AdventAI

Leviticus 19:17

Thou shalt not hate thy brother in thine heart: thou shalt in any wise rebuke thy neighbour, and not suffer sin upon him.

King James Version

Translations

  • American King James Version

    You shall not hate your brother in your heart: you shall in any wise rebuke your neighbor, and not suffer sin on him.

  • King James Version, KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible

    Thou shalt not hate thy brother in thine heart: thou shalt in any wise rebuke thy neighbour, and not suffer sin upon him.

  • Webster Bible

    Thou shalt not hate thy brother in thy heart: thou shalt in any wise rebuke thy neighbor, and not suffer sin upon him.

  • Revised Version

    Thou shalt not hate thy brother in thine heart: thou shalt surely rebuke thy neighbour, and not bear sin because of him.

  • American Standard Version

    Thou shalt not hate thy brother in thy heart: thou shalt surely rebuke thy neighbor, and not bear sin because of him.

  • Young's Literal Translation

    'Thou dost not hate thy brother in thy heart; thou dost certainly reprove thy fellow, and not suffer sin on him.

  • Darby Translation

    Thou shalt not hate thy brother in thy heart; thou shalt earnestly rebuke thy neighbour, lest thou bear sin on account of him.

  • Rotherham's Emphasised Bible

    Thou shalt not hate thy brother in thy heart,—Thou shalt, faithfully reprove, thy neighbour, and not countenance him in sin:

  • Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible

    You must not harbor hatred against your brother in your heart. Directly rebuke your neighbor, so that you will not incur guilt on account of him.

  • World English Bible

    “‘ You shall not hate your brother in your heart. You shall surely rebuke your neighbor, and not bear sin because of him.

  • Bible in Basic English

    Let there be no hate in your heart for your brother; but you may make a protest to your neighbour, so that he may be stopped from doing evil.

  • Geneva Bible

    Thou shalt not hate thy brother in thine heart, but thou shalt plainely rebuke thy neighbour, and suffer him not to sinne.

  • Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)

    Thou shalt not hate thy brother in thy heart, but reprove him openly, lest thou incur sin through him.

Commentary

Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.

Ellen G. White

32 sources

Thou shalt not hate a brother in the heart but shall faithfully rebuke a neighbor rather than leave him in sin, making honest corrective dealing part of how people are to treat one another.Ms 56, 1898, par. 18–20Ms 15, 1901, par. 22–23Ms 60, 1902, par. 31–34 It belongs to God's instruction that His people be holy in just and godly conduct, joined to loving one's neighbor as oneself and forbidding revenge and grudge-holding, spoken by Christ Himself as the same standard of love taught in the New Testament.Ms 15, 1901, par. 22–23Ms 13a, 1891, par. 35–37Lt 42, 1894, par. 16–19Ms 66, 1890, par. 7 Failing to warn a sinning neighbor and seek to save him makes the silent one share his guilt and answerable to God, so wrongdoing must be promptly and plainly reproved rather than excused to seem amiable.Ms 47, 1902, par. 18–19DA 441.1–4Ms 71, 19075T 676Lt 173, 1903, par. 18–19 The wrong is to be told to the person alone and made right privately, not turned into criticism or gossip to others, which adds its own sin and can turn reproof into revenge.DA 441.1–42T 53.17T 260.3–261.1Ms 47, 1902, par. 20–21 Correction is to be given humbly and kindly with Christlike love, pity and prayer, aiming at restoration and healing rather than exposure, without nursing resentment into malice.Ms 16, 1892, par. 2–4DA 441.1–4Ms 71, 19077T 260.3–261.1

Meaning and Setting

Inward hatred held in the heart toward a brother is forbidden, and a neighbor must be faithfully and directly rebuked rather than left to remain in sin.Ms 56, 1898, par. 18–20Ms 15, 1901, par. 22–23Ms 60, 1902, par. 31–34Ms 86, 1905, par. 9–14Ms 34, 1900, par. 11–14 Honest, corrective dealing with others in this way belongs to the Lord's directions for how people are to treat one another.Ms 60, 1902, par. 31–34Ms 86, 1905, par. 9–14 Love for one's neighbor therefore requires caring correction rather than indifference, and among believers it forbids neglecting Christian love or using passionate words and overbearing actions that cause pain, create stumbling blocks, and dishonor the truth professed.Ms 34, 1900, par. 11–14Ms 13a, 1891, par. 35–37 Together with the following verse, the command also forbids revenge and grudges and enjoins love for one's neighbor as oneself.Ms 13a, 1891, par. 35–37

The command belongs to God's instruction that Israel be holy and to His laws for holy living and godly conduct toward others.Ms 15, 1901, par. 22–23Ms 34, 1900, par. 11–14Ms 66, 1890, par. 7 Holiness in this sense requires justice in dealing with others, forbidding oppression of a brother in any way.18MR 87.3–4 The instruction for godly conduct is not limited to members of one's own community.Ms 66, 1890, par. 7

