Numbers 14:27
How long shall I bear with this evil congregation, which murmur against me? I have heard the murmurings of the children of Israel, which they murmur against me.
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible, Revised Version
How long shall I bear with this evil congregation, which murmur against me? I have heard the murmurings of the children of Israel, which they murmur against me.
How long shall I bear with this evil congregation, that murmur against me? I have heard the murmurings of the children of Israel, which they murmur against me.
'Until when hath this evil company that which they are murmuring against Me? the murmurings of the sons of Israel, which they are murmuring against Me, I have heard;
How long [ shall I bear] with this evil assembly, which murmur against me? I have heard the murmurings of the children of Israel, which they murmur against me.
How long, as regardeth this evil assembly, are they to be murmuring against me? The murmuring of the sons of Israel which, they, have been murmuring against me, have I heard,
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
“ How long will this wicked congregation grumble against Me? I have heard the complaints that the Israelites are making against Me.
“ How long shall I bear with this evil congregation that complain against me? I have heard the complaints of the children of Israel, which they complain against me.
How long am I to put up with this evil people and their outcries against me? The words which they say against me have come to my ears.
How long shall I suffer this wicked multitude to murmure against me? I haue heard the murmurings of the children of Israel, which they murmure against me.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
How long doth this wicked multitude murmur against me? I have heard the murmurings of the children of Israel.
Cross-references 20 of 43
- Numbers 14:2
And all the children of Israel murmured against Moses and against Aaron: and the whole congregation said unto them, Would God that we had died in the land of Egypt! or would God we had died in this wilderness!
Israel’s complaint after the spies’ report begins the rebellion behind the verse.
- Numbers 13:30
And Caleb stilled the people before Moses, and said, Let us go up at once, and possess it; for we are well able to overcome it.
contrasts Caleb's bold stand with murmuring congregation
- Numbers 14:34
After the number of the days in which ye searched the land, even forty days, each day for a year, shall ye bear your iniquities, even forty years, and ye shall know my breach of promise.
Forty years of bearing iniquity answer the forty days spent searching the land.
- Hebrews 3:16-19
For some, when they had heard, did provoke: howbeit not all that came out of Egypt by Moses.
Israel’s rebellion and unbelief kept them from entering the promised land.
- Numbers 14:10
But all the congregation bade stone them with stones. And the glory of the LORD appeared in the tabernacle of the congregation before all the children of Israel.
The people’s attempt to stone Joshua and Caleb expresses their rebellion against God.
- 1 Corinthians 10:10-11
Neither murmur ye, as some of them also murmured, and were destroyed of the destroyer.
Israel’s wilderness murmuring and destruction warn later believers as an example.
- Numbers 13:31-33
But the men that went up with him said, We be not able to go up against the people; for they are stronger than we.
The spies’ fearful report preceded Israel’s rebellion and murmuring against God.
- Numbers 14:8-9
If the LORD delight in us, then he will bring us into this land, and give it us; a land which floweth with milk and honey.
Caleb and Joshua trusted the Lord to bring Israel into the land and urged them not to fear.
- Numbers 14:36-37
And the men, which Moses sent to search the land, who returned, and made all the congregation to murmur against him, by bringing up a slander upon the land,
The spies who stirred Israel to murmur died by plague before the LORD.
- Deuteronomy 1:26-40
Notwithstanding ye would not go up, but rebelled against the commandment of the LORD your God:
Recounts Israel’s refusal to enter the land and the resulting delay.
- Hebrews 4:1-3
Let us therefore fear, lest, a promise being left us of entering into his rest, any of you should seem to come short of it.
Israel’s wilderness failure warns against missing God’s promised rest through unbelief.
- Numbers 14:4
And they said one to another, Let us make a captain, and let us return into Egypt.
The people propose choosing a leader to return to Egypt.
- Hebrews 3:7-11
Wherefore ( as the Holy Ghost saith, To day if ye will hear his voice,
Israel’s wilderness rebellion and hardened hearts bring God’s warning and oath.
- Numbers 26:63-65
These are they that were numbered by Moses and Eleazar the priest, who numbered the children of Israel in the plains of Moab by Jordan near Jericho.
The second census confirmed that the rebellious generation had died under judgment.
- Numbers 14:11
And the LORD said unto Moses, How long will this people provoke me? and how long will it be ere they believe me, for all the signs which I have shewed among them?
God asks how long Israel will provoke Him and refuse to believe.
- Psalms 95:10-11
Forty years long was I grieved with this generation, and said, It is a people that do err in their heart, and they have not known my ways:
Israel's wilderness rebellion grieved God, who swore the generation would not enter his rest.
- Numbers 14:1
And all the congregation lifted up their voice, and cried; and the people wept that night.
The people weep all night after rejecting the faithful report.
- Numbers 14:19
Pardon, I beseech thee, the iniquity of this people according unto the greatness of thy mercy, and as thou hast forgiven this people, from Egypt even until now.
Moses pleads for pardon by mercy.
