Numbers 11:13
Whence should I have flesh to give unto all this people? for they weep unto me, saying, Give us flesh, that we may eat.
Translations
From where should I have flesh to give to all this people? for they weep to me, saying, Give us flesh, that we may eat.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Revised Version, American Standard Version
Whence should I have flesh to give unto all this people? for they weep unto me, saying, Give us flesh, that we may eat.
Whence should I have flesh to give to all this people? for they weep to me, saying, Give us flesh, that we may eat.
Whence have I flesh to give to all this people? for they weep unto me, saying, Give to us flesh, and we eat.
Whence should I have flesh to give unto all this people? for they weep unto me, saying, Give us flesh that we may eat!
Whence should, I, have flesh to give to all this people,—for they keep weeping by me saying, Oh give us flesh that we may eat!
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Where can I get meat for all these people? For they keep crying out to me, ‘ Give us meat to eat!’
Where could I get meat to give all these people? For they weep before me, saying, ‘ Give us meat, that we may eat.’
Where am I to get flesh to give to all this people? For they are weeping to me and saying, Give us flesh for our food.
Where should I haue flesh to giue vnto al this people? for they weepe vnto me, saying, Giue vs flesh that we may eate.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Whence should I have flesh to give to so great a multitude? they weep against me, saying: Give us flesh that we may eat.
Cross-references
- Numbers 11:4-6
And the mixt multitude that was among them fell a lusting: and the children of Israel also wept again, and said, Who shall give us flesh to eat?
The people’s craving and complaints over food prompt Moses’s question.
- Numbers 11:33
And while the flesh was yet between their teeth, ere it was chewed, the wrath of the LORD was kindled against the people, and the LORD smote the people with a very great plague.
The meat is provided, then a deadly judgment falls.
- Exodus 16:4
Then said the LORD unto Moses, Behold, I will rain bread from heaven for you; and the people shall go out and gather a certain rate every day, that I may prove them, whether they will walk in my law, or no.
God gives Israel manna in the wilderness.
- Numbers 11:18-20
And say thou unto the people, Sanctify yourselves against to morrow, and ye shall eat flesh: for ye have wept in the ears of the LORD, saying, Who shall give us flesh to eat? for it was well with us in Egypt: therefore the LORD will give you flesh, and ye shall eat.
God answers the demand for flesh and warns of its consequences.
- Psalms 106:14-15
But lusted exceedingly in the wilderness, and tempted God in the desert.
God granted Israel’s craving for meat but sent leanness to their souls.
- Psalms 78:24-25
And had rained down manna upon them to eat, and had given them of the corn of heaven.
Describes the heavenly food God gave Israel.
- 1 Corinthians 10:6
Now these things were our examples, to the intent we should not lust after evil things, as they also lusted.
Israel’s craving for food warns against lusting after evil things.
- Psalms 78:18-21
And they tempted God in their heart by asking meat for their lust.
Israel demands meat and doubts that God can provide it.
- Exodus 16:3
And the children of Israel said unto them, Would to God we had died by the hand of the LORD in the land of Egypt, when we sat by the flesh pots, and when we did eat bread to the full; for ye have brought us forth into this wilderness, to kill this whole assembly with hunger.
Israel complained about food and longed for Egypt’s flesh pots.
- Psalms 78:30-32
They were not estranged from their lust. But while their meat was yet in their mouths,
Israel’s craving for flesh leads to sin and judgment.
- 1 Corinthians 10:10-11
Neither murmur ye, as some of them also murmured, and were destroyed of the destroyer.
Israel’s murmuring and destruction serve as an example and warning for later believers.
- Numbers 11:21-23
And Moses said, The people, among whom I am, are six hundred thousand footmen; and thou hast said, I will give them flesh, that they may eat a whole month.
Moses doubts God’s provision, and God rebukes his distrust.
- Exodus 16:12-14
I have heard the murmurings of the children of Israel: speak unto them, saying, At even ye shall eat flesh, and in the morning ye shall be filled with bread; and ye shall know that I am the LORD your God.
contrasts first giving with second in Numbers 11
- Numbers 11:31
And there went forth a wind from the LORD, and brought quails from the sea, and let them fall by the camp, as it were a day’s journey on this side, and as it were a day’s journey on the other side, round about the camp, and as it were two cubits high upon the face of the earth.
