Matthew 3:12
Whose fan is in his hand, and he will throughly purge his floor, and gather his wheat into the garner; but he will burn up the chaff with unquenchable fire.
Whose fan is in his hand, and he will throughly purge his floor, and gather his wheat into the garner; but he will burn up the chaff with unquenchable fire.
Commentary part 2 of 2
Pioneers and periodicals (continued)
Destruction of Wicked
The burning of the chaff means the wicked are utterly destroyed, consumed and brought to an end, not preserved alive forever in endless conscious torment or misery, for chaff that is burnt up is not always burning.RH Jan 19, 1869ST Jan 29, 1885ST Nov 18, 1880RH Jun 22, 1869ST May 1, 1879
The fire is unquenchable because no one can stop it before it consumes what it burns, which guarantees destruction rather than endless burning afterward.ST Jun 15, 1915RH Dec 2, 1858RH Dec 27, 1855RH Jan 7, 1915RH Feb 20, 1872
Unquenchable does not mean burning forever after the fuel is gone but ceases when the fuel is gone, with everlasting death as the result.ST Jun 15, 1915RH Dec 2, 1858RH Dec 27, 1855ST Jul 26, 1899
Like a courthouse fire that engines could not stop so the house was destroyed, like the great Chicago fire and many others that were unquenchable till what they fed upon was consumed, the fire destroys completely and then stops.ST Jun 15, 1915RH Dec 2, 1858RH Jan 7, 1915ST Jul 26, 1899
The Greek expression for unquenchable fire was also used of intense consuming fires that burned Christians and martyrs at Alexandria and later ceased, denoting intensity and total consumption.ST Jun 15, 1915RH Dec 2, 1858RH Dec 27, 1855RH Jan 7, 1915
What is burned up is totally destroyed, reduced to ashes, left with neither root nor branch and nothing left, and after punishment according to deserts the wicked are consumed completely and are no more.RH Dec 27, 1855ST Apr 17, 1879ST May 2, 1878RH Dec 8, 1868RH May 24, 1870
The fire has power over souls and does not keep them burning forever without consuming them.RH Dec 27, 1855ST Apr 17, 1879ST May 2, 1878RH Dec 8, 1868ST Apr 15, 1875
The fire is called everlasting or eternal because it lasts until nothing remains to consume and because its effects are everlasting, like the fire that overthrew Sodom and Gomorrah and turned them to ashes.ST Oct 9, 1907RH Dec 8, 1868RH Dec 8, 1868ST Feb 5, 1885
Everlasting therefore describes the lasting consequence and result, not an endless process of consuming or endless torment, and once it has consumed what it is to destroy and cleansed the earth it ceases and sin and sinners no longer exist.ST Oct 9, 1907RH Dec 8, 1868RH Dec 8, 1868ST Feb 5, 1885ST Feb 12, 1894
The verse proves annihilation and stands against human immortality and endless torment, for the wicked do not live eternally in fire but are burned up into the end of existence, and it belongs among the texts listing the final penalty as destruction or death.ST Jan 29, 1885ST Nov 1, 1905RH Jun 12, 1856RH Aug 29, 1871RH Dec 19, 1854
After judgment according to deeds done in this life the wicked are completely destroyed and cease to exist.ST Jan 29, 1885ST Nov 1, 1905RH May 24, 1870RH Aug 29, 1871
The chaff represents unbelievers bitten by sin who refuse to look to Christ lifted on the cross, and their burning means to perish by literal death, to die, to be destroyed, consumed and burned up, which is the wages of sin and the second death in the lake of fire, not living forever in torment.RH Jun 12, 1856RH May 24, 1870RH Apr 7, 1868RH Aug 29, 1871
Their punishment, however dreadful and long-lasting and measured according to each person's deeds, ends in complete destruction, not endless life in suffering, linked to the final destruction when the earth is burned and its elements melt before the new earth is made.ST Oct 9, 1907RH May 24, 1870RH Apr 7, 1868ST Sep 28, 1882
The wicked, including Satan and all his followers, deceiver and deceived, will be burned up like perishable chaff and vanish in flames, burned root and branch and consumed into smoke until every rebel voice is hushed in death.RH Dec 8, 1868RH May 24, 1870ST Nov 25, 1886ST Nov 22, 1899ST Nov 7, 1878
They are annihilated not as matter but as conscious intelligent beings so as to become as though they had not been, after redemption is finished at the second resurrection when fire devours the ungodly and purifies the earth, leaving a clean universe with no receptacle of eternal torment and no discordant wailings in universal praise.ST Nov 25, 1886ST Mar 19, 1912ST Nov 7, 1878RH Feb 8, 1912ST Sep 4, 1907
The burning is judgment in the great and terrible day of the Lord that only the righteous can abide.ST Nov 22, 1899ST Mar 19, 1912ST May 26, 1914RH Mar 23, 1916
Those who will not have Christ's living presence within them now will perish in the glory of His revealed presence, with Satan as root and the wicked as branch burned up, so all sin and all identified with sin perish forever and God's universe is clean.ST Nov 25, 1886ST Nov 22, 1899ST Mar 19, 1912ST May 26, 1914RH Mar 23, 1916
Final punishment agrees with the undying worm and unquenchable fire, for as the worm does not die till it has devoured what it preys upon, the fire is not quenched till it burns up the chaff on which it feeds, consuming it completely.ST Mar 10, 1898ST Apr 15, 1913ST Aug 13, 1896ST Apr 9, 1896ST Feb 4, 1897
The work of the fire is to utterly burn up the chaff, who are the wicked, bringing absolute and utter destruction complete to all eternity and never repeated, consuming dead bodies or carcasses completely, one death agent completing what the other leaves, not endlessly tormenting living beings.ST Mar 10, 1898ST Apr 15, 1913ST Aug 13, 1896ST Apr 9, 1896ST Feb 4, 1897
Unquenchable fire cannot be put out before consuming them and does not keep them alive forever but burns them completely, burning long and without intermission until its perishable object is destroyed, for forever applied to what cannot live eternally means continuity of existence until consumed.ST Mar 10, 1898ST Jan 15, 1885RH Mar 27, 1856RH Oct 3, 1854ST Sep 30, 1930
Chaff burnt up is destroyed, put out of existence and not to be found like burnt tares, consuming rather than preserving alive, for wheat and chaff show the wicked are burned to be consumed not preserved, perishing, devoured and dying the second death, the fire lasting till its consuming work is done then ceasing.ST Jan 15, 1885RH Oct 3, 1854RH Dec 8, 1868RH Dec 8, 1868
