Review and Herald, Vol. 74, No. 7.

OUR WORDS

Review and Herald

Feb 16, 1897

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Feb 16, 1897

OUR WORDS.

BY MRS. E. G. WHITE.
“Lord, who shall abide in thy tabernacle? who shall dwell in thy holy hill? He that walketh uprightly, and worketh righteousness, and speaketh the truth in his heart. He that backbiteth not with his tongue, nor doeth evil to his neighbor, nor taketh up a reproach against his neighbor.” “He shall receive the blessing from the Lord, and righteousness from the God of his salvation.” Speech is the means by which thought is expressed. Rightly used, this gift is a wonderful blessing, whose power for good cannot be estimated; misused, it is a curse to humanity and a dishonor to God. “Death and life are in the power of the tongue;” “and a word spoken in due season, how good is it!”
Every uttered word exerts an influence, every action involves a train of responsibility. No one can live to himself in this world, even if he would. Each one forms a part of the great web of humanity, and through our individual threads of influence, we are linked to the universe. Christ used his influence to draw men to God, and he has left us an example of the way in which we should speak and act. A person who is molded by the Spirit of God will know how to speak a “word in season to him that is weary,” and will realize the highest human blessedness,—the joy of imparting to others the precious treasures of the wisdom and grace of Christ. But those who permit themselves to be controlled by the enemy of all good will speak words which should never be uttered.
The great want of the world is hearts in which Christ abides as an honored guest. But the meekness and lowliness of Jesus have been too hard a lesson for many to learn. The sanctifying power of the truth has not been allowed to influence them for good, bringing the emotions of the heart and the words of the lips into conformity to the will of God; and too often, while Jesus stands knocking at the door of the heart, men are so busily engaged in talking of the faults of others that they fail to grant him an entrance.
Some who profess to love Christ, cherish cruel thoughts against others; and these thoughts, with their baleful influence, flow to the world in their words. All such are more closely allied to the great deceiver than to him who said, “Blessed are the peacemakers.” Satan rules the tongues of all who give themselves into his keeping, filling the heart with envy and jealousy, and prompting the false whisper which so often causes untold misery. Those who lend themselves to his service do a work which makes him rejoice; but the angels of God weep as they see the evil that is wrought. Could those who thus give themselves up to mischief-making see how well pleasing their course of action is to the adversary of souls, they would say with the psalmist: “Deliver my soul, O Lord, from lying lips, and from a deceitful tongue. What shall be given unto thee? or what shall be done unto thee, thou false tongue? Sharp arrows of the mighty, with coals of juniper.”
There is need to close the door which now stands open in the free, unjust use of the tongue, by which the enemy so often enters. He is constantly at work, adapting himself to the various dispositions and circumstances of those whom he is seeking to entangle. That soul is in the greatest danger which, though blind to its own faults, is all too quick to make known the failings of others. If the tongue were kept as with a bridle, if the eloquence of silence were more often preserved, how many heartaches would be saved! how many souls kept from entering the dark shadow of despair and discouragement!
It is not God’s purpose that his children should isolate themselves, drawing apart from one another. In their intercourse he would have them reveal him by a patient, long-suffering, forbearing spirit, by words which cheer and encourage those that faint by the way. If we are willing to learn, Christ will teach us to manifest in our daily lives his goodness, mercy, and love. Every soul who will become consecrated to him will be a channel through which his love can flow,—an agent co-operating with divine intelligences,—and will find his happiness increased as he imparts happiness to others.
He who is your neighbor is to be earnestly sought for and labored for. Is he ignorant? let your communication make him more intelligent. Is he downcast and discouraged? let your words speak hope to his soul. Those who are defective in character are the very ones God enjoins us to help. “I am not come to call the righteous,” said Christ, “but sinners to repentance.” By the influence of words spoken from a heart full of love, the discouraged ones may become trophies of grace,—heirs of God, and joint heirs with Jesus Christ.
