2 Corinthians 12:3
And I knew such a man, ( whether in the body, or out of the body, I cannot tell: God knoweth;)
Translations
And I knew such a man, (whether in the body, or out of the body, I cannot tell: God knows;)
And I knew such a man, ( whether in the body, or out of the body, I cannot tell: God knoweth;)
KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
And I knew such a man, (whether in the body, or out of the body, I cannot tell: God knoweth;)
Revised Version, American Standard Version
And I know such a man ( whether in the body, or apart from the body, I know not; God knoweth),
and I have known such a man — whether in the body, whether out of the body, I have not known, God hath known, —
And I know such a man, ( whether in [ the] body or out of the body I know not, God knows;)
And I know such a man as this, whether in the body or apart from the body, [I know not],—God, knoweth,
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
And I know that this man— whether in the body or out of it I do not know, but God knows—
I know such a man ( whether in the body, or outside of the body, I don’ t know; God knows),
And I have knowledge of such a man ( if he was in the body, or out of the body, I am not able to say, but God only),
And I knowe such a man (whether in the body, or out of the body, I can not tell: God knoweth)
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And I know such a man ( whether in the body, or out of the body, I know not: God knoweth),
Pictures

Cross-references
- 2 Corinthians 12:7
And lest I should be exalted above measure through the abundance of the revelations, there was given to me a thorn in the flesh, the messenger of Satan to buffet me, lest I should be exalted above measure.
Paul’s extraordinary revelation was followed by an affliction to keep him humble.
- Acts 22:17-21
And it came to pass, that, when I was come again to Jerusalem, even while I prayed in the temple, I was in a trance;
Paul recounts a temple vision in which he is commissioned to preach to the Gentiles.
- Luke 23:43
And Jesus said unto him, Verily I say unto thee, To day shalt thou be with me in paradise.
Paul’s description of Paradise connects with Jesus’ promise to the thief.
- Numbers 24:16
He hath said, which heard the words of God, and knew the knowledge of the most High, which saw the vision of the Almighty, falling into a trance, but having his eyes open:
Balaam’s vision is compared with the visionary experience described.
- 2 Corinthians 12:8-9
For this thing I besought the Lord thrice, that it might depart from me.
Paul pleaded for his affliction to be removed and received assurance of sufficient grace.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
32 sources
Paul was taken in holy vision to the third heaven, which is Paradise, and he could not tell whether it was in the body or out of the body, but God knew.CET 240.2GC 470.2–471.2WLF 6.7–9BS 81.2AAP 7.3 There he was shown the beauty and glory of heaven and heard things he was not permitted to make known or utter.GC88 471.1BS 81.2Lt 167, 1903, par. 3 Those truths were withheld because they would have been misapplied and could not have been understood or comprehended.Lt 167, 1903, par. 315MR 228.1Lt 161, 1903, par. 5–6 God opened this vision before him to prepare him for his extensive missionary work to the Gentiles.3SP 347.28RED 4.3–5.1ST Jun 12, 1879 It did not lead him to boast or exalt himself, but he walked humbly and let all that was shown to him mold the messages he bore to the churches.GC 470.2–471.2GC88 471.1BS 81.2Lt 167, 1903, par. 315MR 228.1
Vision and Its Revelation
Paul was taken in holy vision to the third heaven, also called Paradise, where he was shown a glimpse of heaven's beauty and glory and of celestial things.CET 240.2WLF 6.7–9BS 81.220MR 153.2–33SP 347.2 The vision revealed glorious scenes and revelations of divine glory, bringing him into close communion with God.BS 81.2AAP 7.33SP 347.2ST Nov 30, 1882 After returning to earthly consciousness he could not adequately describe the wonderful scenes he had seen, but he kept their image in his soul.20MR 153.2–3Lt 47, 1903, par. 7–8
Paradise is the New Jerusalem.WLF 23.1–3 The heaven containing God's temple is distinct from other places or things in Scripture also called heaven.WLF 6.7–9WLF 23.1–3
He could not tell whether the experience was in the body or out of the body; God knew.GC 470.2–471.2AAP 7.38RED 4.3–5.1Ms 11, 1850, par. 4–513MR 299.3–300.1 It was a true visionary state in which a person is wholly unaware of surrounding things and lost to everything around him while God communicates through angels, with no danger of mistake.Ms 11, 1850, par. 4–513MR 299.3–300.15MR 227.1–228.4 Ordinary religious exercises, by contrast, can be shaped and adulterated by prior opinions and knowledge and by unhealthy excitement, and implicit confidence cannot be placed in them.Ms 11, 1850, par. 4–513MR 299.3–300.15MR 227.1–228.4
