Luke 16:28
For I have five brethren; that he may testify unto them, lest they also come into this place of torment.
Translations
For I have five brothers; that he may testify to them, lest they also come into this place of torment.
For I have five brethren; that he may testify unto them, lest they also come into this place of torment.
KJV Cambridge Paragraph Bible, Revised Version, American Standard Version
for I have five brethren; that he may testify unto them, lest they also come into this place of torment.
For I have five brethren; that he may testify to them, lest they also come into this place of torment.
for I have five brothers, so that he may thoroughly testify to them, that they also may not come to this place of torment.
for I have five brothers, so that he may earnestly testify to them, that they also may not come to this place of torment.
for I have five brethren;—that he may solemnly testify unto them, lest, they also, come into this place of torment.
Berean Standard Bible, Majority Standard Bible
for I have five brothers. Let him warn them, so that they will not also end up in this place of torment.’
for I have five brothers— that he may testify to them, so they won’ t also come into this place of torment.’
For I have five brothers; and let him give them an account of these things, so that they may not come to this place of pain.
(For I haue fiue brethren) that he may testifie vnto them, least they also come into this place of torment.
Douay-Rheims (Challoner revision)
That he may testify unto them, lest they also come into this place of torments.
Cross-references
- Luke 16:19-21
There was a certain rich man, which was clothed in purple and fine linen, and fared sumptuously every day:
The rich man’s luxury contrasts with Lazarus’s poverty and suffering.
- Luke 16:24
And he cried and said, Father Abraham, have mercy on me, and send Lazarus, that he may dip the tip of his finger in water, and cool my tongue; for I am tormented in this flame.
The rich man describes his torment in flame.
- Luke 16:1-9
And he said also unto his disciples, There was a certain rich man, which had a steward; and the same was accused unto him that he had wasted his goods.
The steward’s parable urges wise use of wealth in preparation for God’s kingdom.
- John 12:10-11
But the chief priests consulted that they might put Lazarus also to death;
Leaders rejected Lazarus’s resurrection as evidence, while many believed on Jesus.
- John 11:43-44
And when he thus had spoken, he cried with a loud voice, Lazarus, come forth.
Lazarus’s return from the grave was a living witness to Christ’s power.
- Luke 16:23
And in hell he lift up his eyes, being in torments, and seeth Abraham afar off, and Lazarus in his bosom.
The dead are depicted as conscious in torment, with Abraham and Lazarus nearby.
- Luke 15
Then drew near unto him all the publicans and sinners for to hear him.
The preceding parables set the discourse’s context.
- Matthew 25:46
And these shall go away into everlasting punishment: but the righteous into life eternal.
Both describe the wicked facing everlasting punishment.
- Luke 13:28
There shall be weeping and gnashing of teeth, when ye shall see Abraham, and Isaac, and Jacob, and all the prophets, in the kingdom of God, and you yourselves thrust out.
The wicked see the patriarchs in the kingdom after being shut out.
- Luke 16:19
There was a certain rich man, which was clothed in purple and fine linen, and fared sumptuously every day:
The rich man wore purple and fine linen.
- Luke 16:22
And it came to pass, that the beggar died, and was carried by the angels into Abraham’s bosom: the rich man also died, and was buried;
Angels carry the dead into Abraham’s bosom.
- Isaiah 5:14
Therefore hell hath enlarged herself, and opened her mouth without measure: and their glory, and their multitude, and their pomp, and he that rejoiceth, shall descend into it.
Sheol opens beneath to receive those descending into it.
- Isaiah 14:9-10
Hell from beneath is moved for thee to meet thee at thy coming: it stirreth up the dead for thee, even all the chief ones of the earth; it hath raised up from their thrones all the kings of the nations.
The dead in Hades are portrayed as speaking.
- Mark 9:43-47
And if thy hand offend thee, cut it off: it is better for thee to enter into life maimed, than having two hands to go into hell, into the fire that never shall be quenched:
Gehenna is distinguished from the Hades where the rich man is represented.
- John 5:29
And shall come forth; they that have done good, unto the resurrection of life; and they that have done evil, unto the resurrection of damnation.
The rich man awaits resurrection to damnation.
- Matthew 10:28
And fear not them which kill the body, but are not able to kill the soul: but rather fear him which is able to destroy both soul and body in hell.
Both describe punishment in Gehenna involving the whole person.
- Revelation 20:14
And death and hell were cast into the lake of fire. This is the second death.
Identifies the lake of fire as the second death.
Commentary
Each commentary is drawn from primary sources: the writings of Ellen G. White and Adventist pioneers and periodicals. Each commentary is separate. Its own words are not a quotation; follow the references to read the source passages.
Ellen G. White
38 sources
The verse records the rich man in torment pleading for Lazarus to be sent to his father's house to warn his five brothers who are living for self-pleasure as he had, so they will not come to that place of suffering.Ms 81, 1898, par. 18–19Ms 45, 1897, par. 3–4COL 264.1 The dialogue is figurative, framed around the hearers' belief in conscious existence between death and resurrection to teach about stewardship.Ms 6, 1899, par. 15–21ST Jun 1, 1915ST Jun 1, 1915 Eternal destiny is fixed in this life while grace is offered, and wasting probation in self-pleasing leaves an impassable gulf that the dead cannot choose or change.COL 260.1ST Jun 1, 1915Ms 81, 1898, par. 34–36 The brothers are already sufficiently warned by Moses and the prophets, and those who refuse that word will not be persuaded even by a messenger raised from the dead.Ms 6, 1899, par. 15–21Ms 81, 1898, par. 18–19Ms 45, 1897, par. 3–4ST Jun 1, 1915 The rich man is condemned not for possessing riches but for unfaithful stewardship in spending entrusted means on himself instead of relieving the needy at his gate.COL 259.1–2COL 261.2COL 266.1ST Jun 25, 1894Ms 6, 1899, par. 22–24
Plea in Its Setting
The verse records the rich man in the place of torment asking that Lazarus be sent to his father's house to warn his five brothers so they will not also come to that place of suffering.Ms 81, 1898, par. 18–19Ms 45, 1897, par. 3–4COL 264.1 He realizes too late the folly of a life spent pleasing himself with no provision made for eternity, and in that lost condition he thinks of his five brothers still in his father's house who are going on as he had gone, living to please themselves.Ms 6, 1899, par. 15–21COL 264.1 The plea turns on heeding Moses and the prophets, for even a messenger risen from the dead will not persuade those who refuse their testimony.Ms 6, 1899, par. 15–21Ms 81, 1898, par. 18–19Ms 45, 1897, par. 3–4 That refusal is illustrated by the priests' rejection of the evidence of Lazarus, who had been raised after four days in the grave, showing that a miraculous sign does not produce belief in hearts set against the truth.Ms 45, 1897, par. 3–4 The rich man in this represents people who enjoy abundant temporal and spiritual blessings but use them selfishly, and the Jewish nation which had been entrusted with sacred truth and grace yet exalted itself and refused Christ whom God sent to warn them.Ms 81, 1898, par. 18–19
