Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
Them that sin rebuke before all, that others also may fear.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
Them that sin reprove in the sight of all, that the rest also may be in fear.
Those sinning, reprove before all, that the others also may have fear;
Those that sin convict before all, that the rest also may have fear.
But, them who are sinning, before all, do thou reprove, that, the rest also, may have, fear:—
But those who persist in sin should be rebuked in front of everyone, so that the others will stand in fear of sin.
Those who persist in sin should be rebuked in front of everyone, so that the others will stand in fear of sin.
Those who sin, reprove in the sight of all, that the rest also may be in fear.
Say sharp words to sinners when all are present, so that the rest may be in fear.
Them that sinne, rebuke openly, that the rest also may feare.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Them that sin reprove before all: that the rest also may have fear.
Cross-references
- Matthew 18:15-17
Moreover if thy brother shall trespass against thee, go and tell him his fault between thee and him alone: if he shall hear thee, thou hast gained thy brother.
Its private-first steps address personal trespasses, unlike public wrongdoing.
- 1 Corinthians 5:11-13
But now I have written unto you not to keep company, if any man that is called a brother be a fornicator, or covetous, or an idolater, or a railer, or a drunkard, or an extortioner; with such an one no not to eat.
The church is commanded to confront open sin and remove the persistently sinful member.
- 2 Timothy 4:2
Preach the word; be instant in season, out of season; reprove, rebuke, exhort with all longsuffering and doctrine.
Both instruct Timothy to reprove and rebuke.
- Galatians 2:11-14
But when Peter was come to Antioch, I withstood him to the face, because he was to be blamed.
Paul publicly rebuked Peter for conduct that contradicted the gospel.
- Titus 1:13
This witness is true. Wherefore rebuke them sharply, that they may be sound in the faith;
Sharp rebuke aims to make people sound in the faith.
- Titus 2:15
These things speak, and exhort, and rebuke with all authority. Let no man despise thee.
Both command ministers to rebuke with authority.
- Galatians 6:1
Brethren, if a man be overtaken in a fault, ye which are spiritual, restore such an one in the spirit of meekness; considering thyself, lest thou also be tempted.
Both call for corrective action toward someone caught in sin.
- Titus 3:10
A man that is an heretick after the first and second admonition reject;
Both instruct admonition and discipline for wrongdoing.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
13 sources
Those who sin openly and persist in a course that harms others and the work of God are to be corrected openly before all, so that others will take warning and fear to do the same.2T 14.3–16.27MR 210.1–2Lt 6, 1868, par. 4–6Ms 10, 1899, par. 16Lt 2, 1854, par. 6 This public dealing is for known and continued wrongs, not for a private personal offense, which is to be approached privately first, and those who do not know their conduct is sinful are to be reproved before they are publicly rebuked.2T 14.3–16.2Lt 6, 1868, par. 4–6Lt 2, 1854, par. 6 It is the solemn duty of ministers faithfully to expose and correct wrong and uphold discipline, without shrinking because the work is unpleasant and unwelcome.Lt 3, 1892, par. 24–27Lt 12, 1893, par. 33–37ICEP 1.2PP 361.2 That correction is to be given without partiality to rank, office, wealth, or friendship, firmly yet patiently and in the spirit of Christ, for to excuse sin or pass it over in false sympathy sanctions the evil and brings guilt and wrath upon God's people.Lt 12, 1893, par. 33–37ICEP 1.2PP 361.2ST Sep 2, 1913Ms 10, 1899, par. 16 Those who hear the reproof of another must examine themselves, confess and forsake the same sins in themselves, and not flatter themselves that they are approved because they were not named, lest they be left in darkness to be led captive by Satan.2T 112.2–113.1
When Public Rebuke Applies
Public wrongs that threaten the church and its work are to be rebuked publicly before all, so that others may take warning.2T 14.3–16.2Lt 6, 1868, par. 4–6 This public dealing is distinct from the course for a personal trespass or personal offense against the one bringing correction, which begins with a private approach between the two people involved.2T 14.3–16.2Lt 6, 1868, par. 4–6 Where the sin is not merely a private offense, it is not to be handled privately as though it were a trespass between two people, but those at fault are to be reproved before others so that others may fear.2T 14.3–16.2Lt 6, 1868, par. 4–6
Sins committed openly are to be rebuked openly before others, so that others may fear.7MR 210.1–2Ms 10, 1899, par. 16Lt 11, 1870, par. 22 A course that has harmed God's work and people, being censurable and blameworthy, requires a clear and prompt open response rather than toleration or covering up, lest prejudice and distrust take root.7MR 210.1–2Lt 11, 1870, par. 22 Those responsible for the church must not tolerate or cover up a member's sin but must deal with it promptly and openly so others will fear God, requiring the person to put it away or be separated from the church.7MR 210.1–2Lt 11, 1870, par. 22 No rank or office protects anyone from the reach of truth when duty is neglected and opportunities are misused, and faithful reproof is not to be withheld from those who lead others to exalt self and who despise correction.Ms 10, 1899, par. 16
