1 Samuel 8:18
And ye shall cry out in that day because of your king which ye shall have chosen you; and the LORD will not hear you in that day.
Translations
And you shall cry out in that day because of your king which you shall have chosen you; and the LORD will not hear you in that day.
And ye shall cry out in that day because of your king which ye shall have chosen you; and the LORD will not hear you in that day.
And ye shall cry out in that day because of your king which ye shall have chosen you; and the Lord will not hear you in that day.
And ye shall cry out in that day because of your king which ye shall have chosen for yourselves; and the LORD will not hear you in that day.
And ye shall cry out in that day because of your king which ye shall have chosen you; and the LORD will not answer you in that day.
And ye shall cry out in that day because of your king whom ye shall have chosen you; and Jehovah will not answer you in that day.
And ye have cried out in that day because of the king whom ye have chosen for yourselves, and Jehovah doth not answer you in that day.'
And ye shall cry out in that day because of your king whom ye have chosen; and Jehovah will not answer you in that day.
Then will ye make outcry, in that day, because of your king whom ye have chosen for yourselves,—and Yahweh will not answer you, in that day.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
When that day comes, you will beg for relief from the king you have chosen, but the LORD will not answer you on that day.”
You will cry out in that day because of your king whom you will have chosen for yourselves; and the LORD will not answer you in that day.”
Then you will be crying out because of your king whom you have taken for yourselves; but the Lord will not give you an answer in that day.
And ye shall crie out at that day, because of your King, whom ye haue chosen you, and the Lord will not heare you at that day.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And you shall cry out in that day from the face of the king, whom you have chosen to yourselves. and the Lord will not hear you in that day, because you desired unto yourselves a king.
Cross-references
- 1 Samuel 8:7
And the LORD said unto Samuel, Hearken unto the voice of the people in all that they say unto thee: for they have not rejected thee, but they have rejected me, that I should not reign over them.
Israel’s demand for a king is called a rejection of God’s rule.
- Hosea 13:11
I gave thee a king in mine anger, and took him away in my wrath.
God gave Israel the demanded king in anger and judgment.
- 1 Samuel 8:9
Now therefore hearken unto their voice: howbeit yet protest solemnly unto them, and shew them the manner of the king that shall reign over them.
Commands Samuel to warn Israel about the king they demanded.
- 1 Samuel 8:11
And he said, This will be the manner of the king that shall reign over you: He will take your sons, and appoint them for himself, for his chariots, and to be his horsemen; and some shall run before his chariots.
Details the oppressive manner of the king cried out against.
- Deuteronomy 17:14-20
When thou art come unto the land which the LORD thy God giveth thee, and shalt possess it, and shalt dwell therein, and shalt say, I will set a king over me, like as all the nations that are about me;
paired as the second warning sketch of bad kings
- 1 Samuel 12:17-19
Is it not wheat harvest to day? I will call unto the LORD, and he shall send thunder and rain; that ye may perceive and see that your wickedness is great, which ye have done in the sight of the LORD, in asking you a king.
Thunder and rain lead the people to confess their sin in asking for a king.
- Judges 9:6
And all the men of Shechem gathered together, and all the house of Millo, and went, and made Abimelech king, by the plain of the pillar that was in Shechem.
Israel made Abimelech king, with disastrous results.
- 1 Samuel 9:2
And he had a son, whose name was Saul, a choice young man, and a goodly: and there was not among the children of Israel a goodlier person than he: from his shoulders and upward he was higher than any of the people.
Saul is later chosen as the king Israel demanded.
- 1 Samuel 10:23-24
And they ran and fetched him thence: and when he stood among the people, he was higher than any of the people from his shoulders and upward.
people forgot the warning when pleased by Saul's stature
- 1 Samuel 8:3
And his sons walked not in his ways, but turned aside after lucre, and took bribes, and perverted judgment.
gives the failure used to demand a king
- Judges 21:25
In those days there was no king in Israel: every man did that which was right in his own eyes.