- Ezekiel 20:15-16
Yet also I lifted up my hand unto them in the wilderness, that I would not bring them into the land which I had given them, flowing with milk and honey, which is the glory of all lands;
Sabbath pollution in the wilderness brought exclusion from the promised land.
- Numbers 14:31
But your little ones, which ye said should be a prey, them will I bring in, and they shall know the land which ye have despised.
Little ones are brought into the land their parents despised.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
18 sources
At Kadesh near the borders of the promised land the people sent one ruler from each tribe to survey Canaan, then rebelled by receiving the false, discouraging report of the spies despite the promise to give them the land.15MR 289.1–290.3PP 387.1Ms 135, 1899, par. 17 Their murmurings against Moses and Aaron the visible leaders were against God Himself, Christ their divine Leader, who long bore with them and waited for room in their hearts until after signs in Egypt and the wilderness their unbelief provoked Him at the tenth temptation to threaten them with pestilence and disinheritance.CNA 124.4Ms 10, 1903, par. 20–2215MR 292.1–24T 154.3–155.2RH May 20, 1902 He took them at their word when they wished they had died in Egypt or in the wilderness, declaring that all numbered from twenty years old and upward who murmured would fall and die in the wilderness save Caleb and Joshua, while their children would wander forty years, a day for a year of searching, and the little ones would be brought in to know the land their parents despised.1SP 293.2–294.1ST Aug 24, 1888SG4 25.3–26.1 The ten unfaithful spies whose evil report led the people to murmur were struck down and consumed before them, and the people's later grief over the sentence was sorrow for its consequences and not repentance for ingratitude and disobedience, so it could not reverse it.ST Aug 24, 1888ST Sep 2, 18804T 152.3PP 391.4–392.1ST Oct 21, 1880 The history is a warning for God's people today who re-enact the same cowardly complaining and drawing back from risk, for God still hears murmuring against His appointed agencies, and as a man thinks in his heart so he is, the fearful proving their own word true by wearing out their lives in the desert while those who count His promise greater than giants and walled cities prove their word true by entering in.Ms 10, 1903, par. 20–224T 154.3–155.2ST Nov 17, 1909
Context and Complaint
Israel stood at Kadesh, near the borders of the promised land, when the people proposed sending spies to survey Canaan.PP 387.1 Permission was granted, and direction was given that one ruler from each tribe be chosen to inspect the land and its inhabitants.PP 387.1
The complaint arose after the spies brought a false, discouraging report about Canaan.15MR 289.1–290.3Ms 135, 1899, par. 17 Receiving that evil report was rebellion against the Lord despite His promise to give Israel the land.15MR 289.1–290.3Ms 135, 1899, par. 17
The murmurings were spoken against Moses and Aaron, the visible leaders, yet they were directed against God Himself.CNA 124.4Ms 10, 1903, par. 20–2215MR 292.1–215MR 289.1–290.3PP 387.2–3 Christ was the divine Leader who gave Moses the instructions for the people, and the Angel of His presence witnessed in the pillar of cloud, so words aimed at His appointed agencies were heard by Him as spoken against Himself.Ms 10, 1903, par. 20–22PP 387.2–3RH May 20, 1902 He heard them and judged the people an evil, rebellious congregation under His frown.CNA 124.4Ms 10, 1903, par. 20–2215MR 292.1–215MR 289.1–290.31SP 293.2–294.1 The utterance introduces His response and His declared judgment upon the Israelites and upon the men who had caused them to murmur.CNA 124.415MR 292.1–2 What began in disappointment over the report grew into open revolt and mutiny, cursing the leaders, wishing for death in Egypt or in the wilderness, reproaching God for bringing them to fall by the sword and leave wives and children a prey, choosing a captain to return to Egypt, and refusing the call of Caleb and Joshua not to rebel and not to fear because the Lord was with them, even attempting to stone them until the glory of God interposed.RH May 20, 1902
The question how long He shall bear it shows the Lord long bearing with this murmuring congregation.4T 154.3–155.2RH May 20, 1902 He forgave their wanderings and waited for them to give Him room in their hearts, but false ideas, jealousy, and distrust crowded Him out.4T 154.3–155.2 After signs in Egypt and in the wilderness, this unbelief provoked Him at the tenth temptation.RH May 20, 1902 He therefore asked how long He should bear it and threatened to smite with pestilence and disinherit them.RH May 20, 1902
Punishment in the Wilderness
God declared He would do to the people as they had spoken in His ears, taking them at their word when they wished they had died in Egypt or in the wilderness.1SP 293.2–294.1ST Aug 24, 1888SG4 25.3–26.1RH May 20, 1902 All numbered from twenty years old and upward who murmured would not see the promised land but would fall and die in the wilderness, save Caleb and Joshua, while the little ones said to be a prey would be brought in to know the land their parents despised.1SP 293.2–294.1ST Aug 24, 1888SG4 25.3–26.1RH May 20, 19024T 152.3 The children would wander in the wilderness forty years, reckoned from leaving Egypt until the rebellious parents died, bearing the consequence of iniquity forty years according to the days spent searching the land, a day for a year.1SP 293.2–294.1ST Aug 24, 1888SG4 25.3–26.1 This made them fully realize His breach of promise as punishment for idolatry and rebellious murmuring that obliged Him to change His purpose toward them, since they forfeited all claim to favor and protection.1SP 293.2–294.1ST Aug 24, 1888
