Acts 5:8
And Peter answered unto her, Tell me whether ye sold the land for so much? And she said, Yea, for so much.
Translations
And Peter answered to her, Tell me whether you sold the land for so much? And she said, Yes, for so much.
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
And Peter answered unto her, Tell me whether ye sold the land for so much? And she said, Yea, for so much.
And Peter answered to her, Tell me whether ye sold the land for so much? And she said, Yes, for so much.
Revised Version, American Standard Version
And Peter answered unto her, Tell me whether ye sold the land for so much. And she said, Yea, for so much.
and Peter answered her, 'Tell me if for so much ye sold the place;' and she said, 'Yes, for so much.'
And Peter answered her, Tell me if ye gave the estate for so much? And she said, Yes, for so much.
And Peter began to say unto her—Tell me! was it, for so much, ye gave up the field? And she said—Yea! for so much.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
“ Tell me,” said Peter, “ is this the price you and your husband got for the land?”“ Yes,” she answered, “ that is the price.”
Peter answered her, “ Tell me whether you sold the land for so much.”She said, “ Yes, for so much.”
And Peter said to her, Give me an answer: was this amount of money the price of the land? And she said, Yes, it was.
And Peter sayd vnto her, Tell me, solde ye the land for so much? And she sayd, Yea, for so much.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And Peter said to her: Tell me, woman, whether you sold the land for so much? And she said: Yea, for so much.
Pictures



Cross-references
- Acts 5:3-4
But Peter said, Ananias, why hath Satan filled thine heart to lie to the Holy Ghost, and to keep back part of the price of the land?
Peter exposes their concealed proceeds as a lie to the Holy Spirit and to God.
- Acts 5:1-2
But a certain man named Ananias, with Sapphira his wife, sold a possession,
Ananias and Sapphira conceal part of the sale proceeds while presenting their gift as complete.
- Acts 4:34-35
Neither was there any among them that lacked: for as many as were possessors of lands or houses sold them, and brought the prices of the things that were sold,
Believers sold property and gave the proceeds to meet the community’s needs.
- Acts 4:36-37
And Joses, who by the apostles was surnamed Barnabas, ( which is, being interpreted, The son of consolation,) a Levite, and of the country of Cyprus,
Barnabas’s generous gift contrasts with Ananias and Sapphira’s deceit.
- Acts 5:3
But Peter said, Ananias, why hath Satan filled thine heart to lie to the Holy Ghost, and to keep back part of the price of the land?
Peter identifies their deception as a lie to the Holy Spirit.
- Acts 2:44-45
And all that believed were together, and had all things common;
Believers shared their possessions, while Peter asks whether Ananias and Sapphira sold their land for the stated amount.
- Joshua 7:11
Israel hath sinned, and they have also transgressed my covenant which I commanded them: for they have even taken of the accursed thing, and have also stolen, and dissembled also, and they have put it even among their own stuff.
Both accounts describe theft concealed through deceit and exposed by God.
- Acts 4:32
And the multitude of them that believed were of one heart and of one soul: neither said any of them that ought of the things which he possessed was his own; but they had all things common.
Believers shared possessions and were of one heart.
- 1 Corinthians 10:11
Now all these things happened unto them for ensamples: and they are written for our admonition, upon whom the ends of the world are come.
The account of Ananias and Sapphira admonishes later believers.
- Ephesians 4:25
Wherefore putting away lying, speak every man truth with his neighbour: for we are members one of another.
The lesson pairs the account with the command to put away lying and speak truth.
- Leviticus 19:11
Ye shall not steal, neither deal falsely, neither lie one to another.
The command against lying is the moral rule their deception broke.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
52 sources
Peter asked Sapphira whether the land had been sold for the stated sum, giving her opportunity to tell the truth, and about three hours after her husband's death, without knowing what had happened, she affirmed that it had.3SP 284.2–285.2Ms 151, 1906, par. 25–28SG4 210.4RH Feb 2, 1911RH Feb 2, 1911
Keeping part of the proceeds was not itself wrong, for the property remained theirs to keep or give in part, but pretending to bring the whole as a free offering while concealing part was deliberate joint deception with her husband.3SP 284.2–285.2AC1 21.1–22.2AC1 22.3–23.1AA 74.2–75.2
Her false answer was not merely lying to people but dissembling to God and tempting the Holy Spirit, who searches the heart and cannot be deceived or mocked.Ms 151, 1906, par. 25–28RH Feb 2, 1911ST Jan 29, 18801T 202.1–2SG4 201.2
Conviction was followed by swift retribution when she fell dead and was buried beside her husband, bringing great fear on the church and guarding the young, rapidly increasing church from demoralization by hypocrisy.Ms 151, 1906, par. 25–28RH Feb 2, 1911ST Jan 29, 1880AC1 22.3–23.11T 221.2
The questioning and punishment stand as a perpetual danger-signal to professed followers in every age against covetousness, breaking vows, and withholding tithe while pretending to give the whole, for the same God still hates falsehood though visible punishment is not always shown now.Lt 13, 1893, par. 24–26SG4 210.4RH Feb 2, 1911ST Jan 29, 1880ST Jan 29, 1880
Peter Questions Sapphira
Peter put to her the direct question whether the property had been sold for the particular sum named, and in doing so gave her full opportunity to state honestly what the price had been and to tell the truth.Ms 151, 1906, par. 25–28RH Feb 2, 1911RH Feb 2, 1911Lt 232, 1899, par. 26–2813MR 189.2–190.1 The questioning was not mere inquiry but a test, made under the Lord's direction, to convict her of falsehood if she persisted in it.ST Jan 29, 1880ST Jan 29, 1880Ms 142, 1903, par. 105–107 By that exposure the first departure from truthful dealing in the church was brought into the open, and believers were warned that God knows and will search out hidden fraud and dishonesty.ST Jan 29, 1880Ms 91, 1899, par. 34–36Ms 142, 1903, par. 105–107
