Revelation 12:8
And prevailed not; neither was their place found any more in heaven.
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, Webster Bible
And prevailed not; neither was their place found any more in heaven.
and prevailed not; neither was their place found any more in heaven.
Revised Version, Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And they prevailed not, neither was their place found any more in heaven.
and they prevailed not, neither was their place found any more in heaven.
and they did not prevail, nor was their place found any more in the heaven;
and he prevailed not, nor was their place found any more in the heaven.
and he prevailed not, neither was place found for them, any longer, in heaven.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
But the dragon was not strong enough, and no longer was any place found in heaven for him and his angels.
They didn’ t prevail. No place was found for them any more in heaven.
And they were overcome, and there was no more place for them in heaven.
But they preuailed not, neither was their place found any more in heauen.
Pictures




Cross-references 20 of 42
- Isaiah 14:12-15
How art thou fallen from heaven, O Lucifer, son of the morning! how art thou cut down to the ground, which didst weaken the nations!
Lucifer’s self-exaltation is followed by his fall from heaven.
- Ezekiel 28:14-17
Thou art the anointed cherub that covereth; and I have set thee so: thou wast upon the holy mountain of God; thou hast walked up and down in the midst of the stones of fire.
The covering cherub’s pride and iniquity lead to his expulsion from God’s mountain.
- 2 Peter 2:4
For if God spared not the angels that sinned, but cast them down to hell, and delivered them into chains of darkness, to be reserved unto judgment;
Both describe sinful angels cast down from heaven and held for judgment.
- Jude 1:6
And the angels which kept not their first estate, but left their own habitation, he hath reserved in everlasting chains under darkness unto the judgment of the great day.
Both describe angels who abandoned their proper place and were kept for judgment.
- Luke 10:18
And he said unto them, I beheld Satan as lightning fall from heaven.
Jesus describes Satan falling from heaven, confirming his expulsion.
- Revelation 12:4
And his tail drew the third part of the stars of heaven, and did cast them to the earth: and the dragon stood before the woman which was ready to be delivered, for to devour her child as soon as it was born.
The dragon draws a third of heaven’s stars, identified as angels cast out with him.
- Revelation 12:17
And the dragon was wroth with the woman, and went to make war with the remnant of her seed, which keep the commandments of God, and have the testimony of Jesus Christ.
The expelled dragon directs his hostility against the commandment-keeping remnant.
- Revelation 12:12
Therefore rejoice, ye heavens, and ye that dwell in them. Woe to the inhabiters of the earth and of the sea! for the devil is come down unto you, having great wrath, because he knoweth that he hath but a short time.
After his expulsion, Satan comes down with great wrath, knowing his time is short.
- John 12:31
Now is the judgment of this world: now shall the prince of this world be cast out.
Christ’s death brings the casting down and judgment of Satan, the prince of this world.
- Ezekiel 28:17
Thine heart was lifted up because of thy beauty, thou hast corrupted thy wisdom by reason of thy brightness: I will cast thee to the ground, I will lay thee before kings, that they may behold thee.
Pride in beauty and brightness leads to the cherub’s expulsion and fall.
- Revelation 20:2
And he laid hold on the dragon, that old serpent, which is the Devil, and Satan, and bound him a thousand years,
Names the dragon as the Devil and Satan, and describes him bound for a thousand years.
- Revelation 12:13
And when the dragon saw that he was cast unto the earth, he persecuted the woman which brought forth the man child.
After being cast down, the dragon persecutes the woman, representing the church.
- Revelation 12:3
And there appeared another wonder in heaven; and behold a great red dragon, having seven heads and ten horns, and seven crowns upon his heads.
The dragon is introduced in the heavenly conflict that ends with his expulsion.
- Genesis 3:15
And I will put enmity between thee and the woman, and between thy seed and her seed; it shall bruise thy head, and thou shalt bruise his heel.
The promised Seed’s victory assures Satan’s overthrow.
- John 8:44
Ye are of your father the devil, and the lusts of your father ye will do. He was a murderer from the beginning, and abode not in the truth, because there is no truth in him. When he speaketh a lie, he speaketh of his own: for he is a liar, and the father of it.
Both describe Satan as a liar and murderer who did not remain in the truth.
- Isaiah 14:12
How art thou fallen from heaven, O Lucifer, son of the morning! how art thou cut down to the ground, which didst weaken the nations!
Identifies the rebel leader who lost heaven as Lucifer.
- Revelation 13:1-2
And I stood upon the sand of the sea, and saw a beast rise up out of the sea, having seven heads and ten horns, and upon his horns ten crowns, and upon his heads the name of blasphemy.
The beast continues the dragon’s work through earthly powers.
- Ezekiel 28:15-16
Thou wast perfect in thy ways from the day that thou wast created, till iniquity was found in thee.
Iniquity is found in the cherub, and he is cast out of God’s mountain.
- Revelation 12:1
And there appeared a great wonder in heaven; a woman clothed with the sun, and the moon under her feet, and upon her head a crown of twelve stars:
The heavenly conflict unfolds in the prophecy of the woman representing Christ’s church.
- 1 John 3:8
He that committeth sin is of the devil; for the devil sinneth from the beginning. For this purpose the Son of God was manifested, that he might destroy the works of the devil.
Christ came to destroy the devil’s works.