Describes Israel’s disorder when there was no king.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
16 sources
Samuel spoke under God's direction to protest Israel's demand for a king like the nations to judge them, declaring plainly that it was not the right and best way.Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15 Their demand was a sinful rebellion that rejected God as divine King and special leader, preferring visible human power to His unseen guidance, providence and deliverance in order to be like the world.Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–311SP 355.1–2Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29SG4 65.4Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11 He warned that their chosen king would be exalted with honor due to God, take their children for his service, seize land and property, exact heavy tribute and a tenth of income and produce, and oppress them without judging justly or teaching the Lord's ways.SG4 65.4ST Jul 13, 1882SG4 67.2 Because they refused to let the warning change their purpose, God listened to their voice and gave them a king in anger to have their own way, and once the monarchy was established they could not end it but would cry out in distress under its burden without the Lord hearing or delivering them.Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–311SP 355.1–2Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15SG4 67.2 The same folly is repeated today when God's people with self-confidence lean on men and worldly policy to be like other nations, and the safeguard is greater humility with less confidence in self and more trust in God shown by much more praying.Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–316T 249.4–250.2Ms 61, 1890, par. 18Lt 124, 1900, par. 25–294MR 69.2
Israel's Rejection of God
1 Samuel 8:18 is the solemn protest spoken under God's direction through Samuel against Israel's demand for a king to judge them like all the nations, plainly declaring that demanding a king was not the right and best way but would bring trouble that would make them cry out.Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15 The demand was a sinful, rebellious departure from God, rejecting Him as divine King and special leader in favor of a human ruler.1SP 355.1–2SG4 65.4Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11Lt 9, 1901, par. 23–24 It showed lack of faith in His providence and in His unseen guidance and deliverance, following instead the nations that did not acknowledge God.SG4 65.4Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11
In wanting to be like the other nations and to be recognized by the world, the people left their first love and grew weary of God's will and ways and merciful guidance.Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29 They preferred visible human power to the divine power that had led and protected them.6T 249.4–250.2Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11 Choosing a king meant discarding God's appointed servant before God had released him, and in spiritual blindness separating from God's management and control and refusing to be under His jurisdiction.Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31 It was choosing human judgment, worldly policy, and a new order of things that had not entered God's mind, instead of being led and controlled by the Lord and knowing the blessing and safety of being led by Him in all their ways.Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31
The warning detailed what that king would exact: exalted and claiming the honor due to God, he would demand honors and heavy tribute, taxation and service, taking their children for his service, seizing land and property, and claiming a tenth of income and produce.SG4 65.4ST Jul 13, 1882SG4 67.2PP 606.2 He would oppress them, and unlike former rulers he would not judge their disputes or teach them the Lord's ways.SG4 67.2 His authority would be used to raise up the unworthy while making the innocent suffer and to lead the people away from God.SG4 65.4
Consequences of Chosen King
Israel persisted in following its own mind and judgment for imagined national glory, refusing to let the solemn warning change its purpose and casting aside divine wisdom, and therefore God listened to the voice of the people, permitted them to have their own way, and granted the desire of their unsanctified hearts by giving them a king in anger.Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15SG4 67.2Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11 The demand itself was wrongful, for it chose a human ruler in place of God as divine King and followed the nations that did not acknowledge Him, despite His unseen guidance and deliverance.SG4 67.2Lt 12a, 1888, par. 9–11 God plainly told them through Samuel that this was not the right and best way but would bring trouble that would make them cry out, yet He let their choice stand.Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31Ms 40, 1890, par. 10–15