Unquenchable means the fire cannot be put out, not that the chaff burns forever without being consumed, and the burning symbolizes inescapable complete destruction and thoroughness of consumption, not forever punishment, as Jerusalem's fire burned till its work was complete.ST Jul 14, 1898ST Aug 13, 1896ST Apr 9, 1896RH Mar 27, 1856ST Sep 30, 1930
The unquenchable fire is a real destroying fire and agent of destruction, not remorse of conscience nor the soul itself, and not merely mental distress, destroying as fire burns up chaff, stubble, thorns and tares.RH Oct 18, 1864ST Aug 23, 1899ST Aug 2, 1877RH Feb 20, 1872ST Jul 15, 1880
It cannot be put out by the wicked, the devil, his angels, or any outside means, has power over souls, and the righteous pass through it unharmed into safety while it accomplishes utter destruction.RH Oct 18, 1864ST Aug 23, 1899RH Dec 8, 1868ST Jan 19, 1882ST Oct 3, 1906
Final punishment is inflicted by fire, and the fire is the means by which the chaff is destroyed, not something continuing after the chaff is gone.RH Oct 18, 1864ST Aug 2, 1877RH Feb 20, 1872ST Jul 15, 1880
Unquenchable fire is the fiery judgment upon sin and sinners, called everlasting and eternal because its effect is everlasting and eternal, by putting the word describing the effect upon the agent that works it.ST Oct 9, 1907RH Dec 8, 1868ST Feb 5, 1885RH Mar 23, 1916
It consumes utterly until nothing is left, then goes out of its own accord when destruction is complete.ST Apr 15, 1913ST Dec 30, 1903RH Mar 23, 1916ST Nov 13, 1884
Unquenchable refers to intensity not duration, meaning it cannot be put out or quenched so long as there is anything for it to burn, ending in complete destruction after which the wicked always remain dead, so punishment is everlasting in result with agonies ending in blackness of eternal night.ST Apr 15, 1913ST May 26, 1914ST Dec 30, 1903RH Mar 23, 1916ST Nov 13, 1884
The wicked are consumed in fire and perish forever in the second death with no resurrection from that death, and the fire also purifies the earth, the great place of the dead.ST Nov 25, 1886ST Mar 19, 1912RH Feb 8, 1912ST Mar 26, 1912ST Sep 4, 1907
Those disregarding the atonement made for them and going on in transgression of God's law will suffer the original penalty of death, but in a different manner from the death through Adam's sin, namely the second death, a complete destruction by fire in which they perish and are consumed away leaving nothing remaining.RH May 24, 1870RH Apr 7, 1868RH Jul 10, 1860ST Sep 4, 1907
The harvest of the wicked is corruption, meaning decay and death not endless conscious misery, for the chaff consumes away into smoke while those sowing to the Spirit reap eternal life.RH Sep 17, 1857ST Nov 17, 1909RH Aug 22, 1854ST Nov 18, 1913
Like perishable chaff consumed, the wicked are burned up and cease as conscious intelligent beings, their bodies destroyed while reserved till resurrection and final judgment when the chaff is burned at Christ's coming.ST Nov 25, 1886ST Nov 7, 1878ST Sep 4, 1907RH Feb 18, 1873RH Mar 31, 1868
At Christ's coming the wicked are destroyed while the righteous are gathered to salvation and eternal life, with the burning linked to the end, showing the consequences of rejecting God's message as applied to the warning of God's wrath in Revelation 14.ST Mar 13, 1907RH Apr 18, 1854ST Jan 20, 1887ST Jan 16, 1901
The wicked burned up in the final fire become ashes, and the fire is unquenchable in the sense that no one can stop it or escape it, continuing while anything is left to consume.ST Apr 15, 1913ST Dec 30, 1903ST Jan 25, 1899RH Mar 23, 1916ST Nov 13, 1884
Burned like chaff, they show sin results in death not endless torture, and show the end of those rejecting God's plan and refusing the remedy that would save them from death.RH Sep 17, 1857ST Nov 17, 1909RH Aug 22, 1854ST Nov 18, 1913
They are likened to chaff joined with wood, grass, hay, stubble and tow as the most inflammable materials, meaning they will be burned up and destroyed, in harmony with all Scripture, eternal misery having been taught only from the unscriptural doctrine of immortality of the soul.RH Sep 17, 1857ST Nov 17, 1909RH Aug 22, 1854ST Nov 18, 1913
Unquenchable fire brings absolute utter destruction complete to eternity never repeated, for fire consuming chaff images completed punishment not continual punishing, the fire not quenched until it has done its work.ST Jul 14, 1898ST Apr 15, 1913ST Aug 13, 1896ST Apr 9, 1896ST Oct 9, 1907
It utterly consumes the carcasses of transgressors, consuming what the worm does not devour, not endlessly tormenting living beings.ST Mar 10, 1898ST Apr 15, 1913ST Aug 13, 1896ST Apr 9, 1896ST Feb 4, 1897
Gathering wheat is saving the righteous and burning chaff is utter consuming of the wicked, where unquenchable fire will not go out until what is cast into it is gone and turns to ashes, just as the worm does not die until what it feeds upon is consumed.ST Jul 14, 1898ST Apr 15, 1913ST Aug 13, 1896ST Apr 9, 1896ST Oct 9, 1907
It is called everlasting because it lasts until its fuel is gone and because its results last forever, not because torment continues.ST Oct 9, 1907ST Feb 5, 1885ST Apr 15, 1913ST Oct 9, 1907
The wicked as chaff are cast into unquenchable fire to be burned to ashes, the fire being the agent carrying out the death penalty on those not accepting Christ, belonging to the final conflagration on earth after which the saints inherit the renewed earth.RH Jan 19, 1869ST Nov 20, 1884ST Apr 15, 1913ST Nov 13, 1884ST Oct 9, 1907
Unquenchable fire is the day-of-Lord fire no human device can quench, joining fire inside the earth and fire and brimstone from God to melt the earth, and the burning earth is the lake of fire where the wicked receive doom lasting till the lake gives place to the new earth, so forever lasts as long as the fire continues, not endlessly.RH Jan 19, 1869ST Mar 19, 1912RH Feb 8, 1912ST Mar 26, 1912ST Sep 4, 1907
The fire is the great-day fire dissolving the sin-marred earth, destroying the devil's works and burning the wicked, a test and agent of judgment burning chaff while wheat is gathered safely.RH Jan 19, 1869ST Mar 19, 1912RH Feb 8, 1912ST Mar 26, 1912ST Sep 4, 1907
The verse shows the final doom of demons and wicked men, for the fire burns up the chaff not sins in a temporary purgatory, representing the loss of those like wood, hay and stubble brought into the church and the failure of the worker's labor.RH May 26, 1874ST Mar 19, 1912ST May 26, 1914ST Jan 16, 1901
The unregenerate compared to chaff will be utterly annihilated in the judgment, the fire unquenchable because none can put it out before fuel is consumed, and once the chaff is burned the fire dies out.ST Apr 15, 1913ST Dec 30, 1903RH Mar 23, 1916ST Nov 13, 1884
