Numbers 14:3
And wherefore hath the LORD brought us unto this land, to fall by the sword, that our wives and our children should be a prey? were it not better for us to return into Egypt?
Translations
And why has the LORD brought us to this land, to fall by the sword, that our wives and our children should be a prey? were it not better for us to return into Egypt?
And wherefore hath the LORD brought us unto this land, to fall by the sword, that our wives and our children should be a prey? were it not better for us to return into Egypt?
and wherefore hath the Lord brought us unto this land, to fall by the sword, that our wives and our children should be a prey? were it not better for us to return into Egypt?
And why hath the LORD brought us to this land, to fall by the sword, that our wives and our children should be a prey? were it not better for us to return into Egypt?
And wherefore doth the LORD bring us unto this land, to fall by the sword? Our wives and our little ones shall be a prey: were it not better for us to return into Egypt?
And wherefore doth Jehovah bring us unto this land, to fall by the sword? Our wives and our little ones will be a prey: were it not better for us to return into Egypt?
and why is Jehovah bringing us in unto this land to fall by the sword? our wives and our infants are become a prey; is it not good for us to turn back to Egypt?'
And why is Jehovah bringing us to this land that we may fall by the sword, that our wives and our little ones may become a prey? Is it not better for us to return to Egypt?
Wherefore then is Yahweh bringing us into this land, to fall by the sword? Our wives and little ones, will become a prey! Would it not be well for us to go back towards Egypt?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Why is the LORD bringing us into this land to fall by the sword? Our wives and children will become plunder. Would it not be better for us to go back to Egypt?”
Why does the LORD bring us to this land, to fall by the sword? Our wives and our little ones will be captured or killed! Wouldn’t it be better for us to return into Egypt?”
Why is the Lord taking us into this land to come to our death by the sword? Our wives and our little ones will get into strange hands: would it not be better for us to go back to Egypt?
Wherefore nowe hath the Lord brought vs into this lande to fall vpon the sworde? our wiues, and our children shall be a pray: were it not better for vs to returne into Egypt?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Would God that we had died in Egypt and would God we may die in this vast wilderness, and that the Lord may not bring us into this land, lest we fall by the sword, and our wives and children be led away captives. Is it not better to return into Egypt?
Cross-references 20 of 46
- Numbers 13:31-33
But the men that went up with him said, We be not able to go up against the people; for they are stronger than we.
The spies’ alarming report about Canaan provokes Israel’s fear and complaint.
- 1 Corinthians 10:11-12
Now all these things happened unto them for ensamples: and they are written for our admonition, upon whom the ends of the world are come.
Israel’s wilderness failures are recorded as examples and warnings for later believers.
- Hebrews 3:19
So we see that they could not enter in because of unbelief.
Israel’s unbelief kept that generation from entering the promised land.
- Numbers 14:29-31
Your carcases shall fall in this wilderness; and all that were numbered of you, according to your whole number, from twenty years old and upward, which have murmured against me,
The murmuring adults die in the wilderness, while their children enter the land.
- Numbers 13:30
And Caleb stilled the people before Moses, and said, Let us go up at once, and possess it; for we are well able to overcome it.
Caleb’s call to possess the land contrasts with the people’s cry to retreat.
- Exodus 14:11-12
And they said unto Moses, Because there were no graves in Egypt, hast thou taken us away to die in the wilderness? wherefore hast thou dealt thus with us, to carry us forth out of Egypt?
Israel complains against Moses and longs to return to Egypt rather than face death in the wilderness.
- Numbers 14:8-9
If the LORD delight in us, then he will bring us into this land, and give it us; a land which floweth with milk and honey.
Caleb and Joshua urge trust in God’s promise and reject fear of the land’s inhabitants.
- Exodus 14:21-28
And Moses stretched out his hand over the sea; and the LORD caused the sea to go back by a strong east wind all that night, and made the sea dry land, and the waters were divided.
Israel had seen God deliver them through the sea and destroy Pharaoh’s pursuing army.
- Numbers 14:11-12
And the LORD said unto Moses, How long will this people provoke me? and how long will it be ere they believe me, for all the signs which I have shewed among them?
God identifies their rebellion and unbelief and threatens to punish them.
- Numbers 14:42-45
Go not up, for the LORD is not among you; that ye be not smitten before your enemies.
After refusing to enter, Israel presumptuously went up and was defeated.
- Numbers 14:34
After the number of the days in which ye searched the land, even forty days, each day for a year, shall ye bear your iniquities, even forty years, and ye shall know my breach of promise.
The forty days of spying brought forty years of wilderness wandering as judgment.
- Hebrews 4:1-2
Let us therefore fear, lest, a promise being left us of entering into his rest, any of you should seem to come short of it.
Israel’s unbelief warns against falling short of the promised rest.
- Deuteronomy 1:26-36
Notwithstanding ye would not go up, but rebelled against the commandment of the LORD your God:
Israel’s fearful refusal to enter the land brings judgment.
- Numbers 13:32
And they brought up an evil report of the land which they had searched unto the children of Israel, saying, The land, through which we have gone to search it, is a land that eateth up the inhabitants thereof; and all the people that we saw in it are men of a great stature.
The evil report sparked murmuring and a desire to return to Egypt.
- Numbers 26:64-65
But among these there was not a man of them whom Moses and Aaron the priest numbered, when they numbered the children of Israel in the wilderness of Sinai.
The later census confirms that the rebellious generation died in the wilderness.
- Numbers 13:23
And they came unto the brook of Eshcol, and cut down from thence a branch with one cluster of grapes, and they bare it between two upon a staff; and they brought of the pomegranates, and of the figs.
The spies brought back fruit from the land they had feared entering.
- Numbers 14:20-23
And the LORD said, I have pardoned according to thy word:
God pardons the people but bars the unbelieving generation from entering the land.
- Numbers 14:37
Even those men that did bring up the evil report upon the land, died by the plague before the LORD.
The spies who discouraged Israel are struck down by a plague.