Those who persist in sin after being warned and after knowing the church's view are to be rebuked publicly so that others may fear.Lt 2, 1854, par. 6 Those who do not know that their conduct is sinful are first to be reproved before being publicly rebuked.Lt 2, 1854, par. 6 Irreverence that continues after reproof and knowledge brings God's displeasure.Lt 2, 1854, par. 6
Faithful Duty to Correct
Ministers bear a serious duty to correct and expose wrongdoing openly so that others may fear sin and its consequences, proclaiming the truth rather than substituting anecdotes, and this duty must not be avoided because it is unpleasant, unwelcome, and difficult.Lt 3, 1892, par. 24–27Lt 12, 1893, par. 33–37 The rebuke is to be given openly and without partiality, whether the person is high or low, rich or poor, a dear friend, or of any rank or office.Lt 12, 1893, par. 33–37ST Sep 2, 1913Ms 10, 1899, par. 16 No rank or office protects anyone from the reach of truth when duty is neglected and opportunities are misused, and faithful reproof is not to be withheld from those who lead others to exalt self and who despise correction.Ms 10, 1899, par. 16
Sin is to be rebuked firmly and not allowed or excused, so that discipline is upheld and others are warned.ICEP 1.2 At the same time correction is to be carried out patiently and in the spirit of Christ, while keeping hope before those who have done wrong.ICEP 1.2 To neglect correcting error and repressing sin is to disobey God, to sanction sin, and to bring wrath upon His people.ST Sep 2, 1913
Public correction acknowledges the justice of God's judgments and warns others against presuming upon His forbearance.PP 361.2 Excusing sin through false sympathy hides its seriousness, weakens the warning, and hinders the Holy Spirit's work of conviction.PP 361.2 Those who do so may come to share responsibility for the sinner's impenitence.PP 361.2
Warning Others to Fear
The open rebuke of the wrongs of one named person is for the correction of many, and for that reason personal reproofs are rightly published for all to read.2T 112.2–113.1 When one person is reproved for a particular wrong, those who are not singled out are not to take it for granted that they are right or nearly right merely because they were not named.2T 112.2–113.1 Being thought right by others does not make a person right, for God looks upon the heart, and by this public dealing He is proving and testing souls.2T 112.2–113.1
All are to examine themselves closely to see wherein they have failed and been guilty of the same sin, and to possess the spirit of humble confession.2T 112.2–113.1 They are to be warned by what is reproved in another, to fear and shun those errors, and to find by self-examination that they are doing the same things that are condemned.2T 112.2–113.1 Those who truly desire to serve God and fear to offend Him will not wait for their own sins to be specified before confessing, but with humble repentance will return and forsake what has displeased Him according to the light given to others.2T 112.2–113.1
Those who see that they are guilty of the very sins reproved in others, yet continue in the same unconsecrated course because they were not specially named, flatter themselves that God passes over their errors.2T 112.2–113.1 In doing so they deal falsely with their own souls and live in great deception about their true condition, thereby endangering their own souls.2T 112.2–113.1 They will be shut up in darkness and left to their own ways to follow the imagination of their own hearts, and will be led captive by Satan at his will.2T 112.2–113.1
The reproof of the sins of one is so that others may take warning and fear, and the guilt is very great when those who make so high a profession indulge in sin and iniquity.2T 451.2 Seventh-day Adventists above all other people are to be patterns of piety, holy in heart and in conduct, elevated, refined, and sanctified.2T 451.2 As God's chosen peculiar treasure they are to partake of the divine nature, having escaped the corruption that is in the world through lust.2T 451.2
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
18 sources
Those who sin openly are to be reproved openly before all, so that others also may fear and take warning.RH Dec 27, 1853RH Nov 15, 1853RH Nov 18, 1873 It concerns sins made public against the church, the truth, or morality, not private personal wrongs between individuals, which are still to be taken up privately according to Matthew 18:15-18.ST Apr 23, 1885RH Apr 1, 1862RH Aug 6, 1861RH Jul 8, 1862 The charge was given to Timothy as a minister and elder acting with wisdom, judgment, and discretion, not as liberty for any private member to single out others in public.RH Jul 23, 1861RH Nov 18, 1873RH Aug 6, 1861 Reproving wrong is right and Christ-like, and it must be done without partiality whether the erring one is rich or poor, high or low, friend or stranger.ST Sep 2, 1913RH Dec 10, 1867RH Jul 8, 1862RH Jul 22, 1873 If the sinner refuses humble repentance and reform after loving labor, the church must withdraw fellowship to keep itself pure, protect others, and warn all.RH Apr 27, 1911RH Dec 6, 1906RH Jul 21, 1874RH Aug 4, 1874
Public Rebuke Explained