Plans laid without His Spirit react upon their makers, so once the monarchy was established it could not simply be ended when its exactions became oppressive.Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31PP 606.2 The people would cry out in distress and oppression under the burdens imposed by the king of their own choice, including additional taxation and service.1SP 355.1–2Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29PP 604.2ST Jul 13, 1882PP 606.2 By rejecting God's reign for human rule they brought upon themselves the distress that afterward came from that choice.1SP 355.1–2Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29
In that day when they cried out under that burden the Lord would not hear or deliver them.1SP 355.1–2Ms 40a, 1890, par. 24–29PP 604.2ST Jul 13, 1882SG4 67.2 He would not display His mighty power for them as He had in Egypt.1SP 355.1–2SG4 67.2 This refusal to answer was part of the warning given beforehand, showing the painful consequence of rejecting God's warnings and choosing human rule instead.PP 604.2ST Jul 13, 1882
The warning was verified in later history, for the choice shows how seeking worldly status and approval leads to patterning after the world.6T 249.4–250.2Lt 124, 1900, par. 25–29 The people later recognized their desire for a king as a mistake as they saw the ruler's example spreading irreligion and godlessness.PP 663.1–2 Having preferred visible human power to the divine power that had led and protected them, their choice was followed by the destruction of Jerusalem and the nation's dispersion.6T 249.4–250.2
Warning Against Trusting Men
The verse warns against renouncing God's rule for a worldly model and turning away from divine guidance.6T 249.4–250.2Lt 9, 1901, par. 23–244MR 69.2 Israel chose an earthly king to be like the surrounding nations despite the Lord's warning, preferring visible human power to the divine power that had led and protected them.6T 249.4–250.2Lt 9, 1901, par. 23–24 Depending on people rather than God in this way weakens God's people and turns aside the work He would do through them.6T 249.4–250.24MR 69.2 Their choice brought distress in which the Lord would not hear their cries, and it was followed by the destruction of Jerusalem and the dispersion of the nation.6T 249.4–250.24MR 69.2
The folly of Samuel's day will be repeated among God's people today when with self-confidence they lean on men and on their own judgment after worldly plans and policy instead of trusting the Lord as Ruler.Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31Ms 61, 1890, par. 184MR 69.2 Leaving their first love, they want to be like other nations and to be recognized by the world, seeking worldly status, approval, gain and praise by patterning themselves after the world.Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31Lt 124, 1900, par. 25–29 By their own voice they choose to be ruled by human judgment, worldly policy, and a new order of things that has not entered God's mind instead of being led and controlled by the Lord.Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31Ms 61, 1890, par. 18 In spiritual blindness they discard God's appointed servant before God has released him, separate themselves from God's management and control, and refuse to be under His jurisdiction because they do not know the blessing and safety of being led by Him in all their ways.Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31 God listens to the voice of the people and lets their choice stand, but plans laid without His Spirit react upon the makers, so the warning was verified and will be verified again.Ms 53, 1890, par. 26–31Lt 124, 1900, par. 25–29
The safeguard is greater humility with less confidence in self and more trust in God, so that men no longer lean on men or their own judgment but make God their trust.Ms 61, 1890, par. 184MR 69.2 Only then will the work abide the test, as divine power is combined with human effort through dependence on God and the mind of Christ.Ms 61, 1890, par. 18 That dependence is shown by less talking and much more praying, by meekness of spirit, and by caution in plans and movements.Ms 61, 1890, par. 18
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
26 sources
Israel asked for a human king to judge and fight for them like the surrounding nations, rejecting God Himself as their King who had ruled them through judges and prophets with no chosen man as ruler.RH Jan 28, 1902RH Mar 25, 1875ST May 31, 1899ST Apr 17, 1901ST Mar 31, 1909 Samuel was told to grant their persistent demand yet solemnly warn them beforehand what such a king would do.RH Mar 25, 1875ST May 31, 1899 The king they chose for themselves would take their sons for war, their daughters for service, their fields and flocks and a tenth of their increase, until they would become his servants under selfish oppression.ST Apr 17, 1901ST Sep 20, 1883ST Nov 19, 1896 In that day they would cry out because of that oppression, and the Lord would not hear them, having left them to what they had chosen against His original will.ST Jun 25, 1885ST Sep 20, 1883ST Dec 3, 1902RH Oct 28, 1873RH Jul 20, 1911 This was fulfilled when Saul proved a hard master and when Solomon laid heavy burdens that Rehoboam refused to ease, showing that theocracy is self-government under God's law while monarchy is rule of men by men that necessarily resorts to force.ST Jun 25, 1885ST Nov 19, 1896ST Oct 24, 1895RH May 26, 1904ST Apr 17, 1901