- Ezekiel 20:15-16
Yet also I lifted up my hand unto them in the wilderness, that I would not bring them into the land which I had given them, flowing with milk and honey, which is the glory of all lands;
Israel’s rebellion in the wilderness led to exclusion from the land.
- Numbers 14:10
But all the congregation bade stone them with stones. And the glory of the LORD appeared in the tabernacle of the congregation before all the children of Israel.
The LORD’s glory appears as the people threaten to stone the faithful men.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
36 sources
On the night the twelve spies returned, ten of them brought an evil report magnifying walled cities and giants until the whole congregation broke into lamentation and murmuring against Moses and Aaron on the border of the promised land.Lt 39, 1899, par. 2–7Ms 91, 1899, par. 25PP 387.2–3SG4 22.1 The question accuses the Lord of bringing Israel to Canaan only to fall by the sword and leave wives and children as a prey, and judges it better and safer to return to Egypt into slavery.Lt 39, 1899, par. 2–7PP 389.2–313MR 186.1 It expresses unbelief and distrust of God's wisdom and power to give the land, forgetting how He had delivered from four hundred years of bondage, judged Egypt, destroyed Pharaoh's army in the Red Sea, and conducted them thus far.Lt 39, 1899, par. 2–7Ms 10, 1903, par. 9–11PP 387.2–35T 376.1–378.21SP 289.1 That complaint was apostasy and high rebellion stirred by faithless spies under Satan's control, treating God's promise as deception, rejecting His leading and discarding Moses, and wishing to make a new captain to take them back.Lt 39, 1899, par. 2–7PP 389.2–3Ms 91, 1899, par. 25Lt 39, 1899, par. 19–22Lt 129, 1900, par. 5–7 God took the people at their word about dying, so those over twenty would die in the wilderness during forty years of wandering while the children they feared would become a prey were instead brought into the land.Lt 39, 1899, par. 2–713MR 186.1Lt 106, 1897, par. 10–20
Setting and Complaint
The question was asked on the night the twelve spies returned from viewing Canaan, when ten of them, working under the wily foe, brought back an evil report that magnified the difficulties.Ms 91, 1899, par. 25SG4 22.1 That report emphasized strong people, walled and fortified cities, the sons of Anak and giant inhabitants, though the description of the land itself was correct.SG4 22.1PP 436.3 On hearing it the hopes of the people gave way to fear, discouragement and near-panic stirred by exaggerated, disappointing tidings.PP 387.2–3SG4 22.1Lt 1, 1892, par. 9–10
The whole congregation broke into lamentation, mourning, bitter reproaches, wailing and faultfinding, murmuring against Moses and Aaron.Lt 39, 1899, par. 2–7SG4 22.1 This took place at the Jordan on the border of the promised land, where Israel dishonored the Lord by giving way to unbelief after He had fulfilled His word to Abraham to deliver after four hundred years of bondage, visited Egypt with fearful judgments, brought His people forth, and destroyed Pharaoh and his pursuing army in the Red Sea.Ms 91, 1899, par. 25Ms 10, 1903, par. 15 Instead of waiting and reasoning that God who had brought them out thus far and helped under every difficulty would certainly give them the land, they yielded at once to discouragement and trusted not in Him who had hitherto led them.Lt 39, 1899, par. 2–7SG4 22.1
The verse accuses the Lord of bringing Israel unto that land only to fall by the sword and to leave wives and children as a prey to be killed or taken captive.Lt 39, 1899, par. 2–7PP 389.2–313MR 186.1Lt 106, 1897, par. 10–2015MR 289.1–290.3 It questions His wisdom and judges that it would be better and safer to return to Egypt than to enter and face death and capture.Lt 106, 1897, par. 10–2015MR 289.1–290.3Ms 10, 1903, par. 9–11 With that question the people wished they had died in Egypt or in the wilderness.Ms 91, 1899, par. 25SG4 22.1
The complaint joined murmuring against Moses and Aaron with rejection of God's leading and deliverance, discarding Moses their patient leader.Lt 39, 1899, par. 2–7SG4 22.1 The people said to one another to make a new captain, commander and leader to take them back to Egypt into slavery, hardship and bondage rather than seek His direction.Lt 39, 1899, par. 2–7Ms 91, 1899, par. 254T 150.2–3 In that rebellious spirit they forgot God's past deliverance, promise and miracles, so that Moses and Aaron fell on their faces before all the assembly of the congregation.RH May 20, 1902SG4 22.1
Unbelief, Rebellion, Judgment
The question expresses weak confidence, despair, unbelief and distrust of God's wisdom, power and ability to bring Israel safely in and give the land, notwithstanding the miracles He had wrought in their behalf.Ms 10, 1903, par. 9–11PP 387.2–31SP 289.1Ms 3, 1890, par. 22–25PP 436.3 Overwhelmed by the discouraging report, the people imagined He had brought them there only to be killed by the sword and to leave their wives and children as a prey to be killed or taken captive, and they judged that returning to Egypt would be better and safer.PP 387.2–31SP 289.1Ms 3, 1890, par. 22–25PP 436.3PP 388.1–2 The report of the spies about fortified cities and giant inhabitants was correct, but the fatal mistake was distrusting God's power, and that distrust alone kept Israel from entering then, for they acted as though possession depended on their own strength rather than on His gift.4T 148.3PP 436.3PP 388.1–2
That unbelief forgot how the Lord had helped under every difficulty and conducted them thus far, and it limited the power of the Holy One.Lt 39, 1899, par. 2–75T 376.1–378.2RH May 20, 19024T 148.3SG4 22.1 It forgot His word to Abraham to deliver after four hundred years of bondage, His visiting Egypt with fearful judgments, His bringing the people forth, His destroying Pharaoh and his pursuing army in the Red Sea, and His leading by a strong arm and a series of miracles.RH May 20, 19024T 148.3SG4 22.1ST Aug 24, 1888 Instead of waiting and reasoning that the God who had brought them out so far would certainly give them the land, they yielded at once to discouragement and blamed Moses and Aaron for bringing them into trouble.4T 148.3SG4 22.1PP 388.1–2
