Romans 13:4
For he is the minister of God to thee for good. But if thou do that which is evil, be afraid; for he beareth not the sword in vain: for he is the minister of God, a revenger to execute wrath upon him that doeth evil.
Translations
For he is the minister of God to you for good. But if you do that which is evil, be afraid; for he bears not the sword in vain: for he is the minister of God, a revenger to execute wrath on him that does evil.
For he is the minister of God to thee for good. But if thou do that which is evil, be afraid; for he beareth not the sword in vain: for he is the minister of God, a revenger to execute wrath upon him that doeth evil.
for he is the minister of God to thee for good. But if thou do that which is evil, be afraid; for he beareth not the sword in vain: for he is the minister of God, a revenger to execute wrath upon him that doeth evil.
For he is the minister of God to thee for good. But if thou doest that which is evil, be afraid; for he beareth not the sword in vain: for he is the minister of God, an avenger to execute wrath upon him that doeth evil.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
for he is a minister of God to thee for good. But if thou do that which is evil, be afraid; for he beareth not the sword in vain: for he is a minister of God, an avenger for wrath to him that doeth evil.
for of God it is a ministrant to thee for good; and if that which is evil thou mayest do, be fearing, for not in vain doth it bear the sword; for of God it is a ministrant, an avenger for wrath to him who is doing that which is evil.
for it is God's minister to thee for good. But if thou practisest evil, fear; for it bears not the sword in vain; for it is God's minister, an avenger for wrath to him that does evil.
For, God’s minister, is he unto thee for that which is good. But, if, that which is evil, thou be doing, be afraid! For, not in vain, the sword he beareth; for, God’s minister, he is,—an avenger, unto anger, to him who practiseth what is evil.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
For he is God’s servant for your good. But if you do wrong, be afraid, for he does not carry the sword in vain. He is God’s servant, an agent of retribution to the wrongdoer.
for he is a servant of God to you for good. But if you do that which is evil, be afraid, for he doesn’ t bear the sword in vain; for he is a servant of God, an avenger for wrath to him who does evil.
For he is the servant of God to you for good. But if you do evil, have fear; for the sword is not in his hand for nothing: he is God's servant, making God's punishment come on the evil-doer.
For he is ye minister of God for thy wealth, but if thou do euill, feare: for he beareth not the sworde for nought: for he is the minister of God to take vengeance on him that doeth euill.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
For he is God’s minister to thee, for good. But if thou do that which is evil, fear: for he beareth not the sword in vain. For he is God’s minister: an avenger to execute wrath upon him that doth evil.
Cross-references 20 of 30
- 1 Peter 2:13-14
Submit yourselves to every ordinance of man for the Lord’s sake: whether it be to the king, as supreme;
Both texts teach submission to rulers appointed to punish evildoers and commend good conduct.
- Matthew 22:21
They say unto him, Cæsar’s. Then saith he unto them, Render therefore unto Cæsar the things which are Cæsar’s; and unto God the things that are God’s.
tribute is due to Caesar as God's minister
- Acts 5:29
Then Peter and the other apostles answered and said, We ought to obey God rather than men.
states the limit to civil obedience
- Titus 3:1
Put them in mind to be subject to principalities and powers, to obey magistrates, to be ready to every good work,
Both urge believers to obey and submit to civil authorities.
- 1 Timothy 2:1-2
I exhort therefore, that, first of all, supplications, prayers, intercessions, and giving of thanks, be made for all men;
Prayer for rulers supports a quiet and peaceable life under their authority.
- Mark 12:17
And Jesus answering said unto them, Render to Cæsar the things that are Cæsar’s, and to God the things that are God’s. And they marvelled at him.
Jesus distinguishes what is due to civil authority from what is due to God.
- Romans 12:19
Dearly beloved, avenge not yourselves, but rather give place unto wrath: for it is written, Vengeance is mine; I will repay, saith the Lord.
Christians leave vengeance to God, while the state bears authority to punish evil.
- Exodus 20:13
Thou shalt not kill.
Government punishment, including execution, does not violate the commandment against killing.
- 1 Peter 2:14
Or unto governors, as unto them that are sent by him for the punishment of evildoers, and for the praise of them that do well.
Governors are sent to punish evildoers and praise those who do good.
- Genesis 9:6
Whoso sheddeth man’s blood, by man shall his blood be shed: for in the image of God made he man.
It gives the basis for civil punishment of bloodshed.
- Luke 20:25
And he said unto them, Render therefore unto Cæsar the things which be Cæsar’s, and unto God the things which be God’s.
