1 Samuel 2:23
And he said unto them, Why do ye such things? for I hear of your evil dealings by all this people.
Translations
And he said to them, Why do you such things? for I hear of your evil dealings by all this people.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
And he said unto them, Why do ye such things? for I hear of your evil dealings by all this people.
And he said to them, Why do ye such things? for I hear of your evil dealings by all this people.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
And he said unto them, Why do ye such things? for I hear of your evil dealings from all this people.
and he saith to them, 'Why do ye things like these? for I am hearing of your evil words from all the people — these!
And he said to them, Why do ye such things? for I hear of your evil deeds from all this people.
So he said to them, Wherefore should ye do such things as these? for I keep hearing of your wicked doings, from all these people.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
“ Why are you doing these things?” Eli said to his sons. “ I hear about your wicked deeds from all these people.
He said to them, “ Why do you do such things? For I hear of your evil dealings from all these people.
And he said to them, Why are you doing such things? for from all this people I get accounts of your evil ways.
And hee saide vnto them, Why doe ye such things? for of all this people I heare euill reportes of you.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And he said to them: Why do ye these kinds of things, which I hear, very wicked things, from all the people?
Cross-references
- 1 Samuel 3:13
For I have told him that I will judge his house for ever for the iniquity which he knoweth; because his sons made themselves vile, and he restrained them not.
God judges Eli for knowing his sons’ iniquity and failing to restrain them.
- 1 Samuel 2:29-30
Wherefore kick ye at my sacrifice and at mine offering, which I have commanded in my habitation; and honourest thy sons above me, to make yourselves fat with the chiefest of all the offerings of Israel my people?
Eli is rebuked for honoring his sons above God, and judgment is pronounced on his house.
- 1 Samuel 2:12-17
Now the sons of Eli were sons of Belial; they knew not the LORD.
Eli’s sons abuse their priestly service and corrupt the offerings.
- 1 Samuel 4:10-11
And the Philistines fought, and Israel was smitten, and they fled every man into his tent: and there was a very great slaughter; for there fell of Israel thirty thousand footmen.
Israel is defeated, Eli’s sons die, and the ark is captured as judgment for their wrongdoing.
- 1 Samuel 2:34
And this shall be a sign unto thee, that shall come upon thy two sons, on Hophni and Phinehas; in one day they shall die both of them.
It announces the judgment on Eli’s house through his sons’ deaths.
- 1 Samuel 2:17
Wherefore the sin of the young men was very great before the LORD: for men abhorred the offering of the LORD.
The priests’ grave misconduct caused people to despise the Lord’s offering.
- 1 Samuel 2:32
And thou shalt see an enemy in my habitation, in all the wealth which God shall give Israel: and there shall not be an old man in thine house for ever.
The rebuke is followed by a warning of affliction for Eli’s family.
- 1 Samuel 1:14
And Eli said unto her, How long wilt thou be drunken? put away thy wine from thee.
Eli wrongly reproves Hannah while excusing his sons’ wrongdoing.
- 1 Samuel 4:18
And it came to pass, when he made mention of the ark of God, that he fell from off the seat backward by the side of the gate, and his neck brake, and he died: for he was an old man, and heavy. And he had judged Israel forty years.
Eli also dies when the news of Israel’s defeat and his sons’ deaths reaches him.
- Jeremiah 7:12-14
But go ye now unto my place which was in Shiloh, where I set my name at the first, and see what I did to it for the wickedness of my people Israel.
God judged Shiloh for the people’s wickedness.
- 1 Samuel 2:35
And I will raise me up a faithful priest, that shall do according to that which is in mine heart and in my mind: and I will build him a sure house; and he shall walk before mine anointed for ever.
The passage contrasts Eli’s failure to restrain his sons with God’s promise of a faithful priest.
- 1 Samuel 3:18
And Samuel told him every whit, and hid nothing from him. And he said, It is the LORD: let him do what seemeth him good.
Eli accepts the announced judgment without acting to stop the evil.
- Psalms 78:60-62
So that he forsook the tabernacle of Shiloh, the tent which he placed among men;
God forsook Shiloh and gave his glory into the enemy’s hand.
- 1 Samuel 8:3
And his sons walked not in his ways, but turned aside after lucre, and took bribes, and perverted judgment.
