AdventAI

Luke 13:2

And Jesus answering said unto them, Suppose ye that these Galilæans were sinners above all the Galilæans, because they suffered such things?

King James Version

Translations

  • American King James Version

    And Jesus answering said to them, Suppose you that these Galilaeans were sinners above all the Galilaeans, because they suffered such things?

  • King James Version

    And Jesus answering said unto them, Suppose ye that these Galilæans were sinners above all the Galilæans, because they suffered such things?

  • KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible

    And Jesus answering said unto them, Suppose ye that these Galileans were sinners above all the Galileans, because they suffered such things?

  • Webster Bible

    And Jesus answering, said to them, Suppose ye that these Galileans were sinners above all the Galileans, because they suffered such things?

  • Revised Version

    And he answered and said unto them, Think ye that these Galilaeans were sinners above all the Galilaeans, because they have suffered these things?

  • American Standard Version

    And he answered and said unto them, Think ye that these Galilæans were sinners above all the Galilæans, because they have suffered these things?

  • Young's Literal Translation

    and Jesus answering said to them, 'Think ye that these Galileans became sinners beyond all the Galileans, because they have suffered such things?

  • Darby Translation

    And he answering said to them, Think ye that these Galileans were sinners beyond all the Galileans because they suffered such things?

  • Rotherham's Emphasised Bible

    And, answering, he said unto them—Suppose ye, that, these Galilaeans, had become, sinners beyond all the Galilaeans, because, these things, they have suffered?

  • Berean Standard Bible

    To this He replied, “ Do you think that these Galileans were worse sinners than all the other Galileans, because they suffered this fate?

  • Majority Standard Bible

    To this Jesus replied, “ Do you think that these Galileans were worse sinners than all the other Galileans, because they suffered this way?

  • World English Bible

    Jesus answered them, “ Do you think that these Galileans were worse sinners than all the other Galileans, because they suffered such things?

  • Bible in Basic English

    And he, in answer, said to them, Are you of the opinion that these Galilaeans were worse than all other Galilaeans, because these things were done to them?

  • Geneva Bible

    And Iesus answered, and saide vnto them, Suppose ye, that these Galileans were greater sinners then al the other Galileans, because they haue suffered such things?

  • Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)

    And he answering, said to them: Think you that these Galileans were sinners above all the men of Galilee, because they suffered such things?

Commentary

Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.

Ellen G. White

10 sources

Jesus was answering people who had just reported the Galileans whom Pilate and his soldiers slew at the altar while they were offering sacrifices.Ms 7, 1897, par. 4COL 212.3Ms 56, 1894, par. 6–7COL 215 Those who brought the report assumed the victims suffered because they were sinners above all other Galileans, deserved it for their wickedness, and were under God's judgment.Ms 7, 1897, par. 43T 87.1–88.3 In doing so they were judging others by outward fortune as proof of their own righteousness.COL 212.3

By asking whether those Galileans were worse sinners than other Galileans, the question challenges and denies that suffering a violent calamity proves greater guilt, is a reliable measure of guilt, or shows the victims were less favored by God.Ms 7, 1897, par. 4Ms 56, 1894, par. 1–2COL 212.3COL 212COL 213.1–3 The calamity is not grounds for condemning the victims, claiming greater favor, or self-congratulation, and judging them as exceptionally guilty is mistaken.COL 212.3COL 213.1–3Ms 56, 1894, par. 6–7 It is a warning to the living to repent, for unless they repent they will all likewise perish, a lesson repeated with the eighteen killed when the tower in Siloam fell.Ms 7, 1897, par. 4COL 212.3COL 213.1–3

The warning of judgment is joined with the invitation of mercy, setting God's justice and judgment together with His mission of mercy, illustrated by the parable of the barren fig tree.COL 212.1 For His mission is not to destroy men's lives but to save them, and God sent His Son not to condemn the world but that the world through Him might be saved.COL 212.1 The verse belongs to the warning of the coming kingdom of God with sharp rebuke of ignorance and indifference, since the people were quick to read signs in the sky foretelling the weather but did not discern the signs of the times that clearly pointed to His mission.COL 212.2