Commentary part 1 of 4
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
250 sources
Revelation 12:8 describes a real war in heaven in which Michael, who is Christ the Son of God, with His loyal angels fought Satan the dragon with the angels who joined him, and Satan and his angels prevailed not but were defeated and cast out so their place was found no more in heaven.Lt 165, 1903, par. 16–17Lt 210, 1907, par. 2–7Ms 198, 1899, par. 5
Lucifer had stood next to Christ as first of the covering cherubs, most beautiful and exalted, but envy and jealousy of Christ, pride and ambition to be equal with God and first in power, led him to rebel without cause or excuse.4MR 84.1–85.2Ms 163, 1903, par. 1–37MR 62.4–63.25T 56.1ST Sep 14, 1882
The great controversy was over God's law, for he sought to find flaw in it, change or annul it and set his own will above the Creator, but God refused any change and the unchangeable law stood vindicated.1SP 22.3Ms 141a, 1897, par. 12–13Ms 6, 1894, par. 9–13Ms 23, 1900, par. 18–20ST Nov 14, 1895
Expulsion was necessary and just, for after long forbearance, repeated offers of pardon, and full revelation of character, his corrupting influence would have kept heaven in danger, so all who chose his side were removed and heaven was again peaceful and harmonious.Ms 198, 1899, par. 5RH Feb 8, 19154SP 319.1–3CT 268.1RH Feb 8, 1915
The war cast out of heaven continues on earth as the sole theater of struggle, where by the same deception he led Adam and Eve to fall and still works to make void the law, yet his defeat at the cross made certain his final destruction and the triumph of truth.RH May 3, 1906GC88 bB.5–6Ms 167, 1907, par. 11–12ST Sep 23, 1889
Heavenly War and Outcome
The verse describes a real war in heaven in which Michael, Christ, the Son of God and Prince of heaven, with His loyal, good and true angels fought Satan, the dragon, devil and archrebel with the angels who joined him, and Satan and his angels prevailed not but were defeated, overcome, banished, expelled, cast out and driven from heaven so their place was found no more there.Lt 165, 1903, par. 16–17Lt 210, 1907, par. 2–7Ms 198, 1899, par. 54MR 84.1–85.2Ms 163, 1903, par. 1–3 That conflict began in heaven after a long, severe day-by-day course of deception and satanic wiles in misinterpreting God, Christ, and the true and loyal angels until it could be tolerated no more, and every soul liable to act on his side was driven out for the safety of the loyal.Ms 198, 1899, par. 54MR 84.1–85.27MR 62.4–63.2 The dragon is Lucifer, who next to Christ held the most exalted position as first of the covering cherubs, holy, greatly loved, and strong in influence, yet who coveted the homage due alone to the Creator, cherished envy, sought the service and loyalty of angels for himself, and worked by influence of mind on mind as if seeking the good of the universe until his sentiments developed and many listened and believed.4MR 84.1–85.2Ms 163, 1903, par. 1–37MR 62.4–63.2 His formerly unquestionable character gave weight to his disaffection and deceptive representations, drawing large numbers to his side, yet though he knows the result he purposes to carry apostasy, disaffection and rebellion to the bitter end, and some today go over the same ground sustained by his heresies and sophistries.4MR 84.1–85.2Ms 163, 1903, par. 1–3 This conflict begun in heaven will be carried on by him in the last days, and the same warfare continues on earth as the battle between righteousness and sin where holy angels minister, every person must take a decided position on the Lord's side, and Satan will not prevail.Lt 165, 1903, par. 16–17Lt 210, 1907, par. 2–7
The loyal angels fought on God's side and triumphed, and those same victorious angels now minister invisibly with redeemed human beings for salvation.6T 456.1–457.2ST Dec 1, 1909RH Mar 19, 1901Ms 65, 1900, par. 4–8Ms 65a, 1900, par. 4–7 When Satan sought supremacy a real battle was fought in the heavenly courts in which faithful, loyal angels fought on the side of God and won, Satan failing to overcome.ST Dec 1, 1909RH Mar 19, 1901Ms 65, 1900, par. 4–8 Those same victorious angels had shouted for joy over the creation of the world and its sinless inhabitants and over the first parents to inhabit the earth, and had witnessed the fall of man and his expulsion from his Eden home.ST Dec 1, 1909RH Mar 19, 1901 They are now most intensely interested in the spiritual welfare of all seeking to restore the moral image of God in man, desiring to look into the plan of redemption, rejoicing whenever any part of God's work prospers, visiting the world and overseeing the work in the hands of His stewards, ministering in every time of necessity to co-workers with God, cooperating invisibly with visible human agencies as a relief-association to bind up the wounds and bruises sin has made and to save human beings perishing in sin.ST Dec 1, 1909RH Mar 19, 1901 Before that rebellion the angels had almost never thought of law as law, for their service was not rendered in a spirit of legality or as servants for wages to secure position, increase importance, or minister to pleasure, but sprang from love for God and unity with His will in perfect oneness of taste and inclination, so obedience was delight and not drudgery.9MR 210.2
