James 2:26
For as the body without the spirit is dead, so faith without works is dead also.
Translations
American King James Version, King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Webster Bible
For as the body without the spirit is dead, so faith without works is dead also.
Revised Version, American Standard Version, World English Bible
For as the body apart from the spirit is dead, even so faith apart from works is dead.
for as the body apart from the spirit is dead, so also the faith apart from the works is dead.
For as the body without a spirit is dead, so also faith without works is dead.
Just as, the body, apart from spirit, is dead, so, our faith also, apart from works, is dead.
As the body without the spirit is dead, so faith without deeds is dead.
For as the body without the spirit is dead, so faith without deeds is dead.
For as the body without the spirit is dead even so faith without works is dead.
For as the body without ye spirit is dead, euen so the faith without workes is dead.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
For even as the body without the spirit is dead; so also faith without works is dead.
Cross-references 20 of 61
- James 2:17
Even so faith, if it hath not works, is dead, being alone.
Faith without works is described as dead.
- Galatians 5:6
For in Jesus Christ neither circumcision availeth any thing, nor uncircumcision; but faith which worketh by love.
Faith is shown working through love.
- Ephesians 2:10
For we are his workmanship, created in Christ Jesus unto good works, which God hath before ordained that we should walk in them.
Those saved by grace through faith are created for good works.
- Genesis 15:6
And he believed in the LORD; and he counted it to him for righteousness.
Abraham’s faith was counted as righteousness in James’s discussion of works.
- James 2:18
Yea, a man may say, Thou hast faith, and I have works: shew me thy faith without thy works, and I will shew thee my faith by my works.
Faith is shown by works.
- Genesis 22:1-12
And it came to pass after these things, that God did tempt Abraham, and said unto him, Abraham: and he said, Behold, here I am.
Abraham’s willingness to offer Isaac shows faith expressed through obedience.
- Matthew 7:21
Not every one that saith unto me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the kingdom of heaven; but he that doeth the will of my Father which is in heaven.
Entering the kingdom requires doing the Father’s will, not merely professing faith.
- James 2:22
Seest thou how faith wrought with his works, and by works was faith made perfect?
Abraham’s works showed his faith and brought it to maturity.
- Romans 3:28
Therefore we conclude that a man is justified by faith without the deeds of the law.
Justification is by faith apart from works, while living faith is shown by works.
- Revelation 22:12
And, behold, I come quickly; and my reward is with me, to give every man according as his work shall be.
Christ rewards each person according to their work.
- James 2:19
Thou believest that there is one God; thou doest well: the devils also believe, and tremble.
Even demons believe, showing belief without obedience is lifeless.
- Matthew 7:24-27
Therefore whosoever heareth these sayings of mine, and doeth them, I will liken him unto a wise man, which built his house upon a rock:
Hearing Christ’s words with action is contrasted with hearing without doing.
- James 2:14
What doth it profit, my brethren, though a man say he hath faith, and have not works? can faith save him?
Faith without works is dead and cannot save.
- James 1:22
But be ye doers of the word, and not hearers only, deceiving your own selves.
Both passages teach that living faith acts on God’s word.
- Matthew 7:16
Ye shall know them by their fruits. Do men gather grapes of thorns, or figs of thistles?
As a tree is known by its fruit, a Christian is known by deeds.
- Romans 3:31
Do we then make void the law through faith? God forbid: yea, we establish the law.
Faith establishes rather than voids God’s law.
- Philippians 2:12
Wherefore, my beloved, as ye have always obeyed, not as in my presence only, but now much more in my absence, work out your own salvation with fear and trembling.
Obedient works work out the salvation received through faith.
- Hebrews 11:1
Now faith is the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen.
Faith gives substance to hoped-for things, while works show faith in practice.
- Revelation 20:12
And I saw the dead, small and great, stand before God; and the books were opened: and another book was opened, which is the book of life: and the dead were judged out of those things which were written in the books, according to their works.
The dead are judged according to their works.
- Luke 6:46
And why call ye me, Lord, Lord, and do not the things which I say?
Calling Jesus Lord must be matched by doing what he says.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
55 sources
As the body without breath is dead, so faith without obedient action is lifeless and has no life in it.Lt 26, 1907, par. 7–8ST Jul 9, 1894Ms 5, 1866, par. 18–19 Faith and works belong together and each is dead when alone, for faith alone is not enough and works alone cannot suffice.Lt 9a, 1891, par. 11Lt 33, 1874, par. 1–4 Genuine faith is not mere profession or understanding of truth but is expressed in obedience, works by love and purifies the heart and life, and is made complete and shown to be real by what a person does.ST Mar 3, 1887Ms 14, 1889, par. 10RH Mar 27, 19131T 619.2–620.1ST May 12, 1890 Works do not earn salvation but are its fruit and effect through Christ's grace, while mere profession without obedience is presumption of the same kind as the belief of evil angels.RH Mar 27, 1913ST Jul 9, 1894ST Jun 10, 1889Lt 9a, 1891, par. 11GW 260.2–3 A profession of faith alone cannot save, for in the final judgment every person is judged according to deeds done in the body and only living, acting faith that overcomes selfishness and does practical Christian work will endure.1T 191.2SG2 231.1RH May 1, 1900Ms 29, 1911, par. 5517MR 49.2–3
Words of the Comparison
As the body without the spirit is dead, so faith without obedient action is lifeless and has no life, and faith without corresponding works is dead and must be accompanied by action.Lt 26, 1907, par. 7–8ST Jul 9, 1894Ms 5, 1866, par. 18–193T 78.3–79.1 The principles of the chapter are to be lived out in daily conduct, and putting them into practice as part of character building brings happiness of spirit and an experience of strength.Lt 26, 1907, par. 7–8 Living faith acts in line with God's word and promises, and it is made perfect and manifested by works rather than waiting to feel healed or waiting for a change in feelings or circumstances before making an effort.1T 619.2–620.1Ms 5, 1866, par. 18–19 Faith without works is lifeless, and love of money, worldly friendship, and life's cares can choke faith so that it bears no fruit.ST Jul 9, 1894 Faith is put into practice through faithful stewardship of what God entrusts to a person, and withholding resources from God's cause or leaving them to be squandered is unfaithfulness for which each person must answer to God.ST Jul 9, 1894
