The thousand years form part of the day of the Lord, which begins before Christ comes and continues beyond to include the little season, execution, cleansing and new heaven and earth; the thousand years are not identical with that day.RH Nov 29, 1864RH Jul 4, 1871ST Aug 19, 1897ST Aug 26, 1875ST Feb 23, 1882 The first resurrection at Christ's coming raises the righteous to life to be taken up to reign with Him on high in heaven on the sea of glass before God's throne, while the rest remain as bones on a desolate ruined earth where the race is extinct and do not live again until finished, during which Satan is confined by an angel to that planetary void.ST Jul 31, 1893RH Jul 4, 1871ST Aug 19, 1897 The millennium begins with the second coming, the first resurrection and the binding of Satan, and closes with the resurrection of the wicked and the loosing of Satan, making up the greater part of that day but not the whole.RH Nov 29, 1864ST Aug 19, 1897ST Aug 26, 1875 That day begins before the thousand years with the pouring out of the plagues and continues afterward through Satan's final deception and the final destruction of the wicked when earth and elements melt, including not only judging but execution.RH Nov 29, 1864ST Aug 19, 1897ST Aug 26, 1875ST Feb 23, 1882
The day of the Lord covers approximately a thousand years, separating the first burning day at the beginning from the second burning day at the close by approximately the interval between the resurrections.ST Dec 12, 1911RH Apr 25, 1871 The day of judgment is not twenty-four hours but a thousand years synchronous with the millennium, during which the great judicial process takes place.ST Dec 12, 1911RH Apr 25, 1871 The day of the Lord and day of judgment begin before the thousand years and end after to the second resurrection and final destruction, so are not limited to the thousand years, with resurrection of the wicked, execution and passing of heavens after within that day, with unknown period possibly following.ST Aug 26, 1875ST Feb 23, 1882RH Feb 16, 1860ST Aug 26, 1875RH Jul 21, 1874 The thousand years begin at the second advent because the resurrection of the righteous takes place at its commencement, while the rest, the wicked, do not live again until finished, and a thousand years after are raised to be presented before glorified saints around the camp and descended beloved city where they see Abraham, Isaac and Jacob in the kingdom and themselves shut out, then fire devours them with no resurrection from second death, inflicted not at second advent but at third advent at close.ST Aug 26, 1875ST Feb 23, 1882RH Jan 3, 1865RH Jul 21, 1874 The work of the judgment-hour message may overlap with the great day, whose total length and twenty-fourth part the verse does not establish.ST Feb 23, 1882ST Aug 26, 1875
The day of the Lord is not exactly one thousand years but more, with the thousand years coming after that day begun, for that day starts with the seven last plagues before advent and thousand years.RH Aug 7, 1856ST Feb 23, 1882 It begins before advent and first resurrection, lasts more than a thousand years, includes six of seven vials before Christ comes as shown by the warning He comes as thief after the sixth vial, and continues beyond second resurrection.RH Nov 29, 1864 It is about one thousand years long, beginning at close of probation shortly before advent; second coming and day are not strictly identical, but close of probation and events of thousand-year day grow out of return.ST Apr 17, 1893 The whole order belongs to the great day from close of probation through plagues, coming, first resurrection, thousand years of judgment on high and desolation, second resurrection and execution.ST Mar 20, 1901 The thousand-year period is the day of judgment beginning with just resurrection and extending to wicked second death, including two resurrections with great day lasting at least a thousand years.RH Mar 7, 1854ST Jan 15, 1880
The verse does not establish how long between thousand years and final destruction, so cannot determine full length of judgment day, and gives no revealed length for little season or final deceptions and destruction.ST Feb 23, 1882ST Mar 20, 1884 The length of the final post-millennial period is left unstated; after thousand years the wicked live again for brief period whose length the verse does not state, with Isaiah 65:20 offered only as possible inference of one hundred years.ST Mar 20, 1907ST Apr 9, 1896ST Oct 29, 1902 At that time they are deceived by Satan and gather to attack the camp and beloved city, during which those who rejected gospel show justice and goodness of God before new heavens and earth follow destruction; both responsible lost child and mature sinner die at end, only suggested not certain.ST Mar 20, 1907ST Apr 9, 1896ST Oct 29, 1902 The wicked raised after thousand years live through a little season which is one hundred years as indicated in Isaiah 65:20, then die, showing rebellion without repentance before cleansing; that setting belongs at close applied as one hundred years where responsible wicked live then die.ST Jun 27, 1911ST Mar 20, 1907ST Apr 19, 1910ST Jun 3, 1908RH Apr 28, 1868 During this time they remain without sorrow or loyalty, yield to deception and join attack against God and city, demonstrating justice in rejecting them, while saints are with Christ and earth desolate, and children reaching accountability show alignment with wicked before death ends such conditions forever.ST Jun 27, 1911ST Apr 19, 1910ST Jun 3, 1908
The resurrection of the wicked after thousand years opens a little season lasting about one hundred years, shown with Isaiah 65:20, at close when city come down and judgment by fire about to be carried with new earth emerging, during which sinners live out permitted age not fixed lifespan, and at close all doomed die eternally.RH Apr 28, 1868ST May 9, 1906ST Oct 2, 1893ST Sep 17, 1912 They remain on earth for that little season understood as one hundred years; at end sin and sinners are no more while people of Lord endure forever, and hundred years express period of resurrection life not fixed lifespan for every person.ST May 9, 1906ST Oct 2, 1893ST Sep 17, 1912ST Feb 3, 1909 After thousand years the wicked live again for season of one hundred years under Satan while judgment vindicated, and Satan marshals and trains them to fight God before they perish, leaving righteous to inherit land forever.ST Nov 21, 1900 The events in Revelation 20 are not all in chronological order; one series includes thousand years and wicked resurrection, while later verses describe judgment and execution, and Revelation 20:12-15 covers same events again beginning earlier than binding and just resurrection.ST Feb 13, 1896RH Mar 15, 1870ST Oct 17, 1878ST May 30, 1911 The rest besides righteous raised in first remain dead throughout and are raised at end to final judgment, implying second resurrection though not describing it directly, while judgment before advent determines who shares first to immortality and rest left to second death at unjust resurrection after.ST Feb 13, 1896RH Mar 15, 1870
A thousand years stand between second and third advents: first resurrection at second advent when Lord fights nations against Jerusalem, and rest not until thousand years end when Lord makes third advent, sets feet on Olives which cleaves for city, then wicked surround it and are destroyed, earth melted and eternal day begins.RH Jan 3, 1865 Then living waters flow from new Jerusalem, Lord is king over all new earth, and Jerusalem safely inhabited with no more utter destruction forever.RH Jan 3, 1865 Events follow fixed order set in motion by seventh trumpet in 1844: finishing gospel, second coming and first resurrection, thousand-year reign in heaven, descent of city and second resurrection, destruction, purifying and eternal home.RH Sep 17, 1914 The thousand years come after prophetic periods ended; 1,335 years reckoned 508 to 1844, same year 2,300 ends, marking start of heavenly judgment and antitypical atonement in which Daniel and righteous stand and sins blotted out, at whose close first resurrection and coming witnessed.ST Sep 21, 1915RH Jun 4, 1857RH Feb 16, 1869 Before resurrection Daniel and all righteous dead stand in lot with sins blotted through Christ's blood, but coming and resurrection did not take place at termination in 1844.RH Jun 4, 1857RH Feb 16, 1869
The sounding of the seventh angel passes over thousand years to new earth, covering long period beyond close of probation; though begun in 1844 still only at beginning fifty-six years later, so thousand years lies within span, and millennium did not begin in 1844.RH May 7, 1901RH Dec 19, 1907 Christ did not then take position on throne of glory to begin kingdom of glory, proved by absence of glory, for what world has seen since is not what first part of millennium would be like.RH May 7, 1901RH Dec 19, 1907 Christ receives the kingdom before His second coming and rewards His servants at His return in the resurrection of the just, and the parable of the nobleman does not place those events after the thousand years. The passage stands in Revelation 12 to 22 completing Daniel, Ezekiel and Zechariah and corresponding to Daniel 7 to 12 expanding Daniel 2 to the everlasting reign of Christ.ST Apr 29, 1903
Doctrines Proved and Errors Barred
The rest of the dead do not live again until the thousand years are finished, so there is no second chance, future probation, or repentance during the millennial age.RH Jan 24, 1907RH Jan 24, 1907RH Jan 31, 1907 The wicked sleep in their graves throughout that period and are not alive to hear the gospel, believe, or be converted, and probation does not extend after Christ comes, including for the heathen world.RH Jan 24, 1907RH Jan 31, 1907RH Jan 24, 1907 The clause stating this is genuine Scripture and not a later marginal comment or copyist gloss, found in the oldest manuscripts and in translations and Greek texts with no indication of doubt in the Revised Versions, its omission in one or two witnesses being by mistake.RH Jan 24, 1907RH Jan 24, 1907 The age-to-come doctrine that makes it a false hope encouraging present sin is thereby exposed.
