Exodus 10:8
And Moses and Aaron were brought again unto Pharaoh: and he said unto them, Go, serve the LORD your God: but who are they that shall go?
Translations
American King James Version, Webster Bible
And Moses and Aaron were brought again to Pharaoh: and he said to them, Go, serve the LORD your God: but who are they that shall go?
And Moses and Aaron were brought again unto Pharaoh: and he said unto them, Go, serve the LORD your God: but who are they that shall go?
And Moses and Aaron were brought again unto Pharaoh: and he said unto them, Go, serve the Lord your God: but who are they that shall go?
And Moses and Aaron were brought again unto Pharaoh: and he said unto them, Go, serve the LORD your God; but who are they that shall go?
And Moses and Aaron were brought again unto Pharaoh: and he said unto them, Go, serve Jehovah your God; but who are they that shall go?
And Moses is brought back — Aaron also — unto Pharaoh, and he saith unto them, 'Go, serve Jehovah your God; — who and who [are] those going?'
And Moses and Aaron were brought again to Pharaoh. And he said to them, Go, serve Jehovah your God. Who are they that shall go?
So Moses and Aaron were brought back unto pharaoh, and he said unto them—Go, serve Yahweh your God,—who, are they that are going?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
So Moses and Aaron were brought back to Pharaoh. “ Go, worship the LORD your God,” he said. “ But who exactly will be going?”
Moses and Aaron were brought again to Pharaoh, and he said to them, “ Go, serve the LORD your God; but who are those who will go?”
Then Moses and Aaron came in again before Pharaoh: and he said to them, Go and give worship to the Lord your God: but which of you are going?
So Moses and Aaron were brought againe vnto Pharaoh, and he saide vnto them, Goe, serue the Lord your God, but who are they that shall goe?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
And they called back Moses and Aaron to Pharao: and he said to them: Go, sacrifice to the Lord your God: who are they that shall go?
Cross-references
- Exodus 10:24
And Pharaoh called unto Moses, and said, Go ye, serve the LORD; only let your flocks and your herds be stayed: let your little ones also go with you.
Pharaoh permits the people to go but withholds their livestock.
- Exodus 8:25-28
And Pharaoh called for Moses and for Aaron, and said, Go ye, sacrifice to your God in the land.
Pharaoh first offers sacrifice within Egypt, then limits how far Israel may go.
- Exodus 4:22-23
And thou shalt say unto Pharaoh, Thus saith the LORD, Israel is my son, even my firstborn:
The firstborn plague judges Egypt for oppressing Israel.
- Exodus 9:27
And Pharaoh sent, and called for Moses and Aaron, and said unto them, I have sinned this time: the LORD is righteous, and I and my people are wicked.
Pharaoh confesses his sin after the hail.
- Exodus 5:1-4
And afterward Moses and Aaron went in, and told Pharaoh, Thus saith the LORD God of Israel, Let my people go, that they may hold a feast unto me in the wilderness.
Moses asks Pharaoh to let Israel worship God.
- Exodus 10:1-2
And the LORD said unto Moses, Go in unto Pharaoh: for I have hardened his heart, and the heart of his servants, that I might shew these my signs before him:
purpose of signs and telling
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
6 sources
Before this verse Pharaoh's servants, who were his rulers and counselors under him, urged him to let Israel go because Egypt was destroyed.SG3 216.2–217.1 Their cattle were dead, and lightning and hail mingled with fire had nearly ruined the land, broken down forests, destroyed fruit and nearly all grain, left everything in ruin, and caused the loss of all that had been gained through Hebrew labor.SG3 216.2–217.1 In this verse Pharaoh had Moses and Aaron brought back to him and told them to go serve the Lord their God, while asking who would go.SG3 216.2–217.11SP 193.2–194.1ST Mar 18, 1880 The offer and question showed contempt for God's command, giving only the appearance of permitting worship while intending a limited release rather than letting the people go as a whole.SG3 216.2–217.11SP 193.2–194.1ST Mar 18, 1880
The limitation was that only the men might go to serve God, while the little ones, wives, families and the rest of Israel must stay behind.SG3 216.2–217.1ST Mar 18, 1880SG3 245.11SP 218.1 He pretended a special interest in their welfare and tender care for their little ones, treating the children as not needed and the wilderness journey as too dangerous an expedition for wives and little children, though he had oppressed Israel with hard labor to destroy them.SG3 216.2–217.1 He openly declared that God's requirement to take their families into the wilderness should not be obeyed, because God meant only to lead them out to destroy them so their bodies would lie in the wilderness.SG3 216.2–217.1 He intended to keep the families behind as a pledge that the men would return.ST Mar 18, 1880
