Revelation 20:5
But the rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years were finished. This is the first resurrection.
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
But the rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years were finished. This is the first resurrection.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
The rest of the dead lived not until the thousand years should be finished. This is the first resurrection.
and the rest of the dead did not live again till the thousand years may be finished; this [is] the first rising again.
the rest of the dead did not live till the thousand years had been completed. This [ is] the first resurrection.
The rest of the dead, lived not, until the thousand years, were ended. This, is the first resurrection.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
The rest of the dead did not come back to life until the thousand years were complete. This is the first resurrection.
The rest of the dead didn’ t live until the thousand years were finished. This is the first resurrection.
The rest of the dead did not come to life again till the thousand years were ended. This is the first coming back from the dead.
But the rest of the dead men shall not liue againe, vntill the thousand yeres be finished: this is the first resurrection.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
The rest of the dead lived not, till the thousand years were finished. This is the first resurrection.
Cross-references 20 of 63
- 1 Thessalonians 4:16
For the Lord himself shall descend from heaven with a shout, with the voice of the archangel, and with the trump of God: and the dead in Christ shall rise first:
The dead in Christ rise first when the Lord descends.
- 1 Corinthians 15:51-52
Behold, I shew you a mystery; We shall not all sleep, but we shall all be changed,
The just are raised to immortality at Christ’s coming.
- John 5:28-29
Marvel not at this: for the hour is coming, in the which all that are in the graves shall hear his voice,
Both texts distinguish the resurrection of life from the resurrection of judgment.
- Revelation 20:14
And death and hell were cast into the lake of fire. This is the second death.
Death and hell are cast into the lake of fire, which is the second death.
- 1 Corinthians 15:23-26
But every man in his own order: Christ the firstfruits; afterward they that are Christ’s at his coming.
Christ’s people are raised at his coming, and he reigns until death is destroyed.
- Acts 24:15
And have hope toward God, which they themselves also allow, that there shall be a resurrection of the dead, both of the just and unjust.
Both affirm a resurrection of the just and the unjust.
- Luke 20:35-36
But they which shall be accounted worthy to obtain that world, and the resurrection from the dead, neither marry, nor are given in marriage:
The worthy attain resurrection from the dead and cannot die again.
- Daniel 12:2
And many of them that sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake, some to everlasting life, and some to shame and everlasting contempt.
The dead awaken to everlasting life or shame.
- Revelation 20:12-13
And I saw the dead, small and great, stand before God; and the books were opened: and another book was opened, which is the book of life: and the dead were judged out of those things which were written in the books, according to their works.
The dead are raised after the thousand years and judged according to their works.
- Luke 14:14
And thou shalt be blessed; for they cannot recompense thee: for thou shalt be recompensed at the resurrection of the just.
Places the just’s recompense at the resurrection.
- John 11:25
Jesus said unto her, I am the resurrection, and the life: he that believeth in me, though he were dead, yet shall he live:
Jesus identifies himself as the resurrection and promises life to believers.
- Philippians 3:11
If by any means I might attain unto the resurrection of the dead.
Paul seeks to attain the resurrection from among the dead, identified as the first resurrection.
- 1 Thessalonians 4:14
For if we believe that Jesus died and rose again, even so them also which sleep in Jesus will God bring with him.
Those who sleep in Jesus will be brought with Christ.
- 1 Corinthians 6:2-3
Do ye not know that the saints shall judge the world? and if the world shall be judged by you, are ye unworthy to judge the smallest matters?
The resurrected righteous reign with Christ and judge during the thousand years.
- 1 Corinthians 15:26
The last enemy that shall be destroyed is death.
Death is the last enemy to be destroyed.
- 1 Corinthians 15:22
For as in Adam all die, even so in Christ shall all be made alive.
Those who die in Adam are made alive in Christ.
- Revelation 20:13
And the sea gave up the dead which were in it; and death and hell delivered up the dead which were in them: and they were judged every man according to their works.
The dead are raised after the thousand years and judged according to their works.
- 1 Corinthians 15:54
So when this corruptible shall have put on incorruption, and this mortal shall have put on immortality, then shall be brought to pass the saying that is written, Death is swallowed up in victory.
Immortality at the resurrection is linked with death being swallowed up in victory.
- 1 Corinthians 15:42-44
So also is the resurrection of the dead. It is sown in corruption; it is raised in incorruption:
The dead are raised bodily, transformed from corruption and weakness to incorruption and glory.
- Isaiah 26:19
Thy dead men shall live, together with my dead body shall they arise. Awake and sing, ye that dwell in dust: for thy dew is as the dew of herbs, and the earth shall cast out the dead.
