James 2:14
What doth it profit, my brethren, though a man say he hath faith, and have not works? can faith save him?
Translations
What does it profit, my brothers, though a man say he has faith, and have not works? can faith save him?
King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible
What doth it profit, my brethren, though a man say he hath faith, and have not works? can faith save him?
What doth it profit, my brethren, though a man sayeth he hath faith, and hath not works? can faith save him?
Revised Version, American Standard Version
What doth it profit, my brethren, if a man say he hath faith, but have not works? can that faith save him?
What [is] the profit, my brethren, if faith, any one may speak of having, and works he may not have? is that faith able to save him?
What [ is] the profit, my brethren, if any one say he have faith, but have not works? can faith save him?
What profit, my brethren,—if one should be saying he hath, faith, but hath not, works; can his faith save him?
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
What good is it, my brothers, if someone claims to have faith, but has no deeds? Can such faith save him?
What good is it, my brothers, if a man says he has faith, but has no works? Can faith save him?
What use is it, my brothers, for a man to say that he has faith, if he does nothing? will such a faith give him salvation?
What auaileth it, my brethren, though a man saith he hath faith, when he hath no workes? can that faith saue him?
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
What shall it profit, my brethren, if a man say he hath faith, but hath not works? Shall faith be able to save him?
Cross-references 20 of 65
- Galatians 5:6
For in Jesus Christ neither circumcision availeth any thing, nor uncircumcision; but faith which worketh by love.
Faith works through love, describing the active faith James teaches.
- James 2:19
Thou believest that there is one God; thou doest well: the devils also believe, and tremble.
Even demons believe, showing belief alone is not saving faith.
- James 2:26
For as the body without the spirit is dead, so faith without works is dead also.
Faith without works is dead, like a body without a spirit.
- James 2:21-22
Was not Abraham our father justified by works, when he had offered Isaac his son upon the altar?
Abraham’s obedience shows faith working with works and being made perfect.
- James 2:18
Yea, a man may say, Thou hast faith, and I have works: shew me thy faith without thy works, and I will shew thee my faith by my works.
Faith is demonstrated by works.
- Matthew 7:16-20
Ye shall know them by their fruits. Do men gather grapes of thorns, or figs of thistles?
A person’s works reveal whether professed faith is genuine.
- Ephesians 2:8-10
For by grace are ye saved through faith; and that not of yourselves: it is the gift of God:
Salvation is by grace through faith, with good works following.
- Matthew 7:21
Not every one that saith unto me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the kingdom of heaven; but he that doeth the will of my Father which is in heaven.
Doing the Father’s will, not merely professing faith, is the test.
- James 1:22
But be ye doers of the word, and not hearers only, deceiving your own selves.
Both reject professing or hearing without doing.
- James 2:24
Ye see then how that by works a man is justified, and not by faith only.
Works justify and show faith’s fruit, not faith alone.
- Matthew 7:24-27
Therefore whosoever heareth these sayings of mine, and doeth them, I will liken him unto a wise man, which built his house upon a rock:
The wise and foolish are distinguished by whether they act on what they hear.
- Romans 3:31
Do we then make void the law through faith? God forbid: yea, we establish the law.
Faith establishes rather than makes void the law.
- Genesis 22:1-12
And it came to pass after these things, that God did tempt Abraham, and said unto him, Abraham: and he said, Behold, here I am.
Abraham’s offering of Isaac demonstrates faith working through obedience.
- Romans 3:28
Therefore we conclude that a man is justified by faith without the deeds of the law.
Contrasted with James’s emphasis on works connected with faith.
- Genesis 15:6
And he believed in the LORD; and he counted it to him for righteousness.
Abraham’s belief is counted to him as righteousness.
- Revelation 22:12
And, behold, I come quickly; and my reward is with me, to give every man according as his work shall be.
Christ rewards each person according to their works.
- 1 John 2:4-5
He that saith, I know him, and keepeth not his commandments, is a liar, and the truth is not in him.
Keeping God’s word tests whether a profession of knowing him is genuine.
- Matthew 5:16
Let your light so shine before men, that they may see your good works, and glorify your Father which is in heaven.
Good works make faith visible to others and bring glory to God.
- James 2:20
But wilt thou know, O vain man, that faith without works is dead?
Faith without works is dead.
- Titus 1:16
They profess that they know God; but in works they deny him, being abominable, and disobedient, and unto every good work reprobate.
Works can contradict a profession of knowing God.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
41 sources
Merely claiming to have faith while having no works is worthless and does no good.ST Apr 19, 1910Ms 101, 1901, par. 56–57Ms 72, 1898, par. 5 That kind of faith cannot save, for it has no saving power to secure eternal life.ST Apr 19, 1910Ms 101, 1901, par. 56–57Ms 72, 1898, par. 5 Faith without works is dead because it is alone, while faith sustained by works is living faith.Ms 101, 1901, par. 56–57Ms 72, 1898, par. 5GC 471.3–472.2 Genuine faith acts together with works and is brought to maturity and made complete by them, so that good works spring from it and justify it, and a person is justified by works and not by faith alone.ST Apr 19, 1910GC 471.3–472.2Lt 105, 1898, par. 14 This is shown in Abraham offering Isaac upon the altar, and in the brother or sister without clothing and destitute of daily food who is told to depart in peace to be warmed and filled without being given the things needed for the body, proving that words of peace and belief are empty when help is withheld.ST Apr 19, 1910Ms 72, 1898, par. 5GC 471.3–472.2Lt 16, 1868, par. 20–21Ms 39, 1896, par. 10
Profitless Profession Illustrated
Merely saying one has faith, as a claim or profession without works, is of no profit, does no good, and is worthless.ST Apr 19, 1910Ms 101, 1901, par. 56–57Ms 72, 1898, par. 5GC 471.3–472.2Lt 185, 1902, par. 19–21 Such a claim profits nothing and God is displeased with such a religion, for words of peace and belief are empty when the help others need is withheld and Christian speech and conduct must agree with profession.Lt 56, 1901, par. 7–10Lt 185, 1902, par. 19–21Ms 39, 1896, par. 102T 685.1RH Dec 24, 1901 Living faith must be shown through practical care for people in need and active efforts to rescue souls, and without those deeds faith is dead and alone.Ms 101, 1901, par. 56–57Lt 56, 1901, par. 7–10Lt 16, 1868, par. 20–21 Those who profess faith while acting as critics who hinder appointed work in Nashville and the South, withholding and turning away means that ought to go to that hard field and increasing discouragement, have this faith without works and are called to reformation, to stop hindering and help instead, to show greater wisdom and reason from cause to effect, and without delay to do the work they need to do.Lt 185, 1902, par. 19–21