The warning also pointed forward to the destruction of Jerusalem, when unless the people repented and found refuge in Christ they too would perish.COL 213.1–3Ms 56, 1894, par. 6–7 Many Jews would be killed in the temple courts while offering sacrifices as the Galileans had been, leaving them only a brief time to turn to what would bring them peace.COL 213.1–3Ms 56, 1894, par. 6–7 Treating suffering as evidence of special sinfulness adds to the burden of afflicted people, as when the belief was unjustly applied to James White during his sickness.3T 87.1–88.3

Sources

  1. Ms 7, 1897, par. 4 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 12 (1897) — Ms 7, 1897 Ellen G. White, written January 27, 1897
  2. COL 212.3 Christ's Object Lessons — “*Spare It This Year Also*” Ellen G. White, 1900
  3. Ms 56, 1894, par. 6–7 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 9 (1894) — Ms 56, 1894 Ellen G. White, written December 30, 1894
  4. COL 215 Christ's Object Lessons — “*Spare It This Year Also*” Ellen G. White, 1900
  5. 3T 87.1–88.3 Testimonies for the Church Volume Three — THE WORK AT BATTLE CREEK. Ellen G. White, 1875
  6. Ms 56, 1894, par. 1–2 Letters and Manuscripts — Volume 9 (1894) — Ms 56, 1894 Ellen G. White, written December 30, 1894
  7. COL 212 Christ's Object Lessons — “Lost, and Is Found” Ellen G. White, 1900
  8. COL 213.1–3 Christ's Object Lessons — “*Spare It This Year Also*” Ellen G. White, 1900
  9. COL 212.1 Christ's Object Lessons — “*Spare It This Year Also*” Ellen G. White, 1900
  10. COL 212.2 Christ's Object Lessons — “*Spare It This Year Also*” Ellen G. White, 1900

Pioneers and periodicals

28 sources

Jesus answers those who told Him of the Galileans cut down while offering sacrifices, whose blood Pilate mingled with their offerings.ST Feb 16, 1882ST Dec 5, 1895ST Jan 10, 1906 Suffering a violent death, disaster or sudden destruction does not prove its victims were sinners above all others because they suffered such things.RH May 16, 1912ST Jul 9, 1894ST Feb 16, 1882 They were sinners, but their suffering was no evidence of greater guilt, for not every calamity is punishment for a particular sin or proof that its victims were singled out as special objects of wrath.ST Nov 4, 1886ST Aug 20, 1902RH Apr 3, 1913 Their fate warns everyone to repent or likewise perish, for repentance is reformation produced by godly sorrow for sin and is necessary for salvation.ST Jul 9, 1894ST Feb 16, 1882ST Apr 17, 1907RH Apr 8, 1858 Particular calamities must therefore never be used to condemn the sufferers as more guilty, but are permitted to awaken the living from indifference, to teach tenderness and mercy in relieving distress, and to signal the sure approach of destruction upon the world if it fails to turn to God.RH May 16, 1912RH May 20, 1902RH Apr 3, 1913RH Jun 3, 1858

Setting and Plain Meaning

The question concerns Galileans whose blood Pilate mingled with their sacrifices in a massacre, an event recorded in Luke's account and not in the other Gospels.ST Feb 16, 1882ST Dec 5, 1895ST Jan 10, 1906ST Sep 20, 1905 It asks whether those Galileans who were massacred by Pilate were more sinful than other Galileans because they suffered such a violent death.ST Feb 16, 1882ST Dec 5, 1895ST Jan 10, 1906 Their violent deaths did not show that they were greater sinners or more guilty than other Galileans.ST Feb 16, 1882ST Feb 16, 1882RH Dec 10, 1867ST Dec 5, 1895ST Jan 10, 1906

