The Lord spoke to Cain after rejecting his fruit offering while accepting Abel and his lamb, leaving Cain very angry with fallen, downcast face.RH Mar 3, 1874RH Jun 25, 1901RH Mar 10, 1868ST Jul 1, 1889ST Nov 1, 1899 He asked not from lack of knowledge but to make Cain reflect on his conduct, recognize that the fault lay wholly in himself, and repent and return to obedience.ST Dec 16, 1886ST Jul 14, 1898 Cain was rejected because he followed his own way in partial obedience, bringing produce without blood and without faith in the promised Redeemer, seeking approval by his own toil and merit while Abel obeyed by faith.ST Dec 16, 1886ST Jul 1, 1889ST Mar 10, 1898ST Dec 22, 1898 His wrath and fallen countenance were directed against Abel because Abel's acceptance and righteous works exposed his disobedience, and that cherished anger and envy were the first step toward murder.ST Dec 18, 1879RH Jun 25, 1901RH Mar 10, 1868ST Jun 24, 1897ST Mar 25, 1889 In them stand two opposing classes continuing to the end, Abel's voluntary service of love, trust, and obedience against Cain's self-interested departure from God's word in unbelief and disobedience.ST Aug 13, 1894ST Aug 28, 1884ST Sep 1, 1909
Immediate Setting Described
The question comes after the Lord refused Cain's offering while accepting Abel and his offering, leaving Cain very angry with fallen countenance and downcast face.RH Jun 25, 1901RH Mar 10, 1868ST Jul 1, 1889ST Jul 14, 1898RH Jun 27, 1878 His cheaper offering had failed to secure divine approval, blessing, and forgiveness, and his vexation and envy as a rejected worshiper turned toward the one accepted by God.RH Jun 25, 1901RH Mar 10, 1868ST Jul 14, 1898 The Lord confronted him about his anger and dejected look, calling him to recognize his state and turn from it, and telling him that doing well would bring acceptance.ST Jul 1, 1889ST Jul 14, 1898RH Jun 27, 1878ST Jul 14, 1898 Cain stayed rebellious and hateful, and his jealousy grew into hatred and his anger finally led him to murder Abel in the field.RH Jun 25, 1901RH Jun 27, 1878
Cain had brought of the fruit of the ground, even flour, while Abel had brought of the firstlings of his flock.RH Mar 3, 1874ST Nov 1, 1899RH Oct 8, 1872 Abel's lamb, whose blood expressed repentance for sin and faith in a Redeemer and coming Saviour, was accepted by fire from heaven, while Cain's produce without blood expressed refusal to submit to God's appointed offering and proud rejection of dependence on a Saviour.RH Mar 3, 1874ST Dec 25, 1901RH Oct 8, 1872 Abel offered by faith according to God's plan and obtained witness that he was righteous, but Cain did not do well and did not have faith, so God had respect to Abel and his offering and not to Cain and his offering.ST Dec 25, 1901ST Jul 1, 1889RH Jun 26, 1855 Cain's offering was doubly defective in lacking both obedience and faith, with either defect enough to insure rejection, since no one can offer in faith what God never commanded.RH Oct 8, 1872 His anger arose from this refusal, was directed against Abel because Abel as the younger brother was accepted while he was rejected and because Abel maintained that God is just, and, left open to doubts and rebellion, it grew into madness against God and Abel.RH Mar 3, 1874ST Dec 25, 1901
The broader account traces Cain leaving the Lord's presence manifested at the gate of Paradise to settle in Nod at a distance, desiring to be separated from God.RH Dec 23, 1915ST Oct 16, 1879 His posterity for six generations is traced from his birth nearly to the time of the flood, including Enoch and Lamech, and was wholly irreligious, a civilization that forgot God and lived for the present world.RH Dec 23, 1915RH Dec 25, 1913ST Oct 16, 1879ST Sep 5, 1895 The Lamech in Cain's line took two wives and killed a man and was distinct from the Lamech in Seth's line, who fathered Noah, and Cain's family line beginning with a murderer later produced Lamech, another murderer.RH Dec 23, 1915RH Dec 25, 1913 Through character and development of his line Cain stands as the beginning and leader of the ungodly line distinguished from the godly line descended from Seth, standing before the record of descendants skilled in metal-working and music.ST Jul 27, 1915ST Dec 29, 1909 The entire family of Cain perished in the flood, while Eve's hope passed from Cain to Seth given to take Abel's place.ST Oct 16, 1879
The births, murder, and six generations of Cain's descendants are not in strict chronological order, for Bible events are not always given in chronological order.ST Sep 5, 1895 The birth of Seth and of Adam's other sons and daughters recorded afterward belongs earlier in time, and Seth and other children of Adam, and perhaps children of Seth, may already have been born.ST Sep 5, 1895ST Feb 3, 1904 So Cain's wife was one of the daughters of Adam or of Seth, and his fear of being killed after Abel's death reflected the presence of other people descended from Adam and Eve, whose growing family could already have included many people.ST Sep 5, 1895RH Dec 1, 1863ST Feb 3, 1904 His waiting until he and Abel were alone suggests that others had been present at their shared worship gathering.RH Jun 6, 1912 The Lord spoke directly to Cain before Cain killed Abel, questioning his anger and fallen countenance as part of the Lord's instruction to him, and continued after the murder to communicate His will directly to people, including the wicked, as evidence that people had knowledge of God before the giving of the law at Sinai.RH Jun 23, 1903RH Oct 18, 1853
Cain dealt Abel a stunning murderous blow beside the altar where Abel had made his offering, in the field, while Abel was confessing his sins in a solemn act of worship when his life went out.ST Jan 18, 1877ST Feb 16, 1915ST Apr 1, 1880 His rage was still unappeased beside that altar when he struck.ST Jan 18, 1877 Because the dead sleep unconsciously and do not realize passing time, Abel when he awakes will seem to have just arisen from that blow, will look for the altar and expect to see his angry brother near with rage still unappeased, and until informed will be unable to believe centuries have passed while sleeping in the grave.ST Jan 18, 1877
Purpose Of God's Question
The Lord's question to Cain about his anger and fallen countenance was not asked from lack of knowledge, for He knew Cain's resentment, but to confront him with it and make him reflect on his course and conduct, recognize his state and sin, and turn to repentance and return to obedience.ST Dec 16, 1886ST Jul 14, 1898ST Jul 14, 1898 The inquiry called Cain to consider his response after his offering was rejected and gave him opportunity to choose rightly, with warning that acceptance depends on doing well and that sin lies at the door if he does not.ST Jul 14, 1898ST Jul 14, 1898RH Aug 7, 1860 The fault exposed by the question was not in God but wholly in Cain himself, because something was not right with him in that he did not do well and did not have faith, while Abel offered by faith and obtained witness that he was righteous.ST Dec 16, 1886ST Dec 25, 1901ST Jul 1, 1889 Cain had no just cause for wrath against his brother or against God, since his own disregard of God's plainly stated will and expressed requirements had led to the rejection of his offering.ST Dec 16, 1886ST Dec 25, 1901ST Feb 6, 1879 He had not been treated unjustly or with partiality, and his anger directed against Abel because the younger brother's offering was accepted while his own was rejected, and because Abel maintained that God is just, only showed his own disobedience in failing to bring what was required and his refusal to see that this had made his offering unacceptable and valueless.ST Dec 25, 1901ST Feb 6, 1879