He yielded only a little under grievous affliction and only as far as dreadful judgment compelled him, making only reluctant, temporary concessions.SG3 245.11SP 218.1 He acted as a proud and idolatrous king, very slow to meet the requirements of the God of heaven, persisting in rebellion even after Egypt was ruined.SG3 245.1 This offer for the men alone was the second step in that sequence: he first allowed sacrifice to God inside the land of Egypt, then allowed the men alone to go, then after Egypt had been nearly destroyed by the plague of the locusts allowed children and wives to go also but still would not let the cattle go.SG3 245.11SP 218.1 This verse belongs to the account of the plagues that challenged Pharaoh's resistance to Israel's release, which were designed to expose the powerlessness of Egypt's idols, show Jehovah's supremacy, and insist on Israel's deliverance.PP 758.3–760.1
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
36 sources
Moses and Aaron were brought again before Pharaoh after the locusts were threatened, and he gave a limited leave to go and serve the Lord while asking who would go in order to control and restrict the departure.ST Jan 25, 1910ST Nov 14, 1906ST Jan 20, 1909RH Jan 6, 1903ST Sep 28, 1904 Pressed by his servants because Egypt was destroyed, he bargained that only the men should go and the wives, women and little ones should remain as a pledge for return, then in anger drove Moses and Aaron from his presence.ST Mar 18, 1880RH Apr 1, 1862ST Dec 7, 1904 To his question Moses answered that all must go to hold a feast to the Lord, with young and old, sons and daughters, little children and aged parents, rich and poor, with flocks and herds.RH Nov 18, 1909RH Apr 22, 1915 To let the men go while holding back the women and children is partial obedience that keeps one's own way in part, and it must be refused as Moses refused it.RH Jan 6, 1903 The effort to leave the little ones in Egypt teaches thorough arousal and diligent work for youth and children, lest many be left in the world at the final exodus, for as Israel was called out of bondage so God's people are called away from the world's pleasures and work with young and old together.RH Aug 29, 1912RH Nov 3, 1868ST Aug 2, 1910
Place in Exodus Story
The verse stands in the account of the locusts and darkness, after the eighth plague of locusts was threatened, when Moses and Aaron were brought again before Pharaoh, who told them to go and serve the Lord but asked who would go.ST Jan 25, 1910ST Nov 14, 1906ST Jan 20, 1909RH Jan 6, 1903 The summons allowed the Israelites to go and worship, while the question sought to limit and compromise their release and to control who could leave.ST Jan 25, 1910ST Nov 14, 1906ST Jan 20, 1909RH Jan 6, 1903 The deliverance from bondage in Egypt was accompanied by darkness, plagues, and storm, and locusts were one of the plagues sent upon Egypt.ST Sep 28, 1904ST Aug 2, 1899 The warning of locusts, what the Egyptians said when it was threatened, the bringing of the locusts upon the land, what they did, how they rebuked the false worship of Egypt, and Pharaoh's subsequent action with answered prayer for removal and an unhumbled heart all belong together here.RH Jan 6, 1903
The verse belongs to the first, mainly historical division of Exodus in chapters 5-10, which records the interviews of Moses and Aaron with Pharaoh, the contest with Pharaoh's magicians, and the infliction of the plagues upon Egypt toward the tenth plague of the death of the firstborn and the hurried departure of Israel. It stands in the history part of Exodus, chapters 1 to 18, which means the going out and tells of the departure of Israel from Egypt.RH Jan 20, 1916 It belongs to the detailed story of the great deliverance from bitter bondage and oppression, by which the family of Israel grown more and mightier than the Egyptians became a nation with thorough organization, efficient leadership, a complete code of laws, and an established form of worship, with Moses as the chosen leader.RH Jan 20, 1916 It is part of the conflict over Israel's worship and release from bondage, which ends only after the plagues and God's intervention.RH Mar 25, 1909