Jesus distinguishes what is due to Caesar from what is due to God.
- 1 Peter 2:17
Honour all men. Love the brotherhood. Fear God. Honour the king.
Commands honor to the king and submission to civil authority.
- Ecclesiastes 8:11
Because sentence against an evil work is not executed speedily, therefore the heart of the sons of men is fully set in them to do evil.
Delayed punishment can embolden people to do evil.
- Acts 4:19
But Peter and John answered and said unto them, Whether it be right in the sight of God to hearken unto you more than unto God, judge ye.
The apostles question whether human authority should be obeyed over God.
- Matthew 26:52
Then said Jesus unto him, Put up again thy sword into his place: for all they that take the sword shall perish with the sword.
Jesus’ warning against taking the sword distinguishes the church from civil force.
- John 19:10-11
Then saith Pilate unto him, Speakest thou not unto me? knowest thou not that I have power to crucify thee, and have power to release thee?
Christ acknowledges that the governor's authority comes from heaven.
- Jeremiah 27:8
And it shall come to pass, that the nation and kingdom which will not serve the same Nebuchadnezzar the king of Babylon, and that will not put their neck under the yoke of the king of Babylon, that nation will I punish, saith the LORD, with the sword, and with the famine, and with the pestilence, until I have consumed them by his hand.
God uses rulers to punish evildoers.
- Jeremiah 27:6
And now have I given all these lands into the hand of Nebuchadnezzar the king of Babylon, my servant; and the beasts of the field have I given him also to serve him.
Nebuchadnezzar serves God in his civil role.
- Hebrews 13:17
Obey them that have the rule over you, and submit yourselves: for they watch for your souls, as they that must give account, that they may do it with joy, and not with grief: for that is unprofitable for you.
Extends the same subjection to church officers.
- 2 Peter 2:10
But chiefly them that walk after the flesh in the lust of uncleanness, and despise government. Presumptuous are they, selfwilled, they are not afraid to speak evil of dignities.
Condemns despising government and reviling rulers.
Commentary part 1 of 2
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
15 sources
Civil rulers are ministers of God for good, appointed to serve and praise those who do good and to promote the welfare of the people.STA 31.1STOM 25.1Lt 1f, 1890, par. 3–4 They do not bear the sword in vain, but have real authority to restrain and punish wrongdoing, so that those who do evil have reason to be afraid of lawful punishment.STA 31.1STOM 25.1STBk 31.1 Obedience to human government is a sacred duty within its proper civil sphere, to be given peaceably in all things where it does not conflict with the law of God.ST Jun 29, 1882AA 68.2–69.19T 238.4 The word of God is supreme above all human legislation and earthly powers, so when the claims of government conflict with the claims of God, obedience to God comes first.ST Jun 29, 1882AA 68.2–69.19T 238.4 In fulfilling its highest purpose civil government can have no union with religion or the church, with nothing to do with religion and no religion in its statute books.DA 837.1–2AA 68.2–69.1
Purpose of Civil Authority
Civil rulers are ministers of God for good, appointed to serve those who do right, to give praise to those who do good, and to promote the good of the people.STA 31.1STOM 25.1STBk 31.1ST Jun 29, 1882SG4 201.1 Their office is not empty or without purpose, but carries real responsibility to uphold what is right for the benefit of those under their care.STOM 25.1Lt 1f, 1890, par. 3–4STBk 31.1 Even when the law of God is made void, this appointment still stands, calling for no defiant spirit toward earthly powers but for hearts fully surrendered to God with zeal rising to meet the emergency in warm, decided, positive and unflinching testimony.STA 31.1STOM 25.1Lt 1f, 1890, par. 3–4 Obedience within this order means being peaceably subject to the laws of the land so long as those laws do not conflict with duty to God, since obedience to God comes first and civil authority is not absolute.ST Jun 29, 1882SG4 201.1
The ruler does not bear the sword in vain, but bears it as an instrument of punishment with real authority to restrain and punish wrongdoing.STA 31.1STOM 25.1STBk 31.1ST Jun 29, 18821T 362.1–363.1 As minister of God and revenger to execute wrath upon the evildoer, he makes those who do evil have reason to be afraid of lawful punishment and its consequences.STA 31.1STOM 25.1STBk 31.1GC 191.2–3 This fear is purposeful, checking unchecked passions that would otherwise sink men further into evil and requiring rulers to exercise a higher controlling power to repress wrongdoing.ST Jun 29, 18821T 362.1–363.1GC 191.2–3 To throw off this restraint under pretense of throwing off oppression, to denounce all order and declare obedience to princes to be divided loyalty, and to claim divine sanction for breaking away from all control to give rein to prejudice and passion unto sedition, strife and bloodshed, is rebellion against civil authority condemned by this appointment.1T 362.1–363.1GC 191.2–3