God met Cain in mercy, love, and long-suffering and did not forsake him after wilful sin without true repentance, but came to seek him to turn him from sin to righteousness.ST Feb 6, 1879ST Jun 24, 1897RH Jun 27, 1878ST Jun 14, 1910 The question gave him opportunity to put wilfulness away from his heart and offer a broken and contrite heart that God will not despise, assuring him that doing well would bring acceptance.ST Sep 11, 1884RH Jun 27, 1878RH Jun 27, 1878ST Jun 14, 1910 There was blessing enough for both through the covenant of grace, and Cain too could receive blessing instead of envying the blessing given to Abel, for if he followed God's directions in humble faith and obedience God would accept his offering.ST Sep 11, 1884ST Feb 6, 1879ST Jun 24, 1897RH Jun 27, 1878 Cain instead stayed rebellious and hateful, chose his own course, trusted his own merits, remained resentful and blamed God, and his anger finally led him to murder Abel in the field.ST Sep 11, 1884ST Feb 6, 1879RH Jun 27, 1878RH Jun 27, 1878 Acceptance did not rest on one brother being elected to favor and the other to rejection, though Cain in his anger and fallen face accused God of partiality and injustice and thereby manifested an accusing spirit that led directly to violence against man.ST Dec 23, 1886ST Dec 24, 1902 Cain heard the same lessons of salvation as Abel and had the same privileges but did not improve them and ventured contrary to God's commands, so his wrath and fallen countenance were the result of his own disobedience, not of an arbitrary purpose of God, and the question proves acceptance rested wholly on doing or not doing as God had said.ST Dec 23, 1886RH Jan 15, 1875ST Dec 24, 1902 God shows no partiality, for Abel was respected because he offered by faith, and Cain too would be accepted on doing well, which also shows as guilty one conscious of guilt that moral law was already revealed and binding, since sin and guilt cannot exist where there is no law, including the law forbidding murder.RH Jan 15, 1875
God's meeting with Cain in love to turn him from sin to righteousness belongs among His repeated lessons about obedience and disobedience, showing that righteousness is life and sin is death and that God's standards are eternally just.ST May 7, 1894STST Aug 13, 1896 The question teaches that righteousness enlightens while sin blinds and deceives, that the reward of obedience and the fearful result of disobedience are certain, that God's precepts and institutions are holy and He accepts no substitute for them, and that God's love longs and is mighty to save sinners from sin to righteousness so that responsive love and gratitude lead to careful faithfulness in His service.ST Aug 13, 1896 Cain rejected God's promised way of salvation while Abel accepted it in faith, and this example of the two ways carries the same lesson of the certainty of God's dealing with obedience and disobedience.ST May 7, 1894STST Aug 13, 1896
Reason Offering Rejected
Cain wished to have his own way about what to offer, bringing a human substitution that God had not directed instead of just what God declared to be His will, and though he built an altar and brought a sacrifice his obedience was only partial.ST Dec 16, 1886ST Mar 10, 1898RH Mar 16, 1916 His offering was doubly defective in lacking both obedience and faith, and contained no evidence of faith in the promised Offering for sin, so God could not accept it and acceptance turned wholly on doing what God required rather than on sincerity or effort.ST Jul 1, 1889ST Mar 10, 1898ST Dec 22, 1898ST Jul 16, 1894 Cain did not do well and did not have faith, while Abel offered by faith and obtained witness that he was righteous.ST Jul 1, 1889ST Dec 22, 1898
Cain saw no necessity for blood and offered produce without the blood that expressed repentance for sin and faith in the promised Offering, the Redeemer, and the coming Saviour.RH Mar 3, 1874ST Dec 23, 1886ST Mar 10, 1898ST Jul 1, 1889 He could not believe God would be very particular, fed upon doubts and cherished unbelief, and would worship only according to his own ideas, which was not worship of God at all but of a god of his own making, which was self.RH Mar 3, 1874ST Jul 1, 1889 The essential part left out was recognition of the need of a Redeemer, though in building an altar and bringing a sacrifice there was outward obedience.ST Dec 23, 1886
Cain presented the fruits of the ground cultivated by his own toil as a favor done to God by which he expected to secure divine approval, blessing, and forgiveness.ST Sep 11, 1884ST Dec 23, 1886ST Oct 1, 1902 He came as one righteous and as thinking himself righteous, without confessing sin or recognizing his need for mercy, while Abel came as a sinner whose hope was God's unmerited love with blood pointing to the Lamb of God.RH Mar 3, 1874ST Dec 23, 1886 He exalted his own judgment above God, trusted his own merits and hard labor, determined to bring an offering according to his own ideas, and sought to please God by his own work.ST Sep 11, 1884ST Jan 9, 1896ST Oct 1, 1902 His own works were evil because they were his own, and work that is of man comes to nothing.ST Oct 1, 1902
Abel obeyed God's express direction and offered by faith according to God's plan, seeing meaning in the blood of the lamb slain by his own hands, obtaining witness that he was righteous with God testifying of his gifts.ST Jan 9, 1896ST Jul 1, 1889ST Mar 9, 1888ST Jul 1, 1889 His works were righteous because they were the work of the Spirit, not his own, God working in him to will and to do of His good pleasure, so that his sins were forgiven and his soul was saved through believing the gospel of Christ and bringing the offering God commanded.ST Mar 9, 1888ST Oct 1, 1902 By contrast Cain's disobedience exposed by Abel's obedience showed disloyalty, selfishness, love of self rather than supreme love for God, and opposition to God, with Cain as a type of unbelief and hatred and disobedience set against Abel as a type of faith and love and obedience.RH Jul 10, 1860ST Oct 1, 1902ST Sep 1, 1909 Abel would not abandon the true way and leave God's way for Cain's way, yet Cain would not abandon his self-chosen worship and accept the true way.RH Jul 10, 1860
Cain heeded the deceiver rather than God's command, and Satan instigated him and planned against the favored one.RH Jun 26, 1900RH Jun 26, 1855ST Jan 30, 1896 Satan deceived him into believing that one offering is as good as another so long as it is offered to God, a cunning imitation of God's genuine institutions and true worship that began a gradual estrangement from God leading onward to worship of false gods.ST Jan 30, 1896 Cain had expected acceptance because he believed his offering was suitable, supposing God regarded persons rather than offerings and would have accepted the same offering from Abel.ST Jul 16, 1894RH Sep 13, 1870 He was envious as the eldest that respect was denied him, believed God favored Abel, and his jealous brooding made him imagine himself increasingly mistreated until he could see no justice in the rejection, with jealousy cherished until it led to murder.ST Sep 28, 1904RH Sep 13, 1870ST Sep 28, 1904 The rejection was not because he was Cain but because he was a self-willed, sin-loving sinner, since penitent, humble, confessing sinners can come with offerings but self-willed sinners will not be accepted because sacrifice does not cover sin without obedience.RH Sep 13, 1870 His rebellion in bringing a substitute offering without blood is presented as leading to a curse with no remedy.ST Nov 9, 1915
Anger Ripening Into Murder
Cain was angry because God blessed Abel while his own offering was rejected, and his wrath, jealousy, envy and hatred were directed against Abel because Abel's acceptance and righteous works exposed and condemned his own disobedience and evil course.ST Dec 25, 1901RH Jun 25, 1901RH Mar 10, 1868ST Mar 25, 1889ST Aug 1, 1916 His cheaper offering had failed to secure approval, blessing and forgiveness, and instead of receiving the blessing God still offered him — for there was blessing enough for both through the covenant of grace — he envied the blessing given to Abel.RH Jun 25, 1901ST Jun 24, 1897 As the elder brother he was jealous that respect was denied him while the younger was accepted, and because Abel maintained that God is just and would not leave God's way for his way, Cain argued with him and refused to see that his own failure to bring what was required had made his offering unacceptable and valueless.ST Dec 25, 1901ST Aug 1, 1916 That vexation of a rejected worshiper toward one accepted grew from jealousy into hatred and then into murder, the first murder.RH Jun 25, 1901RH Mar 10, 1868ST Aug 1, 1916
The wrath and fallen countenance mark the first step toward murder and a turning away from God, for angry feelings allowed in the heart and cherished jealousy grow into envy and hatred and result in taking a life that only God can give.ST Dec 18, 1879ST Mar 25, 1889ST Sep 28, 1904ST May 22, 1884 Such feelings must be guarded against and brought under control, lest they make a person a partaker with the devil, who was a murderer from the beginning, and a quick temper must not be thought harmless merely because it passes quickly.ST Mar 25, 1889ST May 22, 1884 Cherished until it led to murder, Cain's jealousy with its sense of being wronged made him angry and despondent, and as people persist in sin and harden their hearts the spirit of murderous hatred is formed until each further temptation is easier to yield to.ST Dec 18, 1879ST Sep 28, 1904