She came in about three hours after Ananias had died, not knowing what had been done.RH Feb 2, 1911 When asked, she answered affirmatively that the land had indeed been sold for the amount Peter named.3SP 284.2–285.2SG4 210.4RH Feb 2, 1911Ms 91, 1899, par. 37–38 That short affirmative answer is presented as joining her husband in falsely presenting part of the proceeds as the whole, dissembling in a matter of professed consecration and free-will offering, and illustrating the course of those who put down their property below its value.3SP 284.2–285.2SG4 210.4Lt 83, 1896, par. 19–22
Joint Deception and Motives
Sapphira's short answer was a deliberate lie by which she joined her husband in hiding part of the price of the land while presenting what was brought as the whole amount given as a free-will offering.3SP 284.2–285.2AC1 21.1–22.27RED 22.2AA 71.2–73.3AC1 22.3–23.1 She knowingly confirmed the false figure Peter named, and by that affirmation she shared fully in the agreed deception and in tempting the Spirit of the Lord.AC1 21.1–22.27RED 22.2AA 71.2–73.3AC1 22.3–23.17RED 22.3–23.1 Her word exposed their common hypocrisy, a lie to the Holy Spirit presented as entire consecration to the church.3SP 284.2–285.2AC1 21.1–22.27RED 22.3–23.1
To keep part of the money was not in itself the wrong, for the property and its proceeds remained their own to retain or to give only in part.AC1 22.3–23.1AA 74.2–75.2Lt 232, 1899, par. 26–28Ms 169a, 1899, par. 7–10 God would have accepted a portion honestly given, and the fraud lay in the deliberate false claim that the offering was the full sale price.AC1 22.3–23.1AA 74.2–75.2Lt 232, 1899, par. 26–28Ms 169a, 1899, par. 7–10 Their sin was pretending to give all while withholding part in order to appear to have surrendered everything.AC1 22.3–23.1AA 74.2–75.2Lt 232, 1899, par. 26–28Ms 169a, 1899, par. 7–10
They had pledged the land and its proceeds to God and to His work under the direct influence of the Spirit, and then they drew back from that pledge.4T 462.2–463.3ST Jan 29, 18805T 148.34T 469.2–470.2 What was withheld had already been devoted by promise, so the withholding was breaking a vow, and that broken pledge with its dishonesty was a grave offense requiring faithfulness.4T 462.2–463.3ST Jan 29, 18805T 148.34T 469.2–470.2 They promised part of their property for Christ's cause and then tried to make others believe they had given everything while keeping back what was pledged.4T 462.2–463.3ST Jan 29, 18805T 148.3
The deception grew out of covetousness, selfishness, avarice, and love of money, professing to serve and to be consecrated to God while in heart worshiping mammon.RH Feb 2, 1911ST Jan 29, 18807RED 22.3–23.13SP 285.3–286.1AA 73.4–74.1 Satan filled the heart, and those not wholly consecrated came to regret a pledge made under the Spirit and turned regret into fraud and hypocrisy.RH Feb 2, 1911ST Jan 29, 1880RH Feb 2, 1911 In that false answer she dissembled to God, putting the property below its value while claiming a free and full offering.SG4 210.4RH Feb 2, 19113SP 285.3–286.1
They wanted commendation and to be thought liberal, self-denying, devoted, generous, and sacrificial, gaining esteem and even support from the common fund without surrendering all.RH Feb 2, 1911Lt 15, 1905, par. 6Lt 232, 1899, par. 26–28Ms 169a, 1899, par. 7–10 Their lie sought a reputation for sacrifice and devotion while concealing the truth, sacrificing truth itself in order to gain favor.Lt 15, 1905, par. 6Lt 232, 1899, par. 26–28Ms 169a, 1899, par. 7–10 The Holy Spirit read the deception behind the answer, and the stern and sudden punishment that followed marked Christ's deep contempt for all such underhand dealing.RH Feb 2, 1911Lt 15, 1905, par. 6
Lying to God
Her brief affirmation was not a mere misstatement to men but dissembling before God, a lie to the Holy Spirit and to God Himself, and a deliberate agreement with her husband to tempt the Spirit of the Lord.Ms 151, 1906, par. 25–28RH Feb 2, 1911ST Jan 29, 1880RH Feb 2, 19114T 470.3–472.1 In keeping back part of the price while pretending to bring the whole, she joined Ananias in deception and in underhanded, deceptive dealing in the Lord's work.Ms 151, 1906, par. 25–28RH Feb 2, 1911ST Jan 29, 1880RH Feb 2, 1911 That dealing is the same as unstraightforward, oppressive and unjust business, taking advantage of circumstances, exacting exorbitant prices, conniving in fraud, hindering the triumph of truth, and diverting God's means into a wrong channel.Ms 151, 1906, par. 25–28
To lie to people about consecration and money is to lie to God, for He knows the exact truth of what was sold and what was given.1T 202.1–2SG4 201.2 Nothing is hidden from His search, for He searches the heart and detects hidden sin of the heart.RH Feb 2, 1911ST Jan 29, 1880AA 73.4–74.1RH Feb 2, 1911 The motives and purposes of men cannot be hidden from Him, He cannot be deceived, and He will not be mocked.RH Feb 2, 1911ST Jan 29, 1880RH Feb 2, 1911ST Jan 29, 18804T 469.1
The swift exposure and punishment show how deep is His hatred and contempt for fraud, hypocrisy, deception and falsehood.RH Feb 2, 1911RH Feb 2, 1911 Lying lips are an abomination to Him, and Christ regards all deception with deep contempt.RH Feb 2, 1911Lt 15, 1905, par. 6 Deliberate falsehood is grave sin, exceedingly offensive to God, and the guilt of such deception rests on each deceiver in proportion to the offense.RH Feb 2, 19114T 470.3–472.1Lt 20, 1882, par. 10–12Ms 67, 1894, par. 18–20 The same Spirit who read the deception behind her answer still condemns all underhand dealing today, warns those who know the truth and stand in high positions of trust to guard righteousness and judgment, and calls all selfish meanness to be put away from the character.Lt 15, 1905, par. 6Ms 67, 1894, par. 18–20