The forty years of travel was punishment for disobedience and need not have happened, for had Israel obeyed heaven's army under Christ's generalship stood ready to take them into Canaan long before, as shown when the walls of Jericho were leveled without human power.Ms 135, 1899, par. 17 Had they followed His guidance those who left Egypt would not have died in the wilderness.Ms 135, 1899, par. 17 He mercifully turned their course backward and enclosed them where they would see neither city nor town, and He would not continue to work miraculously for them because their hearts were in no fit state to appreciate it and a display of power would only fill them with pride.ST Sep 2, 18804T 152.3 Their arrogance, unbelief and rebellion meant He could not work for them, since they were unwilling to sanctify Him in their hearts and give Him glory.ST Sep 2, 18804T 152.3
The ten unfaithful spies whose evil report led the people to murmur were struck down before them and consumed by fire, signifying the destruction of all above twenty years of age whose unbelief and rebellion cost them everything.ST Aug 24, 1888ST Sep 2, 18804T 152.3 The perishing of those men before their eyes was the sign of what would come upon the whole murmuring rank above twenty years.ST Sep 2, 1880 Their unbelief cost them all.ST Sep 2, 1880
The people's later grief over the sentence was sorrow for its consequences, not repentance for ingratitude and disobedience, and could not reverse it.PP 391.4–392.1 Their later dissatisfaction with the wilderness delay grew from the earlier cowardly rebellion, blaming God and Moses for not entering sooner.ST Oct 21, 1880 They imagined they could have taken the land without them.ST Oct 21, 1880 Yet once they accepted the sentence as from the Lord they admitted they had sinned against Him and that Moses and Aaron had been right.SG4 35.1
Warning for Today
The history of the twelve spies applies to God's people today, for the same cowardly complaining is re-enacted, the same drawing back from action when risks must be met, and the same unwillingness to heed faithful reports and true counsel.4T 154.3–155.2 The Lord long bore with the evil congregation that murmured against Him, hearing their murmurings, forgiving their wanderings, and waiting for them to give Him room in their hearts, while false ideas, jealousy and distrust crowded Him out.4T 154.3–155.2 Ancient Israel was repeatedly tested and found wanting, and few received the faithful warnings given them of God.4T 154.3–155.2
Darkness and unbelief do not decrease as the time of the second advent nears, truth becomes less palatable to the carnally minded, and hearts are slow to believe and tardy to repent.4T 154.3–155.2 Few dare to come boldly forward and stand firmly for God and the right as Caleb did.4T 154.3–155.2 God hears murmuring still, and the verse reaches those who murmur against His appointed agencies and undermine confidence in people proclaiming truth, for He hears such words too.Ms 10, 1903, par. 20–22
Murmuring unbelief on the borders of Canaan fixed its own outcome, for as a man thinks in his heart so he is.ST Nov 17, 1909 Seeing walled cities, giant warriors and iron chariots and leaving God out, the unbelieving spies decided Israel could not take the land, the multitude echoed their fear, and their word proved true, for they were not able to go up and wore out their lives in the desert, the cowards and rebels perishing in the wilderness.ST Nov 17, 1909 Caleb and Joshua reasoned otherwise, counting God's promise superior to giants, walled cities and iron chariots, and their word proved true for them, for though sharing the forty years' wandering they entered the promised land.ST Nov 17, 1909 Caleb in undiminished courage asked for and received the giants' stronghold, drove out the Canaanites in God's strength, and possessed the vineyards and olive groves where his feet had trodden and ate the grapes of Eschol.ST Nov 17, 1909 Even one departure from right endangers both the wrongdoer and all reached by his influence, since example cast on the side of evil tendencies becomes well-nigh irresistible.ST Nov 17, 1909
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
62 sources
God declares He has heard the murmurings of Israel, which though spoken against Moses and Aaron are against Himself, and asks how long He shall bear with this evil congregation because His patience with persistent rebellion has its limit.ST May 31, 1899ST Feb 17, 1909ST Mar 2, 1882RH Jan 12, 1869ST Feb 11, 1903 The setting is Kadesh-barnea on the very border of the promised land in the second year after eleven days from Sinai, when after forty days the twelve spies brought proof of a good land flowing with milk and honey but ten fixed on giants, walled cities and strong inhabitants and said Israel could not conquer.ST Oct 7, 1930ST Sep 12, 1900ST Dec 2, 1886ST Jul 14, 1881ST Jan 30, 1907 Their sin was unbelief and open rebellion, refusing to trust His promise and enter Canaan, forgetting His covenant-keeping and wonder-working past, wishing to return to Egypt under a chosen captain and even attempting to stone Caleb and Joshua.ST May 31, 1899RH Nov 9, 1916ST Mar 2, 1882ST Sep 12, 1900ST Jan 30, 1907 By solemn oath He sentenced that all numbered from twenty years old and upward who murmured should fall in the wilderness in a forty-year wandering, a year for each day of searching, excepting only faithful Caleb and Joshua while the little ones said to be a prey would be brought in.ST May 31, 1899ST Jun 23, 1881RH Nov 9, 1916ST Apr 10, 1893RH Dec 27, 1906 The land denied is the rest of Psalm 95, not the seventh-day Sabbath but the rest Joshua afterward gave in Canaan as a type of the heavenly kingdom and new earth, warning those upon whom the ends of the world are come against discouragement, murmuring and faultfinding toward God's chosen leaders but to go up at once in courage and possess the land.ST Jun 23, 1881ST Feb 19, 1880RH Oct 8, 1908RH Jul 29, 1873
