AdventAI

Numbers 11:21

And Moses said, The people, among whom I am, are six hundred thousand footmen; and thou hast said, I will give them flesh, that they may eat a whole month.

King James Version

Translations

  • American King James Version

    And Moses said, The people, among whom I am, are six hundred thousand footmen; and you have said, I will give them flesh, that they may eat a whole month.

  • King James Version, Revised Version, American Standard Version

    And Moses said, The people, among whom I am, are six hundred thousand footmen; and thou hast said, I will give them flesh, that they may eat a whole month.

  • KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible

    And Moses said, The people, amongst whom I am, are six hundred thousand footmen; and thou hast said, I will give them flesh, that they may eat a whole month.

  • Webster Bible

    And Moses said, The people among whom I am, are six hundred thousand footmen; and thou hast said, I will give them flesh, that they may eat a whole month.

  • Young's Literal Translation

    And Moses saith, 'Six hundred thousand footmen [are] the people in whose midst I [am]; and Thou, Thou hast said, Flesh I give to them, and they have eaten, a month of days!

  • Darby Translation

    And Moses said, The people in whose midst I am are six hundred thousand footmen; and thou sayest, I will give them flesh that they may eat a whole month.

  • Rotherham's Emphasised Bible

    And Moses said, Six hundred thousand footmen, are the people in whose midst am, I, yet thou hast said—Flesh, will I give unto them, and they shall eat for a month of days.

  • Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible

    But Moses replied, “Here I am among 600,000 men on foot, yet You say, ‘ I will give them meat, and they will eat for a month.’

  • World English Bible

    Moses said, “ The people, among whom I am, are six hundred thousand men on foot; and you have said, ‘ I will give them meat, that they may eat a whole month.’

  • Bible in Basic English

    Then Moses said, The people, among whom I am, are six hundred thousand men on foot; and you have said, I will give them flesh to be their food for a month.

  • Geneva Bible

    And Moses saide, Six hundreth thousande footemen are there of the people, among whom I am: and thou saiest, I will giue them flesh, that they may eate a moneth long.

  • Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)

    And Moses said: There are six hundred thousand footmen of this people, and sayest thou: I will give them flesh to eat a whole month?

Commentary

Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.

Ellen G. White

10 sources

When the promise was made to give flesh for a whole month, Moses answered by pointing to the six hundred thousand footmen among whom he stood and asking how such provision could be made for so great a multitude.1SP 282.2Lt 103, 1896, par. 29–39SG4 16.2ST Aug 12, 1880PP 380.3–381.2 He did not trust that God would give the food that would best preserve health, for the people despised manna as angels' food that would have proved a blessing and cried for meat, so God gave them their own desire.Ms 38, 1898, par. 20–21 His questioning how enough flesh could be supplied for six hundred thousand men to eat for a whole month was distrust, and he was reproved for it.Lt 103, 1896, par. 29–39ST Aug 12, 1880PP 380.3–381.2

He pressed the question further by asking whether slaying the flocks and herds for them could suffice, or whether gathering all the fish of the sea for them could supply them.Lt 103, 1896, par. 29–39SG4 16.2PP 380.3–381.2 This came after it had been said they would eat not one day, nor two, nor five, nor ten, nor twenty days, but a whole month until it came out at their nostrils and became loathsome to them.SG4 16.2 The reason given was that they had despised the Lord who was among them and had wept before Him, asking why they had come out of Egypt.SG4 16.2

His words expressed distrust, and God reproved him by asking whether the Lord's hand had become too short and telling him he would now see whether His word would come to pass.Lt 103, 1896, par. 29–39SG4 16.2ST Aug 12, 1880PP 380.3–381.2 Divine power was affirmed to be not limited, and Moses was to see God's word fulfilled.SG4 16.2PP 380.3–381.2 The same God who had parted the Red Sea and sent manna and brought water from the rock could also provide meat.ST Aug 12, 1880

The demand for meat belonged to wilderness rebellion after God had led Israel out of Egypt to prove them and had taken them as His peculiar treasure.SG4 121.3–122.1 After witnessing His power and pledging to obey Him, they murmured against Moses and against God.PP 378.4–379.1SG4 121.3–122.1 With mourning and murmuring they longed for Egypt's flesh pots and were not satisfied even when God gave manna from heaven as angels' food.SG4 121.3–122.1Lt 224, 1908, par. 6–7 They despised that food that would have best preserved their health and proved a blessing, and cried for meat.Ms 38, 1898, par. 20–21SG4 121.3–122.1