There he saw and heard things that are not lawful to utter and that he was not permitted to make known or speak.GC88 471.1BS 81.2Lt 167, 1903, par. 3AAP 7.3Lt 47, 1903, par. 7–8 He was shown great truths and enrapturing scenes of celestial things.Lt 167, 1903, par. 3Lt 47, 1903, par. 7–8 Those truths were withheld because those who heard them would have misapplied them and made a misapplication of the great truths presented, and because they could not have understood or comprehended them.Lt 167, 1903, par. 315MR 228.1Lt 161, 1903, par. 5–6 What was revealed was too much to tell, so he tells only a tiny fraction, not one-hundredth or one-thousandth part of what he saw.Ms 146, 1906, par. 64–65 When he returned to consciousness of earthly things he found it impossible to describe what had passed before him, but he kept the wonderful picture in his soul.20MR 153.2–3Lt 47, 1903, par. 7–8 This proves that the Lord Jesus can communicate spiritual truths that no human words can adequately express, while the brightness of the celestial world and the splendor and joy of the Christian's hope make the heart glow within yet can only be feebly portrayed.Lt 47, 1903, par. 7–8
The experience brings the eternal world within range of the mind's eye, with the curtain of heaven withdrawn to reveal its treasures and living glories, yet even then a person can grasp only a notion of the infinite, eternal weight of glory.Ms 42, 1890, par. 35 Mysteries hidden for ages were revealed to him there, as much as he could bear of God's workings and of His dealings with human minds.ST Mar 25, 1897 The hidden mystery is the plan foreknown before the creation of the world to be carried out upon the defection of any of the high intelligences of heaven, with an offering prepared in the eternal purposes to do the very work God has done for fallen humanity.ST Mar 25, 1897 He was told he must preach among the Gentiles the unsearchable riches of Christ, and light was to be given to the Gentiles, and this giving of light to the Gentiles is that mystery hidden for ages.ST Mar 25, 1897
Purpose and Effect on Paul
God brought Paul into close communion and close connection with Himself and opened before his enraptured vision a glimpse of the beauty and glory of heaven to prepare him for his extensive and important missionary work to the Gentiles.3SP 347.2ST Jun 12, 1879SLP 41.3ST Apr 23, 1885ST Jun 12, 1879 He had received his commission from God while praying in the temple, with his broad missionary field presented before him with remarkable distinctness.ST Jun 12, 1879 The vision gave preparation for the broad work God had commissioned him to do.8RED 4.3–5.1
Being received into the third heaven was a great honor from God.Lt 159, 1903, par. 18–19 After that honor an affliction was sent to buffet him so he would walk humbly with God and not be lifted up in his own estimation.Lt 159, 1903, par. 18–1921MR 10.5–11.3 Spiritual privilege calls for humility and may be followed by severe trial.21MR 10.5–11.3 God prepares His people for temptation by giving before a great trial a more than usually clear revelation of His presence and compassion and love, with strength sufficient for the trial.Lt 159, 1903, par. 18–19
The heavenly experience did not lead him to boast or trust himself or to exalt himself.GC88 471.1BS 81.2 With humility he called himself less than the least of the saints.GC 470.2–471.2GC88 471.1 He recognized the need for constant watchfulness and self-denial.BS 81.2 He continued pressing toward the prize of God's calling in Christ, showing that he had not already attained perfection and that sanctification is a lifelong work.Ms 36, 1885, par. 21–22
Though he did not directly tell what he had seen in vision, all that was shown to him molded the messages he bore to the churches.Lt 167, 1903, par. 315MR 228.1Lt 161, 1903, par. 5–6 Those great truths were withheld from direct speech because those who heard them would have misapplied them and could not have understood or comprehended them.Lt 167, 1903, par. 315MR 228.1Lt 161, 1903, par. 5–6 The revelation left a lasting impression ever with him that shaped his understanding and presentation of Christian life, character, and duty to God and of the obligation due from man to God.20MR 344.2–345.1Lt 103, 1900, par. 19–22 That lasting impression enabled him to give a correct representation with power that was from God and not from man.Lt 167, 1903, par. 3Lt 103, 1900, par. 19–22 All his writings, letters, admonitions, and appeals bear a heavenly character, with the sure word of prophecy in all his instruction.Ms 174, 1903, par. 12 He spoke little of these special revelations and did not dwell on them at all times when speaking to the people.Lt 103, 1900, par. 19–22