Suffering a violent death, disaster, hardship, or sudden destruction does not prove that its victims were sinners above others because they suffered such things.RH May 16, 1912ST Jul 9, 1894ST Feb 16, 1882ST Feb 16, 1882ST Apr 17, 1907 The Galileans' violent deaths were no measure of their guilt, and people struck by disaster are not thereby shown to be greater sinners than others.RH May 16, 1912ST Jul 9, 1894ST Feb 16, 1882ST Apr 17, 1907RH Dec 10, 1867 The Kingston earthquake, like the Galileans' suffering, does not prove its victims were more wicked than people elsewhere, for sin is found everywhere.RH May 16, 1912ST Jul 9, 1894ST Apr 17, 1907 Such calamities warn the whole earth to repent, and their fate instead warns everyone to repent or perish likewise.ST Jul 9, 1894ST Feb 16, 1882ST Apr 17, 1907RH Dec 10, 1867

The victims were not said to be sinless, for they were sinners, but their suffering was no evidence of greater guilt than other Galileans who suffered no such harm.ST Nov 4, 1886ST Aug 20, 1902ST Jul 9, 1894 Not every calamity is punishment for a particular sin, and a calamity should not be treated as proof that its victims were singled out for God's judgment.ST Nov 4, 1886RH Apr 3, 1913ST Jul 9, 1894ST Apr 15, 1913 Calamity does not prove that the places that suffer are special objects of Heaven's wrath or are especially singled out, and people in places visited by storm and earthquake are not worse sinners than others.ST Nov 4, 1886RH Apr 3, 1913ST Apr 15, 1913 Bodily affliction can sometimes result directly from personal or parental sin, yet suffering unusually does not make suffering proof of greater guilt.ST Mar 8, 1905

The massacre and the fall of the tower at Siloam were treated as warnings of a coming calamity and destruction upon the nation if it rejected light and failed to turn to God.ST Feb 16, 1882ST Jan 10, 1906 Jesus used the deaths of the Galileans and the men killed by the tower of Siloam to warn that unless the people repented they too would perish.ST Feb 16, 1882RH Dec 10, 1867ST Jan 10, 1906 He treated those events not as grounds for revenge or revolt.ST Feb 16, 1882 The circumstances led Jesus to tell the parable of the unfruitful tree, connecting barrenness with sin and fruitfulness with righteousness.ST Dec 25, 1901 Delight in God's law and life-giving work produces fruit, and God's people are expected to bear fruit rather than merely live for themselves.ST Dec 25, 1901 The verse stands among increasingly solemn warnings, which call people to seek God's kingdom and righteousness rather than condemn them.ST Feb 10, 1898

Repentance and Coming Destruction

The violent deaths of the Galileans did not prove they were worse sinners than other Galileans, but warned everyone that without repentance all would perish likewise.ST Jul 9, 1894ST Feb 16, 1882ST Apr 17, 1907RH Dec 10, 1867ST Jun 27, 1906 The massacre and the fall of the tower at Siloam were treated as warnings of a coming calamity upon the nation, not as grounds for revenge or revolt.ST Feb 16, 1882ST Jan 10, 1906 The Kingston earthquake and the San Francisco disaster likewise did not prove their victims more wicked than people elsewhere, for sin is found everywhere, and such calamity is the consequence of widespread wickedness and of the effects of violated law allowed to unfold.ST Apr 17, 1907ST Jun 27, 1906 The lesson is universal, illustrating the doom of all who fail to repent and heed the warning.ST Jul 9, 1894ST Feb 16, 1882ST Apr 17, 1907RH Dec 10, 1867

To perish in this warning carries its ordinary sense of literal death and destruction, not endless torment.RH Dec 9, 1858ST Dec 5, 1895 As to perish in flames means to be burned to death, to perish in water means to be drowned, and to perish with cold means to be frozen to death, so without repentance all will likewise perish and the wicked will ultimately die rather than live forever and be utterly extinct.RH Dec 9, 1858ST Dec 5, 1895 Repentance is necessary for salvation and means reformation produced by godly sorrow for sin rather than sorrow or remorse alone.RH Apr 8, 1858RH Dec 5, 1854 Since repentance is the opposite of sin, which is transgression of God's law, the call to repent teaches observance of the law.