God had not prohibited meat but had withheld it in great measure, while freely giving the healthy food He designed for them.SG4 121.3–122.1 He rained bread from heaven and gave purest water from the rock.SG4 121.3–122.1 With it stood the covenant promise to put no disease upon them if they obeyed in all things.SG4 121.3–122.1

In anger God granted their own desire and fulfilled His word by giving quails in abundance for a whole month to gratify their lustful appetite.Lt 103, 1896, par. 29–39SG4 121.3–122.1Lt 224, 1908, par. 6–7 Their rebellious appetite brought punishment, for while the flesh was still between their teeth plague came upon them destroying thousands.SG4 121.3–122.1Lt 224, 1908, par. 6–7 Great numbers died in the act of eating, and as they reaped the result of transgression the Lord did not work a miracle to preserve their life.SG4 121.3–122.1Lt 224, 1908, par. 6–7 The surrounding account also records judgment by fire against the complainers, showing the demand to be rebellion against God after the people had witnessed His power and pledged to obey Him.PP 378.4–379.1

God is displeased when appetite controls His people, and Israel at times preferred slavery and even death to being deprived of meat.SG4 121.3–122.1 Temperance in eating and drinking is therefore required, and health reform gives clearer minds to discern what affects the salvation of the soul.Lt 224, 1908, par. 6–7 Satan had used Israel's indulgence of appetite to overcome them, and boasted that this showed he could defeat even the Son of God and frustrate God's purpose to save humanity through Christ.LC1 136.2

Sources

  1. 1SP 282.2 Spirit of Prophecy Volume One — CHAPTER XXI. Ellen G. White, 1870
  2. Lt 103, 1896, par. 29–39 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 11 (1896) — Lt 103, 1896 Ellen G. White, written July 17, 1896
  3. SG4 16.2 Spiritual Gifts Volume Four — FACTS OF FAITH. Ellen G. White, 1864
  4. ST Aug 12, 1880 Signs of the Times, Vol. 6, No. 30 — General Articles Ellen G. White, August 12, 1880
  5. PP 380.3–381.2 Patriarchs and Prophets — FROM SINAI TO KADESH—33 Ellen G. White, 1890
  6. Ms 38, 1898, par. 20–21 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 13 (1898) — Ms 38, 1898 Ellen G. White, written March 11, 1898
  7. SG4 121.3–122.1 Spiritual Gifts Volume Four — CHAPTER XXXIX. Ellen G. White, 1864
  8. PP 378.4–379.1 Patriarchs and Prophets — FROM SINAI TO KADESH—33 Ellen G. White, 1890
  9. Lt 224, 1908, par. 6–7 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 23 (1908) — Lt 224, 1908 Ellen G. White, written June 24, 1908
  10. LC1 136.2 Life of Christ, Nos. 1 and 2 — THE TEMPTATION. Ellen G. White, 1874

Pioneers and periodicals

29 sources

Moses questioned how God could supply flesh for six hundred thousand footmen to eat for a whole month, even though God had said He would give it.STST Apr 22, 1889RH Nov 2, 1905 His words expressed doubt and distrust of God's power, and God reproved him for it, though the same God who had parted the Red Sea and sent manna and brought water from the rock could also provide meat.ST Aug 12, 1880 God fulfilled the promise by bringing quails from the sea and letting them fall around the camp a day's journey on each side, flying about three feet high so anyone could take as many as he chose.RH Jan 11, 1915 God had supplied manna because it was the simple, nourishing diet best for Israel and had withheld flesh for their good, so giving flesh for a whole month was not His original plan but was permitted only because of their repining and persistent demands.RH Jun 25, 1914RH Sep 22, 1904RH Dec 21, 1911ST Mar 3, 1914RH Dec 21, 1905 God gave them their request but sent leanness of soul, disease and a very great plague, making their experience a type warning later generations against lusting after evil things and letting appetite rule.ST Apr 22, 1889RH Mar 12, 1867RH Jul 10, 1916RH Apr 9, 1867

Setting and Plain Sense

Moses asked how flesh could be supplied for six hundred thousand footmen traveling with him to eat for a whole month, even though God had said He would give it.STST Apr 22, 1889RH Nov 2, 1905RH Feb 16, 1911 His answer to the great promise carried implied doubt, questioning how so great a supply could be provided for so many men.ST Apr 22, 1889RH Nov 2, 1905RH Feb 16, 1911 The words expressed distrust of God's power, and God reproved him by reminding him that His power had not failed.ST Aug 12, 1880 The same God who had parted the Red Sea, sent manna, and brought water from the rock could also provide meat for Israel.ST Aug 12, 1880

