Haggai 1:6
Ye have sown much, and bring in little; ye eat, but ye have not enough; ye drink, but ye are not filled with drink; ye clothe you, but there is none warm; and he that earneth wages earneth wages to put it into a bag with holes.
Translations
You have sown much, and bring in little; you eat, but you have not enough; you drink, but you are not filled with drink; you clothe you, but there is none warm; and he that earns wages earns wages to put it into a bag with holes.
King James Version, Revised Version, American Standard Version
Ye have sown much, and bring in little; ye eat, but ye have not enough; ye drink, but ye are not filled with drink; ye clothe you, but there is none warm; and he that earneth wages earneth wages to put it into a bag with holes.
Ye have sown much, and bring in little;
Ye eat, but ye have not enough;
Ye drink, but ye are not filled with drink;
Ye clothe you, but there is none warm;
And he that earneth wages earneth wages to put it into a bag with holes.Ye have sown much, and bring in little; ye eat, but ye have not enough; ye drink, but ye are not filled with drink; ye clothe yourselves, but there is none warm; and he that earneth wages earneth wages to put it into a bag with holes.
Ye have sown much, and brought in little, To eat, and not to satiety, To drink, and not to drunkenness, To clothe, and none hath heat, And he who is hiring himself out, Is hiring himself for a bag pierced through.
Ye have sown much, and bring in little; ye eat, but are not satisfied; ye drink, but are not filled with drink; ye clothe yourselves, but there is none warm; and he that earneth wages earneth wages for a bag with holes.
Ye have sown much, but have brought in little, have eaten, and not been filled, have drunk, and not been satisfied with drink, have clothed you, and none hath been warm,—and, he that hath hired himself out, hath put his wages into a bag with holes.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
You have planted much
but harvested little.
You eat but never have enough.
You drink but never have your fill.
You put on clothes but never get warm.
You earn wages to put into a bag pierced through.”You have sown much, and bring in little. You eat, but you don’t have enough. You drink, but you aren’t filled with drink. You clothe yourselves, but no one is warm; and he who earns wages earns wages to put them into a bag with holes in it.’
Much has been planted, but little got in; you take food, but have not enough; you take drink, but are not full; you are clothed, but no one is warm; and he who gets payment for his work, gets it to put it into a bag full of holes.
Ye haue sowen much, and bring in litle: ye eate, but ye haue not ynough: ye drinke, but ye are not filled: ye clothe you, but ye be not warme: and he that earneth wages, putteth the wages into a broken bagge.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
You have sowed much, and brought in little: you have eaten, but have not had enough: you have drunk, but have not been filled with drink: you have clothed yourselves, but have not been warmed: and he that hath earned wages, put them into a bag with holes.
Pictures

Cross-references
- Malachi 3:10-11
Bring ye all the tithes into the storehouse, that there may be meat in mine house, and prove me now herewith, saith the LORD of hosts, if I will not open you the windows of heaven, and pour you out a blessing, that there shall not be room enough to receive it.
Withholding what is due to God brings loss; faithful giving brings blessing and protects crops.
- Haggai 2:16-17
Since those days were, when one came to an heap of twenty measures, there were but ten: when one came to the pressfat for to draw out fifty vessels out of the press, there were but twenty.
Both describe poor returns and crop losses linked to neglecting the temple.
- Luke 12:33
Sell that ye have, and give alms; provide yourselves bags which wax not old, a treasure in the heavens that faileth not, where no thief approacheth, neither moth corrupteth.
Contrasts leaking earthly bags with unfailing heavenly bags.
- Haggai 2:19
Is the seed yet in the barn? yea, as yet the vine, and the fig tree, and the pomegranate, and the olive tree, hath not brought forth: from this day will I bless you.
God promises blessing from the day the people resume his work.
- Proverbs 3:9-10
Honour the LORD with thy substance, and with the firstfruits of all thine increase:
Honoring God with one’s means is connected with material blessing.
- Haggai 1:10
Therefore the heaven over you is stayed from dew, and the earth is stayed from her fruit.
Neglect is linked with withheld dew and harvest.
- Zechariah 8:10
For before these days there was no hire for man, nor any hire for beast; neither was there any peace to him that went out or came in because of the affliction: for I set all men every one against his neighbour.
Describes the people’s former afflictions, including the lack of wages and peace.
- Haggai 1:11
And I called for a drought upon the land, and upon the mountains, and upon the corn, and upon the new wine, and upon the oil, and upon that which the ground bringeth forth, and upon men, and upon cattle, and upon all the labour of the hands.
Both describe drought-struck crops, wine, and oil.
