2 Thessalonians 2:5
Remember ye not, that, when I was yet with you, I told you these things?
Translations
Remember you not, that, when I was yet with you, I told you these things?
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Revised Version, American Standard Version
Remember ye not, that, when I was yet with you, I told you these things?
Remember ye not, that when I was yet with you, I told you these things?
Do ye not remember that, being yet with you, these things I said to you?
Do ye not remember that, being yet with you, I said these things to you?
Remember ye not, that, while I was yet with you, these very things, I was telling you?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
Do you not remember that I told you these things while I was still with you?
Don’t you remember that when I was still with you, I told you these things?
Have you no memory of what I said when I was with you, giving you word of these things?
Remember ye not, that when I was yet with you, I tolde you these things?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
Remember you not, that when I was yet with you, I told you these things?
Cross-references
- 1 Thessalonians 4:13-18
But I would not have you to be ignorant, brethren, concerning them which are asleep, that ye sorrow not, even as others which have no hope.
The earlier epistle led to confusion about the timing of the Lord’s return.
- Acts 17:1-3
Now when they had passed through Amphipolis and Apollonia, they came to Thessalonica, where was a synagogue of the Jews:
Records Paul’s visit when he told them these things.
- 2 Peter 1:12-13
Wherefore I will not be negligent to put you always in remembrance of these things, though ye know them, and be established in the present truth.
Both recall apostolic teaching by reminding believers of what they were taught.
- 1 Thessalonians 5
But of the times and the seasons, brethren, ye have no need that I write unto you.
The first epistle was misunderstood as teaching that the Lord would come in their day.
- Daniel 7:24-25
And the ten horns out of this kingdom are ten kings that shall arise: and another shall rise after them; and he shall be diverse from the first, and he shall subdue three kings.
Daniel’s little horn supplies the prophecy behind Paul’s teaching.
- Matthew 24:23-25
Then if any man shall say unto you, Lo, here is Christ, or there; believe it not.
same warning not to believe here is Christ
- Daniel 7:8
I considered the horns, and, behold, there came up among them another little horn, before whom there were three of the first horns plucked up by the roots: and, behold, in this horn were eyes like the eyes of man, and a mouth speaking great things.
The little horn supplies the prophecy behind Paul’s teaching.
- Isaiah 48:5
I have even from the beginning declared it to thee; before it came to pass I shewed it thee: lest thou shouldest say, Mine idol hath done them, and my graven image, and my molten image, hath commanded them.
God declares events before they come to pass.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
17 sources
Paul was reminding the Thessalonians that he had already told them these things in person while he was still with them, so his letter recalls prior oral instruction.CET 241.1ST May 28, 1894Ms 24, 1891, par. 23–24 What he had told them was that the day of Christ was not immediately at hand, because the falling away must come first and the man of sin must be revealed, who opposes God, sits in the temple of God, works with satanic power and lying wonders, and deceives those who reject love of the truth until they believe a lie and are lost.ST May 28, 1894Ms 24, 1891, par. 23–24AA 265.1–2 That power is the Papacy, through which Satan manifests his character, and it consolidates with infidelity and all elements of evil while increasing in power and working under pretense of godliness to take the world captive.ST May 28, 1894Lt 15, 1889, par. 9–10 Its central effort is to destroy the Sabbath of the fourth commandment and institute a spurious sabbath in its place, which apostate Protestantism accepts, so that oppressive laws enforce a rival worship and those who give God's honor to a man-made institution are left unsealed for judgment.19MR 244.1–3Ms 110, 1904, par. 58–61 The warning applies now with urgency, for churches that refuse the truth including the first, second, and third angels' messages fall into error amid increasing deceptions and false claims of Christ, yet remembering this teaching keeps people from false paths and the apostasy will end in defeat for falsehood and triumph for truth.1MR 301.3–302.1Lt 16, 1893, par. 16–1814MR 287.317MR 1.7Ms 24, 1891, par. 32
Paul's Earlier Oral Teaching
Paul's question recalls that he had already told the Thessalonians these things in person while he was still with them, so the written warning is a reminder of prior oral instruction about the apostasy and the man of sin.CET 241.1ST May 28, 1894Ms 24, 1891, par. 23–2419MR 244.1–3AA 265.1–2 That earlier personal explanation included the events connected with the day of the Lord and the revelation of the man of sin foretold in 2 Thessalonians 2:3-12.ST May 28, 1894Ms 24, 1891, par. 23–2419MR 244.1–3 It had covered the events that must take place before Christ's coming, including the rise of the papal power and its opposition to God.ST May 28, 1894AA 265.1–2 Because that teaching had been given while he was with them, the readers should not mistake his message or believe that he taught the day of Christ was immediately at hand.AA 265.1–2
The surrounding prediction shows that this falling away had already begun to appear among false brethren in the church and would later develop further.CET 241.1 After the apostles died, the prediction was fulfilled as some church members departed from Christ's teaching and joined in heathen practices.CET 241.2 This departure gradually developed into an apostate form of Christianity.CET 241.2 The reminder therefore points back to instruction they had already received before about the matters he was addressing.1MR 361.4–362.1
Apostasy and Man of Sin
