God did not permit Satan to remain after fall because leaving him would constantly jeopardize heaven's government, his fall being rebellion against perfect law, and by the same principle He cannot admit persistent rejecters of His Word into the everlasting kingdom just as Saul was rejected from temporal Israel.ST Mar 24, 1898 After expulsion he determined to make earth his kingdom conquering everything to own and rule the world, thinking overcoming Adam and Eve choosing him as ruler secured possession, so this world became the battlefield and bone of contention where Satan fiercely works while God holds some hearts true.ST Jun 16, 1909 The rebellion cast out was appointed to be conquered by Christ in human flesh as Immanuel so every ill will be extinguished.RH Jul 1, 1902 Mercy must not be overstrained to sympathize with that rebellion beyond reason, for sympathy has right limit, and as with human offenders confession may receive sympathy but shifting ground pleading innocence must be abandoned, since seeking sympathizers injures others and makes the case hopeless while straightforward confession like the prodigal's wins heart, robe and feast.RH Oct 29, 1872
Satan was banished for pride and ambition cherished in heart, deeply rooted in fallen nature overshadowing every good quality and bringing envy and strife. Christians must therefore repress envy as religious duty, rejoice in brethren's superior reputation or prosperity though own achievements are shaded, seek goodness not greatness, have Christ's mind with humble self-views, and labor for church purity ready to sacrifice interests rather than cause dissension. The verse shows defeat and expulsion of his first great confederacy for monopoly control of God's kingdom, launched in his own interest in unbelief in God's power, wisdom and goodness presupposing Christ incapable of running government and Satan's position disregarded, wrecking pure lives of joining angels and ending when they prevailed not and were cast out as profane, while God's kingdom still exists with Christ in control. The spirit of rebellion was cast out with no place, for heaven was strong enough to expel and keeps it out, and this was not merely degradation of angels already outside.RH Sep 7, 1869ST Mar 10, 1881
Timing of Castings
The heavenly war followed Satan's first fall rather than being that first fall itself, with the first fall shown in the drawing of the stars and the later conflict reaching back before the birth of the child to include the defeated effort through pagan Rome.ST Mar 10, 1881ST Jun 18, 1912ST May 13, 1903 After Satan fell, Christ descended from His position with the Father to become Michael the Archangel, and the spiritual conflict between them continued until Christ died.ST Jun 18, 1912 The war belongs to the period preceding the birth of Christ, proving no power can forever prevail against eternal right.ST May 13, 1903
The verse identifies the first casting of Satan and his angels from heaven, after which they no longer had place there.RH Jan 22, 1901ST Feb 3, 1914 This initial expulsion did not prevent Satan from later appearing at heavenly councils as representative of the earth he had usurped from Adam.ST Feb 3, 1914 It is distinct from a second casting down associated with Christ's death on the cross, and from a future third casting down described in Revelation 20.RH Jan 22, 1901ST Feb 3, 1914
The dragon's defeat in conflict with Michael is part of the victory Christ secured through the events culminating in His crucifixion, securing eternal victory for all who trust in Him.ST Jun 17, 1903ST Jul 4, 1911ST Nov 26, 1896 Satan's fall began his opposition to God's people, and Christ's victory in the conflict culminating in the crucifixion secured their final victory.ST Nov 26, 1896
The verse marks final expulsion at Christ's death and ascension, when Satan was cast to earth and the controversy was thereafter confined to earth.RH Oct 8, 1903ST Jul 4, 1911 His work as accuser ended because Christ's obedience and death vindicated God's law and goodness and secured His right to represent this world in place of Satan, who had represented it after Adam forfeited dominion.RH Oct 8, 1903ST Jun 22, 1904 Though cast from where God dwells to overthrow man and become prince of this world, he had still come with the sons of God to present himself before the Lord, but after the cross his appearance among the rulers and heads of worlds could no longer be recognized in heaven.ST May 26, 1909
After Christ conquered through death and resurrection, Satan and the evil angels could no longer take part in the spiritual conflict in heaven or accuse God and His servants there, their character having been demonstrated beyond question.ST Jul 6, 1915 Their warfare thereafter was directed toward destroying humanity.ST Jul 6, 1915 The heaven from which place was lost here denotes the spiritual realm of conflict, not the very heaven where God dwells.ST Jul 6, 1915
The rebellion had left the heavenly world uncertain of its outcome, and place was held vacant while God's justice, wisdom and love were demonstrated and loyal angels remained perplexed but faithful.ST May 30, 1911 When Satan's hatred led him and his angels to bring about Christ's death, their choice became final beyond repentance and hope.ST May 30, 1911 Christ's character exposed Lucifer's true character and defeated him, so the usurping prince could no longer enter God's councils as accuser, showing right not expediency is eternal might.ST May 30, 1911
The final casting down came after Christ rose victorious over death and hell, culminating the conflict between Christ as Michael and Satan following their earlier expulsion.ST Dec 12, 1906 Satan and his angels were cast into the earth after resurrection and ascension, with no power to return.ST Sep 26, 1911ST Nov 25, 1913 The earth becomes his abode during the thousand years, where punishment begins as he faces ruin and confinement to the desolate earth serves as part of punishment and lesson to the universe.ST Sep 26, 1911ST Nov 25, 1913
Satan as prince of this world was judged and cast out at the close of Christ's earthly work, proving a final judgment when all must stand before the judgment-seat of Christ of which the Comforter convinces the world.ST Apr 1, 1897 When Christ cried It is finished, Satan and his angels were uprooted from the affection and sympathy and confidence of unfallen angels, who until then had doubted because of his deception.ST Sep 23, 1889 The cross settled doubt by revealing the contrast between God who moves straightforward and cannot lie and Satan crooked as a serpent, and the resurrection proved power to bind the strong man and despoil his goods, to the joy of all heaven.ST Sep 23, 1889
The casting out belongs to Christ's triumph over sin, Satan and death, announced at Pentecost when the Spirit empowered the apostles to proclaim the crucified and risen Jesus exalted to the Father's throne and beginning High Priest ministry in the heavenly sanctuary.RH Aug 28, 1913 Michael prevailed in the battle of the ages when every power and device against incarnate righteousness was met by the Prince of life with the King's weapons and armor of righteousness before all the host, bringing eternal defeat to Satan and eternal victory to Christ and the faithful.ST May 13, 1903
Christ's victory is linked to undertaking humanity's cause, bearing the Father's wrath in sinners' place, enduring temptation and the cross, and rising conqueror.RH Jun 29, 1869 Defeated by the Son in heaven, Satan tried to overthrow Jesus to keep his claimed kingdom and prevent redemption, inspiring wicked men to nail Him to the cross, yet Jesus remained faithful and the cross triumphed over him.ST Jul 23, 1874ST Oct 23, 1901 Through appointed suffering and death He would reclaim the kingdoms as everlasting possession, and Satan after pretending to be Christ himself will be destroyed, thereby acknowledging defeat.ST Jul 23, 1874ST Jul 4, 1906ST Oct 23, 1901
The conquest took place in connection with the first advent at the climax of the controversy, revealing Christ's love and power to the angels so they could no longer hold place.ST Jun 26, 1893 Lucifer had despised high honor, trusted brightness and beauty, set his heart as God's, and drawn a third of the host into open revolt with anarchy.ST Feb 24, 1898 Refusing confession and all mercy, he became filled with settled hatred and vengeance and resolved on continual war until Christ burst death's bonds, since which he knows himself vanquished with overthrow only a matter of time, ushering great wrath against Jesus and the church growing hotter as his short time nears.ST Feb 24, 1898
At his fall he was still an angel with noble kingly qualities desiring restoration, the full nature and consequences of sin not yet seen.RH Nov 7, 1865 Created perfect without evil nature and placed on probation with power to obey or disobey, he cherished jealousy of Jesus, trusted beauty, wisdom, position and authority to protect him, and persisted into open rebellion against Jesus and the Father with full knowledge and no excuse, so no repentance is granted and rank cannot save.ST Dec 31, 1874 His secession first brought discord into the universe and continued in Eden, where Adam's sin brought earth as his domain into separation from God's government.RH May 28, 1861
The failure to rival God cast Lucifer to earth and transferred the controversy begun in heaven to this world.RH Oct 21, 1902ST Feb 16, 1915 The heavenly conflict centered on demands to change or abolish God's law and government, against which he gathered followers persuaded his cause was just.RH Oct 21, 1902ST May 5, 1898 Not permitted to continue rebellion in heaven, they were cast to earth where Satan found place to carry out principles, demonstrate his government and prove his claims, so this world's history has been that rebellion's history.ST May 5, 1898 God did not at once destroy him and his host lest it seem arbitrary proof of injustice, but left intelligences of this and other worlds to learn divine love.ST May 5, 1898
To place the 2300 days as ending at the ascension would push connected prophetic events back into the past and place the dragon near the time of Moses.ST Aug 12, 1875 The fall and loss of place belong after creation and before man's fall and the plan of redemption, as part of the great controversy running from creation to the new earth and through the destruction of sin and sinners at the close of the thousand years.RH Oct 30, 1900ST Mar 11, 1880ST Jul 21, 1881ST Mar 31, 1881 The verse describes the false religious power's defeat and loss of heavenly place in the first struggle between the dragon and the church, preceding later conflicts between the beast and saints and between the two beasts and the remnant.RH May 3, 1870RH Dec 25, 1900
War Moved Earthward
Cast off from heaven after failing against Michael and his angels, the dragon and his angels no longer had a place there, and the first war begun through pride, selfishness, jealousy against the Son and desire for power and position was transferred to earth.RH Dec 11, 1916ST Jan 29, 1902ST Nov 28, 1900ST Apr 2, 1902 Having lost heaven, Satan sought to establish his kingdom on earth, where he temporarily exercises the dominion he usurped from Adam by deceit for a short race until his utter overthrow is assured, when Christ as the second Adam will take the dominion the first Adam lost and restore the first dominion to earth and humanity.ST Nov 28, 1900ST Apr 2, 1902 Cast off from his earlier connection he came to persecute the seed of the Son made in God's image, leading the first pair through falsehood to join rebellion, and the controversy begun in heaven now stirs human sin and war through pride, ambition and greed.RH Dec 11, 1916ST Jan 29, 1902RH Dec 11, 1916 His true character is thus to be revealed to all the universe while his time is short.
After the conflict in heaven Satan sought dominion over earth and established a rival kingdom to oppose God, draw people into rebellion, destroy humanity especially the loyal, continue war against God and deceive people into disobeying truth, and wrest the earth's possession and sovereignty from the Son, while Christ worked against his efforts to bring humanity under his rule.ST Feb 17, 1909RH Nov 13, 1900RH Oct 8, 1908RH Dec 11, 1916 Through him sin entered the world and death by sin, frustrating in intent God's plan to make human beings a new distinct order in God's image to populate earth in close communion with heaven and live sinless lives upheld by God. He opposed humanity and tried to prevent the promised Deliverer by destroying the Messianic line through which the Messiah was to be born, but God preserved that line to Jesus.ST Nov 7, 1906
After expulsion he tempted Adam by lying reports about God, and Adam and Eve believed his lie and fell, so that sin entered a world created perfect without spot, stain, sin or imperfection, and death entered by sin with trying consequences continuing to the close of earth's history and woe upon the world.RH Jul 21, 1904ST Jun 20, 1900 In Eden he hid evil beneath the serpent's appearance of life and happiness and through disobedience won humanity as his first subject, bringing the spirit of vengeance into human experience, beneath which lie pride and rebellion.ST Sep 30, 1930 In seeking to take God's place he repeated the same claim on earth, telling the first humans they could be like gods.ST May 18, 1904
The deception by which he led angels to rebel was then used against Adam and Eve, and their fall began the continuing conflict between good and evil on earth.RH May 3, 1906 He was first to rebel, left the courts of heaven and carried sin to this world where the first parents dwelt in peace, becoming the great author of sin whose work causes all miseries, sorrows and perplexities of this life.ST Jul 22, 1889 His false claims had first led many angels away from loyalty so they lost their place in heaven, and their fall preceded the temptation of Adam and Eve.RH Jan 21, 1904
The defeat means their place was no longer in heaven and the conflict shifted to earth, where Michael the Son of God as leader of the angels conquered him.ST Apr 7, 1914 Satan did not prevail in conflict with Christ and was driven from heaven, and after Christ's victory his wrath turned against the church, so the conflict continued on earth between spiritual powers of good and evil through visible human forces including the church and earthly powers.ST Nov 7, 1906
The defeat and expulsion did not end warfare or the struggle against right, for he continued on earth the same rebellion and falsehood begun in heaven, laboring constantly to deceive minds to call sin righteousness and righteousness sin, turning censure upon faithful servants standing for truth while his agents are praised as martyrs, a warfare carried century to century to the present.ST Oct 25, 1883RH Sep 30, 1909 The chapter shows Satan as instigator of persecution warring against truth through successive apostasy and persecution through the centuries, even against the remnant who keep God's commandments and have the testimony of Jesus, as the real persecutor of the church whose opposition does not prevail while Christ triumphs over Satan and sin.ST Oct 24, 1911ST Dec 24, 1912ST Dec 23, 1908 Sin and its accuser were barred from heaven, Michael's victory exposed Lucifer's character, freed angels from deception and vindicated God through everlasting righteousness, and Satan in rage for the short time remaining before destruction and cleansing of the universe turns against Christ's followers.ST Nov 5, 1896
Immediately after the expulsion, when the Son and loyal angels prevailed and no taint of rebellion was left and heaven was again peaceful with hosts adoring the God of justice while mourning former companions, the Father consulted Jesus about carrying out their purpose to make man to inhabit earth and place him on probation to test loyalty before rendering him eternally secure, with promise if he endured he would be equal with angels, have God's favor and converse with angels, deliberately not placed beyond power of disobedience.RH Feb 8, 1915 Satan attempted to defeat that plan to make human beings a new distinct order in God's image to populate earth in communion with heaven sinless upheld by God, by bringing jealousy into heavenly courts, communicating disaffection to many angels, causing war, and after expulsion determining to set up his kingdom on earth, through whom sin entered the world and death by sin.
