1 Samuel 28:25
And she brought it before Saul, and before his servants; and they did eat. Then they rose up, and went away that night.
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version
And she brought it before Saul, and before his servants; and they did eat. Then they rose up, and went away that night.
and she brought it before Saul, and before his servants; and they did eat. Then they arose up, and went away that night.
And she brought it before Saul, and before his servants; and they ate. Then they arose and went away that night.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
and she brought it before Saul, and before his servants; and they did eat. Then they rose up, and went away that night.
and bringeth nigh before Saul, and before his servants, and they eat, and rise, and go on, during that night.
and she brought it near before Saul, and before his servants, and they ate. And they rose up and went away that night.
and brought near before Saul and before his servants, and they did eat. Then rose they up and departed, the same night.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
She served it to Saul and his servants, and they ate. And that night they got up and left.
She brought it before Saul and before his servants, and they ate. Then they rose up and went away that night.
And she put it before Saul and his servants, and they had a meal. Then they got up and went away the same night.
Then she brought them before Saul, and before his seruants: and when they had eaten, they stoode, and went away the same night.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And set it before Saul, and before his servants. And when they had eaten they rose up, and walked all that night.
Cross-references
- 1 Chronicles 10:13-14
So Saul died for his transgression which he committed against the LORD, even against the word of the LORD, which he kept not, and also for asking counsel of one that had a familiar spirit, to enquire of it;
Saul’s consultation of a medium is cited as unfaithfulness that led to his death.
- 1 Samuel 28:19
Moreover the LORD will also deliver Israel with thee into the hand of the Philistines: and to morrow shalt thou and thy sons be with me: the LORD also shall deliver the host of Israel into the hand of the Philistines.
The prediction Saul hears before the meal foretells his death in battle.
- 1 Samuel 28:6
And when Saul enquired of the LORD, the LORD answered him not, neither by dreams, nor by Urim, nor by prophets.
The Lord refused to answer Saul through dreams, Urim, or prophets.
- 1 Samuel 28:13-14
And the king said unto her, Be not afraid: for what sawest thou? And the woman said unto Saul, I saw gods ascending out of the earth.
The woman describes the apparition ascending from the earth and as an old man.
- Deuteronomy 18:10-12
There shall not be found among you any one that maketh his son or his daughter to pass through the fire, or that useth divination, or an observer of times, or an enchanter, or a witch,
God forbids the occult practices and consulting familiar spirits exemplified at Endor.
- 1 Samuel 31:4-5
Then said Saul unto his armourbearer, Draw thy sword, and thrust me through therewith; lest these uncircumcised come and thrust me through, and abuse me. But his armourbearer would not; for he was sore afraid. Therefore Saul took a sword, and fell upon it.
Saul’s visit ended in his suicide.
- 1 Samuel 28:7-8
Then said Saul unto his servants, Seek me a woman that hath a familiar spirit, that I may go to her, and enquire of her. And his servants said to him, Behold, there is a woman that hath a familiar spirit at Endor.
Saul sought out a medium after God did not answer him.
- 1 Samuel 28:20
Then Saul fell straightway all along on the earth, and was sore afraid, because of the words of Samuel: and there was no strength in him; for he had eaten no bread all the day, nor all the night.
Saul believed Samuel’s words and fell down in fear.
- 1 Samuel 28:15
And Samuel said to Saul, Why hast thou disquieted me, to bring me up? And Saul answered, I am sore distressed; for the Philistines make war against me, and God is departed from me, and answereth me no more, neither by prophets, nor by dreams: therefore I have called thee, that thou mayest make known unto me what I shall do.
Saul admits God had departed and would no longer answer him.
- 1 Samuel 28:12
And when the woman saw Samuel, she cried with a loud voice: and the woman spake to Saul, saying, Why hast thou deceived me? for thou art Saul.
The woman recognizes Saul when the supposed Samuel identifies him.
