1 Samuel 28:11
Then said the woman, Whom shall I bring up unto thee? And he said, Bring me up Samuel.
Translations
Then said the woman, Whom shall I bring up to you? And he said, Bring me up Samuel.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Revised Version, American Standard Version
Then said the woman, Whom shall I bring up unto thee? And he said, Bring me up Samuel.
Then said the woman, whom shall I bring up to thee? And he said, Bring me up Samuel.
And the woman saith, 'Whom do I bring up to thee?' and he saith, 'Samuel — bring up to me.'
Then said the woman, Whom shall I bring up to thee? And he said, Bring me up Samuel.
Then said the woman, Whom shall I bring up for thee? And he said, Samuel, bring thou up for me.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
“ Whom shall I bring up for you?” the woman asked.“ Bring up Samuel,” he replied.
Then the woman said, “ Whom shall I bring up to you?”He said, “ Bring Samuel up for me.”
Then the woman said, Who am I to let you see? And he said, Make Samuel come up for me.
Then said the woman, Whom shall I bring vp vnto thee? And he answered, Bring me vp Samuel.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And the woman said to him: Whom shall I bring up to thee? And he said, Bring me up Samuel.
Pictures





Cross-references
- Deuteronomy 18:10-12
There shall not be found among you any one that maketh his son or his daughter to pass through the fire, or that useth divination, or an observer of times, or an enchanter, or a witch,
Forbids consulting the dead and familiar spirits.
- 1 Chronicles 10:13-14
So Saul died for his transgression which he committed against the LORD, even against the word of the LORD, which he kept not, and also for asking counsel of one that had a familiar spirit, to enquire of it;
Saul’s consultation with a medium is named among the reasons for his death.
- 1 Samuel 28:6
And when Saul enquired of the LORD, the LORD answered him not, neither by dreams, nor by Urim, nor by prophets.
The Lord had refused to answer Saul through the appointed means before he consulted the woman.
- Isaiah 8:19
And when they shall say unto you, Seek unto them that have familiar spirits, and unto wizards that peep, and that mutter: should not a people seek unto their God? for the living to the dead?
It condemns seeking messages from the dead through familiar spirits.
- Leviticus 19:31
Regard not them that have familiar spirits, neither seek after wizards, to be defiled by them: I am the LORD your God.
Forbids seeking out familiar spirits, as Saul did.
- 1 Samuel 28:3
Now Samuel was dead, and all Israel had lamented him, and buried him in Ramah, even in his own city. And Saul had put away those that had familiar spirits, and the wizards, out of the land.
Saul had expelled mediums, though he later sought one to summon Samuel.
- Leviticus 20:27
A man also or woman that hath a familiar spirit, or that is a wizard, shall surely be put to death: they shall stone them with stones: their blood shall be upon them.
The law forbids familiar spirits and prescribes death for mediums.
- Leviticus 20:6
And the soul that turneth after such as have familiar spirits, and after wizards, to go a whoring after them, I will even set my face against that soul, and will cut him off from among his people.
God forbids seeking familiar spirits.
- 1 Samuel 28:19
Moreover the LORD will also deliver Israel with thee into the hand of the Philistines: and to morrow shalt thou and thy sons be with me: the LORD also shall deliver the host of Israel into the hand of the Philistines.
The apparition foretells Saul’s death and Israel’s defeat the next day.
- 1 Samuel 28:7
Then said Saul unto his servants, Seek me a woman that hath a familiar spirit, that I may go to her, and enquire of her. And his servants said to him, Behold, there is a woman that hath a familiar spirit at Endor.
Saul seeks a medium at Endor to inquire of her.
- 1 Samuel 28:15
And Samuel said to Saul, Why hast thou disquieted me, to bring me up? And Saul answered, I am sore distressed; for the Philistines make war against me, and God is departed from me, and answereth me no more, neither by prophets, nor by dreams: therefore I have called thee, that thou mayest make known unto me what I shall do.
Samuel says Saul disturbed him by bringing him up, while Saul seeks guidance after God’s silence.