Wording and Historical Setting
The declaration is that God Himself had heard the murmurings of the children of Israel, and that their complaints were murmuring against Him even when spoken against His leaders, marking them as an evil congregation in persistent rebellion.ST May 31, 1899ST Feb 17, 1909ST Mar 2, 1882RH Apr 17, 1879 Their refusal to trust the faithful counsel to enter Canaan was rebellion that brought the sentence that the murmuring adults would die in the wilderness rather than enter the land, with only the faithful excepted and their children brought in afterward.ST May 31, 1899ST Mar 2, 1882ST Apr 10, 1893RH Apr 17, 1879ST Feb 11, 1903 The question how long He shall bear with this evil congregation shows that His patience with repeated rebellion has a limit and that He will not bear with that sin forever but will surely deal with it.RH Jan 12, 1869ST Feb 11, 1903RH Jul 30, 1914 Murmuring and faultfinding against those He has chosen to lead His work is murmuring against God Himself, and the fate that fell for failing to uphold them warns against a like fate.RH Jan 12, 1869RH Jul 30, 1914
The evil congregation was almost the whole people breaking out as one man in rebellion from evil hearts of unbelief, held accountable together as a congregation so that even those with faith to enter shared the wandering with its trials.RH Nov 9, 1916ST Jul 14, 1881ST Apr 15, 1903 Among them were men famous in the congregation, men of renown, princes of the assembly, who rebelled and led others into darkness, while the whole host wept and murmured and wished they had never left Egypt and were ready to stone their leaders.RH Nov 9, 1916ST Mar 1, 1910 Though many acted from selfish motives and rose in insurrection against His purposes, proving themselves no part of His true people, He did not abandon the nation He had brought out to start another, but His work moved on and those who kept faith amid difficulties went in.RH Nov 9, 1916ST Mar 1, 1910
The setting is Kadesh-barnea on the very border of the promised land in the second year, after eleven marching days from Sinai and after the year at Sinai and the march in the second month of the second year toward the wilderness of Paran, shortly after keeping the second Passover when Israel first came to the border with great power.ST Oct 7, 1930ST Jul 14, 1881ST Jan 30, 1907RH Oct 8, 1908 Because they were not fit for the land and had not profited by His dealings, He met their murmurings with a solemn oath that they should never set foot on its soil, turning the whole army back into that great and terrible wilderness to live, suffer and die until the grumblers were destroyed.ST Jul 14, 1881RH Oct 8, 1908 Their journey from Sinai, which could have taken eleven days, was thereby prolonged to thirty-eight years in the wilderness, fixed at forty years with each of the spies' days of examining the land answered by a year of wandering.ST Jul 14, 1881ST Jan 30, 1907
The context is the report of the twelve spies, one from each tribe, after forty days examining the land, bringing wonderful proof of fruitfulness such as a cluster of grapes carried on a staff between two men and reporting a good land flowing with milk and honey with large rich cities, goodly mountains and hills, sweet vales and precious things.ST Sep 12, 1900ST Feb 19, 1880RH Jul 29, 1873RH Sep 8, 1874 Ten fixed on the sons of Anak and huge giants in whose sight Israel were as grasshoppers, on strongly fenced cities with thick high walls walled to heaven, and on numerous fierce inhabitants, concluding Israel could not conquer and taking away the heart of the people to go farther.ST Sep 12, 1900ST Dec 2, 1886ST Feb 19, 1880RH Jul 29, 1873RH Sep 8, 1874 The faithful two with undaunted hearts held God's truth, put the Lord between themselves and their troubles instead of putting circumstances before Him, looked into His face and stayed calm saying He was with them, and urged that they were well able to go up at once and possess their heritage appointed by Him who had led them through the wilderness.ST Sep 12, 1900ST Dec 2, 1886RH Jul 29, 1873RH Sep 8, 1874 The counsel of the ten prevailed through the naturally unbelieving heart, the timid host in dismayed unbelief listened to them and melted into murmuring, and by turning backward and grieving their faithful leader they murmured against God Himself.ST Sep 12, 1900RH Jul 29, 1873RH Sep 8, 1874
Nature of Israel's Sin