- 1 Samuel 28:3
Now Samuel was dead, and all Israel had lamented him, and buried him in Ramah, even in his own city. And Saul had put away those that had familiar spirits, and the wizards, out of the land.
Saul had removed mediums and spiritists from the land.
- Leviticus 19:31
Regard not them that have familiar spirits, neither seek after wizards, to be defiled by them: I am the LORD your God.
Forbids seeking out those with familiar spirits.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
4 sources
The verse belongs to the time of Saul's fear and distress as the Philistine army gathered for the coming battle at Gilboa.PP 675.1 He came to the woman at Endor after the Lord refused to answer him by dreams, by the Urim, or by prophets.PP 683.1–2 The meal takes place after the fearful prediction given by the spirit that appeared as Samuel.PP 681.1–2
The woman serves food to Saul and his servants, they eat it, and then they rise and leave that night.SG4 83.3–85.1PP 681.1–2 Weakened by fasting and terror, Saul eats in the sorceress's cave in preparation for the battle in which he will die.PP 681.1–2 The Samuel whom Saul seemed to see was not the prophet raised from the dead, but a counterfeit impersonation by Satan's angels, who could both assume the form of the dead and disclose Saul's fate.SG4 83.3–85.1PP 683.1–2 The message from the counterfeit drove Saul toward ruin rather than leading him to repentance.PP 683.1–2 Consulting the familiar spirit was a transgression against the Lord for which Saul was rejected and left to destruction.PP 683.1–2
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
43 sources
She set food before Saul and his servants, they ate, and then they rose and left that night to return toward the armies awaiting battle the next day.RH Feb 4, 1909ST Sep 25, 1907ST Oct 21, 1930ST Sep 16, 1889RH Jul 2, 1867
What had appeared was not Samuel himself, for Saul saw nothing and only heard the woman describe an old man in a mantle, while the real Samuel lay buried at Ramah and could not be called up by a woman with a familiar spirit when God had refused to answer.ST Sep 16, 1930RH Jan 3, 1865ST Sep 25, 1907ST Nov 4, 1889
It was a deception by Satan in disguise, a fallen angel counterfeiting Samuel's form and voice so his words would be believed.RH Feb 4, 1909STRH Apr 7, 1874ST Oct 11, 1877ST Oct 18, 1877
Saul had separated himself from God by persistent disobedience until God answered him no more by dreams, by Urim, or by prophets, and in that forsaken extremity he turned in desperation to the very witchcraft he had once condemned.STST Sep 16, 1930ST Oct 21, 1930
The lying message foretelling defeat and death broke his courage and left him prostrate with terror, hastening his ruin and death with his sons and Israel's defeat.RH Feb 4, 1909ST Sep 16, 1930ST Oct 21, 1930ST Mar 21, 1911ST Sep 16, 1889
The encounter proves the dead know nothing and cannot communicate with the living, and it exposes modern Spiritualism as communion not with the dead but with devils.RH Apr 7, 1874RH Apr 11, 1854ST Dec 11, 1884ST Nov 17, 1914ST
Closing Meal and Departure
The verse closes the night visit to the woman at Endor, when she brought food before Saul and before his servants, and they ate, and then they rose up and went away that night.ST Sep 25, 1907ST Oct 21, 1930RH Jul 2, 1867ST Oct 10, 1906ST Sep 16, 1889 It is the concluding meal and night departure in the account of Samuel and the witch of Endor, an account that concerns the state of the dead and the sin of witchcraft.RH Jul 2, 1867ST Oct 10, 1906RH Apr 28, 1868 The consultation itself was superstition and spiritual blindness, and after the evil spirit had impersonated the dead prophet the woman served the food and they left that night.ST Oct 10, 1906ST Sep 16, 1889
After the meal Saul and his servants left that night and returned toward the battlefield and to the field of battle.RH Feb 4, 1909ST Sep 16, 1889 There the armies of Israel and the Philistines were facing each other with the result still uncertain for the battle to be fought on the morrow, for God had not decreed that Saul should be slain or Israel defeated.RH Feb 4, 1909 He went back broken-hearted with his remaining courage driven by despair before his death by his own hand, and leaving in that defeated condition made only one ending possible for the morrow's conflict.RH Feb 4, 1909ST Sep 16, 1889
