Galatians 4:9
But now, after that ye have known God, or rather are known of God, how turn ye again to the weak and beggarly elements, whereunto ye desire again to be in bondage?
Translations
But now, after that you have known God, or rather are known of God, how turn you again to the weak and beggarly elements, to which you desire again to be in bondage?
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
But now, after that ye have known God, or rather are known of God, how turn ye again to the weak and beggarly elements, whereunto ye desire again to be in bondage?
But now, after ye have known God, or rather are known by God, how turn ye again to the weak and beggarly elements, to which ye desire again to be in bondage?
but now that ye have come to know God, or rather to be known of God, how turn ye back again to the weak and beggarly rudiments, whereunto ye desire to be in bondage over again?
but now that ye have come to know God, or rather to be known by God, how turn ye back again to the weak and beggarly rudiments, whereunto ye desire to be in bondage over again?
and now, having known God — and rather being known by God — how turn ye again unto the weak and poor elements to which anew ye desire to be in servitude?
but now, knowing God, but rather being known by God, how do ye turn again to the weak and beggarly principles to which ye desire to be again anew in bondage?
Whereas, now, having acknowledged God,—or rather, having been acknowledged by God, how turn ye back again unto the weak and beggarly elementary principles, unto which, over again, ye are wishing, to come into servitude?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
But now that you know God, or rather are known by God, how is it that you are turning back to those weak and worthless principles? Do you wish to be enslaved by them all over again?
But now that you have come to know God, or rather to be known by God, why do you turn back again to the weak and miserable elemental principles, to which you desire to be in bondage all over again?
But now that you have come to have knowledge of God, or more truly, God has knowledge of you, how is it that you go back again to the poor and feeble first things, desiring to be servants to them again?
But now seeing ye knowe God, yea, rather are knowen of God, howe turne ye againe vnto impotent and beggerly rudiments, whereunto as from the beginning ye wil be in bondage againe?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
But now, after that you have known God, or rather are known by God: how turn you again to the weak and needy elements, which you desire to serve again?
Cross-references 20 of 41
- Galatians 5:1
Stand fast therefore in the liberty wherewith Christ hath made us free, and be not entangled again with the yoke of bondage.
Warns believers not to return to the yoke of bondage.
- Galatians 4:3
Even so we, when we were children, were in bondage under the elements of the world:
Both describe former bondage under the world’s elements.
- Colossians 2:14
Blotting out the handwriting of ordinances that was against us, which was contrary to us, and took it out of the way, nailing it to his cross;
The ordinance contrary to us was taken away at the cross.
- Galatians 4:22-31
For it is written, that Abraham had two sons, the one by a bondmaid, the other by a freewoman.
The allegory of Abraham’s two wives illustrates freedom in Christ.
- John 8:36
If the Son therefore shall make you free, ye shall be free indeed.
The Son makes believers free from bondage.
- Colossians 2:16-17
Let no man therefore judge you in meat, or in drink, or in respect of an holyday, or of the new moon, or of the sabbath days:
Describes ceremonial observances as shadows fulfilled in Christ.
- 2 Peter 2:20-22
For if after they have escaped the pollutions of the world through the knowledge of the Lord and Saviour Jesus Christ, they are again entangled therein, and overcome, the latter end is worse with them than the beginning.
Both describe turning back to sin after knowing God and escaping the world’s pollution.
- Leviticus 19:26
Ye shall not eat any thing with the blood: neither shall ye use enchantment, nor observe times.
Both forbid heathen observances such as observing times.
- 1 Corinthians 8:3
But if any man love God, the same is known of him.
Those who love God are known by him.
- Galatians 3:1-3
O foolish Galatians, who hath bewitched you, that ye should not obey the truth, before whose eyes Jesus Christ hath been evidently set forth, crucified among you?
Their turn from faith in Christ to reliance on works is presented as apostasy.
- Colossians 2:8
Beware lest any man spoil you through philosophy and vain deceit, after the tradition of men, after the rudiments of the world, and not after Christ.
Both warn against returning to the world’s rudiments and being turned from Christ.
- 2 Peter 2:19
While they promise them liberty, they themselves are the servants of corruption: for of whom a man is overcome, of the same is he brought in bondage.
Both texts describe those overcome by sin as brought into bondage.
- 2 Corinthians 3:7-11
But if the ministration of death, written and engraven in stones, was glorious, so that the children of Israel could not stedfastly behold the face of Moses for the glory of his countenance; which glory was to be done away:
The old covenant’s fading ministry is contrasted with the surpassing glory of the Spirit’s ministry.
- Galatians 5:4
Christ is become of no effect unto you, whosoever of you are justified by the law; ye are fallen from grace.
Seeking justification through the law makes Christ ineffective and means falling from grace.