The expulsion confirms Satan's rule over the fallen angels cast out with him after failing to prevail and losing place.ST Jan 28, 1875 These are evil spirits that sinned, wicked seducing unclean spirits and spirits of devils under Satan the great dragon, old serpent, devil deceiving the whole world as commander of darkness, opposed by Christ as Captain of the Lord's host with good ministering angels, seeking to deceive, ensnare and drag down every unguarded soul, and their working is the supernatural power behind modern Spiritism.RH Feb 9, 1864ST Sep 11, 1901 They are the unseen spirits behind Spiritualist communications, not spirits of the dead, knowing details of human friends in life and after death claiming to be their disembodied spirits, with Satan appearing as an angel of light and his ministers as ministers of righteousness through mediums at human bidding as demons of the bottomless pit assuming guise of the dear and holy, bringing no benefit but positive damage to character.RH Feb 9, 1864ST May 27, 1880ST Jul 17, 1901
These malign spirits identified as demons, familiar spirits, unclean spirits and angels of the devil can deceive through apparent materialized forms or making people believe they see what is not there.ST Dec 10, 1912 Cast out and now on earth to deceive, they wage warfare appearing to saints as dead loved ones with same features, unchanged voice and loving manner professing to come as special friends to help, exciting sympathy and working miracles to confirm what they declare, adroitly leading into pleasing apparently reasonable but unscriptural doctrines. The same warfare begun in heaven has continued on earth nearly six thousand years under new disguise through pretended visitants teaching no difference between righteous and wicked, undermining Scripture and faith, setting aside God's law, despising grace, counting the covenant blood unholy, denying Christ's divinity and leveling the Creator with themselves, broken only by thorough present truth from Scripture especially the state of the dead and Thus saith the Lord, since the devil comes unexpectedly when people think themselves strong.RH Sep 11, 1916ST Dec 8, 1909
The fallen being and angels with him now roam earth invisibly after losing place, and the fallen foe can exert unseen power including behind levitations at séances, which are not performed by the dead who have no life between death and resurrection.ST Feb 10, 1914 Lucifer the fallen archangel remains as the spirit of evil at work through modern occultism and spiritualism as his agencies, and worship of Lucifer in temples, chapels and the Black Mass is worship of this fallen archangel.RH Mar 15, 1906
His fall exposes voodooism and related beliefs and helps counter evil spirits.RH Nov 3, 1910 His effort to destroy God's people and prevent the Man-child repeatedly failed because God intervened, thwarting his plans through Babylon, Medo-Persia, Grecia and Pagan Rome.ST Nov 19, 1896
Their continued activity on earth is allowed so theories and results of rebellion can be demonstrated and the nature of his government, principles and claims proved, for God did not at once destroy Satan and his host lest it seem arbitrary proof God wished only His own way and increased imagined injustice, while intelligences of this and other worlds would never have known divine love.ST May 5, 1898 His power and freedom are curtailed as Christ receives the kingdom temporarily usurped, preparing final destruction on earth. During the thousand years they are cut off from deceiving and ruining people and can only counsel with one another.ST Jul 31, 1893
The rebellion must be put down because sin could spread to other parts of the universe, aiming to banish sin and restore earth to perfect harmony with God's government.ST Mar 21, 1906 The heavenly rebellion connected with deception in Eden brought discord followed by sin, sorrow and suffering on earth, and accepting and spreading the same falsehood and exalting creature above Creator leads to the fallen cherub's reward.ST Apr 27, 1904RH Oct 10, 1912
When his place was no more found the rebellion begun under Lucifer the covering cherub was transferred to earth under its original leader, who still carries it forward as invisible leader of a worldwide confederacy of evil pervaded by his spirit, whose visible leaders in the final crisis are the papacy as the Beast in the Old World and the Image to the Beast in the New.RH Nov 5, 1901 His attempt to gain power in heaven failed, and Babel's plan for world empire and enforced heathen religion was its earthly counterfeit.ST Jul 18, 1916
In the great closing work of the rebellion evil powers unite in desperate struggle with deceptive plans to ruin souls, with ministers, physicians and lawmakers uniting in rebellion under pretentious garb of righteousness as form of godliness without power, while those heeding sophistries and rejecting light are converted to his theories too late seeing God's angels at war against departers from the faith.RH Sep 30, 1909 This heavenly defeat makes him a defeated foe in the later earthly conflict.ST Nov 23, 1915
Since rebellion and expulsion he continues trying to wrest souls from Christ while flesh and Spirit contend for mastery in lives.RH Aug 24, 1916 He is a fallen angel leading people into sin, and following him binds them toward destruction.RH Jan 7, 1873 His rebellion and influence in heaven preceded tempting humanity, and his defeat there did not end conflict, for he continued trying to thwart God's saving purpose by tempting Christ, working to thwart salvation until Christ ends his career.STST Feb 22, 1883
The one causing rebellion among angels was cast out with no place, compared with humanity driven from Eden.ST Sep 12, 1900 The devil left heaven because resisted and no longer wanted there, and the same principle applies on earth where earnest following of Christ, purity of heart and decided immediate resistance at every return causes him to flee and brings fresh defeat.RH Feb 27, 1908
Satan's rebellion against heaven's government is precedent for later rebellions against it.RH Aug 12, 1862 His success in deceiving angels gave confidence he could also overcome Christ.ST Feb 18, 1913 The faithful angels who fought for God and triumphed so he did not prevail had shouted for joy over creation and sinless inhabitants and witnessed man's fall and expulsion from Eden, and those same victorious messengers now cooperate invisibly with visible agencies, ministering in necessity to co-workers with God, overseeing stewards, caring for spiritual welfare of seekers of God's moral image, rejoicing in prosperity of the work, binding wounds sin made to save the perishing and restore God's image.ST Dec 1, 1909RH Mar 19, 1901
The expulsion followed rebellion and was the immediate cause of enmity against God and humanity after the dragon and his angels failed against Michael and lost place.RH Feb 8, 1915 About one-third sympathized with Lucifer and after open rebellion were cast out with him, losing home and standing, leaving the church to cope with that fallen host against the unnumbered faithful angels.ST Oct 25, 1883ST Jun 22, 1904ST Jul 2, 1902ST Apr 21, 1898
Historic Church Persecution
Revelation 12:8 belongs to the period of papal persecution and suppression of the Scriptures described in Daniel 7:25, Daniel 12, Revelation 11 and Revelation 13.ST Feb 13, 1907ST May 14, 1894ST May 3, 1877RH Jan 14, 1862RH Apr 15, 1875 The 1,260 prophetic days are literal years, reckoned as twelve 30-day months, covering papal supremacy from 538 to 1798.ST Feb 13, 1907ST Apr 6, 1915ST May 14, 1894ST May 3, 1877RH Apr 15, 1875 That period ended when French forces took Rome, carried the pope into exile, took away dominion and gave the deadly wound.ST May 3, 1877RH Jan 14, 1862RH Apr 15, 1875 Through those Dark Ages God preserved an unbroken chain of witnesses holding gospel truth in obscurity, which proves the two witnesses are not two individual persons because no two individuals live through so long an era.ST Feb 13, 1907RH Jan 14, 1862 After the man child Christ ascended to God and His throne, the dragon turned in wrathful persecution upon the woman, the church left upon the earth, and the wilderness to which she flees is an earthly not heavenly retreat, with the earth helping her by swallowing the flood proving the conflict is on earth where the remnant still contends with the devil in this present evil world.ST Feb 13, 1907
The verse is part of the prophecy of the church's time in the wilderness, when during the Dark Ages she was driven into seclusion for 1,260 years and given into the hands of a persecuting power as definite fulfilled prophecy.ST Nov 28, 1895RH Jul 8, 1909 Revelation 12 covers in substance the same history as Daniel 7, the empires of Babylon, Medo-Persia, Grecia and Rome united and divided, including the persecuting career of the little horn of the apostasy from A.D. 538 to 1798 with a brief revival just before the Lord comes, indicating the next great event is the setting up of His kingdom though not revealing the definite time of His coming.ST Nov 28, 1895 The line fixes the time of the end to 1798, the close of the 1,260 days of persecution.ST Nov 28, 1895
In historical application the pagan dragon power persecuted the early church but did not prevail to destroy it and fell before nominal Christianity.RH Feb 21, 1865ST Dec 1, 1914ST Jan 21, 1889 After three centuries persecution ceased for a time when a pagan emperor supported Christianity for political reasons, and the flood of pagan persecution was swallowed when the earth opened her mouth at the professed conversion of Constantine the Roman emperor in the fourth century.ST Dec 1, 1914ST Jan 21, 1889 Satan then changed his method, using corrupt Christianity and the papal Beast to continue attacking the true church.RH Feb 21, 1865RH Mar 17, 1903 The chapter thus begins with Christ's birth and extends to His coming, revealing Satan's work through paganism, the papacy and apostate Protestantism marked by self-salvation and deception hiding Christ as Saviour from sin, and it has been fulfilled in the history of the church under pagan and papal persecution including the effort to destroy the Child Christ Jesus, the 1260 days, the helpful influence of the Reformation in preserving the church, and the final wrath of the dragon against the remnant because of the commandments of God and the spirit of prophecy, bringing the prophecy down to the present day with its wilderness period when Sabbathkeepers were killed and banished.RH Mar 17, 1903RH Jan 12, 1905RH Nov 24, 1910 The dragon's wrath then made war upon the remnant of her seed, the faithful few who rejected the union of church and state and refused to become Papists.ST Jan 21, 1889
The persecuting power did not win, so God's true church was no longer found in Rome but was carried on eagle's wings into the wilderness to the lofty heights of the snow-covered Alps, which God had prepared as a refuge and where He kept the persecuted safely for many centuries during the Dark Ages, in contrast to Babylon the great with its palaces and churches on the seven hills of Rome.RH Sep 13, 1906 The earth helping the woman by swallowing the flood represents the Reformation under Luther and his co-workers, when German states supported the Protestant cause, protected the reformers and restrained persecution, though this help also drew insincere people who joined for self-interest.ST May 25, 1882
The dragon's defeat and the place in the wilderness were fulfilled hundreds of years ago, and the verse does not promise a future refuge from the dragon's wrath in a literal wilderness place nor call believers now to gather to such a place as Shiloh for protection.ST Sep 28, 1904 The vision belongs to the seven-headed dragon whose reign and persecution of Christ's church extend from the beginning to the end of the Christian era.ST Nov 1, 1910ST Oct 22, 1902
Revelation 12 is a sketch of the powers used by Satan against the church from Christ's first advent to His second, namely three powers: the Dragon, the Beast and the Image of the Beast, which are pagan Rome, papal Rome and American Rome.RH Mar 20, 1900 Rome is Satan's seat and the center from which decrees were issued against holders of gospel truths from Constantine's rise in A.D. 312 until the establishment of the Papacy.RH Mar 26, 1857