Samuel’s sons went astray, continuing the lesson about failure in the home.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
41 sources
Eli at last broke his long silence to question his sons about their conduct after reports of their wrongdoing reached him from every side and became widely known.Lt 120, 1897, par. 7–9ST Oct 14, 1913 Their wrongs were gross abuses of sacred office, defrauding the people in the offerings, bold transgression, and impurity that polluted worship and turned men away from sacrifice.ST Oct 14, 1913SG4 103.1–23T 472.2–3 His question was only a mild entreaty without restraint, punishment, or removal from office, springing from indulgent affection that honored his sons above God.Lt 52, 1886, par. 14–15ST Oct 14, 1913Lt 1, 1864, par. 3–5Ms 119, 1899, par. 20–21CE 218.2–219.2 That indulgence kindled God's anger so that his house was warned it would be cut off and both sons fall in one day, while leaving them in place corrupted the people, brought ruin to thousands, and stripped Israel of strength and glory.Lt 1, 1864, par. 3–5SG4 103.1–24T 651.1STSE 84.1–85.21SP 400.1–401.1 The verse therefore teaches that parents and those in holy office must do more than speak against wrong but promptly and firmly restrain it, for failure at home and lax discipline in leaders effaces the distinction between right and wrong and disqualifies a man to guide God's church.Ms 119, 1899, par. 20–21CE 218.2–219.24T 651.1ST Nov 24, 1881
Words and Historical Setting
Eli at last broke long silence to ask Hophni and Phinehas why they did such things, after hearing of their evil dealings from all the people.Lt 120, 1897, par. 7–9ST Oct 14, 1913PP 576.3–4 His knowledge came from faithful men who mourned the corruption of the priesthood and from complaints coming from every side, with the indignation of the people aroused against the priests.ST Oct 14, 1913 Their conduct was widely and publicly known among Israel, reported to him because it dishonored the Lord's people and harmed worship.Lt 120, 1897, par. 7–9PP 576.3–4ST Nov 10, 1881ST Sep 2, 1913 He had passed over their transgressions until he dared remain silent no longer, yet though he knew God's will and had taught his sons, he had let them follow their own wishes until corrupt habits grew to defy human and divine authority.ST Oct 14, 1913ST Nov 10, 1881
Their evils were licentiousness and pollution of the tabernacle, which caused men of Israel to stay away from worship and to offer their own sacrifices.ST Oct 14, 1913 They defrauded Israel in offerings, boldly transgressing God's law with violent conduct that caused Israel to sin, and were selfish, covetous, gluttonous and profligate in abuse of sacred office.SG4 103.1–21SP 400.1–401.1 They served in holy office while living corruptly, polluting and corrupting the people, giving free rein to passion while hiding depravity beneath religion.3T 472.2–3ST Sep 2, 1913 Their course was open contempt for divine authority, with crimes known to all Israel.SG4 103.1–2
He spoke as father, priest, high priest and judge in Israel, accountable for the moral and religious standing of the people and in a special sense for the character of his sons.CE 218.2–219.2SG4 103.1–2Ms 11, 1895, par. 13–14 As high priest he alone was permitted to enter the most holy once a year, and he had exalted his sons to the priesthood to minister at the door of the tabernacle in slaying the beasts and officiating at the altar of sacrifice.SG4 103.1–2 Though his sons were married men, adulthood did not remove his duty as both father and priest to restrain them, and he had authority to stop their wickedness and injustice.Ms 11, 1895, par. 13–142T 622.1–623.1
The wording itself is only a mild remonstrance and mere entreaty, asking why they act wickedly without decisive measures to bring them to justice.ST Oct 14, 1913Lt 1, 1864, par. 3–51SP 401.2 It was words only, occasional rebuke and questioning without restraint, authority, discipline, or ending their place and support.Lt 1, 1864, par. 3–5Ms 119, 1899, par. 20–212T 620.2–4 He treated them as persons of tender conscience who had for once fallen under temptation, when parents must do more than speak against wrongdoing and must use firm, wise discipline to prevent irreverence and disobedience.ST Oct 14, 1913Ms 119, 1899, par. 20–21 Such weak reproof without decided authority stands to rebuke those who neglect to restrain their children and thus let God's cause be dishonored.1SP 401.2
Eli's Weak and Partial Rebuke
Eli's question to his sons was words only, an occasional rebuke and advice and questioning about their wicked conduct without restraining or commanding them, without exercising control or enforcing discipline, without authority, punishment, or decisive measures to bring them to justice.Lt 52, 1886, par. 14–15CE 218.2–219.2SG4 103.1–24T 199.3–200.1Ms 119, 1899, par. 19 Though as high priest and judge he was responsible for their conduct and had exalted them to minister at the door of the tabernacle in slaying beasts and at the altar, he did not remove them at once from the priesthood and from positions of trust, nor judge them as they deserved even unto death for their abominable example, nor end their place and support.Lt 1, 1864, par. 3–5SG4 103.1–21SP 400.1–401.1 His reproof set before them the enormity of their sin, that a sin of one man against another fellow priests could atone for, but when priests themselves sin against God with open contempt for His authority no one remains to atone for them, yet it remained mere entreaty without restraint and they disregarded his counsel.SG4 103.1–21SP 400.1–401.1SG4 104.1–2 His rebuke was not followed by prompt action to restrain them and remove their wrongdoing from Israel, and that culpable neglect and delayed response allowed grave consequences to follow.Lt 52, 1886, par. 14–154T 199.3–200.1