The conversation about sending the warning is figurative, with Christ shaping the story around his hearers' belief in conscious existence between death and the resurrection in order to teach about stewardship.Ms 6, 1899, par. 15–21ST Jun 1, 1915ST Jun 1, 1915 Possessions are lent by God, and misusing them can place a rich person below a poor, afflicted person who loves and trusts God.ST Jun 1, 1915 The request reflects as though the brothers had not been sufficiently warned, but they already have enough light and grace in Moses and the prophets for the duties required.Ms 6, 1899, par. 15–21ST Jun 1, 1915 Each person is given sufficient light and grace for the duties required, and greater evidence will not persuade those who reject the light already given.ST Jun 1, 1915 The rich man's plea also represents the Jewish nation's disregard of the light and instruction it had received, including its duty to help the poor and suffering.Ms 6, 1899, par. 15–21
The rich man was a Jewish steward who knew God's command to love the Lord with all heart, soul, and might and to love his neighbor as himself.COL 261.4 God had made him a steward of means, knowledge, talents, and capabilities to uplift humanity and to attend to just such a case as the beggar, and his abundance increased his obligation.COL 261.4 He forgot his accountability, used God's abundant blessings selfishly to honor himself, lent money and took interest but returned no interest to God for what God had lent him, and left knowledge and talents unimproved.COL 261.4Ms 81, 1898, par. 6 He devoted all his powers to pleasure, gave himself to amusements and the praise and flattery of friends, was surrounded by pleasure and praise while forgetting God and neglecting the Word he knew, and failed to remember that he would answer to God for them.COL 261.4Ms 81, 1898, par. 6 He lost all sense of responsibility to cooperate with God in mercy, and let pleasure-loving society crowd out understanding and practice of God's word.COL 261.4
After death his probation has ended and he is reduced to hopeless poverty and nakedness without the robe of Christ's righteousness to cover him.ST Jun 1, 1915COL 267.1 In life he had all that money could procure but did not possess the riches that keep the account right with God, living as if all he possessed were his own and neglecting the call of God and the claims of the suffering poor, rich in this world's goods but not rich toward God, so that earthly wealth could not save him.ST Jun 1, 1915COL 267.1 By a power he cannot question or resist he is commanded to quit the premises of which he is no longer steward, for he brought nothing into the world and can take nothing out of it.ST Jun 1, 1915 His torment is held up before priests and rulers, scribes and Pharisees, and all in the same condition, to contemplate that what is highly esteemed among men is abhorrent in the sight of God, and that it profits a man nothing to gain the whole world and lose his own soul.ST Jun 1, 1915
During sickness he had learned what suffering meant and remembered his heartless treatment of Lazarus, yet he had no knowledge of God.Ms 22, 1898, par. 27 Selfish pleasure and enjoyment do not bring true happiness, for he had a duty to use his abundance to help Lazarus but instead lived luxuriously.ST Jun 21, 1899Ms 22, 1898, par. 31 When suffering came, he longed for relief and called on Lazarus for it, and would have given everything to exchange places with Lazarus, who had been poor and covered with sores.ST Jun 21, 1899Ms 22, 1898, par. 31 The fixed gulf between them shows that their positions could not be changed.ST Jun 21, 1899
Probation Closed, Warning Sufficient
The verse belongs to a parable showing that eternal destiny is decided in this life while grace is offered and opportunity to choose remains.COL 260.1ST Jun 1, 1915COL 269.3 Wasting that probation in self-pleasing cuts a person off from everlasting life, and no further probation after death is granted.COL 260.1ST Jun 1, 1915 The impassable gulf is fixed by character formed in life, a gulf of disobedience that the dead have no power to choose or change.COL 260.1Ms 81, 1898, par. 34–36COL 269.3 When awakened they rise with the same appetites and passions cherished in life, for God does not remake the person who refused opportunities to be remade, and a life taking no pleasure in God forms a chasm nothing can bridge.Ms 81, 1898, par. 34–36
The parable contrasts the rich who do not depend on God with the poor who trust Him and patiently endure suffering.COL 260.2–3 Earthly riches and hardship do not determine final condition, for Dives tormented after death while Lazarus is comforted shows positions reversed.COL 260.2–3STBk 158.1STA 154.1 Wealth and human honor do not determine worth before God, who values true faith and moral worth.1T 539.2–540.1 Thus Lazarus though poor and despised is welcomed into the company of holy angels, while the wealthy man lacking moral soundness is rejected, and those who trust God will be exalted above those of high worldly status who have not surrendered to Him.COL 260.2–31T 539.2–540.1
The request to send a miraculous warning to the five brothers treats them as though not sufficiently warned, but they already have enough light and grace in Moses and the prophets for the duties required of them.Ms 6, 1899, par. 15–21ST Jun 1, 1915ST Jun 1, 1915 Each person is given sufficient light, and greater evidence will not persuade those who reject the light already given and refuse to receive it.ST Jun 1, 1915 Those unwilling to hear and do God's will, who refuse that word and its testimony, will not be persuaded even by a messenger raised from the dead.Ms 6, 1899, par. 15–21Ms 81, 1898, par. 18–19Ms 81, 1898, par. 28–32 A miraculous sign does not produce belief in hearts set against the truth, as illustrated by the priests' rejection of the evidence of Lazarus who had been raised after four days in the grave.Ms 45, 1897, par. 3–4
The rich man's plea also represents the Jewish nation, which had great spiritual and temporal privileges and gifts to bless and enlighten the world.Ms 81, 1898, par. 18–19COL 269.1 Entrusted with sacred truth and grace and with light and instruction including duty to help the poor and suffering, it kept God's gifts selfishly for itself, exalted itself, neglected eternity, and failed to let its light shine to help people in need.Ms 6, 1899, par. 15–21Ms 81, 1898, par. 18–19COL 269.1COL 267.3 It disregarded what it had received and refused Christ whom God sent to warn them.Ms 6, 1899, par. 15–21Ms 81, 1898, par. 18–19 Thereby it brought ruin upon itself, a warning its hearers remembered when Jerusalem was destroyed and its people suffered starvation and other calamities.COL 269.2