earth casts out dead at resurrection
Commentary part 1 of 4
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
78 sources
The verse teaches two literal resurrections separated by one thousand years, the first to life and the second to damnation after the thousand years are finished.Lt 113, 1886, par. 13–14WLF 11.6–7Ms 81, 1893, par. 44–46 The first resurrection is the raising of dead believers at Christ's coming in glory, when they are made immortal and meet again to live and reign with Christ as blessed and holy priests over whom the second death has no power.Lt 113, 1886, par. 13–1421MR 342.4–5SG2 91.2–92.1Ms 81, 1893, par. 44–46Ms 188, 1903, par. 9–10 The rest of the dead are the wicked, who remain unconscious in the dust with no life throughout the thousand years and are raised only at its close to appear before God for the execution of the judgment written against them.GC 661.2GC88 661.21T 67.2EW 5.1–6.1EW 224.3–225.2 The thousand years are still future, not a time of earthly peace and conversion before Christ comes nor a time to finish warning the world, but a time when the saints rest in the holy city and with Christ review the records and mete out judgment to the wicked and to Satan and his angels while Satan is bound.SG2 97.2–98.1ExVEGW 33.2EW 43.34SP 475.24SP 234.2–235.3 At the close Christ returns in majesty, the wicked come forth as they went down with the same rebellion and are deceived for a final assault, and then fire from God consumes them root and branch and purifies the earth to become the renewed inheritance of the saints.EW 43.1WLF 11.8–12.1SG1 215.2–216.1ExVEGW 35.1EW 45.1 Whether a person has part in the first resurrection is solemn and depends on choices in this life, requiring overcoming sin, washing the robe in the blood of the Lamb, and present readiness in Christ's righteousness.Ms 81, 1893, par. 44–46Ms 188, 1903, par. 9–10Lt 28, 1897, par. 19–20Lt 14a, 1891, par. 6Ms 1, 1890, par. 21
Two Resurrections Defined
There are two literal resurrections separated by one thousand years.Lt 113, 1886, par. 13–14WLF 11.6–7 The dead rise at two different times a thousand years apart, with those who did good rising first to life eternal in the first resurrection and those who did evil staying in their graves through the thousand years and coming forth only afterward to the resurrection of damnation.Lt 113, 1886, par. 13–14Ms 81, 1893, par. 44–46Ms 40, 1893, par. 5 The righteous rise in the first resurrection and the wicked in the second, while those not raised in the first remain in their graves until the thousand years are finished, which makes each person's part in the first resurrection a solemn matter.Ms 81, 1893, par. 44–46Ms 40, 1893, par. 5 Those who share in it are beyond the power of the second death.Lt 113, 1886, par. 13–14Ms 81, 1893, par. 44–46
The rest of the dead are the wicked dead, who remain dead throughout the thousand years and do not live again until the thousand years have ended.GC 661.2GC88 661.2 Their return to life is the second resurrection at its close after Christ's second advent, when they appear before God for the execution of the judgment written against them.GC 661.2GC88 661.21T 67.2
The first resurrection is the raising of dead believers to life when Christ comes in the clouds of heaven with power and great glory as King and Deliverer, rising before the rest of the dead.Ms 188, 1903, par. 9–10GC88 358.2–359.1 At the trump of God the graves are opened and the righteous dead come forth, called from every part of the earth with none overlooked, from rocky caverns, dungeons, caves and the waters of the deep, hearing God's voice and coming forth in triumph and victory to eternal life.Lt 113, 1886, par. 13–1421MR 342.4–5Ms 188, 1903, par. 9–10 It is done because Christ loves the world and gave His life for it, and afterward there is no more death, sin or sorrow.Lt 113, 1886, par. 13–1421MR 342.4–5Ms 188, 1903, par. 9–10
Those who have part in the first resurrection are blessed and holy, and the second death has no power over them.Ms 33, 1897, par. 30–3121MR 342.4–5 Among them are those beheaded for the witness of Jesus and for the word of God, who did not worship the beast or his image and did not receive his mark on forehead or hand, and they live and reign with Christ a thousand years as priests of God and of Christ.Ms 33, 1897, par. 30–31 Christ is the Alpha and Omega, the Genesis of the Old Testament and the Revelation of the New, who by His obedience in overcoming Satan's temptations reconciled Adam and God and redeemed Adam's disgraceful failure and fall, so the two Adams meet in Paradise and embrace each other, while the dragon, the beast, the false prophet, and all who refused the opportunities and privileges given at infinite cost and did not return to loyalty are shut out of Paradise.Ms 33, 1897, par. 30–31
The righteous dead remain asleep until they awake in the first resurrection, when they are made immortal.SG2 91.2–92.1 For the faithful death is not a dark uncertainty, for their hope of eternal life is centered in Jesus, and they will meet one another again when the righteous dead rise.SG2 91.2–92.1
Timing of Thousand Years
The thousand years are still future and have not already occurred in the past, and the claim that they had taken place before is error.SG2 97.2–98.1LSEGW 110.5–111.1 The first resurrection comes before those thousand years, and the living again of the rest of the dead comes after them, at their close following Christ's second advent.1T 67.2Lt 130, 1906, par. 2 During that thousand years God's people are together and at rest in the city of God, almost home after their journey.Lt 130, 1906, par. 2Ms 14, 1850, par. 16–1812MR 250.3–251.1
Afterward the city comes down to earth, which has been cleansed by fire.Lt 130, 1906, par. 2 The thousand years are not a temporal millennium on earth before Christ returns in which the earth will be filled with the knowledge of the Lord.ST Apr 18, 1878LSEGW 20.3–21.1 That expectation of a coming earthly period stood in contrast to the hope of Jesus' soon return, and belonged to belief held before the announcement of His soon coming.ST Apr 18, 1878LSEGW 20.3–21.1
Nor are they a thousand years of spiritual peace and prosperity in which the world is converted before Christ comes, for that doctrine is a dangerous deception.4SP 234.2–235.3ST Jan 3, 1878 The promised millennium does not mean wickedness will steadily disappear as the end approaches, but evil and deception will instead increase before Christ comes.ST Jan 3, 1878 The thousand years are not a temporal period in which to carry out the work of warning the world.FE 356.2–357.2OEWP 28.1–3Ms 10a, 1895, par. 74–75 That work must be done now, before God's dealings with sinful people suddenly change, and not postponed into a supposed millennium.FE 356.2–357.2OEWP 28.1–3
Work of Thousand Years
During the thousand years the saints rest in the holy city and reign with Jesus as kings and priests, while the earth is not yet cleansed.ExVEGW 32.5EW 43.1CET 108.2–316MR 35.2 The wicked dead do not live again until the thousand years are finished, but remain dead throughout that period.ExVEGW 32.5EW 43.1CET 108.2–316MR 35.2 At its close they are raised and gather around the holy city after the descent upon the Mount of Olives, which parts asunder into a mighty plain for the paradise of God to rest upon.ExVEGW 32.5EW 43.116MR 35.2 They are then destroyed by fire from God out of heaven that devours them and burns them up root and branch, and the same fire purifies the earth so that their feet never defile the earth made new.ExVEGW 32.5EW 43.1CET 108.2–316MR 35.2