- Haggai 1:2
Thus speaketh the LORD of hosts, saying, This people say, The time is not come, the time that the LORD’s house should be built.
both blame hardship on neglecting temple building
- Proverbs 11:24
There is that scattereth, and yet increaseth; and there is that withholdeth more than is meet, but it tendeth to poverty.
Both show withholding leads to poverty.
- Haggai 2:17
I smote you with blasting and with mildew and with hail in all the labours of your hands; yet ye turned not to me, saith the LORD.
It describes crop-damaging judgments sent amid their failure to turn to God.
- Malachi 3:9
Ye are cursed with a curse: for ye have robbed me, even this whole nation.
The poor harvest reflects the curse for withholding tithes.
- 2 Corinthians 9:6
But this I say, He which soweth sparingly shall reap also sparingly; and he which soweth bountifully shall reap also bountifully.
sparing sowing reaps sparing
- 2 Corinthians 9:10
Now he that ministereth seed to the sower both minister bread for your food, and multiply your seed sown, and increase the fruits of your righteousness;)
God supplies seed and increases the harvest.
- Ezekiel 7:19
They shall cast their silver in the streets, and their gold shall be removed: their silver and their gold shall not be able to deliver them in the day of the wrath of the LORD: they shall not satisfy their souls, neither fill their bowels: because it is the stumblingblock of their iniquity.
Earthly wealth cannot satisfy or protect from God’s judgment.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
42 sources
The verse describes labor that yields empty returns, where much sowing brings in little and food, drink, clothing and wages fail to give enough, satisfaction and warmth.PK 574.1–575.1PP 527.2–528.110MR 125.2–3 The purse with holes pictures earnings and possessions that quickly disappear and bring no lasting benefit, prosperity or satisfaction.ED 143.1–2Lt 8, 1873, par. 10–13ST Dec 1, 1887 It was spoken to the returned Jews when they dwelt in their own houses and strove for temporal prosperity while the Lord's house lay neglected, well-nigh forsaken and in ruins.PK 574.1–575.1PP 527.2–528.1Ms 116, 1897, par. 38–39PK 573.1–2 Because they made personal interests first and used His bountiful gifts of corn, wine and oil selfishly, He sent wasting drought upon their substance, so their very effort to avoid want brought the want they feared.PK 574.1–575.1PP 527.2–528.1Ms 116, 1897, par. 6–11RH Dec 5, 1907PK 573.1–2 The same loss follows all who disregard His claims and withhold tithes and offerings to advance their own interests, while means willingly given to His work are safely invested as treasure in heaven beyond decay, loss or theft.ED 143.1–2Lt 8, 1873, par. 10–134T 78.3–79.1ST Feb 28, 1884ST Mar 4, 1903
Historical Setting and Cause
The verse describes the returned Jews in the early part of the reign of Darius Hystaspes, when for over a year the temple lay neglected and well-nigh forsaken while the people dwelt in their own homes and strove for temporal prosperity.PK 573.1–2 They left the Lord's unfinished house neglected while giving themselves to their own houses.PK 574.1–575.1PP 527.2–528.1Ms 116, 1897, par. 38–39Ms 116, 1897, par. 6–11RH Dec 5, 1907 They made personal interests first and looked with apathy on His house lying in ruins.PK 573.1–2PK 573.3
Because they let the temple lie waste, the Lord sent a wasting drought upon their substance, so that the very elements of nature seemed to conspire against them.PP 527.2–528.1PK 573.1–2 The fruits of field and garden, the corn and the wine and the oil, had been bestowed as a token of His favor, but because they used these bountiful gifts selfishly the blessings were removed.PK 573.1–2 Their desire to avoid poverty led them to withhold effort from the temple, but that neglect brought the very want they feared.PK 574.1–575.1Ms 116, 1897, par. 6–11RH Dec 5, 1907 Had they honored God by making building His house their first work, they would have invited His presence and blessing.Ms 116, 1897, par. 6–11PK 573.3
Meaning of Empty Returns
Sowing abundantly yet harvesting little, eating without having enough, drinking without being filled, clothing without being warm, and earning wages only to lose them describe labor and resources that fail to meet need for sufficiency, satisfaction, and warmth.PK 574.1–575.1PP 527.2–528.110MR 125.2–3Ms 116, 1897, par. 38–39RH Dec 5, 1907 Crops yield little, food and drink do not satisfy, clothing does not keep warm, and wages are quickly lost when the Lord's unfinished house is neglected while each pursues his own house and interests.PK 574.1–575.1PP 527.2–528.110MR 125.2–3Ms 116, 1897, par. 38–39RH Dec 5, 1907 The attempt to escape poverty by putting personal interests first and withholding effort from the temple brings the very hardship feared, with want following amid drought sent because His house remains neglected.PK 574.1–575.1PP 527.2–528.1RH Dec 5, 1907 The same failure to prosper belongs to neglect of work entrusted, leaving harvests meager and possessions without lasting benefit, and in that application withholding resources brings loss while putting the Lord first by earnestly working to pay debts on houses of worship honors His house.10MR 125.2–3Ms 116, 1897, par. 38–396T 457.3–458.3