Judgment Guards Church
Conviction was followed by instant, swift retribution without delay, for her false affirmation brought death at Peter's feet and burial beside her husband.ST Jan 29, 18801T 221.2RH Feb 2, 1911 Deliberate falsehood is grave sin, and the deception cost them both the life that now is and the life to come.RH Feb 2, 1911Lt 20, 1882, par. 10–12Lt 20a, 1893, par. 50 God regards such dissembling as lying to the Holy Spirit and to God, and ministering angels take note of neglect by those handling sacred things who must maintain strict integrity.Ms 151, 1906, par. 25–28Lt 20a, 1893, par. 50
The deaths brought great fear upon the church and all who heard, exciting reverential awe in all new converts.Ms 151, 1906, par. 25–283SP 285.3–286.1RH Feb 2, 1911 That awe led to greater caution and more thorough self-examination testing the motives of actions.AC1 22.3–23.17RED 22.3–23.13SP 285.3–286.1 Such underhanded, deceptive dealing in the Lord's work will just as surely bring punishment and judgment on its actors.Ms 151, 1906, par. 25–28AC1 22.3–23.1
The signal manifestation of wrath and strict dealing was a check that Infinite Wisdom knew was needed to guard the rapidly increasing young church from demoralization and disgrace.ST Jan 29, 18803SP 285.3–286.1RH Feb 2, 1911 It was a special example necessary to keep the church from adding professed servants of God who worshiped mammon while professing to serve Him.3SP 285.3–286.1RH Feb 2, 1911 The Spirit of truth revealed the real character of these pretenders, and the judgments of God that followed forever rid the church of this foul blot and stain of hypocrisy upon its purity.3SP 285.3–286.14SP 44.1–45.1GC88 44.1 This signal evidence of the discerning Spirit of Christ was a terror to hypocrites and evil-doers, who could not long remain with constant representatives of Christ, so that as long as trials and persecution continued the church remained comparatively pure.3SP 285.3–286.14SP 44.1–45.1
Their presence shows that unworthy and false members joined the disciples even at the beginning, and false brethren will be found in the church till the close of time.ST Feb 9, 1915COL 72.3 Their presence gives the world no right to doubt Christianity and should not dishearten Christians, for believers must bear with false brethren in forbearance lest the precious wheat be rooted up with the tares, since Christ does not want to lose one soul and bears long with perverse human nature.ST Feb 9, 1915COL 72.3 The hidden sin searched out with swift retribution was like Achan's, and warns the church through all time that the same sins that brought God's wrath anciently can bring it still.ST May 5, 1881ST Sep 1, 1909 Their doom shows the fearful consequences of covetousness and proves that no one can defraud God and prosper because all are God's property, since the influence of one unrepentant sinner is defiling and corrupts many others.ST May 5, 1881ST Sep 1, 1909Ms 95, 1902, par. 17–19
The high priest with those with him, the council and all the senate of Israel, decided to turn those deaths into a criminal charge against the disciples.AA 80.2–81.2RH Feb 9, 1911 They falsely accused the apostles of murdering Ananias and Sapphira, with insurrection and conspiring to deprive the priests of authority and put them to death.AA 80.2–81.2RH Feb 9, 1911 They meant to use that charge to excite the mob to take the disciples and deal with them as it had dealt with Jesus.RH Feb 9, 1911 They did so because they feared that if the dissatisfied people accepted the apostles' truths and acknowledged Jesus as Messiah, the anger of the whole people would be raised against the religious authorities for the murder of Christ.RH Feb 9, 1911
Warning for Giving Today
Peter's question and the swift punishment that followed were set as a danger-signal and perpetual warning not only to the early church but to professed followers of Christ in every age against covetousness, hypocrisy, deception and robbing God.Lt 13, 1893, par. 24–26RH Feb 2, 1911ST Jan 29, 18805T 148.3ST Jan 29, 1880 The answer in which Sapphira confirmed the false sale price stands as testimony to the dishonest practice for which judgment came, showing such dishonesty to be serious sin violating God's sacred claims and dignity.Lt 13, 1893, par. 24–265T 148.3 The story warns through all time, as with Achan, that the same sins that brought wrath anciently can bring it on the church, and that human hearts remain continually inclined to this sin.ST Jan 29, 1880ST May 5, 1881
God requires faithfulness in performing vows, and withholding what is pledged to Him is selfishness, fraud, sacrilege and robbery of Him.4T 462.2–463.3ST Jan 29, 1880 Selfishness can harden the heart so that a person withholds what is owed to God while making a false show of faithfulness.5T 150.2 The deliberate confirming of a false amount after pledging under the Spirit's influence, then drawing back and letting Satan fill the heart, was met with instant death as retributive justice.4T 462.2–463.3ST Jan 29, 1880
A pledge to the cause, whether verbal or written before brethren, is a vow made to God, with brethren only as visible witnesses of a contract between the giver and God.ST Jan 29, 1880 No legal bond for payment of money is more binding, and a vow to God the giver of all favors is of still greater importance than a pledge to fellow men, which men do not generally think of asking to be released from.ST Jan 29, 1880 It is not less binding and not less valid because it will not be tried in courts of justice, and to appropriate to one's own use what was once pledged to advance His sacred work is sacrilege and robbery of God by one professing to be saved by the blood of Christ's infinite sacrifice.ST Jan 29, 1880 Vows and actions are weighed in the balance of justice in the heavenly courts.ST Jan 29, 1880
