Romans 13:4
For he is the minister of God to thee for good. But if thou do that which is evil, be afraid; for he beareth not the sword in vain: for he is the minister of God, a revenger to execute wrath upon him that doeth evil.
For he is the minister of God to thee for good. But if thou do that which is evil, be afraid; for he beareth not the sword in vain: for he is the minister of God, a revenger to execute wrath upon him that doeth evil.
Commentary part 2 of 2
Pioneers and periodicals (continued)
Christian Duty to Rulers
Christians are to recognize civil rulers as ordained for good, to be subject to the higher powers, to honor them, pray for them, respect what has been ordained, show courtesy and deference to constituted authority, obey rulers and laws, do good in order to have praise rather than fear, render tribute and custom, pay taxes, and render fear and honor, while not speaking evil of rulers and not turning faith into support for political power or conquest.RH Jul 31, 1860ST Mar 19, 1896ST Oct 31, 1895 This duty follows the example of Christ, who recognized Caesar and submitted to Rome even under illegal arrest, trial and execution.ST Mar 19, 1896 It holds even under a corrupt heathen government like Rome, because even evil government is better than anarchy and mob rule, yet it does not require compromising truth in teaching or example.ST Mar 19, 1896
Submission is owed even to ill-treatment, unjust demands, unequal treatment and unreasonable levies of tribute, taxes or service, without rebellion, and even when rulers are as oppressive as pagan Rome or Turkey.ST Jan 9, 1896ST Nov 28, 1895 Such obedience is not servile service from fear, money, reward, policy or expediency, but for conscience sake and for the Lord's sake.ST Mar 19, 1896ST Jan 9, 1896 True Christians bear the yoke with humility and forbearance and leave all vengeance for wrongs suffered to the Lord instead of seeking vengeance through other earthly powers, and by such obedience enjoy greater freedom.ST Nov 28, 1895 Law-abiding people need not fear the lawful exercise of police power by representatives of law and order put in place for good, such as a city mayor, and Christians of every nationality must uphold proper authority and show respect for its representatives even when they think rulers are wrong, doing no more than warning them, and must have no sympathy with the spirit of anarchy that hisses, jeers, insults and disobeys magistrates.ST Oct 23, 1901
Obedience is limited to lawful matters and rightful civil jurisdiction, for civil authority is meant to restrain evil not good, to administer justice according to the moral law, to protect its subjects, and to punish those who do evil with a sword that is not empty, and it gives no warrant for enacting or enforcing evil.RH Jul 31, 1860RH Jun 8, 1916RH Dec 16, 1862RH May 9, 1865RH Oct 28, 1862 When civil law requires violating God's law or conscience, including Sabbath observance, Christians must obey God rather than men.RH Jul 31, 1860RH Jun 8, 1916RH Dec 16, 1862RH May 9, 1865RH Oct 28, 1862 Then they are to refuse the commanded wrong, calmly explain their position, refuse force, and patiently accept the penalties while remaining committed to righteous principles, without rebellion, resistance by force, plotting, conspiracy, or unwise words of criticism that would class them as lawbreakers or sympathizers with evildoers.RH May 9, 1865RH Oct 28, 1862ST Jun 26, 1884ST Jan 9, 1896
Even where a solemn promise before the Lord constitutes true marriage between a man and a woman and God, the couple must still make it public and of public record through the formal ceremony that custom and law require for the good of wife, children and society.ST May 4, 1904 People may enjoy the benefits of civil law, including legal protection for property and organization, as long as doing so does not require sacrificing duty to God.RH Jan 10, 1865 They may pledge loyalty to the national government and obedience to town council by-laws and orders as part of regulating the community, and they should conform to government in temporal matters while retaining religious freedom.ST Nov 26, 1894ST Mar 11, 1913 The true scope of obedience to the United States is decided by what it would require, such as whether it requires killing a fellow man in war when required by that authority and whether it requires remanding a fugitive to slavery when acting as a commissioner, with the nature of the commanded obedience learned from the tendency of the actions it would require.RH Apr 28, 1859 Paul's respectful conduct toward Felix models the same balance, for he did not take it upon himself to judge those outside the church but spoke with respect for the governing authorities as judge while plainly addressing righteousness and coming judgment.ST Feb 19, 1885