During the thousand years the saints in unison with Jesus mete out to the wicked what they shall receive, sitting with Him in judgment over the wicked dead.ExVEGW 33.2EW 43.3EW 45.1 They review the records of the dead, comparing lives with the Bible and deciding each case according to deeds.ExVEGW 33.2EW 43.34SP 475.2 The sentence each will receive is thus determined according to works and recorded in the book of death.ExVEGW 33.2EW 43.34SP 475.2 When the thousand years are finished the rest of the dead are raised to receive what was meted out, as Jesus and the saints descend from the holy city and the wicked see Jesus in glory and recognize the wounds of His crucifixion.ExVEGW 33.2EW 45.1Ms 14, 1850, par. 10–11
The general judgment takes place at the end of the thousand years, after the saints have taken part in this work of sentencing.EW 45.1Ms 14, 1850, par. 10–11Ms 137, 1897, par. 12 It is distinct from the partial resurrection of those raised after Christ's resurrection and led with Him through the gates of the city to the throne.Ms 137, 1897, par. 12 At the voice of the Son of man every saint who sleeps in Jesus awakes and leaves the prison house before the thousand years, while the rest of the dead remain until they are finished, when those who disowned Christ and betrayed Him in the person of His saints see the result of their work.Ms 14, 1850, par. 10–11Ms 137, 1897, par. 12 Their punishment is the execution of the judgment by fire breathed from God that consumes them, melting the broken ragged mountains with fervent heat and the atmosphere also and consuming all the stubble, after which the saints inherit the whole earth made new, glorious and beautiful.EW 45.1
During the thousand years in which the resurrection of the wicked is still future, Satan is bound.Ms 75, 1906, par. 1615MR 321.3 Satan and the evil angels are also judged in that time between the first and second resurrections.4SP 475.2 After that resurrection come their final destruction and Christ's final triumph and reign on earth.Ms 75, 1906, par. 1615MR 321.3
Through the thousand years the wicked remain mouldered to dust in death, with no conscious life in heaven to teach the living.EW 5.1–6.1SG1 175.2–176.2 Thomas Paine remains in the dust until the second resurrection, not already alive and exalted in heaven.EW 5.1–6.1EW 224.3–225.2SCEV 8.1–10.2SG1 175.2–176.2 At the end of the thousand years he and the rest are called forth in the second resurrection to receive their reward and suffer the second death, which is everlasting with no hope of another resurrection.EW 5.1–6.1EW 224.3–225.2SCEV 8.1–10.2SG1 175.2–176.2
Close of Thousand Years
At the close of the thousand years Christ again returns to the earth in sublimest majesty, accompanied by the host of the redeemed and attended by a retinue of angels, to bid the wicked dead arise to receive their doom.EW 43.1SG3 83.2ST Jun 11, 1902 He descends from the holy city upon the Mount of Olives, which parts asunder and becomes a mighty plain prepared for the paradise of God to rest upon.EW 43.1SG3 83.2EW 250.1 Then in fearful majesty and brightness like lightning He calls them forth from their long sleep, and the rest of the dead, who remained dead through the thousand years while the saints rested in the holy city, live again in the second resurrection.EW 43.1SG3 83.2EW 250.1ST Jun 11, 1902 They come forth a mighty host numberless as the sands of the sea.SG3 83.2ST Jun 11, 1902
As soon as they behold Jesus in stern majesty and resplendent glory they know Him as the crucified one who died to save them and whom they despised and rejected, recognizing Him as the one they mocked and crucified and discerning His wounds.EW 250.2–251.1SG3 83.2ST Jun 11, 1902 Even those who pierced Him see Him in glory as He descends with the saints and holy angels after they have taken part in judgment.SG3 83.2Ms 14, 1850, par. 10–11 Overwhelmed with His glory and affrighted, seeking to hide, they are compelled by the force of truth to exclaim in anguish with one voice, Blessed is he who cometh in the name of the Lord.EW 250.2–251.1SG3 83.2ST Jun 11, 1902 The words are urged from unwilling lips not from love to Jesus but by the force of truth.SG3 83.2ST Jun 11, 1902
Their resurrection gives Satan a vast multitude to rally for his final attempt to overthrow God's city and to seize the Holy City.WLF 11.8–12.1GC 663.1–664.3GC88 663.1 Released, he deceives them into gathering for an attack on the holy city, and they come forth with their former ambitions, thoughts and desires to try to take it.WLF 11.8–12.1SG1 215.2–216.1GC 663.1–664.3 They remain his followers and are destroyed by fire and cease to exist.WLF 11.8–12.1GC88 663.1 The new heaven and new earth appear only after this final destruction.WLF 11.8–12.1
Fire breathed from God out of heaven comes down and devours them, consuming them in the execution of the judgment and the sentence determined during the thousand years.EW 43.1ExVEGW 35.1EW 45.1Ms 4, 1850, par. 1512MR 249.3–250.1 It burns them up root and branch as stubble, with Satan as the root and his children as the branches.EW 43.1EW 45.1 The same fire that destroys the wicked purifies the whole earth, melting the broken ragged mountains with fervent heat and the atmosphere also and consuming all the stubble, so that only then is the earth cleansed and the wicked never desecrate the earth made new.EW 43.1ExVEGW 35.1EW 45.1Ms 4, 1850, par. 1512MR 249.3–250.1 Purified, the earth becomes the saints' inheritance made new, glorious and beautiful, where the city and its inhabitants will never be corrupted.ExVEGW 35.1EW 45.112MR 249.3–250.1Ms 138, 1906, par. 7–14
After rising they receive no further probation but suffer everlasting death with no hope of another resurrection.GC 662.1–2GC88 662.1–3CET 108.2–3 After that resurrection come the final destruction of Satan and the wicked together, and Christ's final triumph and reign on earth.GC 662.1–215MR 321.3Lt 25, 1900, par. 10–11 No sinner became immortal by eating from the tree of life, because Adam's family was barred from it.CET 108.2–3
After their judgment is finished Jesus leaves the city and it descends from heaven to the plain He has prepared, and afterward the city comes down to earth with God's people to that earth cleansed by fire.EW 250.1Lt 130, 1906, par. 2 After the wicked are raised, the saints join Jesus in the final judgment, and God's fire consumes the wicked and purifies the earth.EW 250.1Ms 14, 1850, par. 12–14 The saints then inherit the renewed earth.Lt 130, 1906, par. 2Ms 14, 1850, par. 12–14
State of Those Raised
Those raised in the first resurrection come forth in immortal bloom, clothed with immortal youth and beauty.4SP 476.1GC 662.1–2 They are changed from mortal and corruptible to incorruptible, glorious, powerful and spiritual, and are welcomed by Jesus into the homes He has prepared for them.Ms 167, 1904, par. 9Lt 65a, 1894, par. 6–7 This change comes through the power of Christ's Spirit who dwelt in them in life, because they shared the divine nature, and at the triumphant last trumpet Christ calls them as His purchased possession known by name and kept safe until that hour.Ms 167, 1904, par. 9Lt 65a, 1894, par. 6–7