The people’s request for flesh is granted with abundant quails.
- Psalms 105:40
The people asked, and he brought quails, and satisfied them with the bread of heaven.
identifies the first giving of quails
- Numbers 11:34
And he called the name of that place Kibroth-hattaavah: because there they buried the people that lusted.
Names the burial place of those who lusted after flesh.
- Numbers 11:1-3
And when the people complained, it displeased the LORD: and the LORD heard it; and his anger was kindled; and the fire of the LORD burnt among them, and consumed them that were in the uttermost parts of the camp.
Judgment fell on Israel amid their murmuring.
- Exodus 16:15
And when the children of Israel saw it, they said one to another, It is manna: for they wist not what it was. And Moses said unto them, This is the bread which the LORD hath given you to eat.
Manna was provided, but meat was not part of the wilderness provision.
- Deuteronomy 8:3
And he humbled thee, and suffered thee to hunger, and fed thee with manna, which thou knewest not, neither did thy fathers know; that he might make thee know that man doth not live by bread only, but by every word that proceedeth out of the mouth of the LORD doth man live.
Israel depends on food God provides in the wilderness.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
9 sources
The question is asked when the people press their demand for flesh upon Moses with weeping, family by family, each at the door of his tent.PP 379.3–380.1SG4 16.1ST Aug 12, 1880 They weep throughout their families and complain for flesh, bringing their demand to him in weeping complaint.PP 379.3–380.1SG4 16.1
Their demand springs from lust and discontent, from dissatisfaction and an unsubmissive spirit.PP 378.4–379.1SG4 121.3–122.1SG4 16.1 Though God had given them manna from heaven with other healthy food and water in the wilderness, they long for the meat of Egypt.SG4 121.3–122.1Lt 224, 1908, par. 6–7 Their craving challenges whether God can provide for them in the wilderness.PP 378.4–379.1 After they have witnessed His power and mercy and have covenanted to obey Him, their murmuring is rebellion and transgression.PP 378.4–379.1SG4 121.3–122.1Lt 224, 1908, par. 6–7 It is a complaint against Moses and against God Himself, and a failure of temperance in eating and drinking.SG4 121.3–122.1SG4 16.1Lt 224, 1908, par. 6–7
Moses' question expresses his distress at being expected to find flesh to give to all this people and his sense of being overwhelmed by the responsibility laid upon him.PP 379.3–380.1Lt 103, 1896, par. 29–39SG4 16.1 He has been placed toward the people as a nursing father who must make their sufferings his own.SG4 16.1 He feels his weakness under a great work committed to him as to no other man.SG4 19.2 He is burdened by continually witnessing their disobedience and hearing their murmurings against his commands and against God, a load too heavy for him to bear alone.PP 379.3–380.1SG4 16.1ST Aug 12, 1880
In laying the difficulty before the Lord he is displeased and grieved.SG4 16.1 He is grieved that by perverseness Israel is drawing judgments upon themselves while the enemies of God rejoice at their destruction, so that he would rather die than see it.SG4 16.1 He turns to God for help, yet his prayer has nearly become a complaint.Lt 103, 1896, par. 29–39ST Aug 12, 1880 It reflects his own murmuring and temptation to distrust God rather than full trust, as the complaints make his burden feel unbearable and bring him close to distrust.Lt 103, 1896, par. 29–39ST Aug 12, 1880
The Lord answers by arranging for seventy elders and judges to be appointed to share the burden with him.PP 379.3–380.1SG4 19.2 Aaron and Miriam oppose this, reasoning that because they were chosen to aid Moses and the Lord had spoken by them as well as by Moses, they already bear the work with him and there is no need for the seventy.SG4 19.2 Yet Aaron had shown weakness by yielding to the people and making a molten calf in Moses' absence, while God had ever been Moses' counselor.SG4 19.2
God then gives the people flesh in anger to satisfy their appetite, providing quails in abundance for the vast multitude.SG4 121.3–122.1Lt 224, 1908, par. 6–7 He lets them reap the result without working a miracle to preserve life.Lt 224, 1908, par. 6–7 He sends a plague that destroys thousands while the meat is still in their mouths, and many die while eating it.SG4 121.3–122.1Lt 224, 1908, par. 6–7 Through appetite Satan overcomes them, so that nearly all who left Egypt die in the wilderness instead of entering Canaan.SG4 121.3–122.1LC1 136.2