Cain's anger as a work of the flesh warred against the soul, moved his bosom and maddened his brain, giving him a fallen countenance, and because he did not abstain he murdered his righteous brother who walked with God.ST Mar 9, 1888RH Jun 27, 1878RH Mar 19, 1867 He was very angry and downcast when his offering was refused while Abel and his offering were accepted, and though challenged about his anger and dejected look and told that doing well would bring acceptance, he stayed rebellious and hateful until his wrath led him to kill Abel in the field, waiting until they were alone.RH Jun 27, 1878RH Jun 6, 1912 This gives a striking illustration of what man became when he sinned after the fall, losing self-control, the fear and love of God, and love toward neighbor, and becoming selfish, with covetousness, envy and desire for power bringing murder into human society.ST Apr 22, 1903ST Oct 17, 1895
His anger and fallen countenance were outward signs of inner hatred, jealousy, selfishness and a rebellious, murmuring spirit toward God after his offering was not accepted, standing in contrast to Abel's meek submission to God's authority.ST Dec 16, 1886RH Sep 13, 1870 Disposition was visible in his face, illustrating that a person's character can shape appearance, while a lovely disposition makes a face lovely.RH Sep 13, 1870 Their offerings tested whether they would obey God's requirements, which taught that sin brings death and that people come to God through the promised Redeemer.ST Dec 16, 1886
Cain hated righteousness and loved evil, hating not sin but its punishment and hating all who did not suffer with him, hating the good because it was good.RH Sep 13, 1870 He did wrong yet tried to throw its consequences on the innocent, slaying his brother both because his own works were evil and because his brother's were righteous.RH Sep 13, 1870 His anger and fallen face were an accusation that God was partial and unjust in dealing with him and his brother, manifesting Satan's accusing spirit, and that accusation against God led directly to violence against man.RH Sep 13, 1870ST Dec 24, 1902 That same spirit marks the last days, when men are despisers of those that are good, feeling no pleasure or freedom among the refined, elevated and godly but at home with the giddy, reckless and sensual, watching every act and word of the godly for evil while remaining sanctimonious and crying charity when reproved; though such persons pray and bring offerings as Cain did, while they keep his spirit they and their offerings will be rejected, for hatred is murder concealed in God's sight and his followers are very numerous even among those who bring an offering.RH Sep 13, 1870
His crime violated the second great commandment, the principle of love for others and their equal rights, and was a transgression of the moral law.ST Apr 13, 1915 His worship was profane, and envy of his brother and covetousness of his fortune led him to murder, followed by lying and falsehood to conceal the crime, violating at least four distinct commands of the Decalogue and showing that God's moral law was in force before it was written at Sinai.RH Jan 18, 1870ST Jul 9, 1874
When rebuked and punished he did not repent but murmured at his punishment, blamed God, and went out from God's presence manifested at the gate of Paradise to dwell at a distance, desiring separation from God, leaving in hopeless despair unlike Abel who had hope in Christ.ST Feb 6, 1879ST Oct 16, 1879ST Jan 17, 1884 He blinded himself to light, hardened his conscience, and would not acknowledge himself a lost and undone sinner in need of a Saviour, refusing in unbelief to offer in faith the blood of the Son of God by which transgressions are transferred to Christ and the repenting sinner is declared sinless by Christ's righteousness.ST Jan 16, 1896ST Jun 14, 1910 Refusal to repent and a determined wilful course leads step by step away from God until the conscience is hardened and seared and can no longer hear His call, though God came to seek him with love and long-suffering to give opportunity to put wilfulness away and offer a broken and contrite heart.ST Dec 18, 1879ST Jun 14, 1910
Law Existing Before Sinai
Cain’s sin was a transgression counted against him, proving God’s holy moral law existed before it was given at Sinai.RH Apr 13, 1876RH Mar 26, 1901RH Jan 15, 1875ST Sep 17, 1902 His anger itself was sin, and the warning that sin lay at the door shows that sin is transgression of God’s law, so the law was already in existence.RH Mar 26, 1901RH Jan 15, 1875 In violating the second great commandment, the principle of love for others and their equal rights, Cain transgressed the moral law.ST Apr 13, 1915 The command against killing was already binding on Adam and his descendants, and the history ending in Abel’s murder shows murder was sin in Cain’s day in violation of the sixth commandment.RH Jan 15, 1875RH Oct 11, 1864ST Sep 17, 1902 God confronted Cain over his anger and fallen countenance as a guilty person conscious of guilt, telling him he would be accepted if he did well but if not sin lay at his door, which means moral law was already revealed and binding from creation, including the law forbidding murder, because sin and guilt cannot exist where there is no law.RH Jan 15, 1875 God shows no partiality, for Abel was respected because he offered by faith, and Cain too would be accepted on doing well.RH Jan 15, 1875
The offerings of Cain and Abel show that sacrifices were practiced from that time until Moses, though worship had not yet been regulated by a formal system of ceremonies.RH Apr 13, 1876ST Sep 17, 1902 Cain’s offering of produce could not take the place of the prescribed lamb, so God rejected the substitute and warned Cain that sin was at the door.RH May 25, 1876 The ceremonial rites were not newly created at Sinai, and the law added 430 years after Abraham was not an original creation but the reducing of the pre-existing moral principles and typical rites to written form at Sinai.ST Sep 17, 1902
Two Worshipers Foreshadowed
Cain and Abel present two opposing systems of worship continuing to the end, Abel's voluntary service rooted in love, trust, faith and obedience set against Cain's departure from God's word driven by fear, self-interest, unbelief, hatred and disobedience.ST Aug 13, 1894ST Aug 28, 1884ST Sep 1, 1909 They are wheat and tares, the children of the kingdom and the children of the wicked one, already appearing in Adam's first sons and applying through the whole period to the close of the day of grace when sinners still need and may enjoy the means of grace.ST Aug 28, 1884RH Feb 10, 1874ST Apr 5, 1877 Abel chose true government, self-government under God and with God and in God according to His will and design, while Cain chose the way of Satan, the way of lawlessness and anarchy, and his wrath and killing of his brother strictly accord with that principle and manifest the spirit of its originator, the chief opponent of all government and hater of its principle. Cain gave place to disloyalty, envy, hatred and murder and was a tare, while Abel governed by loyalty, righteousness and truth was wheat, illustrating the appearance of evil alongside righteousness in the world, with both kinds continuing in the Abels and the Cains who have ever since blessed and cursed the earth.ST Aug 28, 1884ST Sep 1, 1909
Abel is God's first noble martyr, who would not compromise the truth to make union with Cain and save his life but died for its honor, while Cain in infidelity was stirred to madness by truth firmly held and slew him because his own works were evil and his brother's righteous.RH Jul 25, 1871ST Nov 13, 1893 Cain was the first man who tried to force his religion upon his fellow man, attacking his brother for worshiping according to God's requirements because Abel did not worship in Cain's way.ST Jan 17, 1911 Ruled by a selfish and perverse disposition, loving self rather than showing supreme love for God and lacking faith in the promised Lamb, he sought to compel Abel to follow his self-chosen sacrifice shaped by his own ideas and convenience, and Abel was killed for holding to freedom of conscience.ST Jul 30, 1894 This anger and downcast face after the difference between his worship and Abel's was the first manifestation of religious bigotry, in which Cain denied Abel the rights and privileges he claimed for himself, denying another the right to worship God and ultimately the right to life, marking wicked Cain and righteous Abel as an early example of persecutors of true religion.ST Dec 7, 1915ST Dec 7, 1915ST Mar 12, 1894