Wicked men face utter destruction, for as chaff is burned so they are consumed in God's presence, unquenchable meaning not quenched till doing its work of consuming them.ST Dec 30, 1903ST Jan 25, 1899RH Mar 23, 1916ST Nov 13, 1884
Chaff's fire is an emblem of destruction not endless torment, burned up not quenched before destroying, showing destruction without remedy or restoration rather than being kept alive in misery, not an eternally continued existence in consuming fire.ST Aug 31, 1882ST May 29, 1884RH Jun 23, 1874ST Jan 17, 1900RH Feb 9, 1864
The hopeless doom of incorrigible sin is annihilation leaving a perfected kingdom, for burning means destruction not torment, since fire in the Bible is an emblem of destruction not torment.ST Aug 31, 1882ST May 29, 1884RH Jun 23, 1874ST Jan 17, 1900RH Feb 9, 1864
Unquenchable fire is the Gehenna fire kept burning outside Jerusalem to destroy refuse and offal, where the undying worm and unquenched fire are emblems of destruction without remedy, not torment.ST Aug 31, 1882ST May 29, 1884ST Jan 17, 1900ST Aug 2, 1899ST Sep 30, 1930
This agrees with man being mortal who must put on immortality, with immortality as God's gift through Christ to those becoming partakers of the divine nature of Him who only has immortality, so eternal life is life eternal and eternal death is death eternal and everlasting destruction is destruction without remedy.ST May 29, 1884ST Nov 18, 1913RH Oct 6, 1859RH Dec 3, 1867RH Nov 14, 1871
The incorrigibly wicked will be annihilated, chaff not tortured but destroyed, fire being emblem of destruction not torment.ST Aug 31, 1882ST May 29, 1884RH Jun 23, 1874ST Jan 17, 1900RH Feb 9, 1864
Christ's describing punishment as burning chaff with unquenchable fire is explicit teaching about the penalty, not peculiar to the New Testament, belonging to the Bible's final retribution, not a figure for something worse beyond but the dread reality itself bringing complete and utter extinction.ST Aug 31, 1882ST May 29, 1884RH Jun 14, 1864RH Jun 23, 1874ST Jan 17, 1900
The fire is the means destroying chaff, not continuing after the chaff is gone, consuming the wicked as fire consumes chaff.ST Apr 15, 1913ST Dec 30, 1903RH Mar 23, 1916ST Nov 13, 1884
Unquenchable fire, pur asbestos, means fire not put out by any outside means till consuming all that can burn, and as in Hinnom constant fires consumed filth and dead bodies with worms devouring what flames spared, so in true Gehenna no part escapes with one death agent completing the other.ST Mar 10, 1898ST Apr 9, 1896ST Feb 4, 1897ST Aug 2, 1899ST Sep 30, 1930
So sin and choosers of evil are ultimately removed while eternal life belongs to receivers through Christ, the chaff burned completely because the fire is not quenched until everything that can burn is consumed, describing complete destruction not punishment lasting forever.ST Aug 31, 1882ST May 29, 1884ST Jan 17, 1900ST Aug 2, 1899ST Sep 30, 1930
Unquenchable fire does not mean eternity of conscious existence but by usage of speech denotes utter complete destruction of what it is applied to.ST Nov 18, 1913RH Oct 6, 1859RH Dec 3, 1867RH Nov 14, 1871RH Feb 11, 1873
To burn up chaff means the wicked, having no inherent immortal principle and never putting on incorruption and immortality obtained alone through Christ at the resurrection, reap corruption and die and perish and are consumed and destroyed and burnt up as withered branches, dried thorns, chaff and stubble, becoming ashes, so as conscious intelligent beings they are annihilated and resolved into original elements while matter passes into other forms as though they had never been.ST Nov 18, 1913RH Oct 6, 1859RH Dec 3, 1867RH Nov 14, 1871RH Feb 11, 1873
Impenitent sinners burned like chaff are destroyed and come to an end rather than living forever by nature in happiness or misery, meaning man is mortal and destructible and eternal life is received only as God's free gift in Christ through faith sought by patient continuance, with life and immortality on one side and death and destruction on the other.ST Nov 18, 1913RH Oct 6, 1859RH Dec 3, 1867RH Nov 14, 1871RH Feb 11, 1873
The godly as wheat are gathered by Christ into the heavenly storehouse at His second advent, while the ungodly as chaff are burned in the final fire where unquenchable cannot be put out but consumes completely leaving ashes, not eternal torment, ending sin and silencing every voice opposed to God.RH Aug 24, 1869RH Oct 31, 1865ST Jan 16, 1901RH Jul 28, 1868RH Dec 3, 1867
The wicked as perishable chaff are burned and ended rather than alive forever, punishment everlasting in consequences while the wicked are destroyed, and those not receiving eternal life through Christ are burned like chaff rather than possessing immortal life.RH Oct 31, 1865ST Nov 18, 1913ST Jan 16, 1901RH Oct 6, 1859RH Jul 28, 1868
The chaff represents those not among God's people, consumed by unquenchable fire following removal of sin and evil and completion of the righteous people's trial when confirmed in virtue and made immortal.RH Aug 24, 1869RH Oct 31, 1865ST Jan 16, 1901RH Jul 28, 1868RH Dec 3, 1867
Chaff burned means utter complete destruction in the second death rather than endless torment or eternal incorruptible existence, for like chaff they perish without immortality or continued consciousness as fuel destroyed without remedy.ST May 5, 1881RH Dec 3, 1867RH Nov 14, 1871ST Jan 6, 1904RH Feb 11, 1873
The fire's work is destruction not preservation, punishment everlasting because its result, the second death, can never be reversed by reprieve or resurrection, while righteousness and life belong with the choice of the wheat.ST May 5, 1881RH Dec 3, 1867RH Nov 14, 1871ST Jan 6, 1904RH Feb 11, 1873
Unquenchable lasts only as long as persons cast in can exist in it, and forever applied covers only the time fuel remains, just as forever elsewhere means a natural lifetime.ST Apr 15, 1913ST Dec 30, 1903RH Mar 23, 1916ST Nov 13, 1884ST Feb 5, 1885
The wicked like chaff are fit for flames when forgetting God or denying Him by actions, and He will destroy them and the world they trust, pointing to separation and fire while the righteous dwell in new heavens and new earth.RH Aug 24, 1869RH Oct 31, 1865ST Jan 20, 1887ST Jan 16, 1901RH Jul 28, 1868
Compared to threshing-floor chaff burned, the wicked are taught destruction alongside fuel burned up, wax melting before flame, fat consumed away, and ashes.ST Nov 13, 1884RH Dec 17, 1857RH Dec 3, 1867RH Nov 14, 1871ST Jan 6, 1904