A third of the angels were drawn away from the Father and Son to join Satan, one-third of the heavenly family going with him when cast out.ST Oct 24, 18783T 114.2Lt 150, 1906, par. 3–4Lt 192, 1903, par. 7–9 Satan deceived a third of the angels into joining him, and a third of the loyal angels sided with the great deceiver because they thought he was being wronged, though he was the source of rebellion, and their deception and divided loyalty warn against sympathizing with a deceiver and turning from truth.ST Oct 24, 18783T 114.2Lt 150, 1906, par. 3–4 His rebellion had spread so widely that he took one-third with him when cast out after he refused to yield his will to God.Lt 192, 1903, par. 7–9 Yet when all the heavenly host were summoned before the Father to have each case determined, Satan openly made known dissatisfaction that Christ was preferred before him, stood up proudly and demanded to be equal with God and to be taken into conference to understand His purposes, and God answered that secret purposes would be revealed to His Son alone and required all the family in heaven, even Satan, to yield the Son implicit, unquestioned obedience, declaring Satan unworthy of a place in heaven.1SP 22.2 Satan then exultingly pointed to his sympathizers, comprising nearly one half of all the angels, challenged God to expel them also and make such a void in heaven, and declared he was prepared to resist the authority of Christ and defend his place by force of might, strength against strength.1SP 22.2
Christ Himself as Prince of life and first great Conqueror overcame, vanquished and expelled Satan, showing the Saviour's power over the evil one.2RED 52.1–21T 625.1–626.2 The war was between Christ and Lucifer over the government of God, when Lucifer sought to change God's rule by deception and falsehood, but Christ overcame him so he did not prevail and was expelled and lost all standing in heaven.Ms 57, 1890, par. 3 Lucifer was cast out because he wanted the place of Christ and could not have it, and Christ left the heavenly throne to come down into this world to meet him and withstand his power, which is ground for trusting Christ, taking Him into the family, teaching children that trust, believing His words and claiming His promise instead of complaining.Ms 86, 1910, par. 19–21 The same two met again in the wilderness, where Christ recognized Satan from the first though he concealed true character and purposes and flattered himself he was unknown, and Christ appeared to be alone yet was encircled by ministering angels as God commissions angels to minister to all under Satan's fearful assaults, and there Christ again defeated him.Ms 57, 1890, par. 32RED 52.1–2 His command Get thee hence, Satan proved all deceptive arts had failed and that identity and past defeat and expulsion were known, and those who defend truth are in combat with Satan and his angels as well as men, so they must not enter in self-sufficiency and reliance on strong argument, sarcasm, playing upon words, or unlawful advantage, but with firm trust in God and the humble, meek and lowly spirit of Jesus, following Christ who though victorious did not bring a railing accusation against Satan, and who died to redeem fallen man from Satan's power.2RED 52.1–21T 625.1–626.2
Their defeat ended Satan's place of honor, supremacy and role in heaven's government, removed him from first estate and all standing and recognition, shut him out of the abode of bliss and God's Paradise, and left joining angels sharing responsibility and consequences.Ms 117, 1908, par. 5–7Ms 78, 1905, par. 181SP 31.1–32.2Ms 130, 1903, par. 27–28 Satan had held high office with a throne radiant with light, but he swerved from allegiance to the blessed and only Potentate and fell from his first estate, and all who sympathized were driven from the presence of God and doomed to be no more acknowledged in the heavenly courts as having a right there.Ms 78, 1905, par. 18Ms 130, 1903, par. 27–28 Stripped of honor and supremacy, he and his followers became enemies of God opposing Him and the cause of truth and righteousness, and on earth he planted the standard of rebellion around which his sympathizers rallied.Ms 117, 1908, par. 5–7Ms 78, 1905, par. 18 If his plans to regain control of heaven failed, there was no hope of regaining or controlling heaven or any part of God's creation, and the angels who joined him shared responsibility for his plans and their consequences.1SP 31.1–32.2Lt 114, 1910, par. 12–14 His plans were restrained and he was made to understand that God rules over the inhabitants of the world, and to choose him now is to be numbered in his army, dishonor Creator and Redeemer, gain nothing but eternal death and lose recognition in heaven, while to choose Christ the only begotten Son who came to redeem the fallen race is to receive power to resist every temptation, build character free from Satan's tendencies, and win victory by doing right because it is right.Lt 114, 1910, par. 12–14Ms 130, 1903, par. 27–28
After removal no taint of rebellion was left and heaven was again peaceful and harmonious with the host adoring the God of justice while mourning former companions, and immediately the Father consulted Jesus about making man to inhabit earth on probation to test loyalty before rendering him eternally secure.RH Feb 8, 1915ST Jan 9, 1879 The Son of God and the loyal angels prevailed while Satan and sympathizers were expelled so no place remained, no taint was left, heaven was again peaceful and harmonious with all acknowledging and adoring the God of justice while mourning the fate of former companions whose loss was felt.RH Feb 8, 1915ST Jan 9, 1879 Their rebellion against God's law was incurable so they could not remain among the heavenly host, and their removal restored peace and harmony.RH Feb 8, 1915ST Jan 9, 1879 Immediately after the expulsion the Father consulted Jesus about carrying out their purpose to make man to inhabit the earth and place him upon probation to test his loyalty before he could be rendered eternally secure, with promise that if he endured he would eventually be equal with the angels, have God's favor, converse with angels, God deliberately not placing him beyond the power of disobedience.RH Feb 8, 1915