The complaint was apostasy, perversity and high rebellion that rejected God's leading and deliverance.Lt 39, 1899, par. 2–7PP 389.2–3Ms 91, 1899, par. 25 It treated His promise of the land as deception and accused God Himself of dealing deceitfully in promising a land they could not possess, while discarding Moses their patient, suffering leader.PP 389.2–34T 148.3SG4 22.1ST Aug 24, 1888 The rebellion was stirred by faithless spies under the control of Satan doing his intended work, who by a lying report broke down the courage of all Israel and predicted defeat.Lt 39, 1899, par. 19–22Lt 129, 1900, par. 5–7 God had planned easy access into Canaan and was holding back the armies that inhabited it, but Israel walked and worked at cross-purposes with Him, and the rebellion became so serious that it called for the presence of God Himself to adjust matters and He purposed to destroy Israel.Lt 39, 1899, par. 19–22Lt 129, 1900, par. 5–7
God took the people at their word about dying in Egypt or in the wilderness: those over twenty would die in the wilderness before reaching the promised land, and Israel must wander forty years for refusing to advance.Lt 39, 1899, par. 2–713MR 186.1Ms 91, 1899, par. 25ST Nov 11, 1880ST Oct 21, 1880 The children they feared would become a prey were instead brought into the land.Lt 106, 1897, par. 10–20 Their later claim that they could have taken the land earlier and their complaint that the delay was unnecessary showed bitter resentment over that delay and failure to trust God.ST Oct 21, 1880 After God declared the forty years of wandering, Israel tried to enter Canaan after the favorable time had passed and the opportunity was lost.CNA 124.4Lt 129, 1900, par. 5–76MR 402.4–404.3 Though Moses warned that the Lord was not with them and their enemies were prepared, their presumptuous advance on their own impulses ended in defeat, and they were not to try to avert God's pronounced judgment by following human impulse.CNA 124.4Lt 129, 1900, par. 5–76MR 402.4–404.3
Warning for Later Times
The verse warns against the same cowardly complaining and withdrawal from action when risks arise in later service for God.4T 154.3–155.2 After the spies' report Israel treated entering the promised land as a threat that would leave wives and children killed or captive, and judged return to Egypt better than trusting God and going forward.4T 154.3–155.2Ms 3, 1890, par. 22–25 That fear and distrust expressed the unfaithful spies' spirit of predicting defeat instead of trusting God, and murmuring in hardship repeats that failure.Ms 3, 1890, par. 22–25 Looking back toward Egypt instead of moving forward with God is the backward course to be rejected as His people serve and seek to save souls.20MR 321.5–6
It illustrates turning back and resisting God's purpose just at the threshold of entering the promised land, even while preparing to enter Canaan and returning to a former course.Ms 195, 1903, par. 20–21 It is a steady retreat from following Christ the Leader toward Egypt, a want of spiritual power at which few are alarmed or astonished.AAP 1.4 That backward turn from the journey toward Canaan is a pattern of influence that leads away from heavenly things and back toward the world.5T 411.1
Remembering Numbers 14:1-10 warns against repeating the spies' work by spreading exaggerated, discouraging reports.Lt 1, 1892, par. 9–10Lt 40, 1887, par. 3 Israel believed entering the land would bring death and expose wives and children to capture, and questioned why God had brought them there instead of leaving them in Egypt.Lt 1, 1892, par. 9–10 Such reports stirred the people to disappointment and near-panic, discouraged confidence, and turned them from a faithful, forward path.Lt 1, 1892, par. 9–10Lt 40, 1887, par. 3
The murmuring against Moses in adverse circumstances shows the temptation of men and women to complain against him who stands in the most responsible position in the cause and work of God, especially when he is under constant pressure of care and labor.3T 85.1–3TCBMP 97.1 It belongs to Israel's rebellious fear and distrust after reaching the promised land, complaining that God had brought them there to die and wanting to return to Egypt.Ms 4, 1875, par. 10–11 It illustrates how those who resist correction answer opposition with murmuring, self-justification, and separation from God's work.Ms 4, 1875, par. 10–11
Leading God's people backward into Egypt instead of forward in the way He leads means refusing the light on health reform and turning back to self-indulgent habits in eating and drinking.Ms 103, 1898, par. 5 Leaders commit this sin by both precept and example when they stand aloof from instructing the people and set a wrong example before the churches.Ms 103, 1898, par. 5
The verse teaches not to let desire to get out of an appointed place lead to the same defeat, but to wait and not rush one movement upon another.Lt 129, 1900, par. 5–7 Israel's complaint came through believing the testimony of the unfaithful spies, even though the Lord was holding back the armies that inhabited Canaan.Lt 129, 1900, par. 5–7 Because of unbelief Israel did not make the right move at the right time and its opportunity was lost.Lt 129, 1900, par. 5–7 God's devised plan is to be given every advantage and not cut across, and His pronounced judgment is not to be averted by following human impulse.Lt 129, 1900, par. 5–7
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
75 sources
The verse is Israel's cry at Kadesh-barnea after the twelve spies returned, charging that the Lord had led them to the border of Canaan only to let them fall by the sword and leave their wives and children as captives, wishing they had died in Egypt or the wilderness and proposing to choose a new captain to take them back to Egypt.ST May 31, 1899RH Jan 12, 1869ST Sep 12, 1900ST May 13, 1889RH Mar 26, 1901 It was spoken despite wonderful deliverance from Egypt, provision of bread and water in the wilderness, guidance by cloud and fire, and the promise to drive out their enemies and give them the fruitful land.ST Aug 31, 1888ST Jan 6, 1904ST Aug 31, 1888 The complaint was fearful and wicked unbelief, trusting human testimony above God's promise, putting difficulty before the Lord and accusing Him of inability and deceit, and in murmuring against Moses and Aaron it murmured against God Himself.RH Mar 7, 1907RH Jun 13, 1854ST Jan 30, 1907RH Mar 31, 1904 Unbelief brought God's solemn oath that all numbered from twenty years old and upward who murmured would fall in the wilderness, with only Caleb, Joshua and the children entering, yet upon Moses' forty-day intercession for the honor of the Lord's name lest the heathen reproach Him, God pardoned according to his word.RH Dec 27, 1906ST Jun 23, 1914RH Aug 16, 1870ST Oct 11, 1877ST Feb 21, 1911 Canaan stands as a type of Paradise and the rest promised in Hebrews III and IV, so the event is an example upon whom the ends of the world are come, warning against discouraging reports, questioning God's power, and turning back to Egypt instead of going up at once in the faith of Caleb and Joshua.RH Jul 20, 1869RH Jul 29, 1873RH Mar 26, 1901RH Feb 28, 1907ST Aug 13, 1902