The burning of chaff shows the final penalty for the impenitent is extinction of conscious life in the second death, not endless suffering.ST May 5, 1881RH Dec 3, 1867RH Nov 14, 1871ST Jan 6, 1904RH Feb 11, 1873
Christ will completely burn up the wicked as chaff with devouring fire while gathering the righteous into His garner to dwell in safety with everlasting burnings, so only walkers righteously can dwell with God and sinners fear utter destruction.ST Nov 22, 1899ST Mar 19, 1912ST Mar 26, 1912ST Jan 16, 1901
Reference to unquenchable fire presents judgment as real against the claim all will be saved and God never punishes, and it belongs to texts usually brought to prove unending conscious existence of the wicked.ST May 5, 1881RH Dec 17, 1857ST Jun 28, 1899RH Jul 15, 1862
Those holding the figurative interpretation under criticism make that fire the remorse of a guilty conscience rather than real fire, which remorse is said to grow weaker as people become more deeply sinful.RH Oct 18, 1864ST Aug 2, 1877RH Feb 20, 1872ST Jul 15, 1880RH Oct 31, 1865
Spirit and Fire Baptisms
The baptism of fire is the burning of the chaff with unquenchable fire, which is immersion in the lake of fire from heaven that rids the earth of worthless chaff and utterly destroys the wicked.ST Jun 24, 1889 Those who yield to the Spirit receive the baptism of the Holy Spirit unto holiness and freedom, which prepares its recipients for the garner of heaven, while those who refuse the Holy Spirit, including the impenitent Pharisees who continued as a brood of vipers without fruits meet for repentance, remain chaff and tares to be gathered out by angels and perish with sin at the judgment executed by Christ.ST Feb 19, 1902ST Mar 31, 1914 The tongues parting asunder like fire at Pentecost that merely sat upon the disciples were not this baptism of fire. The fire is the consuming power of God's unveiled presence at Christ's coming, which destroys sin and those who have chosen to remain identified with it, and the fire of the Holy Spirit can consume sin from a person's life now if it is not quenched, but if quenched the person will be consumed in the final fire.ST Feb 19, 1902RH Nov 27, 1913
Christ gives two baptisms, baptizing with the Holy Ghost those who acknowledge Him and receive of His Spirit and gathering them as wheat into the garner, and baptizing with fire those who prove at last to be only chaff and burning them up with unquenchable fire.RH Oct 29, 1901ST Jul 2, 1896 The baptism of fire does not come first, for before it is reached all must pass the test of the judgment at the conclusion of His mediatorial work when all cases are decided and eternal decisions are rendered.RH Oct 29, 1901 The baptism with fire is the utter destruction of the wicked in the fire of eternal perdition, distinct from the baptism with the Holy Spirit given to believers.ST Jul 2, 1896 That fire is God's unveiled presence at Christ's coming, devouring to the guilty but life and peace forevermore to the righteous, saving them to die no more and changing them to immortality.ST Jul 2, 1896 The chaff represents those who reject the baptism of the Holy Spirit, and their destruction by unquenchable fire that cannot be stopped before it consumes what is combustible is the baptism of fire signifying utter destruction in the lake of fire which is the second death.ST Jul 23, 1894
The baptism of fire is the fate of those who refuse Christ, who are cast into unquenchable fire, while by contrast those who submit to Christ are immersed in the Holy Spirit.ST Jul 23, 1894 As a grain gatherer cleans his threshing floor, Jesus separates two classes, gathering the wheat into His storehouse and burning the chaff, baptizing one class with the Holy Spirit and the other with fire when He returns as the burning glory of His presence in which sin and those identified with sin cannot remain.ST Oct 22, 1912 The Coming One alone can do the work John prepared people for, giving the humble and faithful the life-giving power of His Spirit while those eternally identified with sin perish in the glory of His presence.ST Oct 22, 1912 The Holy Spirit is also God's refining fire separating the precious from the base in the church and the world, purifying the faithful like gold while consuming hypocrisy like dross and chaff and leaving what is pure to shine, a work beginning at Pentecost and awaiting renewal.ST Nov 29, 1899ST
Christ baptizes with Holy Spirit and with fire because God works among men through His Spirit and the Spirit acts in conformity with God's nature as a consuming fire.ST May 10, 1910 The baptism with fire is the Holy Spirit coming as God's flaming Messenger to offer to relieve character of every unholy combustible thing, testing every man's life-work and burning away wood, hay and stubble while melting and purifying but not consuming gold, silver and precious stones.ST Mar 26, 1912ST May 10, 1910 All who submit to the process are cleansed and purified, while those who count the sacrifice too great are left to pass under the final unquenchable burning reserved for the wicked.ST May 10, 1910 In the final separation the Spirit renews God's children while the wicked are baptized with fire and perish, and the fire represents God's just wrath kindled by God's presence which saves His people, tests and reveals the quality of each person's work, destroys sin yet saves people, with the righteous enduring while the chaff burned with unquenchable fire images final destruction that nothing can stop from completing its work.ST Mar 26, 1912ST Mar 14, 1911
Present Sifting of Church
Matthew 3:12 pictures Christ cleansing his people as grain is separated on a threshing floor, gathering the wheat while those who do not submit to this purging are burned like chaff in unquenchable fire.ST Jan 25, 1899ST Jan 25, 1899 It shows the testing and sifting of Israel as a separation in which wheat is preserved and chaff is removed until the chaff is entirely separated from the wheat, with false doctrines among the winds threatening to carry people away.RH Jul 4, 1907 The unquenchable fire means complete destruction that will not be quenched until it has finished its work.ST Jan 25, 1899
The Lord's purging of his floor is a sifting and purification of the church, and the coming test will separate true godliness from its outward appearance so that the faithful remain while the unfaithful and those deceived by false teaching are exposed and removed.ST Jan 13, 1887RH Jul 4, 1907RH Apr 28, 1904 The Lord holding the fan and thoroughly purging his floor tests every soul and purifies the church, with wheat as the true and faithful gathered to God and chaff as those proving false and carried away.RH Apr 28, 1904 This purging is already taking place in some degree, calling the church to be pure and its members to be honest and upright, devoted and single-minded for God's glory.RH Feb 11, 1862