“Take heed to thyself,” was the charge given to Timothy. To-day this lesson is fearfully neglected by those who pride themselves upon entering the kingdom of God. Satan works untiringly to thwart the purpose of God, and he tempts the children of God to be severe upon the errors of others, while they themselves are careless in regard to their own course of action, and mingle defects with their work. There will always be something which we can criticize; but when we view things as God views them, we shall not look at the work of others with a critical eye, eager to find some flaw, but will seek to find something of which we can approve. Let him who makes criticism and faultfinding his first duty, who spends his God-given time in speaking words which sow the seeds of doubt and unbelief, take heed lest defects far more serious be found in his own character.
Be sharp and critical with yourself, for the eternal interests of your soul demand this; but do not place a stumbling-block in the way of sinners by talking of the defects of those around you. Those who love God supremely, and their neighbors as themselves, will see so many imperfections in their own work, so much that needs to be cleansed from defilement, that they will feel no inclination to dwell upon the defects of others.
Nothing is hidden from God. Says the true Witness, “I know thy works.” Every word that we speak is heard and recorded by the Majesty of heaven, who has declared, “By thy words thou shalt be justified, and by thy words thou shalt be condemned.” Could our eyes be opened, could we see the heavenly Watcher by our side, listening to the words we utter, we would strive to control our tongues; for we would realize that we were speaking in the hearing of the heavenly universe. If they are left unrepented of, we shall meet once more the bitter spirit, the revengeful feelings, and the angry words; “For God shall bring every work into judgment, with every secret thing, whether it be good, or whether it be evil.” O that men, instead of making the mistakes of others the subject of their conversation, would turn their critical glances inward, seeking power from on high to guard well their words, that in the Judgment they might stand justified in the sight of God!
Christ, the Lamb of God, can take away the desire to speak words which hurt and bruise the souls of others. His power is limitless, and if we shut ourselves in with him, we shall grow more like him. Strength will be given us to subdue the inclination to speak and judge harshly; we shall be enabled to make straight paths for our feet, lest the “lame be turned out of the way.” If we will yield heart and mind into the keeping of Christ, if we will control our thoughts, bringing them into obedience to his will, our words will be such as the angels love to hear, and will bless all those with whom we come in contact.
All who have the mind of Christ will turn away from everything tending to deformity of character. If Christ is taken as our pattern in all things, if he is formed within, “the hope of glory,” our minds will be filled with thoughts that are pure and lovely. We shall feel no inclination to think or to talk of the failings of others, or to triumph over the knowledge of a brother’s error. Mercy and love will be cherished; that charity which “suffereth long, and is kind,” which “beareth all things” and “thinketh no evil,” will appear in word and action.
The most persuasive eloquence is the word that is spoken in love and sympathy. Such words will bring light to confused minds and hope to the discouraged, brightening the prospect before them. The time in which we live calls for vital, sanctified energy; for earnestness, zeal, and the tenderest sympathy and love; for words that will not increase misery, but will inspire faith and hope. We are homeward bound, seeking a better country, even a heavenly. Instead of speaking words which will rankle in the breasts of those that hear, shall we not speak of the love wherewith God hath loved us? Shall we not try to lighten the hearts of those around us by words of Christlike sympathy? Shall we not tell of the prospective rest in store for the people of God? “A word fitly spoken is like apples of gold in pictures of silver.”
Day by day we are sowing seed for the future harvest, and we cannot be too careful of the seed which we sow by our words. Often words are carelessly spoken and forgotten, but these words, for good or for ill, are bringing forth a harvest. Sow one unkind, harsh word, and this seed, finding soil in the minds of your hearers, will spring up and bear fruit after its own kind. Sow one seed in loving, gentle, Christlike words, and it will bring you rich returns. Our minds must be carefully guarded, lest words be spoken which are not a blessing, but a curse. If by our words we sow wheat, we shall reap wheat; if we sow tares, we shall reap tares; and the harvest, whether of wheat or of tares, will be sure and abundant.

“THAT YOUR JOY MAY BE FULL.”