Wording and Historical Setting
The verse belongs to the rebellion after the sending of the spies into Canaan, in the midst of the marching and murmuring of Israel in the wilderness of Paran at Kadesh-barnea on the very border of the promised land.ST Feb 17, 1909ST Jul 14, 1881ST Jul 31, 1901ST Feb 20, 1912 That border had been reached after eleven marching days from Sinai, inside of a year after the miraculous bringing out of Egypt after a sojourn of more than two hundred years, and the advance toward the land having suffered a reverse the complaint led to being sent back into the wilderness.ST Jul 14, 1881ST Jul 31, 1901ST Jun 9, 1914 The almost unanimous rebellion sprang from evil hearts of unbelief, showed loss of faith in divine leadership and desire to return to Egypt and slavery in preference to unrestrained liberty, and stands as a sad but important lesson.ST Jul 14, 1881ST Feb 20, 1912ST Jun 9, 1914 The report of the spies furnished the trial to show what the people were, proving they were not fit for the land and had not profited by God's wonderful dealings, and in answer God with a solemn oath swore they should never set foot on that good soil, fixing the wandering at forty years, a year for each of the forty days spent examining the land.ST Jul 14, 1881
In wording the verse charges that the Lord had brought Israel into the land to fall by the sword and to leave wives and children as a prey, as killed or taken captive and left vulnerable, and asks whether it were not better and safer to return to Egypt.ST Aug 26, 1880ST May 31, 1899RH Jan 12, 1869ST May 13, 1889RH Oct 29, 1903 The whole congregation murmured after the evil report of the ten, wishing they had died in Egypt or in the wilderness, rejecting the confidence of Caleb and Joshua that the land could be taken and joining the majority in rebellion against God.ST May 31, 1899RH Jan 12, 1869RH Feb 6, 1900 Fear and grief turned against the Lord, blaming Him despite His promise and deliverance, and the people proposed abandoning the journey under cloud and fire by making a captain and returning to Egypt.ST Aug 26, 1880RH Jan 12, 1869RH Feb 6, 1900 Their fearful, faithless complaint is foolish and wicked murmuring that displeased God, who threatened to smite Israel with pestilence and disinherit them to make a mightier nation from Moses, but on Moses' prayer pardoned according to his word while declaring that the carcasses of all numbered from twenty years old and upward who murmured would fall in the wilderness and not come into the sworn land, save Caleb son of Jephunneh and Joshua son of Nun.ST May 13, 1889RH Feb 6, 1900
The complaint was spoken though Israel was highly favored, wonderfully delivered from Egypt with a mighty hand and an outstretched arm, with wonders and mighty miracles wrought in Egypt for deliverance, and with free provision for temporal sustenance.ST Aug 31, 1888ST Jan 6, 1904ST Jun 9, 1914 They had joined in grateful praise and a song of triumph for deliverance at the Red Sea after passing on dry ground and singing the song of Moses, had been fed with bread in the wilderness and given water in the desert, and knew the same God had promised to go before them to drive out enemies and give Canaan for a possession.ST Aug 31, 1888ST Aug 31, 1888RH May 28, 1867 The pillar of cloud by day and of fire by night still stood before them to lead in the way and give light, choosing camping places and leading by the safest way, yet they treated that visible living token of presence and goodness as common camp equipment, murmuring in the splendor of its light and in the grateful shade of its coolness in the desert heat.ST Jan 6, 1904 Forgetting past deliverance and provision, limiting His power and distrusting the guidance that had brought them safely thus far by a series of miracles, they faltered for fear they were not strong enough, their courage utterly forsook them at the false report, and they determined to return to their masters in Egypt.ST Aug 24, 1888ST Aug 31, 1888RH Oct 29, 1903 In high rebellion they not only complained against Moses and Aaron as deceivers bringing trouble, but accused God Himself of dealing deceitfully and foolishly in promising a land they could not possess, discarded Moses their patient suffering leader, and resolved to choose and actually appointed a commander to lead back to slavery and hardship.ST Aug 24, 1888ST Aug 31, 1888RH Oct 29, 1903
The immediate occasion was the searching of the land by twelve men, one from every tribe, who brought wonderful evidence of fruitfulness, a land flowing with milk and honey, even a cluster of grapes carried on a staff between two men.ST Sep 12, 1900RH Jul 29, 1873RH Mar 26, 1901 Ten of the spies reported strongly fenced cities rising walled to heaven, very numerous inhabitants, and fierce giants including the sons of Anak in whose sight Israel were as grasshoppers and as nothing, and concluded they could not conquer.ST Sep 12, 1900RH Jul 29, 1873RH Mar 26, 1901RH Sep 8, 1874 Though the faithful two declared the fair land their heritage appointed by God who had led through the wilderness and whose strength would cover their feebleness, the people listened to fear, let their hearts melt, and let the counsel of the ten prevail.ST Sep 12, 1900RH Jul 29, 1873RH Sep 8, 1874 Frightened by that report they put circumstances before the covenant-keeping and wonder-working Jehovah, kept difficulty and trial in the inner circle instead of God, unlike Caleb and Joshua who put obstacles outside, kept sight of the Lord with them, and remained calm and restful looking into His face.ST Sep 12, 1900 The ten described the obstacles correctly but were destroyed by plague before the congregation because they discouraged the people, and the dismayed trembling host in answer to the fearful tidings refused to venture over, turned backward, grieved their faithful leader, and fell in the wilderness with graves covering the desert as the mournful fate of unbelief.RH Jul 29, 1873RH Jul 22, 1873RH Sep 8, 1874
