AdventAI

2 Corinthians 12:4

How that he was caught up into paradise, and heard unspeakable words, which it is not lawful for a man to utter.

King James Version

Translations

  • American King James Version, King James Version

    How that he was caught up into paradise, and heard unspeakable words, which it is not lawful for a man to utter.

  • KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible

    how that he was caught up into paradise, and heard unspeakable words, which it is not lawful for a man to utter.

  • Webster Bible

    That he was caught up into paradise, and heard unspeakable words, which it is not lawful for a man to utter.

  • Revised Version, American Standard Version

    how that he was caught up into Paradise, and heard unspeakable words, which it is not lawful for a man to utter.

  • Young's Literal Translation

    that he was caught away to the paradise, and heard unutterable sayings, that it is not possible for man to speak.

  • Darby Translation

    that he was caught up into paradise, and heard unspeakable things said which it is not allowed to man to utter.

  • Rotherham's Emphasised Bible

    How that he was caught away into paradise, and heard unspeakable things, which it is not allowable for a man to utter:

  • Berean Standard Bible

    was caught up to Paradise. The things he heard were too sacred for words, things that man is not permitted to tell.

  • Majority Standard Bible

    was caught up to Paradise. The things he heard were inexpressible, things that man is not permitted to tell.

  • World English Bible

    how he was caught up into Paradise and heard unspeakable words, which it is not lawful for a man to utter.

  • Bible in Basic English

    How he was taken up into Paradise, and words came to his ears which may not be said, and which man is not able to say.

  • Geneva Bible

    How that he was taken vp into Paradise, and heard words which cannot be spoken, which are not possible for man to vtter.

  • Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)

    That he was caught up into paradise, and heard secret words, which it is not granted to man to utter.

Pictures

Paul Caught Up to the Third Heaven (2 Corinthians 12:4)
Paul Caught Up to the Third Heaven AI-generated · by KandD

Commentary

Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.

Ellen G. White

31 sources

Paul was taken in holy vision up to paradise, which is the third heaven.GC88 471.1WLF 6.7–9GC 470.2–471.2 That paradise is the New Jerusalem containing God's temple, removed from the earth after the fall and counterpart to Old Jerusalem and its temple.WLF 23.1–3 There he heard words that man is not permitted to utter and was forbidden to tell or make known.AA 469.1GC88 471.1GC 470.2–471.2 What he saw was so enrapturing that human words could not describe it, so he could portray only feebly a hundredth or thousandth part of what was revealed.20MR 153.2–3Lt 47, 1903, par. 7–8Ms 146, 1906, par. 64–65 All that was shown him molded the messages he bore to the churches and was woven into his teachings, yet it did not lead him to boast but deepened his humility, and he did not claim perfection but kept pressing toward the prize.AA 469.1GC88 471.12MR 189.3Lt 167, 1903, par. 3AA 561.3–562.2

The Paradise Vision

In holy vision Paul was caught up to paradise, which is the third heaven, one of the places called heaven.GC88 471.1WLF 6.7–9GC 470.2–471.29MR 300.1–3BS 81.2 He was taken there in vision to the third heaven where he saw glorious scenes and heard words he was not permitted to reveal.GC88 471.1GC 470.2–471.29MR 300.1–3Ms 21, 1891, par. 28–30BS 81.2 That paradise is the New Jerusalem containing God's temple, not the other places also called heaven.WLF 23.1–3 Paradise was removed from the earth after humanity's fall, and the New Jerusalem with its temple has its counterpart in Old Jerusalem and its temple.WLF 23.1–3 The heavenly temple serves the New Covenant and will no longer be needed after Christ finishes His ministry and redeems His people, for when the Holy City comes down after the thousand years God and the Lamb themselves are its temple.WLF 23.1–3

There he was given revelation after revelation in many visions and was shown heaven's beauty and glory.Ms 91, 1903, par. 37–38ST Jun 12, 18798RED 4.3–5.13SP 347.2SLP 41.3 He was shown glorious scenes, revelations of divine glory, and celestial and eternal things in a grand place.CET 240.2BS 81.2ST Jun 12, 18798RED 4.3–5.13SP 347.2 He looked upon Christ there.CET 240.2ST Jun 12, 18798RED 4.3–5.13SP 347.2SLP 41.3 He was so withdrawn from his surroundings that he could not tell whether he was in the body or outside it.13MR 299.3–300.1 Mysteries kept hidden for ages were opened to him there, as much of God's workings and God's dealings with human minds as he could bear.ST Mar 25, 1897

What was opened included God's knowledge before the creation of the world of future events.ST Mar 25, 1897 It included the secret plan made in the eternal purposes for the defection of high intelligences, with an offering prepared to do the work done for fallen humanity.ST Mar 25, 1897 It included the charge to preach the unsearchable riches of Christ so that light would be given to the Gentiles, which is the mystery hidden for ages.ST Mar 25, 1897 His testimony proves that man can grasp only a faint notion of the infinite, eternal weight of glory.Ms 42, 1890, par. 35 His testimony confirms that the things God has prepared for those who love Him lie beyond what eye has seen, ear has heard, or human heart has imagined, and Christ brings the eternal world within the mind's reach, withdrawing heaven's curtain to reveal its treasures and living glories.Ms 42, 1890, par. 35

The Unspoken Words

In paradise he heard unspeakable words, things unutterable by man, which it is not lawful for a man to utter and which he was forbidden and not permitted to speak, tell, or make known.AA 469.1GC88 471.1GC 470.2–471.29MR 300.1–3Ms 21, 1891, par. 28–30 Taken in holy vision to the third heaven, he saw glorious scenes and heard words he was not permitted to reveal.AA 469.1GC88 471.19MR 300.1–3Ms 21, 1891, par. 28–30BS 81.2

What he saw there was so enrapturing that he could not describe it in human words.20MR 153.2–3Lt 47, 1903, par. 7–8 He retained the wonderful picture in his soul though he could portray it only feebly when he returned to consciousness of earthly things.20MR 153.2–3Lt 47, 1903, par. 7–8 He told only a hundredth part, a thousandth part, of what was revealed because it was too much to utter.Ms 146, 1906, par. 64–65 The brightness of the celestial world and the splendor and joy of the Christian's hope make the heart glow within, yet spiritual truths communicated by the Lord Jesus cannot be adequately expressed in human words.Lt 47, 1903, par. 7–8

He would not satisfy curiosity about the heavenly courts and could not tell everything he had seen.Ms 91, 1903, par. 37–38AA 469.12MR 189.3Lt 167, 1903, par. 3AA 469.2 Such things cannot be described so as to make a correct impression upon minds befogged by sin.Ms 91, 1903, par. 37–38 Hearers would misuse his words, misapply the great truths presented, make a wrong use of that knowledge, and would not be able to comprehend them.Ms 91, 1903, par. 37–38AA 469.12MR 189.3Lt 167, 1903, par. 315MR 228.1

Apart from being taken to heaven in this way, the Bible contains all that is known for certain and all that can ever be hoped to be learned in regard to God and Christ.Ms 21, 1891, par. 28–30 The verse means believers are not to search after oddities or unrevealed things in heaven, but to study, teach, and live the things God has commanded.Ms 91, 1903, par. 37–38

Its Mark on Paul

The glimpse brought Paul into close fellowship and close connection with God and prepared him for his extensive and important missionary work, especially his extensive work among the Gentiles.ST Jun 12, 18798RED 4.3–5.13SP 347.2SLP 41.3ST Apr 23, 1885 While he was praying in the temple God gave him his commission and set his broad missionary field before him with remarkable distinctness.3SP 347.2SLP 41.3ST Apr 23, 1885 God gave this more than usually clear revelation of His presence and compassion and love to prepare Paul for temptation, for before a great trial He prepares His people in this way.Lt 159, 1903, par. 18–19