The same contest continues in the Sabbath controversy, for as God had respect for Abel's obedience and none for Cain's counterfeit, so first-day keepers grow angry and dejected because God respects the seventh-day keeper's offering and blesses him richly for obeying the Sabbath law while having no respect for their first-day offering of time and promising them no blessing for it. In that anger they take counsel together to destroy his influence and put him to shame, having him arrested and brought to court for not respecting the first day even while attending to his own business in his garden. God's rebuke shows He means what He says and accepts no substituted service, since without shedding of blood there is no remission and the spotless lamb shadowed the great sacrifice, which Abel believed and obeyed by faith unto witness that he was righteous while Cain lacked faith and fidelity; to keep Sunday instead of the seventh day God required to be observed as holy is to follow Cain's example.RH Sep 22, 1874 The same spirit of envy, jealousy, bitterness, malice and hate appears in those unreconciled to God's law toward those who magnify it as holy, just and good, and in those who ignore the plain command to keep the Sabbath while offering what God never commanded, then treat the obedient as Cain treated Abel.ST Jan 9, 1896 As Cain in anger at Abel for refusing to join his false worship slew him, and as the Jews persecuted Christ because He would not keep the Sabbath according to their ideas, so the controversy will end in an effort to put to death those who will not yield to keeping the Sabbath according to man's command, but God will work deliverance for His people.ST Aug 20, 1896 Cain's substitution is in principle the old covenant of works, man's substitute for free and full salvation in Christ putting man's efforts, vows, promises and power in place of God and gendering to bondage, the same principle as Israel's promise at Horeb to do God's will in their own strength while asking God to speak to them no more, and as the modern Sunday substitute, Sunday laws and salvation by works of various kinds, differing only in that then men proposed to do God's will in their own strength and now many propose to do their own will in God's strength.ST Jul 23, 1896
The account stands at the beginning of the controversy between truth and error and belongs to Satan's effort to destroy the promised Seed through Abel, for after Abel's bloody offering received favor through faith in a Saviour's blood, Satan planned his death.RH Jul 25, 1871RH Jun 26, 1855ST Abel lies dead in the shadow of the cross, having died in faith in the coming Saviour, while Cain is shown leaving God's presence in hopeless despair, unlike Abel who has hope in Christ, for the cross still offers the transgressor hope through repentance and faith in Christ.ST Jan 17, 1884RH May 27, 1873 From righteous Abel onward God has had His called-out ones in all ages, beginning His church with those turning from sin to God, with Adam and Eve and Abel heeding His call to come out from the world and join with Him, even when His church apostatizes and He must call a remnant out again.ST Apr 29, 1908
Practical Warnings Given
Cain's anger and fallen face warn that a quick temper is not harmless because it passes quickly, but must be resisted, guarded, and brought under control.ST Mar 25, 1889ST May 22, 1884 His wrath was envy that his brother's offering was accepted while his own was not, because his own works were evil and his brother's were righteous, and it marks the first step toward murder.ST Mar 25, 1889 Angry feelings allowed in the heart can grow into envy and hatred and end in taking a life that only God can give, so they must be guarded lest they make a person a partaker with the devil, who was a murderer from the beginning.ST Mar 25, 1889
God's question about anger and downcast face is followed by the assurance that doing well brings acceptance, and this teaches those who complain of not receiving responsibility that acceptance and advancement depend on faithful conduct, not on chance or human favoritism, for God determines who is raised up. Cain is an example of one who heard but did not do, offering his own works and expecting acceptance while angry at rejection.ST Jan 23, 1896 His wrath and fallen countenance came from selfishness, preferring his own course to the way God pointed out because God's way was contrary to natural desires.ST Jan 23, 1896 His attitude is that of those who say Lord, Lord and point to works, having a form of godliness but denying its power, an attitude that will prevail among professed Christians as the end approaches, while true following requires both hearing and doing, for not hearers but doers are justified, and his course ends in destruction.ST Jan 23, 1896
Opposition can deaden the sense of right, and the carnal mind blinded leads to the use of force against reform.ST Feb 1, 1883 Cain became angry and downcast toward his brother when he took the place of master and ruler over him in duties of worship toward God, and men do the same when they try to force even the simplest truths of worship upon others, soon growing angry with a dull or slow brother or a willful and stubborn one and wanting to bring punishment upon him.ST Jan 31, 1911 God meets such anger not with force but by continuing to love and bless, following after men and pleading with them in tenderness and pity.ST Jan 31, 1911 Since hatred is murder concealed in God's sight, Cain's followers are very numerous even among those who pray and bring offerings to the Lord.RH Sep 13, 1870 His anger and fallen countenance exposed a heart that hated righteousness and loved evil, doing wrong yet trying to throw its consequences on the innocent, hating not sin but its punishment and hating all who did not suffer with him, and slaying his brother both because his own works were evil and because his brother's were righteous, hating the good because it was good.RH Sep 13, 1870
That same spirit marks the last days, when men are despisers of those that are good, feeling no pleasure or freedom among the refined, elevated and godly but at home with the giddy, reckless and sensual, watching every act and word of the godly for evil while remaining sanctimonious and crying charity when reproved.RH Sep 13, 1870 Though such persons pray and bring offerings as Cain did, while they keep Cain's spirit they and their offerings will fare as he and his fared, rejected by God.RH Sep 13, 1870 The account gives repeated lessons about obedience and disobedience, showing that righteousness is life and sin is death and that God's standards are eternally just.ST It sets forth the contrasting patterns of faith and unbelief and the fruit of each, teaching that sin brings separation from God if persisted in, while God gives hope and help to people in their sinful condition.ST Mar 18, 1903 The gospel was offered to Cain as well as to Abel, but Cain rejected the need for sacrifices and would not recognize that the slain lamb pointed to Jesus Christ, the only provision for salvation, so his unbelief made it to him a message of death.ST Mar 14, 1878 His offering was unacceptable because of unbelief, and his unbelief led him to become a murderer.ST Jul 18, 1900
Up to the time of division their religion was the same to all outward appearance, for they were equal in birth and religious instruction except that Cain as the first-born was in some respects favored, and both were sinners who acknowledged the claims of God as an object of worship.ST Dec 23, 1886 At this point the one was divided from the other by obedience and disobedience, for God tested Cain on the point of obedience as Abel was tested, and Cain and Abel represent the whole human family who will all be tested in the same way.ST Dec 23, 1886ST Dec 23, 1886 Abel bore the proving and revealed the gold of a righteous character and the principles of true godliness.ST Dec 23, 1886 Cain's religion had not a good foundation because it rested on human merit; in bringing the fruits of the ground cultivated by his own toil he presented his offering as a favor done to God by which he expected to secure divine approval, and though he obeyed in building an altar and in bringing a sacrifice his obedience was only partial because the essential part, the recognition of the need of a Redeemer, was left out.ST Dec 23, 1886 He is given as an example of someone who had no respect for God or His commandments and followed his own corrupt course, and such a person is rejected by God rather than blessed.ST Feb 24, 1887 The same rebellious anger seen in his anger and downcast face after disapproval appears in people who resent God for destroying the antediluvian world in the Flood and cursing the earth.ST Mar 20, 1879
Commentary part 2 of 2