Christians themselves ought to need no government but the government of God, and they are to be subject to the powers that be rather than to rule other people or to set up an earthly Christian government or Christian nation by human power, since any such attempt puts them in distrust of God's government.ST Aug 3, 1904 Civil government exists in providence to restrain evil and protect life and property in an evil world, with force necessary to maintain it in civil things, yet civil governments are not Christian and war is not Christian, and the ultimate judgment of government rests with God not with Christians.ST Jun 9, 1898 It is therefore not the mission of Christians to criticize government but to turn men from selfishness to love and from the worship of man to the service of God, best serving fellow men, generation and country by never fighting with earthly weapons, since in Christ love is the all-powerful force.ST Jun 9, 1898 Christianity favors government over anarchy and good government over bad, setting forth the true Christian citizenship which God approves, which must be known and made known to others and which the young cannot learn too soon.RH Aug 12, 1902 Proper instruction in Christ's teaching should lead disciples to obey the law without needing a special appeal, while disregard for law fosters strife rather than peace.ST Jul 16, 1894
Punishment War and Death
The sword gives earthly governments legitimate military power and force to uphold law and order, to defend rights, to enforce decrees and to execute justice when necessary, and the rightful use of that force is not murder.RH Sep 23, 1862RH Oct 14, 1862RH Oct 14, 1862 Civil rulers serve for the good of the people by protecting those who do good and punishing those who do evil, and aiding them with force in that work is not inherently wrong.RH Sep 23, 1862RH Oct 14, 1862RH Oct 14, 1862 Civilized warfare and capital punishment are not violations of the sixth commandment, for rulers may take life under certain circumstances by authority from God as executors of His will without being murderers or impeaching His goodness.RH Oct 14, 1862RH Mar 19, 1861 That permission does not grant private persons the right to take the sword or to imitate acts God performs, and submission to rulers rests both on fear of punishment and on conscience, connected with paying taxes for their public service.RH Oct 14, 1862RH Mar 19, 1861
Lawful execution of a murderer proved beyond all question guilty is not breaking Thou shalt not kill but the penalty appointed in this life for breaking it. That penalty checks further transgression because the executed man cannot repeat the crime and others are restrained from it, and it is defended as a scriptural safeguard against premeditated murder and a just distinction and deterrent for murder.RH Feb 19, 1867 Civil governments in this dispensation have the same right as in any other to take life for murder, with the right and duty to protect their own existence and the rights of their subjects, so that if the death penalty is needed in that work it is justified.ST Feb 27, 1896 The threat of punishment is meant to make evildoers afraid, government must not excuse or sympathize with crime, and its authority to punish, including by execution, is not empty.ST Sep 18, 1884RH Feb 19, 1867
The sword as a deadly weapon includes authority to impose the death penalty, and that authority does not extend to matters of religion or conscience where obedience to God takes precedence over human rulers.ST May 14, 1896 It also supports punishing the leaders of rebellion rather than allowing them to go unpunished through leniency.RH May 23, 1865 A sheriff who executes a murderer and a soldier who defends the government against rebellion are distinguished from the murderers they punish or resist, so defending civil institutions is not murder.RH Apr 18, 1865
When rulers carry out the duty of punishing wrongdoing they restrain evil, but when they reward crime or shield criminals they reverse their role and become a threat to good conduct.ST Oct 30, 1884 When courts fail to punish serious wrongdoing, government no longer serves as a deterrent, public security is weakened, and the failure can encourage further violence and provoke private retaliation.ST Jul 16, 1885 Courts and officers of law are appointed for good to be a terror to evildoers by executing the law, including statutes against evil such as the traffic in liquors on Sunday, and when officers patrol in full view of illegal dram-shops and lager-beer saloons without remonstrance while law is systematically violated and contemned, they have ceased to be a terror to evildoers and society verges toward barbarism where rum rules the city.RH Feb 3, 1859