The verse is cited in connection with the claim that sinners will have a second chance during the thousand years when Satan is bound while righteousness fills the earth, and is misused to teach that all who ever lived will then be resurrected and given another chance to live justly, a doctrine presented as Russellism.RH Jan 31, 1907ST Feb 27, 1893 When Christ comes His priesthood and mediation end and probation closes forever with no mercy or salvation offered afterward, the blessed and holy being forever decided as having part in the first resurrection while the rest are consigned to the second death which is the lake of fire and perdition of ungodly men, which refutes probation after His coming and any future probation.ST Aug 12, 1875 Their resurrection when the period ends leads to destruction in the final judgment by fire from heaven after a final attempt to oppose God, not to another chance at life, probation, or salvation.ST Jun 6, 1916RH Sep 6, 1864RH Apr 22, 1902RH Jul 28, 1910RH Dec 20, 1906 There is no second probation after this life so eternal life must be secured before death, no middle class of mortal nations left in probation under Christ on David's throne in Jerusalem with immortal saints as cabinet, and no further ages beyond the thousand years in which the dead are raised by decades for new probation.RH Apr 22, 1902RH Jul 28, 1910RH Dec 20, 1906ST May 10, 1883
The claim of another probation after death is contradicted because the dead who are not in Christ remain asleep in their graves throughout the thousand years, the Lord's coming and first resurrection do not awaken them, and having refused gospel calls they have no part in the resurrection of life but will be raised afterward to final destiny.ST Jun 3, 1886ST Jun 3, 1886 The earth is thereby utterly depopulated during the millennium, Christ and saints do not then reign on earth, and the dead receive no further opportunity to accept Christ, the wicked dead's resurrection coming only after the righteous'.ST Aug 1, 1916 Revelation 20:4-6 does not warrant a second probation during a thousand-year earthly reign, and Isaiah 65:20 cannot support it, for the raising afterward is for punishment. The later resurrection is of the wicked and does not teach they will be saved after fire; that universal-salvation and universal-restoration use of Revelation 20 is error and was never taught as doctrine, participation in the first resurrection belonging to a life of faith and obedience.RH Feb 19, 1857RH Mar 1, 1860
The resurrection of the rest comes after the thousand years and before their destruction, when they see the holy city and immortal saints, recognize what they have lost, join Satan in attempting to seize the city, and are consumed by God's presence; those with greater light are seen as more guilty, restored to former estate still bearing sins for which they are punished, with no other probation given.ST Oct 9, 1907ST Jan 23, 1907 Resurrection is necessary for both classes because death does not leave people more alive than it found them, the just and unjust rising not together but a thousand years apart, the righteous at the second coming and the rest afterward.RH Mar 11, 1873ST Temporal death through Adam and destruction of the living wicked at the coming are not final perdition for personal transgressions, since that death passes on all alike and cannot satisfy personal guilt, so the wicked must be raised after the thousand years to account according to works and, if unrepented and unforgiven, die the second death as wages of sin beyond which there is no hereafter, distinct from the first death of inherited sinful nature.RH Mar 11, 1873STRH Dec 20, 1864 Language of sleep with no waking can describe death lasting until that appointed resurrection rather than no resurrection, as with Babylonians fallen in their city's ruin, and earth's final storm, earthquake and hail leave the wicked dead until that second resurrection.RH Jan 31, 1865RH Apr 12, 1870
The dead are unconscious until resurrection and punishment comes at judgment not at death, the wicked as the rest not living again until the thousand years end in a resurrection distinct from the earlier rising when the dead in Christ rise first. Death before that resurrection is sleep because an awakening follows, unlike the second death from which there is no awakening and which those not asleep in Jesus will suffer, and being with the Lord does not mean remaining in heaven forever since after the thousand years earth is to be the saints' home.ST Jul 22, 1897 The dead remain asleep until raised, Job expecting to see God in restored flesh at the latter day not at death.RH Feb 13, 1866 David remains dead with mental and physical activities ceased and body subject to decay until the morning of the first resurrection, Christ alone having been raised without corruption, and the first resurrection out from among the dead to a better world is attained only by those accounted worthy who neither marry nor are given in marriage, can die no more, are equal to angels and are immortal sons of God, showing the dead are not alive and conscious.ST Feb 12, 1902ST Feb 6, 1901
The dead remain asleep until Christ returns, when living saints are changed to immortality and raised and living saints ascend with Christ and angels to heaven to remain a thousand years.RH Mar 23, 1916 That thousand years is when saints dwell with Christ in heaven while the wicked of all ages are judged, afterward the wicked destroyed and earth purified by fire, not a period of probation for sinners in an earthly kingdom; the saints reign with Christ in judgment after His return while the wicked are destroyed, earth desolated, and the wicked dead left in graves with Satan for eventual destruction.RH Jul 5, 1915RH Jul 7, 1910ST Aug 26, 1875 The saints live and reign with Christ during that time before Christ dwells with them in the new heaven and new earth, and the verse's place in that account puts the reign before final destruction of the wicked.RH Feb 28, 1856ST Jun 8, 1915 Death is silence, inactivity and unconsciousness, the righteous awakening at the second coming while reviewing cases of those sentenced to eternal death and affirming God's judgments, the wicked remaining in the grave until the thousand years end when raised on the still-unrenewed earth and destroyed by fire.ST Dec 16, 1913RH Jul 27, 1876 The verse rules out dead people returning before Christ comes, after whose resurrection the saints' work is honor and praise to God and the Lamb.RH Feb 21, 1854
There is no consciousness after death, but in the resurrected state the sinner is conscious and recognizes the heaven he rejected and could have enjoyed, and that awareness of guilt and loss is itself consciousness of punishment even before actual suffering.ST Nov 15, 1899 The wicked reap corruption while the righteous are raised incorruptible, preserving mercy and justice, the blessed and holy sharing the first resurrection while the unjust come to damnation and second death without living forever by being raised.ST May 13, 1875 Statements about the wicked punished at Christ's coming do not overturn the order that wicked dead rise a thousand years after the righteous, for if all were punished then some would never be resurrected.RH Nov 3, 1868 Death and resurrection are two separate experiences, the rest not living again until the thousand years end while those who lived and reigned are with the first resurrection, the second resurrection placed after the thousand years in the sequence leading to the close of the seventh millennium.RH Jul 5, 1906RH Apr 3, 1855 The verse concerns the state of the dead, who rises in first and second resurrections and when immortality is bestowed, the first resurrection ending saints' suffering when Jesus immortalizes them to eternal life never to suffer again.RH Dec 29, 1863ST Nov 18, 1897
The verse is connected with the opening of the seventh thousand-year period as grand Sabbatic year and saints' jubilee, when those with part in the first resurrection live and reign as millennial glory begins.RH Jul 29, 1862 The thousand years when the righteous are with God before the rest live again separates the saved from lost loved ones, during which the saved grow in knowledge and trust in His wisdom, justice and goodness with attachment gradually loosened, preparing them to witness the fate of the lost without shock.RH Jul 20, 1876 Together with following events the awakening of the rest after the thousand years marks when righteous and wicked actually see one another's reward, the wicked raised to see redeemed glory and realize lost eternal life before Satan leads them against the city and fire destroys them.ST Jan 29, 1902RH Oct 4, 1906 Raised then with bodies able to endure the presence of the Lamb and holy angels, they gather with Gog and Magog around the Beloved City descended to earth, see Abraham, Isaac and Jacob in the kingdom while shut out, and are devoured by fire from God in the final execution which is the second death from which there is no resurrection, inflicted at the third advent at the close not at the second advent.RH Dec 23, 1851RH Jan 3, 1865RH Jan 7, 1902 Those who did evil thus see the patriarchs in the city but are shut out, and by then destinies are fixed with no further pardon or preaching, the parable's rising from the dead being hypothetical return after seeing the second death not proof of consciousness or pre-resurrection rewards.RH Dec 27, 1855ST Feb 14, 1911
The wicked are given life after the thousand years to see what they rejected, recognize gospel and promises vindicated for believers, stand before the heavenly court, and receive sentence due determined during the thousand years, seeing New Jerusalem and the faithful's reward they could have shared.RH Jan 6, 1859ST Aug 19, 1889 Christ calls the rest, Satan's subjects, to life at the close with the voice of the Archangel and trump of God and they flee His glorious presence; He does not touch earth at the beginning when His people are caught up to meet Him in air, but comes to earth at the end when they come up on the still-unrenewed earth consumed by fire, the same sin-poisoned conditions and plagues remaining to afflict them.ST Mar 14, 1911ST Jun 4, 1874 Their resurrection in the little season before destruction is when earth no longer covers its slain and purification by fire connects with their destruction, showing new earth and inheritance across the whole earth follow the thousand years; hence the call to hide while earth is purged applies after the thousand years not at the second coming.ST Dec 17, 1874ST Jul 27, 1882 They are gathered as prisoners in the pit by lying in the grave prison-house where they live not again a thousand years which are the many days of Isaiah 24:22, their visiting after being resurrection to be found wanting and utterly destroyed.ST Sep 15, 1898
The thousand years is the interval between two deaths of the wicked: first dying by pestilence, famine and seven last plagues at the appearing and remaining dead without living again, then a thousand years afterward devoured by fire from heaven which is the second death, while the righteous live with Christ by the first resurrection and never die.RH Sep 4, 1856 It runs from the appearing when earthly kingdoms are broken in His kingdom until destroyed by fire and His kingdom fills the new earth, connecting two deaths a thousand years apart.RH Sep 18, 1856 Because the rest stay dead through it, the universal melting of elements into one vast lake of fire cannot happen at the beginning but after in the day of the Lord; at the beginning only the unjust living are destroyed while animal life and fowls feasting on Armageddon slain continue, at the close man, beast, fowls and fishes are utterly consumed.ST Aug 19, 1889 Judgment of the dead lies within the thousand years following the plagues, saints and wicked dead judged before raised, wicked raised at its end and destroyed, saints reigning with Christ meanwhile but receiving full reward only when new heavens and earth appear.RH Mar 27, 1856
Before Christ comes every case is decided for first or second resurrection, when He raises the righteous, rewards with immortality and executes judgment for saints; judgment divides the dead between the first and the second after the thousand years, failures with names blotted from life and unconfessed before Father and angels left with sins condemning them to second resurrection then second death in the lake.RH Jun 10, 1858ST Apr 1, 1889 All are not raised at once then separated, but righteous dead from wicked dead and righteous living from wicked living with a thousand years between, the wicked dead taking no part in the coming scene seen by the living, which may include only those then living rather than all ever lived.RH Apr 1, 1858ST Jul 29, 1880RH Oct 16, 1900 The shepherd dividing sheep from goats illustrates separation based on what is already known, saints known before raised or living changed, comprehending the whole execution from reward at coming to driving of wicked to doom at the end.RH Aug 24, 1869 Only at the end in the second resurrection can all nations be gathered and separated, saints as sheep in the Holy City and second-resurrection raised as goats outside, individuals meeting judgment after the thousand years while systems and governments are judged at the coming, all coming before Christ with righteous separated and wicked cast out.ST Sep 12, 1911RH Mar 13, 1856
At the second coming living nations are separated and righteous dead raised, during the thousand years judgment determines reward or punishment, afterward final sentence gives the righteous the kingdom and the wicked extinction.RH Nov 14, 1871 The righteous rise first and the wicked a thousand years later, death remaining enemy holding the wicked until the second death returns them to its dominion without destroying death, while for the just death is destroyed at the coming when raised to immortality never again held.RH Apr 10, 1856ST Dec 30, 1880 The wicked are then punished by annihilating fire, death not being the Christian's gateway or means of victory.ST Dec 30, 1880RH Dec 19, 1865 The righteous are made immortal before gathered into presence and appear first at Christ's judgment-seat to receive reward of well doing not to decide salvation, while at the later resurrection of the ungodly all the wicked stand to receive for unrepented, unpardoned, unblotted evil and hear sentence when every man is rewarded according to works.RH Mar 1, 1870 Their cases facing second death are already decided before the second coming, yet they are not sentenced before He comes but raised and hear sentence at the close, while saints need no final sentence before the first resurrection because names written in heaven show whom to raise and gather to New Jerusalem.RH Jul 21, 1851ST Sep 9, 1875