Those raised in the second resurrection come up as they went down into their graves, with the marks of the curse and of disease and death visible upon them.EW 250.2–251.1GC88 662.1–3SG3 83.2 They rise in the same weak sickly bodies in which they died, retaining the same enmity to Christ and spirit of rebellion, unlike those of the first resurrection who come forth immortal.EW 250.2–251.1GC 662.1–2GC88 662.1–3ST Jun 11, 1902 They come forth a mighty host numberless as the sand upon the seashore, including the giant-like well-proportioned race before the flood down through the continually decreasing dwarfed feeble race to the last generation, from kings, warriors, statesmen and nobles down to the most degraded together.SG3 83.2ST Jun 11, 1902
When raised the wicked resume the desires, purposes, thoughts and ambitions they had when they died.SG1 215.2–216.1GC 663.1–664.3EW 251.2 Satan then gathers them into an army and deceives them into gathering for a final attack upon the holy city.SG1 215.2–216.1GC 663.1–664.3EW 251.2 Balaam will be among those who rise in this second resurrection to face final doom, seeing the redeemed in the city of God but shut out with the wicked.ST Dec 16, 1880
The ignorant slave who died knowing nothing of God or the Bible cannot be taken to heaven in that condition but is left as though he had never lived, with his sins visited upon his master.EW 236.1SG1 193.1 The guilty slave-master who kept slaves in ignorance and degradation must first endure the seven last plagues and then rise in the second resurrection to suffer the second, most awful death.EW 236.1SG1 193.1 By that punishment the justice of God is satisfied.EW 236.1 No sinner became immortal by eating from the tree of life, because Adam's family was barred from it.CET 108.2–3
Sharing First Resurrection
Whether a person shares in the first resurrection is a solemn matter, for the dead who are not raised in it remain in their graves until the thousand years are finished, while those who have done evil rise only in the second resurrection and those who share in the first are beyond the power of the second death.Ms 81, 1893, par. 44–46 Character and choices in this life decide the issue, and if probation closes before a person has overcome and become Christlike, that person will not share in it.Lt 38, 1893, par. 15–17 Only those who have developed characters fit to be numbered with the redeemed will rise in it, with those who have appreciated the privilege of washing their robes and making them white in the blood of the Lamb.Lt 28, 1897, par. 19–20 Those who cling to sin and reject the Spirit of God will not rise in the first resurrection and will not see the King in His beauty.Ms 1, 1890, par. 21
Having part in that resurrection to life of the righteous dead when Christ comes in the clouds with power and great glory requires present readiness, standing prepared as minute men and women so that if life is cut off in a moment by accident or calamity there is preparedness for the life to come, with sins put away and the righteousness of Christ received.Ms 188, 1903, par. 9–10 At the trump of God the graves are opened and the righteous dead come forth, and this is done because Christ loves the world and gave His life for it.Ms 188, 1903, par. 9–10 It is a blessing that can be missed through present unfaithfulness, and having part in it requires widening the separation from the world, with refined and choice conversation and godly company.Lt 14a, 1891, par. 6 Narrowing that separation until it is obliterated, living in spiritual decline with loose, reckless talk and worldly company, leaves a person with no part in it if life were cut off now.Lt 14a, 1891, par. 6 The first resurrection is for those who walk in the light God gives them, are blessed in that light, and die faithful in that light, and even amid widespread corruption they can walk with God as Enoch did, reflect His light to others, form a righteous character, escape the corruption in the world through lust, and be raised when that resurrection comes, while others faithful at the second coming will be translated without seeing death.Ms 83, 1886, par. 4–8
To be saved is to have part in the first resurrection and reign with Christ in glory, and fitting for that reign requires being led by God and taught His will and present truth and what a person must be in order to be saved.Ms 3, 1854, par. 9–13 Those just brought to God and His truth who innocently feel a false power through inexperience are not charged with sin for it, but if humble they will be led along and taught until fitted to be saved and reign with Christ.Ms 3, 1854, par. 9–13 Coming up in the first resurrection at the resurrection morn is the portion of the saved dead and belongs to the righteous, and whether a person will rise then depends on being saved before death.Lt 12, 1857, par. 6Lt 18, 1859, par. 3–4 A child who dies without evidence of salvation will not come up in it, so the eternal interest of children is a burden that calls for salvation in the home, that from the eldest to the youngest all may be saved and give praise.Lt 12, 1857, par. 6 The sinner therefore closes his eyes in death with fearful uncertainty about the future, with no pleasing sense of God's approbation and no cheering hope or pleasure in looking forward to being raised.Lt 18, 1859, par. 3–4
Those who die as sinners rise in the second resurrection, after the thousand years, and then receive their place among the wicked.Lt 23, 1888, par. 16–17 A sinner who dies unreformed will face this resurrection, and the warning urges parents to help their children escape that fate while there is still time.Lt 23, 1888, par. 16–17 There is a second resurrection in which unrepentant souls come up to be lost, left outside the city of God among dogs and sorcerers and adulterers and those who love and make a lie.Lt 23a, 1890, par. 11 Sinners who die without salvation rise in the second resurrection, after the thousand years, and each person then comes to the place determined by life.TEPD 27.1
Those who make determined efforts in Christ's name to overcome unnatural cravings will not die in that struggle.RH Mar 18, 1875 Even if the struggle cost them their lives, they would die in a good cause and rise in the first resurrection to receive the overcomer's reward.RH Mar 18, 1875 If slaves to appetite die in the struggle to free themselves from its controlling power, they die in a good cause, and even victory gained at the cost of human life is not too dearly earned if the victor comes up in the first resurrection.ST Feb 25, 1875 Everything is then gained, but unless a person overcomes as Christ overcame there is no seat with Him upon His throne, and those who in the face of light and truth destroy mental, moral, and physical health by indulgence will lose heaven.ST Feb 25, 1875 The first resurrection is the overcomer's reward for victory over appetite through the name of Christ.ST Feb 25, 1875
The first resurrection belongs to Christ's believing people who have made their calling and election sure.Lt 90, 1898, par. 31 They come forth in that resurrection and join innumerable voices singing that the tabernacle of God is with men and He will dwell with them as their God and wipe away all tears, with no more death, sorrow, crying, or pain because the former things have passed away.Lt 90, 1898, par. 31 Those who lose their lives for the truth will rise and receive everlasting life in the city of God.HSFM 233.4 Their persecutors will remain outside the city and, seeing the faithful honored by Jesus, will regret having persecuted them.HSFM 233.4
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
1,020 sources