The question whether that kind of faith can save is answered that it cannot save and has no saving virtue or power to secure eternal life.ST Apr 19, 1910Ms 101, 1901, par. 56–57Ms 72, 1898, par. 5GC 471.3–472.2Lt 56, 1901, par. 7–10 A person's claim to have faith cannot save if it is not accompanied by works, and claiming the favor of Heaven without complying with the conditions on which mercy is granted is not genuine faith but presumption.ST Apr 19, 1910GC 471.3–472.2 Genuine faith acts and works with obedience, as when Abraham offered Isaac his son upon the altar, and by works faith is brought to maturity and made perfect, so that a person is justified by works and not by faith alone.ST Apr 19, 1910GC 471.3–472.2 Faith without works is dead, and belief in truth cannot save when its principles are not lived out, for professed faith contradicted by selfishness and grasping after worldly goods does not support that profession.Lt 16, 1868, par. 20–212T 656.2–657.2SG1 126.2
The profitlessness is illustrated by a brother or sister without clothing and destitute of daily food who is told to depart in peace to be warmed and filled, while not being given the things needed for the body.Ms 72, 1898, par. 5Lt 16, 1868, par. 20–21Ms 39, 1896, par. 102T 685.1RH Dec 24, 1901 Seeing such need and offering only kind words, good wishes, and saying to be warmed and filled without providing what the body needs does no good and leaves faith dead and useless.Ms 72, 1898, par. 5Ms 39, 1896, par. 102T 685.1 Deeds reveal the character behind a profession of faith as fruit reveals a tree, and works must show that sympathy and love are sincere.2T 685.1 Faith must therefore be expressed in practical care for others and in meeting bodily needs.Ms 72, 1898, par. 5Lt 16, 1868, par. 20–21
The verse stands under being judged by the perfect law of liberty, where speaking and doing must agree and mercy must be shown, because judgment without mercy falls on one who showed no mercy.Ms 39, 1896, par. 10 True faith is proved by being shown in works, and in that condition faith without works is dead, being alone.Ms 39, 1896, par. 10
The verse is underlined by the fact that even Satan and his angels believe truths about Jesus, his crucifixion and resurrection, and tremble, yet that belief produces no obedience or good works.Lt 16, 1868, par. 20–212T 656.2–657.2SG1 126.2EW 191.1 Mere belief in Jesus, his crucifixion, and his resurrection is not enough by itself to save when it produces no good works.SG1 126.2EW 191.1 Living faith leads people to do good works and imitate Christ's self-denying life, while without that fruit a Christian profession can conceal an unchanged, carnal nature and leave evil passions unsubdued, so that such nominal profession can serve Satan and bring reproach on Christ and on true religion.SG1 126.2EW 191.1 Even Satan believes and acts, but his works are evil, showing that belief producing no obedience has no saving virtue.Lt 16, 1868, par. 20–212T 656.2–657.2
Nature of Genuine Faith
Faith without works is dead, being alone, and a bare claim to have faith without works is useless and cannot save.Ms 101, 1901, par. 56–57Ms 72, 1898, par. 5GC 471.3–472.2Lt 11, 1899, par. 4Lt 16, 1868, par. 20–21 Living faith is faith sustained and shown by works, especially deeds of mercy toward those in need, while profession contradicted by neglect of bodily needs, selfishness, and grasping after worldly goods proves the profession empty.Ms 101, 1901, par. 56–57Ms 72, 1898, par. 5Lt 16, 1868, par. 20–21Ms 39, 1896, par. 10ST Sep 10, 1894 Speaking and doing must agree and mercy must be shown, for such faith stands under the perfect law of liberty.Ms 39, 1896, par. 10
Genuine faith acts and works together with works, and by works faith is brought to maturity and made complete.ST Apr 19, 1910GC 471.3–472.2ST Sep 10, 1894GC88 472.1–22T 663.1–664.2 This was proved when Abraham's faith worked with obedience in offering Isaac his son upon the altar, and works brought his faith to maturity.ST Apr 19, 1910GC 471.3–472.2 A life consistent with belief gives reality to faith, producing Christlike selfless concern for saving souls and persevering effort in obedience and service.ST Sep 10, 18942T 663.1–664.2
Good works necessarily spring from genuine faith and justify and endorse it, so a person is justified by works and not by faith alone.ST Apr 19, 1910GC 471.3–472.2Lt 105, 1898, par. 14GC88 472.1–2 Genuine faith relies on God's plain word and cannot be separated from the good works it necessarily produces.Lt 105, 1898, par. 14 Genuine faith is founded in the promises and provisions of Scripture, while claiming the favor of Heaven without complying with the conditions on which mercy is granted is not genuine faith but presumption and an ensnaring falsehood.GC 471.3–472.2Lt 105, 1898, par. 14GC88 472.1–2ST Apr 19, 1910 That foundation embraces the entire being of spirit, soul, and body.ST Apr 19, 1910
Genuine faith works through love, purifies the soul, and bears outward fruit revealing inward piety and Christlike character, while faith producing no such works is false.4SP 311.2Ms 16, 1898, par. 9GC 487.2Lt 105, 1898, par. 1514MR 99.2 Merely claiming faith in Christ has no value apart from love expressed in works, and good works are the necessary fruit and sure evidence of passing from death to life, shown by love for fellow believers and zeal to work for God, though not requiring everyone to follow the same path.4SP 311.2GC 487.2Lt 105, 1898, par. 15 Those lacking this purifying, obedient faith may refuse divine warnings.14MR 99.2
The faith that saves has Jesus always and Jesus only as the object of faith, hope, and love, renews the heart, and brings the new birth in which Christ takes sins upon Himself and imparts His own righteousness.Ms 48, 1891, par. 45 Faith alone is not enough and works alone are not sufficient, but faith must be joined with works, and united they accomplish much.Lt 33, 1874, par. 1–4Ms 48, 1891, par. 45
Justification Obedience Judgment
Abraham offering Isaac his son upon the altar is the proof that faith worked together with obedience and was brought to maturity and made complete by works, so that a person is justified by works and not by faith alone.ST Apr 19, 1910GC 471.3–472.2GC88 472.1–2 A mere claim to have faith cannot save when it is not accompanied by works, because genuine faith acts.ST Apr 19, 1910GC88 472.1–2 Faith that seeks the favor of Heaven without complying with the conditions on which mercy is granted is not genuine faith but presumption, for genuine faith is founded on the promises and provisions of Scripture.GC 471.3–472.2GC88 472.1–2
Faith that does not issue in obedience cannot save, and a claim to holiness is without foundation when one knowingly breaks the commandments.GC 471.3–472.2GC88 472.3 Faith is to be practiced in daily life through obedience to God's law and doing the truth.GC 471.3–472.2Ms 7, 1898, par. 17–20 Saving faith works through love, purifies the soul, and leads to doing what is right and obeying God's law, while profession alone does not prove a saving connection with Christ.14MR 99.26MR 157.2 True repentance is shown by a changed life and good works, with words, conduct and character conforming to God's will, each person doing his own duties and God's will, delighting in His commandments and depending on Jesus Christ for support and strength.14MR 99.26MR 157.2