Faith and works go together and each is dead if alone, for faith alone is not enough and works alone are not sufficient, but together they can accomplish much.Lt 9a, 1891, par. 11Lt 33, 1874, par. 1–4 Works do not save, for they are the fruit of faith, and living faith reveals itself in action.Lt 9a, 1891, par. 11 Faith and obedience are the conditions of salvation for receiving the gift of eternal life Jesus offers, requiring cooperation of the human with the divine in coming to Christ and following Him.Lt 9a, 1891, par. 11 Merely understanding and believing the truth, or being able to teach it, is not enough, for faith without works is dead.Ms 14, 1889, par. 10 Living faith works through love, purifies the soul, and brings every action and emotion into harmony with God's truth and righteousness, while outward religious forms without the reality they once represented are dead formalism.Ms 14, 1889, par. 10SLP 63.3–65.1
A confession of faith without works is like saying without doing, and mere words, profession, pretense and semblance are dead and worthless, while God calls for works and character is known by fruits.17MR 49.2–3 Faith must be expressed in a life transformed by the Holy Spirit, including self-denial and following Christ. Faith must be active in obedience to the Word of God, including His will and His law, and must produce works and fruits.17MR 49.2–3 Living faith is manifested, made complete, made perfect and shown to be real by works, for faith alone is dead while living faith acts and works testify that a person truly believes the truth.1T 619.2–620.11T 191.2ST May 25, 1882 A person's daily life — including dress, speech, home, and associations — testifies to the faith possessed and should agree with profession of faith.ST May 25, 1882
Faith is the inward working of the Holy Spirit and works are the outward demonstration of practical godliness.15MR 40.3–4 No one is at liberty to fold the hands and do nothing, and it is utterly impossible to be saved in indolence and inactivity, for winning eternal life requires constant conflict, and faith and works go hand in hand.Ms 157, 1902, par. 6
Nature of Living Faith
Genuine faith is not mere profession but is expressed in obedience to God's law, especially through practical love and benevolence toward others.ST Mar 3, 1887 Compassionate help like the Samaritan's embodies the spirit of the commandments, while profession without action like the priest and Levite's does not.ST Mar 3, 1887
Living faith works by love and purifies the soul and heart, bringing every action and emotion into harmony with God's truth and righteousness and leading to righteousness.Ms 14, 1889, par. 10RH Mar 27, 1913ST May 12, 189014MR 99.2 Merely understanding and believing the truth, or being able to teach it, is not enough, for faith without works is dead.Ms 14, 1889, par. 10 Genuine faith leads to obedience to the law of God and is needed to truly honor God, and claiming to believe while disobeying God is presumption, not genuine faith.RH Mar 27, 1913ST May 12, 1890 Works do not save as a means of earning salvation, but genuine faith appears in active obedience and allegiance to His law.ST May 12, 1890 Those who profess to obey God but act against His law lack this living faith and may refuse His warnings.14MR 99.2
Genuine faith must accomplish the sanctifying of life and character, with works corresponding to profession and revealing the entrusted truth to the world; a faith that produces no change is of no profit.Ms 5, 1886, par. 8 It goes with repentance, transformation of character and the fruits of the Spirit, shown in practicing what one teaches and obeying God's expressed will.Lt 10, 1888, par. 8 Without moral courage to resist inclination and impulse, a person can be overcome rather than bring forth those fruits.Lt 10, 1888, par. 8
True faith works by love and purifies the heart, producing self-denial and self-sacrifice in imitation of Christ's life so believers become living epistles read and known of all men.Lt 33, 1893, par. 10–11 It removes selfishness, bigotry, spiritual pride, self-centeredness and spending on selfish gratification, and uses every penny to bless others and carry the good news to perishing souls in cooperation with God who gave His Son and opened all heaven's treasures.Lt 33, 1893, par. 10–11 Genuine faith always works by love and supplies a motive power; it is not an opiate but a stimulant.STA 64.1 Looking to Calvary does not quiet the soul in non-performance of duty or compose for sleep, but creates faith that will work and purify the soul from selfishness.STA 64.1 Laying hold of Christ only begins the work, because corrupt and sinful habits must be overcome through vigorous warfare and fighting the fight of faith.STA 64.1 A follower therefore cannot remain sharp in deal, hard-hearted and without sympathy, coarse in speech, a surmiser of evil and accuser of the brethren, full of pomposity and self-esteem, overbearing, or harsh in censure and condemnation.STA 64.1
Works are the fruit and effect of faith made possible through Christ's grace; believers deny self and sin, take up the cross and follow Christ.ST Jun 10, 1889Lt 9a, 1891, par. 11 Genuine living faith is made visible through sacrifice, devotion to God's cause, obedience to Christ's commands, and a righteous and holy life.ST Jun 10, 1889 Faith and works go together and each is dead if alone, and living faith reveals itself in action.Lt 9a, 1891, par. 11 Faith and obedience are the conditions of salvation for receiving the gift of eternal life Jesus offers, requiring cooperation of the human with the divine in coming to Christ and following Him.Lt 9a, 1891, par. 11 Obedience is the fruit of true faith, not a license to break God's law.GW 260.2–3
Mere profession of belief is of the same kind as the belief held by evil angels and Satan, who believe the truth with fear and trembling but without saving virtue.RH Mar 27, 1913ST Jul 9, 1894 Faith that claims God's favor while refusing the conditions of mercy, disobeying God or excusing transgression is presumption, not genuine faith.ST May 12, 1890GW 260.2–3ST Apr 19, 1910 Living faith rests on Scripture's promises and provisions and is expressed in a life offered wholly to God, with the body and every human power kept fit for His service.ST Apr 19, 1910 Professing belief in Jesus, His crucifixion and resurrection without good works is dead faith.SG1 126.2 Living faith leads people to imitate Christ's self-denying life, without which profession can conceal an unsanctified nature and leave a person useful to Satan.SG1 126.2