The experience warns against letting appetite control obedience to God.SG4 121.3–122.1 It teaches that craving flesh meat brings disease and death.Lt 224, 1908, par. 6–7 Health reform and temperance are needed to keep the mind clear to discern what affects the salvation of the soul.Lt 224, 1908, par. 6–7
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
27 sources
Moses cries out under the unbearable burden of leading millions of weeping people who demand flesh for food, asking where he could possibly obtain it for them all.ST Aug 12, 1880RH Mar 22, 1870RH Jul 17, 1860 The cry belongs to the second giving of quails, after God had fed Israel with manna from heaven, when the mixed multitude grew weary of plain food and lusted for the fish and pungent foods of Egypt.ST Apr 22, 1889STST May 6, 1913RH Sep 22, 1904ST Feb 20, 1912 Their weeping demand was lust of appetite and rebellion, dissatisfaction with God's provision, unbelief in His promises and power, and longing to live as in Egypt rather than press toward the promised land.ST Apr 22, 1889STRH Apr 17, 1879 God granted their persistent desire yet sent leanness of soul, disease and plague, so that many fell and the place was called Kibroth-hattaavah, the graves of lust, as a lasting reminder of murmuring against Him.RH Apr 17, 1879ST May 6, 1913RH Jul 25, 1907 It warns Christians not to rebel, complain or look back when God disciplines by trial, but to deny appetite and seek eternal things, for flesh was never man's natural food nor part of God's original plan but was allowed in the desert only as a concession to murmuring.ST Apr 22, 1889RH Jun 25, 1914RH Jun 26, 1860RH Mar 12, 1867RH Dec 21, 1911
Moses's Burden and Setting
The cry is Moses asking where he is to find flesh to give to all the weeping people who demand it, a complaint of excessive burden in leading Israel.ST Aug 12, 1880RH Mar 22, 1870 With responsibility for three million people the burden felt unbearable amid seeming lack of appreciation, bringing him near distrust as he turned to God for help with murmuring mixed into his prayer.ST Aug 12, 1880RH Jul 17, 1860 Looking at himself and his inability to supply what was demanded, he questioned his work and felt set aside and forgotten in the same temporary despondency and depression later known by John the Baptist in prison. Yet his devotion still fitted the mind for action amid heavy responsibilities.RH Jul 17, 1860
Because of that complaint he was told to gather seventy elders of Israel to the tabernacle, and the Spirit that was upon Moses was taken to endow the whole company of seventy.RH Mar 22, 1870 This testifies to the great gifts and graces Moses possessed and proves that when God calls to great labors He gives great grace.RH Mar 22, 1870 It also shows Moses suffered great loss of divine help when the Spirit was divided, so it is wiser to cheerfully bear heavy burdens than to lose such help.RH Mar 22, 1870
The cry belongs to the second giving of quails, a year after the first giving in the Wilderness of Sin when quails came at evening before manna fell in the morning.ST Apr 22, 1889 It comes after the directions for blowing the trumpets and marching of the hosts and stands with speaking against Moses and the searching of the land and the reports of the spies, during the journey from Egypt to Canaan.ST May 6, 1913ST Feb 20, 1912 At that time the mixed multitude of Egyptian and Israelite blood who left Egypt through fear grew weary of manna and fell a lusting for fish and cucumbers and melons and leeks and onions and garlic.ST Apr 22, 1889 Those were strong pungent plants used in licentious idolatrous feasts to stimulate appetite and overindulgence and excite the baser passions.ST Apr 22, 1889
It comes after God had provided manna, bread from heaven, and corn, simple and nourishing food which the people refused and complained against.STRH Sep 22, 1904RH Dec 21, 1911 Even that repeated miracle became ordinary to Israel, hardened them in sin, and they paid little heed to the manna's testimony about the Sabbath.RH Jan 7, 1862 Appetite and habit made Egypt's flesh-pots more enticing than the corn God provided.ST Feb 14, 1911
The Lord brought quails from the sea and let them fall by the camp a day's journey on each side, over about forty miles across.RH Jan 11, 1915 The two cubits high means the quails flew about three feet high above the earth within reach where anyone could take as many as he chose, not that dead birds lay packed solid three feet deep.RH Jan 11, 1915 Israel ate them for a full month, though bodies accustomed to manna were unprepared for flesh which spoiled in them and caused distress.RH Jan 11, 1915RH Apr 9, 1867