- Ephesians 2:15
Having abolished in his flesh the enmity, even the law of commandments contained in ordinances; for to make in himself of twain one new man, so making peace;
Cited with Galatians 4 in the claim that Christ abolished the Levitical law.
- Romans 7:14-15
For we know that the law is spiritual: but I am carnal, sold under sin.
Explains being sold under sin through the sinner’s struggle to do right.
- Jeremiah 2:11-13
Hath a nation changed their gods, which are yet no gods? but my people have changed their glory for that which doth not profit.
Both condemn turning from God back to former worship and practices.
- Romans 8:15
For ye have not received the spirit of bondage again to fear; but ye have received the Spirit of adoption, whereby we cry, Abba, Father.
The Spirit of adoption replaces bondage, while believers await bodily redemption.
- Colossians 2:20
Wherefore if ye be dead with Christ from the rudiments of the world, why, as though living in the world, are ye subject to ordinances,
Uses the same term for worldly elements.
- 1 Corinthians 12:2
Ye know that ye were Gentiles, carried away unto these dumb idols, even as ye were led.
Recalls the Galatians’ former service to gods that were not gods.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
4 sources
After knowing God and being known by God, to turn again to the weak and beggarly elements is to turn away from the righteousness of Christ to desire bondage again.Ms 41a, 1896, par. 23RH Dec 17, 1901 It is to resolve after a time to go back to the world by remaining enslaved to carnal inclinations that have not been relinquished.ST Jul 28, 1898 It is to give up building a pure holy character in the divine likeness and to become spiritually blind to the value of eternal riches and to the sacrifice of Christ.ST Jul 28, 1898 It is to become ashamed of Jesus when scorn and ridicule come, to leave Him to associate with and honor His persecutors, and to fail to endure opposition to the end.ST Jul 28, 1898 This proves the cost was not counted and that conversion to Christ has not taken place, so no one who does this is worthy to be called a disciple, since a disciple intends always to be on the side of truth and righteousness as a brave whole-hearted soldier pressing close to Jesus without faltering or turning back.ST Jul 28, 1898
The weak and beggarly elements include observing days and months and times and years, meaning the observance of holidays and the many traditions brought in with them.Ms 41a, 1896, par. 23 That holiday observance is a great evil that is to be given no sanction or heed.Ms 41a, 1896, par. 23 These elements are also bound up with rejecting God's precepts, especially the Sabbath commandment, and with dishonoring God by misusing what belongs to Him.RH Dec 17, 1901
Turning to them means turning from the light graciously given when obedience involves worldly inconvenience.Lt 29, 1900, par. 12 It is abandoning faith in Christ as the only means of justification and sanctification and communion with God for worldly selfish scheming, including disregarding God's command concerning the Sabbath and thus robbing God.Lt 29, 1900, par. 12 By contrast, refusing to turn back and honoring the Sabbath distinguishes a person from the world and brings delight in the Lord, exaltation, and the heritage of Jacob.Lt 29, 1900, par. 12
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
118 sources
After coming to know God, and more importantly having been known by Him, it is folly to turn back again to powerless and impoverished ways and to desire bondage once more.RH May 15, 1900ST Nov 14, 1900ST Nov 21, 1900ST Nov 14, 1900 Being known by God is not merely hearing about Him or knowing facts about Him, but a life-union in which rebellion is put away and will, body, mind and spirit are submitted to Him through the Holy Spirit.ST Mar 2, 1904ST Feb 13, 1893 The weak and beggarly elements are the former heathen idolatry and service to beings that by nature are no gods, which are weak because they cannot give liberty or peace and beggarly because they are impoverished and despicable.ST Apr 9, 1894ST Nov 21, 1900ST Sep 18, 1884RH May 15, 1900 That bondage is slavery to sin, which is transgression of the law, while freedom comes through Christ alone who pardons and writes the law in the heart to enable obedience.RH Jul 18, 1854ST Feb 20, 1912RH Aug 2, 1870RH Dec 1850 The return was proved by observing again the old pagan days, months, seasons and years, including sun-worship days such as Sunday, Easter and other festivals without Scripture authority, while those who held the other view taught that the elements were the Mosaic ceremonial law of ordinances whose shadows ended at Christ.ST Mar 15, 1899ST Jun 8, 1915ST Aug 23, 1910 Conversion does not make turning back impossible, for those who have known God and received life can yield to temptation, lose hold of God, and become bound again unless they persevere.ST Sep 22, 1914ST Apr 28, 1909RH Sep 19, 1871ST Aug 1, 1916RH Dec 29, 1859
Historical Setting and Wording