The verse warns specifically against withholding in the tithing system a portion of what God claims while pretending to give the whole, with the thought that the brethren will never know it.ST Jan 29, 18804T 469.1 It warns against bringing God a stinted offering while spending lavishly on self-gratification, against putting property down below its value, and against dishonest offering which God no more accepts than He accepted theirs.SG4 210.4RH Feb 2, 1911TBC1868 16.1–17.12T 127.2–128.1 Sapphira's false Yea, for so much dissembled to God while pretending to make a free-will offering with professed consecration, and retribution lingered not.SG4 210.4TBC1868 16.1–17.1
The same underhanded, deceptive dealing in the Lord's work includes unstraightforward, oppressive and unjust business, taking advantage of circumstances, exacting exorbitant prices, conniving in fraud, hindering the triumph of truth and diverting God's means into a wrong channel.Ms 151, 1906, par. 25–28 It includes thinking one is not paid enough for work and taking money or goods to supply that fancied lack, as Judas stole from the bag carrying gifts for the work on the ground his labors were not sufficiently appreciated.Ms 142, 1903, par. 105–107 It includes entering business selfishly and leading customers to think profits aid benevolent enterprises while in reality they are used for personal interests, and acting a lie to brethren about consecration and money.Ms 92, 1902, par. 57–61
God's people and institutions must not misrepresent truth to gain favor or a reputation for devotion and liberality.Lt 15, 1905, par. 6Ms 169a, 1899, par. 3–6 All selfish meanness and deceit must be put away from the character, for the Holy Spirit still condemns all underhand dealing today.RH Apr 13, 1905Lt 15, 1905, par. 6 Those who handle sacred things and carry responsibility as faithful stewards must exemplify the mind of Christ and maintain strict integrity in every transaction rather than marring the sacred cause with selfishness, while ministering angels note neglect; those who know the truth and stand in high positions of trust are responsible to guard righteousness and judgment, to give youth a right impression, and not to pass by, cover, or hold peace toward hidden sin and moral corruption.Lt 20a, 1893, par. 50Ms 67, 1894, par. 18–20
The same God of ancient Israel is the same in the gospel and still condemns all falsehood and dishonest dealing, though without always showing visible displeasure.RH Feb 2, 19111T 529.1–2Ms 67, 1894, par. 18–20 The sin is just as heinous now as then, will surely be visited on the transgressor in the day of judgment and final reckoning, with many feeling the curse of God even in this life, and all who follow the same course destroy their own souls.RH Feb 2, 1911Ms 92, 1902, par. 57–61ST Jan 29, 1880 If the same punishment fell now there would be many dead bodies in churches requiring burial, for God sees motives and purposes of the heart even when visible displeasure is not shown.3SP 285.3–286.11T 529.1–2 For such acts God will just as surely bring punishment and judgment as He struck Ananias and Sapphira dead and brought great fear on the church and all who heard.Ms 151, 1906, par. 25–28
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
105 sources
Peter put a direct question to Sapphira about the sale price to test her and give her a chance to tell the truth, and she answered by affirming the false amount her husband had named.ST May 20, 1889ST Feb 5, 1902ST Oct 13, 1881ST Jun 16, 1909 The land and its money had remained theirs to keep or to give, so the wrong was not in holding back part but in deceptively presenting the part brought forward as the whole price.ST May 20, 1889RH Jun 20, 1871 Her answer was a knowing and agreed lie, driven by covetousness and desire to appear wholly generous, and it was a lie not merely to men but to the Holy Spirit and to God.ST May 10, 1883RH Jul 22, 1909ST May 10, 1883RH Jun 20, 1871 For that lie she was struck dead at Peter's feet and buried beside her husband, showing God's hatred of fraud and that he will not be mocked.RH Feb 2, 1911ST Jan 29, 1880ST May 20, 1889STRH Apr 15, 1858 Great fear came upon the church and all who heard, and the record stands as a perpetual warning against covetousness, hypocrisy, and broken vows in giving.RH Feb 2, 1911ST Jan 29, 1880ST Apr 4, 1900ST Feb 5, 1902RH Apr 7, 1868
Question and False Answer
Peter put to Sapphira the direct question whether she and Ananias had sold the land for so much, naming the amount they had claimed, to test whether she would honestly confirm the sum and to give her opportunity to tell the truth.ST Feb 5, 1902ST Oct 13, 1881ST Jun 16, 1909ST Feb 5, 1902RH Mar 30, 1905 Her coming in was about three hours after Ananias died, when she did not know what had been done to him.RH Feb 2, 1911 She answered Yea, for so much, affirming that the land had been sold for the amount Peter named and agreeing to the false price her husband had claimed.ST May 20, 1889RH Jul 22, 1909ST May 10, 1883ST Sep 6, 1883 In that answer she knowingly joined the deception she and Ananias had planned together, making her spoken lie agree with the lie already acted out.ST May 20, 1889RH Jul 22, 1909ST May 10, 1883ST
The land and its proceeds had remained theirs to give or to keep, and the sin was not in keeping part of the sale price but in deceptively claiming that the part brought and laid down was the whole amount given.ST May 20, 1889RH Jun 20, 1871RH Jan 20, 1916 Covetousness led to that deception, and withholding truth about what was given must be answered for as lying to God.RH Jun 20, 1871RH Jan 20, 1916RH Jan 29, 1861 Her words conveyed the false idea that they had brought the whole price when they had sold the possession for that amount plus something more kept back.RH Jan 17, 1865RH Jan 17, 1865 Such speech is lying by half-truth and by false impression about buying and selling and giving, even when the words can be twisted to claim technical truthfulness that the property sold for that amount plus something else kept back, and evasion of that kind remains a lie deserving certain punishment no less than an outright falsehood.RH Jan 17, 1865RH Jan 17, 1865