Although he could not relate everything, all that was shown him molded the messages God gave him to bear to the churches and was woven into his teachings.AA 469.12MR 189.3Lt 167, 1903, par. 315MR 228.120MR 344.2–345.1 What was revealed gave him a deep understanding of the gospel and shaped his understanding of humanity's duty and obligation to God.AA 469.120MR 344.2–345.1Lt 103, 1900, par. 19–22 It helped him represent Christian life and character correctly in speech and letters.AA 469.220MR 344.2–345.1Lt 103, 1900, par. 19–22 His teaching contains precious lessons of warning and encouragement for all to study, written with power not of man but of God, flashing as a sharp two-edged sword in the demonstration of the Spirit, and all his writings, letters, admonitions, and appeals have a heavenly character bringing in the sure word of prophecy.Lt 167, 1903, par. 3

This great honor did not lead him to boast, exalt himself, trust himself, or become self-confident, but called for constant watchfulness and self-denial and deepened his humility, so that he regarded himself as less than the least of all saints.GC88 471.1GC 470.2–471.29MR 300.1–3Ms 21, 1891, par. 28–30BS 81.2 After such honor is the time to walk humbly with God, and an affliction was sent to buffet him, and his eyes that had looked upon Christ remained afflicted.Lt 159, 1903, par. 18–19 A close view of divine glory deepens humility, and a special revelation of God's presence and love may precede a severe trial and should lead to humility rather than self-exaltation.GC 470.2–471.2Lt 159, 1903, par. 18–19

The experience did not mean he had attained perfection; he did not claim to have attained it but continued pressing toward the prize of God's calling in Christ, showing that spiritual growth and sanctification are lifelong even for one who has received a remarkable heavenly experience.AA 561.3–562.2Ms 36, 1885, par. 21–22 That great privilege, with his knowledge, eloquence, and miracles, would all prove unavailing, a defeat and dishonor, if he failed in duty to the church and the church for whom he labored proved inefficient and unfaithful and received the mold of the human instead of the divine.Lt 9, 1892, par. 19–24 His hope of heaven grew dim when he contemplated any such failure toward the church.Lt 9, 1892, par. 19–24

Though so exalted above the other apostles by revelation, he labored with his hands as a tentmaker, proving that manual labor is not degrading and is not inconsistent with true greatness and elevation of human and Christian character.Lt 103, 1900, par. 19–22 The greatness of what was shown him should wake people to want a home in heaven at the cost of everything here and to work for the conversion of souls.Ms 146, 1906, par. 64–65

Sources

  1. GC88 471.1 The Great Controversy (1888) — CHAPTER XXVII. Ellen G. White, 1888
  2. WLF 6.7–9 A Word to the “Little Flock” — THE VOICE OF GOD. James White, 1847
  3. GC 470.2–471.2 The Great Controversy — MODERN REVIVALS — 27 Ellen G. White, 1911
  4. WLF 23.1–3 A Word to the “Little Flock” — THOUGHTS ON REVELATION 14. James White, 1847
  5. AA 469.1 The Acts of the Apostles — CHAPTER XLV Ellen G. White, 1911
  6. 20MR 153.2–3 Manuscript Releases, vol. 20 [Nos. 1420-1500] — MR No. 1454—Spiritual Knowledge to Be Obtained Through Christ and Nature; Many Jewish People to Receive Christ Ellen G. White, written March 28, 1903; published 1993
  7. Lt 47, 1903, par. 7–8 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 18 (1903) — Lt 47, 1903 Ellen G. White, written March 28, 1903
  8. Ms 146, 1906, par. 64–65 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 21 (1906) — Ms 146, 1906 Ellen G. White, written November 10, 1906
  9. 2MR 189.3 Manuscript Releases, vol. 2 [Nos. 97-161] — MR No. 136—Maintain Unity; Hold Fast To The Truth; Not All To Prophecy; Study the Testimonies Ellen G. White, written July 30, 1903; published 1987
  10. Lt 167, 1903, par. 3 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 18 (1903) — Lt 167, 1903 Ellen G. White, written August 4, 1903
  11. AA 561.3–562.2 The Acts of the Apostles — CHAPTER LV Ellen G. White, 1911
  12. 9MR 300.1–3 Manuscript Releases, vol. 9 [Nos. 664-770] — MR No. 747—Christ Our Righteousness Ellen G. White, written February 27, 1891; published 1990
  13. BS 81.2 Bible Sanctification — THE CHRISTIAN’S PRIVILEGE. Ellen G. White, 1882
  14. Ms 21, 1891, par. 28–30 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 7 (1891-1892) — Ms 21, 1891 Ellen G. White, written February 27, 1891
  15. Ms 91, 1903, par. 37–38 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 18 (1903) — Ms 91, 1903 Ellen G. White, written August 20, 1903
  16. ST Jun 12, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 23 — General Articles Ellen G. White, June 12, 1879
  17. 8RED 4.3–5.1 Redemption: or the Teachings of Paul, and his Mission to the Gentiles — TEACHINGS OF PAUL. Ellen G. White, 1873
  18. 3SP 347.2 Spirit of Prophecy Volume Three — ORDINATION OF PAUL AND BARNABAS. Ellen G. White, 1878
  19. SLP 41.3 Sketches from the Life of Paul — CHAPTER IV. Ellen G. White, 1883
  20. CET 240.2 Christian Experience & Teachings of Ellen White — The Prophetic Gift Publishers, 1922
  21. 13MR 299.3–300.1 Manuscript Releases, vol. 13 [Nos. 1000-1080] — MR No. 1051—Vision at Paris, Maine Ellen G. White, written December 25, 1850; published 1990
  22. ST Mar 25, 1897 Signs of the Times, Vol. 23, No. 12 — THE MYSTERY OF GOD Ellen G. White, March 25, 1897
  23. Ms 42, 1890, par. 35 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 6 (1889-1890) — Ms 42, 1890 Ellen G. White, written October 14–29, 1890
  24. AA 469.2 The Acts of the Apostles — CHAPTER XLV Ellen G. White, 1911
  25. 15MR 228.1 Manuscript Releases, vol. 15 [Nos. 1136-1185] — MR No. 1166—The General Conference Relocation; The Book of Daniel; Elder Haskell's Work and Wages Ellen G. White, written July 30, 1903; published 1990
  26. ST Apr 23, 1885 Signs of the Times, Vol. 11, No. 17 — The First Mission to the Gentiles Ellen G. White, April 23, 1885
  27. Lt 159, 1903, par. 18–19 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 18 (1903) — Lt 159, 1903 Ellen G. White, written July 30, 1903
  28. 20MR 344.2–345.1 Manuscript Releases, vol. 20 [Nos. 1420-1500] — MR No. 1491—Guidelines for Success as a Minister or Physician Ellen G. White, written July 13, 1900; published 1993
  29. Lt 103, 1900, par. 19–22 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 15 (1900) — Lt 103, 1900 Ellen G. White, written July 13, 1900
  30. Ms 36, 1885, par. 21–22 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 4 (1883 - 1886) — Ms 36, 1885 Ellen G. White, written December 13, 1885
  31. Lt 9, 1892, par. 19–24 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 7 (1891-1892) — Lt 9, 1892 Ellen G. White, written December 1, 1891 – December 1, 1892