The question is how, after having known God, or rather having been known by God, the readers could turn again to the weak and beggarly elements and desire again to be in bondage.RH May 15, 1900 The letter was written to a mixed church largely composed of Gauls in Galatia, called the Gaul of the East, a comparatively small district of Asia Minor on a highway of commerce where Gauls dwelling there from about the third century before Christ and subjugated by Rome in B.C. 189 became mixed with Greeks and Romans and to some extent with Hebrews, the church there having been founded by Paul in A.D. 52, and the verse belongs to readings covering Galatians and Romans.ST Nov 22, 1910 Tubal, which is Pontus and Galatia in the northern part of eastern Asia Minor, cannot be counted as never having heard of God, for the Galatians were represented at Jerusalem on the day of Pentecost; they once did not know God but by the time of the letter had heard, knew Him, and were in danger of turning back to gaining favor by their own acts, which rules out giving them an extra chance to hear after probation closes.ST Dec 3, 1896
The verse expresses the same wonder as Galatians 1:6-7 and for the same reason, that after having a glimpse of heaven the readers were turning back to the world, and after having known freedom in God they were deliberately putting themselves under the burdensome bondage of sin.ST Nov 14, 1900 The turning is to the rudiments of the world, the same weak and beggarly rudiments named in Galatians 4:3, and is a relapse into heathenism and a return to former bondage, for the Galatians had formerly been heathen and never Jews.ST Nov 14, 1900 Although Jewish false brethren were teaching them, they were led into another gospel which is no gospel by trusting their own works instead of faith in Christ, for the true gospel is God's power unto salvation to everyone who believes while the false gospel of works is man's power unto destruction because there is no help in man, and when faith is lost people drift back into former habits regardless of who teaches them.ST Nov 14, 1900 The reproof for turning to bondage shows true friendship, since telling the truth about faults makes one counted as an enemy while remaining a true friend.RH Aug 4, 1868
Knowing God and Being Known
The former state was bondage springing from not knowing God and serving beings that by nature are no gods, set against the present state of having come to know God and, more importantly, of being known by Him.ST Nov 14, 1900ST Nov 21, 1900ST Nov 14, 1900 To turn again to the weak and beggarly rudiments after that change is to turn back toward bondage and to reverse conversion.ST Nov 14, 1900ST Nov 21, 1900ST Nov 14, 1900 Observing days and months and seasons and years is the evidence of that turning back to heathenism and old idolatrous customs, giving cause to fear that labor bestowed has been in vain.ST Nov 14, 1900ST Nov 21, 1900ST Nov 14, 1900 Being known by God is the central and vital reality of knowing Him, a life-union and harmony in which rebellion is put away and will, body, mind, and spirit are submitted to Him.ST Mar 2, 1904 Knowing God is not merely hearing about Him or learning facts about Him, but living in union with Him as He works through the Holy Spirit to make followers fruitful, so they must not turn back to weak elements and seek bondage again.ST Mar 2, 1904
Knowing God, or being known by Him, involves the Holy Spirit's life-giving power creating a new heart and bringing new life in the soul.ST Feb 13, 1893 The life of God comes to those whose hearts are open by faith to receive His Spirit, not to the weak, fleshly life turned back to bondage. Having the life of God belongs to those who are known by God, and sinful people do not already possess eternal life simply by being alive.ST Mar 2, 1904 Being known by God brings consolation when the world maligns or threatens, because He is greater and better than the world and able and willing to shield His followers.ST Oct 11, 1899 Communion with Maker and Redeemer satisfies the soul's spiritual needs, with the eye carried beyond earthly dangers to the rest and blessedness of the eternal realm.ST Oct 11, 1899
Knowledge of God rests on God's prior recognition and relationship, so that those who have known God and more truly have been known by God are assured of His reception.ST Feb 17, 1888 It is out of place to speak as though He might refuse the plea of a penitent who comes confessing and forsaking sin, for He promises mercy and abundant pardon to those who turn to Him.ST Feb 17, 1888
Weak and Beggarly Elements
The weak and beggarly elements are the former heathen idolatry from which the readers had been converted, service to beings that by nature are no gods, and turning again to them is becoming idolaters again and returning to former idolatrous bondage.ST Apr 9, 1894ST Nov 18, 1913RH Dec 16, 1858 Having come to know God and to be known by God and having been delivered by Christ from that service and bondage, they in backsliding were turning again to the same bondage, which was return to old idolatrous customs and to bondage to heathen religious practices.ST Apr 9, 1894ST Nov 21, 1900RH Jun 23, 1859 Those elements were the observance of the times of the heathen, days dedicated to the feasts and worship of their gods which God had forbidden, the former observance of days, months, times, and years, and for this reason there was fear for them and rebuke of their turning from God back to things that are not gods.ST Apr 9, 1894ST Jul 29, 1880 In this understanding they are not Mosaic institutions and not the Sabbath, since the readers had previously been heathen and had not observed God's law.RH Dec 16, 1858RH Jun 23, 1859