Peter in this questioning acted as the Lord's representative under the Holy Spirit's direction, so that his words carried the force of God's command.ST Jan 22, 1902ST Feb 5, 1902 The sentence against Sapphira was placed in his mouth by the Spirit of the Lord, showing the apostles as God's spokesmen whose charge that the lie was not merely against men but against God belonged to a divine judgment.ST Jan 22, 1902ST Feb 5, 1902 Her false agreement therefore continued the deliberately planned falsehood and provided the occasion to charge her and Ananias with testing the Spirit of the Lord.ST Feb 5, 1902RH Mar 30, 1905ST Apr 11, 1900
Nature of the Deception
Her answer was knowing and deliberate, affirming as the full sale price the amount her husband had presented when it was not, and in that affirmation she joined the deception she and Ananias had agreed together to tell.ST May 10, 1883RH Dec 1, 1910ST Feb 5, 1902ST Jan 21, 1897 Peter's question exposed her participation, for spiritual discernment laid bare their concealment of the true price before the church undertook its great work.RH Dec 1, 1910RH Sep 28, 1916 Even silence with only part handed over would have left the hypocrisy, since the sin was not only the spoken amount but the planned deceit behind it.ST May 10, 1883
They sought to appear wholly devoted and generous without surrendering what generosity required, claiming the reputation for complete consecration without the experience of it.ST May 10, 1883RH Apr 7, 1868ST May 10, 1883RH Sep 30, 1902 It was an attempt to seem better than they were, to gain honor, credit, esteem, fellowship and support from the common fund, following the example of Barnabas who freely gave all while they kept back part.RH Feb 2, 1911RH Apr 7, 1868RH Sep 30, 1902RH Oct 20, 1874RH Oct 31, 1865 Her confirmation of the stated price concealed the portion withheld in order to secure that standing.RH Oct 20, 1874RH Oct 31, 1865
The lie was driven by covetousness, selfishness, regret of a pledge made under the direct influence of the Holy Spirit, and love of money ripened into fraud and hypocrisy.ST May 10, 1883RH Feb 2, 1911RH Feb 2, 1911RH May 17, 1870 Covetousness led to dissembling and withholding entrusted means from the advancement of the cause while professing to serve God.ST May 10, 1883RH Jun 20, 1871 Pretending to give the full amount vowed while keeping part for themselves made the false affirmation a lie to the Holy Spirit.RH Feb 2, 1911
That falsehood was not merely to men or to Peter but to the Holy Spirit and to God, tempting the Spirit of the Lord.RH Feb 2, 1911ST Jan 29, 1880RH Jul 22, 1909ST Feb 5, 1902ST May 10, 1883 Measured by an earthly standard lying between man and man is already offensive, but measured by the perfect law of heaven a lie against God is a far greater offense, which explains the swiftness and severity that followed.ST Feb 5, 1902 After pledging lands under the Spirit's influence they drew back, let Satan fill the heart, withheld part, and then confirmed the lie together.ST Jan 29, 1880
The sin lay not merely in the outward false answer or its consequences but in the choice and motive already in the heart before it was spoken.ST Nov 14, 1895ST Aug 13, 1896 Keeping back part of the price was keeping back the whole heart, giving some of the money but none of the heart, because money can be divided but the heart cannot be divided.RH Sep 30, 1902 God requires the whole heart and exact obedience and will accept no partial offering or substitute, so partial consecration is no consecration at all, and a heart that claims to have surrendered everything while still holding to the world and yielding only a part remains weak, corrupt and deceptive.RH Sep 30, 1902RH Feb 26, 1857RH Aug 15, 1871RH Aug 12, 1873 Those who love a lie in that inward sense cannot live in the presence of the Spirit of God.ST Aug 13, 1896
They had consecrated the property and its proceeds to God, so presenting the smaller amount as the full sale price while keeping part broke their vow.ST Sep 6, 1883RH Sep 17, 1908ST Oct 13, 1881RH Jun 30, 1903 That withholding of what was pledged and devoted was dishonest use of sacred means, pretending to give God what was kept for self.RH Sep 17, 1908RH Jun 30, 1903 It was selfishness, fraud, theft and robbery of Him, and a promise so accepted must be kept with integrity rather than treated as unimportant or denied.ST Jan 29, 1880ST Oct 13, 1881ST Oct 14, 1880 Yet the lie was not treated as one isolated act deciding their fate by itself; it revealed a longer course of deliberate choices against God.RH May 22, 1900
Divine Exposure and Judgment
Peter exposed the concealed agreement to keep back part of the price by asking Sapphira directly about the amount, seeing through the plan to appear wholly devoted while holding back money, and his ability to know their thoughts and point out secret fault came by the gift of the Spirit and the manifest presence of the Holy Spirit enabling leaders to detect selfish motives and hypocrisy in the voluntary sharing.RH Dec 1, 1910RH Sep 28, 1916RH Apr 7, 1868ST Mar 16, 1904RH May 15, 1856 That discernment applied the written principle against coveting to named persons, for the command alone condemned the act but did not identify the guilty, and the Spirit was given to reprove sin, bring truth to remembrance, and have hidden sin put away before the church undertook its great work, lest it suffer defeat like Israel at Ai.RH Dec 1, 1910RH Sep 28, 1916RH Mar 18, 1915RH May 15, 1856 The questioning itself exercised the power to remit or retain sins imparted when Christ breathed on the disciples, a specific endowment for those addressed on that occasion, distinct from the power from on high for which they were to wait at Jerusalem, possessed by no church or individual now and not transferable to associates or successors.RH Jun 11, 1901