The bag with holes pictures earnings and possessions that quickly disappear and fail to satisfy, prosper, or bring lasting benefit, like money kept that is soon lost.ED 143.1–2Lt 8, 1873, par. 10–13RH Nov 15, 1906Ms 43, 1898, par. 19Lt 70, 1893, par. 27–28 When claims of God are disregarded and tithes and offerings withheld, harvest and provisions fall short and earnings vanish, showing that earthly effort and income cannot do real good apart from His blessing.ED 143.1–2Lt 8, 1873, par. 10–13Lt 70, 1893, par. 27–28 Wisdom and effort cannot prevent Him from scattering what is gathered and accumulated for self, so that losses outpace gains and expected yield and preservation fail.Lt 70, 1893, par. 27–28 Wealth gained while God is neglected consumes attention yet leaves possessors spiritually starved with no progress toward heaven, and money put into worldly use without regard to His work is wasted.ST Dec 1, 1887Ms 43, 1898, par. 19Lt 70, 1893, par. 27–28 By contrast, treasure willingly given to advance His work is safely invested in heaven beyond decay, destruction, loss, or theft, bringing lasting enjoyment, and the warning therefore calls to self-denial and economy so that means may go to His treasury to support workers and help the suffering.RH Nov 15, 1906Ms 43, 1898, par. 19
Work as they might they did not prosper, and spiritually as well as temporally their situation was deplorable.PK 573.1–2 In the early part of the reign of Darius Hystaspes, for over a year the temple lay neglected and well-nigh forsaken while the people dwelt in their own homes and strove for temporal prosperity, making personal interests first and looking with apathy on the Lord's house in ruins.PK 573.1–2 Because they let the temple lie waste He sent a wasting drought upon their substance, so that the very elements of nature seemed to conspire against them.PK 573.1–2 The fruits of field and garden, the corn and the wine and the oil, had been bestowed as a token of His favor, but because they used these bountiful gifts selfishly the blessings were removed.PK 573.1–2
The call to consider one's ways with its account of sowing much and bringing in little is also a prophecy describing the state of the world just before the second coming.Ms 110, 1893, par. 13 That time is marked by iniquity, continual transgression of God's law, and breach of the everlasting covenant.Ms 110, 1893, par. 13
Why Blessing Is Withheld
The losses come because those entrusted with God's gifts disregard His claims, neglect His house and sacred things, and withhold the tithes and offerings due to Him, so that harvest and provisions fall short and earnings disappear like money kept in a bag with holes.ED 143.1–2ST Mar 4, 1903 The verse belongs to the warning to consider one's ways, with the neglected temple identified as the reason for the failure to satisfy or prosper.ED 143.1–2 When people put selfish interests ahead of God's work, His prospering hand does not bless their undertakings.Lt 8, 1873, par. 10–13ST Feb 28, 1884 Earthly effort and income cannot do real good apart from His blessing, so that men may work hard yet gain little, remain unsatisfied and unwarm, and see wages vanish as if stored in a bag with holes.Lt 8, 1873, par. 10–13
God can scatter what people gather and accumulate while He is neglected, so that gain pursued with business and worldly concerns made primary brings no lasting benefit.2T 233.2–234.12T 166.1–167.2Lt 70, 1893, par. 27–28 Those who withhold heart and resources from God may gather, but He will scatter, and instead of flourishing they become unfruitful like a withered branch.2T 166.1–167.2 When what is due to Him is withheld, efforts for earthly prosperity can come to nothing because He can frustrate plans and make losses outpace gains.5T 271.3Lt 55, 1894, par. 11 Earnings and possessions kept for self instead of honoring God are like money put into a bag with holes, failing to yield or preserve what is expected, and no wisdom or effort can prevent Him from scattering them.Lt 70, 1893, par. 27–28 Prosperity cannot be secured by pursuing wealth contrary to His principles, for He can scatter resources faster than human effort can accumulate them, a rule applying to those who serve themselves and give ministers and other workers an unjust estimate of their service unless they repent in light of the truth whose record stands against them in the judgment.Lt 55, 1894, par. 11