Pressed by his servants, princes, and courtiers who urged release because Egypt was destroyed, Pharaoh made a partial compromise to keep control.ST Mar 18, 1880ST Dec 7, 1904 He appeared to permit Israel to worship the Lord while questioning who would go, proposing that only the men who desired it might go and serve the Lord while wives, women, and little ones remained in the land as a pledge and security for return.ST Mar 18, 1880RH Apr 1, 1862ST Dec 7, 1904 This was one of his bargaining attempts alongside proposing sacrifice in Egypt, proposing sacrifice not very far away, and proposing that all go but the cattle remain, by which he hardened his own heart in bantering, parleying, and debating with God over the demand to let Israel go to serve Him.RH Apr 1, 1862 In desperation and uncontrolled anger he insisted only the men might go, threatened that evil was before them, and had Moses and Aaron driven out from his presence by soldiers with spears.ST Dec 7, 1904
To Pharaoh's question Moses answered that all must go to hold a feast unto the Lord, with young and old, sons and daughters, flocks and herds.RH Nov 18, 1909RH Apr 22, 1915ST Dec 7, 1904 God's call out of Egypt embraced every member of the Israelite family, rich and poor, little children as well as gray-haired fathers and mothers.RH Apr 22, 1915 The Lord's invitation to leave Egypt included the children, not only the adults.RH Nov 18, 1909
The plagues that afflicted Egypt would not be expected to appear in Egyptian public records, which recorded royal successes and triumphs.RH Apr 23, 1908 God demanded the instant release of the Israelites from their servile condition as serfs of the Egyptians rather than sanctioning even that modified form of slavery, after allowing them to remain in bondage for a time for His own purposes.RH Oct 1, 1861 When Pharaoh refused, God brought terrible judgments on their Egyptian oppressors, led the Israelites out as an army of fugitive slaves, and drowned their pursuers in the Red Sea.RH Oct 1, 1861
God, Judgment and Prophecy
Exodus 7 to 12 sets God's religious system against Egypt's religious system with miracles on both sides.RH Mar 11, 1915 The miracles wrought by God's power through Moses and Aaron were to convince Pharaoh and his people of their duty to obey God.ST May 4, 1882 That power was not Moses' own but lay in God's word and in how men received or rejected it.ST Apr 4, 1911 The opposing miracles of the magicians were to deceive Pharaoh and shut his heart against the message sent him.ST May 4, 1882 Such magic or enchantment is the work of Satan and his angels, always wrought to turn men away from God and His truth, and its resistance alongside the plagues illustrates the satanic deception accompanying God's work to demonstrate that His people should go free.RH Dec 23, 1851ST May 4, 1882
Through the plagues God made Himself known to Egypt and Israel.ST Nov 27, 1901 The Egyptians were shown that Israel's God is the one all-powerful God and Creator and supreme Ruler, while Egypt's many gods were powerless before Him.ST Nov 1, 1899 Those gods could neither remove evil nor give blessing, were humbled with Egypt, and were rebuked as nothing.ST Feb 4, 1913ST Nov 27, 1901ST Dec 4, 1901 The frogs, lice, flies and locusts were an exercise of creative power showing superiority over the gods and control over the elements to do His bidding, that His power might be shown and His name declared through all the earth.ST Aug 22, 1911 In this humbling of Egypt men were given opportunity to know God personally.ST Nov 27, 1901
The plagues visited on Egypt were literal judgments poured out upon the wicked.ST May 31, 1910 For that reason the last plagues in Revelation and Revelation 16 are likewise to be believed real and literal.ST May 31, 1910RH Mar 23, 1852 The Egyptian plagues are a type, pattern, illustration and comparison for the seven terrible plagues that will sweep the world just before the final deliverance.STRH Mar 23, 1852ST Oct 28, 1930 Exodus 10 belongs to the ten plagues that fell just before the deliverance of God's people.ST Oct 28, 1930 As Israel stayed in Egypt through the plagues, so God's people will not be removed from the earth until after six of the seven last plagues have been poured out but must witness the fearful scenes of the time of trouble, protected by the seal of the living God while destruction falls around them.ST Jul 18, 1878
The Egyptian events provide a pattern for the final deliverance and the judgments that precede it.RH Dec 23, 1851 The plagues vindicated God's right as Creator and supreme Ruler after Pharaoh denied Israel's God, refused to obey His voice to let Israel go, and set aside the Sabbath memorial by charging Moses with making the people rest and laying heavier work on them so they could not keep it.ST Aug 22, 1911 Great prominence was given to the Sabbath as the point of controversy before Israel left Egypt, afterward made the test of obedience before Sinai and given central place in the law spoken amid Sinai's thunders and written with His finger on tables of stone.ST Aug 22, 1911 That deliverance completed at the Red Sea demonstrates God's wisdom, love and power and His ability and right to rule and Israel's obligation to obey, leading to their testing whether they will walk in His law centered on the ancient Sabbath institution requiring daily labor for daily needs with preparation on the sixth day for complete rest throughout the seventh day.ST Mar 7, 1906 The same creative power later fed the multitudes in the wilderness with quails and manna, following the same course as in creation by creating no manna on the seventh day.ST Aug 22, 1911