- Ecclesiastes 9:5
For the living know that they shall die: but the dead know not any thing, neither have they any more a reward; for the memory of them is forgotten.
The dead know nothing and do not communicate with the living.
- 1 Samuel 15:22-23
And Samuel said, Hath the LORD as great delight in burnt offerings and sacrifices, as in obeying the voice of the LORD? Behold, to obey is better than sacrifice, and to hearken than the fat of rams.
Saul’s disobedience and rejection of the Lord’s word precede his resort to a medium.
- 1 Samuel 28:20
Then Saul fell straightway all along on the earth, and was sore afraid, because of the words of Samuel: and there was no strength in him; for he had eaten no bread all the day, nor all the night.
Samuel’s words leave Saul fallen and afraid.
- 1 Samuel 25:1
And Samuel died; and all the Israelites were gathered together, and lamented him, and buried him in his house at Ramah. And David arose, and went down to the wilderness of Paran.
Samuel was buried at Ramah, unlike the apparition’s appearance at Endor.
- 1 Samuel 31:1-6
Now the Philistines fought against Israel: and the men of Israel fled from before the Philistines, and fell down slain in mount Gilboa.
Records Saul’s defeat and death after consulting the spirit.
- 1 Samuel 15:35
And Samuel came no more to see Saul until the day of his death: nevertheless Samuel mourned for Saul: and the LORD repented that he had made Saul king over Israel.
Samuel’s estrangement from Saul explains why Saul sought him through the woman.
- 1 Samuel 28:5
And when Saul saw the host of the Philistines, he was afraid, and his heart greatly trembled.
Saul fears the Philistine army.
- Exodus 22:18
Thou shalt not suffer a witch to live.
Saul had acted to remove those practicing witchcraft.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
10 sources
The request records Saul turning to the woman at Endor after the Lord refused to answer him through dreams, the Urim, or prophets, asking her to inquire of a familiar spirit, and when she asked whom she should bring up he answered Samuel.PP 679.1–2PP 683.1–2PP 683 Saul himself saw nothing in that encounter; the woman described an apparition which Saul took to be Samuel and before which he bowed.PP 679.1–2SG4 83.3–85.1 That figure was not Samuel, God's prophet, who was not present and whom God did not send or cause to appear, for the dead Samuel rested in the grave beyond Satan's power to resurrect, disturb, or bring forth.PP 679.1–2SG4 83.3–85.11SP 376.1PP 683.1–2PP 679.3
The appearance was a supernatural counterfeit produced by Satan's power through his angels, who can take the form of the dead and imitate their speech and actions, with Satan using his intimate knowledge of Samuel to make the apparition speak and act like him, just as Satan could appear as an angel of light to tempt Christ.PP 679.1–2SG4 83.3–85.11SP 376.1PP 683.1–2PP 679.3 The mysterious voices and manifestations at Endor therefore do not prove that the dead communicate with the living; they were deceptive manifestations of evil spirits, by which Satan uses the appearance of departed friends and lies to mislead people.SLP 138.3–139.2RH Sep 7, 1911 The impersonation nevertheless gave a correct and accurate description and statement of Saul's fate, doom, and end, yet its message furthered Saul's ruin rather than leading him to repentance.SG4 83.3–85.11SP 376.2PP 683.1–2
The request gave Satan his opening with Saul as a willing captive, leading him away from God step by step by first coming in a very plausible manner and insinuating into favor and winning control cautiously until perception became blunted, then making bolder suggestions until almost any crime could be committed, then exulting in Saul's confusion at seeing where he was.1SP 376.2 By giving that true announcement of doom Satan opened a way for Israel to be instructed by his satanic cunning, so that in rebellion against God they would learn from him and thereby sever the last link holding them to God.1SP 376.2 The incident served Satan's plan to draw Israel into trusting the sorceress and consulting her, turning from God as their counselor to Satan, and it shows how Spiritualism claims to reveal the future that God has hidden, tempting people to distrust God and seek forbidden knowledge instead of following what God has revealed.PP 686.2