Faith lives, brightens and increases only by working in the personal effort every follower owes to bring friends, relatives and other souls to Christ rather than selfishly enjoying grace alone or leaving all labor to the minister.ST Oct 25, 1877 Those who do nothing gain no living experience, while those who engage in the work God gives have faith called into exercise and grow in courage and hope in proportion to working faith.ST Oct 25, 1877 A profession of faith alone does not prove a saving connection with Christ; like a living body, genuine faith is not lifeless but produces good works, with changed words, conduct and character conforming to God's will showing that connection.6MR 157.2 God's commandment-loving people testify to faith by works, as living faith like a living body must be active.OEWP 6.1–7.1 Faith is weakened when study absorbs a person and displaces communion with God and practical service.OEWP 6.1–7.1
Salvation and Final Judgment
A profession of faith alone cannot save, for faith without works is dead, while a living faith acts and its works testify that the truth is truly believed.1T 191.2SG2 231.1Ms 29, 1911, par. 55 Only living, acting faith saves in the fearful scenes ahead, and genuine conversion is shown by obeying God whatever the cost, walking in His way, overcoming selfishness, and doing practical Christian work.1T 191.2SG2 231.1Ms 29, 1911, par. 55 That practical work includes giving means to carry the truth to others so that they may be saved, for a profession must be proved by such action.SG2 231.1 Faith and obedience are the conditions of salvation for receiving the gift of eternal life that Jesus offers, requiring the cooperation of the human with the divine in coming to Christ and following Him.Lt 9a, 1891, par. 11 Works do not save as a means of earning salvation, for they are the fruit of faith, and living faith reveals itself in action.Lt 9a, 1891, par. 11
Believing God's promises means acting in accordance with that belief rather than waiting to feel healed before making an effort.1T 619.2–620.1Ms 5, 1866, par. 18–19 Living faith acts in line with God's word and promises, is manifested and made perfect by works, and does not wait for a change in feelings or circumstances before acting.1T 619.2–620.1Ms 5, 1866, par. 18–19 God's people should not expect rich blessings while living in unbelief, but should recognize that what God has already done is only the beginning of what He is willing to do, with works corresponding to faith.5T 533.2 A profession of faith in Christ has no value by itself, for genuine faith is made evident through love expressed in works.4SP 311.2GC 487.2 In the judgment the use of each entrusted talent and resource, including time, abilities, words, money, influence, and the light of God's word, will be examined and scrutinized at the Lord's coming, and acts done from love, even those that seem small, are valuable to God and are accepted and rewarded by Him.4SP 311.2GC 487.2
Future happiness depends on active faith in obedience to the Word of God, including His will and His law, producing works and fruits, for mere words, profession, pretense and semblance are dead and worthless and character is known by fruits.17MR 49.2–3 In the day of final judgment every person is judged according to deeds done in the body, when nothing remains but character and the law of God, and all are seen as either righteous or unrighteous.17MR 49.2–3 Only those with working faith as imitators of Christ, meek and lowly of heart, will be prepared to meet the Saviour when He comes with power and great glory.Lt 33, 1893, par. 10–11RH May 1, 1900 Only by giving diligence to do these things is calling and election made sure and an abundant entrance ministered into the everlasting kingdom.RH May 1, 1900 True working faith purifies the heart, produces self-denial and self-sacrifice in imitation of Christ's life, removes selfishness, bigotry, spiritual pride, self-centeredness and spending on selfish gratification, and uses every means to bless others and carry the good news to perishing souls.Lt 33, 1893, par. 10–11
Every duty performed and sacrifice made in Jesus' name brings a reward, as Abraham's obedience despite his age and the painful command concerning Isaac illustrates faith put into action, and age excuses no one from obeying God.ST May 11, 1876ST Oct 25, 1877 Faith lives, brightens, and increases only by working in the personal effort every follower owes to bring friends, relatives, and other souls to Christ rather than selfishly enjoying grace alone or leaving all labor to the minister.ST Oct 25, 1877 Those who do nothing gain no living experience, while those who engage in the work God gives have faith called into exercise and grow in courage and hope in proportion to working faith, advance in the divine life, share largely of divine grace now, and receive the reward of earnest labor hereafter.ST Oct 25, 1877 Those who live to gratify self lose the favor of God and the heavenly reward and testify that they do not have genuine faith, for genuine faith is proved by works, especially unselfish giving for the need of the saints and for advancement of the kingdom, which testifies that grace has not been received in vain.Ms 68, 1894, par. 13 When such self-gratifying professors try to teach present truth, their words are heard as empty noise, while a living example of Christlike unselfish character has great power upon others.Ms 68, 1894, par. 13
At the present time there is great danger of taking false positions about faith and works, for faith and works must go together.Ms 23, 1891, par. 27–30 Satan is ever ready to imbue the mind with his own wisdom, leaving councils with little of God in them, and if he can he will make cavilers and skeptics of all, so that poor souls become confused and walk in darkness in consequence of the words and example of unconsecrated men.Ms 23, 1891, par. 27–30 A man whose heart has not been changed cannot discern spiritual matters and should not undertake to guide God's servants, and it is not safe for men with little of the Spirit of Christ to hold positions where through temptation they may become tempters leading associates into false paths.Ms 23, 1891, par. 27–30 Satan tries to make men believe that messages from God's throne are forgeries while leading them to accept as truth the lies he has forged, as when men in leading positions do not respect the messenger or the messages graciously given by God.Ms 23, 1891, par. 27–30
Law Obedience and Scripture Examples
Genuine faith leads to obedience to the law of God and is needed to truly honor Him, for belief in Jesus must be lived out in obedience and action by practicing truth in daily life and doing the work God gives, and God's law remains the moral standard for those who believe in Christ.Ms 7, 1898, par. 17–20RH Mar 27, 1913 Faith that produces no action has no life, and mere profession of belief is of the same kind as the belief held by evil angels, who believe with fear and trembling but without saving virtue.RH Mar 27, 1913 The living faith of the Bible acts through love and cleanses the soul and heart.RH Mar 27, 1913