The verse belongs to the second giving of quails, a year after the first giving in the Wilderness of Sin when quails came at evening and manna fell the next morning.ST Apr 22, 1889 The craving began after the mixed multitude became weary of the manna.ST Apr 22, 1889 That multitude was an amalgamation of Egyptian and Israelitish blood who left Egypt through fear, and they fell a lusting for fish and cucumbers and melons and leeks and onions and garlic.ST Apr 22, 1889 Those were strong pungent plants regarded as sacred and used in licentious idolatrous feasts to stimulate appetite and overindulgence and to excite the baser passions.ST Apr 22, 1889

God fulfilled the promise for a whole month by bringing quails from the sea and letting them fall by the camp a day's journey on each side, over about forty miles across.RH Jan 11, 1915 The two cubits means the quails flew about three feet high above the face of the earth where anyone could take as many as he chose, not packed solid three feet deep on the ground.RH Jan 11, 1915 The Israelites ate them for a full month.RH Jan 11, 1915 The verse stands in the account of Israel's murmuring, the appointment of the seventy elders, the quails, and the plague that followed.ST Feb 17, 1909

The verse shows Moses complaining of his excessive burdens in leading Israel.RH Mar 22, 1870 The people were one whose complaints and demands tested trust in God.RH Jun 26, 1860 The Lord relieved him by bidding him gather seventy men of the elders of Israel to the tabernacle, then coming down and taking of the Spirit that was upon Moses to endow the whole company of seventy.RH Mar 22, 1870 This sharing testifies to the great gifts and graces Moses possessed, yet Moses suffered great loss in it.RH Mar 22, 1870 God gives great grace when He calls to great labors, and it is wiser to cheerfully bear heavy burdens than to meet the loss of such divine help.RH Mar 22, 1870

After the people greedily ate the quail sent by God, a very great plague struck them and many were slain.ST May 6, 1913RH Jul 25, 1907 They blamed Moses for not warning them of the outcome, though the judgment came from God.RH Jul 25, 1907 The place was named Kibroth-hattaavah, meaning graves of lust, so the name would recall their sin and lead them to humility.ST May 6, 1913 Through disobedience and continued murmuring God's protecting care was withdrawn, they wandered in the wilderness, and the generation that left Egypt died there and did not enter the promised land, except for Caleb and Joshua and the children.RH Apr 17, 1879 Of that generation that came out of Egypt, numbered at six hundred thousand men, only two entered the promised land, while the rest disbelieved God and died in the wilderness.RH Apr 17, 1879RH Jan 21, 1909

Diet and Divine Provision

God had rained bread from heaven for Israel because that simple, nourishing manna was best for them, and He had withheld flesh for their good.RH Sep 22, 1904RH Dec 21, 1911ST Mar 3, 1914RH Apr 9, 1867 Flesh formed no part of man's dietary before sin, it is not man's natural food nor the food on which he should subsist, and it formed no part of the food God provided for His people after calling them out of Egypt.RH Jun 25, 1914RH Dec 21, 1911 His giving of flesh for a whole month was not His original and eternal plan or preferred choice, but was permitted only in consequence of their repining, murmuring, and persistent complaints and demands, even though it was not the food most beneficial to them.RH Jun 25, 1914ST Mar 3, 1914RH Dec 21, 1905 Granting the desire did not make it the best choice.RH Dec 21, 1905

Israel received quail only after asking for flesh and refusing and failing to accept the manna God had provided, rejecting His wisdom about food.STRH Sep 22, 1904 Their appetite and longing for Egypt's food were stronger than reason and gratitude.ST Feb 14, 1911RH Sep 22, 1904 God gave them their request but sent leanness of soul.ST Apr 22, 1889RH Jul 10, 1916RH Dec 21, 1905 Discontent with a simple, nourishing diet brought leanness to their souls, and eating the flesh brought corruption and bodily distress, disease and spiritual leanness, and a curse, so that they suffered the results of their intemperance and the danger of giving appetite its way was shown.RH Jul 10, 1916ST Mar 3, 1914RH Apr 9, 1867RH Dec 21, 1905RH Sep 15, 1874

Later a distinction between clean and unclean beasts was made to safeguard health on physiological grounds.RH Jun 25, 1914 The quails were a painful lesson that God knew best how to provide for His people and how they should be led, and the lesson was intended for their good and remains a warning against murmuring.RH Jun 20, 1871 He still calls people to learn what is good and choose it willingly.RH Dec 21, 1905