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
80 sources
On the eve of battle with the Philistines at Gilboa, with God refusing to answer him, Saul went disguised by night to the medium at Endor, and when she asked whom she should summon he named his dead counselor Samuel buried at Ramah.ST Apr 2, 1912RH Feb 4, 1909ST Jun 3, 1889RH Oct 2, 1855RH Jul 30, 1872
What appeared was not the holy prophet but a lying spirit sent by Satan to imitate him in form and voice, for God who had refused Saul by lawful means would not send Samuel at the bidding of an outlawed witch.ST Nov 4, 1889ST Sep 25, 1907ST Dec 11, 1884RH May 1, 1866ST May 13, 1880
The summoning is spoken of as bringing up from the earth below, not calling down from heaven, which exposes the imposture and disproves that Samuel had gone to glory.ST Apr 2, 1912RH Apr 7, 1874ST Feb 9, 1915ST Nov 4, 1889ST Nov 4, 1889
The dead lie in silence without knowledge or share in earthly affairs until the resurrection at the second coming, so the dead cannot return to converse with the living.ST Nov 4, 1889RH Feb 4, 1909ST May 8, 1879ST Dec 11, 1884ST Dec 11, 1884
For seeking counsel from a familiar spirit instead of the Lord Saul died in defeat with his sons, warning that consulting the dead is abomination and ancient spiritualism whose modern form must be met by God's word and His armor.ST Oct 4, 1877ST Apr 2, 1912RH Feb 4, 1909ST Jun 6, 1900ST Jan 24, 1900
Saul's Crisis and Visit
The Philistines were pitched at Shunem against Israel at Gilboa with battle set for the next day, and the outcome was still uncertain with God having not decreed death or defeat.RH Feb 4, 1909ST Jun 3, 1889RH Oct 2, 1855 Saul was afraid and his heart greatly trembled before them.RH Feb 4, 1909ST Dec 13, 1905RH Oct 2, 1855 The Lord refused to answer him by dreams or by Urim and Thummim or by prophets, answering him nothing.ST Apr 2, 1912ST Jun 3, 1889STRH Oct 2, 1855ST Oct 21, 1930 He desired not communion with God but information from God about the approaching battle, yet received no response because he preferred his own ways, was restive and rebellious under reproof, and would not receive God's words.STST Oct 21, 1930
Saul was the first king of Israel, once good and favored of God.ST Dec 13, 1905ST Oct 21, 1930ST Jun 6, 1900 He had commanded witches and those with familiar spirits and wizards to leave the country and had cut them off, because God was displeased with them and did not want them near His people.ST Dec 13, 1905ST Sep 16, 1930ST Feb 9, 1915 By pride, jealousy, disobedience, selfishness, self-will, partial obedience and rebellion he by slow steps separated himself until those evils utterly possessed him, the Spirit of God withdrew, he lost communion and his right to the throne, and his career recorded in 1 Samuel 14-31 is a wicked downfall and apostasy.ST Dec 13, 1905ST Sep 16, 1930ST Oct 21, 1930ST Sep 20, 1883 It was partly for turning to witchcraft after willful disobedience that he was deserted of God.ST Sep 16, 1930ST Jun 6, 1900
In extremity and in frenzied zeal to know the result he left his royal robes behind, disguised himself, and went secretly by night with two men to a woman at Endor who had a familiar spirit, an agent of Satan.ST Apr 2, 1912ST Jun 3, 1889ST Jun 6, 1900ST Nov 4, 1889 Her home was in the back alleys of Endor where his officers who had scoured the country had failed to go, living in a stable with her calf.ST Nov 4, 1889 He inquired for her after being told of her, assured her no evil or punishment would come to her for doing the work, and swore by a solemn oath that she would not be punished for divining to him by the familiar spirit, so she would not fear his decree against witchcraft.ST Jun 3, 1889RH Oct 2, 1855ST May 13, 1880 She first tested him to learn whether he truly wanted to converse with the dead or was pretending in order to catch her in witchcraft and put her to death, and only then asked whom to bring up unto him.ST Jun 3, 1889RH Oct 2, 1855ST May 13, 1880