He may afflict families and diminish possessions in proportion to unwillingness to give, so that failing material efforts reveal how little divine things are valued.ST Mar 4, 1903 Dearth of means in the treasury is the sure result of work He cannot sanction.Ms 29, 1911, par. 52–53 That occurs when men rob their brethren of their rights and selfishly grasp all available means for the advantage of their own institution while claiming to do it for the cause of God, and He withholds financial blessing.Ms 29, 1911, par. 52–53 Human preferences and prejudices, confederating to sustain methods contrary to the Word, with selfishness leading those who ought to be true to principle to make crooked paths for their feet, bring the lack and loss described.Ms 29, 1911, par. 52–53
The call to stop and consider applies to men in His service who work on principles He cannot sanction.Ms 188, 1901, par. 3–4 It exposes those who corrupt truth and righteousness by depending not on the power of God but on human effort, bringing presumption and human wisdom into the work.Ms 188, 1901, par. 3–4 Such a course shows they are not working in harmony with God and their spirit is not one with His Spirit.Ms 188, 1901, par. 3–4 The Lord will not prosper a man while he remains out of the truth, but his money goes into a basket with holes where it runs in and then runs out and is gone.Lt 110, 1898, par. 4 To end this waste he must come back humbly to the foot of the cross.Lt 110, 1898, par. 4
Stewardship and Lasting Treasure
Want and loss follow robbery of God by stewards entrusted with the greatest capital for the Master, who forget their stewardship of surplus means to advance His work on earth.Ms 47, 1900, par. 6 That forgetfulness becomes selfish use in extravagantly embellishing their own dwelling houses while thinking any place good enough for the worship of God, and by that use they dishonor the Redeemer.Ms 47, 1900, par. 6 By contrast, resources willingly given to advance God's work are safely invested as treasure in heaven, bringing lasting enjoyment beyond the reach of decay, destruction, loss, or theft.4T 78.3–79.1RH Nov 15, 1906 Money kept for oneself cannot provide lasting security or satisfaction, for what is stored in heaven cannot be lost or stolen as earthly holdings can.4T 78.3–79.1RH Nov 15, 1906
Money is a talent to be appreciated and wisely invested in carrying forward God's work in needy fields, with a set-aside portion for the Lord.Lt 218, 1903, par. 3–5 Spending entrusted means for self-gratification and self-pleasing gives no real satisfaction, while faithful stewardship does, since putting money into a bag with holes means spending what is entrusted for self instead of for His service.Lt 218, 1903, par. 3–5 The warning therefore calls to self-denial and economy so that wages and resources are not wasted without regard to God's work, but given to His treasury to support workers in service and help suffering people.Ms 43, 1898, par. 19 Money put to such wasteful use is like money placed in a bag with holes.Ms 43, 1898, par. 19 Money placed in worldly enterprises rather than in work that advances God's kingdom is likewise like wages in a bag with holes, and means should instead be entrusted to God's work where they can help save souls and be preserved as treasure in heaven.Lt 109, 1899, par. 9–11
Wealth gained while God is neglected consumes attention yet leaves people spiritually starved, with no progress toward heaven, for people work and earn yet their resources are like money in a bag with holes and bring no lasting satisfaction.ST Dec 1, 1887 Material gain without godliness is futile in the same way.Lt 48, 1897, par. 27–30 Money obtained unfairly is like wages in a bag with holes, bringing no lasting benefit and ultimately harming the one who gains it.Lt 48, 1897, par. 27–30
Building Houses of Worship
Haggai 1:6 stands in God's rebuke against leaving His house to the last consideration, and it requires making the building of a house for the Lord the first consideration without further delay.Ms 175, 1897, par. 67–6913MR 355.1–2Lt 56, 1897, par. 1–2 That first work is to provide a proper and accessible place of worship on the most favorable ground, large enough for His people to assemble and bow before Him reverently and in good order in a suitable manner.Ms 175, 1897, par. 67–6913MR 355.1–2 A worship place that is too small is not according to His will, and delay in providing it is to be regretted, for with the right kind of faith the work could have been done earlier.Ms 175, 1897, par. 67–6913MR 355.1–2
The chapter's call to build declares that the time had come for the Lord's house to be built, and it was applied to the decision to proceed with the Cooranbong meeting house.Ms 97, 1897, par. 4–6Lt 113, 1897, par. 1 Neglecting the building of the Lord's house while pursuing personal labor leaves work scant, unsatisfying, and unfruitful, with resources failing to prosper.Ms 97, 1897, par. 4–6Lt 113, 1897, par. 1Lt 56, 1897, par. 9 On the school grounds, providing a place for God's people to meet and honor Him should have been the first work, showing reverence for God and meeting His approval.Lt 56, 1897, par. 9