The verse shows Satan the deceiver, accuser and adversary behind the evil Babylonian system of union of church and state from Babylon of old to the Papacy in connection with worldly powers did not prevail.ST Jul 1, 1903 He deceives the nations into believing this system in some form is necessary to salvation, to good order, to civil government and to preservation of religion, and he carries on this deception in every age through great popular but backslidden apostate religious bodies that once knew truth but departed from righteousness by faith, refused increased light and voluntarily united with earthly powers to enforce religious dogmas by law.ST Jul 1, 1903 Through them he accuses those who protest the prevailing religious system, and the accusations end in persecution unless God interposes, and through this system in its various phases he opposes the simple all-effectual truth of God's free gospel of grace received by faith.ST Jul 1, 1903
The dragon prevailed not and lost its place, the dragon being Satan working as pagan Rome which sought to destroy Christ by moving Herod to put Him to death and then made war upon Christ and His people through the first centuries, then assuming the form of the papacy to carry the work forward with the dragon merged in the first Beast, and with the lamb-like beast that came up when the Beast went into captivity in 1798 also speaking like a dragon and causing worship of the Beast and his image.RH Mar 5, 1901 That worship is worship of the dragon and is sun-worship, whether Parsee prayer toward the sun, pagan idolatry, or worship of the image representing the papacy by observing the first day of the week in its honor, and the Third Angel's Message forbids it all, while God's people come out of the conflict in triumph and stand upon Mount Zion by keeping the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus and those rejecting the warning drink the unmixed wrath of God.RH Mar 5, 1901ST May 30, 1911 Michael stands on the side of those preaching the Sabbath, so they need not be frightened by the dragon's opposition.RH Mar 15, 1864
The account of the great red dragon exposes rulers who profess justice yet condemn the innocent.RH Mar 21, 1854 As Pilate found no cause for Christ's death yet ordered Him crucified, so laws and conduct in the United States punishing people for helping enslaved people escape show the same contradiction between profession and action.RH Mar 21, 1854RH Jul 2, 1857
Revelation 12 presents the church passing through a wilderness state during which it absorbed errors from the papacy, and those inherited errors later contributed to division among Protestants whom God would have united in truth.RH Mar 3, 1874 The same spirit of rebellion that failed in heaven and lost its place there worked in fanatical opponents of the Reformation, who falsely claimed injustice, gained sympathy as supposed martyrs and worked to tear down the work.ST Oct 25, 1883 Yet Michael will prevail as people hear the truth and come out of Babylon despite opposition from their leaders.RH Oct 24, 1885
The verse belongs to the account of Satan's rebellion in heaven where he sought to alter God's law, raised his own judgment above his Creator's and placed his will above God's, treating God as fallible, and the same defiance is repeated on earth when the pope claims authority to correct God's law.ST Nov 26, 1912 Cast to earth he insinuated himself between man and the Creator, working under a form of godliness without the power so he himself might not be observed, and instituted a system focused in a visible head called the man of sin repeating his boast to be like the Most High, whose mark of power is its change of God's seventh-day Sabbath to the Sunday institution, a heathen holiday with no divine authority leading men to tread upon God's holy day.ST Jan 21, 1903 Papal power thus fulfilled the little horn's work of speaking great words against the Most High, with priestly claims to power over Christ, forgiveness and judgment presented as that blasphemous exaltation, and the rebellious power that opposed heaven and failed and lost its place there faces expected downfall with its priesthood claiming authority over Christ and over forgiveness of sinners.RH May 24, 1870RH Feb 10, 1874
The verse belongs to a prophetic picture in which the dragon's attacks against the woman, the true church, are overcome and she is protected by God, teaching that the church cannot meet the powers of earth by its own strength but must trust God while warning the world of its coming doom.RH Oct 23, 1913 The casting out of Satan from the heavenly courts at the beginning, when he prevailed not and his place was found no more in heaven, took with him a third part of God's angels.RH Jan 22, 1901 The taking away of the kingly power of Judea by pagan Rome after the death of Herod, leaving the land forsaken of both her kings at Christ's first advent, was a perfect object-lesson illustrating that original expulsion, connected with the later removal of one third of the Jewish nation's rulers by pagan Rome.RH Jan 22, 1901
Doctrine of Law Government
Satan's rebellion arose from ambition, from refusal to submit to Christ's authority, and from opposition to God's constitution and government, especially His law, and therefore he and the angels who joined him did not prevail against Christ and the loyal angels and lost their place in heaven.RH Feb 8, 1915ST Apr 30, 1896 That same rebellion against the law has been carried on ever since the fall of man, as Satan seeks through evil men to make void the law of the Most High, while the Son of God was manifested to destroy those works and vindicated and honored the law as the foundation of all the law and the prophets.ST Apr 30, 1896
Expulsion followed his desire for supremacy above God and his attempt to set aside God's unchangeable law, and Christ came to confront and conquer Satan and expose his misrepresentation of God's character.ST Nov 12, 1912 He was cast out of heaven because of his transgression, and from then on he has sought to defeat God's purpose for humanity by making God's law appear imperfect, unjust, tyrannical, and impossible to keep.RH Apr 29, 1902 By misrepresentations of the law he led many angels of heaven to take his side in apostasy and rebellion, and by the same method he has secured the world and even the largest share of the professedly Christian church in enmity to the law of Jehovah.ST Jan 9, 1896
God's law governs the heavenly kingdom, and because it condemns sin the devil and his angels were banished from heaven.ST Sep 30, 1886ST Nov 11, 1886 The cross of Christ gives that law lasting and enduring honor by satisfying its demands and by showing both the punishment of sin and God's righteousness and justice in that punishment.ST Sep 30, 1886ST Nov 11, 1886
An angel once honored in heaven rebelled and fell from his high estate, then led other fallen angels and fallen humanity in rebellion against God's government.ST Nov 14, 1878 They became fallen angels and powers of darkness waging war against God's truth and government, and because their rebellion opposed heaven's peace, order, and government they were cast down and kept in darkness for judgment.ST Sep 16, 1930RH Jan 9, 1872
Their rebellion was incurable, and their removal from heaven demonstrated God's justice, for God must ultimately remove sin from the universe rather than surrender His throne, and sinners who refuse pardon and cleansing will be removed with sin.ST Jun 23, 1914 Satan was the first great rebel and first apostate who labored earnestly and zealously against the law of God's government in heaven and therefore lost his place there, with no place found for him any more in heaven.ST Apr 7, 1898 Those who reject light and oppose God's commandments and make the Word of God of none effect in their lives take sides with him in that rebellion, and those who refuse to obey God's law during probationary time could not with safety be received into His kingdom, for they would oppose the law of His government just as he did and there would be a second rebellion in heaven.ST Aug 20, 1912ST Apr 7, 1898
He was the first rebel and the great leader of all rebellions, and his rebellion was against the laws of God's government, the ten commandments afterward written with God's own finger upon tables of stone. He prevailed not and his place was found no more in heaven, leaving heaven to pure angels who delight to do God's will and obey the laws of His righteous government. Nearly all the human family have joined that same rebellion by disloyalty to the higher law, openly transgressing it, trampling the Sabbath and breaking the fourth commandment by honoring a papal institution framed by the Man of Sin instead of keeping God's own sanctified rest-day, and God will not take those living in open violation of His law into His glorious presence, for that would bring a second rebellion in heaven, and His indignation is aroused at man's open and daring rebellion.
From the day discord arose in heaven through its author and he prevailed not, he has sought to disparage the Son of God and cast discredit upon His position and work.RH Jan 27, 1910 That same work is carried on by taking creation out of the hands of Christ and bringing it about through an interminable process of autogeneration, and by teaching that men are unfallen beings needing no Saviour, so that Christ's only accomplishment was teaching great moral truths and living an inspiring life.RH Jan 27, 1910 Before his expulsion Satan had personal acquaintance with God and knew His character, and since losing his place his constant effort has been to misrepresent that character by suggesting Christless forms of religion made up of penances and mortifications or of splendid sights and pageantries, like the offering of Cain.ST Mar 3, 1898
The rebellious angels could not keep their place in heaven, for their happiness and place there depended on obedience to God's law, and Satan's rebellion and contempt for that law brought their removal.RH Feb 8, 1915 Lucifer's rebellion against God's law was not tolerated in heaven: he failed to prevail and lost his place there, showing that heaven's order includes consequences for rebellion and that anyone who tried to set aside God's law there would likewise face punishment.ST Jul 22, 1886 Anyone admitted to heaven while still choosing sin would bring another war, and the sinner and those who followed him would be cast out.RH Aug 18, 1904
Satan's challenge against God is repeated on earth when people set themselves up as judges of God's words and works, treating Scripture as inspired but not infallible and trying to separate its supposed errors from its truth.ST Jan 30, 1901 Anarchy and discord began in heaven, and the work of discord begun there is now reaching its culmination on earth.ST Apr 10, 1901 Those who seek by unholy means to elevate themselves at the expense of God's people are defeated and removed in the ultimate result of that heavenly conspiracy and rebellion, ending as Absalom ended when a heap of stones was laid upon him to express detestation of his memory.ST Aug 13, 1896
The devil was a personal being who once held a high position in heaven but through selfish ambition fell and was cast out with his followers, and he did not prevail and his place was no longer found in heaven. God's victory over Satan was certain, and Satan's final removal and the end of the harm caused by his deception are sure.RH Jun 22, 1911 In the conflict Christ casts down the dragon and his host, breaks their power, and brings their kingdom to an end, and Satan with his followers will eventually be destroyed, while now Lucifer, in whom sin originated and whose beauty and brightness fostered pride, haughtiness, and desire for pre-eminence corrupting his wisdom, awaits destruction after God rejected that self-exalting spirit.RH Jan 21, 1909RH Sep 14, 1916
The verse is connected with the error of the Millennial Dawn claim that, when the body of Christ is complete, the church will take the place in heaven then occupied by Satan.RH Jul 30, 1914 It belongs to the account of the origin and destiny of Satan and of the origin of evil, linked to Michael's victory over Satan and his rebellious angels in which they did not prevail against him, ending with the triumph of God's people and the destruction of Satan and his followers.ST Aug 13, 1885ST Jul 1, 1880 Their fall left vacancies in heaven, which will be filled by the redeemed.RH Jul 31, 1913 The devils banished from heaven could find no place there, and when Jesus came near they could find no place in people either and had to leave and enter the swine, for their presence defiled the human body as God's temple.