The verse teaches two literal bodily resurrections separated by one thousand years, the first at the beginning and a distinct second at the close, so the righteous and the wicked do not rise together.RH Jun 13, 1854ST Dec 19, 1916RH Sep 27, 1853 The first resurrection is the resurrection of the righteous dead in Christ to immortal incorruptible life, who are blessed and holy and live and reign with Christ a thousand years.RH Sep 27, 1853ST Jun 8, 1915ST Jan 22, 1885RH Nov 9, 1869RH Nov 9, 1911 The rest of the dead are the wicked who remain dead, unconscious and asleep in their graves throughout the thousand years and do not live again until it is finished, when they are raised to damnation and the second death.RH Jan 12, 1869ST Sep 29, 1881ST Feb 24, 1914RH Sep 11, 1856RH Mar 12, 1857 The thousand years begin at Christ's visible second coming when the righteous dead are raised and the living righteous are changed and caught up to reign with Him in heaven, while the living wicked are slain and the earth is left desolate with Satan bound by having no one to deceive.ST Dec 19, 1916ST Apr 14, 1914ST Jun 25, 1912ST Dec 17, 1896RH Feb 10, 1863 At the close the wicked are raised, gather against the descended city under Satan's deception, and are devoured by fire from God, after which the earth is cleansed and renewed as the eternal home of the righteous.RH Sep 27, 1853RH Jun 9, 1859RH Apr 23, 1901ST Apr 2, 1896
Text and Authenticity
The closing words belong with the preceding verse and identify those who live and reign with Christ during the thousand years as sharing in the first resurrection, while the sentence about the rest of the dead not living again until the thousand years are finished stands parenthetical between them.ST May 16, 1911RH Oct 17, 1854ST Aug 24, 1915 The word first means first in time rather than chief in importance, and together with the word again it proves a second resurrection afterward when the rest come to life once more after having ceased to live.ST Jul 7, 1887RH Oct 10, 1865ST Mar 4, 1889 The first resurrection is therefore for the just, the people of God raised when Jesus comes, a thousand years before the resurrection of the wicked, and there is no other resurrection before, during, or after those two.ST Jul 7, 1887RH Oct 10, 1865RH Oct 17, 1854
The clause that the rest of the dead lived not again until the thousand years were finished is genuine authentic Scripture and not spurious or misplaced.ST Feb 27, 1912ST Aug 24, 1915 It is found in the principal earliest Greek manuscripts that contain Revelation, including Codex Alexandrinus, Codex Ephraemi Rescriptus, and Codex Vaticanus No. 2066, codices from the fourth or fifth century, and in the best Greek text with no doubt marked by the revisers.ST Feb 27, 1912ST May 27, 1897 It is present in Tregelles's Greek text, the Westcott and Hort Greek text, Rotherham, Alford, the Revised Versions, and standard revisions and accepted texts and versions, with no sign of coming in as a gloss or copyist addition.RH Jan 24, 1907ST May 27, 1897 Its absence from the Syriac version and from the eleventh-century Vatican manuscript No. 1160 is omission by oversight, probably accidental and by mistake, while Codex Vaticanus No. 1209 contains no part of Revelation at all and proves nothing against it.ST Feb 27, 1912ST May 27, 1897
It has been alleged that the words about the rest are an addition rather than part of the verse, absent from certain early Greek and Syriac manuscripts and entered in the fifth century after a reader's marginal comment was copied into the text. The words have been charged as spurious, yet omission in one or two old manuscripts is by mistake and does not make them spurious.ST Oct 13, 1909 The effort to rid themselves of the authority of the obscure passage came from doctrinal grounds rather than historical grounds, condemning a doctrine held by those who call it spurious, and the absurdity and false doctrines ascribed to the passage belong to its interpreters and not to the book itself.ST Feb 27, 1912ST Nov 28, 1878
The verse identifies the close of the thousand years as the point when the rest of the dead live again and when sin and sinners are destroyed.ST Oct 2, 1879ST Jul 29, 1880ST Nov 6, 1879 It places the thousand years after Christ's coming, during a period of judgment when Satan is confined on the desolate earth after the wicked are destroyed and the righteous are taken to heaven, and at the end of that time the creation marred by sin is delivered from corruption.ST Aug 8, 1900 It is included among the principal scriptures concerning the events surrounding Christ's return, the resurrection of the wicked, and the thousand years, connected with Christ and the saints descending to the Mount of Olives followed later by the New Jerusalem's descent, giving no support for the righteous and wicked mingling and holding out the hope of sharing in the first resurrection.ST Jul 30, 1912
Two Literal Resurrections
The verse teaches two literal general resurrections separated by one thousand years, the first at the beginning and a distinct second afterward at the close.RH Jun 13, 1854ST Dec 19, 1916RH Sep 27, 1853CO 95.4ST Jul 7, 1887 The righteous and the wicked do not rise together or mingle but are forever separated, with both the just and the unjust ultimately raised in their divisions.RH Jun 13, 1854ST Dec 19, 1916RH Sep 27, 1853CO 95.4ST Jul 7, 1887 The first resurrection is the raising of the righteous to live and reign with Christ a thousand years, which is the millennium and the only millennium promised, including not only those beheaded for witness but all who have not worshiped the beast nor his image nor received his mark.RH Jun 13, 1854RH Sep 27, 1853ST Jun 8, 1915CO 95.4ST Jul 7, 1887 The rest of the dead are the wicked, who remain dead through the millennium and when finished are raised as Gog and Magog to compass the camp and beloved city, where fire devours them and the devil is cast into the lake of fire which is the second death.ST Dec 19, 1916RH Sep 27, 1853ST Jun 8, 1915CO 95.4ST Jul 7, 1887 Those who share in the first are blessed and holy, the second death has no power over them, they serve as priests of God and of Christ, and the same two are the resurrection of life for those who have done good and the resurrection of damnation for those who have done evil.ST Dec 19, 1916RH Sep 27, 1853ST Jun 8, 1915CO 95.4ST Jul 7, 1887
The thousand years is the interval between the two resurrections, bounded at each end by a literal resurrection one thousand years apart.RH Jun 13, 1854ST Apr 14, 1914RH Jun 8, 1916ST Jul 22, 1880RH Feb 9, 1869 It begins with the resurrection of the just and ends with the resurrection of the wicked, with the first resurrection marking the beginning of that period and the resurrection of the wicked placed after it.RH Jun 13, 1854RH Jun 8, 1916ST Jul 22, 1880RH Feb 9, 1869ST Oct 28, 1880 The thousand years begin after the personal visible second coming, not before, and the coming brings the resurrection of the saints whose deliverance is victory over death.RH Jun 13, 1854RH Jun 8, 1916ST Jul 22, 1880RH Feb 9, 1869ST Oct 28, 1880
The hour in John 5 of the dead coming forth can include the long thousand-year interval between the just raised at Christ's coming and the unjust raised after, rather than meaning both happen at the same time.RH May 17, 1864RH Mar 24, 1863 Hour does not necessarily mean a brief literal hour when unqualified, and the same word describes a period extending across the gospel age, so the hour of John 5:25 covering the gospel age shows the hour of John 5:28 may encompass a thousand years.RH May 17, 1864RH Mar 24, 1863 Universal terms like every man can be limited in scope, so the phrase every man in Revelation 22:12 does not mean all the wicked in graves are raised at the second coming.