Faith and works belong together in active obedience to the Word, will and law of God, producing works and fruits, and claiming to believe while disobeying God is presumption rather than genuine faith.ST May 12, 189017MR 49.2–3 Mere words, profession, pretense and semblance are dead and worthless, for God calls for works and character is known by fruits.17MR 49.2–3 Works do not save as a means of earning salvation, but genuine faith appears in a life of obedience to God and allegiance to His law, working by love and purifying the soul.ST May 12, 1890 Genuine faith is not merely profession but is expressed in obedience to God's law, especially through practical love and benevolence toward others in daily life and in loving one's neighbor through true benevolence.ST Mar 3, 18874T 58.1 Professing loyalty to God's law while neglecting its command to love others is not living faith, while the Samaritan's compassionate help embodies the spirit of the commandments and the priest and Levite's profession without action does not.ST Mar 3, 18874T 58.1
Abraham's obedience, despite his age and the painful command concerning Isaac, illustrates faith put into action, showing that age does not excuse anyone from obeying God and that every duty performed and sacrifice made in Jesus' name brings a reward.ST May 11, 1876 Living faith is distinct from dead formalism in that outward religious forms without the reality they once represented are dead, and faith in Christ did not require Gentile converts to observe the abolished ceremonial rites, with keeping God's commandments distinct from relying on those rites for salvation.SLP 63.3–65.1 Faith is the inward working of the Holy Spirit and works are the outward demonstration of practical godliness, and the proof of heart-love for God is obedience to His commandments, including loyalty to the Sabbath as the sign of His government leading through that obedience to faithfulness to every principle of the Decalogue.15MR 40.3–4 All who love God study His words and eat His flesh and drink His blood by living and acting in constant submission to His will.15MR 40.3–4
A profession of faith without corresponding works is nothing, and a professed Christian who lacks the Christian graces and lives a life of sin has dead faith.RH May 1, 1900 He grieves Christ and puts Him to open shame by manifesting a character after Satan's similitude, retaining the same objectionable traits he had before claiming to receive Christ and indulging corrupt tendencies.RH May 1, 1900 He is blind and cannot see afar off and has forgotten that he was purged from old sins, because he forgets to be a doer of the Word, does not eat the flesh nor drink the blood of the Son of God, and does not practice Christ's words nor do His works.RH May 1, 1900 Only by giving diligence to do these things is calling and election made sure and an abundant entrance ministered into the everlasting kingdom.RH May 1, 1900
Practical Life and Service
Mere profession joined with acting as critics is condemned, for hindering the appointed work in Nashville and the South, having no interest in that field, withholding means and circulating reports that turn funds into other channels is what God calls robbery.Lt 185, 1902, par. 19–21 God is displeased with that work and calls for reformation, requiring those at fault to look into the divine mirror and not forget what manner of men they are, to read the Word to purpose and act out its instruction, to reason from cause to effect, to show greater wisdom, to stop hindering and help instead, and without delay to do the work needed for themselves.Lt 185, 1902, par. 19–21 The religion taught is one in which believers put away what hinders them from coming together in unity, make right every wrong between themselves and their brethren, and do not leave sins unconfessed.Lt 204, 1902, par. 1–2
Genuine faith is proved by works, especially by unselfish giving for the need of the saints and for the advancement of the kingdom, which testifies that grace has not been received in vain.Ms 68, 1894, par. 13 A living example of Christlike unselfish character has great power upon others, and everyone must show faith by practical love rather than using up every dollar on supposed wants, conveniences and appetite, remembering others who need food and clothing.Ms 68, 1894, par. 13 Faith is put into practice through faithful stewardship of what God entrusts, while love of money, worldly friendship and life's cares can choke faith so it bears no fruit.ST Jul 9, 1894 Living faith is shown by works that exert a powerful influence for truth, and withholding resources from God's cause or leaving them to be squandered is unfaithfulness for which each must answer to God.ST Jul 9, 1894 Benevolence stands beside faith, love and Christian diligence as the working proof of living faith.ST Apr 29, 1875
A profession of great love that speaks interest in seeing truth advanced but does nothing for its advancement is dead faith.ST Apr 29, 1875 Those who think they can be good Christians while closing ears and hearts to calls for liberality are in fearful deception, because conversion breaks the power of covetousness and produces charity and self-sacrifice for the salvation of others.ST Apr 29, 1875 Professed faith is dead when works do not match profession, for people may claim to know and serve God yet deny Him through conduct, and love of riches can make them selfish, demanding and overbearing and weaken what is noble and Godlike in them.2T 681.3 Practical faith is shown by serving Christ and representing the purity of religion at home, in the church and in business, with abilities and talents devoted to worldly gain instead used for God's work.5T 275.1–276.1 A profession that does not shape life is lifeless, while genuine faith is shown by a corresponding life with good works shining before the world, including daily self-denial in choices about food and dress demonstrating devotion to God rather than bondage to appetite or worldly custom.ST Jun 1, 1882
Faith without action is dead, so circulating books to bring instruction to people is a practical expression of living faith.Lt 322, 1907, par. 4–5 Prayer must be joined with giving, with believers offering labor and means for the work they pray to see fulfilled.RH Dec 23, 1902 Accepting truth as theory without accepting the responsibility it brings is not living faith, but believers show faith through actions as they proclaim the present-truth message.Ms 61, 1909, par. 13 That action includes giving means to carry truth to others so they may be saved, for a profession must be proved by such working and faith that does not work cannot save in the fearful scenes ahead.SG2 231.1 Genuine belief put into practice was seen in Christian Help workers whose deeds proved they were not merely theoretical believers, for by combining faith and works and doing the work God specified they helped enlighten and convict many souls.RH Jan 14, 1902