Samuel was already dead and buried at Ramah.RH Oct 2, 1855ST Feb 9, 1915ST Dec 11, 1884 He had been Saul's old counselor to whom he had often gone for direction.ST Jun 3, 1889 Being distressed and unable to obtain an answer from God, Saul took up the evil thought that he could consult Samuel through forbidden necromancy and named Samuel as the dead person he wanted brought up to him.ST Jun 3, 1889RH Oct 2, 1855RH Jul 30, 1872
Wording and Appearance
The request to bring up means to bring up from where the dead man lay dead and buried, from the earth below, not to call down from heaven where the theology of the immortal soul places the good.ST Feb 9, 1915ST Nov 4, 1889ST Nov 4, 1889RH Oct 2, 1855ST Oct 21, 1930 The wording fits the belief of that time that the dead were in the lower regions of the earth, while the modern form of the same deception brings them down from the upper spheres to fit the prevailing belief that those regions are full of conscious spirits of the departed.ST Oct 21, 1930ST Jun 3, 1889 The word up itself disproves that Samuel had gone to glory at death, for if he had gone to glory she would have called him down, not up.ST Feb 9, 1915ST Nov 4, 1889ST Nov 4, 1889ST Jun 3, 1889 Its coming up from the earth betrays the impersonator, since a heavenly spirit would not come from that direction.ST Apr 2, 1912RH Feb 4, 1909ST Oct 21, 1930
No visible form appeared to Saul himself, for only the woman saw the apparition.ST Apr 2, 1912RH Feb 4, 1909RH Jan 3, 1865ST May 13, 1880RH Aug 4, 1868 Saul perceived from her description alone that it was an old man coming up covered with a mantle, and from her description he supposed the unseen to be the prophet.ST Apr 2, 1912RH Feb 4, 1909RH Jan 3, 1865ST May 13, 1880RH Aug 4, 1868 Saul himself could not see him while the woman could, and he accepted the woman's testimony and treated it as Samuel.RH Jan 3, 1865ST May 13, 1880RH Aug 4, 1868RH Oct 2, 1855 The impossibility of a body buried at Ramah appearing through a door at Endor proves the deception.ST Apr 2, 1912
The record states only what the onlooker seemed to see, using the language of appearance just as when it speaks of the sun rising and setting or standing still.ST May 20, 1908 What was brought before Saul was the appearance or form of Samuel through witchcraft, an ancient case of spirit materialization and deceptive wonder, not a communication from the dead.RH Jul 21, 1853ST May 20, 1908 Its phenomena are facts that must be dealt with as fact and not passed over with a sneer, and their value is decided by Scripture since purely physical science cannot decide them without the aid of revelation.RH Jul 21, 1853ST Feb 19, 1902
Those who held it as a human trick taught that the supposed Samuel was not restored to life but was a witched hoax played upon wicked Saul.RH Apr 7, 1868 It was seen by no one but the witch herself, who did the talking as a ventriloquist and thus deceived him.RH Apr 7, 1868 No witch has power to bring up the dead or raise them from their dusty bed, to make a corpse speak, or to bring a spirit from above, for only God's power can raise the dead and no witch or spirit medium may share it.RH Apr 7, 1868
Those who held it as a false report taught that the woman did not see Samuel but lied about it. The episode is the solitary and only instance of pretended communication from the dead recorded in the Bible.ST Nov 14, 1892 It was not really Samuel but ancient sorcery, which is modern Spiritualism, the work of evil spirits belonging to Satan's masterpiece of deception in the last days.ST Nov 14, 1892
Apparition Was Impostor
Something that looked like Samuel appeared at Endor, but it was not Samuel himself and no miracle occurred.ST Nov 4, 1889RH Jan 3, 1865RH Apr 11, 1854 It was a demon, a familiar spirit, an evil and lying spirit sent by Satan to imitate Samuel and deceive Saul.ST Sep 25, 1907STRH Jan 3, 1865RH Apr 11, 1854 Only the woman saw the apparition, while Saul perceived from her description alone that it was an old man coming up covered with a mantle and supposed the unseen to be the prophet.RH Jan 3, 1865ST May 13, 1880 The question raised by the account is whether the figure who later spoke with Saul could really have been Samuel, and the answer is that it could not.ST Sep 25, 1907ST Dec 11, 1884ST