Christian Life Warning
The powers of hell remain arrayed against people, and no proud self-trusting person can defy them alone and unaided, for Lucifer drew one-third of the angel host to follow him and they fell because they did not prevail.ST When God stands beside the weak, wavering and discouraged one, He sends messengers of light with divine strength to that one's side, the combined hosts of hell quail before them, and victory belongs to the believer by God's might.ST Satan is a conquered foe cast out by Christ, so followers are to look upon him as conquered and accept Christ's victory on the cross as their own.ST Jan 29, 1908 The omnipotent power of the Holy Spirit is the defense of every contrite soul, and Christ will not permit anyone who in penitence and faith has claimed His protection to pass under the enemy's power.ST Jan 29, 1908 Though Satan is powerful, Christ who cast him out is mightier, so believers should not magnify Satan's power but magnify Jesus' power and love, trusting God will never forsake His children in the struggle with evil.ST Jan 29, 1908
Satan's hosts are strong and mighty and fearful to behold, yet they lose so that Michael's forces never give way because heaven has might untold.RH Dec 16, 1909 Christians in their own battle should therefore arm swiftly without delay, stand firm and bold and undaunted in the fray, obey every command of their Captain, not turn back to save treasure, trust God to care for them, and fight in faith knowing victory for eternity is sure if they endure to the end.RH Dec 16, 1909 The dragon hosts do not prevail even though they now gather in malice in fierce array for a mighty conflict, so Christians must wake up and prepare for battle against this enemy in view, girding for the fight though few and weak in numbers.RH May 15, 1855 Taking the breastplate, shield, helmet and sword of truth and standing bold and fearless under a glorious Captain girded with omnipotence gives safe and sure defense with strong and powerful weapons, and faithful fellow-soldiers who remain courageous will see the cause of truth triumph because God gives the victory.RH May 15, 1855
The war was in the spiritual world between Christ and Satan as the very personifications of good and evil, in which the universe and its fate were involved, and Christ was victor while Satan prevailed not.ST May 13, 1903 Christ's victory will not avail for a person unless he is willing that the same principles that prevailed in Christ Jesus shall prevail in his own life, yet Christ will win all victories for him if he is willing.ST May 13, 1903 The controversy that began in heaven is now being fought on earth, and everyone is a participant who must choose a side, with those not actively serving God counted among the powers of darkness.RH Aug 26, 1915ST Jul 19, 1883 That same war between Christ and Satan still goes on with the heart of man as its battlefield and men as the spoil of one or the trophy of the other, where Satan contests every inch of territory while Christ fights for all who yield their wills to Him, so man must take one side or the other and fight with Christ in order to be an overcomer.ST Jan 2, 1907 Satan and his powers oppose Christ, while Jesus and the holy angels press them back and rescue people from Satan's influence, and angels from heaven oppose evil powers and aid people under temptation in a real conflict whose outcome concerns eternal destinies.ST Feb 24, 1887
Every future outbreak of rebellion that tries to retard the work of God will likewise be defeated, as when one third of the heavenly host rebelled against God's righteous government and were cast out. Genuine humility keeps people safe because rebellion cannot exist in the truly humble, who will not be overcome by the wiles of Satan nor by the spirit of rebellion but will stay intimate with God and find in Him grace and strength to remain calm, hopeful and courageous under all circumstances and to come off conquerors over every obstacle. Satan's fall after exalting himself makes the ruin of those who presumptuously exalt themselves and rely on their own power as certain as his own.ST Jan 11, 1905 Self-exaltation brings abasement and a terrible fall, proving God sends judgment on pride and on becoming so self-reliant as to stand independent of the Creator, for Satan exalted himself when he rebelled and was quickly cast out.RH Oct 20, 1874
Pride and ambition led Lucifer to complain against God's rule and seek to overthrow heaven's established order, and after his fall he worked to spread envy, discontent and ambition among people, as seen in Korah's rebellion against God's appointed leaders.RH Nov 12, 1903 Satan's self-exaltation in heaven ended in his being cast out, and the same ruin awaits people who trust in their own power and merits instead of depending on God and the atonement through the crucified and risen Saviour. Satan was cast out when the time came, and preserving an appearance of harmony with those who reject God's counsel cannot justify compromising God's work or truth.RH Apr 27, 1905 This heavenly rebellion connects with Satan's deception in Eden which brought sin and suffering to earth, warning that accepting the same falsehood and exalting the creature above the Creator leads to the fallen cherub's reward.ST Apr 27, 1904
The first apostasy came from feeling slighted, when Satan felt slighted and therefore refused the fundamental truth that God is Supreme Governor, leading the great rebellion in which he was defeated, lost his place, and his case became hopeless.ST Oct 15, 1885 Those who turn away from faith because they have been slighted are actuated by the same spirit and are in danger of becoming as hopeless as Satan.ST Oct 15, 1885 Satan brought politics into heaven when he tried to turn the angels to the kind of government he invented, perverting a multitude of angels, but he did not prevail and they fell with him and lost their place.ST Dec 11, 1901 He has kept doing the same political work ever since, and is doing it now in the church as everywhere else, and multitudes from the church will go with him into Christian politics and go down with him in his final fall which is near, so the Christian's work is to warn men against that deception without doing politics, to walk as Christ walked and do the work committed to him and leave politics to those who will not do God's work.ST Dec 11, 1901 His rebellion began because he wanted the highest rank, equal with God and exalted above Christ, and through pride and ambition tried to gain the honor he believed he deserved and draw heaven to his side, making the rebels alien from God while Michael led heaven's forces against them, though God spared the fallen angels for a time though He had the right to end their lives.RH Jan 29, 1867 Selfishness deceived him into regarding himself as able to improve upon God's arrangement, thinking himself much wiser than he really was in wishing to rule and placing too high an estimate upon his own power in attempting to war with God, in contrast to the Father who though having all power to create the worlds was better pleased to confer that honor upon another and to Jesus who ever honored the Father, both desiring Lucifer's highest happiness within right bounds, so the lesson is to flee such a foe, let Jesus live within the heart and put self to death, since immoderate love for self constitutes sin and sin is a lie and the only truly deceptive thing.RH Aug 27, 1901
After Satan rebelled he was left with no place in heaven, and the same will be true of those who continue in rebellion against God's government and laws. Just before Christ comes in majesty and glory to take vengeance on the rebellious, a proclamation of God's law goes forth so that every disloyal subject may return to allegiance and all are left without excuse, but those who stay in rebellion will have no place in heaven just as Satan had none. Covetousness and envy of God's throne brought this disruption and expulsion, and these traits are unlike God and cannot be tolerated in those who belong wholly to Him.ST Apr 4, 1906 Those who sympathized with his rebellion were cast out and no longer had a place there, warning that a spirit of rebellion or murmuring cannot be tolerated among God's people.RH Nov 18, 1862 Exalted angels forfeited heaven by rebellion and an unyielding spirit that would not submit its own will or concede a point, so refusing to yield when in error brings fatal loss, calling for entire submission with no mental reservation, investigation and cheerful yielding, and receiving needed reproof with deep humility rather than jealousy, envy, self-dignity, impatience, offense or insubordination.RH Jul 9, 1872 Satan is the first great jealous rebel whose spirit is murmuring and raising rebellion against one's best friends, and those who indulge murmuring and rebellion lack the Spirit of God and have fallen under Satan's power and inspiration, ruining those who yield to it.RH
Lucifer was determined to have his own way and to be above Christ, and his example warns that children's training can make them like the fallen angel rather than Christlike.RH Dec 22, 1910 His casting out for disloyalty was no domination of his faith, though he justified rebellion on the ground that his liberty was encroached upon, so insisting that teachers and leaders hold sound belief is likewise no domination of faith. Satan deceived a third of the angels into joining him but he and his followers lost their place, and he is the fallen foe whom Christ later defeated in the wilderness, in which heaven rejoiced.ST Oct 24, 1878 His bid for supremacy failed when he could not obtain the honor he wanted from the Father and Christ, and his later temptation of Christ in the wilderness repeated that demand for worship, but Jesus rejected it and Satan was thwarted again. He had hated Christ for His position in the courts of God, hated Him more when he himself was dethroned, and hated Him who pledged Himself to redeem sinners, yet after losing heaven and claiming dominion over this world God permitted His Son to come as a helpless Babe subject to human weakness to meet life's peril in common with every human soul and fight the battle as every child of humanity must fight it at the risk of failure and eternal loss.ST Dec 9, 1913
Christ cast Satan out of heaven, showing the Saviour's power over the evil one. Christ had met and conquered this foe in heaven before coming to earth, and His victory gives followers courage to resist temptation and discouragement.RH Mar 1, 1906RH Nov 30, 1905 Those cast out were once among God's angels and are now demons of darkness, and under Satan as prince of the powers of darkness they are joined by evil men against Jesus Christ as Prince of Righteousness and Life with the good angels and those actuated by Christ's Spirit.ST May 26, 1898 The same conflict continues now as a greater warfare than any war between nations, fought not with carnal weapons but spiritual, with the fiercest strife in the human heart where Christ seeks to free heart and soul and body from bondage of sin and the prison-house of the grave while Satan seeks to keep souls in bondage, and God calls all through Christ to liberty and victory and to rule the spirit.ST May 26, 1898 The history of the rebellion became a lasting warning against rejecting God's authority, as their continued existence allowed the nature and consequences of sin and the justice, mercy and unchanging character of God's law to become clear to all created beings.RH Feb 8, 1915 That history gives a divine perspective on the past and helps interpret history, and it connects with Satan and his angels attacking God's messengers, calling for prayer that heavenly angels will deliver and shield them.RH Feb 27, 1908RH Sep 18, 1866
Satan failed in the conflict and no longer had a place there, in contrast with Enoch, Noah and Elijah who remained faithful amid surrounding corruption.ST Apr 16, 1896 He was cast out because he exalted himself, considering himself equal with God when he was not, so self-exaltation is a danger God warns against in the second commandment.ST Nov 10, 1898 Light about this apostasy is present truth for this time, needed now as never before to reach many minds and open blind eyes, so it must be given wide circulation through the large books that contain it, especially Patriarchs and Prophets, Daniel and the Revelation, and Great Controversy.RH Jan 23, 1908 The redeemed will sing of victory over Satan in God's presence around His throne before the loyal angels, as a fitting crowning celebration of victory over the chief rebel against government and law.RH Oct 3, 1912 The rebellious and unbelieving angels were not suffered to remain in God's presence, while the angels who now sing praises are beings who were tested and of their own free will chose loyalty, meaning God will have a tried people and men who cherish doubts and unbelief will never be permitted entrance into His glorious kingdom just as unbelief cast angels out.ST Sep 30, 1886
Lucifer's departure to spread doubt, division and hatred, and the failure of those who joined him, did not end God's work or prevent Him from leading His people.RH Jan 18, 1912 His pursuit of liberty as freedom from God's authority ended in expulsion, and the same false idea led him to persuade Adam and Eve that God was tyrannical and withheld what they had a right to have, yet by disobeying they did not become free but came under Satan's control because those who obey sin become its servants, for human beings cannot be independent of God since even before the Fall food was God's gift and afterward God provided clothing.ST Jul 7, 1898 His persistent rebellion arose from envy and disappointed ambition, and God's refusal to yield His throne was not partiality or injustice.RH Jan 11, 1906 Love could not make peace with evil, so rebels who did not prevail were cast out.RH Jan 14, 1904 The loyal angels were not responsible for the war, for the revolt belonged to Satan and his followers in their war against Michael and the loyal angels, and the devil and his angels who oppose Christ are demons who hate Christ and seek to degrade Him.RH Jan 31, 1865RH Jul 26, 1864
The beginning controversy for supremacy was face-to-face combat in heaven in which Satan did not prevail, and the same persons contend over the same issues now as then, but the warfare has been transferred to earth where Christ in the flesh meets and vanquishes Satan through the mystery of godliness answering the mystery of iniquity.ST Apr 9, 1902 That opposition continued to contest Christ's work on earth.RH Jul 19, 1906 After expulsion Satan determined to make earth his kingdom and conquer everything in sight so as to own and absolutely rule the world, thinking that when he overcame Adam and Eve who chose him as ruler he had secured possession, so this world became the great battlefield and bone of contention in the centuries-long contest where Satan fiercely works to conquer while God holds some hearts true to Him.ST Jun 16, 1909 Conquering that rebellion cast from heaven in the flesh was given to Christ, Immanuel, so that by God's purpose and care every ill will be extinguished.RH Jul 1, 1902
God refused to tolerate sin when Satan's great revolt took place, and rather than spare feelings, divide the universe with the devil, perpetuate sin to all eternity or surrender heaven's throne, He stood squarely for righteousness and left them with no place, meaning hatred of sin and direct faithful reproof belong to true religion while easy compromise for feelings and outward peace allows evil to continue.RH Jul 22, 1873 He did not excuse, shield or tolerate sin when it appeared in one third of the angels, but vindicated right by casting them out even though feelings were wounded, a wound not yet healed and not to be healed till Satan and his host are buried in the burning lake, meaning true religion carries out heaven's principles by calling things by right names and refusing to plaster over wickedness or compromise to spare feelings.RH Jul 22, 1873 Deliberate and determined rebellion like this first great rebellion has no remedy and will cease only by extermination, for the angels who conspired were defeated and driven into hopeless exile.RH Oct 28, 1873RH Sep 11, 1900 Satan once stood very high but in rebelling against God's law and heaven's order he prevailed not and fell with very many who loved him, while Jesus was foremost in sustaining God's law and the universe's well-being, and in striving to deprive King Jesus of immortality Satan forfeited his own immortality as his capital offense for which he and followers must finally die by loss of life and reason, yet God allowed time for rebellion to culminate and manifest its character, especially in attempting to annihilate Jesus, to give abundant evidence of wisdom, show mutiny's nature, shut out sympathy, and leave no thought of reform or haste, while man as victim not voluntary participant could be ransomed through the sufficient Redeemer who restores all breaking from Satan to their rightful Sovereign.RH Mar 3, 1863