The murmuring was unbelief and open rebellion against God, a refusal to trust His promise and enter Canaan after the report of the spies discouraged the people.ST May 31, 1899RH Nov 9, 1916ST Mar 2, 1882RH Dec 27, 1906RH Jun 13, 1854 It was being mightily shaken in a movement divinely started in Egypt and divinely led by the pillar of cloud and of fire, rejecting both God and those He had chosen to lead, and choosing instead not to go in and even to return to Egypt under a chosen captain.ST May 31, 1899RH Nov 9, 1916RH Dec 27, 1906 Their failure to enter came from resisting the Holy Spirit's pleadings and refusing to trust Caleb and Joshua and God's leading, a sin abhorrent to Him that kept that generation from the land, and their later repentance came too late.ST May 31, 1899ST Mar 2, 1882RH Dec 27, 1906RH Feb 24, 1916RH Jun 13, 1854 Though the whole congregation broke out as one, weeping and murmuring and wishing they had never left Egypt and ready to stone their leaders, including men famous in the congregation, men of renown and princes of the assembly leading others into darkness, God did not abandon the nation to start another but His work moved on, and those who in the face of difficulties kept faith and stayed with the movement would go in.ST May 31, 1899RH Nov 9, 1916
The people put circumstances before the Lord instead of putting the Lord between themselves and their troubles.ST Sep 12, 1900ST Jan 30, 1907 Forgetting their covenant-keeping and wonder-working Jehovah and all He had done in the past, they listened to the ten spies who told only of the sons of Anak and strongly fenced cities, and their hearts melted into murmuring against Him.ST Sep 12, 1900ST Jan 30, 1907RH Apr 15, 1873 This disbelief treated the God who had overthrown Egypt, opened the Red Sea, divided the sea before them, overthrown their masters in the sea, brought water from the rock, fed them with bread from heaven in a barren desert, guided them by cloud by day and fire by night, preserved clothing and shoes, and promised divine help to drive out enemies and bring them to a land flowing with milk and honey, as unable to bring them into Canaan.ST Jan 30, 1907RH Apr 15, 1873ST Mar 18, 1875 It was the opposite of Caleb and Joshua, who put obstacles outside, refused to let the Anakim and great cities blot out sight of the Lord, looked into His face and stayed calm and restful saying the Lord is with us and will bring them in, while the murmurers believed the unbelieving spies who said giants made them as grasshoppers, limited the Holy One of Israel, left God out of the inner circle of life, forfeited His help to go with them to battle, and wished to die in the wilderness.ST Sep 12, 1900RH Apr 15, 1873ST Mar 18, 1875
Complaint against Moses and Aaron is murmuring against God Himself, which He has heard and regards as spoken against Himself even when directed at His appointed leaders, with the Angel of His presence witnessing in the pillar of cloud.RH May 20, 1902RH Mar 7, 1907ST Mar 10, 1898RH Jul 30, 1914 The murmuring in trial laid blame on Him rather than accepting responsibility for distrust and disobedience, and brought His displeasure and the warning that He will bear with that sin only so long and will surely deal with it.RH Mar 7, 1907ST Mar 10, 1898RH Jul 30, 1914 It grew from disappointment over the spies' report into evil, open revolt and mutiny, bringing an ill report of cities walled to heaven and giants and sons of Anak in the way, cursing leaders, weeping and wailing through the long night after rejecting the faithful, wishing death in Egypt or in the wilderness, reproaching God for bringing them to fall by the sword and leave wives and children a prey, choosing a captain to return to Egypt, and refusing Caleb and Joshua's call not to rebel and not to fear because the Lord is with them.ST Aug 24, 1888RH May 20, 1902RH Mar 26, 1901 It went so far as raging to stone Caleb and Joshua and casting stones at the Calebs and Joshuas when they return, until God's glory interposed, and after signs in Egypt and the wilderness this unbelief after ten temptations provoked Him to ask how long He shall bear it; and faultfinding against those God has chosen to lead His work is the same sin, with the fate of rebellious Israel for failing to stay up the hands of its leaders warning against criticizing burden bearers instead of supporting them and standing by the faithful to go up at once and possess the land.ST Aug 24, 1888RH May 20, 1902RH Mar 26, 1901RH Jul 30, 1914
Sabbath violation and Sabbath pollution is given as one stated reason for the exclusion of those aged twenty and older from the promised land, connecting the judgment with rebellion.RH Jan 7, 1862RH Jan 7, 1862 Their punishment did not mean God destroyed the nation, since He spared the people and gave the younger generation a further probation.RH Jan 7, 1862 Ezekiel 20:15-16 with Numbers 14:35 connects this judgment with rebellion and Sabbath pollution, in the setting where the congregation who later judged the man gathering sticks had themselves violated the Sabbath.RH Jan 7, 1862
Sentence on the Generation
By solemn oath God sentenced that the carcasses of all who were numbered from twenty years old and upward and who murmured would fall in the wilderness and would not come into the land He swore to give them to dwell in.ST May 31, 1899ST Jun 23, 1881RH Nov 9, 1916ST Jul 14, 1887RH Apr 8, 1858 He took them at their own spoken wish that they had died in Egypt or in the wilderness and declared He would do to them as they had spoken in His ears.ST Aug 24, 1888RH May 20, 1902 The evil congregation heard was almost the whole people breaking out as one man, including men famous in the congregation and princes of the assembly.RH Nov 9, 1916