Stewardship and Call to Help
Being rich is no sin when riches are not gained by injustice, and the rich man is not condemned for having riches.COL 266.1Ms 6, 1899, par. 22–24 Condemnation rests on spending entrusted means in selfishness, hoarding treasure for self and forgetting obligation to God.COL 266.1Ms 6, 1899, par. 22–24 Such hoarding proves unfaithful stewardship, leaves nothing of lasting value, and cannot be taken to heaven, though the possessor had his good things in this lifetime.COL 266.1Ms 6, 1899, par. 22–24 By using money to do good he would lay it up beside the throne of God and devote himself to seeking eternal riches that death cannot take away, and faithful service and good deeds done to lead people to Christ are lasting heavenly riches.COL 266.1Ms 6, 1899, par. 22–24
Living for self and covetousness lead to loss of life, as the parable of the rich man and Lazarus warns.COL 259.1–2Lt 207, 1899, par. 7Lt 21, 1898, par. 4–514MR 57.3 The wealthy man had been entrusted with means and blessings but used them for himself and for sumptuous self-gratification instead of helping the beggar at his gate, misusing what was entrusted to him and neglecting Lazarus.Lt 207, 1899, par. 7Lt 21, 1898, par. 4–514MR 57.3 Those who spend God's resources on selfish gratification instead of God's work are accountable stewards and will face a reckoning.Lt 207, 1899, par. 7Lt 21, 1898, par. 4–5 God blesses and commends the suffering faithful, represented by Lazarus, while dealing with those who spend on self what they should share with the poor.Lt 207, 1899, par. 714MR 57.3
The needy are entrusted to the wealthy for help and sympathy, and Lazarus left in great need while a wealthy man who could have helped him lived for himself shows that indifference to their suffering is a grave failure of that responsibility.COL 261.2ST Jun 25, 1894 The duty therefore is to share food and clothing and to provide shelter for the poor.COL 261.2ST Jun 25, 1894 The same picture belongs to large cities where multitudes are destitute of food, clothing and shelter fit for a human being while men of wealth live luxuriously and spend on richly furnished houses, personal ornament and gratification of sensual appetites, tobacco, liquors and other things that destroy the brain, unbalance the mind and debase the soul.STMW7 56.2ST Jun 6, 1900 Means were given to honor the Creator by blessing the world, and to turn them to selfish indulgence is unfaithful stewardship, dishonor to God and neglect of His heritage, while all heaven looks down and God and angels mark the course of those who so indulge themselves.STMW7 56.2ST Jun 6, 1900Ms 87, 1898, par. 26–29
Dives enjoyed the good things of this life while making no right use of what God gave him to carry out God's purposes.ST Jun 6, 1900Ms 87, 1898, par. 26–29 The right use is to lift up a standard against the ruin Satan is working and to be human channels through which Christ communicates His pitying tenderness and His treasures of food and clothing and words fitly spoken to wretched, fallen, hopeless beings, restoring the moral image of God in man.STMW7 56.2Ms 87, 1898, par. 26–29 Those who claim to be sons and daughters of God are not at liberty to live like Dives and leave that work undone.STMW7 56.2Ms 87, 1898, par. 26–29 Lazarus full of sores lying at the gate of Dives portrays the colored people of the South in their need of moral uplifting, education and higher home life, lying at the gate of the white Christian race.SBAWP 49.1–2 Dives is the white race, on whom rests heavy responsibility to bend part of its energies to lifting them, for seeking supremacy as an end in itself and overriding justice causes loss of what is sought, while trying honestly and justly to uplift this people uplifts those who do it, and woe will come if the warning is not heeded.SBAWP 49.1–2
Sources
Pioneers and periodicals
136 sources
The verse is the rich man's plea for Abraham to send Lazarus to warn his five brothers so they will not come to the place of torment, showing urgent concern that they face the same danger.RH May 24, 1870ST Nov 11, 1886RH May 5, 1874 It is his second request in Hades after his plea for relief from his suffering is denied, and it also is refused.ST Jun 23, 1881RH Mar 28, 1865RH Mar 28, 1865 The account is a parable using figurative speech to teach a spiritual and moral lesson, not a literal history of conscious dead speaking to one another.RH Jan 7, 1902ST Mar 28, 1906 The dead are unconscious in death, knowing nothing until the resurrection, and torment and comfort come in the future after resurrection and judgment, with each person's destiny fixed in this life and no second probation after death.RH May 5, 1874RH Mar 4, 1862ST Mar 28, 1906ST Mar 30, 1882RH Oct 31, 1865 Moses and the prophets already give sufficient warning, and those who refuse them will not be persuaded even if someone rises from the dead, while the rich man stands for the self-righteous Jews trusting privilege and riches and Lazarus for the humble who received Christ.RH May 24, 1870ST Nov 11, 1886ST Oct 1, 1894ST Oct 1, 1894ST
Words and Narrative Setting
The verse records the rich man asking Abraham to send Lazarus to testify to and warn his five brothers so that they will not come to the place of torment, showing urgent concern that they face the same danger.RH May 24, 1870ST Nov 11, 1886RH May 5, 1874ST Oct 1, 1894ST Mar 15, 1877 The request is refused because Moses and the prophets already give sufficient testimony and warning, and those who will not hear them will not be persuaded even if someone rises from the dead.RH May 24, 1870ST Nov 11, 1886RH May 5, 1874ST Oct 1, 1894ST Mar 15, 1877 The scene presents the dead as speaking and acting in a way that represents the facts of their lives and deaths, rather than as literally conversing in Hades.RH May 5, 1874ST Mar 15, 1877ST Oct 14, 1913 The plea for the brothers is the rich man's second request in Hades, or Sheol, after his plea that Lazarus cool his tongue is denied, and it also is refused.ST Jun 23, 1881RH Mar 28, 1865RH Mar 28, 1865 Lazarus could warn the brothers only by being raised from among the dead men, not by a disembodied spirit descending from heaven.RH Mar 28, 1865RH Mar 28, 1865
The rich man who speaks in the verse is given no personal name in the Bible.RH Jan 30, 1879ST Mar 30, 1882 Dives is not his name but the Latin word meaning rich or a rich man, corresponding to the Greek plousios used to describe him.RH Jan 30, 1879ST Mar 30, 1882 Latin versions use dives to describe the man who was rich, and the Latin title Dives et Lazarus on old pictures of the subject led uneducated persons to suppose the first word was the rich man's name, as the last word truly was the beggar's name.RH Jan 30, 1879 Calling the rich man Plousios would be just as proper as calling him Dives.RH Jan 30, 1879