Pioneers and periodicals

102 sources

Paul himself was taken up into Paradise, which is the third heaven above the air and the stars, the dwelling place of God where His throne stands.ST Dec 16, 1913STRH Apr 20, 1869ST Dec 10, 1912RH Jun 10, 1875 Whether he was taken there bodily or shown it in vision he did not know, only God knew.RH Apr 20, 1869RH Aug 31, 1869RH Jun 29, 1916RH Oct 15, 1872 There he heard words of heavenly glory too sacred and wonderful for human speech, which he was not permitted to repeat.ST Dec 16, 1913STRH Apr 20, 1869ST Mar 19, 1894 The glimpse was given to strengthen him for his grave work among the Gentiles and to comfort him in suffering, yet lest he be exalted a thorn in the flesh was given to keep him humble.RH May 18, 1869RH Jun 9, 1874 It was the living man taken up in vision, not a conscious soul leaving the body, and it proves nothing for natural immortality or entrance into bliss at death, for Paradise is the future home of all the righteous entered after the resurrection at Christ's return.RH Apr 20, 1869ST Aug 29, 1878ST Jan 4, 1877

Paul's Identity and Timing

The man in Christ is Paul himself, speaking of his own vision and revelation from the Lord in which he was caught up to Paradise, which is the Paradise of God and the same as the third heaven.RH May 18, 1869PGGC 51.3–52.3ST Aug 24, 1904 He speaks of himself indirectly as another man, as a man in Christ, out of modesty and guardedness.RH May 18, 1869ST Aug 24, 1904ST Mar 27, 1879 These visions and revelations carried special danger of exaltation and temptation where Satan had chief power of attack, and his restraint reflected a real awareness of that danger, not affectation.RH May 18, 1869 He had to speak of them from necessity, yet he hides himself to avoid pride and to avoid making them an occasion of sin, with senses trained by use to discern the approach of danger.RH May 18, 1869

The catching up was above fourteen years before he wrote, about fourteen years earlier, an experience fourteen years earlier in which he was caught up to the third heaven where God dwells and into Paradise.RH Apr 20, 1869ST Jun 8, 1915ST Dec 10, 1912RH Jun 26, 1855 That timing places it around A.D. 45.RH Apr 20, 1869ST Jun 8, 1915ST Dec 10, 1912RH Jun 26, 1855 He had kept the vision private for years and spoke of it only once, when circumstances required him to defend his character and work among the Corinthians.ST Jun 8, 1915ST Dec 10, 1912 The experience was so clear and vivid and real as sight with natural eyes that he could not tell whether he was bodily in Paradise or seeing it only in vision, whether in the body or out of the body.RH Apr 20, 1869ST Jun 8, 1915ST Dec 10, 1912 There he saw the heavenly glory and heard words no man is permitted to speak, words that a person is not permitted to utter, and of himself in his earthly state he would glory only in his infirmities.RH Apr 20, 1869ST Jun 8, 1915ST Dec 10, 1912RH Jun 26, 1855

The setting of the remarkable revelation is not identified and the location remains uncertain, its timing only suggesting a possible connection with the period when Barnabas sought Paul at Tarsus. At least some of the direct revelations by which he received his knowledge of Christ directly from Jesus, not from human instruction, came during his time in Arabia, where he went for quiet meditation and communion with God before beginning his life-work.ST Jun 28, 1883 The word for being caught up expresses a miraculous transportation, the same word used for Philip being taken away in Acts 8:39.ST Mar 31, 1914

Vision and Bodily Uncertainty

2 Corinthians 12:4 belongs to Paul's account of visions and revelations of the Lord, granted to him in abundance and presented as evidence of visions and of the gift of prophecy for the church.RH Jan 7, 1858RH Jun 26, 1855RH Nov 22, 1906 The man caught up into paradise heard words no person is permitted to repeat, and the experience is counted among those abundant revelations for which a thorn in the flesh was allowed to keep him from exaltation.ST Aug 29, 1878RH Jan 7, 1858 The vision was so vivid that Paul could not tell whether he was physically present or was seeing a supernatural picture presented to his mind.ST Aug 29, 1878

Paul did not know whether he was taken bodily to Paradise or shown it only in mental vision, whether in the body or out of the body, and only God knew.RH Apr 20, 1869RH Aug 31, 1869RH Dec 12, 1854ST Jan 4, 1877 The experience could have been a vision in which his mind was carried there, so real that he could not tell whether he had been bodily taken there or the vision made it seem so.RH Aug 31, 1869RH Jun 29, 1916 While it lasted he was unconscious of what was happening around him, yet he knew he saw heavenly glory and heard words no man is permitted to speak.RH Apr 20, 1869RH Jun 29, 1916

To be out of the body means only to be in vision, not a conscious soul living apart from the body in death.RH Oct 15, 1872RH Nov 25, 1858ST Jun 6, 1906ST Mar 27, 1879RH Sep 15, 1859 In that state the mind, thoughts and affections are carried to heaven while the body stays where it is, as when one is absent in flesh yet present in spirit with others.RH Nov 25, 1858ST Mar 27, 1879 Whether God took him there bodily with physical eyes or showed it to him in vision through his mind is left with God, and the matter does not concern death.ST Jun 6, 1906RH Sep 15, 1859

The vision was as real as sight with natural eyes, with images formed before the mind so that it appeared to him as if he went up to heaven.ST Dec 10, 1912PGGC 51.3–52.3RH Oct 16, 1855 While in vision he was utterly unconscious of everything around him and entirely shut away from earthly scenes, his mind taken complete possession of by the Spirit of God to behold things in heaven.RH Jun 9, 1874PGGC 51.3–52.3RH Nov 5, 1914 His body was not dead and the functions of life were not entirely suspended, with heart beating and blood circulating, but he was oblivious of everything transpiring around him and lost to earthly surroundings.RH Jun 29, 1916RH Jun 9, 1874 After he came back to his natural condition he testified only of what he saw while in the vision, writing out what was given him to communicate for the benefit of the church.RH Jun 9, 1874PGGC 51.3–52.3

If it was a vision, he seemed to be bodily present while the Holy Spirit enabled his mind to perceive distant or future scenes and hear what was spoken.RH Oct 15, 1872RH Oct 15, 1872 His spiritual senses were opened so that he could be caught up into the third heaven and perceive the spiritual world.RH Oct 15, 1872RH Jan 7, 1873

He was caught up while alive in vision, not taken bodily to heaven to remain there as Enoch and Elijah were.ST Aug 4, 1881ST Apr 16, 1896 Like other prophets he was shown heaven while in vision, and when the vision ended he was still on earth.ST Aug 4, 1881ST Apr 16, 1896 He was not taken there to become immortal or remain there as Elijah did, but God granted him a view of its glory to strengthen him and give divine guidance for weighty responsibilities. This agrees with John 3:13, understood to mean that no man has ascended to heaven to learn divine things and come back to reveal them except Jesus Christ, who spoke what He knew and testified of what He had seen.ST Apr 16, 1896 By contrast, the overcomers will be caught up together, at one time, bodily and in person — not for a brief visit, but to remain and reign with Christ in Paradise.ST Dec 26, 1906

This catching up to behold the glories of the third heaven happened only once in his life, proving that even the greatest supernatural manifestations were rare and not repeated always and everywhere. After it he had to be buffeted by a messenger of Satan to keep him from being exalted above measure.