The vision was one of several visions received during his ministerial labors and of many visions of heaven in the heavenly courts.Lt 161, 1903, par. 5–6Lt 103, 1900, par. 19–22Ms 146, 1906, par. 64–65 He was exalted above the other apostles by the revelation of Christ at his conversion and by these later visions, in which he saw and heard many things not lawful for a man to utter, yet he still labored with his hands as a tentmaker.Lt 103, 1900, par. 19–22 His eyes that had looked upon Christ remained afflicted, yet the Lord often gave him visions of heavenly things.Lt 159, 1903, par. 18–19
His view of eternal scenes, with his knowledge, his eloquence, and his miracles, would all prove unavailing, a defeat and a dishonor, if the church for whom he labored should prove inefficient and unfaithful through any failure of his duty toward them.Lt 9, 1892, par. 19–24 His hope of heaven grew dim when he contemplated the church receiving the mold of the human instead of the divine.Lt 9, 1892, par. 19–24 The vision calls for waking up and wanting a home in heaven at the cost of everything here, speaking a word in season and working to convert souls in places like San Francisco and Oakland.Ms 146, 1906, par. 64–65
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
96 sources
Paul speaks of himself in guarded third-person language as the man caught up into Paradise, which is the third heaven where God dwells.RH May 18, 1869ST Dec 16, 1913RH Apr 20, 1869RH May 19, 1874 He could not tell whether he was taken there in the body or out of the body, and God alone knows the manner of the catching up, though the experience itself was real and vivid.ST Dec 10, 1912ST Jun 8, 1915ST Dec 16, 1913ST Aug 29, 1878RH Dec 12, 1854 To be out of the body is to be in vision, in which the Holy Spirit controls the mind so that distant heavenly scenes appear as clearly as with natural eyes while the person is shut away from earthly surroundings.RH Jun 29, 1916RH Jun 9, 1874RH Oct 15, 1872RH Nov 25, 1858RH Oct 16, 1855 The verse therefore does not by itself prove that the dead are conscious or that a deathless soul can live and think apart from the body, for it speaks of the man himself being caught up and not of a separate soul leaving a dead body.ST Jan 4, 1877RH Nov 25, 1858RH Apr 8, 1858RH Oct 16, 1855 Heaven was opened to him for his own support amid suffering and to prepare him for his missionary work, yet because of the abundance of the revelations he was in danger of pride and was given a thorn in the flesh to keep him humble.ST Jun 12, 1879RH Jun 9, 1874RH May 18, 1869RH Jan 31, 1854
Words and Setting
The man in Christ caught up to Paradise is Paul himself, speaking of himself indirectly as such a man and as such a one in modest and guarded third-person language.RH May 18, 1869PGGC 51.3–52.3ST Aug 24, 1904 That reserve matches the way John speaks of himself as the disciple whom Jesus loved, and it shows that inspiration leaves personal style and identity intact while guarding against self-display.ST Aug 24, 1904 The guardedness was necessary because the extraordinary revelations exposed him to the danger of pride and temptation to exalt himself, so humility was required in telling of them.RH May 18, 1869
The experience had occurred more than fourteen years before he wrote of it, when as the man in Christ he was caught up to the third heaven, to Paradise, and heard words it is not possible for a man to utter.RH Oct 15, 1872RH Nov 22, 1906 He had kept silent about it for a long time and told of it only once, not relying on it or speaking of it for years.ST Jun 25, 1894RH Jan 29, 1857 Even so remarkable an experience did not save him, for Christ alone saves, and it could expose him to self-exaltation so that he needed the thorn in the flesh to keep him humble.RH Jan 29, 1857
The time and place of the experience are uncertain, with the proposed timing placing it around when Barnabas found him at Tarsus. The word knoweth comes from the Greek eido, meaning to see, discern with the eyes, look upon, observe, visit, understand, comprehend, be acquainted, foreknow, remember, concern oneself about, acknowledge and yield reverence.RH Dec 1, 1868 It is the same word translated know in 1 Corinthians 2:2 with the sense of making known.RH Dec 1, 1868 Differences in punctuation among Bible versions do not change the meaning of the verse, which describes a man caught up into Paradise whose being in the body or apart from it was unknown to him but known to God.ST Aug 18, 1887