Faith and good works must go hand in hand in relieving the afflicted and caring for the sick to fit them to glorify God and help them live honoring God.CH 249.1–2CTBH 235.4 Prayer for the sick should be joined with treatment and right habits of living, including obedience to the laws of health.CTBH 235.4 Teaching health reform while serving meat and selling unhealthful food contradicts that teaching and fails to make a deep impression, so instruction must be put into practice as well as spoken, including providing healthful food and explaining the reasons for those choices.6T 112.1 Putting instruction into practice by serving fruits, grains and vegetables instead of meat made the teaching visible and more persuasive, whereas serving meat and unhealthful foods contradicted it and weakened its effect.CH 499.1 The chapter's principles are to be lived out in daily conduct, and putting them into practice as part of character building brings happiness of spirit and an experience of strength.Lt 26, 1907, par. 7–8 Faith must produce good works and be active in every duty and sacrifice done in Jesus' name, with confession expressed in a life transformed by the Holy Spirit including self-denial and following Christ.4T 145.3
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
107 sources
As breath is the life-principle in the nostrils that makes the heart beat and the lungs move, a body without it is dead, inert and soon decays.RH May 21, 1857ST Aug 6, 1896ST Nov 14, 1892RH Dec 17, 1861ST Mar 18, 1903 As a body without breath is dead, so faith without works is dead, for as breath makes the body alive, works make faith living.RH Jan 1, 1901RH Jan 18, 1906RH May 12, 1868 Living faith necessarily acts and works through love and obedience, while faith without works is not merely weak but lifeless, useless and of no avail, no more living faith than the fearful belief of demons.ST Mar 1, 1877RH Jan 1, 1901ST Feb 18, 1886RH May 13, 1862RH Sep 2, 1873 Salvation is all of grace through faith and works do not earn it or remove past sins, yet a dead faith that bears no works cannot save or justify, since initial justification for past sins is by faith alone but is retained and shown to be living only as faith bears good works.RH Jan 1, 1901ST Aug 20, 1896ST Mar 4, 1889ST Aug 6, 1896RH Dec 16, 1873 That living faith is shown by obedience to the commandments and moral law which faith establishes rather than makes void, as Abraham's offering of Isaac showed his faith working with his deeds and bringing it to maturity, while claiming faith while breaking God's precepts is self-deception and presumption.RH May 12, 1868ST Jan 8, 1880RH Sep 30, 1852ST Mar 10, 1890
Words and Comparison
The word rendered spirit means breath, the breath of life in the nostrils, as the margin also indicates.ST Aug 20, 1896ST Aug 6, 1896RH Sep 19, 1854RH Sep 20, 1864 A body without breath is dead, and in the same comparison faith without works is dead.ST Aug 20, 1896RH May 21, 1857ST Aug 6, 1896RH Sep 19, 1854 The spirit the dead body lacks is not a separate immaterial soul that lives and thinks apart from the body, but breath carrying an animating principle of life imparted to the blood in the lungs, which is why blood is also called the life of the flesh because it receives its vitality from the breath.RH Sep 20, 1864
Body and spirit are distinct and not identical, for the body is dead without the spirit.ST Nov 14, 1892ST Mar 18, 1903RH Sep 30, 1858 The spirit is the animating life-principle and vital power that animates the human organism, the vitality that makes the heart beat, the lungs move and thought occur, so that when life and matter are combined the result is a living person.ST Mar 18, 1903RH Sep 30, 1858ST Apr 29, 1903RH Jun 14, 1870 A human body without life is inert matter, and a body without its animating spirit is a picture of death, soon decaying.RH Dec 17, 1861ST Apr 29, 1903RH Jun 14, 1870 In this contrast between death and life, spirit names what gives life, whether understood as this animating principle or as the Holy Spirit.ST Apr 29, 1903RH Jun 14, 1870
The verse reasons by comparison: as a body without breath is dead, so faith without works is dead.RH Jan 1, 1901RH Jan 18, 1906RH May 12, 1868ST Aug 20, 1896RH May 21, 1857 As breath makes the body alive, works make faith living, and living works — especially a disposition to obey God's commandments — are the medium in which faith acts.RH Jan 1, 1901ST Jul 18, 1911RH Sep 19, 1854 Without them faith is powerless, inactive and cannot transform character, and a profession unsupported by a course of action in harmony with what is professed is vain and has no vital substance.RH Jan 1, 1901RH Jan 18, 1906RH Dec 17, 1861 Works do not replace faith but show faith is active, and faith is brought to maturity through works.RH May 12, 1868ST Jul 18, 1911
The verse concludes the argument against separating faith from works, for mere mental agreement with the Gospel disconnected from good works is not saving faith and cannot save its possessor nor help others.ST Aug 20, 1896ST Aug 6, 1896ST Jul 31, 1884 It belongs to strongly practical teaching that sets forth fully the nature of feigned faith, which depends all upon believing without any doing, all faith and no works, in contrast to unfeigned faith which works by love.ST Jul 31, 1884ST Nov 10, 1909 Faith and works cannot be separated, as a candle's light and heat both disappear when the candle is put out, so that faith does not remain without works.RH Jul 19, 1864RH Aug 4, 1874RH Mar 10, 1874
Faith Alive by Works
Faith without works is not merely weak or inactive but dead, without existence, lifeless, useless and of no value and no avail.ST Feb 18, 1886RH Dec 17, 1861ST Mar 20, 1907 Trust in religious teaching without action cannot remain alive, for it is like a body without its animating principle.RH Dec 17, 1861ST Dec 11, 1893 To suppose children will be saved while only praying for them occasionally and leaving them without restraint is not faith, because the evidence gives no ground for that belief, and self-deception and careless security are not faith.ST Feb 18, 1886 The life-giving Spirit of God can give life to the body and make faith living, and living faith works as the faith of Jesus. Trusting in works for salvation is unsafe, for works cannot buy victory, yet true grace is received through faith shown in humble, prayerful obedience, and the needed faith works through love while dead faith and the dead works of the unregenerate are both of no avail.ST Mar 20, 1907