The Holy Spirit's purifying work separates the faithful from unbelief, the faithful like wheat gathered for God while those resisting the Spirit are like chaff that cannot remain with them, a separation taking place in the church that will leave a purified people though only a remnant.ST Nov 29, 1899 God will separate his people as wheat from chaff and gather the wheat while the chaff is consumed, requiring his people to become holy, for those clinging to error and refusing self-denial will be shaken out from among them and consumed with the wicked.RH Dec 12, 1854 The Lord will separate the true from the false, those regenerated by the Holy Spirit being wheat while those without that renewing work are chaff, and his purging of the floor is a coming judgment distinguishing those serving God from those not, which outward forms and profession cannot make clean.ST Jul 14, 1887ST Jan 11, 1883
Christ will separate the spiritually renewed from those lacking the regenerating power of the Spirit as chaff among wheat, thoroughly purging his floor and in the coming day distinguishing servers of God from others.ST Jul 14, 1887 He separates the genuine from the false, with the test of the messages borne by his witnesses revealing wheat and chaff, while church membership and attendance alone prove neither character nor loyalty.ST Apr 26, 1910 In the church's coming sifting genuine godliness and those clothed with Christ's righteousness will be distinguished from outward profession without reality, the chaff carried away while the faithful hidden ones are revealed and gathered under his banner.RH Apr 28, 1904
Coming days of purification will manifest the fan in his hand to thoroughly purge his floor, sifting the Christian world and the church, announced by many varied signs and predictions hastening to their close and arriving in days of wild perplexity when even the elect could be deceived if possible.RH Dec 24, 1861 The purging comes when faithfulness is tested by violence, when the mark of the beast is pressed at sword or bayonet and only renunciation saves from torture or death, separating gold from dross and wheat from chaff with many stars falling and clouds of chaff blown from places looking like rich wheat floors.RH Dec 24, 1861RH Nov 9, 1916 Nothing not from the Spirit survives that ordeal, and everything taking sanctuary ornaments without being clothed by the Lord's hand is seen in the shame of its own nakedness.RH Dec 24, 1861
The final test separates wheat gathered from chaff burned when the mark of the beast is urged and the contest between God's commandments and men's brings derision, insult, threatened imprisonment and death, with gold separated from dross and true godliness clearly distinguished from appearance and tinsel.RH Nov 9, 1916RH Dec 12, 1912 Many with the appearance of wheat prove when tested to be only chaff, yielding step by step to worldly demands and conforming to worldly customs rather than suffer, while half-hearted believers accept strange new doctrines leading from old landmarks, wolves in sheep's clothing work banefully, men arise speaking perverse things, and cares and pleasures choke the word so many choose the less sacrificing easy popular side.RH Nov 9, 1916 The coming demand to worship the beast and its image brings this sifting, and the fire represents the destruction that purifies the earth.RH Dec 12, 1912
Thoroughly purging the floor is the third angel's message doing a refining work among God's people, sweeping away spiritual rubbish and bringing the faithful together as jewels, with wheat as those gathered into one fold united in faith and obedience and chaff as what is removed.RH Dec 1850 The final separation is completed by the loud cry when God's people are separated from Babylon before wrath so none of Zion remains in Babylon and none of Babylon in Zion, wheat and chaff as two fully distinct classes embodying Christ's principles versus Satan's.RH Dec 10, 1901 Separation of wheat from chaff is a sifting now going on with chaff separated from wheat and dross from gold, while the church militant still contains true and false, calling for steadfastness and resistance to false teaching.RH Mar 16, 1916
Chaff is now being sifted out from among God's people, wheat being those abiding in faith showing faith by works and settled in present truth, who after sifting press toward sanctification through to the kingdom, with sifting through loyalty tests leaving only pure wheat.RH Oct 2, 1866RH Jan 27, 1874 True wheat is sifted from chaff when those briefly joining from novelty or excitement leave when trials come while the sincere remain, without risk of losing precious grain.RH Apr 11, 1854 Profession and initial excitement do not prove lasting faith, for later trials and ordinary less exciting seasons separate steadfast wheat holding fast, obeying and saved from fallaways pictured as chaff, and some connected like chaff serve as temporary support while the faithful ripen but will not endure.ST May 20, 1880ST Aug 7, 1884ST Jul 6, 1904
The church is purified as chaff is sifted from wheat when members turning to opponents are separated from the faithful though their departure does not discourage remainers, for God will sift his people and the shaking tests everyone revealing who can stand.RH Jan 6, 1863RH Feb 26, 1867 Trials separate wheat from chaff to distinguish and refine those belonging to God, with tribulation removing what is spiritually worthless, developing character, burning dross, consuming evil, and preparing for triumph, everlasting inheritance and immortal life.ST Sep 30, 1886RH Sep 4, 1855ST Nov 22, 1910ST Aug 8, 1906RH Oct 15, 1857 Tribulation strikes like a threshing sledge separating wheat from chaff yet not one kernel of wheat is lost.RH Jul 5, 1870
Trials are God's fanning mill blowing away chaff and leaving wheat to be gathered into the garner, testing and strengthening believers and separating good from not good in character and church.RH May 23, 1871RH Nov 6, 1900 Persecution, ridicule and temptation are a winnowing sifting the church that exposes and removes hypocrites like chaff while the faithful remain like wheat, and should not be prevented because revealing true followers. What is useful must be threshed and sifted to be cleansed, so hardships of Christian life belong to sanctification not to be resented, with affliction as God's winnowing frame blowing away chaff of vanities people should have laid aside.RH Aug 18, 1868RH Dec 3, 1867