Their expulsion did not reform Satan, for he remained rebellious, resented Christ's position, and later sought worship and supremacy by tempting Christ with the world's kingdoms.ST Apr 11, 1900 The great apostate who refused obedience did not prevail and lost his place, then deceived Adam and Eve bringing woe upon the world.ST Jun 20, 1900 Lucifer's rebellion failed so he and his angels could not overthrow God's order, arising from pride and ambition with the claim that heaven's order restrained liberty, bringing separation, disorder, misery and woe.RH Jul 27, 1916ST Jul 4, 1911 That expulsion followed ambition to set his own rule against God's government of love and unselfishness. God reigns and Satan did not succeed in ruling over humanity, for his rebellion failed and he and his angels did not prevail or retain a place.RH Jul 21, 1868 Before expulsion Satan had personal acquaintance with God and knew His character, and since losing his place his constant effort has been to misrepresent it by Christless religion of penances, mortifications, splendid sights and pageantries like Cain's offering.ST Mar 3, 1898 His fall began a pattern in which those who sympathize with and cooperate with Satan support wrongdoing when it is reproved.LS 285.1–286.3
Commentary part 4 of 4
Pioneers and periodicals (continued)
God did not permit Satan to remain after fall because leaving him would constantly jeopardize heaven's government, his fall being rebellion against perfect law, and by the same principle He cannot admit persistent rejecters of His Word into the everlasting kingdom just as Saul was rejected from temporal Israel.ST Mar 24, 1898 After expulsion he determined to make earth his kingdom conquering everything to own and rule the world, thinking overcoming Adam and Eve choosing him as ruler secured possession, so this world became the battlefield and bone of contention where Satan fiercely works while God holds some hearts true.ST Jun 16, 1909 The rebellion cast out was appointed to be conquered by Christ in human flesh as Immanuel so every ill will be extinguished.RH Jul 1, 1902 Mercy must not be overstrained to sympathize with that rebellion beyond reason, for sympathy has right limit, and as with human offenders confession may receive sympathy but shifting ground pleading innocence must be abandoned, since seeking sympathizers injures others and makes the case hopeless while straightforward confession like the prodigal's wins heart, robe and feast.RH Oct 29, 1872
Satan was banished for pride and ambition cherished in heart, deeply rooted in fallen nature overshadowing every good quality and bringing envy and strife. Christians must therefore repress envy as religious duty, rejoice in brethren's superior reputation or prosperity though own achievements are shaded, seek goodness not greatness, have Christ's mind with humble self-views, and labor for church purity ready to sacrifice interests rather than cause dissension. The verse shows defeat and expulsion of his first great confederacy for monopoly control of God's kingdom, launched in his own interest in unbelief in God's power, wisdom and goodness presupposing Christ incapable of running government and Satan's position disregarded, wrecking pure lives of joining angels and ending when they prevailed not and were cast out as profane, while God's kingdom still exists with Christ in control. The spirit of rebellion was cast out with no place, for heaven was strong enough to expel and keeps it out, and this was not merely degradation of angels already outside.RH Sep 7, 1869ST Mar 10, 1881
Timing of Castings
The heavenly war followed Satan's first fall rather than being that first fall itself, with the first fall shown in the drawing of the stars and the later conflict reaching back before the birth of the child to include the defeated effort through pagan Rome.ST Mar 10, 1881ST Jun 18, 1912ST May 13, 1903 After Satan fell, Christ descended from His position with the Father to become Michael the Archangel, and the spiritual conflict between them continued until Christ died.ST Jun 18, 1912 The war belongs to the period preceding the birth of Christ, proving no power can forever prevail against eternal right.ST May 13, 1903
The verse identifies the first casting of Satan and his angels from heaven, after which they no longer had place there.RH Jan 22, 1901ST Feb 3, 1914 This initial expulsion did not prevent Satan from later appearing at heavenly councils as representative of the earth he had usurped from Adam.ST Feb 3, 1914 It is distinct from a second casting down associated with Christ's death on the cross, and from a future third casting down described in Revelation 20.RH Jan 22, 1901ST Feb 3, 1914
The dragon's defeat in conflict with Michael is part of the victory Christ secured through the events culminating in His crucifixion, securing eternal victory for all who trust in Him.ST Jun 17, 1903ST Jul 4, 1911ST Nov 26, 1896 Satan's fall began his opposition to God's people, and Christ's victory in the conflict culminating in the crucifixion secured their final victory.ST Nov 26, 1896
The verse marks final expulsion at Christ's death and ascension, when Satan was cast to earth and the controversy was thereafter confined to earth.RH Oct 8, 1903ST Jul 4, 1911 His work as accuser ended because Christ's obedience and death vindicated God's law and goodness and secured His right to represent this world in place of Satan, who had represented it after Adam forfeited dominion.RH Oct 8, 1903ST Jun 22, 1904 Though cast from where God dwells to overthrow man and become prince of this world, he had still come with the sons of God to present himself before the Lord, but after the cross his appearance among the rulers and heads of worlds could no longer be recognized in heaven.ST May 26, 1909
After Christ conquered through death and resurrection, Satan and the evil angels could no longer take part in the spiritual conflict in heaven or accuse God and His servants there, their character having been demonstrated beyond question.ST Jul 6, 1915 Their warfare thereafter was directed toward destroying humanity.ST Jul 6, 1915 The heaven from which place was lost here denotes the spiritual realm of conflict, not the very heaven where God dwells.ST Jul 6, 1915
The rebellion had left the heavenly world uncertain of its outcome, and place was held vacant while God's justice, wisdom and love were demonstrated and loyal angels remained perplexed but faithful.ST May 30, 1911 When Satan's hatred led him and his angels to bring about Christ's death, their choice became final beyond repentance and hope.ST May 30, 1911 Christ's character exposed Lucifer's true character and defeated him, so the usurping prince could no longer enter God's councils as accuser, showing right not expediency is eternal might.ST May 30, 1911
The final casting down came after Christ rose victorious over death and hell, culminating the conflict between Christ as Michael and Satan following their earlier expulsion.ST Dec 12, 1906 Satan and his angels were cast into the earth after resurrection and ascension, with no power to return.ST Sep 26, 1911ST Nov 25, 1913 The earth becomes his abode during the thousand years, where punishment begins as he faces ruin and confinement to the desolate earth serves as part of punishment and lesson to the universe.ST Sep 26, 1911ST Nov 25, 1913
Satan as prince of this world was judged and cast out at the close of Christ's earthly work, proving a final judgment when all must stand before the judgment-seat of Christ of which the Comforter convinces the world.ST Apr 1, 1897 When Christ cried It is finished, Satan and his angels were uprooted from the affection and sympathy and confidence of unfallen angels, who until then had doubted because of his deception.ST Sep 23, 1889 The cross settled doubt by revealing the contrast between God who moves straightforward and cannot lie and Satan crooked as a serpent, and the resurrection proved power to bind the strong man and despoil his goods, to the joy of all heaven.ST Sep 23, 1889
The casting out belongs to Christ's triumph over sin, Satan and death, announced at Pentecost when the Spirit empowered the apostles to proclaim the crucified and risen Jesus exalted to the Father's throne and beginning High Priest ministry in the heavenly sanctuary.RH Aug 28, 1913 Michael prevailed in the battle of the ages when every power and device against incarnate righteousness was met by the Prince of life with the King's weapons and armor of righteousness before all the host, bringing eternal defeat to Satan and eternal victory to Christ and the faithful.ST May 13, 1903
Christ's victory is linked to undertaking humanity's cause, bearing the Father's wrath in sinners' place, enduring temptation and the cross, and rising conqueror.RH Jun 29, 1869 Defeated by the Son in heaven, Satan tried to overthrow Jesus to keep his claimed kingdom and prevent redemption, inspiring wicked men to nail Him to the cross, yet Jesus remained faithful and the cross triumphed over him.ST Jul 23, 1874ST Oct 23, 1901 Through appointed suffering and death He would reclaim the kingdoms as everlasting possession, and Satan after pretending to be Christ himself will be destroyed, thereby acknowledging defeat.ST Jul 23, 1874ST Jul 4, 1906ST Oct 23, 1901
The conquest took place in connection with the first advent at the climax of the controversy, revealing Christ's love and power to the angels so they could no longer hold place.ST Jun 26, 1893 Lucifer had despised high honor, trusted brightness and beauty, set his heart as God's, and drawn a third of the host into open revolt with anarchy.ST Feb 24, 1898 Refusing confession and all mercy, he became filled with settled hatred and vengeance and resolved on continual war until Christ burst death's bonds, since which he knows himself vanquished with overthrow only a matter of time, ushering great wrath against Jesus and the church growing hotter as his short time nears.ST Feb 24, 1898
At his fall he was still an angel with noble kingly qualities desiring restoration, the full nature and consequences of sin not yet seen.RH Nov 7, 1865 Created perfect without evil nature and placed on probation with power to obey or disobey, he cherished jealousy of Jesus, trusted beauty, wisdom, position and authority to protect him, and persisted into open rebellion against Jesus and the Father with full knowledge and no excuse, so no repentance is granted and rank cannot save.ST Dec 31, 1874 His secession first brought discord into the universe and continued in Eden, where Adam's sin brought earth as his domain into separation from God's government.RH May 28, 1861
The failure to rival God cast Lucifer to earth and transferred the controversy begun in heaven to this world.RH Oct 21, 1902ST Feb 16, 1915 The heavenly conflict centered on demands to change or abolish God's law and government, against which he gathered followers persuaded his cause was just.RH Oct 21, 1902ST May 5, 1898 Not permitted to continue rebellion in heaven, they were cast to earth where Satan found place to carry out principles, demonstrate his government and prove his claims, so this world's history has been that rebellion's history.ST May 5, 1898 God did not at once destroy him and his host lest it seem arbitrary proof of injustice, but left intelligences of this and other worlds to learn divine love.ST May 5, 1898
To place the 2300 days as ending at the ascension would push connected prophetic events back into the past and place the dragon near the time of Moses.ST Aug 12, 1875 The fall and loss of place belong after creation and before man's fall and the plan of redemption, as part of the great controversy running from creation to the new earth and through the destruction of sin and sinners at the close of the thousand years.RH Oct 30, 1900ST Mar 11, 1880ST Jul 21, 1881ST Mar 31, 1881 The verse describes the false religious power's defeat and loss of heavenly place in the first struggle between the dragon and the church, preceding later conflicts between the beast and saints and between the two beasts and the remnant.RH May 3, 1870RH Dec 25, 1900
War Moved Earthward
Cast off from heaven after failing against Michael and his angels, the dragon and his angels no longer had a place there, and the first war begun through pride, selfishness, jealousy against the Son and desire for power and position was transferred to earth.RH Dec 11, 1916ST Jan 29, 1902ST Nov 28, 1900ST Apr 2, 1902 Having lost heaven, Satan sought to establish his kingdom on earth, where he temporarily exercises the dominion he usurped from Adam by deceit for a short race until his utter overthrow is assured, when Christ as the second Adam will take the dominion the first Adam lost and restore the first dominion to earth and humanity.ST Nov 28, 1900ST Apr 2, 1902 Cast off from his earlier connection he came to persecute the seed of the Son made in God's image, leading the first pair through falsehood to join rebellion, and the controversy begun in heaven now stirs human sin and war through pride, ambition and greed.RH Dec 11, 1916ST Jan 29, 1902RH Dec 11, 1916 His true character is thus to be revealed to all the universe while his time is short.
After the conflict in heaven Satan sought dominion over earth and established a rival kingdom to oppose God, draw people into rebellion, destroy humanity especially the loyal, continue war against God and deceive people into disobeying truth, and wrest the earth's possession and sovereignty from the Son, while Christ worked against his efforts to bring humanity under his rule.ST Feb 17, 1909RH Nov 13, 1900RH Oct 8, 1908RH Dec 11, 1916 Through him sin entered the world and death by sin, frustrating in intent God's plan to make human beings a new distinct order in God's image to populate earth in close communion with heaven and live sinless lives upheld by God. He opposed humanity and tried to prevent the promised Deliverer by destroying the Messianic line through which the Messiah was to be born, but God preserved that line to Jesus.ST Nov 7, 1906
After expulsion he tempted Adam by lying reports about God, and Adam and Eve believed his lie and fell, so that sin entered a world created perfect without spot, stain, sin or imperfection, and death entered by sin with trying consequences continuing to the close of earth's history and woe upon the world.RH Jul 21, 1904ST Jun 20, 1900 In Eden he hid evil beneath the serpent's appearance of life and happiness and through disobedience won humanity as his first subject, bringing the spirit of vengeance into human experience, beneath which lie pride and rebellion.ST Sep 30, 1930 In seeking to take God's place he repeated the same claim on earth, telling the first humans they could be like gods.ST May 18, 1904
The deception by which he led angels to rebel was then used against Adam and Eve, and their fall began the continuing conflict between good and evil on earth.RH May 3, 1906 He was first to rebel, left the courts of heaven and carried sin to this world where the first parents dwelt in peace, becoming the great author of sin whose work causes all miseries, sorrows and perplexities of this life.ST Jul 22, 1889 His false claims had first led many angels away from loyalty so they lost their place in heaven, and their fall preceded the temptation of Adam and Eve.RH Jan 21, 1904
The defeat means their place was no longer in heaven and the conflict shifted to earth, where Michael the Son of God as leader of the angels conquered him.ST Apr 7, 1914 Satan did not prevail in conflict with Christ and was driven from heaven, and after Christ's victory his wrath turned against the church, so the conflict continued on earth between spiritual powers of good and evil through visible human forces including the church and earthly powers.ST Nov 7, 1906
The defeat and expulsion did not end warfare or the struggle against right, for he continued on earth the same rebellion and falsehood begun in heaven, laboring constantly to deceive minds to call sin righteousness and righteousness sin, turning censure upon faithful servants standing for truth while his agents are praised as martyrs, a warfare carried century to century to the present.ST Oct 25, 1883RH Sep 30, 1909 The chapter shows Satan as instigator of persecution warring against truth through successive apostasy and persecution through the centuries, even against the remnant who keep God's commandments and have the testimony of Jesus, as the real persecutor of the church whose opposition does not prevail while Christ triumphs over Satan and sin.ST Oct 24, 1911ST Dec 24, 1912ST Dec 23, 1908 Sin and its accuser were barred from heaven, Michael's victory exposed Lucifer's character, freed angels from deception and vindicated God through everlasting righteousness, and Satan in rage for the short time remaining before destruction and cleansing of the universe turns against Christ's followers.ST Nov 5, 1896
Immediately after the expulsion, when the Son and loyal angels prevailed and no taint of rebellion was left and heaven was again peaceful with hosts adoring the God of justice while mourning former companions, the Father consulted Jesus about carrying out their purpose to make man to inhabit earth and place him on probation to test loyalty before rendering him eternally secure, with promise if he endured he would be equal with angels, have God's favor and converse with angels, deliberately not placed beyond power of disobedience.RH Feb 8, 1915 Satan attempted to defeat that plan to make human beings a new distinct order in God's image to populate earth in communion with heaven sinless upheld by God, by bringing jealousy into heavenly courts, communicating disaffection to many angels, causing war, and after expulsion determining to set up his kingdom on earth, through whom sin entered the world and death by sin.