The verse belongs to Paul's account of visions and revelations of the Lord begun in verse 1, in which he relates a view he had of Paradise.RH Nov 25, 1858 It is connected with the abundance of revelations mentioned in verse 7, and the surrounding verses identify it as his own experience in vision. It belongs also to his account of his labors and sufferings, which he recounted under urgent necessity and in modest terms, even while recognizing that glorying in himself was foolish.RH Nov 24, 1868 The revelations made him a prophet, and those revelations were prophecies.RH May 21, 1861
Vision or Bodily Transport
Paul knew a man caught up to Paradise yet could not tell whether it happened in the body or out of the body, and God alone knew.ST Dec 10, 1912ST Jun 8, 1915ST Dec 16, 1913RH Oct 15, 1872 The uncertainty concerns the manner of being caught up, not the reality of the experience, which was as real as seeing with natural eyes and included hearing words no person can utter.ST Dec 10, 1912ST Jun 8, 1915ST Dec 16, 1913RH Oct 15, 1872RH Jan 7, 1858 The surrounding account identifies this Paradise with the third heaven.ST Dec 16, 1913RH Oct 15, 1872
Out of the body means being in vision, not a conscious soul living apart from the body in death.RH Oct 15, 1872RH Nov 25, 1858RH Oct 16, 1855ST Jun 6, 1906RH Oct 16, 1855 In vision the Holy Spirit controls the mind so that distant or future scenes are perceived and the person seems bodily present in them.RH Oct 15, 1872RH Nov 25, 1858RH Oct 16, 1855ST Mar 27, 1879 In the body means seeing with physical eyes, while out of the body means seeing in the mind by God's power, and these are the only two conditions brought to view, being carried bodily into Paradise or viewing it in vision.RH Nov 25, 1858RH Oct 16, 1855ST Jun 6, 1906RH Oct 16, 1855ST Mar 27, 1879
The revelation was so clear, vivid and real, like seeing with natural eyes, that Paul was uncertain whether he was bodily present or seeing a supernatural picture presented to his mind.ST Dec 10, 1912ST Jun 8, 1915ST Aug 29, 1878RH Dec 12, 1854ST Jun 6, 1906 He could not rule out bodily transport, and his mind seemed caught up to heaven as he saw heavenly scenes.ST Jun 8, 1915ST Jun 6, 1906ST Jan 4, 1877RH May 18, 1869 His uncertainty does not establish that an immortal soul can live apart from the body and does not explain how he was caught up.RH Dec 12, 1854ST Jan 4, 1877
While in vision he was utterly unconscious of everything around him and shut away from earthly scenes, lost to his surroundings while the vision continued.RH Jun 29, 1916RH Jun 9, 1874PGGC 51.3–52.3RH Nov 5, 1914 A true vision from heaven takes a man beyond his natural senses so that he cannot tell whether in the body or out of the body, and remaining conscious of all around while claiming vision proves the Lord of heaven has nothing to do with it.RH Jun 29, 1916RH Jun 9, 1874RH Nov 27, 1860 His physical strength being taken away accompanies such experience, and he was so fully absorbed that he was unaware of what was happening around him.RH Jun 9, 1874PGGC 51.3–52.3RH Nov 5, 1914
Even if his body remained on earth he was not dead, with heart beating and blood circulating, but oblivious to this world while his mind beheld heaven.RH Jun 9, 1874 He was conscious and heard unspeakable words in either condition, whether caught up bodily or mentally.RH Jun 9, 1874 The verse does not say he was dead, or that a conscious spirit left his body and later returned, but describes the man himself being caught up without specifying how.RH Jun 9, 1874
His uncertainty was not about whether he was dead or alive but about whether he had been shown the third heaven in a vision or had been bodily transported there.RH May 18, 1869 He was not translated to heaven to remain there as Enoch and Elijah were, and when the vision ended he was still on earth as were other prophets shown heaven in vision.ST Apr 16, 1896RH May 18, 1869 John 3:13 does not deny this, for it means no man has ascended to learn God's things and return to reveal them except Jesus Christ.ST Apr 16, 1896
The verse leaves open the possibility of a bodily ascent to heaven while leaving the manner of the ascent uncertain.RH May 18, 1869 The glory of what was seen was so great that he could not be sure he had not been taken there bodily.RH May 18, 1869
The experience was a holy vision in which he was taken to Paradise and the third heaven, where glorious scenes were shown that he was not permitted to reveal.ST Nov 30, 1882ST Jan 11, 1883ST Jun 1, 1904RH Aug 5, 1851ST Nov 13, 1893 God preserved Paradise and the tree of life, and redemption will restore access to the tree.ST Jun 1, 1904 Being caught up out of the body in this holy vision is contrasted with the redeemed being caught up together, bodily and in person, to Paradise where they will remain and reign with Christ.ST Dec 26, 1906