The state is ordained by God because of sin, and were there no sin there would be no reason for its existence.DA 837.1–2 Its mission is solely to preserve order and protect men from violence by preventing evil by evil-minded persons through fear of penalties.DA 837.1–2 Acting in its own sphere it is always useful and will remain so as long as sin exists, with God ordaining the state in general according to the demands of its period and place.DA 837.1–2 God still has to do with the laws of the land, working through human laws and rulers as His ministers to restrain evil, and while Jesus is in the sanctuary His restraining Spirit is felt by both rulers and people.SG4 201.11T 362.1–363.1 Since Satan controls the great mass of the world to a great extent, without the laws of the land unchecked passions would sink men further into evil and God's people would suffer greatly, so rulers must exercise a higher controlling power to repress wrongdoing.SG4 201.11T 362.1–363.1
Limits of Civil Jurisdiction
Human government exercises proper jurisdiction only within its legitimate civil sphere when it attends to its own affairs in a civil capacity.DA 837.1–2AA 68.2–69.1 In meeting its highest purpose it can have no union with religion or the church, with no religion in its statute books, no recognition of the church, and nothing to do with religion.DA 837.1–2 Obedience to it is a sacred duty within that sphere.AA 68.2–69.1
People are to be peaceably subject to the laws of the land and to conform in all things to the laws of the state when obedience can be given without conflicting with the law of God and with duty to God.ST Jun 29, 1882AA 68.2–69.19T 238.4 The word of God remains supreme authority above all human legislation and above earthly powers.AA 68.2–69.1 When the claims of government conflict with the claims of God, obedience to God comes first, for the crown of Christ is above earthly powers and a Thus saith the Lord is not to be set aside for church or state.ST Jun 29, 1882AA 68.2–69.1
Civil authority is not absolute, since obedience to God comes first.ST Jun 29, 1882 Throwing off the yoke of the papacy does not remove the restraints of civil authority, for princes and civil authorities remain ministers of God for good, bearing the sword to punish evil, and are to be obeyed.GC 191.2–3 To denounce all order and to declare that to obey princes is to serve both God and evil is false teaching.GC 191.2–34SP 150.1–2 To claim divine sanction for breaking away from all control and giving rein to prejudice and passion, leading to rebellion and sedition and strife and bloodshed, is rebellion against civil authority condemned by the verse.GC 191.2–34SP 150.1–2
Loyalty in Word and Deed
Submission to civil authority does not call for a defiant spirit toward earthly powers and does not mean antagonism to law and order.STA 31.1STOM 25.1Lt 1f, 1890, par. 3–4STBk 31.1AA 68.2–69.1 The ruler is a minister of God for good, appointed to give praise to those who do good and to bear the sword not in vain as a revenger to execute wrath upon evildoers, so that those who do evil have reason to be afraid.STA 31.1STOM 25.1STBk 31.1 Because that authority to punish wrongdoing is real and not empty, respect is due even when God's law is threatened or made void.STA 31.1STOM 25.1Lt 1f, 1890, par. 3–4STBk 31.1 In such a time words spoken or written are to be carefully considered, and nothing is to be said or done that would unnecessarily close the way.AA 68.2–69.1 Hearts are to remain fully surrendered to God while zeal rises with the emergency.STA 31.1Lt 1f, 1890, par. 3–4
Even when the law of God is made void, the true and loyal are to give a more warm and decided, positive and unflinching testimony.STA 31.1Lt 1f, 1890, par. 3–4 Even when truth is forbidden by men, the truths committed in trust are still to be advocated in Christ's name.AA 68.2–69.1 The ruler is Heaven-appointed and chosen by God to execute His law for good and to be a terror to evildoers, and David held that office as leader of the nation.PP 718.1 When in ease and self-security he let go his hold upon God and yielded to Satan, he trampled the very precepts he was appointed to enforce.PP 718.1 By his own guilty act he, instead of being a terror to evildoers, strengthened their hands.PP 718.1
The same principle reaches managers and department leaders in institutions, who are placed by God in positions of trust and honor and must be respected and honored.7T 185.3–186.1 Confidence is due their judgment about what regulations are essential, and respect is due their authority to maintain order and wisely discipline youth.7T 185.3–186.1 Loyalty to them belongs to the foundation principles of loyalty to truth, to fellow beings, and to God, which children must never be taught to treat lightly.7T 185.3–186.1 Parents and church members are to uphold their hands by teaching youth to submit to discipline, by refusing to blindly sustain children against their superiors, and by going directly to those in authority to learn the truth in any difficulty.7T 185.3–186.1 Behind the sword of justice stands God Himself as the eternal, universal guardian of justice, personally concerned in every action toward fellow men and present so that no one can escape Him.RCOC 39.3