While some angels joined Satan in claiming equality with God and refusing to submit to Christ's authority, others opposed his plans and defended God's wisdom in giving authority to Christ.SG3 37.1SG3 37.2 Satan waged war because he was ambitious to exalt himself and refused to submit to Christ, Heaven's commander, claiming he should be equal with God, and the angels were marshaled in companies under their commanders.SG3 37.1SG3 37.2 Jesus passed through those terrible scenes and watched the history and unfolding of sin from the beginning, seeing the evil power of sin bewitch heavenly angels until they sympathized with Satan and joined his rebellion, with all consequences of sin before His vision.Ms 13, 1892, par. 35–36 The outcome was expulsion from the abode of bliss so his place was found there no more.Ms 13, 1892, par. 35–36
Lucifer's Exalted Position and Ambition
Lucifer stood next to Christ as first of the covering cherubs, most beautiful, holy, undefiled, greatly loved, strong in influence, with special light beaming brighter than around other angels, perfect form, noble bearing, powerful intellect, and high position as light-bearer enriched with strength, glory and wonderful power, while Jesus had pre-eminence as one with the Father before angels were created, associate and co-worker in creation, holding supremacy over the angels.4MR 84.1–85.27MR 62.4–63.21SP 17.1Lt 256, 1906, par. 6–10Ms 87, 1903, par. 1–2 He was son of the morning, highest of created beings next to Christ in power and glory, perfect from creation until iniquity was found, honored above the host and entrusted with guidance and guardianship of heaven committed to him.Ms 163, 1903, par. 1–37MR 62.4–63.2Lt 256, 1906, par. 6–10 He envied Christ's first place next to God as one with God to do God's will, felt his beauty and exalted position were not given due honor in being second to Christ, and spread that suggestion until angels sympathized and his party grew strong against Christ in a war that could not be corrected.Ms 90, 1910, par. 4–6RH Feb 24, 1874LC1 109.1–2
He coveted the homage due alone to the Creator, sought equality with God, to be preferred over Christ, to be first in power and authority and ruler of the universe rather than light-bearer, to place his throne above God's and rule independently, and could not obtain what he coveted and demanded.4MR 84.1–85.2Ms 78, 1901, par. 2RH Feb 4, 1909RH Jan 16, 1913ST Nov 5, 1894 His jealousy led him to seek God's throne, to demand a position above Christ, and when refused war followed ending in defeat and loss of place.Ms 78, 1901, par. 2Lt 74, 1910, par. 1–5Lt 189, 1909, par. 29 He concealed his aims while using deceptive insinuations to sow doubt about Christ, won support for his claim to be preferred, and would not accept the position assigned him.RH Feb 4, 1909Lt 189, 1909, par. 29
Envy and jealousy of Christ's first place next to God began the rebellion; desiring to be first and unable to have all power and glory he rebelled and lost place, and envy is not mere temper but a distemper disordering all faculties.5T 56.1ST Sep 14, 1882TBC1882 32.3–33.2 Though an exalted archangel he became dissatisfied because not accorded supreme honor, questioned God's purposes and impugned His justice, told angels who honored him he lacked the honor his position demanded and should be exalted equal in honor with God and Christ, and bent all powers to allure angels from allegiance.ST Sep 14, 1882RH Feb 24, 1874LC1 109.1–2 His complaints at first met no favor yet urged again and again were finally accepted by formerly loyal happy subjects, cherished envy and jealousy gaining power that paralyzed reason and destroyed honor and loyalty, with no shadow of justification or excuse, so he and sympathizers were cast out to be found there no more.ST Sep 14, 1882Ms 97, 1901, par. 2 He then envied our first parents and tempted them to sin, thus ruining them and all the human race.5T 56.1TBC1882 32.3–33.2
Pride and ambition cherished in his heart brought banishment, and self-seeking, desire to live for self and make himself a center of influence opposing the law that none lives to himself continued as rebellion on earth.CT 32.3RH Jan 16, 19135T 242.1CT 33.1Lt 142, 1902, par. 7–8 His rebellion was incited by determination to live for self, and through ambition and selfish desire he led humanity into sin and ruin, establishing a kingdom of his own after expulsion and seeking to draw the world to his rebellion.CT 32.3RH Jan 16, 1913RH Apr 24, 1900 Having swerved from allegiance he became envious and jealous, drawing sympathizers into rebellion, and no soul alienated from God can remain in heaven.Lt 142, 1902, par. 7–8
Sin originated with him without reasonable cause and remains unexplainable; if cause or excuse could be found it would not be transgression, and his transgression of the law had no excuse, defence or justification.Ms 163, 1903, par. 1–3Ms 84, 1910, par. 28Ms 162, 1899, par. 12–14Lt 142, 1902, par. 7–8 Why he rebelled has not been told, leaving his conduct an unexplainable problem, and his formerly unquestionable character gave weight to his disaffection and deceptive representations drawing large numbers to his side to carry apostasy to the bitter end.Ms 163, 1903, par. 1–3Ms 162, 1899, par. 12–14 Beautiful exalted angels fell because they would not obey heaven's laws, though where sin sprang from in them is impossible to tell, and their choice gives no excuse to yield to sin for if excuse could be found it could not be condemned.Ms 84, 1910, par. 28Lt 142, 1902, par. 7–8 His rebellion was against the laws of God's government afterward written on stone, and nearly all the human family joined it by disloyalty.