The righteous resurrection is full acquittal and redemption with sins blotted out at refreshing, absence from the first showing the wicked already condemned with uncovered sins confronting them to bring second death.RH May 30, 1865 The verse establishes the wicked are not raised with the righteous but remain dead until finished, with following events showing their end-time resurrection, affirming both just and unjust will ultimately be raised; the phrase every man in Revelation 22:12 does not put all wicked graves opened at the coming since universal terms can be limited.RH Mar 24, 1863 Those who held that the wicked like the righteous are resurrected at Christ's coming so taught, distinguishing the first resurrection of life for the blessed and holy over whom second death has no power from the later resurrection of the rest.ST May 27, 1913 The wicked do not rise until the thousand years end when they stand before Christ for unrepented deeds after the righteous are already immortal and before Him.ST Sep 26, 1878 Except those in the first resurrection none live again until finished, the souls under the altar being personified as crying though not living until that resurrection.RH Mar 28, 1865
The verse distinguishes the rest from God's people raised at the beginning, the earth bringing forth a nation in one day and the sudden birth in Isaiah 66:8 representing God's people rising together from graves at the thousand years' start, distinct from the later return with the rest.RH Aug 12, 1858RH Aug 12, 1858 It distinguishes only the righteous coming forth in the first while the rest wait until finished, leaving room for a separate special resurrection at receiving the kingdom and beginning of trouble in which some rise to life and others to shame as in Daniel 12, the general wicked resurrection coming a thousand years after Christ comes.ST Jan 11, 1916ST May 7, 1912 Both resurrections are included in Daniel's prophecy with the second a thousand years after the first, together with saints' shining and wicked shame.RH Jan 17, 1856 Judgment and execution lie within the thousand years, after which city and saints descend, the rest live again, the wicked are destroyed, earth purged and becomes the eternal home; the order set in motion by the seventh trumpet in 1844 runs from finishing the gospel to coming and first resurrection, thousand-year heavenly reign, descent of city and second resurrection, destruction, purifying and eternal home.ST Sep 4, 1907RH Sep 17, 1914ST Apr 2, 1912 The rest are all ungodly from Cain to the latest, the first resurrection taking saints at the advent to the Father's house and New Jerusalem, the second raising all wicked at the end with risen saints reigning in judgment in heaven over desolate earth meanwhile, Jesus returning with saints to execute judgment and the kingdom established on earth only at the close of the seventh millennium, saints' full reward and wicked destruction coming after the thousand years before the new earth, the two judgments a thousand years apart.RH Oct 16, 1855RH Nov 23, 1905RH Jan 1, 1901 The passage presents the fate of choosing death contrasted with eternal life and points to God's kingdom as future reality.RH May 21, 1914
Rejected Millennial Theories
The verse rules out a thousand years of peace and universal conversion before Christ comes, for evil grows until He appears, the resurrection comes before the millennium, the righteous are taken to heaven to reign while the wicked stay dead, and the promised glory belongs to the new earth after the wicked are destroyed, with no long spiritual millennium, temporal government, or earthly peace either before or after His return.ST Jun 4, 1874RH Oct 7, 1862ST Apr 14, 1887ST Jan 19, 1915 The thousand years follow His personal visible coming and first resurrection, not a temporal, spiritual or pre-advent millennium of worldwide conversion, peace, holiness and prosperity, and to expect such a period keeps people from watching, removes the need for the Jews to return first, and leaves the impenitent surprised unless they repent at once.RH Jul 6, 1916ST Aug 27, 1885RH Feb 9, 1869ST May 10, 1877RH Sep 20, 1853 That expectation of increasing peace and worldwide conversion from Revelation 20:1-6 is a delusion invented by Daniel Whitby about two centuries ago, now spread from almost every pulpit and paper to please the carnal mind, blinding people to the soon appearing and time of visitation as at the first advent when pride blinded rulers who crucified their King.ST Feb 8, 1883 The millennium will not be produced by converting the world through preaching and prayer, missions, reforms, politics, disarmament, Sunday laws, constitutional amendment or graceless plans, but will be ushered in by the Lord's presence to reward His own and destroy the wicked in heaven not on earth, since only grace changes hearts and no act of Congress can Christianize a city.ST Apr 8, 1889RH Aug 1, 1865ST Feb 14, 1884ST Nov 22, 1910ST Jul 12, 1883 The verse refutes a temporal millennium of world conversion, peace, prosperity or political Christian government before the return, whether by revivals, powers or pacifism, for the last days grow worse with violence, riots and war intensifying to Armageddon, and Christ must come to destroy those who refuse truth and usher in the still-future thousand years of righteousness.GSAM 120.1ST Nov 29, 1899ST Sep 5, 1911ST Jan 10, 1900 That millennium is Christ the Prince of Peace establishing righteousness by grace and faith, not human pacifism establishing peace through goodness, politicians and parliaments; pacifist plans for a golden city may remind of Revelation's golden city but are not its fulfilment, since His kingdom is not of this sin-cursed world which pacifism accepts as it is. The verse teaches no future temporal millennium of earthly peace; the modern doctrine is the prophesied peace-and-safety cry just before and connected with the time of trouble, lulling to lethargy and trust in mighty men rather than God, and no real thousand-year millennium is an era produced by nations or Hague congresses, as bloody wars before agreements are even ratified prove.ST Nov 28, 1900ST Oct 15, 1894 It rejects both a temporal millennium in which the world is converted and a mixed millennium in which Christ reigns on earth among mortal nations, and teaches no spiritual reign for a thousand years but a literal coming and reign.RH Jan 17, 1865RH Sep 4, 1855ST Jun 25, 1874 The thousand years do not mean a spiritual coming and reign through conversions or manifestations of the Spirit, nor repeated comings at each manifestation, but belong to the single personal second appearing wholly distinct from the Spirit sent to comfort and convict, following probation's end and preceding the lake of fire, not brought beforehand by gospel progress.RH Jul 29, 1873RH Dec 16, 1873RH Jul 28, 1859ST Jun 7, 1877ST Nov 4, 1930 That passage describes a personal second coming and distinct thousand-year reign, not a spiritual coming repeated at each manifestation of the Spirit, contrasting Bible teaching of personal advent with the rejected churches' idea of a spiritual coming and reign, a millennium without Christ.RH Nov 30, 1869ST Jun 11, 1874 Christ's reign for a thousand years is literal, not a spiritual reign on earth before His advent; the claim of a spiritual thousand-year reign first is a delusion turning toward Spiritualism, and the first resurrection is a real resurrection not a revival of martyrs' principles, whose plain declaration must not be set aside for figurative explanation.RH Nov 25, 1873ST Jan 13, 1881 The first resurrection is not repentance, spiritual birth through conversion and baptism, or rising from sin to holy life; to call repentance the first resurrection is error, though conversion and baptism prepare for it, and the new birth taught by Christ and the apostles is not only the final resurrection.RH Feb 12, 1857ST May 20, 1889RH Apr 28, 1868RH Aug 16, 1906 The rising is bodily when mortal bodies are made alive by the indwelling Spirit, not moral change; that bodily quickening is the birth of the Spirit prepared by conversion, baptism and faithfulness, while claiming to have already attained it so as to call oneself sinless like angels misuses the teaching.ST Nov 18, 1889RH Feb 12, 1857RH May 11, 1869RH Feb 16, 1869 The first resurrection is future, not an experience already had while living; present moral change and sonship by faith only anticipates by faith and prepares for full adoption, the redemption of the body at the coming when believers receive bodies like His glorious body and are like Him seeing Him as He is.RH Sep 23, 1858RH Jul 2, 1857 Revelation 20:4-6 is used to argue Christ subdues enemies during the reign and they are not destroyed at His coming until near its close, but that location of 1 Corinthians 15:23-28 in the thousand years is merely assumed and cannot be shown, since the promised inheritance is not the old earth but the renewed earth where Christ and saints reign forever, so the thousand-year reign is not on the earth of the eternal reign.RH Jun 18, 1901 The passage alone does not prove enemies remain unsubdued until near the end, because no evident connection with 1 Corinthians 15:23-28 is shown; the claim that the end in 1 Corinthians 15:24 means the close of the thousand years is disputed, since the thousand years are not mentioned there and that passage places the end after His coming without identifying it as their termination.RH Apr 10, 1856RH May 5, 1874 The thousand-year period does not describe Christ's iron rule over enemies; that breaking occurs before and in immediate connection with His coming when nations are broken and enemies made footstool, with no warrant extending it a thousand years, and He will not continue priestly work then for converting sinners, for His priestly rule on the Father's throne will end.RH Aug 14, 1856RH Jun 2, 1910 One position held is that the Lord comes to a wicked world to destroy the impenitent, raise the righteous and reign personally with saints upon earth a thousand years, as apostolic doctrine taught by John to disciples; another held is that the millennial kingdom is literal upon earth renovated by fire to Eden state before general resurrection and judgment, with purification not at His coming but a thousand years after at destruction of the ungodly.RH Sep 30, 1862RH Sep 30, 1862 One position reads prophecy literally as Christ coming before the thousand years to renew earth and establish kingdom there gathering saints to reign as kings and priests, without explaining the rest during or after; another identifies the millennial kingdom as begun with Christ's appearing in the Catholic Church in visible earthly form, though true blessedness belongs to the future.RH Jan 2, 1913RH Oct 7, 1862ST Jun 30, 1914RH May 21, 1914 The teaching of millennial reign connected with the coming was accepted by early Christians but later treated as allegory and rejected as heresy in Constantine's era; expectation faded after his conversion when Christian theocracy as state religion was represented as divine government on earth.RH Feb 10, 1863ST Jun 30, 1914 The verse belongs to the primitive apostolic millennarian faith generally prevalent in the early church, held by Papias, Nepos, Sulpicius and Victorinus, which the council at Rome under Damasus in 376 censured as heresy and suppressed, so that primitive faith is now almost banished, accounting for unpreparedness and loss of original Protestant faith.RH Sep 30, 1862RH Sep 30, 1862 The thousand years were placed by some as beginning under Constantine with their own time in the little season after before final judgment, leaving no hope for world conversion previous to His coming and looking next for His coming to judge; Rome perverted primitive faith which revived with Scripture light, while prophecies were mistakenly applied by a temporary movement near the close of the tenth century which did not fulfill the judgment message.RH Sep 30, 1862RH Sep 30, 1862RH Jan 6, 1874ST Jan 2, 1879 The claim that personal coming occurs only after the thousand years is an opponent's view treating them as symbolic and calculating 365,000 years by day-year, and some likewise interpret prophetically as 365,000 years giving no explanation of the rest or first resurrection.RH Mar 30, 1869ST Jan 28, 1875 At the second appearing God sets up the kingdom where Christ begins a 1000-year reign on David's throne with immortalized saints over unbelieving rulers and subjects granting probation and salvation in the Age to Come; preaching this against the desolate-earth teaching of the Third Angel's Message causes decline and leads away with denial of that message.RH Aug 28, 1856RH Aug 7, 1856 The verse was taken to mean a thousand-year age after the Lord comes and after great destruction when few nations left receive probationary time with ministry, temple, beast sacrifices, feast of tabernacles, and mortals and immortals mingling, yet neglecting commandments and gospel now gains no benefit, so present truth must be attended now. The first resurrection as raising sleeping saints with changing of living righteous and destruction of worst wicked leaves no middle class neither righteous nor wicked surviving as left of nations in mortal probation with twelve tribes under Christ in Jerusalem with immortal cabinet, and gives no further ages beyond with dead raised by decades for new probation.ST May 10, 1883 There is no probation or mixed millennium after the Lord comes in which immortal righteous preach to mortal sinners; prophecy describes the fourth beast's final destruction not conversion, with no existence beyond until second death.ST Jul 23, 1874 The