He takes part against every act of wrong against another, whether high or low, rich or poor.RCOC 39.3 He spreads His own hand as a shield over the rights of brother toward brother.RCOC 39.3 To wound or bruise the soul or rights of a brother is therefore to strike against the hand of justice that holds the sword.RCOC 39.3
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
190 sources
God has ordained civil rulers as his servants for the good of the people, giving them real coercive power with deadly force to punish wrongdoing, so that they are a terror to those who do evil and a praise to those who do good.ST Jun 5, 1884ST Mar 19, 1896RH Jul 4, 1854ST This government of force became necessary after the fall when selfishness destroyed self-control and love for neighbors, and it was ordained as a temporary restraint to preserve order during probation without regard to the religion of ruler or people.ST Feb 14, 1911ST Mar 19, 1896ST Oct 17, 1895ST Oct 17, 1895 Its work is outward and civil, to protect life, property, reputation, liberty and homes, to restrain violence and crime, and to guard the equal rights of all, especially the weakest.ST Mar 6, 1907ST Jun 18, 1912ST Jul 19, 1905ST Dec 23, 1903 That authority is limited to relations between people and to outward conduct that harms others, and does not extend to conscience, faith, worship or the heart, nor can it make people moral or righteous.RH Aug 13, 1908ST Oct 18, 1899ST May 28, 1912ST Sep 4, 1893 Christians are therefore to respect, honor, pray for and be subject to rulers, paying taxes and doing good, yet when civil law requires violating God's law they must obey God rather than men and patiently accept the penalty without rebellion.RH Jul 31, 1860ST Mar 19, 1896RH Jun 8, 1916RH Dec 16, 1862 The sword authorizes force, warfare in defense of rights, and even lawful execution of the proved murderer, but it gives no authority to compel religion or punish belief, for the state uses carnal force while the church works by preaching and persuasion, and their union perverts both.RH Sep 23, 1862RH Oct 14, 1862STST Apr 10, 1884
Words and Symbols
The one called minister in the verse is one who serves as God's agent, and the word so translated is elsewhere rendered servant or deacon.RH Nov 7, 1854 The sword is the civil ruler's power to use physical, coercive, deadly force to punish wrongdoing for the public good.STST Apr 1, 1897 It is not entrusted to the state without purpose, and the ruler bears it to bring punishment upon evildoers so that those who do evil have reason to fear.STST Apr 1, 1897 That civil sword is a worldly, physical weapon imposing penalties according to the offense, distinct from the church's work which uses spiritual means rather than carnal weapons to preach the gospel, persuade, forgive, or excommunicate.STST Dec 24, 1912ST Mar 5, 1894 By contrast God's ministers in the church wield the sword of the Spirit, which is God's word, for correcting disobedience under God's law.RH Jul 10, 1856 The ancient sword was a weapon of war, and in modern times bullet-firing weapons serve the same function of enforcing government decrees when necessary.ST Apr 1, 1897
To bear the sword not in vain means the ruler's authority to punish is real and not empty, purposeless, or without effect.RH Feb 1, 1906RH Jul 10, 1856ST Aug 22, 1911ST Aug 13, 1896 Those who do right need not fear but may receive approval and encouragement, while those who do evil should be afraid because the power to execute judgment carries its penalty with it.RH Jul 10, 1856ST Aug 22, 1911ST Aug 13, 1896RH Oct 19, 1916 The ruler in this office serves God for the good of those under care by protecting people, promoting good conduct, and opposing evil.RH Feb 1, 1906RH Oct 19, 1916 As God's agent the ruler carries out wrath and retribution against wrongdoing.RH Feb 1, 1906RH Oct 19, 1916 The ruler is therefore set forth as an avenger executing punishment against those who do evil.ST Jun 5, 1884ST Mar 19, 1896RH May 23, 1865 That office commends those who do right and is a terror to those who do evil rather than to good works, so that a government that does not restrain evildoers cannot encourage or honor those who do right.ST Mar 19, 1896RH Jul 4, 1854ST Apr 21, 1881RH Apr 21, 1859 The magistrate is not to terrorize those who do good but to be a terror to wrongdoers, and the continuing use of temporal penalties against criminals and against leaders of rebellion rather than leniency belongs to this God-given office.RH Jul 4, 1854RH May 23, 1865RH Apr 21, 1859