What had been told beforehand was the falling away coming first, then the revealing of the man of sin, the son of perdition, who opposes and exalts himself above all that is called God or that is worshiped and sits in the temple of God showing himself that he is God, with the mystery of iniquity already working, the revealing of the wicked one whom the Lord will consume with the spirit of His mouth and destroy with the brightness of His coming, his coming after the working of Satan with all power and signs and lying wonders and with all deceivableness of unrighteousness in those who perish because they received not the love of the truth that they might be saved, and God sending strong delusion that they should believe a lie, that all who believed not the truth but had pleasure in unrighteousness might be damned.ST May 28, 1894 The power so described is the Papacy or popery, through which Satan has manifested his character and brought out the principles of his government, and it is now increasing in power.ST May 28, 1894Lt 15, 1889, par. 9–10 That power combines and consolidates with infidelity, sectarianism, formalism, sin, and all elements of evil for vigorous resistance to God and the truth, while God is dishonored, Christ is rejected, and soul-destroying errors intrude everywhere.Lt 15, 1889, par. 9–10 It works under Satan's master plan disguised under a pretense of godliness to take the world captive through numerous disguised, subtle, persevering, untiring agents employing every instrumentality with marvelous promptitude and energy, while the children of the world rush into every new opening.Lt 15, 1889, par. 9–10
The coming apostasy is Satan's determined effort since Eden to destroy the Sabbath of the fourth commandment, given as the memorial of creation, and to institute a spurious sabbath in its place, so that the memorial of God's works is lost from the mind and worldwide apostasy against God's law is brought about.19MR 244.1–3 Leading men and women to disregard the fourth commandment places them on Satan's side of the controversy, for breaking one point of the law is guilt of all.19MR 244.1–3 The prophecy applies to satanic efforts to enforce a rival sabbath, in which apostate Protestantism accepts the papal sabbath and oppressive laws will be used against those who refuse to worship it, so God's people are to remain loyal to God's commandments and be guided by His Word.Ms 110, 1904, par. 58–61
The prophecy is a figurative outline and delineation of historical events leading down to the close of earth's history, fulfilled directly in historical events that shone out clearly, and it must be applied correctly in light of prophetic fulfillment.Ms 31, 1896, par. 1–217MR 1.7 Its scenes connected with the working of the man of sin are among the last features plainly revealed in this earth's history.Ms 31, 1896, par. 1–217MR 1.7 The man of sin shall be disclosed to the world so that who he is and what his work has been will be made plain, and before that disclosure there will be one fierce struggle.14MR 287.3Lt 112, 1890, par. 14–15 At that time the Protestant world is becoming tender and affectionate toward him, while mystic Babylon has not spared the blood of the saints, so God's people must meet the issue as bold and valiant soldiers of Jesus Christ, with their lives hid with Christ in God, wide awake to catch the light that exposes Babylon and the beams from the angel who is to brighten the earth with his glory.14MR 287.3Lt 112, 1890, par. 14–15
Warning for Present Time
The reminder that these things were told beforehand stands as a warning against rejecting truth and accepting a lie, for churches that refuse the messages of truth will fall into error.1MR 301.3–302.1Lt 16, 1893, par. 16–18 That refusal includes rejecting the warning given in the first, second, and third angels' messages.1MR 301.3–302.1Lt 16, 1893, par. 16–18
The warning applies now with urgency, because deceptions, delusions, and impostures will increase, with cries from every quarter, Lo here is Christ and Lo there is Christ, which must not be followed.14MR 287.317MR 1.7 Remembering the prior teaching and having passed over the ground and acted a part in the proclamation of the first, second, and third angels' messages keeps people from being led into false paths.14MR 287.317MR 1.7 That safeguard is now joined to the special message to give to the world, the third angel's message.14MR 287.317MR 1.7
The foretold apostasy of men and women who have had great light and an abundance of evidence of present truth, together with the seductive working of the enemy in the closing days of earth's history, comes as Scripture said it would come.Lt 266, 1906, par. 2–3 This must be accepted and submitted to even though it brings grief.Lt 266, 1906, par. 2–3 While some will have their eyes opened, for many it may be too late to correct the errors they have made.Lt 266, 1906, par. 2–3
Those who subvert faith into idolatry by giving to a man-made institution the glory and honor God requires for His Sabbath day and compelling others to worship this idol are left unsealed by God.19MR 244.1–3 They are certain to face God's retributive judgments poured out without mixture of mercy upon unrepentant despisers of His law.19MR 244.1–3
These are solemn and fearful days needing daily divine enlightenment.Lt 15, 1889, par. 9–10 The Spirit of God is surely but gradually withdrawn from the earth, while plagues and judgments already fall upon despisers of grace.Lt 15, 1889, par. 9–10 Casualties by sea and by land, with fire and floods in towns and cities, forecast shadows of approaching events of greatest magnitude.Lt 15, 1889, par. 9–10
The apostasy will end in defeat for falsehood and triumph for truth and righteousness.Ms 24, 1891, par. 32 Although Satan and his allies may appear to win, those who believe a lie will be defeated.Ms 24, 1891, par. 32
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
97 sources