The real and holy Samuel would not come in answer to wicked incantations nor arise out of the earth at the bidding of wicked men and women.RH May 1, 1866ST May 13, 1880ST May 13, 1880 Much less would the righteous dead and eminent servants of God be brought up at pleasure by familiar spirits, who have no power to produce the dead in truth.ST May 13, 1880RH Jul 30, 1872 God had refused to answer Saul by lawful means by dreams and by Urim and by prophets, and He would not send Samuel to meet him on forbidden ground through an outlawed witch who should have been put to death.ST May 13, 1880RH Oct 2, 1855RH Jul 30, 1872 Moses' law forbidding men to question the dead proves the answer could not have come from God through the real Samuel, and to suppose God gave the woman power to raise Samuel when He Himself refused to answer is unreasonable.RH May 1, 1866RH Oct 2, 1855RH Jul 30, 1872 It would be inconsistent for holy Samuel to answer when invoked by satanic power through a servant of Satan, and God would not make such a medium of His communication.ST May 13, 1880
The profession to bring up any of the dead who are called for and enable them to speak is a false pretense.ST May 27, 1880ST Oct 11, 1877 The familiar spirit did all the speaking while dead Samuel had nothing to say.ST May 27, 1880ST Oct 11, 1877 Familiar spirits are not the spirits of dead friends but fallen angels imitating and counterfeiting them, and their testimony about their own personality deserves no weight because the Bible warns against them as wicked and deceitful.ST Oct 11, 1877
The imposture is exposed because it comes up from below rather than coming down from heaven where the good are placed, and its coming up from the earth betrays it since a heavenly spirit would not come from that direction.ST Apr 2, 1912ST Sep 16, 1930ST Nov 4, 1889ST Oct 21, 1930 It appears as a bent old man clad in a mantle, which Samuel in glory would not still be, and it is summoned by a dissolute law-breaking woman whom God had condemned.ST Apr 2, 1912ST Sep 16, 1930ST Oct 21, 1930 Its first act is to give the medium private supernatural knowledge to warn her that the inquirer is Saul, so that she is alarmed not at seeing the old man but at learning Saul is in the house.ST Apr 2, 1912RH Apr 7, 1874ST May 13, 1880ST Oct 21, 1930 It then gives Saul information God had refused to reveal, accuses him after the Lord has become his enemy, mixes truth with deception, strips him of courage and perseverance, and drives him to despair.ST Apr 2, 1912RH Apr 7, 1874ST Nov 4, 1889ST Oct 21, 1930
Satan is protean-shaped and the greatest actor on this fallen world, able to act a lie so it has the appearance of truth.ST Jan 24, 1900ST Through convincing likeness and voice and knowledge of private events in the lives of the dead and their friends he made Saul believe the unseen was really Samuel so his words would be implicitly believed.RH Sep 7, 1911RH Oct 10, 1912ST Jan 24, 1900 By controlling the mind and speech of the witch whom he had overcome, and by transforming himself into an angel of light and personating individuals, he deceived Saul through her.RH Sep 7, 1911ST May 7, 1902 The voices at Endor were deceptive manifestations of evil spirits using the appearance of departed friends to mislead, and knowing this power to impersonate the dead is necessary to recognize and overcome him.RH Sep 7, 1911ST Jan 24, 1900
The account represents Samuel as coming bodily up from the earth, being disturbed and disquieted, and speaking with Saul.ST May 8, 1879RH Jul 27, 1869ST May 8, 1879 This shows what was in the grave coming up and talking, not that Samuel's soul lived and knew things while his body remained in the grave.ST May 8, 1879RH Jul 27, 1869ST May 8, 1879 It therefore supports that the dead sleep in the grave rather than that an immortal soul remains conscious apart from the body.ST May 8, 1879ST May 8, 1879
Witchcraft and Spiritualism