Paradise Is Third Heaven
The man in Christ was first caught up to the third heaven and then the same man was caught up into Paradise, which proves the two places are the same, and Paradise is in or corresponds to the third heaven where God dwells.ST Dec 16, 1913RH Apr 20, 1869RH May 19, 1874ST Feb 16, 1915ST Sep 26, 1878 In that place the man heard words that a person cannot utter and that it is not lawful to utter.ST Dec 16, 1913RH Apr 20, 1869RH May 19, 1874 Paul could not tell whether the experience happened in the body or outside the body, and God alone knew.ST Dec 16, 1913RH May 19, 1874ST Nov 13, 1884ST Feb 16, 1915ST Sep 26, 1878
Paradise is the Paradise of God within the gates of the heavenly Jerusalem, identical with or included in the New Jerusalem, embracing the throne of God or lying in close proximity to it.RH May 19, 1874RH Jun 10, 1875RH Mar 1, 1870 There God sits upon His throne, and there the tree of life stands by the river of life flowing from beneath the throne of God and the Lamb.RH May 19, 1874RH Jun 10, 1875ST Apr 25, 1900RH Mar 1, 1870 It is a park or garden with trees, surrounded by angels and the innumerable host, a place of infinite joy and glory where Paul heard unspeakable words of joy, with fullness of joy and pleasures forevermore.RH Jun 10, 1875ST Apr 25, 1900RH Apr 20, 1869 It was prepared for humanity in innocence when the earth was founded and will be part of the overcomers' reward.RH Mar 1, 1870
Paradise is not in hades in the land of death, not in the nether parts or interior of the earth, not in dark caverns, not an intermediate halfway house between the grave and the resurrection, and not a resting place of departed souls apart from where the Father dwells.RH Apr 20, 1869RH May 19, 1874ST Oct 28, 1889RH Oct 1, 1872 It is reached only by entering through the gates of the city of God where the tree of life is and where the eternal King sits.RH Apr 20, 1869RH May 19, 1874RH Apr 20, 1869 Hades is altogether unlike Paradise, for there is no work, knowledge, thought, or consciousness of any kind there, and hades will be cast into the lake of fire.RH Apr 20, 1869RH May 19, 1874
Paul was taken to a third heaven that already existed in his own time, a literal place existing now high above the sun, moon and stars, where Paradise has a present existence, though Paradise will also be found in the new earth hereafter.RH Apr 20, 1869RH Apr 20, 1869RH Jan 20, 1863ST Jul 4, 1878 It was not the future new heavens and new earth which did not then exist and will not exist until after the great burning day.RH Apr 20, 1869RH Apr 20, 1869ST Jul 4, 1878 His not knowing whether he was in the body or out of the body proves this, because he knew the new heavens and new earth did not then exist, so he could not have been uncertain about going there bodily; his uncertainty means he spoke of a heaven to which he might have gone either in vision or literally and bodily.RH Apr 20, 1869RH Apr 20, 1869 That heaven is the highest heaven in dignity, the heaven of heavens where God's throne is, above the atmospheric heaven where birds fly and the starry heaven.RH Apr 20, 1869RH Jan 20, 1863ST Jul 4, 1878
There are three heavens: the first is the atmosphere around the earth, about forty-five miles above the earth, where birds fly and where the sun's rays passing through give light; the second is the starry heaven beyond it where sun, moon, planets and stars are, where all is darkness; and the third is above them, the invisible place of God's throne, where God dwells in the high and holy place.RH Jun 10, 1875RH Jun 26, 1900RH Jan 20, 1863ST Jul 4, 1878ST Sep 23, 1875 The first heaven has been affected by sin and will depart and pass away at Christ's coming, leaving darkness with no animal life, and the first two visible heavens will be shaken with the earth during the last plague so that the things that are shaken are removed.RH Jun 26, 1900ST Sep 23, 1875 But the second heaven and the third heaven are beyond the reach of sin and will not be changed at Christ's coming, and the third heaven cannot be shaken but will remain.RH Jun 10, 1875RH Jun 26, 1900ST Sep 23, 1875 The third heaven is the paradise of God where the New Jerusalem is with foundations that stand secure, where the Father's house with its mansions is, and where the kingdom which cannot be moved is received.RH Jan 20, 1863ST Jul 4, 1878ST Sep 23, 1875
