Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
Open rebuke is better than secret love.
Better is open rebuke than love that is hidden.
Better is open rebuke
Than love that is hidden.Better [is] open reproof than hidden love.
Darby Translation, Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Open rebuke is better than hidden love.
Better is a rebuke that is open, than love carefully concealed.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Better an open rebuke
than love that is concealed.Better is open rebuke
than hidden love.Better is open protest than love kept secret.
Open rebuke is better then secret loue.
Cross-references
- Galatians 2:11-14
But when Peter was come to Antioch, I withstood him to the face, because he was to be blamed.
Paul openly reproved Peter for his dissimulation.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
3 sources
Open rebuke is better than love that stays hidden or is withheld.ED 90.1–2ST Jan 2, 1893STB 42.2–43.1 Honest reproof is more valuable than hidden love and is to be prized above flattery.ST Jan 2, 1893 A rebuke can be an act of love, with even a painful warning meant to heal and give hope.ED 90.1–2 Those who are tempted or have done wrong need such tender correction.ED 90.1–2
Open rebuke is necessary when defiance of God's counsel endangers others, so that others will not be ensnared.STB 42.2–43.1 Staying silent to spare feelings or to protect a wrongdoer's influence supports falsehood.STB 42.2–43.1 Rejecting repeated warnings and the Holy Spirit's reproof hardens the heart and brings spiritual darkness.STB 42.2–43.1
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
16 sources
Direct, open correction is better than love kept secret, hidden and unexpressed that offers no rebuke, and honest reproof is to be prized above flattery, flattering encouragement and flattering silence.ST Jan 2, 1893RH Jan 10, 1854ST Nov 20, 1879RH Jul 6, 1868RH Aug 25, 1868 A true friend shows courage to speak directly of faults unseen and warn of danger, even to frustrate a cherished plan to prevent harm, rather than spreading unfavorable reports to others, for even painful reproof can protect from ruin and bring peace afterward while flattery harms souls.RH Jan 10, 1854ST May 17, 1877RH Jul 6, 1868RH Jun 5, 1866 Proper reproof is given privately first on good evidence of real wrong to win back a brother, from a desire to benefit him and not from ill temper, and timely reproof so given is an act of mercy and sincere friendship that can stop sin and save from harm and future grief.RH Jan 10, 1854RH Oct 5, 1869RH Jul 29, 1875ST Feb 4, 1886ST Mar 24, 1909 It should be humbly borne, listened to and heeded rather than defended or resisted, for when taken to heart it is safe and profitable, leading to repentance and good fruit and bringing the heart into harmony with righteousness and peace.ST May 17, 1877RH Jul 6, 1868RH Jun 5, 1866RH Aug 25, 1868ST Apr 2, 1912
Setting and Plain Meaning
Proverbs 27:5 belongs to chapters 25 to 29, which were copied out of Solomon's writings by men appointed by Hezekiah.ST Sep 8, 1909
Direct, open correction is better than love kept secret, hidden, and unexpressed that offers no rebuke.RH Jan 10, 1854ST Nov 20, 1879RH Aug 25, 1868RH Apr 12, 1864RH Nov 3, 1868
Honest reproof is more valuable than hidden affection.ST Jan 2, 1893RH Jul 6, 1868RH Jan 16, 1872
It is to be prized above flattery, flattering encouragement, and flattering silence.ST Jan 2, 1893RH Jul 6, 1868RH Jan 16, 1872
Plain, faithful reproof is better than love kept hidden or expressed only through evasive praise and flattering silence.RH Jul 6, 1868
Flattery can lead people to ruin, while even painful reproof from a loved friend can protect them from it and bring peace afterward.ST May 17, 1877
Honest correction may bring greater love and respect in the end than evasive praise.RH Jul 6, 1868
A minister who flatters rather than confronting sin can harm people's souls.ST May 17, 1877RH Jul 6, 1868
Giving and Receiving Reproof
A true friend is willing to see faults and has courage to speak of them, rather than hiding love in silence.ST May 17, 1877RH Jun 5, 1866 Such friendship warns of danger and points out faults the person does not see, even to the point of frustrating a cherished plan in order to prevent harm.RH Jun 5, 1866RH Jul 29, 1875 Faults are spoken of directly to the person, not spread in unfavorable reports to others, for spreading reports wounds believers and harms the cause.RH Jan 10, 1854RH Jul 29, 1875 Rebuke is fitting only on good evidence of a real wrong, and the one at fault is to be approached privately first, with further witnesses or the church brought in only if needed, so that the aim throughout is to win back a brother.RH Jan 10, 1854
Right reproof springs from a desire to benefit the wrongdoer and is inspired by the Spirit of God, not from ill temper or personal dissatisfaction, and it is given with care and a desire to help.RH Oct 5, 1869ST Mar 24, 1909 It is therefore wholly different from fault-finding and grumbling, and a church that leaves no place for it is asleep in sin.RH Oct 5, 1869ST Mar 24, 1909 Timely reproof of this kind is an act of mercy and sincere friendship: it can stop sin, save the wrongdoer from harm and future grief, and lead to prayer and good.RH Jul 29, 1875ST Feb 4, 1886ST Mar 24, 1909 Such needed correction should not be withheld for later, for praise and affection expressed only after death cannot do this work.ST Feb 4, 1886
Correction is to be humbly borne, listened to, and heeded rather than defended or resisted, and this includes accepting the Lord's chastening as profitable.RH Jun 5, 1866RH Aug 25, 1868 Those who are instructed should be honored and those who reprove should be thanked, with careful correction from brethren for spiritual welfare received in humility.RH Apr 12, 1864RH Nov 3, 1868 Just correction should be acknowledged promptly for the truth it offers, not rejected because of its manner or suspected motive, with the fault treated as an enemy and resentment resisted.ST Apr 2, 1912 Though unpleasant, reproof taken to heart is safe and profitable, leading to repentance and good fruit in cooperation with God's purpose of salvation.ST May 17, 1877RH Jan 16, 1872 So received, it benefits the soul, helps others, brings the heart into harmony with righteousness and peace, and can bring greater love and respect in the end.ST May 17, 1877RH Jul 6, 1868ST Apr 2, 1912
Sources