The failure came from indulgence and mistaken love and fondness, from undue affection and partiality, from ease-loving negligence and indolence, from fear of his sons' displeasure, and from honoring his sons above God.Lt 52, 1886, par. 14–15CE 218.2–219.2SG4 206.21SP 400.1–401.1RH Apr 11, 1871 He followed his own judgment in overlooking faults and sins in childhood in hope they would outgrow evil tendencies, suffering them to go on in rebellion until they were a curse to Israel.CE 218.2–219.2SG4 206.2RH Apr 11, 1871 Because he neglected his sacred duty and did not exercise his authority to restrain wickedness, his question was mere entreaty and not decided restraint, leaving them in sacred office while they compelled Israel to sin and transgressed God's law.1SP 400.1–401.1SG4 104.1–2
He was a partial judge who through undue affection excused in his sons what he would have condemned in others.1SP 400.1–401.1SG4 104.1–2 He rebuked his own sons lightly while he was quick to see and rebuke the sins of others, even unjustly reproving Hannah, treating the sins of his sons as less offensive than the sins of others and ever ready to find excuses for their perverse course.ST Nov 24, 18811SP 400.1–401.1 That partiality is the natural but unjust and unchristian partiality of parents, especially parents who feel superior, to regard their own children as superior and to pass over in them as smart and witty what would be severely censured in others, doing them great wrong by leaving faults uncorrected until wrong habits strengthen into second nature.ST Nov 24, 1881 The guilt is greater when a parent with a disobedient child under his roof and dependent on him and on the church covers up a greater course while bearing down with an unsparing hand and making a public matter of another's lesser sin.Lt 1, 1864, par. 3–5ST Nov 24, 1881
By believing himself wiser than his Creator and following human wisdom instead of God's commands, he disobeyed God's rules for family government in training his children.CE 218.2–219.2ST Nov 24, 1881 To the extent he permitted or excused sin in his children he became a partaker and partner in their guilt, and those who through lack of courage to reprove wrong or through indolence or lack of interest make no earnest effort to purify the family or the church are just as responsible for evils they might have checked by parental or pastoral authority as if the acts had been their own.CE 218.2–219.2ST Nov 24, 1881Ms 11, 1895, par. 13–14 Because of his responsible position as priest and judge, accountable for the moral and religious standing of the people and in a special sense for his sons, and because as sons of the high priest they were connected with the work of God, his guilt was far greater than that of ordinary men and greatly heightened.CE 218.2–219.2ST Nov 24, 1881 Although he had authority to stop their wickedness and injustice, by allowing them to continue he incurred the Lord's displeasure and could not be depended upon to keep Israel pure.CE 218.2–219.2Ms 11, 1895, par. 13–14
Judgment and Widespread Ruin
God's anger was kindled against Eli for indulging his sons, and He cursed him and reproved him for rebuking them with words only after hearing of their evil dealings by all the people, without restraining them, removing them from holy office, or ending their place and support.Lt 1, 1864, par. 3–54T 651.1Lt 33, 1897, par. 16SG4 104.1–2 He was warned that he had honored his sons above God and suffered them to compel Israel to sin, acting as a partial judge who excused in them what he would have condemned in others, and that for neglecting his sacred duty his cause would be dishonored.Lt 33, 1897, par. 161SP 400.1–401.1SG4 104.1–2 The warning declared that the transgressions of Hophni and Phinehas would not be pardoned, that his house would not be blessed but cut off, and that both his sons would be cut off in one day.Lt 33, 1897, par. 161SP 400.1–401.1SG4 104.1–2 Prompt and decisive restraint was required instead of tolerating rebellion as unavoidable, for fathers are held responsible for training and correcting their children even when experienced and serving in God's work.4T 651.1STSE 84.1–85.2Lt 33, 1897, par. 16
God delayed His threatened judgments year after year to leave time to redeem past failures, giving Eli warning and opportunity to act, repent, and renounce the sin.PP 582.3Ms 3, 1884, par. 5 Eli did not heed the warning and took no effective measures to correct the evils polluting the sanctuary, and his remonstrance was confession without true repentance because it did not restrain them.PP 582.3Ms 3, 1884, par. 5Lt 56, 1893, par. 16–19 The delay only hardened Hophni and Phinehas and made them grow still bolder in transgression.PP 582.3 Eli made known the messages of warning and reproof against his house to the whole nation hoping to counteract in some measure the evil influence of his neglect, but the warnings were disregarded by the people as they had been by the priests.PP 582.3