claim that only a small part of the saved with special faith rise in the first while many other saved rise in the second is Mormonism and error, and the verse allows no new probation or later salvation after the advent.RH Sep 2, 1873 In dispute whether Christ and immortal saints will reign on earth among kingdoms including heathen and tribes, no Scripture was presented to establish it, since Revelation 5:10 offered does not specify when begins or how long lasts.RH Mar 13, 1856 The passage does not teach a thousand-year personal reign upon earth, and to appeal to it for that is false theory, heresy and false doctrine belonging to interpreters not the book; it has been spiritualized to mean long gospel expansion, submission, peace and progress after which Christ would come, replacing personal return.ST Nov 28, 1878ST May 10, 1877 The thousand years teach no temporal millennium yet before Christ and judgment, no return of Jews to build Jerusalem, and no coming to live a thousand years before destroying the wicked, and give sinners no future time or delay to repent, so to use them as shield brings false peace and ruin and repentance must be immediate.RH Sep 20, 1853 There is no millennium of world conversion before coming, and the thousand years close before final judgment with little season between; the verse does not mean conversion and peace, as overcrowded accumulating millions with no place to set feet disprove it, and the unconverted will not then be converted but dark terrible period lies between present and glory.ST Jan 9, 1879RH Sep 30, 1862RH Jan 23, 1866 The verse rejects a golden age before resurrection and return; time before judgment is instead marked by deception, waning faith, conflict and tribulation, and millennium prophecy has not begun in a world marked by greed, sweatshops and oppression which mark last days pointing to soon return.RH Jan 10, 1907ST Apr 25, 1900 Its context does not teach the world converted during a thousand years after gospel preached, and cannot delay the end beyond worldwide proclamation; the gospel preached to all nations as witness, then the end comes, not a thousand years later, against a thousand-year worldwide conversion before the end.ST Mar 22, 1883RH Nov 30, 1869RH May 1, 1855 It belongs to teaching about thousand years against the claim the world is improving toward a coming millennium of righteousness; the millennium is not peace and righteousness produced by civilization and gospel before advent, as God's Word presents the contrary.ST Jan 10, 1900ST Mar 30, 1876 The millennium is not a period when all are brought into church, against lax teaching; transformation to millennial purity is not the church's work in the present world and cannot be brought while workers act selfishly and deceitfully.ST Aug 10, 1882RH Feb 10, 1863RH Jun 9, 1868 The millennium is not a present age of righteousness just at hand, nor about to begin through progress; pulpit portrayal of approaching millennium while world improves and gospel nears triumph is contradicted by decline in respect, corruption and warnings of national decline.RH Apr 16, 1908RH Mar 1, 1860RH Feb 17, 1874 The popular theory of temporal millennium just about to begin is contradicted by continued devotion to evil and neglect of gospel; present greed, London's death, Sabbath labor, drunkenness, impurity, gambling, theft and madness, brutal crime with depraved reading, show corruption not fitness.RH Jun 21, 1864ST Jun 3, 1913RH Dec 27, 1870ST Jan 18, 1883 The verse teaches no approaching millennium of universal conversion; that idea is fabled, with prevailing irreligion, crime, intemperance and immorality among young men showing no approach, and rapid skepticism proves the opposite that peril not betterment is at hand.RH Jun 16, 1863ST Jun 17, 1889 The thousand years are not present calm peace among nations; craze for war, preparations, strained relations, and large armies with Italy 400,000, France 700,000, England 220,000, Austria 650,000 and Germany larger, plus over a billion heathen against few professed Christians, show conflict far from future peace when swords become pruning-hooks.ST Jan 14, 1875ST Jan 30, 1901ST Dec 14, 1904ST Mar 10, 1898 The millennium is not already dawning through wealth or progress, since luxury alongside misery disproves it; few thousands gained abroad while millions apostatize, rising crime, corruption, weapons, church emptiness with less than one-fortieth attending, and persecution of quiet Sabbath-keepers fined, seized and imprisoned at Basel, show it still future not at hand.RH Jul 29, 1873ST Feb 14, 1884ST Aug 23, 1910ST Oct 8, 1894RH Nov 19, 1903 The millennium does not dawn before probation closes for the whole family, and has not dawned in Africa as small proportion converted after scores of years proves; with large numbers outside influence and slow evangelization it is still long way off.ST Nov 18, 1903ST Mar 4, 1889 Expectation of temporal millennium rests on counting Catholics, Muslims, Buddhists and enlightened heathen as Christians, or claiming it begins when world converted and joins church as strongest power; if nations merely declared themselves Christians that would be counted as proof.ST Jan 15, 1885ST Dec 28, 1888ST Jun 28, 1883 The millennium is pictured as universal profession where every adult is member or candidate, arriving sooner through doctrinal unity and consolidation separate from politics; its claimed arrival when boss-ridden cities like Cincinnati and New York are reformed is reported as triumph through united church influence, population and power.ST Jan 3, 1905ST Feb 4, 1913ST May 24, 1883 The verse is linked to expectation of thousand years following union of Man of Sin with Empire; that period did not follow but Dark Ages came when Beast was loosed against God's people, for millennium cannot occur before Christ comes nor coexist with Man of Sin to be destroyed by brightness, its predicted period having ended.RH Apr 24, 1856 The verse belongs to the millennium at center of disagreement, with elder looking for temporal millennium filling earth with knowledge while others longed for soon coming rejecting delay for thousands of years.ST Apr 18, 1878LS 164.2–166.1 The verse concerns whether Christ will come personally for at least a thousand years placing them before personal coming; a brief seasonal pause in European fighting is mockingly inadequate example of temporal reign of peace and safety.ST Mar 31, 1887ST Jul 19, 1883 The verse was taken to mean a temporal millennium just upon us with glorious reign near whether temporally or spiritually as personal appearance for destruction of ungodly and gathering of saints, with Midnight Cry sounded as probation just run out and closing work done with lightning speed.RH Nov 8, 1864 The future millennium had not yet come but was approaching, with peace movement and 1907 council as signs of hoped temporal result; Wesley was quoted that claimants of nearness would soon appear truthful.ST May 8, 1907RH May 6, 1858 The future thousand years of peace will not be seen to begin by people then living, its arrival neither immediate nor near; the thousand-year kingdom imagined by advocates of enforced religious laws would postpone the real coming at least that long.ST May 8, 1907RH Feb 11, 1873 The thousand years were not already past at the Volney meeting and that claim was error; nor did the millennium begin in 1874, against the claim all dead rise together for postmortem offer, for the two resurrections are separated with Satan bound and destroyed after, and second death not limited to living wicked at His coming.LS 247.2–248.1ST Aug 22, 1878RH Dec 20, 1864ST Feb 6, 1896 A cited commentary associated the passage with millennium beginning in 1866, 1,260 years after rise of temporal power in 606. The verse is associated with popular view of millennium as ceasing wars and evils so population grows longer raising whether earth could sustain increase, and with differing claims Christ will come to restore and subdue earth with immortal saints as priests in the age to come.ST Jan 9, 1879RH Dec 11, 1855 German temple colonies believed land restored, temple rebuilt and temporal millennium ushered, welcoming Palestine prominence as steps; yet the verse tells positively when thousand years begin, events during and marks of close, and does not mean conversion of world or return of Hebrews to land.ST Jan 18, 1899ST Sep 16, 1897ST Aug 19, 1897ST Aug 26, 1897 The verse predicts peace continuing a thousand years followed by declension when Satan loosed deceives nations then the end, making time knowable and proving time prophecies understandable before fulfilment; the coming period may follow Armageddon and general war with semblance to expected golden age yet wholly different from universal peace politicians, socialists and Christians expect.RH Oct 13, 1874RH Nov 1, 1853ST Aug 5, 1897 The verse belongs to the thousand-year period of blessedness or Paradise restored following advent not preceding, with premillennial personal appearing and reign against popular conversion and spiritual reign; during it judgment is rendered including decree Satan brought to ashes, earth restored from chaos, wicked ceasing while meek inherit.RH Jan 9, 1872ST Apr 22, 1875ST Apr 1, 1875ST Nov 18, 1913 The verse belongs to millennial prophecy of primitive Protestant faith that kingdom is established after ruin of Antichrist; it is also said the millennium is brought by church revival when church and state unite with political enthusiasm, foreshadowed by Sacramento Sunday-law enthusiasm.RH Oct 7, 1862ST Sep 14, 1882 It belongs to passage about millennium and first resurrection relevant to claim kingdom already realized in Catholic Church though true blessedness is future; its arrival is a future claim churches united with world will falsely announce.RH May 21, 1914ST Nov 30, 1882 The idea of thousand years of peace after war replenishing inhabitants is what people proclaim not God's promise, among last-days sayings Micah heard from nations; discussion contrasts it with human effort building a kingdom for Christ to rule a thousand years.ST Sep 12, 1895ST Jun 2, 1898ST Jun 9, 1898 The verse is invoked for claim the world will be converted into millennial peace, a misleading peace-and-safety song lulling to carnal security; teaching such temporal millennium before coming is rejected, for diffusion of infidelity will continue until the Lord ends it as sign of approach.RH Aug 12, 1862ST Sep 22, 1898RH Apr 21, 1874 The verse is misused when linked to thousand years and advent timing to imply Christ will not come until thousand years pass and world converted; if world converted the millennium would come making unclear how glorious appearing could be expected at same time.RH Oct 21, 1862 The verse does not support a temporal millennium before the end; Christ will instead return in glory, and teaching this millennium before the Lord comes is rejected as old fable.LS 33.2–34.1RH May 1, 1856 The thousand years stand at the beginning of the Lord's coming, at which living wicked are slain not converted during, so the verse does not describe gradual conversion after He appears; the rest returning only after is used to reject gospel going forth during the thousand years to second death.RH Mar 27, 1856ST Apr 14, 1887 The thousand-year reign is not on earth with saints administering government while earthly life and commerce continue and Christ only visits with Jews preaching; His coming destroys sin forever not prolongs it under rule, and Abraham's inheritance could not be fulfilled during mortal dying, with definite when and where different from popular view.RH Nov 25, 1852ST May 13, 1903ST Jan 22, 1902 The claim kingdoms destroyed only after reign is rejected; destruction of governments occurs at second coming at thousand years' beginning, raising whether desolation is at advent or purifying fires at end.RH Dec 23, 1862RH Jan 26, 1860 The reign comes after triumph of beast and image and reception of mark on pain of death, which are past when reign begins, the two periods not same time; saints keeping commandments still endure persecution with patience liable to death before coming, receive immortality at last trumpet, then live and reign, with blessing on those dying in Lord before first resurrection.RH Aug 14, 1856ST Jun 15, 1882RH Dec 9, 1851RH Jan 23, 1855 Worshipers of beast die at beginning, dead not sharing first resurrection remain dead during and are made alive at end to face lake, only sharers saved; punishment of worshipers is at second resurrection after thousand years leading to second death.RH Sep 11, 1856RH Aug 7, 1856 British advocates combined biblical teaching with mixed probation and mortality alongside glorification and expected Jewish return to Christ and Palestine during millennium; yet after first resurrection at personal advent all Israel will be saved and gathered to rest, the one remaining gathering, so no gathering of carnal Jews to Palestine before or after.RH May 29, 1856RH Sep 24, 1857 The verse does not make weekly Sabbath sign or type of thousand-year rest; that use is great error with nothing to support, for Sabbath as sign means only God sanctifies and made heaven and earth in six days resting seventh, and claiming Sabbath type of seventh thousand is inconsistent with saying it could cease at cross before antitype.RH Feb 24, 1859RH Nov 13, 1856 It is connected with glorious seventh thousand as future rest which weekly Sabbath does not typify since instituted before fall independent of ministration; it concerns seventh millennium rest in new earth, so first-day sign would place rest in eighth thousand, linked instead to seventh-day sign.RH May 13, 1862RH Jun 12, 1855RH Aug 23, 1870 The Sabbath is presented as type of future rest in seventh millennium fulfilled when Christ comes to give endless life, without explaining distinction between first resurrection and rest; identification of Lord's day with thousand years is rejected since John saw future in vision but was not in future period not yet arrived.RH Apr 5, 1864RH Aug 5, 1852 The second coming introduces the millennium, bringing not peace and safety but vengeance, cruel wrath to desolate land and destroy sinners; the millennium accompanies advent and great