The word for torment in the verse is basanos, whose primary sense is testing or trial, originally by a touchstone and also by examination, with torture as a derived sense rather than an essential part of the word.ST Aug 14, 1893 In the account basanos in verses 23 and 28 is distinguished from oduno in verses 24 and 25, which denotes anguish or pain.ST Aug 14, 1893 The verse therefore carries the idea of testing or trial rather than simply proving unending torment or everlasting misery of the dead.ST Aug 14, 1893
The place of torment is Hades, identical with Old Testament Sheol in the nether parts of the earth embracing every grave, described as darkness and silence, without knowledge, memory, wisdom, work, or device, and as secrecy, sleep, rest, corruption and worms with no remembrance, thanks, or conversation.RH May 5, 1874RH Mar 28, 1865 The asking does not happen literally, because the wicked are silent in death and cannot converse or devise plans, so the dead man is personified and made to speak and act as though alive, in the same way Rachel, Pharaoh, and the king of Babylon are personified.RH Mar 28, 1865RH Mar 28, 1865 Some readings identify the place of torment as a distinct description of hell with Gehenna and the final punishment of sinners, or with the bottomless pit or the lake of fire on the last day.RH Oct 31, 1865 The account places the rich man in torment speaking across the gulf to Abraham, close enough to converse, which is used to raise how those in Hades could see and converse across the gulf, whether Paradise where Abraham is must be within Hades, and whether the righteous dead could be watching suffering while waiting for judgment.RH Jul 18, 1865ST Sep 2, 1880RH Apr 20, 1869 Taken in that literal way, the place of torment lies in the same vast underground cavern as the abode of the righteous dead, divided only by a gulf, with continually burning flames and scenes of torture perpetually in sight of the blessed, so that Adam, Enoch, Noah, Abraham and others stayed confined in that dismal sepulchral prison for the thousands of years from creation to the cross beholding suffering, which destroys all real felicity and contradicts the character of God seen in the stars, the sunshine, the flowers, the groves and the beautiful vistas of this world.ST Sep 2, 1880
A great fixed gulf separates the rich man from Lazarus so that their positions cannot be changed, and those who waste opportunity in self-pleasing cut themselves off from everlasting life with no further probation granted.ST Jun 21, 1899ST Jun 1, 1915ST Sep 1, 1881 The rich man had good things during this life while Lazarus had evil things, and their conditions are reversed at the final reckoning when judgment is settled.ST Jun 21, 1899ST Sep 1, 1881ST Oct 28, 1889 The request that the rich man's brothers be warned supports the point that the wicked cannot cross that barrier afterward.ST Jun 1, 1915ST Sep 1, 1881
Literary Form and Method
The account is a parable, apologue, allegory or fictional story using figurative speech to teach a spiritual and moral lesson, not a literal history or report of events that actually occurred.RH Jan 7, 1902ST Mar 28, 1906STST Dec 4, 1884 Its figures serve as object lessons to teach spiritual truth and illustrate conditions and attitudes toward God, and it was not intended to teach the condition of the dead or the final reward of the righteous and the wicked nor to establish that the dead are conscious.RH Jan 7, 1902ST Mar 28, 1906STST Dec 4, 1884ST Feb 26, 1902 The reference to five brothers shows urgent concern that they be warned so they will not share torment, yet the opening contrasts this scene with biblical statements that the dead know nothing and their thoughts and feelings perish.ST Mar 28, 1906ST Feb 26, 1902 Understood in harmony with Scripture's declarations about death and resurrection, it should not be used as literal proof that the dead remain conscious or as a literal description of conscious existence after death.RH Jan 7, 1902ST Feb 26, 1902
The parable takes ideas about Hades already resting in Jewish and Pharisaic minds, including flame, torment, Abraham's bosom, angels conveying souls, and the gulf, and uses them for argument without correcting or endorsing them as true.RH Feb 8, 1912ST Sep 16, 1880ST Dec 25, 1901ST Nov 3, 1881ST Sep 16, 1880 It is an argument to the man from premises the hearers admitted, which is honorable and legitimate in debate, Christ assuming the standpoint and belief of those addressed and proving his point from a belief taken from the heathen without declaring that belief true.RH Feb 8, 1912ST Sep 16, 1880ST Nov 3, 1881 Connected with a series of parables spoken to the Jews whose favored way of learning was by parables, it was spoken to covetous Pharisees right after reproving them for covetousness.RH Feb 8, 1912ST Dec 25, 1901 It strikes at covetousness and at the belief that sickness, poverty or suffering proves God has forsaken a person or is displeased with him, teaching that a man's life in this world decides his life beyond, that this life is probation and the life beyond is retribution and reward, and that a poor suffering person may be esteemed in heaven while one living in luxury may be under divine wrath.RH Feb 8, 1912ST Nov 3, 1881ST Sep 16, 1880 The request for the five brethren is thus an appeal to the rich and selfish to make every effort to save the perishing, and an unexplained parable with dead men made to speak cannot establish doctrine about separate apartments for the happy and tormented, since dead men do not actually converse.RH Feb 8, 1912ST Jun 30, 1881
Taken literally the scene makes nonsense, for bodily eyes, tongue, finger and speech are given to the dead whose bodies are in the grave, conflicting with disembodied souls and showing the scene is not a literal description of the dead immediately receiving reward.ST Jul 15, 1913ST Nov 3, 1881RH Dec 12, 1854RH Jan 7, 1902 Treating the characters as real persons who actually went to the places named makes those places matters of fact and part of the structure of the world.ST Sep 2, 1880 It would require belief that God constructed in the bowels of the earth an immense sunless cavern with but one entrance to serve as prison-house for souls of both good and bad during the four thousand years from creation to the cross.ST Sep 2, 1880 That would place the place of torment in the same vast underground cavern as the abode of the righteous dead, divided only by a gulf, with continually burning flames and torture perpetually in sight of the blessed.ST Sep 2, 1880 It would mean Adam, Enoch, Noah, Abraham and others stayed confined in that dismal sepulchral prison for long ages, year in and year out and century in and century out beholding suffering that would chill mortal blood with sympathy, destroying all real felicity and contradicting the character of God seen in stars, sunshine, flowers, groves and beautiful vistas, who would have prepared some better thing for the faithful.ST Sep 2, 1880 Taken literally it would also depict a buried dead man speaking after burial across a literal impassable gulf, and if the spirit were part of God it would place God in hell subject to damnation.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 29, 1863