The wandering was fixed at forty years, a year for each of the spies' forty days searching the land, reckoned from leaving Egypt until the parents died and bore the consequence of iniquity.ST Aug 24, 1888ST Apr 10, 1893RH Dec 27, 1906ST Jul 14, 1881 A journey that could have taken a few days or eleven marching days was prolonged by thirty-eight years of longer wandering because unbelief brought defeat and deprived the whole unbelieving generation of entering the promised land.ST Nov 24, 1887 Such unbelief gave direction to actions and fixed destiny, leaving God out and wearing out lives in the desert.ST Nov 24, 1887
Caleb the son of Jephunneh and Joshua the son of Nun were excepted for faithfulness and triumphant faith when the people opposed the truth, and they alone would go into Canaan.ST Oct 7, 1930RH Nov 9, 1916ST Mar 2, 1882ST Jul 14, 1887RH Apr 8, 1858 The little ones said to be a prey would be brought in to know the land their parents despised, entering as children of faith while unbelieving murmurers were sifted out during the forty years.ST Aug 24, 1888RH May 20, 1902RH Nov 9, 1916ST Jun 23, 1914ST Mar 11, 1886 Those who in the face of difficulties kept faith and stayed with the movement went into the Promised Land, while those willing to face danger were blessed and allowed to enter.RH Nov 9, 1916ST Mar 11, 1886
The ten unfaithful spies who spread discouragement by fixing on giants, walled cities and numerous inhabitants died by plague before the congregation.ST Sep 2, 1880ST Feb 19, 1880RH Jul 29, 1873 They were consumed by fire from the sanctuary, and their perishing before the eyes of Israel signified the destruction of all in their ranks above twenty years of age.ST Aug 24, 1888ST Sep 2, 1880 God was greatly displeased with men who discouraged the people at the edge of the promised land despite proof of a land flowing with milk and honey and the faithful call of the other two spies to trust Him.ST Feb 19, 1880RH Jul 29, 1873
The judgment announced was carried out, so that by the second census only Caleb and Joshua remained alive from those first counted, proving God fulfills threatened judgments and that sin leads to ruin.ST Mar 3, 1881ST Sep 30, 1886 Later repentance came too late to reverse the sentence.RH Jun 13, 1854 The afterward attempt to go up to the hilltop to the place promised had no warrant from God and was built against His direct prohibition not to go, so it was not faith but presumption, only a new phase of the same unbelief, and it was defeated; presumption and unbelief are closely connected and the word of God alone determines who has faith.RH Aug 7, 1866ST Oct 7, 1897
Immediate death by pestilence and disinheritance was escaped for the time being only by the earnest intercession of Moses.RH May 20, 1902RH Aug 7, 1866 He pleaded on the ground of the honor of the Lord's name and the renown gotten by bringing the people out of Egypt with a mighty hand, lest His name be reproached and blasphemed among the heathen if He abandoned them to perish.RH May 20, 1902RH Aug 16, 1870ST Feb 9, 1882ST Oct 11, 1877 God is not moved by ambition and vainglory, but when His people are jealous for the honor of His name and ask Him to work not for personal benefit but for His own glory, that plea is acceptable to Him.RH Aug 16, 1870ST Feb 9, 1882ST Oct 11, 1877 Though He pardoned on the ground of long-suffering mercy and fame among the nations, the pardon left judgment that as they spoke so He did to them.RH May 20, 1902
The whole army of men, women and children was turned back into that great and terrible wilderness to live, suffer and die, where they would see neither city nor town for forty years until all who continually murmured died.ST Sep 2, 1880 Hundreds and thousands who crossed the Red Sea fell by the way, and almost every man and woman who started from Egypt perished, with not one of the men of that evil generation surviving.RH May 28, 1867RH Oct 9, 1866 This belongs to the great rebellion on the borders of the promised land, in which strict order was kept among the people not because God needed it but so they would learn and form systematic character.ST Mar 4, 1913RH Jul 25, 1907
Type of Future Rest
The land sworn away from the murmuring congregation is the same thing called His rest in Psalm 95.ST Jun 23, 1881 That rest was not the seventh-day Sabbath, for all who fell in the wilderness received the Sabbath and Joshua did not give the Sabbath, but it was the rest Joshua afterward gave in Canaan which God swore the rebels should not receive, since He never swore they should not keep the Sabbath but put Sabbath-breakers to death, while He did swear they should not enter Canaan.ST Jun 23, 1881 Because David long afterward still warned against missing that rest, the rest given by Joshua was only a type and not the final rest, proving a rest still remains to the faithful.ST Jun 23, 1881 The oath shutting rebels out of Canaan also alludes to the new earth, with Canaan serving as a type of Paradise, though whether it removed every opportunity for repentance is left uncertain.RH Jul 20, 1869