The expulsion confirms Satan's rule over the fallen angels cast out with him after failing to prevail and losing place.ST Jan 28, 1875 These are evil spirits that sinned, wicked seducing unclean spirits and spirits of devils under Satan the great dragon, old serpent, devil deceiving the whole world as commander of darkness, opposed by Christ as Captain of the Lord's host with good ministering angels, seeking to deceive, ensnare and drag down every unguarded soul, and their working is the supernatural power behind modern Spiritism.RH Feb 9, 1864ST Sep 11, 1901 They are the unseen spirits behind Spiritualist communications, not spirits of the dead, knowing details of human friends in life and after death claiming to be their disembodied spirits, with Satan appearing as an angel of light and his ministers as ministers of righteousness through mediums at human bidding as demons of the bottomless pit assuming guise of the dear and holy, bringing no benefit but positive damage to character.RH Feb 9, 1864ST May 27, 1880ST Jul 17, 1901
These malign spirits identified as demons, familiar spirits, unclean spirits and angels of the devil can deceive through apparent materialized forms or making people believe they see what is not there.ST Dec 10, 1912 Cast out and now on earth to deceive, they wage warfare appearing to saints as dead loved ones with same features, unchanged voice and loving manner professing to come as special friends to help, exciting sympathy and working miracles to confirm what they declare, adroitly leading into pleasing apparently reasonable but unscriptural doctrines. The same warfare begun in heaven has continued on earth nearly six thousand years under new disguise through pretended visitants teaching no difference between righteous and wicked, undermining Scripture and faith, setting aside God's law, despising grace, counting the covenant blood unholy, denying Christ's divinity and leveling the Creator with themselves, broken only by thorough present truth from Scripture especially the state of the dead and Thus saith the Lord, since the devil comes unexpectedly when people think themselves strong.RH Sep 11, 1916ST Dec 8, 1909
The fallen being and angels with him now roam earth invisibly after losing place, and the fallen foe can exert unseen power including behind levitations at séances, which are not performed by the dead who have no life between death and resurrection.ST Feb 10, 1914 Lucifer the fallen archangel remains as the spirit of evil at work through modern occultism and spiritualism as his agencies, and worship of Lucifer in temples, chapels and the Black Mass is worship of this fallen archangel.RH Mar 15, 1906
His fall exposes voodooism and related beliefs and helps counter evil spirits.RH Nov 3, 1910 His effort to destroy God's people and prevent the Man-child repeatedly failed because God intervened, thwarting his plans through Babylon, Medo-Persia, Grecia and Pagan Rome.ST Nov 19, 1896
Their continued activity on earth is allowed so theories and results of rebellion can be demonstrated and the nature of his government, principles and claims proved, for God did not at once destroy Satan and his host lest it seem arbitrary proof God wished only His own way and increased imagined injustice, while intelligences of this and other worlds would never have known divine love.ST May 5, 1898 His power and freedom are curtailed as Christ receives the kingdom temporarily usurped, preparing final destruction on earth. During the thousand years they are cut off from deceiving and ruining people and can only counsel with one another.ST Jul 31, 1893
The rebellion must be put down because sin could spread to other parts of the universe, aiming to banish sin and restore earth to perfect harmony with God's government.ST Mar 21, 1906 The heavenly rebellion connected with deception in Eden brought discord followed by sin, sorrow and suffering on earth, and accepting and spreading the same falsehood and exalting creature above Creator leads to the fallen cherub's reward.ST Apr 27, 1904RH Oct 10, 1912
When his place was no more found the rebellion begun under Lucifer the covering cherub was transferred to earth under its original leader, who still carries it forward as invisible leader of a worldwide confederacy of evil pervaded by his spirit, whose visible leaders in the final crisis are the papacy as the Beast in the Old World and the Image to the Beast in the New.RH Nov 5, 1901 His attempt to gain power in heaven failed, and Babel's plan for world empire and enforced heathen religion was its earthly counterfeit.ST Jul 18, 1916
In the great closing work of the rebellion evil powers unite in desperate struggle with deceptive plans to ruin souls, with ministers, physicians and lawmakers uniting in rebellion under pretentious garb of righteousness as form of godliness without power, while those heeding sophistries and rejecting light are converted to his theories too late seeing God's angels at war against departers from the faith.RH Sep 30, 1909 This heavenly defeat makes him a defeated foe in the later earthly conflict.ST Nov 23, 1915
Since rebellion and expulsion he continues trying to wrest souls from Christ while flesh and Spirit contend for mastery in lives.RH Aug 24, 1916 He is a fallen angel leading people into sin, and following him binds them toward destruction.RH Jan 7, 1873 His rebellion and influence in heaven preceded tempting humanity, and his defeat there did not end conflict, for he continued trying to thwart God's saving purpose by tempting Christ, working to thwart salvation until Christ ends his career.STST Feb 22, 1883
The one causing rebellion among angels was cast out with no place, compared with humanity driven from Eden.ST Sep 12, 1900 The devil left heaven because resisted and no longer wanted there, and the same principle applies on earth where earnest following of Christ, purity of heart and decided immediate resistance at every return causes him to flee and brings fresh defeat.RH Feb 27, 1908
Satan's rebellion against heaven's government is precedent for later rebellions against it.RH Aug 12, 1862 His success in deceiving angels gave confidence he could also overcome Christ.ST Feb 18, 1913 The faithful angels who fought for God and triumphed so he did not prevail had shouted for joy over creation and sinless inhabitants and witnessed man's fall and expulsion from Eden, and those same victorious messengers now cooperate invisibly with visible agencies, ministering in necessity to co-workers with God, overseeing stewards, caring for spiritual welfare of seekers of God's moral image, rejoicing in prosperity of the work, binding wounds sin made to save the perishing and restore God's image.ST Dec 1, 1909RH Mar 19, 1901
The expulsion followed rebellion and was the immediate cause of enmity against God and humanity after the dragon and his angels failed against Michael and lost place.RH Feb 8, 1915 About one-third sympathized with Lucifer and after open rebellion were cast out with him, losing home and standing, leaving the church to cope with that fallen host against the unnumbered faithful angels.ST Oct 25, 1883ST Jun 22, 1904ST Jul 2, 1902ST Apr 21, 1898
Historic Church Persecution
Revelation 12:8 belongs to the period of papal persecution and suppression of the Scriptures described in Daniel 7:25, Daniel 12, Revelation 11 and Revelation 13.ST Feb 13, 1907ST May 14, 1894ST May 3, 1877RH Jan 14, 1862RH Apr 15, 1875 The 1,260 prophetic days are literal years, reckoned as twelve 30-day months, covering papal supremacy from 538 to 1798.ST Feb 13, 1907ST Apr 6, 1915ST May 14, 1894ST May 3, 1877RH Apr 15, 1875 That period ended when French forces took Rome, carried the pope into exile, took away dominion and gave the deadly wound.ST May 3, 1877RH Jan 14, 1862RH Apr 15, 1875 Through those Dark Ages God preserved an unbroken chain of witnesses holding gospel truth in obscurity, which proves the two witnesses are not two individual persons because no two individuals live through so long an era.ST Feb 13, 1907RH Jan 14, 1862 After the man child Christ ascended to God and His throne, the dragon turned in wrathful persecution upon the woman, the church left upon the earth, and the wilderness to which she flees is an earthly not heavenly retreat, with the earth helping her by swallowing the flood proving the conflict is on earth where the remnant still contends with the devil in this present evil world.ST Feb 13, 1907
The verse is part of the prophecy of the church's time in the wilderness, when during the Dark Ages she was driven into seclusion for 1,260 years and given into the hands of a persecuting power as definite fulfilled prophecy.ST Nov 28, 1895RH Jul 8, 1909 Revelation 12 covers in substance the same history as Daniel 7, the empires of Babylon, Medo-Persia, Grecia and Rome united and divided, including the persecuting career of the little horn of the apostasy from A.D. 538 to 1798 with a brief revival just before the Lord comes, indicating the next great event is the setting up of His kingdom though not revealing the definite time of His coming.ST Nov 28, 1895 The line fixes the time of the end to 1798, the close of the 1,260 days of persecution.ST Nov 28, 1895
In historical application the pagan dragon power persecuted the early church but did not prevail to destroy it and fell before nominal Christianity.RH Feb 21, 1865ST Dec 1, 1914ST Jan 21, 1889 After three centuries persecution ceased for a time when a pagan emperor supported Christianity for political reasons, and the flood of pagan persecution was swallowed when the earth opened her mouth at the professed conversion of Constantine the Roman emperor in the fourth century.ST Dec 1, 1914ST Jan 21, 1889 Satan then changed his method, using corrupt Christianity and the papal Beast to continue attacking the true church.RH Feb 21, 1865RH Mar 17, 1903 The chapter thus begins with Christ's birth and extends to His coming, revealing Satan's work through paganism, the papacy and apostate Protestantism marked by self-salvation and deception hiding Christ as Saviour from sin, and it has been fulfilled in the history of the church under pagan and papal persecution including the effort to destroy the Child Christ Jesus, the 1260 days, the helpful influence of the Reformation in preserving the church, and the final wrath of the dragon against the remnant because of the commandments of God and the spirit of prophecy, bringing the prophecy down to the present day with its wilderness period when Sabbathkeepers were killed and banished.RH Mar 17, 1903RH Jan 12, 1905RH Nov 24, 1910 The dragon's wrath then made war upon the remnant of her seed, the faithful few who rejected the union of church and state and refused to become Papists.ST Jan 21, 1889
The persecuting power did not win, so God's true church was no longer found in Rome but was carried on eagle's wings into the wilderness to the lofty heights of the snow-covered Alps, which God had prepared as a refuge and where He kept the persecuted safely for many centuries during the Dark Ages, in contrast to Babylon the great with its palaces and churches on the seven hills of Rome.RH Sep 13, 1906 The earth helping the woman by swallowing the flood represents the Reformation under Luther and his co-workers, when German states supported the Protestant cause, protected the reformers and restrained persecution, though this help also drew insincere people who joined for self-interest.ST May 25, 1882
The dragon's defeat and the place in the wilderness were fulfilled hundreds of years ago, and the verse does not promise a future refuge from the dragon's wrath in a literal wilderness place nor call believers now to gather to such a place as Shiloh for protection.ST Sep 28, 1904 The vision belongs to the seven-headed dragon whose reign and persecution of Christ's church extend from the beginning to the end of the Christian era.ST Nov 1, 1910ST Oct 22, 1902
Revelation 12 is a sketch of the powers used by Satan against the church from Christ's first advent to His second, namely three powers: the Dragon, the Beast and the Image of the Beast, which are pagan Rome, papal Rome and American Rome.RH Mar 20, 1900 Rome is Satan's seat and the center from which decrees were issued against holders of gospel truths from Constantine's rise in A.D. 312 until the establishment of the Papacy.RH Mar 26, 1857