Unexplained metaphorical language cannot establish doctrine, for no parable teaches doctrine but only illustrates what plain Scripture teaches.ST Mar 16, 1876RH Sep 15, 1859ST Mar 3, 1909STST Oct 1, 1894 The imagery of a place of torment is allegory and metaphor and cannot be used as pointed and express evidence to establish doctrine concerning eternal salvation or the immortality of the soul, nor as proof that such an event actually occurred or could occur.ST Mar 16, 1876RH Sep 15, 1859ST Mar 3, 1909ST Oct 1, 1894 At most the plea for the five brethren shows what the persons would say if able to speak, and it is not a representation of conditions after death but part of a parable common among the Jews used to illustrate different attitudes toward Christ.ST Nothing in it is to be used against the plain Bible teaching of the unconscious state of the dead, and to take its details as literal makes God's dealings ridiculous and cruel; its scene of asking that the brothers be warned conveys a lesson and does not teach that Lazarus was in heaven or that the dead are conscious.ST Sep 30, 1908ST Details must not be treated partly as literal and partly as figurative, but the whole must be understood in harmony with other Scriptures and in opposition to the doctrine of inherent immortality.STST Oct 1, 1894
The verse belongs to Luke 16:19-31, part of Luke 16 with the unfaithful steward and part of the series in Luke 15-16 directed against covetousness.RH Jun 9, 1859ST Aug 13, 1894ST Apr 14, 1909RH Dec 16, 1858RH Apr 8, 1858 The chapter teaches pointed lessons about worldly goods, that unrighteous mammon means riches and that by right use of riches men secure friendship of God, Christ and holy angels who alone can receive them into everlasting habitations.RH Jun 9, 1859 The parables are to be meditated upon without speculation, fancies, theories or controversy about their meaning, yet the parable of the rich man and Lazarus is described as obscure and hard to understand.ST Aug 13, 1894RH Dec 16, 1858 Its meaning is given light by testimonies of what the Jews believed about the state of the dead, with more reliable light to be sought from views of Christians in the first century, against use of the parable to prove the dead are conscious contrary to plain Old Testament teaching that the dead sleep unconscious until the resurrection with which apostolic teaching agrees.RH Dec 16, 1858 It illustrates the Oriental custom of bringing allegories and parables into discourse, where figures can be mistaken for facts and parables for real actions unless the custom is known, and whether parable or true history has been in doubt among Christians; Moses did not warn of a future hell of torments in his writings.RH Apr 8, 1858RH Aug 2, 1864
Death as Sleep Without Knowledge
The dead are unconscious in death, knowing nothing, with thoughts, feelings, memory, wisdom, work and device perished, sleeping without passage of time until the resurrection.RH May 5, 1874RH Mar 4, 1862ST Mar 28, 1906RH Dec 22, 1868ST Aug 25, 1881 The scene is in Hades, the place of the dead in the nether parts of the earth, which is darkness and silence and secrecy and sleep, without knowledge, memory, conversation, work or device, where the wicked are silent and cannot converse or devise plans.RH May 5, 1874RH Mar 28, 1865ST Jun 30, 1881 The rich man's asking for Lazarus to be sent to warn his five brothers lest they come to torment is therefore figurative portrayal rather than what the dead can literally do, for the account is a fictional story teaching a spiritual lesson, not a description of conscious life after death.RH May 5, 1874ST Mar 28, 1906ST Aug 25, 1881 If read literally, its scene belongs to the future, after the saints are raised and probation has ended, when the wicked see Abraham, Isaac and Jacob in God's kingdom.RH Mar 4, 1862 The request is the second favor after water for the tongue is denied, and it also is refused because Moses and the prophets already give sufficient warning and instruction to mankind.RH May 5, 1874RH Mar 28, 1865ST Aug 25, 1881
The rich man's speech, distress, memory of brothers and plan to warn them are personification, picturing what the dead would say and do if alive and able to think, not literal conversation in Hades.RH Mar 28, 1865RH Dec 22, 1868ST Jun 30, 1881ST Jun 30, 1881ST Mar 27, 1879 It is the same manner as Rachel, Pharaoh and the king of Babylon are personified, letting the dead speak and act in keeping with the facts of their lives.RH Mar 28, 1865ST Jun 30, 1881 The conversation and distress are personifications of the dead and their future recompense, not conscious life or present punishment in death, for the wicked await resurrection and judgment before punishment.RH Mar 28, 1865ST Jun 30, 1881ST Mar 27, 1879 Their fate is represented as already present because it is certain in God's purpose, and the place of torment is not present but future, spoken of as already existing because in God's purpose it shall surely exist.RH Mar 28, 1865ST Jun 30, 1881 The parable thus agrees with all the Bible that recompense comes at its appointed time, with the day of judgment coming before punishment is inflicted, and it dramatizes the danger of reaching the place of the dead unprepared.RH Dec 22, 1868ST Jun 30, 1881 The plan to warn the brothers is incompatible with the stated condition of the dead as having no wisdom, knowledge or work, and Hades is not a place of thought but of utter forgetfulness and deep sleep, darkness, silence, secrecy and death.ST Jun 30, 1881ST Jun 30, 1881ST Mar 27, 1879
The dead cannot return to converse with or warn the living and take no active interest in earthly affairs, for the dead know nothing about earthly affairs and departed spirits are not permitted to return to earth to communicate or instruct.RH May 19, 1851ST Jan 20, 1887RH Dec 23, 1851ST Oct 1, 1894ST Dec 4, 1884 Claims of such communication therefore do not come from the spirits of the dead.RH Dec 23, 1851 Lazarus could visit and warn the brothers only by being raised from among the dead men, not by a disembodied spirit descending from heaven, and such a return would require resurrection.RH Mar 28, 1865ST Oct 1, 1894ST Mar 27, 1879RH Dec 12, 1854 The narrative is not an account of an actual occurrence and therefore does not teach that the dead can consciously send warnings to the living or return to help convert them.ST Oct 1, 1894ST Dec 4, 1884 Even one raised from the dead would not persuade those who refuse to believe God's word, so the verse points to the word of God as the ground of faith and to the need to seek salvation in this life, not after death.ST Oct 1, 1894 Seeking help from the dead or praying to a human intercessor is therefore futile, and Christ alone is intercessor.RH Mar 28, 1865