Pioneers and periodicals
101 sources
The Lord spoke to Cain after rejecting his fruit offering while accepting Abel and his lamb, leaving Cain very angry with fallen, downcast face.RH Mar 3, 1874RH Jun 25, 1901RH Mar 10, 1868ST Jul 1, 1889ST Nov 1, 1899 He asked not from lack of knowledge but to make Cain reflect on his conduct, recognize that the fault lay wholly in himself, and repent and return to obedience.ST Dec 16, 1886ST Jul 14, 1898 Cain was rejected because he followed his own way in partial obedience, bringing produce without blood and without faith in the promised Redeemer, seeking approval by his own toil and merit while Abel obeyed by faith.ST Dec 16, 1886ST Jul 1, 1889ST Mar 10, 1898ST Dec 22, 1898 His wrath and fallen countenance were directed against Abel because Abel's acceptance and righteous works exposed his disobedience, and that cherished anger and envy were the first step toward murder.ST Dec 18, 1879RH Jun 25, 1901RH Mar 10, 1868ST Jun 24, 1897ST Mar 25, 1889 In them stand two opposing classes continuing to the end, Abel's voluntary service of love, trust, and obedience against Cain's self-interested departure from God's word in unbelief and disobedience.ST Aug 13, 1894ST Aug 28, 1884ST Sep 1, 1909
Immediate Setting Described
The question comes after the Lord refused Cain's offering while accepting Abel and his offering, leaving Cain very angry with fallen countenance and downcast face.RH Jun 25, 1901RH Mar 10, 1868ST Jul 1, 1889ST Jul 14, 1898RH Jun 27, 1878 His cheaper offering had failed to secure divine approval, blessing, and forgiveness, and his vexation and envy as a rejected worshiper turned toward the one accepted by God.RH Jun 25, 1901RH Mar 10, 1868ST Jul 14, 1898 The Lord confronted him about his anger and dejected look, calling him to recognize his state and turn from it, and telling him that doing well would bring acceptance.ST Jul 1, 1889ST Jul 14, 1898RH Jun 27, 1878ST Jul 14, 1898 Cain stayed rebellious and hateful, and his jealousy grew into hatred and his anger finally led him to murder Abel in the field.RH Jun 25, 1901RH Jun 27, 1878
Cain had brought of the fruit of the ground, even flour, while Abel had brought of the firstlings of his flock.RH Mar 3, 1874ST Nov 1, 1899RH Oct 8, 1872 Abel's lamb, whose blood expressed repentance for sin and faith in a Redeemer and coming Saviour, was accepted by fire from heaven, while Cain's produce without blood expressed refusal to submit to God's appointed offering and proud rejection of dependence on a Saviour.RH Mar 3, 1874ST Dec 25, 1901RH Oct 8, 1872 Abel offered by faith according to God's plan and obtained witness that he was righteous, but Cain did not do well and did not have faith, so God had respect to Abel and his offering and not to Cain and his offering.ST Dec 25, 1901ST Jul 1, 1889RH Jun 26, 1855 Cain's offering was doubly defective in lacking both obedience and faith, with either defect enough to insure rejection, since no one can offer in faith what God never commanded.RH Oct 8, 1872 His anger arose from this refusal, was directed against Abel because Abel as the younger brother was accepted while he was rejected and because Abel maintained that God is just, and, left open to doubts and rebellion, it grew into madness against God and Abel.RH Mar 3, 1874ST Dec 25, 1901
The broader account traces Cain leaving the Lord's presence manifested at the gate of Paradise to settle in Nod at a distance, desiring to be separated from God.RH Dec 23, 1915ST Oct 16, 1879 His posterity for six generations is traced from his birth nearly to the time of the flood, including Enoch and Lamech, and was wholly irreligious, a civilization that forgot God and lived for the present world.RH Dec 23, 1915RH Dec 25, 1913ST Oct 16, 1879ST Sep 5, 1895 The Lamech in Cain's line took two wives and killed a man and was distinct from the Lamech in Seth's line, who fathered Noah, and Cain's family line beginning with a murderer later produced Lamech, another murderer.RH Dec 23, 1915RH Dec 25, 1913 Through character and development of his line Cain stands as the beginning and leader of the ungodly line distinguished from the godly line descended from Seth, standing before the record of descendants skilled in metal-working and music.ST Jul 27, 1915ST Dec 29, 1909 The entire family of Cain perished in the flood, while Eve's hope passed from Cain to Seth given to take Abel's place.ST Oct 16, 1879
The births, murder, and six generations of Cain's descendants are not in strict chronological order, for Bible events are not always given in chronological order.ST Sep 5, 1895 The birth of Seth and of Adam's other sons and daughters recorded afterward belongs earlier in time, and Seth and other children of Adam, and perhaps children of Seth, may already have been born.ST Sep 5, 1895ST Feb 3, 1904 So Cain's wife was one of the daughters of Adam or of Seth, and his fear of being killed after Abel's death reflected the presence of other people descended from Adam and Eve, whose growing family could already have included many people.ST Sep 5, 1895RH Dec 1, 1863ST Feb 3, 1904 His waiting until he and Abel were alone suggests that others had been present at their shared worship gathering.RH Jun 6, 1912 The Lord spoke directly to Cain before Cain killed Abel, questioning his anger and fallen countenance as part of the Lord's instruction to him, and continued after the murder to communicate His will directly to people, including the wicked, as evidence that people had knowledge of God before the giving of the law at Sinai.RH Jun 23, 1903RH Oct 18, 1853
Cain dealt Abel a stunning murderous blow beside the altar where Abel had made his offering, in the field, while Abel was confessing his sins in a solemn act of worship when his life went out.ST Jan 18, 1877ST Feb 16, 1915ST Apr 1, 1880 His rage was still unappeased beside that altar when he struck.ST Jan 18, 1877 Because the dead sleep unconsciously and do not realize passing time, Abel when he awakes will seem to have just arisen from that blow, will look for the altar and expect to see his angry brother near with rage still unappeased, and until informed will be unable to believe centuries have passed while sleeping in the grave.ST Jan 18, 1877
Purpose Of God's Question
The Lord's question to Cain about his anger and fallen countenance was not asked from lack of knowledge, for He knew Cain's resentment, but to confront him with it and make him reflect on his course and conduct, recognize his state and sin, and turn to repentance and return to obedience.ST Dec 16, 1886ST Jul 14, 1898ST Jul 14, 1898 The inquiry called Cain to consider his response after his offering was rejected and gave him opportunity to choose rightly, with warning that acceptance depends on doing well and that sin lies at the door if he does not.ST Jul 14, 1898ST Jul 14, 1898RH Aug 7, 1860 The fault exposed by the question was not in God but wholly in Cain himself, because something was not right with him in that he did not do well and did not have faith, while Abel offered by faith and obtained witness that he was righteous.ST Dec 16, 1886ST Dec 25, 1901ST Jul 1, 1889 Cain had no just cause for wrath against his brother or against God, since his own disregard of God's plainly stated will and expressed requirements had led to the rejection of his offering.ST Dec 16, 1886ST Dec 25, 1901ST Feb 6, 1879 He had not been treated unjustly or with partiality, and his anger directed against Abel because the younger brother's offering was accepted while his own was rejected, and because Abel maintained that God is just, only showed his own disobedience in failing to bring what was required and his refusal to see that this had made his offering unacceptable and valueless.ST Dec 25, 1901ST Feb 6, 1879