The verse shows Satan the deceiver, accuser and adversary behind the evil Babylonian system of union of church and state from Babylon of old to the Papacy in connection with worldly powers did not prevail.ST Jul 1, 1903 He deceives the nations into believing this system in some form is necessary to salvation, to good order, to civil government and to preservation of religion, and he carries on this deception in every age through great popular but backslidden apostate religious bodies that once knew truth but departed from righteousness by faith, refused increased light and voluntarily united with earthly powers to enforce religious dogmas by law.ST Jul 1, 1903 Through them he accuses those who protest the prevailing religious system, and the accusations end in persecution unless God interposes, and through this system in its various phases he opposes the simple all-effectual truth of God's free gospel of grace received by faith.ST Jul 1, 1903
The dragon prevailed not and lost its place, the dragon being Satan working as pagan Rome which sought to destroy Christ by moving Herod to put Him to death and then made war upon Christ and His people through the first centuries, then assuming the form of the papacy to carry the work forward with the dragon merged in the first Beast, and with the lamb-like beast that came up when the Beast went into captivity in 1798 also speaking like a dragon and causing worship of the Beast and his image.RH Mar 5, 1901 That worship is worship of the dragon and is sun-worship, whether Parsee prayer toward the sun, pagan idolatry, or worship of the image representing the papacy by observing the first day of the week in its honor, and the Third Angel's Message forbids it all, while God's people come out of the conflict in triumph and stand upon Mount Zion by keeping the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus and those rejecting the warning drink the unmixed wrath of God.RH Mar 5, 1901ST May 30, 1911 Michael stands on the side of those preaching the Sabbath, so they need not be frightened by the dragon's opposition.RH Mar 15, 1864
The account of the great red dragon exposes rulers who profess justice yet condemn the innocent.RH Mar 21, 1854 As Pilate found no cause for Christ's death yet ordered Him crucified, so laws and conduct in the United States punishing people for helping enslaved people escape show the same contradiction between profession and action.RH Mar 21, 1854RH Jul 2, 1857
Revelation 12 presents the church passing through a wilderness state during which it absorbed errors from the papacy, and those inherited errors later contributed to division among Protestants whom God would have united in truth.RH Mar 3, 1874 The same spirit of rebellion that failed in heaven and lost its place there worked in fanatical opponents of the Reformation, who falsely claimed injustice, gained sympathy as supposed martyrs and worked to tear down the work.ST Oct 25, 1883 Yet Michael will prevail as people hear the truth and come out of Babylon despite opposition from their leaders.RH Oct 24, 1885
The verse belongs to the account of Satan's rebellion in heaven where he sought to alter God's law, raised his own judgment above his Creator's and placed his will above God's, treating God as fallible, and the same defiance is repeated on earth when the pope claims authority to correct God's law.ST Nov 26, 1912 Cast to earth he insinuated himself between man and the Creator, working under a form of godliness without the power so he himself might not be observed, and instituted a system focused in a visible head called the man of sin repeating his boast to be like the Most High, whose mark of power is its change of God's seventh-day Sabbath to the Sunday institution, a heathen holiday with no divine authority leading men to tread upon God's holy day.ST Jan 21, 1903 Papal power thus fulfilled the little horn's work of speaking great words against the Most High, with priestly claims to power over Christ, forgiveness and judgment presented as that blasphemous exaltation, and the rebellious power that opposed heaven and failed and lost its place there faces expected downfall with its priesthood claiming authority over Christ and over forgiveness of sinners.RH May 24, 1870RH Feb 10, 1874
The verse belongs to a prophetic picture in which the dragon's attacks against the woman, the true church, are overcome and she is protected by God, teaching that the church cannot meet the powers of earth by its own strength but must trust God while warning the world of its coming doom.RH Oct 23, 1913 The casting out of Satan from the heavenly courts at the beginning, when he prevailed not and his place was found no more in heaven, took with him a third part of God's angels.RH Jan 22, 1901 The taking away of the kingly power of Judea by pagan Rome after the death of Herod, leaving the land forsaken of both her kings at Christ's first advent, was a perfect object-lesson illustrating that original expulsion, connected with the later removal of one third of the Jewish nation's rulers by pagan Rome.RH Jan 22, 1901
Doctrine of Law Government
Satan's rebellion arose from ambition, from refusal to submit to Christ's authority, and from opposition to God's constitution and government, especially His law, and therefore he and the angels who joined him did not prevail against Christ and the loyal angels and lost their place in heaven.RH Feb 8, 1915ST Apr 30, 1896 That same rebellion against the law has been carried on ever since the fall of man, as Satan seeks through evil men to make void the law of the Most High, while the Son of God was manifested to destroy those works and vindicated and honored the law as the foundation of all the law and the prophets.ST Apr 30, 1896
Expulsion followed his desire for supremacy above God and his attempt to set aside God's unchangeable law, and Christ came to confront and conquer Satan and expose his misrepresentation of God's character.ST Nov 12, 1912 He was cast out of heaven because of his transgression, and from then on he has sought to defeat God's purpose for humanity by making God's law appear imperfect, unjust, tyrannical, and impossible to keep.RH Apr 29, 1902 By misrepresentations of the law he led many angels of heaven to take his side in apostasy and rebellion, and by the same method he has secured the world and even the largest share of the professedly Christian church in enmity to the law of Jehovah.ST Jan 9, 1896
God's law governs the heavenly kingdom, and because it condemns sin the devil and his angels were banished from heaven.ST Sep 30, 1886ST Nov 11, 1886 The cross of Christ gives that law lasting and enduring honor by satisfying its demands and by showing both the punishment of sin and God's righteousness and justice in that punishment.ST Sep 30, 1886ST Nov 11, 1886
An angel once honored in heaven rebelled and fell from his high estate, then led other fallen angels and fallen humanity in rebellion against God's government.ST Nov 14, 1878 They became fallen angels and powers of darkness waging war against God's truth and government, and because their rebellion opposed heaven's peace, order, and government they were cast down and kept in darkness for judgment.ST Sep 16, 1930RH Jan 9, 1872
Their rebellion was incurable, and their removal from heaven demonstrated God's justice, for God must ultimately remove sin from the universe rather than surrender His throne, and sinners who refuse pardon and cleansing will be removed with sin.ST Jun 23, 1914 Satan was the first great rebel and first apostate who labored earnestly and zealously against the law of God's government in heaven and therefore lost his place there, with no place found for him any more in heaven.ST Apr 7, 1898 Those who reject light and oppose God's commandments and make the Word of God of none effect in their lives take sides with him in that rebellion, and those who refuse to obey God's law during probationary time could not with safety be received into His kingdom, for they would oppose the law of His government just as he did and there would be a second rebellion in heaven.ST Aug 20, 1912ST Apr 7, 1898
He was the first rebel and the great leader of all rebellions, and his rebellion was against the laws of God's government, the ten commandments afterward written with God's own finger upon tables of stone. He prevailed not and his place was found no more in heaven, leaving heaven to pure angels who delight to do God's will and obey the laws of His righteous government. Nearly all the human family have joined that same rebellion by disloyalty to the higher law, openly transgressing it, trampling the Sabbath and breaking the fourth commandment by honoring a papal institution framed by the Man of Sin instead of keeping God's own sanctified rest-day, and God will not take those living in open violation of His law into His glorious presence, for that would bring a second rebellion in heaven, and His indignation is aroused at man's open and daring rebellion.
From the day discord arose in heaven through its author and he prevailed not, he has sought to disparage the Son of God and cast discredit upon His position and work.RH Jan 27, 1910 That same work is carried on by taking creation out of the hands of Christ and bringing it about through an interminable process of autogeneration, and by teaching that men are unfallen beings needing no Saviour, so that Christ's only accomplishment was teaching great moral truths and living an inspiring life.RH Jan 27, 1910 Before his expulsion Satan had personal acquaintance with God and knew His character, and since losing his place his constant effort has been to misrepresent that character by suggesting Christless forms of religion made up of penances and mortifications or of splendid sights and pageantries, like the offering of Cain.ST Mar 3, 1898
The rebellious angels could not keep their place in heaven, for their happiness and place there depended on obedience to God's law, and Satan's rebellion and contempt for that law brought their removal.RH Feb 8, 1915 Lucifer's rebellion against God's law was not tolerated in heaven: he failed to prevail and lost his place there, showing that heaven's order includes consequences for rebellion and that anyone who tried to set aside God's law there would likewise face punishment.ST Jul 22, 1886 Anyone admitted to heaven while still choosing sin would bring another war, and the sinner and those who followed him would be cast out.RH Aug 18, 1904
Satan's challenge against God is repeated on earth when people set themselves up as judges of God's words and works, treating Scripture as inspired but not infallible and trying to separate its supposed errors from its truth.ST Jan 30, 1901 Anarchy and discord began in heaven, and the work of discord begun there is now reaching its culmination on earth.ST Apr 10, 1901 Those who seek by unholy means to elevate themselves at the expense of God's people are defeated and removed in the ultimate result of that heavenly conspiracy and rebellion, ending as Absalom ended when a heap of stones was laid upon him to express detestation of his memory.ST Aug 13, 1896
The devil was a personal being who once held a high position in heaven but through selfish ambition fell and was cast out with his followers, and he did not prevail and his place was no longer found in heaven. God's victory over Satan was certain, and Satan's final removal and the end of the harm caused by his deception are sure.RH Jun 22, 1911 In the conflict Christ casts down the dragon and his host, breaks their power, and brings their kingdom to an end, and Satan with his followers will eventually be destroyed, while now Lucifer, in whom sin originated and whose beauty and brightness fostered pride, haughtiness, and desire for pre-eminence corrupting his wisdom, awaits destruction after God rejected that self-exalting spirit.RH Jan 21, 1909RH Sep 14, 1916
The verse is connected with the error of the Millennial Dawn claim that, when the body of Christ is complete, the church will take the place in heaven then occupied by Satan.RH Jul 30, 1914 It belongs to the account of the origin and destiny of Satan and of the origin of evil, linked to Michael's victory over Satan and his rebellious angels in which they did not prevail against him, ending with the triumph of God's people and the destruction of Satan and his followers.ST Aug 13, 1885ST Jul 1, 1880 Their fall left vacancies in heaven, which will be filled by the redeemed.RH Jul 31, 1913 The devils banished from heaven could find no place there, and when Jesus came near they could find no place in people either and had to leave and enter the swine, for their presence defiled the human body as God's temple.