Paul was reminding the Thessalonians that he had already told them face to face about the coming of the Lord, the gathering to Him, the falling away first, and the revealing of the man of sin, so his written warning was nothing new to them.ST Sep 2, 1875ST Nov 27, 1879 The reminder corrects the error that the day of Christ was then at hand or already present, insisting no one be deceived because the apostasy and the revealing of the man of sin must come first.RH Apr 26, 1870ST Oct 25, 1883 That falling away is a departure inside the church developing into the man of sin, the lawless one who opposes and exalts himself above all called God or worshiped, sits as God in the temple which is the church, and is the Papacy, the Roman pontiff and papal succession.ST Sep 30, 1880ST Nov 27, 1879ST Dec 22, 1881ST Aug 14, 1893 What held back his full revealing was pagan Rome, the heathen empire and emperors, whose removal and breaking into ten kingdoms would bring on antichrist, followed by the bishop of Rome made head of the church, the 1,260 years of papal supremacy and persecution, the deadly wound in 1798, and a later revival before Christ comes.RH Feb 9, 1860RH Feb 9, 1860RH Feb 15, 1870RH Jul 22, 1858RH Jan 23, 1855 His self-exaltation is shown especially in taking God's law and changing the seventh-day Sabbath to the first day without Scripture authority, yet he remains until Christ's personal coming when he is consumed with the spirit of His mouth and destroyed with the brightness of His coming.RH Jun 6, 1912ST Sep 17, 1874ST Oct 8, 1894
Prior Teaching Recalled
The verse is a reminder that what was written was not new, for Paul had already explained these things in person while he was still present with the Thessalonians, including the coming of the Lord and the gathering together unto Him, the falling away that must come first, and the revealing of the man of sin before Christ comes.ST Sep 2, 1875ST Nov 27, 1879ST Jun 20, 1900RH Sep 29, 1859 That prior teaching warned them not to expect the coming before the man of sin was revealed, although the forces behind him were already at work and hindering causes had first to be removed, and it belongs to a prophecy extending from the time of writing to the Lord's return in which the mystery of iniquity already working would grow until Satanic deception became widespread.ST Nov 27, 1879ST Feb 7, 1906 The man of sin so foretold is the Roman Pontiff, who overrides God's law and claims divine prerogatives, and the reminder supports the warning not to conclude from spirit, word, or letter as from Paul that the day of Christ was at hand, since the great apostasy had to take place first and Christ would come afterward to destroy the wicked by the brightness of His personal presence.ST Nov 27, 1879
The things remembered cover the full sequence: the falling away first, the revealing of the man of sin the son of perdition who opposes and exalts himself above all that is called God or worshiped and sits in the temple of God showing himself that he is God, what withholds his revealing in his time, the mystery of iniquity already working, and the Wicked to be consumed with the spirit of the Lord's mouth and destroyed with the brightness of His coming.ST May 28, 1894ST Oct 25, 1899RH Apr 10, 1900ST Feb 6, 1896 The temple means the church of Christ, and the prediction means the simple beauty of early Christianity would be corrupted, lies calling themselves Christian doctrine would take the place of truth, and the spirit of self-exaltation would take the place of Christian humility until one in the church opposes his will to God's will and demands obedience to himself instead.ST Oct 25, 1899RH Apr 10, 1900 The same description is the Beast, whose rise, time, and place are so clearly marked in Scripture that careful study cannot mistake it, and it belongs to the prophecy of a false theocracy that claims authority in God's place after restraint is removed at its appointed time.RH Apr 10, 1900ST Oct 10, 1895 With this comes his coming after the working of Satan with all power and signs and lying wonders and with all deceivableness of unrighteousness in them that perish because they received not the love of the truth that they might be saved, and God sending strong delusion that they should believe a lie that all who believed not the truth but had pleasure in unrighteousness might be damned.ST May 28, 1894 The power so described is the Papacy, through which Satan has manifested his character and brought out the principles of his government, and the reminder is a strong appeal not to be shaken in mind or troubled by forged claims that the day was at hand, so that ignorance through carelessness leaves no excuse.ST May 28, 1894ST May 28, 1894ST Feb 6, 1896
What was told by mouth was reasoned out of the Scriptures, specifically from Daniel 7 and 8 concerning Rome from its beginning to the end of the world in both its ancient pagan phase as the beast and its modern papal phase as the little horn, which places the little horn's rise and period of power before the Judgment.RH Apr 26, 1870ST Dec 3, 1902RH Apr 10, 1900 Paul preached this at Thessalonica for only three or four weeks over three Sabbath days, giving additional light on Daniel 7 and 8 that began to be fulfilled in the lifetime of those proclaiming the pure gospel, identifying the man of sin as the leading subject of Daniel 7 and 8, the horn with eyes and mouth, in his self-exaltation substituting himself for God in the sanctuary service.ST Dec 3, 1902 He spoke as a prophet after the ancient order by authority given through visions and revelation from God, by virtue of which he could confidently predict the semi-apostasy opening the door for a man of sin to assume the place of God, emerging from the iniquitous religion of the first century whose popular false form was paganism.RH Aug 10, 1911 His question is almost reproachful that they should have remembered, proving he taught no doctrine that the Lord was to come in their day and correcting those who took advantage of his expression about those alive and remaining to teach and write in his name that the day of Christ is at hand.ST May 20, 1886 The work culminating in that self-exaltation had already begun in Paul's time as the mystery of iniquity, by which the Papacy corrupts the true temple service by taking away the continual and putting man in the place of God, substituting the mystery of iniquity for the mystery of godliness.ST Dec 3, 1902
The things told by mouth also include the promise that Jesus purposes to invest the bodies of all His faithful disciples with the same glory seen in His own glorified body, that they will bear the image of the heavenly and shine in glory like Him.RH Apr 18, 1854 Paul had seen the Lord in His glory and had learned this purpose by revelation, so with Peter he often spoke of it in oral preaching as well as in writing to cheer, support, comfort and animate afflicted brethren amid cruel persecutions, and was himself greatly animated by it.RH Apr 18, 1854