Paradise Is Third Heaven

Paul was caught up to the third heaven and then, in restating the same catching up, was caught up into Paradise, so Paradise is the third heaven and the verse fixes its location there.ST Dec 16, 1913RH Apr 20, 1869RH Sep 15, 1859ST Jul 29, 1875RH May 19, 1874 Wherever Scripture speaks of Paradise it refers with certainty to that definitely located place.RH Sep 15, 1859 That third heaven is above the atmosphere and the planetary heavens, the dwelling place of God, not hades or the state of the dead.ST Paul heard there words that were not lawful for a person to utter.ST Dec 16, 1913STRH May 19, 1874 That third heaven is the New Jerusalem, the Paradise of God where the tree of life stands and where the saints will ever dwell, which is above and is to come down from God out of heaven.ST Jul 29, 1875

There are three heavens called heaven in Scripture.RH Aug 5, 1851 The first heaven is the aerial heaven, the atmosphere surrounding the earth where birds fly.RH Jun 10, 1875ST Apr 23, 1896RH Jun 26, 1900ST Jul 4, 1878 The second heaven is the space beyond occupied by suns and planets, the starry or sidereal heaven of sun, moon and stars where the stars are.RH Jun 10, 1875ST Apr 23, 1896RH Aug 5, 1851RH Jun 26, 1900 The third heaven is high above them, God's personal dwelling by His own personal presence, beyond the reach of sin.RH Jun 10, 1875ST Apr 23, 1896RH Jun 26, 1900 The first heaven is affected by sin and will pass away and depart at Christ's coming, but the second and third heavens will not be changed at His coming.RH Jun 26, 1900

Paradise is up, not down in hades.ST Jul 29, 1875 It is the dwelling-place of God in the high and holy place where His throne is prepared, in His direct presence, and whoever goes there goes into the presence of the Father.ST Dec 16, 1913STST Dec 10, 1912ST Oct 28, 1889RH Jun 10, 1875 It is where the throne of God is.ST Oct 28, 1889 Paul's experience fourteen years earlier was being caught up to the third heaven where God dwells and into Paradise, whether bodily or outside the body, and the visions were as real as sight with natural eyes.ST Dec 10, 1912

Paradise means a park or garden with trees, a garden of delights, the Garden of God, the Garden of Eden with the tree of life in its midst.RH Jun 10, 1875ST Jun 16, 1898ST Apr 23, 1896 The pure river of water of life proceeding out of the throne of God and of the Lamb flows there, and the tree of life bearing twelve manner of fruits stands beside it, hard by the throne, near the throne of God.ST Dec 16, 1913RH Jun 10, 1875RH Mar 17, 1859ST Jun 16, 1898 The tree of life is in this heavenly Paradise, transported bodily from its original place in Eden to heaven.RH Feb 5, 1867 Joined with the tree of life being in the midst of the Paradise of God and standing in the New Jerusalem by the pure river proceeding out of the throne, this shows the Paradise of the New Testament is in the holy city above where God maintains His residence and throne.RH Mar 17, 1859

This heavenly Paradise is, or is within, the New Jerusalem, the holy city above where God resides.RH Mar 17, 1859ST Aug 5, 1875RH Oct 1, 1872 The tree of life in the midst of the Paradise of God is the same tree in the New Jerusalem in the midst of the street and on either side of the river of water of life proceeding out of the throne of God and of the Lamb, so Paradise is where the tree of life now is.RH Mar 17, 1859ST Aug 5, 1875RH Oct 1, 1872 Paradise contains the tree of life and was prepared from the foundation of the world when the earth was founded as the blissful home of Adam and Eve in innocence, and after the first Adam was expelled it is now situated within the walls of the heavenly Jerusalem, made infinitely more glorious there.ST Sep 26, 1878 Whoever goes into Paradise therefore goes into the presence of God the Father.RH Oct 1, 1872

Paradise is a place, not merely a condition, and is identified with the third heaven and God's dwelling place.RH Aug 13, 1914 It is a real, located place in heaven, identical with the Father's house and the place Christ went to prepare for His people, distant from earth.RH Sep 15, 1859RH Jun 25, 1867RH Feb 4, 1875 Paul was taken to that real present place now existing in the highest heaven where God's throne is, not in vision only to the future new heavens and new earth where Paradise will also be found.RH Apr 20, 1869 His not knowing whether he was taken there in the body or out of the body proves this, because the new heavens and new earth did not exist in his day and will not exist until after the great burning day, so he could not have been uncertain about being taken there bodily.RH Apr 20, 1869 Paul was caught up in heavenly vision to a literal third heaven existing now, high above the first heaven and second heaven, where paradise and the tree of life are found, where Christ ascended when He left earth and now shares the Father's throne as priest-king, and where the New Jerusalem stands awaiting the saints.ST Jul 4, 1878

Paradise is now withdrawn from the earth in the invisible world and will later return to earth.ST Sep 25, 1907 It was once on this earth and will be on earth again when the New Jerusalem comes down from heaven.ST Jun 16, 1898 It will descend with the holy city and become the capital of the new earth, where the tree of life is near God's throne.ST Oct 6, 1914 It is not the abode of the dead, but most emphatically the abode of the living only.ST Jun 16, 1898

Paradise is not hades or sheol, the grave, the pit, or the state of the dead down in the earth's depths or in the land of death or the earth's interior.STRH Apr 20, 1869ST Jul 29, 1875RH May 19, 1874 Sheol-hades is down, a place of inactivity and silence and unconsciousness and not of reward, from which the saints are delivered at the resurrection to receive their reward and shout victory over it, and which itself will finally be cast into the lake of fire.ST Jul 29, 1875 Paradise is a place of life, joy, peace and knowledge that cannot be cast into Gehenna, while hades is the place or state of the dead.ST Oct 28, 1889 The Paradise of God with its tree of life is in the third heaven, not in hades.RH Apr 20, 1869

The experience gave spiritual instruction and support for his work, but it reveals nothing about where Paradise is, since Paul says nothing about its location.

Unspeakable Words Heard

In Paradise he heard unspeakable words, words of joy concerning heavenly glory, too sacred and wonderful for human language to express.ST Dec 16, 1913STRH Apr 20, 1869RH Aug 31, 1869RH Jun 29, 1916 What he heard it was not lawful for a man to utter, and not possible for a man to utter.ST Dec 16, 1913STRH Apr 20, 1869RH Aug 31, 1869RH Dec 12, 1854 He knew he had seen the heavenly glory and heard words no man is permitted to speak, whether he had been taken there bodily or transported in vision, whether in the body or out of the body.RH Apr 20, 1869RH Aug 31, 1869RH Jun 29, 1916RH Dec 12, 1854 The experience was so vivid and real that he could not tell whether he had been bodily taken there or whether the vision made it seem so, and while it lasted he was unconscious of what was happening around him.RH Apr 20, 1869RH Aug 31, 1869RH Jun 29, 1916 The vision was a revelation from the Lord and a source of heavenly instruction.RH Jun 29, 1916

He was not permitted to repeat or reveal what he heard and saw there.ST Mar 19, 1894RH May 18, 1869 A prophet may see things in holy vision that are not to be made known to people, for not everything seen is to be spoken or written.ST Mar 19, 1894 What was shown him of what is reserved for the overcomers was a private revelation to strengthen him and give him divine guidance for his weighty responsibilities, to comfort him amid suffering and to give him courage to continue his work without fearing for his life.RH May 18, 1869 Even with divine help a prophet may find it difficult to put a message from God into words people can understand.ST Mar 19, 1894RH Sep 13, 1906

The margin gives possibly as well as lawfully for what a person could not utter.RH Nov 22, 1906RH May 21, 1861 The revelations received there are prophecies, and the experience stands as a vision or revelation of the Lord and as an example of the gift of prophecy.RH Nov 22, 1906RH May 21, 1861 Differences in punctuation between Bible versions do not change the meaning, and the catching up into Paradise is the same experience as the catching up to the third heaven.ST Aug 18, 1887RH Nov 22, 1906RH May 21, 1861