Genuine faith leads a person to act, and without living works it is dead because it cannot transform character.ST Mar 1, 1877RH Jan 1, 1901ST Nov 11, 1880 Living works, especially a disposition to obey the commandments, are the medium in which faith acts, and without them faith is powerless.RH Jan 1, 1901 Living faith produces a course of action in harmony with what is professed, demonstrates itself through obedience to what God asks and action on His promises, and a profession unsupported by such actions is vain and without vital substance.RH Jan 18, 1906ST Jul 18, 1911 God calls people to exercise faith in the work He has for their own time, helping and supporting that present work rather than relying only on work completed by others in the past.ST Mar 1, 1877ST Nov 11, 1880 Genuine faith may produce real inward change without its possessor being aware of the transformation.RH Jan 1, 1901
Works are the fruit, outward sign and evidence of living faith, as fruit shows a tree is alive, and they reveal whether faith is genuine.RH Jan 18, 1906ST Jul 18, 1911RH Oct 19, 1916ST Mar 4, 1889 They must agree with the profession rather than contradict it, for obedience to the divine will is a test of genuine faith alongside trust in the promises.RH Jan 18, 1906ST Mar 4, 1889 Works show the measure of faith and bring it to maturity, and faith is brought to maturity through works as Abraham's offering of Isaac showed his faith working with his deeds.RH May 12, 1868ST Jan 8, 1880 Believers are therefore to be careful to maintain good works, and the one described as justified by faith when justified by works is not justified by faith alone.RH May 12, 1868ST Jan 8, 1880
Faith and works must be united in serving God, for either one alone is useless.ST Jan 8, 1885ST May 6, 1886 Faith without works is like a bird without wings, unable to rise from earth to heaven, but joined with works the soul rises toward its eternal rest.ST Jan 8, 1885 Trusting God leads to obeying Him and obedience expresses trust, so faith without works and works without faith are both absent.ST May 6, 1886 Works without faith are a sham, for genuine life joins good works to correct faith in the word, and separating them produces either a life lacking a sound foundation or deeds rooted in self.ST Apr 21, 1881 Genuine faith is not a substitute for righteousness but works through love and is shown in fearing God and doing what is right, and faith and obedience are inseparable as warp and woof are inseparable in a web.RH May 13, 1875
Mere profession, mental agreement, correct belief or feeling alone is not living faith.RH Mar 27, 1913ST Jul 9, 1894RH May 13, 1862RH Sep 2, 1873 Faith that produces no action has no life, and living faith is more than adopting a belief, for it is faith accompanied by works unlike mere proselytism.RH Mar 27, 1913RH Sep 2, 1873 Believing that spiritual gifts belong in the church is only profession if people do not live out the testimony they acknowledge, and doubting or failing to act on it despite finding nothing contrary to the word is faith without works.RH May 13, 1862 Even Satan believes the truth and trembles, but that belief has no saving virtue, and a profession of faith alone cannot save.ST Jul 9, 1894 Dead faith is like the belief of demons who believe with fear and trembling and disobedience, and like a dead professor who has a name to live yet is dead, while genuine faith leads to obedience to the law, acts through love and cleanses the soul.RH Mar 27, 1913RH Dec 2, 1858
Faith comes from genuine trust rather than being gained by working, and works come from faith rather than being added to it.ST Mar 4, 1889ST Feb 4, 1889ST Oct 17, 1895 Christians do not work to gain faith or to become children of God; they work because they already have faith and are children of God.ST Mar 4, 1889 A person lives an obedient life by faith rather than by relying on personal ability, for obedience springs from faith and produces well-doing, not from self-sufficiency.ST Feb 4, 1889 Good works are not done in order to demonstrate faith but because they are its necessary result, just as a man does not breathe to show he lives but breathes because he is alive and lives by breathing, with breath as his life.ST Oct 17, 1895 Living faith is Christ dwelling and living in the believer, so that the life now lived in the flesh is lived by faith of the Son of God, with God working in the believer both to will and to do His good pleasure and the righteousness of the law fulfilled in believers.ST Jun 27, 1911 Works done without faith are unworthy because their motive is impure, and though people may not recognize the difference between works prompted by faith and those prompted by other motives, God sees it and will bring it to light.RH Oct 26, 1869
Justification Law and Obedience
Works do not save, earn salvation, buy victory, remove past sins, cancel transgression, or supply righteousness and life; salvation is all of grace through faith in Jesus Christ, with no room for self-righteous trust in law-keeping or in self and works.ST Aug 20, 1896ST Mar 4, 1889ST Jan 23, 1912ST Nov 1, 1899RH Feb 17, 1852 Living works, especially a disposition to obey God's commandments, are the medium in which faith acts, and without them faith is powerless and cannot transform character, yet a faith that cannot lead a person to live according to what is professed is not living faith.RH Jan 1, 1901ST Aug 20, 1896ST Jan 23, 1912 Christians do not work in order to gain faith or to become God's children, but work because they already have faith and are God's children, with obedience to God's will testing genuine faith alongside trust in His promises.ST Mar 4, 1889ST Nov 1, 1899ST Oct 17, 1895 Works are produced through faith and are the fruit and outflow of God's grace and of the vitality Christ imparts, not a way to earn justification; faith in the blood shed for transgressions of the law justifies without making the law void but establishing it.ST Aug 20, 1896ST Nov 1, 1899RH Feb 17, 1852 Such living faith works by love, and the love of God is shown by keeping His commandments, with perfect love to God as the only fulfilling of the ten commandments that God will accept.ST Jan 23, 1912RH Feb 17, 1852
A dead faith disconnected from good works cannot save its possessor or justify, and no person can be saved without the works that living faith brings forth; faith that produces no works is not saving faith.ST Aug 6, 1896ST Nov 2, 1915RH Dec 13, 1853RH Apr 2, 1872ST Sep 18, 1884 Like a dead person it can neither save itself nor help others, for living faith does not stand alone but leads to obedience and doing what God says.ST Aug 6, 1896ST Nov 2, 1915 Believing that the Sabbath should be kept must lead to keeping it even when persecution or pressure to preserve peace at home makes obedience costly, and those who desire eternal life must be zealous, repent, and promptly put faith into action, since their future course matters to salvation.RH Dec 13, 1853RH Jan 29, 1857 Works therefore belong with faith in the gospel by which people are saved, and living faith is invariably accompanied by good works.RH Apr 2, 1872ST Sep 18, 1884