The tree of life was first on earth in Eden, where man had free access to eat and live forever, and remained on earth with its way guarded by a flaming sword after man sinned so that fallen man could not eat and live forever.RH Sep 21, 1869RH Mar 22, 1860 The earthly Paradise of Eden was not destroyed by sin nor given to sinners to possess, but was kept sacred and holy as heaven itself.RH Sep 21, 1869ST Aug 27, 1894 At the flood the garden of Paradise with the tree, the identical tree that once flourished in the paradise on earth, was removed from earth to the third heaven, where the tree of life now stands in the midst of the Paradise of God.RH Sep 21, 1869ST Aug 27, 1894RH Mar 22, 1860 The word Paradise was familiar to New Testament readers because the Septuagint called the garden of Eden Paradise. Paradise is now withdrawn from the earth into the invisible world, there preserved, and from its holy precincts in heaven the original plan for the earth has been carried forward and the holy city, the New Jerusalem, has been built, so that Paradise and the New Jerusalem are now together in heaven; it will later return to earth as the renewed home of the redeemed, and when the New Jerusalem descends it will contain the original Paradise.ST Sep 25, 1907ST Aug 27, 1894ST Jun 1, 1904 Redemption will restore access to the tree, shown to Paul in vision though he could not tell whether he was in the body or out of it.ST Sep 25, 1907ST Jun 1, 1904
Paradise is the place where all the righteous shall finally stand in the presence of God, the abode of the blessed.RH Apr 20, 1869RH May 19, 1874RH May 26, 1874 Christ has gone thither before them as the forerunner to prepare the place, and when the place is prepared and they are prepared He will return to take them thither to ascend with Him to the Father's house.ST Oct 10, 1878RH May 26, 1874 There they shall with their own eyes behold the city prepared for Abraham and his seed, each finding a mansion prepared expressly for himself, and behold the things God has prepared for those that love Him.RH May 26, 1874 There they shall eat of the tree of life within the gates of the New Jerusalem and drink of the river that issues out of the throne of God, eat the marriage supper and sit at His table, and sit with Christ on thrones of judgment during the thousand years.RH Mar 1, 1870ST Oct 10, 1878RH May 26, 1874 When the New Jerusalem takes its place as the metropolis of the glorified new earth they shall take the kingdom under the whole heaven as their inheritance, and from Sabbath to Sabbath shall gather from the face of the whole earth in Paradise to praise the Creator.RH Mar 1, 1870RH May 26, 1874
Jesus did not enter that Paradise, the third heaven, the heavenly Jerusalem, the house of the Father and the very presence of the Father, until after His resurrection from the dead and His meeting with Mary, for three days afterward He said He had not yet ascended to His Father.RH Mar 1, 1860RH Apr 20, 1869 Therefore wherever He was during the three days He was dead, He had not been in Paradise.RH Mar 1, 1860RH Apr 20, 1869 Therefore the promise to the thief on the cross could not have been fulfilled that very day but looks to the future, when hope of being with Christ is fulfilled through His personal return.RH Mar 1, 1860
Not Proof of Immortal Soul
The verse by itself does not settle what happens between death and resurrection.ST Jan 4, 1877RH Nov 25, 1858RH Apr 8, 1858 It does not prove the conscious existence of the dead.ST Jan 4, 1877RH Nov 25, 1858RH Apr 8, 1858 It belongs to an account of visions and revelations in which a view of Paradise was given, and the only two conditions brought to view are being carried bodily into Paradise or viewing it in vision.RH Nov 25, 1858 Out of the body means merely to be in vision.RH Nov 25, 1858RH Apr 8, 1858
Paul's uncertainty whether he was in the body or out of the body does not establish that a conscious, rational, deathless person can live apart from the body.ST Jan 4, 1877RH Dec 12, 1854ST Jan 4, 1877RH Oct 16, 1855ST Jan 4, 1877 It does not show that his spirit left his body and lived separately from it.RH Aug 31, 1869RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854 Out of the body refers to being caught up in vision, with scenes formed in the mind by the Holy Spirit.RH Nov 25, 1858RH Oct 16, 1855RH Oct 16, 1855 The vision was so clear and vivid that it seemed as real as bodily transport with natural sight, so he could not tell whether he had been taken there bodily or had been carried there in mind.RH Aug 31, 1869ST Aug 29, 1878ST Jan 4, 1877RH Oct 16, 1855ST Jan 4, 1877 The verse therefore speaks of the man himself being caught up, not of his soul leaving his body.RH Oct 16, 1855RH Oct 16, 1855