tribulation foretold for latter days.ST Feb 20, 1879ST Aug 20, 1902 The millennial period stands before heavenly eternal state as transition and prelude; its work is among events connected with second coming before final setting up of everlasting kingdom in earth made new.ST Jul 21, 1881RH Mar 4, 1909 The thousand years come after completion of gospel work of restoring earth expected about six thousand years, as rest in heaven; the verse belongs to earlier part portraying first judgment work and blessed outcome of first resurrection.ST Mar 11, 1913ST Aug 17, 1915 The millennium comes after coming of Son in clouds with Armageddon among winding-up events, nothing withholding coming; its beginning follows end of age and advent with accompanying judgments.RH Mar 31, 1863 The verse belongs to detailed last-day account in Revelation 15-20 ending with sorrow over, Lord come and redeemed entering home, placing thousand years after coming during judgment when earth lies waste until creation delivered; it sets forth millennium and saints in judgment as events of Great Day in connection with coming, among kindred subjects of return, end, judgment, man and armaments.ST Jan 20, 1904RH Sep 30, 1915ST Sep 22, 1898 The verse presents advent, righteous resurrection, millennium and final destruction as prophetic truths later spiritualized; truth of two resurrections belongs with personal coming before millennium and renewed earth as inheritance.ST May 2, 1916RH Jul 2, 1861 The chapter teaches Christ will return personally visibly, resurrect dead, judge world and establish everlasting kingdom in renewed earth, with believers' immortal resurrection as blessed hope; the passage is basis for personal reign before millennium taught after rejecting Napoleonic fulfilments.RH May 21, 1914RH Feb 6, 1855 The passage concerns second coming and thousand-year reign linked to hope He will return, subdue kingdoms, raise dead and reign before final judgment, in which elect reign, evil bound and peace fulfilled; it is promise of future age when good triumphs over apparent failure.ST Nov 5, 1885RH Oct 7, 1862RH Sep 5, 1865ST Jun 14, 1877RH Jan 23, 1872 The verse belongs to vision of millennium before judgment whose events are actual predictions not imagination; it belongs to order of coming, millennium and new earth where fulfilled predictions assure still future will be fulfilled, proving advent before millennium and kingdom possessed after judgment forever not only a thousand years.ST Mar 31, 1914RH Oct 22, 1861RH Apr 23, 1857RH Jan 17, 1871 It belongs with kindred subjects including second coming, time of end, judgment, nature of man and arming of nations; it concerns millennium with resurrection, coming, life only in Christ, destruction and reward.ST Jan 20, 1904RH Sep 30, 1915RH Dec 19, 1907 It belongs to clear truth about millennial reign while many other teachings are vagaries; it gives martyrs hope though sacrificing lives they will find them, reign and receive rich reward.RH Aug 23, 1864RH Jun 18, 1914 The verse was taken to show Christ living on earth with people during thousand years near at hand with just and unjust in view, personal reign after sifting bringing reformation and restoration of Israel, and reign with saints after judgment on purified fitting earth.RH Apr 8, 1873RH Jan 3, 1865RH Nov 16, 1869 The verse was taken to show two conditions among dead: spirits reigning with Christ to be honored, venerated and prayed to for favors through intercession, and souls not pure enough helped toward rest, refreshment and life by sacrifices and prayers.RH Jun 28, 1870 It has been claimed the first resurrection comes after thousand years in union with God withstanding final deception, that thousand years begin at appearing as earthly reign with conversion, that years are prophetic with moral resurrection past and universal peace begun before advent, and variously thousand years past or future and wicked raised or not and righteous mortal or immortal without resolution.RH Apr 11, 1865
Commentary part 3 of 4
Pioneers and periodicals (continued)
Day of Lord Chronology
The thousand years form part of the day of the Lord, which begins before Christ comes and continues beyond to include the little season, execution, cleansing and new heaven and earth; the thousand years are not identical with that day.RH Nov 29, 1864RH Jul 4, 1871ST Aug 19, 1897ST Aug 26, 1875ST Feb 23, 1882 The first resurrection at Christ's coming raises the righteous to life to be taken up to reign with Him on high in heaven on the sea of glass before God's throne, while the rest remain as bones on a desolate ruined earth where the race is extinct and do not live again until finished, during which Satan is confined by an angel to that planetary void.ST Jul 31, 1893RH Jul 4, 1871ST Aug 19, 1897 The millennium begins with the second coming, the first resurrection and the binding of Satan, and closes with the resurrection of the wicked and the loosing of Satan, making up the greater part of that day but not the whole.RH Nov 29, 1864ST Aug 19, 1897ST Aug 26, 1875 That day begins before the thousand years with the pouring out of the plagues and continues afterward through Satan's final deception and the final destruction of the wicked when earth and elements melt, including not only judging but execution.RH Nov 29, 1864ST Aug 19, 1897ST Aug 26, 1875ST Feb 23, 1882
The day of the Lord covers approximately a thousand years, separating the first burning day at the beginning from the second burning day at the close by approximately the interval between the resurrections.ST Dec 12, 1911RH Apr 25, 1871 The day of judgment is not twenty-four hours but a thousand years synchronous with the millennium, during which the great judicial process takes place.ST Dec 12, 1911RH Apr 25, 1871 The day of the Lord and day of judgment begin before the thousand years and end after to the second resurrection and final destruction, so are not limited to the thousand years, with resurrection of the wicked, execution and passing of heavens after within that day, with unknown period possibly following.ST Aug 26, 1875ST Feb 23, 1882RH Feb 16, 1860ST Aug 26, 1875RH Jul 21, 1874 The thousand years begin at the second advent because the resurrection of the righteous takes place at its commencement, while the rest, the wicked, do not live again until finished, and a thousand years after are raised to be presented before glorified saints around the camp and descended beloved city where they see Abraham, Isaac and Jacob in the kingdom and themselves shut out, then fire devours them with no resurrection from second death, inflicted not at second advent but at third advent at close.ST Aug 26, 1875ST Feb 23, 1882RH Jan 3, 1865RH Jul 21, 1874 The work of the judgment-hour message may overlap with the great day, whose total length and twenty-fourth part the verse does not establish.ST Feb 23, 1882ST Aug 26, 1875
The day of the Lord is not exactly one thousand years but more, with the thousand years coming after that day begun, for that day starts with the seven last plagues before advent and thousand years.RH Aug 7, 1856ST Feb 23, 1882 It begins before advent and first resurrection, lasts more than a thousand years, includes six of seven vials before Christ comes as shown by the warning He comes as thief after the sixth vial, and continues beyond second resurrection.RH Nov 29, 1864 It is about one thousand years long, beginning at close of probation shortly before advent; second coming and day are not strictly identical, but close of probation and events of thousand-year day grow out of return.ST Apr 17, 1893 The whole order belongs to the great day from close of probation through plagues, coming, first resurrection, thousand years of judgment on high and desolation, second resurrection and execution.ST Mar 20, 1901 The thousand-year period is the day of judgment beginning with just resurrection and extending to wicked second death, including two resurrections with great day lasting at least a thousand years.RH Mar 7, 1854ST Jan 15, 1880
The verse does not establish how long between thousand years and final destruction, so cannot determine full length of judgment day, and gives no revealed length for little season or final deceptions and destruction.ST Feb 23, 1882ST Mar 20, 1884 The length of the final post-millennial period is left unstated; after thousand years the wicked live again for brief period whose length the verse does not state, with Isaiah 65:20 offered only as possible inference of one hundred years.ST Mar 20, 1907ST Apr 9, 1896ST Oct 29, 1902 At that time they are deceived by Satan and gather to attack the camp and beloved city, during which those who rejected gospel show justice and goodness of God before new heavens and earth follow destruction; both responsible lost child and mature sinner die at end, only suggested not certain.ST Mar 20, 1907ST Apr 9, 1896ST Oct 29, 1902 The wicked raised after thousand years live through a little season which is one hundred years as indicated in Isaiah 65:20, then die, showing rebellion without repentance before cleansing; that setting belongs at close applied as one hundred years where responsible wicked live then die.ST Jun 27, 1911ST Mar 20, 1907ST Apr 19, 1910ST Jun 3, 1908RH Apr 28, 1868 During this time they remain without sorrow or loyalty, yield to deception and join attack against God and city, demonstrating justice in rejecting them, while saints are with Christ and earth desolate, and children reaching accountability show alignment with wicked before death ends such conditions forever.ST Jun 27, 1911ST Apr 19, 1910ST Jun 3, 1908
The resurrection of the wicked after thousand years opens a little season lasting about one hundred years, shown with Isaiah 65:20, at close when city come down and judgment by fire about to be carried with new earth emerging, during which sinners live out permitted age not fixed lifespan, and at close all doomed die eternally.RH Apr 28, 1868ST May 9, 1906ST Oct 2, 1893ST Sep 17, 1912 They remain on earth for that little season understood as one hundred years; at end sin and sinners are no more while people of Lord endure forever, and hundred years express period of resurrection life not fixed lifespan for every person.ST May 9, 1906ST Oct 2, 1893ST Sep 17, 1912ST Feb 3, 1909 After thousand years the wicked live again for season of one hundred years under Satan while judgment vindicated, and Satan marshals and trains them to fight God before they perish, leaving righteous to inherit land forever.ST Nov 21, 1900 The events in Revelation 20 are not all in chronological order; one series includes thousand years and wicked resurrection, while later verses describe judgment and execution, and Revelation 20:12-15 covers same events again beginning earlier than binding and just resurrection.ST Feb 13, 1896RH Mar 15, 1870ST Oct 17, 1878ST May 30, 1911 The rest besides righteous raised in first remain dead throughout and are raised at end to final judgment, implying second resurrection though not describing it directly, while judgment before advent determines who shares first to immortality and rest left to second death at unjust resurrection after.ST Feb 13, 1896RH Mar 15, 1870
A thousand years stand between second and third advents: first resurrection at second advent when Lord fights nations against Jerusalem, and rest not until thousand years end when Lord makes third advent, sets feet on Olives which cleaves for city, then wicked surround it and are destroyed, earth melted and eternal day begins.RH Jan 3, 1865 Then living waters flow from new Jerusalem, Lord is king over all new earth, and Jerusalem safely inhabited with no more utter destruction forever.RH Jan 3, 1865 Events follow fixed order set in motion by seventh trumpet in 1844: finishing gospel, second coming and first resurrection, thousand-year reign in heaven, descent of city and second resurrection, destruction, purifying and eternal home.RH Sep 17, 1914 The thousand years come after prophetic periods ended; 1,335 years reckoned 508 to 1844, same year 2,300 ends, marking start of heavenly judgment and antitypical atonement in which Daniel and righteous stand and sins blotted out, at whose close first resurrection and coming witnessed.ST Sep 21, 1915RH Jun 4, 1857RH Feb 16, 1869 Before resurrection Daniel and all righteous dead stand in lot with sins blotted through Christ's blood, but coming and resurrection did not take place at termination in 1844.RH Jun 4, 1857RH Feb 16, 1869
The sounding of the seventh angel passes over thousand years to new earth, covering long period beyond close of probation; though begun in 1844 still only at beginning fifty-six years later, so thousand years lies within span, and millennium did not begin in 1844.RH May 7, 1901RH Dec 19, 1907 Christ did not then take position on throne of glory to begin kingdom of glory, proved by absence of glory, for what world has seen since is not what first part of millennium would be like.RH May 7, 1901RH Dec 19, 1907 Christ receives the kingdom before His second coming and rewards His servants at His return in the resurrection of the just, and the parable of the nobleman does not place those events after the thousand years. The passage stands in Revelation 12 to 22 completing Daniel, Ezekiel and Zechariah and corresponding to Daniel 7 to 12 expanding Daniel 2 to the everlasting reign of Christ.ST Apr 29, 1903
Doctrines Proved and Errors Barred
The rest of the dead do not live again until the thousand years are finished, so there is no second chance, future probation, or repentance during the millennial age.RH Jan 24, 1907RH Jan 24, 1907RH Jan 31, 1907 The wicked sleep in their graves throughout that period and are not alive to hear the gospel, believe, or be converted, and probation does not extend after Christ comes, including for the heathen world.RH Jan 24, 1907RH Jan 31, 1907RH Jan 24, 1907 The clause stating this is genuine Scripture and not a later marginal comment or copyist gloss, found in the oldest manuscripts and in translations and Greek texts with no indication of doubt in the Revised Versions, its omission in one or two witnesses being by mistake.RH Jan 24, 1907RH Jan 24, 1907 The age-to-come doctrine that makes it a false hope encouraging present sin is thereby exposed.