The doctrine that sanctification is an instantaneous work by faith alone requiring no further effort and releasing people from obligation to keep the law is false.GC 471.3–472.2 No one can be holy in harmony with the will and character of God without coming into harmony with the principles that express His nature and will and show what is well pleasing to Him, which includes obligation to keep the commandments.GC 471.3–472.2
Merely claiming faith in Christ has no value by itself, and whether such faith can save is answered by the need for works that demonstrate faith through love expressed in works.4SP 311.2GC 487.2 Claiming to have faith without works is mere pretense and semblance and profits nothing, because God calls for works and not words alone, and faith must be active in the Word of God including His will, with future happiness depending on that active faith.4SP 311.217MR 49.2–3 In the final and investigative judgment every person will be judged according to deeds done in the body, when use of God-given talents, abilities, time, resources, influence and entrusted truth will be examined.4SP 311.2GC 487.217MR 49.2–3 Then nothing will remain but the character formed and the law of God, with all seen as either righteous or unrighteous, and each person accountable for what has been entrusted to them.4SP 311.2GC 487.217MR 49.2–3
God values good works and rewards each person according to deeds.GC 487.210MR 234.1–236.1 Acts done from love, even if they seem small in human eyes, are accepted and rewarded by God.GC 487.2 Sharing wealth to relieve suffering is an example of being rich in good works.10MR 234.1–236.1
Mercy Mission and Unity
Claiming faith without works is useless and cannot save, for genuine faith is active and must be shown by deeds of mercy toward people in need, and without those deeds it is dead and alone.Ms 101, 1901, par. 56–57Ms 72, 1898, par. 5Lt 56, 1901, par. 7–10 Its emptiness is seen when a brother or sister without clothing and destitute of daily food is met only with kind words to depart in peace to be warmed and filled, while what the body needs is not provided.Ms 72, 1898, par. 5Ms 39, 1896, par. 10RH Dec 24, 1901 Words of peace and belief are empty when help is withheld, for Christian speech and conduct must agree with profession, and belief in truth cannot save when its principles are not lived out in meeting bodily needs.Lt 56, 1901, par. 7–10Lt 16, 1868, par. 20–212T 160.2 This stands under being judged by the perfect law of liberty, where speaking and doing must agree and mercy must be shown, because judgment without mercy falls on one who showed no mercy.Ms 39, 1896, par. 10 Even Satan believes and acts, but his works are evil, and professed faith contradicted by selfishness and eagerly grasping after worldly wealth and goods does not support that profession.Lt 16, 1868, par. 20–212T 160.2
A life consistent with belief gives power to the presentation of truth, convicting sinners and drawing them to Christ, for faith sustained by works is living faith whose reality is shown by such consistency.ST Sep 10, 18942T 663.1–664.2 By contrast, conduct that contradicts profession denies the faith professed, because conduct tells others whether that faith is genuine.4T 250.24T 247.1 Working on the Sabbath is such a denial, and disregarding the sacred weekly rest by taking time set apart for prayer and meditation for worldly work leads others to think the commandments need not be strictly obeyed.4T 250.24T 247.1 Genuine faith therefore produces Christlike, selfless concern for saving souls with persevering effort in obedience and service.ST Sep 10, 18942T 663.1–664.2
That concern calls believers to active efforts to rescue souls and to use the means entrusted by God to advance His cause and help save others, for faith that leaves those duties undone is dead and has no saving virtue.Lt 56, 1901, par. 7–10ST Sep 10, 18942T 656.2–657.2 It leads to willingness to sacrifice money and possessions to help save those perishing, since even Satan believes the truth yet that belief produces no obedience or good works.2T 656.2–657.22T 663.1–664.2 Saying one has faith profits nothing if there are no works, so those who profess to believe must awaken to duty lest more souls be lost who might have been saved.RH Dec 24, 1901 They must put away superficial excuses and delay, do all they can to help forward the work, go into all parts of the world to diffuse truth so men and women may be led to Christ, and as laborers together with God cooperate with angels sent to minister to those who shall be heirs of salvation.RH Dec 24, 1901
The religion of faith with works means putting away all that hinders coming together in unity, with strenuous efforts toward unity in faith.11MR 49.1Lt 204, 1902, par. 1–2 It requires seeking most earnestly as never before to make right every wrong between brethren and leaving no sins unconfessed.11MR 49.1Lt 204, 1902, par. 1–2 God is displeased with a religion that says it has faith without works, for it profits nothing and cannot save.Lt 185, 1902, par. 19–21 Such faith without works is found where those professing faith act as critics hindering appointed work in Nashville and the South, withholding and turning away means that ought to go to that hard field and increasing discouragement for brethren.Lt 185, 1902, par. 19–21 The call is for reformation without delay, to stop hindering and to help instead, to show greater wisdom and reason from cause to effect, and to do the work needed for themselves.Lt 185, 1902, par. 19–21
Now above all times this demands putting every nerve and muscle to the stretch in active work, for true faith is shown by works.Lt 11, 1899, par. 4 The last call to the supper is being given, the lamp of the soul must be kept trimmed and burning by the holy oil, every soul must depart from all iniquity lest the day of the Lord overtake as a thief, and the truth must be proclaimed in clear straight lines as it is in Jesus.Lt 11, 1899, par. 4
Daily Faithfulness Applied
Profession of faith without practical service is not genuine religion, and true conversion is shown by honesty in dealings with others, faithfulness in everyday work, and using one's abilities in Christ's service.MYP 72.2Ms 29, 1911, par. 55 Claiming to have faith without practical Christian work cannot save, for profession must be accompanied by obedience to God at any cost.Ms 29, 1911, par. 55 Overcoming selfishness is a mark of true conversion together with that obedience.Ms 29, 1911, par. 55 A claim to faith or profession of belief does not by itself secure eternal life, but earnest works show living faith.Lt 78, 1907, par. 6
Living faith calls for guarding the heart, controlling the tongue, and seeking opportunities to do good as Jesus did.Lt 78, 1907, par. 6 It looks to Jesus as the source and completion of faith, so that well-built Christian character follows the divine pattern.Lt 78, 1907, par. 6 Sharing wealth to relieve suffering is an example of being rich in good works, for claiming faith is not enough and God values good works and rewards each person according to deeds.10MR 234.1–236.1 Even faith in divine power to heal does not save unless it is joined with intelligent, good works, since claiming faith without such works is dead.HL 238.3