Christian Life Warning
The powers of hell remain arrayed against people, and no proud self-trusting person can defy them alone and unaided, for Lucifer drew one-third of the angel host to follow him and they fell because they did not prevail.ST When God stands beside the weak, wavering and discouraged one, He sends messengers of light with divine strength to that one's side, the combined hosts of hell quail before them, and victory belongs to the believer by God's might.ST Satan is a conquered foe cast out by Christ, so followers are to look upon him as conquered and accept Christ's victory on the cross as their own.ST Jan 29, 1908 The omnipotent power of the Holy Spirit is the defense of every contrite soul, and Christ will not permit anyone who in penitence and faith has claimed His protection to pass under the enemy's power.ST Jan 29, 1908 Though Satan is powerful, Christ who cast him out is mightier, so believers should not magnify Satan's power but magnify Jesus' power and love, trusting God will never forsake His children in the struggle with evil.ST Jan 29, 1908
Satan's hosts are strong and mighty and fearful to behold, yet they lose so that Michael's forces never give way because heaven has might untold.RH Dec 16, 1909 Christians in their own battle should therefore arm swiftly without delay, stand firm and bold and undaunted in the fray, obey every command of their Captain, not turn back to save treasure, trust God to care for them, and fight in faith knowing victory for eternity is sure if they endure to the end.RH Dec 16, 1909 The dragon hosts do not prevail even though they now gather in malice in fierce array for a mighty conflict, so Christians must wake up and prepare for battle against this enemy in view, girding for the fight though few and weak in numbers.RH May 15, 1855 Taking the breastplate, shield, helmet and sword of truth and standing bold and fearless under a glorious Captain girded with omnipotence gives safe and sure defense with strong and powerful weapons, and faithful fellow-soldiers who remain courageous will see the cause of truth triumph because God gives the victory.RH May 15, 1855
The war was in the spiritual world between Christ and Satan as the very personifications of good and evil, in which the universe and its fate were involved, and Christ was victor while Satan prevailed not.ST May 13, 1903 Christ's victory will not avail for a person unless he is willing that the same principles that prevailed in Christ Jesus shall prevail in his own life, yet Christ will win all victories for him if he is willing.ST May 13, 1903 The controversy that began in heaven is now being fought on earth, and everyone is a participant who must choose a side, with those not actively serving God counted among the powers of darkness.RH Aug 26, 1915ST Jul 19, 1883 That same war between Christ and Satan still goes on with the heart of man as its battlefield and men as the spoil of one or the trophy of the other, where Satan contests every inch of territory while Christ fights for all who yield their wills to Him, so man must take one side or the other and fight with Christ in order to be an overcomer.ST Jan 2, 1907 Satan and his powers oppose Christ, while Jesus and the holy angels press them back and rescue people from Satan's influence, and angels from heaven oppose evil powers and aid people under temptation in a real conflict whose outcome concerns eternal destinies.ST Feb 24, 1887
Every future outbreak of rebellion that tries to retard the work of God will likewise be defeated, as when one third of the heavenly host rebelled against God's righteous government and were cast out. Genuine humility keeps people safe because rebellion cannot exist in the truly humble, who will not be overcome by the wiles of Satan nor by the spirit of rebellion but will stay intimate with God and find in Him grace and strength to remain calm, hopeful and courageous under all circumstances and to come off conquerors over every obstacle. Satan's fall after exalting himself makes the ruin of those who presumptuously exalt themselves and rely on their own power as certain as his own.ST Jan 11, 1905 Self-exaltation brings abasement and a terrible fall, proving God sends judgment on pride and on becoming so self-reliant as to stand independent of the Creator, for Satan exalted himself when he rebelled and was quickly cast out.RH Oct 20, 1874
Pride and ambition led Lucifer to complain against God's rule and seek to overthrow heaven's established order, and after his fall he worked to spread envy, discontent and ambition among people, as seen in Korah's rebellion against God's appointed leaders.RH Nov 12, 1903 Satan's self-exaltation in heaven ended in his being cast out, and the same ruin awaits people who trust in their own power and merits instead of depending on God and the atonement through the crucified and risen Saviour. Satan was cast out when the time came, and preserving an appearance of harmony with those who reject God's counsel cannot justify compromising God's work or truth.RH Apr 27, 1905 This heavenly rebellion connects with Satan's deception in Eden which brought sin and suffering to earth, warning that accepting the same falsehood and exalting the creature above the Creator leads to the fallen cherub's reward.ST Apr 27, 1904
The first apostasy came from feeling slighted, when Satan felt slighted and therefore refused the fundamental truth that God is Supreme Governor, leading the great rebellion in which he was defeated, lost his place, and his case became hopeless.ST Oct 15, 1885 Those who turn away from faith because they have been slighted are actuated by the same spirit and are in danger of becoming as hopeless as Satan.ST Oct 15, 1885 Satan brought politics into heaven when he tried to turn the angels to the kind of government he invented, perverting a multitude of angels, but he did not prevail and they fell with him and lost their place.ST Dec 11, 1901 He has kept doing the same political work ever since, and is doing it now in the church as everywhere else, and multitudes from the church will go with him into Christian politics and go down with him in his final fall which is near, so the Christian's work is to warn men against that deception without doing politics, to walk as Christ walked and do the work committed to him and leave politics to those who will not do God's work.ST Dec 11, 1901 His rebellion began because he wanted the highest rank, equal with God and exalted above Christ, and through pride and ambition tried to gain the honor he believed he deserved and draw heaven to his side, making the rebels alien from God while Michael led heaven's forces against them, though God spared the fallen angels for a time though He had the right to end their lives.RH Jan 29, 1867 Selfishness deceived him into regarding himself as able to improve upon God's arrangement, thinking himself much wiser than he really was in wishing to rule and placing too high an estimate upon his own power in attempting to war with God, in contrast to the Father who though having all power to create the worlds was better pleased to confer that honor upon another and to Jesus who ever honored the Father, both desiring Lucifer's highest happiness within right bounds, so the lesson is to flee such a foe, let Jesus live within the heart and put self to death, since immoderate love for self constitutes sin and sin is a lie and the only truly deceptive thing.RH Aug 27, 1901
After Satan rebelled he was left with no place in heaven, and the same will be true of those who continue in rebellion against God's government and laws. Just before Christ comes in majesty and glory to take vengeance on the rebellious, a proclamation of God's law goes forth so that every disloyal subject may return to allegiance and all are left without excuse, but those who stay in rebellion will have no place in heaven just as Satan had none. Covetousness and envy of God's throne brought this disruption and expulsion, and these traits are unlike God and cannot be tolerated in those who belong wholly to Him.ST Apr 4, 1906 Those who sympathized with his rebellion were cast out and no longer had a place there, warning that a spirit of rebellion or murmuring cannot be tolerated among God's people.RH Nov 18, 1862 Exalted angels forfeited heaven by rebellion and an unyielding spirit that would not submit its own will or concede a point, so refusing to yield when in error brings fatal loss, calling for entire submission with no mental reservation, investigation and cheerful yielding, and receiving needed reproof with deep humility rather than jealousy, envy, self-dignity, impatience, offense or insubordination.RH Jul 9, 1872 Satan is the first great jealous rebel whose spirit is murmuring and raising rebellion against one's best friends, and those who indulge murmuring and rebellion lack the Spirit of God and have fallen under Satan's power and inspiration, ruining those who yield to it.RH
Lucifer was determined to have his own way and to be above Christ, and his example warns that children's training can make them like the fallen angel rather than Christlike.RH Dec 22, 1910 His casting out for disloyalty was no domination of his faith, though he justified rebellion on the ground that his liberty was encroached upon, so insisting that teachers and leaders hold sound belief is likewise no domination of faith. Satan deceived a third of the angels into joining him but he and his followers lost their place, and he is the fallen foe whom Christ later defeated in the wilderness, in which heaven rejoiced.ST Oct 24, 1878 His bid for supremacy failed when he could not obtain the honor he wanted from the Father and Christ, and his later temptation of Christ in the wilderness repeated that demand for worship, but Jesus rejected it and Satan was thwarted again. He had hated Christ for His position in the courts of God, hated Him more when he himself was dethroned, and hated Him who pledged Himself to redeem sinners, yet after losing heaven and claiming dominion over this world God permitted His Son to come as a helpless Babe subject to human weakness to meet life's peril in common with every human soul and fight the battle as every child of humanity must fight it at the risk of failure and eternal loss.ST Dec 9, 1913
Christ cast Satan out of heaven, showing the Saviour's power over the evil one. Christ had met and conquered this foe in heaven before coming to earth, and His victory gives followers courage to resist temptation and discouragement.RH Mar 1, 1906RH Nov 30, 1905 Those cast out were once among God's angels and are now demons of darkness, and under Satan as prince of the powers of darkness they are joined by evil men against Jesus Christ as Prince of Righteousness and Life with the good angels and those actuated by Christ's Spirit.ST May 26, 1898 The same conflict continues now as a greater warfare than any war between nations, fought not with carnal weapons but spiritual, with the fiercest strife in the human heart where Christ seeks to free heart and soul and body from bondage of sin and the prison-house of the grave while Satan seeks to keep souls in bondage, and God calls all through Christ to liberty and victory and to rule the spirit.ST May 26, 1898 The history of the rebellion became a lasting warning against rejecting God's authority, as their continued existence allowed the nature and consequences of sin and the justice, mercy and unchanging character of God's law to become clear to all created beings.RH Feb 8, 1915 That history gives a divine perspective on the past and helps interpret history, and it connects with Satan and his angels attacking God's messengers, calling for prayer that heavenly angels will deliver and shield them.RH Feb 27, 1908RH Sep 18, 1866
Satan failed in the conflict and no longer had a place there, in contrast with Enoch, Noah and Elijah who remained faithful amid surrounding corruption.ST Apr 16, 1896 He was cast out because he exalted himself, considering himself equal with God when he was not, so self-exaltation is a danger God warns against in the second commandment.ST Nov 10, 1898 Light about this apostasy is present truth for this time, needed now as never before to reach many minds and open blind eyes, so it must be given wide circulation through the large books that contain it, especially Patriarchs and Prophets, Daniel and the Revelation, and Great Controversy.RH Jan 23, 1908 The redeemed will sing of victory over Satan in God's presence around His throne before the loyal angels, as a fitting crowning celebration of victory over the chief rebel against government and law.RH Oct 3, 1912 The rebellious and unbelieving angels were not suffered to remain in God's presence, while the angels who now sing praises are beings who were tested and of their own free will chose loyalty, meaning God will have a tried people and men who cherish doubts and unbelief will never be permitted entrance into His glorious kingdom just as unbelief cast angels out.ST Sep 30, 1886
Lucifer's departure to spread doubt, division and hatred, and the failure of those who joined him, did not end God's work or prevent Him from leading His people.RH Jan 18, 1912 His pursuit of liberty as freedom from God's authority ended in expulsion, and the same false idea led him to persuade Adam and Eve that God was tyrannical and withheld what they had a right to have, yet by disobeying they did not become free but came under Satan's control because those who obey sin become its servants, for human beings cannot be independent of God since even before the Fall food was God's gift and afterward God provided clothing.ST Jul 7, 1898 His persistent rebellion arose from envy and disappointed ambition, and God's refusal to yield His throne was not partiality or injustice.RH Jan 11, 1906 Love could not make peace with evil, so rebels who did not prevail were cast out.RH Jan 14, 1904 The loyal angels were not responsible for the war, for the revolt belonged to Satan and his followers in their war against Michael and the loyal angels, and the devil and his angels who oppose Christ are demons who hate Christ and seek to degrade Him.RH Jan 31, 1865RH Jul 26, 1864
The beginning controversy for supremacy was face-to-face combat in heaven in which Satan did not prevail, and the same persons contend over the same issues now as then, but the warfare has been transferred to earth where Christ in the flesh meets and vanquishes Satan through the mystery of godliness answering the mystery of iniquity.ST Apr 9, 1902 That opposition continued to contest Christ's work on earth.RH Jul 19, 1906 After expulsion Satan determined to make earth his kingdom and conquer everything in sight so as to own and absolutely rule the world, thinking that when he overcame Adam and Eve who chose him as ruler he had secured possession, so this world became the great battlefield and bone of contention in the centuries-long contest where Satan fiercely works to conquer while God holds some hearts true to Him.ST Jun 16, 1909 Conquering that rebellion cast from heaven in the flesh was given to Christ, Immanuel, so that by God's purpose and care every ill will be extinguished.RH Jul 1, 1902
God refused to tolerate sin when Satan's great revolt took place, and rather than spare feelings, divide the universe with the devil, perpetuate sin to all eternity or surrender heaven's throne, He stood squarely for righteousness and left them with no place, meaning hatred of sin and direct faithful reproof belong to true religion while easy compromise for feelings and outward peace allows evil to continue.RH Jul 22, 1873 He did not excuse, shield or tolerate sin when it appeared in one third of the angels, but vindicated right by casting them out even though feelings were wounded, a wound not yet healed and not to be healed till Satan and his host are buried in the burning lake, meaning true religion carries out heaven's principles by calling things by right names and refusing to plaster over wickedness or compromise to spare feelings.RH Jul 22, 1873 Deliberate and determined rebellion like this first great rebellion has no remedy and will cease only by extermination, for the angels who conspired were defeated and driven into hopeless exile.RH Oct 28, 1873RH Sep 11, 1900 Satan once stood very high but in rebelling against God's law and heaven's order he prevailed not and fell with very many who loved him, while Jesus was foremost in sustaining God's law and the universe's well-being, and in striving to deprive King Jesus of immortality Satan forfeited his own immortality as his capital offense for which he and followers must finally die by loss of life and reason, yet God allowed time for rebellion to culminate and manifest its character, especially in attempting to annihilate Jesus, to give abundant evidence of wisdom, show mutiny's nature, shut out sympathy, and leave no thought of reform or haste, while man as victim not voluntary participant could be ransomed through the sufficient Redeemer who restores all breaking from Satan to their rightful Sovereign.RH Mar 3, 1863
Their expulsion did not reform Satan, for he remained rebellious, resented Christ's position, and later sought worship and supremacy by tempting Christ with the world's kingdoms.ST Apr 11, 1900 The great apostate who refused obedience did not prevail and lost his place, then deceived Adam and Eve bringing woe upon the world.ST Jun 20, 1900 Lucifer's rebellion failed so he and his angels could not overthrow God's order, arising from pride and ambition with the claim that heaven's order restrained liberty, bringing separation, disorder, misery and woe.RH Jul 27, 1916ST Jul 4, 1911 That expulsion followed ambition to set his own rule against God's government of love and unselfishness. God reigns and Satan did not succeed in ruling over humanity, for his rebellion failed and he and his angels did not prevail or retain a place.RH Jul 21, 1868 Before expulsion Satan had personal acquaintance with God and knew His character, and since losing his place his constant effort has been to misrepresent it by Christless religion of penances, mortifications, splendid sights and pageantries like Cain's offering.ST Mar 3, 1898 His fall began a pattern in which those who sympathize with and cooperate with Satan support wrongdoing when it is reproved.LS 285.1–286.3
Sources