Timing Error Corrected
The verse corrects the mistaken idea that the day of Christ was at hand or already present in Paul's day.RH Apr 26, 1870ST Oct 25, 1883ST Aug 12, 1880ST Jan 11, 1883 That idea had come from misunderstanding his first letter, and from spirit and word and forged letter as from him, and the reminder insists that no one should deceive them about it.ST Oct 25, 1883ST Apr 8, 1889 What Paul had already told them when he was yet with them was that that day shall not come except there come a falling away first and the man of sin, the son of perdition, be revealed.ST Oct 25, 1883ST Apr 8, 1889ST Jan 11, 1883 The man is the one who opposes and exalts himself above all that is called God or worshiped, sitting in the temple of God showing himself that he is God, and Christ will come afterward and destroy the wicked by the brightness of his personal presence.ST Apr 8, 1889 The teaching points back to Daniel's prophecy, which places the little horn's rise and its period of power before the Judgment.RH Apr 26, 1870 Its development was restrained until its appointed time, so the warning against expecting the day too soon applies until the end of the papal period, after which the time of the end begins.ST Aug 12, 1880
Paul himself had no idea that Christ would come in his own day and taught no doctrine that He would, having a correct inspired understanding of the time.ST Oct 25, 1883ST Nov 1, 1883ST Dec 12, 1892 His vivid present-tense language and his phrase about those alive and remaining do not mean imminence, for his description of future events as though present does not mean he expected to live until the advent.ST Apr 8, 1889ST Nov 1, 1883 Prophetic language can speak from the viewpoint of a future generation, and if an immediate return had been promised the resurrection and translation would already have occurred.ST Nov 1, 1883 The man of sin was still future in Paul's day, writing about eighteen years before Jerusalem was overthrown, though the forces that would produce it were already at work and hindering causes had yet to be removed; therefore the Lord's coming was not impending then.ST Sep 23, 1889 That man is the Roman pontiff, who legalizes and enforces sin, exalts himself above God by claiming authority over God's law, and claims divine status, and he must first be revealed and complete his blasphemous work.ST Sep 23, 1889RH Jul 20, 1876 The coming of Christ and the gathering of believers to Him therefore do not occur at each saint's death.RH Jul 20, 1876
It was not always proper for people to expect Christ to return in their generation: although patriarchs and prophets taught that Christ would come, they did not teach that He would establish His everlasting kingdom in their generation.ST Apr 15, 1903 A generation will see Christ come in glory, and the church living then is justified in looking for Him and is commissioned to warn the world, for the apostles' words were intended for all time, especially the last days.ST Apr 15, 1903ST Dec 12, 1892 The reminder proves Christians were not taught to watch as if the coming might occur at any time since the apostles, but to watch knowing these appointed events must come first.ST Apr 8, 1889 The promise in 1 Thessalonians 5:1-5 that brethren are not in darkness to be overtaken as by a thief was not for those living in Paul's time but for those who will live when the coming is near.ST Aug 19, 1889 The church was not to look for Christ's return until the Roman Antichrist should have passed through its predicted period of exaltation.ST Apr 22, 1880 When that period had run its course and the tribulation of those days should expire, the signs of His second advent would begin to be seen, and then the saints are to look and wait for their returning Lord.ST Apr 22, 1880 The message of the coming is spiritual food in due season when the Lord has shown that His coming is near, but it can mislead if given too early and be valueless if delayed.ST Apr 28, 1898
Apostasy and Man Foretold
2 Thessalonians 2:5 belongs to a brief prophecy covering the whole period from the writing of the letter to the coming of Christ.STST Feb 7, 1906ST Dec 24, 1912ST Sep 10, 1894 It pictures in one flash of light the entire history of the departure, from the mystery of iniquity already working in apostolic days to the fully revealed man of sin exalting himself and sitting as God in the temple of God, whom the Lord shall consume with the spirit of His mouth and destroy with the brightness of His coming.STRH Jun 6, 1912ST Oct 11, 1883ST Feb 7, 1906 That mystery was already at work in the early church and would increase and grow strong until Satan's power, signs, wonders, deceptions and lying wonders appeared widespread just before the Lord comes.STST Oct 11, 1883ST Feb 7, 1906 The prophecy gives little detail but outlines the great apostasy and its culmination in the man of sin who exalts himself above everything called God or worshiped, and its history with other prophecies points to the closing years of the present age and the nearness of the second coming.ST Oct 11, 1883ST Dec 24, 1912ST Sep 10, 1894
The falling away first is a departure within the church through which the man of sin develops and is revealed at the predicted time.ST Dec 22, 1881ST Aug 14, 1893ST Nov 5, 1912ST Apr 15, 1875 It began as pagan ideas and heathen traditions entered, ambitious bishops turned disciples after themselves and overthrew its simple brotherly order, and false doctrines about God, the soul, and duty arose.ST Aug 14, 1893RH Jul 28, 1868ST May 8, 1884 It was already at work yet restrained in the apostles' days, grew gradually over centuries, and would become a general and widespread fatal defection culminating in the establishment of the Papal church and the Papacy centered in the bishopric of Rome.ST Dec 22, 1881ST Aug 14, 1893RH Jul 28, 1868ST Apr 15, 1875 Paul had already taught these events in person, warning that an apostasy from Christ would come with the man of sin revealed, and that a church power developing early would rise and claim authority over God's law.ST Dec 22, 1881ST Aug 14, 1893ST Nov 5, 1912ST Apr 15, 1875