The new year glances brightly Into my wondering eyes, And to my trembling question Makes hopefulest replies,— “The past for sorrow; yonder Thy gladsome future lies.”
I take His hand and follow; It seems the same old way,— To-morrow bathed in glory, A misty path to-day,— The gladness of the future Seems ever gone astray.
Ah, would the mists but open And let the glory through! My longing eyes are aching For just one splendid view Of hope’s fruition—some year With joy made really new.
Joy? Joy’s a costly jewel Veined in vast depths of love; The mount of crucifixion Rises those steeps above; And those who seek it, never Shall find that treasure-trove.
Only the self-forgetting, Whose watchful, loving care Would lift the sad world’s burden And help its woes to bear,— Only the Christlike lover The crown of joy shall wear. —Mrs. S. M. I. Henry, in Union Signal.

A MILLENNIAL FESTIVAL.

  • (Continued from last week.)*
BY PROF. P. T. MAGAN.
For a few days prior to the celebration, deputations consisting of thousands of men are arriving in Paris from all parts of the empire. En route, the people have fed and housed them free, for all are brothers. Effusive is the welcome offered them at the gay capital.
Museums, monuments,—everything is open and free to these country cousins. Every one vies who shall entertain them, take them to the balls, the illuminations, the sights and pleasures of the capital. Their board and bed are spread in every house. There is a public list where the Parisians put down their names, and the number of guests their house will hold. . . . They shall not be cheated of a sou if the Parisians can help it. A “guide for strangers”—a strange guide we should call it—is expressly compiled for them. It warns them against the exorbitant charges of the hotel-keepers, at a time when so many good citizens distinguish themselves by the grandeur of their sacrifices. It warns them also against the extortions of those women, “in common circumstances named unfortunate,” and does not hesitate to add a tariff according to the neighborhood where these traffickers of Cythera may be found. And this unique and cynical price-list is publicly hawked about in the streets by little girls of eight and nine. “I do not know,” says a witness to this monstrosity, “I do not know what took place at the saturnalia of the Romans, but this I do know, that no people, ancient or modern, have ever offered anything like it in the way of unblushing corruption.”
And yet this was the inaugural of the millennium! Nay, rather, of Sodom!
At length the great day arrives. From the spot where the Bastile once stood, the procession starts for the Field of Mars. First march the deputies from the departments; next a battalion of boys, armed like their fathers, precedes the Assembly. A body of old men follow it, and thus revive the memory of ancient Sparta. Amid the shouts of the watching throngs, the procession crosses the Seine on a bridge of boats, strewed from end to end with flowers. Amid the salvos of artillery, the Champ-de-Mars is entered through a triumphal arch decorated with patriotic inscriptions. In the center of that vast amphitheater, is a magnificent altar—“the altar of the fatherland.” Beside it is a huge platform upon which the king, the royal family, the Assembly, and other notables take their seats.
And now Talleyrand, Bishop of Autun, resplendent in pontifical vestments, and surrounded by four hundred priests, in surplices of snowy whiteness, girded with the national tricolored scarfs, mounts the altar steps. He celebrates mass in the antique, blesses the oriflamme and the banners of the eighty-three departments, and then strikes up the Te Deum. Twelve hundred musicians play that hymn, at the sound of which every heart goes wild with rapturous joy, and even the most abandoned feels pious. Then ensues a deep silence in that vast enclosure, and Lafayette, of American fame, advances to take the civil oath. He is borne up the altar steps in the arms of his grenadiers, and in a loud voice, for himself and the army, he says: “We swear to be ever faithful to the nation, the law, and the king; to maintain with our utmost power the constitution decreed by the National Assembly, and to remain united to all Frenchmen by the indissoluble bonds of fraternity.”
Cheer upon cheer rends the air. From hilltop to hilltop the cannon boom, till the glad news is carried all around the empire. And the cheers and the salvos are taken up in every hamlet and village and city in France; for everywhere the people are celebrating. The president of the Assembly takes a similar oath, and then the king takes it, while the queen raises the infant prince in her arms. At last the happy day’s work is ended with a canticle of thanksgiving. That night and for several days afterward the festivities continue. There are regattas, fireworks, illuminations, balls, and refreshments. On the site of the Bastile a great ball is held; and merrily they dance upon the spot so long the scene of tears and anguish.
France fancied herself at the end of her troubles. Alas! they were just about to begin. Poor, foolish people! A great authority has said: “At every moment, France,—eager to enjoy a revolution which hitherto had brought nothing but suffering, ‘a freedom, the palm of which had been watered with tears and blood,’—France hastened with all her might the completion of the temporal state of affairs; and without considering that revolutions seldom prove profitable to the generations which devote themselves to the making of them, she sought to unite all parties in one spirit of concord and patriotism.” Poor souls! they measured the height of the stature of their happiness by the length of its shadow at eventide. That 14th of July was the “Indian summer of royalty.” That touching festival of the federation was but a fugitive emotion. Hostilities had been suspended, not abandoned. On the morrow all hearts still wished what they had wished the day before, and the war had recommenced.
And now it may not be out of place to inquire if there are not thousands in the United States who are looking for the millennium, and already beginning to celebrate its dawn.