Initial justification for past sins is received entirely by faith apart from works, because no good works, not even baptism, can cancel past sin, and no deeds of law can put away past sin or meet the perfect righteousness of the law; faith takes hold of and appropriates the merits of Christ's death and brings pardon through Christ with grace and strength to do right in the present.RH Dec 16, 1873RH Oct 21, 1873ST Oct 25, 1910 Justification is obtained without works yet cannot be retained without works, for works are needed to show the worth of faith and to maintain justification by keeping from sin, maintaining a righteous character before God and working out salvation.RH Jul 6, 1869ST Oct 25, 1910 Faith cannot take the place of works in forming a holy righteous character acceptable to Heaven, but serves works as a helper to enable people to form a character that will stand in the Judgment, since judgment and reward are given according to works and not according to faith.RH Dec 16, 1873ST Mar 29, 1883 In that sense a person is said to be justified by works, as long as faith is held steadfast to the end so that deeds manifest faith and show it to be the faith which justifies; through faith God forgives sin and regenerates the penitent sinner, implanting His own nature and creating him unto good works.RH Oct 21, 1873RH Jul 6, 1869ST Oct 25, 1910 A person remains in a state of justification by faith only so long as endeavoring to render obedience to God's holy law, with doing the will of God remaining necessary after pardon.RH Dec 16, 1873RH Oct 21, 1873
Living faith is shown by obedience to God's commandments and His moral law, which remains in force as the royal law and constitution of holy principles and is not set aside, weakened, or made void; faith establishes the law, works by love which is the fulfilling of the law, and sanctification is the sure evidence of justification.RH May 26, 1853RH Feb 17, 1852RH Nov 8, 1853RH Dec 1850RH Feb 17, 1852 True faith is invariably manifested by works, and only those who have Abraham's faith and Isaac's faith are counted as Abraham's seed, proved by doing the works of Abraham, which were obeying God's voice and keeping His charge, His commandments, His statutes, and His laws.RH May 26, 1853 Obeying God's commandments is the action that gives faith its evident sign or token, with each commandment calling for obedience as an expression of faith, and those who have named the name of Jesus prove love and faith by departing from iniquity and living as pilgrims and strangers on earth.RH Sep 30, 1852RH May 26, 1853 The works of Abraham show the obedience that accompanies living faith, and they who do those works are blessed with faithful Abraham with right to the tree of life and entrance through the gates into the city.RH May 26, 1853RH Nov 8, 1853
Abraham's offering of Isaac showed his faith working together with his deeds and brought it to maturity, completeness, and perfection, fulfilling that his belief in God was counted to him for righteousness; in that sense a person is described as justified by faith when justified by works, not by faith alone.RH May 12, 1868ST Jan 8, 1880ST Oct 17, 1895ST Nov 10, 1914 Works do not replace faith but show faith is active and reveal its measure, and good works are not done in order to demonstrate faith but because they are the necessary result of faith, just as a man does not breathe to show he lives but because he is alive and lives by breathing, with breath as his life.RH May 12, 1868ST Oct 19, 1888ST Oct 17, 1895 The patriarchs received a good report through such faith perfected by works, and their lives did not lead them to break God's commandments but made them examples for believers to imitate, with Abraham's willingness to offer his son revealing his faith and making it acceptable.ST Oct 19, 1888ST Aug 13, 1885ST Nov 10, 1914
Claiming to believe while disobeying God, despising or breaking His precepts, or continuing in disobedience is presumption and dead faith, not genuine full faith; faith without works does not sanctify and is not reckoned or counted as faith.ST Sep 24, 1894ST Oct 8, 1912ST May 12, 1890ST Mar 10, 1890 Genuine faith in Christ is active, works by love, purifies the soul, and appears in a life of obedience and allegiance to His law, with works making faith visible and character assessed by works.ST Sep 24, 1894ST Oct 8, 1912ST May 12, 1890 Christ's death does not free people from the duty to obey God's law but provides another opportunity to prove loyalty to God, while those who persist in disobedience remain liable for sin's penalty; salvation's benefits are offered through repentance for breaking God's law and faith in Christ, who gives power to obey.ST Sep 24, 1894ST Oct 8, 1912 Professing faith in God as Creator while disregarding the Sabbath memorial of creation is dead faith, for actions deny the faith professed, and obedience to the Sabbath is the work ordained to express faith in the God who created heaven and earth in six days and rested on the seventh.ST Feb 9, 1882ST Feb 7, 1911 Hoping in God's promises to be forgiven of transgression and made immortal in the last great day, while continually despising the commandments and counting them not worthy of observance when inconvenient, inexpedient, unpopular, or demanding sacrifice, is self-deception and not sure hope.ST Feb 9, 1882ST Feb 7, 1911
Human Nature and Death
The body without the breath is dead, for breath is what the word rendered spirit means, as the margin shows.RH Sep 20, 1864RH Nov 3, 1863 At death this breath of life goes out and leaves the body, and its going is the return of the spirit to God who gave it.RH Sep 20, 1864RH Nov 3, 1863ST Apr 20, 1915ST Nov 23, 1915 The breath taken away at death is the same breath sent forth at creation, sustained by breathing in the nostrils, while the man himself, made of dust, returns to dust.RH Nov 3, 1863 When that life-giving vital essence is withdrawn the person is unconscious, without life or knowledge, and life becomes extinct.RH Oct 31, 1865RH May 14, 1861RH May 23, 1865
That breath lacking to a dead body is not a separate immaterial soul that lives and thinks apart from the body, nor an immortal conscious part that continues living after death or goes to another place.ST Oct 9, 1879RH Dec 27, 1855 Without breath the body is dead, deprived of life, and the verse does not establish that an immortal reasoning soul separates from the body at death.RH May 23, 1865ST Oct 9, 1879RH Dec 27, 1855 The spirit is the life God gives, not an independently conscious being, so when God recalls that gift the organized body remains but without life or knowledge.RH Oct 31, 1865RH May 23, 1865
This breath of life is common to people and animals, given and taken back by God, applying to both humans and beasts.RH Nov 3, 1863RH Feb 15, 1870 It carries an animating principle of life that is imparted to the blood in the lungs, which is why blood is also called the life of the flesh because it receives its vitality from the breath.