Rejection and Warning
1 Samuel 8:18 belongs to Israel's formal demand for a human king in place of God's own rule.RH Jan 28, 1902RH Mar 25, 1875ST Mar 31, 1909 Up to that time God Himself was their leader and King, ruling through lieutenants and under-shepherds such as Joshua, the judges, and Samuel, with no man chosen as ruler.RH Mar 25, 1875 The people chose a human king because they wanted to be like other nations, though God had called them to a higher place, and their demand was a rejection of God's rule and a loss of the conditions that called them to trust in God alone as their King.RH Jan 28, 1902ST Mar 31, 1909
The elders gathered to Samuel and asked for a king to judge them like all the nations and to fight their battles.ST Jul 22, 1889RH Mar 25, 1875ST Apr 17, 1901 They wanted to be like other nations with kings of the sons of men, from dissatisfaction with government by judges, pressure from the warlike nations still in Canaan, pride in outward appearance, dissatisfaction with dependence on God, and unwillingness to remain a peculiar people governed by God's law and trusting in God alone.ST Jul 22, 1889ST May 31, 1899ST Feb 27, 1901 At heart they had already become like all the nations and would not govern themselves by the law of God, so they must be governed by men under human law.ST Apr 17, 1901 Their crying for a king was disloyalty in looking to him instead of to God for protection and guidance and in patterning after nations that had lost the memory of God.ST Feb 27, 1901
The thing displeased Samuel and he prayed to the Lord.RH Mar 25, 1875 The Lord answered that the people had not rejected Samuel but had rejected God that He should not reign over them, yet Samuel was to hearken to their voice while solemnly protesting to them and showing them the manner of the king that would reign over them.RH Mar 25, 1875ST May 31, 1899 Because the people refused to obey God's voice speaking through Samuel's warning and insisted, Nay, but we will have a king over us, God let them have their way in anger and left them to what they chose.RH Mar 25, 1875ST May 31, 1899 Their insistence was open rebellion and complete rejection of God and His law for an earthly king and earthly law, rooted in forgetting the Lord and serving Baal and Ashtaroth.ST May 31, 1899ST Apr 17, 1901 The steps to that choice were first doubt and questioning, then positive unbelief, then failure in self-government under the divine law, then utter rejection of that law as the rule of life, then open idolatry in some form, then monarchy.ST Apr 17, 1901
God was unwilling to establish a royal family because absolute power could make rulers proud and oppressive, and the demand was contrary to His will and not His original ideal.ST Sep 20, 1883RH Oct 28, 1873ST Nov 29, 1883 Yet after the people persisted He permitted it in anger, gave them Saul as a king of their own choice, and left them to the oppression of the king they chose.ST May 31, 1899ST Sep 20, 1883ST Oct 17, 1916 Samuel warned them beforehand by the Lord's instruction of the manner of the king: taking sons for chariots and war, daughters for service, fields, vineyards and oliveyards, menservants, maidservants and labor and stock, and the tenth of seed, vineyards and sheep for his officers and servants, with additional taxation and service, until they would be his servants.ST Jul 13, 1882ST Apr 17, 1901RH Mar 11, 1873 That picture is of a selfish, autocratic king, showing everything a good king should not be and should not do, bringing human tyranny and selfish abuse of authority and robbery of subjects.ST Sep 20, 1883ST Nov 19, 1896RH Mar 11, 1873
The verse therefore warns that they would cry out in that day because of oppression by the king they had chosen for themselves, and the Lord would not hear them in that day.ST Jul 13, 1882ST Jun 25, 1885ST Dec 3, 1902ST Apr 17, 1901 The warning was meant to turn them from their error, to lead them to rely on freely given grace, and to show the loss of the conditions that called them to trust in God alone.RH Mar 11, 1873ST Mar 31, 1909RH Jul 20, 1911 Insisting on things God was not ready to give could shut them away from influences that would bring greater spiritual benefit.ST Jul 22, 1889
Fulfilment Doctrine and Application