What should have taken only a few days, an eleven-day journey to the border of the land, was stretched by this fearful response into thirty-eight years of wandering, elsewhere reckoned as forty years in the desert till that generation died.ST Jul 14, 1881RH Apr 6, 1911ST Apr 12, 1883 The lament charging the Lord with bringing them to fall by the sword and leave wives and little ones as prey stands in direct contrast to the song of triumph after passing the Red Sea.ST Aug 13, 1902 Distrust following the spies' report believed human testimony rather than God's promise, and through false counsel and faltering courage the people failed to enter.RH Jun 13, 1854ST Apr 12, 1883 The children whom the people feared would perish as prey later entered the land.RH Apr 6, 1911
Unbelief and Rebellion
The cry to go back to Egypt was fearful, foolish and wicked unbelief, distrusting God's ability and willingness to save His people in Canaan.RH Jun 13, 1854ST Jan 30, 1907 Believing human testimony rather than God's promise, the people joined the majority of the spies against the confidence of Caleb and Joshua and were thereby proved unfit to enter the land.RH Jun 13, 1854 Their proposal to return did not spring from sound concern for survival, for return would have meant cruel bondage and, since they lived by God's daily food, certain death by famine if He let them take that course.ST Aug 31, 1888 Their unbelieving forgetfulness made them stumble because they failed to heed God's earlier testimony and trust His promises.RH Feb 6, 1900
They put circumstances before the LORD, keeping difficulty in the inner circle instead of God.RH Mar 31, 1904RH Mar 31, 1904 Looking at danger, they forgot He was leading them, questioned His purpose in bringing them there, and distrusted His power to save despite His deliverance and care in the wilderness.ST Jan 30, 1907RH Mar 31, 1904 They limited His power and accused Him of dealing deceitfully in promising a land they could not possess.ST Aug 24, 1888 In high rebellion and forgetful of the strong arm that had brought them out of Egypt and conducted them by miracles, they murmured bitterly against God Himself.ST Aug 24, 1888
That murmuring rejected God's appointed leadership, for complaint against Moses and Aaron is counted as complaint against God who chose Moses, instructed him, led his mind and talked with him.RH Mar 7, 1907RH Nov 18, 1873 They discarded Moses their patient, suffering leader and rejected the servant God had chosen.ST Aug 24, 1888ST May 13, 1889 Their fear and distrust turned into rebellion in seeking to replace their leaders, resolving to choose a commander and appointing a captain to lead them back to Egypt.RH May 20, 1902ST Nov 11, 1880ST Aug 24, 1888 They even tried to kill the two faithful spies who urged advance.ST Nov 11, 1880
The cry belonged to continued complaining because they could not live like the surrounding world, longing for the food they had eaten in Egypt.RH Apr 17, 1879 Having been brought out of danger, they yet wished to return rather than trust their deliverance, showing they did not value the deliverance, love their Deliverer, or recognize the danger they had escaped.RH Jun 17, 1862 Facing difficulties after leaving Egypt, they regretted their deliverance and wanted to return to captivity, failing the trial of trusting God who had delivered them so they could serve Him.ST Jun 10, 1880 This came after further probation following the golden calf as a second great failure, joined with idolatry, despising law and Sabbath-breaking.
The episode illustrates the blindness caused by sin and the fruits of unbelief. Peevish, fretful murmuring is sin before a holy God, and selfish murmuring is insurrection against God's purposes and plans.ST Mar 1, 1910 Those called out of Egypt, though given opportunity to show loyalty, acted from selfish motives and proved by their wilderness experience to be no part of the real church of God.ST Mar 1, 1910 For that insurrection they were rejected and destroyed by fire, by earthquake, by pestilence, by serpents, and in war, with God's protecting care withdrawn so that, apart from Caleb, Joshua and the children, they died in the wilderness without entering the promised land.RH Apr 17, 1879ST Mar 1, 1910
Judgment, Pardon and Entry
Unbelief brought a solemn oath shutting the rebels out of Canaan, that the carcasses of all numbered from twenty years old and upward who murmured would fall in the wilderness.ST Oct 21, 1880RH Dec 27, 1906RH Feb 6, 1900 Nearly all that generation died without entering, sifted out during forty years of wandering, elsewhere reckoned as thirty-eight more years, weary and longing for Egypt after rejecting God and Moses instead of trusting Him to bring them into the Promised Land.RH Dec 27, 1906ST Jun 23, 1914ST Nov 24, 1887ST Feb 21, 1911RH Jul 29, 1873 Only Caleb the son of Jephunneh and Joshua the son of Nun with the children would enter, and the generation that entered did so through faith under their leadership.ST Oct 21, 1880RH Feb 6, 1900ST Jun 23, 1914 Their later claim that they could have taken the land earlier showed bitter resentment over that delay and failure to trust God.ST Oct 21, 1880
That murmuring greatly displeased God, who threatened to smite Israel with pestilence and disinherit them and to make a greater and mightier nation from Moses.RH Aug 7, 1866RH Feb 6, 1900 For the time the sentence to die in the wilderness without seeing the promised land was escaped only by the earnest intercession of Moses, yet pardon still left the exclusion standing.RH Aug 7, 1866RH Feb 6, 1900 The ten men who discouraged the people with the evil report died by plague before the congregation.RH Feb 6, 1900RH Jul 29, 1873 Unbelief then turned into presumption, confidence without warrant from God as opposed to faith as confidence in the testimony of God, when they worked themselves into eager confidence to go up to the place promised against the direct prohibition not to go because they had sinned.RH Aug 7, 1866ST Nov 24, 1887 That presumptuous going brought terrible defeat by the Amalekites and Canaanites, who smote and discomfited them on the hilltop, with thirty-eight years longer wandering and loss of the land of promise for the whole unbelieving generation.RH Aug 7, 1866ST Nov 24, 1887RH Jul 29, 1873