Warning for Later Believers

Israel's craving for flesh though fed with manna was sinful rebellion and displeasing to God, showing failure in self-denial and control of appetite, and it brought divine displeasure and the death of thousands.RH Mar 12, 1867RH Nov 2, 1905 Even after the manna had repeatedly testified to the Sabbath, the people treated that miraculous provision as common and complained about the food supplied, revealing hardened disregard for God's testimony.RH Jan 7, 1862 That murmuring belongs to the record of unbelief and hardness of heart.RH Feb 28, 1907

Israel kept looking back and desiring what had been left behind, until the promised land of milk and honey was eclipsed by fancied hardships and lusts of the heart, doubting both God's promises of the land and His power to supply present need.ST Apr 22, 1889 He who begins the Christian life and keeps looking back with longing for things left behind does the same, showing a divided, double-minded and unstable heart lacking faith and consecration, prizing earth above heaven and temporal things above eternal, like Lot's wife looking back with longing for Sodom.ST Apr 22, 1889 No man putting his hand to the plow and looking back is fit for the kingdom, for looking shows interest and a divided heart.ST Apr 22, 1889 The only direction to look is unto Jesus, with anxiety for eternal life rather than for perishing food and drink, seeking first the kingdom of God and His righteousness with all needed things added, since any other way to earthly prosperity brings leanness of soul.ST Apr 22, 1889

Their experience stands as a type for later generations.RH Mar 12, 1867 It warns against lusting after evil things, for their craving was granted yet brought disease and spiritual leanness.RH Mar 12, 1867RH Dec 21, 1905 It warns against giving appetite its way, for their craving brought a curse upon them.RH Sep 15, 1874 It warns that gratifying a perverted appetite can lead to sin and death. Their peevishness, fretfulness and murmuring under trial are sins viewed seriously by God.RH Jun 26, 1860 That painful lesson that God knew best how to provide for His people and how they should be led was intended for their good and remains a warning against murmuring and against doubting God when difficulties arise.RH Jun 26, 1860RH Feb 28, 1907RH Jun 20, 1871

Because Israel persisted and would have flesh for a whole month even against His will when He did not want them to have it, He permitted what they demanded and it spelled disaster.RH Jan 29, 1914 The same will prove true if churches persist in demanding what God has refused and get the state to give it to them.RH Jan 29, 1914 In this account Moses, Caleb and Joshua urge the people to abandon animal flesh as food.RH Nov 2, 1905

Sources

  1. ST Signs of the Times, Vol. 30, No. 35 — FLESH DIET
  2. ST Apr 22, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 16 — UNBELIEF AND ITS PUNISHMENT April 22, 1889
  3. RH Nov 2, 1905 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 82, No. 44 — Why Abstain From Meat? D. H. Kress, Thursday, November 2, 1905
  4. ST Aug 12, 1880 Signs of the Times, Vol. 6, No. 30 — General Articles Ellen G. White, August 12, 1880
  5. RH Jan 11, 1915 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 92, No. 2 — The Inspiration of the Bible[^1] H. L. Hastings, January 11, 1915
  6. RH Jun 25, 1914 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 91, No. 26 — Questions and Answers Editor, Thursday, June 25, 1914
  7. RH Sep 22, 1904 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 81, No. 38 — Flesh Diet September 22, 1904
  8. RH Dec 21, 1911 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 88, No. 51 — Note and Comment December 21, 1911
  9. ST Mar 3, 1914 Signs of the Times, Vol. 41, No. 8 — 4270 — EATING FLESH March 3, 1914
  10. RH Dec 21, 1905 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 82, No. 51 — A Fleshless Diet From a Biblical and Christian Standpoint D. H. KRESS, M. D., December 21, 1905
  11. ST Apr 22, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 16 — NOTE Milton C. Wilcox, April 22, 1889
  12. RH Mar 12, 1867 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 29, No. 14 — The Sermon Stephen Pierce, March 12, 1867
  13. RH Jul 10, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 34 — Health and Temperance July 10, 1916
  14. RH Apr 9, 1867 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 29, No. 18 — The Sermon Eld. James White, Third-day, April 9, 1867
  15. RH Feb 16, 1911 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 88, No. 7 — The Sanhedrin George I. Butler, February 16, 1911
  16. ST Feb 17, 1909 Signs of the Times, Vol. 36, No. 7 — Suggestive Notes Editor, February 17, 1909
  17. RH Mar 22, 1870 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 35, No. 14 — Moses and the Burden of Leadership Third-day, March 22, 1870
  18. RH Jun 26, 1860 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 16, No. 6 — EXTRACT FROM "PROVISION FOR PASSIng over JORDAN." Dr. Scudder, June 26, 1860
  19. ST May 6, 1913 Signs of the Times, Vol. 40, No. 18 — Graves of Lust May 6, 1913
  20. RH Jul 25, 1907 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 84, No. 30 — The Rebellion of Korah, Dathan, and Abiram J. W. Westphal, July 25, 1907
  21. RH Apr 17, 1879 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 53, No. 16 — A PECULIAR PEOPLE J. N. Ayers, April 17, 1879
  22. RH Jan 21, 1909 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 86, No. 3 — Human Wrecks S. N. HASKELL, January 21, 1909
  23. ST Feb 14, 1911 Signs of the Times, Vol. 38, No. 7 — OUR BIBLE BAND February 14, 1911
  24. RH Dec 21, 1905 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 82, No. 51 — A Fleshless Diet From a Biblical and Christian Standpoint D. H. KRESS, M. D., December 21, 1905
  25. RH Sep 15, 1874 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 44, No. 13 — Scriptures Perverted J. H. Waggoner, September 15, 1874
  26. RH Jun 20, 1871 Review and Herald, Vol. 38, No. 1 — Mutual Obligation James White, June 20, 1871
  27. RH Jan 7, 1862 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 19, No. 6 — History of the Sabbath John Nevins Andrews, Third-Day, January 7, 1862
  28. RH Feb 28, 1907 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 84, No. 9 — Clipped from Conference Papers Elder T. H. Jeys, February 28, 1907
  29. RH Jan 29, 1914 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 91, No. 5 — Power From the Wrong Source C. M. S., January 29, 1914