There was no withdrawal of divine influence and no deficiency in God's government to give cause for disaffection, so the divine decrees and government are vindicated and are not responsible for sin.Lt 54, 1895, par. 15SPBC 179.4 Not in the slightest particular was heaven's order deficient, giving no just cause for rebellion, and therefore those bearing responsibility in God's work must likewise give no cause for disaffection and must maintain principles according to heaven's order.SPBC 179.4
He became dissatisfied because God had not revealed every secret of His purposes and disregarded what was revealed about his assigned work, stirring the angels under his command to share discontent and causing their fall.GC 523.1
In a council in heaven before the creation of this world the covering cherub asked to be made prince to govern the world then in prospect and was refused, because Jesus Christ under God was to rule the earthly kingdom and the law of heaven was to be its standard for the new world and human intelligences.Ms 43b, 1891, par. 3 Lucifer became jealous of Christ, jealousy grew into rebellion carrying many holy angels, yet Jesus was not deceived by sophistry but stood true to principle and resisted every line of reasoning, evidencing that every angel might have stood, so Lucifer prevailed not and his place was found no more in heaven.Ms 43b, 1891, par. 3
Controversy Over Law and Government
The great subject of controversy in heaven was God's law, the ten commandments afterward written with God's own finger upon tables of stone, given to govern the high order of intelligences upon condition of obedience with no provision made to save those who should venture to transgress it.1SP 22.35MR 269.2–3 The happiness of the angelic host consisted in perfect obedience to that perfect and unchanging law, each having his special work assigned, until rebellion against it set the rebels against heaven, for sin is the transgression of the law.1SP 22.3Ms 23, 1900, par. 18–20Ms 1, 1902, par. 1 Satan was the first rebel and great leader of all rebellions through bold rebellion and contempt for the Creator's law, claiming angels needed no law but should be left free to follow their own will, and that same controversy over the law that caused his fall has continued ever since as the great test question dividing everyone into the loyal and the transgressors.1SP 22.35MR 269.2–3RH Oct 21, 1902 Those who knowingly break that law and teach others to do so cannot enter heaven, for rebellion and disobedience cannot be carried into God's kingdom where sin has no place.Ms 23, 1900, par. 18–20
War broke out in heaven when Satan rebelled against the order and will of God and the authority of Jesus, Heaven's commander and the Son of God, refusing to submit to Him while ambitious to exalt himself, reform the government of God, conquer the Son of God, crowd out Christ, and claim the highest place above the only begotten Son.SG1 17.2SG3 37.11SP 22.1Ms 84, 1910, par. 36–37 All heaven was in commotion as angels were marshaled in companies, each division with a higher commanding angel at its head, Satan and the angels who sympathized with him fighting against the submissive angels, and their defiance of God's law was followed by the attempt to blame Christ's reproof for causing their rebellion.SG1 17.2GC 499.2–3GC88 499.2–500.11SP 22.1 The good and true angels won, the Prince of life overcame, and by the Father's decision Satan and all who rebelled with him failed to overthrow God's government, would not repent and accept the rule of God nor listen to the highest authority which is God Himself, and were banished, expelled and driven out to have no place there any more.SG1 17.2GC 499.2–3GC88 499.2–500.1Ms 84, 1910, par. 36–37
He sought to find some flaw in the law in order to argue that it must be changed, charging that God had given a law that man could not keep, and after deceiving thousands of angels and drawing them to question the authority of God's law and the justice of God's government he was cast out.ST Nov 14, 189519MR 68.4Ms 164, 1905, par. 13–15 He sought to change or annul the law of God and to make his own word and commands equal with Jehovah's, placing his own judgment above the Creator's and his will above Jehovah's and thereby treating God as fallible, while the fallen angels remain united as with iron bands in determined opposition to the great moral standard that governs all intelligences in Paradise and in the many worlds God created.Ms 55, 1886, par. 18–21Lt 24, 1895, par. 12–14Ms 91, 1894, par. 14 The conflict began with that effort to make God change the law of His government and continues on earth as he leads men to question the words of God, to cover transgression with robes of righteousness as angels of light, to present flattering inducements into sin, and to prove by his own failure to keep God's law that people on earth cannot keep it either.Ms 55, 1886, par. 18–21Lt 24, 1895, par. 12–1419MR 68.4Ms 164, 1905, par. 13–15 The pope's attempt to adjust God's law to his own ideas repeats that rebellion on earth.Ms 91, 1894, par. 14
He prevailed not because God refused any change, for when the first suggestion of a change in God's law was made in the heavenly courts it was met by God with a decided No, and not the smallest jot or tittle was given over to be manipulated.Ms 4a, 1898, par. 8–11SG1 110.1ST Nov 14, 1895 Satan, next to Christ the most exalted being in the heavenly court, charged that the law should be abolished or altered to meet his request, wanted God to change His unalterable law, but was not permitted to do so, was overcome with his sympathizers, and was cast out with the angels that had taken sides with him.Ms 141a, 1897, par. 12–13Ms 4a, 1898, par. 8–11SG1 110.1Lt 110, 1896, par. 9–15 The law was not changed in one jot or tittle, proving God wise and unchangeable and Satan's charge false, proving he was not right and that God has not abolished His law as he claimed He should.Ms 141a, 1897, par. 12–13Ms 4a, 1898, par. 8–11ST Nov 14, 1895 The law of God is a transcript of His character, as unchangeable as His character and as unalterable as His throne and His character, so if any change had been possible it would have been made then to save the rebellion in heaven, and had the law been changed in even one precept since his expulsion he would have gained on earth after his fall what he could not gain before his fall.Ms 6, 1894, par. 9–13Lt 110, 1896, par. 9–1521MR 281.3–282.4 Therefore the law remains with all its binding force upon every human being, proved also by Adam's fall and Christ's sacrifice, for if the law could have been changed to meet man in his fallen condition Adam would have been pardoned and retained Eden and Christ could have been retained in the heavenly courts without the immense sacrifice, but instead the penalty of transgression was death, Christ became man's substitute and surety, Adam lost Eden and with all his posterity was placed upon probation, and every soul's salvation is determined by obedience or disobedience to the unchanged law.Lt 110, 1896, par. 9–15