The verse gives practical health principles as God's great remedy for diseases of body and soul and as God's health reform prescription.Lt 26, 1907, par. 7–8 Genuine faith embraces the entire being of spirit, soul, and body and does not claim favor without complying with the conditions on which mercy is granted, having its foundation in the promises and provisions of Scripture.ST Apr 19, 1910 All powers are to be preserved in the best possible condition for the service of the Creator, presenting the body as a living sacrifice, holy and acceptable and without blemish like the ancient sacrifices, offering nothing less than the best.Lt 26, 1907, par. 7–8ST Apr 19, 1910 Every practice that weakens physical or mental strength is to be put away as unfit for His service.ST Apr 19, 1910
Its lessons are to be brought into daily life and daily course of action and into character building, with the heart opened to principles of righteousness under large grace.Lt 26, 1907, par. 7–8 Taking heed to it day by day brings triumph at last with the overcomers, along with prosperity and heaven brought very near.Lt 26, 1907, par. 7–8 It brings happiness of spirit and sight of divine salvation, and an experience that makes a tower of strength, making a place of work a place where angels delight to come.Lt 26, 1907, par. 7–8
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
96 sources
To say one has faith while having no works brings no profit and cannot save from sin, for the expected answer is no.ST Apr 19, 1910ST May 13, 1897ST May 12, 1890ST Aug 6, 1896ST Nov 10, 1909 Such faith without works is dead, being alone, a hollow and counterfeit profession rather than living faith.ST May 13, 1897ST Mar 1, 1877ST May 13, 1897ST May 13, 1897ST Aug 6, 1896 Genuine saving faith is living and active, trusting in the Messiah and working through love to give power to obey, so that good works necessarily follow as its fruit and visible sign.ST Sep 10, 1894ST May 13, 1897ST May 13, 1897ST May 13, 1897ST Apr 7, 1881 This does not teach salvation by works apart from Christ, for remission of past sins is received entirely by faith without works, while that justification is then shown, kept and maintained by faith bearing good works, which do not earn forgiveness or take the place of Christ's blood.ST Jan 8, 1880ST Aug 23, 1877ST Sep 12, 1878ST Mar 29, 1883 The works that complete faith are obedience to every precept of the royal law of liberty, fulfilled in love to God and neighbor, and proved in practical charity to the hungry, naked, sick and poor rather than in words alone.RH Sep 30, 1852ST Jun 17, 1897RH Sep 30, 1852ST Jul 31, 1884RH Jul 4, 1854
Letter Setting and Question
James 2:14 belongs to James's exceedingly practical general epistle, written by the brother of the Lord to Christians scattered abroad.ST Dec 12, 1911 It was addressed not to any special class but to the people of God scattered abroad, applied in the apostle's day, and looked forward to a time when the Lord's coming is near.ST Dec 12, 1911 It stands in an epistle marked by strong practical teaching and application.ST Nov 10, 1909
The verse asks what profit there is though a man say he hath faith and have not works, and whether that faith can save him.ST May 12, 1890ST Aug 6, 1896ST Nov 10, 1909 The implied and expected answer is no: a mere claim to have faith cannot save if it has no works.ST May 12, 1890ST Aug 6, 1896 Lack of good works, or fruit of the Spirit, shows that the person does not actually possess faith despite professing it, for genuine faith necessarily produces works and excludes boasting.ST May 12, 1890 The verse does not deny faith's power to save, but shows that a false profession has no saving power, since saving faith is not dead or alone but is shown in the good works it produces.ST May 12, 1890ST Aug 6, 1896 Belief has no saving value if it does not lead to action, and professing faith without works raises the question of whether that faith can save, because genuine faith is evidenced by good works as proof that it is real.ST May 18, 1904RH Oct 19, 1916 Faith is shown by acting on God's word, as when accepting Christian education and its principles by faith means committing to them in practice and allowing them to test whether one trusts God.RH Dec 16, 1902
Faith is a condition of salvation, not its cause: faith does not save, but Christ does.ST Jul 22, 1880 Saving faith is a sign of salvation, and faith is necessary to please God.ST Jul 22, 1880 Faith does not remove the need for personal effort, for each person has work to do in seeking salvation and helping save others, which Christ, the angels, and the Holy Spirit do not perform in place of people.ST Oct 27, 1881
Faith Without Works Is Dead
To say one has faith while having no works brings no profit and cannot save from sin.ST Apr 19, 1910ST May 13, 1897ST May 13, 1897ST Aug 6, 1896ST Oct 21, 1886 Such a claim is counterfeit when it refuses to bear or even attempt to bear the fruit of the Spirit, for saving faith works through love while works themselves do not earn justification.ST May 13, 1897ST May 13, 1897ST Jul 18, 1911 Genuine faith trusts in the Messiah and leads to doing what God's law requires, and like Abraham's faith working with his obedience in offering Isaac, works reveal faith and bring it to maturity.ST Apr 19, 1910ST May 13, 1897 Living faith is shown by the good works it produces and by doing what God asks and acting on His promises, so faith and works are not opposed.ST Aug 6, 1896ST Jul 18, 1911 A claim to care for one lacking food or clothing is empty if no help is given, and mere belief that God exists is not enough.ST Aug 6, 1896ST Oct 21, 1886
Faith without works is dead, being alone, a hollow profession rather than Christian faith that leads to good works.ST May 13, 1897ST Oct 21, 1886 Faith that does not lead to action is dead, for faith is meant to lead a person to work in the work God has for his own time, taking part in and supporting it rather than resting only on work already completed by others.ST Mar 1, 1877 Faith that remains alone is counterfeit, powerless, feigned, useless, and an empty profession rather than living faith.ST May 13, 1897ST May 13, 1897ST Aug 6, 1896 Claimed faith without works gives no reason to believe faith is present, since faith is the life and good works are its proof.ST May 6, 1889
Dead faith is powerless like a body without breath, and as useless as a body without the spirit.ST Aug 6, 1896 It is like words offering warmth and food to a needy, naked, hungry, freezing brother or sister destitute of daily food without providing what is needful to the body, telling such a one to depart in peace, be warmed and filled, which profits nothing.ST Aug 23, 1877RH Dec 16, 1873RH Nov 15, 1853 So faith if it has no works is dead, being alone, and a profession of faith without the righteous acts required by God's law cannot save.RH Dec 16, 1873RH Aug 5, 1852 Mere saying one believes, only believing and trembling like devils, is no more saving than the devils' belief, for they believe and tremble but are not saved.ST Aug 6, 1896ST Aug 23, 1877 Dead faith receives the Holy Ghost and the blessings of justification and glorification as into a grave, and the quickening, life-giving Spirit must be sought to give living, working faith.