Authority to use the sword to punish evil belongs to the state, not the church, so Christians may not take up arms to defend civil government but may wield the sword of the Spirit, which is God's word.RH May 30, 1865 Submission to civil authority and respect for rulers and obedience to laws apply only when those laws do not conflict with God's word, and therefore do not include bearing arms or engaging in war, which is contrary to Christ's teachings and God's law.RH May 28, 1867 Disputes among believers should be brought before competent people in the church, the church itself, or its ministers, rather than settled in courts before unbelievers, with church discipline including removing a wicked member carried out according to Scripture and the testimony of two or three witnesses by those who judge with Bible testimony.RH Jul 10, 1856
Christians are not to act as censors over the ruler's decisions, though they may regret those decisions and their consequences.ST Feb 15, 1899 Man must not undertake to become God's avenger by force, for God Himself is the avenger against evil.ST May 13, 1903 Men should appeal to God to make men better by purifying hearts, instructing minds and awakening conscience, while civil government should only protect them in that work and not put forth its strong arm to punish violations of God's law, such as forcing keeping the first day holy or stopping carrying mail, opening post offices or receiving letters on Sunday, since one who undertakes to become God's avenger becomes ferocious and unrelenting under religious zeal.ST Feb 15, 1899ST May 13, 1903
Church State and Application
Church and state are distinct institutions with separate spheres, each a blessing when kept independent, for civil power is ordained to protect rights irrespective of class or belief and to punish uncivil conduct, while the church gathers people from sin to salvation with authority direct from Christ.ST Apr 10, 1884ST Nov 21, 1895ST Jan 27, 1890 Their union is a virulent poison in the body politic that undermines the dearest and most sacred rights, turns America away from liberty as the cradle of liberty, violates conscience and brings persecution, and enables the state to punish Bible Christians at the church's direction while the church defines approved religion.ST Apr 10, 1884ST Nov 21, 1895ST Dec 25, 1901 Civil government holds its own rightful position to guard political liberty separate from religious liberty, distinct from the perfect theocracy, looks after things civil and has no religion, since religion belongs to individuals, and any attempt to unite them repudiates a fundamental principle of Christianity proven by twenty-five centuries of Bible history.RH Jun 18, 1908ST Jan 27, 1890RH Mar 26, 1908ST Dec 25, 1901
Civil authority must not use its power to require religious duties, punish religious opinions, decide who may teach, enforce Sunday observance, or compel church attendance, for such work lies outside the minister's appointment to civil good.ST Oct 18, 1899RH Mar 23, 1905RH Oct 10, 1907ST Dec 5, 1895 Compelling attendance, purging amusements and Sunday labor, newspapers and excursions to fill churches, enforcing Sunday laws, and prosecuting heresy for preaching where forbidden pervert faith, require sin, produce hypocrisy, oppression and contempt for law, and do not bring God's kingdom, since God accepts only willing service and conscience must not be compelled even for the genuine Sabbath.ST Oct 18, 1899ST Mar 30, 1882ST Dec 5, 1895 The contrary use that would punish heresy and religious practices judged to produce practical evil, denying that appeals to conscience shield offenders, stands against this limit.ST Aug 27, 1894
Luther's invoking of the ruler's sword against Anabaptist dissent, treating religious dissent as punishable resistance to authority, is a papal form of religious intolerance.RH Jun 4, 1908 The doctrine of direct divine right holds that the pope received immediately from God full power in spiritual and temporal things, that the temporal ruler is only the pope's official receiving the temporal sword from him to be used in conformity with divine order, and that the pope may deprive him of it when used against that order.ST Jun 30, 1914
Civil government is limited to man's relation to fellow men and to earthly government, to restrain uncivil things for good, while religious duties belong to God alone.ST Sep 8, 1914 When civil laws and penalties enforce religious duties regardless of conscience and put a man or system in God's place as vicegerent, that perverts God's order by the enemy of righteousness; when churches use civil law to enforce reforms, that power brings oppression and persecution, and using sword-bearing power to restrict liberty of conscience and decide who may teach brings defeat upon the oppressor and enslaves his own soul.ST Sep 8, 1914ST Jan 9, 1901