The verse belongs to the instruction of Romans 13:1-7, joined to the teaching to render to Caesar what belongs to Caesar in order to render to God what belongs to God.ST Oct 31, 1895ST Mar 5, 1894 It upholds two distinct realms, a civil realm of this world concerning ordinances of men and relations of citizens where earthly rulers are supreme, and a religious realm concerning ordinances of God where God is supreme.ST Oct 31, 1895ST Sep 16, 1889 In the proper sphere of civil affairs earthly rulers are God's ministers to promote peace among men by being a terror to evildoers and a praise to those who do well, so that tribute and honor remain due to them.ST Oct 31, 1895ST Sep 16, 1889 Debts owed to God cannot be paid to Caesar nor debts owed to Caesar paid to God.ST Oct 31, 1895 The civil work is limited to outward conduct of man to man and to society, protecting outer life, property, chastity, honor, and home, while the higher moral government takes cognizance even of thoughts and intents of the heart and preaches forgiveness; the two works aid each other but are not one.ST Sep 16, 1889
Origin and Setting
Civil government was ordained by God as a temporary government of force and physical restraint to preserve order and security during the probation of a sinful world, ordained without reference to the religion of the people or of the ruler, even under pagan Rome.ST Feb 14, 1911ST Mar 19, 1896 It serves God's purpose of preserving people from the anarchy caused by sin, restraining evil and protecting life and property in an evil world, with force necessary to maintain it in civil things.ST Feb 14, 1911ST Jun 9, 1898ST Sep 16, 1889 It is divinely appointed to promote temporal welfare, distinct from spiritual good, and exists as a delegated authority to carry out God's will on earth through the laws of the nation.ST Jun 23, 1914ST Sep 16, 1889 Its authority is to be respected and honored while it remains within civil bounds, for even evil government is better than anarchy and mob-rule, but it must not take God's place and God is not responsible for human perversions of it.ST Feb 14, 1911ST Jun 9, 1898 Christians are therefore to recognize it, be subject to the higher powers not only for wrath but for conscience sake, do good to have its praise, pay tribute and custom, and render fear and honor, even as Christ recognized Caesar and submitted to Rome under illegal arrest, trial and execution.ST Mar 19, 1896 The respect required does not mean compromising truth in teaching or example, and when civil power oversteps its proper bounds and interferes with duty to God its requirements must be disregarded, but even then with deferential courtesy and without unwise criticism that would class believers as lawbreakers or sympathizers with evildoers.ST Feb 14, 1911
Government became necessary after the fall, when people lost self-control, reverence and love for God and love for neighbors and became selfish.ST Oct 17, 1895ST Oct 17, 1895 Abel's murder illustrates the resulting lack of self-control, and as men increased with the idea that liberty meant self-exaltation the stronger dominated the weaker, so that bondage of spirit begat bondage of person and a restraint upon the anarchistic nature of fallen man was needed.ST Oct 17, 1895ST Jul 7, 1898 Had man not sinned the mind of Christ would have worked through all lives and no one would have been disturbed in enjoying his rights, but sin brought rebellion against divine government, dominion of Satan, turning of liberty into license, and enmity between men so that they denied to others the rights they themselves enjoyed.ST Oct 31, 1916ST Jul 7, 1898 To help man God ordained that even while in rebellion against God man should be protected in his rights, and so instituted civil government as government among men and by men and for men for good.ST Oct 17, 1895ST Oct 31, 1916 Its proper work is to be a terror to evil, not to good, protecting people and property and restraining wrongdoing, with real authority to punish so that those who do evil should fear consequences as rulers act as agents executing punishment on wrongdoers.ST Oct 17, 1895ST Oct 17, 1895
No particular form of government or class of rulers was specially ordained, for civil government exists to protect God-given rights, not to grant them, and its authority is limited to relations between people and does not include a right to compel people in matters that concern only themselves.RH Aug 13, 1908 Though the people may choose who holds power, the ruler must serve all the people rather than favor the majority that elected him at the expense of the minority, being God's minister appointed to serve the public good and responsible to God for administration of office.RH Feb 1, 1906 The king's authority is bounded by law and must act under law, not personal will, for law makes him king and he can exercise power only through lawful means.ST Aug 7, 1901