The general statement does not take account of special resurrections.ST Nov 1, 1910ST Jan 11, 1916ST May 7, 1912RH May 4, 1869 Some wicked including those who took part in His crucifixion are specially raised just before Christ comes or during the time of trouble to see Him and receive plagues, then perish in His glory and rise again in the second general resurrection, and their earlier death is incidental and is not the second death.ST Nov 1, 1910RH May 4, 1869RH May 1, 1856 Some righteous are specially raised to everlasting life, without altering the two general divisions, and this supports that Daniel 12 describes a separate special mixed resurrection at Christ's receiving His kingdom in which some rise to everlasting life and others to shame and everlasting contempt, leaving room for a special resurrection at the beginning of the time of trouble.ST Nov 1, 1910ST Jan 11, 1916ST May 7, 1912 The general rule that the wicked dead do not live again until finished does not exclude occasional exceptions for a special purpose, and this later resurrection makes it possible for every eye to see Him as described in Revelation 1:7.ST Nov 1, 1910RH May 4, 1869RH May 1, 1856
Resurrection and living again mean literal bodily bringing back to physical life from dust and grave.RH Jun 13, 1854ST Aug 21, 1884RH May 28, 1857RH Nov 30, 1869RH May 28, 1857 It is not a spiritual resurrection apart from bodies or a resurrection of principles, doctrines, regeneration, conversion, or representational living again.RH Jun 13, 1854ST Aug 21, 1884RH May 28, 1857RH May 28, 1857ST Mar 4, 1889 Again means living once more after having ceased to live and cannot describe continuous life, so the verse presents death as ending of life and resurrection as life restored, with return to life after an interval of death not continued existence of something that never died.ST Aug 21, 1884RH May 28, 1857RH May 28, 1857ST Mar 4, 1889 To spiritualize the first resurrection removes ground for holding literal what is said of the rest, the throne and other advent texts.RH Jun 13, 1854RH May 28, 1857RH May 28, 1857
Resurrection is used for the raising of both classes without distinguishing the event by condition.ST May 13, 1875RH Aug 6, 1872RH May 28, 1861RH Feb 14, 1865 The wicked's restoration is called a resurrection just as truly as the righteous', even though they are not raised to immortality or to live forever, for every restoration from death is a real resurrection.ST May 13, 1875RH Aug 6, 1872RH May 28, 1861 Being raised does not mean they will live forever, but preserves both mercy and justice as the wicked reap corruption while the righteous are raised incorruptible, coming forth to the resurrection of damnation to suffer the second death.ST May 13, 1875RH Aug 6, 1872RH May 28, 1861 The wicked dead must live again before they can be tormented, and their punishment concerns deeds done in the body.ST May 13, 1875RH Feb 14, 1865
The two resurrections are real bodily events of the same bodily kind and must be understood as literally as each other.RH Dec 17, 1872RH Apr 25, 1865ST Apr 10, 1879ST Aug 25, 1881ST Mar 30, 1882 The martyrs' rising is a real resurrection of whole persons, not the release of a conscious immortal soul at death, and souls means the persons raised to immortal life as man formed of dust became a living soul and as eight souls means eight persons.RH Dec 17, 1872RH Apr 25, 1865ST Apr 10, 1879ST Aug 25, 1881 The beheaded witnesses had been dead and live again for the first time at the resurrection of the just, their appearance in vision being symbolic representation pointing to future resurrection, and the first stands before the final judgment and millennium.RH Dec 17, 1872RH Apr 25, 1865ST Apr 10, 1879ST Aug 25, 1881ST Oct 28, 1913 The wicked dead's return to life and final punishment after the thousand years when they surround the camp, the beloved city, is when they see the righteous in the kingdom, while before then the dead are unconscious and await resurrection and respective rewards.ST Apr 10, 1879ST Aug 25, 1881ST Mar 30, 1882ST Oct 28, 1913
The verse proves the wicked will be resurrected, contrary to claims they never will be.RH Apr 19, 1870RH Jul 31, 1860RH Jan 8, 1901RH Jan 7, 1873ST Jun 3, 1875 To teach their non-resurrection denies what it states about the rest living again when finished, and the resurrection in Luke 20:35-36 with Philippians 3:11 refers to the special first resurrection from among the dead leaving the rest to be raised later.RH Apr 19, 1870RH Jul 31, 1860RH Jan 8, 1901RH Jan 7, 1873ST Jun 3, 1875 The wicked spirits are not now being tormented but await the judgment, when they will be sent into everlasting fire with wicked human beings.ST May 27, 1880
The verse is one of the most unequivocal passages on resurrection, advent, judgment and conflagration that proves a pre-millennial advent and coming literal resurrection and judgment.ST Jun 11, 1874RH Sep 4, 1855RH Feb 3, 1859 It belongs with plain declarations about Christ's appearing that must not be applied mystically to death or conversion or spiritual manifestations.ST Jun 11, 1874RH Feb 3, 1859 It stands with the personal Advent and the Kingdom on the renewed earth as fundamental principles, insisting on bodily resurrection and real future judgment and that the second coming is not merely a spiritual coming to each person at death.ST Jun 11, 1874RH Sep 4, 1855RH Feb 3, 1859
First Resurrection Shared
The first resurrection is the resurrection of the righteous, the just, the saints, the dead in Christ, the blessed and holy, those belonging to Christ and accounted worthy.RH Sep 27, 1853RH Nov 9, 1869RH Nov 9, 1911ST Aug 19, 1889ST Jan 29, 1880 It includes all saints of all ages, those who died in Christ with no exception, all whose names are in the book of life, and not martyrs only.RH Sep 27, 1853RH Nov 9, 1869ST Jan 29, 1880 It includes also all who did not worship the beast nor his image nor receive his mark, meaning secular power ruling in opposition to Christ and all submission to Christ at the cross, with all the saints coming with the Lord at His coming.RH Sep 27, 1853
The phrase rest of the dead proves that those who live and reign had also been dead, for rest marks the remainder of the same dead class.RH Sep 27, 1853RH Nov 9, 1869ST Aug 19, 1889ST Jan 29, 1880 The promise of the first place in the resurrection is equivalent to the first resurrection, distinct from the later resurrection of the rest.RH Nov 9, 1911