Suffering sudden destruction does not mean its victims were sinners above all others because they suffered such things.RH May 20, 1902RH Apr 3, 1913ST Jan 10, 1906 The volcanic fire that blotted out St. Pierre did not show its inhabitants wicked above all others on the earth, yet a destruction like that which fell on St. Pierre awaits the whole world at no distant date when God punishes the inhabitants of the earth for iniquity.RH May 20, 1902 These calamities warned of the destruction that would come upon the nation if it rejected light and failed to turn to God.ST Feb 16, 1882ST Jan 10, 1906 Disasters are to be read as signs of the sure approach of the day of God.RH Apr 3, 1913

Calamity does not prove that the places that suffer are special objects of Heaven's wrath, for the sufferers are neighbors and friends.RH Apr 3, 1913ST Apr 15, 1913 The lesson of disaster is for those who live, for once dead the sufferers are beyond its reach.RH Apr 3, 1913ST Apr 15, 1913 The living must awake from indifference and carnal security and sound the warning to a world in wickedness while probation still lingers.RH Apr 3, 1913 Such visitations are permitted not to destroy life but to save life, warning everyone else to give heed and to become more tender and sympathetic, opening hearts and giving means to relieve distress.RH Apr 3, 1913ST Apr 15, 1913

Disasters Forbid Judgment, Demand Mercy

Particular calamities must not be used to judge those who suffer them, nor to claim that disaster came upon them as special punishment for their sins, for suffering does not prove its victims were greater sinners than others.RH May 16, 1912RH Jun 3, 1858RH Jun 27, 1907RH Feb 15, 1870 Affliction gives no warrant for condemning sufferers as more guilty, and those who so judge them may themselves face severe trials.RH Jun 3, 1858 The suffering of a calamity does not mean the sufferer was more sinful or more careless than others.RH Jun 27, 1907

Those who judge should instead offer encouragement rather than deepen the despair of the afflicted.RH Jun 3, 1858 Those left uninjured must learn from such visitations and become more tender and sympathetic, opening their hearts and giving of their means to relieve the distress of the sufferers.RH Jun 3, 1858ST Apr 15, 1913 Such visitations are permitted not to destroy life but to save life, as warnings to everyone else to give heed.ST Apr 15, 1913 Affliction shared can give understanding of others' hardships and enable truthful witness to their work.RH Jun 27, 1907

The Kingston earthquake does not prove its victims were more wicked than people elsewhere, for sin is found everywhere, and like the suffering of the Galileans it warns the whole earth to repent lest those who do not repent likewise perish.ST Apr 17, 1907 San Francisco's disaster does not prove its victims were more sinful than others, but is the consequence of widespread wickedness and of the effects of violated law allowed to unfold, with the same lesson that all must repent or perish.ST Jun 27, 1906 Sudden destruction does not mean its victims were sinners above all others because they suffered such things, so the volcanic fire that blotted out St. Pierre does not mean its inhabitants were wicked above all others on the earth.RH May 20, 1902 Storm and earthquake do not show that people in the places visited are worse sinners than others or are especially singled out, but such calamities affect every part of the world.RH Jul 18, 1912ST Apr 15, 1913

Financial troubles that followed wrong decisions to buy land beyond means do not make the sufferers sinners above all others.RH Jun 24, 1858 The warning in such hardship is for the whole people to repent of love of the world and covetousness, lest they too face rebuke.RH Jun 24, 1858 Reproof of selfishness, neglect, and wrongs in the church does not mark its members as sinners above all other professed Christians, but faithfully points out the wrongs done so that more watchfulness may be practiced and such errors avoided in the future.RH Feb 15, 1870 Applied to dress, the question whether sufferers are more sinful than others leaves uncertain whether the people of one place as a body are more at fault than people elsewhere.RH Sep 5, 1871

Destructive calamities can serve as a warning that turns people to the Lord.RH Jul 18, 1912