The laws of nations are supposed to rest on the Bible's principles of moral action, while the gospel itself is not a political program but teaches principles that make people better under any government.ST Jul 27, 1882 Civil government is God's ordinance for the suppression of wickedness and the promotion of morality and religion, requiring that people be taught the fear of the Lord and be awed by the authority of His law and the fear of His judgments, with swift and certain punishment following the prostitution of government into taxing the public and dividing the spoils.RH May 2, 1871RH Mar 19, 1867 The secular theory of government diminishes the sense of responsibility to God and helps cause political corruption.RH May 2, 1871 A nation's laws cannot simply be called God's laws to give its institutions divine authority or to make God responsible for its laws.ST Aug 5, 1897
In Rome the sword-power to punish, banish, or put to death was claimed as ultimate authority in affairs of religion, with Caesar as head of the state religion and director of worship.ST Jul 4, 1899 Patriotism and religion were united as one, so that refusal to honor the gods was unpatriotic as well as irreligious, and even the person of Caesar was declared sacred.ST Jul 4, 1899 The subject was treated as the property and slave of the government in mental, physical, and religious life, so religious liberty was unknown and the worship of Jehovah was permitted only because the gods of a subject nation were made part of the deities of the realm.ST Jul 4, 1899
Civil government is not God's ideal, and the history of governments proves it has failed to meet God's standard.ST Oct 31, 1916ST Jul 23, 1894 Like every other gift of God in the hands of sinful men it was perverted, rulers became tyrants, and when government itself violates equal rights it fails in its proper purpose though it remains necessary in humanity's fallen condition.ST Jul 7, 1898ST Jul 23, 1894 Human struggles for liberty produced only temporary, superficial victories and reversals of conditions while bondage still prevailed.ST Jul 7, 1898
Divine Purpose for Good
The ruler is God's minister for the good of the people and of those under care, with authority to punish wrongdoing that is real and not empty, so that people should pray for rulers, pay taxes, and render fear and honor while obeying God's law.RH Jul 31, 1856RH May 10, 1906RH Jun 17, 1909 Civil officers serve for the good of society and the preservation of social order, and those who do good need not fear their power, without becoming part of the world's company or wielding the sword themselves.RH Jul 31, 1856RH Jun 17, 1909 Civil powers are moved in favor of God's people by the Holy Spirit, angels and loyal men, and are used to defend them against unjust government even in spite of the adversary.ST Aug 4, 1909 When God's people depart and do evil, protection is withdrawn and they are left to the power of government, so that the ruler does not bear the sword in vain but punishes them, and when nations become so far removed that they cannot respond to these influences in behalf of His people, they cease to exist and are condemned to overthrow.ST Aug 4, 1909 Whether the description applies without limit or only to righteous rulers is set beside this, since a ruler might require God's children to break the commandments.RH Sep 23, 1862
Its God-given work is outward preservation of order, not inward production of righteousness, and when outward force is used to try to make men righteous, justice is perverted and respect for courts is lost.ST Jul 19, 1905 It protects natural and individual rights between people, including life, property, reputation, chastity, liberty and homes, maintains public order and ordinary peace and safety, and provides roads, bridges, schools, defense and protection from violence through laws, courts and prisons, which makes paying taxes a proper way to give government its due.ST Mar 6, 1907ST Jun 30, 1909RH Oct 28, 1862RH Oct 23, 1913ST Feb 22, 1910 Its authority, including punishment for wrongdoing, applies only within the civil sphere assigned to it and does not extend to directing worship, conscience, faith, or other religious duties that belong to God.ST Mar 6, 1907ST Jun 30, 1909 It cannot create inward morality or change the heart, so that in matters of moral character outward obedience has no value apart from heart religion.ST Feb 22, 1910
It restrains people who would otherwise violate others' rights for selfish ends, curbs uncivil conduct, holds in check floods of evil deeds, deters crime and encourages well-doing, so that breaking the law invades others' rights and tolerating it would destroy government's protections.ST Jun 18, 1912ST Mar 5, 1894ST May 28, 1912 Its threat of punishment restrains the selfish, while those governed by love respect rights from principle rather than fear of penalty, and those guided by God's Spirit do what just civil laws require from inward principle even when no human observer is present, without needing compulsion.ST Mar 5, 1894 Its coercive power is needed where people do not yield to God's Spirit, and it can compel outward conduct only while people are within its reach. Its authority to punish is not empty and should make evildoers fear consequences, as shown when a king rightly punished men who conspired against life, while courts that fail to punish serious wrongdoing weaken public security, cease to deter, and encourage further violence and private retaliation.ST Jun 18, 1912ST Jan 13, 1898ST Jul 16, 1885