Encouragement and Humility Purpose

The catching up into Paradise was given to guide Paul in his grave responsibilities and to favor and direct him by the divine Spirit.ST Oct 30, 1884 God brought him into close connection with Himself and opened before his enraptured vision a glimpse of the beauty and glory of heaven.ST Jun 12, 1879ST Apr 23, 1885ST Jun 12, 1879 This was done to prepare him for his extensive and important missionary work, setting his broad field among the Gentiles before him with remarkable distinctness while he was praying in the temple and receiving his commission.ST Jun 12, 1879ST Apr 23, 1885ST Jun 12, 1879

There he was permitted to see what is reserved for the overcomers and what God has prepared for them, gaining knowledge of the glory awaiting His people.RH May 18, 1869RH Jun 30, 1863 The glory was shown so vividly that he could not tell whether he had seen it in vision or had been physically transported there, yet he was not taken there to become immortal or to remain as Elijah did, but granted a temporary view of its glory.RH May 18, 1869 This private revelation, which he was not permitted to disclose, answered his prayer for strength to bear his burdens and served as personal encouragement and support amid great sufferings.RH May 18, 1869 It gave him comfort and courage to view present suffering as brief beside the eternal glory ahead, to endure trials with joy and faith, to continue his work without fearing for his life, and to comfort others in affliction.RH May 18, 1869 Lifted to the third heaven and then brought down again to endure the smarting pain of his thorn, he rose like a giant exulting in sustaining grace sufficient for each moment, pressing on toward the incorruptible crown and supporting the hope of the eternal inheritance of the saved.RH Jan 6, 1874RH Jan 31, 1854

In Paradise mysteries hidden for ages were opened to him, as much of God's work and dealings with human minds as he could bear.ST Jan 30, 1912ST Mar 25, 1897 Wonders of redeeming grace were opened that were not revealed to all prophets, marking him as the leading prophet of his time.RH Aug 10, 1916 Through the heavenly vision he received the mystery of God's plan once hidden in God and disclosed through the preaching of Jesus Christ, that Jesus took man's original nature and position, endured the test man had failed, and by His death made life possible for every person who wills to receive it.ST Nov 18, 1913 What was opened included God's foreknowledge before creation of future events, the secret plan in the eternal purposes concerning the defection of high intelligences of heaven with an offering prepared to do the work God has done for fallen humanity, and the charge to preach the unsearchable riches of Christ so that light would be given to the Gentiles.ST Mar 25, 1897

Because of the abundance of these visions and revelations of the Lord he was in danger of being exalted above measure, for such manifestations carried special danger of exaltation where Satan had chief power of attack.RH May 18, 1869RH Jun 9, 1874RH Jan 7, 1858 He therefore spoke of himself as another man out of modesty and guardedness, hiding himself to avoid making them an occasion of sin, with restraint reflecting real awareness of the danger of pride and temptation and not affectation.RH May 18, 1869 To keep him humble a thorn in the flesh, a messenger of Satan to buffet him, was given, explaining why one so favored needed such buffeting.RH Jun 9, 1874RH Jan 7, 1858RH Jun 8, 1911 The catching up to behold the glories of the third heaven happened only once in his life, proving that even the greatest supernatural manifestations were rare and not repeated always and everywhere.

Even this extraordinary knowledge and these attainments gave him no ground to boast or to trust in himself for justification before God.RH Jan 29, 1857RH May 5, 1868 His experience of being taken into heaven and seeing wonderful things was not something to rely on or boast about, and he did not mention it until years afterward.RH Jan 29, 1857 These extraordinary experiences did not make him stop striving, but he continued to watch, pray, labor and press forward in progressive sanctification, regarding his own growth humbly and not claiming to have already attained perfection.ST Jul 7, 1887RH Apr 22, 1862 Salvation rests on Christ and not on even the richest spiritual experience, and the catching up did not take the place of reading and study.RH Jan 29, 1857RH Jul 25, 1912 The experience stands as the measure of spiritual exaltation, yet revelations from God do not lead to self-exaltation.RH May 18, 1869ST Dec 30, 1903

No Proof for Immortal Soul

The man himself was caught up into Paradise, whether bodily taken there or shown it only in mental vision, not his soul separately from his body.ST Aug 29, 1878RH Oct 16, 1855RH Oct 16, 1855 He did not know which it was, whether in the body or out of the body, and only God knew.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Oct 16, 1855RH Oct 16, 1855 The verse says nothing of his dying, of a conscious spirit leaving his body, or of his soul being caught up.ST Aug 29, 1878RH Dec 12, 1854RH Oct 16, 1855 The vision was so vivid and real that he could not tell whether he was physically present or beholding a supernatural picture presented to his mind, with images formed before his mind by the Holy Spirit as real as if he had literally gone to heaven.ST Aug 29, 1878RH Oct 16, 1855RH Oct 16, 1855ST Jan 4, 1877

It proves nothing about the intermediate state and gives no support for man's natural immortality.ST Jan 4, 1877RH Nov 25, 1858ST Jan 4, 1877 It does not teach that man has a separate immaterial intelligent soul, that such a soul can live apart from the living organism and see and hear apart from it, that the dead are conscious, or that a vision requires the soul to leave the body and be carried to what is seen.ST Jan 4, 1877RH Nov 25, 1858RH Oct 15, 1872ST Mar 27, 1879RH Sep 15, 1859 To be out of the body means only to be in vision.RH Nov 25, 1858ST Mar 27, 1879RH Sep 15, 1859 To make the verse prove a deathless soul requires forcing it to affirm that a man can be caught up to the third heaven out of the body, then inferring without warrant that man contains a conscious rational entity that is the real man and can live and exercise its senses apart from the body, then asserting without warrant that this entity is deathless.ST Jan 4, 1877

To interpret the experience as his soul or spirit actually leaving his body would imply that his body died during the vision and that his return was a resurrection from the dead.RH Dec 12, 1854ST Mar 27, 1879 No such deaths and resurrections of prophets and apostles are recorded, and a body without its spirit would have been dead.RH Dec 12, 1854ST Mar 27, 1879 His mind, thoughts and affections were carried to heaven while his body stayed where it was, as one can be absent in flesh yet present in spirit, with the Holy Spirit enabling the mind to perceive what was shown.RH Nov 25, 1858RH Oct 16, 1855ST Mar 27, 1879 His experience therefore, given while he was alive in vision and not after death, does not establish that the dead consciously exist apart from the body or in Paradise, nor does it prove the conscious state of the dead.RH Nov 25, 1858ST Aug 4, 1881ST Aug 4, 1881RH Oct 15, 1872RH Sep 15, 1859

Like other prophets he was shown heaven while in vision, and when the vision ended he was still on earth.ST Apr 16, 1896 He was not taken bodily to heaven to remain there as Enoch and Elijah were.ST Apr 16, 1896 This agrees with John 3:13, which means that no man has ascended to heaven to learn the things of God and then come back to reveal them to the world except Jesus Christ, who spoke what He knew from ages of experience and testified of what He had seen.ST Apr 16, 1896

Saints Future Inheritance

Paradise is the place where all the righteous shall finally stand in the presence of God, the abode of the blessed and the future home of the saints.RH Apr 20, 1869RH May 19, 1874RH Mar 13, 1879 It is in the third heaven before God's throne, either the New Jerusalem itself or part of it near the throne, a place of life, joy, peace and perfect bliss.RH Mar 13, 1879ST Aug 23, 1877 The saints enter this heavenly city above when Christ comes to give rewards and raises the dead, before the New Jerusalem descends after the thousand years, and not at death while the dead rest in silence and unconsciousness in the grave.RH Mar 13, 1879ST Aug 23, 1877RH Nov 15, 1853 The thief on the cross and all the saints will be taken there after Christ returns and raises the dead, not on the day of the crucifixion.ST Aug 23, 1877