After hundreds of years of slavery had unfitted Israel to comprehend God's great salvation and the character He required, God redeemed Israel with a mighty hand and gave a great multiple object-lesson by various forms and rites comprehending in its teaching the great plan of salvation. He instructed Moses to take free-will offerings of the children of Israel to make Him a sanctuary that He might dwell among them. The verse is one step in that considerate and kind dealing with Pharaoh reaching from the first demand that Israel might go to hold a feast to Him in the wilderness to Israel's song of triumph on the other side of the Red Sea.ST Feb 4, 1913 Yielding to the first request would have opened Pharaoh's own heart to receive further truth that might have followed.ST Feb 4, 1913 Instead Pharaoh hardened his own heart step after step by bantering, parleying, debating and driving a sharp bargain with God, as when sinners try to drive a sharp bargain with God.RH Apr 1, 1862
That bargaining included three attempts, proposing sacrifice in Egypt, proposing sacrifice not very far away, and proposing in this verse that only the men go while the women and little ones remain behind, alongside proposing that all go but the cattle remain.RH Apr 1, 1862 Such hardening comes from human nature and the sinner's own act, not from any direct influence of God.RH Apr 1, 1862 Pharaoh continued to ignore warnings until the Spirit of God left him and his host was devoted to destruction, after God had dealt first in kindness and afterward showed by mighty miracles that the gods of Egypt were all nothing before Him.ST Feb 4, 1913ST Dec 4, 1901 The words everlasting and eternal do not always mean endless duration but their duration is determined by the person or thing to which they relate, and where connection requires a limited sense they must be so understood.RH Oct 17, 1854 This verse is one such text where connection requires that limited sense, proving that the everlasting fire of the future punishment of the wicked must be understood in a limited sense because the wicked will come to an end, die and be no more, and the penalty of God's law for personal disobedience is literal death, not endless misery.RH Oct 17, 1854
Call for Full Separation
Pharaoh sought to escape divine judgment by partial obedience, obeying the command to let Israel go to serve the Lord in part while keeping his own way in part.RH Jan 6, 1903 After his servants pressed him to release Israel, he recalled Moses and Aaron and offered to let the men go while holding back the women and children.RH Jan 6, 1903 Moses and Aaron refused to agree that this compromise was right, and for that refusal they were driven from his presence.RH Jan 6, 1903 That course of half-compliance remains a pattern many still follow.RH Jan 6, 1903
The demand that the little ones stay in Egypt was an effort to separate the youth from God's people.RH Aug 29, 1912 To his question who should go, the answer was that all must go, young and old, sons and daughters.RH Aug 29, 1912 This teaches the need to be thoroughly aroused to the dangers besetting youth and children and to labor diligently for them.RH Aug 29, 1912 Otherwise many young people will be left in this world when the final exodus takes place.RH Aug 29, 1912
God's call to serve embraces children and youth as well as adults, young and old, sons and daughters.ST Aug 2, 1910 As Israel was called out of Egyptian bondage, so God's people in later days are called away from the world's pleasures and work.ST Aug 2, 1910 Pharaoh's troubling of Israel by resisting their departure illustrates the persecution and inner struggle that attend the call to leave the world and fallen churches and unite with His people.RH Nov 3, 1868
The locusts of Egypt, with the frogs and lice, were a desolating scourge sweeping over the land.RH Jun 23, 1868 Together with the cankerworm, the caterpillar, and the palmer-worm they form a great devouring army that will ravage parts of the earth in the last days and stand among the terrors of that time.ST Aug 2, 1899 Man with all his inventions and devices is as powerless to prevent them as a tornado or an earthquake.ST Aug 2, 1899 Light, popular, fascinating literature and mixed publications now sweeping over the land are even more desolating.RH Jun 23, 1868 The remedy is to turn to God with all the heart with fasting and weeping and mourning.ST Aug 2, 1899
Sources