His direct confrontation named and rebuked the deceit without yielding to concern over wounded feelings or consequences, exercising decisive judgment against fraud even though a fearful outcome followed.RH Jul 22, 1873RH Jul 16, 1872 Sapphira affirmed the false amount her husband had named, repeating on her own responsibility the lie he had failed under when tested, and after rebuke she fell dead at Peter's feet and was buried beside her husband, showing swift justice with conviction followed by retribution.RH Feb 2, 1911STRH Apr 15, 1858ST Jul 29, 1897ST Feb 5, 1902 She spoke the lie in the specially manifest presence of God, where those identified with sin perished, while Barnabas, separated from sin, was blessed in that same presence.STST Sep 3, 1894ST Jan 29, 1908ST Oct 9, 1901 The stern punishment, in which she lost this life and the life to come, shows how deep is God's hatred and contempt for fraud, that lying lips are an abomination to him, that he searches the heart, detects hidden sin, and will not be mocked, and that the same God still condemns all falsehood and dishonest dealing today though without always showing visible displeasure.RH Feb 2, 1911ST Jan 29, 1880RH Feb 2, 1911RH Apr 13, 1905ST May 20, 1889
The case illustrates that God may show displeasure by judgment at the time of transgression and punish wickedness in this life as a temporal example warning of ultimate retribution, with their sins going beforehand to judgment in signal vengeance manifest before all.ST Feb 5, 1880RH Jan 24, 1865RH Aug 1, 1865 This is not generally the time of final reward, judgment against an evil work is not always speedily executed, and not every liar is struck dead at once, any more than every Sabbath-breaker is now put to death as in Old Testament times, which does not do away with the commandment or prove lying has ceased to be sin.ST Feb 5, 1880RH May 12, 1868RH Jul 30, 1908RH Jan 24, 1865ST Mar 24, 1887 If sentence were executed at once every liar would fall under the same judgment, but retribution is reserved for the great day of wrath, as with Dathan and Abiram reserved until God utters his voice in the mighty earthquake.RH Jan 24, 1865ST Mar 24, 1887 Afterward the deaths were turned by the high priest, those with him, the council and all the senate of Israel into a criminal charge that the disciples had murdered Ananias and Sapphira by insurrection and conspiracy to deprive the priests of authority and put them to death, meant to excite the mob to deal with the disciples as it had dealt with Jesus, because they feared the dissatisfied people would accept the apostles' truths, acknowledge Jesus as Messiah, and turn in anger against the rulers for the murder of Christ.RH Feb 9, 1911 Later Porphyry likewise accused Peter of killing them.RH Dec 11, 1860
Impact on Early Church
Great fear fell upon the church and upon all who heard of the judgment on the false answer.RH Feb 2, 1911ST Apr 4, 1900RH Apr 7, 1868ST Jun 27, 1900RH Dec 4, 1913 That fear kept hypocrites from joining themselves to the believers, so that outsiders did not dare join themselves to them.ST Apr 4, 1900ST Jul 29, 1913ST Jun 27, 1900RH Dec 4, 1913 The church at Jerusalem was no safe place for hypocrites, liars, deceivers, and insincere professors.ST Jul 29, 1913ST Jul 14, 1881ST Jun 27, 1900RH Dec 4, 1913 The judgment kept out those of the same mind as Ananias and Sapphira, who would have used the growing popularity of the young church to gain honor for themselves.ST May 10, 1883ST Jul 29, 1913RH Dec 4, 1913
While the insincere were kept back, sincere believers seeking God yielded themselves and were added to the Lord in multitudes of men and women.ST Apr 4, 1900ST Jul 29, 1913RH Dec 4, 1913 Five thousand more were added to the church in Jerusalem.ST Jul 29, 1913 The same gift of discernment that laid bare disguise will be restored in the church preparing for the second coming, when hypocrisy will again be unable to hide and true believers who love the truth will be added in great numbers as at the first.RH Dec 4, 1913RH Nov 12, 1901
The signal wrath was necessary to guard the rapidly increasing young church from demoralization.RH Feb 2, 1911ST Jan 29, 1880RH Feb 2, 1911 It was necessary to guard against adding professed servants of God who worshiped Mammon, against pretense and hypocrisy and robbing God.RH Feb 2, 1911ST Jan 29, 1880RH Feb 2, 1911 The account shows God's power exposing and removing unworthy members to keep the church pure and clean, with the Holy Spirit exposing hypocrisy and the guilty receiving swift punishment under Christ's direction as head of the church.ST Oct 16, 1893ST Sep 24, 1896ST Apr 11, 1900RH Jul 16, 1872 Peter's questioning by Spirit-enabled discernment confronted and dealt with sin, reproved Sapphira, and helped guard the young church from hypocrisy.ST Apr 11, 1900RH Mar 18, 1915RH Jul 16, 1872 The organized church was responsible for confronting and cleansing its unrepentant members when discipline was otherwise ineffective.ST Jun 27, 1900
False brethren and self-deceived professors were present even when the gospel was preached in primitive purity with demonstration of the Spirit and of power.ST Feb 9, 1915ST Jul 7, 1914RH Feb 28, 1856RH Sep 9, 1858 Sapphira joined herself to the disciples while remaining a false believer, showing that the visible church can include people who are not true subjects of God's kingdom and that purity of the message does not keep out false-hearted professors.ST Feb 9, 1915ST Jul 7, 1914RH Feb 28, 1856 Such false professors will be found in the church till the close of time, and their presence gives the world no right to doubt the truth of Christianity and should not dishearten Christians nor be thought strange among professors of present truth.ST Feb 9, 1915RH Feb 28, 1856 Christ bears long with perverse human nature because He does not want to lose one soul, so believers must bear with false brethren with forbearance rather than uproot them, lest the precious wheat be rooted up with the tares.ST Feb 9, 1915 One person's sin can delay the progress of God's people, so each person should be careful not to be counted among the guilty.RH Jun 12, 1913