They are weak because they are powerless and cannot give the liberty or peace they promise, earthly rather than heavenly, and beggarly because they are impoverished and despicable, sin being despicable.ST Sep 18, 1884RH May 15, 1900 They are sin in its various forms, including the idolatry and accompanying vices practiced before knowing God, the sinful desires and practices of the world, the lust of the flesh and the lust of the eyes and the pride of life, and return to heathen practices is return to sin.ST Sep 18, 1884RH May 15, 1900 They are chains of sin and captivity willingly taken up again, the old life taken up despite having received Christ's liberty and light, showing the human tendency to become attached even to degrading bondage.ST Mar 15, 1899 They are like the husks of sin that cannot satisfy even when desired, the world's beggarly elements whose slavery is to be refused by seeking God while dissatisfaction and conviction are felt rather than stifling the Spirit and losing interest in divine things.ST Mar 15, 1899ST Jul 1, 1886
They are the forms of sin marking life apart from God, and bondage to them is equivalent to being under the law as condemned for sin, belonging to the former life of walking according to the world rather than following the Spirit.ST May 13, 1886ST Jun 24, 1886 That bondage is bondage to the principles of the world, the condition all are in by birth, the bondage under sin in which Scripture holds all, entered by beginning the Christian life by faith and the Spirit and then seeking to carry it forward by another way, forsaking God and accepting another master in apostasy from the faith.ST Dec 19, 1900 Deliverance from that bondage is by Christ through faith and receiving the Spirit, putting on Christ and obtaining His freedom, becoming children of God with the heavenly Jerusalem as mother, and the verse stands between two states, bondage and freedom, illustrated by the old covenant which can only bring bondage and the new covenant which brings freedom, so that the bondwoman and her son, the bondage itself, must be cast out.ST Dec 19, 1900 The beggarly elements are the same selfish worldliness and the same unsaved condition everywhere, only modified by surrounding circumstances, whether appearing as ancient heathen rites such as voodooism and cannibalism or as other forms of worldliness, and in the strict Bible sense all who are not in Christ are heathen.ST May 13, 1886ST May 6, 1897
They are powerless, impoverished efforts at self-salvation, including idolatrous practices and ordinances treated as necessary for salvation, and those freed from bondage to sin should not return to human practices as means of saving themselves.ST Feb 20, 1912 The Galatians had been freed from idolatry, but making circumcision a condition of salvation would turn them back to salvation by their own works and away from Christ.ST Feb 20, 1912 Turning from the Lord to self-justification and to gain salvation through unaided efforts leads back into bondage to weak and worthless religious practices, to bondage to the heathen gods and the observance of their days, months, seasons, and years in hope of salvation, while freedom comes through Christ who alone pardons and enables meeting the law's requirements.ST Aug 18, 1909ST Jun 3, 1886 The days, months, seasons, and years in the surrounding argument are human-devised practices or observances used as means of salvation, not God's appointed times, the Sabbath, the Lord's Supper, or His simple ordinances, and the verse contrasts that return with knowing God or, more fundamentally, being known by God.ST Feb 20, 1912ST Aug 18, 1909
In one understanding, they are the ceremonial law of Moses, the law of commandments contained in ordinances, the law of enmity written by Moses and placed beside the ark, distinct from the moral law spoken by God, written on stone and placed in the ark, of which the seventh-day Sabbath is a part. They are the old Jewish ceremonial feasts and holy days, done away at the cross, shadows whose appointed purpose ended when Christ came, dispensations changed, and priestly work transferred from earth to heaven, so that restoring them as living service is going back into bondage where Christ's atonement profits nothing.ST Nov 11, 1930ST Jan 24, 1900 The days associated with that bondage are ceremonial observances, not the weekly Sabbath, for the weekly Sabbath was established at creation and commanded in the moral law while ceremonial feasts, new moons, and sabbaths were not binding after the ceremonial law was done away. Remembering Moses' law to understand the sanctuary and its types does not mean restoring its ceremonies as a living service, and the beggarly element identified with a short-lived Jewish ordinance pointing to Christ and ending with His death is distinguished from the Sabbath and the other moral commandments which are universally binding and have no beginning or ending with those rites.ST Jan 24, 1900RH Apr 7, 1851RH Sep 20, 1853