Paradise already exists now in the third heaven, the highest heaven where God's throne is, and Paul was taken to that real present place.RH Apr 20, 1869 He was not taken in vision only to the future new heavens and new earth where Paradise will also be found.RH Apr 20, 1869 His not knowing whether he was taken there in the body or out of the body proves this, because the new heavens and new earth did not exist in his day and will not exist until after the great burning day, so he could not have been uncertain about being taken there bodily.RH Apr 20, 1869

Paradise contains the tree of life preserved by God, now in the midst of the Paradise of God in the third heaven where God dwells and reigns on His throne.ST Sep 26, 1878RH Sep 21, 1869ST Jun 16, 1898ST Jun 1, 1904ST Jul 2, 1894 It was prepared from the foundation of the world when the earth was founded as the blissful home of Adam and Eve in innocence, where man had free access to the tree and by eating would continue to live.ST Sep 26, 1878RH Sep 21, 1869 After Adam the first was expelled and man was shut away from the tree lest he live forever in sin, the garden was kept sacred and holy as heaven itself and not left for sinners to possess.ST Sep 26, 1878RH Sep 21, 1869ST Aug 27, 1894 It was probably removed from earth at the time of the flood and transplanted to heaven, now situated within the walls of the heavenly Jerusalem and made infinitely more glorious there.ST Sep 26, 1878RH Sep 21, 1869ST Aug 27, 1894ST Jul 2, 1894 There the tree of life stands hard by the throne of God, and from its holy precincts the original plan for the earth has been carried forward and the holy city has been built.ST Aug 27, 1894ST Jun 16, 1898 Paradise is not the abode of the dead, but most emphatically the abode of the living only, and its continued existence supports the promise that redemption restores access to the tree of life.ST Jun 16, 1898ST Jun 1, 1904

Adam the second first introduces the saved into Paradise as the capital of the kingdom when they enter the New Jerusalem and receive the tree of life as part of the overcomer's reward.ST Sep 26, 1878RH Mar 1, 1870 That Paradise is the Paradise of God within the gates of the New Jerusalem, the house of the Father, the city prepared for Abraham and his seed, with a mansion prepared expressly for each saint.RH May 26, 1874 Christ has gone there before the saints as the forerunner to prepare the place, and when the place is prepared and the saints are prepared he will return to take them there to ascend with him and bring them into the presence of the Father.ST Oct 10, 1878RH Mar 8, 1870RH May 26, 1874 There the saints will with their own eyes behold the things God has prepared for those that love him, eat of the tree of life, drink of the river that issues out of the throne of God, eat the marriage supper, and sit with Christ on thrones of judgment during the thousand years.RH May 26, 1874 The kingdom prepared from the foundation of the world that Christ gives to the saints in executing judgment is this Paradise, not at once the new earth, which cannot exist until the wicked have been sentenced and punished in the lake of fire on this earth.ST Sep 26, 1878 When the New Jerusalem becomes the metropolis of the glorified new earth they will take the kingdom under the whole heaven as their inheritance and from Sabbath to Sabbath gather from the whole earth in Paradise to praise the Creator.ST Sep 26, 1878RH May 26, 1874

Thief and Other Scriptures

Paradise is the third heaven, for the place called paradise is the same place called the third heaven where the man in Christ was caught up, and joined to the promise of eating of the tree of life in the midst of the paradise of God and to the tree of life in the New Jerusalem beside the river of water of life proceeding out of the throne of God and of the Lamb, it is where the tree of life now is, in the holy city above where God maintains His residence and throne.RH Oct 1, 1872ST Jan 18, 1916ST Aug 23, 1877ST Feb 20, 1901 Whoever goes into Paradise therefore goes into the presence of God the Father, and going there on the day of the crucifixion would have meant going into the presence of the Father that day.RH Oct 1, 1872ST Jan 18, 1916RH Jan 7, 1873 Jesus did not go there on the day of the crucifixion, for on the third day after He had not yet ascended to His Father.ST Jan 18, 1916RH Mar 1, 1860ST Feb 20, 1901RH Jan 7, 1873 Christ did not go to Paradise on the day He died, so the thief could not have been with Him in Paradise that day.RH Oct 1, 1872RH Mar 1, 1860RH Jan 7, 1873

The promise to the thief therefore referred to a future time, not that very day, and did not rule out his hope of being with Christ at Christ's personal return when He comes into His kingdom.RH Mar 1, 1860ST Feb 20, 1901 The thief on the cross and all the saints will be taken there after Christ returns and raises the dead; the identification of Paradise with the third heaven does not mean that the thief went to Paradise with Jesus on the day of the crucifixion.RH Apr 8, 1858ST Aug 23, 1877RH Jul 5, 1864ST Apr 1, 1880 The promised place in Paradise would mean heaven, but it does not establish that he entered it immediately after death or received the bliss of Paradise immediately.RH Jul 5, 1864ST Apr 1, 1880 Christ's words to the thief on the cross do not teach consciousness in death.RH Jan 7, 1873

The Paradise promised to the thief is Christ's kingdom, ultimately this earth made new, where the Tree of Life and River of Life are found.ST Jun 16, 1909 That kingdom is associated with Christ's second appearing, not with the day of death.RH Oct 17, 1854 Against this, the teaching of those who held the other view presents Paradise as above, not beneath the earth, where spirits go to be with Jesus while their bodies remain in the grave, with Paradise transferred from the earth to heaven, a transfer rejected as unsupported by Scripture.RH Jul 6, 1916