Mere saying, feeling, knowing, theological trust, good intention, or religious appearances cannot be counted as living faith.RH May 2, 1865RH Sep 2, 1873RH Nov 24, 1859ST May 6, 1889ST Nov 10, 1881 A claim to faith without works has no saving benefit, for genuine faith is shown in action, not in feelings or words alone.RH May 2, 1865 Living faith is needed rather than mere agreement with a belief, and profession must be consistent with conduct toward God and Christ and toward other people, lest inconsistency bring religion into disrepute.RH Sep 2, 1873RH Nov 24, 1859 Saying one has faith is not enough to save, for faith must be joined with works and prayer, acting on what it believes and placing treasure beyond rather than hiding it in shifting sand, since mere talk and doing as others do cannot secure it when terror and danger come.ST Nov 10, 1881 Claiming to believe is of no use if a person does not act on belief and continues in wrongdoing unchanged in character and conduct, for genuine conversion and repentance turn from the old way and renewal by God's Spirit changes behavior.RH Nov 17, 1859
Claimed faith must be evidenced by good works, for good works are necessary as evidence that faith is real and are a measure of faith and part of Christian duty.RH Oct 19, 1916ST Sep 12, 1878 Works reveal whether a person truly knows and loves God, so profession without obedience can be self-deception.RH Apr 3, 1855 Believing true teachings about Jesus or professing faith in Him is not enough unless Christ is revealed in a life of righteous deeds and obedience, for works reveal character and whether faith is real.ST Feb 3, 1909 What people do shows whether they truly believe and are preparing for Christ's coming, and works that do not arise from faith cannot be relied on as lasting evidence.ST May 6, 1889RH Nov 28, 1871
Genuine Saving Faith Works
Genuine saving faith is active and living, trusting in the Messiah and working through love to do what God's law requires, giving power to obey and necessarily producing good works as its fruit and visible sign.ST May 13, 1897ST May 13, 1897ST May 13, 1897ST Jan 8, 1880ST May 12, 1890 A bare claim to have faith while having no works profits nothing and cannot save from sin, for refusing to bear or even attempt to bear the fruit of the Spirit shows the claim to be hollow, counterfeit profession rather than possession of faith.ST May 13, 1897ST May 13, 1897ST May 13, 1897ST Jan 8, 1880ST May 12, 1890 Works do not earn justification and eternal life is not gained by good works alone apart from the Saviour, for Christ died for sins and the redeemed wash their robes white in His blood; faith justifies, but genuine faith is never fruitless and never remains alone, and it excludes boasting.ST May 13, 1897ST May 13, 1897ST Jan 8, 1880ST May 12, 1890 Such faith is not a claim to favor apart from obedience but rests on Scripture's promises and provisions and meets the conditions on which mercy is granted, working with obedience so that works show it to be living.ST Mar 30, 1888ST May 13, 1897
Works reveal, show, and measure faith and bring it to maturity, for deeds done because faith is already present are its fruits and visible signs, not means to obtain faith or earn salvation.ST Apr 19, 1910RH Sep 30, 1852ST Mar 4, 1889ST Aug 23, 1877 Abraham's offering of Isaac is the example, where faith worked with obedience and works brought faith to maturity and made it complete, so that a person is justified by works and not by faith alone.ST Apr 19, 1910 In the same way obedience to every precept makes faith complete and proves it genuine and saving, each act of obedience serving as a visible sign of faith, and justification first gotten entirely by faith without works cannot be kept without works to show its virtue, maintain righteous character, keep from sin, and work out salvation.RH Sep 30, 1852 Like words offering warmth and food to a needy person without providing either, faith without action is profitless and dead, no more saving than the devils' belief, rejecting both trust in good works apart from Christ and a faith that leaves life out of harmony with God's commandments.ST Aug 23, 1877
Faith is meant to lead to work, and faith that does not lead to action is dead.ST Mar 1, 1877ST Nov 11, 1880 Living faith trusts and supports the work God calls people to do in their own time, taking part in it and sustaining it rather than resting only on work already completed by others in the past.ST Mar 1, 1877ST Nov 11, 1880 Merely knowing and believing the truth and holding firmly to it will not save, for truth saves only when honored and used, when knowledge and faith are put to work with all God-given abilities to advance the cause of truth, assist others to gain the kingdom, and exalt it.ST Jun 12, 1884 For one who believes the present message is now being given, genuine faith is proved by not grasping after the world but by freely giving means to sustain God's work, and using surplus goods to advance present truth is a test of conduct bearing on readiness for Christ's return.RH Dec 9, 1852
Faith and works must not be divided, for they may be divided in the intellect but in reality they belong together.RH Jul 19, 1864RH Aug 4, 1874 They are like light and heat in a candle, so that when the candle is put out both are gone and one does not remain without the other, and like warp and woof inseparable in a web, so that either one alone is useless in serving God.RH Jul 19, 1864RH Aug 4, 1874 Saying one has faith without works is only pretending to believe, and working without believing is equally defective; a saint does both, obeying the law as fully as if there were no gospel to be believed and believing the gospel as fully as if there were no law to be obeyed.RH Dec 22, 1863 So also they are not dissevered in healing: claiming faith for removal of infirmities while rejecting institutions and means for recovery is false faith, while true faith joins works of obedience to health laws, simple rational treatments, discarding drug medication, learning to dress, breathe, eat and prevent sickness properly, and enlarging facilities so those healed can act as medical missionaries.RH Apr 23, 1908