The visit was degraded and desperate, for conscious of his degradation Saul left his royal robes behind and sought her companionship in her home in the back alleys of Endor where his own officers had failed to go.ST Nov 4, 1889 It was a hut that was a stable where she kept her calf with a dirt floor, where the stately king of Israel fell full length upon the ground when the message took away the last atom of his courage.ST Nov 4, 1889 By going he gained nothing and lost everything, marking the second step in his downward course after God departed from him, fallen too low with one more fall still to come.ST Nov 4, 1889 The whole account involved no miracle, for Samuel did not appear or speak to Saul though something that seemed to be Samuel appeared, since the dead have no knowledge or thoughts and cannot be released from the grave.ST Nov 4, 1889ST Dec 11, 1884
Apparition Was Not Samuel
Saul himself saw no visible form or appearance at Endor, for only the woman saw the peculiar apparition and described it at his request, and from her description of an old man coming up covered with a mantle he supposed and called it Samuel.ST Sep 16, 1930RH Jan 3, 1865ST Sep 25, 1907RH Aug 4, 1868 He did not see the figure but accepted the woman's description and treated it as Samuel, concluding it was the prophet from what she reported.RH Feb 4, 1909ST Sep 25, 1907RH Aug 4, 1868 The apparition came up out of the earth in the woman's sight at Endor, while Samuel was buried at Ramah many miles away.RH Jan 3, 1865 If Samuel had been in heaven he would have come down, not come up from below out of the earth.RH Jan 3, 1865ST Nov 4, 1889
The figure cannot have been Samuel's disembodied immortal soul, for disembodied souls do not become old and wear mantles or stay down in the earth.RH Jan 3, 1865 Samuel's soul would have been near his body at Ramah rather than at Endor.RH Jan 3, 1865 A bent old man clad in a mantle, appearing as an old man dressed and speaking like Samuel and saying why he had been disquieted, coming against his will as one compelled, enslaved and not at rest and subject to the summons of witches, does not match the heaven of the New Testament.ST Sep 16, 1930ST Nov 4, 1889
A wicked woman living openly contrary to God's law and in open violation of it, acting at the desire of one whom God had abandoned, was not permitted to disturb the repose of a most holy prophet in the unseen world.ST Sep 16, 1930RH Jan 3, 1865 Such a dissolute woman could not call him up from the earth, and could not make him answer when God had refused to answer Saul.ST Sep 16, 1930 God had strictly forbidden witchcraft on pain of death, and the Lord had nothing to do with this working.RH Jan 3, 1865RH Apr 11, 1854
What appeared was a deception by a familiar spirit, a spirit that pretended to be Samuel brought up.STST Sep 25, 1907RH Aug 4, 1868 It was Satan or the devil in disguise, a fallen angel impersonating a dead friend and counterfeiting Samuel's familiar form, voice, and manner so its words would be implicitly believed.RH Feb 4, 1909RH Apr 11, 1854STST Oct 11, 1877 Satan fashioned himself into a representation of Samuel and was ready for the occasion to make Saul believe the unseen was really Samuel, working in the same way as modern spirit manifestations.RH Feb 4, 1909RH Apr 11, 1854ST Nov 4, 1889 Satan has power to assume different appearances and to personate individuals so the deception looks righteous.ST Dead Samuel had nothing to say and the familiar spirit did all the speaking while counterfeiting him, proving familiar spirits are not the spirits of dead friends but fallen angels imitating them, so their claim to be the dead deserves no weight because they are wicked and deceitful, and the chapter does not prove the dead have knowledge or can appear and communicate.RH Apr 7, 1874RH Apr 11, 1854ST Oct 11, 1877
Saul's Rejection and Desperation
Saul's downfall began long before Endor, when he began to prefer his own ways to God's ways and grew restive and rebellious under reproof.ST By pride, jealousy, disobedience and selfishness he separated himself from the divine will until the Spirit of God withdrew, and by lack of faith in God and persistent self-will he brought himself to ruin.ST Oct 21, 1930ST Feb 19, 1885 When he would not receive God's words, God left him.ST