That man of sin, son of perdition, opposes and exalts himself above all that is called God or worshiped, sits as God in the temple of God showing himself that he is God, with the temple meaning the church of Christ.ST May 28, 1894ST Sep 30, 1880ST Oct 25, 1899ST Dec 24, 1902 He thinks to change times and laws, casts down truth, practices and prospers, makes war on the saints, claims Christ's place and authority to rule, direct, judge and punish God's servants, and comes after the working of Satan with all power and signs and lying wonders and with all deceivableness of unrighteousness in them that perish.ST May 28, 1894ST Oct 25, 1899ST Jun 13, 1900 The simple beauty of early Christianity would be corrupted, lies calling themselves Christian doctrine would take the place of truth, and the spirit of self-exaltation would take the place of Christian humility until one in the church opposes his will to God's will and demands obedience to himself instead.ST Oct 25, 1899ST Dec 24, 1902 Anyone in the church who assumes the place and prerogatives of God is a manifestation of that mystery and is a man of sin, illustrated in the Papacy exalted as head of all churches and corrector of heretics, with men bowing to the pope as Lord God, the voice of man received as the voice of God, and Inquisition and persecution bringing wretchedness, suffering and death, and the same results follow wherever man takes God's place and dictates conscience.ST May 28, 1894ST Sep 30, 1880ST Dec 24, 1902 The mystery of iniquity was already working but restrained for a time, then that Wicked would be revealed to be consumed with the spirit of the Lord's mouth and destroyed with the brightness of His coming, for human efforts to remove it or root up the tares before the final harvest would prove abortive and the usurper, like Judas the son of perdition assuming the rights and privileges of divinity, was only to be dethroned by the Lord at His coming.ST May 28, 1894ST Oct 25, 1899ST Jun 13, 1900
Restraint and Historical Development
What held back the full revealing was the continuance of pagan Rome, the heathen government and empire with its emperors, Imperial Pagan Rome as the sixth head.RH Feb 9, 1860RH Feb 9, 1860RH Feb 15, 1870 While that power persecuted Christians it still held back lawlessness, and Christians prayed for the emperors and for the continued state and perpetuity of the empire in order to defer the dreadful end and the most horrible evils hanging over the world at the conclusion of the age.RH Feb 9, 1860RH Feb 9, 1860 Its removal, the taking of the Roman state out of the way and its breaking into ten kingdoms, would bring on antichrist, and Paganism delaying the manifestation of the Papacy shows the two desolating powers following one another.RH Feb 9, 1860RH Feb 15, 1870RH May 19, 1874 The mystery of iniquity was already at work in Paul's day, but pagan rule and the pagan government still restrained its development, so centuries of apostasy and rebellion against God would pass before the papal power rose among the ten kingdoms and openly warred against God, His law and His saints.RH May 19, 1874ST Oct 13, 1881RH Jun 24, 1875
The restrainer is also what God placed in the world to oppose evil, His Holy Spirit, and Christ dwelling by faith in the church holding back self-exaltation in the church.ST Mar 12, 1896ST Dec 24, 1902ST Jun 23, 1898 While Christ dwells there by faith the lawless power is not revealed, but when Christ is rejected within and the gospel and Christ's righteousness are rejected for human law and coercion, the mystery enthroned is revealed.ST Mar 12, 1896ST Oct 8, 1894 Neither mystery can be perfectly manifested until the other is taken out of the way, so the mystery of iniquity cannot be fully developed until the Spirit of God is withdrawn.ST Dec 24, 1902 That withdrawal comes at the close of human probation, when those not saved are abandoned by the Spirit by their own choice, leaving two classes: one from whom Satan's spirit is entirely shut out, revealing the mystery of godliness and ready to receive Christ at His personal appearance in the clouds of heaven, and one from whom God's Spirit is entirely shut out, revealing the mystery of iniquity and ready to receive Satan at his personal appearance among men.ST Dec 24, 1902 For this reason Christ in the hearts of His people held the working back so that the church remained comparatively pure to the end of the first century, and when every apostolic voice was hushed at the beginning of the second century the work of apostasy began in earnest.ST Jun 23, 1898
The predicted development therefore runs from apostolic beginnings under pagan restraint to division of the fourth empire into ten kingdoms, then to Justinian making the bishop of Rome head over the whole church by the opening of the sixth century, then to 1,260 prophetic years of papal supremacy and persecution when millions died for their faith.RH Jan 23, 1855ST Jun 22, 1882RH Jul 16, 1908RH Nov 20, 1900 Paul's argument drew on Daniel's prophecy that the man of sin and little horn would arise after that division and exercise power for 1,260 years, so the judgment could not be preached as immediately impending until those events had occurred and were complete.RH Jan 23, 1855ST Jun 22, 1882 The man of sin had not yet succeeded the one who restrained him in the apostles' time, and his later rise came in the same period as the rise of Daniel's little horn and the transgression of desolation, reaching full development in the papacy after the division.ST Jun 20, 1900RH Jul 16, 1908 That papal supremacy was taken away in 1798 with loss of civil dominion as a deadly wound, marking that the day of the Lord hastens greatly, yet with a later revival and brief restored supremacy before Christ comes to consume and destroy.RH Jul 22, 1858
Papal Power Identified