God sifts life to separate chaff from wheat, and purging by fire describes trials removing impurity so the person comes through purified reflecting character.RH Jul 14, 1910 Christ holds the flail to thresh wheat from straw and purge chaff so true worth appears through great affliction, beating vain affections and corruptions out, while the Spirit removes straw of worldly treasures, dust of empty pleasures and husk of flesh until the soul is uncovered and made poor to rise to highest wealth.ST Dec 13, 1883 Wheat and chaff picture sifting where rough winds scatter chaff and leave what lasts, which God allows but limits, saying when chaff is scattered Be still enough, applied to painful trials purifying character and teaching patience.ST
The time of sifting brings successive tests where some endure one trial but fail the next while dross and chaff are exposed, showing trials reveal the faithful, with God providing means for purification.RH May 7, 1861 Trials and changes sift members as some lose interest or become worldly while others remain loyal, bringing residents nearer God and one another and leading to correcting records.RH Apr 14, 1910 Proclamation of the message separates like wheat from chaff as people prove loyalty standing firm amid bitter opposition, giving honest-hearted more opportunity to hear and accept.
Separation comes through the clear sharp testimony of living truth dividing half-hearted from humble devoted, wheat being humble devoted and chaff half-hearted, requiring yielding self-confidence, boasting and pride of talent, falling broken on the Rock, crucifying self and thorough transformation to stand faultless.ST Jun 26, 1884ST Oct 26, 1904 A coming test will separate faithful from unfaithful with wheat as true godliness and chaff as outward profession, so thorough that even brilliant people or seemingly faithful places may be swept away.RH Feb 22, 1912 The Lord sifts people separating found wheat from chaff, gathering those whose character is ripe while chaff is driven away and consumed, making holy living essential and raising whether each will be found wheat or chaff at judgment.RH Jun 19, 1866RH Apr 16, 1872
Christ tests and purges his floor gathering wheat and rejecting chaff by response to truth, with those rejecting teaching and turning away when corrected separated and their choice to walk no more not reversed.ST May 15, 1901 He separates faithful from false gathering wheat and removing chaff in the sifting when apostate leaders and false brethren are distinguished from true and hidden faithful revealed.RH Mar 16, 1916 He will examine and separate at his coming where genuine holiness endures testing while false profession is exposed, life's trials revealing what is in a person and final judgment bringing the full test.RH Jul 29, 1858
Christ's separating gives his work a judgment-day quality, so preachers should likewise have separating effect awakening opposition rather than remaining wholly popular.ST Jul 3, 1884 God's word through ministry is a winnowing instrument separating chaff from wheat, where faithful reproving preaching distinguishing unconverted from faithful has power that pleasing preaching loses.RH Aug 12, 1909 The Holy Spirit purifies and separates wheat from chaff in the latter-day harvest, refining the faithful like gold into a holy remnant while unbelief and sin are exposed, calling them out of spiritual Babylon and preparing a cleansed visible church for Christ's return.ST Those not filled with the Holy Spirit will be shaken out like chaff, so people must be sanctified by obedience to truth and brought into right relation to God to be ready for the latter rain.RH Dec 23, 1915
Scripture Echoes and Life
Christ at the end separates people as wheat is separated from chaff, gathering the righteous safely to his kingdom while destroying the wicked, the same division shown in the harvest of the earth and the vine cast into wrath, executed at his return when angels reap the earth and each person receives blessing or condemnation.RH Mar 12, 1857 Those who keep the commandments of God and have the faith of Jesus are gathered like wheat, while worshipers of the beast and its image are counted as chaff to be burned, for worshiping the beast violates God's commandments and brings his wrath, whereas keeping them draws the beast's oppressive power against the keepers.ST Jul 30, 1885 The same harvest separation, with wheat gathered and tares ripened for burning, describes the approaching day of the Lord in which Spiritualism ripens the tares and God's timely truths ripen the wheat for the garner.RH May 6, 1862
The Word of God is itself a fire that burns the chaff of the wicked, and false teaching and human imaginings are chaff while God's established Word is wheat that endures and will be the standard of judgment.ST May 23, 1911RH May 18, 1911 Wheat and chaff picture what is nourishing and true distinguished from what is worthless, applied to the difference between the nourishing teaching of God's Word and human opinions or creeds, which many fail to discern and so choose chaff though wheat is freely available.RH Dec 24, 1903 The Bible separates people like wheat from chaff, exposing differences and dividing the human family as gold from dross, bringing light to some and darkness to others according to reception, so believers are prepared for the heavenly garner while rejecters of truth face destruction.ST Dec 4, 1884ST May 1, 1907 That wheat-and-chaff distinction is the separation between God's faithful people who keep his commandments and opposers who break them and teach others to do so, and even slanderous reports can be used by God to help people recognize the difference.RH Sep 2, 1852
Like a fan separating wheat from chaff, God's law tests every life, exposing the heart, revealing dross, distinguishing those worthy to stand with God and receive eternal life from those who are not, with none escaping its test of who can dwell in his presence. Knowing God, receiving his Spirit, and being filled with his words enables a person to discern good from evil and separate what is good from what is worthless.ST Mar 1, 1899 Judgment will expose the true worth of deeds, so actions seeming good to others may prove worthless like chaff, warning against relying on one's own goodness for salvation, while Christ knows both the ill and the good and true in his children's works, winnowing chaff from wheat, rewarding each and owning their work, which brings wholesome fear yet also hope and joy because he discerns motive and blesses work even when marred by self.RH May 5, 1868ST Jan 14, 1897