The warning came to pass when the people fixed on outward appearance in pride and lost sight of what had been told them, choosing Saul, the goodliest in all Israel and head and shoulders above other men, who proved a hard master they had chosen for themselves.ST Oct 24, 1895ST Jul 29, 1889 The same warning picture of a selfish, autocratic king, showing everything a good king should not be and should not do, was fulfilled again under Solomon, who became and did exactly what it describes.ST Jun 25, 1885ST Nov 19, 1896 He laid heavy burdens on the people to support himself and his household, so that when they asked Rehoboam for relief he mocked their grievance rather than easing it.ST Jun 25, 1885 His course left him without excuse despite the wisdom, blessings, and instruction God had given him.ST Nov 19, 1896
Trouble followed when a king turned from the Lord's direction and followed his own way after the choice that had been granted with warning.ST Oct 17, 1916 Some of the permitted kings proved very bad, though God permitted the office and directed His prophets to anoint kings.ST Nov 29, 1883 The demand for a king despite the warning began a path toward ruin, for the defender expected to fight their battles could ultimately bring only weakness, failure, and loss.RH Jun 29, 1916
Theocracy is self-government by aid of the divine law, while monarchy is government of men by fellow men under human law.ST Apr 17, 1901 Monarchy naturally and necessarily brings the use of force to compel performance of what the governor conceives to be duty, so that even the most conscientious rulers become persecutors trying to enforce what seems to them plain moral duty.ST Apr 17, 1901 The people wanted a king to restrain disorder, but their need was not a different system of government; it was a change in themselves and greater discipline in self-government.RH May 26, 1904 Their movement by steps ran from doubt and questioning to positive unbelief to failure in self-government under divine law to utter rejection of that law as the rule of life to open idolatry in some form to monarchy and its suffering cry.ST Apr 17, 1901
The statement that the king would take the tenth of seed and sheep does not set God's plan for the tithe and does not make it right to deduct taxes to government from what belongs to God's cause.RH Mar 11, 1873 It describes selfish abuse of authority and robbery of subjects, taking for officers and servants what rightfully belongs to others, along with sons, daughters, fields, vineyards, stock, animals, and labor.RH Mar 11, 1873 Even if later kings did take a tenth in this way, it proves nothing about God's design.RH Mar 11, 1873 The coming oppression and the unanswered crying out under the chosen king were held up to turn them away from electing such a ruler.RH Mar 11, 1873
God's permission for a king was a concession to demand and not His original ideal, parallel to His permission for man to eat flesh.RH Oct 28, 1873 As the permission for a king was followed by punishment in the unanswered crying out because of the chosen king, so man's days gradually shortened after flesh was permitted for food.RH Oct 28, 1873 Although God allowed an earthly ruler, He would not let Israel's king lead His chosen people in the way of the surrounding nations, and the warning was meant to turn them from error and lead them to rely on freely given grace.RH Jul 20, 1911 The kingdom given to Israel and organized under Saul and established under David was made in some respects a type of the kingdom of God soon to be established under the seed of David, the Lord Jesus Christ.RH Mar 25, 1875
The verse illustrates human rule that lords it over others as though their welfare did not matter, bringing oppression with the king they chose.ST Dec 3, 1902 Israel's crying for a king was disloyalty to God as ruler and leader, looking to a visible king instead of to God for protection and guidance from dissatisfaction with dependence on God.ST Feb 27, 1901ST Oct 13, 1881 They did not want to remain a peculiar people as God's example to the world, but forsook God as King to pattern after nations that had lost the memory of God, and with their king came oppression and long and bloody wars as the guerdon of disloyalty.ST Feb 27, 1901 Their prideful demand deprived them of greater blessings and communion with God, leaving them afraid when Goliath challenged Saul and his army, and insisting on things God was not ready to give could shut them away from influences that would bring greater spiritual benefit.ST Jul 22, 1889ST Oct 13, 1881
The same principle holds when people persist in demanding what God has denied and God allows them to receive it to their disaster.RH Jan 29, 1914 Israel's desire to be like the surrounding nations parallels America's drift from founding principles toward militarism and involvement in other powers' conflicts. It applies likewise to the churches' effort to secure a Sunday law through state power after prayers for it have gone unanswered, for insistence against God's will can end in distress where the cry is not answered then.RH Jan 29, 1914
Sources