Saul's asking for Samuel to be brought up was consulting the dead through a medium, dealing with a familiar spirit, divining by means of the dead, necromancy, sorcery and witchcraft.ST Oct 4, 1877ST May 6, 1880RH Jul 30, 1872ST Jan 9, 1893 What claimed to be intercourse with the dead was in fact direct intercourse with Satan or his evil angels.ST Oct 4, 1877ST May 6, 1880 Consulting one having a familiar spirit was among the practices of the former heathen dwellers in Palestine that made them abhorrent to God, which God forbade among His chosen people, commanded mediums to be destroyed and removed from among His people, and punished with death, and which Saul himself had punished.ST Oct 4, 1877ST May 6, 1880RH Jul 30, 1872ST Jun 6, 1900ST Jan 9, 1893 Distressed and unable to obtain an answer from God, Saul turned to this forbidden necromancy in an attempt to consult the dead, with the woman professing to call up Samuel who was dead, though the Bible recognizes such mediums and claims of communication without approving them.RH Jul 30, 1872ST Jun 6, 1900ST Jan 9, 1893
The transaction was ancient spiritualism, a seance in which the woman undertook to produce Samuel, the Bible's extended specimen of the work of familiar spirits.ST Oct 4, 1877ST Dec 8, 1909ST Mar 11, 1908 It was the legitimate child and pattern of modern spiritualism with its godless blasphemies and corruptions, belonging to the same category of necromancy and sorcery forbidden by the testimony of both the Old and the New Testament, and Bible teaching and predictions about spiritualism are fulfilled by Spiritualists.ST Oct 4, 1877ST Mar 11, 1908 To hold that Samuel really returned in conscious life is in theory to be a spiritualist, making ancient necromancy a divine practice and modern spiritualism the oracle of truth and purity, and paves the way for seducing spirits and doctrines of devils from Satan's first falsehood to Eve that death is not death.ST Oct 4, 1877ST Oct 4, 1877ST Jun 3, 1889
Bringing up any dead person who was named was the medium's business and customary language.ST May 13, 1880ST Oct 4, 1877 The medium asks which dead person the inquirer wishes to consult and claims she can bring up the dead at will, the inquirer names the person, and the spirit professes to bring up anyone desired.ST Oct 4, 1877ST Oct 4, 1877ST May 13, 1880 Her question is exactly that of a present-day spirit medium, and Saul's request is an instance of seeking knowledge from the dead, which Isaiah describes as seeking the living from the dead, a kind of exchange modern spiritualism repeats.ST May 13, 1880ST Oct 4, 1877ST May 13, 1880
The only difference is in form.ST May 13, 1880ST Jun 3, 1889RH Oct 2, 1855 Then the deception was performed by pretending to raise the dead person desired for consultation and calling them up from a region below, fitting the belief of that time that the dead were in the lower regions of the earth.ST May 13, 1880ST Jun 3, 1889RH Oct 2, 1855 Now spirits professing to be the souls of departed friends come to instruct and are brought down from the third heaven or higher spheres, to fit the prevailing belief that those regions are full of conscious spirits of the departed.ST May 13, 1880ST Jun 3, 1889RH Oct 2, 1855
The witch's intercourse with a familiar spirit stands on a level with claimed spirit communications in later times such as Victoria C. Woodhull's, portraying such intercourse as demonic and unhallowed.RH Sep 26, 1871 The claim that an angel appeared to Saul and declared himself one of the prophets' brethren is an incorrect account of the event.ST Oct 20, 1887
Dead Unconscious Till Resurrection
The request to bring Samuel up says nothing about a soul and gives no support for communication between spirits of the dead and the living, nor does it prove immortality or that man possesses an immortal soul capable of conscious existence between death and resurrection.ST Nov 4, 1889ST Dec 8, 1909RH Jun 23, 1859RH Jul 30, 1872RH Oct 2, 1855 People turn to the Endor episode for proof that the dead survive and for assurance of resurrection, drawing that conclusion from prior belief in the soul's inherent immortality, but the account itself teaches the state of the dead.RH Jun 23, 1859RH Jul 30, 1872RH Oct 2, 1855 To use it for immortality makes the Bible a fiction, makes ancient necromancy a divine practice, and makes modern spiritualism the oracle of truth.ST Dec 8, 1909RH Jul 30, 1872 The language of bringing up means bringing him up from where he lay dead and buried, and he could not converse in that manner without a resurrection; if the scene was real, being disquieted and brought up shows a bodily raising.ST May 8, 1879RH Oct 2, 1855 It is unreasonable to suppose God gave the woman power to raise Samuel to speak with Saul when He Himself had refused to answer Saul by dreams, Urim, and prophets, and something that looked like Samuel appeared, but it was not Samuel and no miracle occurred.ST Nov 4, 1889ST Dec 8, 1909RH Oct 2, 1855