The man of sin, the son of perdition, the lawless one, the Wicked, Antichrist and Beast is the Papacy, the Roman pontiff, the pope and the papal succession arising from apostasy within the church.ST Sep 30, 1880ST Nov 27, 1879ST Sep 23, 1889ST Sep 30, 1880 He fulfills the prophecy by exalting himself above all that is called God or that is worshiped, sitting as God in the temple which is the church, showing himself to be God, overriding God's law, legalizing and enforcing sin, claiming authority over God's law and divine status, and receiving worship as Lord God.ST Sep 30, 1880ST Nov 27, 1879ST Sep 23, 1889ST Apr 1, 1886 This includes claiming authority to change God's law and to set aside the seventh-day Sabbath, and claiming infallibility as in 1870.ST Sep 30, 1880 His account draws on the little-horn prophecy in Daniel 7 and is repeated in substance in Revelation 13, which together mark his rise, seat, office, work, time, place and dominion over God's people so plainly that careful study cannot mistake him.ST Sep 30, 1880ST Sep 30, 1880 Paul had already told these things in person to the Thessalonians, warning them not to expect the coming and the gathering before the falling away and the revealing of this power, for although the forces behind him were already at work, hindering causes had yet to be removed.ST Sep 30, 1880ST Nov 27, 1879ST Sep 23, 1889ST Apr 1, 1886 He remains until Christ's personal coming and is then consumed with the spirit of His mouth and destroyed with the brightness of His coming, proving the apostasy is not converted away before the Second Advent.ST Apr 1, 1886ST Oct 25, 1905
This power began early as antichrist, as the mystery of iniquity or lawlessness already working and beginning to develop in apostolic days into the beginning of the Papacy which would exalt itself above God.RH Jun 6, 1912ST Sep 17, 1894RH Sep 30, 1909 Paul's words picture the whole history of the departure in one flash of light, spanning the dispensation from Christ's first advent to His second, from the mystery already working to the fully revealed man of sin sitting as God in the temple.RH Jun 6, 1912ST Sep 17, 1894ST Apr 22, 1875 It grew as Christianity became popular under Constantine, joined with the State to enforce obedience by civil power and Inquisition bringing martyrdom and religious tyranny, and operated through Satan's influence with a worldly clergy and power replacing Christ's kingdom.ST Apr 22, 1875RH Sep 30, 1909ST Sep 2, 1889 It made an earthly city the center of worship with a throne called a Holy See, setting up an earthly priesthood and earthly altars as the only way to heaven, thereby obscuring and trampling underfoot the truths of Christ's sanctuary ministry above.RH Jun 6, 1912ST Sep 2, 1889 It placed human tradition above God's word, stood in the temple assuming to give laws for the church, claimed divine authority and worship, and became a power antagonistic to God's work.RH Sep 30, 1909ST Oct 25, 1905ST Sep 2, 1889
Satan was behind its development and aided it toward completion.ST Sep 17, 1894ST Sep 2, 1889 The same man-of-sin result follows also wherever systems seek to place civil government and religious practice under clerical rule.RH Sep 30, 1909 The Papacy will be prominent in the world and to a certain extent dominant until Christ comes, practicing and prospering until its destruction in the burning glory of His second coming.RH Jun 6, 1912ST Apr 1, 1886ST Oct 25, 1905
Links to Daniel and Revelation
Paul had already told the Thessalonians in person that Christ's coming and the judgment were not at hand because the falling away and the revealing and work of the man of sin had to come first, and that oral teaching reasoned out of the Scriptures, specifically Daniel 7 and Daniel 8 concerning Rome from its beginning to the end of the world in both its ancient pagan phase as the beast and its modern papal phase as the little horn.RH Apr 26, 1870RH Apr 10, 1900RH Jan 23, 1855 His account of this power draws directly on the little-horn prophecy in Daniel 7, identifying the man of sin with the horn having eyes and mouth, the transgression of desolation, and the leading subject of Daniel 7 and 8.ST Sep 30, 1880ST Dec 3, 1902RH Apr 10, 1900 He taught that this power would arise after the fourth empire was divided into ten kingdoms and would then exercise dominion over God's people for 1,260 prophetic years before the judgment and the everlasting kingdom, so the judgment could not be preached as immediately impending until those events had occurred.RH Apr 26, 1870RH Jan 23, 1855ST Jun 22, 1882 What he thus told them gives additional light on Daniel 7 and 8, whose fulfillment began even in the lifetime of those proclaiming the pure gospel, with the self-exaltation in the sanctuary service already begun in Paul's time as the mystery of iniquity.ST Dec 3, 1902RH Apr 10, 1900
The same power described by Paul is repeated in substance in Revelation 13 as the Beast, whose rise, seat, office, work, dominion, time and place are so clearly marked in Scripture that careful study cannot mistake it.ST Sep 30, 1880RH Apr 10, 1900 It is likewise the power exposed in Revelation 14 in the third angel's message, and in the prophecies of Babylon, the two mysteries, and the sanctuary.ST Dec 3, 1902RH Oct 29, 1903ST Sep 2, 1889 Paul's inspired prophetic description therefore stands alongside Daniel 8 and Revelation 13 as one witness to the Papacy, a religious power claiming divine authority and worship, operating through Satan's influence, and replacing Christ's kingdom with a worldly clergy and power.RH May 15, 1913ST Sep 2, 1889 Its meaning depends on knowing God's salvation as taught through the sanctuary and its services, for it reveals a power that exalts itself in God's temple and perverts Christ's gospel by taking away the continual, putting man in the place of God, substituting the mystery of iniquity for the mystery of godliness with a human gospel that cannot save.ST Dec 3, 1902RH Oct 29, 1903 That perversion of the gospel gives the key to Daniel 7 and 8.ST Dec 3, 1902RH Oct 29, 1903
Sabbath and Law Attacked
The reminder that these things had already been told in person concerns the falling away and the revealing of the man of sin, identified as the papacy, whose lawlessness is claiming authority to change God's law and set aside the seventh-day Sabbath.ST Sep 17, 1874ST Oct 8, 1894ST Feb 21, 1911 The apostasy began in the apostolic age as the mystery of iniquity and developed into a power arising within the church that arrogantly thought it could change God's times and laws, including the fourth commandment, though it could claim to change them but could not actually change God's law.ST Oct 8, 1894ST Sep 21, 1882ST Dec 4, 1893 This self-exaltation above God and claim of divine authority is done not by professed opposition to God but by taking hold of the law of God and changing it and demanding obedience to the change as if God were its author.ST Dec 4, 1893ST Feb 21, 1911ST May 31, 1877 The change is putting the first day of the week in place of the seventh without Scripture sanction, set forth as evidence of a right to legislate in divine things and claimed on church authority, not made by Christ, and this power will be brought to an end at His coming.ST Sep 17, 1874ST May 31, 1877