Saving faith does not stand alone but is joined with a life of obedient character, continued growth in grace, prayer, and doing the duty at hand.ST Apr 7, 1881ST Nov 10, 1881ST Jun 3, 1889 Faith sustained by works is living faith whose reality is shown by a life consistent with belief, producing Christlike selfless concern for saving souls and persevering effort in obedience and service, practiced in ordinary family duties and service to others.ST Sep 10, 1894ST Jun 3, 1889 Genuine faith appears in just and merciful treatment of others, for piety is not genuine if prayers and religious zeal coexist with withholding alms, dishonesty, injustice, harshness, or oppression; love of God is shown in love for people, the fruits of the Spirit accompany it, and religious appearances without these works are empty and cannot prove saving faith. Faith acts on what it believes, placing treasure beyond rather than hiding it in shifting sand, for mere talk and doing as others do cannot secure it in terror and danger, and charitable giving must be accompanied by kind sympathetic words to be genuine charity, lest faith leave a person selfish and unfruitful.ST Nov 10, 1881ST Jun 3, 1889 Faith which believes God's promises but rejects His commands is not true, full, or complete, for turning away from commanded duty puts a person out of harmony with Him.ST Apr 16, 1912
Justification by Faith and Works
James does not contradict Paul and does not teach salvation by works alone apart from Christ.ST Jan 8, 1880ST Aug 23, 1877ST Sep 12, 1878ST Mar 20, 1907 James warns against relying on an inactive faith that leaves life out of harmony with God's commandments, while Paul warns against trusting works to earn salvation.ST Aug 23, 1877ST Mar 20, 1907 A claim to faith without works is profitless and dead, like offering words of warmth and food to a needy person without providing either, and it cannot save, being no more saving than the belief of devils.ST Jan 8, 1880ST Aug 23, 1877ST Sep 12, 1878 Grace, faith, and works are all included in salvation, with works belonging with faith in the gospel by which people are saved, and faith is not presented as a substitute for obedience.ST Sep 18, 1884ST Mar 20, 1907 Eternal life is not gained by good works alone apart from the Saviour, for Christ died for sins and the redeemed are washed white in the blood of the Lamb and overcome by the blood of the Lamb and the word of their testimony, and good works cannot purchase victory or God's favor though victory cannot be had without them.ST Jan 8, 1880ST Mar 20, 1907 James's argument has a different subject from Paul's discussion of justification for remission of past sins.
Initial justification and remission of past sins is gotten entirely by faith without works, since no present doing can atone for the past.RH Dec 16, 1873ST Mar 29, 1883RH Jul 25, 1854RH Jul 6, 1869 Paul describes a sinner's initial justification as by faith without works, while James describes the justified Christian's continuing standing before God as shown and maintained by faith bearing good works.RH Jul 6, 1869 James is speaking not about remission of past sins, which works cannot affect, but about forming character through actions after a person is justified by faith.ST Mar 29, 1883RH Jul 6, 1869 That justification cannot be kept without works, for works are needed to show the virtue of faith, to maintain a righteous character before God, to keep from sin so that justification anew is not needed, and so to work out salvation by continuing patiently in well-doing.ST Mar 29, 1883 Obedience to God's law can accompany justification by faith in Christ through whom past sins are forgiven, as fruit of faith rather than seeking justification by keeping the law.ST Mar 29, 1883RH Jul 25, 1854
Works do not earn forgiveness, purchase God's favor, or take the place of Christ's blood.RH Dec 16, 1873RH Feb 17, 1852ST Sep 18, 1884ST Mar 20, 1907RH Apr 19, 1864 Faith brings pardon of past sins through grace and redemption in Christ's blood, since no one is righteous, and then supplies strength to do right, work out salvation, and form a holy character.RH Dec 16, 1873ST Mar 29, 1883RH Feb 17, 1852 Salvation is by grace through faith in Christ's blood, and that faith establishes the law and leads to its fulfillment by working through love and carrying love for God and neighbor into the duties of the commandments, not making the law void nor serving as a basis for self-righteousness or salvation by law.RH Feb 17, 1852ST Sep 18, 1884RH Jul 25, 1854 Professed faith without works cannot save, yet good works do not earn salvation but are necessary in the life of someone who is saved.ST Sep 18, 1884ST Mar 20, 1907RH Apr 19, 1864
Faith is a handmaid to works to enable people to form the holy, righteous character that is acceptable in heaven and enters the kingdom, for faith will not take the place of works in forming such character.RH Dec 16, 1873 Faith never comes into the judgment, but reward is always given according to works, and works are evidence of faith considered in judgment.RH Dec 16, 1873ST Oct 7, 1930 A claim of faith contradicted by conduct that tramples God's law cannot deceive the Lord, but genuine abiding faith in Christ is proved by good works.ST Oct 7, 1930 As telling a naked brother or sister destitute of daily food to depart in peace, be warmed and filled, without giving the things needful to the body profits nothing, so faith if it has no works is dead, being alone.RH Dec 16, 1873
Genuine faith is not a claim to God's favor apart from obedience; it rests on Scripture's promises and provisions and meets the conditions on which mercy is granted.ST Mar 30, 1888ST Apr 19, 1910 Faith works with obedience, and works show that faith is living.ST Mar 30, 1888 The doctrine of faith without works is an ensnaring presumption, not genuine faith.ST Mar 30, 1888ST Apr 19, 1910 That genuine faith embraces the entire being — spirit, soul, and body — requiring all powers to be preserved in the best possible condition for the Creator's service, presenting the body a living sacrifice holy and acceptable to God without blemish like the ancient sacrifices, offering nothing less than the best and putting away every practice that weakens physical or mental strength as unfit for His service.ST Apr 19, 1910
Obedience to Royal Law
James 2 enforces the royal law, the law of liberty, as still binding in every precept, including the fourth commandment.RH Feb 3, 1852RH Dec 1850RH Aug 31, 1905RH Jul 22, 1852 That law is the ten commandments drawn out by themselves, spoken by God's voice, written by His finger, placed under the mercy seat, and continued as Christ's law for Christians and not merely for ancient Israel.RH Feb 3, 1852ST Jan 22, 1880RH Dec 1850RH Aug 31, 1905 It is not among the abolished Jewish ordinances that governed ceremonial life, but governs men as moral beings accountable to God, and grace requires its righteousness to be fulfilled rather than excusing disobedience.RH Feb 3, 1852ST Jan 22, 1880RH Jul 22, 1852 The apostles did not set it aside, for the law their Lord left in force remains in force and therefore was not re-enacted as something new in the New Testament.RH Dec 1850RH Aug 31, 1905RH Jul 22, 1852 Respect of persons is sin by which that law convinces transgressors, and James quotes the sixth and seventh commandments to teach that breaking one precept makes a person guilty of breaking the law.RH Feb 3, 1852RH Jul 22, 1852