The dead do not know anything, have no thoughts, knowledge or wisdom in the grave, lie in silence without memory or sense, unknowing and unknown, with no share in anything done beneath the sun.RH Feb 4, 1909ST Dec 11, 1884ST Dec 11, 1884RH Apr 7, 1868 They cannot take part in earthly affairs or return to communicate with the living, cannot converse without a resurrection, and cannot be sent back on such a mission.RH Feb 4, 1909ST Dec 11, 1884ST Dec 11, 1884RH Apr 7, 1868 The entire hope of the dead rests in resurrection at the second coming of Christ, held by death and darkness until then.RH Apr 7, 1868ST Dec 27, 1905 The request was unreasonable because the dead do not know, and insulting to the loyal Samuel who would never communicate through that hated channel, though Saul knew he would have given him no answer and though God had commanded mediums to be destroyed.RH Feb 4, 1909RH Apr 7, 1868 No witch has power to bring up the dead or raise them from their dusty bed, for only God's power can raise the dead and no witch or spirit medium may share it, make a corpse speak, or bring a spirit from above; the supposed Samuel was not restored to life, and if one man could be restored to life ten thousand more could be, making Saul's slaying useless.RH Apr 7, 1868 The profession to bring up any of the dead who are called for and enable them to speak is a false pretense; the familiar spirit did all the speaking while dead Samuel had nothing to say, and the testimony of familiar spirits about their own personality deserves no weight because the Bible warns against them as wicked and deceitful and the facts of death prove they do not come from the dead and cannot bring up any of the dead.ST Dec 11, 1884ST Dec 27, 1905
The promise that Saul and his sons would be with the apparition the next day teaches the falsehood that the wicked and the righteous are consciously together after death, which is taught nowhere else in Scripture.ST Oct 21, 1930ST Dec 5, 1892 Its claim was a lie since Saul was still alive when that day passed.ST Oct 21, 1930ST Dec 5, 1892
Seeking to converse with dead Samuel was a great sin forbidden by the law of Moses, so Christ's conversing with Moses on the mount could not have been the same kind of conversing with the dead, and Moses must have been resurrected and not still numbered with the dead.ST Sep 22, 1881
Transgression Judgment and Warning
In asking counsel of one that had a familiar spirit to inquire of it instead of inquiring of the Lord, Saul transgressed against the Lord, and for that transgression he died.ST Apr 2, 1912RH Feb 4, 1909ST Jun 6, 1900ST Oct 21, 1930ST Sep 19, 1911 It was partly for this cause that he was deserted of God and permitted to be slain by Israel's enemies, and he soon fell in battle with his sons.ST Apr 2, 1912RH Feb 4, 1909ST Jun 6, 1900 His utter downfall in turning to the power of Satan to bring up Samuel, and his blindness in undertaking a war with the Philistines under such circumstances, led to utter defeat with the loss of his own life and that of Jonathan.ST Apr 2, 1912RH Feb 4, 1909ST Apr 7, 1909 His punishment stands as a warning beacon against going to Spiritualists for communications from departed friends, for seeking the dead through divination, a consulter with familiar spirits, a wizard, or a necromancer is an abomination unto the Lord, and those who practice that abomination will in no wise enter the new heaven and new earth.ST Oct 21, 1930ST Sep 19, 1911
The familiar spirit speaking as Samuel told Saul what to do about the Philistines, predicting that his army would be beaten and that he and his sons would die on the morrow and be with him.RH Feb 4, 1909ST Dec 13, 1905ST Apr 7, 1909ST Nov 4, 1889 The false message mixed truth with deception and stripped Saul of the courage and perseverance that were his only hope of success.RH Feb 4, 1909ST Nov 4, 1889 It used his dread to break his heart and take away his courage, leaving him fallen full length on the dirt floor sore afraid and broken-hearted, and ensured the defeat on the morrow.RH Feb 4, 1909ST Sep 16, 1889ST May 20, 1880 His appeal to evil spirits marked his final break with the Lord; he returned to battle broken-hearted and died in despair, gaining nothing and losing everything, with one more step still to fall when he falls upon his sword.RH Feb 4, 1909ST Dec 13, 1905ST Sep 16, 1889