God met Cain in mercy, love, and long-suffering and did not forsake him after wilful sin without true repentance, but came to seek him to turn him from sin to righteousness.ST Feb 6, 1879ST Jun 24, 1897RH Jun 27, 1878ST Jun 14, 1910 The question gave him opportunity to put wilfulness away from his heart and offer a broken and contrite heart that God will not despise, assuring him that doing well would bring acceptance.ST Sep 11, 1884RH Jun 27, 1878RH Jun 27, 1878ST Jun 14, 1910 There was blessing enough for both through the covenant of grace, and Cain too could receive blessing instead of envying the blessing given to Abel, for if he followed God's directions in humble faith and obedience God would accept his offering.ST Sep 11, 1884ST Feb 6, 1879ST Jun 24, 1897RH Jun 27, 1878 Cain instead stayed rebellious and hateful, chose his own course, trusted his own merits, remained resentful and blamed God, and his anger finally led him to murder Abel in the field.ST Sep 11, 1884ST Feb 6, 1879RH Jun 27, 1878RH Jun 27, 1878 Acceptance did not rest on one brother being elected to favor and the other to rejection, though Cain in his anger and fallen face accused God of partiality and injustice and thereby manifested an accusing spirit that led directly to violence against man.ST Dec 23, 1886ST Dec 24, 1902 Cain heard the same lessons of salvation as Abel and had the same privileges but did not improve them and ventured contrary to God's commands, so his wrath and fallen countenance were the result of his own disobedience, not of an arbitrary purpose of God, and the question proves acceptance rested wholly on doing or not doing as God had said.ST Dec 23, 1886RH Jan 15, 1875ST Dec 24, 1902 God shows no partiality, for Abel was respected because he offered by faith, and Cain too would be accepted on doing well, which also shows as guilty one conscious of guilt that moral law was already revealed and binding, since sin and guilt cannot exist where there is no law, including the law forbidding murder.RH Jan 15, 1875
God's meeting with Cain in love to turn him from sin to righteousness belongs among His repeated lessons about obedience and disobedience, showing that righteousness is life and sin is death and that God's standards are eternally just.ST May 7, 1894STST Aug 13, 1896 The question teaches that righteousness enlightens while sin blinds and deceives, that the reward of obedience and the fearful result of disobedience are certain, that God's precepts and institutions are holy and He accepts no substitute for them, and that God's love longs and is mighty to save sinners from sin to righteousness so that responsive love and gratitude lead to careful faithfulness in His service.ST Aug 13, 1896 Cain rejected God's promised way of salvation while Abel accepted it in faith, and this example of the two ways carries the same lesson of the certainty of God's dealing with obedience and disobedience.ST May 7, 1894STST Aug 13, 1896
Reason Offering Rejected
Cain wished to have his own way about what to offer, bringing a human substitution that God had not directed instead of just what God declared to be His will, and though he built an altar and brought a sacrifice his obedience was only partial.ST Dec 16, 1886ST Mar 10, 1898RH Mar 16, 1916 His offering was doubly defective in lacking both obedience and faith, and contained no evidence of faith in the promised Offering for sin, so God could not accept it and acceptance turned wholly on doing what God required rather than on sincerity or effort.ST Jul 1, 1889ST Mar 10, 1898ST Dec 22, 1898ST Jul 16, 1894 Cain did not do well and did not have faith, while Abel offered by faith and obtained witness that he was righteous.ST Jul 1, 1889ST Dec 22, 1898
Cain saw no necessity for blood and offered produce without the blood that expressed repentance for sin and faith in the promised Offering, the Redeemer, and the coming Saviour.RH Mar 3, 1874ST Dec 23, 1886ST Mar 10, 1898ST Jul 1, 1889 He could not believe God would be very particular, fed upon doubts and cherished unbelief, and would worship only according to his own ideas, which was not worship of God at all but of a god of his own making, which was self.RH Mar 3, 1874ST Jul 1, 1889 The essential part left out was recognition of the need of a Redeemer, though in building an altar and bringing a sacrifice there was outward obedience.ST Dec 23, 1886
Cain presented the fruits of the ground cultivated by his own toil as a favor done to God by which he expected to secure divine approval, blessing, and forgiveness.ST Sep 11, 1884ST Dec 23, 1886ST Oct 1, 1902 He came as one righteous and as thinking himself righteous, without confessing sin or recognizing his need for mercy, while Abel came as a sinner whose hope was God's unmerited love with blood pointing to the Lamb of God.RH Mar 3, 1874ST Dec 23, 1886 He exalted his own judgment above God, trusted his own merits and hard labor, determined to bring an offering according to his own ideas, and sought to please God by his own work.ST Sep 11, 1884ST Jan 9, 1896ST Oct 1, 1902 His own works were evil because they were his own, and work that is of man comes to nothing.ST Oct 1, 1902
Abel obeyed God's express direction and offered by faith according to God's plan, seeing meaning in the blood of the lamb slain by his own hands, obtaining witness that he was righteous with God testifying of his gifts.ST Jan 9, 1896ST Jul 1, 1889ST Mar 9, 1888ST Jul 1, 1889 His works were righteous because they were the work of the Spirit, not his own, God working in him to will and to do of His good pleasure, so that his sins were forgiven and his soul was saved through believing the gospel of Christ and bringing the offering God commanded.ST Mar 9, 1888ST Oct 1, 1902 By contrast Cain's disobedience exposed by Abel's obedience showed disloyalty, selfishness, love of self rather than supreme love for God, and opposition to God, with Cain as a type of unbelief and hatred and disobedience set against Abel as a type of faith and love and obedience.RH Jul 10, 1860ST Oct 1, 1902ST Sep 1, 1909 Abel would not abandon the true way and leave God's way for Cain's way, yet Cain would not abandon his self-chosen worship and accept the true way.RH Jul 10, 1860
Cain heeded the deceiver rather than God's command, and Satan instigated him and planned against the favored one.RH Jun 26, 1900RH Jun 26, 1855ST Jan 30, 1896 Satan deceived him into believing that one offering is as good as another so long as it is offered to God, a cunning imitation of God's genuine institutions and true worship that began a gradual estrangement from God leading onward to worship of false gods.ST Jan 30, 1896 Cain had expected acceptance because he believed his offering was suitable, supposing God regarded persons rather than offerings and would have accepted the same offering from Abel.ST Jul 16, 1894RH Sep 13, 1870 He was envious as the eldest that respect was denied him, believed God favored Abel, and his jealous brooding made him imagine himself increasingly mistreated until he could see no justice in the rejection, with jealousy cherished until it led to murder.ST Sep 28, 1904RH Sep 13, 1870ST Sep 28, 1904 The rejection was not because he was Cain but because he was a self-willed, sin-loving sinner, since penitent, humble, confessing sinners can come with offerings but self-willed sinners will not be accepted because sacrifice does not cover sin without obedience.RH Sep 13, 1870 His rebellion in bringing a substitute offering without blood is presented as leading to a curse with no remedy.ST Nov 9, 1915
Anger Ripening Into Murder
Cain was angry because God blessed Abel while his own offering was rejected, and his wrath, jealousy, envy and hatred were directed against Abel because Abel's acceptance and righteous works exposed and condemned his own disobedience and evil course.ST Dec 25, 1901RH Jun 25, 1901RH Mar 10, 1868ST Mar 25, 1889ST Aug 1, 1916 His cheaper offering had failed to secure approval, blessing and forgiveness, and instead of receiving the blessing God still offered him — for there was blessing enough for both through the covenant of grace — he envied the blessing given to Abel.RH Jun 25, 1901ST Jun 24, 1897 As the elder brother he was jealous that respect was denied him while the younger was accepted, and because Abel maintained that God is just and would not leave God's way for his way, Cain argued with him and refused to see that his own failure to bring what was required had made his offering unacceptable and valueless.ST Dec 25, 1901ST Aug 1, 1916 That vexation of a rejected worshiper toward one accepted grew from jealousy into hatred and then into murder, the first murder.RH Jun 25, 1901RH Mar 10, 1868ST Aug 1, 1916
The wrath and fallen countenance mark the first step toward murder and a turning away from God, for angry feelings allowed in the heart and cherished jealousy grow into envy and hatred and result in taking a life that only God can give.ST Dec 18, 1879ST Mar 25, 1889ST Sep 28, 1904ST May 22, 1884 Such feelings must be guarded against and brought under control, lest they make a person a partaker with the devil, who was a murderer from the beginning, and a quick temper must not be thought harmless merely because it passes quickly.ST Mar 25, 1889ST May 22, 1884 Cherished until it led to murder, Cain's jealousy with its sense of being wronged made him angry and despondent, and as people persist in sin and harden their hearts the spirit of murderous hatred is formed until each further temptation is easier to yield to.ST Dec 18, 1879ST Sep 28, 1904