The narrative mentions no soul or spirit and describes embodied men rather than immaterial souls changed at death, giving no indication of separation of soul from body and no proof of natural immortality.RH Aug 12, 1862RH Nov 18, 1858RH Dec 19, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854RH Apr 16, 1861 Its characters speak as people in the flesh and describe bodily suffering and comfort, pictured in two distinct states to teach a lesson.RH Aug 12, 1862RH Dec 19, 1854 It speaks for the sake of the lesson as present what will not take place till after the day of judgment, and gives no teaching of separation of the soul from the body.RH Nov 18, 1858 It does not establish that the dead are conscious before the resurrection or that people go directly to heaven or hell when they die, and gives no indication that the speakers are spirits.RH Dec 19, 1854 If the rich man represented the conscious dead suffering before the resurrection, it would imply the wicked are punished before the day of judgment, making a later judgment unnecessary.RH Apr 16, 1861 Those who held the tribal reading taught that the five brothers as embodied men needing warning represent the supposed lost tribes, each brother for two tribes, together with the rich man making the twelve tribes, describing the change in condition of Jews and Gentiles brought about by a change of dispensations.RH Dec 12, 1854
Future Judgment and Closed Probation
The torment and the comfort belong to the future, after the saints are raised and after the resurrection, the judgment, and the giving of rewards.RH Mar 4, 1862ST Mar 30, 1882RH Sep 15, 1859RH Jan 7, 1902ST Dec 24, 1896 The scene is set when probation has ended and the wicked see Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob in God's kingdom and see the redeemed inside the New Jerusalem, yet are shut out.RH Mar 4, 1862RH Sep 15, 1859RH Jan 7, 1902 That punishment comes around the beloved city and before destruction, when the wicked are raised and fire from God devours them on earth, and only then is the separation irrevocable.ST Mar 30, 1882RH Jan 7, 1902ST Dec 24, 1896 The wicked are now asleep in Sheol awaiting resurrection to damnation and are reserved to the day of judgment, so the dead in Hades are delivered up when judgment comes and the rich man cannot be an exception already suffering there.ST Mar 30, 1882RH Oct 31, 1865 For this reason the account does not describe bliss or woe entered consciously at death nor events immediately after death, since the dead are unconscious and return to the grave.ST Mar 30, 1882RH Sep 15, 1859RH Jan 7, 1902ST Dec 24, 1896
Each person decides eternal destiny in this life, while grace is offered and opportunity to choose remains.ST Jun 1, 1915ST Oct 31, 1900RH Oct 10, 1912 Death ends probation and fixes the gulf, so no further probation is granted, there is no probation after death, no postmortem repentance, and a sealed destiny cannot be changed nor the course altered by return.ST Jun 1, 1915ST Oct 31, 1900ST Nov 14, 1900ST Nov 30, 1915 The dead cannot return to warn or help convert the living, and such a visit would require resurrection from among the dead.ST Oct 1, 1894ST Nov 30, 1915 Even one raised from the dead would not persuade those who refuse to heed Moses and the prophets and to believe God's word, for faith must rest on Scripture and salvation must be sought in this life and not after death.ST Oct 31, 1900ST Nov 14, 1900ST Oct 1, 1894 Wealth and possessions do not make anyone valued by God, and those who waste opportunity in self-pleasing cut themselves off from everlasting life, being held accountable for the use of what is entrusted to them and fixing by their own choice the impassable gulf between them and God.ST Jun 1, 1915RH Oct 10, 1912
The conversation and distress are personification, picturing what the dead would say and do if alive and able to think and speak, not conscious life or present punishment in death.RH Mar 28, 1865ST Jun 30, 1881ST Jun 30, 1881RH May 12, 1874RH May 12, 1874 Hades is not a place of thought but of utter forgetfulness, deep sleep, darkness, and silence, and Lazarus rests there without awareness with no passage of time experienced between death and resurrection.ST Jun 30, 1881ST Jun 30, 1881RH May 12, 1874RH May 12, 1874RH May 12, 1874 The place of torment is not present but future, yet is spoken of as already existing and already happening because in God's purpose it shall surely exist.RH Mar 28, 1865ST Jun 30, 1881ST Jun 30, 1881RH May 12, 1874RH May 12, 1874 The rich man is thus represented as already suffering the fire that will be his portion after resurrection and judgment, and his comfortless state and Lazarus's comfort represent the future recompense appointed to each at its time, with judgment coming before punishment is inflicted.RH Mar 28, 1865ST Jun 30, 1881ST Jun 30, 1881RH May 12, 1874RH May 12, 1874
God's fire consumes sin, and whether it cleanses the person or consumes the person depends on whether the person identifies with sin.ST Aug 24, 1904 That fire is therefore not proof of remedial torment, nor is Hades an eternal place of torment.ST Aug 24, 1904ST Feb 20, 1912 The prospect of endless misery raises the question whether an eternal torment can be reconciled with the justice of God.ST Jan 6, 1909
Sufficiency of Revealed Testimony
The request to send back a witness to warn five brothers against sharing torment is refused because the testimony already given is enough.RH May 24, 1870ST Nov 11, 1886RH May 5, 1874ST Oct 1, 1894ST Mar 15, 1877 Moses and the prophets supply sufficient warning, so the brothers are directed to hear them.ST Nov 11, 1886RH May 5, 1874ST Oct 1, 1894ST Mar 15, 1877ST Jun 23, 1881 People are to believe that clear light and act on it during this life rather than expect additional supernatural light or a sign from the dead.RH May 24, 1870RH Dec 27, 1855ST Aug 25, 1881ST Oct 1, 1885RH May 24, 1870 The second plea follows the denied plea for cooling, and both are denied in Hades, the place of the dead described as darkness and silence without knowledge, memory, or conversation, so the speaking and planning picture the facts of life and death figuratively rather than showing what the dead can literally do.RH May 5, 1874ST Mar 15, 1877ST Jun 23, 1881 Trust in ancestry and privilege gives no help, for even descendants of Abraham must heed that revealed word while time remains.ST Oct 1, 1894ST Aug 25, 1881
Those who will not listen to Moses and the prophets will not be persuaded even if someone rises from the dead.ST Nov 11, 1886ST Oct 1, 1894ST Aug 25, 1881ST Oct 1, 1885ST Nov 14, 1900 Further signs would not persuade those who refuse to hear, because unbelief is a matter of heart and will rather than lack of evidence.RH Dec 27, 1855ST Oct 1, 1885 Greater evidence does not convince those who reject light already given, and there is no second probation after death.RH Dec 27, 1855ST Nov 14, 1900 This was shown when signs were demanded yet Lazarus was sought to be killed and the resurrection of Jesus was denied.RH May 24, 1870ST Nov 11, 1886ST Oct 1, 1894ST Aug 25, 1881ST Oct 1, 1885