Those who sin openly are to be rebuked before all, so that others also may fear and be warned, for public faults are not to be handled privately.RH Dec 27, 1853RH Nov 15, 1853RH Nov 18, 1873RH Jul 22, 1873 The rebuke belongs to publicly evident offenses against the church, the truth, society, or morality, including public misquotations of Scripture and charges of crime, heresy, or indebtedness, rather than to private offenses against an individual.ST Apr 23, 1885RH Apr 1, 1862RH Jul 8, 1862 This does not conflict with Matthew 18:15-18, for private personal trespasses and misunderstandings between individuals are still to be taken up privately or in a less public manner.ST Apr 23, 1885RH Apr 1, 1862RH Aug 6, 1861 Even public wrongdoing does not dispense with care for the erring person's welfare, but calls for private labor where fitting and for justice balanced with mercy.ST Apr 23, 1885
The charge was given to Timothy as an elder and minister, a man full of wisdom and the Holy Ghost with judgment and discretion, as part of the authority entrusted by Christ for leaders to correct wrongdoing.RH Nov 18, 1873RH Aug 6, 1861 It does not authorize a private church member to reprove openly, to cast private grudges out in the social meeting, or to single out persons without counsel.RH Jul 23, 1861RH Aug 6, 1861 To give the same liberty to all would poison the atmosphere, give Satan place, bring confusion, and destroy pure worship.RH Jul 23, 1861RH Aug 6, 1861 One who has something against another must go to him in private and spare his feelings in public, seeking the edification of all, while the one in Timothy's place must make public those sins which call for public rebuke.RH Aug 6, 1861
Even ministers are to use open personal rebuke only when the nature of the case absolutely demands it, since correction can almost always be done fully in private visits or church labor meetings rather than introduced into public worship.RH Jul 23, 1861 They are to exalt pure principles of truth and righteousness with pointed Bible language, not to particularize too much or single out persons unnecessarily, lest people be led to dwell on the faults of others instead of on truth and holiness.RH Jul 23, 1861 A charge of crime, heresy, or indebtedness must be stated plainly with reasons given, so that those accused have opportunity to vindicate innocence or honesty of motives, and not by blind insinuation that calumniates the innocent rather than reforms the erring.RH Jul 8, 1862 Taken with verse 19, the direction shows that lawlessness had already begun entering the church through unconverted people, an early working of the mystery of iniquity.ST Mar 12, 1896
Duty to Discipline and Warn
To reprove wrong and set error right is right and honorable and Christ-like, and to rebuke those who sin openly so that others may fear is a minister's duty.RH Dec 10, 1867RH Jul 8, 1862RH Jul 22, 1873 Neglecting that work lets sin pass unnoticed, disobeys God, sanctions sin, and brings wrath upon His people.ST Sep 2, 1913RH Jul 22, 1873 Christian charity does not excuse or shield wrongdoing but calls sin by its right name and stands consistent with reproving it.RH Jul 22, 1873 Withholding a needed warning fails that duty.ST Sep 2, 1913RH Dec 10, 1867
The rebuke is to be given openly and without partiality.ST Sep 2, 1913RH Dec 10, 1867RH Jul 22, 1873 No difference is to be made for the wealthy, the influential, the friendly, or the helpful, nor for high or low, rich or poor, nor even for a dear friend.ST Sep 2, 1913RH Dec 10, 1867 The church must not tolerate sin among its members but must oppose it and labor lovingly to bring the sinner to see it and repent of it.RH Apr 27, 1911RH Aug 4, 1874 It is to make serious efforts to reform those who act wrongly.RH Aug 4, 1874 Bringing sin to light and reproving it serves as a warning so that others will take heed and fear.RH Apr 27, 1911RH Dec 6, 1906RH Aug 4, 1874 Such reproof does not mean the erring person is more blameworthy than professed Christians in other churches.RH Dec 6, 1906
If the one who persists in sin refuses humble repentance and conversion and refuses to conform to right principles, the church must remove that person from its membership and withdraw fellowship.RH Apr 27, 1911RH Aug 4, 1874 Simply dropping an unworthy name without church labor and action does not fulfill the instruction, but patient effort followed, when restoration proves impossible, by withdrawing fellowship protects the church and others from harm.RH Apr 27, 1911RH Jul 21, 1874RH Aug 4, 1874 Faithful discipline of this kind helps keep the church pure, protects its witness, and warns others against sin.RH Aug 4, 1874 Neglecting it hinders God's Spirit and harms both faithful members and those observing the church.RH Aug 4, 1874
Open sin in the church is to be reproved publicly before all, even to withdrawing fellowship until there is full confession and forsaking of sin, so that others also fear and are led to voluntary confession and to holy Sabbathkeeping according to the commandment.RH Nov 15, 1853RH Jun 23, 1859 This was applied to Sabbath-breaking such as taking a grist from the mill, hiring a blacksmith to shoe a horse, and allowing family work like preparing cheese curd on the Sabbath after justification of such acts was exposed.RH Jun 23, 1859 It was applied also to persistent fault-finding against those who believe the visions, without making confession of faith in the visions itself a requirement for fellowship.RH Jun 23, 1859 It was applied to disorderly conduct that burdens and harms the church.RH Nov 15, 1853 In the setting of the Lord's Supper, open sin to be rebuked publicly is the exception to serving everyone who wishes to partake.RH Mar 7, 1912
Sources