Cain's anger as a work of the flesh warred against the soul, moved his bosom and maddened his brain, giving him a fallen countenance, and because he did not abstain he murdered his righteous brother who walked with God.ST Mar 9, 1888RH Jun 27, 1878RH Mar 19, 1867 He was very angry and downcast when his offering was refused while Abel and his offering were accepted, and though challenged about his anger and dejected look and told that doing well would bring acceptance, he stayed rebellious and hateful until his wrath led him to kill Abel in the field, waiting until they were alone.RH Jun 27, 1878RH Jun 6, 1912 This gives a striking illustration of what man became when he sinned after the fall, losing self-control, the fear and love of God, and love toward neighbor, and becoming selfish, with covetousness, envy and desire for power bringing murder into human society.ST Apr 22, 1903ST Oct 17, 1895
His anger and fallen countenance were outward signs of inner hatred, jealousy, selfishness and a rebellious, murmuring spirit toward God after his offering was not accepted, standing in contrast to Abel's meek submission to God's authority.ST Dec 16, 1886RH Sep 13, 1870 Disposition was visible in his face, illustrating that a person's character can shape appearance, while a lovely disposition makes a face lovely.RH Sep 13, 1870 Their offerings tested whether they would obey God's requirements, which taught that sin brings death and that people come to God through the promised Redeemer.ST Dec 16, 1886
Cain hated righteousness and loved evil, hating not sin but its punishment and hating all who did not suffer with him, hating the good because it was good.RH Sep 13, 1870 He did wrong yet tried to throw its consequences on the innocent, slaying his brother both because his own works were evil and because his brother's were righteous.RH Sep 13, 1870 His anger and fallen face were an accusation that God was partial and unjust in dealing with him and his brother, manifesting Satan's accusing spirit, and that accusation against God led directly to violence against man.RH Sep 13, 1870ST Dec 24, 1902 That same spirit marks the last days, when men are despisers of those that are good, feeling no pleasure or freedom among the refined, elevated and godly but at home with the giddy, reckless and sensual, watching every act and word of the godly for evil while remaining sanctimonious and crying charity when reproved; though such persons pray and bring offerings as Cain did, while they keep his spirit they and their offerings will be rejected, for hatred is murder concealed in God's sight and his followers are very numerous even among those who bring an offering.RH Sep 13, 1870
His crime violated the second great commandment, the principle of love for others and their equal rights, and was a transgression of the moral law.ST Apr 13, 1915 His worship was profane, and envy of his brother and covetousness of his fortune led him to murder, followed by lying and falsehood to conceal the crime, violating at least four distinct commands of the Decalogue and showing that God's moral law was in force before it was written at Sinai.RH Jan 18, 1870ST Jul 9, 1874
When rebuked and punished he did not repent but murmured at his punishment, blamed God, and went out from God's presence manifested at the gate of Paradise to dwell at a distance, desiring separation from God, leaving in hopeless despair unlike Abel who had hope in Christ.ST Feb 6, 1879ST Oct 16, 1879ST Jan 17, 1884 He blinded himself to light, hardened his conscience, and would not acknowledge himself a lost and undone sinner in need of a Saviour, refusing in unbelief to offer in faith the blood of the Son of God by which transgressions are transferred to Christ and the repenting sinner is declared sinless by Christ's righteousness.ST Jan 16, 1896ST Jun 14, 1910 Refusal to repent and a determined wilful course leads step by step away from God until the conscience is hardened and seared and can no longer hear His call, though God came to seek him with love and long-suffering to give opportunity to put wilfulness away and offer a broken and contrite heart.ST Dec 18, 1879ST Jun 14, 1910
Law Existing Before Sinai
Cain’s sin was a transgression counted against him, proving God’s holy moral law existed before it was given at Sinai.RH Apr 13, 1876RH Mar 26, 1901RH Jan 15, 1875ST Sep 17, 1902 His anger itself was sin, and the warning that sin lay at the door shows that sin is transgression of God’s law, so the law was already in existence.RH Mar 26, 1901RH Jan 15, 1875 In violating the second great commandment, the principle of love for others and their equal rights, Cain transgressed the moral law.ST Apr 13, 1915 The command against killing was already binding on Adam and his descendants, and the history ending in Abel’s murder shows murder was sin in Cain’s day in violation of the sixth commandment.RH Jan 15, 1875RH Oct 11, 1864ST Sep 17, 1902 God confronted Cain over his anger and fallen countenance as a guilty person conscious of guilt, telling him he would be accepted if he did well but if not sin lay at his door, which means moral law was already revealed and binding from creation, including the law forbidding murder, because sin and guilt cannot exist where there is no law.RH Jan 15, 1875 God shows no partiality, for Abel was respected because he offered by faith, and Cain too would be accepted on doing well.RH Jan 15, 1875
The offerings of Cain and Abel show that sacrifices were practiced from that time until Moses, though worship had not yet been regulated by a formal system of ceremonies.RH Apr 13, 1876ST Sep 17, 1902 Cain’s offering of produce could not take the place of the prescribed lamb, so God rejected the substitute and warned Cain that sin was at the door.RH May 25, 1876 The ceremonial rites were not newly created at Sinai, and the law added 430 years after Abraham was not an original creation but the reducing of the pre-existing moral principles and typical rites to written form at Sinai.ST Sep 17, 1902
Two Worshipers Foreshadowed
Cain and Abel present two opposing systems of worship continuing to the end, Abel's voluntary service rooted in love, trust, faith and obedience set against Cain's departure from God's word driven by fear, self-interest, unbelief, hatred and disobedience.ST Aug 13, 1894ST Aug 28, 1884ST Sep 1, 1909 They are wheat and tares, the children of the kingdom and the children of the wicked one, already appearing in Adam's first sons and applying through the whole period to the close of the day of grace when sinners still need and may enjoy the means of grace.ST Aug 28, 1884RH Feb 10, 1874ST Apr 5, 1877 Abel chose true government, self-government under God and with God and in God according to His will and design, while Cain chose the way of Satan, the way of lawlessness and anarchy, and his wrath and killing of his brother strictly accord with that principle and manifest the spirit of its originator, the chief opponent of all government and hater of its principle. Cain gave place to disloyalty, envy, hatred and murder and was a tare, while Abel governed by loyalty, righteousness and truth was wheat, illustrating the appearance of evil alongside righteousness in the world, with both kinds continuing in the Abels and the Cains who have ever since blessed and cursed the earth.ST Aug 28, 1884ST Sep 1, 1909
Abel is God's first noble martyr, who would not compromise the truth to make union with Cain and save his life but died for its honor, while Cain in infidelity was stirred to madness by truth firmly held and slew him because his own works were evil and his brother's righteous.RH Jul 25, 1871ST Nov 13, 1893 Cain was the first man who tried to force his religion upon his fellow man, attacking his brother for worshiping according to God's requirements because Abel did not worship in Cain's way.ST Jan 17, 1911 Ruled by a selfish and perverse disposition, loving self rather than showing supreme love for God and lacking faith in the promised Lamb, he sought to compel Abel to follow his self-chosen sacrifice shaped by his own ideas and convenience, and Abel was killed for holding to freedom of conscience.ST Jul 30, 1894 This anger and downcast face after the difference between his worship and Abel's was the first manifestation of religious bigotry, in which Cain denied Abel the rights and privileges he claimed for himself, denying another the right to worship God and ultimately the right to life, marking wicked Cain and righteous Abel as an early example of persecutors of true religion.ST Dec 7, 1915ST Dec 7, 1915ST Mar 12, 1894