In the opposing understanding, they cannot mean the ceremonies of the Levitical law or a return to the Jewish ritual.RH Jul 18, 1854RH Aug 27, 1857RH Aug 27, 1857 Those ceremonies were required in the service of the true God under the former dispensation, were never contrary to the knowledge of God, were never observed by those who knew not God, and their observance never was service to beings which by nature are no gods.RH Jul 18, 1854 The Gentile converts when they knew not God did service to false gods and now desired again to be in bondage to that former pagan service, expressed in observing days and months and times and years, so to make the ritual originate in false gods would be absurd.RH Jul 18, 1854RH Aug 27, 1857 The Gentile Galatians had not previously observed the Jewish ritual, so adoption of it could not be a return to something once practiced, and their days, months, times, and years were former heathen festivals observed before conversion, not the annual festivals of the ceremonial law, and their return to former heathen practices was what caused alarm.ST Jul 29, 1880RH Aug 27, 1857
Bondage Freedom Law Faith
Paul's appeal belongs to his warning against departure from the faith and falling away from Christ, for false teachers through vain philosophy were leading those who had come to know God back into bondage to weak religious practices and to pagan beliefs about God, the soul, and duty to the Maker, with their keeping of days, months, seasons and years marking that return to worship of beings that are not truly gods.ST Mar 15, 1899ST Aug 24, 1904ST Dec 3, 1902
Bondage to those elements is slavery to sin, which is transgression of the law, and being under the law, being after the flesh, and being in bondage are the same condition of violation under condemnation.RH Aug 2, 1870ST Jun 24, 1886 Accepting pardoning grace removes that condemnation without giving permission to sin, for grace writes the law in the heart to be cherished and obeyed rather than left standing over as a condemning authority.ST Feb 20, 1912 Freedom comes through Christ alone, who pardons and so enables the righteousness of the law to be fulfilled in those freed from the carnal mind, while persisting in transgression and remaining under condemnation makes one the seed of the bondwoman and returning to idolatry makes one a child of the bondwoman.RH Aug 2, 1870 Even when the sinner agrees the law is good and desires to obey, sinful habit holds him helpless under sin's dominion until Christ delivers.ST Jun 24, 1886
That bondage is not obligation to keep God's commandments and not bondage to the Levitical law, for when the readers knew not God and served no-gods they were not keeping the true God's holy, just, good and spiritual law but following a heathen custom abominable to Him.RH Jul 18, 1854RH Aug 2, 1870ST Jul 15, 1880 Obedience to His commandments is not the condemned bondage, and their observance of times belonged to those former heathen practices, not to the Ten Commandments or the law of Moses.RH Aug 2, 1870ST Jul 15, 1880 Redemption from the curse proves they had been under its curse by transgression and proves the law continues, for had they kept it they would never have come under its curse and had it been abolished there would be no curse to redeem them from, and that redemption was necessary so that the blessing of Abraham might come upon the Gentiles, showing transgression shuts out from that blessing.RH Aug 2, 1870 Read with Galatians 5:14 and with Romans 3 and 7, the argument in Galatians 3-4 is consistent with the continuing importance of God's law and presents Christ as redeeming from the curse of the moral law into freedom from sin.RH Dec 1850RH Jul 25, 1854
Turning from wholehearted faith in Christ in hope that fleshly descent from Abraham will secure heirship to the promises repeats the same error, for physical descent is not enough: the children of the flesh are not counted as God's children, but the children born by promise are counted as Abraham's seed.ST Mar 22, 1899 Natural descent from Jacob likewise does not guarantee remaining God's chosen people, for those once named as His people with their children could be rejected.RH Jan 26, 1860
The epistle's central message is salvation through faith in Jesus Christ, not reliance on human actions to save, and seeking another means of justification repudiates Christ and rejects the freedom found in Him.ST Nov 21, 1911ST Sep 15, 1909 The verse stands between bondage illustrated by the old covenant, which can only bring bondage and must be cast out with the bondwoman and her son, and freedom illustrated by the new covenant.ST Nov 21, 1911ST Sep 15, 1909 Jerusalem which is above is free and is the mother of the children of promise, understood as the New Jerusalem to which Isaiah's words about the Maker as husband apply.RH Jan 31, 1871
God's people are begotten through the truth in this life with the spirit of adoption as pledge of what is to come, sealed while waiting for the resurrection when their bodies are redeemed and they are born as free children entering the kingdom when the Son makes them free indeed, in contrast with the bondage to which the verse warns against returning.RH Mar 20, 1856 The world's beggarly elements are powerless to add anything to redemption, for believers are redeemed from them by a full and complete redemption that no human supplement can increase, and to turn back is to become subject to them again after knowing God and being known by Him.ST Oct 24, 1911