The verse does not say that he was dead. It is not a report that Paul died or that a conscious spirit left his body and later returned.ST Aug 29, 1878RH Oct 15, 1872 If his body had died while his soul departed, its return would imply a resurrection, yet no such death or resurrection is recorded.RH Dec 12, 1854 He was conscious and heard unspeakable words in either condition, whether bodily or mentally, without specifying how he was caught up.RH Oct 15, 1872 The question of his bodily condition during the vision remains unknown except to God.RH Dec 12, 1854
Scenes formed in the mind by the Holy Spirit can be as real to the person as physical sight.RH Nov 25, 1858RH Oct 16, 1855RH Oct 16, 1855 To use the verse for the conscious existence of the dead would first require proof that man possesses a separate, immaterial, intelligent entity called the soul.RH Nov 25, 1858 It would further require proof that this entity can exist independent of the living organism, and that having a vision requires this soul to be separated from the body and carried to the objects presented, none of which can be shown.RH Nov 25, 1858 Those who held otherwise taught that by the touching and opening of his spiritual senses giving him open vision of the spirit world, Paul was caught up to the third heaven, which proves man possesses a spiritual nature by which he exists after death and is made capable of recognizing the spiritual world and its inhabitants.RH Jan 7, 1873
Purpose and Effect for Paul
Heaven was opened to Paul as a faithful answer to prayer in which he sought only submission to God's will and strength to bear his burden, not less labor and suffering. The vision was granted for his own personal benefit and support amid severe suffering, to strengthen him to bear his burdens and continue his work.RH May 18, 1869 In being caught up to Paradise he was given a glimpse of the saints' promised inheritance and of what is reserved for overcomers, and heard unspeakable words he was not permitted to disclose except in general terms.RH May 18, 1869RH Jan 31, 1854 It raised him above gloom and discouragement, made the sufferings of this present time seem light affliction for a moment, filled him with exceeding joy in tribulation, and comforted him in affliction so that he could comfort others. It gave him a foretaste of glorious immortality and a confident hope of eternal glory that made him eager to escape earthly sorrow and regain that vision.RH Jan 31, 1854RH Jul 16, 1857
God brought him into close fellowship and close connection with Himself and opened before his enraptured vision a glimpse of heaven's beauty and glory.ST Jun 12, 1879ST Apr 23, 1885ST Jun 12, 1879 This was to prepare him for his extensive and important missionary work, in connection with his first mission to the Gentiles.ST Jun 12, 1879ST Apr 23, 1885ST Jun 12, 1879 It followed his commission from God while praying in the temple, when his broad missionary field was presented before him with remarkable distinctness.ST Jun 12, 1879
In Paradise he saw and heard things that could not lawfully be spoken or uttered, and mysteries hidden for ages were revealed to him.ST Jan 30, 1912ST Mar 25, 1897ST Jan 11, 1883RH Aug 10, 1916 There was made known to him as much as he could bear of God's work and dealings with human minds, including insight into the mystery of God's purpose which he then unfolded.ST Jan 30, 1912ST Mar 25, 1897ST Nov 18, 1913 The hidden mystery was the plan foreknown before the creation of the world to be carried out upon the defection of any of the high intelligences of heaven, with an offering prepared in the eternal purposes to do the very work God has done for fallen humanity, and Paul was told he must preach among the Gentiles the unsearchable riches of Christ, with light to be given to the Gentiles.ST Mar 25, 1897 The experience revealed wonders of redeeming grace not revealed to all prophets.RH Aug 10, 1916 That revelation exceeded in wisdom and glory all that he could speak or write, so he saw and knew more than he was able to record for the church, and even with that surpassing revelation he still knew only in part and saw through a glass darkly, which proves that which is perfect has not yet come and that which is in part is not done away.ST May 6, 1875 After he came back to his natural condition he wrote out what was given him to communicate for the benefit of the church.RH Jun 9, 1874