Christ Himself is the speaker of the command, speaking from the cloudy pillar.Ms 15, 1901, par. 22–23Lt 42, 1894, par. 16–19 He gave in it the same high standard of love taught in the New Testament.Lt 42, 1894, par. 16–19 It stands as a lasting lesson for future generations, calling those who have received God's great gift in Christ to love one another as Christ has loved them.Lt 42, 1894, par. 16–19 These truths had been taught through Moses but had become obscured by hardness of heart and love of sin. In Christ's day Jewish religious leaders neither taught nor practiced this commandment.Ms 56, 1898, par. 18–20 The command against cherished hatred belongs with the duty to love one's neighbor as oneself, and with the prohibition of vengeance and grudges.Ms 15, 1901, par. 22–23Ms 13a, 1891, par. 35–37Ms 16, 1892, par. 2–4 Loving the Lord with all heart, soul, strength, and mind and loving neighbor as self means not hating a brother in the heart, faithfully rebuking a neighbor rather than letting sin rest upon him, not taking revenge and not holding a grudge, but loving neighbor as self because the Lord commands it.Lt 22c, 1890, par. 1Ms 16, 1892, par. 2–4 Keeping this law is keeping the way of the Lord to inherit eternal life, which requires a converted heart made one with Christ with the human will made God's will.Lt 22c, 1890, par. 1

Responsibility to Reprove Sin

Failing to warn a sinning neighbor and seek to save him from sin implicates the silent person in his guilt, making him alike guilty with the guilty and responsible as though guilty of the act itself.Ms 47, 1902, par. 18–19DA 441.1–4Ms 71, 19075T 6764T 513.1 To leave sin unspoken upon a brother is to be guilty, and God holds accountable those who stay silent when they see sin and could have checked the evil, with His displeasure as sure upon the silent as upon the guilty.DA 441.1–4Ms 71, 19075T 6764T 513.1 This is a plain scriptural duty of faithful stewardship, to deal with wrongs and sins apparent among God's people by reproof aimed at restoration rather than passing by indifferent.Ms 47, 1902, par. 18–19DA 441.1–45T 676 Such personal dealing seeks to make the matter right and settle it easily, clears the way to higher ground, preserves love for brethren with pity and prayer for those in error, and keeps souls from being lost over unsettled grievances.Ms 47, 1902, par. 18–19DA 441.1–4Ms 71, 1907

God's servants must give pointed testimony and promptly and plainly reprove and rebuke wrongdoing rather than remain silent, excuse it, or allow sin to remain unaddressed in a brother.GW92 85.21T 213.2–215.2CH 672.2Ms 25, 1906, par. 20SG4 205.2 They must not shield the wrongdoer from deserved correction, especially when wrongdoing dishonors the truth or may harm and contaminate others.1T 213.2–215.2CH 672.2Ms 25, 1906, par. 20 To pass by wrongs indifferent virtually sustains and justifies the sinner, and to excuse wrongs because reproof is disagreeable to feeling in order to seem amiable and lovely in disposition is to shun plain duty and incur God's displeasure.5T 676Lt 173, 1903, par. 18–19 Love for others requires faithfully reproving wrongdoing rather than overlooking it, because passing wrongs by would sustain them.5T 676Lt 173, 1903, par. 18–19

Wrongdoing must be addressed without hypocrisy or partiality toward poor or powerful, and those responsible for sacred interests must be especially earnest that no evil principle goes unnoticed.Ms 26, 1896, par. 8 Rebuke may require putting away sins or separation from the church, and if wrongdoers refuse to repent and correct their faults they must be separated from the work because their principles will corrupt those connected with them.Ms 26, 1896, par. 8CH 672.2 Sympathizing with one doing wrong or opposing those who reprove him can hinder the correction God intends, encourage self-deception, and make the sympathizer accountable for failing to warn of danger.1T 213.2–215.2 Cherishing iniquity in the heart keeps the Lord from hearing, and wrong may be carried openly into life as well as held in the heart.1T 213.2–215.2 To love brethren is to love them too well to suffer sin upon them, giving faithful rebuke instead of studying self-interest and flattering and dissembling to please unsanctified ears and hearts.5T 299.3 Doing this under criticism requires a face like flint, indomitable faith and courage, and a heart made strong by constant communion with God, without which the minister shapes his testimony to avoid criticism, separates from God, loses the sense of divine favor, and his testimony becomes tame and lifeless and his labors powerless, and faithful men who so love their brethren are few indeed.5T 299.3 Failing to reprove wrong in a neighbor is neglect and unfaithfulness, and this neglect is a great sin before God, and those who praise the unfaithful and flatter the unconsecrated share in that same sin.Ms 3, 1871, par. 1

Correcting in Love

The wrong is to be taken up directly and privately with the one at fault, going to him alone, telling him his fault, explaining the matter, admonishing him so he can see his wrong, and trying to make it right and settle it easily.Ms 71, 19077T 260.3–261.1Ms 47, 1902, par. 20–21GW 498.3–499.2Lt 30, 1868, par. 8 Love for a brother rules out both hatred in the heart and silence about his wrongdoing, and requires this humble, sincere dealing rather than letting wrongs stand.Ms 71, 19077T 260.3–261.1Ms 47, 1902, par. 20–21GW 498.3–499.2Lt 30, 1868, par. 8 Such personal, calm discussion according to God's instruction clears the way to higher ground, heals the difficulty, preserves love for brethren, and keeps souls from being lost over unsettled grievances.Ms 71, 1907Ms 47, 1902, par. 20–21GW 498.3–499.2 Neglecting that plain duty leaves guilt of sin and a burdened conscience.Lt 30, 1868, par. 8