A living man cannot have his soul or spirit literally go out of his body to another place and come back without dying and needing a resurrection, leaving a lifeless carcass behind.ST Mar 27, 1879 Paul being caught up to the third heaven was therefore not a literal leaving of the body for heaven and return, but a carrying of mind and thoughts there in vision so real he could not tell whether he was taken bodily or only saw it in his mind, just as being absent in flesh yet present in spirit means thoughts and affections are where the body is not.ST Mar 27, 1879 So also a prophet in trance may lie unmoved and seem lifeless while taken to other places and talking with heavenly beings, yet is not dead and has had no parting of soul or spirit or life from the body, the functions of the body being only suspended as in dreaming while God by divine means pictures to the mind what natural eyes cannot see.ST Jan 13, 1898
The same comparison describes prayers not animated by living faith, for prayer without faith is dead and loathsome like a body without breath or life.RH Aug 20, 1861RH Jul 30, 1861 It describes a form of Christianity that lacks its spiritual power, and Christianity without zeal as lifeless like a body without life, with zeal when guided by knowledge preferable to indifference.RH Nov 15, 1906RH Feb 19, 1857 It describes an institution as spiritually dead when its outward form remains but the principle that gives it life is neglected, as when churches preserve organization more than power, keep the form while Christ is shut out and spiritual life is gone.RH Jul 8, 1858
Practical Christian Application
Faith without works being dead means belief must lead to action in the work appointed for one's own time rather than resting on what others did in the past.ST Mar 1, 1877ST Nov 11, 1880ST Jun 12, 1884 To believe present truth with the whole heart is to take part in it and support it, and to believe the final warning message is to give worldly resources willingly to advance it.ST Nov 11, 1880RH Apr 3, 1855RH Dec 9, 1852 Believing this is the last generation requires living as the last generation, believing the advent movement is God's appointed means for carrying the final gospel message to the world requires working with it, and believing that closing message should go quickly to the ends of the earth requires hastening it by consecration of self and means to hasten the Redeemer's kingdom.RH Oct 15, 1903ST Jun 12, 1884 Such faith honors truth by earnest effort to advance its cause and help others gain the kingdom with every God-given ability, for without that persevering work it is lifeless and will avail nothing in the end.ST Mar 1, 1877ST Jun 12, 1884 Claiming to believe the third angel's message while grasping the world and holding covetously to means is self-deception, since one who truly believes it lets means go to sustain the work and trusts God to sustain him.RH Apr 3, 1855RH Dec 9, 1852
Genuine faith is proved by practical care for sufferers, giving what can be spared to help them.ST Sep 29, 1881RH May 31, 1870RH Mar 2, 1911 It feeds the hungry and clothes the naked instead of merely telling them to be filled and clothed, cares for widows, orphans, the sick, the fallen and the needy, and lifts them with deeds that raise, touch bitter needs, and extend a helping hand.ST Jan 30, 1879RH May 31, 1870RH Mar 2, 1911ST Jan 26, 1882 The Samaritan's compassionate help embodies the spirit of the commandments, while the priest and Levite show profession without action, and neglecting Christ's example by favoring the rich and excluding the poor neglects what this chapter teaches.ST Mar 3, 1887ST Jan 30, 1879 Prayers for the spread of God's cause must likewise be backed by earnest work, for words or prayers alone profit nothing when unaccompanied by action.RH Mar 2, 1911ST Jan 26, 1882
Living faith is shown by works including willing, costly giving to the cause of truth, and a person is known by those works.ST May 25, 1882RH Apr 3, 1855 Trying God's promise in returning tithe means showing faith through obedience, since merely nominal belief in His work is dead.ST Jul 9, 1894 Faithful stewardship of what God entrusts to a person puts faith into practice, while love of money, worldly friendship and life's cares choke it so it bears no fruit, and withholding resources from God's cause or leaving them to be squandered is unfaithfulness for which each must answer to God.ST Jul 9, 1894RH Dec 9, 1852ST Jan 26, 1882 Prayers for God's cause must therefore be seconded by giving means to carry it forward, and covetousness, stinginess and withholding show dead faith.ST May 25, 1882RH Dec 9, 1852ST Jan 26, 1882
Prayer, preaching and words alone are vain when a person remains idle, for faith and works belong together and cannot be separated.RH Jan 28, 1902RH Dec 1, 1904 The prayer of faith does heal the sick, yet that healing faith is shown just as truly by practical work according to knowledge as by vocal prayer. This includes giving hot or cold water treatment, teaching people how to live by right principles and care properly for the body God gave them so He can purify it and make it a fit temple for His Holy Spirit, using the means He Himself has provided. Trust in God does not excuse neglecting appointed duties, but joins faithful effort with trust; living faith acts, works earnestly, aids in overcoming obstacles rather than waiting passively for God to remove them, and serves with Christ as coworkers with God.RH Jan 28, 1902RH Dec 1, 1868RH Dec 1, 1904 Prayer alone, however earnest, without being seconded by right doing, humble obedience and holy living, is vain, and faithful work is more acceptable than zealous worship alone, while genuine fruits are good works such as caring for the needy, the fatherless and widows rather than cheap tied-on fruits of mere talk and exhortation.RH Dec 1, 1868RH Dec 1, 1904
Believing the Sabbath should be kept must lead to keeping it even when persecution or pressure to preserve peace at home makes obedience costly, for faith without works cannot save.RH Dec 13, 1853RH Mar 22, 1860 Those who profess the commandments of God and the faith of Jesus should bear Bible fruits, since profession denied by works lowers the standard and gives others reason to profess without living it.ST May 25, 1882RH Jun 9, 1859 Daily life testifies to the faith possessed and should agree with profession, including dress, speech, home and associations.ST May 25, 1882RH Jun 9, 1859 Assenting to God's promises and warnings without letting them affect the way of life is dead faith, whereas real faith makes unseen promises vivid and consequential rather than letting pursuit of present wealth take priority.ST Jul 9, 1894RH Jan 8, 1867 A Christian who professes faith in God's word about coming destruction but does not labor to save his household has a faith that cannot save, while living faith works as Noah's did when, moved by reverent fear, he prepared an ark for his family with prayer and labor and desperate effort for reconciliation before final separation at judgment.RH Jan 8, 1867RH Mar 22, 1860
Belief confined to the mind is useless unless it affects life and separates followers of truth from the world in zeal for good works, even at the cost of the world's displeasure and scoffs.RH Mar 13, 1856ST Dec 9, 1880 Truth must bear fruit by making a person more unselfish, generous, helpful, compassionate, patient and earnest, for without such fruit preaching is ineffective, and love and repentance likewise are known only by their effects.ST Jul 1, 1875ST Dec 9, 1880 Works do not purchase salvation, but living, saving faith produces obedience and removes corruptions of covetousness, pride, envy, malice and dishonesty, so faith that leaves people in those evils while treating good works as unnecessary is not living.RH Mar 13, 1856ST Jul 1, 1875 Asking the Lord for help must be joined with persevering action, and asking for the latter rain requires living faith expressed in keeping God's commandments and doing what pleases Him.RH Jul 9, 1901RH Mar 14, 1871 Honest daily industry is as valuable as pious devotion, since faith without works is dead.
Sources