The verse is cited in connection with the claim that sinners will have a second chance during the thousand years when Satan is bound while righteousness fills the earth, and is misused to teach that all who ever lived will then be resurrected and given another chance to live justly, a doctrine presented as Russellism.RH Jan 31, 1907ST Feb 27, 1893 When Christ comes His priesthood and mediation end and probation closes forever with no mercy or salvation offered afterward, the blessed and holy being forever decided as having part in the first resurrection while the rest are consigned to the second death which is the lake of fire and perdition of ungodly men, which refutes probation after His coming and any future probation.ST Aug 12, 1875 Their resurrection when the period ends leads to destruction in the final judgment by fire from heaven after a final attempt to oppose God, not to another chance at life, probation, or salvation.ST Jun 6, 1916RH Sep 6, 1864RH Apr 22, 1902RH Jul 28, 1910RH Dec 20, 1906 There is no second probation after this life so eternal life must be secured before death, no middle class of mortal nations left in probation under Christ on David's throne in Jerusalem with immortal saints as cabinet, and no further ages beyond the thousand years in which the dead are raised by decades for new probation.RH Apr 22, 1902RH Jul 28, 1910RH Dec 20, 1906ST May 10, 1883
The claim of another probation after death is contradicted because the dead who are not in Christ remain asleep in their graves throughout the thousand years, the Lord's coming and first resurrection do not awaken them, and having refused gospel calls they have no part in the resurrection of life but will be raised afterward to final destiny.ST Jun 3, 1886ST Jun 3, 1886 The earth is thereby utterly depopulated during the millennium, Christ and saints do not then reign on earth, and the dead receive no further opportunity to accept Christ, the wicked dead's resurrection coming only after the righteous'.ST Aug 1, 1916 Revelation 20:4-6 does not warrant a second probation during a thousand-year earthly reign, and Isaiah 65:20 cannot support it, for the raising afterward is for punishment. The later resurrection is of the wicked and does not teach they will be saved after fire; that universal-salvation and universal-restoration use of Revelation 20 is error and was never taught as doctrine, participation in the first resurrection belonging to a life of faith and obedience.RH Feb 19, 1857RH Mar 1, 1860
The resurrection of the rest comes after the thousand years and before their destruction, when they see the holy city and immortal saints, recognize what they have lost, join Satan in attempting to seize the city, and are consumed by God's presence; those with greater light are seen as more guilty, restored to former estate still bearing sins for which they are punished, with no other probation given.ST Oct 9, 1907ST Jan 23, 1907 Resurrection is necessary for both classes because death does not leave people more alive than it found them, the just and unjust rising not together but a thousand years apart, the righteous at the second coming and the rest afterward.RH Mar 11, 1873ST Temporal death through Adam and destruction of the living wicked at the coming are not final perdition for personal transgressions, since that death passes on all alike and cannot satisfy personal guilt, so the wicked must be raised after the thousand years to account according to works and, if unrepented and unforgiven, die the second death as wages of sin beyond which there is no hereafter, distinct from the first death of inherited sinful nature.RH Mar 11, 1873STRH Dec 20, 1864 Language of sleep with no waking can describe death lasting until that appointed resurrection rather than no resurrection, as with Babylonians fallen in their city's ruin, and earth's final storm, earthquake and hail leave the wicked dead until that second resurrection.RH Jan 31, 1865RH Apr 12, 1870
The dead are unconscious until resurrection and punishment comes at judgment not at death, the wicked as the rest not living again until the thousand years end in a resurrection distinct from the earlier rising when the dead in Christ rise first. Death before that resurrection is sleep because an awakening follows, unlike the second death from which there is no awakening and which those not asleep in Jesus will suffer, and being with the Lord does not mean remaining in heaven forever since after the thousand years earth is to be the saints' home.ST Jul 22, 1897 The dead remain asleep until raised, Job expecting to see God in restored flesh at the latter day not at death.RH Feb 13, 1866 David remains dead with mental and physical activities ceased and body subject to decay until the morning of the first resurrection, Christ alone having been raised without corruption, and the first resurrection out from among the dead to a better world is attained only by those accounted worthy who neither marry nor are given in marriage, can die no more, are equal to angels and are immortal sons of God, showing the dead are not alive and conscious.ST Feb 12, 1902ST Feb 6, 1901
The dead remain asleep until Christ returns, when living saints are changed to immortality and raised and living saints ascend with Christ and angels to heaven to remain a thousand years.RH Mar 23, 1916 That thousand years is when saints dwell with Christ in heaven while the wicked of all ages are judged, afterward the wicked destroyed and earth purified by fire, not a period of probation for sinners in an earthly kingdom; the saints reign with Christ in judgment after His return while the wicked are destroyed, earth desolated, and the wicked dead left in graves with Satan for eventual destruction.RH Jul 5, 1915RH Jul 7, 1910ST Aug 26, 1875 The saints live and reign with Christ during that time before Christ dwells with them in the new heaven and new earth, and the verse's place in that account puts the reign before final destruction of the wicked.RH Feb 28, 1856ST Jun 8, 1915 Death is silence, inactivity and unconsciousness, the righteous awakening at the second coming while reviewing cases of those sentenced to eternal death and affirming God's judgments, the wicked remaining in the grave until the thousand years end when raised on the still-unrenewed earth and destroyed by fire.ST Dec 16, 1913RH Jul 27, 1876 The verse rules out dead people returning before Christ comes, after whose resurrection the saints' work is honor and praise to God and the Lamb.RH Feb 21, 1854
There is no consciousness after death, but in the resurrected state the sinner is conscious and recognizes the heaven he rejected and could have enjoyed, and that awareness of guilt and loss is itself consciousness of punishment even before actual suffering.ST Nov 15, 1899 The wicked reap corruption while the righteous are raised incorruptible, preserving mercy and justice, the blessed and holy sharing the first resurrection while the unjust come to damnation and second death without living forever by being raised.ST May 13, 1875 Statements about the wicked punished at Christ's coming do not overturn the order that wicked dead rise a thousand years after the righteous, for if all were punished then some would never be resurrected.RH Nov 3, 1868 Death and resurrection are two separate experiences, the rest not living again until the thousand years end while those who lived and reigned are with the first resurrection, the second resurrection placed after the thousand years in the sequence leading to the close of the seventh millennium.RH Jul 5, 1906RH Apr 3, 1855 The verse concerns the state of the dead, who rises in first and second resurrections and when immortality is bestowed, the first resurrection ending saints' suffering when Jesus immortalizes them to eternal life never to suffer again.RH Dec 29, 1863ST Nov 18, 1897
The verse is connected with the opening of the seventh thousand-year period as grand Sabbatic year and saints' jubilee, when those with part in the first resurrection live and reign as millennial glory begins.RH Jul 29, 1862 The thousand years when the righteous are with God before the rest live again separates the saved from lost loved ones, during which the saved grow in knowledge and trust in His wisdom, justice and goodness with attachment gradually loosened, preparing them to witness the fate of the lost without shock.RH Jul 20, 1876 Together with following events the awakening of the rest after the thousand years marks when righteous and wicked actually see one another's reward, the wicked raised to see redeemed glory and realize lost eternal life before Satan leads them against the city and fire destroys them.ST Jan 29, 1902RH Oct 4, 1906 Raised then with bodies able to endure the presence of the Lamb and holy angels, they gather with Gog and Magog around the Beloved City descended to earth, see Abraham, Isaac and Jacob in the kingdom while shut out, and are devoured by fire from God in the final execution which is the second death from which there is no resurrection, inflicted at the third advent at the close not at the second advent.RH Dec 23, 1851RH Jan 3, 1865RH Jan 7, 1902 Those who did evil thus see the patriarchs in the city but are shut out, and by then destinies are fixed with no further pardon or preaching, the parable's rising from the dead being hypothetical return after seeing the second death not proof of consciousness or pre-resurrection rewards.RH Dec 27, 1855ST Feb 14, 1911
The wicked are given life after the thousand years to see what they rejected, recognize gospel and promises vindicated for believers, stand before the heavenly court, and receive sentence due determined during the thousand years, seeing New Jerusalem and the faithful's reward they could have shared.RH Jan 6, 1859ST Aug 19, 1889 Christ calls the rest, Satan's subjects, to life at the close with the voice of the Archangel and trump of God and they flee His glorious presence; He does not touch earth at the beginning when His people are caught up to meet Him in air, but comes to earth at the end when they come up on the still-unrenewed earth consumed by fire, the same sin-poisoned conditions and plagues remaining to afflict them.ST Mar 14, 1911ST Jun 4, 1874 Their resurrection in the little season before destruction is when earth no longer covers its slain and purification by fire connects with their destruction, showing new earth and inheritance across the whole earth follow the thousand years; hence the call to hide while earth is purged applies after the thousand years not at the second coming.ST Dec 17, 1874ST Jul 27, 1882 They are gathered as prisoners in the pit by lying in the grave prison-house where they live not again a thousand years which are the many days of Isaiah 24:22, their visiting after being resurrection to be found wanting and utterly destroyed.ST Sep 15, 1898
The thousand years is the interval between two deaths of the wicked: first dying by pestilence, famine and seven last plagues at the appearing and remaining dead without living again, then a thousand years afterward devoured by fire from heaven which is the second death, while the righteous live with Christ by the first resurrection and never die.RH Sep 4, 1856 It runs from the appearing when earthly kingdoms are broken in His kingdom until destroyed by fire and His kingdom fills the new earth, connecting two deaths a thousand years apart.RH Sep 18, 1856 Because the rest stay dead through it, the universal melting of elements into one vast lake of fire cannot happen at the beginning but after in the day of the Lord; at the beginning only the unjust living are destroyed while animal life and fowls feasting on Armageddon slain continue, at the close man, beast, fowls and fishes are utterly consumed.ST Aug 19, 1889 Judgment of the dead lies within the thousand years following the plagues, saints and wicked dead judged before raised, wicked raised at its end and destroyed, saints reigning with Christ meanwhile but receiving full reward only when new heavens and earth appear.RH Mar 27, 1856
Before Christ comes every case is decided for first or second resurrection, when He raises the righteous, rewards with immortality and executes judgment for saints; judgment divides the dead between the first and the second after the thousand years, failures with names blotted from life and unconfessed before Father and angels left with sins condemning them to second resurrection then second death in the lake.RH Jun 10, 1858ST Apr 1, 1889 All are not raised at once then separated, but righteous dead from wicked dead and righteous living from wicked living with a thousand years between, the wicked dead taking no part in the coming scene seen by the living, which may include only those then living rather than all ever lived.RH Apr 1, 1858ST Jul 29, 1880RH Oct 16, 1900 The shepherd dividing sheep from goats illustrates separation based on what is already known, saints known before raised or living changed, comprehending the whole execution from reward at coming to driving of wicked to doom at the end.RH Aug 24, 1869 Only at the end in the second resurrection can all nations be gathered and separated, saints as sheep in the Holy City and second-resurrection raised as goats outside, individuals meeting judgment after the thousand years while systems and governments are judged at the coming, all coming before Christ with righteous separated and wicked cast out.ST Sep 12, 1911RH Mar 13, 1856
At the second coming living nations are separated and righteous dead raised, during the thousand years judgment determines reward or punishment, afterward final sentence gives the righteous the kingdom and the wicked extinction.RH Nov 14, 1871 The righteous rise first and the wicked a thousand years later, death remaining enemy holding the wicked until the second death returns them to its dominion without destroying death, while for the just death is destroyed at the coming when raised to immortality never again held.RH Apr 10, 1856ST Dec 30, 1880 The wicked are then punished by annihilating fire, death not being the Christian's gateway or means of victory.ST Dec 30, 1880RH Dec 19, 1865 The righteous are made immortal before gathered into presence and appear first at Christ's judgment-seat to receive reward of well doing not to decide salvation, while at the later resurrection of the ungodly all the wicked stand to receive for unrepented, unpardoned, unblotted evil and hear sentence when every man is rewarded according to works.RH Mar 1, 1870 Their cases facing second death are already decided before the second coming, yet they are not sentenced before He comes but raised and hear sentence at the close, while saints need no final sentence before the first resurrection because names written in heaven show whom to raise and gather to New Jerusalem.RH Jul 21, 1851ST Sep 9, 1875
The righteous resurrection is full acquittal and redemption with sins blotted out at refreshing, absence from the first showing the wicked already condemned with uncovered sins confronting them to bring second death.RH May 30, 1865 The verse establishes the wicked are not raised with the righteous but remain dead until finished, with following events showing their end-time resurrection, affirming both just and unjust will ultimately be raised; the phrase every man in Revelation 22:12 does not put all wicked graves opened at the coming since universal terms can be limited.RH Mar 24, 1863 Those who held that the wicked like the righteous are resurrected at Christ's coming so taught, distinguishing the first resurrection of life for the blessed and holy over whom second death has no power from the later resurrection of the rest.ST May 27, 1913 The wicked do not rise until the thousand years end when they stand before Christ for unrepented deeds after the righteous are already immortal and before Him.ST Sep 26, 1878 Except those in the first resurrection none live again until finished, the souls under the altar being personified as crying though not living until that resurrection.RH Mar 28, 1865
The verse distinguishes the rest from God's people raised at the beginning, the earth bringing forth a nation in one day and the sudden birth in Isaiah 66:8 representing God's people rising together from graves at the thousand years' start, distinct from the later return with the rest.RH Aug 12, 1858RH Aug 12, 1858 It distinguishes only the righteous coming forth in the first while the rest wait until finished, leaving room for a separate special resurrection at receiving the kingdom and beginning of trouble in which some rise to life and others to shame as in Daniel 12, the general wicked resurrection coming a thousand years after Christ comes.ST Jan 11, 1916ST May 7, 1912 Both resurrections are included in Daniel's prophecy with the second a thousand years after the first, together with saints' shining and wicked shame.RH Jan 17, 1856 Judgment and execution lie within the thousand years, after which city and saints descend, the rest live again, the wicked are destroyed, earth purged and becomes the eternal home; the order set in motion by the seventh trumpet in 1844 runs from finishing the gospel to coming and first resurrection, thousand-year heavenly reign, descent of city and second resurrection, destruction, purifying and eternal home.ST Sep 4, 1907RH Sep 17, 1914ST Apr 2, 1912 The rest are all ungodly from Cain to the latest, the first resurrection taking saints at the advent to the Father's house and New Jerusalem, the second raising all wicked at the end with risen saints reigning in judgment in heaven over desolate earth meanwhile, Jesus returning with saints to execute judgment and the kingdom established on earth only at the close of the seventh millennium, saints' full reward and wicked destruction coming after the thousand years before the new earth, the two judgments a thousand years apart.RH Oct 16, 1855RH Nov 23, 1905RH Jan 1, 1901 The passage presents the fate of choosing death contrasted with eternal life and points to God's kingdom as future reality.RH May 21, 1914
Rejected Millennial Theories
The verse rules out a thousand years of peace and universal conversion before Christ comes, for evil grows until He appears, the resurrection comes before the millennium, the righteous are taken to heaven to reign while the wicked stay dead, and the promised glory belongs to the new earth after the wicked are destroyed, with no long spiritual millennium, temporal government, or earthly peace either before or after His return.ST Jun 4, 1874RH Oct 7, 1862ST Apr 14, 1887ST Jan 19, 1915
The thousand years follow His personal visible coming and first resurrection, not a temporal, spiritual or pre-advent millennium of worldwide conversion, peace, holiness and prosperity, and to expect such a period keeps people from watching, removes the need for the Jews to return first, and leaves the impenitent surprised unless they repent at once.RH Jul 6, 1916ST Aug 27, 1885RH Feb 9, 1869ST May 10, 1877RH Sep 20, 1853
That expectation of increasing peace and worldwide conversion from Revelation 20:1-6 is a delusion invented by Daniel Whitby about two centuries ago, now spread from almost every pulpit and paper to please the carnal mind, blinding people to the soon appearing and time of visitation as at the first advent when pride blinded rulers who crucified their King.ST Feb 8, 1883
The millennium will not be produced by converting the world through preaching and prayer, missions, reforms, politics, disarmament, Sunday laws, constitutional amendment or graceless plans, but will be ushered in by the Lord's presence to reward His own and destroy the wicked in heaven not on earth, since only grace changes hearts and no act of Congress can Christianize a city.ST Apr 8, 1889RH Aug 1, 1865ST Feb 14, 1884ST Nov 22, 1910ST Jul 12, 1883
The verse refutes a temporal millennium of world conversion, peace, prosperity or political Christian government before the return, whether by revivals, powers or pacifism, for the last days grow worse with violence, riots and war intensifying to Armageddon, and Christ must come to destroy those who refuse truth and usher in the still-future thousand years of righteousness.GSAM 120.1ST Nov 29, 1899ST Sep 5, 1911ST Jan 10, 1900
That millennium is Christ the Prince of Peace establishing righteousness by grace and faith, not human pacifism establishing peace through goodness, politicians and parliaments; pacifist plans for a golden city may remind of Revelation's golden city but are not its fulfilment, since His kingdom is not of this sin-cursed world which pacifism accepts as it is.