Leaving men loaded with guilt in the priesthood led the people to lightly regard crime and to despise the sacrificial offerings.SG4 103.1–21SP 400.1–401.1 Their openly practiced iniquities polluted the people and led thousands in Israel to ruin, while those inclined to cherish sin excused it because men in sacred office were leading others into transgression.PP 582.3ST Oct 7, 1913 The failure to stand for what was right and suppress their sin made Eli responsible for the harm that followed, including Israel's loss of strength and glory when the ark was taken.PP 582.34T 516.1–2 The iniquities openly practiced in Israel emboldened surrounding nations in idolatry and crime and took away their sense of guilt for sin because Israel had not preserved its integrity, making it necessary for God to interpose to maintain the honor of His name as the day of retribution approached.PP 582.3
In contrast Samuel, though surrounded by these corrupting influences that were corrupting Israel, remained untainted and close to God.3T 472.2–3 God accepted the boy whom his mother dedicated to His service, while the aged priest had failed to fulfill his sacred duty and train his children rightly.2MR 278.1–2 An angel was sent to speak with Samuel about their sins, and God gave the boy a solemn message against Eli's house.3T 472.2–32MR 278.1–2
Parental Duty and Discipline
Merely asking wayward children why they act wickedly does not fulfill a parent's duty, for parents must do more than speak against wrongdoing and must use firm, wise discipline to prevent irreverence and disobedience.Ms 119, 1899, par. 20–21CE 218.2–219.2Ms 119, 1899, par. 19 They are to watch strictly over their children, advise them, and promptly and decisively restrain wrongdoing rather than tolerate it as unavoidable.4T 651.1STSE 84.1–85.2ST Nov 10, 1881 Restraint is to begin with mild measures, and if these do not avail the wrong is to be subdued by the severest means, reproving sin and executing justice upon the sinner before indulgence strengthens rebellion into second nature.CE 218.2–219.2STSE 84.1–85.2 Every parent must not only teach and exemplify right but actively restrain evil and strive to make the family a pattern of good works, a perfect Christian household, and in a pre-eminent degree this belongs to those who minister in sacred things.CE 218.2–219.2ST Nov 10, 1881
A parent with a disobedient child under his roof and dependent on him and on the church must require conformity to rules and restraint by counsel and wishes.Lt 1, 1864, par. 3–5RH Apr 11, 1871 When she will not consent she must no longer remain dependent and supported while going and coming as she pleases, choosing her own society, writing to whom she pleases, talking and tattling as she pleases, bringing trial upon the church and reproach upon the cause, covering up her course while bound by the marriage vow yet scattering her ways to strangers and encouraging the addresses of corrupt and vile men.Lt 1, 1864, par. 3–5 Parents are required to restrain their children with decision while they are under their roof and dependent on them, and not yield to them from mistaken love and fondness, because the salvation of children depends very much upon the course pursued by parents.Lt 1, 1864, par. 3–5SG4 206.2RH Apr 11, 1871
True parental love must be blended with duty to correct faults, rather than selfish and idolatrous affection that is partial, blinds parents to faults, and gratifies and indulges children.4T 383.12T 620.2–4TBC1872 45.1–46.1 Such indulgence lets a child rule and become headstrong, willful, perverse, selfish, disobedient and ruler in the house, with strong will undirected and strong passions uncontrolled.4T 383.1TBC1872 45.1–46.1 Mistaken love and fondness that indulges children to their hurt nourishes pride and vanity over dress, leaves the heart void of Christian graces and filled with self-love, haughtiness and uncontrolled passion, sows seed that springs up to make children despise parental authority, and makes their company poisonous and leading to death to be shunned even when they are Sabbath-keepers' children.SG4 206.2RH Apr 11, 1871 A father who only occasionally rebukes yet excuses faults and lets children act as they please repeats the same sin and risks a similar judgment, with his example harming other children as well as his own.4T 383.12T 620.2–4
Parents who permit children to disobey teach them to disregard God's commands, and such indulgent neglect brings sorrow and ruin.Lt 52, 1886, par. 14–15Lt 56, 1893, par. 16–19 They must not believe themselves wiser than the Creator and follow human wisdom instead of God's commands, nor trust self-confidence, learning and intelligence to find a better way than God has given in His word.Lt 52, 1886, par. 14–15ST Nov 24, 1881 God's word is the only safe guide in the management of children, because the Creator who bought children with His own blood best understands all their needs, and human philosophy has devised nothing wiser.ST Nov 24, 1881 Parents must earnestly pray, Teach us how shall we order the child, and faithfully study and obey God's word, or their unrestrained children will confirm forward, selfish, disagreeable ways into habits that render them unloving and unlovable and bring soul-anguish over perverse conduct, disaster and death to parent, ruin to sons, and ruin to thousands.ST Nov 24, 1881Lt 56, 1893, par. 16–19
Leadership and Church Warning