THE SABBATH BEFORE THE GIVING OF THE LAW.

BY ELDER M. E. KELLOGG.
(Battle Creek, Mich.)
It is admitted by a writer in the Gospel Advocate, published at Dallas, Tex., that God rested on, blessed, and sanctified the seventh day at the close of the creation week. But he claims that it was not there and then given to mankind, and that it was not so given for twenty-five hundred years afterward. We deny this proposition, and affirm that it was given to man at creation. Passing down those years until the time when the law was formally proclaimed, we hear God giving as a reason why the seventh day should be kept, the facts that at creation he had rested on, blessed, and sanctified the seventh day. Now these were no new facts. They had existed for twenty-five hundred years. These reasons are not peculiar to the Jews; in fact, the Jews were not mentioned either in the account in Genesis or in the Sabbath law at Sinai. The reasons are as broad as God’s creation. Therefore we are asked to believe that, with a reason as old and as broad as creation for the observance of the seventh day, it was not commanded for twenty-five hundred years! It looks like charging God with folly to say that he would do such a thing.
Further: the Advocate does not take into account the peculiar meaning of the word “sanctify.” This word often has the meaning of “appoint.” An illustration of this use of the word may be seen in Joshua 20:1, 7. The words “appoint” and “appointed” are “sanctify” in the Hebrew. (See margin of verse 7.) Joshua sanctified, or appointed, seven cities of refuge, to which one who had killed a person could flee. How did he do this?—By proclaiming the use of these cities. So God, in sanctifying the Sabbath, declared its use. Indeed, that is the only way that he could sanctify it; for “sanctification” means “to set apart.” The Sabbath was set apart at the close of the creation week. Christ said that the Sabbath was made for man (Mark 1:29), and that means for all mankind. The Advocate admits that it was made at creation; but, according to its own theory, twenty-five hundred years of mankind had passed away before the Sabbath was given to man. And after that time, the Sabbath, which was made for man, was taken away from him. This is very remarkable logic.
It is further argued that the Sabbath was not known between Adam and Moses, because it is not specifically mentioned. We must remember that Genesis is the very brief history of a very long period of time. The mention of many things must, therefore, necessarily be omitted. Genesis is not a book of law, but it is a history. If we should take a position that nothing was binding on the patriarchs but what is mentioned specifically in Genesis, we should allow them to do about as human nature chooses to do. Even that great command to love God with all the heart is not mentioned in Genesis. Shall we, therefore, conclude that it was not binding on the patriarchs?
But, after all, we do not admit that the Sabbath was not known in the period covered by Genesis. It was sanctified, appointed, at the very beginning of the period. Noah reckoned time by sevens of days. Gen. 10:1-12. Such an arbitrary division was without reason, except for the Sabbath. “A week” is spoken of as a well-known division of time in the patriarchal age. Gen. 29:27. What but the Sabbath marks the boundary of the week! These are sufficient reasons to prove that the original sanctification of the Sabbath in Eden was known and understood by the patriarchs. The object of the Sabbath was to keep in mind the Creator. Surely they needed to do this just as much in the patriarchal age as in the Jewish.
We now pass to the time when the manna was given. Thus we read: “Then said the Lord unto Moses, Behold, I will rain bread from heaven for you; and the people shall go out and gather a certain rate every day, that I may prove them, whether they will walk in my law, or no.” Ex. 16:4. We see that God had a law at this time, and by it he proposed to prove Israel. A law is a rule of action, and a rule of action which is obligatory. In regard to what did he prove them by this falling of the manna?—In regard to the observance of the Sabbath. Then a precept concerning the Sabbath was a part of his existing law, even before the law was formally proclaimed on Sinai; and they, as the descendants of Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, had a knowledge of that requirement as they had of other duties which they owed to God. They were to gather twice as much manna on the sixth day as on other days; but there is no record that Moses told them why they were to do so. Nor are we told what day they began to gather the manna; but since the sixth and seventh days are mentioned, we may conclude that they understood the week. Their general directions were that no manna should be kept over from one day to the other, and some who tried to do so, found that it would spoil, and Moses “was wroth with them.” Verses 19, 20. But still there is no mention of the Sabbath.