Willful disobedience had taken away his right to the throne and his privilege of calling upon the Lord for help.ST Sep 16, 1930 God answered him no more by Urim and Thummim, nor by dreams, nor by prophets.STST Oct 21, 1930 Forsaken and refused an answer, he was left in that condition without divine guidance.STST Feb 1, 1905ST Sep 20, 1905
In that forsaken extremity, when war with the Philistines came, he sought information from God but received no answer, so in frenzied zeal to know the result of the approaching battle he sought a woman with a familiar spirit to bring up Samuel.ST Oct 21, 1930 He turned to an aged spiritist medium, who brought up a spirit that pretended to be Samuel.ST Though when in touch with God he had decreed the destruction of all who had familiar spirits, he now turned to the witchcraft God calls an abomination.ST Sep 16, 1930
The meal and departure that night stand in the sad record of Saul's rashness, weakness, failure, rejection, and ever-downward course.STST Apr 11, 1911 That course is set against the choosing of David and his checkered but ever-rising career, showing the habits and customs of the people, the influence of surrounding nations upon them, and God's providence shaping and molding national events while still remembering the promised Seed.ST Apr 11, 1911 Going to Endor was the second step down after disobeying God until God departed from him, with one more fall still to come before his unhappy death and Israel's defeat.ST Nov 4, 1889ST Feb 19, 1885
Lying Message and Ruin
The voice that spoke claimed to be Samuel brought up from the grave, complaining that Saul had disturbed his rest to bring him up, reproaching Saul for asking of him what God had withheld and then giving that withheld information, and assuring him that after the morrow's battle all, good and bad, would be together.ST Oct 21, 1930RH Jul 27, 1869 It came bodily up from the earth as one who had died and slept, disturbed and speaking with Saul, not as a living soul speaking while its body remained in the grave.RH Jul 27, 1869
Satan knew what Saul dreaded and expected, and announced that Israel with Saul would be delivered into the hand of the Philistines and that Saul and his sons would die on the morrow.RH Feb 4, 1909ST Nov 4, 1889 That prediction bore Satan's mark of part truth and part falsehood, with just enough truth to hide the lie, and it needed little ingenuity when the army was about to be crushed.RH Feb 4, 1909ST Nov 4, 1889 The demon inferred defeat and death from God's anger seen in Saul's actions and in his consultation of the medium, but was wrong about the day of his death.RH Aug 4, 1868 A witch, fortune-teller, Spiritualist, or necromancer can only tell what the devil has seen in a person's past life and what his shrewdness foresees from forces already in operation, and can go no further.ST Nov 4, 1889
The message changed Saul from apprehensive to defeated, broke his heart, and took away his courage and perseverance, his only hope of success.RH Feb 4, 1909ST Nov 4, 1889 It left him fallen prostrate, fainting with terror and sore afraid.RH Feb 4, 1909ST Oct 21, 1930 He went back broken-hearted with his remaining courage driven by despair, and leaving in that condition made only one ending possible for the morrow's conflict.RH Feb 4, 1909ST Sep 16, 1889 There the message took away the last atom of his courage and left him fallen full length upon the ground, fallen too low with one more fall still to come.ST Nov 4, 1889
Saul died for his transgression against the word of the Lord which he kept not and for asking counsel of one that had a familiar spirit to inquire of it instead of inquiring of the Lord.RH Feb 4, 1909ST Sep 16, 1930ST Mar 21, 1911 In blindness he undertook war with the Philistines under such circumstances, leading to Israel's defeat and his utter defeat.ST Apr 7, 1909ST Feb 19, 1885 That course ended in his unhappy death by his own hand, with the loss of his own life and that of Jonathan.ST Apr 7, 1909ST Sep 16, 1889ST Feb 19, 1885
State of the Dead