Moses pleaded for Israel on the ground of the honor of the Lord's name, pointing to the bringing out of Egypt with a mighty hand and the renown gained thereby by wonderful works among them.RH Aug 16, 1870ST Oct 11, 1877ST Feb 9, 1882 He urged that abandoning them to perish would lose that renown and give the Egyptians occasion to think He was unable to bring His people into the promised land, so that His name would be reproached and blasphemed among the heathen.RH Aug 16, 1870ST Oct 11, 1877ST Feb 9, 1882ST Jun 19, 1884 He fell down before the Lord forty days and forty nights fasting and interceding, pleading that after doing so much and bearing so long God should not now destroy them, that He should show mercy for the sake of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob and not regard only the sin of the present generation.ST Jun 19, 1884 God heard and spared them and pardoned according to his word, making the case a monument of the value of intercessory prayer.RH Feb 6, 1900ST Jun 19, 1884 This does not mean God is moved by ambition and vainglory, but that He accepts prayer when His people are jealous for the honor of His name and show love by asking Him to work not for their own personal benefit but for His own glory.RH Aug 16, 1870ST Oct 11, 1877ST Feb 9, 1882
Canaan had been promised to the fathers centuries before and offered vineyards, grain, pasture and physical comfort after servitude, but God intended more than temporal prosperity.ST Jan 4, 1905 The journey from Egypt to Canaan was preparation to develop character fit to exemplify righteousness and be a light to a world in darkness, confusion, error and sin.ST Jan 4, 1905 Viewed rightly and met with trust in God it would have been a triumphal procession into the rest God had prepared.ST Jan 4, 1905 Instead they murmured homesick and restless, fearful and trembling and looking with apprehension into the future.ST Jan 4, 1905 God wanted them to learn to trust His word and power to overcome difficulties they could not overcome themselves, to rest quietly and wait for His salvation at every step under circumstances entirely beyond their own power to deliver themselves, because rest and trust come only by exercise as does any growth.ST Jan 4, 1905
Faith, Presumption and Doctrine
The complaint sets the language of unbelief directly against the language of faith. Faith holds that what God promised to do in going before Israel and giving the land He will do, recounts past mercies, praises Him for past deliverances, and trusts Him for future victories while keeping sight of the Lord with them and remaining calm. Unbelief falters, charges God with foolishness in His leading, makes cowards of men of war who ought to go forward in His name, and fears defeat with loss of wives and children so that it desires return to Egypt. It takes up the false report of the ten spies and murmurs when the intent was to pass over at once and possess the inheritance, showing unbelief in the Saviour tenderly guiding and failure to appreciate blessings and privileges, and this grieves God and warns lest a promise of entering rest be left unfulfilled by those who marvel at Israel yet murmur over smaller trials and fail small tests of faith.ST Aug 31, 1888ST Sep 30, 1886
Unbelief and presumption are closely connected, for unbelief is confidence without warrant from God as opposed to faith as confidence in the testimony of God. In unbelief Israel charged that the Lord brought them into the land to fall by the sword and make wives and children a prey and wished to return to Egypt, bringing sentence to die in the wilderness without seeing the promised land, escaped for the time only by earnest intercession. That same unbelief then worked itself into eager confidence to go up to the place promised against direct prohibition not to go because they had sinned, and enemies smote and discomfited them on the hilltop. Shifting feelings that first followed the ten spies in fear of death and captivity and then swung to zeal to go when forbidden did not remedy the failure to enter through unbelief.RH Aug 7, 1866ST Oct 7, 1897
Unbelief is abhorrent to God, grieves Him and His tender Spirit, provokes Him to anger and incurs His displeasure. Man is responsible for his faith and under obligation to trust God, and unbelief is sin with moral bearing on character and destiny, producing restlessness, distrust, alarm and terror, giving direction and character to actions and fixing destiny. Fearful forebodings about the way God leads through His chosen servants is distrust of His guidance that opens the heart to evil and moves by steps from being fearful to being distrustful to being rebellious. Such unbelief and rebellion brought terrible affliction upon the whole congregation and defeat by the Amalekites and Canaanites with thirty-eight years longer wandering, depriving the whole unbelieving generation of entering the promised land, and those remaining in such fear toward His work and chosen leaders will have no part in the glad shout of final triumph but will have their portion outside the city of God in the lake of fire.RH Feb 24, 1916ST Nov 24, 1887RH May 20, 1873
The exclusion of that generation expressly joined this murmuring with despising God's judgments, not walking in His statutes, hearts going after idols, and violation of the Sabbath. It belongs to the second great failure after further probation granted following the idolatry of the golden calf, when He lifted up His hand that all over twenty years of age should not enter the land flowing with milk and honey. God spared the nation from utter destruction and extended further probation to the younger generation, while in Caleb and Joshua was another spirit for they followed the Lord fully.RH Jan 7, 1862RH Jan 7, 1862
Trials, afflictions and pains under which Israel sinned by peevishness, fretfulness and murmuring are the heavenly Father's discipline answering prayer for sanctification with no reserve as to means. That murmuring spirit is sin in the sight of a holy God, and as much sin is committed when Christians are peevish, fretful and murmuring under little family trials and other trials. Such discipline is sent expressly for good as love tokens for sanctification, so that if one trial were withheld the soul might be lost. Chastisement is a greater mark of the Father's love than caressing because it is painful to inflict and pleasant to impart, and since He afflicts not willingly every trial, affliction and pain should be welcomed as choicest blessing leading to the Saviour.RH Jun 26, 1860
The six hundred thousand who came out of Egypt supposing themselves the true church and expecting to enter the promised land yet destroyed in pride and self-righteousness stand as a living warning example for people in the last days. Called out and given opportunity to show loyalty, they acted from selfish motives and proved by wilderness experience to be no part of the real church of God and no members of the body of Christ. Their murmuring and complaining was insurrection against the purposes and plans of God, and for it they were rejected and destroyed by fire, by earthquake, by pestilence, by serpents, and in war. Though literal descendants of Jacob according to the flesh, those who thus murmured fell in the wilderness as sinners under judgment among the millions who fell, and have no title by descent to the promises or to salvation as Israel.ST Mar 1, 1910RH Nov 27, 1860RH Jan 16, 1872