Now comes the most remarkable part of the story. Right in the face of the fact that attempts made by individuals to preserve the manna over one day had failed, and Moses was wroth with them for so doing, the whole congregation on the sixth day did gather twice as much manna as on other days, and then “all the rulers of the congregation came and told Moses” what they had done. Verse 22. Then, and not until then, Moses said “Sabbath” to them. “And he said unto them, This is that which the Lord hath said, To-morrow is the rest of the holy Sabbath unto the Lord: bake that which ye will bake to-day, and seethe that which ye will seethe; and that which remaineth over lay up for you to be kept until the morning.” Verse 23.
Thus we find them preparing for the Sabbath under circumstances which compel us to believe that they knew why they were gathering an extra amount of manna on the sixth day, and that they had faith to believe that it would keep sweet over the Sabbath, when they well knew that attempts to keep it over on other days had failed. This can only be accounted for on the ground that they had a knowledge of the sanctity of the Sabbath, and readily understood the meaning of the command to gather a double portion of manna on the sixth day; and since they did understand the meaning of this command, it furnishes strong ground to believe that they had before-time made preparation for the Sabbath and kept it. Moses’ words to them, when he does mention the Sabbath, confirm this idea: “This is that which the Lord hath said, To-morrow is the rest of the holy Sabbath unto the Lord.” Notice that Moses speaks of what the Lord hath said—past tense. God had said something that made the Sabbath holy. When had he said it? There is a record that God rested on, blessed, and sanctified the seventh day at creation. This made it holy. And if these acts of the Creator made it holy thirty days before the law was proclaimed on Sinai, it truly had been holy from the time it was made until that time.
Not until the first Sabbath after the falling of the manna, did Moses tell the children of Israel that no manna would fall upon the seventh day. On that day he said, “Eat that [what was kept over] to-day; for to-day is a Sabbath unto the Lord: to-day ye shall not find it in the field.” Verse 25. It is quite possible that during their bondage they had not been allowed to keep the Sabbath nor the other pious customs received from their fathers; but the object of God in taking them out of Egypt was that they might obey his laws. Thus we read in his word: “And he brought forth his people with joy, and his chosen with gladness: . . . that they might observe his statutes, and keep his laws. Praise ye the Lord.” Ps. 105: 43-45. It is a remarkable fact that the Sabbath is mentioned and specifically pointed out and accepted by the people of Israel in a way that shows that they understood about it thirty days before the rest of that law, of which the Sabbath precept was a part, was publicly proclaimed.
Let us now sum up what we have learned in regard to the Sabbath, as seen in the circumstance of the falling manna:—
1. God proposed to test the people, whether they would walk in his law or not; but he commanded no law, but through Moses gave certain directions which did bring a test upon them in regard to the observance of the Sabbath. This proves that they knew something of the Sabbath, and of the obligation to keep it. It would be manifestly unjust in God to test them in regard to a law of which they knew nothing.
2. The fact that the manna did not keep over on other days was well calculated to discourage them from trying to gather twice as much on the sixth day, especially as they were not told why they were to gather a double portion on that day. It was left for their faith to see and determine the reason for the command. That they did gather twice as much on the sixth day, under such circumstances, evinces that they knew, without being told, that this extra gathering was in preparation for the Sabbath. Nor would they so readily have understood the meaning of this command had they not had a previous knowledge of the Sabbath, and the way that preparation should be made to keep it holy.
3. Moses spoke to the Israelites of the Sabbath as an existing institution, concerning which it was only necessary that he should remind them: “This is that which the Lord hath said.”
4. Taking these facts as recorded in Genesis and Exodus all together, they offer irrefutable proof that God had a code of laws during the patriarchal age; that a precept for the observance of the Sabbath, blessed and sanctified at creation, was one of these laws; that this was understood by the people of Israel; that the Sabbath was kept by them before the proclamation of the law on Sinai; and that this was done in reference to the acts of God in relation to that day at the close of the first week of time.