Abolishing the Sabbath, the fourth statute that clothes the divine law with majesty and authority, abolishes from the Bible the God of the Bible and turns it into mere machinery of priestcraft.RH Jan 8, 1861RH Oct 7, 1851 This self-exaltation, sitting as God in the temple of God and saying in the heart I AM and NONE ELSE BESIDES ME, is the last crowning invention of man matching the first invention to become as gods by the forbidden fruit, and is the identical course of the man of sin and the first beast.RH Oct 7, 1851ST May 31, 1877 The Saviour did not destroy or make void the Father's law, did not come to do His own will but the Father's will, and gave no law superseding the fourth commandment or instituting another Sabbath, so the setting aside of the Sabbath is the work of the man of sin and not of Christ, leaving the choice between the gospel of Jerusalem and the gospel of Rome, while the true Lord's day remains the seventh day.RH Jan 8, 1861ST May 31, 1877 Sunday observance entered gradually and was not at first treated as obligatory, becoming established years later through the combined influence of church and state and later enforced by Sunday laws, with the papal power holding for long ages a near monopoly on Christian teaching that spread error and darkness, some of whose teachings and practices remained among Protestant churches and spread the thought that God's law is abolished.RH Jan 19, 1911RH Jul 21, 1874ST Apr 25, 1900
The mystery of iniquity is the spirit of self-exaltation shown in adopting and enforcing Sunday as a rival to God's Sabbath, where without divine authority men exalt a human institution above God and set themselves above Him.RH Jan 19, 1911ST May 31, 1877 Deliberately keeping that institution of the beast instead of the commandments of God, with light before the mind and the issue pressed between God and this wicked power, is worshiping the beast and receiving his mark.ST May 31, 1877
Destroyed at Christ Coming
The man of sin remains until Christ's personal coming and is then consumed with the spirit of His mouth and destroyed with the brightness of His coming.ST May 28, 1894RH Jun 6, 1912ST Apr 1, 1886 The spirit of His mouth is truth, and the brightness of His coming is His personal presence, by which the wicked are destroyed afterward, not before the great apostasy has first taken place.ST May 28, 1894RH Jun 6, 1912 The power so destroyed is the Papacy, the papal succession worshiped as God, which exalts itself and sits as God in the temple which is the church, claims authority to change God's law and set aside the seventh-day Sabbath, makes an earthly city the center of worship with a throne called a Holy See, and sets up an earthly priesthood and earthly altars as the only way to heaven, thereby obscuring and trampling the truths of Christ's sanctuary ministry above, through which Satan has manifested his character and the principles of his government.ST May 28, 1894RH Jun 6, 1912 Paul's words picture that whole history of departure in one flash of light, from the mystery of iniquity already working in apostolic days to the fully exalted man of sin, and the developed history answers to that flash.ST May 28, 1894RH Jun 6, 1912 Because this worshiped god-man cannot live on earth during the millennium when God's will is done on earth as in heaven, he must be destroyed before the millennium begins, leaving no room for his continuance through it and proving Christ comes before the millennium to end evil rather than after a converted world, for the apostasy is not converted away before the Second Advent.ST Jul 22, 1880ST Apr 1, 1886
Because the apostasy must run its course, the kingdom is not given into the hands of the saints until the work of this power, identical with the little horn of Daniel 7, is completed.RH Jan 23, 1855ST Jun 22, 1882RH Jun 9, 1859 That completion is the stone smiting the image on the feet in Daniel 2, when the nations are dashed in pieces at the coming of Christ, with the judgment and the second advent, so the kingdom cannot be established on earth prior to Christ's second advent.RH Jan 23, 1855ST Jun 22, 1882RH Jun 9, 1859 His argument drawn from Daniel is that the man of sin, the Roman Antichrist, would arise after the fourth empire was divided into ten kingdoms, then exercise power for 1,260 prophetic years in a foretold period of exaltation, prosperity, cruelty and audacity over the nations, and the judgment could not be preached as immediately impending until those events had occurred.RH Jan 23, 1855ST Jun 22, 1882RH Aug 18, 1874ST Apr 22, 1880 The church was therefore commanded not to look for Christ's return until that period had run its course, and only when its tribulation should expire would the signs of His second advent begin and believers watch and wait for their returning Lord.ST Apr 22, 1880 That man of sin has now arisen and finished his 1,260 years and lost his civil dominion, so with the end right upon us Paul's caution against looking for Christ is removed and the next event is the coming, for which reason the warning against worshiping the beast must be given before Christ comes.RH Aug 18, 1874