Types and Scriptural Parallels
Canaan serves as a type of Paradise, the future rest promised to believers in Hebrews III and IV, and God's oath against the wilderness rebels shut them out from Canaan and may also have excluded them from entering Paradise.RH Jul 20, 1869 The full reach of that oath is uncertain, leaving open whether those who murmured still had opportunity to repent.RH Jul 20, 1869
The complaint stands in direct contrast to the song of triumph sung after passing the Red Sea on dry ground and singing the song of Moses, showing how soon fearful lament replaced praise.ST Aug 13, 1902RH May 28, 1867 After the evil report of the spies Israel lamented further, charging the Lord with bringing them into the land to fall by the sword and leave wives and little ones as a prey, and asking whether returning to Egypt would be better.ST Aug 13, 1902RH May 28, 1867 That murmuring and unbelief caused hundreds and thousands to fall and die in the wilderness, and the same falling by the way happens to hundreds and thousands who were in the great Advent movement of 1844 when through unbelief they reject truth, sin against light, and draw back.RH May 28, 1867
Egypt stands for the former life left behind and for the world-wilderness, and returning to it offers no true rest.ST Aug 13, 1902RH Jul 3, 1856 To return to Egypt means to cling to worldliness, unrighteousness and unholiness and to stand with those who do not serve God, set against crossing over Jordan with those who serve Him.ST Aug 13, 1902RH Jan 25, 1906 It marks the separating line drawn in God's purifying of His church, when impurity and dross are removed from the mixture of divine with worldly elements so the church becomes capable of high use and the wonders of His saving power can be revealed through her.RH Jan 25, 1906 Israel's doubting of God's leadership and resisting of the exodus movement He had begun serves as an admonition to later generations.RH Mar 18, 1909 In choosing Egypt rather than battling for final victory under the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus, God gave them their choice and let them die in the wilderness, and thousands of professed children of God make the same choice today in practical life.ST Aug 13, 1902 The world is free to choose whom they will serve without compulsion, for salvation is freely offered, the invitation earnestly extended, the necessary sacrifice made in love, and whosoever will may take the water of life freely.ST Aug 13, 1902
Present Warning and Duty
The episode stands as an example for those upon whom the ends of the world are come, warning against talking discouragement and questioning God's dealings, power and readiness to work.RH Jul 29, 1873RH Feb 28, 1907 After twelve men, one from every tribe, searched the land and brought wonderful evidence of its fruitfulness, even a cluster of grapes carried on a staff between two men showing a land flowing with milk and honey, ten reported huge giants before whom Israel were as grasshoppers, thick high walls and very numerous inhabitants, and concluded conquest was impossible.RH Jul 29, 1873 Their testimony took away the people's heart to go farther, though two tried to speak faith, because the human heart is naturally unbelieving and eager to doubt, and complaining against God in the wish to return was sin greatly displeasing to Him.RH Jul 29, 1873RH Feb 28, 1907 Such discouraging reports weaken all effort, lose favor and darken into doubt, while faith and hope and courage are needed for God to work through human agencies with help from One who never fails, so doubt and repeated talk of difficulties must be shunned as bringing discouragement and hardness of heart.RH Jul 29, 1873RH Feb 28, 1907 The ten who discouraged the people died by plague before the congregation, and the multitude had to turn back over their weary course and wander forty years in the desert until that generation died for that act.RH Jul 29, 1873
Murmuring, complaining and fault-finding when first come up to the borders of Canaan with great power turned Israel back into the wilderness until the grumblers were destroyed.RH Oct 8, 1908 When they came to the border the second time a remnant of complainers was still among them and was destroyed in sight of the land, after which the people rose as one man to do the work God wanted, and neither the swelling Jordan, the Moabites, nor the walls of Jericho were barriers, for God led with a strong arm.RH Oct 8, 1908 So likewise after coming up with power with ministers and people selling books by the thousands, murmuring and complaining turned God's people back into the wilderness, but now delay is to be no longer and they are in sight of the heavenly kingdom again with murmurers and fault-finders rapidly falling out.RH Oct 8, 1908 If ministers and workers now rise up and lead the people in scattering the printed page, obstacles will not stop them, the earth will be lighted with the glory of God, and they will be at home in the kingdom.RH Oct 8, 1908
The right course before cities walled to heaven and giants, the sons of Anak, is to cease reckoning from a merely human standpoint.RH Mar 26, 1901 To complain that the Lord brought His people there to fall by the sword and leave wives and children a prey, to ask if return to Egypt were not better, to choose a captain to lead back, and to cast stones at the Calebs and Joshuas returning with a good report, brings weeping through the long night that follows and then wandering and death in the wilderness of sin without sight of the promised land.RH Mar 26, 1901 Instead trust is required that if God be for His people no power of earth or darkness can stand before Him, standing by the Calebs and Joshuas and answering, Let us go up at once and possess it, for we are well able to overcome it.RH Mar 26, 1901
Refusing to enter when first called makes the task harder, for Israel eventually took the land but with severer battles.RH Oct 19, 1905 God always sets the first open door before His people, and entering it at once saves many a severe battle, while failure to move forward after He has prepared the way brings some of the severest battles of the wilderness.RH Oct 19, 1905 Delay leaves the last opening less favorable than the beginning because others step into the opening instead, as in failing to enter the cities when prepared.