Scriptural Links and Doctrines
The lying answer falls under the curse for breaking the ninth commandment.ST Sep 9, 1913 Lying between people is already offensive by an earthly standard, but this lie was against God and is measured by the perfect law of heaven, making it a far greater offense, and that greatness explains the swiftness and severity of the punishment.ST Feb 5, 1902
Affirming a false sale price while concealing part of the truth for personal advantage violates the command against stealing.RH Sep 17, 1872RH Jul 30, 1872 This holds even when such dishonesty in buying and selling is customary or practiced within the church.RH Sep 17, 1872 Sapphira's agreement that the land sold for the amount named hid the part kept back in order to benefit herself and her husband.RH Sep 17, 1872RH Jul 30, 1872
The hidden sin searched out by God and met with swift retribution was like the coveting and dissembling of Achan.ST May 5, 1881RH Dec 2, 1858 As with Achan, such uncleanness must be detected and put away rather than left uncorrected within the church, for it keeps the church from receiving the fullness of God's power.RH Sep 28, 1916ST Nov 15, 1899RH Dec 2, 1858 Peter's exposure of the wife's share in concealing part of the price, by discernment given through the manifest presence of the Holy Spirit, cleared the sin away before the church undertook its work and so prevented a defeat like Israel's at Ai.RH Sep 28, 1916 Their doom likewise shows the fearful consequences of covetousness.ST Sep 1, 1909
The awful judgment after the crucifixion displays the same summary punishment for sin given before it in the burning of Nadab and Abihu and in the death of Zimri, as also seen afterward in the awful death of Herod.ST Jan 2, 1901 It proves God has not changed and is no more merciful now than when He ministered summary punishment through men under the theocracy.ST Jan 2, 1901 Sin in this age will as surely be punished as sin in that age, with even sorer punishment for despising Christ, for sin is death and righteousness is life.ST Jan 2, 1901 The changeless Creator and Redeemer who judges still longs to save men to righteousness and is mighty to save.ST Jan 2, 1901
Severe retribution for lying can occur in the gospel age just as in the Jewish age.ST Jul 22, 1880 The new covenant retains a death penalty, for they died for transgressing God's law, which remains the rule of conduct under both old and new covenants.ST Jan 24, 1906 Yet physical punishment was not administered by Christ's servants as a church penalty under the new dispensation; the deaths were a divine judgment.ST Jan 24, 1906
Cutting short what is offered while claiming it is the whole is robbing God in tithes and offerings.RH Jun 5, 1900 To withhold a portion of what God claims in the tithing system while pretending to give the whole, with the thought that fellow believers will never know, repeats the sin of affirming the false price while keeping part of the vowed proceeds from covetousness, lying to the Holy Spirit.ST Jan 29, 1880RH Jul 22, 1909 God searches the heart, and human motives and purposes cannot be hidden from Him, as the exposure of the lie evidences.ST Jan 29, 1880 That deception brought swift, rigid divine judgment in death and being carried out for burial, and the same unswerving judgment would cut down many today if so meted out.RH Jun 5, 1900 God instead pleads for honesty to bring the whole tithe into the storehouse without deceit, promising to open heaven and pour out blessing too large to receive, if not in outward goods then in communion and larger possession of Himself.RH Jun 5, 1900 The story therefore stands as a perpetual warning to Christians of all ages against the sin to which human hearts are continually inclined, and warns the church to fulfill its vows and not pretend to pay a full tithe while withholding part.ST Jan 29, 1880
They loved a lie and could not live in the presence of the Spirit of God.STST Aug 13, 1896 Their judgment shows God's standards are exact, that righteousness is life and sin is death, that righteousness enlightens while sin blinds and deceives.STST Aug 13, 1896 In contrast to the sinner who longs for righteousness and is cleansed and made whole, those who love a lie cannot remain where the Spirit is manifest.ST Aug 13, 1896 It reveals how holy are God's precepts and institutions and that He accepts no substitutes for either.ST Aug 13, 1896 A soul still marked by sin cannot receive God's Spirit in its fullness, for God does not give His glory to sin.ST Aug 21, 1901
God demands the strictest obedience and will accept no half-way service, requiring the whole price rather than part kept back through covetousness.RH Feb 26, 1857 Applied to the command to keep holy the Sabbath day, this means the seventh day, not the first, the day He hallowed and set apart and sanctified and blessed, binding children and the stranger under the roof as much as the head of the house, so that letting children or visiting relatives labor on that day while professing to rest breaks His demand for all.RH Feb 26, 1857 The instant death of liars in the apostles' days does not mean every liar afterward must fall dead at once, and the fact that thousands lie daily and remain alive does not mean lying has ceased to be sin.RH Jul 30, 1908 In the same way the fact that Sabbath-breakers are not now put to death as in Old Testament times does not do away with the fourth commandment or remove the obligation to keep the Sabbath.RH Jul 30, 1908
The record stands as past history in the class of historic truths given as examples to guide conduct through life.RH Mar 11, 1873 It teaches that those who disregard the truth must expect to suffer the consequences.RH Mar 11, 1873
Present Warnings and Duties