In this prophecy the dragon represents Satan primarily and pagan Rome secondarily, pagan Rome being his chief agent in making war on Christ and His people during the first centuries of the Christian era, as when Satan moved Herod to seek Christ's death.GC88 438.2 Christ had entered into a covenant with God to vindicate every specification of God's character as expressed in His holy law and to refute Satan's lie by giving Himself as a sacrifice for sin, thus revealing to the heavenly universe that the law is as unchangeable, immutable, and eternal in its character as Jehovah Himself.Ms 141a, 1897, par. 12–13 Though Lucifer had the advantage that he could lie, deceive and accuse while God cannot lie and moved serpent-like in a crooked, wriggly, twisting course, God moved in a straightforward course of truth and justice to vindicate His law, warned Lucifer as only God can warn, allowed him to go on until his true character was revealed, and pure truth proved a match for falsehood.Ms 22, 1885, par. 17–18 By giving His own life to maintain the honor of God's law Christ destroyed the works of Satan, proving the truth that was truth when the world was made will remain truth when the earth is purified for the saints, while that same controversy over God's law remains the great test dividing the loyal and the transgressors into two parties who blindly pursue the same warfare against God's law that Satan began in heaven.Ms 141a, 1897, par. 12–13Ms 22, 1885, par. 17–18
Deceptive Methods in Heaven
After a long severe day-by-day course of deception he hid his real purpose while insinuating doubt and suspicion into angelic minds by influence of mind on mind, as if seeking the good of the universe, misinterpreting God, Christ and the true loyal angels until it could be tolerated no more.Ms 198, 1899, par. 5Lt 256, 1906, par. 11–12Ms 142, 1906, par. 2–4 His power was deception, and by seducing statements he won the confidence of many angels and drew them after him until open war broke out and Michael and His angels fought against him.Ms 198, 1899, par. 5Lt 256, 1906, par. 11–12Ms 106, 1905, par. 27–30 That hidden work had to be allowed to fully develop before it could be dealt with, God letting what was in him work out until wickedness originating with him came to the surface and had to come to an end in the heavenly courts.Ms 198, 1899, par. 5Ms 142, 1906, par. 2–4Ms 13, 1906, par. 1 Then there were two parties, Satan warring on one side and God and His angels on the other, and he was overcome, defeated, and thrust down to this world with every soul liable to act on his side driven out for the safety of the loyal, after which there was peace in heaven.Ms 198, 1899, par. 5Lt 256, 1906, par. 11–12Ms 142, 1906, par. 2–4
He spread rebellion by stealthy adroit underhand suggestions, placing his own thoughts in angelic minds, winning a few at a time, leaving insinuations to develop until angels openly communicated the new theories.Ms 34, 1906, par. 10–12Lt 107a, 1900, par. 2–3Lt 113, 1903, par. 12Ms 184, 1905, par. 9–15Ms 78, 1905, par. 15–17 He pretended loyalty while putting subtle sophistries into minds, then called angels to state their objections, deceiving a large number, gathering many to listen to specious devisings without compromising himself, ensnaring the unsuspecting and bringing what had never before been seen in heaven.Ms 34, 1906, par. 10–12Ms 78, 1905, par. 15–17 He placed thoughts in minds of angels who supposed he was in harmony with God and the Prince of heaven and expressed assent, then repeated those suggestions to the highest Authority as disaffection from members of the royal family, and presented those he had deceived as originating the suggestions and calling for investigation.Lt 107a, 1900, par. 2–3Ms 78, 1905, par. 15–17Ms 13, 1906, par. 1 He covered his tracks so greatly admired for beauty and exalted loveliness that suspicion and distrust of God and distrust of one another came in without anyone being able to define how.Lt 107a, 1900, par. 2–3 The same enemy now works upon human minds in the same way, exercising deceptive power not only upon inexperienced youth but upon men and women of mature years, especially men bearing large responsibilities, seeking to link up with them to fill their minds with evil devisings contrary to the mind of God and put them in danger of changing leaders, and carrying on the same work of creating disloyalty in churches by bringing in one error after another to bewilder minds.Ms 184, 1905, par. 9–15Ms 78, 1905, par. 15–17Ms 159, 1903, par. 12–13
He won confidence by seducing statements, falsehood, false teaching and misrepresentation against God, appealing to sympathies, making good appear evil, misstating Christ's words and giving false meaning to every truthful statement.Ms 34, 1906, par. 10–12Ms 106, 1905, par. 27–3010MR 162.5 Through insinuations angels were turned against God and Christ, believing God and Christ, though infinitely powerful and majestic, were their enemies and Satan their benefactor.GW92 86.13T 327.3–329.1 By ingenious misrepresentation he deceived angels, claimed God's perfect unchanging law needed to be changed, persuaded many to join him, and made it appear that God misjudged him.Ms 34, 1906, par. 10–1210MR 162.5Ms 61b, 1895, par. 27–30 His lie against God continued on earth when he used the serpent to persuade Adam and Eve to trust his words instead of God's, declaring God was withholding the higher education that would make them as gods, bringing sin into the world, and his false sentiments still press upon God's people so that when they accept them Christ is compelled to bear their shameful infirmities.Ms 106, 1905, par. 27–3010MR 162.5Ms 61b, 1895, par. 27–30