Neglecting God's house while each attends to his own home and interests brings meager returns in which much effort produces little and ordinary needs remain unmet.10MR 125.2–3Ms 116, 1897, par. 38–3910MR 124.1Ms 116, 1897, par. 35Ms 116, 1897, par. 6–11 Crops yield little, food and drink do not satisfy, clothing does not keep warm, and wages are quickly lost as if disappearing.10MR 125.2–3Ms 116, 1897, par. 38–39Ms 116, 1897, par. 6–11 Putting the Lord first by honoring Him in building His house and by working earnestly to pay church debts honors Him, while withholding resources for it brings loss rather than blessing.10MR 125.2–3Ms 116, 1897, par. 38–39 The attempt to avoid poverty by postponing His house brings the very hardship feared, whereas putting His interests first invites His presence.Ms 116, 1897, par. 6–11
Churches that neglect to build or maintain their buildings, rely on borrowed money, and make too little sacrifice to free them from debt dishonor God.10MR 124.1Ms 116, 1897, par. 35 Interest then consumes means that could reduce the principal, leaving houses of worship burdened with debt through failure to give sacrificially.Ms 116, 1897, par. 38–3910MR 124.1Ms 116, 1897, par. 35 The chapter is cited in connection with using God's resources to relieve burdens resting on His institutions when labor and possessions otherwise bring little satisfaction or lasting benefit.6T 457.3–458.3 Those who realize the nearness of the Lord are to act their faith when one of His instrumentalities is languishing or in peril by manifesting practical interest and unitedly taking His own substance to lift those burdens, with the promise that He will cooperate with them.Ms 65, 1900, par. 9–11
Personal Examination and Giving
Haggai 1:6 belongs to the warning to consider one's ways, echoing the call for a person to examine his course and repent.ED 143.1–217MR 284.1 When those entrusted with God's gifts disregard His claims, their labor and possessions fail to satisfy or prosper, with harvest and provisions falling short and earnings disappearing like money kept in a bag with holes.ED 143.1–2 The neglected temple and the withheld tithes and offerings are the reason for such losses.ED 143.1–2 It exposes the futility and lack of blessing that accompany neglect of God's work when business and worldly concerns are made primary while service to God is neglected.2T 233.2–234.1Lt 56, 1897, par. 9 Gain gathered while God is neglected does not bring lasting benefit, for God can scatter what people accumulate.2T 233.2–234.1
Providing a place for God's people to meet and honor Him should have been the first work, showing reverence for God and meeting His approval, and this lesson applies to the school grounds.Lt 56, 1897, par. 9 Aid given to those who are in poverty and want through waste of time and lack of effort to sustain themselves is lost like treasure put into a basket with holes unless those faults are seen and corrected.Ms 89, 1898, par. 19–21 The hardworking are not required to support those who are not diligent and waste hours and days doing nothing.Ms 89, 1898, par. 19–21 Unavoidable poverty and misfortune, by contrast, are to be met with tenderness and compassion.Ms 89, 1898, par. 19–21
The image of wages put into a bag with holes describes money that is wasted and brings no lasting relief.Lt 36, 1897, par. 4–10 Entrusting money to someone who misuses it would be like this, with the money lost without relieving his difficulties.Lt 36, 1897, par. 4–10
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
48 sources
It describes five linked disappointments in daily life where hard work and provision fail to satisfy or last, ending in earnings that vanish as if dropped into a torn purse.ST Dec 22, 1914ST May 21, 1912ST Aug 24, 1904 It was spoken to returned exiles who left God's house in ruins while they pursued their own well-finished homes.RH Dec 5, 1907ST Aug 30, 1883ST Feb 20, 1893 The want came because they put their own comfort first and neglected His house, so He withdrew His prospering hand, blighting their harvests and scattering what they gathered.ST Aug 14, 1879RH Nov 17, 1904ST Jan 22, 1880ST Apr 9, 1902RH May 21, 1914 No one can afford to withhold tithe and offerings for His work, for keeping back His portion brings the very poverty that is feared.RH Sep 16, 1902RH May 21, 1914RH Feb 25, 1904 What is spent on selfish gratification or hoarded for gain is lost like wages in a leaking bag, while what is given to advance His cause is kept safe and lays up lasting treasure.RH Nov 15, 1906RH Apr 17, 1879ST Aug 23, 1883RH Oct 5, 1911ST May 19, 1898
Wording and Imagery