A faltering mind at Kadesh-barnea brought thirty-eight years of wandering in the wilderness, while courage then would have brought eternal victory. A murmur now and a word of unbelief today brings the same result. Another thirty-eight years of wandering cannot be afforded if this generation is to meet Christ.
In practical life thousands of professed children of God today make Israel's choice, choosing Egypt and the world-wilderness rather than battling for final victory under the banner of the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus.ST Aug 13, 1902 God gave Israel their choice and let them die in the wilderness, and so the world is free to choose whom they will serve.ST Aug 13, 1902 Salvation is freely offered, the invitation earnestly extended, the necessary sacrifice made in the love of God, and whosoever will may take the water of life freely, but there is no compulsion.ST Aug 13, 1902
The refusal to enter on the spies' report put the life of the whole nation at stake under sentence of destruction, and Moses fell down before the Lord forty days and forty nights fasting and interceding.ST Jun 19, 1884 He pleaded that after doing so much for them and bearing so long with them God should not now destroy them, that He should show mercy for Abraham, Isaac and Jacob's sake and not regard only the sin of the present generation, and that He must not give the Egyptians occasion to think He was unable to bring His people into the promised land.ST Jun 19, 1884 God heard and spared them, making the case a monument to the value of intercessory prayer.ST Jun 19, 1884 It encourages prayer for one's country, for the reviving of religion in declension, and for sinners in danger of perdition.ST Jun 19, 1884
The same falling by the way happens to hundreds and thousands who were in the great Advent movement of 1844.RH May 28, 1867 As hundreds and thousands of Israel fell in the wilderness after crossing the Red Sea on dry ground and singing the song of Moses, through murmuring and unbelief that the Lord brought them to fall by the sword and make wives and children a prey, so through unbelief they reject truth, sin against light, and draw back.RH May 28, 1867
God's people must not turn back into the wilderness but should trust God and go forward to possess the land.RH Oct 29, 1903RH Nov 18, 1902 Israel's unreadiness, having lost the hope and aim of the movement God was leading out of Egypt into Canaan, kept the people wandering, and just as soon as God found a people prepared to follow Him the Jordan rolled back and the wanderings ceased.RH Nov 18, 1902 They are not to wander indefinitely in the wilderness of this world nor settle down merely to philanthropic enterprise and humanitarian service, but to do the work committed to them and bear the warning message that made them a people, which hastens the consummation of hope in the coming of Jesus and the city of God.RH Nov 18, 1902
Those now standing on the very confines of heaven and face to face with great neglected cities in the way must not cry for retreat as the former generation did forty years before Joshua stood before Jericho, crying for bondage in Egypt and graves in the desert rather than face the terrors of the great walled cities.RH Sep 21, 1916 Their faith staggered at walled cities and giants within, choosing retreat over the onward march.RH Sep 21, 1916 The call now is to look up, be of good courage, and go directly through these modern Hebrons and Jerichos to warn them and gather out the honest, for we are well able to go up and possess the land.RH Sep 21, 1916
Only those like Caleb and Joshua, who cultivated faith, hope and courage and hastened to advance ready to meet every obstacle and possess the goodly land, entered in from Egypt into the promised land, while those who murmured fearing that they and their children would starve if they went forward did not go through. Trusting God now by giving means to advance His cause trains the perfect faith needed to depend wholly on God for miraculous bread and water when probation closes and the plagues bring hunger on the wicked.
To return to Egypt means to cling to worldliness, unrighteousness and unholiness and to stand with those who do not serve God, set against crossing over Jordan with those who serve Him.RH Jan 25, 1906 It marks one part of the mixed multitude turning back instead of going forward.RH Jan 25, 1906 In purifying His church God thus draws a separating line, removing impurity and dross from the mixture of divine with worldly elements so she becomes capable of the high use He intends and the wonders of His power unto salvation can be revealed through her.RH Jan 25, 1906
Complaining against the Lord's leading from fear that following Him will bring death, with desire to return rather than go forward, is distrust that the next step under God will be good and needed, bracing back and going grudgingly against advance reform.RH Feb 14, 1865 Applied to health, it forbids fearing that giving up tobacco and injurious articles of diet such as tea and coffee will lead to starvation and wanting the old habits again.RH Feb 14, 1865 The Lord leads His people aright to bring soul and body to health and make them temples of the Holy Spirit, and the coming step brings blessing and what is needed, not harm.RH Feb 14, 1865
Turning back from the promised land into the wilderness of unbelief when entry was possible warns schools and education.RH Mar 19, 1901RH Mar 19, 1901 When the ten spies brought a discouraging report, the giant of financial difficulty looked invincible, Israel were as grasshoppers in their own sight, and fear of future difficulties led them to give up and return.RH Mar 19, 1901 So closing church schools because the church fears it cannot afford to pay the teacher is the same unbelief, leaving the promised land of Christian education for the wilderness.RH Mar 19, 1901 Having great light on education yet refusing to receive and act on it, hiding the light under a bushel instead of advancing, likewise fails to be leaders in education and fails to advance spiritually.RH Mar 19, 1901
The image of a people after leaving Egypt under Moses becoming dissatisfied on the desert journey and wanting to set him aside and return pictures citizens who expect political change to deliver from graft, greed and dissatisfaction but may soon reject their chosen leader and choose a worse one.ST Nov 22, 1910 Complaining in trial against Moses, though not directly against God, was counted as murmuring against God because God had chosen and instructed him, led his mind and talked with him, and the people had evidence of this.RH Nov 18, 1873 Loyalty to the Creator is thus tested by whether men love downtrodden truth most or the approbation of the world in an unpopular special movement of God, showing the fearful responsibility of leading such a work requiring special instruction by the Spirit, where to hinder and discourage such a chosen leader and refuse his testimony works against God who made him His agent and certainly brings His frown upon the hinderers.RH Nov 18, 1873
Sources