Those who share in it are blessed and holy, the second death has no power over them, and they are raised to life and immortality to eternal life.RH Sep 27, 1853ST Jun 8, 1915ST Jan 22, 1885ST Feb 12, 1885RH Mar 8, 1870 They serve as priests of God and of Christ, live and reign with Christ a thousand years, take part in judgment, and share the inheritance when the holy city descends.RH Sep 27, 1853ST Jun 8, 1915RH Mar 8, 1870ST Sep 26, 1911 Those raised later are by contrast unholy, cursed, and subject to the second death in the lake of fire, which is still future and comes at the harvest, the end of the world.ST Jan 22, 1885ST Feb 12, 1885
The first resurrection raises the righteous to incorruptible, immortal, glorious, powerful, spiritual bodies like Christ's, fashioned like His glorious body.ST Jan 22, 1894RH Dec 11, 1855ST Mar 11, 1913 Infirmities of mind and body are gone, every trace of disease is left in the tomb, and they enter life without sorrow, sickness, pain or death to joy and glory beyond description prepared for those who love Him.RH Dec 11, 1855ST Apr 19, 1910ST Aug 27, 1902 The wicked by contrast rise mortal, corruptible, physically mortal with the same mortal bodies, and able to die again.ST Jan 22, 1894ST Apr 19, 1910
It is the resurrection of life, of the just, and out from among the dead to life and immortality, the out-resurrection and better resurrection receiving reward and crown as blessed.ST Sep 14, 1888ST Aug 13, 1902ST Aug 10, 1915 The second is the resurrection of damnation, condemnation and everlasting death, of the unjust, coming a thousand years after and before punishment in the lake of fire and the earth's burning.ST Aug 13, 1902ST Apr 27, 1882ST May 24, 1905 Christ raises all from the first Adamic death, but believers are specially saved from sin and receive eternal life and are not harmed by the second death.ST Aug 10, 1915
It is the resurrection Paul desired to attain, not merely to rise from the dead but to rise from among the dead and have part in this resurrection.RH Aug 24, 1869ST Jul 15, 1875 It is attained only by those accounted worthy to attain that world, who neither marry nor are given in marriage, can die no more, are equal to angels, and are immortal sons of God, sons of the resurrection.ST Feb 6, 1901 This is the only hope of the dead, showing the dead are not alive and conscious.ST Feb 6, 1901 The two risings are real bodily events of the same literal kind, with the martyrs' rising to be understood as literally as the rest's rising, and the first stands before the final judgment and the millennium.
The change making the dead live again takes place at the Lord's coming, when the dead are raised incorruptible and mortals put on immortality.ST Feb 24, 1914ST Feb 20, 1893 The living righteous are made immortal together with the righteous dead and caught up to meet the Lord in the air, and that change is equivalent to death and resurrection.RH Dec 1, 1859 During the thousand years the wicked dead remain in the sleep of death and the righteous live with Jesus in heaven, with the saints' thousand-year reign in judgment beginning with the first resurrection.ST Feb 24, 1914ST Jan 14, 1875RH Sep 11, 1856RH Sep 4, 1856 All the wicked destroyed at the second coming live not again for a thousand years while the righteous live with Christ by the first resurrection and never die.RH Sep 4, 1856
The first resurrection includes all the saved, both those raised from the dead and those still living who are changed at Christ's coming.RH Dec 1, 1859 The living are said to live and to share in the resurrection because in their changed, glorious condition they live as truly as those raised from the grave.RH Dec 1, 1859 The verse does not show that those who refuse to worship the beast or its image are killed.RH Dec 1, 1859
Lived not again means did not come to life, and the souls who live and reign were dead and then came to life at events connected with Christ's second coming.RH Oct 2, 1855 The rest did not come to life until the thousand years were finished, so the verse gives no proof for consciousness in death.RH Oct 2, 1855 The dead remain asleep unconscious without inherent immortality until the righteous receive immortality from God through Christ at their resurrection, while the wicked remain unconscious until the end and then rise.ST Dec 11, 1928RH Mar 21, 1871ST Apr 14, 1914
The saints who sleep in Jesus are brought from the dead in the likeness of Christ's resurrection and are not brought down from heaven, because no saints are sleeping in heaven.ST Oct 18, 1883 With Him describes the manner of their resurrection, not its timing.ST Oct 18, 1883
Rest of Dead Reserved
The rest of the dead are the wicked, unjust and ungodly dead, those not in Christ, including Satan's subjects and all who did not share in the first resurrection and reign, who remain dead, unconscious and asleep in their graves under the power of death throughout the thousand years and do not live again until that period is finished, when they are raised in the second resurrection to damnation.ST Feb 24, 1914RH Sep 11, 1856ST Jan 28, 1889RH May 21, 1901RH Apr 1, 1858 During those thousand years the righteous live with Jesus in heaven, while the wicked dead remain in the sleep of death awaiting a later resurrection distinct from the first resurrection of the righteous.ST Feb 24, 1914ST Jan 28, 1889RH Apr 1, 1858 The saints' thousand-year reign in judgment begins with the first resurrection, and the rest remain dead during those thousand years to be raised when they end to face destruction in the second death.RH Sep 11, 1856RH May 21, 1901 The thousand years are not identical with the day of the Lord, for that day begins before Christ's coming and continues beyond the thousand years, when the wicked are raised, judgment is executed, and the present heavens and earth pass away.RH Mar 12, 1857 The events of verses 6-15 are that second resurrection, when the wicked gather around the city and meet their final end by fire after surrounding the saints' camp.RH May 21, 1901RH Apr 1, 1858
The wicked dead are all ungodly sinners from Cain to the latest outside Christ, who do not live again with the righteous but remain until the thousand years end, which establishes that they are not raised before, with the following events showing their resurrection at the end.ST Jun 28, 1877RH Dec 13, 1864RH Aug 24, 1869 At the time the righteous are delivered and rise from Sheol to immortal life in the first resurrection, the living wicked are cut off from the earth and consigned to Sheol, where they remain with the wicked dead of earlier ages until the resurrection of the unjust.ST Jun 28, 1877 At the second coming the wicked on earth are slain, leaving the earth without human inhabitants under the curse until the second resurrection, and afterward the wicked are destroyed, the earth is made new, and the meek inherit it forever.RH Dec 13, 1864 The righteous take part in the first resurrection at Christ's coming to reign with Christ during those thousand years, while the rest do not live again until the thousand years are finished, and the second death has no power over those who share in the first resurrection.RH Aug 24, 1869 After that period the wicked are raised so they can see what they rejected, recognize that God's gospel and its promises have been vindicated and fulfilled for those who believed and obeyed, and receive the sentence due for their deeds as determined during the thousand years.ST Aug 19, 1889 Those slain in the last great battle and destroyed at Christ's appearing remain dead while the earth lies desolate, and afterward Christ, the saints and the city descend to the desolate earth where Satan and the wicked gather around the holy city and are destroyed by fire from heaven.ST Apr 8, 1875ST Mar 3, 1914