The verse sets out five linked frustrations of futility and insufficiency that follow neglect of rebuilding the Lord's house: heavy sowing that yields only a small harvest, eating that leaves hunger unsatisfied, drinking that leaves thirst unquenched, clothing that leaves the wearer cold, and wages that vanish as though dropped into a pierced bag.ST Dec 22, 1914ST May 21, 1912ST Aug 24, 1904ST Apr 9, 1902ST Jul 14, 1887 Abundant planting still ends in scant reaping, and food, drink, clothing, labor, and pay all prove unproductive and insufficient to meet need.ST Dec 22, 1914ST May 21, 1912ST Aug 24, 1904ST Apr 9, 1902ST Jul 14, 1887 The shortfall extends to drought and failed crops, with money and goods yielding little practical benefit, and it serves as a call to consider one's ways.ST Dec 22, 1914ST Aug 24, 1904ST Apr 9, 1902
The term for drinking denotes drinking amply or freely rather than becoming intoxicated.RH Oct 13, 1868 The pierced bag signifies that resources are dissipated instead of conferring lasting benefit.RH Mar 2, 1876RH Apr 17, 1879ST Dec 30, 1903 It is an emblem of the uncertainty and unreliability of all earthly possessions, in which wealth may be present yet afford no satisfaction, enjoyment, or practical use, and is liable to wear out and be lost.RH Apr 17, 1879ST Feb 2, 1882ST Dec 30, 1903 By contrast, releasing possessions in faith and love for distribution to needy brethren secures them beyond change or danger under divine guardianship as treasure laid up in heaven, making the heart more heavenly.ST Feb 2, 1882
The same image covers money committed to seemingly secure earthly depositories that can nevertheless fail and disappear.RH Apr 17, 1879 It likewise covers labor and earnings that are wasted and fall short of need, a condition illustrated by severe poverty in educational work where strenuous effort and sacrifice still leave funds inadequate to cover expenses.RH Apr 17, 1879RH Feb 23, 1905
Historical Setting
The word was spoken to the company that came up from Babylon to build the temple and then left the house of the Lord waste and unfinished while giving attention to their own homes.RH Dec 5, 1907ST Aug 30, 1883ST Feb 20, 1893ST Jul 14, 1887 While His house lay in ruins they dwelt in their own ceiled houses, finished luxuriously, every man running to his own house.ST Aug 30, 1883ST Feb 20, 1893 Their labor therefore brought little return, with poor harvests, insufficient food and drink, clothing that did not keep warm, and wages quickly lost.RH Dec 5, 1907ST Feb 20, 1893ST Jul 14, 1887 They forsook the work for years in the face of opposition and a severe drought that cut off crops, and they concluded from the hard times that the time had not come to build.ST Aug 30, 1883
The want described belonged to the time soon after the foundation of the temple was laid, when the temple still lay unfinished.ST Jun 21, 1883ST Jun 21, 1883 It was the deplorable condition of Jerusalem's people and of the Jews while the rebuilding was in progress, with crops and earnings yielding little and food, drink, and clothing failing to meet need.ST Jun 21, 1883ST Jun 21, 1883 That affliction was afterward recalled as a warning and encouragement to remain obedient to God.ST Jun 21, 1883 In that setting of disobedience and distress, the promise of renewed security seemed astonishing.ST Jun 21, 1883
The hardship came while God's blessing was withheld as they neglected His house for their own comfort and interests.ST Oct 13, 1909ST Apr 9, 1902 Haggai's rebuke called them to consider their ways and to put God's work first by rebuilding the temple.ST Oct 13, 1909ST Apr 9, 1902 They resumed His work, and from that time He promised to bless them.ST Aug 30, 1883 Then His blessing returned upon their labor and increase.ST Aug 30, 1883
Cause and Divine Action
The shortfall came because the people put their own interests, homes, comfort and needs first while the Lord's house lay neglected and waste, attending to their own ceiled houses yet slow, selfish and neglectful in rebuilding His house and cause and making His cause secondary.ST Aug 14, 1879ST Jan 22, 1880ST Apr 9, 1902ST Sep 12, 1878RH Feb 17, 1874 For that reason hard work yielded little benefit and labor and possessions failed to satisfy or prosper: much sowing brought in little harvest, eating left want of enough, drinking left want of being filled, clothing gave no warmth, and wages quickly disappeared as if put into a bag with holes.ST Jan 22, 1880ST Apr 9, 1902RH Apr 14, 1910ST Sep 12, 1878RH Feb 17, 1874 They could not prosper for themselves while the temple remained neglected, and the losses were the result of God withholding blessing and His prospering hand because His claims were neglected.ST Aug 14, 1879ST Jan 22, 1880RH Apr 14, 1910ST Sep 12, 1878RH Feb 17, 1874