The divinely ordained duty to protect every person in natural, God-given rights includes protecting liberty to worship or not worship so long as neighbors' equal rights are not infringed, and protecting liberty to keep the brain normal and remain sober with proper use of mind.ST Jul 18, 1916 The liquor traffic hourly invades millions' right to remain sober, wrecks liberty, reason and property, menaces society, destroys homes, property and lives, degrades wives, children and youth, burdens taxation, and exposes families to degradation and death, so suppressing it is the state's first duty and the state has unquestionable right to eradicate the saloon and mete out corporal punishment to invaders of rights.ST Jul 18, 1916ST Jul 18, 1916ST Sep 1, 1914ST Nov 24, 1881ST Sep 1, 1914 It was never ordained to legalize traffic in bodies and souls or to grant immunity and cooperation to what trenches upon others' right to remain sober, and giving legal permission contradicts its purpose; only thus is protection assured to the household against a drunken husband and father, to the weak against the strong, and to the minority against the majority.ST Sep 1, 1914ST Nov 24, 1881RH Apr 3, 1913 Its authority to punish supports this protection, not making men moral or directing faith, which belongs to the church.RH Apr 3, 1913
Lawful authority belongs to orderly government and courts, not to private lawless groups claiming to enforce God's law, nor to mob action seizing authority, nor to selfish combinations expressing intolerance when another's liberty does not promote temporal advantage.ST Oct 29, 1912ST Feb 4, 1889RH Aug 29, 1907 Dynamiting, flogging, burning, destruction of property, death threats and violence by farmers' associations, labor unions, trusts and intolerant religious bodies are lawlessness at variance with divine and civil law, marking waning spirituality and loss of faith in God, requiring the faithful to set the face toward the city of God.RH Aug 29, 1907 Occupations fostering incivility and disregard for rights should be prohibited at all times and places, not treated as legitimate on some days and criminal on others.ST Jan 24, 1906
Rulers serve God by administering just laws for good within the proper civil sphere between people, without extending to faith and worship, and are accountable to God for official duties according to principles of right and justice.RH Feb 1, 1906 Though the people may choose holders of power, the ruler must serve all rather than favor the electing majority at the minority's expense, and rewards and punishments are necessary and just with punishment rightly inflicted on wrongdoers to restrain rebellion against rule.RH Feb 1, 1906RH May 23, 1871 The magistrate's appointment gives direction and limits, calls subjects to honor governors and servants to obey, defends rights of all, brings punishment on defaulters, overreachers and trespassers, and carries blessing and protection for those living by God's rules.ST Jul 22, 1875RH Mar 30, 1869
Civil power must be kept totally separate from the church with no religious legislation, including no civil enforcement of Sabbath observance, while upholding religious freedom and Christians conscientiously observe the Sabbath themselves and stand for civil and religious liberty.RH Jun 19, 1913 Government looks after things civil and has no religion, and stating the church's attitude toward civil government accords with recognizing and honoring those in authority, praying for their health and success in promoting peace, prosperity and welfare.RH Jun 19, 1913RH Mar 26, 1908RH Jun 8, 1905
The purpose for which the powers are ordained defines the present relation of church and state as proven by Bible history, calls for reverence without requiring subjects to adopt rulers' religion since religious authority comes from God not princes, and shows Adventist work explaining duty to government to be not dangerous.RH Jan 14, 1909ST Sep 9, 1889ST May 28, 1912ST Jan 27, 1890 That civil good is connected with civil and religious liberty and reform, as pointed to in Mexico under growing Protestant influence.ST Jun 18, 1894