The night at Endor shows that the dead do not pass knowledge to the living, for the dead know nothing, have no knowledge or thoughts, have no more reward, their memory is forgotten, their love and hatred and envy have perished, they have no more portion forever in anything done under the sun, and man lies down and rises not till the heavens be no more, neither awaking nor being raised out of sleep.RH Apr 7, 1874RH Apr 11, 1854ST Dec 11, 1884ST Nov 17, 1914RH Jun 23, 1859 The figure taken for Samuel was not Samuel raised from the dead and did not appear or speak as Samuel, but was a familiar spirit impersonating him, the devil in disguise working as in modern spirit manifestations, which Satan cannot do by releasing the dead from the grave.RH Apr 7, 1874RH Apr 11, 1854ST Dec 11, 1884ST Nov 17, 1914 The Lord had nothing to do with it, for the Lord had departed from Saul and would not answer him, and such messages are of satanic origin.RH Apr 7, 1874RH Apr 11, 1854 The chapter therefore does not prove that the dead have knowledge or that the conscious dead can appear and communicate with the living, and to use the witch of Endor as proof for Spiritualism is deception.RH Apr 11, 1854ST Nov 17, 1914RH Jun 23, 1859 Necromancy is forbidden on pain of death, yet necromancy is not real communion with the dead but only pretended communication with the dead to reveal future events.RH Apr 11, 1854
The passage gives the Bible's full specimen of the work of familiar spirits, where the spirit working with the woman professed to bring up the dead at pleasure and to enable them to speak to the living, but the profession was a false pretense.ST Oct 11, 1877ST Oct 18, 1877 Dead Samuel had nothing to say, and the familiar spirit did all the speaking while counterfeiting him.ST Oct 11, 1877 This proves familiar spirits are not the spirits of dead friends but fallen angels imitating them, and their own claim to be the dead deserves no weight because they are wicked and deceitful.ST Oct 11, 1877 The episode illustrates how witchcraft used the belief that the dead remain conscious and can communicate, while the supposed response came from evil spirits rather than the dead.ST Oct 18, 1877 Satan and his angels have power to transform themselves into angels of light and to assume different appearances and to personate individuals and the dead so the deception looks righteous.ST Nov 17, 1914ST All who profess to consult with the dead really commune with devils and have fellowship with devils, consulting with evil angels.ST Nov 17, 1914
By contrast, what those held who described it otherwise is that the event is Samuel coming bodily up from the earth, being disturbed, and speaking with Saul, presented as the one who had died and slept coming up from the grave, not as Samuel's soul living and speaking while his body remained there.RH Jul 27, 1869 The account of Samuel and the witch of Endor, closed by the bringing of food before Saul and his servants and their eating and going away that night, is a remarkable portion of Scripture that teaches man's nature and destiny, whether man is immortal, the state of the dead, and the sin of witchcraft.RH Mar 10, 1868RH Jul 2, 1867RH May 12, 1868ST Sep 30, 1886RH May 5, 1868 It bears on those questions and shows that Spiritualism is a satanic delusion.RH Mar 10, 1868RH Jul 2, 1867ST Sep 30, 1886RH May 5, 1868RH May 26, 1868
Warning Against Modern Spiritualism
Saul's night visit ends with eating and going away, but that meal does not prove messages come from the spirit world, for he did not commune with Samuel but with a fallen angel after willful disobedience had taken away his right to the throne and his privilege of calling upon the Lord for help.ST Sep 16, 1930 In his extremity, when God had forsaken him and refused to answer him, he sought a woman with a familiar spirit to bring up Samuel, though when in touch with God he had decreed the destruction of all who had familiar spirits, and so turned to a spiritualist practice not from God but to the witchcraft God calls an abomination.ST Sep 16, 1930ST Feb 1, 1905 He only judged from the medium's description of an old man coming up covered with a mantle that it was Samuel, yet Samuel if in heaven would not still be a bent old man clad in a mantle, would not be called up from the earth, could not be called up by a dissolute woman living contrary to God's law, and could not be made to answer when God had refused to answer Saul.ST Sep 16, 1930 For asking counsel of one that had a familiar spirit Saul died and paid the penalty for his transgression.ST Sep 16, 1930