The verse teaches no future temporal millennium of earthly peace; the modern doctrine is the prophesied peace-and-safety cry just before and connected with the time of trouble, lulling to lethargy and trust in mighty men rather than God, and no real thousand-year millennium is an era produced by nations or Hague congresses, as bloody wars before agreements are even ratified prove.ST Nov 28, 1900ST Oct 15, 1894
It rejects both a temporal millennium in which the world is converted and a mixed millennium in which Christ reigns on earth among mortal nations, and teaches no spiritual reign for a thousand years but a literal coming and reign.RH Jan 17, 1865RH Sep 4, 1855ST Jun 25, 1874
The thousand years do not mean a spiritual coming and reign through conversions or manifestations of the Spirit, nor repeated comings at each manifestation, but belong to the single personal second appearing wholly distinct from the Spirit sent to comfort and convict, following probation's end and preceding the lake of fire, not brought beforehand by gospel progress.RH Jul 29, 1873RH Dec 16, 1873RH Jul 28, 1859ST Jun 7, 1877ST Nov 4, 1930
That passage describes a personal second coming and distinct thousand-year reign, not a spiritual coming repeated at each manifestation of the Spirit, contrasting Bible teaching of personal advent with the rejected churches' idea of a spiritual coming and reign, a millennium without Christ.RH Nov 30, 1869ST Jun 11, 1874
Christ's reign for a thousand years is literal, not a spiritual reign on earth before His advent; the claim of a spiritual thousand-year reign first is a delusion turning toward Spiritualism, and the first resurrection is a real resurrection not a revival of martyrs' principles, whose plain declaration must not be set aside for figurative explanation.RH Nov 25, 1873ST Jan 13, 1881
The first resurrection is not repentance, spiritual birth through conversion and baptism, or rising from sin to holy life; to call repentance the first resurrection is error, though conversion and baptism prepare for it, and the new birth taught by Christ and the apostles is not only the final resurrection.RH Feb 12, 1857ST May 20, 1889RH Apr 28, 1868RH Aug 16, 1906
The rising is bodily when mortal bodies are made alive by the indwelling Spirit, not moral change; that bodily quickening is the birth of the Spirit prepared by conversion, baptism and faithfulness, while claiming to have already attained it so as to call oneself sinless like angels misuses the teaching.ST Nov 18, 1889RH Feb 12, 1857RH May 11, 1869RH Feb 16, 1869
The first resurrection is future, not an experience already had while living; present moral change and sonship by faith only anticipates by faith and prepares for full adoption, the redemption of the body at the coming when believers receive bodies like His glorious body and are like Him seeing Him as He is.RH Sep 23, 1858RH Jul 2, 1857
Revelation 20:4-6 is used to argue Christ subdues enemies during the reign and they are not destroyed at His coming until near its close, but that location of 1 Corinthians 15:23-28 in the thousand years is merely assumed and cannot be shown, since the promised inheritance is not the old earth but the renewed earth where Christ and saints reign forever, so the thousand-year reign is not on the earth of the eternal reign.RH Jun 18, 1901
The passage alone does not prove enemies remain unsubdued until near the end, because no evident connection with 1 Corinthians 15:23-28 is shown; the claim that the end in 1 Corinthians 15:24 means the close of the thousand years is disputed, since the thousand years are not mentioned there and that passage places the end after His coming without identifying it as their termination.RH Apr 10, 1856RH May 5, 1874
The thousand-year period does not describe Christ's iron rule over enemies; that breaking occurs before and in immediate connection with His coming when nations are broken and enemies made footstool, with no warrant extending it a thousand years, and He will not continue priestly work then for converting sinners, for His priestly rule on the Father's throne will end.RH Aug 14, 1856RH Jun 2, 1910
One position held is that the Lord comes to a wicked world to destroy the impenitent, raise the righteous and reign personally with saints upon earth a thousand years, as apostolic doctrine taught by John to disciples; another held is that the millennial kingdom is literal upon earth renovated by fire to Eden state before general resurrection and judgment, with purification not at His coming but a thousand years after at destruction of the ungodly.RH Sep 30, 1862RH Sep 30, 1862
One position reads prophecy literally as Christ coming before the thousand years to renew earth and establish kingdom there gathering saints to reign as kings and priests, without explaining the rest during or after; another identifies the millennial kingdom as begun with Christ's appearing in the Catholic Church in visible earthly form, though true blessedness belongs to the future.RH Jan 2, 1913RH Oct 7, 1862ST Jun 30, 1914RH May 21, 1914
The teaching of millennial reign connected with the coming was accepted by early Christians but later treated as allegory and rejected as heresy in Constantine's era; expectation faded after his conversion when Christian theocracy as state religion was represented as divine government on earth.RH Feb 10, 1863ST Jun 30, 1914
The verse belongs to the primitive apostolic millennarian faith generally prevalent in the early church, held by Papias, Nepos, Sulpicius and Victorinus, which the council at Rome under Damasus in 376 censured as heresy and suppressed, so that primitive faith is now almost banished, accounting for unpreparedness and loss of original Protestant faith.RH Sep 30, 1862RH Sep 30, 1862
The thousand years were placed by some as beginning under Constantine with their own time in the little season after before final judgment, leaving no hope for world conversion previous to His coming and looking next for His coming to judge; Rome perverted primitive faith which revived with Scripture light, while prophecies were mistakenly applied by a temporary movement near the close of the tenth century which did not fulfill the judgment message.RH Sep 30, 1862RH Sep 30, 1862RH Jan 6, 1874ST Jan 2, 1879
The claim that personal coming occurs only after the thousand years is an opponent's view treating them as symbolic and calculating 365,000 years by day-year, and some likewise interpret prophetically as 365,000 years giving no explanation of the rest or first resurrection.RH Mar 30, 1869ST Jan 28, 1875
At the second appearing God sets up the kingdom where Christ begins a 1000-year reign on David's throne with immortalized saints over unbelieving rulers and subjects granting probation and salvation in the Age to Come; preaching this against the desolate-earth teaching of the Third Angel's Message causes decline and leads away with denial of that message.RH Aug 28, 1856RH Aug 7, 1856
The verse was taken to mean a thousand-year age after the Lord comes and after great destruction when few nations left receive probationary time with ministry, temple, beast sacrifices, feast of tabernacles, and mortals and immortals mingling, yet neglecting commandments and gospel now gains no benefit, so present truth must be attended now.
The first resurrection as raising sleeping saints with changing of living righteous and destruction of worst wicked leaves no middle class neither righteous nor wicked surviving as left of nations in mortal probation with twelve tribes under Christ in Jerusalem with immortal cabinet, and gives no further ages beyond with dead raised by decades for new probation.ST May 10, 1883
There is no probation or mixed millennium after the Lord comes in which immortal righteous preach to mortal sinners; prophecy describes the fourth beast's final destruction not conversion, with no existence beyond until second death.ST Jul 23, 1874
The claim that only a small part of the saved with special faith rise in the first while many other saved rise in the second is Mormonism and error, and the verse allows no new probation or later salvation after the advent.RH Sep 2, 1873
In dispute whether Christ and immortal saints will reign on earth among kingdoms including heathen and tribes, no Scripture was presented to establish it, since Revelation 5:10 offered does not specify when begins or how long lasts.RH Mar 13, 1856
The passage does not teach a thousand-year personal reign upon earth, and to appeal to it for that is false theory, heresy and false doctrine belonging to interpreters not the book; it has been spiritualized to mean long gospel expansion, submission, peace and progress after which Christ would come, replacing personal return.ST Nov 28, 1878ST May 10, 1877
The thousand years teach no temporal millennium yet before Christ and judgment, no return of Jews to build Jerusalem, and no coming to live a thousand years before destroying the wicked, and give sinners no future time or delay to repent, so to use them as shield brings false peace and ruin and repentance must be immediate.RH Sep 20, 1853
There is no millennium of world conversion before coming, and the thousand years close before final judgment with little season between; the verse does not mean conversion and peace, as overcrowded accumulating millions with no place to set feet disprove it, and the unconverted will not then be converted but dark terrible period lies between present and glory.ST Jan 9, 1879RH Sep 30, 1862RH Jan 23, 1866
The verse rejects a golden age before resurrection and return; time before judgment is instead marked by deception, waning faith, conflict and tribulation, and millennium prophecy has not begun in a world marked by greed, sweatshops and oppression which mark last days pointing to soon return.RH Jan 10, 1907ST Apr 25, 1900
Its context does not teach the world converted during a thousand years after gospel preached, and cannot delay the end beyond worldwide proclamation; the gospel preached to all nations as witness, then the end comes, not a thousand years later, against a thousand-year worldwide conversion before the end.ST Mar 22, 1883RH Nov 30, 1869RH May 1, 1855
It belongs to teaching about thousand years against the claim the world is improving toward a coming millennium of righteousness; the millennium is not peace and righteousness produced by civilization and gospel before advent, as God's Word presents the contrary.ST Jan 10, 1900ST Mar 30, 1876
The millennium is not a period when all are brought into church, against lax teaching; transformation to millennial purity is not the church's work in the present world and cannot be brought while workers act selfishly and deceitfully.ST Aug 10, 1882RH Feb 10, 1863RH Jun 9, 1868
The millennium is not a present age of righteousness just at hand, nor about to begin through progress; pulpit portrayal of approaching millennium while world improves and gospel nears triumph is contradicted by decline in respect, corruption and warnings of national decline.RH Apr 16, 1908RH Mar 1, 1860RH Feb 17, 1874
The popular theory of temporal millennium just about to begin is contradicted by continued devotion to evil and neglect of gospel; present greed, London's death, Sabbath labor, drunkenness, impurity, gambling, theft and madness, brutal crime with depraved reading, show corruption not fitness.RH Jun 21, 1864ST Jun 3, 1913RH Dec 27, 1870ST Jan 18, 1883
The verse teaches no approaching millennium of universal conversion; that idea is fabled, with prevailing irreligion, crime, intemperance and immorality among young men showing no approach, and rapid skepticism proves the opposite that peril not betterment is at hand.RH Jun 16, 1863ST Jun 17, 1889
The thousand years are not present calm peace among nations; craze for war, preparations, strained relations, and large armies with Italy 400,000, France 700,000, England 220,000, Austria 650,000 and Germany larger, plus over a billion heathen against few professed Christians, show conflict far from future peace when swords become pruning-hooks.ST Jan 14, 1875ST Jan 30, 1901ST Dec 14, 1904ST Mar 10, 1898
The millennium is not already dawning through wealth or progress, since luxury alongside misery disproves it; few thousands gained abroad while millions apostatize, rising crime, corruption, weapons, church emptiness with less than one-fortieth attending, and persecution of quiet Sabbath-keepers fined, seized and imprisoned at Basel, show it still future not at hand.RH Jul 29, 1873ST Feb 14, 1884ST Aug 23, 1910ST Oct 8, 1894RH Nov 19, 1903
The millennium does not dawn before probation closes for the whole family, and has not dawned in Africa as small proportion converted after scores of years proves; with large numbers outside influence and slow evangelization it is still long way off.ST Nov 18, 1903ST Mar 4, 1889
Expectation of temporal millennium rests on counting Catholics, Muslims, Buddhists and enlightened heathen as Christians, or claiming it begins when world converted and joins church as strongest power; if nations merely declared themselves Christians that would be counted as proof.ST Jan 15, 1885ST Dec 28, 1888ST Jun 28, 1883
The millennium is pictured as universal profession where every adult is member or candidate, arriving sooner through doctrinal unity and consolidation separate from politics; its claimed arrival when boss-ridden cities like Cincinnati and New York are reformed is reported as triumph through united church influence, population and power.ST Jan 3, 1905ST Feb 4, 1913ST May 24, 1883
The verse is linked to expectation of thousand years following union of Man of Sin with Empire; that period did not follow but Dark Ages came when Beast was loosed against God's people, for millennium cannot occur before Christ comes nor coexist with Man of Sin to be destroyed by brightness, its predicted period having ended.RH Apr 24, 1856
The verse belongs to the millennium at center of disagreement, with elder looking for temporal millennium filling earth with knowledge while others longed for soon coming rejecting delay for thousands of years.ST Apr 18, 1878LS 164.2–166.1
The verse concerns whether Christ will come personally for at least a thousand years placing them before personal coming; a brief seasonal pause in European fighting is mockingly inadequate example of temporal reign of peace and safety.ST Mar 31, 1887ST Jul 19, 1883
The verse was taken to mean a temporal millennium just upon us with glorious reign near whether temporally or spiritually as personal appearance for destruction of ungodly and gathering of saints, with Midnight Cry sounded as probation just run out and closing work done with lightning speed.RH Nov 8, 1864
The future millennium had not yet come but was approaching, with peace movement and 1907 council as signs of hoped temporal result; Wesley was quoted that claimants of nearness would soon appear truthful.ST May 8, 1907RH May 6, 1858
The future thousand years of peace will not be seen to begin by people then living, its arrival neither immediate nor near; the thousand-year kingdom imagined by advocates of enforced religious laws would postpone the real coming at least that long.ST May 8, 1907RH Feb 11, 1873
The thousand years were not already past at the Volney meeting and that claim was error; nor did the millennium begin in 1874, against the claim all dead rise together for postmortem offer, for the two resurrections are separated with Satan bound and destroyed after, and second death not limited to living wicked at His coming.LS 247.2–248.1ST Aug 22, 1878RH Dec 20, 1864ST Feb 6, 1896
A cited commentary associated the passage with millennium beginning in 1866, 1,260 years after rise of temporal power in 606.