Lax discipline by one in holy office exerts a corrupting influence upon the whole nation and church.CE 218.2–219.2ST Nov 10, 18811T 234.2–235.2 Eli as priest and judge, accountable for the moral and religious standing of the people and in a special sense for his sons, was required first to restrain evil by mild measures and, if these did not avail, to subdue wrong by the severest means, reproving sin and executing justice upon the sinner.CE 218.2–219.2 Instead he gave right instruction and good example but failed with promptness and decision to restrain inclination to evil, offering only mild words of reproof for evil dealings known by all the people, without ruling well his own house, restraining his children, or removing them from trust.CE 218.2–219.2ST Nov 10, 18811T 234.2–235.2 Those who through lack of courage to reprove wrong or through indolence or lack of interest make no earnest effort to purify the family or the church are as responsible for evils they might have checked by parental or pastoral authority as if the acts had been their own.CE 218.2–219.2 Because of his responsible position his negligent, ease-loving, indulgent example was imitated throughout Israel, bringing reproach on truth, disgrace on the cause of Christ, ruin upon himself and his household, judgment from God as followed in his case, and guilt far greater than that of ordinary men.CE 218.2–219.21T 234.2–235.2
Every parent must not only teach and exemplify right but actively restrain evil and strive to make the family a pattern of good works, a perfect Christian household.ST Nov 10, 1881 In a pre-eminent degree this duty belongs to those who minister in sacred things, to whom the people look for instruction and guidance.ST Nov 10, 1881 Ministers of Christ must be examples to the flock, and he who fails to direct wisely his own household misleads many by wrong example, sanctions the growth of evil instead of repressing it, effaces from minds the distinction between right and wrong, purity and vice, and is not qualified to guide the church of God.ST Nov 24, 1881ST Nov 10, 1881 That evil is tenfold greater when found in those who stand in Christ's stead to instruct the people, for partiality that excuses in one's own sons and daughters what would be condemned in others dishonors God, makes one a partaker in their guilt, and shows blindness at home while judging other children.ST Nov 24, 1881 Eli revealed such undue affection, rebuking his own sons lightly while quick to see and rebuke the sins of others, treating their perverse course as less offensive and ever ready to find excuses for it.ST Nov 24, 1881
A leader must not remain silent when people do wrong but should faithfully confront them and warn them of danger by asking why it is done.Lt 94, 1901, par. 13–14Lt 253, 1903, par. 2–3 Even a person in position of authority may be challenged for wicked conduct, for power does not place anyone beyond correction.17MR 196.1 Resisting anyone who can say this leaves no room for the Saviour's presence.Lt 94, 1901, par. 13–14 God sends warning, reproof and correction to expose transgression of His law and evil dealings, especially in ministers whose changeable, unconsecrated life unfits them to minister and makes them stumbling blocks pointing souls to death, so that souls blinded by the enemy may realize their condition and be saved and transformed by divine grace.Ms 2, 1888, par. 4–6 Satan works to make such reproof of none effect and to cut off the light God has for His people, so that no correcting voice is heard and every man walks in his own light and follows his own judgment, refusing to be corrected and resisting anything that interferes with personal ideas and course of action.Ms 2, 1888, par. 4–6 Unbelief and opposition still leave the duty to counsel, warn, entreat and reprove unchanged.Ms 2, 1888, par. 4–6
Religious position and outward piety do not prove faithfulness, as shown by men serving in sacred office while giving free rein to passion and hiding depravity beneath religion.ST Sep 2, 1913 Exposed corruption in sacred office damages confidence in religion and weakens trust in God's word.ST Sep 2, 1913 The wickedness of ungodly sons left unrestrained makes them corrupt and a proverb of reproach, exerts corrupting influence where they live, disgusts unbelievers, brings reproach upon the cause of truth, and brings judgment from God as followed in Eli's case.1T 234.2–235.2
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
36 sources
The verse records Eli confronting his sons Hophni and Phinehas over the evil reported about them, asking why they do such things.ST Apr 8, 1913RH Aug 28, 1856ST Mar 31, 1909ST Jul 20, 1904 Their evil dealings were greedy extortion, licentiousness and pollution of the tabernacle, publicly known and heard by all the people with complaints coming from every side.ST Dec 1, 1881ST Oct 14, 1913ST Apr 8, 1913RH Jan 6, 1853 His question was only a mild remonstrance, a feeble verbal protest with no decisive measures to restrain them, stop the evil or bring them to justice.ST Dec 1, 1881ST Oct 14, 1913ST Apr 6, 1888RH Oct 9, 1900 By permitting and excusing sin in his children when as father and priest he was required to restrain them, their sins became his own and brought declared judgment and ruin on Eli, his sons and his house.ST Apr 23, 1912ST Nov 24, 1881ST Nov 24, 1881ST Aug 31, 1888RH Jul 16, 1857 Warnings and admonitions alone are therefore not enough, for parents and especially those who minister in sacred things must with decision actively restrain evil, correct firmly and enforce obedience while children are under their roof.ST Nov 24, 1881ST Nov 10, 1881RH Oct 9, 1900ST Aug 31, 1888ST Oct 9, 1907