Vows and offerings made to God must be treated as sacred and kept truthfully, for the question about the price tests whether the full amount received for the land will be honestly confirmed.ST Oct 13, 1881ST Oct 14, 1880RH Jun 30, 1903 To affirm a false amount while concealing that part of the proceeds has been kept back joins in the lie about what was received and breaks a promise accepted by God.ST Oct 14, 1880RH Jun 30, 1903RH Jul 22, 1909 A pledge to the cause is a vow to God with brethren only as visible witnesses, more binding than a legal bond, and it must be kept with integrity because breaking it brings spiritual peril.ST Jan 29, 1880RH Jun 30, 1903 Withholding part of what was pledged while pretending to give the whole amount attempts to deceive Him who cannot be deceived, and failing to fulfill a vow when able is as serious as pretending to pay a full tithe while withholding part of what is owed.ST Jan 29, 1880RH Jun 30, 1903RH Jul 22, 1909 To appropriate pledged means is sacrilege that will surely be visited in judgment even when no visible mark follows now, for God searches out covetousness, selfishness and deception, and withholding from Him what is pledged is fraud and robbery of Him.ST Jan 29, 1880RH Jul 22, 1909
The same account warns against dishonest stewardship such as giving little while pretending to have given all, for falsely claiming that a gift represents the full amount available for God's work is lying to God.RH Dec 10, 1903ST Nov 28, 1892ST Feb 20, 1907RH Oct 26, 1905ST Apr 8, 1875 Giving only a small amount while falsely claiming it is all one can spare is deceitful, and giving part while pretending to give all is not faithful service, since seeking the appearance of generosity does not win approval.ST Feb 20, 1907RH Oct 26, 1905ST Apr 8, 1875 This includes understating means, failing to pay pledges, or professing to follow Systematic Benevolence while deliberately reporting property at low figures, which is the same dissembling rooted in selfishness and covetousness watched by angels.ST Nov 28, 1892RH Oct 26, 1905ST Apr 8, 1875 God disapproves of dishonesty in business matters and jealousy guards what He has made holy, so affirming a false sale price and treating what belongs to Him as ordinary brings judgment.RH Dec 10, 1903RH Oct 28, 1873
The episode calls for entire consecration and full self-surrender, giving the whole heart with exact obedience rather than a partial offering while still holding to the world.RH Feb 26, 1857RH Aug 15, 1871RH Aug 12, 1873RH Jul 24, 1860 To confirm a false sale amount while secretly keeping back part exposes a weak, corrupt, deceptive heart that yields only a part, with false thoughts rising even while penitent to keep the world before the eyes.RH Feb 26, 1857RH Aug 15, 1871RH Aug 12, 1873 Converted believers belong to God's service in property as in heart, and He does not accept a heart that withholds part of what is owed nor something else in place of all.RH Feb 26, 1857 Clinging to earth though earthly gains are known to be worth little must give way to freedom from lack of self-control, victory in the strife with self, and full surrender to Him who has given so much.RH Aug 15, 1871RH Jul 24, 1860
Departing from God's plan for giving by withholding part while claiming to give all lays a foundation for lying and brings fear, while surrender in giving brings faith, so giving all is the key to victory.ST Aug 7, 1901
The case is put on record as a danger-signal and perpetual warning to all professed followers in every age to guard against covetousness, stinted offerings with lavish spending on self, and all hypocrisy.RH Feb 2, 1911ST Jan 29, 1880RH Feb 2, 1911RH Sep 30, 1902 It tests whether truth or love of the world predominates, pressing each person to ask if he is pretending to give all while keeping back part in order to have the reputation for complete consecration without the actual experience.RH Feb 2, 1911RH Sep 30, 1902RH Oct 20, 1874 Lying between man and man is already offensive, but a lie against God measured by the perfect law of heaven is a far greater offense, which explains swift and severe dealing.RH Feb 2, 1911ST Feb 5, 1902 Following the same course destroys the soul and bars from the kingdom, for she lost this life and the life to come, showing how deep is hatred and contempt for fraud, that lying lips are an abomination, that hidden sin of the heart is detected and will not be mocked, and that the same God still condemns all falsehood today though without always showing visible displeasure.RH Feb 2, 1911RH Feb 2, 1911 Keeping back part of the price was keeping back the whole of the heart, giving some of the money but none of the heart, because money can be divided but the heart cannot be divided, so partial consecration is no consecration at all, and he who gives all receives all.RH Feb 2, 1911RH Sep 30, 1902RH Oct 20, 1874
The same gift of discernment that laid bare disguise will be restored in the church preparing for the second coming, when hypocrisy will again be unable to hide and unworthy members will separate.RH Mar 30, 1905RH Dec 4, 1913RH Nov 12, 1901 By directly testing profession no disguise can avail before God-given discernment, and the judgment that deters hypocrites so that no man dares join from insincere motives will be seen again when the Spirit comes in fullness.RH Dec 4, 1913RH Nov 12, 1901 In the power of the latter rain many will fall as Ananias and Sapphira did, and before the work closes the church will be so filled with divine presence and purity that sinners and hypocrites will not remain or unite with it, while true believers who love the truth are added in great numbers as at the first.RH Mar 30, 1905RH Dec 4, 1913RH Nov 12, 1901
Breaking the hedge of conscience by sin brings sin's consequences, for cherished sin leaves hearts not right with God and vulnerable to temptation.RH Jan 20, 1916ST Dec 16, 1913 The dishonesty revealed hearts not right with God rather than merely keeping some of the money, and the lie leads to death as the wages of sin.RH Jan 20, 1916ST Apr 23, 1902 Those who remain identified with sin cannot sin with impunity, for the danger lies in choosing sin and sharing in its destructive power.ST Apr 23, 1902ST Jul 30, 1902
Sources