“ACCORDING TO HIS FAITH.”

BY ELDER F. D. STARR.
(Nashville, Tenn.)
THE Saviour once told two blind men who came to him desiring to receive their sight, and who expressed the most complete belief that he was able to do that which they desired to have done, “According to your faith be it unto you.” The desired result immediately followed. Like results would more frequently follow if the necessary conditions were fulfilled; that is, if faith were supported by works.
But it is not to the case of the blind men that attention is now called by the phrase at the head of this article. In “Testimonies for the Church,” Vol. II, page 161, we read: “You may believe all the truth, yet if its principles are not carried out in your lives, your profession will not save you. Satan believes and trembles. He works. He knows his time is short, and he has come down in great power to do his evil works according to his faith.” It may perhaps be said that Satan does not possess faith, but this assertion is shown to be incorrect by the extract just quoted, as well as by such passages as James 2:18-20, where the words “faith” and “belief” both occur, both being taken from the same original term in the Greek. The quotation continues: “But God’s professed people do not support their faith by their works. They believe in the shortness of time, yet grasp just as eagerly after this world’s goods as though the world was to stand a thousand years as it now is.” The instruction of James 2 is also introduced into this paragraph.
Satan’s faith is very different from the living, saving faith of the Christian. “He works,” it is true, but there is as much distinction between the different kinds of works as between the different kinds of faith. There is a living faith and a dead faith; there are “dead works” (Heb. 6:1; 9:14), and works that are not dead. There is a faith that seems to stand in the wisdom of men, and a faith that does not stand in man’s wisdom. 1 Cor. 2:5.
Faith, to benefit us, must be mixed with all our thoughts and actions, whether the action be that of hearing and comprehending the word of God, or putting that word in practise. Heb. 4:2. “There is fulness in Jesus. You can obtain strength from him which will qualify you to walk even as he walked; but there must be no separation of affections from him. He requires the entire man, the soul, body, and spirit. When you do all on your part which he requires, he will work for you, and bless and strengthen you by his grace.”—Id., page 156. Our faith will not then be like that possessed by Satan, but of the true, saving kind.

WHERE GOD WAS.