The consuming began through gospel preaching at the Reformation and through the nations taking away dominion, distinguishing the papacy's secular power which the nations consume from the papacy itself which is consumed by the brightness of the Lord's coming.ST May 28, 1885RH Feb 11, 1873 Its decline will not end in a natural death but only in decline until its final utter destruction at Christ's advent, for the wicked one, the persecuting little horn, will abide upon the earth till Christ comes again.ST Nov 21, 1895ST Mar 27, 1884RH Feb 11, 1873 The close of this dispensation is therefore a time of special activity and increase of evil, not gradual regeneration of the world into a millennium, with the mystery of iniquity growing until its climax in the man of sin who is destroyed by Christ at His coming.RH Jun 7, 1915 This proves good and evil grow side by side to the end with growing degeneracy, the world not converted before Christ comes but wheat and tares, righteous and wicked, growing together till the harvest at the end of the world when they are separated, the coming being the revelation of Christ in administering the divine government as the now resurrected and exalted Son of God over the living and the dead in both the visible and invisible world.RH Jun 7, 1915ST Nov 21, 1895 Thus the wicked may triumph in the present world while the saints await their reign in the world to come, where the wicked cannot triumph.ST Mar 27, 1884
Warning and Watchfulness Applied
The reminder looks back to instruction already given in person about what must happen before the coming of the Lord and the gathering to Him, namely a falling away first and the revealing of the man of sin whose appearing is held back until the restraining power is removed.RH Nov 10, 1868ST Feb 6, 1896ST Jun 16, 1887 It means they had been told beforehand that the day of Christ was not at hand, that it will not come except the falling away come and the man of sin the son of perdition be revealed, who opposes and exalts himself above all called God or worshiped and sits in the temple of God showing himself to be God.RH Nov 10, 1868ST Feb 6, 1896 It is therefore a strong appeal and safeguard against error about the timing of the coming, not to be shaken in mind or troubled by spirit, word, or forged letter as from Paul claiming the day was at hand, and to let no man deceive them, so that ignorance through carelessness leaves no excuse.RH Feb 28, 1854ST Feb 6, 1896 The chapter to which it belongs is cited in connection with Satan's coming deception and the strong delusions that overtake those who reject truth, showing that those who do not love the truth but take pleasure in unrighteousness are left to strong delusion, and that turning from God's law weakens discernment in sacred things.RH Feb 28, 1854ST May 13, 1875 Believers must remember prior instruction, love truth, keep lamps burning, and study the specific marks of the falling away as part of the third angel's message.ST Feb 6, 1896ST May 13, 1875
The foretold deception before Christ comes is Satan working with power and signs and lying wonders and with unrighteousness to deceive, and the reminder points back to earlier teaching so they would not be deceived.RH Feb 28, 1854ST Mar 6, 1884ST Nov 1, 1883 Its most prominent marks are wonderful spiritual manifestations about which there is doubt whether they are of the devil, now going under the name of Spiritual reform as the embryo of the consummation of Satan's deceptive work, a manifest disposition to reject the truth, and being deluded and delighted with fables of unrighteousness.RH Jul 22, 1858RH Feb 28, 1854 Spiritualism will prevail remarkably just before the Lord comes, and its present phase is essentially new, belonging to Paul's warning about deceptions that arise just before the second advent.RH Jul 22, 1858ST Mar 6, 1884ST Jun 24, 1875 That warning also covers occult healers ignoring Jesus and religious coercion by church, group, government, or Church-and-State union enforcing conscience, while true Bible Christians will not be led away though many run after such powers.RH Feb 28, 1854ST Mar 6, 1884ST Nov 1, 1883
Anyone in the church who assumes the place and prerogatives of God is a manifestation of the mystery of iniquity already working in Paul's day and is a man of sin, illustrated in the Papacy exalted as head of all churches and corrector of heretics, with men bowing to the pope as Lord God, the voice of man received as the voice of God, and Inquisition and persecution bringing wretchedness, suffering and death.ST Dec 24, 1902RH Jul 22, 1858 The same results follow wherever man takes God's place and dictates conscience.ST Dec 24, 1902 Full manifestation was hindered, for what God placed in the world to oppose evil is His Holy Spirit, and neither mystery can be perfectly manifested until the other is taken out of the way, so the mystery of iniquity cannot be fully developed until the Spirit of God is withdrawn.ST Dec 24, 1902 When human probation closes those not saved are abandoned by the Spirit, leaving two classes, one from whom Satan's spirit is entirely shut out, revealing the mystery of godliness and ready to receive Christ at His personal appearance in the clouds of heaven, and one from whom God's Spirit is entirely shut out by their own choice, revealing the mystery of iniquity and ready to receive Satan at his personal appearance among men.ST Dec 24, 1902 Since the papal supremacy was taken away in 1798 the day of the Lord hastens greatly, warning against falling into the snare of the devil.RH Jul 22, 1858
The prophecy shows not the triumph of the world's conversion but the sad apostasy, the falling away, and the manifestation of the papacy, the man of sin, who continues until Christ destroys him at His coming, leaving no room for a temporal millennium of peace and triumph of the church before the second advent.ST Apr 1, 1886ST Jun 4, 1874ST Jan 29, 1880 These events, rather than conversion and triumph, characterize the period before the advent, for the close of this dispensation is a time of special activity and increase of evil, not gradual regeneration of the world into a millennium.ST Jun 4, 1874RH Jun 7, 1915 The mystery of iniquity grows until it reaches its climax in the man of sin, proving good and evil grow side by side to the end with growing degeneracy and a climax of evil, including departure in the professed church, and that Christ comes before the millennium to end it.RH Jun 7, 1915ST Nov 29, 1899 The apostasy is therefore not converted away before the Second Advent, wickedness persists to the close of the world, and they describe no period of earthly prosperity for the church before that event.ST Apr 1, 1886RH Dec 27, 1853ST Nov 29, 1899 Therefore the church must expect tribulation not earthly prosperity, discard relics of popery, stand on God's word against world-wide despotism, and proclaim Christ's literal coming in flaming fire with angels.RH Jun 7, 1915RH Dec 27, 1853ST Jan 29, 1880
Sources