He used false science, false assertions and subtle scientific theories and sophistry with hypnotic deception, presenting deceptive scientific problems to sow rebellious seed with apparent innocence until it took root.8T 290.1–3Ms 100, 1905, par. 1Ms 13, 1906, par. 1 He worked in the heavenly courts by sophistry and hypnotic deception, a deceptive science, and his sophistries were accepted there even though he did not prevail.Ms 100, 1905, par. 1Ms 13, 1906, par. 1 His science is taking captive the minds of those who associate with him, seen in mesmerism and hypnotism, which men and women must not study or tamper with but must resist.Ms 86, 1905, par. 15 The same science by which Adam and Eve were deceived is deceiving men today, with doctors and ministers influenced by the hypnotism exercised by the father of lies, whose disobedience estranged humanity from God and separated earth from heaven, so ministers and lay members nigh and afar off must be guarded from being misled by deceptive underhand working to obtain control condemned by the law of God.8T 290.1–3Ms 100, 1905, par. 1
He promised a new and better government with freedom, claimed Jehovah's law hampered them and that change would work for the great advantage of the heavenly family, suggesting he could do most wonderful things if unhampered.Lt 107a, 1900, par. 2–31SP 20.1PP 37.1–38.1 Concealing real purposes after leaving the immediate presence of the Father dissatisfied and filled with envy against Jesus, he assembled the host as one aggrieved, relating the preference given Jesus to his neglect, declaring sweet liberty at an end and that a ruler had been appointed over them to whom they must henceforth yield servile honor.1SP 18.2PP 37.1–38.1 He assured them he would no longer submit to this invasion of his rights and theirs, would never again bow to Christ, would take upon himself the honor which should have been conferred upon him as commander of all who would submit to follow him and obey his voice, and promised that if he attained his true exalted position great good and freedom would come to the entire host.1SP 18.21SP 20.1PP 37.1–38.1 He worked with mysterious secrecy under appearance of reverence for God, insinuating doubts concerning laws governing heavenly beings and claiming angels being more exalted and holy and incapable of error needed no restraint because their own wisdom was sufficient guide, while representing the exaltation of the Son as equal with the Father as injustice to himself and claiming he also was entitled to reverence and honor.1SP 18.2PP 37.1–38.1 He professed to be seeking to promote stability of the divine government while secretly bending every effort to secure its overthrow, striving to reform God's government because discontented and unhappy that he could not look into unsearchable wisdom and ascertain purposes in exalting the Son and endowing Him with unlimited power and command, and he flattered himself he would win all angels to his side and be equal with God himself with his voice of authority commanding the entire host.1SP 18.21SP 20.1GC88 591.1–2
He accused the loyal angels of the very disloyalty he pursued and charged upon them the overthrow he was endeavoring to accomplish.GC 591.1GC88 591.1–2 When evil originating in himself appeared he refused to repent and instead began accusing the heavenly angels, beginning the work of faultfinding and accusing.Ms 175, 1903, par. 25–26 That same policy of professed support for divine government joined with secret rebellion and with accusing the loyal as guilty marks his final conflict with God's people, and that same work continues when he gains the least advantage over people to weaken moral power and then discourage them until they criticize others.GC88 591.1–2Ms 175, 1903, par. 25–26
His rebellion began with murmuring and pitying himself over what he thought was lack of due consideration, entertaining disaffection, refusing to keep it to himself, and telling others he was not treated as he should be.18MR 363.1–2 He spread criticism and rebellion through subtle means over a long time before exposure, stirring up selfish unconsecrated minds with a spirit of criticizing and accusing against those in positions of trust, telling others of mistakes and errors, creating alienation and strife, and bringing unjust and false charges to discourage and destroy God's servants.Lt 162, 1906, par. 5–718MR 359.2–3Ms 57, 1896, par. 5–6 By sowing unbelief, discord and disloyalty he led others to murmur and complain, so that root of bitterness springing up defiled many, impressing the mind and stirring passions to unite with evil, getting them committed to the wrong side, then carrying them step by step farther until bitterness toward brethren is believed right and going on believed necessary.18MR 363.1–25MR 277.4–278.1 The same work continues on earth, with Satan working everywhere among churches to produce differences, discord and strife for supremacy, carried on by those supposing their own wisdom supreme and holding theories infallible, producing confused untruthful statements and unscrupulous principles in those becoming his helpers, bringing severe trials against those trying to carry forward God's work with fidelity without partiality or hypocrisy.18MR 359.2–318MR 363.1–2Lt 32a, 1891, par. 22–23Ms 57, 1896, par. 5–6
His work was secret underhanded pretense carried on with guile and deceptive undercurrent working, plotting in secret while pretending loyalty.Lt 5, 1887, par. 5–6Ms 141, 1906, par. 49–5220MR 234.2–235.3 He worked in an underhanded way with every possible deception to obtain advantage, concluding he could work better than God and Jesus Christ, producing conflict between two powers in heaven, and his settled rebellion was incurable.Ms 1, 1865, par. 6–7Ms 141, 1906, par. 49–52 His deception involved false inspiration that led rebels to believe they were acting in truth and righteousness while claiming holy inspiration, spreading falsehood and accusing the brethren.STB 367.120MR 234.2–235.3 For that reason everything secret and underhanded for any purpose and in any form must be shunned, with no guile in lips, motives or practice and no undercurrent working, but openness as the day, for a rebellion patterned after his first rebellion does not prevail and loses its place, as seen when ministers working in subtle deceiving manner while still paid, carrying churches by house-to-house falsehoods and opposing present truth, are exposed and go out beyond recovery.Lt 5, 1887, par. 5–6Lt 149a, 1897, par. 32–3920MR 234.2–235.3