Flesh, Judgment, and Warning
Flesh food is not man's natural food nor the food he should live on, for it formed no part of the original diet given to the race and no part of God's own provision for leading Israel to Canaan.RH Jun 25, 1914RH Dec 21, 1911 God's own provision was bread from heaven, simple and nourishing food, and meat in the desert was allowed only as a concession to repining and murmuring, not as part of God's original and eternal plan.RH Jun 25, 1914RH Dec 21, 1911ST Mar 3, 1914 God had withheld meat for their good, but gave it after persistent demands, and appetite is not proof that flesh is best but a morbid desire that can lead to harm.ST Mar 3, 1914ST Jun 10, 1875
The weeping demand for flesh was lust of appetite, dissatisfaction with and refusal of the simple food God provided, complaint against it, unbelief and hardness of heart, rebellion and perverted appetite for self-gratification.ST Apr 22, 1889RH Sep 22, 1904RH Mar 12, 1867RH Feb 28, 1907 The people longed for the food eaten in Egypt and wanted to live as before, continually looking back and letting fancied hardships and lusts eclipse the promised land of milk and honey.ST Apr 22, 1889RH Apr 17, 1879 They doubted God's promises of the land and His power to supply present need, living to eat rather than eating to live until appetite overcame reason, and refusing to remain separate from the world.ST Apr 22, 1889RH Apr 17, 1879 They were unwilling to accept God's wisdom about their food, and quails were supplied only after they cried for flesh.STRH Sep 22, 1904
God granted their persistent desire but sent leanness of soul, disease, and distress from intemperance.ST Apr 22, 1889RH Jul 10, 1916ST Mar 3, 1914RH Dec 21, 1905 They ate greedily and were struck by a great plague in which many were slain and thousands fell under the curse.ST May 6, 1913RH Jul 25, 1907 The place was called Kibroth-hattaavah, meaning graves of lust, an unpleasant reminder ever to recall their sin and lead to humility.ST May 6, 1913 Their murmuring led to withdrawal of protecting care and perishing in the wilderness, and they blamed Moses for not warning them and saw the sentence to die in the wilderness as his arbitrary decision.RH Apr 17, 1879RH Jul 25, 1907
The quails taught the murmuring people that God knew best how to lead and provide, a lesson meant to warn later generations that when they will not learn through love and prosperity God can teach submission through painful judgments and adversity.RH Jun 20, 1871 The passage presents God permitting people to eat what they desire while still wanting them to learn to choose what is good.RH Dec 21, 1905
The conduct reveals how God views a peevish, fretful, murmuring spirit and warns Christians not to rebel, complain, doubt, or give way to discouragement when God permits wilderness trials, afflictions, and pain as discipline for sanctification.RH Jun 26, 1860RH Feb 28, 1907RH Jun 20, 1871 It warns those starting the Christian life not to look back with longing like Lot's wife looking to Sodom, which shows a divided, double-minded, unstable heart lacking faith and consecration that prizes earth above heaven and temporal above eternal and gains earthly prosperity only at leanness of soul.ST Apr 22, 1889 Instead the only direction to look is unto Jesus, seeking first the kingdom and righteousness with anxiety for eternal life rather than perishing food and drink.ST Apr 22, 1889 Denying self and training appetite to plain food would have preserved obedience and favor, since what is eaten and drunk can defile and ruin for time and eternity and flesh eating can be sinful under certain circumstances.RH Mar 12, 1867
The weeping demand also means persisting in demanding something Jehovah has heard and refused, then determining to have it whether God wants it or not and getting it without Him by compelling another power to give it.RH Jan 29, 1914 When people insist on what God has denied He may permit it, but having it against His will spells disaster, as it will prove for those who get the state to answer prayers Jehovah refused to answer.RH Jan 29, 1914
Moses joined Caleb and Joshua in urging the people in their rebellion to abandon animal flesh as food.RH Nov 2, 1905 As God prepares a people for the heavenly Canaan it is better to conform diet to the original vegetable plan belonging to His unchanging purpose.RH Jun 25, 1914
Sources