BY J. E. EVANS.
(New Orleans, La.)
Since the fall of man, and his banishment from the presence of God in the garden, a loving Father has been seeking to bring his children into his presence again. This he will do; for he has promised, “Blessed are the pure in heart: for they shall see God.” To be permitted to see God, we must be made “like him.” By beholding the likeness of God in the face of Jesus Christ, we become changed. The divine glory was veiled by the humanity of Christ, and it is through this veil that we must enter if we would again see and become like the Father.
The Saviour referred to this when he said, “Are ye able to drink of the cup that I shall drink of, and to be baptized with the baptism that I am baptized with?” That experience which made our Lord the perfect expression of his Father, often becomes a dark cloud to us, but it is necessary that we pass through the cloud to see him who is thus sometimes hidden.
From the cloud came the words, “This is my beloved Son, in whom I am well pleased.” The heavenly messenger appears clothed with a cloud. Rev. 10:1. The bow of promise, too, may be seen in the approaching cloud which promises naught but a refreshing shower. Clouds must accompany rain, and to live “in the time of the latter rain” is to live in the time when we may expect clouds to appear. To those who thus behold the Saviour near, the cloud becomes bright. When all is bright around us, we need the cloud to keep us from choosing our own way. At night we need the pillar of fire lest we become lost and discouraged. Of Moses the record says, “And the Lord came down in a cloud, and spake unto him.” Num. 11:25. “And the people stood afar off, and Moses drew near unto the thick darkness where God was.” Ex. 20:21.

Living in the Present Moment

YESTERDAY is yours no longer; to-morrow may never be yours; but to-day is yours, the living present is yours, and in the living present you may stretch forward to the things that are before.— F. W. Farrar.

An Important Decision.

February 1 the United States Supreme Court handed down one of the most important and far-reaching decisions ever made by a court in this country. It is that each State has the right to tax the capital stock of interstate corporations doing business within its limits. The causes which led to this decision may be briefly stated. The States of Indiana and Ohio have levied taxes on the business of the Adams Express Company within their borders. Previous to 1893, the Adams Express Company and certain other telegraph and telephone companies had been taxed in these States for their personal property in these States, and for the volume of business done there; but the third attempt to tax them on a portion of their capital was resisted, and the cases have been carried successively through the courts of these States to the highest court in the nation, which now has affirmed the validity of these State laws, and the consequent right of a State to assess a general tax upon such companies as are doing business within its limits.
To illustrate: the whole capital stock of the Adams Express Company may be supposed to be one hundred million dollars. This money is not invested in great buildings, as no manufacturing is done; but by a concession from the government, the business is carried on by the railroad companies all over the United States. Thus the business of this company has no local place, but is diffused all over the country. For this reason the State of Ohio computes the amount of business done by this company in that State, and assesses the capital stock of the company for the amount which is represented by the volume of business done there. This has been done by both Ohio and Indiana, and now, as we have said, the Supreme Court has affirmed the validity of the action of those States. Justices Field, Harlan, and White gave dissenting opinions.
It will be seen at once that unless New York State, where the company offices are located, and where they have heretofore been taxed for the full amount of their capital stock, will not remit taxes on that portion of the capital stock of the Express Company taxed in other States, it will amount to double taxation; and it is largely upon this view of the question that the dissenting justices based their objections. On the other hand, it may be said for the decision that a business so generally diffused, which has no large investments in one place, and whose money is drawn from every part of the country, should pay its taxes where it does its business. Other States will undoubtedly now fall into line, and this company and other companies of a similar nature will be obliged to pay their taxes in the States where they do their business, in proportion to the volume of business done in the several States; and one State will no longer be able to draw taxes from business done all over the United States.
Should New York remit that portion of the taxes on the companies which are assessed in the different States, as it will probably be compelled to do, it is still likely that the whole amount of taxes paid by such companies will be larger when thus distributed than before; for often these very wealthy companies, by ways best known to themselves but suspected by others, avoid assessment for the full value of their property,—something they will find it very difficult to do in so many States. But should they be compelled to pay higher taxes because of this decision of the Supreme Court, they ought not to complain. The wealthy men who own the stock in these great companies have, during the past year, affirmed their belief in the absolute infallibility of the Supreme Court. When the income-tax decision of the Supreme Court removed from them the nightmare of a tax on their wealth, they were ready to exclaim, “A Daniel come to judgment!” and now that a decision from the same court bids fair to draw upon their purses, they should not complain, but stand up and take their medicine without a grimace, like little men, remembering that in this life the bitter is often strangely mingled with the sweet.
M. E. K.
Continue reading: SOUTH AFRICA