Justice and Necessity of Expulsion
Expulsion was necessary because the tempter's presence would have kept the angels in constant danger from tainting and corrupting influence, and every soul liable to act on his side was driven out for the safety of the loyal after a long, severe day-by-day course of deception and satanic wiles in misinterpreting God, Christ, and the true and loyal angels until it could be tolerated no more.Ms 198, 1899, par. 5CT 268.14MR 202.2–203.2Lt 15a, 1896, par. 16–18 In the heavenly courts he cast blame for his defection upon God and Jesus Christ, claiming he would not have gone on as he did if they had not so firmly resisted his plans, and by so misrepresenting his case he found sympathizers and drew many angels from allegiance.4MR 202.2–203.2 The same rule applies on earth, that a corrupting student who incites others to disobedience and disloyalty to God and loves the wrong kind of knowledge must be separated from school as Satan was separated from heaven, though such discipline is reserved for very grave fault.CT 268.14MR 202.2–203.2Lt 15a, 1896, par. 16–18
God did not immediately use power to punish or destroy but allowed the conflict to reveal character, each angel choosing a side so that rebellion and judgment became clear to the heavenly host and allegiance became clear and justice manifest.1SP 21.1RH Feb 8, 1915 Rebellion was not ended by immediate destruction because God allowed evil to develop fully so loyal angels could see Satan's character and recognize God's justice and love, the long delay reflecting patience and the danger of uprooting good with evil explaining why He bore with Satan.ST Feb 9, 1915 Their continued existence allowed the nature and consequences of sin and the justice, mercy, and unchanging character of God's law to become clear to all created beings, and the history of their rebellion became a lasting warning against rejecting God's authority.RH Feb 8, 1915
Message after message calling to reform did not reform them, for after stubbornly rejecting repeated offers of pardon and opportunities to repent and submit and continuing to misrepresent God, removal became necessary to vindicate the justice of His rule and the honor of His throne.4SP 319.1–3ST Mar 12, 1885Ms 34, 1906, par. 9 They persisted in disloyalty and refused to acknowledge wrongdoing, so their place was found no more there, and Satan's power of seduction continued as a schooling in deception, fraud, and all unrighteousness.ST Mar 12, 1885Ms 34, 1906, par. 9 His rebellion had spread so widely that he took one-third of the heavenly family with him when cast out, after refusing to yield his will to God, worshiping his own ideas and plans and refusing correction, so that justice decreed his expulsion and he could no longer claim God's mercy and love.Lt 192, 1903, par. 7–9Lt 44, 1910, par. 19–22
God bore long and permitted the enemy to work out his plans so the universe of heaven could see the goodness of God in contrast with the character of Satan, so the unfallen worlds would not be taken unawares and would be prepared for change, so He could have the final victory and gather the true and loyal under one head.Lt 179, 1896, par. 39–41 He permitted him to continue his work so that his character, the results of sin, and the justice and mercy of God's government could be fully seen by all created beings.ST Nov 11, 1913 Their removal vindicated God's character before heaven and the unfallen worlds which had witnessed the conflict between Christ and Satan.ST Nov 30, 1882 That defeat and loss of place was meant to be a lesson to the universe through all coming ages, a perpetual testimony to the nature and terrible results of sin, showing what must be the fruit of setting aside divine authority, testifying that with the existence of God's government and His law is bound up the well-being of all creatures He has made, standing as a perpetual safeguard to all holy intelligences to prevent deception as to the nature of transgression and to save them from sin and its punishment.Ms 125, 1907, par. 26
Angels in heaven were on probation, and those deceived by Satan failed to bear the test brought upon them and did not prevail, so they fell and their place was no longer found in heaven.2RED 15.2LC1 119.2RH Feb 24, 1874 The same experience set in operation in the heavenly courts is repeated on earth, where those exalted to high positions of influence with great opportunities and great light refuse to heed that light because it does not agree with the desires of their hearts, turn aside counsel to open the door to seductive influence, and are defeated and lose place, and their cases will be tried in the judgment before final execution of sentence upon all on earth.Lt 120, 1906, par. 7 After being shut out they repented and wished reinstatement, willing to take proper place or any place assigned, weeping and imploring to be taken back into favor, but were refused because heaven must not be placed in jeopardy and all heaven might be marred if he were taken back, for sin originated with him and seeds of rebellion were still within him, and their sin, hate, envy and jealousy had been so great that God could not blot it out and it must remain to final punishment.SG1 18.1
Heaven allows no dissension or strife, so Satan who sought to carry out his own will instead of God's, with all who joined his rebellion, has no place there and must ultimately be destroyed.Ms 49, 1907, par. 13–16 Self-seeking entered the heavenly courts but was cast out, and selfishness will never again find place there.Lt 71, 1895, par. 8 Their expulsion brought them into strife, discord and despair, excluded them from heaven's worship and the joy of Christ's presence, and left them lost beyond redemption with misery as the result of rebellion and disobedience.1SP 28.1–29.1
Sources