Observing Days and Times
The return to bondage is proved by observing days and months and times and years, which joins turning back to weak bondage under law to the contrast of freedom and inheritance through Christ.ST Mar 15, 1899ST Aug 23, 1910ST Jan 3, 1905ST Feb 13, 1896 These times are the heathen religious times from when the readers did not know God and served those which by nature are no gods.ST Aug 23, 1910ST Jul 15, 1880ST Jan 3, 1905ST Feb 13, 1896ST Apr 4, 1906 That means keeping the old heathen calendar with the year marked out and devoted to different deities and the months for worship of the moon.ST Aug 23, 1910ST Feb 13, 1896 Their observance of days, months, seasons, and years was participation in idolatrous customs, and this return to bondage made Paul fear his labor had been in vain.ST Mar 15, 1899ST Jan 3, 1905ST Feb 13, 1896
Among those observances was Sunday, the ancient first day of the week devoted to the sun, the wild solar holiday of all pagan times kept by nearly all pagan nations.ST Jun 8, 1915ST Aug 23, 1910ST Jul 10, 1901ST Jul 16, 1902ST Sep 24, 1896 It is identified as the chief idolatrous day, and turning back included sun-worship and its festivals.ST Jun 8, 1915ST Jan 3, 1905ST Feb 13, 1896ST Jun 18, 1902 Its observance as a holy day came not from apostolic precept or example, for the apostles did not keep Sunday as Sabbath or holy day and the early Christians did not keep it until they turned back in this way.ST Jun 8, 1915ST Apr 2, 1896 Sunday observance as a holy day therefore came from a return to heathenism, which may already have begun to appear at that early time.ST Jun 8, 1915ST Apr 2, 1896
For those who have known God to keep pagan holy days is to turn back again to weak and powerless bondage, and Paul feared for such keepers that his labor on them had been wasted.ST Jul 29, 1913ST Apr 20, 1904ST Jun 4, 1885 This includes weekly Sunday observance in honor of the sun, Easter, and Saturnalia-derived celebrations, as well as Christmas, Lent, Good Friday, Passion Week, papal holidays, and church days and seasons on a Roman foundation.ST Jul 29, 1913ST Apr 20, 1904ST Jun 4, 1885ST Apr 2, 1896ST Apr 9, 1894 These are wholly of men with no Scripture authority and traceable to pagan and idolatrous customs, especially Christmas, Easter, and Sunday, and to continue to observe Sunday in the face of increasing light makes void a command of God.ST Apr 20, 1904ST Apr 2, 1896ST Apr 9, 1894 The Roman Church has gone far beyond those heathen elements with its list of occasions, many made over from heathen festivities and many grown out of its own idolatry, while Protestant churches in observing the other feasts come to outdo Rome with ornate services and appeals to the senses and even propose to go beyond Rome in observing times and years on a Roman foundation.ST Apr 2, 1896ST Apr 9, 1894 Keeping them obscures God's light and brings weakness, for when the living constant witness designed of God is silenced by sin and selfishness human devices are invented to fill the vacancy, whereas God's witnesses to the power of the resurrection are the lives of regenerated human beings not on Sundays or dress-parade days but every day in all the transactions of life, and to keep up these observances the church is compelled to use force and appeal to the civil power, so the call is to turn from tradition to God's holy word and to the truth as it is in Christ Jesus.ST Apr 2, 1896ST Apr 9, 1894
The days, months, seasons, and years they began observing were pagan religious observances, not Jewish days, not God's appointed times, Sabbath, Lord's Supper, or simple ordinances.ST Dec 13, 1883ST Jul 15, 1880ST Jun 18, 1902ST Apr 4, 1906ST Mar 15, 1899 They were heathen observances including sun-worship festivals used as means of salvation, not keeping the Ten Commandments or law of Moses.ST Dec 13, 1883ST Jun 18, 1902ST Apr 4, 1906ST Mar 15, 1899 The verse therefore has nothing whatever to do with the Sabbath of the Lord or any of God's appointments or requirements, and does not classify the seventh-day Sabbath as a heathen practice or burden of rites and ceremonies, for God promised that honoring the Sabbath would bring delight in Him.ST Dec 13, 1883ST Jul 15, 1880ST Jun 18, 1902ST Mar 15, 1899
The weak and beggarly elements are idolatry, not observance of the seventh-day Sabbath.RH Oct 1, 1901ST Apr 27, 1904RH Jun 22, 1869 The Sabbath was given as a sign of having nothing to do with the beggarly elements of the world, so turning to those elements does not begin Sabbath observance but gives it up, for pollution of the Sabbath comes before going back into idolatry.RH Oct 1, 1901 In this setting the warning applies to Christians who abandon the Lord's seventh-day Sabbath and adopt pagan observances as a return to bondage.RH Oct 1, 1901ST Apr 27, 1904 Keeping the seventh day as God's appointed weekly rest is not treating days and times as the essence of Christianity or returning to Jewish ordinances.RH Jun 22, 1869 A supposed weekly cycle that begins with God's seventh day and ends with His sixth was not the week God ordained, and God's weeks have remained unchanged.ST May 1, 1879