The harvest tests what a life has produced, gathering useful fruit and discarding what is useless or harmful, and the fruit that counts is not showy conduct but patient submission, self-denial, secret good to others, and faithful obedience in public duty, so a life lived only for self bears no fruit and ends in ruin, with present life already showing what judgment will reveal.RH Jun 21, 1870ST Sep 9, 1875 Christ as harvester separates the fruitful from the unfruitful, gathering wheat into the garner and burning chaff with unquenchable fire, warning that bearers of no good fruit face destruction, and the final burning is the fate of what is dead and fruitless, like hypocritical branches cut from the Vine and gathered in bundles.ST Apr 8, 1903 He will fully cleanse his field by saving those in harmony with God and destroying the incorrigibly wicked who refuse such character and would cause endless discord, showing the death penalty for sin is not arbitrary because sin and death belong together and universal harmony after sin can be restored only by removing both through destruction.ST Nov 14, 1895 In that separation Christ exercises justice and mercy, gathering the righteous as wheat to safety and utterly destroying the wicked as chaff with unquenchable fire that brings them to an end, so wickedness and misery cease and death itself is destroyed, the burning being utter destruction of what proved worthless, not endless suffering.RH May 15, 1855ST Jul 10, 1893
The fire consumes hurtful thorns and tares and useless chaff and stubble, meaning self-conceited, self-righteous, self-seeking professed servants who do not devote themselves to his cause will not remain among the faithful.RH Jul 6, 1869 At the great harvest Christ gathers the fruitful and leaves barren professed Christians to burn with the chaff, for religious form is not fruit, and those whose faith is choked by cares, riches, or pleasures may keep attending church yet remain unfruitful.RH Jun 29, 1869 Professions of piety without genuine repentance and good fruit are like chaff destined for destruction, while justice, benevolence, mercy, and love of God mark commandment-keepers, without which religious claims do not secure the kingdom.ST Oct 18, 1877 Empty outward observance is chaff with no harvest value, for conformity to forms, ceremonies, and observances imposed by human law cannot preserve the soul, since genuine worship must come from the heart.ST May 24, 1905ST Apr 2, 1912
Chaff surrounding wheat is eventually separated by the fan and burned while wheat is gathered, the separation not final at first but coming in time, and persisted selfishness makes a person like chaff and dross that earth's cleansing fires will consume, leading from eternal life toward death.ST Apr 16, 1885RH Jan 30, 1908 Chaff shows the fate of those refusing the Lord and remaining on the enemy's side as temporary, to be burned in last-day fires, while servers of God are lasting treasure like an indestructible jewel, and the earth with its attractions is chaff that will pass, with only those hidden in Jesus victorious.RH Nov 30, 1905RH Jul 4, 1912 The final judgment separates those joined to Christ from those not, the faithful gathered for eternity while the unfruitful and backsliding are shut out from his presence, lose happiness forever, and are destroyed by unquenchable fire.RH Mar 20, 1866 Christ separates people as wheat from chaff, gathering wheat and burning chaff, which is the fate of those rejecting every ray of light and becoming useless like chaff on the floor.ST Dec 16, 1897 The wicked as chaff are worthless or harmful facing devouring fire while wheat is gathered, accompanying the truth that salvation is offered to all and the wicked are lost because they refuse it, not because God withholds it or irresistibly condemns them.RH Sep 21, 1869
All the earth is a grainfield and all history the growing of a harvest now nearing gathering, where wheat multiplies wheat for the garner while weeds give no promise of garner treasure, and the same fixed law rules men and nations so that broad sowing of folly, self-love, and willful living must ripen into a reaping of terror, hatred, shame, crime, and war as hosts crowd to the final day.ST Nov 29, 1899 Grain and chaff show good and evil dwelling together in the present world, which is a time of conflict not triumph continuing toward its close before brotherhood and peace are restored.RH Jun 25, 1914 That chaff perishes applies to the soul, which like a seed grows toward judgment if willed to grow but perishes if not.ST Sep 10, 1894 Wheat gathered and weeds burned shows burning prepares soil to bear more fruit, pointing to future renewal, a better spring and summer for the world.RH Aug 27, 1861
God's judgment separating gathered wheat from destroyed chaff is applied to wars and destruction among nations sifting humanity as warning of coming wrath and the seven last plagues, and every soul is on trial in the God-Satan conflict where each life shows the side chosen and only sound wheat remains.RH Feb 25, 1915 The separation pictures God's people brought out to stand firm for truth, and the day God settles accounts shows obeyers as wheat distinct from chaff.RH Feb 7, 1856RH Mar 25, 1873 In the gathering time the Lord separates wheat to be gathered from chaff to be burned with unquenchable fire, warning that feeders on what is worthless take its character and are counted with chaff, and that chaff sifted and blown away calls people to set affections above and use talents, influence, ability, and means in God's work rather than chiefly seeking wealth.RH Jul 16, 1901
Presuming to sift God's Word and decide what is wheat or chaff belongs to God, not fallible judges, and attempting it is rebellion that can sever from his family, whereas separating chaff from grain rightly pictures discernment by which wisdom sifts error from sound so good is retained and errors swept away to clear gain.ST Jan 30, 1901ST Nov 22, 1883RH Jan 3, 1865 Treating parts of the Bible as chaff to discard takes a place above God and is rejected, because the whole Bible is accepted as God's word needed to furnish thoroughly.RH Aug 21, 1913ST Jul 7, 1890 The same sorting applies to human creeds containing truth and error, whose false teachings will be separated and burned like tares while truth is gathered into ready hearts.RH Sep 5, 1912 Christianity is like wheat because it builds up and satisfies, while atheism is moral chaff offering only denial without goodness or comfort, and chaff mixed with wheat represents fraudulent counterfeits whose presence does not condemn genuine faith.