Rebuke is to be directed to the wrongdoer himself, not turned into private criticism, repeated gossip, or spreading the report to others.DA 441.1–42T 53.17T 260.3–261.1Ms 47, 1902, par. 20–21GW 498.3–499.2 Speaking of his faults to someone else does not fulfill the duty but adds a sin of its own, and excusing gossip as a way to relieve the burdened conscience is wrong.DA 441.1–42T 53.1Lt 30, 1868, par. 8 Telling faults to another instead of to the brother does not rightly unburden the conscience.2T 53.1Lt 30, 1868, par. 8 Spreading the matter exposes him, worsens the difficulty and the harm to the church, and can turn reproof into revenge.DA 441.1–47T 260.3–261.1Ms 47, 1902, par. 20–21GW 498.3–499.2 In correcting a fellow believer needless exposure is to be avoided.DA 441.1–47T 260.3–261.1GW 498.3–499.2

Correction is to be given humbly, sincerely, kindly, courteously, and calmly, with Christlike love, pity, forgiveness, and prayer for those in error and wrong.DA 441.1–4Ms 71, 19077T 260.3–261.1Ms 47, 1902, par. 20–21GW 498.3–499.2 Workers are to treat fellow workers with the same earnest concern they have for themselves, showing the pity and forgiveness they themselves need from Christ.Ms 16, 1892, par. 2–4DA 441.1–4 The duty to warn an erring brother is to be carried out with kindness and love, because wrongdoing may come from spiritual blindness and deception, and the erring person is not to be treated as an enemy.RH May 13, 1909 Those who accept Christ's sacrifice are pledged to care especially for a brother who is going wrong.RH May 13, 1909

The aim is restoration, resolving the difficulty, helping the erring person, healing the breach, clearing the way to higher ground, preserving love for brethren, and keeping souls from being lost over unsettled grievances, not exposure or punishment.DA 441.1–4Ms 71, 1907Ms 47, 1902, par. 20–21GW 498.3–499.2 Resentment must not be allowed to grow into malice, and the hurt must not be nursed, further offenses sought, or poisoned speech and railing indulged.7T 260.3–261.1Ms 47, 1902, par. 20–21 The wrong should be discussed calmly and privately.7T 260.3–261.1

Love for a neighbor does not keep silent when the neighbor does wrong, including departure from strict honesty, but makes the duty to do right clear to him rather than letting sin remain upon a brother.Ms 34, 1900, par. 11–14Ms 2, 1897, par. 34–37 Speaking up is required even when others call it mean, narrow, or cowardly.Ms 2, 1897, par. 34–37 Neglecting Christian love, or using passionate words and overbearing actions, causes pain, creates stumbling blocks, and dishonors the truth professed.Ms 34, 1900, par. 11–14

Neglecting the commanded reproof tramples God's command, hates the brother or neighbor in the heart, leaves guilt of sin and a burdened conscience, and is reproved by God as a sin of omission.2T 53.1Lt 30, 1868, par. 8 Telling the brother's faults to another person instead is a sin of commission that does not rightly relieve or unburden the conscience.2T 53.1Lt 30, 1868, par. 8