The same contest continues in the Sabbath controversy, for as God had respect for Abel's obedience and none for Cain's counterfeit, so first-day keepers grow angry and dejected because God respects the seventh-day keeper's offering and blesses him richly for obeying the Sabbath law while having no respect for their first-day offering of time and promising them no blessing for it. In that anger they take counsel together to destroy his influence and put him to shame, having him arrested and brought to court for not respecting the first day even while attending to his own business in his garden. God's rebuke shows He means what He says and accepts no substituted service, since without shedding of blood there is no remission and the spotless lamb shadowed the great sacrifice, which Abel believed and obeyed by faith unto witness that he was righteous while Cain lacked faith and fidelity; to keep Sunday instead of the seventh day God required to be observed as holy is to follow Cain's example.RH Sep 22, 1874 The same spirit of envy, jealousy, bitterness, malice and hate appears in those unreconciled to God's law toward those who magnify it as holy, just and good, and in those who ignore the plain command to keep the Sabbath while offering what God never commanded, then treat the obedient as Cain treated Abel.ST Jan 9, 1896 As Cain in anger at Abel for refusing to join his false worship slew him, and as the Jews persecuted Christ because He would not keep the Sabbath according to their ideas, so the controversy will end in an effort to put to death those who will not yield to keeping the Sabbath according to man's command, but God will work deliverance for His people.ST Aug 20, 1896 Cain's substitution is in principle the old covenant of works, man's substitute for free and full salvation in Christ putting man's efforts, vows, promises and power in place of God and gendering to bondage, the same principle as Israel's promise at Horeb to do God's will in their own strength while asking God to speak to them no more, and as the modern Sunday substitute, Sunday laws and salvation by works of various kinds, differing only in that then men proposed to do God's will in their own strength and now many propose to do their own will in God's strength.ST Jul 23, 1896
The account stands at the beginning of the controversy between truth and error and belongs to Satan's effort to destroy the promised Seed through Abel, for after Abel's bloody offering received favor through faith in a Saviour's blood, Satan planned his death.RH Jul 25, 1871RH Jun 26, 1855ST Abel lies dead in the shadow of the cross, having died in faith in the coming Saviour, while Cain is shown leaving God's presence in hopeless despair, unlike Abel who has hope in Christ, for the cross still offers the transgressor hope through repentance and faith in Christ.ST Jan 17, 1884RH May 27, 1873 From righteous Abel onward God has had His called-out ones in all ages, beginning His church with those turning from sin to God, with Adam and Eve and Abel heeding His call to come out from the world and join with Him, even when His church apostatizes and He must call a remnant out again.ST Apr 29, 1908
Practical Warnings Given
Cain's anger and fallen face warn that a quick temper is not harmless because it passes quickly, but must be resisted, guarded, and brought under control.ST Mar 25, 1889ST May 22, 1884 His wrath was envy that his brother's offering was accepted while his own was not, because his own works were evil and his brother's were righteous, and it marks the first step toward murder.ST Mar 25, 1889 Angry feelings allowed in the heart can grow into envy and hatred and end in taking a life that only God can give, so they must be guarded lest they make a person a partaker with the devil, who was a murderer from the beginning.ST Mar 25, 1889
God's question about anger and downcast face is followed by the assurance that doing well brings acceptance, and this teaches those who complain of not receiving responsibility that acceptance and advancement depend on faithful conduct, not on chance or human favoritism, for God determines who is raised up. Cain is an example of one who heard but did not do, offering his own works and expecting acceptance while angry at rejection.ST Jan 23, 1896 His wrath and fallen countenance came from selfishness, preferring his own course to the way God pointed out because God's way was contrary to natural desires.ST Jan 23, 1896 His attitude is that of those who say Lord, Lord and point to works, having a form of godliness but denying its power, an attitude that will prevail among professed Christians as the end approaches, while true following requires both hearing and doing, for not hearers but doers are justified, and his course ends in destruction.ST Jan 23, 1896
Opposition can deaden the sense of right, and the carnal mind blinded leads to the use of force against reform.ST Feb 1, 1883 Cain became angry and downcast toward his brother when he took the place of master and ruler over him in duties of worship toward God, and men do the same when they try to force even the simplest truths of worship upon others, soon growing angry with a dull or slow brother or a willful and stubborn one and wanting to bring punishment upon him.ST Jan 31, 1911 God meets such anger not with force but by continuing to love and bless, following after men and pleading with them in tenderness and pity.ST Jan 31, 1911 Since hatred is murder concealed in God's sight, Cain's followers are very numerous even among those who pray and bring offerings to the Lord.RH Sep 13, 1870 His anger and fallen countenance exposed a heart that hated righteousness and loved evil, doing wrong yet trying to throw its consequences on the innocent, hating not sin but its punishment and hating all who did not suffer with him, and slaying his brother both because his own works were evil and because his brother's were righteous, hating the good because it was good.RH Sep 13, 1870
That same spirit marks the last days, when men are despisers of those that are good, feeling no pleasure or freedom among the refined, elevated and godly but at home with the giddy, reckless and sensual, watching every act and word of the godly for evil while remaining sanctimonious and crying charity when reproved.RH Sep 13, 1870 Though such persons pray and bring offerings as Cain did, while they keep Cain's spirit they and their offerings will fare as he and his fared, rejected by God.RH Sep 13, 1870 The account gives repeated lessons about obedience and disobedience, showing that righteousness is life and sin is death and that God's standards are eternally just.ST It sets forth the contrasting patterns of faith and unbelief and the fruit of each, teaching that sin brings separation from God if persisted in, while God gives hope and help to people in their sinful condition.ST Mar 18, 1903 The gospel was offered to Cain as well as to Abel, but Cain rejected the need for sacrifices and would not recognize that the slain lamb pointed to Jesus Christ, the only provision for salvation, so his unbelief made it to him a message of death.ST Mar 14, 1878 His offering was unacceptable because of unbelief, and his unbelief led him to become a murderer.ST Jul 18, 1900
Up to the time of division their religion was the same to all outward appearance, for they were equal in birth and religious instruction except that Cain as the first-born was in some respects favored, and both were sinners who acknowledged the claims of God as an object of worship.ST Dec 23, 1886 At this point the one was divided from the other by obedience and disobedience, for God tested Cain on the point of obedience as Abel was tested, and Cain and Abel represent the whole human family who will all be tested in the same way.ST Dec 23, 1886ST Dec 23, 1886 Abel bore the proving and revealed the gold of a righteous character and the principles of true godliness.ST Dec 23, 1886 Cain's religion had not a good foundation because it rested on human merit; in bringing the fruits of the ground cultivated by his own toil he presented his offering as a favor done to God by which he expected to secure divine approval, and though he obeyed in building an altar and in bringing a sacrifice his obedience was only partial because the essential part, the recognition of the need of a Redeemer, was left out.ST Dec 23, 1886 He is given as an example of someone who had no respect for God or His commandments and followed his own corrupt course, and such a person is rejected by God rather than blessed.ST Feb 24, 1887 The same rebellious anger seen in his anger and downcast face after disapproval appears in people who resent God for destroying the antediluvian world in the Flood and cursing the earth.ST Mar 20, 1879
Sources