Sources

  1. ST Dec 16, 1913 Signs of the Times, Vol. 40, No. 48 — 4235 — THE THIRD HEAVEN T. C. B., December 16, 1913
  2. ST Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 30 — Is Sin Eternal? No John Norton Loughborough
  3. RH Apr 20, 1869 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 33, No. 17 — Paradise John Nevins Andrews, Third-day, April 20, 1869
  4. ST Dec 10, 1912 Signs of the Times, Vol. 39, No. 48 — 3937 — Man in Christ I. T., December 10, 1912
  5. RH Jun 10, 1875 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 45, No. 24 — ABOUT GOD'S BEAUTIFUL HOME M. M. Osgood, June 10, 1875
  6. RH Aug 31, 1869 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 34, No. 10 — IN THE BODY, OR OUT?—2 COR. XII, 1-4 Dudley Marvin Canright, August 31, 1869
  7. RH Jun 29, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 32 — Biblical Teaching about Visions and Their Perpetuation in the Church George Ide Butler, June 29, 1916
  8. RH Oct 15, 1872 Review and Herald, Vol. 40, No. 18 — In the Body and Out October 15, 1872
  9. ST Mar 19, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 20 — THE VALUE OF PROPHECY George I. Butler, Monday, March 19, 1894
  10. RH May 18, 1869 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 33, No. 21 — PAUL'S VISION OF THE THIRD HEAVEN John Nevins Andrews, May 18, 1869
  11. RH Jun 9, 1874 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 43, No. 26 — VISIONS AND PROPHECY George I. Butler, June 9, 1874
  12. RH Apr 20, 1869 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 33, No. 17 — Paradise John Nevins Andrews, Third-day, April 20, 1869
  13. ST Aug 29, 1878 Signs of the Times, Vol. 4, No. 33 — Debate on Immortality B. A. Stephens, August 29, 1878
  14. ST Jan 4, 1877 Signs of the Times, Vol. 3, No. 2 — THE TEACHINGS OF PAUL C. W. Stone, Fifth-day, January 4, 1877
  15. PGGC 51.3–52.3 The Prophetic Gift in the Gospel Church — PART TWO John Norton Loughborough, John N. Loughborough, 1901
  16. ST Aug 24, 1904 Signs of the Times, Vol. 30, No. 34 — NEHEMIAH F. D. Starr, August 24, 1904
  17. ST Mar 27, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 13 — General Articles Dudley Marvin Canright, March 27, 1879
  18. ST Jun 8, 1915 Signs of the Times, Vol. 42, No. 23 — QUESTION CORNER Milton C. Wilcox, June 8, 1915
  19. RH Jun 26, 1855 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 32 — THE ONENESS OF THE CHURCH AND THE David Arnold, Vol. VI, No. 32, June 26, 1855
  20. ST Jun 28, 1883 Signs of the Times, Vol. 9, No. 25 — The Sabbath-School. ## Lesson for Pacific Coast—July 7. Acts 9:23-35; Gal. 1:15-18. ## Notes on the Lesson June 28, 1883
  21. ST Mar 31, 1914 Signs of the Times, Vol. 41, No. 12 — 4285—"CAUGHT AWAY" L. V. P., March 31, 1914
  22. RH Jan 7, 1858 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 11, No. 9 — Unity and Gifts of the Church James White, January 7, 1858
  23. RH Nov 22, 1906 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 83, No. 47 — The Spirit of Prophecy GEORGE A. IRWIN, November 22, 1906
  24. RH Dec 12, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 17 — MAN NOT IMMORTAL: D. P. Hall, December 12, 1854
  25. RH Nov 25, 1858 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 13, No. 1 — To Correspondents Editor, Fifth-Day, November 25, 1858
  26. ST Jun 6, 1906 Signs of the Times, Vol. 32, No. 22 — Question Corner June 6, 1906
  27. RH Sep 15, 1859 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 14, No. 17 — MORTAL OR IMMORTAL? WHICH? Editor, September 15, 1859
  28. RH Oct 16, 1855 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 7, No. 8 — IS THE SOUL IMMORTAL? John Norton Loughborough, October 16, 1855
  29. RH Nov 5, 1914 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 91, No. 46 — The Second Advent Movement John Norton Loughborough, Thursday, November 5, 1914
  30. RH Oct 15, 1872 Review and Herald, Vol. 40, No. 18 — In the Body and Out October 15, 1872
  31. RH Jan 7, 1873 Review and Herald, Vol. 41, No. 4 — The Intermediate State of the Dead S. S. Griswold, January 7, 1873
  32. ST Aug 4, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 29 John Norton Loughborough, August 4, 1881
  33. ST Apr 16, 1896 Signs of the Times, Vol. 22, No. 16 — Question Corner B. W. P., April 16, 1896
  34. ST Dec 26, 1906 Signs of the Times, Vol. 32, No. 50 — A SHORT WORK H. A. St. John, December 26, 1906
  35. RH Sep 15, 1859 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 14, No. 17 — MORTAL OR IMMORTAL? WHICH? Editor, September 15, 1859
  36. ST Jul 29, 1875 Signs of the Times, Vol. 1, No. 38 — Hope of the Gospel J. N. Loughborough, July 29, 1875
  37. RH May 19, 1874 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 43, No. 23 — Paradise John Nevins Andrews, May 19, 1874
  38. RH Aug 5, 1851 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 2, No. 1 — THE VOICE OF GOD The True Midnight Cry, August 5, 1851
  39. ST Apr 23, 1896 Signs of the Times, Vol. 22, No. 17 — Question Corner I. E. H., April 23, 1896
  40. RH Jun 26, 1900 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 77, No. 26 — BIBLE READINGS WITH FAMILIES Mrs. S. N. Haskell, June 26, 1900
  41. ST Jul 4, 1878 Signs of the Times, Vol. 4, No. 25 — The New Jerusalem Uriah Smith, July 4, 1878
  42. ST Oct 28, 1889 Signs of the Times, Vol. 15, No. 41 — Hades Is Not Paradise Editor, October 28, 1889
  43. ST Jun 16, 1898 Signs of the Times, Vol. 24, No. 24 — Question Corner June 16, 1898
  44. RH Mar 17, 1859 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 13, No. 17 — PARADISE—WHERE IS IT? March 17, 1859
  45. RH Feb 5, 1867 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 29, No. 9 — Paradise and the Tree of Life Third-day, February 5, 1867
  46. ST Aug 5, 1875 Signs of the Times, Vol. 1, No. 39 — Question John Norton Loughborough, August 5, 1875
  47. RH Oct 1, 1872 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 40, No. 16 — With Me in Paradise October 1, 1872
  48. ST Sep 26, 1878 Signs of the Times, Vol. 4, No. 36 — The Order of Events in the Judgment John Nevins Andrews, Fifth-day, September 26, 1878
  49. RH Aug 13, 1914 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 91, No. 33 — Is Pork Eating a Test of Fellowship? August 13, 1914
  50. RH Jun 25, 1867 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 30, No. 2 — GOD A BEING AND HEAVEN A PLACE Wm. S. Ingraham, Third-day, June 25, 1867
  51. RH Feb 4, 1875 Review and Herald, Vol. 45, No. 6 — Will the Saints Go to Heaven? A. Smith, Fifth-day, February 4, 1875
  52. RH Apr 20, 1869 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 33, No. 17 — Paradise John Nevins Andrews, Third-day, April 20, 1869
  53. ST Sep 25, 1907 Signs of the Times, Vol. 33, No. 39 — Where This Garden of Eden, Paradise, Is Said to Be Now Arthur L. Manous, SEPTEMBER 25, 1907
  54. ST Oct 6, 1914 Signs of the Times, Vol. 41, No. 39 — 27 — THE LORD'S ANSWER TO THE THIEF Dudley Marvin Canright, October 6, 1914
  55. RH May 18, 1869 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 33, No. 21 — PAUL'S VISION OF THE THIRD HEAVEN John Nevins Andrews, May 18, 1869
  56. RH Sep 13, 1906 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 83, No. 37 — The Gift of Prophecy Stephen N. Haskell, September 13, 1906
  57. RH May 21, 1861 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 18, No. 1 — THE LAW UNTIL JOHN S. P., May 21, 1861
  58. ST Aug 18, 1887 Signs of the Times, Vol. 13, No. 32 — PUNCTUATION AND INSPIRATION W., August 18, 1887
  59. ST Oct 30, 1884 Signs of the Times, Vol. 10, No. 41 — Leadings of the Spirit in Missionary Work W. H. Ernst, October 30, 1884
  60. ST Jun 12, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 23 — General Articles Ellen G. White, June 12, 1879
  61. ST Apr 23, 1885 Signs of the Times, Vol. 11, No. 17 — The First Mission to the Gentiles Ellen G. White, April 23, 1885
  62. ST Jun 12, 1879 Signs of the Times, Vol. 5, No. 23 — Mission of Paul and Barnabas Ellen G. White, June 12, 1879
  63. RH Jun 30, 1863 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 22, No. 5 — To the Young A. C. Hudson, June 30, 1863
  64. RH Jan 6, 1874 Review and Herald, Vol. 43, No. 4 — Strength for the Day John R. Macduff, January 6, 1874
  65. RH Jan 31, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 5, No. 2 — ALL THINGS ARE YOURS Editor, January 31, 1854
  66. ST Jan 30, 1912 Signs of the Times, Vol. 39, No. 5 — The Mystery of God Ellen G. White, January 30, 1912
  67. ST Mar 25, 1897 Signs of the Times, Vol. 23, No. 12 — THE MYSTERY OF GOD Ellen G. White, March 25, 1897
  68. RH Aug 10, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 40 — Apostles and Prophets S. N. HASKELL, August 10, 1916
  69. ST Nov 18, 1913 Signs of the Times, Vol. 40, No. 44 — God's Estimate of Man John Orcutt Corliss, November 18, 1913
  70. RH Jun 8, 1911 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 88, No. 23 — Perversion of Spiritual Gifts W. A. S., June 8, 1911
  71. RH Jan 29, 1857 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 9, No. 13 — Advanced Christians Maine Evangelist, January 29, 1857
  72. RH May 5, 1868 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 31, No. 21 — AN APOSTLE’S RELIGION Ryle, Third-day, May 5, 1868
  73. RH Apr 22, 1862 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 19, No. 21 — CHARACTER GEO. WRIGHT, Third-Day, April 22, 1862
  74. ST Jul 7, 1887 Signs of the Times, Vol. 13, No. 26 — FRUITS MEET FOR REPENTANCE Ellen G. White, July 7, 1887
  75. RH Jul 25, 1912 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 89, No. 30 — Good Books G. B. Thompson, July 25, 1912
  76. ST Dec 30, 1903 Signs of the Times, Vol. 29, No. 52 — XVIII. ASSUMPTIONS OF CHRISTIAN SCIENCE J. A. L. Derby, December 30, 1903
  77. RH Oct 16, 1855 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 7, No. 8 — IS THE SOUL IMMORTAL? John Norton Loughborough, October 16, 1855
  78. ST Jan 4, 1877 Signs of the Times, Vol. 3, No. 2 — THE TEACHINGS OF PAUL C. W. Stone, Fifth-day, January 4, 1877
  79. RH Dec 12, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 17 — MAN NOT IMMORTAL: D. P. Hall, December 12, 1854
  80. ST Aug 4, 1881 Signs of the Times, Vol. 7, No. 29 August 4, 1881
  81. RH May 19, 1874 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 43, No. 23 — Paradise John Nevins Andrews, May 19, 1874
  82. RH Mar 13, 1879 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 53, No. 11 — PARADISE J. O. Corliss, March 13, 1879
  83. ST Aug 23, 1877 Signs of the Times, Vol. 3, No. 33 — The Punctuation of the Bible B. A. STEPHENS, Fifth-day, August 23, 1877
  84. RH Nov 15, 1853 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 4, No. 19 — The Saints During the Millennium November 15, 1853
  85. RH Sep 21, 1869 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 34, No. 13 — BRIEF THOUGHTS CONCERNING LIFE AND DEATH Third-day, September 21, 1869
  86. ST Jun 1, 1904 Signs of the Times, Vol. 30, No. 22 — ACCESS TO THE TREE OF LIFE June 1, 1904
  87. ST Jul 2, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 34 — THE CURSE OF SIN UPON THE EARTH William Covert, Monday, July 2, 1894
  88. ST Aug 27, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 42 — CAPITAL CITY OF THE NEW EARTH William Covert, Monday, August 27, 1894
  89. RH Mar 1, 1870 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 35, No. 11 — The Order of Events in the Judgment Third-day, March 1, 1870
  90. RH May 26, 1874 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 43, No. 24 — Paradise John Nevins Andrews, May 26, 1874
  91. ST Oct 10, 1878 Signs of the Times, Vol. 4, No. 38 — The Order of Events in the Judgment October 10, 1878
  92. RH Mar 8, 1870 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 35, No. 12 — The Order of Events in the Judgment Third-day, March 8, 1870
  93. ST Jan 18, 1916 Signs of the Times, Vol. 43, No. 3 — QUESTION CORNER January 18, 1916
  94. ST Feb 20, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 8 — A WONDERFUL EXAMPLE OF FAITH February 20, 1901
  95. RH Jan 7, 1873 Review and Herald, Vol. 41, No. 4 — The Intermediate State of the Dead January 7, 1873
  96. RH Mar 1, 1860 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 15, No. 15 — FAITH OF JESUS Editor, March 1, 1860
  97. RH Apr 8, 1858 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 11, No. 21 — BRIEF REPLY April 8, 1858
  98. RH Jul 5, 1864 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 24, No. 6 — When have Inspired Men Expected the Bliss of Heaven? R. F. Cottrell, Third-Day, July 5, 1864
  99. ST Apr 1, 1880 Signs of the Times, Vol. 6, No. 13 — WHEN HAVE INSPIRED MEN EXPECTED THE BLISS OF HEAVEN? R. F. Cottrell, April 1, 1880
  100. ST Jun 16, 1909 Signs of the Times, Vol. 36, No. 23 — Question Corner P. G. L., June 16, 1909
  101. RH Oct 17, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 10 — THE ATONEMENT J. M. Stephenson, October 17, 1854
  102. RH Jul 6, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 33 — Where Did the Saved Thief Go? F. M. W., July 6, 1916