Sources

  1. Ms 56, 1898, par. 18–20 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 13 (1898) — Ms 56, 1898 Ellen G. White, written April 27, 1898
  2. Ms 15, 1901, par. 22–23 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 16 (1901) — Ms 15, 1901 Ellen G. White, written May 1900; published 1901
  3. Ms 60, 1902, par. 31–34 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 17 (1902) — Ms 60, 1902 Ellen G. White, written May 12, 1902
  4. Ms 13a, 1891, par. 35–37 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 7 (1891-1892) — Ms 13a, 1891 Ellen G. White, written December 29, 1891
  5. Lt 42, 1894, par. 16–19 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 9 (1894) — Lt 42, 1894 Ellen G. White, written October 24, 1894
  6. Ms 66, 1890, par. 7 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 6 (1889-1890) — Ms 66, 1890 Ellen G. White, written 1890
  7. Ms 47, 1902, par. 18–19 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 17 (1902) — Ms 47, 1902 Ellen G. White, written April 2, 1902
  8. DA 441.1–4 The Desire of Ages — CHAPTER FORTY-EIGHT. Ellen G. White, 1898
  9. Ms 71, 1907 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 22 (1907) — Ms 71, 1907 Ellen G. White Estate, written February 16, 1907
  10. 5T 676 Testimonies for the Church Volume Five — DUTY TO GIVE REPROOF. Ellen G. White, 1889
  11. Lt 173, 1903, par. 18–19 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 18 (1903) — Lt 173, 1903 Ellen G. White, written August 5, 1903
  12. 2T 53.1 Testimonies for the Church Volume Two — EVIL-SPEAKING. Ellen G. White, 1871
  13. 7T 260.3–261.1 Testimonies for the Church Volume Seven — CHURCH DISCIPLINE. Ellen G. White, 1902
  14. Ms 47, 1902, par. 20–21 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 17 (1902) — Ms 47, 1902 Ellen G. White, written April 2, 1902
  15. Ms 16, 1892, par. 2–4 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 7 (1891-1892) — Ms 16, 1892 Ellen G. White, written December 22, 1892
  16. Ms 86, 1905, par. 9–14 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 20 (1905) — Ms 86, 1905 Ellen G. White, written July 14, 1905
  17. Ms 34, 1900, par. 11–14 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 15 (1900) — Ms 34, 1900 Ellen G. White, written June 26, 1900
  18. 18MR 87.3–4 Manuscript Releases, vol. 18 [Nos. 1301-1359] — MR No. 1312—Miscellaneous Writings on Christ's Ministry, Health Reform, and the Christian Life Ellen G. White, Ellen G. White Estate, written 1902; published 1990
  19. Lt 22c, 1890, par. 1 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 6 (1889-1890) — Lt 22c, 1890 Ellen G. White, written March 28, 1890
  20. 4T 513.1 Testimonies for the Church Volume Four — THE CAUSE AT BATTLE CREEK. Ellen G. White, 1881
  21. GW92 85.2 Gospel Workers (1892) — FAITHFULNESS IN REPROVING SIN. Ellen G. White, 1892
  22. 1T 213.2–215.2 Testimonies for the Church Volume One — NUMBER SIX. Ellen G. White, 1868
  23. CH 672.2 Counsels on Health — • BLINDED BY SIN Ellen G. White, 1923
  24. Ms 25, 1906, par. 20 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 21 (1906) — Ms 25, 1906 Ellen G. White, written February 14, 1906
  25. SG4 205.2 Spiritual Gifts Volume Four — Number Six. Ellen G. White, 1864
  26. Ms 26, 1896, par. 8 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 11 (1896) — Ms 26, 1896 Ellen G. White, written September 25, 1896
  27. 5T 299.3 Testimonies for the Church Volume Five — CRITICISING MINISTERS. Ellen G. White, 1889
  28. Ms 3, 1871, par. 1 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 2 (1869 - 1875) — Ms 3, 1871 Ellen G. White, written 1871
  29. GW 498.3–499.2 Gospel Workers — CHURCH DISCIPLINE Ellen G. White, 1915
  30. Lt 30, 1868, par. 8 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 1 (1844 - 1868) — Lt 30, 1868 Ellen G. White, written April 6, 1868
  31. RH May 13, 1909 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 86, No. 19 — The Relation of Man to His Fellow Man Ellen G. White, May 13, 1909
  32. Ms 2, 1897, par. 34–37 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 12 (1897) — Ms 2, 1897 Ellen G. White, written January 18, 1897

Pioneers and periodicals

39 sources

Hatred kept in the heart, with its malice, grudges and resentment, is forbidden, and love requires openly rebuking a neighbor rather than letting sin rest upon him unchallenged.RH May 21, 1857ST Apr 7, 1914RH Jan 7, 1902RH Aug 23, 1864 Faithful correction is what it truly means to love a neighbor as oneself, for love does not overlook, excuse or conceal sin.RH Feb 10, 1916RH Jan 7, 1902ST Nov 1, 1883ST Jul 10, 1893 To stay silent about a brother's fault or to let a fellow being go on in sin without warning is itself hatred in the heart, and under the spirit of the sixth commandment it is equivalent to murder.RH Jun 20, 1854 That reproof is to be given usually in private, with humility, meekness, kindness and patience to reclaim the erring one, and never by talking over his faults with others behind his back.RH May 13, 1909STRH Apr 21, 1868RH Dec 24, 1872 Every person is his brother's keeper, so churches as well as individuals must prayerfully watch over one another, warn the erring when in danger, and by patient discipline protect the purity of the body.ST Feb 1, 1883RH Jan 22, 1857RH Aug 4, 1874RH Dec 24, 1872

Words and Historical Setting

In the original command the terms brother and neighbor are synonymous, both meaning a fellow member of Israel.RH Aug 23, 1864 Inward hatred is forbidden and a neighbor at fault is to be corrected rather than left with his sin unchallenged.RH Aug 23, 1864 Neighbor was understood by the Jews to mean a fellow Jew, and the question Who is my neighbour? was used to imply that the law had been fulfilled by right conduct toward people of one's own nation.ST Jan 5, 1882 Neighborly duty is now to be extended to any person in need, whatever nation, religion, or kindred, so that anyone known or within reach is neighbor and has a claim on mercy and kindness.ST Jan 5, 1882

The chapter belongs to laws set in contrast with the pagan customs of the nations around Israel.ST Feb 7, 1911 It was spoken less than a year after Israel left Egypt, before the people left Sinai.RH Aug 2, 1870 It was therefore not a new law given nearly forty years later, but belonged to the law given at Sinai.RH Aug 2, 1870

The verse stands among laws, ordinances, prohibitions, and precepts whose reasons are mostly self-evident. Its surrounding chapter also shows that love for one's neighbor is not a New Testament command alone.