The return reflects apostasy already beginning in the Christian church in apostolic times, with the Galatians turning back to pagan observances after knowing God and being known by Him.ST Jun 19, 1907ST Feb 23, 1915ST Apr 8, 1897 This turning back includes the origin of pagan days entering the church.ST Jun 19, 1907 The Galatian believers had begun observing days God had not commanded, described as a return to bondage to heathen religious practices that were weak and beggarly elements, not teachings of God.ST Feb 23, 1915ST Apr 8, 1897 Lawlessness had already begun entering the church through unconverted people, linked to the mystery of iniquity at work before the man of sin was fully revealed, causing fear that labor was in vain.ST Feb 23, 1915ST Apr 8, 1897ST Mar 12, 1896
It is disputed whether Galatians 4:8-10 refers to the seventh-day Sabbath or the yearly sabbaths of the Mosaic law, with the demand for proof before applying it to observances established by Israel's God and the question whether those who once did not know God observed either kind of Sabbath while serving gods that are not gods.ST Jul 31, 1879 The weight of teaching rejects using the warning to abolish the Sabbath law or to turn it into a general duty to keep every day holy, arguing that the Sabbath command remains definite and binding rather than being replaced by Sunday observance or by an indefinite seventh part of one's time.ST Jul 31, 1879RH May 15, 1856ST Apr 5, 1883 It likewise rejects treating the Sabbath as a short-lived Jewish ordinance, teaching that the Sabbath is distinct from abolished rites and belongs with the enduring moral law.RH May 15, 1856ST Apr 5, 1883 Beside this stands the teaching of those who held that treating particular days as holy by divine ordinance amounts to returning to bondage under the law, presenting this as Paul's view of Jewish observances and regarding it as incompatible with Christianity.RH Jun 11, 1857
Apostasy Perseverance and Doctrine
Coming to know God does not make turning back impossible, for conversion is a complete turning around that still leaves a person capable of returning to the world's weak and beggarly elements and becoming bound to them again.ST Apr 28, 1909RH Dec 29, 1859 Continued spiritual life and salvation therefore require perseverance, and the warning applies especially to believers who grow weary and give way to temptation by going back to their former ways.ST Apr 28, 1909RH Dec 29, 1859 Life received at conversion is not held in a way that cannot be lost, since one who has come to know God and received life can still turn back to weak elements and come again into bondage.ST Aug 1, 1916
What is needed is genuine inward renewal rather than mere outward profession, for Christ dwelling within by faith is the hope of glory.RH Apr 9, 1857 Without Christ within there is no well-grounded hope, so believers must examine whether Christ is in them.RH Apr 9, 1857 Reliance on Jewish ceremonies did not simply exchange Christianity for Judaism, but led toward former heathenism and its religious forms and ceremonies. The same turning is seen in the corruption of pure faith when heathen ideas, speculative philosophies, and human traditions displace Christ and God's Word and bring people into bondage to weak, impoverished religious practices.ST Nov 23, 1904
The verse has been invoked to argue that the Sinai covenant brings bondage and that keeping the Ten Commandments therefore enslaves and excludes from the inheritance.RH Sep 10, 1872 That conclusion is rejected, because keeping the commandments cannot itself enslave someone who is still expected to keep nine of them.RH Sep 10, 1872 The Sabbath is not oppressive but a rest made for humanity and a delight, and only the carnal mind finds honoring God's holy time burdensome.RH Sep 10, 1872 It has likewise been invoked in dispute over whether keeping the seventh-day Sabbath puts one in bondage to the law or means falling from grace.RH Aug 4, 1853 Those charges are the claims of opponents against Sabbath-keepers, challenged as inconsistent when their own arguments imply observance of the seventh day.RH Aug 4, 1853
Warning and Christian Living
Those who have known God and are known by Him can still turn back into bondage to weak and worthless powers.ST Sep 22, 1914RH Sep 19, 1871 After finding pardon, communion with God, and freedom from sin, yielding to temptation and losing hold of God is a return to sin's slavery.ST Sep 22, 1914 It is a strange desire to take up again the fetters from which Christ set the soul free.ST Sep 22, 1914 Those once enlightened may become absorbed in what can be seen, felt, and heard until faith grows lifeless, spiritual powers are blunted, Satan takes them captive, and they forsake God's work through love of the world rather than returning fully and heartily to it.RH Sep 19, 1871
Turning back after knowledge is a return to former defilement and worthless worldly ways in bondage.ST Apr 29, 1903 It is forcibly pictured by a sow going back to wallow in the mire and a dog eating its own vomit.ST Apr 29, 1903 The elements include worldly tinsel and pleasures that draw hearts away from truth, fleeting and short-lived, such as amusements serving only the senses without nourishing moral or intellectual life.ST Feb 17, 1881RH Feb 2, 1860RH Aug 1, 1907 Sunday newspapers are one influence that can encourage this drift in children away from what their parents profess to love.RH Aug 1, 1907 A beloved child won by prayer may apostatize to beggarly ways, causing sorrow too deep for words like Paul's when Demas forsook him in greatest need and trial, yet hope remains through prayer as Jesus answers and the Spirit calls the wanderer back while the hungry heart keeps seeking other souls to win as jewels for the King's diadem.ST Jan 9, 1912