No messenger will come from the skies and no dead person will return to testify to those in darkness.RH May 24, 1870RH May 11, 1905 The saving of the world is left to the living, who must take Christ's commission and go with Christ-like love and zeal to nations waiting in darkness, since only that living witness will warn them and redeem the world to God.RH May 11, 1905 The rich man's recognition that his brothers face the same danger shows that testimony should urge turning from the life that leads to judgment.ST Jan 29, 1902 That same anguish echoes in a father who sees his son dying spiritually unprepared and regrets that the gospel had not been supported and carried to him, in people in India asking how to know which religion is right when no one has returned from the burning ghats to tell them, and in warning that seemingly harmless choices lead to a deadly end from which others must be warned.ST Mar 7, 1878RH Nov 15, 1906RH Sep 20, 1906
Figures of Jews and Gentiles
The rich man stands for the Jews, the Pharisees, and the literal descendants of Abraham who trusted in ancestry, privilege, riches, position and self-righteousness while rejecting Christ, and Lazarus stands for the poor and humble Gentiles who hungered for spiritual riches, sought God, received Christ and were brought near to Him.ST Oct 1, 1894STST Mar 6, 1907ST Apr 10, 1907ST Mar 24, 1909 The teaching was given first to Israel as the recognized people through whom the message would reach the nations, and the whole scene is figurative rather than literal history, with the impassable gulf being the unbelief of those who reject their Saviour.ST Oct 1, 1894STST Mar 6, 1907ST Apr 10, 1907RH Jan 7, 1902 Ancestry and Abraham give no help toward salvation, for though entrusted with God's law and grace the rich man class misused its trust, lived for self and received good things in this life, while those who deny self, live for Christ and lay hold on eternal life receive grace.ST Oct 1, 1894ST Mar 6, 1907ST Apr 10, 1907RH Jan 7, 1902ST Oct 14, 1913 Moses and the prophets already supply the needed testimony, and those who refuse their teaching will not be persuaded even if one rises from the dead.ST Oct 1, 1894ST Oct 1, 1894
The five brothers are the ten tribes of Israel, each brother standing for two tribes, while the rich man is the two tribes of Judah and Benjamin, together making the twelve tribes.ST Mar 28, 1906RH Dec 12, 1854ST Mar 28, 1906RH Dec 12, 1854 They were to hear about Christ through the preaching of the apostles, heeding Moses and the prophets and recognizing their fulfillment in Christ as the Ethiopian eunuch did.ST Mar 28, 1906RH Dec 12, 1854ST Mar 28, 1906 The figures describe a change of condition between Jews and Gentiles brought about by a change of dispensations, in which the Jewish nation lost much while the Gentiles gained much.RH Dec 12, 1854RH Dec 12, 1854 The request for testimony is concern that those tribes receive warning.RH Dec 12, 1854
The same five brothers also stand for people living now who need help, lack personal acquaintance with Christ and have no knowledge of the future before them, and they are directed to hear Moses and the prophets, meaning the Bible.ST Jan 26, 1915ST Jan 26, 1915ST Jan 26, 1915ST Oct 14, 1913 The plea brings the parable back to Jesus' own time, portraying Israel's rejection of Christ and the condition of those who would not heed the light and signs before them.ST Oct 28, 1913ST Oct 28, 1913ST Oct 14, 1913 Its lesson is aimed especially at the Jewish nation yet applies to every person, rebuking covetousness among God's professed people in every age and warning that choices made in this life fix eternal gain or loss without opportunity to live life again.ST Oct 28, 1913ST Jan 26, 1915ST Jan 26, 1915ST Oct 14, 1913
The Lazarus of the parable is not Lazarus the brother of Martha and Mary but a typical case representing the Gentiles hungry for the spiritual riches Christ would give, while the rich man is a type of the Jews who felt themselves rich in everything spiritual.ST Mar 24, 1909 His name means Whom God aids, the Greek form of the Hebrew Eleazar.ST Mar 24, 1909 He is pictured lying at the rich man's gate begging crumbs from his table with only dogs to nurse his wounds, yet possessing the peace of God in his soul, in contrast to the rich man's luxury and refusal to share even crumbs with the poor at his gate.ST Aug 24, 1904ST Jun 11, 1912
The parable was spoken to the covetous Pharisees right after reproving them for covetousness and in response to their derision, using their favored method of parables and their own admitted ideas to prove the point.RH Feb 8, 1912RH Dec 19, 1854 It strikes at trusting in riches and at the Jewish belief that sickness, poverty or suffering proves God has forsaken a person or is displeased with him, a belief that nourished self-righteousness and heartlessness.RH Feb 8, 1912 Wealth does not entitle anyone to happiness in the future state, and its application to the Jews became clear at the destruction of Jerusalem.RH Dec 19, 1854ST Aug 2, 1910 The rich man's request for his brethren becomes an appeal to the rich and selfish and to Christians to make every effort to save the perishing.RH Feb 8, 1912
Reliance on descent from Abraham cannot save, for human status and claims of birth do not make anyone worthy of salvation.ST Oct 31, 1900ST Oct 1, 1894 Entering heaven requires the righteousness of Christ to be imputed to the person, and the Messiah saves all who come to Him as sinners regardless of birth or social position.ST Oct 31, 1900ST Oct 1, 1894 Abraham cannot help his descendants to secure the promises, and the word of God in Moses and the prophets, not human traditions, is the standard of faith by which those who believe them will accept Jesus as Messiah.ST Oct 1, 1894
Stewardship and Warning on Riches
A life of luxurious self-indulgence ends in torment and loss, even where there has been no injustice or extortion, and the request to warn the five brothers stands as warning to all who indulge in worldly riches and glorify self.RH Jul 10, 1856ST Mar 30, 1882RH Oct 10, 1912 The whole chapter to which the verse belongs, with the unfaithful steward and the rich man and Lazarus in Luke 16:19-31, is directed against covetousness and shows the true value of riches in God's sight in the final reversal by which the self-exalting rich are brought low and the humble are exalted.ST Mar 30, 1882RH Oct 10, 1912ST Aug 13, 1894 Spoken to the covetous Pharisees right after reproving them for covetousness, it strikes at covetousness and at the belief that sickness, poverty or suffering proves that God has forsaken a person or is displeased with him, a belief that nourished self-righteousness and heartlessness.RH Feb 8, 1912 It belongs to a series of parables spoken to the Jews, whose favored way of learning was by parables and who would receive figurative instruction when they would reject literal truth, proving the point by assuming the standpoint and belief of those addressed, including their belief in the immortality of the soul taken from the heathen, without declaring that belief true.RH Feb 8, 1912 The parables are to be meditated upon more than ever, without speculation, fancies, theories or controversy about their meaning, and the rich man's plea for his brothers is an appeal to the rich and selfish and to Christians to make every effort possible to save the perishing.RH Feb 8, 1912ST Aug 13, 1894 Riches will not help in the judgment unless they have been used rightly and generously, and poverty does not keep a person out of heaven, for the parable does not teach that persons are conscious in death or that the soul never dies.RH Feb 8, 1912RH Aug 7, 1916