He blew upon what they brought home until it came to little and was gone, stayed heaven from dew and earth from fruit, called drought upon the land and upon human labor, and withheld rain and fruitful crops.RH Nov 17, 1904RH May 21, 1914ST Mar 9, 1915ST Aug 30, 1883ST Feb 7, 1878 He allowed drought and pestilence alongside luxurious finishing of their own homes so they would recognize His displeasure and consider their ways and rebuild the temple.ST Apr 9, 1902ST Aug 30, 1883ST Feb 20, 1893 The wasted labor and scarce provision therefore show His power both to bestow and to withhold material blessings and to diminish the earth's increase and its products.RH Nov 17, 1904ST Aug 30, 1883ST Feb 7, 1878 The silver and gold are His, showing His ability to give and withhold prosperity and His right to receive homage.ST Aug 30, 1883
Withholding more than is meet and refusing to sacrifice from what one has to help His cause tends to poverty and pecuniary embarrassment, while scattering to assist His cause increases, with sparing sowing reaping sparingly and bountiful sowing reaping bountifully as God makes all sufficiency abound.ST Aug 30, 1883 The desire to avoid poverty by withholding effort from the temple brought the very want that was feared.RH Dec 5, 1907ST Aug 30, 1883 When His people withhold what is due to Him and neglect sacred things, He may afflict their families and diminish their possessions in proportion to their unwillingness to give, so that material efforts fail to bring blessing.ST Mar 4, 1903ST Aug 30, 1883
Tithe Offerings and Blessing
The verse warns that no one can afford to rob God by withholding tithe, freewill offerings, vows, and pledges for His work, and it is unsafe to defer offerings.RH Sep 16, 1902RH Feb 25, 1904RH Sep 9, 1902 Neglecting God's house while pursuing personal needs brings frustration and loss, with labor made to yield little.RH Sep 16, 1902 Withholding what belongs to God brings lack rather than gain, so that crops, food, drink, clothing, and wages do not meet needs.RH Feb 25, 1904 Neglecting to pay tithe and fulfill vows and choosing a life of personal exertion without faith brings removal of blessing, so that much effort produces little return and earnings disappear as if kept in a leaking bag, in clear contrast to a life of faith and obedience that proves the Lord and receives blessing from the open windows of heaven. A failed bean harvest illustrates sowing much and bringing in little when pledges to give for His work are not honored.RH Sep 9, 1902
Those who feel too poor to pay into His treasury and keep His portion for their own use sow much and bring in little, eat without enough, drink without being filled, clothe themselves without being warm, and put wages into a bag with holes, because God blows upon what they bring home until it comes to little and is gone while His house lies waste.RH May 21, 1914 The cause is that each runs to his own house while God's house lies waste, so heaven is stayed from dew and earth is stayed from fruit.RH May 21, 1914 God blows upon the business labor of those who neglect His work and fail to do their part, so however diligent they are they bring in little.RH Jul 28, 1868 Those who attend His gatherings in the fear of God even in a busy season like haying lose nothing pecuniarily because He can bless them, while property gained without faithful service to God profits nothing.RH Jul 28, 1868
A farmer's crops failed after he stopped bringing all the tithe to the storehouse, even while neighboring fields yielded abundantly, but after he resolved to give the Lord what was due he had a good harvest.RH Dec 17, 1903 The poor harvests, unmet needs, lack of warmth, and dwindling wages were part of the hardship faced while neglecting the rebuilding of God's house.ST Jun 22, 1904 When men regard their own work, houses, and gain as more important than the Lord's house and work, their sowing, eating, drinking, clothing, and wages bring little and leave them unsatisfied.ST Mar 13, 1884 When men put the Lord's work first, even giving money laid aside for years to buy a farm for old age, the whole amount needed to wipe out a church debt can be subscribed in less than an hour.ST Mar 13, 1884 Poverty is not accepted as an excuse to stop the work, for the deeper obstacles are personal sin and lack of faith in God's work, and correcting these opens the way for means to be provided.ST Jun 22, 1904
Use of Wealth Today
Means spent for personal gratification, comforts, and luxuries, or selfishly hoarded for greed of gain, is wages put into a leaking bag and is lost, while means invested in high and holy enterprises that carry God's cause forward is put into bags that have no holes, where it is profitable and safe and secure and gives a more elevated and permanent enjoyment.ST Aug 23, 1883RH Oct 5, 1911ST May 19, 1898 Planning for self, using what is made for one's own purposes, and giving God only what remains wastes earnings, for often there is then little or nothing left to give to support His work while His house and work lie waste.RH Oct 5, 1911ST May 19, 1898 Putting treasures into bags with holes is spending on self-indulgence instead of denying self as Christ allowed Himself only meager necessities and put His Father's business before all else.ST Aug 23, 1883RH Oct 5, 1911