Hatred Forbidden, Love Required

The verse forbids hatred kept in the heart, including malice, grudges, and resentment toward another, and it shows that hatred and malice were already forbidden under the Mosaic law.ST Apr 7, 1914RH Jan 7, 1902RH Mar 23, 1852ST Nov 1, 1883ST Oct 18, 1877 Guarding against grudges and refusing to hold resentment are therefore required, with love for a brother excluding inward hatred and requiring rebuke rather than letting sin rest upon him.ST Apr 7, 1914RH Jan 7, 1902RH Mar 23, 1852ST Nov 1, 1883 Together with the command in the next verse to love the neighbor as oneself, this teaches a duty that applied from the beginning and expresses the second great commandment, showing that the commandments grow out of love for God and for one another.RH Jan 7, 1902RH Mar 23, 1852 Correcting a neighbor's sin is thus a duty of love, not leaving the person in sin, and the church helps keep its members in harmony through correction that is charitable rather than harsh or censorious.ST Nov 1, 1883

The prohibition forbids hating a neighbor whose creed does not fit one's own doctrine, since both parties may be wrong and no one person sees all pure truth.ST Feb 27, 1912 It forbids hating men for hard hands, patched garments, or unfashionable dress, since a well-dressed man may have a patched soul and a ragged heart while a poor man may have worth, and outward condition does not measure worth.ST Feb 27, 1912 It forbids hating any fellow man, alien or neighbor, near or far.ST Feb 27, 1912 Such hatred is small work unworthy of a person, and beneath vast heavens that show how small man is, in a large world there is no space or time to spare for it.ST Feb 27, 1912

Failing to tell a brother privately about his fault is disobedience to God and amounts to hating him in the heart.RH Jun 20, 1854 The fault must be addressed between the two of them by going to the brother, rather than easing a troubled conscience by telling someone else.RH Jun 20, 1854 Failing to warn a fellow being who is in danger is likewise hatred for him, for to allow one to continue in sin without warning of its results is equivalent to murder under the spirit of the sixth commandment, since the wages of sin is death. The Gospel is the antidote for sin, and one who has received it is debtor to every man who has not received it to the extent it dwells in himself, so to sit in comfort while shipwrecked fellows perish for want of help that could easily be given, or like the priest and Levite to pass by one fallen among thieves and leave him to perish, is to leave men to perish temporally or eternally for lack of that of which there is abundance. The verse shows what it really means to love the neighbor as oneself, making faithful correction a duty of love rather than leaving the person in sin, with care more for restoring a brother than for self and desire to bring him back to God's favor rather than letting sin go unaddressed.RH Feb 10, 1916ST Nov 1, 1883ST Jul 10, 1893

Rebuke as Duty of Love

Love for a neighbor requires plain and faithful reproof of his sin rather than letting it rest upon him or go unchallenged, for love does not overlook, excuse, or conceal wrongdoing.RH May 21, 1857RH Jan 7, 1902RH Aug 23, 1864ST Sep 3, 1896RH Jul 31, 1860 One who truly loves a brother will point out his faults with patience and love, because he cannot be saved while persisting in them, and refusal to rebuke even a dear friend wrongly supports the wrong and can make repentance less likely.ST Sep 3, 1896RH Jul 31, 1860RH Dec 24, 1872 Such correction is meant to reclaim the erring one rather than to treat him with personal abuse or false sympathy, and if after patient care there is no hope of reform and he persists in resisting light, separation may be necessary to protect the church.RH Dec 24, 1872

To please a person by helping him sin or by withholding a needed warning is cruelty and not kindness, while rebuke that seeks his good is kindness.ST Sep 3, 1896 The duty to reprove applies to sin in high places and in low places, and must not be set aside from fear of giving offense or provoking hatred.RH May 21, 1857 It is evangelical in spirit and calls for self-denial, since faithful performance may bring opposition.RH Sep 10, 1857 Christ's faithful reproofs and His suffering for others supply the example and strengthen the call to follow it.RH Sep 10, 1857

The command reaches such evils as profanity, abuse, and ridicule of religion, requiring Christians promptly to warn those who commit them of their sin and of exposure to divine wrath.RH Dec 15, 1859RH Sep 10, 1857 To recognize and correct wrongdoing does not make a person a participant in the sin, but rebuking it clears him of complicity.RH Apr 28, 1910 Silent acquiescence, covering up wrong, or fellowshipping wrongdoing makes one share responsibility and become a partaker of other men's sins, while kindly, honest, and faithful reproof is consistent with charity and forgiveness.ST Dec 3, 1885RH Apr 28, 1910RH Apr 21, 1868 There are proper times to speak about another even to his detriment, in a court of law where truth must be told that justice may be done, and to proper church authorities when a brother persists in wrongdoing in the interest of good order and discipline.ST Dec 3, 1885

The verse does not call for constant criticism of every fault, for love covers many sins and a spirit of relentless accusation is opposed to God's loving Spirit.RH May 11, 1869 Admonition is required when needed for the offender's good or for Christ's honor rather than leaving sin unaddressed, and Christians and reformers have a duty to reprove and rebuke wrongdoing with patience and instruction, with correction informed and aimed at setting things right and not merely condemning.RH May 11, 1869RH Apr 26, 1860 Failure to reprove contributes to corruption in the church and in the world.RH May 21, 1857 When members fail faithfully to correct those who err, sin is left unchecked among them, and alienation, division, and apostasy follow.RH May 21, 1857RH Jan 15, 1901