Wealth itself does not prove God's favor nor secure salvation, and poverty carries no merit nor bars heaven.RH Oct 10, 1912RH Aug 7, 1916ST Sep 9, 1880 Possessions do not prove divine approval and present fortunes do not determine the final outcome, just as the rich man's fate shows wealth does not guarantee divine approval and Lazarus's favor with God shows poverty does not prove a person is accursed.ST Sep 9, 1880ST Aug 26, 1880 Temporal blessings, health, success or affliction do not measure God's love or disapproval, for judgment measures character and the use made of providential circumstances, with patient endurance developing pity, patience, meekness, humility, faith and hope.RH Jul 10, 1856RH Oct 10, 1912 The main lesson is to condemn the inordinate admiration of wealth and teach the proper estimation of riches in this life, teaching that uprightness even in poverty will be rewarded in the future while selfishness brings ruin and destruction.ST Aug 19, 1880RH Aug 7, 1916 The request for the five brothers is an auxiliary, figurative feature of the story, not proof that the dead are conscious, using beliefs about the afterlife already familiar to the hearers to confront them with the consequences of their own ideas without by itself affirming or denying those beliefs, and establishing no literal place of torment.ST Aug 19, 1880ST Sep 9, 1880RH Aug 7, 1916ST Aug 26, 1880
The rich are stewards who must renounce the world and all worldly tempers, and by the right use of riches, called unrighteous mammon, secure the friendship of God, of Christ and of holy angels, who alone can receive them into everlasting habitations.RH Jul 10, 1856RH Jun 9, 1859 Selfish pleasure and enjoyment do not bring true happiness, for the rich man had a duty to use his abundance to help Lazarus but instead lived luxuriously, and when suffering came he longed to exchange places and called on him for relief, yet the fixed gulf showed their positions could not be changed.ST Jun 21, 1899 His fate followed failure to show gratitude to God or sympathy for Lazarus and to use his blessings to relieve distress, giving only crumbs after luxury while refusing to share even crumbs with the poor man at his gate.ST Jun 21, 1899RH Oct 20, 1904ST Aug 24, 1904 Neglecting the suffering poor while accumulating wealth breeds selfishness, indolence and ease that bury charity under gold, and the parable representing the rich and the poor warns of the consequences of failing to care for people in need.RH Jul 10, 1856ST Aug 24, 1904 The duty is to relieve the poor with food and clothing, provide shelter and show hospitality, for God regards the poor and unfortunate with pity and his children must imitate this care, a principle applying to oppressed nations as to individuals.ST Jun 25, 1894RH Oct 20, 1904
The contrast teaches that prosperity now may be followed by torment and suffering now by comfort hereafter, the wicked enjoying good things now and facing torment hereafter while the righteous suffer now and receive comfort hereafter.RH Mar 12, 1857RH Feb 19, 1857 Wealth and fine clothing did not protect from the consequences of sin, but the evil use of riches left the marks of sin at life's end, showing earthly wealth cannot secure what is needed in the next life.RH Jun 30, 1863RH Apr 22, 1915 The story warns against living like the rich man while expecting to die with the righteous.ST Mar 10, 1881 Sinners are lost and undone and poor, feeling need of a covering from wrath, unable to purchase it by keeping the holy law blameless or by good works, and God now offers the perfect robe of Christ's righteousness to cover all sins and fit all wants without money and without price, to be taken freely by taking God at his word with thanks.RH Nov 29, 1864 Modern piling of colossal fortunes while sufferers lack necessities shows the gulf that fulfills prophecy of Christ's coming.RH Jun 30, 1863ST Aug 24, 1904
Reported Contrary Readings
The account to which the verse belongs is brought forward as apparent proof that departed spirits remain conscious, immortal and active after death, the righteous already happy and the wicked already tormented in flames across an impassable gulf.RH Aug 27, 1872RH Dec 22, 1868ST Jun 23, 1881RH May 5, 1874RH Mar 4, 1862 The rich man's lifting of his eyes in torment and his awareness of his condition are taken as evidence against the claim that the dead lose consciousness or that the wicked are annihilated, whether good or evil.RH Dec 22, 1868ST Jun 23, 1881RH May 5, 1874RH Mar 4, 1862ST Sep 29, 1881 It is treated as a clear, minutely circumstantial and decisive proof of conscious existence during the state of death, with separate abodes in Hades and an intermediate state giving a foretaste of final reward, including what is claimed as the Bible's only instance of praying to a saint.RH Aug 27, 1872RH Dec 22, 1868ST Jun 23, 1881RH May 5, 1874ST Sep 29, 1881 His request to warn his brothers belongs to that portrayal of communication involving the dead, yet the dead are also described as having no knowledge, their thoughts perished, sleeping the sleep of death.RH Aug 27, 1872RH Dec 22, 1868ST Jun 23, 1881RH May 5, 1874RH Mar 4, 1862 After the case of the Sodomites is set aside, his remains the sole individual case left to argue that wicked people are now being tormented after death.RH Dec 22, 1868ST Jun 23, 1881RH May 5, 1874RH Mar 4, 1862ST Sep 29, 1881
That literal use meets very serious difficulties and does not clearly teach conscious misery immediately after death.ST Jun 23, 1881RH May 5, 1874RH Feb 2, 1864RH Jul 18, 1865RH Sep 23, 1858 If it describes the intermediate state it conflicts with the expectation that the wicked face sentence at the judgment, making judgment unnecessary by punishing before it, while if it describes what follows probation it is consistent with that expectation and does not prove greater wisdom for the dead than for the living.ST Jun 23, 1881RH May 5, 1874RH Feb 2, 1864RH Jul 18, 1865RH Sep 23, 1858 Taken literally it would place heaven and hell within seeing and speaking distance across the gulf, so that cries of torment interrupt songs of blessedness, with the wicked already suffering while their persecutors may still be alive on earth.ST Jun 23, 1881RH May 5, 1874RH Feb 2, 1864RH Jul 18, 1865ST Nov 16, 1876 Put together with the souls under the altar in Revelation, it exposes inconsistency in treating both as literal conscious souls, since martyrs asking how long they must wait for judgment and vengeance would already see their persecutors entering torment.ST Jun 23, 1881RH May 5, 1874RH Feb 2, 1864RH Jul 18, 1865ST Nov 16, 1876 It therefore conflicts with texts that the dead know nothing and await resurrection.RH Aug 27, 1872RH Dec 22, 1868ST Jun 23, 1881RH May 5, 1874RH Feb 2, 1864
The unbridgeable gulf of the parable is also used as an image of social distance between a poor workingman and a wealthy minister and congregation, without explaining the reference to the five brothers or their need for warning.ST Oct 8, 1885
Sources