Keeping human laws that do not conflict with God cannot make people spiritually righteous nor teach God's law by unaided effort; true change comes from a cleansed heart and the mind of Christ.ST Jan 30, 1901 When faith in the Bible as God's Word is lost, the binding claim of both God's law and the law of the land sits lightly, people become hard to reach with the gospel, give themselves to pleasure and grasping worldly things as the only world expected, let self drive them to excess, and decreasing church gain and rising criminality follow wherever unbelief is taught.RH Feb 15, 1912
Stopping a preacher in the name of public order while tolerating other disturbances and harmful conduct uses civic power against gospel preaching rather than consistently for good, contrary to the servant's appointment to punish wrongdoing.ST Sep 11, 1884 Opposition to all civil governments contrasts with that God-given role for people's good.RH Nov 19, 1857
Civil authorities ordained by God are to be submitted to in lawful matters, which supports using civil laws and provisions for truth and temporal concerns, with rulers honored only so far as duty to God allows.RH Aug 28, 1860 The magistrate is appointed for people's good with authority to punish, giving direction to magistrates, placing limits on rulers, and calling subjects to honor and servants to obey, presenting authority as service for good not unlimited power.ST Jul 22, 1875
Loyalty to human government within its proper sphere accords with loyalty to God's government, and disregard for God's principles undermines the conscience needed for civil loyalty.ST Jul 23, 1894 Respect for God's law supports civil law and order while rejecting it encourages disloyalty, irreverence and lawlessness, so government acting within civil law and order deserves support, though oppression and wrongdoing are not defended.ST Jul 16, 1894
The minister's work is simply to forbid uncivil acts interfering with person, property or character, going that far but no farther without trespass, leaving faith and religion to the individual.ST Sep 2, 1889 Rulers enforce laws against acts harming others and duties citizens owe one another, with real authority to punish evil limited to protection, not compelling duties owed to God, and may interfere with uncivil robbery of property or rights even when wrongdoers profess to be God's spokesmen and ambassadors, dealing with them as with others, without authority to direct religious teaching and work.ST Jun 5, 1884ST Oct 16, 1901
Christianity sanctions civil government as promoting human happiness and virtue, without making religion its basis or requiring it to train people religiously, and the state as God's servant for civil good was not appointed to teach God's law.RH Mar 9, 1905ST Nov 13, 1893 A nation may not establish a legal Sabbath demanding obedience for conscience sake; people must remain free to obey God's law, and conscience must not be compelled even for the genuine Sabbath, since civil governments were ordained to protect rights of men not religious institutions.ST Jan 24, 1900ST Dec 5, 1895
Civil ministry for good is protection of human rights to life, liberty and pursuit of happiness already bestowed by God under a second and lower charter beneath Jehovah's higher charter in creation.ST Oct 27, 1914 God's ordering power works through people and rulers to restrain anarchy, preserve order, protect civil and religious liberty regardless of citizenship, praise good and bring wrath on evil.ST Jun 17, 1897
Government serves God by restraining acts threatening life and property and providing peace and safety through civil punishment, yet cannot create inward morality or change the heart.ST Feb 22, 1910 Its work is outward conformity to human law, distinct from inward conformity to God's law and righteousness; civil law may even conflict with moral principles and punishes disobedience without regard to repentance, while officers enforce rather than preach, and outward obedience has no value apart from heart religion.ST Sep 4, 1893ST Feb 22, 1910 The state restrains evil through laws protecting lives, property, character and reputation, distinct from the church's spiritual work of warning against sin and saving through the gospel, and distinct from compelling voluntary obedience to moral law, for the sword is not borne in vain to protect others' rights against murder and robbery.ST Jan 23, 1893ST Feb 27, 1901
A justice of the peace as minister for good finds that good does not include swearing warrants, committing cases or hearing prosecutions for Sunday violations; such work lowers the office's dignity and is mean, so a true magistrate will hear no more Sunday cases and pronounce the procedure unconstitutional.RH Apr 29, 1909 Courts established by God preserve order outwardly, not produce righteousness inwardly, and using outward force to make men righteous perverts justice and causes loss of respect.ST Jul 19, 1905