When Israel first came to the border of Canaan with great power, the murmurings, complainings, and fault-finding heard by God turned them back into the wilderness until the grumblers were destroyed.RH Oct 8, 1908 At Kadesh-barnea a murmur, a word of unbelief, brought thirty-eight years of wandering instead of the eternal victory that courage would have brought. When they came to the border the second time with a remnant of complainers, those complainers were destroyed in sight of the land, and then the people rose up as one man to do God's work with His strong arm so that the swelling Jordan, the Moabites, and the walls of Jericho could not stop them.RH Oct 8, 1908 The same pattern holds now for entrance into the heavenly kingdom after delay, for murmuring and unbelief today bring the same wandering when God's people came in sight of the kingdom with power, and now delay is to be no longer as murmurers and fault-finders are rapidly falling out and ministers and workers must rise up to scatter the printed page until the earth is lighted with glory and they are home in the kingdom, since this generation cannot afford thirty-eight years of wandering if it is to meet Christ.RH Oct 8, 1908
Hundreds and thousands who crossed the Red Sea on dry ground and sang the song of Moses afterward fell by the way in the wilderness because of murmurings and unbelief in rejecting light.RH May 28, 1867 Their falling is repeated by hundreds and thousands who were in the great Advent movement in 1844 and have since rejected truth and sinned against light.RH May 28, 1867
Doctrine Proved by Verse
The verse belongs under God's pardoning mercy as His response to persistent rebellion and murmuring against Him.RH Feb 17, 1916 The millions who fell in the wilderness are lost and will not be saved, though they were literal descendants of Jacob with special light, which proves fleshly descent from Abraham does not entitle anyone to the promises but character and not lineage decides who receives blessing.RH Jan 16, 1872 Though called out of Egypt and given opportunity to show loyalty, many acted from selfish motives, murmured and complained, and rose in insurrection against the purposes and plans of God, thereby proving they were really not members of the body of Christ and no part of the real church of God, and they were therefore rejected and destroyed by fire, by earthquake, by pestilence, by serpents, and in war.ST Mar 1, 1910
Murmuring against God is unbelief, and unbelief is sin with moral bearing on character and destiny for which man is responsible.ST Nov 24, 1887 It is want of confidence in God's ability and willingness to lead safely into Canaan, and faith instead in the wisdom of returning to Egypt under a chosen captain, which is rebellion producing restlessness, distrust, alarm and terror, provoking God to anger and incurring His displeasure.ST Nov 24, 1887 Such unbelief gives direction and character to actions and fixes destiny, bringing defeat in battle with the Amalekites and Canaanites, thirty-eight years longer wandering in the wilderness, and depriving the whole generation of unbelieving Israelites of entering the land of promise.ST Nov 24, 1887 Seeing walled cities, giant warriors and iron chariots and leaving God out, the unbelieving spies decided Israel could not take the land and the multitude echoed their fear, and their word proved true because they were not able to go up and wore out their lives in the desert, the cowards and rebels perishing in the wilderness.ST Nov 17, 1909ST Nov 24, 1887 Caleb and Joshua reasoned otherwise, counting God's promise superior to giants, walled cities and iron chariots, and their word proved true for them, for though sharing the forty years' wandering they entered the promised land, Caleb in undiminished courage asking for and receiving the giants' stronghold, driving out the Canaanites in God's strength and possessing the vineyards and olive groves where his feet had trodden and eating the grapes of Eschol.ST Nov 17, 1909 As a man thinks in his heart so he is, and even one departure from right endangers both the wrongdoer and all reached by his influence, since example cast on the side of evil tendencies becomes well-nigh irresistible.ST Nov 17, 1909
The murmuring was rebellion by unbelief at the report of the ten unbelieving spies, which escaped death for the time being only by earnest intercession and brought the sentence to die in the wilderness without seeing the promised land.RH Aug 7, 1866 Working themselves up afterward to believe they could still go up to the place promised and presuming to go up to the hilltop was not faith but presumption, because it had no warrant and authority from God and was built up against His direct prohibition not to go because they had sinned, proving presumption and unbelief are closely connected and the word of God alone determines who has faith and who has presumption.RH Aug 7, 1866 When Israel murmured He would not go with them to battle, and even though He had divided the sea before them, overthrown their masters in the sea, brought water from the rock, and fed them in a barren desert, their murmuring forfeited His help.ST Mar 18, 1875 The Spirit is given to all but its workings are various and cannot be dictated to serve any private purpose or gratify curiosity, for it asks faith and chooses its own method of trying faith.ST Mar 18, 1875
Warning and Application Today