The rest do not live again with the righteous at the first resurrection but remain without life until the period ends with the dead in Christ rising first, and are called forth only when it ends to face destruction in the second death.ST Feb 24, 1914RH Sep 11, 1856ST Jan 28, 1889RH May 21, 1901RH Apr 1, 1858 The wicked live again after the thousand years have ended to die the second death and receive everlasting punishment, in contrast to the saints' resurrection at the advent and after Christ and the saints have reigned in heaven, and they live again to be deceived and destroyed by fire.RH Jun 4, 1857ST Jul 27, 1882RH Jun 18, 1901RH Aug 12, 1858RH Jul 9, 1867 The saints' thousand-year reign is therefore not their eternal reign on the renewed earth, for the wicked are then destroyed by the purifying fire that renews the earth, the new earth appears afterward, and the saints inherit it and reign forever.RH Jun 4, 1857 The resurrected wicked gather around the beloved city with Satan, and fire from God destroys them and purifies the earth.ST Jul 27, 1882RH Aug 12, 1858 This marks the end of the period in which Christ reigns until all enemies including death are put under His feet, before He delivers the kingdom to the Father, at the time when the melted earth and elements burn closing the great day introduced by the plagues and the advent.RH Jun 18, 1901RH Jul 9, 1867
When raised after the thousand years the rest are judged according to their works and die the second death in the lake of fire because of their own transgressions, forfeiting eternal life.RH Jan 12, 1869ST Sep 29, 1881ST Mar 18, 1903 The righteous rise in the first resurrection at Jesus' coming, which includes only those who died in Christ, to live and reign with Christ a thousand years as blessed and holy priests of God and of Christ over whom the second death has no power, while the rest, they that have done evil unto the resurrection of damnation, do not live again until the thousand years are finished.RH Jan 12, 1869ST Sep 29, 1881ST Mar 18, 1903 These raised dead stand before God and are judged according to their works, and those who died in their sins face punishment and separation from God.ST Sep 29, 1881 The two resurrections are separated by that thousand-year period during which Satan is bound, the thousand years cannot be placed in the past, and the wicked are destroyed in the lake of fire which is called the second death, with Satan destroyed there after the thousand years.RH Dec 20, 1864 They rise afterward as the wicked, are deceived by Satan, and face destruction in the second death, so their resurrection is therefore the second resurrection ending in final destruction.RH May 21, 1901ST Jul 29, 1880
They rise at the close with the carnal mind which is hostile to God and not subject to His law, and are vulnerable to Satan's deception because they resisted God's Spirit and rejected the grace and mercy offered in the Gospel before death.ST Mar 17, 1909 They rise with their characters unchanged, still loving sin and hating God and His government, bearing the marks of sin in body and soul.RH Dec 8, 1915 They rise in a vast multitude, still bearing the marks of their sinful lives, in contrast to the righteous who rose in the first resurrection at the beginning of the thousand years.ST May 12, 1914 Their resurrection at the end of that period includes all who throughout history opposed God and refused Christ as Saviour, and they become the nations from the four quarters of the earth whom Satan deceives and gathers to fight against Jerusalem, seeking to establish his rule, until fire from God consumes them.ST Jan 7, 1903 This resurrection to repopulate the earth is brought about by the voice of the Son of God and precedes Satan's release from his prison, giving him people to deceive so his release from the prison of the desolate earth follows their return to life.ST Aug 11, 1914ST Jun 6, 1916
The thousand years are spent on an earth devoid of human beings, because at Christ's second coming the righteous are taken to heaven beyond Satan's reach and the wicked are slain, leaving Satan and his angels chained to this pit of desolation until the wicked dead are raised in the second resurrection after the thousand years, which looses Satan to work upon his subjects again.RH Feb 10, 1916 Their resurrection takes place as Christ descends to the earth with the host of the redeemed in glory and majesty, beheld then by all the world, and their return to life looses Satan with his angels from his long idle bound prison condition to go forth to deceive again the nations brought forth from death.ST Sep 3, 1902 The wicked dead concerned include the heathen, who are raised after the thousand years, and this does not teach that they receive a second probation during a millennial age.RH Dec 20, 1906 They include vast multitudes who died in battle and the kings of the earth and their armies gathered to make war against Him that sits upon the horse and His army when Jesus comes to gather His saints at the beginning of the thousand years, and in that warlike mind and spirit they are slain by the brightness of His coming.RH Feb 6, 1900 When they awake from the dead at the end of the thousand years it is to them just as if they had awaked in the midst of the battle and turmoil in which they went down, almost a continuation of the scenes in which they perished, and with Satan present and his spirit reigning supreme this warlike spirit makes it easy for him to seize their minds and draw them up to battle against the camp of the saints and the beloved city.RH Feb 6, 1900
The rich man represents the wicked Jewish nation that rejected and killed Jesus, placed among the wicked dead who rise after the thousand years in the resurrection of judgment.ST Oct 28, 1913 Balaam will be among the wicked dead who rise in the second resurrection after the thousand years and face their final doom, seeing the redeemed in the city of God but shut out with the wicked.ST Dec 16, 1880
Sources