How to Give Rebuke

Reproof must be given in the Spirit of Christ, with God-given wisdom and love for the soul, leaving the results to God, and only when God's Spirit calls for it.RH May 21, 1857ST Sometimes dignified silence is the better response to idle or foolish talk than any attempt at correction.ST The usual rule is to reprove privately, with humility, meekness, kindness, and patience.RH May 13, 1909STRH Dec 24, 1872

That gentleness is required because wrongdoing may come from spiritual blindness and deception, so the erring person is not to be treated as an enemy.RH May 13, 1909 Correction is meant to reclaim him, pursued with patient care rather than treated as personal abuse or covered by false sympathy.RH Dec 24, 1872 It should be charitable, not harsh or censorious, and in this form helps keep members in harmony.ST Nov 1, 1883 It is to be administered by the Scriptural method, not through an anonymous letter.RH Mar 2, 1905

Brotherly love requires faithfully admonishing an erring brother to his face rather than talking over his faults with others.RH Apr 21, 1868 Gossip is contrary to brotherly love, destroys confidence and fellowship, and must be speedily and entirely changed through confession and reform.RH Apr 21, 1868 Reproof must therefore be kindly, honest, and faithful rather than silence or fellowship with wrongdoing.RH Apr 21, 1868 It must also be prompt and decisive, calling the sinner to put away sins rather than allowing sin to persist and contaminate others.RH Apr 21, 1868RH Oct 19, 1916

Reproof is an act of compassion for the ignorant and for those out of the way, and a word spoken in season does good, striking with power.RH Aug 4, 1868 Increase in riches steels the heart against that compassion and causes neglect of this duty.RH Aug 4, 1868 Care for a neighbor includes kindly reproving sin alongside sharing grief, relieving need, and loving in deed rather than only in words.RH Jul 16, 1857 It approaches him with desire to bring him back to God's favor rather than regard for self.ST Jul 10, 1893RH Jul 16, 1857

Church Responsibility and Discipline

The verse means that every person is his brother's keeper, so God requires His people to have care for one another and not leave a neighbor in wrong.ST Feb 1, 1883RH Jan 22, 1857 That care belongs to churches as well as to individuals, who must kindly and prayerfully watch over members.ST Feb 1, 1883RH Jan 22, 1857 It includes noticing when someone repeatedly stops attending worship and seeking out the cause.RH Jan 22, 1857

When a brother is in danger of error he must be warned rather than left in it, for more is required than merely refusing to hate him inwardly.RH Apr 21, 1868RH Jan 22, 1857 Failing to give that warning allows sin to fall upon him and makes the one who stays silent guilty of omission.RH Apr 21, 1868RH Jan 22, 1857 Such silence is serious because others may be hardened in sin, and the silent one may bear responsibility for souls.RH Apr 21, 1868

The verse commands strict church discipline, requiring the church to search out the erring one and rebuke him.ST Feb 1, 1883 That work is absolutely necessary to the church's own existence and purity as a whole.ST Feb 1, 1883 The sin of one member is imputed to the entire body until the offender is searched out and punished.ST Feb 1, 1883

As a man cannot be sound if one limb is diseased, so the church is not pure unless each individual member is walking orderly.ST Feb 1, 1883 A single individual by a wrong course may defeat all the labors of those who would advance the cause.ST Feb 1, 1883 He may involve many others in his own ruin, so each person bears heavy responsibility for his course.ST Feb 1, 1883

The verse requires church order and organization that guards and enforces the principles of the message and holds believers closely to those principles.RH Feb 26, 1867 Believers are to influence and encourage one another by precept as well as by example to perseverance.RH Feb 26, 1867 They are to bear one another's burdens and to separate false brethren who hinder them and the cause.RH Feb 26, 1867

Love requires members and church officers to watch over one another and labor to help those in their care by reproving sin rather than leaving a person in it.RH Aug 4, 1874RH Dec 24, 1872RH Oct 19, 1916 That reproof must be plain and faithful, given with patience and love to reclaim the erring, not taken as personal abuse nor covered by false sympathy or concealment.RH Aug 4, 1874RH Dec 24, 1872 It must be prompt and decisive, calling the sinner to put away his sins rather than allowing sin to persist and contaminate others.RH Dec 24, 1872RH Oct 19, 1916 This faithful dealing serves both the individual and the church, yet if patient care gives no hope of reform and a member persists in rejecting right principles and resisting light, he is to be removed from fellowship and separated to protect the church.RH Aug 4, 1874RH Dec 24, 1872

Links to Other Commandments

Love for the neighbor in verse 18 stands together with the ban on hidden hatred and the charge to correct the neighbor rather than leave sin upon him, showing a duty that bound from the beginning and did not start with the Christian dispensation.RH Jan 7, 1902 The surrounding chapter itself makes clear that neighbor love is not a New Testament command alone.RH Jan 7, 1902 Love for one another was already part of God's law, forbidding hatred and grudges, requiring rebuke instead of letting sin go unchallenged, and calling for loving the neighbor as oneself.RH Mar 23, 1852 These precepts express the second great commandment and reveal that the commandments of the law grow out of love for God and for one another, with Christ's teaching and example giving this neglected command new luster.RH Mar 23, 1852RH Oct 28, 1873