Cross-references

  1. Revelation 2:7

    He that hath an ear, let him hear what the Spirit saith unto the churches; To him that overcometh will I give to eat of the tree of life, which is in the midst of the paradise of God.

    Both identify Paradise as the setting of the promised reward for the righteous.

  2. Luke 23:43

    And Jesus said unto him, Verily I say unto thee, To day shalt thou be with me in paradise.

    Both passages speak of Paradise, and Jesus promises the penitent thief a place there.

  3. Revelation 22:1-2

    And he shewed me a pure river of water of life, clear as crystal, proceeding out of the throne of God and of the Lamb.

    The river and tree of life stand by God’s throne in Paradise.

  4. Genesis 2:8-9

    And the LORD God planted a garden eastward in Eden; and there he put the man whom he had formed.

    Eden is identified as the original earthly paradise prepared for humanity.

  5. Genesis 3:23-24

    Therefore the LORD God sent him forth from the garden of Eden, to till the ground from whence he was taken.

    Humanity’s expulsion from Eden depicts paradise removed from earth.

  6. 1 Corinthians 2:9

    But as it is written, Eye hath not seen, nor ear heard, neither have entered into the heart of man, the things which God hath prepared for them that love him.

    Both describe God’s prepared glory beyond human sight and understanding.

  7. Revelation 21:1-2

    And I saw a new heaven and a new earth: for the first heaven and the first earth were passed away; and there was no more sea.

    Paradise is associated with New Jerusalem, which descends from heaven to earth.

  8. 1 Thessalonians 4:17

    Then we which are alive and remain shall be caught up together with them in the clouds, to meet the Lord in the air: and so shall we ever be with the Lord.

    Both describe being caught up; here the redeemed meet the Lord.

  9. Acts 8:39

    And when they were come up out of the water, the Spirit of the Lord caught away Philip, that the eunuch saw him no more: and he went on his way rejoicing.

    Uses the same word for Philip being caught away.

  10. John 20:17

    Jesus saith unto her, Touch me not; for I am not yet ascended to my Father: but go to my brethren, and say unto them, I ascend unto my Father, and your Father; and to my God, and your God.

    Jesus’ statement that he had not yet ascended bears on when he went to paradise.

  11. Revelation 10:4

    And when the seven thunders had uttered their voices, I was about to write: and I heard a voice from heaven saying unto me, Seal up those things which the seven thunders uttered, and write them not.

    John is told not to write what the seven thunders said.

  12. Luke 16:22

    And it came to pass, that the beggar died, and was carried by the angels into Abraham’s bosom: the rich man also died, and was buried;

    Lazarus is carried to Abraham’s bosom, compared with Paradise.

  13. John 14:2

    In my Father’s house are many mansions: if it were not so, I would have told you. I go to prepare a place for you.

    The Father’s house Christ prepares is identified with Paul’s Paradise.

  14. Revelation 22:1

    And he shewed me a pure river of water of life, clear as crystal, proceeding out of the throne of God and of the Lamb.

    The river of life is in the city identified with Paradise.