Setting in Shiloh
The verse belongs to the account of Eli's sons, Hophni and Phinehas, whose greedy extortions made the people abhor God's service and whose licentiousness and pollution of the tabernacle caused men of Israel to stay away from worship and offer their own sacrifices.ST Oct 14, 1913 Their conduct took place when every man did what seemed right to himself, and the priests had brought heathen excesses and worship of strange gods and Ashtaroth into Israel's worship, so that priests and people together were grossly wicked at Shiloh.RH Jan 6, 1853 Their evil dealings were publicly known and heard by all the people, with complaints coming from every side, the indignation of the people aroused, and reports brought by faithful men who mourned the corruption of the priesthood.ST Dec 1, 1881ST Oct 14, 1913ST Apr 6, 1888ST Apr 8, 1913 Eli's love blinded him to the full seriousness of their sin even as their corruption became grievous and widely known, yet he confronted them over the evil reported about them.ST Apr 6, 1888ST Jun 22, 1882ST Apr 8, 1913
The verse records Eli confronting his sons and asking why they do such things, and it stands as part of the record of his weakness as priest and of the corrupt condition of Israel and his failure in home government.RH Aug 28, 1856ST Mar 31, 1909ST Jul 20, 1904ST Mar 11, 1897 His reproof did not restrain them, and his questioning warns mothers to be faithful to their trust by carefully correcting and admonishing children in love, showing them correction is done because they are loved, and by frankly acknowledging mistakes and asking forgiveness, which brings children near, for the little ones are lambs of the flock who must not be offended or neglected.ST Jul 20, 1904 The episode is part of a noted backsliding and apostasy of the Israel of God, the church in the wilderness in the days of Samuel. That apostasy was not utter apostasy from which there is no recovery, for the church was restored again through the ministrations of Samuel the prophet.
The wretched atmosphere of Eli's household ruined Hophni and Phinehas, in contrast to the godly home of Elkanah and Hannah that produced Samuel.ST Sep 9, 1880 Eli had full proof of his sons' crimes yet excused them, while he had unjustly reproved Hannah for drunkenness without proof, and her son Samuel even as a child foretold the ruin of Eli's family.RH Apr 5, 1860 The child Samuel was surrounded by most corrupting influences and saw and heard things that grieved his soul, yet he did not fellowship with those sins or delight in them but kept his soul in close connection with Heaven.RH Dec 17, 1901 An angel was sent to talk with him about the sins of Eli's sons, whose evil dealings heard by all the people filled all Israel with fearful reports and corrupted Israel.RH Dec 17, 1901 The chapter shows God using women and giving them instruction, supporting the place and voice of women in the church.
Eli's Feeble Rebuke
Eli's question was only a mild remonstrance, a feeble verbal protest, with no decisive measures to bring his sons to justice, restrain them, or stop the evil.ST Dec 1, 1881ST Oct 14, 1913RH Oct 9, 1900ST Jul 20, 1904 He had heard reports from the people about their evil conduct and confronted them, but despite public complaints and the seriousness of their wrongdoing he took no decisive action to bring them to justice.ST Dec 1, 1881ST Apr 23, 1912 He finally spoke to Hophni and Phinehas after long silence about their licentiousness and pollution of the tabernacle that caused men of Israel to stay away from worship and to offer their own sacrifices.ST Oct 14, 1913 He knew their course from faithful men who mourned the corruption of the priesthood and from complaints coming from every side with the indignation of the people aroused, and he had passed over their transgressions until he dared remain silent no longer.ST Oct 14, 1913 His rebuke revealed the aged father's partiality toward his wayward sons, treating them as persons of tender conscience who had for once fallen under temptation.ST Oct 14, 1913
He spoke only after the complaints of the people forced him to stop hiding his eyes from their crimes, grieved and perplexed over their violent deeds.ST Apr 6, 1888 He had made the mistake of permitting them to minister in holy office while excusing their course on one pretext and another until he was blinded to their sins.ST Apr 6, 1888 His rebuke came too late and was too weak to be heeded, for after allowing them to grow hardened and entrenched in sin he could not make them heed him.ST Oct 23, 1884ST Oct 23, 1884ST Jul 8, 1889 They had been repeatedly warned but continued in sin until it was too late to escape the threatened punishment.ST Jul 8, 1889
His failure was not that he said nothing, but that he did not restrain them as both father and priest and leader of Israel required.ST Nov 10, 1881ST Apr 6, 1888RH Oct 9, 1900 He knew God's will and had taught them God's law and set a good example, yet by letting them follow their own wishes he allowed corrupt habits to grow until they defied human and divine authority.ST Nov 10, 1881 His love for them blinded him to the full seriousness of their sin, grievous corruption though it was.ST Apr 8, 1913 As an indulgent father he never decidedly commanded their obedience, bringing them up to think of no one but themselves, so they grew up casting off all restraint and caring for no one else.ST Apr 6, 1888 That undue affection was ever ready to find excuses for their perverse course, treating their sins as less offensive than the sins of others.ST Nov 24, 1881