Its penalties are for civil and national purposes in this life, distinct from the final penalty of God's law reserved for judgment.RH Apr 23, 1872 It punishes crime carried into practice such as theft and murder growing out of covetousness, hate and greed, but cannot punish evil thoughts alone, cannot make people cease being covetous or hateful, does not demand righteousness but only civility, and does not punish sin but only crime.RH Oct 23, 1913STST It can demand no religious duty or service toward God, cannot enforce requirements that are voluntary, and cannot invade the sacred right of choice without violating divine principles.RH Oct 23, 1913 It guards and defends the individual, even the weakest and the minority, in equal rights with all others, conserving human rights, protecting the weak and securing equal liberty for all rather than oppressing people or governing for party or class.ST Dec 23, 1903ST Jan 23, 1907 It does not bestow those rights and does not exist to uphold systems or doctrines apart from men, but to protect man in rights given by the Maker, so that conservation of the rights of the one means conservation of the rights of all, with the greatest good to the greatest number as the result, and maintaining this equality upholds stability while destroying it presages ruin.ST Dec 23, 1903ST Dec 23, 1903
When earthly governments refuse to protect men and the church rejects saving men, both must be set aside and Christ must come to render justice and judgment, bringing destruction on those who ignored His way and salvation to those who trust in Him.ST Dec 23, 1903ST Feb 22, 1910 The state remains an important institution ordained for correction of evildoers and protection of those who do well, yet evil is marshaled against it in open national life, with integrity broken down, offices becoming prey of scheming men, votes bought and sold, franchises and special privileges purchased with gold wrung from a suffering people, legislation forced to protect the public from privileged classes and the money power, conflict between capital and labor become acute, and commercial competition turned into struggle for mastery, wealth, ambition and very existence, even while parties still hold men of integrity and scores in trust seek in the fear of God to stem the tide.RH Feb 23, 1911 Statesmen who restrain evil and work to prevent war and hold evil in check serve as instruments giving people time to repent and prepare for return.ST Apr 11, 1900 Leaving debts unpaid violates the great law of love behind the second table and must not be, requiring careful reading followed by doing and not hearing only, including small sums owed for periodicals and publications amounting to eight thousand dollars due.RH May 30, 1871
Limits of Civil Power
Civil authority is limited to relations between people and to outward conduct that harms others, including taking life or property, protecting individual rights and maintaining public order, and its authority to punish wrongdoing applies only within that civil sphere God assigned it.RH Aug 13, 1908ST Oct 18, 1899ST Mar 6, 1907 It does not extend to conscience or the soul, to duties or relationship to God, to faith, worship, observance, or other religious duties that belong to God, nor to the heart, and no particular form of government or class of rulers was specially ordained.RH Aug 13, 1908ST Oct 18, 1899ST Mar 6, 1907ST Mar 19, 1894 People are not bound to obey rulers when they act contrary to God's will, and submission to earthly powers is limited to their rightful civil jurisdiction.ST Jul 17, 1907ST Apr 11, 1878 Its coercive power such as the sword belongs to the state's work of enforcing justice and serving the public good, not to the church's religious mission, and the verse does not authorize government to control religious belief.RH Mar 26, 1914
It can force outward conduct but cannot change the heart, thoughts or motives, cannot make a person submit inwardly to the divine, and cannot make people moral or righteous.ST May 28, 1912ST Sep 4, 1893ST Mar 11, 1897ST Jun 21, 1899 Its work is outward conformity to human law and temporal good through restraint and punishment in human affairs, distinct from morality as inward conformity to God's law and righteousness and distinct from the church's spiritual work of teaching salvation.ST Sep 4, 1893ST Mar 11, 1897ST Jun 21, 1899 Civil officers enforce the law rather than preach or persuade people to do right, civil law may even conflict with moral principles, and its punishment follows disobedience without regard to repentance.ST Sep 4, 1893 Civil laws may compel outwardly civil conduct but cannot produce the chosen, spiritual obedience required by the Decalogue and the Golden Rule, and that reform comes through the Spirit of God.ST Jun 21, 1899ST Sep 11, 1901 The state has no right to punish any violation of God's law as sin, to inquire or dictate whether a man serves God, or to enforce even the last six commandments as the law of God, and it can in nowise enforce the tenth, since God's law reaches purposes and motives of the heart.ST Apr 14, 1898