The hearing of murmuring at the edge of the promised land stands as a warning against talking discouragement while engaged in God's work.ST Feb 19, 1880RH Jul 29, 1873RH Feb 28, 1907RH Jul 22, 1873 The spies brought wonderful proof of fruitfulness, even a cluster of grapes carried on a staff between two men from a land flowing with milk and honey, yet ten fixed on huge giants in whose sight Israel were as grasshoppers, thick high walls, numerous inhabitants, cities walled to heaven and sons of Anak, and concluded conquest was impossible against the faith urged by the other two.ST Feb 19, 1880RH Jul 29, 1873RH Mar 26, 1901 Their discouraging testimony took away the heart of the people to go farther, because the human heart is naturally unbelieving, and unbelief and hardness of heart turned focus on obstacles into doubting that God could bring them forward.RH Jul 29, 1873RH Feb 28, 1907 God was greatly displeased with the men who spread discouragement, destroyed them by plague before the congregation, and turned that murmuring multitude back to wander forty years in the desert until that generation died for that act.ST Feb 19, 1880RH Jul 29, 1873RH Jul 22, 1873 The ten gave a quite correct account of the difficulties standing in the way, yet they were destroyed because they discouraged the people, proving that discouragement and darkness give no reason to stop or come down from God's work for the last days but require courage in the Lord, intelligent zeal, and firm earnest forward movement even when danger, darkness and trials surround it, as an example for those upon whom the ends of the world are come.RH Jul 29, 1873RH Jul 22, 1873
The fate of that rebellion warns against murmuring, grumbling, faultfinding, indifference and neutrality toward those God has chosen to lead, and against refusing to stay up their hands.RH Mar 7, 1907RH Mar 26, 1901RH Jul 30, 1914ST Mar 11, 1886 Complaint against the appointed leader is complaint against God Himself, whom He has heard and will bear with only so long before He surely deals with it, so bringing an ill report, casting stones at the faithful Calebs and Joshuas when they return, and weeping and wailing through the long night after rejecting them is murmuring against God.RH Mar 7, 1907RH Mar 26, 1901RH Jul 30, 1914 To refuse and choose a captain to return to Egypt brings judgment to wander and die in the wilderness of sin without sight of the promised land, and indifference and neutrality in the present crisis will not escape God's curse.RH Mar 26, 1901ST Mar 11, 1886 His people must therefore cease reckoning from a merely human standpoint, stand still to see His salvation, stand by the faithful, support burden bearers instead of criticizing them, and go up at once and possess the land, for if God be for them no power of earth or darkness can stand before the Captain of the hosts of God.RH Mar 26, 1901RH Jul 30, 1914
A peevish, fretful, murmuring spirit under little trials in families and from other sources is the same sin as Israel's in the wilderness, viewed by a holy God as sin.RH Jun 26, 1860 Murmuring is rebellion against the heavenly Father when He answers prayer for sanctification by exposing to trials from the heart or from others or by sending bodily affliction and pain.RH Jun 26, 1860 Every trial, affliction and pain is a love token sent expressly for good and for sanctification, so that withholding one might mean being lost, and chastisement is a greater mark of the Father's love than caressing because He afflicts not willingly.RH Jun 26, 1860 Murmuring marks utter vileness and pollution, must be guarded against, confessed and forgiven for Christ's sake, never again given place in the bosom, and replaced by welcoming trials, afflictions and pains as the choicest blessing leading to the Saviour.RH Jun 26, 1860 True turning from groundless complaint about His dealings, declaring return to Egypt and despising the blessings He offered, would have been mourning for ingratitude and disobedience itself when faithfully laid before them, which would have prevented the sentence of taking away what was despised and barring entrance to Canaan for forty years.RH Nov 5, 1903 Mourning only for the punishment and its disastrous consequences is not repentance and cannot secure a reversing of the sentence, as seen in weeping after rejecting faithful counsel contrasted with Moses and Aaron, Caleb and Joshua, who accepted the bitter decree without a murmur.RH Nov 5, 1903
Feelings first led Israel to reject the promise and refuse to enter Canaan, then after warning swung to enthusiasm to go when forbidden, and defeat in that presumptuous attempt showed the problem was unbelief, not lack of feeling or zeal.ST Oct 7, 1897 The same murmuring when almost gaining the promised land, fearing possession was impossible, sent them back to wander forty years till almost every man and woman who started from Egypt perished.RH Oct 9, 1866 The warning is therefore against refusing the first privilege to obey from feeling unworthy and fearful, waiting till the privilege is withdrawn and left to weep and lament half-heartedness.RH Oct 9, 1866 The lesson is to gladly receive the first privilege to obey at once, not in personal worthiness but in the worthiness of Jesus, through whom come eternal life and all things, better influence and greater happiness.RH Oct 9, 1866 The account of refusal and delay shows they eventually took the land, but it would have been easier if they had gone when God first wanted them to, for delay made the task harder, and its lesson applies to the present that God's people should heed the warning, have faith, and go forward rather than turn back.RH Oct 19, 1905RH Oct 29, 1903 To charge the disasters and exclusion from Canaan to mismanagement of overbearing rulers who wrongly reproved sinners, claiming the congregation desired nothing more than their rights as a holy people with the Lord among them and would have had a peaceful prosperous journey directly to the promised land if led by dwelling on good deeds instead of reproving sins, mistakes the congregation's fault deserving reproof, for their murmuring and disobedience brought them into strait places where many perished.RH Nov 12, 1903
Sources