian marriages.ST Dec 11, 1928 It addresses the individual conscience and soul rather than changing civil statute, and following it does not violate civil law.ST Jan 10, 1900ST Jan 10, 1900 Christ's answer is strict and severe, setting the Biblical principle and New Testament standard governing divorce.ST Oct 31, 1916 Marriage is not a temporary contract to be broken at the whim, passion, or will of either party.ST Oct 31, 1916
Marriage is a sacred commitment, and minor grievances or incompatibility are not sufficient grounds for breaking the vow.RH Dec 28, 1911 Reconciliation and adjustment should be pursued instead of divorce.RH Dec 28, 1911 Divorce on unscriptural grounds and adultery are both violations of God's law, although legal divorce is preferable to open adultery.ST Jul 18, 1900
Application to Church and Society
Christ's answer on divorce is strict and severe, setting the Biblical principle and New Testament standard that governs divorce.ST Oct 31, 1916 Marriage is not a temporary contract to be broken at the whim, passion, or will of either party, and divorce followed by remarriage on other than Scriptural grounds is iniquitous, unscriptural, and antibiblical.ST Oct 31, 1916 Christian ministers must come into line with that standard and refuse to take part in such divorce business or to officiate at the remarriage of persons divorced on unscriptural grounds, even if holding to it brings the charge of being narrow, fanatical, and old-fashioned.ST Oct 31, 1916 Catholic teaching and practice are closer to that New Testament standard than those of Protestant churches, which should follow Scripture rather than human standards.ST Sep 18, 1884
The marriage-and-divorce teaching applies to the difficulty of people entering the church while living in unlawful domestic relationships, including relationships formed after a divorce where remarriage is not permitted.ST Apr 9, 1894 Jesus' teaching on the family relationship is the only matter on which He distinctly legislated.RH Aug 23, 1906 Belief that marriage belongs to God, with rejection of divorce, stands against the view that marriage belongs only to people, which is associated with prevalent divorce.ST Sep 22, 1898
The verse records the Pharisees tempting Jesus over whether a man may put away his wife for every cause, answering His teaching that husband and wife are no more twain but one flesh joined by God that no man should put asunder by asking why Moses commanded divorce by a writing of divorcement. The question treats Moses as commanding divorce, and the correction is that Moses only suffered divorce because of hardness of heart, that from the beginning it was not so, and that putting away a wife except for fornication and marrying another is adultery. The verse concerns the closest tie that should bind husband and wife, and its breaking brings growing evils of unnatural affection where the principle of lifelong union is no longer recognized. Laws making divorce easy contribute to the decay of family life.RH Jul 4, 1912
Unrealistic romantic ideas can lead people to become dissatisfied with marriage, break their vows, and divorce.ST Jan 27, 1890 Moses' rules permitting divorce were allowances suited to people's sinful condition, not the final expression of God's will for marriage.ST Aug 25, 1887 God's original intention was for one man and one woman to remain together throughout life, marriage is sacred, and its ideal is part of the restoration of human society to God's kingdom.ST Aug 25, 1887
Sources