The civil magistrate keeps peace in the state while the gospel minister preaches and baptizes, each with a distinct legitimate sphere under God that need not conflict when each remains within it, and this divine appointment establishes the state's freedom and independence from the church.ST Nov 11, 1889 A government acting civilly protects all alike regardless of creed and does not persecute for belief through laws or courts; persecution arises when civil power joins legalized religion.ST Jun 20, 1911
Civil government restrains wrongdoing and protects equal civil rights concerning civil harms, not religion or the heart, protecting each person's freedom to worship or not worship by conscience without prescribing worship or religious days.ST Jul 18, 1900 Its wholesome laws restrain wrongdoing and encourage virtue for present life, liberty and property applying equally to all, restraining vice without directing duty to the Creator, which is governed by reason and conviction before God's judgment, safeguarding property, life, chastity and reputation.ST Jul 17, 1907ST Jun 18, 1912ST Apr 21, 1909 It was ordained to protect natural rights and free exercise of conscience provided equal rights of others are not invaded, not to abridge rights of a class or minority even of one man, so religious legislation is class legislation invading divine rights, and using law to privilege a religious institution turns authority from its purpose to injustice.ST Nov 23, 1915ST Feb 11, 1897
Obedience is owed to laws protecting equal natural rights for the Lord's sake, not merely from fear, giving government its due without conflict with faith.ST Nov 19, 1896ST Nov 5, 1896ST Nov 26, 1896 That authority applies to laws needed for protection and does not require obeying human enactments conflicting with obedience to God in conscience.ST Nov 5, 1896ST Nov 26, 1896
Government authority concerns civil conduct protecting rights and restraining actions endangering life or property, not religious convictions or worship unless their exercise threatens those rights.ST Jul 30, 1894 It restrains outward selfish acts and punishes wrongdoing without compelling worship, since conscience belongs to a separate domain, using physical force over outward acts unlike Christ's spiritual kingdom which judges the heart by choice and love rather than force.ST Jul 30, 1894
The state's unquestionable right to eradicate the saloon rests on hourly invasion of millions' right to remain sober with proper use of mind, which it is divinely bound to protect.ST Jul 18, 1916 Civil law cannot make people moral or shape character, and treating moral reform as the state's work leads to religious control; it may compel outward civil conduct but cannot produce chosen spiritual obedience to the Decalogue and Golden Rule, which reform comes through God's Spirit, while the church preserves and proclaims the gospel without wielding civil power.RH Apr 3, 1913ST Jun 21, 1899ST Feb 13, 1901
City rulers such as a mayor represent law and order for good to preserve order, so the law-abiding need not fear police power, and Christians of every nationality must uphold proper authority and respect representatives even when deeming them wrong, doing no more than warning them, with no sympathy for anarchic hissing, jeering, insult and disobedience.ST Oct 23, 1901 The same power to punish not in vain as retribution supports orderly courts against mob seizure of authority and punishing leaders of rebellion and lawlessness rather than leniency letting them go unpunished.RH May 23, 1865ST Oct 29, 1912
Coercive power is needed where people do not yield to God's Spirit to restrain the lawless and uphold good, compelling outward conduct only within its reach, while those guided by the Spirit do just laws from inward principle even unseen without needing compulsion. The government's threat restrains the selfish who would violate rights, while Christians respect rights because love governs not fear of penalty, and its punishing authority targets evil actions and uncivil conduct protecting all classes, not opinions themselves.ST Mar 5, 1894ST Jul 22, 1897 Earthly government necessarily relies on authorized force with the sword while people remain unregenerate, unlike heaven's government of love, as a temporary necessity from sin to maintain order while redemption gathers the willing to God's law of love.ST Apr 23, 1894ST Mar 29, 1905
Civil law should protect good and restrain evil rather than be exploited by technicalities so wrongdoers escape to harm others, requiring juries and justice to make evildoers fear.ST Nov 10, 1881 The sword is not empty, for one who deliberately kills may face the prescribed penalty including execution in protection of citizens and punishment of wrongdoing.
Sources