Sources

  1. ST Feb 16, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 7 — The Sabbath-School February 16, 1882
  2. ST Dec 5, 1895 Signs of the Times, Vol. 21, No. 48 — The Law and Judgment Ellet Joseph Waggoner, December 5, 1895
  3. ST Jan 10, 1906 Signs of the Times, Vol. 32, No. 2 — The Deluge W. E. Videto, January 10, 1906
  4. RH May 16, 1912 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 89, No. 20 — Disasters by Land and Sea F. M. W., May 16, 1912
  5. ST Jul 9, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 35 — LESSON III.—SABBATH, JULY 21, 1894 Monday, July 9, 1894
  6. ST Nov 4, 1886 Signs of the Times, Vol. 12, No. 42 — The Voice of God N. Y. Observer, November 4, 1886
  7. ST Aug 20, 1902 Signs of the Times, Vol. 28, No. 34 — THE VOLCANIC VISITATION W. A. Sweany, August 20, 1902
  8. RH Apr 3, 1913 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 90, No. 14 — The Portent of the Times April 3, 1913
  9. ST Feb 16, 1882 Signs of the Times, Vol. 8, No. 7 — The Sabbath-School February 16, 1882
  10. ST Apr 17, 1907 Signs of the Times, Vol. 33, No. 16 — THE KINGSTON EARTHQUAKE April 17, 1907
  11. RH Apr 8, 1858 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 11, No. 21 — CONDITIONS OF SALVATION. No. 4. M. E. S., April 8, 1858
  12. RH May 20, 1902 Review and Herald, Vol. 79, No. 20 — Sudden Destruction L. A. S., May 20, 1902
  13. RH Jun 3, 1858 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 12, No. 3 — Comfort in Sorrow June 3, 1858
  14. ST Sep 20, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 38 — SEARCH THE SCRIPTURES F. D. Starr, September 20, 1905
  15. RH Dec 10, 1867 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 30, No. 26 — EXPERIENCE Elder Joseph Bates, Third-day, December 10, 1867
  16. ST Jul 9, 1894 Signs of the Times, Vol. 20, No. 35 — LESSON III.—SABBATH, JULY 21, 1894 Monday, July 9, 1894
  17. ST Apr 15, 1913 Signs of the Times, Vol. 40, No. 15 — The Toll of the Big Tornado T., April 15, 1913
  18. ST Mar 8, 1905 Signs of the Times, Vol. 31, No. 10 — LESSON 12.—MARCH 19.—HEALING OF THE MAN BORN BLIND March 8, 1905
  19. ST Dec 25, 1901 Signs of the Times, Vol. 27, No. 52 — LESSON 1.—JANUARY 4.—THE BARREN FIG TREE December 25, 1901
  20. ST Feb 10, 1898 Signs of the Times, Vol. 24, No. 6 — Lesson IX.—Sunday, February 27, 1898 February 10, 1898
  21. ST Jun 27, 1906 Signs of the Times, Vol. 32, No. 25 — The Queen City of the West in Sackcloth and Ashes June 27, 1906
  22. RH Dec 9, 1858 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 13, No. 3 — THE DESTINY OF THE WICKED: M. Hull, December 9, 1858
  23. RH Dec 5, 1854 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 6, No. 16 — THE ATONEMENT J. M. Stephenson, December 5, 1854
  24. RH Jun 27, 1907 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 84, No. 26 — Solusi Mission and Experience with African Fever G. A. Irwin, June 27, 1907
  25. RH Feb 15, 1870 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 35, Nos. 8 & 9 — The Articles of Eld. T. M. Preble John Nevins Andrews; John Harvey Waggoner, February 15, 1870
  26. RH Jul 18, 1912 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 89, No. 29 — Alberta (Canada) Camp-Meeting G. B. Thompson, July 18, 1912
  27. RH Jun 24, 1858 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 12, No. 6 — TENT MEETING IN ILLINOIS James White, June 24, 1858
  28. RH Sep 5, 1871 The Advent Review and Sabbath Herald, Vol. 38, No. 12 — A True Picture Editor, Third-day, September 5, 1871

Cross-references

  1. John 9:2

    And his disciples asked him, saying, Master, who did sin, this man, or his parents, that he was born blind?

    Jesus rejects linking affliction to greater sin.

  2. Job 4:7-8

    Remember, I pray thee, who ever perished, being innocent? or where were the righteous cut off?

    Job’s friends reflect the belief that affliction follows sin.

  3. Luke 13:6-9

    He spake also this parable; A certain man had a fig tree planted in his vineyard; and he came and sought fruit thereon, and found none.

    The fig tree continues the warning of judgment and the need to bear fruit before the delay ends.