The verse belongs to Moses' summary of the law as twofold duty, love to God and love to other people.RH Mar 12, 1908 It belongs to the enduring standard of righteousness, a law of love by which people are judged, requiring love for one's neighbor as oneself.RH Mar 12, 1908ST Sep 9, 1930 Hatred in the heart and failure to rebuke a neighbor are violations of the sixth commandment, showing that the command against killing includes responsibility to confront wrongdoing rather than allow another to remain in sin.ST Dec 27, 1905 To let one continue in sin without warning of its results is equivalent to murder in spirit, since the wages of sin is death.ST Dec 27, 1905 One who has received the Gospel as the antidote for sin is debtor to share it to the extent it dwells within, and not to sit in comfort while shipwrecked fellows perish for want of help easily given, nor like the priest and Levite to pass by one fallen among thieves and leave him to perish temporally or eternally when there is abundance to give.

Sources

  1. RH May 21, 1857 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 10, No. 3 — GET THEIR HATRED May 21, 1857
  2. ST Apr 7, 1914 Signs of the Times, Vol. 41, No. 13 — SYSTEMATIC BIBLE STUDY Editor, April 7, 1914
  3. RH Jan 7, 1902 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 79, No. 1 — THE OLD-NEW COMMANDMENT GEO. W. SPIES., January 7, 1902
  4. RH Aug 23, 1864 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 24, No. 13 — Who is my Neighbor? Editor, Third-Day, August 23, 1864
  5. RH Feb 10, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 8 — The Bible Year Thursday, February 10, 1916
  6. ST Nov 1, 1883 Signs of the Times, Vol. 9, No. 41 — The Sabbath-School November 1, 1883
  7. ST Jul 10, 1893 Signs of the Times, Vol. 19, No. 35 — Church Discipline and Restoring a Brother Monday, July 10, 1893
  8. RH Jun 20, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 5, No. 21 — THE CURE OF EVIL SPEAKING JUNE 20, 1854
  9. ST Signs of the Times, Vol. 32, No. 28 — Question Corner L. G. L.; Inquirer.
  10. RH Apr 21, 1868 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 31, No. 19 — Praying for Faithful Messengers L. C. Hutchins, Third-day, April 21, 1868
  11. RH May 13, 1909 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 86, No. 19 — The Relation of Man to His Fellow Man Ellen G. White, May 13, 1909
  12. RH Dec 24, 1872 Review and Herald, Vol. 41, No. 2 — Tent Meetings in San Francisco, California John Norton Loughborough, December 24, 1872
  13. ST Feb 1, 1883 Signs of the Times, Vol. 9, No. 5 — The Sabbath-School Ellet Joseph Waggoner, February 1, 1883
  14. RH Jan 22, 1857 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 9, No. 12 — Am I my Brother's Keeper? January 22, 1857
  15. RH Aug 4, 1874 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 44, No. 8 — THE NATURE, POSITION, AND RESPONSIBILITY OF THE CHURCH George Ide Butler, August 4, 1874
  16. ST Jan 5, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 1 — The Sabbath-School Editor, January 5, 1882
  17. ST Feb 7, 1911 Signs of the Times, Vol. 38, No. 6 — Schedule for Week Ending February 18, 1911 February 7, 1911
  18. RH Aug 2, 1870 Review and Herald, Vol. 36, No. 7 — Review of Wellcome and Goud Joseph Harvey Waggoner, Third-day, August 2, 1870
  19. RH Mar 23, 1852 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 2, No. 14 — THE LAW OF GOD ILLUSTRATED Newell Mead, March 23, 1852
  20. ST Oct 18, 1877 Signs of the Times, Vol. 3, No. 40 — Iowa G. V. Kilgore; Hart, October 18, 1877
  21. ST Feb 27, 1912 Signs of the Times, Vol. 39, No. 9 — Work for Small Men Sam Walter Foss, February 27, 1912
  22. ST Sep 3, 1896 Signs of the Times, Vol. 22, No. 35 — THE LAW OF CHRIST Ellet Joseph Waggoner, September 3, 1896
  23. RH Jul 31, 1860 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 16, No. 11 — OUR INFLUENCE July 31, 1860
  24. RH Sep 10, 1857 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 10, No. 19 — On the Propriety of Introducing Religion in General Conversation Fifth-Day, September 10, 1857
  25. RH Dec 15, 1859 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 15, No. 4 — THE DUTY OF REPROOF December 15, 1859
  26. RH Apr 28, 1910 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 87, No. 17 — Judge Not C. P. Bollman, April 28, 1910
  27. ST Dec 3, 1885 Signs of the Times, Vol. 11, No. 46 — Comments on Psalm 15 Ellet Joseph Waggoner, December 3, 1885
  28. RH May 11, 1869 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 33, No. 20 — PASSING OVER FAULTS May 11, 1869
  29. RH Apr 26, 1860 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 15, No. 23 — CENSURE AGAINST CRITICISM E. Goodrich, April 26, 1860
  30. RH Jan 15, 1901 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 78, No. 3 — DISTRICT 5 R. M. Kilgore, January 15, 1901
  31. RH Mar 2, 1905 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 82, No. 9 — Anonymous Communications Editor, March 2, 1905
  32. RH Oct 19, 1916 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 93, No. 52 — W. S. CHAPMAN W. S. Chapman, October 19, 1916
  33. RH Aug 4, 1868 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 32, No. 7 — DANGER OF RICHES John Wesley, August 4, 1868
  34. RH Jul 16, 1857 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 10, No. 11 — AM I MY BROTHER'S KEEPER? July 16, 1857
  35. RH Feb 26, 1867 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 29, No. 12 — The Sermon Eld. D. T. Bourdeau, Third-day, February 26, 1867
  36. RH Oct 28, 1873 Review and Herald, Vol. 42, No. 20 — FORTY ANSWERS TO FORTY SO-CALLED OBJECTIONS AGAINST THE LAW AND SABBATH D. T. Bourdeau, October 28, 1873
  37. RH Mar 12, 1908 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 85, No. 11 — Aids for Bible Readers Walter Quincy Scott, D. D., March 12, 1908
  38. ST Sep 9, 1930 Signs of the Times, Vol. 57, No. 35 — EXPLORING YOUR BIBLE Rose E. Boose, September 9, 1930
  39. ST Dec 27, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 52 — THE TEN COMMANDMENTS AND GENTILES E. L. Maxwell, December 27, 1905