The works that make faith complete are obedience to every precept of that royal law.RH Sep 30, 1852RH Sep 30, 1852 Each precept calls for an act of obedience as a visible sign of faith in it, so faith is shown by action and without such works is dead and cannot save.RH Sep 30, 1852RH Sep 30, 1852 The fourth precept points out the true God, and remembering the Sabbath and keeping it holy is the act that serves as a sign of faith in His existence.RH Sep 30, 1852 Believers are judged by the law of liberty, which defines good works, so genuine faith works with obedience and mercy rather than standing alone.RH Apr 24, 1866RH Oct 25, 1853RH Nov 6, 1900
The faith of Jesus is manifested in keeping God's law and cannot be held with respect of persons nor with conscious breaking of the commandments even in a single point.RH Oct 25, 1853RH Sep 2, 1862RH Nov 6, 1900ST Oct 21, 1886 Favoritism to the rich, dishonoring and excluding the poor, and choosing which precepts to obey makes a person a transgressor judged by that law.RH Apr 24, 1866RH Oct 25, 1853ST Jan 30, 1879RH Sep 2, 1862RH Nov 6, 1900 Merely saying one has faith while having no works profits nothing, and saying believe and be saved does not mean entrance into the City without any other condition, since justification and salvation require faith joined with good works whose genuineness is tested by fruit.RH Apr 24, 1866RH Oct 25, 1853RH Sep 2, 1862RH Nov 6, 1900ST Oct 21, 1886 Those who truly have the faith of Jesus keep the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus together, with law and gospel unseparated.RH Oct 25, 1853RH Nov 6, 1900ST Oct 21, 1886
Genuine faith works through love, and this love fulfills the law's purpose by carrying the principles of love for God and neighbor into the duties expressed in the commandments.ST Jul 31, 1884RH Jul 4, 1854RH Feb 17, 1852RH Mar 17, 1874 Faith does not make God's law void but establishes it, so true faith and obedience to the ten commandments always go together as the rule and test of the good works living faith must produce.RH Feb 17, 1852RH Jul 9, 1901RH Mar 17, 1874 Faith and keeping God's commandments are the two great principles that form a righteous character fit for God's kingdom, expressed in keeping His commandments and doing what pleases Him rather than in mere belief that one will receive what one asks.RH Jul 4, 1854RH Feb 17, 1852RH Jul 9, 1901 A claim to love one's neighbor is not credible when a person refuses to meet that neighbor's need for food or clothing, for genuine love leads to practical help and the moral commandments concerning relations with others grow out of that love.ST Jul 31, 1884RH Feb 17, 1852RH Nov 15, 1853 Sinners are not justified by the law but by faith as Abraham was, yet those justified by faith keep God's law, with salvation by grace through faith in Christ's blood and not by self-righteousness or salvation by law.RH Feb 17, 1852RH Mar 17, 1874
Faith which believes God's promises but rejects His commands is not true, full, or complete faith, and turning away from a commanded duty puts a person out of harmony with Him.ST Apr 16, 1912ST Feb 7, 1911ST Feb 4, 1897RH Feb 28, 1854 True faith trusts God's promises and respects His precepts together, not treating commandments as unimportant when inconvenient, unpopular, or costly, and hope in the promises is not secure when joined to disregard for the commands.ST Feb 7, 1911ST Feb 4, 1897RH Feb 28, 1854 A command also carries an implied promise, so wholehearted faith and submission allow God to work the commanded righteousness in character, while professing faith in Jesus while trampling the commandments, or outwardly keeping them without faith in Jesus, does not lead to salvation.ST Feb 4, 1897RH Feb 28, 1854 The command to love one's neighbor as oneself did not originate with Christ, because the same words are already found in Leviticus 19:18.RH May 3, 1864 Mere faith that scrupulously attends to religious things such as temple worship profits nothing without works, which mean obedience to God's moral will in worship and in domestic, social, and political duties, and Israel's keeping religious faith while disobeying the moral law left them incorrigibly callous, led them to reject the Saviour, and brought ruin, dispersion, and scattering among the nations idolizing gain and trade.ST Apr 16, 1912ST Feb 7, 1911RH Dec 15, 1868
Practical Life of Faith
James 2:14 calls for practical charity that supplies bodily need with both kind words and deeds, for a claim to faith without such deeds is barren and cannot save.ST Jun 17, 1897RH May 31, 1870ST Nov 24, 1881RH Mar 2, 1911 To meet a hungry person without clothing, a freezing widow without firewood, the sick, the poor, the fallen, destitute children, and suffering neighbors with only profession, preaching through many Sabbaths, or prayer profits nothing, because saying one has faith must be joined to a helping hand that touches bitter need.ST Sep 29, 1881RH May 31, 1870RH Dec 13, 1870RH Mar 2, 1911 The rich man's keeping of the commandments failed this test when he kept far more than he needed while needy people lacked life's necessities, showing that love for neighbor requires action and not merely a claim of faith.ST Nov 24, 1881 Practice is better than preaching for the needy to understand, since prayers without good deeds never reach them.RH Mar 2, 1911
Faith is proved by using surplus goods to advance present truth, for lifeless intention alone is not enough and bears on readiness for Christ's return.RH Dec 9, 1852 Merely knowing and believing the truth and holding firmly to it will not save unless knowledge and faith are put to work with all God-given abilities to advance, honor, and exalt the cause of truth in the earth and assist others to gain the kingdom.ST Jun 12, 1884ST Apr 17, 1879 Thousands go through all the motions without lifting weight and do comparatively nothing to help the cause along, but true faith takes hold and helps in missionary work to save sinners.ST Jun 12, 1884ST Apr 17, 1879 Genuine repentance and faith are demonstrated by praying for laborers and providing means for those sent to preach, so that Christ's character becomes visible in life.RH May 7, 1857 Such practical financial help through systematic benevolence for publishing, health, conference, and missionary needs proves genuine love for the Redeemer's cause, rather than grasping after the world while professing belief that the third angel's message is now being given.RH Dec 9, 1852RH Oct 10, 1871