He had full proof of his sons' crimes but excused them, while he was quick to see and rebuke the sins of others.ST Nov 24, 1881RH Apr 5, 1860 He had even unjustly reproved Hannah for drunkenness without proof, while rebuking his own sons lightly.ST Nov 24, 1881RH Apr 5, 1860 Though warned of the consequences of their sin, their hard hearts were untouched by his grief, they were not impressed, and they would not change their evil course.ST Apr 6, 1888ST Oct 23, 1884ST Oct 23, 1884 They would not heed their father but continued in sin until it was too late to escape punishment.ST Oct 23, 1884ST Oct 23, 1884ST Jul 8, 1889 The question itself shows that confronting wrongdoing includes asking those responsible why they are acting as they do.RH Oct 31, 1907
Judgment on Eli's House
The gross wickedness of the priests at Shiloh, joined with the sin of the people, caused God to forsake His habitation at Shiloh and to give His glory, the ark of His testament, into the hands of the enemy, the Philistines.RH Aug 28, 1856RH Jan 6, 1853 The verse belongs to Eli's confrontation of his sons over the evil reported about them among the people.RH Aug 28, 1856 Israel's defeat when the ark was carried showed that carrying the ark could not protect a sinful people nor conceal transgression from God, for the ark was no safeguard once God had departed from them.RH Aug 28, 1856
God declared judgment and a curse on Eli's house because Eli knew of his sons' iniquity in their priestly service, by which they brought the people to despise the Lord's offerings and worship, yet did not restrain them.ST Aug 31, 1888 That failure to use authority to restrain them, questioning them about their widely known evil conduct instead, dishonored God, polluted the services of the sanctuary, corrupted the people, and became part of the reason judgment fell on his household.ST Jun 22, 1882RH May 12, 1868 Divine justice therefore brought disaster and death on Eli himself, ruin on his sons, ruin on thousands in Israel, and destruction on Eli and his sons.ST Nov 24, 1881ST Jun 22, 1882 They had been repeatedly warned but continued in sin until it was too late to escape the threatened punishment, and Eli also failed to heed God's reproof for not restraining them, so that negligence led to his death after warnings were despised.ST Jul 8, 1889
Failure to restrain his sons at the right time and in the right way made their sins his own, and he was held responsible and accountable for allowing their wrongdoing to continue.RH Jul 16, 1857ST Oct 23, 1884RH Jul 22, 1873 His remonstrance and mild protest lacked firm determination and decisive action, did not stop their contempt for the sanctuary and the harm they caused, dishonored God, and left public discredit on religion.ST Apr 23, 1912RH Jul 16, 1857RH Jul 22, 1873 By permitting or excusing sin in his children he became a partaker in their guilt.ST Nov 24, 1881 That guilt was greatly heightened because as sons of the high priest they were connected with the work of God.ST Nov 24, 1881 His light rebuke of his own sons, while he was quick to see and rebuke the sins of others and had even unjustly reproved Hannah, treated their sins as less offensive than the sins of others and revealed an undue affection ever ready to find excuses for their perverse course, a natural but unjust and unchristian partiality that dishonors God, misleads the people, and does children great wrong by leaving faults uncorrected until wrong habits strengthen into second nature.ST Nov 24, 1881
Corruption of Worship
Hophni and Phinehas by greedy extortion and vile, licentious conduct in priestly service made the people abhor God's service and brought them to despise the Lord's offerings and worship.ST Aug 31, 1888 Their pollution of the tabernacle caused men of Israel to stay away from worship and to offer their own sacrifices.ST Oct 14, 1913 This was done in a time when people did what seemed right to themselves, when the priests had also brought heathen excesses and worship of strange gods and Ashtaroth into Israel's worship. The evil was widely reported, with complaints coming from every side and the indignation of the people aroused, brought by faithful men who mourned the corruption of the priesthood, until Eli after long silence dared remain silent no longer and spoke only a mild remonstrance with no decisive measures to bring them to justice.ST Oct 14, 1913 His knowing of their iniquity yet not restraining them brought reproach on his office and drew God's declared judgment on his house.ST Aug 31, 1888
Their sins polluted the services of the sanctuary and corrupted the people and the whole nation.ST Jun 22, 1882 Their crimes brought public discredit on religion, and Eli's failure to stop them with firm determination left him accountable for allowing their wrongdoing to continue.RH Jul 16, 1857 His remonstrance did not restrain them, and his failure to discipline and train them dishonored God and allowed their harmful example to continue.ST Apr 23, 1912 That lax discipline, though joined with right instruction and good example, failed with promptness and decision to restrain inclination to evil, and because he stood in holy office his laxity and their selfish, irreverent, licentious course exerted a corrupting influence upon the whole nation.ST Nov 10, 1881 Divine justice therefore brought destruction on Eli and his sons.ST Jun 22, 1882