Wheat gathered images the faithful gathered to God, while bigotry reverses the separation with certainty, condemning wheat to the unquenchable fire of its hatred and storing chaff in its garner, hunting and punishing the brave and sincere who will not belie conviction and shutting them from public trust, while rewarding the knave and coward who professes whatever creed is safe with influence, power, and place.ST May 14, 1896 Churches are charged with reversing the picture by preserving chaff and straw while letting wheat go.RH Apr 25, 1871 The wicked gathered for burning while wheat is still to be gathered is applied to the wicked bound in secret societies and combinations, and people as wheat and chaff are separated by adversity, with precious grain remaining at the thresher's feet rather than flying against him like chaff.RH Dec 11, 1856ST Feb 3, 1887 Like grain at the thresher's feet, people should remain humble under adversity rather than react like chaff flying in the thresher's face.ST Sep 27, 1883
The cleansing is destruction of the wicked and every sinful thing preparing the kingdom to fill the earth, and the fire burning chaff consumes sin and those identifying with sin, not as a remedy restoring the unrepentant, so God's presence removes sin leaving the universe clean, and whether one is cleansed or cleansed away depends on attitude toward sin.RH Jun 2, 1904ST Aug 24, 1904 Judgment as winnowing means decisive crises expose and separate good from evil though importance may be recognized only after judgment has passed, for God's stern crises in the living present are beacon moments coming to every man and nation to decide for good or evil, darkness or light, driving earth's chaff from their feet with a choice going forever.ST Jul 9, 1912ST Dec 23, 1903 Moments of decision are divine winnowing between truth and falsehood whose full importance often becomes clear only after the choice has passed, warning that the choice is final and truth may seem defeated before vindication, with God's stern crises as winnowers from which earth's chaff must fly.ST Nov 28, 1900ST
Christ's coming is a work of judgment in which he comes with the fan to search thoroughly, discern the heart, test work with cleansing fire, separate and purify, bringing both punishment and blessing.ST Dec 21, 1882 Affliction is a furnace dividing gold from chaff, refining some like gold while many more are burned like chaff, and excessive sorrow burns piety by taking fervor, vigor for action, bodily health, light of reason, and repose of conscience.RH Dec 15, 1859 Fanning wheat from chaff patterns the peacemaker who retains good in others' words, confronts harmful speech directly, and lets the bad pass from memory, and the same separating pictures prayer in which requests are sifted with the worthwhile separated from chaff.RH Sep 2, 1862ST Jan 13, 1888 A sound kernel contrasted with chaff shows an heir of heaven should not shrink in shame before outsiders, just as healthy grain would not be abashed before chaff, since shrinking suggests a weak shriveled kernel.
Material possessions, honors, physical qualities, and harmful passions are like chaff not enduring beyond death, while wheat is spiritual and moral character formed by truth, honesty, fairness, generosity, and affection carried beyond the grave.RH Jul 1, 1873 Grain is precious to be housed while chaff is worthless to be burned, so housing chaff and burning grain is blind, hugging unusable wealth while lacking riches all may gain, and worldly wealth and labor made life's object instead of God's service are worthless at judgment like chaff fit only for last-day fires.ST Oct 31, 1900ST Jul 20, 1882 God estimates not by number but worth, so a bushel of wheat exceeds ten bushels of chaff, and he will not lose a grain, meaning every believer who obeys will be saved and valued, while unbelievers perish in unquenchable fire, so the gospel does not fail when few believe, just as eight in the ark outweighed millions perishing, its triumph being to save all who believe.RH Dec 24, 1872 The Lord thoroughly cleansing his floor, gathering wheat and burning chaff, explains why human greatness differs from God's judgment, for God sees what is truly valuable.ST Apr 28, 1898
The great Winnower gathers his harvest sweeping away as threshing-floor chaff those withholding compassion from the needy, and glory among the saints will soon purge all chaff, ending dull sameness, separating vile from true so the strong grow stronger as the refreshing nears, which all may come to.RH Dec 3, 1901RH Apr 28, 1859 Christ's coming as gathering brings salvation and loss, the faithful gathered to the heavenly garner while others face doom, making the end of sin a joy yet warning of grave unpreparedness and laying on seers of danger the duty to awaken others.RH Dec 10, 1903 The Lord thoroughly purging his floor and gathering wheat from chaff includes shaking what can be shaken, warning dishonorers who do not change face punishment while repenters may receive pity.RH Jan 12, 1911 Christ separates righteous from wicked, gathering the righteous to the garner and punishing the wicked, his harvest imagery applied to his coming when he reaps the earth, and as the mighty one announced by John he thoroughly purges his floor, gathers wheat to the storehouse, and burns chaff with unquenchable fire, showing authority to separate, gather, and judge.RH Sep 16, 1902RH Nov 19, 1908
Christ will judge separating people as wheat from chaff, gathering wheat and destroying chaff before lasting peace, which depends on truth and righteousness accomplished by God not human effort. The verse stands among prophetic texts describing the time of trouble when the claim that the Sabbath was made only for Jews collapses and many perish.RH Apr 28, 1853 The day of God separating gathered wheat from consumed chaff shows an advent theory lacking immortality through Christ alone to be an empty shell to be destroyed, with a little truth mixed with falsehood excusing none.RH Sep 19, 1871 God's people and church are grain in the world's field ripening for harvest when wheat is gathered to the garner and chaff with tares burned with unquenchable fire.ST Feb 14, 1884 Jesus as great High Priest holds the fan and thoroughly purges his floor, in the sanctuary cleansing caring for every jewel.RH Apr 7, 1851
Sources