Cross-references 20 of 25

  1. Matthew 18:15

    Moreover if thy brother shall trespass against thee, go and tell him his fault between thee and him alone: if he shall hear thee, thou hast gained thy brother.

    Commands privately correcting a brother who has sinned.

  2. Galatians 6:1

    Brethren, if a man be overtaken in a fault, ye which are spiritual, restore such an one in the spirit of meekness; considering thyself, lest thou also be tempted.

    Believers are to restore someone caught in sin with meekness and care.

  3. Genesis 4:9

    And the LORD said unto Cain, Where is Abel thy brother? And he said, I know not: Am I my brother’s keeper?

    Cain denies responsibility for his brother; Leviticus commands admonishing a neighbor.

  4. John 13:34

    A new commandment I give unto you, That ye love one another; as I have loved you, that ye also love one another.

    Christ commands the mutual love expressed in the neighbor-love instruction.

  5. James 5:20

    Let him know, that he which converteth the sinner from the error of his way shall save a soul from death, and shall hide a multitude of sins.

    Turning a sinner back from error saves a soul and covers sins.

  6. Matthew 22:39

    And the second is like unto it, Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself.

    Jesus summarizes the command to love one’s neighbor as oneself.

  7. 2 Timothy 4:2

    Preach the word; be instant in season, out of season; reprove, rebuke, exhort with all longsuffering and doctrine.

    Commands reproof and rebuke with patience and instruction.

  8. Ezekiel 3:18-19

    When I say unto the wicked, Thou shalt surely die; and thou givest him not warning, nor speakest to warn the wicked from his wicked way, to save his life; the same wicked man shall die in his iniquity; but his blood will I require at thine hand.

    Both make one responsible to warn a wrongdoer rather than leave him in sin.

  9. 1 John 2:9-11

    He that saith he is in the light, and hateth his brother, is in darkness even until now.

    Love for a brother means walking in light, while hatred leaves one in darkness.

  10. John 15:17

    These things I command you, that ye love one another.

    Jesus commands his followers to love one another.

  11. Luke 10:30-37

    And Jesus answering said, A certain man went down from Jerusalem to Jericho, and fell among thieves, which stripped him of his raiment, and wounded him, and departed, leaving him half dead.

    The Good Samaritan parable illustrates who acted as neighbor to the injured man.

  12. Luke 10:27

    And he answering said, Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy strength, and with all thy mind; and thy neighbour as thyself.

    Jesus affirms love for one’s neighbor as a command of the law.

  13. Proverbs 25:9

    Debate thy cause with thy neighbour himself; and discover not a secret to another:

    Both direct a person to address a neighbor privately rather than expose the matter to others.

  14. Luke 17:3

    Take heed to yourselves: If thy brother trespass against thee, rebuke him; and if he repent, forgive him.

    A trespassing brother is rebuked and forgiven if he repents.

  15. James 2:8

    If ye fulfil the royal law according to the scripture, Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself, ye do well:

    Both command love of neighbor as the law requires.

  16. Proverbs 28:23

    He that rebuketh a man afterwards shall find more favour than he that flattereth with the tongue.

    Rebuke earns more favor than flattery.

  17. Matthew 5:23-24

    Therefore if thou bring thy gift to the altar, and there rememberest that thy brother hath ought against thee;

    Distinguishes a case where the speaker must first seek reconciliation.

  18. 1 John 3:11-12

    For this is the message that ye heard from the beginning, that we should love one another.

    The command to love one another contrasts with Cain’s failure to love his brother.

  19. Psalms 15:3

    He that backbiteth not with his tongue, nor doeth evil to his neighbour, nor taketh up a reproach against his neighbour.

    The duty to rebuke a neighbor qualifies the ban on evil speech.

  20. Luke 10:29

    But he, willing to justify himself, said unto Jesus, And who is my neighbour?

    The lawyer asks who counts as a neighbor.