Saul received a revelation through this forbidden consultation because his perverted, wicked heart sought refuge in a witch instead of in God.ST Nov 27, 1879 But God did not approve Saul's method and does not approve consulting familiar spirits.ST Nov 27, 1879
Saul's case proves that obedience is the condition on which God answers prayer, for refusing to walk in known duty places a person where God looks upon prayer as abomination and will not hear, and cherishing iniquity in the heart shuts out answers.ST Nov 15, 1905 His resort to the devil's emissaries for light after partial obedience to God's commands demonstrates that disobedience is not genuine obedience.ST Nov 15, 1905ST Oct 17, 1895 His mistaking the satanic spirit working through the witch for the Holy Spirit working through Samuel belongs to a state of moral confusion, after repeated resistance to conscience had hardened him against the Spirit.ST Oct 9, 1907ST Oct 30, 1907 His seeking guidance from the witch through a deceptive spiritualist seance shows superstition sinking ruler and people, a case of the blind leading the blind, with Saul sunk to a low intellectual and moral grade and vacillating as a ruler.ST Oct 10, 1906ST Oct 30, 1907 His turning to a necromancer after rejecting God's instruction warns that rebellion against God leads toward spiritualism and past opposition to it does not protect someone who persists in disobedience, and that continued sin and refusal to yield to God can lead a person far from Him, lying in a witch's dwelling and receiving instruction from an evil spirit, and grieve the Holy Spirit.RH Nov 2, 1905ST Oct 30, 1907
The episode shows the danger of seeking guidance through a witch or other occult practitioner, who may disclose things about the past or infer what is likely to happen from events already underway but cannot know beyond that, and Saul's resort to the witch led toward spiritual and physical ruin.ST Nov 4, 1889 Inquiring of the dead for knowledge of future events and the invisible world instead of seeking satisfaction in the divinely revealed record from the hand of the living God and the sure word of prophecy is impiety as great as Ahaziah inquiring of Baal-zebub the god of Ekron, sinking under the dominion of darkness and imposture through infernal influence.ST Nov 4, 1889RH Dec 10, 1861 Its modern counterpart is visionaries and somnambulists, pretended prophets and fortune-tellers, forebodings, presentiments and dreams treated as divine oracles, covert associations seeking disclosures, and amulets, charms and sympathetic remedies, proving that disbelief in the sure word of prophecy only leads into new superstition.RH Dec 10, 1861
Knowing the enemy's deceptive power to impersonate the dead is necessary to recognize him and to overcome him, which is done not alone but by putting on the whole armor of God, which is Christ, and by the blood of the Lamb and the word of testimony through faith.ST Jan 24, 1900 This error about the conscious state of the dead is the spring of almost every system of error by which he will try to deceive even the very elect, for Satan transforms himself into an angel of light to carry on this impersonation.ST Jan 24, 1900ST Dec 27, 1905 The voice associated with Endor belongs to sorcery and speaks lying words that mislead people, for the voices there were deceptive manifestations of evil spirits, not proof that the dead communicate with the living.ST Jun 4, 1885RH Sep 7, 1911ST Dec 27, 1905 It was ancient sorcery, which is modern Spiritualism, the work of evil spirits, and belongs to Satan's masterpiece of deception in the last days, which Christian people should not dabble with or encourage but meet by believing God's word on the condition of the dead and heeding His warnings against Spiritism.ST Dec 27, 1905ST Nov 14, 1892ST Jun 2, 1898
Sources