The church itself can despise its heavenly birthright by exchanging its heritage for these beggarly elements and returning to spiritual bondage.ST Sep 13, 1905 Such pleasures are shed not by forceful denunciation but as new love for God takes hold and conscience is quickened, with the response being to keep moving forward rather than turn back.ST Feb 17, 1881RH Feb 2, 1860 Refusing to turn back means having no desire to return to former error after God has made a person free, but pressing toward the promised reward and the kingdom without returning to former ways.RH Feb 17, 1859 It means the worldly life left at conversion is left behind as bondage, forsaking sin with its companions, pursuits, and attachments that hinder the journey to the heavenly country, waiting on the Lord and keeping all God's commandments and the faith of Jesus even when crooked paths have been made.RH Oct 15, 1861RH Dec 26, 1865
The weak and beggarly elements of earthly life offer no lasting reward, in contrast to life under Christ bringing joy, peace, true holiness, and everlasting life, so returning to the former is returning to bondage to sin from which release comes through death to sin.ST Aug 31, 1915 The sinful world and its attractions are the weak and worthless things to which those who know God and are known by Him must not be drawn back, and hope of Christ's soon coming keeps believers from desiring them.RH Oct 15, 1903 The elements are also dead religious forms and ceremonies that cannot save, especially when relied on while conforming to the world, which is passing again under sin's yoke instead of living faith in Jesus who cleanses from sin and fills the soul with God's fullness.RH Apr 11, 1865 They are vain philosophy and inherited traditions displacing Scripture, mystifying its plain teachings, denying the bodily resurrection and ridiculing being caught up in the air, so the course is to refuse such preaching and meet for prayer, Scripture reading, encouragement, and singing.RH Aug 19, 1851RH Nov 26, 1861
Abandoning the Bible for human tradition and accepting preaching that explains away plain Scripture is this return to bondage.RH Nov 26, 1861 Doctrines are good when the soul has Christ first, but doctrines presented without Him confuse and leave souls outside both Christ and the doctrines.RH Nov 6, 1900 Treating duties of the Christian life as beneath concern is to make them beggarly elements, for religious talk, zeal for particular beliefs, and pride in a minister are not genuine piety without duties done and godly tempers formed.RH Jun 12, 1856 Falling back into habitual tobacco use and giving up the Lord's Sabbath to find employment is turning again to bondage, leaving a correct position still acknowledged as right for a scattered low state with no mercy expected unless there is speedy repentance and first works. That turning is also shown by saying the Lord delays His coming instead of remaining faithful and ready for His return.RH Jul 26, 1864
Limited knowledge from natural science of earth and stars is weak and beggarly compared with Scripture, which opens heaven, God's glory, Christ's intercession, angels, and the perfected righteous. The danger includes abandoning Sabbath-keeping if persecution comes.RH Oct 20, 1859 The things of this world are disobedience to God's commandments, and to turn to them is to remain a sinner unreconciled to God, while leaving them is reconciliation by learning His commandments in Exodus 20 and obeying them, escaping everlasting shame and receiving right to the tree of life, entrance through the gates into the city, and the kingdom under the whole heaven.RH Dec 4, 1860
Turning again means resolving after a time to go back to the world, remaining enslaved by unrelinquished carnal inclinations, giving up building a pure holy character, becoming blind to eternal riches and Christ's sacrifice, becoming ashamed of Jesus under scorn, associating with His persecutors, and failing to endure to the end, proving cost was not counted and conversion had not occurred.ST Jul 28, 1898 None doing this is worthy to be called a disciple, who must always side with truth, press close to Jesus without faltering, and serve as a brave whole-hearted soldier.ST Jul 28, 1898 It is turning from Christ's righteousness to reject God's precepts, especially the Sabbath, and dishonoring God by misusing what is His.RH Dec 17, 1901 It is staying in sinning and repenting under fleshly lusts warring against the soul, after Christ opened prison doors into light and liberty, with liberty taken by living faith in His life and indwelling Spirit and maintained by daily faith unto perfection.RH Oct 5, 1916
To turn again is to go back to union of church and state after having been set free from it.ST Feb 11, 1897 That return misrepresents practical Christianity by limiting its free exercise through religious legislation.ST Feb 11, 1897 It changes free government into religious autocracy under the claim of making a Christian nation.ST Feb 11, 1897
Sources