The verse is associated with popular view of millennium as ceasing wars and evils so population grows longer raising whether earth could sustain increase, and with differing claims Christ will come to restore and subdue earth with immortal saints as priests in the age to come.ST Jan 9, 1879RH Dec 11, 1855
German temple colonies believed land restored, temple rebuilt and temporal millennium ushered, welcoming Palestine prominence as steps; yet the verse tells positively when thousand years begin, events during and marks of close, and does not mean conversion of world or return of Hebrews to land.ST Jan 18, 1899ST Sep 16, 1897ST Aug 19, 1897ST Aug 26, 1897
The verse predicts peace continuing a thousand years followed by declension when Satan loosed deceives nations then the end, making time knowable and proving time prophecies understandable before fulfilment; the coming period may follow Armageddon and general war with semblance to expected golden age yet wholly different from universal peace politicians, socialists and Christians expect.RH Oct 13, 1874RH Nov 1, 1853ST Aug 5, 1897
The verse belongs to the thousand-year period of blessedness or Paradise restored following advent not preceding, with premillennial personal appearing and reign against popular conversion and spiritual reign; during it judgment is rendered including decree Satan brought to ashes, earth restored from chaos, wicked ceasing while meek inherit.RH Jan 9, 1872ST Apr 22, 1875ST Apr 1, 1875ST Nov 18, 1913
The verse belongs to millennial prophecy of primitive Protestant faith that kingdom is established after ruin of Antichrist; it is also said the millennium is brought by church revival when church and state unite with political enthusiasm, foreshadowed by Sacramento Sunday-law enthusiasm.RH Oct 7, 1862ST Sep 14, 1882
It belongs to passage about millennium and first resurrection relevant to claim kingdom already realized in Catholic Church though true blessedness is future; its arrival is a future claim churches united with world will falsely announce.RH May 21, 1914ST Nov 30, 1882
The idea of thousand years of peace after war replenishing inhabitants is what people proclaim not God's promise, among last-days sayings Micah heard from nations; discussion contrasts it with human effort building a kingdom for Christ to rule a thousand years.ST Sep 12, 1895ST Jun 2, 1898ST Jun 9, 1898
The verse is invoked for claim the world will be converted into millennial peace, a misleading peace-and-safety song lulling to carnal security; teaching such temporal millennium before coming is rejected, for diffusion of infidelity will continue until the Lord ends it as sign of approach.RH Aug 12, 1862ST Sep 22, 1898RH Apr 21, 1874
The verse is misused when linked to thousand years and advent timing to imply Christ will not come until thousand years pass and world converted; if world converted the millennium would come making unclear how glorious appearing could be expected at same time.RH Oct 21, 1862
The verse does not support a temporal millennium before the end; Christ will instead return in glory, and teaching this millennium before the Lord comes is rejected as old fable.LS 33.2–34.1RH May 1, 1856
The thousand years stand at the beginning of the Lord's coming, at which living wicked are slain not converted during, so the verse does not describe gradual conversion after He appears; the rest returning only after is used to reject gospel going forth during the thousand years to second death.RH Mar 27, 1856ST Apr 14, 1887
The thousand-year reign is not on earth with saints administering government while earthly life and commerce continue and Christ only visits with Jews preaching; His coming destroys sin forever not prolongs it under rule, and Abraham's inheritance could not be fulfilled during mortal dying, with definite when and where different from popular view.RH Nov 25, 1852ST May 13, 1903ST Jan 22, 1902
The claim kingdoms destroyed only after reign is rejected; destruction of governments occurs at second coming at thousand years' beginning, raising whether desolation is at advent or purifying fires at end.RH Dec 23, 1862RH Jan 26, 1860
The reign comes after triumph of beast and image and reception of mark on pain of death, which are past when reign begins, the two periods not same time; saints keeping commandments still endure persecution with patience liable to death before coming, receive immortality at last trumpet, then live and reign, with blessing on those dying in Lord before first resurrection.RH Aug 14, 1856ST Jun 15, 1882RH Dec 9, 1851RH Jan 23, 1855
Worshipers of beast die at beginning, dead not sharing first resurrection remain dead during and are made alive at end to face lake, only sharers saved; punishment of worshipers is at second resurrection after thousand years leading to second death.RH Sep 11, 1856RH Aug 7, 1856
British advocates combined biblical teaching with mixed probation and mortality alongside glorification and expected Jewish return to Christ and Palestine during millennium; yet after first resurrection at personal advent all Israel will be saved and gathered to rest, the one remaining gathering, so no gathering of carnal Jews to Palestine before or after.RH May 29, 1856RH Sep 24, 1857
The verse does not make weekly Sabbath sign or type of thousand-year rest; that use is great error with nothing to support, for Sabbath as sign means only God sanctifies and made heaven and earth in six days resting seventh, and claiming Sabbath type of seventh thousand is inconsistent with saying it could cease at cross before antitype.RH Feb 24, 1859RH Nov 13, 1856
It is connected with glorious seventh thousand as future rest which weekly Sabbath does not typify since instituted before fall independent of ministration; it concerns seventh millennium rest in new earth, so first-day sign would place rest in eighth thousand, linked instead to seventh-day sign.RH May 13, 1862RH Jun 12, 1855RH Aug 23, 1870
The Sabbath is presented as type of future rest in seventh millennium fulfilled when Christ comes to give endless life, without explaining distinction between first resurrection and rest; identification of Lord's day with thousand years is rejected since John saw future in vision but was not in future period not yet arrived.RH Apr 5, 1864RH Aug 5, 1852
The second coming introduces the millennium, bringing not peace and safety but vengeance, cruel wrath to desolate land and destroy sinners; the millennium accompanies advent and great tribulation foretold for latter days.ST Feb 20, 1879ST Aug 20, 1902
The millennial period stands before heavenly eternal state as transition and prelude; its work is among events connected with second coming before final setting up of everlasting kingdom in earth made new.ST Jul 21, 1881RH Mar 4, 1909
The thousand years come after completion of gospel work of restoring earth expected about six thousand years, as rest in heaven; the verse belongs to earlier part portraying first judgment work and blessed outcome of first resurrection.ST Mar 11, 1913ST Aug 17, 1915
The millennium comes after coming of Son in clouds with Armageddon among winding-up events, nothing withholding coming; its beginning follows end of age and advent with accompanying judgments.RH Mar 31, 1863
The verse belongs to detailed last-day account in Revelation 15-20 ending with sorrow over, Lord come and redeemed entering home, placing thousand years after coming during judgment when earth lies waste until creation delivered; it sets forth millennium and saints in judgment as events of Great Day in connection with coming, among kindred subjects of return, end, judgment, man and armaments.ST Jan 20, 1904RH Sep 30, 1915ST Sep 22, 1898
The verse presents advent, righteous resurrection, millennium and final destruction as prophetic truths later spiritualized; truth of two resurrections belongs with personal coming before millennium and renewed earth as inheritance.ST May 2, 1916RH Jul 2, 1861
The chapter teaches Christ will return personally visibly, resurrect dead, judge world and establish everlasting kingdom in renewed earth, with believers' immortal resurrection as blessed hope; the passage is basis for personal reign before millennium taught after rejecting Napoleonic fulfilments.RH May 21, 1914RH Feb 6, 1855
The passage concerns second coming and thousand-year reign linked to hope He will return, subdue kingdoms, raise dead and reign before final judgment, in which elect reign, evil bound and peace fulfilled; it is promise of future age when good triumphs over apparent failure.ST Nov 5, 1885RH Oct 7, 1862RH Sep 5, 1865ST Jun 14, 1877RH Jan 23, 1872
The verse belongs to vision of millennium before judgment whose events are actual predictions not imagination; it belongs to order of coming, millennium and new earth where fulfilled predictions assure still future will be fulfilled, proving advent before millennium and kingdom possessed after judgment forever not only a thousand years.ST Mar 31, 1914RH Oct 22, 1861RH Apr 23, 1857RH Jan 17, 1871
It belongs with kindred subjects including second coming, time of end, judgment, nature of man and arming of nations; it concerns millennium with resurrection, coming, life only in Christ, destruction and reward.ST Jan 20, 1904RH Sep 30, 1915RH Dec 19, 1907
It belongs to clear truth about millennial reign while many other teachings are vagaries; it gives martyrs hope though sacrificing lives they will find them, reign and receive rich reward.RH Aug 23, 1864RH Jun 18, 1914
The verse was taken to show Christ living on earth with people during thousand years near at hand with just and unjust in view, personal reign after sifting bringing reformation and restoration of Israel, and reign with saints after judgment on purified fitting earth.RH Apr 8, 1873RH Jan 3, 1865RH Nov 16, 1869
The verse was taken to show two conditions among dead: spirits reigning with Christ to be honored, venerated and prayed to for favors through intercession, and souls not pure enough helped toward rest, refreshment and life by sacrifices and prayers.RH Jun 28, 1870
It has been claimed the first resurrection comes after thousand years in union with God withstanding final deception, that thousand years begin at appearing as earthly reign with conversion, that years are prophetic with moral resurrection past and universal peace begun before advent, and variously thousand years past or future and wicked raised or not and righteous mortal or immortal without resolution.RH Apr 11, 1865
Sources