Because of the abundance of the revelations he was in great danger of being exalted above measure, so there was given him a thorn in the flesh, the messenger of Satan to buffet him to keep him from becoming exalted and vulnerable to spiritual pride.RH Jun 9, 1874RH Jun 8, 1911 The experience he described he had only once, and its uncertainty about in or out of the body does not lessen that danger of pride.RH Jun 8, 1911 The extraordinary revelations brought new ideas and duties, but no new principle conflicting with God's or Christ's principles.RH May 8, 1856 He could not understand why his bodily affliction remained though he sought its removal three times, and was assured that heavenly grace would meet his need.RH Feb 24, 1916 Taken up to the third heaven and then brought down to endure the smarting pain of his thorn, he rose from the fall exulting in sustaining grace, proving that God proportions grace to the nature and season of trial and is all-sufficient for every emergency as it comes.RH Jan 6, 1874
Even such remarkable gifts and revelations did not become ground for boasting or confidence in his own merit and did not make him consider himself secure, finished, or saved, for Christ alone saves.RH Jan 29, 1857RH Apr 22, 1862RH May 5, 1868 He recounted his labors and sufferings under urgent necessity and in modest terms, recognizing that glorying in himself was foolish.RH Nov 24, 1868 The heavenly experience was not something he relied on or spoke of for years, yet even it could expose him to self-exaltation, so he needed the thorn to keep him humble.RH Jan 29, 1857 He continued to watch, pray, labor, and grow in humility and holiness.RH Apr 22, 1862 At least some of these wonderful revelations came during his time in Arabia, when he was away for quiet meditation and communion with God.ST Jun 28, 1883 Even this extraordinary experience of being caught up to the third heaven and hearing things he could not utter did not take the place of books and study.RH Jul 25, 1912
Application and Wider Connections
The experience shows the reality and importance of visions and revelations from God, through which instruction was given and Paul was enabled to prophesy more than all others for the benefit of the church.RH Jun 29, 1916RH Jun 9, 1874 While in vision he was utterly unconscious of everything around him and shut away from earthly scenes, caught up to Paradise and the third heaven and shown things there and hearing unspeakable words not lawful to utter.RH Jun 29, 1916RH Jun 9, 1874 It was so clear and real that he could not tell whether he was taken there bodily or whether his mind was taken complete possession of by the Spirit, God alone knowing, and even if his body remained on earth he was not dead, with heart beating and blood circulating yet oblivious to this world.RH Jun 29, 1916RH Jun 9, 1874 After returning to his natural condition he wrote out what was given him to communicate, and because of the abundance of the revelations there was given him a thorn in the flesh, the messenger of Satan to buffet him lest he be exalted above measure.RH Jun 9, 1874
A true vision from heaven takes a man beyond his natural senses so that he cannot tell whether in the body or out of the body, and to remain conscious of all around while claiming vision proves the Lord of heaven has nothing to do with it.RH Nov 27, 1860 Loss of physical strength accompanies such experience, when the person’s strength is taken away during the encounter.RH Jul 2, 1867 A later vision echoes the same uncertainty by saying its recipient could not tell whether sleeping or awake or whether in the body or out of it.RH May 19, 1863 Communion with God through the Spirit can fill the soul with such rapture that a person may not know whether in the body or out of it.
Paul’s special revelations serve as evidence of divine power and of God’s nearness to deliver His people.RH Jul 16, 1872 Yet a claim to a heavenly experience does not by itself establish that the experience is from God, for revelations from God do not self-exalt.ST Feb 21, 1911 He was caught up to heaven in vision, not taken bodily to remain there as Enoch and Elijah were, for when the vision ended he was still on earth as were other prophets shown heaven in vision.ST Apr 16, 1896 John 3:13 does not deny this, for it means no man has ascended to heaven to learn the things of God and come back to reveal them except Jesus Christ, who spoke what He knew and testified what He had seen through the ages.ST Apr 16, 1896
The identification of Paradise with the third heaven bears on the claim that the dying thief entered heavenly bliss immediately, which stands contrasted with Peter’s statement that David had not ascended into heaven.ST Apr 1, 1880 Paul had been given views of Paradise revealing the deep things of God, and Demas living in his society could converse with him about those views and witness his mighty miracles and godly life and unselfish devotion, giving Demas a wonderful opportunity to learn.RH Jul 13, 1869 Paul’s account of going to the third heaven describes a spiritual height that stands contrasted with Christian Science’s claim of exalted spiritual understanding.ST Dec 30, 1903
Sources