It punishes crime carried into practice such as theft and murder growing out of covetousness, hate and greed, and thereby holds in check floods of evil deeds, but it cannot punish evil thoughts alone, cannot make people cease being covetous or hateful, demands civility rather than righteousness, and does not punish sin but only crime.ST Jun 11, 1912RH Oct 23, 1913ST Apr 3, 1901 Sin as a matter of conscience or religion is judged by God, while the state as judge over those who wantonly invade rights to person, life, property, chastity, reputation and liberty uses force and fear of punishment to compel people to refrain from evil deeds.ST Jun 11, 1912RH Oct 23, 1913 Its authority to punish wrongdoing is not for vindicating the divine law but for safeguarding human rights, and fear of summary punishment restrains those who will not heed conscience.ST Apr 3, 1901 When the state deals with killing, stealing and like wrongs it acts only because the offender is uncivil, not because he is irreligious and has broken God's commandment as such, with account for irreligious principle belonging to God as Supreme Judge at the last great day.ST Apr 14, 1898 Man must not undertake to become God's avenger by putting forth the strong arm to punish violations of God's law, such as forcing keeping the first day holy or stopping mail and post-offices on Sunday, but should appeal to God to make men better by purifying hearts, instructing minds and awakening conscience, while civil government only protects them in that work.ST May 13, 1903
Civil government exists to protect God-given rights, not to grant them, and its ministry for good is simply the protection under a second and lower charter of the human rights to life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness already bestowed by God under the higher charter of Jehovah's voice in man's creation.RH Aug 13, 1908ST Sep 1, 1914ST Oct 27, 1914 That divinely ordained duty includes protecting liberty of choice to worship God or not to worship so long as equal rights of neighbors are not infringed, protecting liberty to keep the brain in normal condition and remain sober with proper use of the mind, and protecting the free exercise of conscience provided there is no invasion of equal rights.ST Jul 18, 1916ST Nov 23, 1915 In harmony with that duty the state has the unquestionable right to eradicate the saloon and suppress the liquor traffic as a great menace, because that traffic hourly invades the right of millions to remain sober and trenches upon protection for the household, the weak and the minority.ST Jul 18, 1916ST Sep 1, 1914 It was never ordained to legalize traffic in the bodies and souls of boys and girls, and it cannot by divine right legalize by legislation a traffic which by its very nature enables the trafficker to wreck liberty, reason and property.ST Jul 18, 1916ST Sep 1, 1914 Government was not ordained to abridge the rights of a class or minority, not even of one man, so religious legislation is class legislation and an invasion of divine rights.ST Nov 23, 1915
The sword is not entrusted to the state in vain, and the ruler acts as a revenger executing wrath on evildoers through lawful force to punish wrongdoing, deter crime and administer civil law.STST This civil authority has a distinct task from the church, which is to preach the gospel, warn against sin, offer mercy and forgiveness to those who confess and truly repent, save people through the gospel, and use spiritual means rather than carnal weapons.STSTST Apr 14, 1909 Civil law and punishment do not make people righteous or reform them spiritually, and mixing these roles defeats the purpose of civil authority and leads to punishment for religious belief rather than civil crime.ST Apr 14, 1909ST Feb 13, 1901 The state governs outward conduct toward one another, not thoughts or relation to God, so Caesar's force is not to be used to put religious teaching into effect, since the church's work is to persuade hearts rather than compel them and to preserve and proclaim the gospel without wielding civil power or directing political affairs.ST Feb 13, 1901ST Sep 16, 1889
Whether the description of the ruler as God's minister for good applies without limit or only to righteous rulers is raised, since a ruler might require God's children to break the commandments.RH Sep 23, 1862 Human government is fallible and cannot override the claims of God, so citizens should submit unless rule conflicts with God's will.RH Jul 28, 1874ST Apr 11, 1878
The verse belongs to Paul's discussion of duties to other people, which does not list every duty in the law, and love fulfills obligations to government and fellow people.ST Aug 12, 1886ST Jul 17, 1907 Duties to neighbor are included in the command to love one's neighbor, while duties to God, including keeping the Sabbath, are included in the command to love God.ST Aug 12, 1886 Faith does not make God's law void, but true faith leads to fulfilling the law's righteousness through love.RH Feb 17, 1852
Sources