Their sinful example brought temptation to Israel, for people inclined to cherish sin excused it because men in sacred office were leading others into transgression.ST Oct 7, 1913 Such exposed corruption damages people's confidence in religion and weakens their trust in God's word.ST Sep 2, 1913 Hophni and Phinehas thus stand as examples of men serving in sacred office while giving free rein to passion and hiding depravity beneath religion.ST Sep 2, 1913 Their course warns that religious position and outward piety do not prove a person faithful.ST Sep 2, 1913
Duty of Parents and Leaders
The question to his sons shows that mere words do not satisfy parental duty, for warnings and admonitions alone are not enough. ST Nov 10, 1881RH Apr 11, 1871RH Oct 9, 1900ST Oct 9, 1907RH Jul 22, 1873 A parent must not only reprove wrongdoing or express regret but must with promptness and decision take necessary measures to stop it, actively restraining evil and correcting children firmly and wisely. ST Nov 10, 1881RH Apr 11, 1871RH Oct 9, 1900ST Oct 9, 1907RH Jul 22, 1873 While children are under the roof and dependent, parents are required to enforce submission to proper authority with positive injunctions and even punishment, and must not from mistaken love yield to the importunities of a much-loved child from fear of causing unhappiness or displeasure. RH Apr 11, 1871ST Oct 9, 1907 The child is far happier when he learns obedience, and the salvation of children depends very much upon the course pursued by parents, since indulgence nourishes pride and vanity and bears fruit in despising parental authority. RH Apr 11, 1871ST Oct 9, 1907
The failure began earlier, in not enforcing parental authority when the sons were young, so that unchecked habits grew until as priests they dishonored their office and defied God's law. ST Nov 12, 1912 Faults left uncorrected because they are treated as harmless, or passed over as smart and witty in one's own children when the same would be severely censured in others, do great wrong by allowing wrong habits to strengthen into second nature. ST Nov 24, 1881ST Nov 12, 1912 Vain hope that children will correct themselves as adults leaves pride and vanity nourished until rebellion becomes a curse and bears fruit in despising parental authority. ST Nov 24, 1881RH Apr 11, 1871ST Nov 12, 1912
Such indulgence is believing oneself wiser than the Creator and following human wisdom instead of God's commands in training children. ST Nov 24, 1881 Parental unfaithfulness rooted in self-confidence, learning, and intelligence brings disaster and death, ruin to sons, ruin to thousands, and soul-anguish over perverse conduct. ST Nov 24, 1881 God's word is the only safe guide in the management of children, because the Creator who bought them with His own blood best understands all their needs, and human philosophy has devised nothing wiser. ST Nov 24, 1881 Parents must therefore earnestly pray to be taught how to order the child, and faithfully study and obey God's word, lest unrestrained children confirm forward, selfish, disagreeable ways into habits that render them unloving and unlovable. ST Nov 24, 1881
This duty belongs in a pre-eminent degree to those who minister in sacred things and to church officers, to whom the people look for instruction and guidance. ST Nov 10, 1881 He who fails to direct wisely his own household and to control his own sons and daughters is not qualified to guide the church of God. ST Nov 24, 1881ST Nov 10, 1881 Failure to restrain unruly children brings reproach upon office and can lead others to despise the Lord's offerings and worship. ST Aug 31, 1888 It misleads many by wrong example, sanctions the growth of evil instead of repressing it, shows blindness at home while judging other children, effaces from minds the distinction between right and wrong, purity and vice, and exerts a corrupting influence upon the whole nation. ST Nov 24, 1881ST Nov 10, 1881 That evil is tenfold greater when found in those who stand in Christ's stead to instruct the people. ST Nov 24, 1881
Religious observances and prayers for children are not enough when daily conduct and influence fail to restrain sin and lead them toward Christ and His commandments. ST Oct 23, 1884 Parents whose eyes are closed must open them to the danger hanging over their children's heads, seek a place of safety, remove every stumbling-block out of the way, and begin even now to do just as they would wish they had done. RH Oct 15, 1857 Otherwise neglected children will be left to perish in the approaching storm, and parents themselves cannot expect to enter the kingdom while their children perish through neglect. RH Oct 15, 1857 Mothers in particular must be faithful to their trust by carefully correcting and admonishing children in love, showing that correction is done because they are loved, and by frankly acknowledging mistakes and asking forgiveness, which brings children near, for the little ones are the lambs of the flock who must not be offended or neglected.
The same rule holds in the church, where overseers should seek to correct evils rather than leave them unchecked, and confronting wrongdoing includes asking those responsible why they are acting as they do. RH Oct 31, 1907
Sources