The account of Samuel and the witch of Endor gives Bible evidence on the source and character of Spiritualism and bears on man's nature and destiny, whether man is immortal, and the state of the dead.ST Mar 11, 1908ST Sep 30, 1886 It is a Bible example of spirit manifestation that exposes modern Spiritualism and its strange phenomena as a supernatural deception and satanic delusion, the great deception foretold by prophecy.RH Feb 18, 1909 Bible teaching and predictions are fulfilled by Spiritualists.ST Mar 11, 1908
Saul came afraid with greatly trembling heart to seek one with a familiar spirit for Samuel, though Samuel being loyal to God could not be forced to speak through a medium God had ordered destroyed and would have given him no response.RH Feb 4, 1909 He himself saw no visible form but from the woman's description supposed the unseen was the prophet, and Satan who impersonates dead friends was ready for the occasion and made him believe the unseen was really Samuel so its words would be implicitly believed.RH Feb 4, 1909 Satan knew what he dreaded and expected and announced that Israel with Saul would be delivered into the hand of the Philistines and Saul and his sons would die on the morrow, which changed him from apprehensive to defeated, broke his heart, took away his courage, and left him fallen prostrate and sore afraid, so that leaving in that condition toward the battle to be fought the next day while the armies of Israel and the Philistines were facing each other with the result still uncertain made only one ending possible, for God had not decreed that he should be slain or Israel defeated.RH Feb 4, 1909 Spiritualism has no standard of right and wrong and acknowledges no authority, and only curses the man led away with it.RH Feb 4, 1909 The consultation is superstition and spiritual blindness and being led by the power of darkness, closed by bringing food before Saul and his servants, their eating, rising, and leaving that night.ST Oct 10, 1906RH Sep 20, 1906
Saul gained nothing and lost everything by going to the witch of Endor, marking the second step in his downward course after disobeying God until God departed from him, fallen too low with one more step still to fall.ST Nov 4, 1889 Conscious of his degradation he left his royal robes behind and sought her companionship in her home in the back alleys of Endor where his own officers who had scoured the country for witches had failed to go, a hut that was a stable where she kept her calf with a dirt floor, where the stately king of Israel fell full length upon the ground when the message he received took away the last atom of his courage.ST Nov 4, 1889 A witch, fortune-teller, Spiritualist, or necromancer can only tell what the devil has seen in a person's past life and what his shrewdness foresees from forces already in operation, and can go no further.ST Nov 4, 1889 All who turn into that gate gain nothing and lose everything and are in great danger of speedily committing spiritual and physical suicide, like Saul.ST Nov 4, 1889 Sharing the meal prepared by the woman with a familiar spirit, the spiritualist medium whose instruction he followed, together with his servants, and then leaving that night belongs to the sad account ending with his death, showing the miserable end of one who had been strong and noble in his youth because he turned to a spiritualist medium.ST Apr 22, 1913
Refusing to walk in known duty places a person where God regards his prayer as abomination and will not hear him, so obedience is the condition on which God answers prayer and unwillingness to comply with the conditions is why many prayers are not answered, as Saul's case shows.ST Nov 15, 1905 The assigned reading of 1 Samuel 26-28 carries the lesson that God will finally reject the disobedient.RH Mar 23, 1916 The woman at Endor who dealt with familiar spirits and was consulted by Saul stands as the comparison for a woman devoted to communicating with spirits.RH Sep 26, 1871
Sources