Claimed faith without action brings no profit and cannot save, and what people do shows whether they truly believe and are preparing for Christ's coming.RH Dec 13, 1853RH Oct 4, 1853RH Nov 28, 1871 Belief in keeping the Sabbath must be shown by keeping it even when persecution follows, for yielding God's commandments to preserve peace in a household leaves faith without works.RH Dec 13, 1853 Saying Christ's coming is near while continuing to make long-term plans as though the world will remain unchanged denies that faith by action, and professing the heavenly judgment and the sealing of the remnant without corresponding works leads to spiritual death, as Abraham's offering of Isaac shows faith working with action and made complete through it.RH Oct 4, 1853RH Feb 5, 1867 Saying one has faith without corresponding works gives no assurance of readiness when all nations are gathered and separated as sheep from goats, where neglect of the least is neglect of Christ and only faithful doing receives approval.RH Feb 18, 1915ST Oct 7, 1930 Readiness requires choosing the Lord's fast and not one's own way, reading, studying, and obeying Isaiah 58 in practical mercy, light, and hospitality in homes and churches, so that the faith of Jesus is manifest in life and divine light, glory, and power are received for giving the last message, for conduct that tramples God's law contradicts faith and works are evidence considered in judgment.RH Feb 18, 1915ST Oct 7, 1930
In health and healing, claiming faith to have all infirmities removed while rejecting obedience to the laws of health is false faith, for faith and works are not to be dissevered.RH Jan 7, 1902RH Apr 23, 1908 True faith for healing must be joined with works of obedience and use of the means provided for healing and education in right habits of living, including discarding drug medication, using simple rational methods of treatment, and learning how to dress, breathe, and eat properly and how to prevent sickness.RH Apr 23, 1908 Because the Lord is soon to come, faith requires decided action to increase facilities so a great work of healing and teaching can be done in a short time, so that those who regain health and learn how to live can act as medical missionaries.RH Apr 23, 1908 The doctrine of faith without works is an ensnaring presumption that claims the favor of Heaven without complying with the conditions upon which mercy is granted, whereas genuine faith rests on the promises and provisions of Scripture and embraces spirit, soul, and body, preserving all powers in the best possible condition for the Creator's service, presenting the body a living sacrifice holy and acceptable without blemish like the ancient sacrifices, offering nothing less than the best, putting away every practice that weakens physical or mental strength, practicing what is professed in healthful food and teaching others to do the same.RH Jan 7, 1902ST Apr 19, 1910
Merely believing or claiming the truth does not sanctify or save, for faith without works cannot bring the sanctification that comes through the truth, and works are essential alongside faith in overcoming.RH Apr 21, 1868ST Mar 10, 1890 Faith in Christ's blood gives strength to reform and replace evil habits with good, while works put that faith into practice in overcoming, walking in light, and using opportunities.RH Apr 21, 1868ST Jun 3, 1889 Faith acts on what it believes, placing treasure on the other side rather than hiding it in shifting sand, for mere talk and doing as others do cannot secure it when terror and danger come, and faith must be joined with works and prayer.ST Nov 10, 1881 Accepting Christian education and its principles by faith means committing to them in practice and allowing them to test trust in God, as exemplified in leaving Battle Creek without a secure new home and later giving up rented buildings before the replacement was ready.RH Dec 16, 1902 Trust in God is expressed by obedience and doing the duty at hand in ordinary family duties and service to others, including Mrs. Wesley's service in reclaiming the immoral and church building by volunteered labor, for faith is not fruitful when it leaves a person selfish or unwilling to help others, and charitable giving must be accompanied by kind, sympathetic words to be genuine charity; believing true teachings about Jesus is not enough unless Christ is revealed in a life of righteous deeds and obedience, with works revealing character and whether faith is real.ST Feb 3, 1909ST Jun 3, 1889
Profession must be consistent with conduct in holiness toward God and Christ and toward other people, for lack of consistency brings religion into disrepute.RH Nov 24, 1859 Claiming to believe is of no use if a person does not act on that belief and continues in wrongdoing unchanged in character and conduct, for faith does not save one who walks in old ways while talking of New Jerusalem; genuine conversion and repentance turn from the old way of life and renewal by God's Spirit changes behavior.RH Nov 17, 1859RH May 15, 1855 A claim to faith separated from works of obedience is an empty pretense that cannot support hope of salvation, and merely hearing or professing without practicing leads to ruin.RH May 15, 1855RH Sep 30, 1873 A holy-day religion that takes a holiday during the week, steals tithe or an employer's time or goods, or neglects loans proves profession empty, while true faith keeps both sides of the books, becomes acted sermons and living epistles, and gains a good report from outsiders.RH Nov 24, 1859RH Nov 17, 1859 Teaching Bible truths without living out their effects in becoming more unselfish, generous, compassionate, patient, and helpful makes teaching fruitless and brings it into ridicule rather than favor, for professed faith must produce practical fruit, be shown in practical devotion, sacrifice, service, and bearing responsibilities to renovate and purify the heart, and must never be treated as a reason to have no good works.RH Sep 30, 1873ST Mar 1, 1883
Sources