By contrast, investing in the spread of divine light and truth is the better use of wealth, for earthly gain and provision are unreliable, with labor and earnings leaving needs unmet and wages lost, and money entrusted to apparently safe earthly deposits able to fail and disappear.RH Apr 17, 1879 Treasure willingly given for God's work is a safe investment that brings lasting enjoyment and is stored in heaven beyond the reach of decay, destruction, or theft.RH Nov 15, 1906 Accumulating wealth keeps money in such a pierced bag, liable to wear out and be lost as an apt emblem of the uncertainty of all earthly possessions, while parting with possessions in faith and love to distribute to needy brethren secures against that loss, laying up treasure in heaven under God's guardianship out of reach of change or danger and making the heart more heavenly.RH Nov 15, 1906RH Apr 17, 1879ST Feb 2, 1882 Spreading the third angel's message is the work that such secure investment supports.RH Aug 30, 1906
Money put into plausible worldly schemes to get rich quickly is earnings lost through a leaking purse, often ending with depleted means, with no dividend while the promoter grows rich and with riches still beyond reach.RH Jul 23, 1914RH Aug 30, 1906 God's blessing is not upon such investments, and investments that remain beyond reach and yield no return divert means that could have supported the work.RH Jul 23, 1914RH Aug 30, 1906 The loss comes from being minded to be rich and loving money, which lets the adversary prompt and foster the scheme, hold the means where it can never be obtained for spreading God's message, and advance his own purposes while hindering God's work.RH Jul 23, 1914 Entrusting means given as a stewardship to worldly money-making turns its handling over to the god of this world, who will never use it to advance God's cause or serve eternal interests, and it is far better to store treasure in heaven where it does not fail.RH Jul 23, 1914
Sending men and money to proclaim the message in all parts of the world without the manifestation of God's power is wasted like money in a bag with a hole, for the Holy Spirit must be present for mission work to succeed.RH Jul 22, 1909 Wealth gained while neglecting God brings no lasting satisfaction, for people work and earn yet their resources are like money in a bag with holes, consuming attention and leaving them spiritually starved with no progress toward heaven.ST Dec 1, 1887ST May 13, 1908 Money gathered through commerce and greed is like money placed in a bag with holes, and holding on to it can draw the soul toward destruction.ST Dec 1, 1887ST May 13, 1908 Earnings and possessions can fail to provide security, with wages gained only to disappear like money kept in a bag with holes, as seen when possessions were swept away, in contrast with generous giving to the Lord despite poverty.RH Apr 3, 1879
The same condition is illustrated by barren fields and labor that yields no harvest, over which Israel sighs and weeps and longs for plentiful rain.ST Jun 28, 1905 It is illustrated also by severe poverty in educational work, where labor and earnings fail to provide enough because resources are wasted or do not meet needs, and despite effort and sacrifice funds remain inadequate to cover expenses and carry on the work.ST Jun 28, 1905RH Feb 23, 1905 Neglect of God's work while devoting self to personal comfort leaves labor and earnings bringing little benefit, with poor crops, food and drink that do not satisfy, clothes that do not keep warm, and wages quickly lost and spent, because God's blessing is not present.ST Oct 13, 1909ST Aug 24, 1904ST Sep 9, 1913ST Aug 23, 1899 This frustration and want from self-serving work and neglect of the temple, rooted in selfishness and sin and lack of faith, is a rebuke that carries also a promise of blessing and calls to consider ways, to rise and rebuild the temple and put God's work first.ST Oct 13, 1909ST Aug 24, 1904ST Sep 9, 1913ST Aug 23, 1899
To consider ways is to stop saying with lips what actions deny, to live with Christ's coming in this generation as an ever-present thought, to separate from self-indulgence to be true sons and daughters of God, and to deny self so mission funds are increased and missionaries are not forced to return and the work retarded.RH Oct 5, 1911 It is to answer the Macedonian cry and to make it the principal object of life and delight of the heart to point clearly to Christ rather than neglect so great salvation.RH Oct 5, 1911
Sources