Cross-references

  1. Numbers 11:31-33

    And there went forth a wind from the LORD, and brought quails from the sea, and let them fall by the camp, as it were a day’s journey on this side, and as it were a day’s journey on the other side, round about the camp, and as it were two cubits high upon the face of the earth.

    Quail are provided in abundance after the people demand flesh, followed by a plague.

  2. Exodus 16:4

    Then said the LORD unto Moses, Behold, I will rain bread from heaven for you; and the people shall go out and gather a certain rate every day, that I may prove them, whether they will walk in my law, or no.

    God supplied Israel with bread from heaven in the wilderness.

  3. 1 Corinthians 10:6

    Now these things were our examples, to the intent we should not lust after evil things, as they also lusted.

    Israel’s craving for flesh warns against lusting after evil things.

  4. Psalms 78:27-31

    He rained flesh also upon them as dust, and feathered fowls like as the sand of the sea:

    God gave Israel flesh in abundance, then sent wrath upon them.

  5. Numbers 11:4

    And the mixt multitude that was among them fell a lusting: and the children of Israel also wept again, and said, Who shall give us flesh to eat?

    The people’s craving for flesh begins the account.

  6. Psalms 78:27-29

    He rained flesh also upon them as dust, and feathered fowls like as the sand of the sea:

    God’s promise to give the people flesh is fulfilled with quails.

  7. Numbers 11:13

    Whence should I have flesh to give unto all this people? for they weep unto me, saying, Give us flesh, that we may eat.

    Moses asks how he can provide flesh for the people.

  8. Psalms 78:19-20

    Yea, they spake against God; they said, Can God furnish a table in the wilderness?

    Israel questioned whether God could provide meat in the wilderness.

  9. Psalms 106:14-15

    But lusted exceedingly in the wilderness, and tempted God in the desert.

    Israel’s craving in the wilderness was granted, but brought leanness to their soul.

  10. Numbers 11:31

    And there went forth a wind from the LORD, and brought quails from the sea, and let them fall by the camp, as it were a day’s journey on this side, and as it were a day’s journey on the other side, round about the camp, and as it were two cubits high upon the face of the earth.

    promise fulfilled with quails

  11. Exodus 16:12-13

    I have heard the murmurings of the children of Israel: speak unto them, saying, At even ye shall eat flesh, and in the morning ye shall be filled with bread; and ye shall know that I am the LORD your God.

    An earlier provision of quail and bread contrasts with the promise of flesh for a month.

  12. Psalms 105:40

    The people asked, and he brought quails, and satisfied them with the bread of heaven.

    God provides the people with the promised food.

  13. Psalms 78:30-31

    They were not estranged from their lust. But while their meat was yet in their mouths,

    Their craving persisted, and judgment followed.

  14. Numbers 11:34

    And he called the name of that place Kibroth-hattaavah: because there they buried the people that lusted.

    The people who craved meat were buried at Kibroth-hattaavah.

  15. 1 Corinthians 10:10-11

    Neither murmur ye, as some of them also murmured, and were destroyed of the destroyer.

    Israel’s murmuring and destruction warn later believers.